Which market? - PwC
Transcript of Which market? - PwC
www.pwc.ru/capital-markets
Capital Markets
The process of selectingthe most appropriate exchange for yourbusiness to list its sharesis challenging andcomplex. Understandingthe differences among global exchangesand determining theexchange that best fitsthe unique needs of yourbusiness are key aspectsof a successful listing
Which market? An overview of London, New York and Hong Kong stock exchanges
In recent years, a number of factors have been driving an upward trend in global equity issuance. As markets and businesses become increasingly global, the decision of choosing the most appropriate exchange becomes more challenging. A number of factors must be considered in determining the best option, and planning early can help your company comply with listing and regulatory requirements.
To help you determine which option is best for your company, we have highlighted some of the factors to consider and explained some of the high-level differences among the largest stock exchanges located in London, New York and Hong Kong.
Where to list
Admission/eligibility criteria• Thiscriteriamaybedifficulttoachieveasthepre-listingregulatoryreviewrequirementsvary
bymarket.
• Costsoflistingvaryineachmarket.
Valuation• Certainindustriesandtypesofcompaniesmayachievefavorablevaluations
incertainmarkets,duetocompetitorsandotherrecentlistingsofpeercompanies.
Location of holding company and trading operations
• Thecompany’scorebusinesslocationsmayaffecttheappetiteforitsequity,oftendrivingadomesticlisting.
• Thestageofdevelopmentofyourbusinessmaymakeitmoresuitableforaparticularmarket.Acompanywishingtoenteranewmarketorgaingreaterrecognitioninthatmarketmaychoosetolistinthatmarketasawaytogetexposuretonewcustomers,vendorsandshareholders.
• Taxationconsiderationscanimpactthelocationoftheholdingcompany.
Market and stakeholder relations• Investorandanalystbriefings,aswellasinterestinthebusiness,canvary
indifferentlocations.
• Expectationsofotherstakeholders,suchasbankersandemployees,canbeafactor.
Continuing obligations
• Differencesexistinpost-listingcomplianceobligationsamongmarketsandmayhavevaryingcostimplications,forinstance,requirementsrelatedtoXBRL,semi-annualandotherinterimreportingandreportingoninternalcontrols.
• Markets’regulatoryframeworks,includingcorporategovernancerequirements,mayhavebusinessimplications.
Other factors
• Tradingvolumesandliquidityoftheunderlyingsharescanvaryindifferentlocations.
• Proceedsintheacquisitioncurrencymayberequiredforbusinessdevelopmentincertainlocations.
• Incertainlocationsthereismorethanonemarket.Whichoneismostsuitableforyourcompany?
• Ifinclusioninmarketindicesisimportant,thismayrestrictthemarketchoicesavailable.
• Employeesmaydesireoptionsinaparticularmarket.
Some factors to consider include:
PwC | 3
4 | Which market? AnoverviewofLondon,NewYorkandHongKongstockexchanges
Overview of key regulatory requirements
1. A number of advisors will be involved in helping you successfully list your company. The Sponsor is typically the appointed investment bank that co-ordinates the overall project management of the IPO process.
2. Company history refers to the length of time the company has been in existence.3. Free float is the number of company shares traded on a market that are held by investors likely to be willing to trade.
LSE (Premium Listing) NYSE NASDAQ (Global Select)5 HKEX (Main Board)
Initial listing criteria
Sponsor1 Required Notrequired Notrequired Required
Audited track record 3yearsauditedaccounts,nomorethan6monthsold 3yearsauditedaccounts,nomorethan9monthsold 3yearsauditedaccounts,nomorethan9monthsold 3yearsauditedaccounts,nomorethan6monthsold
Accounting standard
EUIFRSorequivalentfornon-EUissuers USGAAPorIFRS USGAAPorIFRS HKFRS,IFRS,CASBE(forPRCissuersonly),USGAAPorotheraccountingstandardsmaybeacceptedincertaincircumstances
Minimum revenues Atleast75%oftheentity’sbusinessmustbesupportedbyarevenueearningstrackrecordforthe3yearperiod(somedispensationforspecificindustries(e.g.mining))
i)≥US$75minrevenueinmostrecentyearandii)≥US$750mglobalmarketcap.
i)≥US$90mtotalrevenueinmostrecentyearandii)averagemarketcap.≥US$850m
i)≥HKD500mandii)≥HKD4bnglobalmarketcap.
