Weak hadiths in tamil

60
`jP]; fspd; ngauhy; ... ,g; gbAk; rpy `jP]; fs; !? Mrphpau; : K.M. Kfk; kJ KifjP d; cytp> ntspaP L: ijkpa; ah gg; spNf\d; ]; > kJiu. gjpg;Giu Kd;Diu 1. kf; fhit tpl kjP dh rpwe; jjh? 2. `[; [{f; F ele; J nrd; why; mjpf ed; ikah? 3. tpgr;rhuk; nra; jhy; ...! 4. Fjpiuf; fwp cz;zf;$lhjh? 5. cyfj;jpy; gw;ww; W tho; tJ? 6. njhOifapy; ifia cau; j; jyhkh? 7. Nfhop MlhFkh? 8. [{k; M `[; [hFkh? 9. kiwTWg;igg; ghu; j; jhy; ..! 10. jiyg;ghifAld; njhOjhy; ...! 11. nra; jp $Wk; NghJ Jk; kyhkh? 12. ngz;fspd; Ngr; irf; Nfl; fyhkh? 13. ngz;Zf;F khW nra; tJ? 14. jyhf; $wNt $lhJ? 15. ,uz; lh? ehd; fh? 16. cz;Zk; Kd;Gk; gpd; Gk; x@? 17. cSr; nra; j gpwF 97tJ mj;jpahak; XJjy;? 18. nts;spad; W...? 19. `a; a myy; /gyh`; vd;W $Wk;NghJ...? 20. nts;spf;fpoik NjhWk;... 21. mq;Nf ahrP d; mj;jpahak; Xjpdhy;... 22. rigapy; ,Ue; J vOk;NghJ... 23. njhOJ nfhz; Nl jhd; ,Uf; f Ntz; Lkh? 24. Rg;`{ njhOifapy; 94 kw;Wk; 105 tJ mj;jpahaq; fis XJjy;? 25. flypy; gazk; nra; ayhkh? 26. cykhf;fis gpd; gw;wj; jhd; Ntz; Lkh? Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.ht m 1 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

description

Collection of Weak Hadiths in Tamil. This is for creating awareness to the Tamil Muslim Community.

Transcript of Weak hadiths in tamil

Page 1: Weak hadiths in tamil

`jP];fspd; ngauhy;... ,g;gbAk; rpy `jP];fs;!?

Mrphpau;: K.M. Kfk;kJ KifjPd; cytp> ntspaPL: ijkpa;ah gg;spNf\d;];> kJiu.

gjpg;Giu

Kd;Diu

1. kf;fhit tpl kjPdh rpwe;jjh?

2. `[;[{f;F ele;J nrd;why; mjpf ed;ikah?

3. tpgr;rhuk; nra;jhy;...!

4. Fjpiuf; fwp cz;zf;$lhjh?

5. cyfj;jpy; gw;ww;W tho;tJ?

6. njhOifapy; ifia cau;j;jyhkh?

7. Nfhop MlhFkh?

8. [{k;M `[;[hFkh?

9. kiwTWg;igg; ghu;j;jhy;..!

10. jiyg;ghifAld; njhOjhy;...!

11. nra;jp $Wk;NghJ Jk;kyhkh?

12. ngz;fspd; Ngr;irf; Nfl;fyhkh?

13. ngz;Zf;F khW nra;tJ?

14. jyhf; $wNt $lhJ?

15. ,uz;lh? ehd;fh?

16. cz;Zk; Kd;Gk; gpd;Gk; x@?

17. cSr; nra;j gpwF 97tJ mj;jpahak; XJjy;?

18. nts;spad;W...?

19. `a;a myy; /gyh`; vd;W $Wk;NghJ...?

20. nts;spf;fpoik NjhWk;...

21. mq;Nf ahrPd; mj;jpahak; Xjpdhy;...

22. rigapy; ,Ue;J vOk;NghJ...

23. njhOJ nfhz;Nl jhd; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lkh?

24. Rg;̀ { njhOifapy; 94 kw;Wk; 105 tJ mj;jpahaq;fis XJjy;?

25. flypy; gazk; nra;ayhkh?

26. cykhf;fis gpd;gw;wj; jhd; Ntz;Lkh?

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

1 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
By A.Umar Ali
Sticky Note
Web site where this is collected.
By A.Umar Ali
Sticky Note
Title of this e-book
Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 2: Weak hadiths in tamil

27. kpk;ghpy; ,Uf;Fk;NghJ Ngryhkh?

28. tpgr;rhuf; Foe;ijfs;

29. egp(]y;) mtu;fis Nehpy; fhz Ntz;Lkh?

30. egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; fhz Ntz;Lkh?

31. Nfhgk; Vw;gl;lhy;...?

32. kiof; fhyq;fspy; jhd; kdpjdpd; cs;sk;?

33. mugp nkhop NgRgtd; /ghu;]p nkhopNgrf;$lhJ?

34. gl;L nkj;ijapy; mkuyhkh?

35. ,fhkj; thrfk; xU jlit kl;Lk; $wpdhy; Fw;wkh?

36. mRj;j ,lk; ][;jh nra;jhy; Rj;jkhFkh?

37. jpUkzj;jpw;F Kd; `[; nra;jhy;?

38. Foe;ijf;F K`k;kJ vd ngahplhtpl;lhy;..

39. ngz;fs; tpisahl;L nghUl;fs;?

40. moF> gzk;> ghuk;ghpak; ,tw;wpw;fhf jpUkzk; nra;ayhk;?

41. mofpa Kfk; ,Ug;gpd;...

42. Gwk;NgRtJ?

43. k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; cghpj; njhOif...!

44. jhdpaq;fspy; ]fhj; kjpg;gPL msT vd;d?

45. mwpthsp MfNtz;Lkh?

46. ghtkd;dpg;Gf; fl;lhakhdjy;y!

47. rpye;jpahf khw;wg;gl;l i\j;jhd;?

48. ,ilj;jufu; ,y;iy!?

49. muG kf;fis ntWf;fyhkh?

50. /ghu;]p nkhop rpwe;jjh?

51. mugp jhd; nrhu;f;f nkhopah?

52. tpahghhpAk; tptrhapAk; nfl;ltu;fsh?

53. egp(]y;) Nehpy; re;jpj;j ed;ik ngw...

54. K`k;kJk; K`k;kjpd; je;ijAk; nrhu;f;fk; nry;tu;?

55. egp(]y;) ,Wjp egpah? ,y;iyah?

56. gpufhrpf;Fk; ,Us;?

57. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; VO Jzpfshy; fgdplg;gl;lhu;fsh?

58. ]`u; Neuk; vJtiu?

59. nts;is epwr; Nrtiy cz;zhjPu;?

60. ghtpfSld; Nru;e;Jz;zy;!?

61. ,ukshdpy; Vw;gLk; fLk; rg;jk;?

62. ukshd; vd;W $wf;$lhjh?

63. Fspg;G flikahdtd; fly; ePhpy; Fspf;fyhkh?

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

2 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Page 3: Weak hadiths in tamil

64. Fspg;Gf; flikahdtd; Fspayiwapy; Fspf;fyhkh?

65. m]u; njhOifia jhkjpf;fj;jhd; Ntz;Lkh?

66. uf;mj;fspy; Xjhky; U$c> ][;jh Kiwahf ,Ue;jhy; kl;Lk; NghJkh?

67. fhJfs; tiu ifia cau;j;JtJ gpj;mj;jh?

68. Y`u;> m]hpy; Xj Ntz;lhkh?

69. njho itg;gtu; mofhf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lkh?

70. njhO Neha;f;fhd fhuzk;?

71. ghu;itapd; $u;ikf;F...

72. Mz;fs; nfl;Lg; Nghf ngz;fNs fhuzk;?

73. Mz;fs; eufk; nry;y fhuzk; ngz;fNs!

74. ,iwtdpd; tpNuhjpfs; ngz;fshtu;?

75. k`Uf;F msTz;lh?

vr;rhpf;if!

gjpg;Giu

Gfo; midj;Jk; my;yh`;tpw;Nf!

my;yh`;tpd; khngUk; fpUigapdhy; jw;NghJ `jP]; E}w;fspd; jkpohf;fq;fs; ntsptUk; fhyk; ,J.gy;NtW jiyg;GfspYk; ,];yhkpa E}w;fs; ntspte;J> ,];yhkpar; rpe;jidia jkpo; NgRk; kf;fSf;FngUk; gad; mspf;Fk; fhyKk; $l.

,e;j tifapy; fle;j khjk; vkJ Kjy; ntspaPlhf ''egp(]y;) Nghjpj;j ew;gz;Gfs;'' vd;w E}iyKjy; ntspaPlhf Kd; itj;Njhk;. jw;NghJ ,uz;lhk; ntspaPlhf '',g;gbAk; rpy `jP];fs;'' E}iycq;fs; Kd; itj;Js;Nshk;.

Nghypahd `jP];(?)fisAk; $l ek;gp nray;gLk; mwpQu;fs; cz;L. ,jdhy; ,];yhkpar; rl;lq;fspy;Nfypf; $j;jhdit-Kl;lhs;jdkhditfs; $l Eioe;Jtpl;ld. åju;fspd; rjpapd; Kaw;rpf;Ff; fpilj;jntw;wp ,J vdyhk;.

MdhYk; Mapuf;fzf;fhd `jP];fs; ,l;Lf; fl;lg;gl;L> Gidag;gl;L cs;sd. mit midj;ijAk;,q;Nf Fwpg;gpLtjhdhy; gy thy;åk;fs; jhd; mr;rpl Ntz;baJ tUk;. xU ghid Nrhw;Wf;F xU NrhWgjk; vd;ghu;fs;. ,jdhy; rpy `jP];fs; kl;Lk; cq;fs; ghu;itf;F!

,tw;iwg; Ghpe;J nfhz;lhNy `jP];fspd; ngauhy;... $wg;gLk; rpy jtwhd nra;jpfs; tp\aj;jpy;c\huhf ,Uf;fyhk;. xU rpyu; tuk;G kPwp> ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP];fs; cs;sjhy;> `jP];fNsNtz;lhk;> Fu;Md; kl;LNk NghJk; vd;gu;. ,JTk; jtwhd ek;gpf;ifahFk;.

,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP];fis milahsk; fz;L> jpUf;Fu;Md; kw;Wk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd egptopg;gbnray;gl KidNthkhf!

- ijkpa;ah gg;spNf\d;];

kJiu

Kd;Diu

Gfo; midj;Jk; my;yh`;tpw;Nf!

Fu;MDk;> `jP]{k; jhd; jk; tho;f;ifapd; topfhl;b. mijg;gpd;gw;w jtwpaJ jhd;> ehk; topNfl;by;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

3 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Umar
Underline
Page 4: Weak hadiths in tamil

Ngha;tpl fhuzkhdJ vd;gijg; Ghpe;J nfhz;ldu; K];ypk;fs;.

Fu;MDk;> `jP]{k; mugpapy; cs;sjhy; mijj; jkpopy; juNtz;baJ muG nkhop mwpe;j mwpQu;fs;kPJs;s flikahfpd;wJ. Fu;Md; 50 tUlq;fSf;F Kd;Ng jkpopy; jug;gl;Ltpl;lJ. Mdhy; jw;NghJjhd; `jP];fs; KOikahf nkhopngau;g;G nra;ag;gl;L tUfpd;wJ.

åj> fpUj;Jtu;fs;> mtu;fsJ iff;$ypfs; J}a;ikahd ,];yhj;ij fsq;fg;gLj;j Ntz;Lk; vd;Wvz;zp ,];yhj;jpy; ,y;yhj> my;yh`;Tk; mtdJ J}jUk; $whj gy nra;jpfis gug;gpdu;. Fu;Mdpy;jq;fsJ ifruf;if mtu;fshy; Eiof;fKbatpy;iy. fhuzk; mJ KOikahf ghJfhf;fg;gl;LtUfpd;wJ. Mdhy; `jP];fNsh mg;gb ghJfhf;fg;gltpy;iy. ,J ,];yhj;ij fsq;fg;gLj;jvz;zpNahUf;F ngUk; tha;g;ghf mike;Jtpl;lJ. jq;fs; ,\;lj;jpw;F ''`jP];fspd; ngauhy;'' gytp\aq;fis egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf gug;gptpl;L tpl;lhu;fs;.

,jd; tpisT `jP]; fiy mwpQu;fs; `jPi] jq;fspd; E}y;fspy; gjpT nra;Ak;NghNj `jP]pd;juj;ijAk; vOjpdu;.

,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ.

,J Gidag;gl;lJ.

,J gytPdkhdJ

vd;nwy;yhk; milahsk; fhl;bdu;. Mdhy; K];ypk;fs; me;j ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l> gytPdkhd nra;jpfisjq;fisAk; mwpahky; nray;gLj;jp tpl;ldu;. `jPi] kl;Lk; Nghjpj;J tpl;L> `jP]py; cs;sGidag;gl;litfis Nghjpf;fj; jtwpajpdhy; kt;ytpfSk; $l jukpoe;j `jP];fis `jP]pd; ngauhy;kf;fSf;F Nghjpj;J tUfpd;wdu;.

`jP];fis nkhop ngau;g;G nra;Ak; NghNj mjd; juj;ijAk; jw;NghJ nkhop ngau;g;gtu;fs; Fwpg;gpl;lhYk;> `jP];fspd; ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;lijAk; jdp E}w;fshf je;jhy; jkpo; K];ypk;fs;tpopg;Gld; ,Ug;gu;. ,JNghd;w `jP];fis $WNthhplk; vr;rhpf;ifAld; ele;J nfhs;tu;; vd;gjhy; jhd;ap̀ jP];fspd; ngauhy;... ,g;gbAk; rpy `jP];fs;'' vd;w E}iyj; njhFj;Js;Nsd;.

,e;E}y; ntsptu MNyhrid toq;fpa Fitj; rNfhjuu;fs; kt;ytp S.K.rk;RjPd; kw;Wk; K.jh[{j;jPd;

M.A.> MfpNahUf;F vd; kdkhu;e;j ed;wpiaj; njhptpj;Jf; nfhs;fpNwd;.

ehk; `jP];fis ed;fwpe;J> cz;ikapy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf cs;s ]`P̀ hd `jPi]Nagpd;gw;wp tho ty;y my;yh`; mUs;Gthdhf!

,tz;>

K.M. Kfk;kJ KifjPd;

14-02-2005

ey;Y}u;> kJiu.

1. kf;fhit tpl kjPdh rpwe;jjh?

ku;thd; ,g;D `fk; mtu;fs; kf;fhtpy; ciuahw;wpf; nfhz;bUe;jhu;fs;. mg;NghJ kf;fhitg; gw;wpAk;mjd; rpwg;igAk; $wpf; nfhz;bUe;jhu;fs;. mg;NghJ kpk;gUf;F mUfpy; ,Ue;J uhgpT ,g;D `jP[;mtu;fs;> apePu; kf;fhitAk;> mjd; rpwg;igAk; $wpdPu;. mJ ePu; $wpagbNa cs;sJ jhd;. Mdhy; ePu;kjPdhitg; gw;wp $Wtij ck;kplk; ehd; Nfl;ftpy;iyNa. (Vd; $wj;jtwpdPu;?) 'kf;fhit tplkjPdhNt kpfr; rpwe;jJ' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wp ,Ug;gij ehd; Nfl;ljw;F rhl;rp $WfpNwd;''vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.

,g;gb xU rk;gtk; ele;jjhf GfhuP mtu;fs; jdJ 'jhFy; fgPu;' vDk; E}ypYk;> jg;uhdp mtu;fs; jdJfgPYk;> Kgo;oYy; [{d;jp mtu;fs; 'gohapYy; kjPdh' vDk; E}ypYk; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

4 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 5: Weak hadiths in tamil

,jpy; kpf Kf;fpakhf ftdpf;fg;gl Ntz;baJ 'kf;fhit tpl kjPdhNt kpfr; rpwe;jJ' vd;wthrfj;ijj; jhd;.

,r;rk;gtj;ij mwptpf;Fk; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ,lk;ngWk; K`k;kJ ,g;D mg;Ju; u`;khd; my; Mkpvd;gtu; rhpahdtu; my;yu;.

',tu; gykhdtu; my;y' vd;W mg+`hjk; mtu;fSk;> ',tuJ gy mwptpg;Gfs; ghJfhf;fg;glhjit' vd;W,g;D mjP mtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

'kf;fhit tpl kjPdhNt kpfr; rpwe;jJ' vd;w thrfKk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F khw;wkhfcs;sJ. kjPdhTf;F vd;W jdpr;rpwg;Gfs; cz;L vd;gij ehk; kWf;ftpy;iy. mjw;nfd jdpr;rpwg;Gfs;cz;L vd;gjw;F gpd;tUk; `jP];fs; Mjhukhf cs;sd.

Iu;> ]t;u; Mfpa ,uz;L kiyfSf;fpilNa cs;s kjPdh rpwg;Gkpf;f gFjpahFk; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs;$wpajhf myP(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

',iwth! kf;fhtpy; eP Vw;gLj;jpa mgptpUj;jp Nghd;W ,uz;L klq;Ffis kjPdhtpYk; Vw;gLj;Jthahf!'vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

'kjPdhtpd; ,uz;L vy;iyfSf;F cl;gl;l gFjpfspy; mjd; Gw;g+z;Lfis (Njitapy;yhky;) ntl;bvwptijAk;> mjd; Ntl;ilg; gpuhzpfs; nfhy;yg;gLtijAk;> ehd; `uhkhf Mf;FfpNwd;. kjPdh khefuk;jhd; mtu;fSf;F rpwe;jJ. ,ij mtu;fs; mwpaf; $lhjh? ahNuDk; kjPdhit ntWj;J mij tpl;Lk;nrd;why; my;yh`; mtiu tpl rpwe;jtiu mjw;Fg; gfukhf jq;f itj;J tpLthd;. ahNuDk; grpf;nfhLikiaAk;> rpukj;ijAk; jhq;fpf; nfhz;L cWjpahf kjPdhtpNyNa ,Ue;jhy; fpahk ehspy;mtDf;F ehd; ghpe;Jiu nra;gtdhf MNtd;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ]/J(uyp) mtu;fs;mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

,e;j `jP];fs; kjPdhtpd; rpwg;Gf;fis mwptpg;gjpy; ,Ue;Nj kjPdhtpd; rpwg;Gf;fs; cau;e;jit vd;gJnjspthdhYk; mNj rkak; kf;fhtpd; rpwg;Gfs; vd;gJ mijAk; tpl kpfr; rpwe;j xd;whFk;. ,ijgpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; %yk; tpsq;fyhk;.

'kw;w ,lq;fspy; Mapuk; njhOiffisj; njhOtij tpl vdJ ,e;jg; gs;spapy; xU njhOifnjhOtJ rpwe;jJ. Mdhy; k];[pJy; `uhk; (f/gh Myak;) jtpu. k];[pJy; `uhkpy; xU njhOifnjhOtJ> vdJ ,e;jg; gs;spapy; njhOk; 100 njhOiffis tplTk; rpwe;jJ' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs;$wpajhf mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D ]{igu;(uyp) mwptpf; fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: m`;kj;> ,g;D`pg;ghd;

'k];[pJy; `uhk; jtpu> vdJ ,e;jg; gs;spapy; xU njhOif njhOtJ kw;w ,lq;fspy; njhOk; 1000njhOiffis tplTk; NkyhdJ' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

',e;j Ciu (kf;fhit) thdq;fs;> g+kpiag; gilj;jjpy; ,Ue;Nj my;yh`; fz;zpag;gLj;jptpl;lhd;.my;yh`;Nt fz;zpag;gLj;jp tpl;ljhy; fpahkehs; tiuapYk; ,J fz;zpakpf;fjhFk;' vd;W egp(]y;)mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

,e;j `jP];fs; kjPdhit tpl kf;fhTf;F kpf rpwg;G cz;L vd;gij mwptpg;gjhy; kjPdh> kf;fhittpl rpwe;j Cu; vd;gJ kpifg;gLj;jg;gl;ljhFk;.

NkYk; 'Cu;fspd; jha;'> 'ck;Ky;Fuh' vd;W my;yh`; kf;fhit Fwpg;gpLfpwhd;.

,J> jha; fpuhkj;ij (kf;fh)itAk;> mijr; Rw;wp As;stu;fisAk; (K`k;kNj!) ePu; vr;rhpg;gjw;fhfehk; mUspa Ntjk;. ghf;fpak; ngw;wJk;> jdf;F Kd; nrd;wtw;iw cz;ikg; gLj;jf; $baJkhFk;.kWikia ek;GNthu; ,ij ek;Gfpd;wdu;. mtu;fs; jkJ njhOifapy; NgZjyhfTk; cs;sdu;.my;Fu;Md; 6:92

NkYk; kf;fhtpy; f/gh> `[Uy; m];tj;> kfhNk ,g;uh`Pk;> [k;[k; ePu; Cw;W> ]gh> ku;th kiyf;Fd;WNghd;w khz;GkpF jyq;fSk; cz;L.

,JNghd;w vz;zpylq;fh rpwg;Gfs; kf;fhtpw;F cz;L. kjPdhtpw;F vd rpwg;Gfs; cz;L vd;whYk;>

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

5 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Page 6: Weak hadiths in tamil

'kf;fhit tpl kjPdhNt kpfr; rpwe;jJ' vd;w thrfk; jtwhdJ. vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp egp(]y;)mtu;fspd; ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;ljhFk;.

2. `[;[{f;F ele;J nrd;why; mjpf ed;ikah?

''thfdj;jpy; Vwp `[; nra;ar; nrd;wtUf;F mtuJ thfdk; vLj;J itf;Fk; xt;nthU mbf;Fk; 70ed;ikfs; cz;L. (Mdhy; `[; nra;a) ele;J nry;gtUf;Nfh mtu; itf;Fk; xt;nthU mbf;Fk; 700ed;ikfs; cz;L.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. jg;uhdP mtu;fs; jd; fgPy;gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; a`;ah ,g;D Riyk;> Kfk;kJ ,g;D K];ypk; ,UtUk;rhpahdtu; fsy;yu;. ',t;tpUtUk; gytPdu;fs;' vd ,khk; m`;kj; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j ,UtUk;xUKiw jq;fSf;F ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D ik]puh mwptpj;jjhfTk;> kw;nwhU Kiw ,];khaPy; ,g;Dcikah mwptpj;jjhfTk; $wp> mwptpg;gtu;fs; thpiriaf; Fog;gf; $batu;fshf cs;sdu;.

NkYk; ,Nj K`k;kJ ,g;D K];ypk; topahf fPo;f;fz;l `jPi] ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; jd; E}ypy; gjpTnra;Js;shu;fs;.

'xUtu; thfdj;jpy; nrd;W `[; nra;jhy; mtUf;F xt;nthU vl;Lf;Fk; xU ed;ik cz;L. xUtu;ele;J nrd;W `[; nra;jhy; mtUf;F `ukpd; ed;ikfspypUe;J xt;nthU mbf;Fk; 70 ed;ikAz;L'vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;. `ukpd; ed;ikfs; vd;why; vd;d? vd;W xUtu; Nfl;lhu;. 'mjd; xUed;ik xU yl;rk; ed;ikf;Fr; rkkhFk;' vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;.

,e;j `jP]py; mg;Jy;yh ,g;D K`k;kJ my;Fj;jhkP vd;gtUk; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tUk; rhpahdtuy;yvd;W ,g;D mjP mtu;fNs $wTk; nra;fpwhu;fs;.

xUKiw egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; kjPdhtpypUe;J xU $l;lKk;> `{ijy; gFjpapypUe;J xU $l;lKk;te;jdu;. ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! kf;fnsy;yhk; thfdj;jpd; kPJ Vwp (`[; nra;ar; nry;Yk; epiyapy;ehq;fNsh kf;fhtpw;F ele;Nj nry;fpd;Nwhk;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> 'ele;Jnry;gtUf;F 30 `[; nra;j $yp cz;L' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.

,ij mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf jg;uhdP mtu;fs; jdJ mt;]j;jpy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; K`k;kj; vd;gtu; ngha;au;; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd;W i`jkP mtu;fs;$Wfpwhu;fs;. vdNt ,J gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;.

`[; nra;a thfdj;jpy; nry;tij tpl> ele;J nry;tij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; rpwg;gpj;Jf; $wpajhf ve;jxU Mjhug; g+u;tkhd `jP]{k; ,y;iy. NkYk; mjw;F vd jdpr;rpwg;G ,Ue;jpUe;jhy;> egpj;Njhou; gyu;`[; nra;Js;sdu;. mtu;fs; ele;J nry;tij Nju;e;njLj;jpUg;ghu;fs;. ,g;gb rpwg;G fUjp egpj;Njhou;vtUk; ele;J nrd;W `[; nra;jjhf ve;j xU Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpiaAk; ehk; mwpatpy;iy.

NkYk; ele;J nrd;W `[; nra;tjpy; rpwg;G cs;sJ vd;W ,Uf;Fkhdhy; ,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fSk;nra;jpUg; ghu;fs;. Mdhy; egp(]y;) mtu;fNsh thfdj;jpy; nrd;W jhd; `[; nra;Js;sdu; vd;gijgpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; %yk; mwpaKbfpwJ.

