When Words Get in the Way
-
Upload
center-for-american-progress -
Category
Documents
-
view
223 -
download
0
Transcript of When Words Get in the Way
-
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
1/20
When Words Get in the WayNew SEC Trove o Plain English Disclosures by Money Manage
Reveals Much, Leaves Much to Be Desired
Gadi Dechter October 2011
www.americanprogress.o
http://www.americanprogress.org/http://www.americanprogress.org/ -
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
2/20
When Words Get in the WayNew SEC Trove o Plain English Disclosures by Money
Managers Reveals Much, Leaves Much to Be Desired
Gadi Dechter October 2011
CAPs Doing What Works project promotes government reorm to eciently allocate scarce resources and
achieve greater results or the American people. This project specically has three key objectives:
Eliminating or redesigning misguided spending programs and tax expenditures, ocused on priority areas
such as health care, energy, and education Boosting government productivity by streamlining management and strengthening operations in the areas
o human resources, inormation technology, and procurement
Building a oundation or smarter decision-making by enhancing transparency and perormance
measurement and evaluation
-
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
3/20
1 Introduction and summary
4 Progress: From check-the-box to plain English
8 Problems: Not-so-plain English and not so easy to use
12 Recommendations: Release, test, and enforce
14 Conclusion
15 About the author and Acknowledgements
16 Endnotes
Contents
-
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
4/20
1 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
Introduction and summary
People paid o manage ohers money have a legal duy o pu clien ineress
above heir own. And ye your rused adviser a AXA Equiable Lie Insurance
Company won ge healh benes unless he convinces you o buy he insurance
gians wares over hird-pary producs. Bank o America Corp.s wealh manag-
ers a is Merrill Lynch subsidiary have a policy o ring cliens who reuse o
engage in a ype o ransacion idenied by Congress as poenially abusive. And
raders a Goldman Sachs Group Inc.s proprieary rading desks someimes be
agains he very people whose money hey manage.
Tese are among he many revealing disclosures released publicly wih litle an-
are earlier his year by he Securiies and Exchange Commission, he Washingon
regulaor ha keeps abs on more han 11,000 invesmen advisers. Now, under
new rules more han a decade in he making, all money managers regisered wih
he SEC mus publicly release annual disclosures o heir ees, conics o ineres,
and disciplinary hisoryand do so in plain English.1
For he rs ime since he SEC began regisering money managers in 1940, hese
brochures are now available o he general public and in one searchable daa-
base. Tey represen one o he mos imporan invesor proecion iniiaives
in decades, according o SEC Commissioner Elisse B. Waler. Indeed, hey are a
major sep orward by he ederal governmen in helping invesors make inormed
choices abou perhaps he single-mos imporan nancial decision hey make:
Whom o enrus wih heir money.2
Unorunaely, he new Form ADV Par 2 disclosures (he bureaucraic name
or hese documens) are also an objec lesson in missed opporuniy. Teyre sill
oo hard o undersand, cumbersome o navigae, and will likely coninue o beignored by he very people heyre inended o helpunless he SEC releases he
daa in a more user-riendly way, or encourages he privae secor o do i.
http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/%28S%28l3lkmxtiomqpvb23nwihy03r%29%29/IAPD/Content/IapdMain/iapd_SiteMap.aspx.http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/%28S%28l3lkmxtiomqpvb23nwihy03r%29%29/IAPD/Content/IapdMain/iapd_SiteMap.aspx.http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/%28S%28l3lkmxtiomqpvb23nwihy03r%29%29/IAPD/Content/IapdMain/iapd_SiteMap.aspx.http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/%28S%28l3lkmxtiomqpvb23nwihy03r%29%29/IAPD/Content/IapdMain/iapd_SiteMap.aspx. -
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
5/20
2 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
Teyre a vas improvemen over wha we had beore, which ses a prety low bar,
says Barbara oper, direcor o invesor proecion wih he Consumer Federaion
o America. Teres beter disclosure abou conics o ineress. Teres a clearer
descripion o he services hey re oering.3
William Luz, a reired English proessor who led a yearlong SEC disclosure iniia-ive during he Bush adminisraion, is less chariable. Te random sample ha I
looked a were prety errible, he says.4
For he SEC o make good on is regulaory goal o ensuring ha invesors ge
clearly writen, meaningul, curren disclosure o he business pracices, conics
o ineress and background o he invesmen adviser,5 he agency should ake
he ollowing hree seps:
Te commission should bulk-release all adviser regisraion inormaion on daa.
gov, in a orma ha mos readily allows he daa o be sliced and diced in mean-ingul ways by privae companies and consumer advocaes.
