Western Ghats Ecology Experts Panel: XI Meeting Ghats Ecology Experts Panel: XI Meeting 24/3/11 1...
Transcript of Western Ghats Ecology Experts Panel: XI Meeting Ghats Ecology Experts Panel: XI Meeting 24/3/11 1...
WGEEP made a presentation on its approach, guiding principles and the broad outline of the contents of its report under
preparation before the Hon. Union Minister for Environment and Forests and senior
officials of the Ministry on 24th March 2011. The Hon. Minister endorsed the
24/3/11 2
2011. The Hon. Minister endorsed the approach and asked the Panel to proceed
along proposed lines. This work will continue and lead to a concluding
Workshop at KILA, Thrissoor on 3 to 5 May 2011.
The presentation at the meeting on 24th
March 2011 incorporates excerpts from several sources, including representations
from civil society.
WGEEP has welcomed such submissions and is actively examining them. All such
excerpts are underlined in this
24/3/11 3
excerpts are underlined in this presentation. However their inclusion does not necessarily imply their acceptance by
WGEEP.
The other material in this presentation represents what has been prepared by
WGEEP.
• Western Ghats are truly a comely young maiden, with Agasthyamalai her head,
Nilgiris and Anemalais her breasts, Goa her waist, Arabian Sea her blue garment,
24/3/11 4
her waist, Arabian Sea her blue garment, and Satpuras her feet.
– Kalidasa, Raghuvamsa, Canto IV
~ 2nd century CE
• “When ascending, and on gaining the summit of any of these passes (in the Western Ghats), the scenery which everywhere presents itself is of the grandest kind. Some idea of it may be formed by imagining mountains succeeding mountains, 3 or 4 thousand feet high, covered with trees, except in places where the huge, black, barren rocks are so solid as to prevent the hardiest shrub from finding root in their clefts. The verdure about the Ghats to the southward of
24/3/11 5
The verdure about the Ghats to the southward of Poona is perpetual, but during the rainy season, when the torrents are pouring from the sides of the mountains, the effect is greatly heightened by the extreme luxuriance of vegetation”.
- Grant Duff (1826) History of Marathas, Vol. 1
• “Our Navy needs large timber as planks, beams and masts. This should be acquired by felling trees like teak from our kingdom as appropriate. Beyond this, the timber should be imported from outside. Trees like mango and jackfruit are also of use to the navy. But these should not be touched within the boundary of our kingdom. After all, these cannot be grown in a year or two. Our people have nurtured them like their own children over long periods. They will be deeply hurt if they
24/3/11 6
over long periods. They will be deeply hurt if they are cut. What is gained by hurting others can never last long. Rather, it constitutes a blemish on the ruler for exploiting the citizenry. Furthermore the land suffers in absence of these trees. Hence, this should never be permitted to happen. If there be an old, decaying tree, then it could be harvested after due payment to the owner”.
- Edict of Shivaji Maharaj, ~1670
Ram Guha: A Nation consumed by the State; Outlook,
January 31, 2011 - 1• To be sure, the Indian economy needs to grow at a
steady rate to lift our people out of poverty. However, we must look more carefully at the components of that growth, at its distributive impacts across and between generations. We must assess different enterprises and sectors according to the kinds of employment they generate, and their varying impacts on nature. We must ensure that all processes of land acquisition and natural resource allocation are fair, just and transparent.
24/3/11 7
resource allocation are fair, just and transparent.
• The costs of a narrow-minded focus on GDP growth, and of a fetishisation of a particular number -8%, 9%, 10%-can be colossal. For the GDP accounts do not subtract for the loss of water, land and vegetation polluted or destroyed by open-cast mining.
• The market can promote efficiency and productivity, but not ecological sustainability or social justice. The market does not value the needs of poor people who have no money, it does not value the future, and it does not value the right of other species to exist.
Ram Guha: A Nation consumed by the State; Outlook,
January 31, 2011 - 2
• It is thus in the rational interest of miners and industrialists to externalise the costs of degradation and pollution. (The laws to prevent this exist on the statute books, but, with a few spectacular exceptions, are not implemented.)
• India today is thus an environmental basket-case, characterised by falling water tables, dead
24/3/11 8
case, characterised by falling water tables, dead rivers, massively high rates of air pollution and soil erosion, the unregulated disposal of toxic wastes, and the decimation of forests and biodiversity. These processes are caused by a combination of inequality and corruption. Politicians at the Centre and the states, acting at the behest of the wealthy, pass on the costs of environmental damage to the poor and to future generations.
The Panel shall perform, the following
functions:
1. Assess the current status of ecology of the Western Ghats region.
2. Demarcate areas within the Western Ghats Region which need to be notified as ecologically
sensitive and to recommend for notification of such areas as ecologically sensitive zones
24/3/11 9
sensitive and to recommend for notification of such areas as ecologically sensitive zones
under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.
3. Make recommendations for the conservation, protection and rejuvenation of the Western Ghats Region following a comprehensive consultation process involving people and Governments of all the concerned States.
The Panel shall perform, the following
functions:
4. Suggest measures for effective implementation of the notifications issued by the Government of India in the Ministry of Environment and Forests declaring specific areas in the Western Ghats Region as eco-sensitive zones under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.
5. Recommend the modalities for the establishment of Western Ghats Ecology Authority under the Environment
24/3/11 10
5. Recommend the modalities for the establishment of Western Ghats Ecology Authority under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 which will be a professional body to manage the ecology of the region and to ensure its
sustainable development with the support of all concerned states.
6.Deal with any other relevant environment and ecological issues pertaining to Western Ghats Region, including
those which may be referred to it by the Central Government in the Ministry of Environment and Forests
Activities undertaken
• Panel meetings
• Brainstormings
• Commissioned papers
• Website
• Govt consultations
24/3/11 11
• Govt consultations
• Public consultations
• Field visits
• Formulation of scientific methodology
• Scientific publication
• Database compilation and analysis
Defining Western Ghats: Setting
boundaries
• There are no hard and fast boundaries
• Strong westward linkages in terms of coastal air pollution and coastal power
lines impacting WG forest
24/3/11 12
lines impacting WG forest
• Strong eastward linkages in terms of east-flowing river systems
Defining Western Ghats: Setting
boundaries
• Geological province or domain known as “Western Ghāt” comprises the
mountainous Sahyadri Range, the great escarpment Western Ghāt sensu stricto,
and the Konkan–Kanara–Malabar Coastal
24/3/11 13
and the Konkan–Kanara–Malabar Coastal Belt. The eastern flank of the Sahyadri
slopes gently eastwards, and the western flank breaks into scarps. Evidently, there
are no hard and fast limits.
Biogeographic
regions of the
Indian
subcontinent
(Blanford, 1901).
West Coast is
included in
24/3/11 14
included in
Sahyadris, there
are no clear
boudaries
between
Sahyadri and
Western
Peninsular tract
Defining Western Ghats: Setting
boundaries
• Development administration: Planning
Commission – disbursement of Central
Government assistance. At Taluka level.