''ehd; egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; xl;lfj;jpy; mtu;fSf;Fg; gpd;dhy; mku;e;J mughtpypUe;J kpdh tiunrd;Nwd;. [k;uJy; mfghtpy; fy;nywpAk; tiu mtu;fs; jy;gpah $wpf; nfhz;NlapUe;jhu;fs;'' vd /go;Y,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> jpu;kpjP

ehq;fs; filrp `[;[pd; NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; `[; nra;Njhk;. mg;NghJ gpyhy;(uyp)>c]hkh(uyp) Mfpa ,Uty; xUtu; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; xl;lfj;jpd; fbthsj;ijg; gpbj;Jf; nfhz;lhu;.kw;nwhUtu; mtu;fs; kPJ ntapy; glhky; jdJ Milia cau;j;jpg; gpbj;Jf; nfhz;lhu; vd;W ck;Ky;`{i]d;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

6 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 7: Weak hadiths in tamil

ehd; mughtpy; egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; gpd;Nd xl;lfj;jpy; mku;e;jpUe;Njd;. mtu;fs; jkJ iffiscau;j;jp gpuhu;j;jid nra;jhu;fs;. mtu;fspd; xl;lfk; mtu;fis FYf;fpaJ. mjdhy; mjd; fbthsk;fPNo tpOe;Jtpl;lJ. xU ifahy; mij vLj;jhu;fs; vd c]hkh ,g;D i]j;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.E}y;: e]aP

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kpdhtpy; `[; ngUehs; jpdj;jpy; jkJ ms;gh vDk; xl;lfj;jpd; kPjku;e;J (Fj;gh)ciu epfo;j;jpaij ehd; ghu;j;jpUf;fpNwd; vd `pu;kh]; ,g;D ]pahj;(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;:m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;

thfdj;jpy; mku;e;J egp(]y;) mtu;fs; `[;[pd; fphpia fis epiwNtw;wpAs;sdu; vd;gJ kl;Lky;yegpj;Njhou;fSk; thfdj;jpy; nrd;Nw `[; nra;Js;sdu;.

xU kdpju; ,`;uhk; fl;bapUf;Fk;NghJ mtuJ thfdk; mtiuf; fPNo js;spaJ. clNd mtu;,we;Jtpl;lhu;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jz;zPuhYk;> ,ye;ij ,iyahYk; mtiuf; Fspg;ghl;Lq;fs;.mtuJ ,U Milfspy; mtiu fgdpLq;fs;. mtuJ Kfj;ijNah> jiyKbiaNah %lNtz;lhk;.Vnddpy; fpahkj; ehspy; jy;gpah $wpatuhf vOg;gg;gLthu; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;> e]aP> ,g;Dkh[h

`];mk; Nfhj;jpuj;ijr; Nru;e;j xU ngz;kzp my;yh`;tpd; J}jNu! vd; je;ij xl;lifapd; KJfpy;mku ,ayhj taJilatuhf ,Uf;Fk;NghJ> mtUf;F `[; vDk; my;yh`;tpd; flik Vw;gl;Ltpl;lJvd;W $wpdhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; 'mtUf;fhf eP `[; nra;' vd;W mthplk; $wpdhu;fs;. E}y;fs;:GfhuP> K];ypk;> mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> jpu;kpjP

vdNt ele;J nrd;W `[; nra;jhy; jdp ed;ikAz;L vd;gjhf tUk; Nkw;fz;litfs; mwptpg;ghsu;njhlhpy; cs;s FiwghLfshy; kl;Lk; rhpahdjhf ,y;iy vd;gjy;y! Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fspd;epiyf;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sJ.

3. tpgr;rhuk; nra;jhy;...!

'tpgr;rhuk; nra;tJ Vo;ikia Vw;gLj;Jk;' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D cku;(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.

K];dJ\;\p̀ hg; vDk; jdJ E}ypy; fshaP mtu;fs; ,ijg; gjpT nra;Js;shu;. ,e;j `jP]py;,lk;ngWk; iy]; ,g;D mgPRiyk; vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtu;. NkYk; khsP ,g;D K`k;kJ vd;gtu;ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;.

,khk; Råj;jp mtu;fSk; ,Nj `jPi] jd; [hkp,y; gjpT nra;Jtpl;L ,J gytPdkhdNj vd;WcWjpg; gLj;Jfpwhu;fs;. ig`fP ,khk; mtu;fSk; jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;Jtpl;L> ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; khsP ,g;D K`k;kJ vd;gtiu `jP]; fiyapy; kWf;fj; jf;ftu; vd;W$Wfpwhu;fs;.

,JNghy; ,g;D mgP̀ hjk; mtu;fs; jdJ ,yy;' vDk; E}ypy; ,e;j `jP]; gw;wp ''vd; je;ij(mgP̀ hjk;) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;Nld;. mjw;F mtu;fs;> ,J jtwhd `jP];. ,g;gb xU `jPi] ehd;mwpatpy;iy'' vd;W Fwpg;gpl;lhu;fs; vd gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

tpgr;rhuk; nra;tij cq;fSf;F vr;rhpf;fpNwd;. tpgr;rhuk; nra;jhy; MW tpisTfs; Vw;gLk;. %d;W,t;Tyfj;jpYk;> kw;w %d;W kWikapYk; epfOk;. cyfj;jpy; Vw;gLk; %d;W epiyfs; 1. re;Njhrk;Ngha;tpLk;> 2.Vo;ik Vw;gLk;> 3. mgptpUj;jp FiwAk;. kWikapy; Vw;gLk; %d;W epiyfs; 1. ,iwtdpd;Nfhgj;ij Vw;gLj;Jk;> 2. Nfs;tp fzf;F fLikahFk;> 3. epue;ju NtjidAz;L

vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf `{ijgh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.

,ij ,g;D mjP> mg+ eaPk; MfpNahu; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;. ,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; m`;k\; vd;gtu; kddrf;jp Fiwthdtu;; kWf;fj;jf;ftu; vd ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. m`;k\; topahf tUk; ,Jmg+u;tkhdjhFk;. NkYk; ,jpy; tUk; k];ykh vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtu; vd;W mg+eaPk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

7 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 8: Weak hadiths in tamil

',l;Lf;fl;baitfs;' (kt;@Mj;) vDk; E}ypy; ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,e;j`jP]{f;F vt;tpj mbg;gilAk; ,y;iy vd ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,khk; ig`fP mtu;fs;jdJ \{/Gy; <khdpy; ,ijg; gjpT nra;Jtpl;L> ',jpy; ,lk;ngWk; k];ykh `jP]; fiyapduhy;iftplg;gl;ltu;; mg+ mg;Ju;u`;khd; my;$gP vd;gtu; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;' vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

tpgr;rhuk; nra;tij cq;fSf;F vr;rhpf;fpNwd;. tpgr;rhuk; nra;tjpdhy; MW tpisTfs; cz;L. %d;W,t;Tyfj;jpYk; %d;W kWikapYk; Vw;gLk;. Kf moF Ngha;tpLjy;> cztpy; mgptpUj;jp Fiwjy;>kuzk; rPf;fpuk; tUjy; ,k;%d;Wk; cyfj;jpy; tUgitahFk;. ,iwtdpd; Nfhgk;> Nfs;tp fzf;F fLikmy;yh`; ehbdhNy jtpu epue;ju eufk; Mfpa %d;Wk; kWikapy; epfo;gitahFk;. vd;W egp(]y;)$wpajhf md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.

,JTk; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lNj! ,jpy; ,lk; ngWk; f/G ,g;D mk;U ,g;D [/gu; vd;ghu; rhpahdtuy;y vdfjPg; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,ij ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fs; jdJ 'kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypYk;Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

tpgr;rhuk; nra;tij vr;rhpf;fpNwd;. mjdhy; ehd;F tpisTfs; Vw;gLk;. 1.Kf moF Ngha;tpLk;>2.czT gQ;rk; Vw;gLk;> 3.,iwtdpd; Nfhgk; Vw;gLk;> 4. epue;jukhd eufk; cz;L. vd;W egp(]y;)mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,ij jg;uhdP jdJ m];tj;jpYk; ,g;D [t;]P mtu;fs; kt;@Mj;jpYk; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;. ,jd;mwptpg;ghsu;fspy; xUtuhd ,g;D [{iu[; topahf mk;U ,g;D [kPc vd;gtiuj; jtpu vtUk;mwptpf;ftpy;iy vd jg;uhdP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j mk;U ,g;D [kPc vd;gtu; ngUk; ngha;au; vd ,g;Dy;[t;]P $Wfpwhu;fs;. jg;uhdpapd; mt;]j; E}ypy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;s `jP]pd; mwptpg;ghsy; xUtuhdmk;U ,g;D [kPc vd;gtu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd;W i`]kP jdJ k[;kctpy;$Wfpwhu;fs;.

nghJthf tpgr;rhuk; nra;tJ vd;gJ ,];yhj;jpd; ghu;itapy; fLk; Fw;wk; jhd;. jpUkzk; nra;ahjtu;tpgr;rhuk; nra;jhy; firab nfhLf;f Ntz;Lk;. jpUkzk; nra;jtu; tpgr;rhuk; nra;jhy; fy;yhy; vwpe;Jnfhy;yg;glNtz;Lk; vdf; $wg;gLk; msTf;F khngUk; nfhba Fw;wk; jhd;. vdpDk; ,jw;fhf egp(]y;)mtu;fs; $whj xd;iw $wpajhf $wg;gLtijNa ngha; vd;fpNwhk; vd;gij epidtpy; nfhs;f!

4. Fjpiuf; fwp cz;zf;$lhjh?

''Fjpiu> NfhNtWf; fOij> fOij Mfpatw;wpd; ,iwr;rpia cz;gJ `yhy; (mDkjpf;fg;gl),y;iy.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fsplkpUe;J jhd; Nfl;ljhf fhypj; gpd; tyPj; (uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,Jmg+jh¥j;> e]aP> ,g;Dkh[h> j`htPapd; \u`{y; kMdp> ig`fP> m`;kj;> jg;uhdP Mfpa E}y;fspy;,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ.

',ij mwptpf;Fk; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngw;wpUf;Fk; ]hyp̀ ; ,g;D a`;ah vd;gtu; FiwghLilatuhf ,Uf;fpwhu;' vd ,khk; GfhuP Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. j`gP> ,g;D`[u; MfpNahUk; ,tiugytPdkhdtu;fs; gl;baypy; Nru;f;fpwhu;fs;.

,tu; gw;wpa mwpKfk; VJk; fpilf;ftpy;iy. NkYk; ,tuJ je;ij gw;wpa mwpKfKk; fpilf;ftpy;iy.,tuJ ghl;ldhu; kpf;jhk; ,g;D k`;jPfu;G vd;gtiuj; jtpu. ,tNuh> ,tuJ je;ijNah mwpag;glhjegu;fshf cs;sdu; vd %]h ,g;D `h&d; vd;ghu; $Wfpwhu;. ,tu; jd; je;ij a`;ah %yNk jtpuNtW vtu; %yKk; `jP];fis mwptpg;gjpy;iy vd> kP]hdpy; j`gP Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

jd; ghl;ldhhplk; jhNd Nfl;lJ Nghd;Wk;> jd; je;ij jd; ghl;ldhhplk; Nfl;L jdf;F jd; je;ij$wpaJ Nghd;Wk; ,tu; topahf ,e;j `jP]; mwptpf;fg;gLfpwJ. ,g;gb mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapYk; FsWgbcs;sJ.

NkYk; ,e;j `jPi] egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ifgu; Nghu; rkaj;jpy; $wpajhf fhypj; gpd; tyPj; (uyp)

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

8 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 9: Weak hadiths in tamil

mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ. Mdhy; ,e;j egpj;Njhou; mtu;fNsh ifgu; Nghu; rkaj;jpy;K];ypkhftpy;iy. kf;fh ntw;wp nfhz;l tUlj;jpy; jhd; K];ypkhdtu; vd;gJ Fwpg; gplj;jf;fJ. ,ij,g;D `[u; mtu;fSk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

NkYk; ,J Nghd;w xU `jPi] [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; NtW $Wfpwhu;fs;. fhypj; (uyp) mtu;fs; jhd;ifgu; Nghu; rkaj;jpy; K];ypkhftpy;iy. Mdhy; [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; mg;gbapy;iyNa; vdNt [hgpu; (uyp)mtu;fspd; `jPi] itj;J fhypj;(uyp) mtu;fspd; topahf mwptpf;fg;gLk; `jPi] '`]d;' vd;wme;j];j;jpw;F cau;j;jyhNk vd;W rpyu; $Wtu;.

Mdhy; [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; topahf mwptpf;fg;gLk; `jP]{k; gytPdkhdJ jhd;. ,jpy; ,lk; ngWk;,f;kh gpd; mk;khu; vd;ghu;> a`;ah ,g;D mgPfjPu; topahf mwptpf;Fk; ve;j `jP]{k; rhpahdjy;y. ,ija`;ah ,g;D ]aPj; my; Fj;jhd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. a`;ah topahf ,f;kh mwptpf;Fk; `jP]; ',o;jpuhg;'MFk; vd GfhuP $Wfpwhu;fs;. vdNt [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; ngauhy; mwptpf;fg;gLk; `jP]{k; rhpahdjy;yvd;gjhy; me;j `jPi] itj;Jf; nfhz;L ,e;j `jPi] '`]d;' Mf Mf;f KbahJ.

NkYk; ,e;j [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; ,Nj fUj;Jf;F khw;wkhf NtW Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jPi]mwptpf;fpwhu;fs; vd;gJ Fwpg;gplj;jf;fjhFk;. NkYk; Nkw;fz;l `jP]; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;Fkhw;wkhf cs;sjhYk; ,J gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; ,Njh;

ifgu; Nghd; NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; tPl;Lf; fOij (cz;z) jil nra;jhu;fs;. Fjpiu ,iwr;rpia(cz;z) mDkjpj;jhu;fs;. mwptpg;gtu;: [hgpu;(uyp)> E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> e]aP> mg+jh¥j;

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vq;fSf;Ff; Fjpiuf; fwpia cz;zj; je;jhu;fs;. fOijapd; fwpia cz;z jilnra;jhu;fs;. E}y;: jpu;kpjP

egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ehq;fs; gazk; nra;Js;Nshk;. mg;NghJ ehq;fs; Fjpiuf; fwpia cz;zf;$batu;fshfTk;> mjd; ghiyf; Fbg;gtu;fshfTk; ,Ue;Njhk;. E}y;: jhuFj;dP

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; fhyj;jpy; ehq;fs; kjPdhtpy; ,Ue;j NghJ Fjpiuia mWg;Nghk;. mij cz;Nghk;vd m];kh gpd;j; mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

Fjpiuf; fwpia cz;zyhk; vd ,e;j `jP];fs; $Wfpd;wd. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;l `jPN]h mij `uhk;vdf; $WfpwJ. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;F khw;wkhf ,Ug;gjhYk;> ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirrhpapy;yhjjhYk; ,J gytPdkhd `jP]hFk; vd;gij epidtpy; nfhs;f!

,e;jj; jtwhd `jPi] itj;Jj; jhd; `dgP kj;̀ gpy; Fjpiuf; fwp cz;zyhfhJ vd;fpd;wdu;. xUjtwhd `jPi] itj;J ehk; mky; nra;ayhfhJ.

5. cyfj;jpy; gw;ww;W tho;tJ?

''cyfj;jpy; gw;ww;W tho;tJ cs;sj;ijAk;> cliyAk; eyj;Jld; ,Uf;fr; nra;Ak;.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,e;j `jPi] cifyP>,g;D mjP> jg;uhdP MfpNahu; jq;fspd; E}y;fspy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.

,J gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;. ,jpy; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk;. ,\;m]{ ,g;DGuhR vd;gtu;gytPdkhd eguhFk;. ,tuJ `jP]; Vw;fg;glj;jf;fjy;y vd ,khk; GfhuP $Wfpwhu;fs;. '`jP]; fiyNkijfshy; iftplg;gl;ltu;' vd ,khk; e]aP mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; %d;whtJmwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk; myP ,g;D i]J vd;w ,g;D [j;Md; vd;gtUk; gytPduhthu;.

''cyfj;ij tpUk;gp tho;tJ> ftiyiaAk; ifNrjj;ijAk; mjpff;Fk;.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf jh¥]; vd;ghu; mwptpf;fpd;whu;. ,tu; egpj;Njhouy;yu;. ,JKu;]yhFk;. ,ij ,g;D mgP Jd;ah vd;ghu; jd; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;.

,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; K`k;kj; ,g;D K];ypk; vd;w mwptpg;ghsu; kdd rf;jp FiwghLilatu; vd;gjhYk;,J gytPdkhdjhFk;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

9 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 10: Weak hadiths in tamil

,Nj `jPi] ,Nj ,g;D mgP Jd;ah mtu;fs; NtW xU mwptpg;ghsu; topahfTk; ,ij gjpTnra;Js;shu;fs;. mjpy; ,lk;ngWk; ,g;uh`Pk; ,g;D m];m]{ vd;gtUk; kdd rf;jp Fiwe;jtuhthu;.

,Nj `jPi] foh, mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; NtW mwptpg;ghsu; thpirAld; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.MdhYk; mjpYk; gytPdu;fNs ,lk;ngWfpd;wdu;. m`;kj; ,g;D /gu;[{ vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtu;.

NkYk; gf;U ,g;D Fid]; vd;gtUk; gytPdu;. ,tiu gytPdu; gl;baypy; ,khk; j`gPFwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

Nkw;fz;l `jP];fs; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; cs;s NfhshWfspdhy; kl;Lk; FiwAilaJ vd;W$wpltpy;iy. mJ Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F khw;wkhfTk; cs;sJ. jpUkiwf;Fu;MDk; ,e;jgw;ww;w tho;f;ifia Mjf;ftpy;iy.

,JNghd;w jtwhd-gytPdkhd `jP];fis itj;J rpyu; Jwtp Nt\k; Nghl;Lj; jphpfpd;wdu;. jpUkzk;Nghd;w ma Rd;dj;ij-egptopiag; gpd;gw;wj; jtwptpLfpd;wdu;. fhL fspYk;> kiyfspYk;> FiffspYk;Ngha; jdpikapy; mku;e;J nfhz;L ,iwtid milag; Nghtjhff; $wp> gpwF jq;fisNa flTshff;fUjpf; nfhz;ltu;fSk; cz;L. ,g;gb gyu; topjtwpg; Nghff; fhuzk; ,e;j gytPdkhd `jP]; jhd;vd;gij ehk; epidtpy; nfhs;s Ntz;Lk;.

...Jwtpj;jdj;ij ehk; mtu;fs; kPJ flikahf;ftpy;iy.. (my;Fu;Md; 57:27)

egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ehq;fSk; rpWgilahf NghUf;Fr; nrd;Nwhk;. mg;NghJ jz;zPUk;> fPiufSk;tsu;e;jpUf;fpd;w xU Fif topahfr; nry;Yk; NghJ ehd; ,t;Tyfj; njhlu;Gfis tpl;L Kw;wpYk; tpyfp>me;jf; Fifapy; jq;fg; NghfpNwd; vdj; jdf;Fj;jhNd xU kdpju; vz;zpf; nfhz;L> mjw;fhfegp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; mDkjp Nfl;lhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> åju;fis Nghd;Nwh> fpwpj;jtu;fisg;Nghd;Nwh (kidtp> kf;fSld; thohky; FiffspYk;> Njthyaq;fspYk; jdpj;J jq;fp thOkhW) ehd;mDg;gp itf;fg;gltpy;iy. khwhf njspthd khu;f;fj;ijf; nfhz;L mDg;gg;gl;Ls;Nsd; vdf; $wpegp(]y;) mtu;fs; mtUf;F mDkjp kWj;Jtpl;ldu;. (,q;Nf `jP]pd; fUj;Nj jug; gl;Ls;sJ) ,ijmg+ckhkh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: m`;kj;

vq;fisj; jpUkzk; nra;Ak;gb VtpaJld;> jpUkzk; nra;ahjpUg;gij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; fLikahfvr;rj;jhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: ,g;D`pg;ghd;

egp(]y;) mtu;fsJ kidtpfsplk; %d;W Ngu; te;J> egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; tzf;f Kiw gw;wpf; Nfl;Lmwpe;jJk;> ',dp ehd; J}q;fhky; tzf;fk; GhpNtd;' vd xUtUk;> 'ehd; njhlu;e;J Nehd;G itg;Ngd;'vd xUtUk;> ehd; jpUkzk; nra;a khl;Nld; vd xUtUk; $wpdu;. ,ij mwpe;j egp(]y;) mtu;fs;mk;%tiuAk; mioj;J> ehd; xU ehs; Nehd;G itj;J kWehs; tpl;L tpLfpNwd;. J}q;fTk; nra;fpNwd;.tzf;fKk; GhpfpNwd;. jpUkzKk; nra;Js;Nsd; vd;W $wp tpl;L> ',it vd; topKiw. ,ijg;Gwf;fzpg;gtd; vd;idr; Nru;e;jtdy;y' vd;Wk; $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;:GfhuP

,q;Nf ehk; vLj;Jf;fhl;bAs;s trdk; kw;Wk; Mjhug; g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F khw;wkhfNt Muk;gj;jpy;cs;s gytPdkhd `jP];fs; cs;sd.

jpUkzk; nra;jhy;> ehk; kidtp-kf;fs; vd;w FLk;g tl;lj;jpy; rpf;fp ,iwtid kwe;JtplNtz;b tUk;vd;W $wp tho;Nthu; jtwhd tho;f;ifNa tho;fpd;wdu;.

cyf tho;f;if vd;gJ kWik tho;f;iff;F ek;ikj; jahu;gLj;jpf; nfhs;Sk; fskhFk; vd;gijNa xU%kpd; Ghpe;J nfhz;lhy;> ,JNghd;w jtwhd `jP];fs; $wg;gl;lJk;> ,J jtwhdit vd;W clNdtpsq;fptpLk;.

6. njhOifapy; ifia cau;j;jyhkh?

''njhOifapy; jd; ,UiffisAk; xUtu; cau;j;jpdhy; mtUf;Fj; njhOifNa fpilahJ. (mjhtJmtuJ njhOif tPzhfptpLk;.)''

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

10 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 11: Weak hadiths in tamil

,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahFk;. ,ij ,g;D jh`pu; mtu;fs; jdJ> 'jj;fpuj;Jy; kt;SMj;' vDk;E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,e;jr; nra;jpia mwptpg;gtu;fspy; xUtuhf ,lk;ngWk; 'k/%d; ,g;Dm`;kj; my;̀ u;tP vd;gtu; `jPi] ,l;Lf; fl;lf;$ba khngUk; ngha;au;' vd;W ,g;D jh`pu; mtu;fNsFwpg;gplTk; nra;fpwhu;fs;.

NkYk; gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhfTk; ,J cs;sJ.

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; njhOiff;fhf epw;Fk;NghJ jdJ ,uz;L Njhs;G[q;fs; tiu ,U iffisAk;cau;j;Jthu;fs;. U$Tf;F jf;gPu; $Wk; NghJk; ,Nj Nghy; nra;thu;fs;. U$tpypUe;J vOk;NghJk;,t;thW nra;thu;fs;'' vd mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D cku; (uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP

njhOifapy; ,Uf;Fk;NghNj U$tpw;F Kd;Gk; gpd;Gk; iffis cau;j;jNtz;Lk; vd;W Mjhug;g+u;tkhd,e;j `jP]; mwptpf;fpwJ. Mdhy; NkNy ehk; Fwpg;gpl;l nra;jpNah> ,jw;F khw;wkhf cs;sJ.,jpypUe;J ,J ,l;Lf;fg;gl;l xd;W jhd; vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

7. Nfhop MlhFkh?

''Nfhop vdJ rKjhaj;jpy; cs;s ViofSf;Fhpa MlhFk;. [{k;M vdJ rKjhaj;jpy; cs;sViofSf;Fhpa `[;[hFk;.''

,e;j `jPi] ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf ,g;D `pg;ghdpy; cs;sJ. ,ijg; gjpTnra;Js;s ,g;D `pg;ghd; mtu;fNs> ''ve;j mbg;gilAk; ,y;yhj NkhrkhdJ ,J NkYk; ,jd;mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; tUk; `p\hk; ,g;D cigJy;yh vd;gtu; Mjhukhf nfhs;sj; jf;ftu; my;y''vdf; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

',e;j `jP]; ngha;ahdJ. ,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; k`;k\; vd;w mwptpg;ghsu; `jPi] ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu;' vdjhuFj;dP (u`;) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j nra;jpfis kt;@Mj; vDk; jdJ E}ypy; ,g;Dy;[t;]P(u`;) mtu;fs; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

ML> khL> xl;lfk; ,itfis Fu;ghdp nfhLf;f mDkjp cs;sJ. xU Vio jdf;F ML thq;f trjp,y;iy vd;gjhy; `[; ngUehs; md;W xU Nfhop thq;fp mWj;jhy; Ml;il mWj;J Fu;ghdp nfhLj;jed;ik fpilf;Fkh? fpilf;Fk; vd;gijj; jhd; Nkw;fz;l `jP]; njhptpf;fpwJ. ,g;gb xU jtwhdfUj;ijj; jUk; nra;jpia egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wp ,Ug;ghu;fsh? vdNt ,e;j `jP]; ,l;Lf;fg;gl;lxd;Nw!

8. [{k;M `[;[hFkh?

''[{k;M ViofSf;Fhpa `[;[hFk;.''

,ij ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf ,g;D m]hfpu;> fshaP> ,g;Dy; ]d;[tpah> `h]; ,g;D mgPc]hkh MfpNahu; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ,lk;ngWk; <]h ,g;D ,g;uh`pKy; `h\pk; vd;gtUk;> Kfhjpy; vd;gtUk;gytPdkhdtu;fs; vd KiwNa `hgpo; ,uhfp mtu;fSk;> ,khk; ]`htP mtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

NkYk; ,khk; GfhuP> ,khk; e]aP MfpNahUk; <]h ,g;D ,g;uh`pk; vd;gtiug; gw;wp $Wk;NghJ '`jP];fiyapy; Vw;Wf; nfhs;sg;glj; jfhjtu;' vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP]; vd ,khk;]MdP mtu;fs; jdJ 'my; m`hjP]py; kt;@Mj;' E}ypy; ,ijg; gjpT nra;Js; shu;fs;.

[{k;M vd;gJ Vio> gzf;fhud; vd tpj;jpahrk; ,d;wp midtu; kPJk; cs;s flikahFk;. ,ij 62:9trdk; mwptpf;fpwJ.

