WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

37
summary of wiki- related research conversation at WikiMedia San Francisco, 2011 Dr Mark Graham Oxford Internet Institute www.geospace.co.uk www.zerogeography.net www.wikichains.org e: [email protected] t: @geoplace

description

Talk given by Mark Graham at Wi

Transcript of WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Page 1: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

summary of wiki-related research

conversation at WikiMedia San Francisco, 2011

Dr Mark GrahamOxford Internet Institute

www.geospace.co.ukwww.zerogeography.net

www.wikichains.org

e: [email protected]: @geoplace

Page 2: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Spatial Palimpsests

Page 3: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

“The Internet surrounds us like air, saturating our offices and our homes. But it’s not confined to the ether. You can touch it. You can map it. And you can photograph it”

- Andrew Blum 2009

Page 4: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 5: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

“here be dragons”

Psalter World map (1265)

Page 6: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 7: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Map by Mark Graham, Monica Stephens, Matthew Zook

Page 8: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Map by Mark Graham, Monica Stephens, Matthew Zook

Page 9: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 10: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

total number of Wikipedia articles in all languages

Page 11: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 12: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 13: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 14: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 15: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Eastern Canada: English and French

Page 16: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Spain: Spanish (Castilian) and Catalan

Page 17: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Israel/Palestine: Arabic and Hebrew

Page 18: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Bangkok

วั�ด (“temple” in Thai) “temple” in English

Page 19: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Wikipedia research:- The Middle East and North Africa- East Africa

Collaborators: Dr Bernie Hogan (Oxford), Richard Farmbrough (Oxford), Dr Ali Frihida (Tunis National School of Engineering, Tunisia), Dr Ilhem Allagui (American University of Sharjah, UAE)

Page 20: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Wikipedia research:

(1) what is the geography of articles in the Middle East/North Africa/East Africa compared to the rest of the world?

Page 21: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 22: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 23: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 24: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 25: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 26: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 27: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 28: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 29: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Wikipedia research:

(2) do local authors in the Middle East/North Africa/East Africa comprise disproportionately fewer of the contributors to articles about that region?

Page 30: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Wikipedia research:

(3) are the contributions of local contributors undervalued?

Page 31: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

Breadth from bilingual contributors?

German geo-taggedarticles in Latin America

Spanish geo-tagged articles in Latin America (good coverage even in Brazil)

Little overlap between language editions (Hecht and Gergle 2010)

Regions without many speakers of a given language are relatively under-represented in that language edition of the encyclopedia.

What role do bilinguals and foreign-language sources play?

What incentives might increase contributions from 2nd language learners & bilinguals and hence increase coverage?

- Scott Hale (scotthale.net)Oxford Internet Institute Wikipedia working group:http://www.oii.ox.ac.uk/research/projects/?id=66

Page 32: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

wikichains.org

Page 33: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 34: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 35: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 36: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham
Page 37: WikiMedia 2011 mark graham

thank you

Dr Mark GrahamOxford Internet Institute

[email protected]@geoplace