Will There Be Enough Fresh Water? - National Geographic Society · 2017-02-04 · 1 of 39 lesson...
Transcript of Will There Be Enough Fresh Water? - National Geographic Society · 2017-02-04 · 1 of 39 lesson...
1of39
lesson
WillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?Howcanwepreservesuppliesoffreshwaterforthefuture?
ContentCreatedby
Activity1:AvailabilityofFreshWater|45minsDirections1.EngagestudentsinthinkingabouthowwaterisdistributedonEarth.
ShowtheEarthfromSpacephotograph.TellstudentsthatmostofEarthiscoveredwithwater.ShowtheDiagramofWaterDistributiononEarth.(Inmediacarousel;clickthephotographimages.Clicktheimageandcarouseldownarrowstoseethefullimage.)Ask:
Howmuchofthewaterisavailableforustouseforthingslikedrinkingandcropirrigation—thingsthatrequirefreshwater?(Lessthan3%ofthetotalwateronEarthisfreshwater.)HowdoeswatercyclethroughEarth'ssystems?(WatermovesthroughoutEarth'ssystemsthroughprecipitation,runoff,andevaporation,amongotherprocesses.)
2.Discusstheroleofuncertaintyinthescientificprocess.
Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Weseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyintheforecastingofprecipitationamounts.HavestudentsgototheNOAANationalWeatherService.Askthemtoinputtheirzipcodesintothe"Localforecastby"City,St"orZIPcode"boxinthetopleft(under"Home"),hit“Go”,scrolldowntothebottomofthepage,andclickonthe“HourlyWeatherGraph”.Thispageshowsthehourlyweatherforecastforyourarea.Thefirstboxshowsthepredictedtemperatureanddewpoint(alongwithwindchillorheatindex,whenapplicable).Thesecondboxshowsthepredictedwindspeedanddirection.Thethirdboxshowsthepredictedskycover(i.e.cloudcover),relativehumidity,andchanceforprecipitation.Theboxesbelowthatlineshowwhethertheprecipitationislikelytoberain,snow,freezingrain,orsleet.Pointoutthelineforprecipitationpotential(thebrownline).Ask:
Whyistheprecipitationshownasa“%”?(Precipitationisdependentonotherfactors,suchasrelativehumidityandtemperature.Itismorelikelytoprecipitatewhenthetemperatureisthe
2of39
sameasorlowerthanthedewpoint.)Ifthereisalikelihoodofprecipitation,whyistheamountofrain/snowshownasranges?(Theamountofprecipitationthatwillfallisdependentontheamountofmoistureintheatmosphere.Theatmosphereiscontinuallychanging,sotheamountsareguidelinesforwhatcouldhappenratherthanperfectpredictions.)
Tellstudentsthattheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictionsandthattheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataisavailableastheyassesstheircertaintywiththeiranswers.Encouragestudentstodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions.
3.IntroducetheconceptofsystemsinEarth'swaterresources.
TellstudentsthatforecastingwhatwillhappeninEarth'sclimatesystemisacomplicatedprocessbecausetherearemanydifferentinteractingparts.Scientiststhinkabouthowonepartofthesystemcanaffectotherpartsofthesystem.Givestudentsasimpleexampleofasystem,asdescribedinthescenariobelow.
Onanisland,thereisapopulationoffoxesandapopulationofrabbits.Thefoxespreyontherabbits.Ask:
Whentherearealotofrabbits,whatwillhappentothefoxpopulation?(Itwillincreasebecausethereisanamplefoodsupply.)Ask:Whathappenstothefoxpopulationwhenthey’veeatenmostoftherabbits?(Thefoxeswilldieofstarvationastheirfoodsupplydecreases.)Whathappenstotheamountofgrasswhenthefoxpopulationishigh?(Theamountofgrasswillincreasebecausetherearefewerrabbitstoeatthegrass.)Ifthereisadroughtandthegrassdoesn’tgrowwell,whatwillhappentothepopulationsoffoxesandrabbits?(Therabbitpopulationwilldecreasebecausetheyhavealesserfoodsupply.Thefoxpopulationshouldalsodecreaseastheirfoodsupplydecreases.)
Humansintroducedogstotheisland.Thedogscompetewiththefoxesovertherabbitfoodsupply.Ask:Whatwillhappentothepopulationsoffoxes,rabbits,andgrassafterthedogsareintroduced?(Thefoxeswilldecreasebecausethey’resharingtheirfoodsupply,therabbitswilldecreasebecausethey’vegotmorepredation,andthegrasswilldowellbecauseoftheloweredimpactofthesmallerrabbitpopulation.)
Tellstudentsthatsimplecause-effectrelationshipscanexpandintomorecomplexsystemrelationships.Letstudentsknowthattheywillbeexploringtherelationshipbetweenhowsediments
3of39
androcktypesaffectsgroundwatermovement.Encouragestudentstothinkabouthowhumanactionsplayaroleinchangesintheflowofwaterandinfreshwateravailability.
4.Introduceanddiscusstheuseofcomputationalmodels.
Introducetheconceptofcomputationalmodels,andgivestudentsanexampleofacomputationalmodelthattheymayhaveseen,suchasforecastingtheweather.Theweatherforecastprovidesagoodexampleofhowmodelinputisusedtopredictfutureconditions.ProjecttheNOAAWeatherForecastModel,whichprovidesagoodexampleofacomputationalmodel.Tellstudentsthatscientistsusedcurrentinformationabouttheenergyandmoistureintheatmosphereasaninputtothemodel,andthatwhattheyseeontheweathermapistheoutputofthemodel'scalculations.
5.HavestudentslaunchtheAvailabilityofFreshWaterinteractive.
ProvidestudentswiththelinktotheAvailabilityofFreshWaterinteractive.Dividestudentsintogroupsoftwoorthree,withtwobeingtheidealgroupingtoallowgroupstoshareacomputerworkstation.Tellstudentstheywillbeworkingthroughaseriesofpagesofmodelsanddatawithrelatedquestions.Askstudentstoworkthroughtheactivityintheirgroups,discussingandrespondingtoquestionsastheygo.
LetstudentsknowthatthisisActivity1oftheWillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?lesson.
6.Discusstheissues.
Afterstudentshavecompletedtheactivity,bringthegroupsbacktogetherandleadadiscussionfocusingonthefollowingquestions.Ask:
Whenwaterfallsontheground,whatcanhappentoit?(Waterthatfallsonthegroundcanrunoffintostreamsoritcanbeabsorbedintotheground.Studentsmayalsosaythatwatercanevaporate.)Whyiswaterconsideredarenewableresource?(Waterisconsideredarenewableresourcebecauseitcyclesthroughthegroundandatmosphere.)Whataresomewaysthathumanshaveaffectedthequantityandqualityofwatersuppliesaroundtheworld?(Humanshavechangedthesurface,whichhasallowedlesswatertoinfiltratethesurface.Theyhavepulledwateroutofverydeepaquifersindesertareas.Theyhaveinadvertentlycontaminatedsomewatersupplies.)
TipTosavestudents'dataforgradingonline,registeryourclassforfreeattheHigh-AdventureScience
4of39
portalpage.
TipThisactivityispartofasequenceofactivitiesinthelessonWillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?.Theactivitiesworkbestifusedinsequence.
ModificationThisactivitymaybeusedindividuallyoringroupsoftwoorthreestudents.Itmayalsobemodifiedforawhole-classformat.Ifusingasawhole-classactivity,useanLCDprojectororinteractivewhiteboardtoprojecttheactivity.Turnembeddedquestionsintoclassdiscussions.Uncertaintyitemsallowforclassroomdebatesovertheevidence.
InformalAssessment1.Checkstudents'comprehensionbyaskingstudentsthefollowingquestions:
Whenwaterfallsontheground,whatcanhappentoit?Whyiswaterconsideredarenewableresource?
2.Usetheanswerkeytocheckstudents'answersonembeddedassessments.