Mdhy; `[;N[h trjpahdtu;fs; kPJ kl;LNk flik vd;gij 3:97 trdk; mwptpf;fpwJ. ,e;j `jP]py;cs;s thrfk; Viofs; jhq;fSk; `[; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W vz;Ztij> Kaw;rpg;gij jil

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

11 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 12: Weak hadiths in tamil

nra;fpwJ. ,JNghy; kf;fhtpy; `[; nra;a te;j ekf;F [{k;M flik ,y;iy. [{k;M jhd;ViofSf;Fhpa `[;jhNd! me;j ed;ikia mtu;fNs milal;Lk;. ehk; NtW Vd; [{k;M njhoNtz;Lk;? vd;W `[; nra;J te;Js;s gzf;fhuu;fs; vz;zTk; fhuzkhfptpLfpwJ. ,g;gb Kd;Df;Fg;gpd; Kuzhd tifapy; cs;s xd;iw egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpapUf;fkhl;lhu;fs;. ,J åju;fspd;ifthpirahy; `jP]; vd;w ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;gNj njspT.

'my;[{k;M `[;[{y; Gfuhc ([{k;M Viofspd; `[;)' vd;w ,e;j `jPi] \hgp kj;̀ igg;gpd;gw;WNthu; njhOk; gs;spapy; [{k;M md;W ,khk; kpk;ghpy; VwpaJk; gs;spapy; Kmj;jpd; (Nkhjpdhu;)vOe;J ifj;jbia gpbj;j tz;zk; $Wthu;. gpd;G me;j ifj;jbia ,khkplk; ju> mjd; gpd;Ng mtu;Fj;gh epfo;j;Jthu;.

,jpy; Ntbf;if vd;dntd;why; ,ij mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpg;gjhfTk;> ,J GfhuP> K];ypkpy;cs;sjhfTk; $Wthu;. ,J gr;irg; ngha;ahFk;.

Nkw;fz;l ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jPi]Na \hgp kj;̀ gpdu; $wpr; nra;fpd;wdu;. ',g;gb ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lgytPdkhd `jP];fs; jhd; kf;fsplk; rl;lkhf;fg;gl;Ls;sd' vd;gij kf;fs; czu;e;J ]`P̀ hd`jP];gb elf;f Kd; tu Ntz;Lk;.

9. kiwTWg;ig ghu;j;jhy;...!

''cq;fspy; xUtu; jd; kidtpaplNkh> mbikg; ngz;zplNkh clYwT nfhz;lhy; mtspd;kiwTWg;igg; ghu;f;fNtz;lhk;. Vnddpy; mg;gbg; ghu;g;gJ (fz;iz) FUlhf;fptpLk;.''

,ij ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf ,g;D mjP(u`;) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. me;j `jPi]'kt;@Mj;' (,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfs;) vDk; jkJ E}ypy; ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P(u`;) mtu;fs; gjpTnra;Js;shu;fs;.

,e;j `jP]; mwptpg;ghsu;fspy; xUtuhf ,lk; ngWk; gfpa;ah vd;gtu; ngha;au;fspy; xUtu;. NkYk;xUthplk; Nfl;fhkNyNa mthplk; Nfl;ljhf mwptpg;gtu; vd ,g;D `pg;ghd;(u`;) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

clYwT nfhs;Sk; xUtu; jd; kidtpapd; kiwTWg;ig ghu;f;fhky; ,Uf;f ,ayhJ. mg;gbg; ghu;j;jhy;

mJ fz;iz FUlhf;fptpLk; vd;W $Wtijg; ghu;j;jhy; Mz;fspy; 99% Ngu; FUlu;fshfj; jhd; Mfp,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. NkYk; ,d;iwa kUj;Jtu;fs; ,];yhj;ijf; Nfypf;Fhpajhfj; jhd; ghu;g;ghu;fs;.vj;jidNah lhf;lu;fs;> ngz; kUj;Jtu;fs;> gpurtk; ghu;f;Fk;NghJ xU ngz;zpd; kiwTWg;igghu;f;fNt nra;thu;fs;. ,tu;fSf;nfy;yhk; fz; FUlhfp tpl;ljh? jtwhd fUj;ijg; gpujpgypf;Fk; ve;jnra;jpiaAk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wNt khl;lhu;fs;. vdNt mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; kl;Lk; ,J NfhshWcilajy;y. mwpTg;g+u;tkhfTk; $l Vw;Wf; nfhs;s Kbahj `jPN]ahFk;.

kidtpapd; kiwTWg;igg; ghu;f;ff;$lhJ vd;w ,e;j ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP];> gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd`jP]{f;Fk; Kuz;gLfpwJ.

ehDk; egp(]y;) mtu;fSk; xNu ghj;jpuj;jpy; Fspg;Nghk;. vdf;F (nfhQ;rk; jz;zPu;) itAq;fs;.vdf;F (nfhQ;rk; jz;zPu;) itAq;fs; vd;W ehd; nrhy;Yk; msTf;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vd;dplk;Nghl;b NghLthu;fs; vd Map\h(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

fztDk; kidtpAk; xNu ,lj;jpy;> xNu ghj;jpuj;jpy; ,Ue;J ,UtUk; Nru;e;J jz;zPu; ms;spFspf;Fk;NghJ xUtUf;nfhUtu; jq;fspd; kiwTg; gFjpiag; ghu;f;f Ntz;baNj Vw;gLk;. mg;gbg; ghu;j;jegp(]y;) mtu;fSf;Nfh> Map\h(uyp) mtu;fSf;Nfh fz;zpy; Fiw VJk; Vw;gltpy;iy. NkYk; ,e;j`jPi]Na Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; kiwTWg;ig ghu;f;fyhk; vd;gjw;F Mjhukhff; nfhz;Ls;shu;fs;vd;gij gpd;tUk; rk;gtk; njspTgLj;JfpwJ.

xUtu; jd; kidtpapd; kiwTWg;igg; ghu;f;fyhkh? vd ehd; mjhc mtu;fsplk; Nfl;Nld;. mjw;Fmtu;fs; ,Nj tp\aj;ij ehDk; Map\h(uyp) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;lNghJ mtu;fs;> jhDk; egp(]y;)mtu;fSk; xNu ghj;jpuj;jpy; Fspj;j `jPi] $wptpl;L> ',e;j `jPN] xU ngz; jd; fztdpd;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

12 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 13: Weak hadiths in tamil

kiwTWg;igg; ghu;g;gJk;> fztd; kidtpapd; kiwTWg;igf; fhz;gJk; $Lk; vd;gjw;F MjhukhFk;'vd;W Map\h(uyp) $wpajhf mjhc mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: ,g;D `pg;ghd;

vdNt kiwTWg;igg; ghu;g;gjhy; fz; FUlhfptpLk; vd;Ws;s `jP]; ngha;ahd `jP]hFk;.

10. jiyg;ghifAld; njhOjhy;...!

''jiyg;ghif mzpe;J xU (uf;mj;) njhOtJ> jiyg;ghif mzpahky; 25 (uf;mj;) njhOtjw;Fg;gfukhFk;. jiyg;ghif mzpe;J xU [{k;M njhOtJ> jiyg;ghif mzpahky; 70 [{k;MnjhOtjw;Fg; gfukhFk;. kyf;Ffs; [{k;Mtpy; jiyg;ghif mzpe;Nj fye;J nfhs;thu;fs;. md;Wjiyg;ghif mzpe;J nfhs;gtUf;F #hpad; kiwAk; tiu JMr; nra;thu;fs;.''

jiyg;ghif mzpe;jpUe;j mg;Jy;yh ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fsplk; ehd; nrd;Nwd;. mJ rkak; mtu;fs;vd;dplk;> kfNd! jiyg;ghif mzpe;J nfhs;tij tpUk;gpf; nfhs;. kfNd! jiyg;ghif mzpe;Jnfhs;! eP fz;zpak; ngWtha;! cau;T miltha;; kjpg;G ngWtha; vd;W $wptpl;L> Nkw;fz;l nra;jpiaegp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhfTk; $wpdhu;fs;.

,ij mg;Jy;yh ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fspd; kfd; ]hypk; vdf;F mwptpj;jhu; vd k`;jP ,g;D ik%d;mwptpf;fpd;whu;. ,ij ,g;D e[;[hu; mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.

,e;j `jP]; gw;wp `hgpo; ,g;D `[u; (u`;) mtu;fs; 'yprhDy; kP]hd;' vDk; jkJ E}ypy; ,e;j`jP]; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;Wk; ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; cs;s rpyu; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;fs;vd;Wk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; ,khk; Råj;jp(u`;) mtu;fSk; ,ij ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP]; vdmwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.

''jiyg;ghif mzpe;J ,uz;L uf;mj; njhOtJ> jiyg;ghif ,y;yhky; 70 uf;mj; njhOtij tplrpwe;jJ.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. ,e;j `jPi] ,khk; Råj;jp(u`;)mtu;fs; jkJ 'my;[hkpc]; ]fPu;' vDk; E}ypy; nfhz;L te;J ',J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ' vdmilahsk; fhl;Lfpwhu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; jhf; ,g;D mg;Jw;w`;khd; vd;gtu; rhpahdtu; my;y vd,khk; e]aP (u`;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf j`gP(u`;) mtu;fs; jdJ 'Ymgh/' vDk; E}ypy;Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j `jP]; rhpay;y vd ,khk; ]`htP(u`;) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

''jiyg;ghif mzpe;J njhOtJ> 10 Mapuk; ed;ikfs; nra;tjw;Fg; gfukhFk;.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. mijAk; Råj;jp(u`;)mtu;fs; jdJ 'm`hjPjpy; kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy; nfhz;L te;J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd milahsk;fhl;Lfpwhu;fs;. ,khk; ]`htP> ,khk; kD}/gP> ,khk; ,g;D `[u; MfpNahUk; ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l`jP]; vd;Nw Fwpg;gpLfpd;wdu;.

Nkw;fz;l `jP];fspd; fUj;Jk; ed;F rpe;jpj;jhy; jtW vd;gJ tpsq;Fk;. jiyg;ghif> njhg;gp,y;yhky; gy rkak; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; njhOJs;sjw;F epiwa `jP];fs; cs;sd. jiyg;ghifmzpe;J njhOtjhy; mjpf ed;ik fpilf;Fk; vd;wpUe;jhy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vg;NghJk; jiyg;ghifmzpe;Nj njhOjpUf;f Ntz;Lk;. Mdhy; mtu;fs; jiyiaj; jpwe;j epiyapy; njhOjjpy; ,Ue;Nj ,e;jnra;jpfis ahNuh ,l;Lf;fl;bapUf;fpwhu;fs; vd;gJ njspthFk;.

jiyiaj; jpwe;j epiyapy; njhOtJ egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;F kl;LNk cs;s jdpr;rYif vd;W $l rpyu;thjplyhk;. Mdhy; egpj;Njhou;fs; gyu; jiyia jpwe;j epiyapy; njhOjjhf `jP];fs; cs;sdNt.,e;j `jP];fs; cz;ik vd;wpUe;jhy; `jP];fis mg;gbNa gpd;gw;wp tho;e;j ]`hgpfs; jiyg;ghifmzpahky; njhOjJ %yk; Rd;dj;jpw;F khw;wk; nra;jpUg;ghu;fsh? vdNt Nkw;fz;l `jP];fSk;,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfNs!

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

13 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 14: Weak hadiths in tamil

11. nra;jp $Wk; NghJ Jk;kyhkh?

''xUtd; xU nra;jpiar; nrhy;Yk;NghJ (mtNdh my;yJ NtW ahNuh) Jk;kpdhy; mr;nra;jpcz;ikahFk;.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,r;nra;jpia mg+a/yh>jg;uhdP MfpNahu; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;. ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P(uyp) mtu;fs; jdJ kt;@Mj; vd;w E}ypy;,ijf; nfhz;L te;J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;W milahsk; fhl;Lfpwhu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; KMtpah vd;gtu; Kw;wpYk; gytPdkhdtu; vd ,g;DKaPd;>mg+`hjk;> e]aP MfpNahu; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ig`fP mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;Jtpl;L 'Vw;Wf;nfhs;sg; glj;jf;fjy;y' vd;Wk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

ve;jg; Ngr;rpd; NghJ Jk;kg;gLNkh me;jg; Ngr;Nr kpf cz;ikahdJ.

,r;nra;jpia egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. jg;uhdP mtu;fs;jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,e;j `jPi] `hgpo; i`jkP mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;J>'jtwhd `jP];' vd Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; ckhuh ,g;D ]hjhd;vd;gtu;> jhgpj; vd;gtd; topahf md];(uyp) $wpajhf Vw;Wf; nfhs;sj;jfhj epiwa `jPi]mwptpj;Js;shu; vd ,khk; m`;kj;(u`;) $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j `jP]{k; jhgpj; topahf ckhuhmwptpg;gjhFk;.

Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L `jP];fSk; cz;ikahdJ jhd; vd xUtd; nrhd;dhy; ehk; ,e;E}ypy;vLj;Jf;fhl;Lk; Nghyp `jP];fSk; rhp> ,d;Dk; gy vz;zw;w Nghyp `jP];fSk; rhp midj;Jk;nrhy;yg;gLk; NghJ> xUtd; Jk;kptpl;lhy; mitfSk; ey;yjhfptpLk;. nfhiy nra;j xUtd; ehd;nfhiyahsp my;y vdr; nrhy;Yk; NghJ vtNuDk; Jk;kptpl;lhy; mtd; nfhiyahsp ,y;iy vd;Wnrhy;y KbAkh? ,g;gb xt;nthd;whf Nahrpj;Jg; ghUq;fs;. vd;d epiy Vw;gLk;? ,J Nghd;w jtwhdfUj;ijg; gpujpgypf;Fk; xd;iw egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpapUg;ghu;fsh?

Jk;kpdhy; nra;ag;NghFk; fhhpak;> epidf;Fk; fhhpak; elf;fhJ vd;W K];ypky;yhjtu;fs; nrhy;thu;fs;.mtu;fSf;F khw;wkhf ehk; vijahtJ nrhy;y Ntz;Lk; vd;W vz;zp Nkw;fz;l tp\aj;ij ,l;Lf;fl;btpl;lhu;fs; Nghy; njhpfpwJ.

12. ngz;zpd; Ngr;irf; Nfl;fyhkh?

''ngz;fSf;F fl;Lg;gl;L (mtu;fsJ Ngr;irf; Nfl;L) elg;gJ ifNrjj;jpw;FhpajhFk;.''

,J i]j; ,g;D ]hgpj;(uyp) mtu;fs; %yk; mwptpf;fg; gLk; `jP]hFk;. ,ij ,g;D mjp mtu;fs; jd;E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;. ,e;j `jP]py; ,lk;ngWk; 'md;g]h ,g;D mg;Ju;u`;khd;' vd;gtu;rhpahdtuy;y vd;gjhy; mJ gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;.

,tu; `jP];fis ,l;Lf;fl;b $Wgtu; vd ,khk; mg+`hjk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

',J rhpahd `jP]; my;y. ,e;j md;g]h vd;gtUk; rhpahdtuy;y' vd;W ,e;j `jPi] gjpTnra;Js;s ,g;D mjPNa $Wtjhf ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P jd; 'kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

,NjNghy; Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; $Wtjhf xU `jPi] cifyP> ,g;D mjP> ,g;D m]hfPu; MfpNahu;jq;fs; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.

,e;j `jP]{k; $l gytPdkhdJ jhd;. fhuzk;> ,e;j `jP]pd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk;K`k;kJ ,g;D Riykhd; ,g;D mg+fuPkh vd;gtu; jhd;.

,tUf;F Ke;ija mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk; `p]hk; ,g;D cu;th %yk; $Wk; ,tu;> rpy `jP];fs;jtwhdjhf ,Uf;Fk;. 'mJNghd;w mbg;gilaw;w `jP]; jhd; ,J' vd;W cifyP mtu;fs;$Wfpwhu;fs;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

14 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 15: Weak hadiths in tamil

`p]hk; %yk; ,tu; mwptpf;Fk; ,e;j `jP]; gytPdkhdNj! ,Nj `jPi] `p\hk; %yk; fhypj; ,g;DtyPj; my;kf;]{kP vd;gtUk; mwptpf;fpwhu;. ,tu; Nkw;$wpa K`k;kJ ,g;D Riykhd; ,g;D mg+fkhittpl kpfTk; gytPdkhdtu; vd;W ,g;D mjP $Wfpwhu;fs;.

egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;F Kjd; Kjyhf t`P te;jNghJ> jpLf;Fw;wtu;fshf> gae;jtu;fshf> jkJtPl;bw;F te;J> md;id fjP[h(uyp) mtu;fsplk; te;J ele;j nra;jpfisf; $Wfpwhu;fs;. clNdfjP[h(uyp) mtu;fs; tufh ,g;D et;gy;(uyp) mtu;fsplk; mioj;Jr; nrd;W ele;jtw;iwf; $wpdhu;fs;.mg;NghJ tufh ,g;D et;gy;(uyp) mtu;fs; ''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; xU ,iwj;J}ju;'' vd;w nra;jpia$wpdhu;fs;. ,J Map\h(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L GfhuPapy; cs;sJ. vdNt ngz;fspd; Ngr;irf;Nfl;L elf;fyhk; vd;gjw;F ,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhf cs;sJ.

13. ngz;Zf;F khW nra;tJ?

''ngz;fSf;F khW nra;Aq;fs;. mtu;fSf;F khW nra;tjpy; guf;fj; cz;L. ngz;fsplk; MNyhridnra;Aq;fs;. mNj rkak; (mtu;fspd; MNyhridf;F) khW nra;Aq;fs;''

vd;W cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; $Wtjhf xU nra;jpAk; ,lk; ngWfpd;wJ. ,e;jr; nra;jpAk; $l rhpahdjy;y,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; `g;]; ,g;D cJkhd; ,g;D cigJy;yh vd;gtu; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;. NkYk;mg+ cify; vd;w a`;ah ,g;D Kj;jtf;fpy; my; ckuP vd;gtUk; gytPdkhdtuhthu;.

ngz;fSk; MNyhrid ngwg;glj;jf;ftu;fNs! mtu;fsplk; MNyhrpj;J fhhpak; Mw;Wtjpy; vt;tpjj;jtWkpy;iy.

xt;nthU ngz;fSk; (mtu;fspd; FLk;gj;jpw;F) nghWg;ghdtu;fs;. mtu;fspd; nghWg;G gw;wpAk; tprhhpf;fg;gLk; vd;gJ egpnkhop (E}y;:GfhuP). ,e;j `jP]pypUe;J ngz;fSf;F nghWg;Gz;L vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.mtu;fs; nghWg;Gilatu;fs; vd;gjpypUe;Nj MNyhrid nra;ag;glj; jFjpAs;stu;fNs vd;gJnjspthFk;. ,e;j mbg;gilapYk; $l ngz;fs; Ngr;ir Nfl;ff;$lhJ vd;gJk; mtu;fSf;F khW nra;aNtz;Lk; vd;gJk; jtW vd;gij tpsq;fyhk;. ,jd; %yKk; Nkw;fz;l `jP]; gytPdkhdJ vdg;Ghpayhk;.

14. jyhf; $wNt $lhJ?

''ePq;fs; jpUkzk; nra;Aq;fs;. jyhf; (tpthfuj;J) nrhy;yhjPu;fs;. Vndd;why; jyhf; nrhy;tJ %yk;mu;\; eLq;FfpwJ.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf myP(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy;,lk;ngWk; mk;U ,g;D [kPc vd;gtd; ngUk; ngha;ad;; Vw;Wf; nfhs;sj;jfhj gy `jP];fisAk;mwptpg;gtd; vd fjPg;(u`;) njhptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,ijNa ,khk; Råj;jp(u`;) mtu;fSk;cWjpg;gLj;Jfpwhu;fs;.

,q;Nf ,lk;ngWk; kw;nwhUtuhd [{itgu; vd;gtUk; Kw;wpYk; gytPdkhdtu;. ,g;D [t;]P(u`;)mtu;fs; ',r;nra;jp rhpahdjy;y' vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. ]Mdp(u`;) mtu;fs; jdJ 'kt;@Mj;' vDk;E}ypy; ,ijg; gjpT nra;J> ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd milahsk; fhl;Lfpwhu;fs;.

NkYk; ,e;jr; nra;jp gy rhpahd `jP];fSf;Fk; Fu;Md; trdq;fSf;Fk; Kuz;gLfpwJ. jpUkiwapd;2:227> 232> 236> 237> 241> 33:49> 38:6> 65:1 Mfpa trdq;fs; jyhf; rk;ge;jkhd rl;lq;fis nrhy;tjpy;,Ue;Nj> jyhf; tplTk; nra;ayhk; vd;gJ njspthFk;.

,e;jr; nra;jp rpy egpj;Njhou;fspd; tho;f;ifiaAk; jtW vd;W nrhy;fpwJ. Mk;! egp(]y;) mtu;fshy;tsu;f;fg;gl;l i]j;(uyp) mtu;fs;> i]dg;(uyp) mtu;fis jpUkzk; nra;jpUe;J> gpd;du; jyhf;tpl;Ltpl;lhu;fs; vd;w rk;gtk; cs;sJ. NkYk; rpy egpj;Njhou;fs; jq;fs; kidtp jq;fSf;F cld;gl;Ltuhjjhy; tpthfuj;J nra;Js;sdu;. ,J cz;ik vd;W ,Uf;Fkhdhy; egpj;Njhou;fs; jyhf; nrhy;yp,Ug;ghu;fsh?

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

15 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 16: Weak hadiths in tamil

NkYk; jdf;Fg; gpbf;fhj my;yJ jd;idg; gpbf;fhj fztdplkpUe;J jd;id capUld; jw;fhj;Jf;nfhs;s ,e;j jyhf; cjtp nra;fpwJ. ngz;Zhpikia ,];yhk; toq;Ftijf; fz;l vhpr;rYw;w rpyfatu;fs; ,];yhKk; ngz;fis mbikg;gLj;jNt nra;fpwJ. mjdhy; jhd; tpthfuj;ij $lhJvd;fpwJ vd;W nrhy;tjw;fhfTk; $l ,e;jr; nra;jpia ,l;Lf;fl;bapUf;f Ntz;Lk;.

15. ,uz;lh? ehd;fh?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; [{k;Mtpw;F Kd; ehd;F uf;mj;Jk;> mjd; gpd; ehd;F uf;mj;Jk;> me;juf;mj;JfSf;fpilNa gphpf;fhky; (xNu ]yhKld;) njhOthu;fs;.''

,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,J ,g;Dkh[h tpy; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;fs;njhlhpy; ,lk;ngWk; Kg\;\pu; ,g;D igJ vd;gtu; ,l;Lf;fl;lf; $batu;. NkYk; `[;[h[; ,g;Dmu;jhj;> mjpa;ah my;$gP Mfpa ,UtUk; gytPdu;fs; vd iyy< mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpL fpwhu;fs;. vdNt ,JgytPdkhd `jP]hFk;.

',J jtwhd `jP];' vd ettP mtu;fSk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; ,e;j `jP]; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd`jP];fSf;F Kuz;glTk; nra;fpwJ vd;gjhYk; ,J gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;.

nghJthf [{k;Mtpw;F gs;spf;F tUgtu; ,khk; Fj;gh ciu epfo;j;jpf; nfhz;bUe;jhYk; ,uz;L uf;mj;njho Ntz;Lk;. [{k;M Kbe;jJk; gs;spapy; ,Ue;jhy; ehd;F uf;mj;Jk; tPl;bw;F clNd nrd;Wtpl;lhy;mq;Nf ,uz;L uf;mj;Jk; njho Ntz;Lk;. ,ijg; gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs;njspTgLj;Jfpd;wd.

[{k;M jpdj;jpy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ciu epfo;j;jpf; nfhz;bUe;j NghJ xU kdpju; gs;spf;Fs;Eioe;jhu;. ePu; njhOJ tpl;Buh? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfl;lhu;fs;. mtu; ,y;iy vd;whu;. ,uz;Luf;mj;fs; njhOtPuhf! vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; mthplk; $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij [hgpu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> jpu;kpjP> ,g;Dkh[h

'',khk; ciu epfo;j;jpf; nfhz;bUf;Fk;NghJ vtNuDk; te;jhy; RUf;fkhf mtu; ,uz;L uf;mj;fs;njho Ntz;Lk;'' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

''cq;fspy; xUtu; [{k;M njhOjhy; mjd;gpd; mtu; ehd;F uf;mj;fs; njhol;Lk;'' vd;W egp(]y;)mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;> e]aP> mg+jh¥j;>,g;Dkh[h

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; [{k;Mtpw;F gpwF tPl;bw;F nrd;W ,uz;L uf;mj;fs; njhOthu;fs; vd ,g;Dcku;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP

,e;j Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; mwptpf;Fk; nraYf;F khw;wkhfTk; NkNy $wpa ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp)mtu;fspd; `jP];(?) mike;Js;sijf; fhzyhk;.

16. cz;gjw;F Kd;Gk; gpd;Gk; x@?

''cztpy; guf;fj; (mgptpUj;jp) vd;gJ> mjw;F Kd; x@r; nra;tjpy; ,Uf;fpwJ '' vd jt;uhj;jpy;cs;sJ. ,ij ehd; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; $wpNdd;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> ''cz;gjpy; guf;fj;>mjw;F Kd;Gk; gpd;Gk; xSr; nra;tjpy; cs;sJ '' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.

,ij ]y;khd;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf jahyp]p mtu;fs; jdJ K];dj;jpy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.mg+jh¥j;> jpu;kpjP> `hfpk;> m`;kj; Mfpa E}y;fspYk; ,J cs;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; if]; ,g;D ugPc vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtu; vd;W mg+jh¥j;$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; topahfNt jtpu (NtW topfspy;) ,e;j `jPi] ehk; mwpatpy;iy. ,tu; `jP];Jiwapy; gytPdg; gLj;jg;gl;l tuhthu; vd;W jpu;kpjP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. j`gP> `hfpk; MfpNahUk;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

16 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 17: Weak hadiths in tamil

,f;fUj;ijNa Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. Kd;jpuP mtu;fs; ,tiu ''ey;ytu;'' vd;W $wpdhYk;> '',tu; kddrf;jpFiwe;jtu; jhd;'' vd;W Fwpg;gplj; jtwtpy;iy.

