WORSE CASE OR BEST CASE?? Examining the Consequences of Mortgage Irregularities for Financial...

8/3/2019 WORSE CASE OR BEST CASE?? Examining the Consequences of Mortgage Irregularities for Financial Stability and Foreclosure Mitigation-Congressional Overs

1/171

RKYSW$ 888we Jom`sfzzQRNsoa wef V-Z- @o~fsmafmw Yslmwlm` OnnljfQ

JOM@SFZZLOMHD O^FSZL@EW YHMFD

MO^FACFS O^FSZL@EW SFYOSW +

!!!!!!!!!!

FUHALMLM@ WEF JOMZFXVFMJFZ ON

AOSW@H@F LSSF@VDHSLWLFZ NOSNLMHMJLHD ZWHCLDLW\ HMG

NOSFJDOZVSF ALWL@HWLOM

Mo~facfs 8>$ 3989-!!Osgfsfg wo cf yslmwfg

+ Zvcalwwfg vmgfs Zfjwlom 836%c,%8, on Wlwdf 8 on wef Fafs`fmj|Fjomoalj Zwhcldl{hwlom Hjw on 3995$ Yvc- D- Mo- 889!:7:

JOM@SFZZLOMHD O^FSZL@EW YHMFD

MO^FACFS O^FSZL@EW SFYOSW +

__________


2/171

FUHALMLM@ WEF JOMZFXVFMJFZ ON AOSW@H@F LSSF@VDHSLWLFZ NOSNLMHMJLHD

ZWHCLDLW\ HMG NOSFJDOZVSF ALWL@HWLOM

Mo~facfs 8>$ 3989-!!Osgfsfg wo cf yslmwfg

+ Zvcalwwfg vmgfs Zfjwlom 836%c,%8, on Wlwdf 8 on wef Fafs`fmj|Fjomoalj Zwhcldl{hwlom Hjw on 3995$ Yvc- D- Mo- 889!:7:

______

V-Z- @O^FSMAFMW YSLMWLM@ ONNLJF>8!5:6 YGN PHZELM@WOM ; 3989

___________________________________________________________________________Nos zhdf c| wef Zvyfslmwfmgfmw on Gojvafmwz$ V-Z- @o~fsmafmw Yslmwlm`Onnljf$ewwy;//coobzwosf-`yo-`o~- Nos aosf lmnosahwlom$ jomwhjw wef @YO Jvzwoafs

Jomwhjw Jfmwfs$ V-Z- @o~fsmafmw Yslmwlm` Onnljf- Yeomf 393!683!8599$ os5>>!683!8599 %wodd!nsff,- F!ahld$ `yoIjvzwefdy-joa-

JOM@SFZZLOMHD O^FSZL@EW YHMFDYhmfd Afacfsz

Zfm- Wfg Bhvnahm$ JehlsahmSljehsg E- Mflahm

Ghaom Zld~fszK- Ahsb AjPhwwfsz


3/171

Bfmmfwe Wsozbf

J O M W F M W Z

!!!!!!!!!!Yh`f

Fufjvwl~f Zvaahs|------------------------------------------------ 8Zfjwlom Omf;

H- O~fs~lfp-------------------------------------------------- 7C- Chjb`sovmg------------------------------------------------ 6J- Wlafdlmf-------------------------------------------------- >G- Df`hd Jomzfxvfmjfz on Gojvafmw Lssf`vdhslwlfz------------- 89

8- Yowfmwlhd Ndhpz lm wef Sfjosglm` hmg Wshmznfs on

Aosw`h`fz hmg ^lodhwlomz on Yoodlm` hmg Zfs~ljlm`H`sffafmwz--------------------------------------------- 83

3- Yozzlcdf Df`hd Jomzfxvfmjfz on wef GojvafmwLssf`vdhslwlfz wo ^hslovz Yhswlfz---------------------- 85

Zfjwlom Wpo; Jossfzyomgfmjf plwe Wsfhzvs|------------------------ 08Zfjwlom Wesff; WHSY Vyghwfz Zlmjf Dhzw Sfyosw-------------------- 03Zfjwlom Novs; O~fszl`ew Hjwl~lwlfz------------------------------- Zfjwlom Nl~f; Hcovw wef Jom`sfzzlomhd O~fszl`ew Yhmfd------------ -7 wslddlom lm Hafsljhm aosw`h`fz ah|eh~f c|yhzzfg df`hdd| sfxvlsfg zwfyz wo nosfjdozf om h eoaf-Faydo|ffz os jomwshjwosz on Chmb on Hafsljh$ @AHJ Aosw`h`f$ hmgowefs ahkos dohm zfs~ljfsz wfzwlnlfg wehw wef| zl`mfg$ hmg lmzoaf jhzfz chjbghwfg$ weovzhmgz on gojvafmwz jdhlalm` yfszomhd


5/171

bmopdfg`f on nhjwz hcovw aosw`h`fz wehw wef| glg mow hjwvhdd|bmop wo cf wsvf-

Hddf`hwlomz on iisoco!zl`mlm`'' hsf gffyd| glzwvsclm` hmgeh~f `l~fm slzf wo omòlm` nfgfshd hmg zwhwf lm~fzwl`hwlomz- Hwwelz yolmw wef vdwlahwf laydljhwlomz sfahlm vmjdfhs- Lw lz

yozzlcdf$ eopf~fs$ wehw iisoco!zl`mlm`'' ah| eh~f jomjfhdfgavje gffyfs ysocdfaz lm wef aosw`h`f ahsbfw wehw jovdgyowfmwlhdd| wesfhwfm nlmhmjlhd zwhcldlw| hmg vmgfsalmf wefò~fsmafmw'z fnnoswz wo alwl`hwf wef nosfjdozvsf jslzlz-Hdweovè lw lz mow |fw yozzlcdf wo gfwfsalmf pefwefs zvjewesfhwz pldd ahwfslhdl{f$ wef Yhmfd vs`fz Wsfhzvs| hmg chmbsf`vdhwosz wo whbf laafglhwf zwfyz wo vmgfszwhmg hmg ysfyhsfnos wef yowfmwlhd slzbz-

Lm wef cfzw!jhzf zjfmhslo$ jomjfsmz hcovw aosw`h`fgojvafmwhwlom lssf`vdhslwlfz ah| yso~f o~fscdopm- Lm welz ~lfp$pelje ehz cffm facshjfg c| wef nlmhmjlhd lmgvzws|$ h ehmgnvd onfaydo|ffz nhldfg wo noddop ysojfgvsfz lm zl`mlm` nosfjdozvsf!sfdhwfg hnnlgh~lwz$ cvw wef nhjwz vmgfsd|lm` wef hnnlgh~lwz hsfgfaomzwshcd| hjjvshwf- Nosfjdozvsfz jovdg ysojffg hz zoom hzwef lm~hdlg hnnlgh~lwz hsf sfydhjfg plwe ysoyfsd| fufjvwfgyhyfsposb-

Wef poszw!jhzf zjfmhslo lz jomzlgfshcd| `slaafs- Lm welz~lfp$ pelje ehz cffm hswljvdhwfg c| hjhgfaljz hmg eoafopmfshg~ojhwfz$ wef iisoco!zl`mlm`'' on hnnlgh~lwz zfs~fg wo jo~fsvy wef nhjw wehw dohm zfs~ljfsz jhmmow gfaomzwshwf wef nhjwzsfxvlsfg wo jomgvjw h dhpnvd nosfjdozvsf- Lm fzzfmjf$ chmbz ah|

cf vmhcdf wo yso~f wehw wef| opm wef aosw`h`f dohmz wef| jdhlawo opm-

Wef slzb zwfaz nsoa wef yozzlcldlw| wehw wef shylg `sopweon aosw`h`f zfjvslwl{hwlom ovwyhjfg wef hcldlw| on wef df`hdhmg nlmhmjlhd z|zwfa wo wshjb aosw`h`f dohm opmfszely- Lmfhsdlfs |fhsz$ vmgfs wef wshglwlomhd aosw`h`f aogfd$ heoafopmfs cossopfg aomf| nsoa h zlm`df chmb hmg wefm yhlg chjbwef zhaf chmb- Lm wef shsf lmzwhmjfz pefm h chmb wshmznfssfglwz slèwz$ wef zhdf phz sfjosgfg c| ehmg lm wef cossopfs'zjovmw| ysoyfsw| onnljf- Wevz$ wef opmfszely on hm| lmgl~lgvhd

aosw`h`f jovdg cf fhzld| gfaomzwshwfg-Mophgh|z$ h zlm`df aosw`h`f dohm ah| cf zodg go{fmz onwlafz cfwpffm ~hslovz chmbz hjsozz wef jovmws|- Lm wef ~lfp onzoaf ahsbfw yhswljlyhmwz$ wef zeffs zyffg on wef aogfsmaosw`h`f ahsbfw ehz sfmgfsfg oczodfwf wef wshglwlomhd lmb!hmg!yhyfs sfjosghwlom ysojfzz$ zo wef nlmhmjlhd lmgvzws| gf~fdoyfghm fdfjwsomlj wshmznfs ysojfzz wehw c|yhzzfz jovmw| ysoyfsw|onnljfz- Welz fdfjwsomlj ysojfzz ehz$ eopf~fs$ nhjfg df`hd


6/171

jehddfm`fz wehw jovdg$ lm hm fuwsfaf zjfmhslo$ jhdd lmwoxvfzwlom wef ~hdlglw| on :: alddlom aosw`h`f dohmz-

Nvswefs$ wef nlmhmjlhd lmgvzws| mop joaaomd| cvmgdfz wefslèwz wo weovzhmgz on lmgl~lgvhd dohmz lmwo h aosw`h`f!chjbfgzfjvslw| %ACZ,- Wef zfjvslwl{hwlom ysojfzz lz joaydljhwfg hmg

sfxvlsfz zf~fshd ysoyfsd| fufjvwfg wshmznfsz- Ln hw hm| yolmwwef sfxvlsfg df`hd zwfyz hsf mow noddopfg wo wef dfwwfs$ wefmwef opmfszely on wef aosw`h`f dohm jovdg nhdd lmwo xvfzwlom-Eoafopmfs hg~ojhwfz eh~f hddf`fg wehw nsfxvfmw iisoco!zl`mlm`''on opmfszely hnnlgh~lwz ah| eh~f jomjfhdfg fuwfmzl~f lmgvzws|nhldvsfz wo gojvafmw aosw`h`f dohm wshmznfsz ysoyfsd|-

Ln gojvafmwhwlom ysocdfaz yso~f wo cf yfs~hzl~f hmg$ aosflayoswhmwd|$ wesop lmwo govcw wef opmfszely on mow omd|nosfjdozfg ysoyfswlfz cvw hdzo yoodfg aosw`h`fz$ wefjomzfxvfmjfz jovdg cf zf~fsf- Jdfhs hmg vmjomwfzwfg ysoyfsw|slèwz hsf wef novmghwlom on wef eovzlm` ahsbfw- Ln wefzfslèwz nhdd lmwo xvfzwlom$ wehw novmghwlom jovdg joddhyzf-Cossopfsz ah| cf vmhcdf wo gfwfsalmf pefwefs wef| hsf zfmglm`wefls aomwed| yh|afmwz wo wef slèw yfoydf- Kvg`fz ah| cdojbhm| fnnosw wo nosfjdozf$ f~fm lm jhzfz pefsf cossopfsz eh~fnhldfg wo ahbf sf`vdhs yh|afmwz- Avdwlydf chmbz ah| hwwfayw wonosfjdozf vyom wef zhaf ysoyfsw|- Cossopfsz peo eh~f hdsfhg|zvnnfsfg nosfjdozvsf ah| zffb wo sf`hlm wlwdf wo wefls eoafzhmg nosjf hm| mfp opmfsz wo ao~f ovw- Povdg!cf cv|fsz hmgzfddfsz jovdg nlmg wefazfd~fz lm dlaco$ vmhcdf wo bmop plwe hm|jfswhlmw| pefwefs wef| jhm zhnfd| cv| os zfdd h eoaf- Ln zvje

ysocdfaz pfsf wo hslzf om h dhs`f zjhdf$ wef eovzlm` ahsbfwjovdg fuyfslfmjf f~fm `sfhwfs glzsvywlomz wehm eh~f hdsfhg|ojjvssfg$ sfzvdwlm` lm zl`mlnljhmw ehsa wo ahkos nlmhmjlhdlmzwlwvwlomz- Nos fuhaydf$ ln h Phdd Zwsffw chmb pfsf woglzjo~fs wehw$ gvf wo zeoggld| fufjvwfg yhyfsposb$ lw zwlddopmz alddlomz on gfnhvdwfg aosw`h`fz wehw lw weovèw lw zodgonn |fhsz hò$ lw jovdg nhjf clddlomz on goddhsz lm vmfuyfjwfgdozzfz-

Gojvafmwhwlom lssf`vdhslwlfz jovdg hdzo eh~f ahkos fnnfjwzom Wsfhzvs|'z ahlm nosfjdozvsf ysf~fmwlom fnnosw$ wef Eoaf

Hnnosghcdf Aoglnljhwlom Yso`sha %EHAY,- Zoaf zfs~ljfsz gfhdlm`plwe Wsfhzvs| ah| eh~f mo df`hd slèw wo lmlwlhwf nosfjdozvsfz$pelje ah| jhdd lmwo xvfzwlom wefls hcldlw| wo `shmwaoglnljhwlomz os wo gfahmg yh|afmwz nsoa eoafopmfsz- Wefzfs~ljfsz' vzf on iisoco!zl`mlm`'' ah| hdzo eh~f hnnfjwfggfwfsalmhwlomz hcovw lmgl~lgvhd dohmz2 zfs~ljfsz ah| eh~f cffmaosf plddlm` wo nosfjdozf ln wef| pfsf mow cfhslm` wef nvddjozwz on h ysoyfsd| fufjvwfg nosfjdozvsf- Wsfhzvs| ehz zo nhs


7/171

mow yso~lgfg sfyoswz on hm| lm~fzwl`hwlom hz wo pefwefsgojvafmwhwlom ysocdfaz jovdg vmgfsalmf EHAY- Lw zeovdg fm`h`flm hjwl~f fnnoswz wo aomlwos wef layhjw on nosfjdozvsflssf`vdhslwlfz$ hmg lw zeovdg sfyosw lwz nlmglm`z wo Jom`sfzzhmg wef yvcdlj-

Lm hgglwlom wo gojvafmwhwlom jomjfsmz$ hmowefs ysocdfa ehzhslzfm plwe zfjvslwl{fg aosw`h`f dohmz wehw jovdg hdzo wesfhwfmnlmhmjlhd zwhcldlw|- Lm~fzwosz lm aosw`h`f!chjbfg zfjvslwlfzw|yljhdd| gfahmgfg jfswhlm hzzvshmjfz hcovw wef xvhdlw| on wefdohmz wef| yvsjehzfg; nos lmzwhmjf$ wehw wef cossopfsz ehgjfswhlm almlava jsfglw shwlm`z hmg lmjoaf$ os wehw wefls eoafzehg hyyshlzfg nos hw dfhzw h almlava ~hdvf- Hddf`hwlomz eh~fzvsnhjfg wehw chmbz ah| eh~f alzsfysfzfmwfg wef xvhdlw| on ahm|dohmz zodg nos zfjvslwl{hwlom- Chmbz novmg wo eh~f yso~lgfgalzsfysfzfmwhwlomz jovdg cf sfxvlsfg wo sfyvsjehzf hm| hnnfjwfgaosw`h`fz- Cfjhvzf alddlomz on wefzf aosw`h`fz hsf lm gfnhvdwos nosfjdozvsf$ wef sfzvdw jovdg cf fuwfmzl~f jhylwhd dozzfz lnzvje sfyvsjehzf slzb lz mow hgfxvhwfd| sfzfs~fg-

Wo yvw lm yfszyfjwl~f wef yowfmwlhd ysocdfa$ omf lm~fzwoshjwlom hdomf jovdg zffb wo nosjf Chmb on Hafsljh wo sfyvsjehzfhmg hczosc yhswlhd dozzfz om vy wo 70 clddlom lm wsovcdfgdohmz gvf wo hddf`fg alzsfysfzfmwhwlomz on dohm xvhdlw|- Chmbon Hafsljh jvssfmwd| ehz 3:9 clddlom lm zehsfeodgfsz' fxvlw|$zo ln zf~fshd zlaldhs!zl{fg hjwlomz!!pefwefs aowl~hwfg c|jomjfsmz hcovw vmgfspslwlm` os dohm opmfszely!!pfsf wo zvjjffg$wef joayhm| jovdg zvnnfs glzhcdlm` ghah`f wo lwz sf`vdhwos|

jhylwhd- Lw lz yozzlcdf wehw plgfzysfhg jehddfm`fz hdom` wefzfdlmfz jovdg yozf slzbz wo wef ~fs| nlmhmjlhd zwhcldlw| wehw wefWsovcdfg Hzzfw Sfdlfn Yso`sha phz gfzl`mfg wo ysowfjw- Wsfhzvs|ehz jdhlafg wehw chzfg om f~lgfmjf wo ghwf$ aosw`h`f!sfdhwfgysocdfaz jvssfmwd| yozf mo ghm`fs wo wef nlmhmjlhd z|zwfa$ cvwlm dl`ew on wef fuwfmzl~f vmjfswhlmwlfz lm wef ahsbfw wogh|$Wsfhzvs|'z hzzfswlomz hyyfhs ysfahwvsf- Wsfhzvs| zeovdg fuydhlmpe| lw zffz mo ghm`fs- Chmb sf`vdhwosz zeovdg hdzo jomgvjw mfpzwsfzz wfzwz om Phdd Zwsffw chmbz wo afhzvsf wefls hcldlw| wogfhd plwe h yowfmwlhd jslzlz-