ObjectivesSubjects&DisciplinesScience
EarthscienceGeneralscience
LearningObjectivesStudentswill:
describethelocationsoffreshwateronEarthexplainwhyfreshwaterisconsideredarenewableresourcedescribehowhumanshaveaffectedfreshwatersuppliesonEarth
TeachingApproachLearning-for-use
TeachingMethodsDiscussionsMultimediainstructionSelf-pacedlearningVisualinstructionWriting
SkillsSummaryThisactivitytargetsthefollowingskills:
5of39
21stCenturyStudentOutcomesInformation,Media,andTechnologySkills
Information,Communications,andTechnologyLiteracyLearningandInnovationSkills
CriticalThinkingandProblemSolving21stCenturyThemes
EnvironmentalLiteracyGlobalAwareness
CriticalThinkingSkillsAnalyzingEvaluatingUnderstanding
NationalStandards,Principles,andPractices
NationalScienceEducationStandards
•(5-8)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardE-2:Understandingsaboutscienceandtechnology•(5-8)StandardG-1:Scienceasahumanendeavor•(5-8)StandardG-2:Natureofscience•(9-12)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardE-2:Understandingsaboutscienceandtechnology•(9-12)StandardF-4:Environmentalquality•(9-12)StandardG-2:Natureofscientificknowledge
CommonCoreStateStandardsforEnglishLanguageArts&Literacy
•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.9-10.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:
6of39
KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.6-8.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.11-12.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.1
ISTEStandardsforStudents(ISTEStandards*S)
•Standard3:ResearchandInformationFluency•Standard4:CriticalThinking,ProblemSolving,andDecisionMaking
NextGenerationScienceStandards
•CrosscuttingConcept1:Patterns•CrosscuttingConcept2:Causeandeffect:Mechanismandprediction•CrosscuttingConcept3:Scale,proportion,andquantity•CrosscuttingConcept5:Energyandmatter:Flows,cycles,andconservation•ScienceandEngineeringPractice1:Askingquestionsanddefiningproblems•ScienceandEngineeringPractice4:Analyzingandinterpretingdata•ScienceandEngineeringPractice5:Usingmathematicsandcomputationalthinking•ScienceandEngineeringPractice6:Constructingexplanationsanddesigningsolutions•ScienceandEngineeringPractice7:Engaginginargumentfromevidence•ScienceandEngineeringPractice8:Obtaining,evaluating,andcommunicatinginformation
7of39
PreparationBackground&VocabularyBackgroundInformationWatercyclesthroughEarth'ssystems.ItfallsonEarth'ssurfaceasprecipitation.Theprecipitationcanevaporatebackintotheatmosphere,itcanpercolateintotheground,oritcanrunoffintosurfacebodiesofwater.Thecompositionofthelayersofrockandsedimentdeterminewhetherprecipitationcanpercolateintothegroundwater.
PriorKnowledge[]RecommendedPriorActivities
None
VocabularyTerm Partof
Speech Definition
aquifer noun anundergroundlayerofrockorearthwhichholdsgroundwater.
condensation noun processbywhichwatervaporbecomesliquid.
conservation nounmanagementofanaturalresourcetopreventexploitation,destruction,orneglect.
evaporation noun processbywhichliquidwaterbecomeswatervapor.
freshwater adjectivehavingtodowithahabitatorecosystemofalake,river,orspring.
groundwater noun waterfoundinanaquifer.
model,computationalnoun
amathematicalmodelthatrequiresextensivecomputationalresourcestostudythebehaviorofacomplexsystembycomputersimulation.
precipitation noun allformsinwhichwaterfallstoEarthfromtheatmosphere.
sustainability noun useofresourcesinsuchamannerthattheywillneverbeexhausted.
system nouncollectionofitemsororganismsthatarelinkedandrelated,functioningasawhole.
transpiration noun evaporationofwaterfromplants.
watercycle noun movementofwaterbetweenatmosphere,land,andocean.
Partner
8of39
FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder
GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.
Activity2:UsingFreshWater|45minsDirections1.Engagestudentsinthinkingabouthowfreshwaterisused.
Tellstudentsinthisactivitytheywillbetakingacloselookathowhumansusewater—bothindirectandindirectways.Theywillexaminetherelationshipbetweenfreshwaterdistributionandpopulations,andtheywillanalyzethecostsandbenefitsofputtingdamsonriversandstreams.Tobegin,ask:Howdoyouusefreshwater?(Studentanswerwillvary,butwillincludeexampleslikethefollowing:Freshwaterisusedfordrinking,bathing,flushingtoilets,andirrigating.Freshwaterisalsousedinelectricityproductionandmanufacturing.)
2.Discusstheroleofuncertaintyinthescientificprocess.
Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Wecanseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyintheforecastingofprecipitationamounts.HavestudentsgototheNOAANationalWeatherService.Askthemtoinputtheirzipcodes,hit“Go”,scrolldowntothebottomofthepage,andclickonthe“HourlyWeatherGraph”.Thispageshowsthehourlyweatherforecastforyourarea.Thefirstboxshowsthepredictedtemperatureanddewpoint(alongwithwindchillorheatindex,whenapplicable).Thesecondboxshowsthepredictedwindspeedanddirection.Thethirdboxshowsthepredictedskycover(i.e.cloudcover),relativehumidity,andchanceforprecipitation.Theboxesbelowthatlineshowwhethertheprecipitationislikelytoberain,snow,freezingrain,orsleet.Pointoutthelineforprecipitationpotential(thebrownline).Ask:
Whyistheprecipitationshownasa“%”?(Precipitationisdependentonotherfactors,suchasrelativehumidityandtemperature.Itismorelikelytoprecipitatewhenthetemperatureisthesameasorlowerthanthedewpoint.)Ifthereisalikelihoodofprecipitation,whyistheamountofrain/snowshownasranges?(Theamountofprecipitationthatwillfallisdependentontheamountofmoistureintheatmosphere.Theatmosphereiscontinuallychanging,sotheamountsareguidelinesforwhatcouldhappen
9of39
ratherthanperfectpredictions.)
*Ifthereisnoorlowlikelihoodofprecipitationinyourarea,youmaywanttofindadifferentlocation(intheUnitedStates)thathasahigherlikelihoodofprecipitation.Youcanlookatacurrentweathermap(radar)tofindwhereintheUnitedStatesprecipitationishappeningcurrently.Yourstudentswillthenbeabletoseescientists'forecastsofprecipitationamountsrepresentedasarangeoverlaidonthebargraphs.
Tellstudentstheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictionsandthattheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataareavailableastheyassesstheircertaintywiththeiranswers.Encouragestudentstodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions.
3.IntroducetheconceptofsystemsinEarth'swaterresources.
TellstudentsthatforecastingwhatwillhappentoEarth'sfreshwatersuppliesisacomplicatedprocessbecausetherearemanydifferentinteractingparts.Tellstudentsthatscientiststhinkabouthowonepartofthesystemcanaffectotherpartsofthesystem.Givestudentsasimpleexampleofasystem,asdescribedinthescenariobelow.
Onanisland,thereisapopulationoffoxesandapopulationofrabbits.Thefoxespreyontherabbits.Ask:
Whentherearealotofrabbits,whatwillhappentothefoxpopulation?(Itwillincreasebecausethereisanamplefoodsupply.)Whathappenstothefoxpopulationwhenthey’veeatenmostoftherabbits?(Thefoxeswilldieofstarvationastheirfoodsupplydecreases.)Whathappenstotheamountofgrasswhenthefoxpopulationishigh?(Theamountofgrasswillincreasebecausetherearefewerrabbitstoeatthegrass.)Ifthereisadroughtandthegrassdoesn’tgrowwell,whatwillhappentothepopulationsoffoxesandrabbits?(Therabbitpopulationwilldecreasebecausetheyhavealesserfoodsupply.Thefoxpopulationshouldalsodecreaseastheirfoodsupplydecreases.)
Humansintroducedogstotheisland.Thedogscompetewiththefoxesovertherabbitfoodsupply.Ask:Whatwillhappentothepopulationsoffoxes,rabbits,andgrassafterthedogsareintroduced?(Thefoxeswilldecreasebecausetheyaresharingtheirfoodsupply,therabbitswilldecreasebecausetheyhavemorepredators,andthegrasswilldowellbecauseoftheloweredimpactofthesmallerrabbitpopulation.)