Ritj; ,g;D E/khd; (uyp) mtu;fs; ifgu; Aj;jk; ele;j tUlk; egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ifgUf;Fr;nrd;whu;fs;. ifgiu mLj;Js;s ]`;gh/ vd;w ,lj;ij mile;jJk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; m]u;njhOifiaj; njhOjhu;fs;. gpd;du; gaz czitf; nfhz;L tUkhW $wpdhu;fs;. mg;NghJ> khitj;jtpu NtW vJTk; nfhz;L tug;gltpy;iy. mijf; Fiof;Fk;gb fl;lisapl;lhu;fs;. mJFiof;fg;gl;lJk; mij egp(]y;) mtu;fSk;> ehq;fSk; rhg;gpl;Nlhk;. gpd;du; k/hpGj; njhOiff;fhfr;nrd;whu;fs;. mg;NghJ thia (kl;Lk;) nfhg;gspj;jhu;fs;. ehq;fSk; tha; nfhg;gspj;Njhk;. Gjpjhf xSr;nra;ahkNyNa njhOjhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

,e;j `jP];> vijAk; rhg;gpl;l gpd;G x@r; nra;aj; Njitapy;iy vd;W mwptpf;fpd;wd. Mdhy; ehk;NkNy Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s nra;jpNah> rhg;gpl;l gpd;G x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W $WfpwJ. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd`jP];fSf;F Kuzhf cs;sjpy; ,Ue;Nj mJ ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahfj; jhd; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;vd;w KbTf;F tuyhk;.

xl;lfj;jpd; ,iwr;rpia rhg;gpl;lhy; xS nra;a Ntz;Lkh? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk;Nfl;fg;gl;lNghJ> mjw;fhf xSr; nra;Aq;fs; vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;. Ml;L ,iwr;rpia rhg;gpl;lgpd;G x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lkh? vd;W Nfl;fg;gl;ljw;F mjw;fhf x@r; nra;a Ntz;lhk; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;vd guh ,g;D M]pg;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> jpu;kpjP> mg+jh¥j;> m`;kj;>,g;Dkh[h

x@Tld; rhg;gpLgtu; xl;lf ,iwr;rpia cz;lhy; kl;LNk x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W ,e;j `jP];mwptpf;fpd;wJ. kw;w czTfs; cz;gjhy; cz;l gpd;G x@r; nra;a Ntz;bajpy;iy vd;gijg;Ghpayhk;.

cz;gjw;F Kd; x@ mtrpak; vd;W ,Uf;Fkhdhy; cz;l gpd;G x@r; nra;aj; Njitapy;iy vd;Wjhd; KbTf;F tuNtz;Lk;. rhg;gpLk; Kd; nra;j x@ Kwpe;jhy; kl;LNk rhg;gpl;l gpd;G nra;jy; mtrpak;vd;W ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. vijAk; rhg;gpl;lhy; x@ KwpAk; vd;W ,Uf;Fkhdhy; cz;Zk; Kd; x@r;nra;a Ntz;bajpy;iy. ,J jhd; rhpahFk;.

rhg;gpl;lhy; x@ KwpAk; vd;W tUk;NghJ rhg;gpLk; Kd; x@r; nra;tJ vd;gJ mu;j;jkw;wjhfptpLfpd;wJ. mu;j;jkw;w nraiy egp(]y;) mtu;fs; nra;Ak;gb tw;GWj;jp ,Ug;ghu;fsh? vd;W Nahrpf;fNtz;Lk;. ,e;j mbg;gilapy; $l cz;Zk; Kd; x@r; nra;tjpy; guf;fj; cz;L vd;W $WtJ ngha;vd;W Ghpayhk;.

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Fspg;Gf; flikahd epiyapy; cz;zNth> cwq;fNth tpUk;gpdhy; x@r; nra;Jnfhs;thu;fs; vd Map\h(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;> e]aP

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Fspg;Gf; flikahd epiyapy; cwq;f tpUk;gpdhy; x@r; nra;J nfhs;thu;fs;.cz;zNth> gUfNth tpUk;gpdhy; jk; ,UiffisAk; fOtp tpl;Nl cz;ghu;fs; vd;W Map\h(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: m`;kj;> e]aP

,e;j `jP];fs; Fspg;Gf; flikahdtu; cz;z tpUk;gpdhy; iffis fOtpdhy; NghJk;. MdhYk;x@r; nra;tNj rpwg;G vd;W $Wfpd;wd. Fspg;Gf; flikahdtu; $l cz;Zk; Kd; x@r; nra;tJrpwg;G vd;W jhd; $wg;gLfpd;wJ.

vdNt> cz;gjw;F Kd;Dk;-gpd;Dk; x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W tUk; `jP]; rhpahdjy;y. mNj rkak;xl;lff; fwpia cz;l gpd;G x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lk;. Fspg;Gf; flikahdtu; cz;Zk; Kd; x@r; nra;Jnfhs;tJ rpwg;ghFk; vd;gJ kl;LNk egptop.

17. cSr; nra;j gpwF 97tJ mj;jpahak; XJjy;?

''x@r; nra;j gpwF ,d;dh md;]y;dhF.. vd;W Jtq;Fk; 97tJ mj;jpahak; XjNtz;Lk;.''

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

17 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 18: Weak hadiths in tamil

,g;gbg;gl;l nra;jp xd;W gutyhf egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; $w;whfg; Ngrg;gl;Lk;> ,ij nray;gLj;jg; gl;Lk;tUfpwJ. ,ij ]fhtP mtu;fs;> ve;j mbg;gilAkpy;yhj nra;jp ,J vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,J gpd;tUk;Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sJ.

cq;fspy; vtNuDk; x@r; nra;J Kbj;j gpd; ''m\;̀ J md;yhapyh` ,y;yy;yh`{ yh\uPf y`{tm\;̀ J md;d K`k;kjd; mg;J`{ tu#Y`{'' vd;W $wpdhy; Rtu;f;fj;jpd; vl;L thapy;fSk;mtUf;fhfj; jpwf;fg;gLfpd;wd vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf cf;gh ,g;D Mkpu;(uyp) mtu;fs;mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;F khw;wkhf ,J ,Ug;gjpy; ,Ue;Nj 97tJ mj;jpahaj;ij XjNtz;Lk;vd;gJ ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l gr;irg; ngha; vd;gij tpsq;fyhk;.

18. nts;spad;W...?

''[{k;M ehspy; xUtu; Nehd;G itj;jtuhfTk;> Nehahspia Neha; tprhhpj;jtuhfTk;> (grpj;j) Viof;Fcztspj;jt uhfTk;> [dh]hit gpd;gw;wpatuhfTk; ,Ue;jhy; mtiu ehw;gJ tUlq;fspd; Fw;wq;fs;milahJ.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; jdJmy;fhkpy; vDk; E}ypy; ghfk;-2> gf;fk;-122y; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,g;Dy; [t;]p mtu;fSk; jdJmy;kt;@Mj; vDk; E}ypy; ghfk;-2> gf;fk;-107y; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; fPo;f;fz;Nlhu; ,lk; ngWfpd;wdu;.

m) ,];khapy; ,g;D ,g;uh`Pk;

M) fyPy; ,g;D Ku;uh

,) mk;U ,g;D `k;]h my;g]uP

,tu;fs; rhpahdtu;fsy;yu;> gytPdu;fs; vd;W ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

''[{k;M ehspy; Nehd;ghspahf> Nehahspia tprhhpj;jtuhf> [dh]htpy; fye;J nfhz;ltuhf> VNjDk;ju;kk; nra;jtuhf xUtu; ,Ue;jhy; mtUf;F Rtu;f;fk; flikahf;fg;gl;L tpl;lJ.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ig`fPapy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ. ,jpYk; $l mg;Jy; m[P]; ,g;Dmg;Jy;yh my;cit]p> ,g;D Yi`M MfpNahu; ,lk; ngWtjhy; ,JTk; gytPdkhdjhFk;. mg;Jy;m[P]; mtu;fis j`gP mtu;fs; jdJ 'my;Ymghc' vDk; E}ypy; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

nghJthf Neha; tprhhpf;fNth> Viof;F cztspf;fNth> egpyhd Nehd;G Nehw;fNth> [dh]htpy;fye;J nfhz;L mijg; gpd; njhlu;e;J nry;tNjh khu;f;fj;jpy; mDkjpf;fg;gl;Lj; jhd; cs;sJ. ,jw;Fepiwa `jP];fspy; Mjhuk; cz;L. Fwpg;ghf ,e;j `jP];fs; cs;s tp\aq;fs; midj;ijAk; xNuehspy; nra;tjhy; Rtu;f;fk; cz;L vd;gij Mjhug;g+u;tkhd gpd;tUk; `jP]; njspTgLj;JfpwJ.

,d;W cq;fspy; Nehd;ghspahf ,Ug;gtu; ahu;? vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfl;lhu;fs;. mg+gf;fu;(uyp)mtu;fs;> ehd; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,d;W cq;fspy; Nehahspia tprhhpj;jtu; ahu;? vd;W egp(]y;)mtu;fs; Nfl;f> ehd; vd;W mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. ,d;W cq;fspy; [dh]htpy; fye;Jnfhz;ltu; ahu;? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfl;f> ehd; vd;W mg+gf;fu;(uyp) $wpdhu;fs;. ,d;W Viof;Fcztspj;jtu; ahu;? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfl;f> ehd; vd mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;.'xUthplk; xNu ehspy; ,e;j ew;nray;fs; Nru;e;jhy; mtu; Rtu;f;fj;jpy; EioahjpUg;gjpy;iy' vd;Wmg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;:K];ypk;

,e;j Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]py; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; nts;spahd ,d;W vd;W $wtpy;iy. ,e;jew;nray;fis vd;iwf;Fk; vtu; nra;jhYk; Rtu;f;fk; cz;L vd;gijNa ,e;j %yk; `jP]; tpsq;fKbfpwJ.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

18 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 19: Weak hadiths in tamil

',d;W' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpf; Nfl;l NghJ> md;W nts;spf;fpoikahf Vd; ,Uf;ff;$lhJ?vd;W rpyu; $wp> Nkw;fz;l gytPdkhd `jPi] '`]d;' vd;w me;j];jpw;F nfhz;L tu Kaw;rpf;fyhk;.Mdhy; md;W nts;sp jhd; vd;gjw;F mg+gf;fu;(uyp) rk;ge;jg;gl;l `jP]py; vt;tpjf; Fwpg;Gk; ,y;iy.md;W nts;sp jhd; vd;W $WNthuhYk; Mjhuj;ijf; fhl;l ,ayhJ.

NkYk;> nts;spad;W kl;Lk; Nehd;G itf;f nghJthfj; jilAk; cs;sJ.

''nts;spf;fpoikf;F Kd;dhNyh my;yJ gpd;dhNyh Nehd;G itg;gtu; jtpu kw;wtu; nts;spf;fpoikNehd;G Nehw;f Ntz;lhk;'' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> jpu;kpjP

,e;j tifapYk; $l Nkw;Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s nra;jp jtwhdJ vd;gJ njspthfpwJ.

19. '`a;a myy; /gyh`;' vd;W $Wk;NghJ...?

''`a;a myy; /gyh`; vd;W Kmj;jpd; $Wtijf; Nfl;lhy; my;yh`{k;k[;mydh K/g;yp̀ Pd (,iwth!vq;fis ntw;wpahsu;fshf Mf;fp itg;ghahf!)'' vd;W $wNtz;Lk;.

,ij KMtpah ,g;D mgP]{g;ahd;(uyp) mwptpf; fpwhu;fs;. ,ij ,g;D]{d;dp mtu;fs;> 'mkYy; at;kpty;iyyj;' vDk; jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; e];u; ,g;D juP/g; vd;gtuhy; ,J jtwhd nra;jpahfptpLfpwJ.',tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu;' vd e]aP mtu;fSk; kw;wtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;. '`jPi],l;Lf;fl;Ltjpy; gpugy;a khd egu;fspy; xUtu; jhd; ,tu;' vd a`;ah ,g;DKaPd; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,JNghy; ,jd; mwptpg;ghsy; ,lk; ngWk; mg;Jy;yh ,g;Dthfpj; vd;gtUk; Kw;wpYk; gytPduhFk;. ,tu;`jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd;Wk;> ,tu; gw;wpa ey;y fUj;ij vtUk; $wtpy;iy vd;Wk;,khk; GfhuP $Wfpwhu;. ,tu; rhpahdtu; my;yu; vd e]aP $Wfpwhu;fs;. [uPu; mtu;fs; ',tiu gytPdu;'vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

,J gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sJ.

my;yh`{ mf;gu; my;yh`{ mf;gu; vd;W Kmj;jpd; $Wk;NghJ> cq;fspy; xUtu; my;yh`{ mf;gu;my;yh`{ mf;gu; vd;Wk;> gpd;G m\;̀ J md;yhapyh` ,y;yy;yh`; vd;W $wpdhy;> m\;̀ Jmd;yhapyh` ,y;yy;yh`{ vd;Wk;> gpd;G m\;̀ J md;d K`k;kju; u#Yy;yh`{ vd;W (Kmj;jpd;)$Wk;NghJ m\;̀ J md;d K`k;kju; u#Yy;yh`; vd;Wk;> gpd;G `a;a my];]yhj; vd;W (Kmj;jpd;)$Wk;NghJ> yh `t;y tyh Ft;tj;j ,y;yh gpy;yh`; vd;Wk;> `a;a myy; /gyh`; vd;W $Wk;NghJ>yh `t;y tyh Ft;tj;j ,y;yh gpy;yh`; vd;Wk;> gpd;G my;yh`{ mf;gu; my;yh`{ mf;gu; vd;W$Wk;NghJ my;yh`{ mf;gu; my;yh`{ mf;gu; vd;Wk;> yhapyh` ,y;yy;yh`{ vd;W $Wk;NghJyhapyh` ,y;yy;yh`{ vd;Wk; (,itfis) kdjpw;Fs; $wpdhy; mtu; Rtu;f;fk; Eiothu; vdcku;(uyp) $wpdhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]py; 'yh `t;y tyh Ft;tj;j ,y;yh gpy;yh`;' vd;W jhd; '`a;a myy; /gyh`;'vd;W $wg;gLk;NghJ $wNtz;Lk; vd Fwpg;gplg;gLtjhy; Nkw;$wpa nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l xd;Nwvd;gij tpsq;fyhk;.

20. nts;spf;fpoik NjhWk;...

''xUtu; jd; ngw;Nwhu; ,UtuJ fg;iu my;yJ mt;tpUtu;fspy; xUtuJ fg;iu xt;nthU ([{k;M)nts;spf;fpoikfspYk; ]pahuj; nra;tjhy; mtuJ Fw;wq;fs; kd;dpf;fg;gLk;. ed;ik vOjg;gLk;.''

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,ij jg;uhdP mtu;fs; jdJ]fPu;> mt;]j; E}y;fspy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,e;j xU mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; kl;LNk mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf ,e;j `jP]; cs;sJ vd;W

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

19 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 20: Weak hadiths in tamil

jg;uhdP mtu;fs; Fwpg;gplTk; nra;fpwhu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ,lk;ngWk; a`;ah ,g;D my;myhc my;g[yP vd;gtu; `jP]; fiyapduhy;iftplg; gl;ltuhthu;.

,e;j a`;ah ngha;au; vd tfPc mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; ngha;au;; ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu; vd ,khk;m`;kj; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,tuJ gy mwptpg;Gfs; gytPdkhdJ vd;gJ njspthd jhFk;. NkYk; ,tu; %yk; tUk; `jP];fs;,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;litfNs vd;W ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

a`;ahTf;F ,r;nra;jpia mwptpj;j mg;Jy; fuPk; cika;ah mtu;fSk; gytPduhthu;. ,ij ,khk; Råj;jp$Wfpwhu;fs;.

mg;Jy; fuPk; mtu;fis gytPdu; vdf; $Wk; mNj rkak; ,e;j a`;ahit ,d;dhu; vd njhpatpy;iyvdTk; Råj;jp $Wfpwhu;fs;. Mdhy; Råj;jp mtu;fspd; ,f;$w;W rhpay;y!

fhuzk;> a`;ah vd;gJ ,d;dhu; vd;gJ Ge;jJ jhd;. mtu; ngha;au; vd;gJk; njspT.

,e;j `jP]pd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; cs;s FiwghL fshy; kl;Lk; Fiw fhztpy;iy. ,JMjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; $l khw;wkhfNt cs;sJ.

''fg;Ufis ]pahuj; nra;a ehd; jil nra;jpUe;Njd;. K`k;kJ (Mfpa ehd;) jd; jhahd; fg;iu]pahuj; nra;a mDkjpf;fg;gl;lhu;. vdNt ePq;fSk; ]pahuj; nra;Aq;fs;. (mJ) kWikiaepidTgLj;Jk;'' vd;W (]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf Giujh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;>jpu;kpjP

,e;j `jP]py; cs;s ]pahuj; nra;Aq;fs;> mJ kWikia epidTgLj;Jk; vd;w thu;j;ijiaftdpf;Fk;NghJ> (egp) mtu;fs; nghJthf ]pahuj; nra;Aq;fs; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fNs jtpu> Fwpg;gpl;lehspy; Fwpg;gpl;l Neuj;jpy; ]pahuj; nra;Aq;fs; vd;W $wtpy;iy vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

NkYk; ,e;j `jP]py; 'kWikia epidTgLj;Jk;'vd;Wk;> kw;nwhU `jP]py; 'kuzj;ij epidTgLj;Jk;'vd;W jhd; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fNs jtpu> 'ghtq;fs; kd;dpf;fg; gLk; ed;ikfs; vOjg;gLk;'vd;nwy;yhk; $wtpy;iy vd;gijAk; Ghpayhk;.

NtW Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fspy; ,Uf;fyhky;yth? vd;why; mJTk; ,y;iy. vdNt ,J,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP]hFk;.

21. mq;Nf ahrPd; mj;jpahak; Xjpdhy;...

''xUtu; jd; ngw;Nwhu; ,Utd; fg;iuAk; xt;nthU nts;spf;fpoikAk; ]pahuj; nra;J mt;tpUtUk;(mlf;fkhfp) cs;s ,lj;jpy; ahrPd; mj;jpahaj;ij Xjpdhy; me;j xt;nthU Maj;jpd; vz;zpf;ifmsTf;F my;yJ mjd; vOj;Jf;fspd; vz;zpf;if msTf;Ff; Fw;wq;fs; kd;dpf;fg;gLk;''

vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,ij ,g;DmjP> mg+eaPk; jq;fs;E}y;fspYk;> mg;Jy;fdP my; Kfj;j]{ mtu;fs; jdJ Rdd;-Yk; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;fspy; xUtuhd mk;U ,g;D ]pahuj; vd;gtu; rhpahdtuy;yu;; ',tu; `jP];fis,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu;' vd jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fSk; ,e;j `jPi](,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfs; vd;w ngaUila) jdJ 'my;kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

fg;iu nts;spf;fpoik ([{k;M) md;W ]pahuj; nra;jhy; Fw;wq;fs; kd;dpf;fg;gLk; vd;w thrfk;jtwhdNj vd;gij tpsq;fpNdhk;.

,e;j `jP]pNyh> ahrPd; Xjpdhy; vd;W cs;sJ. ,t;thW fg;U nrd;W ahrPd; XJtjw;FMjhug;g+u;tkhd ve;j xU `jP]{k; ,y;iy. khwhf fg;iu ]pahuj; nra;ar; nrd;why; rpy thrfq;fisnrhy;Yk;gb jhd; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpAs;shu;fs;. mjw;F gpd;tUk; `jP]; Mjhukhf cs;sJ.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

20 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 21: Weak hadiths in tamil

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kjPdhtpy; cs;s mlf;f];jyq;fis fle;J nrd;wNghJ mtw;iw Neuhf Nehf;fp>''m];]yhK miyf;Fk; ah m`;yy; Fg+u;> a/gpUy;yh`{ydh tyFk; md;Jk; ]yGdh tE`;Dgpy;m]u;'' vdf; $wpdhu;fs; vd;W Giujh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; mlf;fj;jyj;jpw;F te;J> ''m];]yhK miyf;Fk; jhu ft;kpd; K/kpdPd ,d;\hmy;yh`{ gpFKy; yh`p$d;'' vd;W $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;:K];ypk;> m`;kj;> e]aP

''m];]yhK miyf;Fk; m`;yj;jpahu; kpdy; K/kpdPd ty;K];ypkPd t,d;dh ,d;\h my;yh`{ gpFk;yyh`p$d;. e];mYy;yh`ydh tyFKy; M/gpaj;j'' vd;W $Wk;gb mlf;fj;jyq;fSf;Fnry;NthUf;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; fw;Wj; jUthu;fs; vd Giujh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;>m`;kj;> ,g;Dkh[h

,e;j ]`P̀ hd `jP];fSf;F khw;wkhf Nkw;$wpa `jP]; ahrPd; XJk;gb $WtjpypUe;J ,J,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP];(?) vdg; Ghpayhk;.

22. rigapy; ,Ue;J vOk;NghJ...

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; VjhtJ xU rigapy; ,Ue;J vOe;J tpl ehbdhy;> m];j/gpUy;yh`;(,iwtdplk;) kd;dpg;Gf; NfhUfpNwd;) vd;W 10 Kjy; 15 jlit $Wthu;fs;''

,ij mg+ckhkh(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpajhf g`;tP> ,g;D]d;dP> ,g;D mjP Nghd;Nwhu; jq;fsJ E}y;fspy;gjpT nra;Js;sdu;. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ,lk; ngWk; [/gu; rhpahdtuy;y vd;gjhy; ,e;jr;nra;jp gytPdkhd jhFk;. ,tu; ngha;au; vd;W \{/gh $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd;W ,khk; GfhuP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tuJ `jP];fs;gytPdkhdit vd;gJ njspthdJ vd;W ,g;D mjP mtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; rigapy; ,Ue;J vOk;NghJ 20 jlit m];j/gpUy;yh`; $Wgtu;fshf ,Ue;jdu;

vd;W mg;Jy;yh ,g;D eh]p̀ ; my;̀ s;ukP mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D]d;dP mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;.

,ij mwptpf;Fk; mg;Jy;yh ,g;D eh]p̀ ; mtu;fs; egpj;Njhou; my;y vd;W mg+eaPk; mtu;fs;Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j tifapy; ,r;nra;jp Ku;]yhFk;.

e];u; ,g;D Fi]kh vd;gtu; ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirj; njhlhpy; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tiug; gw;wpf;Fwpg;G VJk; fpilf;ftpy;iy vd;gjhYk; ,r;nra;jp gytPd khdjhFk;.

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; xU rigapypUe;J vOk;NghJ ,Wjp apy;> ]{g;̀ hdfy;yh`{k;k tgp̀ k;jpf m\;̀ Jmd; yhapyh` ,y;yh md;j;j m];j/gpUf;f tmJ}G ,iyf vd;W $Wgtu;fshf ,Ue;jdu;. mg;NghJxU kdpju;> my;yh`;tpd; J}jNu! ,jw;F Kd;G nrhy;yhj xU nrhw;nwhliu ePq;fs; $wpdPu;fNs! vdr;nrhy;y mJ me;j rigapy; epfo;e;jtw;wpw;F gfhukhfptpLfpwJ vdf; $wpdhu;fs; vd;W mg+gu;]h(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: mg+jh¥j;> `hfpk;

rigapy; ,Ue;J vOk;NghJ ,jidj;jhd; $w Ntz;Lk; vd;W njspthf egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpapUf;f,jw;F khw;wkhf NkNy Fwpg;gpl;l nra;jpfs; ,Ug;gjpy; ,Ue;Nj> mitfs; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfs; jhd;vd;gjpy; re;Njfkpy;iy.

23. njhOJ nfhz;Nl jhd; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lkh?

''xU mbahd; njhOifapy; ,Uf;Fk;NghJ ,iwtdpd; ,U fz;fSf;fpilNa ,Uf;fpwhd;. njhOifiaKbj;J jpUk;gpdhy; Mjkpd; kfNd! eP ahu; gf;fk; jpUk;Gfpwha;? vd;id tpl cdf;F rpwe;jtd; gf;fkh(jpUk;gp tpl;lha;) Mjkpd; kfNd! cd; njhOifapd; gf;fk; (kPz;Lk;) eP th! eP vtu; gf;fk;jpUk;GfpwhNah mtiu tpl ehd; cdf;Fr; rpwe;jtd;.''

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

21 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 22: Weak hadiths in tamil

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,r;nra;jpia cifyp mtu;fs;jd; 'mo;Om/gh' vd;w E}ypYk; g];]hu; mtu;fs; jdJ K];dj; tpYk; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; ,g;uh`Pk; ,g;D a]Pj; my;$gp vd;gtu; rhpahdtu; my;y vd;W,g;D KaPd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. `jP]; fiyapy; iftplg;gl;ltu; ,tu; vd m`;kj;> GfhuP> e]aP MfpNahu;$Wfpwhu;fs;.