24/3/11 15
Government assistance. At Taluka level.
• This administrative definition has no implications
in terms of environmental regulation
• Experience of Bhimashankar not being an
acceptable hill area for purposes of Govt
schemes!
Defining Western Ghats: Setting
boundaries
• WGEEP has proposed geographical
boundaries on basis of slope,
24/3/11 16
elevation and continuity of hilly tracts
Implications of setting boundaries: abrupt or gradual change in management regime
Two alternatives: • [a] Develop recklessly – conserve thoughtlessly
– Constitute islands of biodiversity (and social
exclusion) in an ocean of ecological devastation
24/3/11 17
exclusion) in an ocean of ecological devastation
• [b] Develop thoughtfully - conserve thoughtfully
• We advocate a layered, nuanced, participatory
approach; so that boundaries will not be
discontinuities and therefore will not be of undue
significance
L1- Surat-Goa Deccan Trap Landscape L2- Goa-Nilgiris Pre-Cambrian Dharwar System Landscape L3- Goa-Nilgiris Pre-Cambrian Peninsular Gneiss Landscape L4- Goa-Nilgiris Pre-Cambrian Charnockites Landscape L5- Goa-Nilgiris Recent Sedimentary Rocks Landscape L6- South of Palghat Gap Pre-
Western Ghats Landscapes
(Daniels)
24/3/11 18
L6- South of Palghat Gap Pre-Cambrian Charnockites Landscape L7- South of Palghat Gap Pre-Cambrian Peninsular Gneiss Landscape L8- South of Palghat Gap Pre-Cambrian Khondalites Landscape L9- South of Palghat Gap Recent Sedimentary Rocks Landscape
Setting: Landscapes & ecosystems
• Natural
• Human induced transformations
• Human interventions in terms of Property Rights, and Access regimes
24/3/11 19
Rights, and Access regimes
• Habitat fragmentation
• Significance of corridors
Special Ecosystems
• Evergreen sholas- grasslands; with notable
endemic species - wattle invasions
• Laterite plateaus
24/3/11 21
• Laterite plateaus
• Myristica swamps
• Riparian forests
Impact of Invasive Alien Species:
Eupatorium, Water Hyacinth, Tilapia; Subabul,
Wattle
In the globalizing world
• Our national capabilities of interfering in environment have grown substantially
• Corruption and lawlessness has skyrocketed
24/3/11 22
skyrocketed
• Rich and poor divide has widened
• Rich and powerful are all out to make money, ignoring environmental damage and merrily passing on the costs to the
poor and the weak
Challenges
• Our ability to protect environment is very weak
• Our Ministries and Commissions devoted to safeguarding the interests of the weaker sections of the community are thoroughly
ineffective
24/3/11 23
ineffective
• Ministry of En & F has the onerous task of safeguarding not only environmental, but social interests as well through instruments such as assessment of socio-economic impacts and
public hearings related to development projects
Case studies
• Environmental degradation –Goa mines, Maharashtra Sahyadris;
• Growing social divides –ecological refugees: fisherfolk of Dabhol esturary, BRT hills, impoverishment
of Solligas;
• Regulatory coordination and deficits: ZASI exercise
24/3/11 24
• Regulatory coordination and deficits: ZASI exercise
• Informational gaps and asymmetries: Jindal Committee
• The false dichotomy of environment and development; case study of Ramnagar resettlement,
Konkan Rly: Karambolim wetland
Alternative paths to prosperity
• Inclusive, caring vs exclusionary, uncaring;
• Egalitarian, such as nature loving regimes of Scandinavian countries, rich in forest and
mineral Resources
• Finland earns as much by exporting “zero
24/3/11 25
• Finland earns as much by exporting “zero effluent technologies” as by selling paper
• Norwegian Petroleum Fund
• Exclusionary path: Stratified, violence torn, such as white supremacist regime of South Africa
• Case study of Kalane mine, Sindhudurg district
Moving towards sustainable and inclusive growth
• We are practicing exclusionary development, exclusionary conservation;
24/3/11 26
development, exclusionary conservation; for vested interests profit from such
exclusion
Who profits from exclusion?
• Exclusionary development = Passing on the
costs of environmental degradation to poor
• Exclusionary conservation = Collect bribes from
rich to break rules, extort bribes from poor to
24/3/11 27
rich to break rules, extort bribes from poor to
permit them to eke out a livelihood
• Regrettably, Forest Department, often in charge
of conservation, is the only wing of Government
that officially declares that people are its
enemies
Amartya Sen :‘Development as
Freedom’
• Process of expanding real freedoms that people enjoy
• Access to –
• Adequate Food, Clean water, Unpolluted
24/3/11 28
• Adequate Food, Clean water, Unpolluted Air, Shelter, Education, Health Care, and
Gainful Employment
• Above all development should lead to an enhanced capacity to engage in social,
political, and economic decision making.
Towards sustainable development
• Putting into practice: Public trust doctrine
• Putting into practice: Polluter pays principle
• Putting into practice: Precautionary principle
24/3/11 29
• Ensuring Social or distributive justice
• Promoting Social ecology and green economy.
Key questions
• Is environment being effectively protected?
• Are environmental costs acceptable?
• Are transfers of environmental costs (Inter-sectoral, Inter-regional, Inter-class, Inter-generational) acceptable?
• Are people being involved in good management of environment?
24/3/11 30
environment?
• Are people being involved in deciding upon an appropriate development path?
• Are development policies leading to sustainable development?
• Are decision-makers at centres of power aware of what is happening on ground?
• Are people’s civil rights being respected?
Summary of Ratnagiri- Sindhudurg report
Currently available tools
• Development Planning and democratic devolution
• Case study: Kerala experience
• Goa decentralization proposal
24/3/11 31
• Goa decentralization proposal
Currently available tools:PESA
• Experience of implementation of Extension of Panchayat Raj to Scheduled Areas in
Schedule V district of Nandurbar
24/3/11 32
Currently available tools
• Ecorestoration programmes
• Watershed development activities. Case study: Masur- Lukkeri
• Role of MGNREGA in Ecorestoration.