Wef Yhmfd fayehzl{fz wehw aosw`h`f dfmgfsz hmgzfjvslwl{hwlom zfs~ljfsz zeovdg mow vmgfswhbf wo nosfjdozf omhm| eoafopmfs vmdfzz wef| hsf hcdf wo go zo lm nvdd joaydlhmjfplwe hyydljhcdf dhpz hmg wefls jomwshjwvhd h`sffafmwz plwe wefeoafopmfs-

Wef Hafsljhm nlmhmjlhd z|zwfa lz lm h ysfjhslovz ydhjf-Wsfhzvs|'z hvweoslw| wo zvyyosw wef nlmhmjlhd z|zwfa wesov`ewef Wsovcdfg Hzzfw Sfdlfn Yso`sha ehz fuylsfg$ hmg wef


8/171

sfzodvwlom hvweoslw| jsfhwfg c| wef Gogg!Nshmb Phdd ZwsffwSfnosa hmg Jomzvafs Ysowfjwlom Hjw on 3989 sfahlmz vmwfzwfg-Wef 399< zwsfzz wfzwz wehw f~hdvhwfg wef efhdwe on wefnlmhmjlhd z|zwfa doobfg omd| wo wef fmg on 3989$ yso~lglm`dlwwdf hzzvshmjf wehw chmbz jovdg plwezwhmg zehsy dozzfz lm wef

|fhsz wo joaf- Wef eovzlm` ahsbfw hmg wef csohgfs fjomoa|sfahlm wsovcdfg hmg wevz ~vdmfshcdf wo nvwvsf zeojbz- Lm zeosw$f~fm hz wef ò~fsmafmw'z sfzyomzf wo wef nlmhmjlhd jslzlz lzgshplm` wo h jdozf$ zf~fsf wesfhwz sfahlm wehw eh~f wefyowfmwlhd wo ghah`f nlmhmjlhd zwhcldlw|-

ZFJWLOM OMF;

H- O~fs~lfp

Lm wef nhdd on 3989$ plwe wef Wsovcdfg Hzzfw SfdlfnYso`sha'z %WHSY, hvweoslw| fuylslm`$ sfyoswz cf`hm wo zvsnhjfon ysocdfaz plwe nosfjdozvsf gojvafmwhwlom$ yhswljvdhsd| lmzwhwfz pefsf nosfjdozvsfz ehyyfm wesovè wef jovswz- @AHJAosw`h`f$ h zvczlglhs| on jvssfmw WHSY sfjlylfmw Hdd|Nlmhmjlhd$ hmmovmjfg om Zfywfacfs 37$ 3989 wehw lw ehglgfmwlnlfg lssf`vdhslwlfz lm lwz nosfjdozvsf gojvafmwysojfgvsfz wehw shlzfg xvfzwlomz hcovw wef ~hdlglw| onnosfjdozvsfz om aosw`h`fz wehw lw zfs~ljfg- Zlaldhs sf~fdhwlomzzoom noddopfg nsoa Chmb on Hafsljh$ h nosafs WHSY sfjlylfmw$hmg owefsz- Faydo|ffz on wefzf joayhmlfz os wefls jomwshjwosz

eh~f wfzwlnlfg wehw wef| zl`mfg$ hmg lm zoaf jhzfz chjbghwfg$weovzhmgz on gojvafmwz hwwfzwlm` wo yfszomhd bmopdfg`f on nhjwzhcovw wef aosw`h`f hmg wef ysoyfsw| wehw wef| glg mow hjwvhdd|bmop wo cf wsvf- Aosw`h`f zfs~ljfsz hdzo hyyfhsfg wo cf jvwwlm`josmfsz lm owefs ph|z- Hjjosglm` wo wefzf chmbz$ weflsfaydo|ffz pfsf eh~lm` wsovcdf bffylm` vy plwe wef jsvze onnosfjdozvsfz$ cvw hgglwlomhd wshlmlm` hmg faydo|ffz povdg`fmfshdd| zvnnljf wo `fw wef ysojfzz lm osgfs h`hlm-

Hw ysfzfmw$ wef sfhje on wefzf lssf`vdhslwlfz lz vmbmopm-Wef lssf`vdhslwlfz ah| cf dlalwfg wo yhyfsposb fssosz haom`

jfswhlm zfs~ljfsz lm jfswhlm zwhwfz2 hdwfsmhwl~fd|$ wef| ah|jhdd lmwo xvfzwlom hzyfjwz on wef zfjvslwl{hwlom ysojfzz wehwyoodfg hmg zodg lmwfsfzwz lm lmmvafshcdf aosw`h`fz gvslm` wefeovzlm` cooa- Gfyfmglm` om wefls fuwfmw$ wef lssf`vdhslwlfz ah|hnnfjw cowe Wsfhzvs|'z omòlm` nosfjdozvsf yso`shaz hmg wefnlmhmjlhd zwhcldlw| wehw Wsfhzvs|$ vmgfs wef Fafs`fmj| FjomoaljZwhcldl{hwlom Hjw on 3995 %FFZH,$ phz whzbfg plwe sfzwoslm`-Nvswefs$ wef aosw`h`f ahsbfw nhjfz omòlm` slzbz sfdhwfg wo wef


9/171

slèw on aosw`h`f!chjbfg zfjvslwlfz wo nosjf chmbz wosfyvsjehzf hm| dohmz- Dozzfz zwfaalm` nsoa wefzf sfyvsjehzfzpovdg joayovmg hm| slzbz hzzojlhwfg plwe gojvafmwhwlomlssf`vdhslwlfz-

Vmgfs FFZH$ wef Jom`sfzzlomhd O~fszlèw Yhmfd lz jehs`fg

plwe sf~lfplm` wef jvssfmw zwhwf on wef nlmhmjlhd ahsbfwz hmgwef sf`vdhwos| z|zwfa- Wef Yhmfd'z o~fszlèw lmwfsfzw lmnosfjdozvsf gojvafmwhwlom lssf`vdhslwlfz zwfaz nsoa zf~fshdglzwlmjw jomjfsmz;

Ln Zf~fsf Glzsvywlomz lm wef Eovzlm` Ahsbfw Ahwfslhdl{f$Nlmhmjlhd Zwhcldlw| hmg Whuyh|fs Nvmgz Jovdg Cf Layfsldfg- Lngojvafmw lssf`vdhslwlfz yso~f wo cf yfs~hzl~f hmg$ aosflayoswhmwd|$ wesop lmwo xvfzwlom opmfszely on mow omd|nosfjdozfg ysoyfswlfz cvw hdzo yoodfg aosw`h`fz$ wef sfzvdwjovdg cf zl`mlnljhmw ehsa wo nlmhmjlhd zwhcldlw|!!wef ~fs|zwhcldlw| wehw wef WHSY phz gfzl`mfg wo ysowfjw- Lm wef poszwjhzf zjfmhslo$ h jdfhs jehlm on wlwdf!!hm fzzfmwlhd fdfafmw onh nvmjwlomlm` eovzlm` ahsbfw!!ah| cf glnnljvdw wo fzwhcdlze nosysoyfswlfz zvckfjw wo aosw`h`f dohmz wehw pfsf yoodfg hmgzfjvslwl{fg- Shwlm` h`fmjlfz hsf hdsfhg| jhvwlovz lm weflsovwdoob nos wef chmblm` zfjwos$ hmg nvswefs cdopz jovdg eh~f hzl`mlnljhmw fnnfjw- Wef laydljhwlomz jovdg hdzo cf glsf noswhuyh|fsz' sfjo~fs| on wefls WHSY lm~fzwafmwz- Wsfhzvs| zwlddehz >>-5 clddlom lm~fzwfg lm wef chmblm` zfjwos `fmfshdd|$ hmghz wef Yhmfd glzjvzzfg lm lwz Kvd| sfyosw$ iiZahdd Chmbz lm wef

Jhylwhd Yvsjehzf Yso`sha$'' wef ysozyfjwz nos sfyh|afmw nsoazahddfs chmbz hsf zwldd vmjfswhlm hmg gfyfmgfmw$ lm `sfhw yhsw$om h zfjwos efhdwe| fmovè wo hwwshjw ysl~hwf lm~fzwafmw-T8T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T8T Whuyh|fsz ah| hdzo cf hw slzb nos dozzfz sfdhwfg wo Wsfhzvs|'zlm~fzwafmw lm HL@- Wef Ahlgfm Dhmf LL hmg Ahlgfm Dhmf LLL ~feljdfz$pelje wef Nfgfshd Sfzfs~f Chmb on Mfp \osb %NSCM\, jsfhwfg wo eodghzzfwz yvsjehzfg nsoa HL@$ eodg zvczwhmwlhd haovmwz on sfzlgfmwlhdaosw`h`f!chjbfg zfjvslwlfz %SACZz,$ aozw on pelje hsf flwefs zvc!yslafos Hdw!H aosw`h`fz osl`lmhwfg gvslm` wef eovzlm` cooa- Wsfhzvs|'z

hcldlw| wo sfjo~fs wef nvmgz lw ehz yvw lmwo HL@ gfyfmgz lm zl`mlnljhmwyhsw om NSCM\'z hcldlw| wo joddfjw om wefzf lm~fzwafmwz$ hmgvmjfswhlmw| hzzojlhwfg plwe wef lm~fzwafmwz jovdg elmgfs wehw ysojfzz-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!EHAY Ah| Sfd| om Vmjfswhlm Df`hd Hvweoslw| hmg LmhjjvshwfNosfjdozvsf Jozw Fzwlahwfz$ Yowfmwlhdd| Yozlm` h Slzb woNosfjdozvsf Alwl`hwlom Fnnoswz- Ln lssf`vdhslwlfz lm wefnosfjdozvsf ysojfzz sfndfjw gffyfs nhldvsfz wo gojvafmw


10/171

ysoyfsd| jehm`fz on opmfszely hz aosw`h`f dohmz pfsfzfjvslwl{fg$ wefm lw lz yozzlcdf wehw Wsfhzvs| lz gfhdlm` plwewef psom` yhswlfz lm wef jovszf on wef Eoaf HnnosghcdfAoglnljhwlom Yso`sha %EHAY,- Welz jovdg afhm wehw cossopfszflwefs sfjfl~fg os pfsf gfmlfg aoglnljhwlomz laysoyfsd|- Zoaf

zfs~ljfsz gfhdlm` plwe Wsfhzvs| ah| eh~f mo df`hd slèw wolmlwlhwf nosfjdozvsfz$ pelje ah| jhdd lmwo xvfzwlom weflshcldlw| wo `shmw aoglnljhwlomz os wo gfahmg yh|afmwz nsoaeoafopmfsz$ pefwefs wef| hsf yhsw on h nosfjdozvsf alwl`hwlomyso`sha os owefsplzf- Wef zfs~ljfsz' wfmgfmj| wo jvw josmfszah| hdzo eh~f hnnfjwfg wef gfwfsalmhwlom wo aogln| os nosfjdozfvyom lmgl~lgvhd dohmz- Cfjhvzf wef mfw ysfzfmw ~hdvf %MY^,aogfd joayhsfz wef mfw ysfzfmw ~hdvf on wef aoglnljhwlom wo hnosfjdozvsf$ laysoyfs ysojfgvsfz wehw jvw josmfsz alèw eh~fhnnfjwfg wef nosfjdozvsf jozw jhdjvdhwlom hmg wevz alèw eh~fhnnfjwfg wef ovwjoaf on wef MY^ wfzw-WHSY!Sfjlylfmw Chmbz Ah| Eh~f Nhldfg wo Affw Df`hd Ocdl`hwlomz-Ahm| on wef fmwlwlfz laydljhwfg lm wef sfjfmw gojvafmwlssf`vdhslwlfz$ lmjdvglm` Hdd| Nlmhmjlhd$ Chmb on Hafsljh$ hmgKYAos`hm Jehzf$ hsf jvssfmw os nosafs WHSY sfjlylfmwz- Hdd|Nlmhmjlhd$ mowhcd|$ sfahlmz lm WHSY hmg lz lm yozzfzzlom on80-3 clddlom lm whuyh|fs nvmgz- Chmb on Hafsljh sfjfl~fg nvmgzmow omd| nsoa WHSY'z Jhylwhd Yvsjehzf Yso`sha %JYY, cvw hdzopehw Wsfhzvs| gffafg iifujfywlomhd hzzlzwhmjf'' nsoa WHSY'zWhs`fwfg Lm~fzwafmw Yso`sha %WLY,- Zoaf on wef chmbz lm~od~fgpfsf hdzo zvckfjw wo wef Zvyfs~lzos| Jhylwhd Hzzfzzafmw Yso`sha

%ZJHY,$ hdzo bmopm hz wef zwsfzz wfzwz; Wsfhzvs|'z hmg wefCohsg on @o~fsmosz on wef Nfgfshd Sfzfs~f'z %Nfgfshd Sfzfs~f,fnnoswz wo gfwfsalmf wef efhdwe on wef dhs`fzw chmbz vmgfs h~hslfw| on zwsfzzfg zjfmhsloz-

Wef Jom`sfzzlomhd O~fszlèw Yhmfd pldd jomwlmvf wo aomlwosWsfhzvs|'z fm`h`fafmw plwe wefzf omòlm` f~fmwz$ mow omd| woysowfjw wef whuyh|fsz' fulzwlm` WHSY lm~fzwafmwz hmg wo o~fszfflwz nosfjdozvsf alwl`hwlom yso`shaz$ cvw hdzo wo affw wefYhmfd'z zwhwvwos| ahmghwf wo iisf~lfp wef jvssfmw zwhwf on wef

nlmhmjlhd ahsbfwz hmg wef sf`vdhwos| z|zwfa-''

C- Chjb`sovmg

Lm wef nhdd on 3989$ h zfslfz on sf~fdhwlomz hcovwnosfjdozvsf gojvafmwhwlom lssf`vdhslwlfz elw wef eovzlmàhsbfwz- Wef wshmznfs on h ysoyfsw|'z wlwdf nsoa wef aosw`hòs%wef eoafopmfs, wo wef aosw`h`ff %w|yljhdd| h chmb os h wsvzw,


11/171

mfjfzzhs| nos h zvjjfzznvd nosfjdozvsf sfxvlsfz h zfslfz onzwfyz fzwhcdlzefg c| zwhwf dhp-T3T Hz nvswefs gfzjslcfg cfdop$gfyozlwlomz whbfm lm h ~hslfw| on jhzfz lm pelje eoafopmfszpfsf nlèwlm` nosfjdozvsf hjwlomz lmgljhwfg wehw aosw`h`fzfs~ljfs faydo|ffz!!peo pfsf sfxvlsfg wo eh~f yfszomhd

bmopdfg`f on wef ahwwfsz wo pelje wef| pfsf hwwfzwlm` lm weflshnnlgh~lwz!!pfsf zl`mlm` evmgsfgz on wefzf gojvafmwz h gh|-Owefs gojvafmwz hyyfhsfg wo eh~f cffm chjbghwfg laysoyfsd| hmglmfnnfjwl~fd| os lmjossfjwd| mowhsl{fg- Peldf wefzfgojvafmwhwlom lssf`vdhslwlfz ah| zovmg almos$ wef| eh~f wefyowfmwlhd wo wesop wef nosfjdozvsf z|zwfa!!hmg yozzlcd| wefaosw`h`f dohm z|zwfa hmg eovzlm` ahsbfw lwzfdn!!lmwo wvsaold-Hw h almlava$ lm jfswhlm jhzfz$ zl`mfsz on hnnlgh~lwz hyyfhs woeh~f zl`mfg gojvafmwz hwwfzwlm` wo lmnosahwlom wehw wef| glgmow ~fsln| hmg plweovw h mowhs| ysfzfmw- Ln welz lz wef fuwfmwon wef lssf`vdhslwlfz$ wefm wef lzzvf ah| cf dlalwfg wo wefzfzl`mfsz hmg wef nosfjdozvsf ysojffglm`z wef| pfsf lm~od~fg lm$hmg lm ahm| jhzfz$ wef lssf`vdhslwlfz ah| yowfmwlhdd| cfsfafglfg c| sf~lfplm` wef gojvafmwz aosf weosovèd| hmg wefmsfzvcalwwlm` wefa- Ln$ eopf~fs$ wef ysocdfa lz sfdhwfg mowzlayd| wo h dlalwfg mvacfs on nosfjdozvsf gojvafmwz cvw hdzo wolssf`vdhslwlfz lm wef aosw`h`f osl`lmhwlom hmg yoodlm` ysojfzz$wefm wef layhjw on wef lssf`vdhslwlfz jovdg cf nhs csohgfs$hnnfjwlm` h ~hzw mvacfs on lm~fzwosz lm wef aosw`h`f!chjbfgzfjvslwlfz %ACZ, ahsbfw$ hdsfhg| joaydfwfg nosfjdozvsfz$ hmgjvssfmw eoafopmfsz- Welz dhwwfs zjfmhslo jovdg sfzvdw lm

fuwfmzl~f dlwl`hwlom$ hm fuwfmgfg nsff{f lm wef nosfjdozvsfahsbfw$ hmg zl`mlnljhmw zwsfzz om chmb chdhmjf zeffwz hslzlm`nsoa wef zvczwhmwlhd sfyvsjehzf dlhcldlw| wehw jhm hslzf nsoaalzwhbfz os alzsfysfzfmwhwlomz lm aosw`h`f gojvafmwz-T:T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T3T Wefzf zwfyz gfyfmg om pefwefs h zwhwf lz h kvgljlhd nosfjdozvsfzwhwf os h mom!kvgljlhd nosfjdozvsf zwhwf$ hz nvswefs gfzjslcfg cfdop$lm noowmowf 80-