,JNghd;w `jP];fis itj;Jj; jhd; rpyu; FLk;gj;ij kwe;J> cwit kwe;J> r%f tho;it kwe;Jrjh NeuKk; njhOfpNwhk; vd;w ngay; ,Ue;J Kw;wpYk; topnfl;Lg; Ngha; tpLfpd;wdu;. kiyapd;FiffspYk;> kuj;jbfspYk; jpahdk; vd;w ngay; topnfl;Lg; Nghdtu;fs; ,J Nghd;w `jP];fspd;ngauhy; cs;s nra;jpfis itj;Jj;jhd;.

egp(]y;) mtu;fsJ kidtpau; xUthplk; %d;W Ngu; te;J> egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; tzf;fk; gw;wp Nfl;Lmwpe;jJk;> ,dp ehd; J}q;fhky; tzf;fk; GhpNtd; vd xUtUk;> ehd; njhlu;e;J Nehd;G itg;Ngd; vdxUtUk;> ehd; jpUkzNk nra;a khl;Nld; vd xUtUk; $wpdu;. ,ij mwpe;j egp(]y;) mtu;fs;mk;%tiuAk; mioj;J> ehd; xU ehs; Nehd;G itj;J kWehs; tpl;L tpLfpNwd;. J}q;fTk; nra;fpNwd;.tzf;fKk; GhpfpNwd;> jpUkzKk; nra;Js;Nsd;; vd;W $wptpl;L ,it vd; topKiw. ,ijg;Gwf;fzpg;gtd; vd;idr; Nru;e;jtd; my;yd; vd;W $wpdhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;:GfhuP

egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ehq;fs; rpWgilAld; NghUf;Fr; nrd;Nwhk;. mg;NghJ jz;zPUk;> fPiufSk;tsu;e;jpUf;fpd;w xU Fif topNa nry;Yk;NghJ> 'ehd; ,t;Tyfj; njhlu;Gfis tpl;L Kw;wpYk; ePq;fp>me;jf; Fifapy; jq;fg; NghfpNwd;' vd jdf;Fj;jhNd xU kdpju; vz;zpf; nfhz;L> mjw;fhf egp(]y;)mtu;fsplk; mDkjp Nfl;lhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; åju;fisg; Nghd;Nwh> fpUj;jtu;fisg; Nghd;Nwh(kidtp> kf;fSld; thohky;) FiffspYk; Njthyaq;fspYk; jdpj;J jq;fp tpLkhW ehd; mDg;gpitf;fg;gltpy;iy. khwhf njspthd khu;f;fj;ijf; nfhz;L mDg;gg;gl;Ls;Nsd; vdf; $wp> egp(]y;)mtu;fs; mtUf;F kWg;Gj; njhptpj;Jtpl;ldu; vd;W mg+ckhkh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;:m`;kj;

njhlu;e;J njhOJ nfhz;Nl ,Ue;jhy; ,iwtdpd; md;G fpilf;Fk; vd;W vjpu;ghu;j;jhy; mJ kpfTk;jtwhFk;. Iq;fhyj; njhOifiaj; njhOtJ jhd; fl;lhaf; flikahFk;. cghpahd njhOiffisg;nghWj;jtiu ,ju flikfis epiwNtw;Wtjw;F ,ilåwhf ,y;yhj Neuj;jpy; jhd; cghptzf;fq;fs; nra;a Ntz;Lk;. cghp tzf;fq;fis nra;fpNwhk; vd;w ngay; kidtp kf;fSf;F nra;aNtz;ba flikfis Gwf;fzpf;fj; J}z;baJk; ,JNghd;w nra;jpfs; jhd;.

xNu xStpy; 40 tUlk; me;j ,khk; njhOjhu;> ,e;j ,khk; ,unty;yhk; epd;W nfhz;Nl Fu;Mid xNu,utpy; Xjp Kbj;jhu; vd;W fijfs; $wg;gl ,e;j nra;jp jhd; fhuzkhf mike;jJ.

vdNt> Nkw;$wpa mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;g jhf $wg;gLk; ,r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJvd;gNj cz;ikahFk;.

24. Rg;̀ {j; njhOifapy; 94 kw;Wk; 105 tJ mj;jpahaq;fis XJjy;?

''Rg;̀ {j; njhOifapy; myk; e\;u`;...vd;W Jtq;Fk; 94tJ mj;jpahaj;ijAk;> myk; juif/g...vd;W Jtq;Fk; 105tJ mj;jpahaj;ijAk; xUtd; Xjpdhy; mtd; e\;lkila khl;lhd;.''

,g;gbAk; xU nra;jpia egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf gutyhf $wg;gl;Lk;> nray;gLj;jg;gl;Lk; tUfpwJ.Mdhy; ]fhtP mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; 200k; gf;fj;jpy; ,J vt;tpj mbg;gilAkw;wJ vd;WFwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; ,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd gpd;tUk; `jP];fSf;Fk; khw;wkhfNt cs;sJ.

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Y`y;> 'ty;iyyp ,jh a`;\h' vd;W Jtq;Fk; 92tJ mj;jpahaj;ij XJthu;fs;.m]Yk; mJ Nghd;w #uhit XJthu;fs;. Rg;̀ py; mijtpl kpf ePz;l #uhf;fis XJthu;fs; vd[hgpu; ,g;D ]Kuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

22 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 23: Weak hadiths in tamil

g[;hpd; ,uz;L uf;mj;jpNyh my;yJ mjd; ,uz;bd; xd;wpNyh 60 Kjy; 100 trdq;fs; tiu XJthu;fs;vd mg+gu;]h(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk; (789)

,JNghd;w ,d;Dk; gy `jP];fspy; Rg;̀ {j; njhOifapy; Xjpa #uhf;fs; gw;wpf; Fwpg;gplg;gLfpwJ.Mdhy; 94tJ> 105tJ mj;jpahaq;fs; gw;wp $wg;glNtapy;iy.

Rg;̀ pd; gu;S jhd; mJ. ,e;j `jP]py; $wg;gl;lNjh g[;hpd; Rd;dj; njhOif gw;wpaJ vd;W $l rpyu;$wyhk;. Mdhy; me;j thjKk; itf;f ,ayhJ vd;gijg; gpd;tUk; `jP];fs; njspTgLj;JfpwJ.

g[;hpd; Rd;dj; njhOifapy; Kjy; uf;mj;jpy; gfuhtpd; '$Y} Mkd;dhgpy;yh`p tkh cd;rpy ,iydh'vd;w trdj;ijAk; ,uz;lhk; uf;mj;jpy; 'Mkd;dh gpy;yh`p t\;̀ j; gp md;dh K];yp%d;' vd;wtrdj;ijAk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Xjp te;jdu; vd ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf; fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; g[;hpd; Rd;dj;jpy; 'Fy;ah ma;A`y; fhgp&d> Fy;̀ {ty;yh`{ m`j;' Mfpamj;jpahaq;fis Xjp te;jdu; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> mg+jh¥j;>,g;Dkh[h> e]aP

Mjhug;g+u;tkhd ve;j `jP]pYk; 94> 105tJ mj;jpahaq; fisg; gw;wpf; $wg;glhjjhy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp,l;Lf; fl;lg;gl;lNj vd;gJ njspthFk;.

25. flypy; gazk; nra;ayhkh?

''`[; nra;gtu; my;yJ ck;uh nra;gtu; my;yJ ,iwtopapy; Nghu; Ggtu; MfpNahu; jtpu NtW vtUk;flypy; gazk; nra;af;$lhJ. Vndd;why; flypd; fPo;(euf) neUg;G cs;sJ.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D mk;U(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,J mg+jh¥j;E}ypy; cs;sJ. fjPg; mtu;fs; jdJ jy;fP]; E}ypYk;> ig`fP mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypYk; gjpTnra;Js;sdu;.

,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; G\;u; mg+mg;Jy;yh vd;gtUk; g\Pu; ,g;D K];ypk; vd;gtUk; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;fs; vd ,g;D`[u; mtu;fs; jdJ 'jf;uPg;' E}ypy; $Wfpwhu;fs;. 'kP]hd;' vDk; E}ypy; $lmt;thW jhd; Fwpg;gplg; gl;Ls;sJ.

NkYk; ,e;j `jP]py; ,o;jpuhy; cs;sJ. mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D mk;U(uyp) topahf g\Pu; mwptpg;gjhfTk;>mtu;fs; topahf mwptpf;fg;gLfpwJ vd jdf;F nra;jp fpilj;jJ vd;gjhfTk;> mtu;fs; topahf xUkdpju; mwptpg;gjhfTk; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; FsWgb cs;sJ. ,ij Kd;jpu; mtu;fs; jdJ'K];j]uP];]{dd;' vDk; jdJ E}ypy; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,e;j `jP]; rhpay;y vd;W GfhuP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ig`fP mtu;fSk; ,t;thNw $Wfpwhu;fs;.,g;Dy; Ky;fPd; mtu;fs; jdJ 'Fyhgh' E}ypy; midj;J ,khk;fSk; ,ij gytPdkhdJ vd;W$Wfpd;wdu; vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. fjhgP mtu;fs;> ,ij `jP]; fiy mwpQu;fs; ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;thpirfis gytPdg;gLj;jpAs;sdu; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. mg+jh¥j; mtu;fs; ,e;j (G\;u;> g\Pu;) ,UtUk;ahnud mwpag;glhjtu;fs; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;.

''`[; nra;gtu; my;yJ ck;uh nra;gtu; my;yJ ,iwtopapy; Nghu; Ggtu; jtpu (kw;wtu;) flypy; gazk;nra;af;$lhJ''

vd;w thrfk; kl;Lk; `h]; ,g;D myP c]hkh mtu;fspd; ]thapj; E}ypYk; cs;sJ.

,JTk; rhpahdjy;y. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; fyPy; ,g;D ]fa;ah vd;gtu;rhpahdtuy;yu; vd;gjhy; ,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahFk;.

,g;D mt;d;> `gPg; ,g;D \`Pj; Mfpa ,Utu; topahf ,tu; epiwa jtwhd `jP];fis mwptpj;Js;shu;vd ,g;D]; ]f;D $Wfpwhu;fs;.

ek;gfkhdtu;fs; topahf gy jtwhd `jP];fis mwptpg;gtu; ,tu; vd;W cifyP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu;`jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd jf;uPgpy; ,g;D `[u; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

23 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 24: Weak hadiths in tamil

Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;Fk; $l ,J khw;wkhf cs;sJ vd;gjhYk; ,J rhpahd nra;jpapy;iy.

''my;yh`;tpd; J}jNu! Fiwe;j msT jz;zPiu vLj;Jf; nfhz;L ehq;fs; flypy; gpuahzk;nra;fpNwhk;. ehq;fs; me;jj; jz;zPiu x@r; nra;ag; gad;gLj;jpdhy; jhfj;jhy; rpukg;gLNthk;. vdNtfly; ePuhy; x@r; nra;ayhkh?'' vd;W xU kdpju; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;lhu;. 'fly; ePu; Rj;jg;gLj;j Vw;wjhFk;. mjpy; nrj;jitfSk; (cz;z mDkjpf;fg; gl;ljhFk;)' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs;$wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.

E}y;fs;: m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> ,g;Dkh[h> jpu;kpjP> ,g;DFi]kh> ,g;D `pg;ghd;> `hfpk;>jhuFj;dP> ig`fP

tu;j;jf uPjpahd gpuahzq;fis egpj;Njhou; gyu; fg;gypy; Nkw;nfhz;Ls;sdu; vd;gjw;F ,d;Dk; gy`jP];fs; cs;sd. vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lNj!

26. cykhf;fis gpd;gw;wj;jhd; Ntz;Lk;!

''cykhf;fis gpd;gw;Wq;fs;; epr;rakhf mtu;fs; cyfj;jpd; xspahtu;. kWikapd; tpsf;Ffshtu;''

vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. 'K];dJy; gpu;jt;];' vDk; E}ypy;,khk; ijykP mtu;fSk;> 'my;[hkpc];]fPu;' vDk; E}ypy; Råj;jp mtu;fSk; ,e;j `jPi] gjpTnra;Js;sdu;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; fh]pk; ,g;D ,g;uh`pk; my;Ky;jP vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ',tu; ngha;au;'vd jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

NkYk; ,J jpUkiw trdq;fSf;Fk; Mjhug; g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sJ

(kdpju;fNs!) cq;fs; ,iwtdplkpUe;J cq;fSf;F ,wf;fg;gl;lijg; gpd;gw;Wq;fs;. mtidad;wp(NtnwtiuAk;) ghJfhtyu;(fshf;fpf; nfhz;L mtu;)fis gpd;gw;whjPu;fs;. ePq;fs; nrhw;gkhfNtey;Yzu;T ngWfpwPu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 7:3)

<khd; nfhz;ltu;fNs! ePq;fs; my;yh`;Tf;F topgLq;fs;. ,d;Dk; (,iwj;) J}jUf;Fk; fl;Lg;gLq;fs;.(kw;wtu;fisg; gpd;gw;wp) cq;fs; nray;fis ghohf;fp tplhjPu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 47:33)

,it my;yh`;tpd; tiuaiwahFk;. vtu; my;yh`;Tf; Fk;> mtd; J}jUf;Fk; fPo;g;gbe;J elf;fpwhNuhmtiu Rtdgjpfspy; gpuNtrpf;fr; nra;thd;. (my;Fu;Md; 4:15)

ahu; my;yh`;Tf;Fk;> (mtdJ) J}jUf;Fk; fPo;g;gbe;J elf;fpwhu;fNsh mtu;fs; my;yh`;tpd; mUisg;ngw;w egpkhu;fs;> ]pj;jpfPd;fs;> (rj;jpathd;fs;) capu; jpahfpfs;> ew;fUkq;fSilatu;fs;Mfpatu;fSld; ,Ug;ghu;fs;. ,tu;fs; jhk; kpf;f mofhd Njhou;fs; Mthu;fs;. my;Fu;Md; 4:69

cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; jt;uhj;jpd; xU gFjpia nfhz;L te;jhu;fs;. ,iwj;J}ju;mtu;fNs! ,J jt;uhj;jpd; xU gFjpahFk; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; NgrhjpUe;jhu;fs;.cku;(uyp) mtu;fNsh ,ijg; gbf;f Muk;gpj;jhu;fs;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; KfNkh (Nfhgj;jhy;) khwj;Jtq;fpaJ.

mg;NghJ mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fs; cd;id f\;lq;fs; milal;Lk;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Kfj;ijg;ghu;f;ftpy;iyah? vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; Kfj;ijg; ghu;j;j cku;(uyp) mtu;fs;>'my;yh`;Tila Nfhgj;ij tpl;Lk;> mtdpd; J}jd; Nfhgj;ij tpl;Lk; my;yh`;tplk; ghJ fhg;Gj;NjLfpNwd;. my;yh`;it ,iwtdhfTk;> ,];yhj;ij khu;f;fkhfTk;> K`k;kj;(]y;) mtu;fisegpahfTk; ehk; xg;Gf; nfhz;Nlhk;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.

mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> ',e;j K`k;kjpd; capiu ifapy; itj;jpUg;gtd; kPJ rj;jpakhf! %]h>cq;fspilNa te;J vd;id tpl;L tpl;L mtiu ePq;fs; gpd;gw;wpdhy;> ePq;fs; Neu;topia tpl;Lk; Ngha;tpLtPu;fs;. %]h (,t;Tyfpy;) capUld; ,Ue;jpUe;J> vd;id egpahf mtu; mile;jhy;> mtu; vd;idj;jhd; epr;rak; gpd;gw;wp ,Ug;ghu;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij [hgpu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: jhukP

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

24 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 25: Weak hadiths in tamil

NkYk; (ek;) J}ju; cq;fSf;F vijf; nfhLf;fpd;whNuh mij vLj;Jf; nfhs;Sq;fs;. ,d;Dk; vijtpl;Lk; cq;fis tpyf;Ffpd;whNuh mij tpl;Lk; tpyfpf; nfhs;Sq;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 59:7)

cq;fspilNa ,uz;il tpl;Lr; nry;fpNwd;. me;j ,uz;ilAk; gpd;gw;Wk; tiu top jtwNt khl;Bu;fs;.1) ,iwkiw Ntjk;> 2) vdJ topKiw vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. E}y;: my;Kmj;jh

Nkw;fz;l Fu;Md; trdq;fs;> egpnkhopfs; egp(]y;) mtu;fis gpd;gw;Wtjd; mtrpaj;ijtypAWj;Jfpd;wd. Mdhy; ,jw;F Neu; tpNuhjkhf cykhf;fis gpd;gw;Wq;fs; vd;W NkNy Fwpg;gpl;lnra;jp $Wfpd;wJ.

cykhf;fis gpd;gw;w Ntz;Lk; vd;W kl;Lk; $wg;gl tpy;iy. mtu;fs; 'cyf xsp> kWik tpsf;F'vd;W $wg;gL fpd;wJ. ,e;j thrfNk> cykhf;fshy; jhd; ,l;Lf; fl;lg;gl;bUf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;Wvz;zj; J}z;LfpwJ.

Fu;Md;-`jP]; mbg;gilapy; vtu; ve;jr; nra;jpia $wpdhYk; mij Vw;W elg;gJ jhd; xU K];ypkpd;Ntiy. $Wgtu; cykhthfj;jhd; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;W ve;j epge;jidAk; ,y;iy. $wg;gLk; nra;jpFu;MDf;Fk; `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhdjhf ,Ug;gpd; mijg; Gwf;fzpf;fTk; Ntz;Lk;. mijf; $wpatu;vt;tsT ngatuhf ,Ue;jhYk; rhpNa!

,J Nghd;w `jP];fisf; $wp 'vq;fisg; gpd;gw;Wq;fs;' vd;W ,tu;fs; $wpajhy; K];ypk;fs;cykhf;fs; nrhd;dhy; rhpahfj;jhd; ,Uf;Fk; vd;W vz;zj; jiyg;gl;L tpl;lhu;fs;.

,tu;fs; gytPdkhd `jPi]Ak; rl;lkhf;fyhk; vd;W vz;zpAs;sjhy; gytPdkhdJ vd;WRl;bf;fhl;bdhYk; Vw;gjpy;iy.

cykhf;fs; vd;w ngay; NghypfSk; ,];yhj;ijj; jtwhd Kiwapy; rpj;jhpf;Fk; egu;fSk; cz;L vd;WGhpe;J nfhz;lhYk; ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahfj;jhd; ,Uf;f KbAk; vd;w KbTf;F tuyhk;.

27. kpk;ghpy; ,khk; ,Uf;Fk; NghJ Ngryhkh?

''cq;fspy; xUtu; kpk;ghpy; ,khk; ,Uf;Fk; epiyapy; gs;spapDs; Eioe;jhy; ,khk; mjpypUe;J ,wq;Fk;tiu njhof;$lhJ; Ngrf;$lhJ.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,ij jg;uhdP mtu;fs;jd; fgPy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ma;åg; ,g;D Ei`f; vd;ghu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;.

,tiug; gw;wp vd; je;ij (mg+`hjk;) mtu;fs;> ,tu; `jP]; Jiwapy; gytPdkhdtu; vd;W $wf;Nfl;Ls;Nsd; vd;W ,g;D mgP̀ hjk; mtu;fs;> jdJ 'my;[u;c tj;j`;jPy;' E}ypy; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

,tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu;. ,tiu midtUk; gytPdu; vd;fpd;wdu; vd jd;>'my;k[;kc'tpy; ,khk; i`jkP Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

,e;j `jP]; gytPdkhdJ vd;W ,khk; ,g;D `[u; mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

''[{k;M ehsd;W njhOiff;fhf ,khk; te;J tpl;lhy; NgRtij tpl;LtplNtz;Lk;.''

,e;jf; fUj;jpy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jpig`fPapy; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ. ,JTk; gytPdkhdJ jhd;.

Mjhug;g+u;tkhd gpd;tUk; `jP];fSf;Fk; ,J Kuz;ghlhf cs;sJ.

,khk; ciu epfo;j;jpf; nfhz;bUf;Fk;NghJ cq;fspy; vtNuDk; te;jhy; mtu; RUf;fkhf ,uz;Luf;mj;fs; njho Ntz;Lk; vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd; whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

[{k;M ehsd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ciu epfo;j;Jk; NghJ xUtu; gs;spf;Fs; Eioe;jhu;. ePu; njhOJtpl;Buh? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfl;lhu;fs;. mtu; ,y;iy vd;W $wpdhu;. ,uz;L uf;mj;fs;njhOtPuhf! vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; mthplk; $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij [hgpu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;:

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

25 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 26: Weak hadiths in tamil

GfhuP> K];ypk;> m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> jpu;kpjP> ,g;Dkh[h

,khk; kpk;ghpy; cl;fhu;e;J ,Uf;Fk;NghJ kl;Lkpd;wp> ciu epfo;j;Jk;NghJ $l njhoyhk; vd;WMjhug;g+u;tkhd ,e;j `jP]; $Wfpd;wJ. ,jw;F khw;wkhf Nkw;Fwpg;gpl;l `jP]; cs;sJ vd;gijg;Ghpayhk;.

'njhof;$lhJ' vd;gjw;F> njhoyhk; vd;W Mjhug; g+u;tkhd `jP]; %yk; $wpdhYk; Ngrf;$lhJvd;gJ rhp jhNd; mjw;F gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; Mjhukhf cs;sjy;yth!

'[{k;M ehsd;W ,khk; Fj;gh elj;Jk; Ntisapy; (NgRk;) ckJ Njhoiu NgrhNj vd;W eP $wpdhy;>ePAk; jtwpioj;J tpl;lha;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf GfhuP> K];ypkpy; cs;s `jP];gb'Ngrf;$lhJ' vd;w thrfk; rhpahdJ jhd; vd;W rpyu; $wyhk;.

xU `jP]; gytPdkhdJ vd;W $Wk;NghJ me;j `jP]pd; kw;nwhU thrfk; rhp vd;W $WtJ rhpay;ymJ kl;Lky;y me;j `jP]py; kpk;ghpy; ,Uf;Fk;NghNj NgRtij tpl Ntz;Lk; vd;W $wg;gLfpwJ.Mdhy; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]pNyh ,khk; Fj;gh elj;Jk; Ntisapy; vd;W $wg;gLfpwJ. vdNt ,khk;Fj;gh elj;Jk;NghJ jhd; Ngrf;$lhJ. ,jw;F gpd;tUk; cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; fhyj;jpy; ele;jepfo;r;rpAk; rhd;whf cs;sJ.

''cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; kpk;ghpy; mku;e;jpUf;Fk;NghJ ghq;F $Wgtu; jd; ghq;if epWj;Jk;tiu kf;fs;Ngrpf; nfhz;bUg;ghu;fs;. kpk;ghpy; (cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; vOe;J epd;Wtpl;lhNyh mtu;fs; jdJ ,uz;LFj;ghf;fisAk; Kbf;Fk; tiu kf;fs; Ngrkhl;lhu;fs;.'' ,ij j/ygh ,g;D mgPkhypf; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.E}y;: my;Kmj;jh

vdNt Nkw;fz;l `jP]; gytPdkhdjhFk;.

28. tpgr;rhuf; Foe;ijfs;

''tpgr;rhuj;jpd; %yk; gpwe;j Foe;ijfs; kWikapy; Fuq;Ffs;> gd;wpfs; cUtpy; (vOg;gp) xd;W Nru;f;fg;gLthu;fs;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mk;U(uyp) mwptpj;jhu;fs;. ,r;nra;jpia cifyP mtu;fs;jdJ my; 'Ymgh/' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,jpy; ,lk; ngWk; i]J ,g;D ,aho; vd;gtu;rhpahdtuy;y ,tiug; gw;wp gpd;tUk; nra;jp> ,tiu gytPdu; vd milahsk; fhl;LfpwJ.

xUtu; xU `jPi] ma;åg; mtu;fsplk; $wpdhu;. mij epuhfj;j ma;åg; mtu;fs;> ,r;nra;jpia cdf;F$wpatu; ahu;? vd;W Nfl;lhu;. K`k;kJ ,g;D th]pc (jhd; mwptpj;jhu;) vd;W mtu; gjpy; $wpdhu;.tpL mtu; rhpahdtNu. mLj;J vtu; %yk; mwptpj;jPu;? vd;W ma;åg; mtu;fs; Nfl;ljw;F> i[J ,g;D,aho; vd;W $wpdhu;. eP (K`k;kJ ,g;D th]pc tiu epWj;jpf; nfhz;L mjw;F Nky; i[J ,g;D,ahioAk; $wp) mjpfg;gLj;jhNj! vd;W ma;åg; mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd ]yhk; ,g;D mgP KjP,vd;gtu; $Wfpd;whu;.

vdNt i[J ,g;D ,aho; gytPdu; vd;gjhYk; ,J gytPdkhd `jP]hfpwJ. NkYk; ,jpy; ,lk;ngWk;<]h ,g;D Fj;jhDy; Uf;fh\p vd;gtUk; rhpahdtuy;y ,tiu ,g;D `pg;ghd; Nghd;Nwhu; rhpfz;lhYk;> ,td; `jPi] Mjhukhf vLj;Jf; nfhs;sf;$lhJ vd;W ,g;D mg;Jy;gu; mtu;fs;<]hitg; gw;wp Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

,e;j `jPi] jdJ 'my;kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy; ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fs; vOjptpl;L> ',J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ. vt;tpj mbg;gilAkw;wJ' vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. Råj;jp mtu;fSk; mijNa jdJ E}ypy;vOJfpwhu;fs;.

,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd jpUkiw trdq;fSf;Fk; khWgl;Ls;sJ.

vtd; topNfl;by; nry;fpd;whNdh mtd; jdf;Nf NfL nra;J nfhz;lhd;. ve;j Mj;khtpd; ghtr;RikiaAk; NtnwhU Mj;kh Rkf;fhJ. (my;Fu;Md; 17:15)

(kWik ehspy; jd; Rikiaj; jtpu) xU Mj;kh kw;nwhU Mj;khtpd; Rikia Rkf;fkhJ. fbdkhd

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

26 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 27: Weak hadiths in tamil

Rikiar; Rkf;Fk; Mj;kh mijr; Rkf;f (kw;nwhd;iw) mioj;jhy; mJ neUq;fpa cwtpduhf,Ue;jhYk; mjpypUf;Fk; vijAk; Rkf;fg;glhJ. (my;Fu;Md; 35:18)

mNj fUj;jpNyNa 37:7> 53:38 trdq;fSk; mwptpf;fpd;wJ. ,t;trdq;fs;> vtd; ghtr;RikiaAk; vtUk;mJTk; mtu; vt;tsT neUq;fpa cwtpdu;fshf ,Ug;gpDk; Rkf;f khl;lhu;fs; vd;W njspthfmwptpf;fpd;wd.

ngw;Nwhu; nra;j Fw;wj;jpw;fhf ngw;nwLf;fg;gl;l Foe;ijfs; Fw;wthspfshf;fg;gl;L Fuq;Ffshf>gd;wpfshf khw;wg;gLtu; vd;W $WtJ; NkNy ehk; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s trdq;fSf;F Kuz;ghlhfNt mikAk;.

vdNt jpUkiwapd; trdq;fSf;F Kuz;ghlhf egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpapUf;fkhl;lhu;fs; vd;W KbTnra;J> ,ij gytPdkhdJ> Vd;? ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;Nw $wyhk;.