24/3/11 33
• Role of MGNREGA in Ecorestoration. Case study: Attapdi, Wynaad, Lamkani in
Dhule district
Currently available tools: Regional Plans
• Town and Country Planning, merits and limitations
• Case studies: Pune and Ratnagiri districts
24/3/11 34
• Hill stations policy, Lake District, Lavasa, Amby Valley
• Goa Regional Plan 2021
• Zoning Atlases for Siting of Industries: Case studies: Pune and Ratnagiri districts
Currently available tools
• Environmental Protection Act 1986; strengths and limitations
• Air pollution
• Water Pollution
• Case study: Lote MIDC
• Environmental Impact Assessment, clearances,
24/3/11 35
• Environmental Impact Assessment, clearances, monitoring
• Participatory monitoring: Bhimashankar windmills, Goa school: violation of fishing
season ban
• Paryavaran Vahini; case study:Dakshin Kannada
Currently available tools
• Special Economic Zones:
• Case studies:
Raigad district
24/3/11 36
Rajgurunagar, Pune district
Bhutkhamb, Goa,
Dakshin Kannada district
Currently available tools
• Forest and Wildlife Conservation legislation, Forest Act, Wild Life Preservation Act
• Forest Act ; Village Forest provision: Case study: Halkar village, Muroor Kallabbe
• Protected Areas, Tiger reserves, Case study: BRT hills
24/3/11 37
• Protected Areas, Tiger reserves, Case study: BRT hills
• Community Conservation Areas, Case study: Udambanchola, Idukki district, Salim Ali Bird Sanctuary
• Positive incentives for conservation: Kerala mangroves
• Creating a viable programme of people earning livelihoods through providing ecological services
• Experience of vulture breeding sites
Currently available tools
• Biological Diversity Act
• Kerala, positive and Goa, negative
experiences
24/3/11 38
experiences
Currently available tools
• Forest Conservation Act; Case study: Mining related Forest Clearances in Goa,
Kolhapur – mining without clearances Joint Forest Management, Case study:
24/3/11 39
Joint Forest Management, Case study: Dakshin Kannada
• Forest Rights Act: Case study: Athirapally Gundia, Goa
Currently available tools
• Ecologically Sensitive Areas; Basis in
EPA
• Case study of Panchagani-
24/3/11 40
Mahabaleshwar ESA
Pronab Sen Committee Defn
Ecological sensitivity is defined as the imminent possibility of:
• Permanent and irreparable loss of extant life forms from the world;
24/3/11 41
extant life forms from the world;
or
• Significant damage to the natural processes of evolution and speciation
Sen Cmt Primary Criteria
Species based
1. Endemism
2. Rarity
3. Endangered species
24/3/11 42
3. Endangered species
4. Centers of evolution of domesticated species – Uttara Kannada world’s richest repository
Sen Cmt Primary Criteria
• Ecosystem based
Wildlife Corridors – routes of upstream migration
of spawning fishes
Specialized ecosystems
24/3/11 43
Specialized ecosystems
Special breeding site/area – Sea Eagle, Vultures
Areas with intrinsically low resilience
Sacred groves
Frontier Forests
Sen Cmt Primary Criteria
• Geo-morphological features based
Uninhabited Islands in the sea
Steep Slopes
24/3/11 44
Steep Slopes
Origins of Rivers – entire crestline
Sen Cmt Auxillary Criteria
• Species based
• Areas or centers of less known food plants
24/3/11 45
plants
• Ecosystem based
• Wetlands
• Grasslands
Sen Cmt Auxillary Criteria
• Geo-morphological features based
• Upper Catchment areas
• Not so Steep Slopes
24/3/11 46
• Not so Steep Slopes
• High Rainfall Areas
• Other uninhabited Islands
Ecological Sensitivity
Applying Pronab Sen criteria
• Entire Western Ghats region, (as well as much
of the rest of the country) qualifies as ESA
24/3/11 47
of the rest of the country) qualifies as ESA
• Pronab Sen Committee provides no guidelines
for management of ESAs
• WGEEP needs to work out a graduated
approach, suggesting management guidelines
Currently available tools
• Proposals of Goa Regional Plan 2021: • Constitute 80% of Goa as ESZ’s
• ESZ-I comprising Govt. and private forests, national parks, wild life sanctuaries, mangrove forest and water bodies, constitutes 54% of Goa’s area. No
24/3/11 48
parks, wild life sanctuaries, mangrove forest and water bodies, constitutes 54% of Goa’s area. No
intervention will be permitted.
• ESZ-II comprising paddy area and khazan, command area, salt pans and heritage zones,
constitutes 26% of Goa’s area. Very limited intervention will be permitted.
Currently available tools
• Proposals of Min EnF Wild Life
Division for management of ESAs
around PAs
24/3/11 49
Min En&F Wild Life Division ESA
Proposals content
1. Physical boundaries
2. Legal status
3. Biodiversity values
4. Livelihood resource base
24/3/11 50
4. Livelihood resource base
5. Activities to be prohibited/ regulated/ promoted
6. Protected Areas
Activity x Rg � Remark
1 Commercial
mining
* Digging/ quarrying OK if
related to personal house
construction
2 Tree felling * Permission from authority
3 Saw mills *
24/3/11 51
3 Saw mills *
4 Hotels, resorts * Per Master plan
5 Commercial
fire wood use * For hotels, businesses
Activity x Rg � Remark
6 Polluting industry *
7 Drastic change in
farming
*
8 Commercial use of * Per
24/3/11 52
8 Commercial use of
natural water sources
including ground water
* Per
Master
plan
9 Major Hydel project *
10 Electric cables * Undergro-
und
Activity x Rg � Remark
11 Organic farming
by locals
* Per Master
plan
12 Rain water
harvesting
* Promote
13 Fencing hotels *
24/3/11 53
13 Fencing hotels *
14 Organic farming * Promote
15 Polythene bags
in shops
*
Activity x Rg � Remark
16 Renewable
energy
* Promote
17 Road widening * With EIA &
mitigation
18 Vehicular traffic at
night
* Commercial
vehicles
24/3/11 54
night vehicles
19 Exotic species *
20 Use/ production
hazardous
material
*
Activity x Rg � Remark
21 Overflying by hot air
baloon
*
22 Protecting hill slopes/
river banks
* Per Master
plan
23 Discharging effluents/ *
24/3/11 55
23 Discharging effluents/
solid waste in
water/land
*
24 Air & vehicular
pollution
*
25 Sign boards &
hoardings
*
Concept of ecological sensitivity- 1
• We consider ecologically and economically important’ areas as biologically and ecologically `rich’ `valuable’ and, or `unique’ areas that are largely irreplaceable if
destroyed.
• By virtue of their biological richness, could be potentially of high value to human societies, help in maintaining the
24/3/11 57
of high value to human societies, help in maintaining the ecological stability, and be significant in conserving
biological diversity.
• Their `uniqueness’ may be recognised either by the rarity of the living systems they harbour that are difficult to
replace if lost, or by the uniqueness of the services they offer to human society.
Current Science, Vol 100(2) 25/1/11 pages 175-182
Concept of ecological sensitivity- 2
• Their `vulnerability’ could be determined by
physiographic features that are prone to erosion
or degradation under human and other
influences such as erratic climate, and on the
basis of historical experience.
24/3/11 58
basis of historical experience.
• ESAs as those areas that are ecologically and
economically important, but vulnerable even to
mild disturbances, and hence demand careful
management.