10of39
Tellstudentsthatsimplecause-effectrelationshipscanexpandintomorecomplexsystemrelationships.Letstudentsknowthattheywillbeexploringtherelationshipbetweenhowsedimentsandrocktypesaffectsgroundwatermovement.Encouragestudentstothinkabouthowhumanactionsplayaroleinchangesintheflowofwaterandinfreshwateravailability.
4.HavestudentslaunchtheUsingFreshWaterinteractive.
ProvidestudentswiththelinktotheUsingFreshWaterinteractive.Dividestudentsintogroupsoftwoorthree,withtwobeingtheidealgroupingtoallowgroupstoshareacomputerworkstation.Tellstudentsthattheywillbeworkingthroughaseriesofpagesofdatawithquestionsrelatedtothedata.Askstudentstoworkthroughtheactivityintheirgroups,discussingandrespondingtoquestionsastheygo.
TellstudentsthatthisisActivity2oftheWillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?lesson.
5.Discusstheissues.
Afterstudentshavecompletedtheactivity,bringthegroupsbacktogetherandleadadiscussionfocusingonthesequestions:
Evenifyouliveinanareawherefreshwaterisplentiful,whydoyouhavetobeconcernedaboutthefreshwatersupply?(Youshouldstillbeconcernedaboutthefreshwatersupplybecauseitcanbecontaminatedbyhumanactions.Thiswouldmakethefreshwateruselesseveniftherewasalotofit.)
Arethebenefitsofdamsworththecostsofdams?(Answerswillvary.Someofthebenefitsofdamsarefloodcontrol,recreation,andelectricityproduction.Someofthecostsofdamsarehabitatdisruption,sedimentdepletionofriverdeltas,andlossofsurroundingland.)
Whataresomewaysthathumanshaveaffectedthequantityandqualityofwatersuppliesaroundtheworld?(Humanshavechangedthesurface,whichhasallowedlesswatertoinfiltratethesurface.Theyhavepulledwateroutofverydeepaquifersindesertareas.Theyhaveinadvertentlycontaminatedsomewatersupplies.)
TipTosavestudents'dataforgradingonline,registeryourclassforfreeattheHigh-AdventureScienceportalpage.
Tip
11of39
ThisactivityispartofasequenceofactivitiesinthelessonWillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?.Theactivitiesworkbestifusedinsequence.
ModificationThisactivitymaybeusedindividuallyoringroupsoftwoorthreestudents.Itmayalsobemodifiedforawhole-classformat.Ifusingasawhole-classactivity,useanLCDprojectororinteractivewhiteboardtoprojecttheactivity.Turnembeddedquestionsintoclassdiscussions.Uncertaintyitemsallowforclassroomdebatesovertheevidence.
InformalAssessment1.Checkstudents'comprehensionbyaskingthemthefollowingquestions:
HowarefreshwaterresourcesdistributedonEarth?Whataresomedirectandindirectusesofwater?
2.Usetheanswerkeytocheckstudents'answeronembeddedassessments.
ObjectivesSubjects&DisciplinesScience
EarthscienceGeneralscience
LearningObjectivesStudentswill:
describetherelationshipbetweenfreshwaterdistributionandpopulationslistdirectandindirectusesoffreshwaterdescribesomeofthecostsandbenefitsofputtingdamsonriversandstreams
TeachingApproachLearning-for-use
TeachingMethodsDiscussionsMultimediainstructionSelf-pacedlearningVisualinstructionWriting
SkillsSummaryThisactivitytargetsthefollowingskills:
12of39
21stCenturyStudentOutcomesInformation,Media,andTechnologySkills
Information,Communications,andTechnologyLiteracyLearningandInnovationSkills
CriticalThinkingandProblemSolvingCriticalThinkingSkills
AnalyzingEvaluatingUnderstanding
NationalStandards,Principles,andPractices
NationalScienceEducationStandards
•(5-8)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardE-2:Understandingsaboutscienceandtechnology•(5-8)StandardG-1:Scienceasahumanendeavor•(5-8)StandardG-2:Natureofscience•(9-12)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardE-2:Understandingsaboutscienceandtechnology•(9-12)StandardF-4:Environmentalquality•(9-12)StandardG-2:Natureofscientificknowledge
CommonCoreStateStandardsforEnglishLanguageArts&Literacy
•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.9-10.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.1
13of39
•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.6-8.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.11-12.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.1
ISTEStandardsforStudents(ISTEStandards*S)
•Standard3:ResearchandInformationFluency•Standard4:CriticalThinking,ProblemSolving,andDecisionMaking
NextGenerationScienceStandards
•CrosscuttingConcept1:Patterns•CrosscuttingConcept2:Causeandeffect:Mechanismandprediction•CrosscuttingConcept3:Scale,proportion,andquantity•CrosscuttingConcept5:Energyandmatter:Flows,cycles,andconservation•ScienceandEngineeringPractice1:Askingquestionsanddefiningproblems•ScienceandEngineeringPractice4:Analyzingandinterpretingdata•ScienceandEngineeringPractice5:Usingmathematicsandcomputationalthinking•ScienceandEngineeringPractice6:Constructingexplanationsanddesigningsolutions•ScienceandEngineeringPractice7:Engaginginargumentfromevidence•ScienceandEngineeringPractice8:Obtaining,evaluating,andcommunicatinginformation
PreparationBackground&Vocabulary
14of39
BackgroundInformationFreshwaterresourcesareunevenlydistributedonEarth'ssurface.Thisisduetoclimaticconditions(precipitationandtemperature)andtogeologicalconditions(theabilityofwatertopercolateintothegroundwater).
Waterisusedformanydifferentpurposes.Someusesareclear:waterfordrinking,bathing,andwateringplants.Otherusesarehidden:industrialprocesses,electricityproduction,manufacturing.Theobvioususesarecalled“directusage”;thehiddenusesofwaterarecalled“indirectuses”.
Asthehumanpopulationhasgrown,wateruseforagricultural,industrial,andmunicipaluseshasincreased.Wherethereisalargeamountofwateravailable,therehavebeenrelativelyfewproblems.Butwherewateravailabilityislimited,theincreasedwaterusagehasledsomecommunitiestoimposebansonunnecessarywateruse.
PriorKnowledge[]RecommendedPriorActivities
AvailabilityofFreshWater
VocabularyTerm Partof
Speech Definition
agriculture nountheartandscienceofcultivatingthelandforgrowingcrops(farming)orraisinglivestock(ranching).
aquifer noun anundergroundlayerofrockorearthwhichholdsgroundwater.
dam noun structurebuiltacrossariverorotherwaterwaytocontroltheflowofwater.
freshwater adjectivehavingtodowithahabitatorecosystemofalake,river,orspring.
groundwater noun waterfoundinanaquifer.
model,computationalnoun
amathematicalmodelthatrequiresextensivecomputationalresourcestostudythebehaviorofacomplexsystembycomputersimulation.
municipal adjectivehavingtodowithlocalgovernment.
percapitaadjective
foreachindividual.
15of39
populationdensity noun thenumberofpeoplelivinginasetarea,suchasasquaremile.
reservoir noun naturalorman-madelake.
runoff noun overflowoffluidfromafarmorindustrialfactory.
systems-understandingnoun
processofcomprehendingandcommunicatingcomplex,relatedsetsofinformationandinteractions.
Term PartofSpeech Definition
Partner
FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder
GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.
Activity3:GroundwaterMovement|45minsDirections1.Sparkstudentdiscussionabouthowwatermoves.
ShowtheModel2:SedimentColumns.Runthemodel,andletstudentsobservehowthewatermoleculesmovethroughthedifferentsediments.Ask:
Whydoyouthinkwaterpoolsatthetopoftheblackcolumnwhileitflowsthroughthepinkcolumn?(Studentsmightrespondthatthematerialoftheblackcolumnhasfewerholesthroughwhichthewatercanflow.Thematerialinthepinkcolumnmightbemorelooselypackedthanthematerialintheblackcolumn.Thespacesallowthewatertoflowdown.Iftherearenospaces,thenthewatercan'tflowdownaseasily(oratall).)Whatwouldhappenifthewaterlevelreachedthetopoftheblackbasin?(Ifthewaterlevelreachedthetopoftheblackbasin,itwouldspilloverintothenextcolumn.)
