(/)

What Crimea telecom link could meanfor Russia-Ukraine cyber-conflictPlans for a fiber-optic cable between Russia and Crimea are 'at an advanced stage,'and could change the balance of cyber-power by providing Russia with moreoffensive options, experts say.

By Mark Clayton, Staff writer APRIL 7, 2014

Russia (/tags/topic/Russia)’s promise to start providing Internet and telecom

infrastructure to Crimea (/tags/topic/Crimea) via Rostelecom, the semi­privatized

state telecom of Russia, hasn’t been fulfilled – yet. But if and when such a linkup

happens, the ongoing tit­for­tat cyber­conflict between Russia and Ukraine

(/tags/topic/Ukraine) could quickly change in unpredictable ways, mostly to

Russia's benefit, cyber­security experts monitoring the fluid situation say.

Plans to deploy a fiber­optic submarine telecom link between Russia’s mainland

and Crimea are “at an advanced stage, and the cable could be in operation as early

as this month,” TeleGeography, a telecommunications market research firm

reported Friday, citing Russian news agency RIA Novosti.

Cyber Conflict MonitorKeeping watch on the digital domain(/World/Security-Watch/Cyber-Conflict-Monitor)

WORLD (/WORLD) | SECURITY WATCH (/WORLD/SECURITY-WATCH) | CYBER CONFLICT MONITOR (/WORLD/SECURITY-WATCH/CYBER-CONFLICT-MONITOR)

DC Decoder (/USA/DC-Decoder) | Security Watch(/World/Security-Watch)

(https://w1.buysub.com/servlet/OrdersGateway?cds_mag_code=CSZ&cds_page_id=156346&cds_response_key=I4FZXSNT)

World (/World) USA (/USA) Commentary (/Commentary) Business (/Business) Energy / Environment (/Environment) InnovationScience (/Science) Culture (/The-Culture) Books (/Books) Take Action (/Take-Action) (/content/search)

Maxim Shemetov/Reuters | View Caption

Popular Now

Secret Service directorquits: Here's whyCongress was extra-madwith her (+video)(/USA/DC-Decoder/Decoder-Buzz/2014/1001/Secret-Service-director-quits-Here-s-why-Congress-was-extra-mad-with-her-video)

(/USA/DC-Decoder/Decoder-

Buzz/2014/1001/Secret-Service-director-quits-Here-s-why-Congress-was-extra-mad-with-her-video)

1

Bizarre moonstructures: How did theyget there?(/Science/2014/1001/Bizarre-moon-structures-How-did-they-get-there)

(/Science/2014/1001/Bizarre-moon-structures-How-did-they-get-there)

2

Navy searches formissing MV-22 Ospreycrew member(/USA/Military/2014/1001/Navy-searches-for-missing-MV-22-Osprey-crew-member)

(/USA/Military/2014/1001/Navy-searches-for-missing-MV-22-Osprey-crew-member)

3

(/The-

Culture/Movies/2014/1001/The-Decent-One-The-documentary-about-Heinrich-Himmler-is-

4

TEST YOUR KNOWLEDGE

(/csmlists/quizzes) | How much doyou know about Ukraine? Take ourquiz! (/World/2013/1202/How-much-do-you-know-about-Ukraine-Take-our-quiz/Population)

IN PICTURES (/Photo-Galleries/In-Pictures) | Ukraine: 10 years in 30images (/Photo-Galleries/In-Pictures/Ukraine-10-years-in-30-images)

PHOTOS OF THE DAY (/Photo-Galleries/Photos-of-the-Day) | Photosof the Day 10/01 (/Photo-Galleries/Photos-of-the-

That announcement closely followed Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev’s

call late last month for Rostelecom to start offering telecom and Internet services

in the newly annexed Crimean Peninsula as a way of safeguarding communications

channels.

Recommended: How much do you know about Ukraine? Take our quiz!(/World/2013/1202/How­much­do­you­know­about­Ukraine­Take­our­quiz/Population)

“We must have Rostelecom and its subsidiaries come to Crimea as soon as

possible,” Mr. Medvedev said at a Moscow meeting on Crimea’s future, according

to a March 25 government news release. “We cannot tolerate a situation in which

sensitive information and documents related to the administration of the two

constituent entities of the Russian Federation are relayed by foreign

telecommunications companies. This must be terminated.”

A submarine telecom cable could fit in sync with

Russian efforts to link Crimea into its energy

network as well. Russia is developing plans to build

an undersea gas pipeline to Crimea and could build

three power stations on the Black Sea peninsula

following annexation from Ukraine, Reuters

reported April 1.

Russia’s military forces are still reported to be

conducting exercises along its long border with

Ukraine, adding to diplomatic and regional

tensions. But up to this point, little has changed in

the cyber­connection realm between Ukraine and

Crimea.