Te SEC should use is newound auhoriy under he Dodd-Frank nancial
reorm law o conduc invesor esing o deermine wheher he new disclo-
sures are comprehensible, useuland improve hem accordingly.
Te SEC should vigorously enorce is plain English requiremen, penalizing
money managers ha ail o explain heir business pracices and conics o
ineress in a way ha he average invesor can undersand.
In general, he commission and oher governmen agencies should move oward
an oucome-ocused way o measuring wheher regulaed indusries are airly,
eecively, and ecienly disclosing inormaion.
Wha do we mean by ha? oday, laws ha require companies o share inorma-
ion wih invesors or consumers end o measure compliance by wheher man-
daory disclosures are made. Bu any casual reader o a Federal egiser noice
or credi card agreemen knows ha ineecive disclosures can undermine he
civic and proecive aims o a responsible governmen. oo much inormaionis overwhelming. Poorly presened inormaion creaes conusion. Grauious
complexiy sows disrus.
http://data.gov/http://data.gov/http://data.gov/http://data.gov/ -
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
6/20
3 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
We need a beter sandard or deermining wheher he governmen and he
indusries i regulaes are ullling heir obligaions o communicae openly and
honesly wih he public. Tas why in addiion o measuring wheher companies
are complying wih disclosure requiremens by oupuswheher a required
disclosure orm was lled ouhe SEC should measure ransparency by ou-
comeswheher he inormaion was comprehensible o is inended audience.Tis paper deails how his can and mus happen.
-
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
7/20
4 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
Progress
From check-the-box to plain English
Unil his year, nancial advisers who managed more han $25 million in clien
asses had o le a series o orms every year wih he SEC, one o which was also
given o prospecive and curren cliens. Ta disclosure was a generic check-he-
box shee ha ofen ailed o meaningully convey wha powers advisers had, how
hey were paid, poenial conics o ineress, and disciplinary record, according
o SEC Chairman Mary Schapiro.6
Under new rules rs proposed in 2000 and nalized las year, advisers mus
now also give cliens deailed narraive disclosures in plain English, including
ar more inormaion abou he conics o ineres ha bedevil he money man-ager businessor example, when advisers are also sockbrokers who peddle
rades or commission, or when hey ge cliens o buy securiies o he rms
own books. (See box)
So do he new disclosures give invesors meaningul disclosure ha invesors can
acually undersand, as SEC ocials inended? Well, hey cerainly give invesors
more inormaion, judging by a cursory examinaion o several dozen new disclo-
sures. And more disclosure is generally good.
o wi, some o he revelaions conained in hese housands o lings should give
pause o anyone huning or a rused adviser, such as he AXA Advisory acknowl-
edgmen ha is nancial planners may qualiy or cerain [employee] benes,
such as healh and reiremen benes, based solely on sales o proprieary
producs issued by AXA raher han producs issued by hird paries. 7
Or consider Goldman Sachs Asse Managemen, careaker o $523 billion in cli-
en asses, which ells wealhy cliens abou midway hrough is 74-page disclosure
ha heir advisers may buy or cusomers a sock ha he marke-moving rm is
simulaneously beting agains. Such a so-called shor posiion may impair hecliens holdings, Goldman admis in is disclosure.8
Anoher o he poenial conics o ineress he SEC requires advisers o
highligh in heir brochures is wheher hey engage in principal ransacions. A
-
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
8/20
5 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
principal ransacion is when he adviser causes he clien o buy an invesmen
produc rom he advisory rms own accoun. Tese ransacions are more heavily
regulaed because o congressional worries ha rused advisers would use clien
accouns as a dumping ground or undesirable or hard-o-sell rm holdings.