Tellstudentsthattheywillbeinvestigatingthecharacteristicsofdifferentrocksandsedimentsthatletwaterflowthroughatdifferentrates.
16of39
2.Discusstheroleofuncertaintyinthescientificprocess.
Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Wecanseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyintheforecastingofprecipitationamounts.HavestudentsgotoNOAANationalWeatherService.Askthemtoinputtheirzipcodes,hit“Go”,scrolldowntothebottomofthepage,andclickonthe“HourlyWeatherGraph”.Thispageshowsthehourlyweatherforecastforyourarea.Thefirstboxshowsthepredictedtemperatureanddewpoint(alongwithwindchillorheatindex,whenapplicable).Thesecondboxshowsthepredictedwindspeedanddirection.Thethirdboxshowsthepredictedskycover(i.e.cloudcover),relativehumidity,andchanceforprecipitation.Theboxesbelowthatlineshowwhethertheprecipitationislikelytoberain,snow,freezingrain,orsleet.Pointoutthelineforprecipitationpotential(thebrownline).Ask:
Whyistheprecipitationshownasa“%”?(Precipitationisdependentonotherfactors,suchasrelativehumidityandtemperature.Itismorelikelytoprecipitatewhenthetemperatureisthesameasorlowerthanthedewpoint.)Ifthereisalikelihoodofprecipitation,whyistheamountofrain/snowshownasranges?(Theamountofprecipitationthatwillfallisdependentontheamountofmoistureintheatmosphere.Theatmosphereiscontinuallychanging,sotheamountsareguidelinesforwhatcouldhappenratherthanperfectpredictions.)
*Ifthereisnoorlowlikelihoodofprecipitationinyourarea,youmaywanttofindadifferentlocation(intheUnitedStates)thathasahigherlikelihoodofprecipitation.Youcanlookatacurrentweathermap(radar)tofindwhereintheUnitedStatesprecipitationishappeningcurrently.Yourstudentswillthenbeabletoseescientists'forecastsofprecipitationamountsrepresentedasarangeoverlaidonthebargraphs.
Tellstudentstheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictionsandthattheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataareavailableastheyassesstheircertaintyabouttheiranswer.Encouragestudentstodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions.
3.IntroducetheconceptofsystemsinEarth'swaterresources.
TellstudentsthatforecastingwhatwillhappentoEarth'sfreshwatersuppliesisacomplicatedprocessbecausetherearemanydifferentinteractingparts.Tellstudentsthatscientiststhinkabouthowonepartofthesystemcanaffectotherpartsofthesystem.Givestudentsasimpleexampleofasystem,asdescribedinthescenariobelow.
Onanisland,thereisapopulationoffoxesandapopulationofrabbits.Thefoxespreyontherabbits.
17of39
Ask:
Whentherearealotofrabbits,whatwillhappentothefoxpopulation?(Itwillincreasebecausethereisanamplefoodsupply.)Whathappenstothefoxpopulationwhenthey’veeatenmostoftherabbits?(Thefoxeswilldieofstarvationastheirfoodsupplydecreases.)Whathappenstotheamountofgrasswhenthefoxpopulationishigh?(Theamountofgrasswillincreasebecausetherearefewerrabbitstoeatthegrass.)Ifthereisadroughtandthegrassdoesn’tgrowwell,whatwillhappentothepopulationsoffoxesandrabbits?(Therabbitpopulationwilldecreasebecausetheyhavealesserfoodsupply.Thefoxpopulationshouldalsodecreaseastheirfoodsupplydecreases.)
Humansintroducedogstotheisland.Thedogscompetewiththefoxesovertherabbitfoodsupply.Ask:Whatwillhappentothepopulationsoffoxes,rabbits,andgrassafterthedogsareintroduced?(Thefoxeswilldecreasebecausetheyaresharingtheirfoodsupply,therabbitswilldecreasebecausetheyhavemorepredators,andthegrasswilldowellbecauseoftheloweredimpactofthesmallerrabbitpopulation.)
Tellstudentsthatsimplecause-effectrelationshipscanexpandintomorecomplexsystemrelationships.Letstudentsknowthattheywillbeexploringtherelationshipbetweenhowsedimentsandrocktypesaffectsgroundwatermovement.Encouragestudentstothinkabouthowhumanactionsplayaroleinchangesintheflowofwaterandinfreshwateravailability.
4.Introduceanddiscusstheuseofcomputationalmodels.
Introducetheconceptofcomputationalmodels,andgivestudentsanexampleofacomputationalmodelthattheymayhaveseen,suchasforecastingtheweather.Theweatherforecastprovidesagoodexampleofhowmodelinputisusedtopredictfutureconditions.GotoNOAAWeatherForecastModel.Tellstudentsthatscientistsusedcurrentinformationabouttheenergyandmoistureintheatmosphereasaninputtothemodel,andthatwhattheyseeontheweathermapistheoutputofthemodel'scalculations.
5.HavestudentslaunchtheGroundwaterMovementinteractive
ProvidestudentswiththelinktotheExploringGroundwaterMovementinteractive.Dividestudentsintogroupsoftwoorthree,withtwobeingtheidealgroupingforsharingcomputerworkstations.Informstudentstheywillbeworkingthroughaseriesofpagesofmodelswithquestionsrelatedtothemodels.Askstudentstoworkthroughtheactivityintheirgroups,discussingandrespondingtoquestionsastheygo.
18of39
LetstudentsknowthatthisisActivity3oftheWillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?lesson.
6.Discusstheissues.
Afterstudentshavecompletedtheactivity,bringthegroupsbacktogetherandleadadiscussionfocusingonthesequestions:
Howcanwatermovethroughrocksthatlooksolid?(Watermovesthroughverysmallspaces.Therockcanlooksolidevenwhenithasmanytinyspacesthroughwhichwatercanmove.)Howdoestheshapeandsizeofporespacesaffectthepermeabilityofdifferentsediments?(Moreporoussedimentshavelargerparticleswithlargespacesbetweenthem.Sedimentswithsmallerparticlesarelesspermeablebecausetheparticlespackclosertogether,leavinglessspaceforwatertomovethrough.)Ifarock/sedimentisporous,doesthatmeanitisalsopermeable?(Arock/sedimentcanbeporouswithoutbeingpermeable.Ifthespacesdonotconnecttoeachother,watercannotmovethroughtherock/sediment.)Whatkindofrocks/sedimentsmakeagoodaquifer?(Rocks/Sedimentsthatareverypermeablemakeagoodaquifer.Thisisbecausetheyallowquickflowofwater,whichmeansthatyoucangetagoodflowfromthewellaswellasquickrechargefromprecipitation,assumingthattheaquiferisunconfined.
TipTosavestudents'dataforgradingonline,registeryourclassforfreeattheHigh-AdventureScienceportalpage.
TipThisactivityispartofasequenceofactivitiesinthelessonWillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?.Theactivitiesworkbestifusedinsequence.
ModificationThisactivitymaybeusedindividuallyoringroupsoftwoorthreestudents,orasawholeclassactivity.Ifusingasawholeclassactivity,useanLCDprojectororinteractivewhiteboardtoprojecttheactivity.
InformalAssessment1.Checkstudents'comprehensionbyaskingthefollowingquestions:
Howcanwatermovethroughrocksthatlooksolid?Whydoessandhavesuchahighflowratecomparedtoclay?Ifarockisporous,doesthatmeanitisalsopermeable?Isitbettertouseaconfinedaquiferoranunconfinedaquiferforawatersupply?
19of39
2.Usetheanswerkeytocheckstudents'answersonembeddedquestions.