Current Science, Vol 100(2) 25/1/11 pages 175-182
Ecological sensitivity
• Public inputs:• Resolutions of several Gram Sabhas in
Ratnagiri and Sindhudurg districts
• Proposals from NGOs:
24/3/11 59
• Proposals from NGOs:
• Kodagu
• Sahyadri and Kodachadri Ecologically Sensitive Areas
• SWGM
All of Western Ghats
• Since all of Western Ghats qualify as Ecologically Sensitive Area on several of
Pronab Sen Cmt criteria, WGEEP proposes that the entire tract be regarded
24/3/11 60
proposes that the entire tract be regarded as an
“Ecologically Significant Area”
Ecological sensitivity zones
• Within Western Ghats, one may recognize:
• Regions of highest sensitivity = Ecosensitive core
• Regions of high sensitivity = ESZ1
24/3/11 61
• Regions of high sensitivity = ESZ1
• Regions of moderate sensitivity= ESZ2
• Regions of low sensitivity = ESZ3
• Regions of lowest sensitivity = Ecologically significant matrix
Marrying Conservation to
Development
• The entire Western Ghats tract may serve as a laboratory for fashioning development programmes compatible with nature
conservation and social justice
24/3/11 62
conservation and social justice
• Emphasize conservation and efficient use of resources- green architecture, rain water
harvests
• Avoiding waste
• Creating wealth from waste – energy from sewage, fertilizer from kitchen waste
Development strategy needs to be elaborated for various sectors with respect to
Ecosensitive core, ESZ1, ESZ2,
ESZ3 & Ecologically significant matrix
• Lessons from Himachal Pradesh,
24/3/11 63
• Lessons from Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Sikkim
• Lessons from Costa Rica, Australia, Norway, Switzerland
Ecologically Sensitive Area : Talkat, Dodamarg, Sindhudurg - 1
• It is necessary to consider following things for conservation of forest, and development of the village:
• Watershed development programme : • Though we have perennial streams as a water source for
village, it is important to plan methods for efficient use of these resources. In summer orchards do not get enough water due to lack of planning. It is possible to build Nala
24/3/11 64
water due to lack of planning. It is possible to build Nalabunds and small dams for water storage. Each Wadi in
village is need of this.• Perennial streams are present in Western Ghats ridges in
the village. It is possible to build mini-hydel projects for power generation on these streams. There is need to
study this possibility.
Ecologically Sensitive Area : Talkat, Dodamarg, Sindhudurg - 2
• It is needed to improve present condition of Cashewnut and arecanut orchards. In the area where forest and
enough water sources for horticulture are not present, we can develop agroforestry dependent on rainwater.
We require training and funds from government for this.
• At present we don’t have nursery of plants. We can
24/3/11 65
• At present we don’t have nursery of plants. We can develop one indigenous plant nursery through self help
groups
• Village tourism: Traditional houses, orchards and greenery in our village attract tourists. Our people from
Mumbai come here along with their city friends. There is scope to develop village as a tourist place.
Ecologically Sensitive Area : Talkat, Dodamarg, Sindhudurg - 3
• Human- Wild life conflict- Location of Talkat village is near to forest. Orchards are surrounded by forest. The forest area in the village is
blessed with rich wildlife as it is a part of forest between Amboli-Tillari. We are living with this wildlife since years. But these days we
are facing nuisance from monkey, sambar, elephant and leopard. While preparing development plan we have to consider this issue.
• We do like to live with wildlife.
24/3/11 66
• We do like to live with wildlife.• This is what we think. Government and villagers should work on development plan of Ecologically Sensitive Area. We are ready to do it. Because projects like mining are hazardous for our life as well
as it will destroy our income source. Instead of such projects we would like to have our village in Ecologically Sensitive area.
What do we want in SESA?
1. No displacement of people at all.
2. No activity or land use practice which is harmful to ecology and environment (like some of the industries, mining projects) and which either causes destruction/degradation or pollution of soil, water, air and living beings.
3.Give stake and incentive to people in and around ESA’s educate and motivate them; and force the implementation
24/3/11 68
educate and motivate them; and force the implementation of constitutional amendments on GP’s, TP’s, ZP’s, Ministries, MLA’s, MP’s in regard to promoting eco matters – however, no proposals to translate this into practice, no consultation with local communities in formulation of proposals.
4. A thorough study and data collection of flora, fauna and natural resources; and undertaking necessary steps, including research, to maintain, sustain, enhance biorichness as well as biodiversity.
Experts indicate that SESA/KESA are too big for management, and that it should be
reduced to smaller areas like Matheran, Mahabaleshwar, Panchagani. This is
ridiculously absurd in the context of saving WG. i.e. if we want to save the biodiversity towards saving the WG from further loot.
Reluctance to experiment and hesitation to
24/3/11 69
towards saving the WG from further loot. Reluctance to experiment and hesitation to a take bold step when we have come to this
pass and thus far, indicate timidity, irresponsibility and insincerity on the part of
the govt., bureaucracy and various committees and panels appointed by them.
SESA proposal
• We, from the people, have submitted our proposals based on the guidelines issued
by the Govt. The Govt. and the administrators have sat on it for seven years. And now the very criteria in the
24/3/11 70
years. And now the very criteria in the guidelines and their applicability are being questioned. This, to us is breach of trust
and insincerity of the system and its offshoot, the WGEEP, if our proposals are
not utilized and developed further in the interest of saving our ecology.
SESA proposals
• Whatever the arrangement, it is imperative that SESA ensure
protection under legal provisions, if the continued services provided by these forests are to be assured for
24/3/11 71
these forests are to be assured for the present and the future.
Principles governing development
controls and programmes for SESA
• Only those activities shall be permitted or promoted that enhance and conserve biodiversity and protect and enhance the water resources of the area.
• Activities to be promoted would focus on
24/3/11 72
• Activities to be promoted would focus on restoration of native flora and rehabilitation of natural assets.
• Only those activities shall be permitted or promoted that will rehabilitate the wildlife spaces and niches available in the areas.
Sahyadri Ecology Authority –a highly cenrtalized one- will review the existing
gamut of planning activities• Plans necessary to be examined and
scrutinized would include:• Development plans of panchayats and
towns falling in the areas prepared under the 73rd and 74th Constitutional
24/3/11 73
the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments.
• The management plans for wildlife sanctuaries and national parks falling in the area.
• Working plans of the respective forest departments.
SESA proposals:Plans necessary to be examined
• Zoning Atlases, if prepared, for the districts involved.
• Planning component of development proposal originating from the Planning
24/3/11 74
proposal originating from the Planning Commission (Central and State).
• Any statutory land use plans of the individual states.
• Coastal Zone Management Plans in so far as they impinge on SESA.
SESA proposals
• SEA shall thereafter interact with the local and other planning authorities to
reformulate the SESA component of these planning areas and bring them in line with
24/3/11 75
planning areas and bring them in line with the principles governing special
development programmes reserved for SESA
SESA proposals
• All development plans in force or proposed for these areas shall be in harmony with the above stated broad principles and no
activities which conflict with these
24/3/11 76
activities which conflict with these principles would be permitted or further
encouraged in these areas.