T:T Ln aosw`h`f gojvafmwhwlom ehz fssosz os alzsfysfzfmwhwlomz$cv|fsz on wef aosw`h`f yhyfs jhm iiyvw!chjb'' wef aosw`h`f wo lwz

osl`lmhwos hmg sfxvlsf wefa wo sfyvsjehzf wef aosw`h`f- Nos h aosfjoaydfwf glzjvzzlom on welz yozzlcldlw|$ zff Zfjwlomz G-8-c hmg G-3-Zf~fshd hmhd|zwz hmg fuyfswz eh~f zyfjvdhwfg om wef yowfmwlhd nos

plgfzysfhg layhjw- Aos`hm Zwhmdf|$ Eovzlm` Ahsbfw Lmzlèwz; Phzelm`wom$Pf Eh~f h Ysocdfa %Ojw- 83$ 3989,2 Haefszw Aosw`h`f Lmzlèw$ WefHnnlgh~lw Nlhzjo!!Laydljhwlomz nos Lm~fzwosz lm Ysl~hwf DhcfdZfjvslwlfz %Ojw- 83$ 3989,2 NCS Jhylwhd Ahsbfwz$ Jomnfsfmjf Jhdd;Nosfjdozvsf Ahmlh; Cl` Gfhd os Mow? %Ojw- 86$ 3989, %efsflmhnwfs iiNCS


12/171

Nosfjdozvsf Ahmlh Jomnfsfmjf Jhdd'',- Lm h jomnfsfmjf jhdd plwelm~fzwosz$ Khalf Glaom$ JFO on KYAos`hm Jehzf$ zyfjvdhwfg wehw weflzzvf jovdg flwefs cf h iicdly'' os h aosf fuwfmgfg ysocdfa plwe iihdow on jomzfxvfmjfz$ aozw on pelje pldd cf hg~fszf om f~fs|cog|-''Jhsglnn @hsjlh$ KYA om Nosfjdozvsfz$ AFSZ$ Nlmhmjlhd Wlafz Hdyeh~lddf

Cdo` %Ojw- 8:$ 3989, %omdlmf hw nwhdyeh~lddf-nw-joa/cdo`/3989/89/8:/:>/kya!om!nosfjdozvsfz!afsz/, %efsflmhnwfs iiKYA om Nosfjdozvsfz$AFSZ'', %iiLn |ov whdb hcovw wesff os novs pffbz lw pldd cf h cdly lmwef eovzlm` ahsbfw- Ln lw pfmw om nos h dom` yfslog on wlaf$ lw plddeh~f h dow on jomzfxvfmjfz$ aozw on pelje pldd cf hg~fszf omf~fs|cog|-'',-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

J- Wlafdlmf

Hnwfs wef eovzlm` ahsbfw zwhswfg wo joddhyzf lm 399>$ weffnnfjwz slyydfg wesov`e wef nlmhmjlhd zfjwos hmg dfg woglzsvywlomz lm wef jsfglw ahsbfwz lm 3995 hmg 399T Eopf~fs$ pefm wef eovzlm` cvccdf cvszw$ hmg wefmvacfs on gfdlmxvfmjlfz cf`hm wo slzf$ wef sodf on zfs~ljfszf~od~fg jossfzyomglm`d|-T0T Zfs~ljfs nojvz zelnwfg nsoa


13/171

yfsnosalm` yvsfd| hgalmlzwshwl~f whzbz wo fm`h`lm` lm hjwl~fdozz alwl`hwlom fnnoswz-T5T Zfs~ljfsz novmg wefazfd~fzsfzyomzlcdf nos ysojfzzlm` hdd gfnhvdwz$ aoglnljhwlomz$ zeoswzhdfz$ hmg nosfjdozvsfz-T$3989, %omdlmf hw ppp-zl`whsy-ò~/sfyoswz/jom`sfzz/3989/Ojwocfs3989_Xvhswfsd|_Sfyosw_wo_Jom`sfzz-ygn, %efsflmhnwfs iiOjwocfs3989 ZL@WHSY Sfyosw'',-

T>T Zfs~ljfs gvwlfz lmjdvgfg nlfdglm` cossopfs lmxvlslfz$joddfjwlm` aosw`h`f yh|afmwz nsoa wef cossopfsz$ hmg sfalwwlm` aosw`h`fyh|afmwz wo wef wsvzw- Zff Lg- hw 860$ 8>7- Zff hdzo Jom`sfzzlomhdO~fszlèw Yhmfd$ Ahsje O~fszlèw Sfyosw; Nosfjdozvsf Jslzlz; Posblm`Wophsg h Zodvwlom$ hw 79!73 %Ahs- >$ 3999

T0T Zff Ahsje 399< O~fszlèw Sfyosw$ zvysh mowf >$ hw 79-T5T Zff Ahsje 399< O~fszlèw Sfyosw$ zvysh mowf >$ hw 79!73- Zff

hdzo Ojwocfs 3989 ZL@WHSY Sfyosw$ zvysh mowf 6$ hw 865-T


14/171

nhjfg plwe sf~fdhwlomz wehw soco!zl`mfsz ehg zl`mfg wfmz onweovzhmgz on nosfjdozvsf gojvafmwz plweovw hjwvhdd| ~fsln|lm`wef lmnosahwlom lm wefa$ Chmb on Hafsljh hmmovmjfg om Ojwocfs5$ 3989$ wehw lw povdg nsff{f nosfjdozvsf zhdfz lm hdd 69zwhwfz vmwld lw jovdg lm~fzwl`hwf hmg hggsfzz wef

lssf`vdhslwlfz-T8>T @AHJ Aosw`h`f woob zlaldhs hjwlom$hmmovmjlm` wehw peldf lw povdg mow zvzyfmg nosfjdozvsfz$ lw ehgiiwfayoshsld| zvzyfmgfg f~ljwlomz hmg yozw!nosfjdozvsfjdozlm`z'' lm 3: zwhwfz-T80T Lm h zwhwfafmw$ lw sfnfssfg wo weflzzvf hz h iiysojfgvshd fssos - - - lm jfswhlm hnnlgh~lwz'' hmgzwhwfg wehw iipf hsf jomnlgfmw wehw wef ysojfzzlm` fssosz glgmow sfzvdw lm hm| lmhyysoyslhwf nosfjdozvsfz-'' @AHJ hdzohmmovmjfg wehw wef joayhm| ehg whbfm wesff sfafglhd zwfyz wohggsfzz wef ysocdfa; hgglwlomhd fgvjhwlom hmg wshlmlm` nosfaydo|ffz$ wef sfdfhzf on h iiaosf socvzw yodlj|'' wo `o~fsmwef ysojfzz$ hmg wef elslm` on hgglwlomhd zwhnn wo hzzlzw plwenosfjdozvsf ysojfzzlm`-T85T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T88T Aosw`h`fz wehw hsf aosf wehm 95!nlszwefhslm`-jna,2 Jom`sfzzlomhd O~fszl`ewYhmfd$ JOY Efhslm`; Joylm` plwe wef Nosfjdozvsf Jslzlz lm Yslmjf@fos`f'z Jovmw|$ Ahs|dhmg %Nfc- 30$ 399T83T Wef gfwhldz on iisoco!zl`mfsz'' hjwlomz zvsnhjfg om wefLmwfsmfw lm Zfywfacfs 3989$ lmjdvglm` ~lgfo hmg wshmzjslywlomz ongfyozlwlomz nldfg c| soco!zl`mfsz- Zff$ f-`-$ Wef Ndoslgh NosfjdozvsfNshvg Pfcdo`$ Kfnnsf| Zwfyehm Hnnlgh~lwz iPlwegshpm' c| Ndoslgh Gfnhvdw


15/171

Dhp @sovy %Zfyw- 86$ 3989, %omdlmf hw ndoslghnosfjdozvsfnshvg-joa/3989/9

T8:T @AHJ Aosw`h`f lz h zvczlglhs| on Hdd| Nlmhmjlhd- Wef Yhmfdfuhalmfg Hdd| Nlmhmjlhd$ wefm mhafg @AHJ$ lm gfwhld lm lwz Ahsje 3989sfyosw- Zff Jom`sfzzlomhd O~fszlèw Yhmfd$ Ahsje O~fszlèw Sfyosw; WefVmlxvf Wsfhwafmw on @AHJ Vmgfs WHSY %Ahs- 88$ 3989, %omdlmf hwjoy-zfmhwf-ò~/gojvafmwz/joy!9:8889!sfyosw-ygn,-

T87T Nfgfshd Mhwlomhd Aosw`h`f Hzzoj- ~- Mljoddf Cshgcvs|$ zvyshmowf 83- Wefsf hsf wpo yslahs| jomjfsmz plwe hnnlgh~lwz- Nlszw; hsf wefhnnlgh~lwz hjjvshwf? Nos fuhaydf$ f~fm ln wef eoafopmfs lz lmgfcwfg$wef haovmw on wef lmgfcwfgmfzz lz h yhsw on wef hwwfzwhwlom- Wef haovmwon wef lmgfcwfgmfzz avzw cf hjjvshwf cfjhvzf wefsf alèw cf hzvczfxvfmw gfnljlfmj| kvgàfmw h`hlmzw wef eoafopmfs$ pelje povdgsfxvlsf wef eoafopmfs wo jo~fs wef sfahlmlm` haovmw opfg wo wef dfmgfs-Hmg f~fm ln wefsf phz mo gfnljlfmj| kvgàfmw$ hm lmndhwfg jdhla povdg

lmjsfhzf wef sfjo~fs| on wef aosw`h`f zfs~ljfs nsoa wef nosfjdozvsfzhdf ysojffgz wo wef gfwslafmw on owefs yhswlfz lm wef ysojfzz- Zfjomg$f~fm ln wef lmnosahwlom lm wef hnnlgh~lw lz jossfjw$ lw avzw cf zposmovw c| zoafomf plwe yfszomhd bmopdfg`f on wef lmgfcwfgmfzz2 owefsplzflw lz efhszh| hmg `fmfshdd| mow hgalzzlcdf hz f~lgfmjf- Zff$ f-`-$Wshmzjslyw on Jovsw Ysojffglm`z$ @AHJ Aosw`h`f$ DDJ ~- Gfcclf ^lzjhso$fw hd-$ Mo- 9098:957JL %Ndh- Jls- Jw- Hys- 0$ 3989, %omdlmf hwndoslghnosfjdozvsfnshvg-joa/py!jomwfmw/vydohgz/3989/97/979089-ygn,%glzjvzzlm` pefwefs hnnfjwfg hnnlgh~lwz pfsf hgalzzlcdf,- Zff `fmfshdd|Jom`sfzzlomhd O~fszlèw Yhmfd$ Pslwwfm Wfzwlaom| on Bhwefslmf Yoswfs$

ysonfzzos on dhp$ Vml~fszlw| on Loph Joddf`f on Dhp$ JOY Efhslm` omWHSY Nosfjdozvsf Alwl`hwlom Yso`shaz %Ojw- 30$ 3989, %omdlmf hwjoy-zfmhwf-ò~/gojvafmwz/wfzwlaom|!893089!yoswfs-ygn, %efsflmhnwfsiiPslwwfm Wfzwlaom| on Bhwefslmf Yoswfs'',-

T86T Nfgfshd Mhwlomhd Aosw`h`f Hzzoj- ~- Mljoddf Cshgcvs|$ zvyshmowf 83- Lm hgglwlom$ h Ndoslgh jovsw hgaomlzefg @AHJ nos zlaldhsysocdfaz lm 399>- Ydhlmwlnn'z Mowljf on Joaydlhmjf plwe welz Jovsw'zOsgfs Ghwfg Ah| 8$ 399>$ WJLN SF93 ~- Dflcoplw{$ Mo-


16/171

8>3997JH9975:6UUUUAH %Kvmf 87$ 399>, %gfwhldlm` @AHJ'z yodljlfz omhnnlgh~lwz nldfg lm nosfjdozvsf jhzfz,- Wefzf hjwlomz$ ln wsvf$ povdgcf lmjomzlzwfmw plwe wef vzvhd gojvafmwhwlom sfxvlsfafmwz mfjfzzhs| nosysoyfs ysojfzzlm` on h nosfjdozvsf$ `l~lm` slzf wo jomjfsmz wehw wefnosfjdozvsf phz mow df`hdd| zvnnljlfmw- Zff `fmfshdd| Pslwwfm Wfzwlaom|

on Bhwefslmf Yoswfs$ zvysh mowf 87-T8>T Chmb on Hafsljh Josyoshwlom$ Zwhwfafmw nsoa Chmb on Hafsljh

Eoaf Dohmz %Ojw- 5$ 3989, %omdlmf hw afglhsooa-chmbonhafsljh-joa/yeofmlu-{ewad?j13:769:.y1lsod!mfpzHswljdf.LG18759>60.elèdlèw1,%efsflmhnwfs iiZwhwfafmw nsoa Chmb on Hafsljh Eoaf Dohmz'',- Hw wefzhaf wlaf$ Chmb on Hafsljh h`sffg wo lmgfamln| Nlgfdlw| MhwlomhdNlmhmjlhd$ h wlwdf lmzvsfs$ nos dozzfz glsfjwd| lmjvssfg c| iinhldvsfwo joayd| plwe zwhwf dhp os dojhd yshjwljf om cowe wshmzhjwlomz lmpelje nosfjdozvsf ehz hdsfhg| ojjvssfg os cffm lmlwlhwfg hmg weozf wocf lmlwlhwfg lm wef nvwvsf-'' Zff Nlgfdlw| Mhwlomhd Nlmhmjlhd$ Nlgfdlw|Mhwlomhd Nlmhmjlhd$ Lmj-$ Sfyoswz FYZ on 9-:> %Ojw- 39$ 3989, %omdlmfhw nldfz-zehsfeodgfs-joa/gopmdohgz/NMW/89680T80T Wpfmw|!wpo zwhwfz sfxvlsf kvgljlhd o~fszlèw on nosfjdozvsfysojffglm`z- Lm wefzf kvgljlhd nosfjdozvsf zwhwfz wef aosw`h`ff avzwfzwhcdlze lwz jdhla!!zeop wehw h cossopfs lz lm gfnhvdw!!cfnosf h

kvg`f- Lm mom!kvgljlhd zwhwfz h nosfjdozvsf jhm ysojffg vyom hgfxvhwfhmg wlafd| mowljf wo wef cossopfs$ hz gfnlmfg c| zwhwvwf- Lm mom!kvgljlhd zwhwfz$ h yopfs on zhdf jdhvzf lmjdvgfg lm h gffg on wsvzwhddopz h wsvzwff wo jomgvjw h mom!kvgljlhd nosfjdozvsf- Mom!kvgljlhdnosfjdozvsfz jhm ysojffg aosf xvljbd| zlmjf wef| go mow sfxvlsfhgkvgljhwlom- Aosw`h`f Chmbfsz Hzzojlhwlom$ Kvgljlhd ^fszvz Mom!Kvgljlhd Nosfjdozvsf %Ojw- 3>$ 3989, %omdlmf hw ppp-achh-os`/nldfz/SfzovsjfJfmwfs/NosfjdozvsfYsojfzz/Kvgljlhd^fszvzMom!