ObjectivesSubjects&DisciplinesScience
EarthscienceGeneralscience
LearningObjectivesStudentswill:
explainthedifferencebetweenporosityandpermeabilitywithinthecontextofwatermovementexplainhowthepermeabilityofasedimentaffectswatermovementpredictwherewaterwillaccumulatebasedontopographyandpermeabilitypredictthelocationofaquifersbasedonagiventopographypredictwhattypesofrocks/sedimentswillformaquifers
TeachingApproachLearning-for-use
TeachingMethodsDiscussionsMultimediainstructionSelf-pacedlearningVisualinstructionWriting
SkillsSummaryThisactivitytargetsthefollowingskills:
21stCenturyStudentOutcomesInformation,Media,andTechnologySkills
Information,Communications,andTechnologyLiteracyLearningandInnovationSkills
CriticalThinkingandProblemSolving21stCenturyThemes
EnvironmentalLiteracyGlobalAwareness
CriticalThinkingSkillsAnalyzingEvaluatingUnderstanding
20of39
NationalStandards,Principles,andPractices
NationalScienceEducationStandards
•(5-8)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardD-1:Structureoftheearthsystem•(5-8)StandardE-2:Understandingsaboutscienceandtechnology•(5-8)StandardG-2:Natureofscience•(9-12)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardB-2:Structureandpropertiesofmatter•(9-12)StandardB-6:Interactionsofenergyandmatter•(9-12)StandardD-1:Energyintheearthsystem•(9-12)StandardE-2:Understandingsaboutscienceandtechnology•(9-12)StandardG-1:Scienceasahumanendeavor•(9-12)StandardG-2:Natureofscientificknowledge
CommonCoreStateStandardsforEnglishLanguageArts&Literacy
•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.9-10.4
21of39
•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.11-12.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.3
ISTEStandardsforStudents(ISTEStandards*S)
•Standard3:ResearchandInformationFluency•Standard4:CriticalThinking,ProblemSolving,andDecisionMaking
NextGenerationScienceStandards
•CrosscuttingConcept2:Causeandeffect:Mechanismandprediction•CrosscuttingConcept4:Systemsandsystemmodels•CrosscuttingConcept5:Energyandmatter:Flows,cycles,andconservation•CrosscuttingConcept6:Structureandfunction•CrosscuttingConcept7:Stabilityandchange•ScienceandEngineeringPractice1:Askingquestionsanddefiningproblems•ScienceandEngineeringPractice2:Developingandusingmodels•ScienceandEngineeringPractice3:Planningandcarryingoutinvestigations•ScienceandEngineeringPractice4:Analyzingandinterpretingdata•ScienceandEngineeringPractice6:Constructingexplanationsanddesigningsolutions•ScienceandEngineeringPractice7:Engaginginargumentfromevidence•ScienceandEngineeringPractice8:Obtaining,evaluating,andcommunicatinginformation
PreparationBackground&VocabularyBackgroundInformationWatermovesthroughEarth'sgeologicallayers.Itsmovementiscontrolledbythetopographyandthe
22of39
permeabilityofthelayers.Sedimentshavedifferentporositiesandpermeabilities.Porosityisameasureofhowmuchspacethereisbetweensedimentparticles.Permeabilityisameasureofhowconnectedtheholesare.Asedimentcanbeporouswithoutbeingpermeableiftheporesdonotconnecttoeachotherandtotheoutside.
Aquifersarelayersofrock/sedimentbelowEarth'ssurfacethatholdgroundwater,preventingitfromseepingfurtherunderground.Whenhumansdrillwellsintothegroundtoextractwater,theydrillintoaquifers.Theflowofwateroutofanaquiferisdependentonthepermeabilityoftherocks/sedimentsaroundit.
Aquiferscomeintwovarieties:confinedandunconfined.Confinedaquifersarecoveredbyanimpermeablelayer,preventingprecipitationfromrefillingtheaquifers.Unconfinedaquifersarecoveredbypermeablelayers,allowingprecipitationtorefillthem.
PriorKnowledge[]RecommendedPriorActivities
AvailabilityofFreshWaterUsingFreshWater
VocabularyTerm Partof
Speech Definition
aquifer noun anundergroundlayerofrockorearthwhichholdsgroundwater.
bedrock noun solidrockbeneaththeEarth'ssoilandsand.
clay noun typeofsedimentaryrockthatisabletobeshapedwhenwet.
confinedaquifer noun layerofwater-bearingrockbetweentwolayersoflesspermeablerock.
conservation nounmanagementofanaturalresourcetopreventexploitation,destruction,orneglect.
freshwater noun waterthatisnotsalty.
gravel noun smallstonesorpebbles.
groundwater noun waterfoundinanaquifer.
23of39
model,computationalnoun
amathematicalmodelthatrequiresextensivecomputationalresourcestostudythebehaviorofacomplexsystembycomputersimulation.
permeable adjectiveallowingliquidandgasestopassthrough.
pore noun tinyopening.
porosity nountheratioofthevolumeofallthepores,orholes,inanobjectandtheobject'stotalmass.
porous adjectivefulloftinyholes,orabletobepermeatedbywater.
pumice noun typeofigneousrockwithmanypores.
recharge verb toreneworrestoretoapreviouscondition.
runoff noun overflowoffluidfromafarmorindustrialfactory.
sand noun small,loosegrainsofdisintegratedrocks.
silt noun smallsedimentparticles.
sustainability noun useofresourcesinsuchamannerthattheywillneverbeexhausted.
system nouncollectionofitemsororganismsthatarelinkedandrelated,functioningasawhole.
topography noun theshapeofthesurfacefeaturesofanarea.
unconfinedaquifer noun layerofwater-bearingrockcoveredbypermeablerock.
watercycle noun movementofwaterbetweenatmosphere,land,andocean.
Term PartofSpeech Definition
Partner
FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder
GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedin
24of39
thismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.
Activity4:GroundwaterandSurfaceWater|45minsDirections1.Engagestudentsinthinkingabouthowwatermovesthroughsediments.
Tellstudentsthatmuchoftheirwatercomesfromgroundwaterandthatwatermovesfromthegroundtothesurface.Ask:
Whydoeswatermovethroughgravelmorequicklythanitmovesthroughclay?(Gravelismorepermeablethanclay.)Woulditbeeasiertogetwateroutofsandoroutofgravel?(Itwouldbeeasiertogetwateroutofgravelbecausetheporespacesarelarger.Thewaterwillmovemorequicklythroughlargerporespaces.)
2.Discusstheroleofuncertaintyinthescientificprocess.
Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Wecanseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyintheforecastingofprecipitationamounts.HavestudentsgotoNOAANationalWeatherService.Askthemtoinputtheirzipcodes,hit“Go”,scrolldowntothebottomofthepage,andclickonthe“HourlyWeatherGraph”.Thispageshowsthehourlyweatherforecastforyourarea.Thefirstboxshowsthepredictedtemperatureanddewpoint(alongwithwindchillorheatindex,whenapplicable).Thesecondboxshowsthepredictedwindspeedanddirection.Thethirdboxshowsthepredictedskycover(i.e.cloudcover),relativehumidity,andchanceforprecipitation.Theboxesbelowthatlineshowwhethertheprecipitationislikelytoberain,snow,freezingrain,orsleet.Pointoutthelineforprecipitationpotential(thebrownline).Ask:
Whyistheprecipitationshownasa“%”?(Precipitationisdependentonotherfactors,suchasrelativehumidityandtemperature.Itismorelikelytoprecipitatewhenthetemperatureisthesameasorlowerthanthedewpoint.)Ifthereisalikelihoodofprecipitation,whyistheamountofrain/snowshownasranges?(Theamountofprecipitationthatwillfallisdependentontheamountofmoistureintheatmosphere.Theatmosphereiscontinuallychanging,sotheamountsareguidelinesforwhatcouldhappenratherthanperfectpredictions.)
*Ifthereisnoorlowlikelihoodofprecipitationinyourarea,youmaywanttofindadifferentlocation(intheUnitedStates)thathasahigherlikelihoodofprecipitation.Youcanlookatacurrentweathermap(radar)tofindwhereintheUnitedStatesprecipitationishappeningcurrently.Yourstudentswillthenbeabletoseescientists'forecastsofprecipitationamountsrepresentedasarangeoverlaidonthebargraphs.