Careul readers o he Bank o Americas Merrill Lynch Personal Advisor Programdisclosure will learn i doesn care or cliens who are uncomorable wih hese
rades. I you revoke your consen o principal ransacions, Merrill says in is
new disclosure, we will erminae your paricipaion in [Merrill Lynch Personal
Advisor Program].9 A cauious invesor migh be wise o ask why. (Te company
did no reply o a reques or more inormaion abou his pracice.)
Single, searchable website is major step forward
Anoher major developmen under he new disclosure rules is he SECs laudabledecision o make hem all available o anyone or ree hrough one websie. Unil
now, advisers only had o oer he disclosures o prospecive and exising cliens,
alhough oher regisraion inormaion has been available online since 2001.
Te new and improved policy should make i easier or people o go online and
compare, evaluae, and rae he rms hey enrus wih heir savings, reiremen,
and uure amily securiy.
Tas good. oday, less han 10 percen o people searching or a nancial services
rm use he Inerne o make heir decision, according o a 2010 RND survey,
even hough nearly 90 percen o Americans making over $75,000 a year conduc
consumer research on he web.10
Despie hese advances, here remain wo major obsacles sanding in he way o
he SECs goal in he redesign, which was o ensure invesors had clear and con-
cise inormaion presened in a way ha makes i easy o compare and conras
advisers. Well explore hose obsacles in he nex secion.
http://www.sec.gov/rules/final/2010/ia-3060-secg.htm.http://www.sec.gov/rules/final/2010/ia-3060-secg.htm. -
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
9/20
Old Form ADV Part 2 brochure
FORM ADV
Part II - Page 6
Applicant: SEC File Number:
801-
Date:
12. Investment or Brokerage Discretion.
A. Does applicant or any related person have authority to determine, without obtaining specific client consent, the:
Yes No
(1) securities to be bought or sold? ...............................................................................................................
Yes No
(2) amount of securities to be bo ught or so ld? .........................................................................................Yes No
(3) broker or dealer to be used? ................................................................................................................
Yes No
(4) commission rates paid? ...........................................................................................................................
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Yes No
B. Does applicant or a related person suggest brokers to clients? .......................................................................
For each yes answer to A describe on Schedule F any limitations on the authority. For each yes to A(3), A(4)
or B, describe on Schedule F the factors considered in selecting brokers and determining the reasonableness
of their commissions. If the value of products, research and services given to the applicant or a related
person is a factor, describe:
the products, research and services
whether clients may pay commissions higher than those obtainable from other brokers in return for those products
and services
whether research is used to service all of applicant's accounts or just those accounts paying for it; and
any procedures the applicant used during the last fiscal year to direct client transactions to a particular broker in
return for product and r esearch services received.
13. Additional Compensation.
Does the applicant or a related person have any arrangements, oral or in writing, where it:
A. is paid cash by or receives some economic benefit (including commissions, equipment or non-research Yes No
services) from a non-client in connection with giving advice to clients? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Yes No
B. directly or indirectly comp ensates any person for clien t referrals?. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
(For each yes, describe the arrangements on Schedule F.)
14. Balance Sheet. Applicant must provide a balance sheet for the most recent fiscal year on Schedule G if applicant:
has custody of client funds or securities (unless applicant is registered or registering only with theSecurities and Exchange Commission); or
requires prepayment of more than $500 in fees per client and 6 or more months in advanceYes No
Has applican t provided a Schedule G b alance sh eet?..............................................................................
Answer all items. Complete amended pages in full, circle amended items and file with execution page (page 1)
6 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
Source: SEC.gov
The old brochure was
meant to help investors
it doesnt even address
to them. It looks more lgovernment orm lled
an applicant or a licen
permit o some kind.
The check-the-box orm
doesnt give context or
what a yes or no mea
Relevant details are rele
to schedules that are
appended to the orm.