17/171

KvgljlhdNosfjdozvsf-ygn,- W|yljhdd|$ zwhwfz wehw sfd| om aosw`h`fz hsfkvgljlhd nosfjdozvsf zwhwfz$ peldf zwhwfz wehw sfd| om gffgz on wsvzwhsf mom!kvgljlhd nosfjdozvsf zwhwfz- Zwhmghsg . Yoos'z$ ZwsvjwvsfgNlmhmjf Sfzfhsje Pffb; Eop Pldd wef Nosfjdozvsf Jslzlz Hnnfjw V-Z- EoafYsljfz? %Ojw- 38$ 3989, %efsflmhnwfs iiZ.Y om Nosfjdozvsf Jslzlz'',-

T85T Hdd| Nlmhmjlhd$ Lmj-$ @AHJ Aosw`h`f Yso~lgfz Vyghwf omAosw`h`f Zfs~ljlm` Ysojfzz %Zfyw- 37$ 3989, %omdlmf hw afglh-hdd|-joa/lmgfu-yey?z17:.lwfa1780,-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Wefzf ~odvmwhs|$ ysl~hwfd| gfwfsalmfg zvzyfmzlomz pfsfcslfn-T8


18/171

T33T Zff Pslwwfm Wfzwlaom| on Bhwefslmf Yoswfs$ zvysh mowf 87$ hw89 %iiLm wef phbf on wefzf yhswlfz' dom`zwhmglm` hddf`hwlomz hmgnlmglm`z on lmhyysoyslhwf hmg lddf`hd yshjwljfz$ L ha vmhcdf wo `l~fpflèw wo sfjfmw zwhwfafmwz c| chmbz zvje hz Chmb on Hafsljh wehw omd|89 wo 36 on wef nlszw zf~fshd evmgsfg dohmz wehw lw ehz sf~lfpfg eh~f

ysocdfaz-'',-T3:T Pfddz Nhsò . Joayhm|$ Pfddz Nhsò Yso~lgfz Vyghwf om

Nosfjdozvsf Hnnlgh~lwz hmg Aosw`h`f Zfjvslwl{hwlomz %Ojw- 30$ 3989,%omdlmf hw ppp-pfddznhsò-joa/ysfzz/3989/39898930_Aosw`h`f,%efsflmhnwfs iiPfddz Nhsò Vyghwf om Hnnlgh~lwz hmg Aosw`h`fZfjvslwl{hwlomz'',-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Afhmpeldf$ hz wef sf~fdhwlomz on lssf`vdhslwlfz xvljbd|avdwlydlfg$ zoaf hs`vfg wehw o~fs hmg hco~f wef chmbz' hmgzfs~ljfsz' ~odvmwhs| hjwlomz$ wef nfgfshd ò~fsmafmw zeovdglayozf h mhwlomplgf aoshwoslva om nosfjdozvsfz-T37T Eovzlm` hmgVschm Gf~fdoyafmw Zfjsfwhs| Zehvm Gomo~hm sfkfjwfg wef lgfh$hs`vlm` wehw iih mhwlomhd$ cdhmbfw aoshwoslva om hddnosfjdozvsf zhdfz povdg go nhs aosf ehsa wehm òog-'' T36T Hwwef zhaf wlaf$ om Ojwocfs 8:$ hwwosmf|z `fmfshd nsoa hdd 69zwhwfz T3>T hmmovmjfg h clyhswlzhm fnnosw wo doob lmwo wefyozzlcldlw| wehw gojvafmwz os hnnlgh~lwz pfsf laysoyfsd|zvcalwwfg lm wefls kvslzgljwlomz-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T37T Zff$ f-`-$ Onnljf on Zfmhwos Ehss| Sflg$ Sflg Pfdjoafz Chmb onHafsljh Gfjlzlom$ Jhddz Om Owefsz Wo Noddop Zvlw %Ojw- 5$ 3989, %omdlmf

hw sflg-zfmhwf-ò~/mfpzsooa/ys_898995_chmbonhafsljh-jna, %efsflmhnwfsiiSflg Pfdjoafz Chmb on Hafsljh Gfjlzlom'',2 Gfhm Chbfs$ NosfjdozvsfAoshwoslva; Jshjblm` Gopm om Dlhs Dlfmz$ Jfmwfs nos Fjomoalj hmg Yodlj|Sfzfhsje %Ojw- 85$ 3989, %omdlmf hw ppp-jfys-mfw/lmgfu-yey/oy!fgz!.!jodvamz/oy!fgz!.!jodvamz/nosfjdozvsf!aoshwoslva!jshjblm`!gopm!om!dlhs!dlfmz, %efsflmhnwfs iiNosfjdozvsf Aoshwoslva; Jshjblm` Gopm om DlhsDlfmz'',-

T36T Zehvm Gomo~hm$ zfjsfwhs|$ V-Z- Gfyhswafmw on Eovzlm` hmg VschmGf~fdoyafmw$ Eop Pf Jhm Sfhdd| Efdy Nhaldlfz %Ojw- 85$ 3989, %omdlmf hwyoswhd-evg-ò~/yoswhd/yh`f/yoswhd/EVG/ysfzz/cdo`/3989/cdo`3989!89!85,-

T3>T Mhwlomhd Hzzojlhwlom on Hwwosmf|z @fmfshd$ 69 Zwhwfz Zl`mAosw`h`f Nosfjdozvsf Kolmw Zwhwfafmw %Ojw- 8:$ 3989, %omdlmf hwppp-mhh`-os`/kolmw!zwhwfafmw!on!wef!aosw`h`f!nosfjdozvsf!avdwlzwhwf!`sovy-yey, %efsflmhnwfs ii69 Zwhwfz Zl`m Aosw`h`f Nosfjdozvsf KolmwZwhwfafmw'',-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Hdweovè wef yvcdlj nojvz wogh| dlfz `fmfshdd| omnosfjdozvsfz$ wef yozzlcldlw| on gojvafmw lssf`vdhslwlfz lm


19/171

aosw`h`f wshmzhjwlomz ehz fuyhmgfg cf|omg wefls zl`mlnljhmjf wonosfjdozvsf ysojffglm`z- Sfjfmwd|$ lm~fzwosz eh~f cf`vm wojdhla wehw zlaldhs lssf`vdhslwlfz lm osl`lmhwlom hmg yoodlm` ondohmz zeovdg wsl``fs hjwlomz h`hlmzw fmwlwlfz lm wef aosw`h`fosl`lmhwlom$ zfjvslwl{hwlom$ hmg zfs~ljlm` lmgvzwslfz-T30T

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!T30T Jhzfz lm~od~fg zvlwz h`hlmzw Chmb on Hafsljh %hz wef yhsfmw on

dohm osl`lmhwos Jovmws|plgf, jdhlalm` ~lodhwlomz on sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmgphsshmwlfz hmg zovèw wo fmnosjf yvw!chjb yso~lzlomz- @sffmpljeNlmhmjlhd Zfs~ljfz Glzwsfzzfg Nvmg : D-D-J- ~z- Jovmws|plgf NlmhmjlhdJosy$ fw hd-$ 8;95!j~!88:7:!SKE %Z-G-M-\- Ojw- 86$ 3989,2 Noowcslg`fDlalwfg Wsvzw hmg OEY Oyyoswvmlw| Wsvzw ~z- Chmb on Hafsljh$ J^99:>0%Z-G-M-\- Ojw 8$ 3989,-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

G- Df`hd Jomzfxvfmjfz on Gojvafmw Lssf`vdhslwlfz

Wef yozzlcdf df`hd jomzfxvfmjfz on wef gojvafmwhwlomlssf`vdhslwlfz gfzjslcfg hco~f shm`f nsoa almos$ jvshcdf wlwdfgfnfjwz nos jfswhlm nosfjdozfg eoafz lm jfswhlm zwhwfz wo aosfzfslovz jomzfxvfmjfz zvje hz wef vmfmnosjfhcldlw| onnosfjdozvsf jdhlaz hmg owefs opmfszely slèwz wehw sfd| om wefhcldlw| wo fzwhcdlze jdfhs wlwdf wo sfhd ysoyfsw|$ nosjfg yvw!chjbz on gfnfjwl~f aosw`h`fz wo osl`lmhwosz$ hmg ahsbfwvyefh~hd- Wef zf~fslw| hmg dlbfdleoog on wefzf ~hslovz yozzlcdfjomzfxvfmjfz gfyfmg om pefwefs wef lssf`vdhslwlfz hsf yfs~hzl~f

hmg pefm lm wef ysojfzz wef| ojjvssfg-Fnnfjwl~f wshmznfsz on sfhd fzwhwf gfyfmg om yhswlfz' cflm`

hcdf wo hmzpfs zffalm`d| zwshlèwnosphsg xvfzwlomz; peo opmzwef ysoyfsw|? eop glg wef| joaf wo opm lw? jhm hm|omf ahbf hjoayfwlm` jdhla wo lw? Wef lssf`vdhslwlfz eh~f wef yowfmwlhd woahbf wefzf zffalm`d| zlaydf xvfzwlomz joaydfu- Hz h wesfzeodgahwwfs$ h yhsw| zffblm` wo fmnosjf wef slèwz hzzojlhwfg plwewef aosw`h`f avzw eh~f zwhmglm` lm jovsw$ afhmlm` wehw h yhsw|avzw eh~f hm lmwfsfzw lm wef ysoyfsw| zvnnljlfmw wehw h jovswpldd efhs wefls jdhla hmg jhm yso~lgf wefa plwe sfdlfn-T35T Nos

h aosw`h`f$ iiRhQ aosw`h`f ah| cf fmnosjfg omd| c|$ os lmcfehdn on$ h yfszom peo lz fmwlwdfg wo fmnosjf wef ocdl`hwlomwef aosw`h`f zfjvsfz-'' T3


20/171

hwwhjefg wo wef aosw`h`f hmg wef mowf$ wehw yhsw| ah| mow cfhcdf wo whbf wef ysoyfsw| plwe jdfhs wlwdf wehw jhm cf yhzzfgom wo hmowefs cv|fs-T:8T Wevz$ ln yslos wshmznfsz on wefaosw`h`f pfsf vmzvjjfzznvd os laysoyfs$ zvczfxvfmw wshmznfsz onwef ysoyfsw|$ zvje hz h nosfjdozvsf os f~fm hm osglmhs| zhdf$

jovdg cf hnnfjwfg- Nvswefs$ nhldvsf wo nosfjdozf ysoyfsd|!!pefwefs cfjhvzf wef nosfjdozlm` yhsw| glg mow hjwvhdd| eodg wefaosw`h`f hmg wef mowf$ os cfjhvzf soco!zl`mlm` hnnfjwfg wefeoafopmfs'z gvf ysojfzz sl`ewz!!afhmz wehw wef yslos eoafopmfsah| cf hcdf wo hzzfsw jdhlaz h`hlmzw h zvczfxvfmw opmfs on wefysoyfsw|-T:3T Lm welz ph|$ gojvafmwhwlom lssf`vdhslwlfz jhmhnnfjw wlwdf wo h ysoyfsw| hw h mvacfs on zwh`fz$ hz nvswefsgfzjslcfg cfdop-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T35T Zff Zwfyefm S- Cvjefmsowe hmg @sfwjefm G- Kfnnslfz$ SfjfmwNosfjdozvsf Jhzfz; Dfmgfsz Cfphsf %Kvmf 3990, %omdlmf hwppp-hchmfw-os`/syyw/yvcdljhwlomz/fsfyosw/3990/>/OeloNosfjdozvsfJhzfz-ygn,2 Pfddz Nhs`o ~- Kosghm$ ,- Hjjosglm`d|$ h zfjomg zfw on ysocdfaz sfdhwfz wo wef jehlmon wlwdf om aosw`h`fz hmg wef hcldlw| on wef nosfjdozlm` yhsw| wo yso~fwehw lw ehz df`hd zwhmglm` wo nosfjdozf- Peldf wefzf ysocdfaz hsf mowdlalwfg wo wef zfjvslwl{hwlom ahsbfw$ wef| hsf fzyfjlhdd| hjvwf noszfjvslwl{fg dohmz cfjhvzf wefsf hsf aosf joaydfu jehlm on wlwdf lzzvfzlm~od~fg-

T3


21/171

jomwshjwvhd chs`hlm ahgf cfwpffm cossopfsz hmg dfmgfsz-T:9T Wehw yhsw| avzw flwefs opm wef aosw`h`f hmg wef mowf os cf

df`hdd| fayopfsfg wo hjw om wef opmfs'z cfehdn- Zfs~ljfsz hjwlm` omcfehdn on h wsvzw os hm osl`lmhwos go mow opm wef aosw`h`f$ cvw c|jomwshjw hsf `shmwfg wef hcldlw| wo hjw om cfehdn on wef wsvzw os wef

osl`lmhwos- Zff Nfgfshd Wshgf Joaalzzlom$ Nhjwz nos Jomzvafsz %omdlmfhw ppp-nwj-ò~/cjy/fgv/yvcz/jomzvafs/eoafz/sfh89-zewa, %hjjfzzfg Mo~-83$ 3989, %iiLm wogh|'z ahsbfw$ dohmz hmg wef slèwz wo zfs~ljf wefaonwfm hsf covèw hmg zodg- Lm ahm| jhzfz$ wef joayhm| wehw |ov zfmg|ovs yh|afmw wo lz mow wef joayhm| wehw opmz |ovs dohm-'',- Zff hdzoOjwocfs 3989 ZL@WHSY Sfyosw$ zvysh mowf 6$ hw 8>9 %gfzjslclm` jdlfmwzon zfs~ljfsz,-

T:8T Dhpz ò~fsmlm` wef sfafglfz h~hldhcdf wo h dfmgfs nosfjdozlmòm h ysoyfsw| ~hs| jomzlgfshcd|- Zwhwfz hdzo glnnfs ahsbfgd| lm eopdom` lw whbfz wef dfmgfs wo nosfjdozf gfyfmglm` om wef h~hldhcdfysojfgvsfz- Lm `fmfshd$ jdhlahmwz jhm zffb wo sfjo~fs dohm haovmwz c|nosfjdozlm` om wef ysoyfsw| zfjvslm` wef gfcw- Ln wef dohm lz iimom!sfjovszf$'' wef dfmgfs omd| ah| nosfjdozf vyom wef ysoyfsw|$ cvw ln wefdohm lz iisfjovszf$'' wef dfmgfs ah| nosfjdozf vyom wef ysoyfsw| hmgowefs cossopfs hzzfwz- Aozw zwhwfz hsf sfjovszf zwhwfz- H dohm lm hsfjovszf zwhwf hddopz h aosw`h`ff wo nosfjdozf vyom ysoyfsw| zfjvslm` hysoalzzos| mowf hmg$ ln wehw ysoyfsw| lz lmzvnnljlfmw wo glzjehs`f wefgfcw$ ao~f h`hlmzw wef cossopfs'z owefs hzzfwz- Lm mom!sfjovszf zwhwfz$sfjo~fs| on wef dohm haovmw lz dlalwfg wo wef dohm joddhwfshd- Yvwhmowefs ph|$ wef dfmgfs jhmmow ò hnwfs wef cossopfs'z owefs hzzfwz lmh mom!sfjovszf zwhwf ln wef ysoyfsw| lz lmzvnnljlfmw wo glzjehs`f wef

gfcw- Lw lz poswe mowlm` wehw f~fm lm sfjovszf zwhwfz$ `l~fm wefjvssfmw fjomoalj jdlahwf$ wef aosw`h`ffz' sfjovszf wo wef cossopfs'zyfszomhd hzzfwz ah| cf zoafpehw lddvzos| zlmjf wef| ah| cf almlahdsfdhwl~f wo wef jozwz hmg gfdh| lm yvszvlm` hmg joddfjwlm` om hgfnljlfmj| kvgàfmwz- Zff Hmgsh J- @efmw hmg Ahslhmmh Bvgd|hb$ Sfjovszfhmg Sfzlgfmwlhd Aosw`h`f Gfnhvdw; Wefos| hmg F~lgfmjf nsoa V-Z- Zwhwfz$Nfgfshd Sfzfs~f Chmb on Sljeaomg Posblm` Yhyfs$ Mo- 9

T:3T Jeslzwoyefs Dfplz Yfwfszom$ hzzojlhwf gfhm nos hjhgfaljhnnhlsz hmg ysonfzzos on dhp$ Z-K- Xvlmmf| Joddf`f on Dhp$ Vml~fszlw|

on Vwhe$ jom~fszhwlomz plwe Yhmfd zwhnn %Mo~- 5$ 3989,-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

8- Yowfmwlhd Ndhpz lm wef Sfjosglm` hmg Wshmznfs on Aosw`h`fz hmg^lodhwlomz on Yoodlm` hmg Zfs~ljlm` H`sffafmwz

h- Aosw`h`f Sfjosghwlom$ Yfsnfjwlm` Wlwdf$ hmg Wshmznfsslm`Wlwdf


22/171

l- WlwdfWef V-Z- sfhd ysoyfsw| ahsbfw gfyfmgz om h zfddfs'z hcldlw|

wo jom~f| iijdfhs wlwdf''; hm hzzvshmjf wehw wef yvsjehzfs opmzwef ysoyfsw| nsff on fmjvacshmjfz os joayfwlm` jdhlaz-T::T Dhpzò~fsmlm` wef wshmznfs on sfhd ysoyfsw| lm wef Vmlwfg Zwhwfz

pfsf gfzl`mfg wo jsfhwf h yvcdlj$ wshmzyhsfmw sfjosghwlomz|zwfa wehw zvyydlfz sfdlhcdf lmnosahwlom om opmfszelylmwfsfzwz lm ysoyfsw|- Fhje on wef 69 zwhwfz ehz dhpz ò~fsmlm`wlwdf wo dhmg plwelm lwz df`hd covmghslfz- F~fs| jovmw| lm wefjovmws| ahlmwhlmz sfjosgz on peo opmz dhmg wefsf$ on wshmznfszon opmfszely$ hmg on sfdhwfg aosw`h`fz os gffgz on wsvzw- Peldffhje zwhwf'z dhpz eh~f vmlxvf nfhwvsfz$ wefls chzljsfxvlsfafmwz hsf wef zhaf$ jomzlzwfmw plwe wef mowlom wehw wefyvsyozf on wef sfjosglm` z|zwfa lz wo fzwhcdlze jfswhlmw|sf`hsglm` ysoyfsw| opmfszely- Lm osgfs wo ysowfjw opmfszelylmwfsfzwz$ nvdd| fufjvwfg$ osl`lmhd %joaaomd| sfnfssfg wo hziipfw lmb'', gojvafmwz avzw cf sfjosgfg lm h `shmwos/`shmwfflmgfu hw h jovmw| sfjosglm` onnljf-T:7T Lm wef jhzf on hyvsjehzfs os wshmznfsff$ h ysoyfsd| sfjosgfg gffg gfzjslclm`cowe wef ysoyfsw| hmg wef yhswlfz wo wef wshmznfs fzwhcdlzefzysoyfsw| opmfszely-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T::T Cdhjb'z Dhp Gljwlomhs|$ hw 8633 %3997,-T:7T Zff Jlmjlmmhwl Dhp Sf~lfp Yhyfs om Nosfjdozvsf$ zvysh mowf 35-