Minimum asset / equity requirements
Norequirements i)Marketcap≥US$150mandii)atleastUS$75mintotalassetstogetherwithatleastUS$50minstockholders’equity.(Thistestdoesnotapplytointernationalissues)
i)Marketcap.≥US$160mandii)totalassets≥US$80mandstockholdersequity≥US$55m
Norequirements
Minimum profits Norequirements • Sumoflastthreeyears:≥US$10m• Eachoftwomostrecentyears:≥US$2m• Nolossesinpriorthreeyears
• Sumoflastthreeyears:≥US$11m• Eachoftwomostrecentyears:≥US$2.2m• Nolossesinpriorthreeyears
• Sumoflastthreeyears:≥HKD50m• Sumoflasttwoyears:≥HKD30m
• Mostrecentyear:≥HKD20m
Profit forecast Optional4 Norequirements Norequirements Optional4
Working capital statements
Covering12months Notrequired Notrequired Covering12months
Company history2 Atleastthreeyearfinancialhistoryoftheunderlyingbusinessistobeavailable,subjecttoexemptions
Anoperatinghistoryofthreeyearsisgenerallyrequired Atleasttwoyearfinancialhistory Tradingrecordofatleastthreeyears,subjecttoexemptions
Ownership of assets
Controloverthemajorityofassetsforthe3yearperiod Norequirements Norequirements Ownershipcontinuityforatleastthemostrecentauditedfinancialyear
Minimum number of shareholders
Norequirements 400roundlot*shareholders 450roundlot*shareholders 300
Minimum free float (or public float)3
25%ofclassofshareslisted 1,100thousandshares 1,250thousandshares 25%oratleastHKD50m;Ifmarketcap.≥HKD10bn,canbereducedto15%
Minimum market capitalisation requirements at admission
£700,000 US$40m US$45m HKD200m
Internal control certification
n/a Sarbanes-OxleyAct(SOX) Sarbanes-OxleyAct(SOX) n/a
Regulatory and ongoing obligation requirements
Special criteria for international issuers
• Onlyforeigncompanieswith>50%freefloatareeligibletoFTSEUKindicesinclusion
• If200ormoreshareholdersor10%ormoresharesheldbyUKshareholders,requiredtoappointaregistrarintheUK
ToqualifyasaForeignPrivateIssueraninternationalissuermustbe:
• aforeign(non-US),non-governmentissuer• 50%ofequityorlessheldbyUSresidents-ifmorethan50%,mustnot
- haveamajorityofitsdirectorswhoareUSresidents- havemorethan50%ofitsassetslocatedintheUS- administeritsbusinessprincipallyintheUS
Differentminimumdistributionrequirements,marketvaluerequirementandfinancialstandardsareapplied(5,000roundlotshareholders,atleast2.5mpubliclyheldsharesworldwidewithmarketvalueatleastUS$100m)
MustregistertheclassofsecuritiesitintendstolistwithSECbyfilingaregistrationstatement(Form20-F)
ToqualifyasaForeignPrivateIssueraninternationalissuermustbe:
• aforeign(non-US),non-governmentissuer• 50%ofequityorlessheldbyUSresidents-ifmorethan50%,
mustnot- haveamajorityofitsdirectorswhoareUSresidents- havemorethan50%ofitsassetslocatedintheUS- administeritsbusinessprincipallyintheUS
MustregistertheclassofsecuritiesitintendstolistwithSECbyfilingaregistrationstatement(Form20-F)
• Mustbeincorporatedinan“acceptablejurisdiction”• Must,whilstitislistedandoneyearthereafter,appointaprocessagentinHKto
acceptnotices• Mustappointatleastoneauthorizedrepresentativeastheprincipalchannelof
communicationbetweenforeignissuerandHKEX• MustkeeparegisterofholdersinHKfortransferstoberegisteredlocally• Mustberegisteredasanon-HKcompanyundertheHKCompaniesOrdinance