Confict-o-interest ino
is presented in a generi
that doesnt convey wh
investor should care or
the risks areor even u
phrase confict o intere
http://sec.gov/http://sec.gov/ -
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
10/20
7 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
New plain English brochure
Source: SEC.gov
The new brochure is w
as a narrative, ollowing
ormat set by the SEC tsure certain topics are c
Conficts o interests ar
clearly labeled and det
The degree to which ea
new disclosure conorm
to the plain English va
with advisers, but they
are told to be concise a
direct, using denite,
concrete, everyday wor
The new ormat allows
encourages advisers to
explicit about how they
conficts o interests.
- 7 -
Bauman Advisory Group, LLC
Material Relationships Maintained by this Advisory Business and Conflicts ofInterest
Managing Member Todd Baumans principal business is as an insurance agent andan estate planner. Greater than 50% of Mr. Baumans time is spent in thesebusiness practices. From time to time, he will offer clients advice or products fromthose activities.
These practices represent potential conflicts of interest because it gives Mr. Baumanan incentive to recommend products based on the compensation amount received.This conflict is mitigated by the fact that clients are not required to purchase anyproducts or services. Clients have the option to purchase these products or servicesthrough another insurance agent or estate planner of their choosing.
Recommendations or Selections of Other Investment Advisors and Conflicts ofInterestBAG may at times utilize the services of Third Party Money Managers to manageclient accounts. In such circumstances, BAG will share in the Third Party assetmanagement fee. This situation creates a conflict of interest. However, whenreferring clients to a third party money manager, the clients best interest will be the
main determining factor of BAG.These fees do not include brokerage fees that maybe assessed by the custodial broker dealer. Fees for these services will be based ona percentage of assets under management not to exceed any limit imposed by anyregulatory agency. The final fee schedule will be attached to Exhibit D in BAG'sInvestment Advisory Agreement.
This relationship will be disclosed to the client in each contract between BAG andThird Party Money Manager. BAG does not charge additional management fees forThird Party managed account services. Client's signature is required to confirmconsent for services within Third Party Investment Agreement. Client will initial BAG'sInvestment Advisory Agreement to acknowledge receipt of Third Party fee Scheduleand required documents including ADV2 disclosures.
Item 11: Code of Ethics, Participation or Interest in Client Transactionsand Personal Trading
Code of Ethics DescriptionThe employees of BAG have committed to a Code of Ethics that is available forreview by clients and prospective clients upon request. The firm will provide a copyof the Code of Ethics to any client or prospective client upon request.
Investment Recommendations Involving a Material Financial Interest andConflict of InterestBAG and its employees do not recommend to clients securities in which we have amaterial financial interest.
-
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
11/20
8 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
Problems
Not-so-plain English and not so easy to use
Te rs problem is ha hese plain English disclosures are ofen writen in ur-
gid and convolued prose ha is anyhing bu plain. Tis obscures he very inor-
maion heyre mean o reveal. In some cases, hese documens seem o violae
in a single paragraph every rule o plain wriing laid down in he SECs own Plain
English Handbook.11 Consider his 104-word senence rom Goldman Sachs:
Emerging Markets and Growth Markets RiskIn addition to the risks
described in Non-U.S. Securities Risk below, investing in the securities o
governments in emerging markets involves certain considerations not usually
associated with investing in securities o developed market companies or coun-tries including, without limitation, political and economic considerations, the
potential difculty o repatriating unds, general social, political and economic
instability and adverse diplomatic developments, the small size o the securities
markets in such countries and the low volume o trading , resulting in potential
lack o liquidity and in price volatility, and certain government policies that may
restrict an Advisory Accounts investment opportunities.
(ranslaion ino acual plain English: Lending money o poorer counries, even
i heyre growing as, is riskier han buying U.S. reasury bonds. Tese counries
are more likely o have poliically unsable governmens and volaile economies.
Ta means you migh no ge paid back on ime or ever, and you migh no be
able o sell he bonds when you wan o.)