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!ll- Wshmznfs

Lm h yvsjehzf on h eoaf vzlm` h aosw`h`f dohm$ sfxvlsfggojvafmwz lmjdvgf %h, h ysoalzzos| mowf fzwhcdlzelm` wefaosw`hòs'z yfszomhd dlhcldlw|$ %c, h aosw`h`f f~lgfmjlm` wefzfjvslw| lmwfsfzw lm wef vmgfsd|lm` joddhwfshd$ hmg %j, ln wefaosw`h`f lz wshmznfssfg$ ysoyfs hzzl`mafmwz on wef aosw`h`f hmgwef mowf-T:6T Wefsf hsf h mvacfs on ph|z nos h aosw`h`fosl`lmhwos wo ysojffg vyom fmwfslm` lmwo h dohm zfjvsfg c| sfhdysoyfsw|- Wef| ah| bffy wef dohm om wefls opm coobz2 wefzf hsfzo!jhddfg iipeodf dohmz-'' Eopf~fs$ ln wef dohm lz zodg lm hzfjomghs| ahsbfw!!flwefs hz h peodf dohm os lm h zfjvslwl{hwlom

ysojfzz!!wef dohm avzw cf ysoyfsd| wshmznfssfg wo wefyvsjehzfs- Wo cf wshmznfssfg ysoyfsd|$ cowe wef dohm hmghjjoayhm|lm` gojvafmwhwlom avzw cf wshmznfssfg wo wefyvsjehzfs$ hmg wef wshmznfs avzw cf sfjosgfg-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T:6T Wefsf hsf wpo gojvafmwz wehw mffg wo cf wshmznfssfg hz yhsw onwef zfjvslwl{hwlom ysojfzz!!h ysoalzzos| mowf hmg wef zfjvslw|lmzwsvafmw %wef aosw`h`f os gffg on wsvzw,- Wef ysoalzzos| mowf


23/171

facoglfz wef gfcw ocdl`hwlom$ peldf wef zfjvslw| lmzwsvafmw yso~lgfzwehw ln wef gfcw lz mow sfyhlg$ wef jsfglwos ah| zfdd wef gfzl`mhwfgjoddhwfshd %wef eovzf,- Cowe wef mowf hmg wef aosw`h`f mffg wo cfysoyfsd| wshmznfssfg- Plweovw wef mowf$ h aosw`h`f lz vmfmnosjfhcdf$peldf plweovw wef aosw`h`f$ h mowf lz zlayd| hm vmzfjvsfg gfcw

ocdl`hwlom$ mo glnnfsfmw nsoa jsfglw jhsg gfcw- Zff NCS NosfjdozvsfAhmlh Jomnfsfmjf Jhdd$ zvysh mowf :- Wef svdfz nos wefzf wshmznfsz hsf`fmfshdd| ò~fsmfg c| wef Vmlnosa Joaafsjlhd Jogf %VJJ,$ hdweovè omfhvweos zwhwfz wehw wef hyydljhwlom on wef VJJ wo wef wshmznfs on wefmowf lz mow jfswhlm- Zff Ghdf H- Pelwahm$ Eop Mfòwlhcldlw| Ehz NovdfgVy wef Zfjomghs| Aosw`h`f Ahsbfw$ hmg Pehw wo Go Hcovw Lw$ YfyyfsglmfDhp Sf~lfp$ ôd- :0$ hw 065!06< %3989,-

Zwhwfz hgoyw hswljdfz on hmg sf~lzlomz wo wef VJJ lmgl~lgvhdd|$ hmgzo wefsf jhm cf ~hslhwlom haom` zwhwfz lm wef hyydljhwlom on wef VJJ-Welz sfyosw gofz mow hwwfayw wo lgfmwln| hdd on wef yozzlcdflwfshwlomz- Shwefs$ lw gfzjslcfz `fmfshd hmg joaaom hyydljhwlomz on wefVJJ wo zvje wshmzhjwlomz-

Wefsf hsf wpo afweogz c| pelje h ysoalzzos| mowf ah| cfwshmznfssfg- Nlszw$ lw ah| cf wshmznfssfg c| iimfòwlhwlom$'' wefzl`mlm` o~fs on lmgl~lgvhd ysoalzzos| mowfz wesovè lmgoszfafmw$ lm wefzhaf ph| wehw h jefjb jhm cf wshmznfssfg ~lh lmgoszfafmw- Zff VJJZfj- Zfj- :!398$ :!39:- Wef yoodlm` hmg zfs~ljlm` h`sffafmwz %YZHz, noszfjvslwl{fg dohmz `fmfshdd| jomwfaydhwf wshmznfs wesovè mfòwlhwlom-W|yljhd dhm`vh`f lm YZHz sfxvlsfz wef gfdl~fs| wo wef zfjvslwl{hwlomwsvzw on wef mowfz hmg wef aosw`h`fz$ lmgoszfg lm cdhmb- Hdwfsmhwl~fd|$h ysoalzzos| mowf ah| cf wshmznfssfg c| h zhdf jomwshjw$ hdzo ò~fsmfg

c| pefwefs h zwhwf ehz hgoywfg yhswljvdhs sf~lzlomz wo wef VJJ- Lm ahm|zwhwfz$ lm osgfs nos h wshmznfs wo whbf ydhjf vmgfs wef sfdf~hmwyoswlom on wef VJJ$ wefsf hsf omd| wesff sfxvlsfafmwz; wef cv|fs on wefysoalzzos| mowf avzw `l~f ~hdvf$ wefsf avzw cf hm hvwefmwljhwfggojvafmw on zhdf wehw gfzjslcfz wef ysoalzzos| mowf$ hmg wef zfddfsavzw eh~f slèwz lm wef ysoalzzos| mowf cflm` zodg- VJJ Zfj-

Wef nlszw wpo sfxvlsfafmwz zeovdg cf fhzld| afw lm aozwzfjvslwl{hwlomz2 wef wshmznfs on wef aosw`h`f dohmz hw fhje zwh`f onwef zfjvslwl{hwlom lm~od~fz wef cv|fs `l~lm` wef zfddfs ~hdvf hmg h

gojvafmw on zhdf %h aosw`h`f yvsjehzf hmg zhdf h`sffafmw os h YZH, wehwzeovdg lmjdvgf h zjefgvdf lgfmwln|lm` wef ysoalzzos| mowfz lm~od~fg-Wef welsg sfxvlsfafmw$ eopf~fs$ wehw wef zfddfs avzw eh~f slèwz lm wefysoalzzos| mowf cflm` zodg$ lz aosf joaydljhwfg$ hz lw sfxvlsfz hmvmcsobfm jehlm on wlwdf chjb wo wef dohm'z osl`lmhwos- Peldf wef dohmzhdf gojvafmwz ydvz wefls zjefgvdfz hsf f~lgfmjf on zvje h jehlm onwlwdf$ wef| jhmmow fzwhcdlze wehw wef dohm phz mow ysf~lovzd| zodg wohmowefs yhsw|-


24/171

Nvswefs$ welz glzjvzzlom omd| hggsfzzfz wef ~hdlglw| on wshmznfszcfwpffm zfddfsz hmg cv|fsz on aosw`h`f dohmz- Lw gofz mow hggsfzz weffmnosjfhcldlw| on weozf dohmz h`hlmzw eoafopmfsz$ pelje sfxvlsfzye|zljhd yozzfzzlom on wef osl`lmhd mowf- Wevz$ nos cowe zfjvslwl{fghmg mom!zfjvslwl{fg dohmz$ lw lz mfjfzzhs| nos h yhsw| wo zeop wehw lw

lz fmwlwdfg wo fmnosjf wef ysoalzzos| mowf %hmg wefsfnosf `fmfshdd|wehw lw lz h eodgfs on wef ye|zljhd osl`lmhd mowf, lm osgfs wo joaydfwfh nosfjdozvsf zvjjfzznvdd|-

Yfsehyz aosf jslwljhdd|$ yhswlfz hsf nsff wo jomwshjw hsovmg wefVJJ- VJJ Zfj- 8!:93- Welz shlzfz wef xvfzwlom on pefwefs YZHz nos ACZyso~lgf nos h ~hslhmjf nsoa wef VJJ c| h`sffafmw on wef yhswlfz- WefYZH lz wef gojvafmw wehw yso~lgfz nos wef wshmznfs on wef aosw`h`f hmgmowfz nsoa wef zfjvslwl{hwlom zyomzos wo wef gfyozlwos hmg wefmjf wowef wsvzw- Wef YZH lz hdzo wef gojvafmw wehw jsfhwfz wef wsvzw- Wefwshmznfs nsoa wef osl`lmhwos wo wef zyomzos lz w|yljhdd| `o~fsmfg c| hzfyhshwf gojvafmw$ hdweov`e zfjwlomz on lw ah| cf lmjosyoshwfg c|sfnfsfmjf lm wef YZH-

Ln h YZH lz jomzlgfsfg h ~hslhwlom c| h`sffafmw nsoa wef VJJ$ wefmwefsf lz h xvfzwlom on pehw wef YZH lwzfdn sfxvlsfz wo wshmznfs wefaosw`h`f dohmz hmg pefwefs weozf sfxvlsfafmwz eh~f cffm afw- Lm zoafjhzfz$ YZHz hyyfhs wo sfxvlsf h joaydfwf jehlm on lmgoszfafmwz om wefmowfz nsoa osl`lmhwos vy wo wef gfyozlwos$ plwe h nlmhd lmgoszfafmw lmcdhmb wo wef wsvzw- H joaydfwf jehlm on lmgoszfafmwz$ shwefs wehm hzlm`df lmgoszfafmw lm cdhmb plwe wef mowfz wshmznfssfg wefsfhnwfs hzcfhsfs yhyfs$ lz layoswhmw nos fzwhcdlzelm` wef iichmbsvywj|sfaowfmfzz'' on wef wsvzw hzzfwz- H jslwljhd yhsw on zfjvslwl{hwlom lz

wo fzwhcdlze wehw wef wsvzw'z hzzfwz hsf chmbsvywj| sfaowf$ afhmlm`wehw wef| jovdg mow cf jdhlafg c| wef chmbsvywj| fzwhwf on hm vyzwsfhawshmznfsos on wef hzzfwz- Plweovw h joaydfwf jehlm on lmgoszfafmwz$ lwlz glnnljvdw$ ln mow layozzlcdf$ wo fzwhcdlze wehw wef dohmz pfsf lmnhjw wshmznfssfg nsoa osl`lmhwos wo zyomzos wo gfyozlwos wo wsvzw$shwefs wehm glsfjwd| nsoa osl`lmhwos os zyomzos wo wef wsvzw- Ln wefwshmznfs pfsf glsfjwd| nsoa wef osl`lmhwos os zyomzos wo wef wsvzw$ wefdohmz jovdg yozzlcd| cf jdhlafg hz yhsw on wef osl`lmhwos'z oszyomzos'z chmbsvywj| fzwhwf- Wef xvfzwlomz hcovw pehw wef wshmznfszsfxvlsfg$ wefsfnosf$ lm~od~f cowe wef xvfzwlom hz wo pefwefs wef

sfxvlsfg wshmznfsz hjwvhdd| ehyyfmfg$ hz pfdd hz pefwefs$ ln wef|ehyyfmfg$ wef| pfsf df`hdd| zvnnljlfmw-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

lll- Aosw`h`f Zfjvslwl{hwlom Ysojfzz

NL@VSF 8; WSHMZNFS ON SFDF^HMW YHYFSPOSB LM ZFJVSLWL[HWLOMYSOJFZZ T:>T


25/171

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T:>T NCS Nosfjdozvsf Ahmlh Jomnfsfmjf Jhdd$ zvysh mowf :-

Zfjvslwl{hwlomz on aosw`h`fz sfxvlsf avdwlydf wshmznfsz$hmg$ hjjosglm`d|$ avdwlydf hzzl`mafmwz- Aosw`h`fz wehw pfsfzfjvslwl{fg pfsf osl`lmhwfg wesovè chmbz hmg aosw`h`fcsobfsz!!aosw`h`f osl`lmhwosz- Mfuw wef| pfsf zfjvslwl{fg c|lm~fzwafmw chmbz!!wef zyomzosz!!wesovè wef vzf on zyfjlhdyvsyozf ~feljdfz$ wsvzwz wehw xvhdln| nos Sfhd Fzwhwf Aosw`h`fLm~fzwafmw Jomgvlw %SFALJ, zwhwvz- Wefzf wsvzwz hsf chmbsvywj|!sfaowf$ whu!fufayw ~feljdfz wehw yoodfg wef aosw`h`fzwshmznfssfg wo wefa hmg zodg lmwfsfzwz lm wef lmjoaf nsoa weozfaosw`h`fz wo lm~fzwosz lm wef nosa on zehsfz- Wef yoodz pfsfjoddhwfshdl{fg c| wef vmgfsd|lm` sfhd ysoyfsw|$ cfjhvzf haosw`h`f sfysfzfmwz h nlszw!dlfm zfjvslw| lmwfsfzw om hm hzzfwlm wef yood!!h eovzf-T:0T H ò~fsmlm` gojvafmw noszfjvslwl{hwlomz jhddfg h yoodlm` hmg zfs~ljlm` h`sffafmw %YZH,lmjdvgfz ~hslovz sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmg phsshmwlfz nos wefvmgfsd|lm` aosw`h`fz- Lw hdzo gfzjslcfz wef sfzyomzlcldlwlfz onwef wsvzwff$ peo lz sfzyomzlcdf nos eodglm` wef sfjosgfgaosw`h`f gojvafmwz$ hmg on wef zfs~ljfs$ peo ydh|z hm

hgalmlzwshwl~f sodf$ joddfjwlm` hmg glzcvszlm` aosw`h`f hmgsfdhwfg yh|afmwz om cfehdn on wef lm~fzwosz lm wef ACZ-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T:0T Nos hm o~fs~lfp on SFALJz$ zff Nfgfshd Mhwlomhd Aosw`h`fHzzojlhwlom$ Chzljz on SFALJz %Kvmf 8>$ 399 JNS Zfj- 8 %Hv`- 80$ 8


26/171

ppp-hafsljhmzfjvslwl{hwlom-joa/vydohgfgNldfz/SACZ&39Ovwdlmf-ygn,-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Hz gfzjslcfg hco~f$ lm osgfs wo jom~f| òog wlwdf lmwo wefwsvzw hmg yso~lgf wef wsvzw plwe cowe òog wlwdf wo wefjoddhwfshd hmg wef lmjoaf nsoa wef aosw`h`fz$ fhje wshmznfs lm

welz ysojfzz sfxvlsfg yhswljvdhs zwfyz-T:5T Aozw YZHz hsfò~fsmfg c| Mfp \osb dhp hmg jsfhwf wsvzwz ò~fsmfg c| Mfp \osbdhp-T:

T7:T Zff NCS Nosfjdozvsf Ahmlh Jomnfsfmjf Jhdd$ zvysh mowf :-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

^hslovz joaafmwhwosz eh~f cf`vm wo hzb pefwefs wef yoossfjosgbffylm` hmg fssos!nlddfg posb fuelclwfg lm nosfjdozvsfysojffglm`z$ gfzjslcfg hco~f$ lz dlbfd| wo eh~f ahsbfg fhsdlfs

zwh`fz on wef ysojfzz hz pfdd- Ln zo$ wef fnnfjw jovdg cf wehwslèwz pfsf mow ysoyfsd| wshmznfssfg gvslm` wef zfjvslwl{hwlomysojfzz zvje wehw wlwdf wo wef aosw`h`f hmg wef mowf alèw sfzwplwe hmowefs yhsw| lm wef ysojfzz owefs wehm wef wsvzw-T77T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T77T Zff$ f-`-$ NCS Nosfjdozvsf Ahmlh Jomnfsfmjf Jhdd$ zvysh mowf:-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


27/171

l~- AFSZLm hgglwlom wo wef jomjfsmz plwe wef zfjvslwl{hwlom ysojfzz

gfzjslcfg hco~f$ h afweog hgoywfg c| wef aosw`h`fzfjvslwl{hwlom lmgvzws| wo wshjb wshmznfsz on aosw`h`fzfs~ljlm` sl`ewz ehz joaf vmgfs xvfzwlom- H aosw`h`f gofz mow

mffg wo cf sfjosgfg wo cf fmnosjfhcdf hz cfwpffm wef aosw`h`oshmg wef aosw`h`ff os zvczfxvfmw wshmznfsff$ cvw vmdfzz haosw`h`f lz sfjosgfg$ lw gofz mow yso~lgf wef aosw`h`ff os lwzzvczfxvfmw wshmznfsff plwe ysloslw| o~fs zvczfxvfmw aosw`h`ffzos dlfm eodgfsz-T76T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T76T Sfzwhwfafmw %Welsg, on Ysoy- %Aosw`h`fz, Zfj- 6-7 jaw- C%8


28/171

T7-8 M-F- 3g 58 %M-\- 399>,-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

AFSZ fuyfslfmjfg shylg `sopwe gvslm` wef eovzlm` cooa-Zlmjf lwz lmjfywlom lm 8 alddlom aosw`h`fz eh~f cffmsf`lzwfsfg lm wef AFSZ z|zwfa hmg :: alddlom AFSZ!sf`lzwfsfgdohmz sfahlm ovwzwhmglm`-T69T Gvslm` wef zvaafs on 3989$ omffuyfsw fzwlahwfg wehw AFSZ phz lm~od~fg lm >9 yfsjfmw onaosw`h`f dohmz osl`lmhwfg lm wef Vmlwfg Zwhwfz-T68T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T69T AFSZ jom~fszhwlomz plwe Yhmfd zwhnn %Mo~- 89$ 3989,-T68T Jlmjlmmhwl Dhp Sf~lfp Yhyfs om Nosfjdozvsf$ zvysh mowf 35$ hw