29. egp(]y;) mtu;fis Nehpy; fhz Ntz;Lkh?

''xUtu; [{k;M ,utpy; Fspj;J ,uz;L uf;mj; njhOJ me;j ,uz;L uf;mj;fspYk; 'Fy;̀ {ty;yh`{m`j;..' (112tJ mj;jpahak;) vd;w #uhit 1000 jlit Xjp njhOJtpl;L gpd;G J}q;fpdhy; egp(]y;)mtu;fisf; fhz;ghu;.''

,r;nra;jpia ,g;D\p`hg; mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;Dy; [t;]p mtu;fs; jdJ 'my;kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy;gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;s K`k;kJ ,g;D cfh\h vd;gtu; gpd;tUkhW NkYk;$Wfpwhu;.

xt;nthU [{k;M ,uTk; ehd; Fspj;J> ,uz;L uf;mj;fs; njhONtd;. egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy;fhz Ntz;Lk; vd;W #uhit XjpNdd;. Vwj;jho ,uz;L tUlk; ,t;thW nra;Njd;. xU ehs; Fspuhd,uT md;W ehd; Fspj;Jtpl;L> 'Fy;̀ {ty;yh`{ m`J' vDk; #uhit 1000 jlit Xjp ,uz;Luf;mj; njhONjd;; gpd;G gLj;Jtpl;Nld;. vdf;F ];fypjk; Vw;gl;lJ. ,uz;lhk; Kiwahf vOe;JFspj;Njd;. Fy;̀ {ty;yh`{ #uhit 1000 jlit Xjp ,uz;L uf;mj; njhONjd;. ]`u; Neuk; te;jepiyapy; me;j ,uz;L uf;mj;fisAk; Kbj;J tpl;L ehd; Rtw;wpy; rha;e;jpUe;Njd;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;)mtu;fs; vd;dplk; te;jhu;fs;. mtu;fs; kPJ ,uz;L Nghu;it ,Ue;jJ.

NkYk;> K`k;kJ (,g;D cfh\h)Nt! my;yh`; ckf;F MAis ePl;b itg;ghdhf vd;W egp(]y;) $wpvd;id (tho;j;Jtjpy;) Ke;jpf; nfhz;lhu;fs;.

,JTk; ,g;Dy; [t;]p mtu;fspd; my;kt;@Mj; vDk; E}ypy; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ.

,r;nra;jpia mwptpf;Fk; ,g;D cfh\h ngUk; ngha;ad; vd;gjhy; ,r;nra;jpAk;> NkNy Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s,g;D \p̀ hg; mtu;fsJ ngauhy; mwptpf;fg;gLk; nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,td; ,lk;ngWtjhy; mr;nra;jpAk; 'ngha;> ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;gij Ghpayhk;. ,td; ngha;ad;' vd jhuFj;dPmtu;fSk; $Wfpwhhf;s;.

NkYk; ,r;nra;jp Fu;MDk;> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{k; $Wk; Kf;fpakhd epfo;Tf;F khw;wkhfTk;cs;sJ. Mk;! kdpj tho;tpy; gpwg;G vg;gb cz;ikNah mJ Nghy; ,wg;G vDk; epfo;T cz;L.

ePq;fs; vq;fpUe;j NghjpYk; cq;fis kuzk; mile;Nj jPUk;. ePq;fs; kpfTk; cWjpahff; fl;lg;gl;lNfhl;ilapy; ,Ue;j NghjpYk; rhpNa. (my;Fu;Md; 4:78)

,t;trdk; kdpjDf;F fz;bg;ghf kuzk; cz;L vd;gijj; njspthfNt mwptpf;fpwJ. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;lnra;jpNah egp(]y;) mtu;fis md;Wk; capUld; cs;sdu; vd;w fUj;ijj; njhptpf;fpd;wJ. egp(]y;)mtu;fSk; $l kuzpg;gtu;fs; jhd; vd;gij gpd;tUk; trdk; njspthfNt $WfpwJ.

epr;rakhf ePUk; kuzpg;gtNu; epr;rakhf mtu;fSk; kuzpg;gtu;fNs! (my;Fu;Md; 39:30)

NkYk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kuzpj;Jtpl;lhu;fs;. Mdhy; kf;fNsh> cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; cl;gl egp(]y;)

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

27 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 28: Weak hadiths in tamil

mtu;fs; ,wf;ftpy;iy vd;W $wpf; nfhz;bUe;jdu;. mq;Nf te;j mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fs; egp(]y;)mtu;fspd; Kfj;ij jpwe;J> new;wpapy; Kj;jkpl;L tpl;L> egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,we;Jtpl;l nra;jpia kpk;ghpy;Vwp kf;fsplk; njhptpf;fpwhu;fs;. mg;NghJ mtu;fs;> ''xUtd; my;yh`;it tzq;fp ,Ue;jhy; my;yh`;jhd; capUld; ,Ug;gtd;. mtd; kuzpg;gjpy;iy. K`k;kJ(]y;) mtu;fs; tzq;fp ,Ue;jhy; mtu;fs;,we;Jtpl;lhu;fs;'' vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,e;jf; fUj;jpy; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; GfhuP> e]aP>,g;Dkh[h> ig`fP> m`;kj; Mfpa E}y;fspy; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ.

,q;Nf mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fspd; mwpTiuia ftdj;jpy; nfhs;s Ntz;Lk;. xUtid tzq;Ftjhf,Ue;jhy; mtd; ,wg;nga;ahjtdhf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. mjhtJ flTs; kl;LNk ,wg;ig milahjtd;.egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> kdpjNu! mtu;fSf;F kuzk; cz;L. mtu;fs; jw;NghJ kuzpj;J tpl;lhu;fs; vd;wfUj;ijj; jhd; mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fspd; $w;W tpsf;FfpwJ.

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kuzpj;Jtpl;lhu;fs; vd;gJ cz;ik vdj; njhpAk;NghJ> kuzj;ij jOtpa mtu;fs;vg;gb Nehpy; tUthu;fs;? mJTk; ngha;ia ek;gr; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;w ce;Jjypy;> Nghu;it mzpe;Jte;jhu;fs; vd;Wk; ngha; $wg;gl;Ls;sJ.

vdNt kuzpj;jtu; tug;Nghtjpy;iy. tuKbahj epiyapy; cs;s xUtiu tUthu;fs; vd;W $WtJrhpay;y. ,J Fu;MDf;Fk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sJ vd;gjhy; ,r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ jhd; vd ve;j xU K];ypKk; KbTf;F tuNtz;Lk;.

30. egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; fhz Ntz;Lkh?

''xU %kpd; nts;spf;fpoik ,uT ,uz;L uf;mj; njhOJ mjpy; xt;nthU uf;mj;jpYk;Fy;̀ {ty;yh`{... #uhit 25 jlit Xjptpl;L> gpd;G ]yhk; nfhLj;Jtpl;L ']y;yy;yh`{ myhK`k;kjpd; egpa;apy; ck;kpa;ap' vd;W Mapuk; jlit $wpdhy; md;iwa ,utpy; fdtpy; vd;id epr;rakhffhz;ghd;. kWthuk; nts;sp tUk; Kd; fdtpy; vd;idf; fhz;ghd;. vd;id xU thuk; ghu;j;Jtpl;lhy;my;yh`; mtdJ Fw;wq;fis kd;dpf;fpwhd;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;Fk; xU nra;jpia ,g;Dy; [t;]Pmtu;fs; jdJ 'my;kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;fs; mwpKfkw;w gyu; ,lk; ngWtjpypUe;Nj ,JgytPdkhd nra;jp jhd; vd;gJ GydhFk;.

egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; ehk; fhz KbAkh? fhz KbAk; vd;gjw;F rpyu; fPo;f;fz;l `jP];fisMjhukhf itf;fpd;wdu;.

''ahu; vd;id fdtpy; fhz;fpwhNuh mtu; vd;idNa fz;lhu;. Vnddpy; i\j;jhd; vd; tbtpy;tukhl;lhd;'' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP>K];ypk;

ahu; vd;idf; fhz;fpwhNdh mtd; cz;ikiaNa fz;lhd; vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf mg+fjhjh(uyp)mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> m`;kj;

,e;j `jP];fs; NknyOe;j thahfg; ghu;f;Fk; NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; fhz KbAk; vd;Wnjhpe;jhYk;> cz;ikapy; egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; fhz Ntz;Lkhdhy; mtu;fs; capUld; ,Uf;Fk;NghJ fdtpy; fhz;gtu; egp(]y;) mtu;fisj; jhd; fz;L nfhz;lhu; vd;Wk; my;yJ ,Jtiu Nehpy;fhzhjtu;> fdtpd; %yk; fz;lhy; ,dp NeYk; fhz;ghu; vd;Wk; jhd; KbTf;F tuNtz;Lk;. ',e;jKbT jhd; Nkw;nfhs;s Ntz;Lk;' vd;gij gpd;tUk; `jP]; njspTgLj;JfpwJ.

'ahu; vd;id fdtpy; fhz;fpwhNuh mtu; (NeYk;) tpopg;gpYk; vd;idf; fhz;ghu;. Vndd;why; i\j;jhd;vd; tbtj;jpy; tukhl;lhd;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

fdtpy; fz;lhy; NeYk; fhz;ghu; vd;why;> Nehpy; fhz;gJ mtu;fs; capUld; cs;s fhyj;jpNyNa

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

28 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 29: Weak hadiths in tamil

nghUe;Jk;. njspthd Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; %yk; mtu;fs; capUld; trpf;fhj fhyj;jpy; cs;sek;ikg; Nghd;wtu;fshy; egp(]y;) mtu;fisf; fhz KbahJ vd;gJ njspthfpwJ.

,e;j Mjhug;g+u;tkhd epiyf;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sjhYk; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ jhd;vd;gJ GhpAk;.

31. Nfhgk; Vw;gl;lhy;...?

''epr;rakhf Nfhgk; (nfhs;tJ vd;gJ) i\j;jhd; (Fzq;fspy;) epd;WKs;sjhFk;. epr;rakhfi\j;jhd; neUg;gpy; ,Ue;Nj gilf;fg;gl;Ls;shd;. jz;zPuhy; jhd; neUg;G mizAk;. vdNt cq;fspy;xUtUf;F Nfhgk; Vw;gl;lhy; x@r; nra;J nfhs;sl;Lk;.''

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf $wg;gLk; ,r;nra;jp m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;> ,g;D m]hfPu; Mfpa E}y;fspYk;GfhuP mtu;fspd; jh`; E}ypYk; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhj ,Utu; ,lk;ngWfpd;wdu;. vdNt ,J rhpapy;yhj`jP]hFk;. ,J Nghd;Nw kw;nwhU nra;jp KMtpah(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf tUfpwJ.

''Nfhgk; i\j;jhdpd; epd;WKs;sjhFk;. i\j;jhd; neUg;gpyhdtd;. jz;zPu; jhd; neUg;igmizf;Fk;. vdNt cq;fspy; vtUf;NfDk; Nfhgk; te;jhy; mtu; Fspf;fl;Lk;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wp> jhd; Nfl;ljhf KMtpah(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;jjhf mg+eaPk;> ,g;Dm]hfPu; MfpNahu; jq;fspd; E}y;fspy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ahrPd; ,g;D mg;Jy;yh ,g;D cu;th ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tiug; gw;wpmwpKfk; VJk; ,y;iy. mg;Jy; k[Pj; ,g;D mg;Jy; m[P]; vd;gtUk; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. mtiug; gw;wp,g;D `[u; mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLk; NghJ> ',tu; cz;ikahsu; jhd;. vdpDk; jtW nra;gtu; vdf;$Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg; gl;ltu;' vd;W ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. vdNt,r;nra;jpAk; $l rhpaw;wjhFk;.

mg;gbahdhy; 'Nfhgk; nfhs;syhkh?' vd;W rpyUf;F vz;zj; Njhd;Wk;. mJ rhpay;y. Nfhgk;nfhs;tjpy; jtwpy;iy vd;w fUj;jpy; ,r;nra;jpia tpku;rpf;ftpy;iy. Nfhgk; nfhs;sf;$lhJ vd;gjw;Fgpd;tUk; Mjhug; g+u;tkhd gy `jP];fs; cz;L.

vdf;F Nghjid nra;Aq;fs; vd;W xU kdpju; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;lNghJ> Nfhgk; nfhs;shNj!vd;wdu;. gy Kiw mtu; Nfl;lNghJk;> 'Nfhgk; nfhs;shNj' vd;Nw $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP

jhf;Fk; jpwd; mbg;gilapy; tPuid vil Nghlg;gL tjpy;iy. tPud; vd;gtd; Nfhgj;jpd; NghJ jd;idf;fl;Lg;gLj;jpf; nfhs;gtNd vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;.E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

Nfhgj;ij jtpu;f;f Ntz;Lk; vd;gij Mjhug; g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; mwptpg;gjhy; Nfhgj;ij iftplNtz;Lk;. mNj rkak; Nfhgj;ij iftplf; $Wk; topKiw jhd; rhpay;y vd;gNj ,q;Nftpku;rpf;fg;gLfpwJ.

Nfhgk; Vw;gl;lhy; x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk; Fspf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk; $wg;gl;L tUk; nra;jpfs;rhpay;y vd;gNj ,q;Nf ftdpf;fg;gl Ntz;ba epiy. Nfhgk; Vw;gl;lhy; vd;d nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;gijgpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jp tpsf;FfpwJ.

''xUtu; epd;W nfhz;bUf;Fk;NghJ Nfhgk; te;jhy; cl;fhu;e;J tpll;Lk;> Nfhgk; Ngha;tpl;lhy; r.,y;iyNay; gLj;Jtpll;Lk;'' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ju;(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;:m`;kj;> jpu;kpjP

vdNt> NkNy Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s x@ my;yJ Fspf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;w fUj;jpy; cs;s nra;jpfs; `jP];fs;my;y `jP];fs; ngauhy; jpzpf;fg;gl;litNa.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

29 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 30: Weak hadiths in tamil

32. kiof;fhyq;fspy; jhd; kdpjdpd; cs;sk;...?

''kdpjdpd; cs;sq;fs; kiof;fhyq;fspy; jhd; kpUJthf MFk;. Vnddpy; (Kjy; kdpjuhd) Mjk;(miy) mtu;fis kz;zpypUe;J jhd; my;yh`; gilj;jhd;. kz;> kiof;fhyj;jpy; jhd; kpUJthf,Uf;Fk;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf KMj; ,g;D [gy; (uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs; vd mg+eaPk;mtu;fs; jdJ 'my;̀ {ah' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; cku; ,g;D a`;ah vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy;iftplg;gl;ltu;. ,g;D`[u; mtu;fs; ,tiug; gw;wp Fwpg;gpLk; NghJ ,e;j mk;U ,g;D a`;ah vd;gtu;cku; ,g;D a`;ah ,g;D cku; ,g;D mgP]y;kh ,g;D mg;Ju; u`;khd; ,g;D mt;G vd;gtuhfj;jhd;,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. ,tiu jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; gytPdg;gLj;jpf; $Wfpd;wdu; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;.

NkYk; ,J mwpTf;Nf Vw;Wf; nfhs;shj tp\akhFk;. rhjhuz epiyapy; cs;std; $l ,J ngha;.,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ jhd; vd;W tpsq;fp tpLthd;. ,];yhk; mwpthu;e;j khu;f;fk; vd;w $w;iw ngha;g;gLj;jvz;zpatd; jhd; ,ij ,l;Lf;fl;b ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;gjpy; Iakpy;iy.

33. mugp nkhop NgRgtd; /ghu;]p nkhop Ngrf;$lhJ?

''cq;fspy; vtNuDk; mugpapy; mofhf Ngrpdhy; mtu; ghu;]p nkhopapy; Ngrpl Ntz;lhk;. kPwp Ngrpdhy;mJ eatQ;rfj; jd;ikia Vw;gLj;jptpLk;.''

,g;D cku;(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf ,r;nra;jp `hfpkpy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. ,jd; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu;cku; ,g;D `h&d; vd;gtu; rhpahdtuy;y! ,tiu ,g;D KaPd; gytPdu; vd;W $WtjhfTk;> ,ju`jP]; fiyapdu; ,tiu iftpl;L tpl;ljhfTk; j`gP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

mugp nkhop kPJ Nkhfk; nfhz;L> mNj rkak; /ghu;]p nkhopapy; Nfhgk; nfhz;ltdhy; jhd; ,r;nra;jp,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;bUf;f Ntz;Lk;.

jw;NghJ vg;gb jkpo; nkhop kPJ gw;W nfhz;L ,e;jp nkhop NgRgtd; kPJ ntWg;Gld; rpyu; cs;sdNuh>mJ Nghy; mugp nkhop kPJ Nkhfj;Jld; ,Ue;j xU $l;lk; jhd; ,r;nra;jpia ,l;Lf; fl;bf; $wpapUf;fNtz;Lk; vd;gjpy; re;NjfNk ,y;iy.

34. gl;L nkj;ijapy; mkuyhkh?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; gl;L tphpg;gpy; mku;e;jpUe;jdu;.''

,ij i]y< mtu;fs; jd; E}yhd 'e];Gu; u/ah'tpy; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. `dgP kj;̀ G E}yhd'`pjhah'tpYk; $l ,JNghd;Nw $wg;gl;Ls;sJ. gl;L tphpg;gpy; mkuyhk; vd `dgP kj;̀ G $wTk;nra;fpwJ. Mdhy; ve;j mbg;gilAkw;w nra;jpahFk; ,J.

,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhfj; jhd; cs;sJ.

jq;fk;> nts;sp ghj;jpuq;fspy; cz;gijAk;> Fbg;gijAk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vq;fSf;Fj; jiltpjpj;jpUe;jdu;. gl;L Mil mzptijAk;> mjd; Nky; mku;tijAk; jil nra;jpUe;jdu; vd`{ij/gh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP

gl;L Milapy; mku;tij jil nra;Js;sjhf tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;F khw;wkhfNt ,r;nra;jpmike;Js;sJ. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kl;LNk jdpNa rYif mspf;fg;gl;L ,Ue;jdu; vd;W vtNuDk;$wpdhy; mjw;Fk; Mjhuk; fhl;lNtz;Lk;.

egptopf;F khw;wkhfj; jhd; kj;̀ Gfs; cs;sd vd;gjw;F ,e;j gl;L tphpg;gpy; mkuyhk; vd;w `dgP

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

30 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 31: Weak hadiths in tamil

kj;̀ gpd; $w;W> rhd;whf cs;sJ.

gl;L nkj;ijapNyh> tphpg;gpNyh mkuyhk; vd;w fUj;jpy; cs;s Nkw;fz;l nra;jp vt;tpj mbg;gilAkw;wnra;jpAkhFk;.

35. ,fhkj; thrfk; xU jlit kl;Lk; $wpdhy; Fw;wkh?

'',fhkj; thrfj;ij xw;iwahf xUtu; $wpdhy; mtu; vd;idr; rhu;e;jty;iy.''

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;w ,r;nra;jpia ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P(u`;)mtu;fs; jdJ kt;@Mj; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,uz;lhk; mwptpg;ghs uhf o`;̀ hf; ,g;D k]h`pk; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;.%d;whk; mwptpg;ghsuhf [{itgpu; ,lk; ngWfpd;whu;. NkYk; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhj rpyUk; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sdu;.

,uz;lhk; mwptpg;ghsu; o`;̀ hf; vd;gtu;> ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fsplk; vijAk; nrtpAwtpy;iy vdmg+ ]u;M $Wfpwhu;fs;. k\h\; mtu;fsplk; ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fsplk; o`;̀ hf; vijAk;Nfl;Ls;shuh? vd;W Nfl;l NghJ> mtiu mtu; xU NghJk; ghu;j;jNj ,y;iy vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;.

o`;̀ hf; vd;gthplkpUe;J Nfl;ljhf %d;whk; mwptpg;ghsu; [{itgpu; mwptpg;git> Nkhrkhdit vd,g;D KaPd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. NkYk; gpd;tUk; `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhfTk; cs;sJ.

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ghq;if ,uz;buz;lhfTk; ,fhkj;ij xt;nthd;whfTk; $Wk;gb gpyhy;(uyp)mtu;fSf;F fl;lisapl;lhu;fs;'' vd md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; fhyj;jpy; ghq;F ,uz;buz;lhfTk; ,fhkj; xt;nthd;whfTk; vd ,Ue;jJ.'fj;fhkjp];]yhj;> fj; fhkjp];]yhj;' vd;W eP (,uz;L jlit) $Wtijj; jtpu vd;W ,g;Dcku;((uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: e]aP

egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; fhyj;jpy; ,fhkj; thrfk; xU Kiw $wpajhf te;Js;sNghJ> xU Kiw $wpdhy;>mtd; vd;idr; Nru;e;jtd; my;yd; vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $Wthu;fsh? vdNt ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lnra;jp vd;gij epidtpy; nfhs;f!

36. mRj;j ,lk; ][;jh nra;jhy; Rj;jkhFkh?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; njhOk; ,lj;jpy; mtu;fspd; cwTf;fhu; (fshd Nguu;)fs; `]d;> `{i]d;,UtUk; kyk; fopj;jhu;fs;. mg;NghJ ehd;> ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! ePq;fs; njhOkplj;jpy; cq;fspd;cwTf;fhu rpWtu;fs; `]d;-`{i]d; ky-[yk; fopf;fpwhu;fNs' vd;W Nfl;Nld;. mjw;F egp(]y;)''mtu;fs; rpfg;G epwg;ngz;Nz! vd; rKjhaj;jpy; cs;s xUtu; jdJ new;wpia g+kpapy; itj;jhy; me;j][;jh %yk; VO g+kp tiu my;yh`; J}a;ikahf;fptpLthd;. vdNt me;j ,lk; mRj;jj;ij Vw;Wf;nfhs;shJ vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.''

,ij Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;J> ,g;D `pg;ghd;> jg;uhdP Mfpa E}w;fspy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ehd;fhtjhf ,lk; ngWk; g]Pf; ,g;D `];]hd; vd;gtu; ngha;$Wgtuhthu;. ,r;nra;jpia ,g;D `pg;ghd; mtu;fs; jd; k[;&`Pd; vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;J tpl;L>,tu; ey;ytu;fspd; ngau;fisg; gad;gLj;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpfis $Wk; eguhthu; vd;Wk;Fwpg;gpLwhu;fs;.

,g;D mjP mtu;fs; ',td; `jP];fs; epuhfg;gl Ntz;bait vd;Wk;> jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; ,td; `jP];fs;xJf;fg;gl Ntz;bait' vd;Wk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,Nj `jP]; NtW mwptpg;ghsu; thpirAld; jg;uhdPapy; ,lk; ngWfpwJ. ,ij mwptpf;Fk; Map\h(uyp)mtu;fis ,jd; ,uz;lhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhd Kmg;gj; vd;gtu; re;jpf;fNt ,y;iy. ,jdhy; njhlu;G

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

31 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 32: Weak hadiths in tamil

mWe;jit (Kd;fjp̀ ;) vDk; me;j];j;ij mile;J gytPd `jP]hfpwJ.

,J kl;Lky;y. ,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; Kuz;gl;L ,Uf;fpwJ.

fpuhkg;Gw mugp xUtu; kjPdh efu; gs;spthrypy; rpWePu; fopj;jhu;. (,ijf; fz;lJk;) mq;fpUe;j rpyu;mtiu mbf;f neUq;fpdu;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; mtiu tpl;L tpLq;fs;. (mtu; rpWePu; fopg;gij)jLf;fhjPu;fs; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. mtu; (rpWePu; fopj;J) Kbj;jJk;> xU thsp jz;zPu; tutioj;J me;j,lj;jpy; Cw;wpdhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

njhOkplj;jpy; rpWePu; fopj;jjhy; fOtpAs;sdu;. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp cz;ikahdhy;> fOtNtz;bajpy;iy. njhOk;NghJ jhdhfNt Rj;jkhfp tpLk; jhNd! Mdhy; fOtp cs;sdu; vDk; NghJNkw;fz;l nra;jp '`jP];fspd; ngauhy;' cUthf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ vdg; Ghpayhk;.

37. jpUkzj;jpw;F Kd; `[; nra;jhy;...?

''`[; nra;tJ jpUkzj;jpw;F Kd;G jhd;.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,J Råj;jp mtu;fspd;'my;[hkpc];]fPu;' vDk; E}ypy; gjpthfpAs;sJ. 'K];dJy; gpu;jt;];' vDk; E}ypy; ijykP mtu;fSk;Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

,jpy; fpah]; ,g;D ,g;uh`Pk; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vdj`gP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ikrpuh ,g;D mg;Ju;ug; vd;gtUk; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; ngUk; ngha;au; vd j`gP$Wfpwhu;. Nkhrkhd ngha;au; vd fpah]; gw;wp ,g;D KaPd; $Wfpwhu;. ,ijNa mg+jh¥j; mtu;fSk;$Wfpwhu;fs;.

''`[; nra;Ak; Kd; xUtu; jpUkzk; nra;J tpl;lhy; mtu; Fw;wk; nra;aj; Jtq;fpatuhthu;''

vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,ij ,g;D mjPmtu;fs; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;fspy; MwhtJ eguhf ,lk; ngWk; K`k;kj; ,g;D ma;åg; epiwa ,l;Lf;fl;bmwptpg;gtu; vd;W ,g;Dy; [t;]p $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,ij Råj;jp mtu;fSk; jd; E}ypy;cWjpg;gLj;Jfpwhu;fs;. '7tJ mwptpg;ghsuhd m`;kj; ,g;D [{k;̀ {u; ngha; $Wgtd;' vd Råj;jp$Wfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; u[hc ,g;D&`; vd;gtu; gw;wpa Fwpg;igAk; ehd; fhztpy;iy vd Råj;jp$Wfpwhu;fs;.