Te second big problem is ha he disclosures and he daa hey conain are no
presened in a way ha enables invesors o easily compare, search, or rae di-
eren nancial advisers. An invesor in upsae New York, or example, who is
looking o place $500,000 in he care o a alened money manager should be able
o use he wealh o inormaion gahered by he SEC o nd and hen compare all
regisered advisers ha mee he ollowing crieria:
Locaed wihin driving disance o his address Have been in business a leas 10 years Have beween $100 million and $500 million in asses under managemen (big
http://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdf -
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
12/20
9 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
enough o be repuable, bu no so big ha his $500,000 is insignican o hem) Charge beween 0.5 percen and 1.5 percen o asses under managemen (o all
wihin he low end o naional adviser ees) eceive no commissions on sales or rades (o avoid conics o ineres or
churning o clien unds or ransacion ees)
Accep no perormance-based compensaion (o avoid incenives or excessiverisk-aking by he adviser) Have no record o disciplinary acion agains he rm or is employees wihin
he las 10 years
Alas, he primiive uncionaliy o he governmen websie only allows users o
search advisers by nameno locaion, size, ee schedules, or any oher useul search
variable. Te erm primiive is oo generous, says Luz. Neanderhal leaps o mind.
Te SEC is aware o hese limiaions. Agency sa in Januaryrecommended ha
he commissioners enhance he search eaures o he websie and add educa-ional conen o make he daa more useul o invesors.12 Te repor also rec-
ommended merging he adviser disclosures daabase wih a separaely mainained
one called BrokerCheck ha conains he disciplinary hisory o sockbrokers
(who are ofen also regisered advisers).
Tese are welcome suggesions. Te commissioners should ac on hem, bu is
unlikely ha a bureaucracy ha produced such an unwieldy produc will sud-
denly ransorm ino an exper creaor o user-riendly web services. Case in poin:
Te new disclosures are so hard o nd on he SECs websie ha Te Wall Sree
Journal had o recenly publish a guide or is readers on he nine-sep process:13
http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/%28S%28dqa3ddxywm55jjlimdrkr452%29%29/IAPD/Content/Search/iapd_Search.aspx.http://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2011/919bstudy.pdf.http://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2011/919bstudy.pdf.http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/%28S%28dqa3ddxywm55jjlimdrkr452%29%29/IAPD/Content/Search/iapd_Search.aspx. -
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
13/20
10 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
Happily, we don have o wai or he SEC o become a paragon o user-cenered
design beore his valuable inormaion can be pu o eecive use. Jus as Yahoo!
Finance and oher websies mine he commissions EDGA corporae lings daa-
base o give users a usable presenaion o company nancials, so should privae
companies be able o le reail invesors slice and dice he unwieldy Invesmen
Adviser Public Disclosure daabase.
One rm, San Diego-based BrighScope, has already begun o manually gaher
and republish SEC adviser daa in a ree, searchable websie ha already has ar
more robus search uncionaliy han he governmen sie. BrighScope co-
ounder and CEO Mike Alred says his company has no plans o charge invesors,
who will evenually be able o conduc searches like he one described above. Bu
he acknowledges i won happen overnigh. Everybody wries a narraive dier-
enly, so you need o have MBA-level people guring ou whas behind he daa,
says Alred, whose eam o 40 employees has been working on he projec or a
year. Tis is he area has absoluely going o be he bigges challenge.14
Brighscopes rs-ieraion Advisor Pages are promising, and he companys
pledge o keep is daa ree o consumers is imporan. Bu he SEC should make i
easier or oher companies and invesor advocaes o also disribue such daa, and
encourage healhy compeiion in his space.
In he nex secion we recommend hree seps he SEC can ake o enhance he
impac o is new adviser disclosure rules.