8:>3-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Plgfzysfhg xvfzwlomz hcovw wef fnnljhj| on wef AFSZ aogfdglg mow hslzf gvslm` wef cooa$ pefm eoaf ysljfz pfsf fzjhdhwlm`hmg wef lmjlgfmjf on nosfjdozvsfz phz almlahd-T63T Cvw hznosfjdozvsfz cf`hm wo lmjsfhzf$ hmg gojvafmwhwlomlssf`vdhslwlfz zvsnhjfg lm zoaf jhzfz hmg shlzfg xvfzwlomzhcovw h plgf shm`f on df`hd lzzvfz$ lmjdvglm` wef df`hdlw| onnosfjdozvsf ysojffglm`z lm `fmfshd$T6:T zoaf dlwl`hmwz shlzfg

xvfzwlomz hcovw wef ~hdlglw| on AFSZ-T67T Wefsf lz dlalwfg jhzfdhp wo yso~lgf glsfjwlom$ cvw zoaf zwhwf jovswz eh~f sfmgfsfg~fsgljwz om wef lzzvf- Lm Ndoslgh$ nos fuhaydf$ hyyfddhwfjovswz eh~f gfwfsalmfg wehw AFSZ ehg zwhmglm` wo cslm` hnosfjdozvsf ysojffglm`-T66T Om wef owefs ehmg$ lm ^fsaomw$ hjovsw gfwfsalmfg wehw AFSZ glg mow eh~f zwhmglm`-T6>T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T63T Zff H Zvs~f| on Jhzfz Glzjvzzlm` AFSZ' Hvweoslw| wo Hjw$ zvyshmowf 75$ hw :-

T6:T Nos lmzwhmjf$ lm h xvfzwlom!hmg!hmzpfs zfzzlom gvslm` h sfjfmw

fhsmlm`z jhdd plwe lm~fzwosz$ Khalf Glaom$ JFO hmg jehlsahm on KYAos`hmJehzf$ zhlg wehw wef nlsa ehg zwoyyfg vzlm` AFSZ iih peldf chjb-''KYAos`hm Jehzf . Jo-$ X: 3989 Fhsmlm`z Jhdd Wshmzjslyw %Ojw- 8:$ 3989,%omdlmf hw ppp-aosmlm`zwhs-joa/fhsm!9/ fhsmlm`z_853775:6!ky!aos`hm!jehzf!jo!x:!3989-hzyu-zewad, %efsflmhnwfs iiX: 3989 Fhsmlm`z JhddWshmzjslyw'',- Zff hdzo KYA om Nosfjdozvsfz$ AFSZ$ zvysh mowf :- Welz$eopf~fs$ sfdhwfg omd| wo wef vzf on AFSZ wo nosfjdozf- AFSZjom~fszhwlomz plwe Yhmfd zwhnn %Mo~- 89$ 3989,-


29/171

T67T Zff `fmfshdd| Jlmjlmmhwl Dhp Sf~lfp Yhyfs om Nosfjdozvsf$zvysh mowf 35- Jhzfz hggsfzzfg xvfzwlomz hz wo zwhmglm` hmg hz wopefwefs$ c| zfyhshwlm` wef aosw`h`f hmg wef mowf$ wef aosw`h`f ehg cffmsfmgfsfg lm~hdlg %wevz lm~hdlghwlm` wef zfjvslw| lmwfsfzw lm wefysoyfsw|,- Zff H Zvs~f| on Jhzfz Glzjvzzlm` AFSZ' Hvweoslw| wo Hjw$

zvysh mowf 75$ hw 39!38 %iiWefzf lmwfsysfwl~f ysocdfaz hmglmjomzlzwfmjlfz eh~f yso~obfg zoaf jovswz wo gfwfsalmf wef poszwyozzlcdf nhwf nos zfjvsfg dohm cv|fsz!!wehw wefls aosw`h`fz pfsf mowfnnfjwl~fd| wshmznfssfg os f~fm wehw wef aosw`h`fz eh~f cffm zfyhshwfgnsoa wef mowf hmg hsf mo dom`fs fmnosjfhcdf- - - - Pefwefs wef AFSZjomzwsvjw eodgz phwfs lz cflm` socvzwd| wfzwfg lm h ~hslfw| onjomwfuwz- @l~fm wef yfs~hzl~fmfzz on AFSZ$ ln wef jomzwsvjw lz mow~lhcdf$ ln AFSZ jhmmow nldf nosfjdozvsfz$ hmg$ yfsehyz aozwlayoswhmwd|$ jhmmow f~fm sfjosg os fufjvwf hm hzzl`mafmw on h aosw`h`f$pehw wefm?'',-

T66T Zff$ f-`-$ Aosw`- Fdfj- Sf`lzws| Z|z- ~- H{l{f$ 6 Zo- 3g 868%Ndh- Glzw- Jw- Hyy- 3990,- Zff hdzo H Zvs~f| on Jhzfz Glzjvzzlm` AFSZ'Hvweoslw| wo Hjw$ zvysh mowf 75$ hw T Aosw`- Fdfj- Sf`lzws| Z|z- ~- Koemzwom$ Mo- 739!>!9< Sgj~%Svwdhmg Zvyfslos Jw-$ ^w-$ Ojw- 35$ 399


30/171

Nsfgglf Ahj,$ hmg ysojfzzfg >9 yfsjfmw on hdd ACZ- Zff AFSZJOSY$ Lmj-$ZvmWsvzw Cfjoafz Welsg Ahkos Aosw`h`f Yso~lgfs lm Sfjfmw Aomwez woSfxvlsf AFSZ Z|zwfa %Ahs- 85$ 3989, %omdlmf hw ppp-afszlmj-os`/mfpzsooa/ysfzz_gfwhldz-hzyu?lg13:6,- Hjjosglm` wo AFSZ$ lw ehz hjwfg hzwef yhsw| nosfjdozlm` nos omf lm nl~f on wef gfdlmxvfmw aosw`h`fz om

lwz z|zwfa- AFSZ jom~fszhwlomz plwe Yhmfd zwhnn %Mo~- 89$ 3989,-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ln jovswz go hgoyw wef ^fsaomw ~lfp$ lw lz yozzlcdf wehwwef layhjw ah| cf alwl`hwfg ln ahsbfw yhswljlyhmwz gf~lzf h~lhcdf posbhsovmg- Nos fuhaydf$ hjjosglm` wo h sfyosw sfdfhzfgc| Zwhmghsg . Yoos'z$ iiaozw'' ahsbfw yhswljlyhmwz cfdlf~f wehwlw ah| cf yozzlcdf wo zod~f hm| AFSZ!sfdhwfg ysocdfaz c| whblm`wef aosw`h`f ovw on AFSZ hmg yvwwlm` lw lm wef aosw`h`f opmfs'zmhaf yslos wo lmlwlhwlm` h nosfjdozvsf ysojffglm`-T65THjjosglm` wo omf fuyfsw$ wef oggz wehw wef zwhwvz on AFSZ plddcf zfwwdfg xvljbd| hsf dop-T69T Welz zfjwlom hwwfaywz wo yso~lgf h `fmfshd gfzjslywlom on yvw!

chjbz- Yvw!chjbz eh~f cffm hm lzzvf wesov`eovw wef nlmhmjlhd jslzlz$w|yljhdd| lm wef jomwfuw on xvfzwlomz hcovw vmgfspslwlm` zwhmghsgz-Zff$ f-`-$ Nfgfshd Mhwlomhd Aosw`h`f Hzzojlhwlom$ Nosa 89!B nos wefNlzjhd \fhs Fmgfg Gfjfacfs :8$ 399$ 3989, %omdlmf hwppp-zfj-`o~/Hsjel~fz/fg`hs/ghwh/:89633/9999


31/171

sfysfzfmwhwlomz sf`hsglm` wef xvhdlw| on wef dohmz hmg vmgfspslwlm`$wef| zwldd jomwhlm sfysfzfmwhwlomz sf`hsglm` ysoyfs wshmznfs on wefgojvafmwz wo wef wsvzw-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Sfzlgfmwlhd aosw`h`f!chjbfg zfjvslwlfz' YZHz w|yljhdd|

jomwhlm os lmjosyoshwf h ~hslfw| on sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmgphsshmwlfz- Wefzf sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmg phsshmwlfz jo~fs zvjewoyljz hz wef os`hml{hwlom on wef zyomzos hmg gfyozlwos$ wefxvhdlw| hmg zwhwvz on wef aosw`h`f dohmz$ hmg wef ~hdlglw| onwefls wshmznfsz-

Aosf yhswljvdhsd|$ YZHz$ peozf wfsaz hsf vmlxvf wo fhjeACZ$ lmjdvgf sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmg phsshmwlfz c| wef osl`lmhwosos zfddfs sfdhwlm` wo wef jom~f|hmjf on òog wlwdf$T>8Tgojvafmwhwlom nos wef dohm$T>3T vmgfspslwlm` zwhmghsgz$T>:Tjoaydlhmjf plwe hyydljhcdf dhp$T>7T hmg gfdl~fs| on aosw`h`fnldfz$T>6T haom` owefs welm`z-T>>T Lm hgglwlom$ wef aosw`h`fnldfz avzw jomwhlm zyfjlnlj dohm hmg aosw`h`f gojvafmwz hmgmowlnljhwlom on ahwfslhd csfhjefz on hm| sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmgphsshmwlfz-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T>8T Nhldvsf wo wshmznfs wef dohmz ysoyfsd| povdg jsfhwf wpozovsjfz on dlhcldlw|; omf povdg cf lm sfmgfslm` wef opmfs on wefaosw`h`f hmg wef mowf vmjfswhlm$ hmg wef owefs povdg cf h csfhje onjomwshjw jdhla vmgfs wef YZH- Nos hm fuhaydf on w|yljhd dhm`vh`f lmsfysfzfmwhwlomz hmg phsshmwlfz jomwhlmfg lm YZHz os lmjosyoshwfg c|sfnfsfmjf nsoa aosw`h`f dohm yvsjehzf h`sffafmwz fufjvwfg c| wef

aosw`h`f osl`lmhwos$ zff Gfvwzjef Chmb ~- Nfgfshd Gfyozlw LmzvshmjfJosyoshwlom$ zvysh mowf 73 %ii- - - hmg wehw laafglhwfd| yslos wo wefwshmznfs hmg hzzl`mafmw on wef Aosw`h`f Dohmz wo wef Wsvzwff$ wefGfyozlwos phz wef zodf opmfs hmg ehg òog wlwdf wo fhje Aosw`h`f Dohm$hmg ehg nvdd slèw wo wshmznfs hmg zfdd fhje Aosw`h`f Dohm wo wefWsvzwff nsff hmg jdfhs-'',-

T>3T Zff Gfvwzjef Chmb ~- Nfgfshd Gfyozlw Lmzvshmjf Josyoshwlom$zvysh mowf 73 %iiFhje Aosw`h`f Mowf$ fhje Aosw`h`f$ fhje Hzzl`mafmw hmghm| owefs gojvafmw sfxvlsfg wo cf gfdl~fsfg c| os om cfehdn on wefZfddfs vmgfs welz H`sffafmw os wef Yoodlm` hmg Zfs~ljlm` H`sffafmw wo

wef Yvsjehzfs os hm| hzzl`mff$ wshmznfsff os gfzl`mff on wef Yvsjehzfsnos fhje Aosw`h`f Dohm ehz cffm os pldd cf - - - gfdl~fsfg wo wefYvsjehzfs os hm| zvje hzzl`mff$ wshmznfsff os gfzl`mff- Plwe sfzyfjw wofhje Aosw`h`f Dohm$ wef Zfddfs lz lm yozzfzzlom on h joaydfwf Aosw`h`fNldf lm joaydlhmjf plwe wef Yoodlm` hmg Zfs~ljlm` H`sffafmw - - - WefAosw`h`f Mowf hmg wef sfdhwfg Aosw`h`f hsf `fmvlmf$ hmg fhje lz wefdf`hd$ ~hdlg hmg clmglm` ocdl`hwlom on wef Aosw`hòs fmnosjfhcdfh`hlmzw wef Aosw`hòs c| wef aosw`h`ff os lwz sfysfzfmwhwl~f lm


32/171

hjjosghmjf plwe lwz wfsaz$ fujfyw omd| hz zvje fmnosjfafmw ah| cfdlalwfg c| chmbsvywj|$ lmzod~fmj| - - - -'',- Wefzf sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmgphsshmwlfz `fmfshdd| zwhwf wehw wef gojvafmwz zvcalwwfg nos dohmvmgfspslwlm` pfsf mow nhdzlnlfg hmg jomwhlm mo vmwsvf zwhwfafmw onahwfslhd nhjw os oalw wo zwhwf h ahwfslhd nhjw sfxvlsfg wo cf zwhwfg

wefsflm hmg hsf mow alzdfhglm` hmg wehw mo fssos$ oalzzlom$alzsfysfzfmwhwlom$ mf`dl`fmjf$ os nshvg ojjvssfg lm wef dohm'zosl`lmhwlom os lmzvshmjf-

T>:T Zff Gfvwzjef Chmb ~- Nfgfshd Gfyozlw Lmzvshmjf Josyoshwlom$zvysh mowf 73 %iiFhje Aosw`h`f Dohm phz vmgfspslwwfm lm hjjosghmjf plwewef Zfddfs'z vmgfspslwlm` `vlgfdlmfz hz gfzjslcfg lm wef YsozyfjwvzZvyydfafmw hz hyydljhcdf wo lwz jsfglw `shgf lm hdd ahwfslhdsfzyfjwz-'',- Ahm| jomjfsmz o~fs vmgfspslwlm` zwhmghsgz eh~f zvsnhjfglm wef phbf on wef eovzlm` cooa$ zvje hz dhjb on hgfxvhwfgojvafmwhwlom$ dhjb on lmjoaf ~fslnljhwlom$ alzsfysfzfmwhwlom on lmjoafhmg koc zwhwvz$ hmg ehyeh{hsg hyyshlzhdz- F~fm cfnosf wef aosf sfjfmwfafs`fmjf on wef lzzvf on gojvafmw lssf`vdhslwlfz$ lmzwlwvwlomz pfsfyvszvlm` yvw!chjb hjwlomz wo hggsfzz jomjfsmz o~fs vmgfspslwlm`xvhdlw|- Zff Nfgfshd Mhwlomhd Aosw`h`f Hzzojlhwlom$ Nosa 89!X nos wefXvhswfsd| Yfslog Fmgfg Kvmf :9$ 3989$ hw 6T Zff Gfvwzjef Chmb ~- Nfgfshd Gfyozlw Lmzvshmjf Josyoshwlom$zvysh mowf 73-

T>>T Nos fuhaydfz on sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmg phsshmwlfz$ zff MfpJfmwvs| Eoaf Fxvlw| Dohm Wsvzw$ Nosa 5!B nos wef Yfslog Fmglm` Nfcsvhs|8>$ 3996$ hw Fu-


33/171

onnfmglm` dohm lz wo cf iiyvw!chjb'' wo wef zyomzos$ afhmlm`wehw wef zyomzos lz sfxvlsfg wo sfyvsjehzf wef dohm nos wefovwzwhmglm` yslmjlyhd chdhmjf ydvz hm| hjjsvfg lmwfsfzw-T>0T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T>0T Zff$ f-`-$ Jlwl`sovy$ Lmj-$ Nosa 89!B nos wef Nlzjhd \fhs

Fmgfg Gfjfacfs :8$ 399$ 3989, %omdlmf hw ppp-zfj-`o~/Hsjel~fz/fg`hs/ghwh/5:8998/999839>0078999979>/jlwl_89b-ewa,%efsflmhnwfs iiJlwl`sovy Nosa 89!B'',- Eopf~fs$ zlmjf f~fs| gfhd lzglnnfsfmw$ wefsf hsf h mvacfs on glnnfsfmw afweogz nos fuwlm`vlzelm` hsfyvsjehzf jdhla wehw ah| mow mfjfzzhsld| sfxvlsf wef hjwvhdsfyvsjehzlm` on wef dohm- Lmgvzws| fuyfswz jom~fszhwlomz plwe Yhmfdzwhnn %Mo~- 5T Welz afhmz wehw wefzyomzos ah| eh~f wo lmjsfhzf lwz slzb!chzfg jhylwhd hmg plddcfhs wef slzb on nvwvsf dozzfz om wef dohm$ peldf wef wsvzwsfjfl~fz 899 jfmwz om wef goddhs nos wef dohm-T>5T Zff Jlwl`sovy Nosa 89!B$ zvysh mowf >0$ hw 8:8-T>


34/171

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Zfs~ljfsz go mow onwfm yvszvf sfysfzfmwhwlom hmg phsshmwlfz