`[; vd;gJ njhOif> Nehd;G Nghd;w flik jhd;. mjpYk; trjp cs;stu;fs; kPJs;s fl;lhaf;flikahFk;. ,Jgw;wp Fu;MDk;> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSk; $Wfpd;wd.

my;yh`;Tf;fhf ,e;j Myak; nrd;W `[; nra;tJ> kdpju;fspy; mjd;ghy; (nrd;Wtu) rf;jp ngw;wtu;kPJ flikahFk;. (my;Fu;Md; 3:98)

kdpju;fNs! my;yh`; cq;fs; kPJ `[;i[f; flikahf;fp As;shd;. vdNt ePq;fs; `[; nra;Aq;fs;vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vq;fSf;F Mw;wpa ciuapd; NghJ Fwpg;gpl;lhu;fs; vd;W mg+`{iuuh(uyp)mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;> e]aP

,e;j trdKk; `jP]{k; nghJthf `[; flik vd;W jhd; $WfpwNj jtpu> jpUkzj;jpw;F Kd;Ngnra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W $wtpy;iy. ,jpypUe;Jk; Nkw;$wpa nra;jpfs; ngha; vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

jpUkzk; nra;aj;jfhj Mz; cwtpdUld; jtpu ngz;fs; gazk; Nkw;nfhs;sf;$lhJ vd;W egp(]y;)mtu;fs; jkJ nrhw;nghoptpy; Fwpg;gpl;lhu;fs;. mg;NghJ xUtu; vOe;J my;yh`;tpd; J}jNu! vd; kidtp`[; nra;tjw;fhf Gwg;gl;Ltpl;lhu;. ehd; ,d;dd;d Nghu;fspy; <LgLj;jg;gl;L tpl;Nld; vd;W $wpdhu;.mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ePu; Gwg;gl;Lr; nrd;W ck; kidtpAld; `[; nra;tPuhf! vd;W $wpdhu;fs; vd,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> m`;kj;

jpUkzj;jpw;F gpd;Ng `[; nra;ar; nrd;Ws;sdu; vd;gij ,e;j `jP]; njspTgLj;JfpwJ. vz;zw;w

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

32 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 33: Weak hadiths in tamil

egpj; Njhou;fSk; NjhopaUk; jpUkzk; nra;j gpwF `[; nra;ar; nrd;Ws;sdu; vd;gij gy `jP];fs;njspthfNt mwptpf;fpd;wd. egp(]y;) mtu;fSk;> ,ju egpj;Njhou;fSk; `[; nra;a nry;Yk; NghJjq;fsJ kidtpaiu mioj;Jr; nrd;wdu; vd;gijAk; gy `jP];fs; tpsf;Ffpd;wd.

vdNt jpUkzj;jpw;F Kd;Ng `[; nra;ar; nry;y Ntz;Lk;. mg;gb kPwp nra;jhy; Fw;wk; vd;nwy;yhk;tUk; Nkw;fz;l nra;jpfs; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litNa!

38. Foe;ijf;F K`k;kJ vd ngahplh tpl;lhy;...?

''xUtUf;F %d;W Foe;ijfs; ,Ue;J> mtu;fspy; xUtUf;NfDk; K`k;kj; vd;W ngahplhtpl;lhy; mtu;kilaNu!''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L mJ jg;uhdP(fgPu;)apy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;s K];mg; ,g;D ]aPj; vd;ghu; rhpahdtuy;y vd;gjhy; ,e;j`jP]{k; rhpahdjhf ,y;iy.

,e;j K];mg; ,g;D ]aPj;> ek;gfkhdtu; topahf gy jtwhd `jP];fis mwptpg;gtu; vd;W ,g;D mjPmtu;fs; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

,Nj `jP]; NtW mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; th]pyh ,g;D m];fc(uyp) topahfTk; kw;Wk; [/gu; ,g;DK`k;kj; mtu;fs; jd; ghl;ldhu; topahfTk; mg;Jy; kypf; ,g;D `h&d; ,g;D md;jpuh mtu;fs; jd;ghl;ldhu; topahfTk; mwptpg;gjhf ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ. ,g;D Gifu; mtu;fs; ,e;j `jP];fis jdJE}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

th]pyh mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; `jP]py;> cku; ,g;D %]h my;t[P̀ p vd;w ,l;Lf;fl;bf; $Wgtu; ,lk;ngWtjhy; me;j `jP]; gytPdg;gl;Lg; NghfpwJ.

[/gu; ,g;D K`k;kj; mtu;fs; jdJ ghl;ldhu; topahf mwptpf;Fk; `jP]py;> mg;Jy;yh ,g;D jh`pu;mu;uh]P vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tiu ,g;Dy; [t;]P> j`gP MfpNahu; Fiw $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j`jP]{k; gytPdkhdjhfpwJ.

jdJ ghl;ldhu; topahf mwptpf;Fk; mg;Jy; kypf; ,g;D `h&d; vd;gtNu ngha;au;; ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu;vd;gjhy; me;j `jP]{k; gytPdkhdjhfpwJ.

gy egpj;Njhou;fSf;F %d;W Mz; Foe;ijfSf;F Nky; cs;sJ. Mdhy; mtu;fspy; vtUk; K`k;kj;vd;W ngahpl;ljhf ve;j `jP]{k; ,y;iy. egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; nrhy;iy kpf cau;thf kjpj;Jgpd;gw;wp tho;e;j egpj; Njhou;fspd; xt;nthU FLk;gj;jpYk; K`k;kj; vd;W ngahplg;gl;Ls;stu;fs;,Ue;jhu;fsh vd;why; mJTk; ,y;iy. ,e;j mbg;gilapYk; 'K`k;kj; vd;W jd; Foe;ijfspy;vtUf;NfDk; xUtUf;F ngahplhjtu; kilaNu' vd;W tUk; nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lNj!

egpkhu;fspd; ngau;fshy; ngaLq;fs;. my;yh`;Tf;F kpfg; gphpakhd ngau; mg;Jy;yh. mg;Jw;w`;khd;vd;gjhFk; vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+t`;G(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: mg+jh¥j;

,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]hFk;. ,J Nghd;W Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fshf> K`k;kj; vd;W ngahplf;$Wk; `jP];fs; cs;sjh vd;why; mJTk; ,y;iy. vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lNjvd;gjpy; re;Njfkpy;iy.

39. ngz;fs; tpisahl;Lg; nghUl;fs;?

''ngz; tpisahl;Lg; nghUshths;. ePq;fs; ,\;lg;gb ele;J nfhs;Sq;fs;''

vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mk;Ug;Dy; M];(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpajhf `hfpk; E}ypy; gjpTnra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

33 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 34: Weak hadiths in tamil

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; ,g;DYi`M vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtuhthu;. NkYk; ,jpy; ,lk;ngw;Ws;s m`;t]; vd;gtUk; mk;U ,g;D M];(uyp) mtu;fSf;FkpilNa mwptpg;ghsu; thpirtpLgl;Ls;sJ.

''ngz; tpisahl;Lg; nghUshths;. mtis tpisahl;Lg; nghUshf cgNahfpg;gtu; mofhf itj;Jf;nfhs;sl;Lk;. ''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+gf;fu; ,g;D `];k; vd;ghu; $Wfpwhu;. ,ij `huP]; ,g;D myPc]hkh mtu;fs; jdJ K];djpy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.

,ij mwptpf;Fk; mg+gf;fu; ,g;D `];k; ,tu;fs; egpj;Njhouy;y `p[;hp 120-y; ,we;jtu;. ,e;j tifapy;,J Ku;]yhFk;. NkYk; ]{i`u; ,g;D K`k;kj; my;Fuh]hdP m\;\hkP vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;.,tu; gytPduhthu;. NkYk; m`;kj; ,g;D a]Pj; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; gw;wpa mwpKfk;VJkpy;iy. vdNt ,JTk; gytPdkhd nra;jpNa!

,ij ngz;fis Nftyg;gLj;j Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk; ,];yhj;ij ,opT gLj;j Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk; vz;ZNthu;jhd; ,l;Lf;fl;bapUf;f Ntz;Lk;.

40. moF> gzk;> ghuk;ghpak; ,tw;wpw;fhf jpUkzk; nra;ayhk;?

''xU ngz;iz mtspd; fz;zpaj;jpw;fhf xUtd; jpUkzk; nra;jhy; mtDf;F my;yh`; ,opitj; jtpu(NtW vijAk;) mjpfg;gLj;j khl;lhd;. mtspd; gzj; jpw;fhf mtis jpUkzk; nra;jhy; mtDf;Fmy;yh`; tWikiaj; jtpu (NtW vijAk;) mjpfg;gLj;jkhl;lhd;. mtspd; moFf;fhf mtis jpUkzk;nra;jhy; mtDf;F ifNrjj;ijj; jtpu (NtW vijAk;) mjpfg;gLj;Jtjpy;iy. xUtd; xU ngz;izjpUkzk; nra;fpwhd;. mtd; jd; ghu;itia (gpw md;dpag; ngz;fisg; ghu;g;gij tpl;Lk;) jho;j;jpf;nfhs;sTk; my;yJ jd; ku;k];jhdj;ij ghJfhf;fTk; my;yJ jd; cwtpdiu Nru;j;J thoTNk jtpuNtW vjw;Fk; mtis jpUkzk; nra;atpy;iy vd;why;> my;yh`; mtDf;F mtspd; tp\aj;jpy; guf;fj;nra;fpwhd;. mtSf;Fk; mtd; tp\aj;jpy; guf;fj; nra;fpwhd;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md]; ,g;D khypf; (uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;J jg;uhdp mtu;fspd;my; mt;]j; E}ypy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

,e;j nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; FsWgb cs;sjhy; ,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahFk;. ,uz;lhk;mwptpg;ghsuhd ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D mgP mg;yh mtu;fs; topahf mg;J];]yhk; ,g;D mg;Jy; Fj;J}];kl;LNk ,r;nra;jpia mwptpf;fpwhu;. Mdhy; ,e;j mg;J];]yhk; ,g;D mg;Jy; Fj;J}]; rhpahdtuy;yu;.

,tu; gytPdkhdtu; vd mg+`hjk; mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,tuJ je;ij mg;Jy; Fj;J}];rhpahdtuy;y. ,tiuAk; tpl ,tuJ kfd; mg;J];]yhk; kpf Nkhrkhdtu; vd mg+jh¥j;Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

,tu; epiwa ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpia mwptpg;gtu; vd;Wk;> ,tu; ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D mgP mg;yh topahfNt,tu; mwptpg;ghu; vd;Wk; mo;Omghc vDk; E}ypy; ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. i`jkP mtu;fs; ,tu;gytPdkhdtu; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. Kd;jpuP mtu;fs; jdJ mj;ju;fPg; E}ypy; gytPdu; vd;NwFwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

''ePq;fs; ngz;fis mtu;fspd; moFf;fhf jpUkzk; nra;ahjPu;fs;. mtu;fspd; moNf mtu;fisehrg;gLj;jTk; $Lk;. NkYk; mtu;fspd; nry;tq;fSf;fhfTk; mtu;fis jpUkzk; nra;ahjPu;fs;.mtu;fspd; nry;tq;fNs mtu;fis topnfLf;fTk; $Lk;. vdpDk; mtu;fis khu;f;fj;jpw;fhf jpUkzk;nra;Aq;fs;. khu;f;fk; mwpe;j fUg;G epw fhjWe;j xU mbikg; ngz;Nz (,ju ngz;fis tpl jpUkzk;nra;a) kpfr; rpwe;jtu;.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg;Jy;yh ,g;D mk;U (uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,g;Dkh[h>ig`fP Mfpa E}y;fspy; ,J ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ.

,jpy; ,/g;uPfP vd;gtu; ,lk;ngWfpwhu;. ,tuJ ngau; mg;Jw;w`;khd; ,g;D ]pahj; ,g;D m\;\{mghd;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

34 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 35: Weak hadiths in tamil

vd;gjhFk;. ',tu; gytPdkhdtu;' vd jdJ 'm];]thapj;' vDk; E}ypy; g+]p mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.vdNt ,JTk; gytPdkhd `jP]; jhd;.

`jP];fspd; ngauhy; cs;s Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L nra;jpfSNk eilKiwapy; rhj;jpag;glhj-,y;yhjxd;iwNa mwptpf;fpd;wd.

fz;zpak; fUjp> FLk;g ghuk;ghpaj;jpw;fhf jpUkzk; nra;Ak; xUtDf;F ,opT jhd; kpQ;Rk; vd;W Kjy;`jP]; $WfpwJ. fz;zpakhd FLk;gj;jpy; ,Ue;J jpUkzk; nra;Ak; midtUk; ,opthd epiyf;Fj;jhd; Mshfp cs;shu;fsh? epr;rakhf ,y;iy. ,e;j `jP];gb ,ope;j epiyf;Fj; jhNd Mfp ,Uf;fNtz;Lk;. ,y;iy vd;why; `jP]pd; fUj;J ngha; vd;W jhNd MFk;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; eilKiwapy;fhzKbahj-nghUe;jhj nra;jpiar; nrhy;yp ,Ug;ghu;fsh? nrhy;ypapUf;fkhl;lhu;fs;. ,jpypUe;Nj,r;nra;jp ngha; vd;gJ GhpAk;.

,JNghy; mtsplk; cs;s trjp fUjp xU ngz;iz jpUkzk; nra;jhy; mtd; Vioahfj;jhd; Mthd;vd;fpwJ me;j `jP];. ,g;gb vtuhtJ jpUkzk; nra;jjhy; jhd; Vo;ikf;F Mshdhu;fsh? vd;why;>mg;gb xUtiu fhz;gJk; mNj! ,jd; %yKk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,ij $wpapUf;f khl;lhu;fs; vd;gijmwpayhk;.

,JNghy; jhd; moFk;; mofpiaj; jpUkzk; nra;j midtUNk ifNrjk; mile;jjpy;iy vd;gijvtUk; kWf;fkhl;lhu;fs;. ,jdhYk; ,J ngha; vd;gJ njspthFk;.

,t;thNw ,uz;lhtjhf ,q;Nf Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s gytPdkhd nra;jpiag; ghUq;fs;.

''moFf;fhf jpUkzk; nra;jhy; moF mopaTk; $Lk;. trjpAs;s ngz;fis jpUkzk; nra;jhy; mtu;fs;mjd; %yk; top nflTk; $Lk; vd;W mr;nra;jp $WfpwJ.''

moFs;s ngz;fs; midtUk; jq;fspd; mofpdhNyNa ehrkile;jtu;fSky;y. trjpkpf;f ngz;fs;midtUk; mtu;fspd; nry;tj;jpdhNyNa topnfl;ltu;fSky;y. ,J jhd; cz;ik epiy. ,jpypUe;J,uz;lhtJ nra;jp Gidag;gl;lNj vd;gJ GhpAk;.

NkYk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;Fk; ,J Kuzhf cs;sJ. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jPi]g; ghUq;fs;.

''xU ngz; mtsJ nry;tk;> FLk;gg; ghuk;ghpak;> moF> khu;f;ff; fy;tp Mfpa ehd;Ff;fhf jpUkzk;nra;ag;gLfpwhs;. vdpDk; eP khu;f;fg; gw;Ws;s kq;ifiaNa kzKbj;J ntw;wp ngW'' vd;W egp(]y;)$wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> ,g;Dkh[h> e]aP> mg+jh¥j;

,e;j Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jPi] ed;F rpe;jpf;f Ntz;Lk;. ,e;j `jP]py; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ehd;Ffhhpaq;fSf;fhf mjhtJ gzk;> ghuk;ghpak;> moF> khu;f;ff; fy;tp Mfpatw;wpw;fhfNt xU ngz;jpUkzk; nra;ag;gLfpwhs; vd;W $wptpl;L> 'khu;f;fk; mwpe;jtis eP jpUkzk; nra;! ntw;wp ngWtha;'vd;W $Wfpwhu;fNs jtpu kw;w %d;iwAk; fUj;jpy; nfhs;tij mwNt $lhJ vd;W $wtpy;iy.

xU ngz;iz moFf;fhfTk; jpUkzk; nra;ayhk;; nry;t epiyapy; cs;sts; vd;gjw;fhfTk; jpUkzk;nra;ayhk;. FLk;gg; ghuk;ghpak; fUjpAk; jpUkzk; nra;ayhk;. ,jpy; vg;gb Ntz;LkhdhYk; jpUkzk;nra;jhYk; khu;f;ff; fy;tp mwpe;jtisNa jpUkzk; nra;tNj rpwg;G vd;gNj ,e;j Mjhug;g+u;tkhd`jP]pd; epiy.

moF vd;W jpUkzk; nra;Ak;NghNj khu;f;ff; fy;tp cs;sjh? vd;W ghu;f;f Ntz;Lk;. ghuk;ghpak; fUjp>trjp fUjp jpUkzk; nra;Ak; NghNj khu;f;f mwpT cs;sjh? vd;W njhpe;J nfhs;sTk; Ntz;Lk;. ,Jjhd; tho;f;ifia ntw;wpahf;Fk; vd;gijAk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; tpsf;FfpwJ.

moF> ghuk;ghpak;> nry;tk; ,tw;iw fUj;jpNy nfhs;tijNa Nkw;fz;l gytPdkhd nra;jpfs; jilnra;fpd;wd. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]pd; fUj;Jf;Nf ,J khw;wkhFk;.

trjp cs;std; trjpahd FLk;gg; ngz;iz jpUkzk; nra;aNt tpUk;Gthd;. xU rpyu; tpjptpyf;Fngw;wpUf;fyhk;. ,J Nghy; ghuk;ghpakpf;f FLk;gj;ijr; rhu;e;jtd; jdf;F ,izahd epiyapy;cs;stisNa jpUkzk; Kbf;f vz;Zthd;. ,J $lhJ vd;W $wpdhy; jpUkzk; vDk; tho;f;ifxg;ge;jk; ,ilapNyNa rpy rkak; Kwpe;JtpLk;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

35 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Page 36: Weak hadiths in tamil

vdNt Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L nra;jpfSNk Gidag;gl;l ngha;r; nra;jpfshFk;.

41. mofpa Kfk; ,Ug;gpd;...

''epr;rakhf my;yh`; mofpa-ftu;r;rpahd Kfk; cs;stu;fis Ntjid nra;akhl;lhd;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf ijykP mtu;fs; jd; E}ypy;gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; mg;Jy; khypf; ,g;D K`k;kj; mu;Uf;fh\P vd;gtu;cz;ikahdtu;. vdpDk; ,tu; gf;jhj; vDk; CUf;F te;jNghJ mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapYk; `jP]pd;thu;j;ijapYk; FsWgb nra;aj; Jtq;fpdhu;. ,tu; gw;wpa Fwpg;G 'j`;jPGj;j`;jPG' vDk; E}ypy; cs;sJ.,e;j `jP]{k; mtu; nra;j FsWgbfSf;Fg; gpd;dhy; jhd; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. NkYk; ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; gyu; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;fshf cs;sdu;. ,tu;fSk; ,l;Lf;fl;b,Uf;ff;$Lk;.

''mofpa> ftu;r;rpahd Kfq;fis> gw;wpf; nfhs;Sq;fs;. epr;rakhf my;yh`; mofpa Kfj;ij neUg;gpy;Nghl;L Ntjid nra;a ntl;fkilfpwhd;.''

,JTk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ jhd;. ,ij ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fs;my;kt;@Mj; vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; `]d; ,g;Dmyp,g;D [fa;ah my; mj;tP vd;gtu; rhpahdtuy;yu; vd;W ,g;Dy; [t;]P $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu;,l;Lf;fl;bf; $Wtjpy; gpugykhdtu;fspy; xUtu; vd;W Råj;jp mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ',e;j Nkhrkhdnra;jpia ,l;Lf;fl;batd; kPJ ,iwtdpd; rhgk; cz;lhFk;' vd ,e;jr; nra;jp gw;wp $Wk;NghJm\;i\f; fh mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,r;nra;jp NtW mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapYk; tUfpwJ. ,jpy; ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D Riykhd; m];]pahj; vd;gtu;,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; rhpahdtuy;yu; vd ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; K`k;kj; ,g;Djy;̀ h my;f&fp> K`k;kJ ,g;D mg;Jy;yh ,g;D mgPGu;jh my;fhoP Mfpa ,UtUk; ahnud;Nwmwpag;glhjtu;fs;. NkYk; yh`pf; ,g;D `{i]d; vd;gtUk; Nkhrkhdtu;. ',tu; ngUk; ngha;au;' vd,j;uP]; `hgpo; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L nra;jpfSk; mwptpg;ghsu; thpir fhuzkhf kl;Lk; FiwAilaJ my;y. khwhfFu;Mdpd; trdq;fSf;Fk;> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd egpnkhopfSf;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sjhYk; ,itfs;,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;litNaahFk;.

,t;Tyfpy; kdpjd; Nkw;nfhs;Sk; tho;f;iff;F Vw;gj; jhd; kWik tho;tpd; #o;epiyAk; mikAk;.,iwtDf;F kpf tpUg;gkhd fhhpaq;fis nra;J tho;e;J kuzpj;jhy; mtd; Rtu;f;fj;jpy; Eiothd;.,iwtDf;F khW nra;J> mtDf;F Nfhgj;ij Vw;gLj;Jk; nray;fis xUtd; nra;jhy; mtd; eufpy;Eiothd; vd;gJ jhd; ,];yhkpa mbg;gilf; nfhs;ifahFk;.

my;yh`; xt;nthU Mj;khTf;F mJ rk;ghjpj;jjw;fhd $yp nfhLg;gjw;fhfNt (mtu;fis my;yh`;,t;thW nra;thd;) epr;rakhf my;yh`; Nfs;tp fzf;F Nfl;gjpy; kpfTk; jPtpukhdtd;. (my;Fu;Md;14:57)

cq;fsplk; ,Ug;git jPu;e;JtpLk;. my;yh`;tplk; ,Ug;gNj (mopahJ> vd;nwd;Wk;) epiyj;jpUf;Fk;.vtu;fs; nghWikAld; (f\;lq;fisr;) rfpj;Jf; nfhs;fpwhu;fNsh> mtu;fSf;F mtu;fs; nra;Jnfhz;bUe;jtw;wpypUe;J kpfTk; mofhd $ypia epr;rakhf ehk; nfhLg;Nghk;. (my;Fu;Md; 16:96)

(%kpd;fNs!) kWikapy; ePq;fs; tpUk;gpagbNah> my;yJ Ntjj;ijAilatu;fs; tpUk;gpagbNahele;JtpLtjpy;iy. vtd; jPik nra;fpwhNdh mtd; mjw;Fhpa jz;lid toq;fg;gLthd;. ,d;Dk; mtd;(mq;F) my;yh`;itj; jtpu NtW vtiuAk; (jdf;Fg;) ghJfhtydhfNth> Jiz nra;gtdhfNthfhzkhl;lhd;.

MfNt> MzhapDk; rhp> ngz;zhapDk; rhp> ahu; ahu; <khd; nfhz;ltu;fNsh> ew;fUkq;fs;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

36 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 37: Weak hadiths in tamil

nra;fpwhu;fNsh mtu;fs; Rtdgjpapy; Eiothu;fs;. ,d;Dk; mtu;fs; ,k;kpNaDk; mepahak;nra;ag;glkhl;lhu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 4:123> 124)

vtu; xUtu; xU ed;ik nra;fpwhNuh mtUf;F mJNghy; gj;J klq;F ed;ik cz;L. vtu; xU jPiknra;fpwhNuh mijg; Nghd;w msTila $ypia nfhLf;fg;gLthu;. mtu;fs; mepahak; nra;ag;glTk;khl;lhu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 6:160)

vtu; xU mZtsT ed;ik nra;jpUe;jhYk;> mj(w;Fhpa gy)id mtu; fz;L nfhs;thu;. NkYk; vtu; Xu;mZtsT jPik nra;jpUe;jhYk; mj(jw;Fhpa gy)idAk; mtd; fz;L nfhs;thd;. (my;Fu;Md; 99:8)

,t;trdq;fs; midj;Jk;> jPikfSf;Nfw;gNt xUtd; jz;bf;fg;gLthd; vd;gij tpsf;Ffpd;wd.mtdtd; nra;j gyid mtdtd; mile;Nj jPUthd;. mJ mZtsNtDk; ,Ug;gpDk; rhpNa vd;Wmy;yh`; njspTgLj;Jfpwhd;. ,iwtdpd; ,e;jf; $w;Wf;F khw;wkhd Nkw;fz;l nra;jpfs;,Ug;gjpypUe;Nj mit ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litNa vd;gJ GhpAk;.

epr;rakhf my;yh`; cq;fspd; clk;igNah> Njhw;wj; ijNah fhz;gjpy;iy. khwhf mtd; cq;fspd;,jaq;fisAk;> nray;fisAk; ghu;f;fpwhd; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf K];ypkpy; `jP]; xd;Wcs;sJ. ,e;j `jP]{f;Fk; ,J khw;wkhfNt cs;sJ.

my;yh`; cs;sj;ij-nraiyg; ghu;f;fpwhNd jtpu> cUtj;ij-Njhw;wj;ijf; fhz;gjpy;iy vd;Wegp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpAs;sJ Mjhug;g+u;tkhf cs;sjhYk;> ,jw;F khw;wkhd fUj;ijNa - mofpa Kfk;cs;stu;fis fz;L jz;bf;fg; gLtjpy;iy vd;w fUj;ijNa - $WtjhYk; Nkw;fz;l ,uz;Lnra;jpfSk; ,l;Lf;fl;Lg;gl;l nra;jpfNs vd;gJ NkYk; GydhFk;.