25of39
Tellstudentstheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictionsandthattheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataareavailableastheyassesstheircertaintywiththeiranswers.Encouragestudentstodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions.
3.IntroducetheconceptofsystemsinEarth'swaterresources.
TellstudentsthatforecastingwhatwillhappentoEarth'sfreshwatersuppliesisacomplicatedprocessbecausetherearemanydifferentinteractingparts.Tellstudentsthatscientiststhinkabouthowonepartofthesystemcanaffectotherpartsofthesystem.Givestudentsasimpleexampleofasystem,asdescribedinthescenariobelow.
Onanisland,thereisapopulationoffoxesandapopulationofrabbits.Thefoxespreyontherabbits.Ask:
Whentherearealotofrabbits,whatwillhappentothefoxpopulation?(Itwillincreasebecausethereisanamplefoodsupply.)Whathappenstothefoxpopulationwhenthey’veeatenmostoftherabbits?(Thefoxeswilldieofstarvationastheirfoodsupplydecreases.)Whathappenstotheamountofgrasswhenthefoxpopulationishigh?(Theamountofgrasswillincreasebecausetherearefewerrabbitstoeatthegrass.)Ifthereisadroughtandthegrassdoesn’tgrowwell,whatwillhappentothepopulationsoffoxesandrabbits?(Therabbitpopulationwilldecreasebecausetheyhavealesserfoodsupply.Thefoxpopulationshouldalsodecreaseastheirfoodsupplydecreases.)
Humansintroducedogstotheisland.Thedogscompetewiththefoxesovertherabbitfoodsupply.Ask:Whatwillhappentothepopulationsoffoxes,rabbits,andgrassafterthedogsareintroduced?(Thefoxeswilldecreasebecausetheyaresharingtheirfoodsupply,therabbitswilldecreasebecausetheyhavemorepredators,andthegrasswilldowellbecauseoftheloweredimpactofthesmallerrabbitpopulation.)
Tellstudentsthatsimplecause-effectrelationshipscanexpandintomorecomplexsystemrelationships.Letstudentsknowthattheywillbeexploringtherelationshipbetweenhowsedimentsandrocktypesaffectsgroundwatermovement.Encouragestudentstothinkabouthowhumanactionsplayaroleinchangesintheflowofwaterandinfreshwateravailability.
4.Introduceanddiscusstheuseofcomputationalmodels.
26of39
Introducetheconceptofcomputationalmodels,andgivestudentsanexampleofacomputationalmodelthattheymayhaveseen,suchasforecastingtheweather.Theweatherforecastprovidesagoodexampleofhowmodelinputisusedtopredictfutureconditions.GotoNOAAWeatherForecastModel.Tellstudentsthatscientistsusedcurrentinformationabouttheenergyandmoistureintheatmosphereasaninputtothemodel,andthatwhattheyseeontheweathermapistheoutputofthemodel'scalculations.
5.HavestudentslaunchtheGroundwaterandSurfaceWaterinteractive.
ProvidestudentswiththelinktotheGroundwaterandSurfaceWaterinteractive.Dividestudentsintogroupsoftwoorthree,withtwobeingtheidealgroupingforsharingcomputerworkstations.Informstudentstheywillbeworkingthroughaseriesofpagesofmodelswithquestionsrelatedtothemodels.Askstudentstoworkthroughtheactivityintheirgroups,discussingandrespondingtoquestionsastheygo.
LetstudentsknowthatthisisActivity4oftheWillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?lesson.
6.Discusstheissues.
Afterstudentshavecompletedtheactivity,bringthegroupsbacktogetherandleadadiscussionfocusingonthesequestions:
Howdoesthewatertableaffecttherelativeamountofwaterinsurfacebodiesandunderground?(Whenthewatertableishigh,meaningthesoilissaturated,waterwillmove[orstay]abovegroundandsurfacebodiesofwaterwillexpand.Whenthewatertableislow,waterwillmovefromthesurfacedownwardtowardtheground.)Whataretheeffectsonastreamofremovingtoomuchwaterfromtheground?(Iftoomuchwaterisremovedfromtheground,thestreamcandryup.Thewatertablecanbeloweredbelowthelevelofthestream.)Howcanhumansbettermanagetheiruseoflimitedwatersupplies?(Humanscanconservewater.Theycanusethewastewatertorechargethewatersupplies.)Areriversanendlesssupplyoffreshwater?(Riversarenotanendlesssupplyoffreshwater.Theycanberundryifthewatertablegoestoolow.Thiscanhappenwhenpeoplewithdrawtoomuchwaterfromtheriverand/orfromthegroundwaterthatsuppliestheriver.Eventhoughtheriversstillreceiveprecipitation,theycanbedepletedifthewatertableisn'thighenough.)
TipTosavestudents'dataforgradingonline,registeryourclassforfreeattheHigh-AdventureScienceportalpage.
27of39
TipThisactivityispartofasequenceofactivitiesinthelessonWillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?.Theactivitiesworkbestifusedinsequence.
ModificationThisactivitymaybeusedindividuallyoringroupsoftwoorthreestudents,orasawholeclassactivity.Ifusingasawholeclassactivity,useanLCDprojectororinteractivewhiteboardtoprojecttheactivity.
InformalAssessment1.Checkstudents'comprehensionbyaskingstudentsthefollowingquestions:
Howdoeswatermovebetweengroundwaterandsurfacewaterwhenthewatertableishigh?Whatcanhumansdotokeepwaterflowinginstreams?
2.Usetheanswerkeytocheckstudents'answersonembeddedassessments.
ObjectivesSubjects&DisciplinesScience
EarthscienceGeneralscience
LearningObjectivesStudentswill:
describehowwatermovesbetweenthegroundandsurfacewaterbodiesdependingonthelevelofthewatertabledescribetheeffectsonastreamofwithdrawingtoomuchwater
TeachingApproachLearning-for-use
TeachingMethodsDiscussionsMultimediainstructionSelf-pacedlearningVisualinstructionWriting
SkillsSummaryThisactivitytargetsthefollowingskills:
28of39
21stCenturyStudentOutcomesInformation,Media,andTechnologySkills
Information,Communications,andTechnologyLiteracyLearningandInnovationSkills
CriticalThinkingandProblemSolving21stCenturyThemes
GlobalAwarenessCriticalThinkingSkills
AnalyzingEvaluatingUnderstanding
NationalStandards,Principles,andPractices
NationalScienceEducationStandards
•(5-8)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardD-1:Structureoftheearthsystem•(5-8)StandardG-2:Natureofscience•(9-12)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardB-6:Interactionsofenergyandmatter•(9-12)StandardG-2:Natureofscientificknowledge
CommonCoreStateStandardsforEnglishLanguageArts&Literacy
•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.9-10.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.11-12.4
29of39
•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.1
ISTEStandardsforStudents(ISTEStandards*S)
•Standard3:ResearchandInformationFluency•Standard4:CriticalThinking,ProblemSolving,andDecisionMaking
NextGenerationScienceStandards
•CrosscuttingConcept2:Causeandeffect:Mechanismandprediction•CrosscuttingConcept3:Scale,proportion,andquantity•CrosscuttingConcept4:Systemsandsystemmodels•CrosscuttingConcept5:Energyandmatter:Flows,cycles,andconservation•CrosscuttingConcept6:Structureandfunction•CrosscuttingConcept7:Stabilityandchange•ScienceandEngineeringPractice1:Askingquestionsanddefiningproblems•ScienceandEngineeringPractice2:Developingandusingmodels•ScienceandEngineeringPractice3:Planningandcarryingoutinvestigations•ScienceandEngineeringPractice4:Analyzingandinterpretingdata•ScienceandEngineeringPractice5:Usingmathematicsandcomputationalthinking•ScienceandEngineeringPractice6:Constructingexplanationsanddesigningsolutions•ScienceandEngineeringPractice7:Engaginginargumentfromevidence•ScienceandEngineeringPractice8:Obtaining,evaluating,andcommunicatinginformation
30of39
PreparationBackground&VocabularyBackgroundInformationWatermovesbetweenthegroundwaterandsurfacebodiesofwater.Gainingstreamsgainwaterfromthegroundwater.Losingstreamslosetheirwatertothegroundwater.Thelevelofthewatertabledetermineswhichwaywaterwillmovebetweenthegroundwaterandsurface.Humanscanalterthewatertablebywithdrawingwaterfromthegroundwaterwithwells.