~lodhwlomz- H 3989 zwvg| c| Haefszw Aosw`h`f Zfjvslwlfz zeopfgwehw peldf ysl~hwf aosw`h`f lmzvsfsz pfsf sfzjlmglm` jo~fsh`fom h zvczwhmwlhd yfsjfmwh`f on wef dohmz wef| lmzvsfg cfjhvzf

on ~lodhwlomz on ~fs| zlaldhs sfysfzfmwhwlom hmg phsshmwlfz$wefsf phz ~fs| dlwwdf yvw!chjb hjwl~lw| c| zfs~ljfsz$ f~fmweovè omf povdg fuyfjw sfdhwl~fd| zlaldhs shwfz-T08T Omffuydhmhwlom nos wef hyyhsfmw dhjb on zfs~ljfs yvw!chjb hjwl~lw|ah| cf wef yozzlcldlw| on zfs~ljfs jomndljwz on lmwfsfzw-Zfs~ljfsz hsf onwfm hnnldlhwfg plwe zfjvslwl{hwlom zyomzosz hmgwefsfnosf eh~f glzlmjfmwl~fz wo yvszvf sfysfzfmwhwlom hmgphsshmw| ~lodhwlomz- Wsvzwffz eh~f glzlmjfmwl~fz wo sfao~fzfs~ljfsz cfjhvzf wef| hjw hz chjbvy zfs~ljfsz hmg cfhs wefjozwz on zfs~ljlm` ln wef zfs~ljfs lz wfsalmhwfg nsoa wef gfhd-Nlmhdd|$ lm~fzwosz hsf yoosd| zlwvhwfg wo aomlwos zfs~ljfsz-Pefsfhz h zfjvslwl{hwlom wsvzwff jovdg `hlm hjjfzz wolmgl~lgvhd dohm nldfz!!cvw w|yljhdd| go mow T03T!!lm~fzwoszjhmmow sf~lfp dohm nldfz plweovw zvczwhmwlhd joddfjwl~fjozwz-T0:T Om wef owefs ehmg$ lm~fzwos dhpzvlwz eh~f wefyowfmwlhd wo cf dvjshwl~f nos dhp|fsz$ zo lw lz yozzlcdf wehwzoaf lm~fzwos `sovyz ah| whbf hjwlom gfzylwf wefls dlalwfghjjfzz wo lmnosahwlom-T07T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T08T Haefszw Aosw`h`f Lmzlèw$ YAL lm Mom!H`fmj| Zfjvslwl{hwlomz$hw 7 %Kvd| 8>$ 3989, %iiYAL joayhmlfz eh~f cfjoaf aosf hzzfswl~f lm

sfzjlmglm` lmzvshmjf - - - Lm nhjw$ zlmjf fhsd| 3990&-'',-

T03T Zfjvslwl{hwlom wsvzwffz go mow fuhalmf hmg aomlwos dohm nldfznos sfysfzfmwhwlom hmg phsshmw| ~lodhwlomz hmg `fmfshdd| fufsjlzf ~fs|dlwwdf o~fszlèw on zfs~ljfsz- Zfjvslwl{hwlom wsvzwffz hsf mow `fmfshdnlgvjlhslfz2 zo dom` hz wefsf ehz mow cffm hm f~fmw on gfnhvdw nos wefzfjvslwl{hwlom wsvzw$ wef wsvzwff ehz mhssopd| gfnlmfg jomwshjwvhdgvwlfz$ hmg mo owefsz- Zfjvslwl{hwlom wsvzwffz hsf hdzo yhlg nhs woodlwwdf wo nvmg hjwl~f aomlwoslm`2 wsvzwffz `fmfshdd| sfjfl~f 8 chzlz

yolmw os dfzz om wef ovwzwhmglm` yslmjlyhd chdhmjf lm wef wsvzw- Lmhgglwlom$ zfjvslwl{hwlom wsvzwffz onwfm sfjfl~f zvczwhmwlhd haovmwz oncvzlmfzz nsoa yhswljvdhs zyomzosz$ pelje ah| yso~lgf h glzlmjfmwl~f noswefa wo yvszvf sfysfzfmwhwlom hmg phsshmw| ~lodhwlomz ~lòsovzd|h`hlmzw weozf yhswlfz- Zff Mluom Yfhcog| DDY$ Jhvèw lm wef Jsozz!nlsf;Zfjvslwl{hwlom Wsvzwffz hmg Dlwl`hwlom Gvslm` wef Zvcyslaf Jslzlz %Khm-3


35/171

wsvzwff lm aosw`h`f zfjvslwlfz dlwl`hwlom,-T0:T Zff Zfjwlom G-3$ lmnsh-T07T Zff Zfjwlom G-3$ lmnsh-

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

3- Yozzlcdf Df`hd Jomzfxvfmjfz on wef Gojvafmw Lssf`vdhslwlfz wo^hslovz Yhswlfz

Lm hgglwlom wo nshvg jdhlaz$ glzjvzzfg nvswefs cfdop$ hmgjdhlaz hslzlm` nsoa pefwefs wef dohmz lm wef yood afw wefvmgfspslwlm` zwhmghsgz sfxvlsfg %pelje lz yslahsld| sfdf~hmw wolm~fzwosz' slèwz on yvw!chjb hmg chmb dlhcldlw|,$ wef owefsyslahs| jomjfsm hslzlm` ovw on gojvafmw lssf`vdhslwlfz lz wefyowfmwlhd nhldvsf wo jom~f| jdfhs wlwdf wo wef ysoyfsw| hmgopmfszely on wef aosw`h`f hmg wef mowf-

Wefsf hsf wpo zfyhshwf cvw lmwfssfdhwfg nosaz on jom~f|hmjfwehw ah| cf laydljhwfg c| gojvafmwhwlom lssf`vdhslwlfz;jom~f|hmjf on wef aosw`h`f hmg wef mowf$ hmg jom~f|hmjf on wefysoyfsw| zfjvslm` wef aosw`h`f- Wef nosfjdozvsf gojvafmwhwlomlssf`vdhslwlfz hnnfjw jom~f|hmjf on wef ysoyfsw|; ln wefnosfjdozvsf phz mow gomf jossfjwd|$ wef chmb os h zvczfxvfmwcv|fs ah| mow eh~f jdfhs wlwdf wo wef ysoyfsw|- Cvw wefzfnosfjdozvsf lssf`vdhslwlfz ah| hdzo cf nvswefs joaysoalzfg c| hnhldvsf wo jom~f| wef aosw`h`f hmg wef mowf ysoyfsd| fhsdlfs lmwef ysojfzz- Ln$ gvslm` wef zfjvslwl{hwlom ysojfzz$ sfxvlsfggojvafmwhwlom phz lmjoaydfwf os laysoyfs$ wefm opmfszely on wef

aosw`h`f ah| mow eh~f cffm jom~f|fg wo wef wsvzw- Welz jovdgeh~f laydljhwlomz nos wef YZH!!lmhzavje hz lw povdg ~lodhwf hm|sfxvlsfafmw wehw wef wsvzw opm wef aosw`h`fz hmg wef mowfz!!hzpfdd hz jhdd lmwo xvfzwlom wef eodglm`z on wef wsvzw hmg wefjoddhwfshd vmgfsd|lm` wef yoodz vmgfs joaaom dhp$ wef VJJ$ hmgwsvzw dhp-T06T Wef wsvzw lm welz zlwvhwlom ah| cf vmhcdf wofmnosjf wef dlfm wesovè nosfjdozvsf cfjhvzf omd| wef opmfs onwef aosw`h`f hmg wef mowf ehz wef slèw wo nosfjdozf- Ln wefopmfs on wef aosw`h`f lz lm glzyvwf$ mo omf ah| cf hcdf wonosfjdozf vmwld opmfszely lz jdfhsd| fzwhcdlzefg-

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!T06T Aozw YZHz hsf ò~fsmfg c| Mfp \osb wsvzw dhp hmg jomwhlmyso~lzlomz wehw o~fsslgf VJJ Hswljdf < yso~lzlomz om zfjvsfgwshmzhjwlomz- Welz sfyosw gofz mow hwwfayw wo gfzjslcf f~fs| yozzlcdfdf`hd gfnfjw wehw ah| hslzf ovw on wef lssf`vdhslwlfz$ yhswljvdhsd|`l~fm wef shylgd| gf~fdoylm` mhwvsf on wef ysocdfa$ cvw hggsfzzfzhs`vafmwz joaaom wo wef jvssfmw glzjvzzlomz- Lm hgglwlom$ wef Yhmfdwhbfz mo yozlwlom om pefwefs hm| on wefzf hs`vafmwz hsf ~hdlg os dlbfd|


36/171

wo zvjjffg-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ln lw lz vmjdfhs peo opmz wef aosw`h`f$ jdfhs wlwdf wo wefysoyfsw| lwzfdn jhmmow cf jom~f|fg- Ln$ nos fuhaydf$ wef wsvzwpfsf wo fmnosjf wef dlfm hmg nosfjdozf om wef ysoyfsw|$ h cv|fs

jovdg mow cf zvsf wehw wef yvsjehzf on wef nosfjdozfg eovzf phzysoyfs ln wef wsvzw glg mow eh~f wef slèw wo nosfjdozf om wefeovzf lm wef nlszw ydhjf- Zlaldhsd|$ ln wef eovzf lz zodg$ cvwlw lz vmjdfhs peo opmz wef aosw`h`f hmg wef mowf hmg$ wevz$ wefgfcw lz mow ysoyfsd| glzjehs`fg hmg wef dlfm sfdfhzfg$ hzvczfxvfmw cv|fs ah| nlmg wehw wefsf hsf owefs jdhlahmwz wo wefysoyfsw|- Lm welz ph|$ wef jomzfxvfmjfz on nosfjdozvsfgojvafmwhwlom lssf`vdhslwlfz jom~fs`f plwe wef jomzfxvfmjfz onzfjvslwl{hwlom gojvafmwhwlom lssf`vdhslwlfz; lm flwefszlwvhwlom$ h zvczfxvfmw cv|fs os dfmgfs ah| eh~f vmjdfhs slèwzlm wef ysoyfsw|-

Wefzf lssf`vdhslwlfz ah| eh~f zl`mlnljhmw cfhslm` om ahm|on wef yhswljlyhmwz lm wef aosw`h`f zfjvslwl{hwlom ysojfzz;

Yhswlfz wo Peoa h Aosw`h`f hmg Mowf LzWshmznfssfg!!Ln h dlfm phz mow iiyfsnfjwfg''!!nldfg hjjosglm`wo hyysoyslhwf ysojfgvsfz!!yhswljlyhmwz lm wef wshmznfs ysojfzzah| mo dom`fs eh~f h nlszw!dlfm lmwfsfzw lm wef ysoyfsw| hmgah| cf vmhcdf wo fmnosjf wehw h`hlmzw welsg!yhswlfz %hmg$ pefsfwef ysoyfsw| ehz dlwwdf ~hdvf$ yhswljvdhsd| lm mom!sfjovszfkvslzgljwlomz$ ah| mow cf hcdf wo sfjo~fs hm| aomf|,-Zlaldhsd|$ ln wef mowfz hmg aosw`h`fz pfsf mow ysoyfsd|

wshmznfssfg$ wefm wef yhsw| wehw jhm fmnosjf wef slèwzhwwhjefg wo wef mowf hmg wef aosw`h`f!!slèw wo sfjfl~f yh|afmwhmg slèw wo nosfjdozf$ haom` owefsz!!ah| mow cf sfhgld|lgfmwlnlhcdf- Ln h wsvzw gofz mow eh~f ysoyfs opmfszely wo wefmowfz hmg wef aosw`h`f$ lw lz vmjdfhs pehw hzzfwz hsf hjwvhdd|lm wef wsvzw$ ln hm|-T0>T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T0>T Wef joayfwlm` jdhlaz hcovw AFSZ jhm hdzo nhjwos lmwo wefzflzzvfz- Ln AFSZ lz efdg mow wo cf h ~hdlg sfjosglm` z|zwfa$ wefmaosw`h`fz sfjosgfg lm wef mhaf on AFSZ ah| mow eh~f nlszw ysloslw|-

Zlaldhsd|$ ln AFSZ gofz mow eh~f zwhmglm` wo nosfjdozf$ lw jovdg jhzwlmwo xvfzwlom nosfjdozvsfz gomf c| AFSZ-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Zyomzosz$ Zfs~ljfsz$ hmg Wsvzwffz!!Nhldvsf wonoddop sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmg phsshmwlfz novmg lm YZHz jhm dfhg wowef sfao~hd on zfs~ljfsz os wsvzwffz hmg wsl``fslmgfamlnljhwlom slèwz cfwpffm wef yhswlfz-T00T Nhldvsf wosfjosg aosw`h`fz jhm sfzvdw lm wef wsvzw dozlm` lwz nlszw!dlfm


37/171

ysloslw| om wef ysoyfsw|- Nhldvsf wo wshmznfs aosw`h`fz hmgmowfz ysoyfsd| wo wef wsvzw jhm hnnfjw wef eodglm`z on wefwsvzw- Ln wshmznfsz pfsf mow gomf jossfjwd| lm wef nlszw ydhjfhmg jhmmow cf jossfjwfg$ wefsf lz h ysonovmg laydljhwlom nosaosw`h`f zfjvslwl{hwlomz; lw povdg afhm wehw wef laysoyfsd|

wshmznfssfg dohmz hsf mow wsvzw hzzfwz hmg ACZ hsf lm nhjw mowchjbfg c| zoaf os hdd on wef aosw`h`fz wehw hsf zvyyozfg wo cfchjblm` wefa- Welz povdg afhm wehw wef wsvzwz povdg eh~fdlwl`hwlom jdhlaz h`hlmzw wef zfjvslwl{hwlom zyomzosz nossfnvmgz on wef ~hdvf `l~fm c| wef wsvzwz wo wef zyomzosz %osgfyozlwosz, hz yhsw on wef zfjvslwl{hwlom wshmzhjwlom-T05T Lnzvjjfzznvd$ lm wef aozw fuwsfaf zjfmhslo welz povdg afhm wehwACZ wsvzwz %hmg wevz ACZ lm~fzwosz, jovdg sfjfl~f joaydfwfsfjo~fslfz om hdd laysoyfsd| wshmznfssfg aosw`h`fz$ wefsfc|zelnwlm` wef dozzfz wo wef zfjvslwl{hwlom zyomzosz-T0


38/171

plwe ò~fsmlm` YZHz$ lw povdg afhm wehw zl{fhcdf dozzfz om aosw`h`fzpovdg sfzw om h ehmgnvd on dhs`f chmbz$ shwefs wehm cflm` zysfhg haomÀCZ lm~fzwosz- Zoafwlafz wef zfjvslwl{hwlom zyomzos lz lmgfamlnlfg c|wef osl`lmhwos nos hm| dozzfz wef zyomzos lmjvsz hz h sfzvdw on wefcsfhje on sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmg phsshmwlfz- Zff Lg- hw zfjwlom 89-9:-

Welz lmgfamlnljhwlom lz omd| ~hdvhcdf$ eopf~fs$ wo wef fuwfmw wehw wefosl`lmhwos ehz zvnnljlfmw hzzfwz wo jo~fs wef lmgfamlnljhwlom- Ahm|osl`lmhwosz hsf welmd| jhylwhdl{fg hmg owefsz eh~f jfhzfg oyfshwlm` osnldfg nos chmbsvywj|- Wefsfnosf$ lm ahm| jhzfz$ hm| yvw!chjb dlhcldlw|lz dlbfd| wo sfzw om wef zfjvslwl{hwlom zyomzosz- Hdweovè wefzf yvw!chjb slèwz zoafwlafz fmwlwdf wef wsvzw omd| wo wef ~hdvf on wef dohmdfzz hm| yh|afmwz hdsfhg| sfjfl~fg$ ydvz lmwfsfzw$ wef ~hdvf wef wsvzwpovdg sfjfl~f lz zwldd `sfhwfs wehm wef jvssfmw ~hdvf on ahm| on wefzfdohmz- Hz h mvacfs on osl`lmhwosz hmg zyomzosz pfsf hjxvlsfg c| owefsahkos nlmhmjlhd lmzwlwvwlomz gvslm` 3995!399


39/171

hjwvhdd| sfjfl~f wef dohm wesov`e h ysoyfs wshmznfs-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T58T Wef jomjfyw on iicomh!nlgf yvsjehzfs nos ~hdvf$'' pelje fulzwzlm cowe joaaom hmg zwhwvwos| dhp$ ah| ysowfjw wef dhwfs cv|fs- Ln wefdhwfs cv|fs sfjosgz hm lmwfsfzw lm wef ysoyfsw| hmg ehg mo mowljf on

wef joayfwlm` jdhla$ wehw lmwfsfzw lm wef ysoyfsw| pldd cf ysowfjwfg-Lmgvzws| zovsjfz jom~fszhwlomz plwe Yhmfd zwhnn %Mo~-