SESA proposals
• Where there are no such existing plans, the SEA together with its state
components shall ensure that village level and district level plans with these
24/3/11 77
and district level plans with these intentions are drawn up by competent
persons or agencies through transparent processes involving persons already
residing in the area – how? no mechanism proposed.
SESA proposals
• SEA will also identify within a period of two years activities that are destructive of biodiversity and which therefore need to be restricted or closed down or relocated. Activities to be discouraged, phased out or banned or prohibited would also
24/3/11 78
phased out or banned or prohibited would also include industrial-scale horticulture or
monocultures of any kind. Certain types of agricultural activities like the use of pesticides,
use of bulldozers, etc., would also be absolutely banned in view of their impacts on bird and bee
populations.
SESA proposals
• All Plans will become operational only after
approval of the Ministry of Environment &
Forests. Subsequent to the approval of such
Plans, they must be widely disseminated and
made available to the public by the State
24/3/11 79
made available to the public by the State
Governments for comments, which shall also be
sent to the MoEF
• Again, a highly centralized procedure is
proposed.
SESA proposals
• Pending the preparation of and approval by the Ministry of Environment & Forests for all the Plans for SESA, the following
conditions shall be adhered to by the
24/3/11 80
conditions shall be adhered to by the Central and State Governments for all activities connected with development
within SESA:
SESA proposals• From the date of this notification, no further changes
will be permitted either allowing dereservation of forests notified under the Indian Forest Act, 1907 or diversion of forest lands under the Indian Forest Act, 1980. Neither will authorities be permitted to change or modify the existing boundaries of wildlife sanctuaries and national parks within the SESA.
24/3/11 81
sanctuaries and national parks within the SESA.• There shall be no reduction in the Tribal Areas –what
are these? No mention of FRA- /Green Areas/ Agricultural Areas identified as such as on the date of this notification.
• Absolute height of buildings shall not exceed 9 meters and number of storeys shall not exceed ground plus one upper. This does not include hospitals and specialized non-commercial buildings in urban areas.
SESA proposals
• Any new construction in other areas of the eco-sensitive zone will be in accordance with the norms
laid out in this notification. The relevant local Government Departments or authorities shall be
responsible for following the norms laid out in this notification while according building and other
construction licenses.
24/3/11 82
• The Development Plans (DP) shall demarcate all common lands, grazing lands, gaothans (or their
equivalent revenue categories), gaothan expansion areas, forests, green areas, horticultural areas,
agricultural areas, orchards, tribal areas including tribal hamlets, natural springs, natural heritage sites, sacred groves (locally known as Devara Kadu / Devrai / Kans) and other environmentally and ecologically sensitive
areas.
SESA proposals
• No change of land use from green uses such as horticulture areas, agriculture, and others to non-green uses shall be
permitted. However the concerned
24/3/11 83
permitted. However the concerned Authority may permit conversion of
barren lands for the purpose of residential construction for personal uses
and petty shops and notified activities. No change of land use from tribal to non-
tribal uses shall be permitted.
SESA proposals
• Green land uses that require excessive water extraction in upper and lower catchment areas and
/or which require excessive as well as high potency chemical fertilizers and pesticides etc and
other practices harmful to the ecology, soil and subsoil water in the SESA must be discouraged,
reduced and eventually stopped in the SESA.
24/3/11 84
reduced and eventually stopped in the SESA. Economically attractive and ecologically
sustainable alternatives must be explored and encouraged. This must be reflected in the DP. The
Plans shall provide for restoration of denuded areas, management of catchment areas, provision
for fuel wood and needs of local community. However this should be done without converting
forest lands (owned by forest department / revenue department / private parties).
SESA proposals
• The DP shall place special emphasis on providing protection to threatened and /
or endemic species of plants and animals within SESA and shall
24/3/11 85
animals within SESA and shall incorporate measures to conserve the
same.
SESA proposals
The DP should also cover the following subjects:
- Eco-friendly and sustainable livelihood and development options within the SESA region.
- Sustainable grazing plans.
- Sustainable and ecologically benign agriculture,
24/3/11 86
- Sustainable and ecologically benign agriculture, promotion of local land races, organic farming practices.
- Solid waste management guidelines, based on segregation, recycling, composting etc.
- Actions and strategies for rain water harvesting
The SESA DP should also cover the
following subjects:
- Construction of roads, and guidelines for the same
- Measures and stipulations of regulating traffic especially through-traffic in the SESA.
- Measures for rejuvenation of water sources and
24/3/11 87
- Measures for rejuvenation of water sources and village level watershed management systems
- Building regulations for townships
- Conservation plans for natural and man made heritage sites, gene pool reserves and growth
centers.
SESA proposals
- Special focus on identification and protection of threatened / endemic species
of plants and animals and their habitats.
- Provisions of the Western Ghats Eco-
24/3/11 88
- Provisions of the Western Ghats Eco-region Biodiversity Strategy Action Plan,
and the Goa, Maharashtra and Karnataka Biodiversity Strategy Action Plans.
Land use policy
• Competing demands over land; land acquisition policy; displacement and
rehabilitation• Kodagu ESA proposals: Kodagu is a hilly area
with extremely high rain fall. It is therefore
24/3/11 89
with extremely high rain fall. It is therefore necessary to give due importance to land
stability during construction of roads as well as buildings. There is also a need to prevent
proliferation of mines and quarries.
Land use policy
• Kodagu ESA proposals
• Town and city delimitation- Restriction on extension of existing town/city limits without approval of monitoring body.
• Villages in close proximity to towns and cities will
24/3/11 90
• Villages in close proximity to towns and cities will not be included in the town/ city limits without approval from respective Gram Sabhas.
• Restriction on conversion of wetlands and coffee plantations into commercial sites for development of residential layouts or other non-agricultural purposes.
Kodagu ESA proposals
• Restriction on heights of buildings and on number of storeys.
• Rules and regulations regarding town and
24/3/11 91
• Rules and regulations regarding town and country planning to be strictly implemented.
• Building permission should be denied on hill sides with slopes in excess of a prescribed incline.
Water use policy
• Competing demands over land; displacement and rehabilitation
• Policy options for land use in upper catchments of Western Ghats streams
• Competing demands of maintenance of environmental flows, irrigation, power, industrial, domestic and
24/3/11 92
flows, irrigation, power, industrial, domestic and recreational uses, sand mining
• Policy options for maintenance of Environmental Flows
• SWGM:Rivers, Lakes and other natural fresh water source should not be leased or sold to MNCs or any
other conglomerates. There are enough and more rivers flowing to the East from the Western Ghats, and hence
no attempt should be made to turn any river to east. Protect River basins .