PriorKnowledge[]RecommendedPriorActivities
AvailabilityofFreshWaterGroundwaterMovementUsingFreshWater
VocabularyTerm Partof
Speech Definition
aquifer noun anundergroundlayerofrockorearthwhichholdsgroundwater.
confinedaquifer noun layerofwater-bearingrockbetweentwolayersoflesspermeablerock.
conservation nounmanagementofanaturalresourcetopreventexploitation,destruction,orneglect.
freshwater noun waterthatisnotsalty.
groundwater noun waterfoundinanaquifer.
model,computationalnoun
amathematicalmodelthatrequiresextensivecomputationalresourcestostudythebehaviorofacomplexsystembycomputersimulation.
permeable adjectiveallowingliquidandgasestopassthrough.
porosity nountheratioofthevolumeofallthepores,orholes,inanobjectandtheobject'stotalmass.
porous adjectivefulloftinyholes,orabletobepermeatedbywater.
precipitation noun allformsinwhichwaterfallstoEarthfromtheatmosphere.
rechargeverb
toreneworrestoretoapreviouscondition.
31of39
runoff noun overflowoffluidfromafarmorindustrialfactory.
stream noun bodyofflowingwater.
sustainability noun useofresourcesinsuchamannerthattheywillneverbeexhausted.
system nouncollectionofitemsororganismsthatarelinkedandrelated,functioningasawhole.
topography noun theshapeofthesurfacefeaturesofanarea.
unconfinedaquifer noun layerofwater-bearingrockcoveredbypermeablerock.
watercycle noun movementofwaterbetweenatmosphere,land,andocean.
watertable nounundergroundareawheretheEarth'ssurfaceissaturatedwithwater.Alsocalledwaterlevel.
Term PartofSpeech Definition
Partner
FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder
GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.
Activity5:UsingGroundwaterWisely|45minsDirections1.Engagestudentsinthinkingabouthowwatercyclesthroughtheground.
Tellstudentsthatmuchoftheirwatercomesfromgroundwaterandthatwatermovesfromthegroundtothesurface.ShowtheUrbanWaterCycle diagram.Ask:
Whenprecipitationfalls,howdoesitmoveintoandthroughtheground?(Whenprecipitationfallsontheground,itcanrundownthesurface(runoff)oritcanmoveintotheground.Watermovesthroughthegroundbecausesedimentsarepermeable.Ifthesedimentsareverypermeable,
32of39
thewatercanpenetratedeepintotheground,butiftheyarelesspermeable,thewaterwillnotbeabletoflowverydeepintotheground.)Whateffectshavehumanshadonthenaturalmovementofwater?(Humanshavemadealotofthesurfaceimpermeablewithbuildingsandpavement.Thewatercannoteasilyenterthegroundthroughpavedsurfacesbecausetheyareimpermeable.)
2.Discusstheroleofuncertaintyinthescientificprocess.
Tellstudentsthatscienceisaprocessoflearninghowtheworldworksandthatscientistsdonotknowthe“right”answerswhentheystarttoinvestigateaquestion.Wecanseeexamplesofscientists'uncertaintyintheforecastingofprecipitationamounts.HavestudentsgototheNOAANationalWeatherService.Askthemtoinputtheirzipcodes,hit“Go”,scrolldowntothebottomofthepage,andclickonthe“HourlyWeatherGraph”.Thispageshowsthehourlyweatherforecastforyourarea.Thefirstboxshowsthepredictedtemperatureanddewpoint(alongwithwindchillorheatindex,whenapplicable).Thesecondboxshowsthepredictedwindspeedanddirection.Thethirdboxshowsthepredictedskycover(i.e.cloudcover),relativehumidity,andchanceforprecipitation.Theboxesbelowthatlineshowwhethertheprecipitationislikelytoberain,snow,freezingrain,orsleet.Pointoutthelineforprecipitationpotential(thebrownline).Ask:
Whyistheprecipitationshownasa“%”?(Precipitationisdependentonotherfactors,suchasrelativehumidityandtemperature.Itismorelikelytoprecipitatewhenthetemperatureisthesameasorlowerthanthedewpoint.)Ifthereisalikelihoodofprecipitation,whyistheamountofrain/snowshownasranges?(Theamountofprecipitationthatwillfallisdependentontheamountofmoistureintheatmosphere.Theatmosphereiscontinuallychanging,sotheamountsareguidelinesforwhatcouldhappenratherthanperfectpredictions.)
*Ifthereisnoorlowlikelihoodofprecipitationinyourarea,youmaywanttofindadifferentlocation(intheUnitedStates)thathasahigherlikelihoodofprecipitation.Youcanlookatacurrentweathermap(radar)tofindwhereintheUnitedStatesprecipitationishappeningcurrently.Yourstudentswillthenbeabletoseescientists'forecastsofprecipitationamountsrepresentedasarangeoverlaidonthebargraphs.
Tellstudentstheywillbeaskedquestionsaboutthecertaintyoftheirpredictionsandthattheyshouldthinkaboutwhatscientificdataareavailableastheyassesstheircertaintywiththeiranswers.Encouragestudentstodiscussthescientificevidencewitheachothertobetterassesstheirlevelofcertaintywiththeirpredictions.
33of39
3.IntroducetheconceptofsystemsinEarth'swaterresources.
TellstudentsthatforecastingwhatwillhappentoEarth'sfreshwatersuppliesisacomplicatedprocessbecausetherearemanydifferentinteractingparts.Tellstudentsthatscientiststhinkabouthowonepartofthesystemcanaffectotherpartsofthesystem.Givestudentsasimpleexampleofasystem,asdescribedinthescenariobelow.
Onanisland,thereisapopulationoffoxesandapopulationofrabbits.Thefoxespreyontherabbits.Ask:
Whentherearealotofrabbits,whatwillhappentothefoxpopulation?(Itwillincreasebecausethereisanamplefoodsupply.)Whathappenstothefoxpopulationwhenthey’veeatenmostoftherabbits?(Thefoxeswilldieofstarvationastheirfoodsupplydecreases.)Whathappenstotheamountofgrasswhenthefoxpopulationishigh?(Theamountofgrasswillincreasebecausetherearefewerrabbitstoeatthegrass.)Ifthereisadroughtandthegrassdoesn’tgrowwell,whatwillhappentothepopulationsoffoxesandrabbits?(Therabbitpopulationwilldecreasebecausetheyhavealesserfoodsupply.Thefoxpopulationshouldalsodecreaseastheirfoodsupplydecreases.)
Humansintroducedogstotheisland.Thedogscompetewiththefoxesovertherabbitfoodsupply.Ask:Whatwillhappentothepopulationsoffoxes,rabbits,andgrassafterthedogsareintroduced?(Thefoxeswilldecreasebecausetheyaresharingtheirfoodsupply,therabbitswilldecreasebecausetheyhavemorepredators,andthegrasswilldowellbecauseoftheloweredimpactofthesmallerrabbitpopulation.)
Tellstudentsthatsimplecause-effectrelationshipscanexpandintomorecomplexsystemrelationships.Letstudentsknowthattheywillbeexploringtherelationshipbetweenhowsedimentsandrocktypesaffectsgroundwatermovement.Encouragestudentstothinkabouthowhumanactionsplayaroleinchangesintheflowofwaterandinfreshwateravailability.
4.Introduceanddiscusstheuseofcomputationalmodels.
Introducetheconceptofcomputationalmodels,andgivestudentsanexampleofacomputationalmodelthattheymayhaveseen,suchasforecastingtheweather.Theweatherforecastprovidesagoodexampleofhowmodelinputisusedtopredictfutureconditions.GototheNOAAWeatherForecastModel.Tellstudentsthatscientistsusedcurrentinformationabouttheenergyandmoistureintheatmosphereasaninputtothemodel,andthatwhattheyseeontheweathermapistheoutputofthemodel'scalculations.