Financial reporting requirements
• Annual• Half-yearly• Interimmanagementstatement
• Annual• Quarterly
• Annual• Quarterly
• Annual• Half-yearly• Quarterly(recommended)
Lock-up requirements - period within which major shareholders are not allowed to sell shares
Typically6-18monthsdependingonnatureofIPO(marketpractice)
6months(marketpractice) 6months(marketpractice) 6monthsthenafurther6monthswherethecontrollingshareholdersareexpectedtoremainthecontrollingshareholders
Regulatory authority FSA/UKLA SEC SEC,FINRA HKEX,SecuritiesandFuturesCommission(SFC)
Major transaction pre-approval by the shareholders
Aspartofcontinuingobligations,approvalisrequiredforsignificantacquisitionsanddisposalsandmaterialrelatedpartytransactions
• Issuancesresultinginachangeofcontrol• Equitycompensationplans• Priortotheissuanceofsecuritiesinanytransactiontoadirector
ofthecompany,subsidiary,affiliateorothercloselyrelatedpersonofarelatedparty;oranycompanyorentityinwhicharelatedpartyhassubstantialinterest
• Priortotheissuanceofsecuritiesinanytransactionifthevotingpowerisequaltoorinexcessof20%ofthevotingpoweroutstandingbeforetheissuanceor5%ormoreofthepre-transactionoutstandingshares(therearecertainconditionswhenapprovalisnotrequired)
• Acquisitionswheretheissuanceequals20%ormoreofthepre-transactionoutstandingshares,or5%ormoreofthepre-transactionoutstandingshareswhenarelatedpartyhasa5%orgreaterinterestintheacquisitiontarget
• Issuancesresultinginachangeofcontrol• Equitycompensation• Privateplacementswheretheissuance(togetherwithsales
byofficers,directors,orsubstantialshareholders,ifany)equals20%ormoreofthepre-transactionoutstandingsharesatapricelessthanthegreaterofbookormarketvalue
Anyspin-offafterthreeyearsofthecompany’soriginallisting
PwC | 5
4. If the company chooses to include a profit forecast, the listing registration document must contain the principal assumptions upon which the company has based its forecast and be publicly reported upon by the independent accountant.
5. NASDAQ Global Select market has four alternative financial standards and liquidity requirements. This relate to the standard 3 requirements.* Round lot is the term used for a normal unit of trading, which is 100 shares.
LSE (Premium Listing) NYSE NASDAQ (Global Select)5 HKEX (Main Board)
Initial listing criteria
Sponsor1 Required Notrequired Notrequired Required
Audited track record 3yearsauditedaccounts,nomorethan6monthsold 3yearsauditedaccounts,nomorethan9monthsold 3yearsauditedaccounts,nomorethan9monthsold 3yearsauditedaccounts,nomorethan6monthsold
Accounting standard
EUIFRSorequivalentfornon-EUissuers USGAAPorIFRS USGAAPorIFRS HKFRS,IFRS,CASBE(forPRCissuersonly),USGAAPorotheraccountingstandardsmaybeacceptedincertaincircumstances
Minimum revenues Atleast75%oftheentity’sbusinessmustbesupportedbyarevenueearningstrackrecordforthe3yearperiod(somedispensationforspecificindustries(e.g.mining))
i)≥US$75minrevenueinmostrecentyearandii)≥US$750mglobalmarketcap.
i)≥US$90mtotalrevenueinmostrecentyearandii)averagemarketcap.≥US$850m
i)≥HKD500mandii)≥HKD4bnglobalmarketcap.
