WQCD Response:Selenium/Misc.

1

Reverse Osmosis Treatment• Colorado currently has

42 RO treatment plants. Attractive for communities with lower source water quality

• RO can concentrate ambient pollutants 4-6x in waste brine

• If source water pollutants are elevated and the plant is located on low-dilution stream, RO brine is at risk of compliance problems

Cottonwood Proposal• RO facility not discharging

since 2011• Unable to consistently

meet effluent limits from beginning of operations.

• Currently operating as a micro-filtration plant with effluent piped to ACCWA WWTF

• UAA characterized the biological and chemical conditions in 3 adjacent creeks in support of ambient Se standards

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

5/2/10 6/21/10 8/10/10 9/29/10 11/18/10 1/7/11 2/26/11 4/17/11 6/6/11

Sele

nium

ug/

L

Cottonwood ROTP Effluent Selenium Concentrations

Chronic Std

Acute Std

Summary Cottonwood UAA• Upper reaches of Cottonwood, Lone Tree and Windmill

Creeks drain selenium bearing shales. No evidence of point sources

• Chemistry: Sampling over 17 months with generally good spatial coverage. (given the challenges of flow)

• Biology: MMI scores and fish community composition generally indicative of urbanized, flow limited systems.

Aquatic biota (fish and bugs) have elevated tissue concentrations ranging from 10-24ug/g at most sites.

3 of 1700 fish found with Se related deformities.

• Highest Attainable Use= Elevated Se in tissues with a low rate of fish deformities.

Underlying Geology

Ambient Se TVS

LEGEND

Cottonwood 4b StandardsAmbient based standards for the upper portions of

these systems and TVS* in lower

Summer and Winter standards (due to 2x greater winter concentrations)

Assessment locations capture the spatial variability well

The Division recommends the proposal as stated in WQCD Exhibits 38-26 and 27

Milliken Overview• History of compliance violations due to selenium

• DMR delinquency etc

• New personnel and technical consulting evaluating new treatment technologies and source water

• Proposal seeking continuation of the Se temporary modification on Little Thompson River.

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

4019

85

1990

1995

2000

2005

2010

2015

Se (u

g/l)

Little Thompson Selenium Concentrations (1987-2014)

Site 124 Selenium

85th percentile

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

0 2 4 6 8 10 12

Sele

nium

ug/

L

Month

Town of Milliken ROTP Effluent Selenium Concentrations

2012

2013

2014

Chronic Std

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

2006

2008

2009

2010

2012

2013

2014

2016

Milliken ROTP Effluent Se Concentrations

2007

2008

2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

Linear (All)

Temporary ModificationThe Division withdrew our initial proposal for a “current

conditions” temporary modification due to several concerns about Milliken’s facility.

• “Current Conditions” equals no discharge in this case.

• Uncertainty about the consistent and worsening trend in effluent quality.

• A numeric temporary modification does not build in assimilative capacity.

Other ProposalsClear Creek Segment 2c: The Division supports

CCCSD’s proposal for new and revised temporary modifications.

Big Dry Creek Segment 1: The Division supports BDCWA’s proposal to move one of the assessment locations and correct typos.

Regulation 38.7: The Division supports the inclusion of language specifying that Marston Forebay is not Waters of the State.

Questions?

Se (ppm)

USGS National Geochemical Map for selenium.Map was compiled by Andrew Grosz and Jeffrey Grossman, 2006.