http://www.brightscope.com/financial-planning/find/advisor/http://www.brightscope.com/financial-planning/find/advisor/http://www.brightscope.com/financial-planning/find/advisor/http://www.brightscope.com/financial-planning/find/advisor/ -
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
14/20
11 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
A tour of plain English disclosures by asset managers
The good
Heres an example o a clearly written disclosure o a potential confict o interest by Sunlake Investment
Management o Ithaca, New York:
Sunlake may reer clients to unaliated proessionals or specifc needs, such as accounting and estate
planning. These proessionals may reer clients to Sunlake or investment management. We do not have any
agreements with individuals or companies that we reer clients to, and we do not receive any compensation or
these reerrals. However, it could be concluded that Sunlake is receiving an indirect economic beneft rom the
arrangement, as the relationships are mutually benefcial. For example, there could be an incentive or us to
recommend services o frms who reer clients to Sunlake.15
The bad
And heres Credit Suisse Asset Managements attempt at explaining a related business practice in their
plain English brochure:
Written agreements may be entered into between the Registrant and solicitors pursuant to Rule 206(4)-3
under the Advisers Act. Pursuant to such agreements, the Registrant provides the solicitor with this Part 2 o its
Form ADV, or the relevant Schedule H, Managed Accounts Brochure, as applicable (Disclosure Documents).
The solicitor must provide to clients, at the time o solicitation, (i) the Registrants Disclosure Documents and
(ii) a written disclosure statement on the solicitors letterhead which shall: (a) advise the client o the nature
o the relationship between the solicitor and the Registrant; (b) include a statement that the solicitor will
be compensated or its solicitation services by the Registrant; (c) indicate the terms o such compensation
arrangement, including a description o the compensation paid or to be paid to the solicitor by the Registrant as
a result o the solicitation agreement,; and (d) indicate whether client will be charged amounts in addition to the
investment advisory ee in connection with the solicitation agreement between solicitor and the Registrant.16
and the bizarre
Finally, heres a paragraph rom Annapolis, Maryland-based Adrian Day Asset Managements disclosure
that ends up disclosing Mr. Days worldview o, among other things, the SEC, the Internal Revenue
Service, and the Transportation Security Administration, in addition to his business practices:
We do not accept as clients employees o the IRS, SEC or TSA, nor other known criminals (whose crimes
involve serious violations o other individuals rights), nor illiberal dictators or their agents unless and until a
public apology or their crimes is orthcoming.17
In an e-mail, Day claried: Yes, I do indeed mean that people who spend their working day ondling
people, and others who steal 40 percent o productive workers income are criminals. A liberal dictator
might be more acceptable than an i lliberal democracy. I you have to ask, you obviously dont get it.18
-
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
15/20
12 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
Recommendations:
Release, test, and enforce
As he Brighscope example shows, governmen ocials do no need o designperec inormaion sysems o improve he useulness o disclosure regimes. In
many cases, complemening governmen websies by also releasing inormaion
in machine-readable ormas will allow he privae secor o ransorm daa ino
usable ools, websies, and services.
I he inormaion is useul, and he daa are easy o manipulae, hen enerprising
companies and public-ineres advocaes have an incenive o gure ou how o
bes presen ia no addiional cos o he axpayer. As a rs sep, hen, he SEC
should release all adviser regisraion inormaion on daa.govin a orma ha
mos readily allows he daa o be manipulaed. Te daa should be available orbulk download, as well.
I should hen require FINR, he independen regulaor o sockbrokers, o
likewise release all BrokerCheck daa. FINRs erms and condiions requires
BrokerCheck users o agree hey will no use he inormaion rerieved rom
FINR BrokerCheck o develop or creae a daabase o inormaion o be sold,
licensed or made oherwise commercially available. Tas an ourage. Tis is
inormaion colleced or public bene, and he public should be able o access i
in whaever manner i sees .
Meanwhile, he SEC should ake advanage o is claried auhoriy in he Dodd-
Frank nancial reorm bill o engage in invesor esing, somehing ha migh
have helped hem design more user-riendly disclosure brochures in he rs
place.19 I you ook mos SEC disclosures ou ino he eld and esed hem you
would nd ha mos people don have a clue, and ha he commission is no pro-
viding inormaion in a orm ha invesors are eiher willing o look a or capable
o undersanding, says oper o he Consumer Federaion o America. So obvi-
ously, he SEC should es hese orms.20
Agood model or he SEC in his regard is he new Consumer Financial
Proecion Bureau, which is subjecing revamped morgage disclosures o con-
sumer esing beore beginning he ormal rule-making process. We hink he
http://data.gov/http://brokercheck.finra.org/Support/TermsAndConditionsText.aspxhttp://www.americanprogress.org/issues/2011/05/atw_top_model.htmlhttp://www.americanprogress.org/issues/2011/05/atw_top_model.htmlhttp://brokercheck.finra.org/Support/TermsAndConditionsText.aspxhttp://data.gov/ -
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
16/20
13 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
CFPB is on he righ rack in erms o building in ha consumer esing on he
ron end o make sure hey convey he desired inormaion, oper says.
