Why it is important to recycle bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash...

20
On-going development of forest-based energy in Sweden

description

By Hillevi Eriksson, Swedish Forest Agency, for woodenergyproject.eu

Transcript of Why it is important to recycle bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash...

Page 1: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

On-going development of forest-based energy in Sweden  

Page 2: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Energy consumption in Sweden 2010

Hydropower Nuclear power

Bioenergy Oil

Page 3: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Energy use in Sweden

Page 4: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Bioenergy development in Sweden 1970-2005

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

1970

1973

1976

1979

1982

1985

1988

1991

1994

1997

2000

2003

2006

TWh

Share of domestic energy consumption

•1970: 9%

•1980: 11%

•1990: 15%

•2000: 20%

•2009: 29%

Page 5: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

25

30

35

40

45

50

1990

1992

1994

1996

1998

2000

2002

2004

2006

2008

Share of renewable energy in total energy consumption [%]

Page 6: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

GHG emissions in Sweden 1990-2008

Page 7: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Main drivers affecting present changes towards renewable energy

• Carbon dioxide tax from 1991

• Certificates for renewable electricity production from 2001

• Political will – affecting community owned energy production units, vehicles

• Emission trading in the EU• Individuals choices – green electricity,

transports

Page 8: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Energy mix in district heating 1970-2008

oil

coal

biomass

TWh

Page 9: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Example CHP in Ostersund

Page 10: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Energy in industry sector

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

1801

97

0

19

73

19

76

19

79

19

82

19

85

19

88

19

91

19

94

19

97

20

00

20

03

20

06

Coal and coke

Biofuel, peat, etc,

District heating

Electricity

Natural gas andgasworks gas

Oil products

Page 11: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Biopower 2002-2010

0,0

2,0

4,0

6,0

8,0

10,0

12,0

14,0

16,0

2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

TW

h

KVV, Avfall

KVV, Torv

KVV, Biogas

KVV, Övr.Bio

Massaind.

WastePeat

Other bio

Pulp indu

www.svebio.se

Page 12: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

36 %

Pulp & Paper

16 % Pulp chips

13 % energy (bark, sawdust, etc)

20 %Sawn wood46 %

Saw logs

8 % energy (direct harvest)

23 %

energy (black liqour, etc)

46 %pulpwood

Annual cut~ 90 mill m3

Source: Skogsindustrierna, 2003 and Official Statistics of Sweden

Wood use in the Swedish forest sector~6-7 % of biomass harvest: energy (branches and tops (and stumps))

12

Page 13: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Stemwood stock in Swedish forest

• 1926 – c. 1780 m3

• 1990 – c. 2800 m3

• 2007 – c. 3240 m3

Page 14: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Positive effect for climate questioned…, however

• Branches and tops – Highly positive in a 15-20 yr time frame

• Stumps – Highly positive in a 40-50 yr time frame

• Increased harvest – stock loss = unknown ”payback time”

• Higher value for wood => more silviculture + better damage protection + reforestation (”forest that pays stays”)

• Harvest before large-scale damage (fire, stormfelling, insects, etc)

• Still, peat drainage = negative for climate

Page 15: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Development of regulations

• Forestry Act – improved 1998– Damage on soil or water should be avoided or

limited– Measures should be taken to prevent damage

on long-term nutrient status of forest soils

• Recomm 1998, new 2001, rev 2008• Prel recomm conc stump harv 2009• On-going research

15

Page 16: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Environmental goals – 16 areas

• Clean air, lakes, rivers, etc

• Natural biodiversity in the sea, forest, wetlands, etc

• Cultural heritage, aesthetic landscape values

=> Long-term goals, short-term goals, cost/benefit-evaluated action plans

Page 17: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Coming..

• Pine diesel (to be mixed with fossil diesel)

• DME from black liquor gasification– adapted motors in Volvo trucks

• Biorefineries

• Methanol/biogas

• -> Net export?

Page 18: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Energy carriers in transportation

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

1601

97

0

19

75

19

80

19

85

19

90

19

95

20

00

20

05

Renewable motor fuels

Natural gas, incl LPG

Aviation fuels etc

Med/heavy fuel oils

Bunkers oils

Electricity

Diesel/gas oil

Petrol

Page 19: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Sustainability= Ecology, economy, social values

1. ≥ Sustained level of biomass production

2. Biodiversity preservation

3. Positive greenhouse gas balance

4. Sustained chemical environment

5. ≥ Sustained cultural and social values

Σ ≥ for coming generations

Page 20: Why it is important to recycle  bioenergy ashes back to forest in Sweden, motives, ash pre-treatment, logistic and environmental aspects

Who define sustainability for practical use?

• MCPFE (Pan-european forest policy process)• Montreal process (North american -:-)• ITTO (Tropical -:-)• European Commission - RES Directive• National authorities• Certifiers, public procurement• and many others…