Minimum asset / equity requirements
Norequirements i)Marketcap≥US$150mandii)atleastUS$75mintotalassetstogetherwithatleastUS$50minstockholders’equity.(Thistestdoesnotapplytointernationalissues)
i)Marketcap.≥US$160mandii)totalassets≥US$80mandstockholdersequity≥US$55m
Norequirements
Minimum profits Norequirements • Sumoflastthreeyears:≥US$10m• Eachoftwomostrecentyears:≥US$2m• Nolossesinpriorthreeyears
• Sumoflastthreeyears:≥US$11m• Eachoftwomostrecentyears:≥US$2.2m• Nolossesinpriorthreeyears
• Sumoflastthreeyears:≥HKD50m• Sumoflasttwoyears:≥HKD30m
• Mostrecentyear:≥HKD20m
Profit forecast Optional4 Norequirements Norequirements Optional4
Working capital statements
Covering12months Notrequired Notrequired Covering12months
Company history2 Atleastthreeyearfinancialhistoryoftheunderlyingbusinessistobeavailable,subjecttoexemptions
Anoperatinghistoryofthreeyearsisgenerallyrequired Atleasttwoyearfinancialhistory Tradingrecordofatleastthreeyears,subjecttoexemptions
Ownership of assets
Controloverthemajorityofassetsforthe3yearperiod Norequirements Norequirements Ownershipcontinuityforatleastthemostrecentauditedfinancialyear
Minimum number of shareholders
Norequirements 400roundlot*shareholders 450roundlot*shareholders 300
Minimum free float (or public float)3
25%ofclassofshareslisted 1,100thousandshares 1,250thousandshares 25%oratleastHKD50m;Ifmarketcap.≥HKD10bn,canbereducedto15%
Minimum market capitalisation requirements at admission
£700,000 US$40m US$45m HKD200m
Internal control certification
n/a Sarbanes-OxleyAct(SOX) Sarbanes-OxleyAct(SOX) n/a
Regulatory and ongoing obligation requirements
Special criteria for international issuers
• Onlyforeigncompanieswith>50%freefloatareeligibletoFTSEUKindicesinclusion
• If200ormoreshareholdersor10%ormoresharesheldbyUKshareholders,requiredtoappointaregistrarintheUK
ToqualifyasaForeignPrivateIssueraninternationalissuermustbe:
• aforeign(non-US),non-governmentissuer• 50%ofequityorlessheldbyUSresidents-ifmorethan50%,mustnot
- haveamajorityofitsdirectorswhoareUSresidents- havemorethan50%ofitsassetslocatedintheUS- administeritsbusinessprincipallyintheUS
Differentminimumdistributionrequirements,marketvaluerequirementandfinancialstandardsareapplied(5,000roundlotshareholders,atleast2.5mpubliclyheldsharesworldwidewithmarketvalueatleastUS$100m)
MustregistertheclassofsecuritiesitintendstolistwithSECbyfilingaregistrationstatement(Form20-F)
ToqualifyasaForeignPrivateIssueraninternationalissuermustbe:
• aforeign(non-US),non-governmentissuer• 50%ofequityorlessheldbyUSresidents-ifmorethan50%,
mustnot- haveamajorityofitsdirectorswhoareUSresidents- havemorethan50%ofitsassetslocatedintheUS- administeritsbusinessprincipallyintheUS
MustregistertheclassofsecuritiesitintendstolistwithSECbyfilingaregistrationstatement(Form20-F)
• Mustbeincorporatedinan“acceptablejurisdiction”• Must,whilstitislistedandoneyearthereafter,appointaprocessagentinHKto
acceptnotices• Mustappointatleastoneauthorizedrepresentativeastheprincipalchannelof