o be sure, he SEC is under grea srains o implemen hundreds o new rules and
provisions under is purview in he Dodd-Frank Ac. Once i ges a breaher, he
commission should also ge serious abou enorcing he plain English require-men in he new disclosures.
Jus as i did when requiring muual und prospecuses be writen in plain
English, he SEC should oer model examples o wha a well-writen disclosure
looks like, and i should penalize advisory rms ha so brazenly ou he clariy
and conciseness rules.21
Te name o he game, as we all know wih regulaion, is enorcemen, says
Luz, he English proessor-urned SEC consulan. I people never go pulled
over or running red lighs, how many people would sop or hem? Go o Parisand youll nd ou.
-
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
17/20
14 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
Conclusion
Te SECs plain English revamp o invesmen adviser disclosures, and is wise
decision o release hem online, presen an opporuniy or he commission olead a shif in governmen disclosure policy. By requiring money managers o
explain heir business in plain language brochures, he SEC is acknowledging
as i has in he pasha mere disclosure is insucien o proec invesors. For
markes o uncion well, all paricipans mus have access o useul and under-
sandable inormaion.
Te only way o know or cerain wheher a documen is comprehensible is o
es i on is inended audience. Te Consumer Financial Proecion Bureau is
conducing user esing o guide is revamp o morgage disclosures. Te SEC
should likewise conduc invesor esing o sudy how well he new invesmenadviser disclosures are working.
I i does, he commission will likely nd ha many o hese new plain English
brochures are sill oo conusing and dense o be useuland ha invesors
would more likely pay atenion i he daa were presened in online comparison
and search ools ha had more robus uncionaliy and inuiive inerace.
Tas why he SEC should vigorously enorce is new plain English sandard, and
also release all is adviser regisraion daa, so ha enerprising companies and
advocaes can explore ways o make his inormaion relevan o invesors when
hey need i, and in a orm has easy o use.
-
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
18/20
15 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
About the author
Gadi Dechter is Associae Direcor o Governmen eorm a American Progress,
where he ocuses on inormaion policy. He previously worked as a reporer aBloomberg News, Te Balimore Sun, and Balimores Ciy Paper. A Bloomberg,
Gadi was an invesigaive reporer covering he inersecion o nance and poliics.
A Te Sun, he covered he Maryland General Assembly and higher educaion. He
received he American Associaion o Universiy Proessorss 2009 Iris Molosky
Award or Excellence in he Coverage o Higher Educaion and was a nalis in he
2008 Livingson Award or Young Journaliss compeiion. He holds a bachelors
degree in lieraure rom Yale and a masers in wriing rom Johns Hopkins. He
eaches public policy communicaions a George Washingon Universiys School
o Media and Public Aairs, and has also lecured a Georgeown Universiy, Johns
Hopkins Universiy, and he Maryland Insiue College o Ar.
Acknowledgments
Te auhor hanks Ed Paisley and he members o he CAP wriing workshop or
heir commens on a draf in progress.
-
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
19/20
16 cener r Aeran prgre | Wen Wrd Ge n e Way
Endnotes
1 U.s. seure and Exange cn, sEc A-rve Dlure Fr cange prvde inverGreaer inran Abu ter inveen Adver,pre releae, July 2010, avalable a ://www.e.gv/new/re/2010/2010-127..
2 Ele B. Waler, saeen a sEc en eeng,July 2010, avalable a ://www.e.gv/new/
ee/2010/072110ebw-adv..