Crimea’s Internet providers are still getting their

outside Internet services supplied via providers in

mainland Ukraine, which in turn gets most of their

bandwidth from fiber optic lines running to

Western countries, reports Renesys, a cyber­

security firm in Manchester, N.H., that monitors

Internet pathways.

Russian Internet service providers (ISPs), by

contrast, have so far played a very minor role in

providing outside access for ISPs in Ukraine (or

Crimea for that matter), the company says. But that

could all change in a flash.

(/World/2013/1202/How-much-do-you-know-about-Ukraine-Take-our-quiz)

(/Photo-Galleries/In-Pictures/Ukraine-10-years-in-30-images)

(/Photo-Galleries/Photos-of-the-Day/2014/Photos-of-the-Day-10-01)

'The Decent One': Thedocumentary aboutHeinrich Himmler isexcruciating (/The-Culture/Movies/2014/1001/The-Decent-One-The-documentary-about-Heinrich-Himmler-is-excruciating)

excruciating)

Appeals court blockspart of N.C. voting law.Will Supreme Court stepin?(/USA/Justice/2014/1001/Appeals-court-blocks-part-of-N.C.-voting-law.-Will-Supreme-Court-step-in)

(/USA/Justice/2014/1001/Appeals-court-blocks-part-of-N.C.-voting-law.-Will-Supreme-Court-step-in)

5

(http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/2011/0104/Could-you-pass-a-US-citizenship-test/Who-signs-bills?cmpid=prc:ctzn:e)Could you pass a US citizenship test? Find out.(http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/2011/0104/Could-you-pass-a-US-citizenship-test/Who-signs-bills?cmpid=prc:ctzn:e)

(https://w1.buysub.com/servlet/OrdersGateway?cds_mag_code=CSZ&cds_page_id=156346&cds_response_key=I4FZXRRTY)

4 Free issuesSUBSCRIBE

(https://w1.buysub.com/servlet/OrdersGateway?cds_mag_code=CSZ&cds_page_id=156346&cds_response_key=I4FZXRRTY)

Day/2014/Photos-of-the-Day-10-01)An undersea link would allow the Russians to

provide Internet directly to Crimea without

traversing mainland Ukraine. While laying a new submarine cable is typically a

long process, Russian ISPs could in the meantime provide bandwidth temporarily

through existing landlines to Crimea – and that could happen fast, according to a

Renesys analysis.

Whatever link is established could change the balance of cyber­power, which so

far has seemed to be a stalemate, some experts say. If Crimean Internet service

providers then switch over to Russian providers, it would give Russia added

security for its communications with Crimea and additional offensive cyber­

options, according to Doug Madory, a senior analyst with Renesys.

“Lets say Russia brings Crimea into their fold, into their network, well they

wouldn’t be nearly as worried about collateral damage to Crimea if they wanted to

conduct a cyber or other attack on Ukraine’s Internet infrastructure,” Mr. Madory

says. “Conversely, if Crimea was the target of DDoS attacks from Ukraine, if that

Internet traffic had to go through Russia to get to Crimea, the Russian provider

could take it upon itself to protect Crimea.”

So far, the Russia­Ukraine cyber­conflict over Crimea has seen each nation’s

powerful criminal hacker communities apparently parrying and thrusting at each

other with distributed denial of service (DDoS) and other types of attacks,

although other entities, including hacktivists, are also reported to be active.

Prior to the Russian­Ukrainian confrontation that emerged late last year, criminal

hacker communities in the two countries were often in collaboration with each

other via organized cyber­gangs. Up to that point, they had appeared to refrain

from attacking each other’s countries, according to Jason Healey, director of the

Cyber Statecraft Initiative at the Atlantic Council, a national security think tank.

The Ukraine cyber fight has been different than Russia's past cyber conflicts.

Kremlin in 2007 sparked a weeks­long cyber­assault on Estonia by “ignoring or

encouraging” attacks by nationalist groups, Mr. Healey notes. A year later, in

attacks on Georgia, Putin allowed his security services to coordinate and possibly

even direct attacks on Georgian government and banking websites.

“In Ukraine, the Russians have used a more traditional path of propaganda,

misinformation, physical destruction, and modification of telecommunications

equipment, and cyber­attacks, all integrated into a single campaign,” Mr. Healey

wrote in a recent online analysis.

Results so far in the Russia­Ukraine conflict have seen hundreds of DDoS attacks

and presumably included clandestine cyber­attacks that disrupted e­mail systems

and websites at Russia’s central bank and foreign ministry, Ukraine’s Parliament,

and other government sites on both sides.