Water Use
• Case study: Athirapally
• Mining destroying natural springs
• Siltation of streams and rivers, river floods
• Groundwater depletion
24/3/11 93
• Groundwater depletion
• Case studies from Goa mining tracts
Agriculture
• Major contexts
• Valley Agriculture and Horticulture
• Hill Slope Agriculture
• Hill Slope Horticulture
24/3/11 94
• Hill Slope Horticulture
• Plantation crops
Agriculture
• Policy options for
• Organic agriculture
• Genetically modified crops
• C sequestration in agricultural soils;
24/3/11 95
• C sequestration in agricultural soils; Australian scheme
• Erosion of crop cultivars; PPVFR
Agriculture
• SWGM:The WG area would be a role model for
the country on Organic farming
• No agro Chemicals and pesticides. No GM
Crops in this Biodiversity rich Western Ghats,
24/3/11 96
Crops in this Biodiversity rich Western Ghats,
absolute no even to plantation crops, coffee, Tea
Rubber, Areca nut, Coconut . Coffee , Tea or
other estates when abandoned / or whose lease
is over, should not be permitted again.
Agriculture
• Kodagu ESA proposals
• Providing assistance for GI certification of Kodagu produce to include Kodagu coffee
and Kodagu honey.
24/3/11 97
and Kodagu honey.
• Implementing schemes related to floriculture etc with sizeable subsidies for
the local farmers.
Animal Husbandry
• Ban on goats?
• Policy options for maintenance of livestock land races
• Pastoral communities like Todas,
24/3/11 98
• Pastoral communities like Todas, Dhangars
• Kodagu ESA proposals:
• Implementing schemes related to animal husbandry, bee keeping, etc with sizeable subsidies for the local farmers.
Fisheries
• Policy options for:
• Habitat degradation
• Water flow disruption
• Overexploitation
24/3/11 99
• Overexploitation
• Pollution
• Destructive fishing methods
• Aquarium fish trade
Community Lands
• Community Grazing Lands: Encroachments, Grazing regulation
• Community Forest Lands: Cumindad lands
24/3/11 100
• Community Forest Lands: Cumindad lands of Goa
Reserved Forests
• SWGM:
• Forests should not be destroyed for Wind Mills
or Power lines – (how about laterite plateus?)
• When tree plantation and afforestation work is
24/3/11 101
• When tree plantation and afforestation work is
undertaken, no exotic species should be
planted, only local species should be planted.
• Mono culture plantations, including Oil yielding
trees, even by Forest Department should be
banned
Reserved Forests
• Kodagu ESA proposals• [a] Formation of core committee to look into
encroachments. This should include revenue and forest department officials
• [b] Proper boundary demarcation of forest areas, river banks and sacred groves.
24/3/11 102
banks and sacred groves.
• [c] Removal of encroachments from forests, river banks and sacred groves.
• [d] Core committee to periodically review status of forest lands, sacred groves and river banks in order to prevent any fresh encroachments.
Reserved Forests
• Kodagu ESA proposals• Ecological Territorial Army Unit
• There is a strong case for setting up an Eco- TA unit for Kodagu. Such units are carrying out excellent work in other regions of India. The man power is from retired
24/3/11 103
in other regions of India. The man power is from retired Defence Service Personnel, with a core team of
serving Army officers, Junior Commissioned Officers and Non- Commissioned officers. The unit in Kodagu
could take up the following key tasks:• [i] Forest protection- Prevention of poaching and illegal
logging• [ii] Identification and reporting of any fresh forest
encroachments
Kodagu ESA proposals: Ecological Territorial Army Unit
• [iii] Rejuvenation of degraded forest land- this should include the important task of phasing out teak monoculture in the eastern belt forests of Kodagu and planting indigenous tree species
• [iv]Raising nurseries for saplings of indigenous tree
24/3/11 104
• [iv]Raising nurseries for saplings of indigenous tree species- The saplings should also be made available to the local farmers at reasonable rates. This would go a long way in reintroducing local tree varieties in the coffee estates. At present, the tree diversity in the coffee estates is being adversely affected due to monoculture of silver oak.
• [v] Preventing and combating forest fires.
• [vi] Developing and improving water points for wildlife.
Protected Areas
• Critical Wildlife Areas
• Ecologically Sensitive Areas around PAs may be managed as ESZ1
24/3/11 106
may be managed as ESZ1
• SWGM:Charge more for people who wish to enter National Parks and reserves.
Traditional Conservation Practices
• Policy options for promoting traditional conservation ethos and practices, sacred
groves, rivers, ponds
24/3/11 108
Human- Wildlife Conflict
• Kodagu ESA proposals
• Providing funds and resources for mitigation of Human elephant conflict.
24/3/11 109
Village Industries and Handicrafts
• VGKK experiences of developing forest based enterprises
• Bamboo, cane
24/3/11 110
Organized Industry
• Kodagu ESA proposals
• Only non-polluting industries to be permitted
• Setting up agro/plantation based industries in Kodagu, such as coffee and pepper processing plants, fruit
canning units, etc.
24/3/11 111
canning units, etc.
• SWGM:
• No polluting Industries on West Coast, for their emissions directly affect flora and hence fauna ,
denuding the Western Ghats; it will also affect health and even psyche of people.
• Goa Golden Jubilee Development Council
• Proposed environmentally benign industrial activities
Mining
• Kodagu ESA proposals
• No fresh licenses should be issued for mining or quarrying. Renewal of existing
leases will be subject to approval from the
24/3/11 112
leases will be subject to approval from the monitoring committee.
• SWGM:
• No mining to be permitted in any part of Western Ghats
Power
• Demand side and supply side management
• Power generation
• Power transmission
24/3/11 113
• Power transmission
• Conservation
• Any party wishing to use air conditioning should be obliged to do so only using
power generated through solar panels, put up at their own cost
Power
• SWGM:
• No new dams or tail race projects.
• Run of the river projects to be encouraged so also small power stations.
24/3/11 114
so also small power stations.
• Other energy systems that could be encouraged would be biomass based
• Generate energy from sewage, water hyacinth, waste from food processing
plants
TourismSWGM:
Strengthen and promote (by not allowing 5 star establishments ) Home based Eco-tourism
Kodagu ESA proposals[a] Constitution of a tourism regulatory body
[b] A cap on issue of licenses for construction of any new tourist
24/3/11 115
[b] A cap on issue of licenses for construction of any new tourist resort or expansion of existing facilities, until a complete review
is carried out with regard to carrying capacity and effects of tourism.
[c] Formulation of a tourism master plan by the regulatory body[d] A total ban on new tourist resorts within ten km of Protected
Areas[e] A review of the Karnataka Tourism development policy with
regard to areas in the Western Ghats.
Transport and Communication
SWGM:
No more Airports. Growth of Mobile
towers should be restricted.
Kodagu ESA proposals
24/3/11 116
Kodagu ESA proposals
Kodagu is a hilly area with extremely high rain fall.
It is therefore necessary to give due importance
to land stability during construction of roads as
well as buildings.