3 Barbara Rer, ne nervew w aur, June 6,2011.
4 Wlla Luz, ne nervew w aur, June 6,2011.
5 ofe inver Eduan and Advay, U.s. seur-e and Exange cn, inver Bullen:Aenden Fr ADV, newleer, July 2010, aval-able a ://www.e.gv/nver/aler/bullen-radv..
6 mary L. sar, saeen a sEc en eeng,July 2010, avalable a ://www.e.gv/new/ee/2010/072110l-adv..
7 AXA Advr LLc, sEc Fr ADV, par 2, avalable a
://www.advern.e.gv.
8 Gldan sa Ae manageen, L.p., sEc Fr ADV,par 2, avalable a ://www.advern.e.gv.
9 merrll Lyn pernal Advr prgra, sEc Fr ADV,par 2, avalable a ://www.advern.e.gv.
10 Angela A. hung and er, inver knwledge andExerene w inveen Adver and Brer-Dealer (sana mna: RAND inue r cvl Jue,2010); J Janen, onlne prdu Reear (Wang-n: pew inerne & Aeran Le prje, 2010).
11 U.s. seure and Exange cn, A planEngl handb: hw creae clear sEc DlureDuen (1999), avalable awww.e.gv/d/andb.d.
12 ofe inver Eduan and Advay, U.s. seur-e and Exange cn, sudy and Reen-dan n irved inver Ae Regran
inran Abu inveen Adver and Brer-Dealer (2011), avalable a ://www.e.gv/new/ude/2011/919budy.d.
13 ian salbury, inver Ge New tl pre FnanalAdver, Wall sree Jurnal, may 28, 2001, avalable a://nlne.wj./arle/sB10001424052748704281504576329590056065676.l.
14 me Alred, ne nervew w aur, July 6, 2011.
15 sunlae inveen manageen, sEc Fr ADV, par2, avalable a ://www.advern.e.gv.
16 cred sue Ae manageen, sEc Fr ADV, par 2,avalable a ://www.advern.e.gv.
17 Adran Day Ae manageen, sEc Fr ADV, par 2,avalable a ://www.advern.e.gv.
18 Adran Day, eal nervew w aur, July 6, 2011.
19 Ddd-Fran Wall sree Rer and cnuer pre-n A, publ Law 111-203, 111 cng., (July 21,2010), se. 912,
20 Rer, nervew.
21 U.s. seure and Exange cn, sEc seeVew Fr inver n pral irve muualFund Dlure, November 2007, available at hp://www.sec.gov/investor/enhanceddisclosure.htm.
http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2010/2010-127.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/news/press/2010/2010-127.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/news/speech/2010/spch072110ebw-adv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/news/speech/2010/spch072110ebw-adv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/investor/alerts/bulletin-formadv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/investor/alerts/bulletin-formadv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/news/speech/2010/spch072110mls-adv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/news/speech/2010/spch072110mls-adv.htmhttp://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2011/919bstudy.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2011/919bstudy.pdfhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704281504576329590056065676.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704281504576329590056065676.htmlhttp://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.sec.gov/investor/enhanceddisclosure.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/investor/enhanceddisclosure.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/investor/enhanceddisclosure.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/investor/enhanceddisclosure.htmhttp://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704281504576329590056065676.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704281504576329590056065676.htmlhttp://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2011/919bstudy.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2011/919bstudy.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdfhttp://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.adviserinfo.sec.gov/http://www.sec.gov/news/speech/2010/spch072110mls-adv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/news/speech/2010/spch072110mls-adv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/investor/alerts/bulletin-formadv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/investor/alerts/bulletin-formadv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/news/speech/2010/spch072110ebw-adv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/news/speech/2010/spch072110ebw-adv.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/news/press/2010/2010-127.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/news/press/2010/2010-127.htm -
8/4/2019 When Words Get in the Way
20/20
The Center or American Progress is a nonpartisan research and educational institute
dedicated to promoting a strong, just and ree America that ensures opportunity
or all. We believe that Americans are bound together by a common commitment to
these values and we aspire to ensure that our national policies relect these values.
We work to ind progressive and pragmatic solutions to signiicant domestic and
international problems and develop policy proposals that oster a government that
is o the people, by the people, and or the people.