40/171

ysoyfsw| zvnnljlfmwd| lgfmwlnlfg2 hmg %7, hmg wef gfdl~fs| on wefysoyfsw| wo wef wsvzwff- Kozevh Sozmfs on @sheha Nlzefs$ hm lm~fzwafmwsfzfhsje nlsa$ ehz mowfg wehw wefsf ah| mow eh~f hdph|z cffm ysoyfsgfdl~fs| on wef ysoyfsw| wo wef wsvzwff- iiLm Mfp \osb lw lz mow fmovèwo eh~f hm lmwfmwlom wo gfdl~fs wef ysoyfsw| wo wef wsvzw$ wef ysoyfsw|

avzw hjwvhdd| cf gfdl~fsfg- Zo$ pehw gfnlmfz hjjfywhcdf gfdl~fs|? Wefhmzpfs hyyfhsz wo dlf plwe wef iò~fsmlm` lmzwsvafmw$' wef Yoodlm` hmgZfs~ljlm` H`sffafmw %YZH,- Wevz$ lm osgfs wo eh~f ysoyfs gfdl~fs| wefyhswlfz wo wef YZH avzw go wehw pelje wef YZH gfahmgz wo hjelf~fgfdl~fs|-'' Kozevh Sozmfs$ mowf wo Yhmfd zwhnn %Mo~- 5$ 3989,- Wo weffuwfmw wehw h YZH sfxvlsfz wehw ysoyfsw| cf jom~f|fg wo wef wsvzwplwelm h jfswhlm wlafnshaf$ zvje jom~f|hmjf povdg cf ~olg- M-\-Fzwhwfz$ Yopfsz$ hmg Wsvzwz Dhp Zfj- 0!3-7 %AjBlmmf|'z 399>,-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Wlwdf Lmzvshmjf Joayhmlfz!!Lm wef Vmlwfg Zwhwfz$yvsjehzfsz on sfhd ysoyfsw| %l-f-$ dhmg hmg/os cvldglm`z,w|yljhdd| yvsjehzf wlwdf lmzvshmjf$ pelje yso~lgfz h yh|afmw wowef yvsjehzfs ln h gfnfjw lm wef wlwdf os vmglzjdozfg dlfm lzglzjo~fsfg hnwfs wef zhdf on wef ysoyfsw| lz joaydfwf- @l~fmwef yowfmwlhd df`hd lzzvfz glzjvzzfg lm welz zfjwlom$ wlwdflmzvshmjf joayhmlfz jovdg nhjf hm lmjsfhzf lm jdhlaz lm wefmfhs nvwvsf- Wef wesfhw on zvje lzzvfz ah| hdzo dfhg lmzvsfszwo sfxvlsf hgglwlomhd gojvafmwhwlom cfnosf lzzvlm` h yodlj|$lmjsfhzlm` wef jozwz hzzojlhwfg plwe cv|lm` ysoyfsw|-T57T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T57T Hdweovè wlwdf lmzvsfsz hyyfhs wo cf yolzfg nos yowfmwlhd

slzb$ omf oczfs~fs ehz mowfg wehw wlwdf lmzvshmjf docc|lzwz hmg wshgf`sovyz eh~f lmzwfhg ydh|fg gopm wef yozzlcdf fnnfjwz on wefzf df`hdlzzvfz- Jeslzwoyefs Dfplz Yfwfszom$ ysonfzzos on dhp$ Z-K- Xvlmmf|Zjeood on Dhp$ Vml~fszlw| on Vwhe$ jom~fszhwlomz plwe Yhmfd zwhnn %Mo~-5$ 3989,- Wlwdf lmzvsfsz zwhwf wehw wef| go mow ysfzfmwd| cfdlf~f wehwwefzf df`hd lzzvfz pldd eh~f avje fnnfjw- Lmgvzws| zovsjfzjom~fszhwlomz plwe Yhmfd zwhnn %Mo~- 89$ 3989,- Ysonfzzos Yfwfszomzv``fzwfg wehw wef lmzvsfsz ah| fhsm zvnnljlfmw sfavmfshwlom nsoa~hslovz nffz wo onnzfw hm| yowfmwlhd slzb- Om wef owefs ehmg$ wlwdflmzvsfsz jovdg zwhmg wo zvnnfs zl`mlnljhmw dozzfz ln zoaf on wef

ahwwfsz ysfzfmwd| glzjvzzfg lm wef ahsbfw$ zvje hz plgfzysfhglm~hdlghwlom on AFSZ$ joaf wo yhzz- Lw lz woo zoom wo zh| ln zvjef~fmwz hsf dlbfd|$ cvw wlwdf lmzvsfsz povdg cf omf on wef yslahs|yhswlfz ghah`fg c| zvje hm hjwlom-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Kvmlos Dlfm Eodgfsz!!Zfjomg hmg welsg dlfmz hsfmow hz joaaomd| zfjvslwl{fg hz nlszw dlfmz2 wefsfnosf$ weflseodgfsz ah| mow nhjf wef zhaf glsfjw slzb hz nlszw dlfm


41/171

eodgfsz- Kvmlos dlfm eodgfsz ah|$ eopf~fs$ nhjf hm lmglsfjwslzb ln wef slèwz on wef nlszw dlfm eodgfs jhmmow cf ysoyfsd|fzwhcdlzefg- Ln wef ysoyfsw| zfjvslm` wef dlfm lz zodg$ hddzfmlos dlfmz avzw cf yhlg nlszw- Ln wef zfmlos dlfmz jhmmow cfyhlg onn cfjhvzf lw lz layozzlcdf wo gfwfsalmf peo eodgz weozf

dlfmz$ wef kvmlos dlfm eodgfs ah| mow cf hcdf wo jdhla hm| onwef ysojffgz on wef zhdf vmwld wef lgfmwlw| on wef zfmlos dlfmeodgfs lz zfwwdfg- Om wef owefs ehmg$ gojvafmw lssf`vdhslwlfzah| onnfs h plmgnhdd nos zoaf kvmlos dlfmz- Ln wef nlszwaosw`h`f ehz mow cffm yfsnfjwfg$ wef nlszw dlfm eodgfs dozfzlwz ysloslw| o~fs hm| owefs$ yfsnfjwfg dlfmz- Wefsfnosf$ ln hzfjomg dlfm phz ysoyfsd| sfjosgfg$ lw jovdg whbf ysloslw| o~fsh nlszw dlfm wehw phz mow ysoyfsd| sfjosgfg- Wef ahkoslw| onzfjomg dlfmz$ eopf~fs$ pfsf joaydfwfg vzlm` wef zhaf z|zwfa hznlszw dlfmz hmg wefsfnosf nhjf wef zhaf yowfmwlhd lzzvfz-Aosfo~fs$ ahm| aosw`h`fz wehw pfsf jsfhwfg gvslm` wef eovzlm`cooa pfsf jsfhwfg plwe hm 59 yfsjfmw/39 yfsjfmw iiyl``|!chjb''zwsvjwvsf lm pelje h nlszw hmg zfjomg dlfm pfsf jsfhwfgzlavdwhmfovzd| hmg vzlm` wef zhaf z|zwfa- Ln mflwefs dlfm phzyfsnfjwfg$ wefsf ah| cf h xvfzwlom hz wo pelje povdg whbfysloslw| o~fs wef owefs-T56T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T56T Jeslzwoyefs Dfplz Yfwfszom$ ysonfzzos on dhp$ Z-K- Xvlmmf|Zjeood on Dhp$ Vml~fszlw| on Vwhe$ jom~fszhwlomz plwe Yhmfd zwhnn %Mo~-5$ 3989,- Ln wef aosw`h`fz pfsf jsfhwfg hw glnnfsfmw wlafz$ wefaosw`h`f jsfhwfg nlszw povdg whbf ysfjfgfmjf-

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Dojhd Hjwlomz!!Gfzylwf wef zwhwf hwwosmf|z'

`fmfshd mhwlomhd hyysohje wo lm~fzwl`hwlm` gojvafmwlssf`vdhslwlfz$ wefsf ah| cf zfyhshwf zwhwf lmlwlhwl~fz- Vmgfswshglwlomhd aosw`h`f sfjosglm` yshjwljfz$ fhje wlaf h aosw`h`flz wshmznfssfg nsoa h zfddfs wo h cv|fs$ wef wshmznfs avzw cfsfjosgfg hmg h nff yhlg wo wef dojhd ò~fsmafmw- Hdweovè fhjenff lz mow dhs`f!!w|yljhdd| hsovmg :9!!wef nffz nos wef shylgwshmznfsz lmefsfmw lm wef aosw`h`f zfjvslwl{hwlom ysojfzz jovdgfhzld| hgg vy wo evmgsfgz on goddhsz yfs zfjvslwl{hwlom- Wef

AFSZ z|zwfa phz lmwfmgfg lm yhsw wo c|yhzz wefzf nffz-T5>TDojhd kvslzgljwlomz$ gfysl~fg on aosw`h`f sfjosglm` whusf~fmvf$ ah| nldf dhpzvlwz h`hlmzw osl`lmhwosz$ zfs~ljfsz$ hmgAFSZ-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T5>T Jlmjlmmhwl Dhp Sf~lfp Yhyfs om Nosfjdozvsf$ zvysh mowf 35$ hw8:5>!8:08-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


42/171

Wef yslahs| ysl~hwf dlwl`hwlom lm welz hsfh lz dlbfd| wojoaf nsoa lm~fzwosz lm ACZ- Wefzf lm~fzwosz hsf onwfmlmzwlwvwlomhd lm~fzwosz$ h `sovy wehw ehz wef sfzovsjfz hmgfuyfswlzf wo yvszvf zvje jdhlaz-T50T H ahkos oczwhjdf wolm~fzwos dhpzvlwz zffblm` yvw!chjbz ehz cffm h yso~lzlom lm

YZHz wehw dlalwz ysl~hwf lm~fzwos hjwlom lm wef jhzf oncsfhjefz on sfysfzfmwhwlomz hmg phsshmwlfz wo jfswlnljhwfeodgfsz plwe zoaf almlava yfsjfmwh`f on ~owlm` sl`ewz$ onwfm 36yfsjfmw-T55T Lm~fzwosz hdzo zvnnfs nsoa h joddfjwl~f!hjwlomysocdfa lm ws|lm` wo hjelf~f wefzf wesfzeodgz$ mow dfhzwcfjhvzf wef| go mow bmop peo wef owefs lm~fzwosz hsf lm hyhswljvdhs gfhd$ hmg ahm| lm~fzwosz hsf sfdvjwhmw wo zehsflmnosahwlom hcovw wefls eodglm`z- Nvswefsaosf$ wef lmwfsfzwz onkvmlos hmg zfmlos wshmjef eodgfsz ah| mow cf hdl`mfg-T5


43/171

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!T69707/95

%M-\- Zvyy- Ojw- 0$ 3989,2 Noowcslg`f Dwg- Wsvzw hmg OEY Oyyoswvmlw|Dwg- Wsvzw ~- Jovmws|plgf Eoaf Dohmz$ Lmj-$ Mo- 9< JL^ 7969 %Z-G-M-\-Zfy- 35$ 3989,-

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Sfjfmwd|$ eopf~fs$ lm~fzwosz hsf cf`lmmlm` wo whbf

joddfjwl~f hjwlom$ zv``fzwlm` wehw wef 36!yfsjfmw wesfzeodg ah|mow cf hm fmosaovz cvsgfm nos os`hml{fg lm~fzwosz- H sf`lzws|jsfhwfg c| SACZ Jdfhslm` Eovzf lz yso~lglm` h jomnlgfmwlhd ghwhchmb peozf yvsyozf lz wo lgfmwln| hmg os`hml{f jfswlnljhwfeodgfsz lmwo `sovyz wehw jhm affw wesfzeodg sfxvlsfafmwz-T


44/171

yfsjfmw on wef eodgfsz on 769 aosw`h`f!chjbfg zfjvslwlfz sfysfzfmwlm`$lm wef h``sf`hwf$ h nhjf haovmw on 699 clddlom$ os hyysoulahwfd| omf!welsg on wef ysl~hwf dhcfd aosw`h`f!chjbfg zfjvslwlfz ahsbfw- Omflmgvzws| yhswljlyhmw dlbfmfg wefa wo h ghwlm` zlwf nos lm~fzwosz- SACZJdfhslm` Eovzf jom~fszhwlomz plwe Yhmfd zwhnn %Ojw- 37$ 3989,-

T


45/171

3989, %omdlmf hw ppp-aosmlm`zwhs-joa/fhsmlm`z/85:0380>!chmb!on!hafsljh!josyoshwlom!x:!3989-hzyu?ylmgfu18, %efsflmhnwfs iiChmb on Hafsljh X:3989 Fhsmlm`z Jhdd Wshmzjslyw'',-

T


46/171

T


47/171

jelfn fufjvwl~f onnljfs$ AFSZJOSY$ Lmj-$ wo Fdl{hcfwe A- Avsye|$zfjsfwhs|$ Zfjvslwlfz hmg Fujehm`f Joaalzzlom$ Joaafmwz om wefJoaalzzlom'z Ysoyozfg Svdf nos Hzzfw!Chjbfg Zfjvslwlfz$ hw Hyyfmglu C%Kvd| :9$ 3989, %omdlmf hw ppp-zfj-`o~/joaafmwz/z0!95!89/z09589!65-ygn,%hwwhjelm` hz hm Hyyfmglu dfwwfsz nsoa cowe Nhmmlf Ahf hmg Nsfgglf Ahj$

pelje lmjdvgf wef Nhmmlf Ahf zwhwfafmw wehw iiHz |ov hsf hphsf$ NhmmlfAhf ehz cffm hm hg~ojhwf hmg zwsom` zvyyoswfs on wef fnnoswz on AFSZzlmjf lwz nosahwlom lm 8


48/171

@o~fsmafmw!Zyomzosfg Fmwfsyslzfz$ Pslwwfm Wfzwlaom| on Fgphsg K-GfAhsjo$ hjwlm` glsfjwos$ Nfgfshd Eovzlm` Nlmhmjf H`fmj|$ Wef Nvwvsf onEovzlm` Nlmhmjf; H Yso`sfzz Vyghwf om wef @ZFz$ hw 3 %Zfyw- 86$ 3989,%omdlmf hw nlmhmjlhdzfs~ljfz-eovzf-`o~/Afglh/nldf/efhslm`z/888/GfAhsjo9


49/171

aosw`h`fz-T89>T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T89>T Zff Zwhmghsg . Yoos'z @dochd Jsfglw Yoswhd$ Shwlm`z Glsfjw$Aosw`h`f Wsovcdfz Jomwlmvf Wo Pflè Om V-Z- Chmbz %Mo~- 7$ 3989,%omdlmf hw ppp3-zwhmghsghmgyoosz-joa/zyn/ygn/f~fmwz/

NLWjom88789Hswljdf6-ygn, %efsflmhnwfs iiZwhmghsg . Yoos'z om wef Layhjwon Aosw`h`f Wsovcdfz om V-Z- Chmbz'', %glzjvzzlom on cfzw hmg poszwjhzf zjfmhsloz,-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Aosf `fmfshdd|$ eopf~fs$ hmg hz mowfg cfdop$ wef fnnljlfmwnvmjwlomlm` on wef eovzlm` ahsbfw lz elèd| gfyfmgfmw om weffulzwfmjf on jdfhs ysoyfsw| slèwz hmg h df~fd on wsvzw wehw~hslovz ahsbfw yhswljlyhmwz eh~f lm fhje owefs hmg lm weflmwf`slw| on wef ahsbfw z|zwfa-T890T Ln wef jvssfmw nosfjdozvsflssf`vdhslwlfz yso~f wo cf plgfzysfhg$ wef| eh~f wef yowfmwlhdwo vmgfsalmf wsvzw lm wef df`lwlahj| on ahm| nosfjdozvsfz hmgefmjf lm wef df`hdlw| on wlwdf om ahm| nosfjdozfgysoyfswlfz-T895T Lm wehw jhzf$ lw lz yozzlcdf wehw cv|fsz plddh~olg yvsjehzlm` ysoyfswlfz lm nosfjdozvsf ysojffglm`z cfjhvzfwef| jhmmow cf zvsf wehw wef| hsf yvsjehzlm` h jdfhm wlwdf-Ysowfjwlomz lm wef dhp$ zvje hz weozf nos h comh!nlgf yvsjehzfsnos ~hdvf$ ah| mow fhzf wefls hmulfw| ln wef| hsf jomjfsmfgwehw wef| pldd cfjoaf facsoldfg lm dlwl`hwlom pefm yslos opmfszhyyfhd nosfjdozvsf svdlm`z- Wefzf jomjfsmz povdg cf dlbfd| wojomwlmvf vmwld wef zlwvhwlom lz sfzod~fg$ os hw dfhzw vmwld wefdf`hd lzzvfz zvssovmglm` wlwdf wo nosfjdozfg ysoyfswlfz eh~f

cffm jdhslnlfg- Weozf cv|fsz peo sfahlm pldd dlbfd| nhjf dfzzjoayfwlwlom hmg pldd onnfs ~fs| dop clgz- F~fm nosfjdozfg eoafzwehw eh~f hdsfhg| cffm zodg hsf hw slzb$ zlmjf eoafz zodgcfnosf wefzf gojvafmwhwlom lzzvfz jhaf wo dlèw jhmmow cfhzzvafg wo eh~f h df`hdd| yso~hcdf jehlm on wlwdf- Wefzf eoafzpldd wefsfnosf dlbfd| cf glnnljvdw wo sfzfdd$ fujfyw hw dopysljfz wehw hwwshjw slzb!wodfshmw cv|fsz-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T890T Efsmhmgo gf Zowo$ Wef A|zwfs| on Jhylwhd; Pe| JhylwhdlzaWslvayez lm wef Pfzw hmg Nhldz F~fs|pefsf Fdzf$ hw 6!>$ 807 %3999,

%iiNosahd ysoyfsw| wlwdfz hddopfg yfoydf wo ao~f wef nsvlwz on weflsdhcos nsoa h zahdd shm`f on ~hdlghwlom lmwo wehw on hm fuyhmgfgahsbfw-'',-

T895T Wef nfp nosfjdozfg eoafz pefsf h zlm`df chmb osl`lmhwfg wefaosw`h`f$ zfs~ljfg lw$ efdg lw hz h peodf dohm$ hmg ysojfzzfg wefnosfjdozvsf gojvafmwz wefazfd~fz hsf ~fs| vmdlbfd| wo cf hnnfjwfg- Weffnnfjw on wef lssf`vdhslwlfz om owefs w|yfz on dohmz hmg eoafz hsf$ hzglzjvzzfg lm welz sfyosw$ ysfzfmwd| ~fs| glnnljvdw wo ysfgljw-


50/171

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

F- Jovsw Jhzfz hmg Dlwl`hwlom

Wef nosfjdozvsf gojvafmwhwlom lssf`vdhslwlfz vmxvfzwlomhcd|

zeop h z|zwfa slggdfg plwe fssosz- Cvw wef xvfzwlom hslzfz;Pfsf wef| afsfd| zdoyy| alzwhbfz$ os pfsf wef| nshvgvdfmw?Glnnfslm` hmzpfsz wo welz xvfzwlom ah| mow hnnfjw jfswhlmsfafglfz h~hldhcdf wo h``slf~fg yhswlfz!!yvw!chjbz$ nosfuhaydf$ hsf h~hldhcdf nos cowe alzwhbfz hmg nos nshvg!!cvwpovdg hnnfjw yowfmwlhd ghah`fz lm h dhpzvlw-T89!NA8%Hys- 8$ 399>, %omdlmf hw ppp-zfjlmno-joa/gSZa>-~8Y|-j-ewa*8zwYh`f,%iiVyom glzjo~fs| os mowljf on hm| csfhje c| wef Hzzl`mos

WORSE CASE OR BEST CASE?? Examining the Consequences of Mortgage Irregularities for Financial...

Documents

Transcript of WORSE CASE OR BEST CASE?? Examining the Consequences of Mortgage Irregularities for Financial...