Human Settlements
• Shelter: Promote green architecture, rain water harvesting
• Domestic Energy
• Drinking Water: Strongly discourage use of individual plastic bottles
24/3/11 117
individual plastic bottles
• Sanitation
• Solid waste disposal: Compulsory segregation of garbage
• Ban use of plastic carry-bags
• Toxic and biomedical wastes: Disposal into ground water
Human Setlements
• Kodagu ESA proposals
• All cities and towns must have proper sewage treatment facilities. At present, untreated raw
sewage is released directly into rivers and streams that feed the tributaries to River Cauvery.
24/3/11 118
that feed the tributaries to River Cauvery.
• Proper garbage and disposal and waste management facilities must be set up in the cities
and towns
• Bio-medical waste- Proper bio medical waste management facilities must be made mandatory for
both government and private hospitals
Nutrition
• Loss of wild edible plants
• Loss of fish, traditionally hunted wild animals
24/3/11 119
animals
Should culling of wild pigs be legalised?
Health
• Breathing in dust day in and day out
• Polluted waters – even ground water
• Food with pesticide, heavy metal residues
• Choked traffic, accidents
24/3/11 120
• Choked traffic, accidents
• What are the policy options?
Health
Kodagu ESA proposals
• Setting up health care centers in remote areas to provide in-situ affordable health
24/3/11 121
areas to provide in-situ affordable health care to communities in and around forest
areas of Kodagu
Education
• Promote student activities to monitor local environmental parameters and create a
public, transparent database
• Promote environmentally positive action
24/3/11 122
• Promote environmentally positive action by students, going beyond tree planting
Science and technology
• Promote green technologies
• Case study: Kerala
24/3/11 123
• Case study: Kerala
• Promote Citizen Science
• Australian River Watch model
Managing information
• Follow the lead of Goa Regional Plan 2021, that has put together an excellent
GIS database, pulling together information from diverse agencies, could be used in
many ways, e.g. to identify mine degraded
24/3/11 124
many ways, e.g. to identify mine degraded areas outside mining leases; or to identify
encroachments in riverine areas
• Government agencies should proactively disclose information as required by RTI
Managing information
• No information is currently available on vital issues such as natural springs
• Potential valuable role of student projects
• Need to create publicly accessible,
24/3/11 125
• Need to create publicly accessible, transparent, participatory database on
environmental resources
Institutional arrangements
• Political Institutions
• Gandhian ideal of self-governing local communities
• Democratic devolution: Operationalizing 73rd and 74th Amendments of the Constitution
24/3/11 126
and 74th Amendments of the Constitution
• Social audits
• Engaging people in planning and monitoring of environmental resources
• Participatory monitoring programmes like Paryavaran Vahini
• Put in place a grievance redressal system
Legal and administrative provisions
towards Environmental Protection
• Case studies of Environmental Impact Analyses, Public Hearing process,
Environmental Clearances and Environmental Management Plans:
24/3/11 127
Environmental Management Plans: Lavasa, Rivan, Devpan, Gundia,
Athirapally
Legal and administrative provisions
towards Environmental Protection
Case studies of Forest Clearances: Goa
Case studies of pollution control measures
• Lote MIDC
• Ore transport in Goa
24/3/11 128
• Ore transport in Goa
Reforms desired
Towards social harmony
• Tailoring economic growth to carrying capacity
• Carrying capacity can go up through technological, social innovations
• Promote an inclusive approach towards environmental protection
24/3/11 129
environmental protection
• Mines and other industries to proactively disclose all environmentally and socially
pertinent information
• No mine- or any such activity- to be allowed to continue if rules are flouted
• Environmental ombudsman
Western Ghats Ecology Authority
• Should be a Statutory Authority authorized to take actions under Section 5 of
Environmental Protection Act, 1986
• State level organization?
24/3/11 130
• State level organization?
SESA proposals: Composition and
Structure• The Sahyadri Ecology Authority (SEA) shall be
constituted by the Central Government in the Ministry of Environment and Forests, consisting of the following members for a term of 3 years.
The membership of the Authority should be such that at least 50% of the members are non-official
24/3/11 131
that at least 50% of the members are non-official members and should be from the SESA area. The selection of non-official members of the
Authority shall be undertaken through an open nomination process and through the
establishment of a Search Committee appointed by the MoEF.
SESA proposals: SEA Composition
and Structure
Chairperson: An eminent and competent
environmentalist or administrator or retired judge
of the Supreme Court or concerned High Court
or an environmental scientist having adequate
knowledge of the Western Ghats and
24/3/11 132
knowledge of the Western Ghats and
environmental issues
.Members: One representative of the State
Governments of Maharashtra, Karnataka and
Goa from their Departments of Environment and
Forests.
SESA proposals: SEA Composition
and Structure
• Members: Three representatives of NGOs or noted environmentalists from each of the concerned States.
• Members: Eminent experts and practitioners in the field of social science, anthropology,
24/3/11 133
the field of social science, anthropology, research methodology, ecology, botany, environmental justice, social justice etc.
• Member Secretary: A representative of the Ministry of Environment and Forest in the level of an Additional Secretary
SESA proposals: SEA Composition
and Structure
The SEA is empowered to co-opt one or more persons as its members or as
special invitees for dealing with specific issues. While dealing with issues
24/3/11 134
issues. While dealing with issues pertaining to a particular State, wherever
feasible, the Conservator of Forests of the particular Forest Circle shall be co-opted
as a member.
SESA proposals: SEA
Functions• The Authority shall have the powers to take the
following measures for protecting and improving
the quality of the environment of SESA and
preventing, abating, regulating, monitoring and
controlling environmental degradation and
24/3/11 135
controlling environmental degradation and
pollution in the areas covered by the SESA
Notification in general and shrinkage, alteration
of natural composition, denudation and depletion
of forests, flora, fauna and natural resources
within SESA, in particular.
SESA proposals: SEA
Functions
• (i) To exercise powers under section 5 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 for issuing directions and for taking measures with respect to matters referred to in clauses (v), (vi), (vii) (viii), (ix), (x) and (xii) of sub-section (2) of section
24/3/11 136
(viii), (ix), (x) and (xii) of sub-section (2) of section 3 of the said Act;
• (ii) To act as a 'Protection and Monitoring' authority, responsible for the implementation of the provisions of the SESA notification.
• (iii) To take all measures related to protecting and promoting the environment of the SESA in consultation with the Working Plans of the Forest Department.
SESA proposals: SEA
Functions(iv) To undertake activities for the protection and
improvement of the environment of the SESA according to the various Development and Management Plans as
specified in this Notification.
(v) To deal with any other relevant environmental issues pertaining to the SESA, including those which may be
24/3/11 137
pertaining to the SESA, including those which may be referred to it by the Central Government in the Ministry of
Environment and Forests.
(vi) To draw up guidelines for drawing up the various Plans for SESA to follow a participatory and transparent process. Such Guidelines shall be formulated as
specified in the SESA notification within one month of the constitution of the SEA and all the SSCs.
SESA proposals: SEA
Functions(vii) The SEA should make specific recommendations for
the drafting of the various Development and Protection Plans as mandated in the Notification, especially the
Tourism Development Plans and the Areas Development Plans.