34of39
5.HavestudentslaunchtheUsingGroundwaterWiselyinteractive.
ProvidestudentswiththelinktotheUsingGroundwaterWiselyinteractive.Dividestudentsintogroupsoftwoorthree,withtwobeingtheidealgroupingforsharingcomputerworkstations.Informstudentstheywillbeworkingthroughaseriesofpagesofmodelswithquestionsrelatedtothemodels.Askstudentstoworkthroughtheactivityintheirgroups,discussingandrespondingtoquestionsastheygo.
LetstudentsknowthatthisisActivity5oftheWillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?lesson.
6.Discusstheissues.
Afterstudentshavecompletedtheactivity,bringthegroupsbacktogetherandleadadiscussionfocusingonthesequestions:
Whathappenstorainwaterwhenitrainsinacity?(Therainrunsoffimpermeablesurfacesintobasinsorrivers.)Howdoesthatdifferfromwhenitrainsinanon-urbanarea?(Inanon-urbanarea,thewatercanpenetratethegroundbecauseitisnotcoveredbyimpermeablesurfaces.Thewaterinnon-urbanareascanrechargeaquifers.)Howcanhumansbettermanagetheiruseoflimitedwatersupplies?(Humanscanusewatersparinglyfornecessarypurposes.Theycanusethewastewatertorechargeaquiferssothatthewellsdon'trundry.)
TipTosavestudents'dataforgradingonline,registeryourclassforfreeattheHigh-AdventureScienceportalpage.
TipThisactivityispartofasequenceofactivitiesinthelessonWillThereBeEnoughFreshWater?.Theactivitiesworkbestifusedinsequence.
ModificationThisactivitymaybeusedindividuallyoringroupsoftwoorthreestudents.Itmayalsobemodifiedforawhole-classformat.Ifusingasawhole-classactivity,useanLCDprojectororinteractivewhiteboardtoprojecttheactivity.Turnembeddedquestionsintoclassdiscussions.Uncertaintyitemsallowforclassroomdebatesovertheevidence.
InformalAssessment1.Checkstudents'comprehensionbyaskingthemtorespondtothefollowingquestion.
35of39
Whicharea'saquiferismorelikelytoberechargedbyprecipitation:anurbanareaoraruralarea?Explainyouranswer.
2.Usetheanswerkeytocheckstudents'answersonembeddedassessments.
ObjectivesSubjects&DisciplinesScience
EarthscienceGeneralscience
LearningObjectivesStudentswill:
describehowhumandevelopmentshavechangedthenaturalwatercycledescribehowwastewatercanbeusedtorechargeanaquifer
TeachingApproachLearning-for-use
TeachingMethodsDiscussionsMultimediainstructionSelf-directedlearningVisualinstructionWriting
SkillsSummaryThisactivitytargetsthefollowingskills:
21stCenturyStudentOutcomesInformation,Media,andTechnologySkills
Information,Communications,andTechnologyLiteracyLearningandInnovationSkills
CriticalThinkingandProblemSolvingCriticalThinkingSkills
AnalyzingApplyingEvaluatingUnderstanding
NationalStandards,Principles,andPractices
36of39
NationalScienceEducationStandards
•(5-8)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(5-8)StandardB-1:Propertiesandchangesofpropertiesinmatter•(5-8)StandardG-2:Natureofscience•(9-12)StandardA-1:Abilitiesnecessarytodoscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardA-2:Understandingsaboutscientificinquiry•(9-12)StandardB-6:Interactionsofenergyandmatter•(9-12)StandardF-6:Scienceandtechnologyinlocal,national,andglobalchallenges•(9-12)StandardG-2:Natureofscientificknowledge
CommonCoreStateStandardsforEnglishLanguageArts&Literacy
•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.6-8.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.6-8.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.9-10.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.9-10.4•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.1•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:KeyIdeasandDetails,RST.11-12.3•ReadingStandardsforLiteracyinScienceandTechnicalSubjects6-12:CraftandStructure,RST.11-12.4
NextGenerationScienceStandards
•ScienceandEngineeringPractice1:
37of39
Askingquestionsanddefiningproblems•ScienceandEngineeringPractice2:Developingandusingmodels•ScienceandEngineeringPractice3:Planningandcarryingoutinvestigations•ScienceandEngineeringPractice4:Analyzingandinterpretingdata•ScienceandEngineeringPractice6:Constructingexplanationsanddesigningsolutions•ScienceandEngineeringPractice7:Engaginginargumentfromevidence•ScienceandEngineeringPractice8:Obtaining,evaluating,andcommunicatinginformation
PreparationBackground&VocabularyBackgroundInformationHumandevelopmenthasaffectedthenaturalwatercycleinmanyways.Onewayisintheurbanizationofthelandscapewithmoreimpermeablesurfacesthatdonotallowwatertoinfiltratethegroundwater.Anotherwayisinextractingwaterfromaquifersatarategreaterthanthenaturalrechargerate.
Increasingly,waterhasbeentransferredfromoneaquifertoanotheraswaterispipedintourbanareasfromruralareas.Thiscandepletetheaquifersintworegions,aswaterthatfallsintotheurbanareaisunabletopenetratetheimpermeablesurfaces.
Septicsystemsallowforlocalrechargeoftheaquifers.Waterthatisremovedfromlocalwellsisreturnedasitleachesoutofthesepticsystem'sleachingfields.Bycontrast,urbanwastewatertreatmentplantsoftendumpthetreatedwaterintostreams,rivers,ortheocean.Thiswaterdoesnotrechargethelocalaquiferortheaquiferfromwhichitcame.Thewastewatercanbedischargedintoholdingpoolswhereitcanpercolatethroughthesoilandeventuallyreachalocalaquifer.
PriorKnowledge[]RecommendedPriorActivities
AvailabilityofFreshWaterGroundwaterandSurfaceWaterGroundwaterMovementUsingFreshWater
38of39
VocabularyTerm Partof
Speech Definition
aquifer noun anundergroundlayerofrockorearthwhichholdsgroundwater.
confinedaquifer noun layerofwater-bearingrockbetweentwolayersoflesspermeablerock.
conservation nounmanagementofanaturalresourcetopreventexploitation,destruction,orneglect.
freshwater noun waterthatisnotsalty.
groundwater noun waterfoundinanaquifer.
model,computationalnoun
amathematicalmodelthatrequiresextensivecomputationalresourcestostudythebehaviorofacomplexsystembycomputersimulation.
permeable adjectiveallowingliquidandgasestopassthrough.
porosity nountheratioofthevolumeofallthepores,orholes,inanobjectandtheobject'stotalmass.
porous adjectivefulloftinyholes,orabletobepermeatedbywater.
precipitation noun allformsinwhichwaterfallstoEarthfromtheatmosphere.
recharge verb toreneworrestoretoapreviouscondition.
runoff noun overflowoffluidfromafarmorindustrialfactory.
stream noun bodyofflowingwater.
sustainability noun useofresourcesinsuchamannerthattheywillneverbeexhausted.
system nouncollectionofitemsororganismsthatarelinkedandrelated,functioningasawhole.
topography noun theshapeofthesurfacefeaturesofanarea.
unconfinedaquifer noun layerofwater-bearingrockcoveredbypermeablerock.
urbanization nounprocessinwhichthereisanincreaseinthenumberofpeoplelivingandworkinginacityormetropolitanarea.
watercycle noun movementofwaterbetweenatmosphere,land,andocean.
39of39
waterinfiltration noun
processbywhichwateronthegroundsurfaceoratmosphereentersthesoil.
watertable nounundergroundareawheretheEarth'ssurfaceissaturatedwithwater.Alsocalledwaterlevel.
Term PartofSpeech Definition
Partner
FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder
GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.
Partner
FunderThismaterialisbaseduponworksupportedbytheNationalScienceFoundationunder
GrantNo.DRL-1220756.Anyopinions,findings,andconclusionsorrecommendationsexpressedinthismaterialarethoseoftheauthor(s)anddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheNationalScienceFoundation.
©1996–2016NationalGeographicSociety.Allrightsreserved.