communicationbetweenforeignissuerandHKEX• MustkeeparegisterofholdersinHKfortransferstoberegisteredlocally• Mustberegisteredasanon-HKcompanyundertheHKCompaniesOrdinance
Financial reporting requirements
• Annual• Half-yearly• Interimmanagementstatement
• Annual• Quarterly
• Annual• Quarterly
• Annual• Half-yearly• Quarterly(recommended)
Lock-up requirements - period within which major shareholders are not allowed to sell shares
Typically6-18monthsdependingonnatureofIPO(marketpractice)
6months(marketpractice) 6months(marketpractice) 6monthsthenafurther6monthswherethecontrollingshareholdersareexpectedtoremainthecontrollingshareholders
Regulatory authority FSA/UKLA SEC SEC,FINRA HKEX,SecuritiesandFuturesCommission(SFC)
Major transaction pre-approval by the shareholders
Aspartofcontinuingobligations,approvalisrequiredforsignificantacquisitionsanddisposalsandmaterialrelatedpartytransactions
• Issuancesresultinginachangeofcontrol• Equitycompensationplans• Priortotheissuanceofsecuritiesinanytransactiontoadirector
ofthecompany,subsidiary,affiliateorothercloselyrelatedpersonofarelatedparty;oranycompanyorentityinwhicharelatedpartyhassubstantialinterest
• Priortotheissuanceofsecuritiesinanytransactionifthevotingpowerisequaltoorinexcessof20%ofthevotingpoweroutstandingbeforetheissuanceor5%ormoreofthepre-transactionoutstandingshares(therearecertainconditionswhenapprovalisnotrequired)
• Acquisitionswheretheissuanceequals20%ormoreofthepre-transactionoutstandingshares,or5%ormoreofthepre-transactionoutstandingshareswhenarelatedpartyhasa5%orgreaterinterestintheacquisitiontarget
• Issuancesresultinginachangeofcontrol• Equitycompensation• Privateplacementswheretheissuance(togetherwithsales
byofficers,directors,orsubstantialshareholders,ifany)equals20%ormoreofthepre-transactionoutstandingsharesatapricelessthanthegreaterofbookormarketvalue
Anyspin-offafterthreeyearsofthecompany’soriginallisting
6 | Which market? AnoverviewofLondon,NewYorkandHongKongstockexchanges
Stock exchange
Overview Market Admitable securities
Main indices
LondonStockExchange(LSE)
TheLSE’sMainMarketistheprincipalmarketforUKandinternationallistedcompanies,fromallindustriesandsectorsinavarietyofsizes.TheMainMarketaccommodatestheadmissiontotradingofcompanieswitheitheraPremiumorStandardListing(equityorGlobalDepositaryReceipts(GDRs)).APremiumListingentailshighercomplianceanddisclosurerequirementsthantheEUminimumstandardsforStandardListings(equityorGDRs).
MainMarket • Equities• DRs
• FTSEseries–opentointernationalissuers
• FTSE100• FTSE250• FTSEAll-Share• FTSEtechMark• FTSERussiaIOB–
top15RussianGDRs
AIMistheLSE’sinternationalmarketforsmallergrowthcompanies.
AIM • Equities • TheFTSEAIMIndexSeriesincludestheFTSEAIMUL50Index,FTSEAIM100Index,FTSEAIMAll-ShareIndexandFTSEAIMAll-ShareSupersectorIndices
NYSEEuronext(US)
TheNYSEisownedandoperatedbyNYSEEuronextanditisthelargestcashequitiesmarketintheworld.
NYSE • Equities• DRs
• DowJonesIndustrial• NYSEComposite• NYSEEnergy• S&P500
NASDAQOMX
NASDAQiswellknownforattractinghighgrowthcompaniesinparticularinthetechnologysector,includingbio-technologyandbio-pharmaceuticals.