(viii) To ensure that the execution of various Plans so
24/3/11 138
(viii) To ensure that the execution of various Plans so developed, adhere to the restrictions, rules and
provisions of the SESA Notification.
(xi) Pending the preparation of the various Plans for the SESA, and their approval by the Ministry of Environment
& Forests, the SEA shall ensure compliance with the provisions of the SESA Notification.
SESA proposals: SEA
Functions(x) The SEA and representatives from the three State Standing Committees shall be a part of the
Committee for drafting the Private Forest Protection Plans.
(xii) The SEA shall be the final authority to give special permission for limited quarrying of
24/3/11 139
(xii) The SEA shall be the final authority to give special permission for limited quarrying of
materials required for the construction of local residential housing and traditional road making and maintenance work in the municipal council areas of SESA only, provided that such areas
are not forest lands and that such material quarried are not minor or major minerals.
SESA proposals: SEA
Functions(xiii) Inquire into cases of violations of the provisions of
the SESA Notification brought to its notice, and if found necessary, issue directions under section 5 of the EP Act. For this purpose the SEA shall have the power to:
(a) Call for any documents from any person or the government of the Union or the State or any other official.
24/3/11 140
government of the Union or the State or any other official.
(b) Summon any person and receive evidence from such person on oath either on affidavit or otherwise.
(c) Seek assistance / presence of any persons(s) / official(s) required by it in relation to its work.
(xiv) Review of cases involving violations of the provisions of the SESA Notification, if found necessary to refer with comments to the MoEF for review.
SESA proposals: SEA
Functions(xv) The SEA shall be empowered to invite any person/ organisation to particular meetings, to undertake or call
for studies to be undertaken which are necessary for the discharge of its functions, and also to hold public hearings on specific issues at any specific place.
The manner and means of doing so will be decided by the
24/3/11 141
The manner and means of doing so will be decided by the SEA. The respective State Governments shall assist the
SEA with logistical assistance.
(xvi) The SEA shall be empowered to promote capacity building programmes for the involvement of local people
in the monitoring and implementing process for the purpose of ensuring local representation on the SEA in
following tenures.
SESA proposals: SEA
Functions(xvii) The SEA may decide its own procedure for
dealing with matters related to the implementation of the SESA notification and its
own functioning.
III. The SEA shall meet as frequently as required
24/3/11 142
III. The SEA shall meet as frequently as required but not less than once a month. Meetings should be held as far as possible in a manner and time suitable to all members. The SEA shall ensure
that at least two third of its members are present during its meetings. The SEA can function, and
decisions may be taken with 2/3rd quorum.
SESA proposals: SEA
FunctionsThe SEA shall furnish a report of its activities at
least once in 6 months to the MoEF.
Such reports should be translated and published in
the regional language by the MoEF & made
24/3/11 143
the regional language by the MoEF & made
available to the public on request by both the
SEA and the MoEF. Any other relevant reports,
annual accounts etc shall also be published in
the regional language and be made available to
the public.
SESA proposals: SEA
Functions• The expenses and honorarium of the members of the SEA shall be borne by the
MoEF.
• The MoEF shall consult with the SEA on
24/3/11 144
• The MoEF shall consult with the SEA on the budget and other financial aspects of
the functioning of the Authority.
SESA proposals: State Standing
Committees (SSC)• In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 23 of the
Act, read with sub-rule (4) of rule 5 of the Environment (Protection) Rules, 1986, the Central Government
hereby constitutes State Standing Committees for the purpose of implementation of the SESA notification. The State Standing Committees for each of their States shall
24/3/11 145
State Standing Committees for each of their States shall be constituted according to composition outlined below and with suggestion invited from the Secretaries, State Governments in their Departments of Environment and
Forests. The purpose of the SSCs is to assist in the monitoring and decision-making of the SESA, in so far
as it falls within the jurisdiction of the three different states.
SESA proposals: Composition of
SSC
Secretary, State Departments of Environment, Maharashtra, Goa and Karnataka are requested provide the
24/3/11 146
names of the suitable members to assist the MoEF in making a final
selection within one month from the date of publication of this notification.
SESA proposals: Composition of
SSC
1. District Collector (or such deputy officer designated by the D.C) Chairperson
2. Representative of local elected bodies
24/3/11 147
2. Representative of local elected bodies (Zilla Parishad), Member
3. Representative of District Panchayat, Member
4. Representative from the Department of Agriculture, Member
SESA proposals: Composition of
SSC
5. Representative from the Department of Animal Husbandry, Member
6. Two representatives of local NGOs / noted environmentalists, Member
24/3/11 148
noted environmentalists, Member
7. The Honorary Wildlife Warden of the districts, Member
8. Representative from Forest Department not below the level of ACE, Member-Secretary
SESA proposals: Functions of SSC
1. The concerned State Standing Committees shall assist the SEA in the monitoring and implementation of the provisions of the SESA Notification, and shall extend all possible assistance in gathering data and in fulfilling any requests made by the SEA for the purpose of the SESA Notification. This does not include the power to accord
24/3/11 149
Notification. This does not include the power to accord permission to any development project, which is the responsibility of the SEA alone.
2. The concerned State Standing Committees shall participate in the drafting of all the development and protection plans of the region and shall take all necessary steps to ensure that the drafting process is participatory.
SESA proposals: Functions of SSC
3. The concerned State Standing Committees may take all necessary steps to interact between the local authorities, bodies and people and the SEA, for purposes of the SESA Notification and its effective implementation.
4. The State Standing Committee shall assist the SEA in monitoring the implementation of all the approved plans
24/3/11 150
monitoring the implementation of all the approved plans within SESA.
5. The State Standing committees shall meet and as often as required but not less than once a month. Reports of the State Standing Committees shall furnish a report of its activities to the SEA at least once in two months. Such reports shall be made available to the public on request.
WGEEP would work out and
suggest a down- top, bottom- up
approach
• Western Ghats Ecology Authority, as well as
State level Ecology Authorities would play a
facilitatory role, provide broad guidelines and
24/3/11 151
facilitatory role, provide broad guidelines and
support
• Guidelines would be fine tuned to the
contexts of PAs, Ecosensitive core, ESZ1,
ESZ2, ESZ3, and the Ecologically significant
matrix
An environmentally and socially
sustainable development process• Joint Protected Area Management systems would be promoted in all PAs
• An effective bottom up process of development planning, and regulations
24/3/11 152
development planning, and regulations and promotion within the bounds of
guidelines proposed for the various zones will be promoted throughout the region
Kindly note that this presentation incorporates excerpts from several
sources, including representations from civil society.
WGEEP has welcomed such submissions and is actively examining them. All such
excerpts are underlined in this
24/3/11 153
excerpts are underlined in this presentation. However their inclusion does not necessarily imply their acceptance by
WGEEP.
The other material in this presentation represents what has been prepared by
WGEEP.