Web.mit.Edu Comm-Forum Mit4 Papers Stanek

8/3/2019 Web.mit.Edu Comm-Forum Mit4 Papers Stanek

1/67


2/67


3/67


4/67


5/67


6/67


7/67


8/67


9/67


10/67


11/67


12/67


13/67


14/67


15/67


16/67


17/67


18/67


19/67


20/67


21/67


22/67


23/67


24/67


25/67


26/67


27/67


28/67


29/67


30/67


31/67


32/67


33/67


34/67


35/67


36/67


37/67


38/67


39/67


40/67


41/67


42/67


43/67


44/67


45/67


46/67

Project of Nowa Huta, 1949-1959 [Ptaszycki:1959]


47/67

Plac Centralny (beginning of the 1950s) and a block of flats (1958) [Ptaszycki:1959].


48/67

The mud of Nowa Huta [DS 1974(24.07), GK 1984(no.84)]


49/67

The socialist city of workers [Z 1974(no.30)]


50/67

The city of riots [P 1982(no.3)].


51/67

The defense of the cross (1960), picture taken by a secrete police agent [R 2000(no.99)].


52/67

Nowa Huta as a city of peasants [GK 1996 (28.02)]


53/67

Nowa Huta as an area of ecological disaster [GK 1996(28.02)] and as the green city [Karnasiewicz:2003]


54/67

Nowa Huta as a threat - a picture from one of the Krakows local newspapers [GK 2004(no.127)]


55/67

The following diagram shows the number of articles in the local weekly magazine of NowaHuta Gos Nowej Huty/ Gos Tygodnik Nowohucki which support the representation ofNowa Huta as a socialist or antisocialist city. The diagram bases on the investigation of allissues of this magazine from 1988 to 2002.

Symbols used in the diagram:

S the collection of articles which support the representation of Nowa Huta as asocialist city;

A the collection of articles which support the representation of Nowa Huta as aantisocialist city;

[if one article provides arguments for both of these representations, it isincluded to both of these collections]

X the number of items in the collection X;+ algebraic sum;- algebraic subtraction;

logical mulitiplication (common part);


56/67

Upper curve:S +A

Lower curve: [S +A] - [SA]The distance between the lowerand the upper curve shows thenumber of articles which providearguments for both oppositorypositions.

10

11

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

00

frn

eP

K

Co

n

eec

T

I

i

na

oA

ie

ue

XB

e

nle

frch

tct

r

w

dsg

o

rA

R

Ne

ei

nf

leja

x

i

SO

C

LAN

De

hib

iton

Te

nf

o

mu

ism n

Pln

.

h

e

doc

m

n

ioa

d

0h

nive

ro

Nw

ta.

4t

an

rsay

fo

aH

u

45

t

i

rsar

of

ow

a

ua

.

han

nve

y

N

Ht

N

ta

bco

s

ow

a

Hu

e

me

e

alyro

tct

dm

nu

n.

alg

lp

e

e

o

me

t

e

iye

et

l

Th

c

tdcid

so

esta

bish

h

o

tm

u

u

te

Nw

aH

ua

sem

.

Co

nfe

rnce

SE

KW

e

Mu

n

icipale

lectio

a

mp

aig

n

nc

5t

ann

irsa

ryof

No

wH

ua

.

0h

ve

a

t

06

05

04

03

02

01

A : the number of articlesupporting the representation oNowa Huta an antisocialist city.

S : the number of articlessupporting the representation ofNowa Huta as a socialist city.

S - A : the idealized curvshows the difference between thearticles supporting the oppositorypositions.

2002

1988

1989

1990

1991

1992

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

1993

[te9

1isu

o

s

h

1

9 s

e

fG

o

ico

le

is n

mp

te

due

oog

nza

toy

chn

e]

t r

ai

r

ag

s


57/67

The plan of the centre of Nowa Huta and the section in the axis [Garlinski:1953]


58/67

The only partially realized design of the centre of Nowa Huta [Garlinski:1953]


59/67

Aleja R at the beginning of the 1950s [Garlinski:1953]


60/67

Political ceremony in front of the Lenin monument [DP 1996(no.124)]


61/67

The supervised emptiness in Aleja R [GwK 1998(no.68)]


62/67

The new design for Aleja R [renderings from the web page of the designers]


63/67

The council of the district proudly presents the realized design [GTN 2001(no.43)]


64/67

The critique of the realized design [GTN 2002(no.243)]


65/67

Nowa Huta as a green city [GwK 1997(3.07)]


66/67

The picture of Aleja R from the 1960-s as a critique of the realized design [GTN 2002(no.35)]


67/67

Web.mit.Edu Comm-Forum Mit4 Papers Stanek

Documents

Transcript of Web.mit.Edu Comm-Forum Mit4 Papers Stanek