NASDAQ • Equities• DRs
• NASDAQ100• NASDAQOMX100• NASDAQGlobalSelectMarketcomposite• S&P500
HongKongExchange(HKEX)
TheHKEXMainBoardissuitableforestablishedcompaniesthatmeetaprofitorotherfinancialrequirementstoraisefundsinthemarket.
MainBoard • Equities• DRs
• HangSengIndex
TheGrowthEnterpriseMarket(GEM)isdesignedforgrowthcompaniesandisopentointernationalbusinesses.
GEM • Equities
Total market capitalisation as at 31 December 2011 (US$ bn)
Number of listed companies as at 31 December 2011
Average money raised at admission (US$ m)
Source: Exchange statistics, World Federation of Exchanges, PwC IPO WatchEurope data.
2,258
5,681
15,641
Hong Kong
London
New YorkNASDAQ(3,845)
NYSE(11,796)
24
537
817
1,472
1,982
4,083
Hong Kong
London
New York
DomesticNon-domestic
NYSE (1,700) NASDAQ (2,383)
NASDAQ(287)
NYSE(520)
150
345
444
481
New York (NASDAQ)
New York (NYSE)
London (Main Market)
Hong Kong (Main Board)
Stock exchanges overview and vital statistics
PwC | 7
Total number of IPOs and proceeds raised during the five years ended 31 December 2011
The number of non-domestic IPOs and total proceeds raised during the five years ended 31 December 2011
Sector split of listings by number of IPOs during the five years ended 31 December 2011
LondonNew York Hong Kong
724
647
395
New York
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
0
25
50
75
100
125
150
175
200
London Hong Kong
194
171
98
New York Hong Kong London
Num
ber
of IP
Os
Off
erin
g va
lue
(US$
bn)
26%
19%
13%
11%
11%
8%
7%4% 1%
41%
23%
11%
8%
6%
4%3% 3% 1%
26%
15%
15%
12%
10%
6%
6%
5%3%
Financial Services
Technology
Health
Energy
Business Services
Consumer
Industrials
Transportation
Other
48
4443
Hong Kong London New York
245
181
32
London New York Hong Kong
0
10
20
30
40
50
0255075
100125150175200225250
Num
ber
of IP
Os
Off
erin
g va
lue
(US$
bn)
Source: PwC US IPO Watch, PwC Europe IPO Watch, PwC Greater China IPO Watch
Source: PwC US IPO Watch, PwC Europe IPO Watch, PwC Greater China IPO Watch
Source: PwC US IPO Watch, PwC Europe IPO Watch, PwC Greater China IPO Watch
Other considerations
While the key considerations we have discussed in this document will be your primary decision factors when considering “which market,” there are other less tangible factors that may also play a role, such as:• Political environment• Commercial/business environment• Location of existing stakeholders• Domestic regulatory environment• Personal preferences of current shareholders• The equity story to be told/the “value proposition”• Longer term plans• Taxation implications• Listing currency considerations
Because of these many and varied factors, the decision as to which market to select can be complex. Engaging experienced advisors with a global presence and knowledge of the capital markets can help you determine the market that is best suited to your needs, anticipate issues, avoid delays and otherwise navigate successfully through the life cycle of your capital market transaction. Using an advisor who is experienced with the multiple elements of the transaction process, along with having the ability to advise on technical accounting and financial reporting complexities associated with the process of going public, will allow you to focus more time on the marketing phase of the deal and ongoing management of your business.
To talk more about your company’s capital market needs, please contact your PwC relationship partner or learn more at www.pwc.ru/capital-markets
©2012ZAOPricewaterhouseCoopersAudit.Allrightsreserved.
“PwC”and“PricewaterhouseCoopers”refertoZAOPricewaterhouseCoopersAuditor,asthecontextrequires,othermemberfirmsofPricewaterhouseCoopersInternationalLimited,eachofwhichisaseparateandindependentlegalentity.
25.04.2012