(/World/2013/1202/How-much-do-you-know-about-Ukraine-Take-

our-quiz)

Share this story:

(https://plus.google.com/share?url=http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Security-

Watch/Cyber-Conflict-Monitor/2014/0407/What-Crimea-telecom-link-could-mean-for-Russia-

Ukraine-cyber-conflict)

(/layout/set/print/World/Security-Watch/Cyber-Conflict-Monitor/2014/0407/What-

Crimea-telecom-link-could-mean-for-Russia-Ukraine-cyber-conflict)

On the day of the disputed vote over Crimean secession, Ukranian government

websites were hit by a wave of 42 cyberattacks during Crimea’s vote to secede

from Ukraine and join Russia. All of those were DDoS attacks, which clog

websites with bogus data, echoing DDoS attacks by Russia when it invaded the

former Soviet state of Georgia in 2008.

The day after the Crimean vote, however, saw a huge, apparently retaliatory,

counter wave of attacks against Russia, including 132 separate DDoS blasts

slamming Russian websites. One 18­minute DDoS attack that hit Russia March 17

was 148 times more powerful than anything Russia did in Georgia in 2008, and

four times larger than a large attack emanating from Russia just days earlier,

according to Arbor Networks of Burlington, Mass., which tracks such attacks.

“Of course a submarine Internet link would help the Russians more firmly monitor

and secure communications in an out of Crimea – and it means the Crimeans will

be less dependent upon old Ukrainian infrastructure,” Healey says in an interview.

“When the Russian pathways come in, I wouldn’t be surprised to see the links with

Ukraine cut or rarely used. Crimea would then be dependent solely on Moscow’s

whims.”

Related Stories

TEST YOUR KNOWLEDGE

(/csmlists/quizzes) How much do you know about Ukraine? Take our quiz!(/World/2013/1202/How­much­do­you­know­about­Ukraine­Take­our­quiz/Population)

Pro­Russia crowds rise up in Ukraine's east, as Moscow stands pat (+video)(/World/Europe/2014/0407/Pro­Russia­crowds­rise­up­in­Ukraine­s­east­as­Moscow­stands­pat­video)

Massive cyberattacks slam official sites in Russia, Ukraine (/World/Security­Watch/Cyber­Conflict­Monitor/2014/0318/Massive­cyberattacks­slam­official­sites­in­Russia­Ukraine)

Major cyber­assaults on Ukraine, then Moscow, on eve of Crimea vote (+video)(/World/Security­Watch/Cyber­Conflict­Monitor/2014/0314/Major­cyber­assaults­on­Ukraine­then­Moscow­on­eve­of­Crimea­vote­video)

How Ukraine crisis could dent country's booming cyber­crime (/World/Security­Watch/Cyber­Conflict­Monitor/2014/0326/How­Ukraine­crisis­could­dent­country­s­booming­cyber­crime)

MORE EMAIL

PRINT

   Enter your email ...

Follow Stories Like ThisGet the Monitor stories you care about

delivered to your inbox.

(https://w1.buysub.com/servlet/OrdersGateway?cds_mag_code=CSZ&cds_page_id=156346&cds_response_key=I4FZXCFAT)

(/)

STAY CURRENT. GO FAR.DISCOVER THE MONITOR DIFFERENCE

(/About)

ABOUT (/ABOUT) | CONTACT US (/ABOUT/CONTACT) | SUBSCRIBE (HTTPS://W1.BUYSUB.COM/PUBS/TF/CSZ/PRINT_DIGITAL_COMBO.JSP?CDS_PAGE_ID=156346&CDS_MAG_CODE=CSZ&ID=1402508303756&LSID=41621238237041116&VID=1&CDS_RESPONSE_KEY=I4FZXSUBP) | E-READERS

Global Galleries (/Photo-Galleries)

Photos of the Day 10/01 (/Photo-Galleries/Photos-of-the-Day/2014/Photos-of-the-Day-10-01)

Editors' picks

Faced with Islamic State horror, Iraqis retaliatewith humor (/World/Middle-East/2014/1001/Faced-with-Islamic-State-horror-Iraqis-retaliate-with-humor)

Doing Good (/World/Making-a-difference)

7 groups making communities morecompassionate (/World/Making-a-difference/Change-Agent/2014/0930/7-groups-making-communities-more-compassionate)

| ADVERTISE WITH US (/ABOUT/ADVERTISE) | CAREERS (/ABOUT/CAREERS) | FIND US ONLINE (/ABOUT/FIND-US-ONLINE)

CONTENT MAP (/CSM/CONTENTMAP) | TEXT (/TEXTEDITION) | MULTIMEDIA (/MULTIMEDIA) | CORRECTIONS (/ABOUT/CORRECTIONS) |CULTURE/ARTICLES-ON-CHRISTIAN-SCIENCE)© The Christian Science Monitor. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. (/About/Terms) Privacy Policy. (/About/Privacy-Policy)