NkYk; mofpa Kfk; cilNahiu jz;bf;f khl;lhd; vd;W $Wtjhy; mofpa Kfk; cilNahu; ve;jjtW nra;jhYk; kd;dpf;fg;gLtu; vd;W njhpa tUfpwJ. mg;gbahdhy; mtu;fs; ,\;lg;gb thoyhk; vd;WMfptpLk;. ,J rhj;jpag;gLkh? my;yh`; jdf;F ,iz itg;Nghiu jz;bg;ghd;. kd;dpf;fNt khl;lhd;vd;W $Wfpwhd;. mofpa Kfk; cilNahu; ,iz itj;jhYk; jz;bf;fg; gl khl;lhu;fs; vd;W jhd;>,e;j nra;jpfs; cz;ik vd;W $wpdhy; vz;zj; Njhd;Wk;. ,J kl;Lk; tpjptpyf;Fg; ngw;w rl;lk; vd;W$wpdhy; ,jw;F ve;j Kfhe;jpuj;ijAk; ,e;j nra;jpfspy; ngw Kbatpy;iy.

,t;thW midj;J tif Fw;wq;fshd tpgr;rhuk;-Nghijg; nghUs; cz;Zjy; ,d;Dk; gy rl;lq;fiskPWjy; Nghd;w jtwhd nray;fisr; nra;jhy; jz;lid VJ kpUf;fhJ vd;whfptpLk;. ,JTk;rhj;jpag;glhj xd;Nw! ,e;j tifapy; ,itfs; ngha;ahd nra;jpNa vd;gJ tpsq;Fk;.

,e;j nra;jp cz;ikahf ,Ug;gpd; K];ypk;fs; kl;LNk mofpa Kfk; cilatu;fshf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;.fhgpu;fs; tpfhuKilNahuhf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. ,Uf;fpwjh? ,y;iy vd;gjpypUe;Jk; ,it ngha; vd;gJcWjpahFk;. ey;y-jPa Kbit mofpa-mrpq;fkhd Kfq;fSf;Nfw;g KbT nra;ag;gLtjpy;iy. khwhfey;y-jPa KbTf;Nfw;gNt Kfk; khWk; vd;W Fu;Md; $WfpwJ.

me;j ehspy; kdpjd; kpuz;L XLthd;. jd; rNfhjuid tpl;Lk;> jd; jhia tpl;Lk;> jd; kf;fis tpl;Lk;md;W xt;nthU kdpjDf;Fk; mtdtd; (mty) epiyNa NghJ khdjhapUf;Fk;. me;ehspy; rpy Kfq;fs;,yq;fpf; nfhz;bUf; Fk;. rpj;jitahfTk;> kfpo;TilajhfTk; ,Uf;Fk;. Mdhy; me;ehspy; (NtW) rpyKfq;fs; mtw;wpd; kPJ GOjp gbe; jpUf;Fk;. mtw;iwf; fUik ,Us; %bapUf;Fk;. mtu;fs; jhk;epuhfj;jtu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 80:34-42)

,t;trdq;fs; midj;Jk; $Wk; fUj;Jf;F khw;wkhf Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L nra;jpfSk; cs;sj;jhy; mitNkYk; gytPdg;gLtNjhL kl;Lkpy;yhky;> mit ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;litfshfTk; Mfpd;wJ.

42. Gwk; NgRtJ...?

''Gwk; NgRtJ> x@itAk;> njhOifiaAk; Kwpj;JtpLk;.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,ij mg+eaPk; mtu;fs;jd; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

37 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 38: Weak hadiths in tamil

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ,lk; ngWk; ,];khapy; ,g;D a`;ah ,g;D mg;Jy;yh`; vd;fpw mg+ a`;ahmj;ijkP vd;gtu; ngUk; ngha;auhthu;.

,tiug; gw;wp jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLk; NghJ> ,tu; khypf;> jt;uP ,d;Dk; gyu; topahf ngha;$Wgtu; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,tu; khypf;> k];¥J> ,g;D mgPjp̀ ;G MfpNahu; topahf gy ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpfis mwptpj;Js;shu;vd;W `hfpk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

'`jPi] ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu; ,tu;' vd fjPg; mtu;fSk;> ,r;nra;jpapy; gytPdk; cz;L vd ,g;Dk/$yhmtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;:-

'',uz;L egu;fs; Y`iuNah> my;yJ m]iuNah njhOjdu;. me;j ,uz;L NgUNk Nehd;Gitj;jpUe;jdu;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; njhOifia Kbj;j NghJ> (mt;tpUtUk; mioj;J) 'ePq;fs;,UtUk; kPz;Lk; x@r; nra;J kPz;Lk; njhOq;fs;. cq;fspd; Nehd;igAk; tPzbj;Jtpl;Bu;fs;. mijNtnwhU ehspy; kPz;Lk; epiwNtw;Wq;fs;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. my;yh`;tpd; J}jNu! Vd;? vdmt;tpUtUk; Nfl;ldu;. ,d;d kdpjiug; gw;wp ePq;fs; ,UtUk; Gwk; NgrpdPu;fs; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs;$wpdhu;fs;.''

,r;rk;gtj;ij ig`fP mtu;fs; jdJ \{/Gy; <khd; vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,Jkp\;fhJy; k]hgP̀ ; E}ypy; 4783 vz;zpl;l `jP]hfTk; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ.

,r;nra;jpAk; $l ve;j mbg;gilAk;> Kiwahd mwptpg;ghsu; thpirAkpd;wp gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. vdNt,JTk; ngha;r; nra;jp jhd;.

Gwk;NgRjy; vd;gJ ,];yhj;jpd; ghu;itapy; Fw;wkhFk;. gpwuJ Fw;wq;Fiwfs; gw;wp Ngrplf; $lhJvd;W ,];yhk; $WfpwJ.

%kpd;fNs! (re;Njfkhd) gy vz;zq;fspypUe;J jtpu;e;J nfhs;Sq;fs;. Vnddpy; epr;rakhfvz;zq;fspy; rpy ghtq;fshf ,Uf;Fk;. (gpwu; Fiwfis) ePq;fs; JUtpj; JUtp Muha;e;Jnfhz;buhjPu;fs;. NkYk; cq;fspy; rpyu; rpyiug; gw;wp Gwk; NgrNtz;lhk;. cq;fsJ vtNuDk; jkJ,we;j rNfhjud; khkprj;ij cz;z tpUk;Gthuh? (,y;iy). mij ePq;fs; ntWg;gPu;fs;. ,d;Dk;ePq;fs; my;yh`;it mQ;Rq;fs;. epr;rakhf ghtj;jpypUe;J kPs;tij my;yh`; Vw;Wf; nfhs;gtd;; kpff;fpUig nra;gtd;. (my;Fu;Md; 49:12)

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kpk;ghpy; Vwp Fuiy cau;j;jp> ehthy; (kl;Lk;) ,];yhj;ij Vw;Wf; nfhz;L>cs;sj;jpy; <khd; Eioahj $l;lj;jpdNu! K];ypk;fSf;Fj; njhy;iy juhjPu;fs;; mtu;fis Fiw$whjPu;fs;. mtu;fspd; Fiwfisj; Njb miyahjPu;fs;; ahu; jkJ rNfhjud; Fiwfisj; NjbmiyfpwhNuh mtuJ Fiwia ,iwtd; NjLthd;. ahUila Fiwia my;yh`; Njlj; Jtq;fptpl;lhNdh mtu; jkJ tPl;bd; eLg;gFjpapy; ,Ue;jhYk; mtiu my;yh`; ,opTgLj;jptpLthd; vd;W$wpdhu;fs;. ,ij ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: jpu;kpjP

Gwk; NgRjy; vd;gJ ahJ? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;fg;gl;lJ. mjw;ftu;fs; 'ckJ rNfhjuu;ntWf;ff;$ba xd;iw ePu; NgRtNj Gwk;' vd;whu;fs;. ehd; $WtJ mthplk; cz;ikapNyNa,Ue;jhy;...? vdf; Nfs;tp Nfl;ltu; Nfl;lhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; 'eP $wf;$baJ mthplk;,Ue;jhy; jhd; ePu; Gwk; NgrpatuhtPu;. mthplk; mf;Fiw ,y;iynadpy; ePu; mtJ}W $wpatuhtPu;' vd;Wtpsf;fpdhu;fs;. ,ij mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: jpu;kpjP

Gwk; NgRjy; rk;ge;jkhf gy `jP];fs; tUfpwJ. Gwk; NgRjiy jil nra;fpwJ. Mdhy; Gwk; Ngrpdhy;x@ KwpAkh? Nehd;G tPzhFkh? vd;why; mjw;F ve;jnthU Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{k; tutpy;iy.vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jpAk; rk;gtKk; ngha;; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;gNj rhpahFk;.

43. k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; cghpj; njhOif...!

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

38 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 39: Weak hadiths in tamil

''k/hpGf;Fk;> ,\hTf;Fk; ,ilNa ,UgJ uf;mj;fs; xUtu; njhOtjhy; mtUf;F my;yh`;nrhu;f;fj;jpy; xU tPl;il fl;Lfpwhd;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;J ,g;Dkh[htpy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; a/$g; ,g;D tyPj; vd;gtu; rhpahdtuy;yu;. ,tiugytPdg;gLj;jpf; $Wtjpy; mwpQu;fs; xd;Wgl;Ls;sdu; vd;W g+]puP mtu;fs; m];]thapj;jpy;Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; ngUk; ngha;au;fspy; xUtu;> `jP];fis ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu; vd ,khk; m`;kj;$Wfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; ,g;DKaPd;> mg+`hjk; MfpNahUk; ,tu; gw;wp Fiw $Wfpwhu;fs;.

''xUtu; k/hpG njhOiff;Fg; gpd; vijAk; NgRk; Kd; MW uf;mj;fs; njhOjhy; mtUf;F mjw;fhfIk;gJ tUl ghtq;fs; kd;dpf;fg;gLk;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg;Jy;yh ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L fpahKy;iyypvd;Dk; E}ypy; ,g;D e]u; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,g;D mgP̀ hjk; mtu;fs; my;,yy; vDk; jkJ E}ypy; ,ijf; Fwpg;gpl;L tpl;L> ,jpy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sK`k;kj; ,g;D f];thd; mj;jpkp\;fP vd;gtu; `jP]; Jiwapy; kWf;fg;gl;ltu; vd;W mg+]u;M mtu;fs;$wpaijAk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

''xUtu; k/hpGf;F gpd; MW uf;mj;fs; njhOJ mtw;wpw;fpilNa vJTk; NgrhjpUg;ghuhdhy; mtuJmj;njhOif gdpnuz;L tUlj;jpw;F tzf;fk; nra;jjw;F epfuhf;fg;gLk;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,J jpu;kpjP>,g;Dkh[h> ,g;De];u;> ,g;D ]hifd;> Kf;yp];> m];fuP> ,g;D ]k;Cd;> my;thapy; MfpNahuhy;mtutu;fsJ E}y;fspy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

,jw; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; cku; ,g;D mgP̀ ];mk; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; jtwhd `jP];fismwptpg;gtu; vd ,khk; GfhuP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; topahf kl;LNk ,ij ehk; mwpfpNwhk; vd ,khk; jpu;kpjP$Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; %yk; ,uz;L jtwhd `jP];fs; cz;L. ,jpy; ,JTk; xd;W vd;W j`gP$Wfpwhu;fs;.

k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; mt;thgPd; vd;nwhU njhOif njhog;gLtJz;L. mjw;F ,ijNa Mjhukhff; nfhs;fpd;wdu;. ,J gytPdkhd `jP]; vd;gjhy; ,ij itj;J mky; nra;af;$lhJ. NkYk; ,e;j MWuf;mj;Njh> ,UgJ uf;mj;Njh k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; njhOtJ gw;wp tuf;$ba midj;JNk gytPdkhdnra;jpfshfNt cs;sd.

NkYk; Nkw;fz;l %d;W nra;jpfSNk gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F khw;wkhfNt cs;sd.

,utpYk;> gfypYk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; gj;J uf;mj;fs; njhOjij ehd; ftdpj;Js;Nsd;. Y`Uf;F Kd;,uz;L uf;mj;fs;> Y`Uf;F gpd; ,uz;L uf;mj;fs;> k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; ,uz;L uf;mj;fs;> ,\hTf;Fg; gpd;,uz;L uf;mj;fs;> g[Uf;F Kd; ,uz;L uf;mj;fs; (Mf gj;J uf;mj;fs;) vd `g;]h(uyp) mtu;fs;jd;dplk; $wpajhf ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> jpu;kpjP

k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; ,uz;L uf;mj;jpYk;> g[;Uf;F Kd; ,uz;L uf;mj;jpYk;> Fy;ah ma;A`y; fh/gp&d>Fy;̀ {ty;yh`{ m`j; Mfpa mj;jpahaq;fis egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Xjpaij vd;dhy; fzf;fpl;Lr;nrhy;y KbahJ vd ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> mg+jh¥j;> m`;kj;>,g;Dkh[h

vdNt k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; ,uz;L uf;mj; njhOtNj egptop. mjw;F khw;wkhf mwptpf;fg;gLk; ,UgJ uf;mj;>MW uf;mj; gw;wpa `jP];fs; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfNs!

44. jhdpaq;fspy; ]fhj; kjpg;gPL msT vd;d?

''(jhdpa tiffspy;) mit Fiwthf ,Ug;gpDk;> mjpfkhf ,Ug;gpDk; mit thdj;J kio ePu; %yk;tpise;J te;jpUg;gpd; gj;J rjtPjKk;> jz;zPiu Rke;J my;yJ ,iwj;J ePu; gha;r;rp fpilj;jpUg;gpd;Ie;J rjtPjKk; ]fhj; cz;L ''

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

39 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 40: Weak hadiths in tamil

vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; gpd;tUkhW;-

1. egpj;Njhou; xUtu; (ngau; Fwpg;gplhky; xU kdpju; vd;Nw cs;sJ)

2. mghd; ,g;D mgP ,ah\;

3. mg+`dPgh

4. mg+KjPc my;g];fP

,e;j ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhd mg+KjPctpd; ngau; my;̀ fk; ,g;D mg;Jy;yh`; vd;gjhFk;. ,tu;,l;Lf; fl;Lgtu; vd [t;]Py;fhdP vd;gtu; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,e;j nra;jpia jdJ e];Gu;uhah vDk; E}ypy; i]y< mtu;fs; gjpT nra;J tpl;L> mg+`dPgh topahfmwptpf;Fk; mg+KjPcy; ty;fP vd;gtd; $w;iwNa `dgP kj;̀ gpdu; Mjhuk; gpbf;fpwhu;fs; vd ,g;Dy;[t;]p $wpajhfTk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs.

,g;D KaPd;> m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j; MfpNahUk; ,e;j mg+KjPc my;gy;fP vd;gtiu FiwahfNtFwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; ,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; mghd; ,g;D mgP ,ah\; vd;gtUk; rhpahdtuy;y. ,tiu\{/gh Nghd;Nwhu; gytPdg;gLj;jpf; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

,e;j `jP]pd; fUj;J> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fspYk; cs;sNj. mg;gbahdhy; ,J `]d; vDk;epiyf;F te;J tpLNk vd;W rpyu; $wp gpd;tUk; `jPi] Mjhukhff; $wyhk;.

kio kw;Wk; Cw;Wfs; tpistpj;jitfspYk;> epyj;jb ePiu kl;Lk; cwpQ;rp tpisgtw;wpYk; gj;JrjtPjKk;> ePu; gha;r;rp tpistpf;fg;gl;ltw;wpy; Ie;J rjtPjKk; (]fhj;ij) egp(]y;) mtu;fs;eilKiwg;gLj;jpdhu;fs; vd;W ,g;D cku;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> e]aP> jpu;kpjP>mg+jh¥j;> ,g;Dkh[h

kioePhpy; tpise;jjw;F 10% vdTk; ePu; gha;r;rp tpisar; nra;gtw;wpy; 5** vdTk; ]fhj; flik jhd;vd;gjpy; re;Njfkpy;iy. Nkw;fz;l nra;jp mf;fUj;jpy; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;F Kuz;glTkpy;iyvd;gjpYk; re;Njfkpy;iy.

Mdhy; ,r;nra;jpapy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;s mit mjpfkhf ,Ug;gpDk; Fiwthf ,Ug;gpDk; vd;w thrfk;jhd; gpur;ridf;FhpaNj! ,e;j thrfg;gb tpisAk; nghUl;fspy; ,d;d msT ,Ue;jhy; jhd; ]fhj;flik vd;wpy;iy. vt;tsT tpisfpwNjh mJ Fiwthf ,Ug;gpDk; ]fhj; flik vd;W tpsq;fKbfpwJ.

mNjrkak; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fNsh tpisAk; nghUl;fspYk; msit epu;zapf;fpwJ.

Ie;J xl;lfq;fSf;F Fiwthdtw;wpy; ]fhj; ,y;iy. Ie;J CfpahTf;F Fiwthd (nts;spapy;)]fhj; ,y;iy. Ie;J t]f;if tpl Fiwthd (jhdpaj;)jpy; ]fhj; ,y;iy vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs;$wpajhf mg+]aPj; my;Fj;uP(uyp) mg+`{iuuh(uyp)> ,g;D cku;(uyp)> [hgpu;(uyp)> mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;Dmk;U(uyp) MfpNahu; mwptpf;fpd;wdu;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> jpu;kpjP

,e;j `jP]; jhdpa tiffspy; Ie;J t]f; ,Ue;jhy; jhd; ]fhj; flik vd;gij mwptpf;fpwJ. t]f;

vd;why; 60 ]hcthFk;. xU ]hc vd;gJ 51%3 uhj;jy; MFk;. Mf 300]hc(5t]f;) ,Ue;jhNy[fhj; flik vd;W Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; $WfpwJ.

Mdhy; ,e;j nra;jpNah Fiwthf ,Ug;gpDk; ]fhj; flik vd;fpwJ.

vdNt ,r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ jhd; vd;gjpy; re;Njfkpy;iy. ,e;j ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp jhd;`dgP kj;̀ Gf;F Mjhukhf cs;sJ vd;gijAk;> ,e;jr; nra;jpia xJf;fptpl;L 5 t]f; msitFwpg;gpLk; `jPi]Na mg+ `dPgh mtu;fspd; khztu; K`k;kj; mtu;fs; Mjhukhff; nfhs;fpwhu;fs;vd;gijAk; epidtpy; nfhs;f!

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

40 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Page 41: Weak hadiths in tamil

45. mwpthsp MfNtz;Lkh?

''my;yh`;tpw;fhf ehw;gJ ehl;fs; xUtu; xJf;fpdhy; mtd; ehtpy; mwptpd; Cw;Wfs; ntspg;gLk;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+ma;åg; my; md;rhuP(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;w ,r;nra;jp mg+eaPkpd;my;̀ py;ah vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; ,uz;lhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; kf;̀ {y; vd;gtu;> egpj;Njhou;mg+ma;åg; md;rhuP(uyp) mtu;fsplkpUe;J vijAk; nrtpAw;wjpy;iy vd ,g;Dy; [t;]P $Wfpd;whu;fs;.%d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsu; `[;[h[; vd;gtu; rhpapy;yhjtu;. NkYk; Ie;jhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; K`k;kJ ,g;D,];khaPy; vd;gtu; ahu; vd;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;. Råj;jp mtu;fs; ,r;nra;jpia fLikahfr; rhLfpd;whu;fs;.,jpypUe;J ,r;nra;jp jtwhdJ vd;gij tpsq;fyhk;.

,e;jj; jtwhd nra;jpia Mjhukhff; nfhz;L rpyu;> my;yh`;tpd; ghijapy; ehw;gJ ehs; thUq;fs;vd;W miof;fpd;whu;fs;. ,jw;F xU [py;yh vd;W ngaUk; itj;Js;sdu;. md;whlk; cioj;jhy; jhd;FLk;gj;ij ghJfhf;f KbAk; vd;w epiyapy; cs;stu;fisf; $l thu;j;ij [hyq;fshy; kaf;fp>jq;fs; fw;gid gazj;jpw;F mioj;Jr; nry;fpd;whu;fs;.

,jdhy; ghu;f;Fk; Ntiy Ngha;> nra;Ak; njhopy; erpe;J jd; FLk;gj;ij grp> gl;bdp vd;W Nghl;L tpl;LmiyAk; K];ypk;fs; cz;L. ,ij gpd;tUk; `jP]; fz;bf;fpwJ.

jhd; nghWg;gpy; cs;s egu;fis xUtd; ftdpf;fhky; ,Ug;gNj> mtd; ghtp vd;gjw;fhfr; rhd;whFk;vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpAs;shu;fs;. E}y;: mg+jh¥j;

vdNt xUtd; khu;f;f mwpTngw my;yJ rhjhuz mwpT ngw my;yJ nkQ;Qhdk; vd;w ngay; NghypmwpT ngw ehw;gJ ehl;fs; xJf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;w ek;gpf;if nfhs;s>Nkw;fz;l nra;jpia Mjhukhff;nfhs;s KbahJ.

46. ghtkd;dpg;Gf; fl;lhakhdjy;y!

''my;yh`; jd;id ftdpj;Jf; nfhz;bUf;fpd;whd; vd;gij czu;e;jtuhf ghtr; nraiy xUtu;nra;jhy;> mtu; ghtkd;dpg;Gf; Nfl;fhtpl;lhYk; mtiu my;yh`; kd;dpg;ghd;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D k];¥j;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp jg;uhdP(mt;]j;)y; cs;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D `puh]h vd;gtu; ngha;au; vd mg+jh¥j;$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tiug; ngha;au; vd NkYk; gy mwpQu;fSk; $Wfpd;wdu;. vdNt ,J gytPdkhd`jP]hFk;.

ehk; nra;Ak; ghtr; nraiy my;yh`; ftdpj;Jf; nfhz;bUf;fpd;whd; vd;gNj cz;ikahFk;. ,jpy;vtUk; khw;Wf; fUj;Jf; nfhs;skhl;lhu;. ,e;j tifapy; ghtk; nra;Ak; xU K];ypk;> ghtk;kd;dpf;fg;gl;ltdhf MfptpLfpd;whd;. ,ijNa Nkw;fz;l nra;jp $WfpwJ. Mdhy; K];ypk; xUtd;kWikapy; ghtpahf-Fw;wthspahf epw;ghd;. mtdpd; Fw;wr; nraYf;F Vw;g eufk; nry;thd; vdMjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; $Wfpd;wd.

mJkl;Lky;y ghtkd;dpg;Gf; Nfhu Ntz;bajpy;iy. mJ fl;lhaKk; ,y;iy vd;Wk; ,e;jr; nra;jp$WfpwJ.

(<khd; nfhz;l) tpRthrpfNs! my;yh`;tplk; fyg;gw;w Kiwapy; ghtkd;dpg;Gj; NjLq;fs;. (my;Fu;Md;66:8)

,jd; %yk; ghtkd;dpg;Gf; NfhUq;fs; vd my;yh`; fl;lisapLfpwhd;. egp(]y;) mtu;fSk; $l xUehisapy; 100 jlitf;F Nky; ghtkd;dpg;Gf; Nfhhp cs;shu;fs;. mtu;fs; Kd;-gpd; ghtq;fs; midj;Jkd;dpf;fg;gl;ltu;fs;. mtu;fNs ghtkd;dpg;Gf; Nfhhp cs;s NghJ> Fw;wr; nray; GhpAk; ehk; ghtkd;dpg;GNfhNa MfNtz;Lk; vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

41 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 42: Weak hadiths in tamil

my;yh`;tpd; Mizf;F khw;wkhf ,e;jr; nra;jp cs;sjhy; ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vdg; Ghpayhk;.

47. rpye;jpahf khw;wg;gl;l i\j;jhd;?

''rpye;jpg;g+r;rp i\j;jhdhFk;. my;yh`;jhd; i\j;jhid (rpye;jpg; g+r;rpahf) cUkhw;wpdhd;. vdNtmijf; nfhy;Yq;fs;!''

,t;thW egp(]y;) $wpajhf ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp ,g;D mjPapd; my;fhkpy;E}ypy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; k];ykh vd;gtd; midj;Jr;nra;jpfSk; NfhshWfs; cilaitNa vd ,ij gjpT nra;j ,g;D mjP mtu;fNs Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;.

''my;yh`; vij cUkhw;wpdhNdh> mjw;F tk;rhtopNah> Foe;ijfNsh tpl;L itf;ftpy;iy'' vd;Wegp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;Dk];¥j;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;

cUkhw;wk; nra;ag;gl;l ve;j capdj;jpw;Fk; thrpy;iy vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $Wk;NghJ rpye;jpg; g+r;rpcUkhw;wk; nra;ag;gl;bUf;Fkhdhy; mjw;F thR ,Uf;f tha;g;gpy;iy vd;whfptpLfpwJ. rpye;jpg;g+r;rpiacUkhw;wk; nra;jjhf ve;j xU Mjhuf; Fwpg;Gk; ,y;iy. mg;gbNa cUkhw;wk; nra;jJ cz;ik jhd;vd;gij Vw;Wf; nfhz;lhYk; khw;wg;gl;l rpye;jpNahL mJ xope;J tpLfpwJ. mjdhy; thRr; rpye;jpiaj; jUk; tha;g;gpy;iy vd;gjhy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha; vd tpsq;fyhk;.

Mdhy; rpye;jpg; g+r;rpiaf; nfhy;yf;$lhJ vd;W $WNthUk; cz;L. mjw;Fg; gpd;tUk; nra;jpiaMjhukhff; $Wthu;fs;.

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; `p[;uj; nra;jNghJ> ]t;u; vDk; Fifapy; xspe;jhu;fs;. vjphpfs; Fifapd; gf;fk;te;jdu;. mg;NghJ xU rpye;jpg;g+r;rp> Fif thapypy; tiy gpd;dpaJ. rpye;jp tiy mWglhky;cs;sijf; fz;l vjphpfs; cs;Ns vtUk; ,y;iy vd;W fUjp jpUk;gpr; nrd;wdu;. ,jdhy; jd;idg;ghJfhj;j rpye;jpiaf; nfhy;yf;$lhJ vd egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;.''

,Ug;gpDk; ,e;jr; nra;jpf;Fk; Mjhuk; ,y;iy. ,JTk; fw;gidNa. vdNt rpye;jpiaf; nfhy;yNth>nfhy;yhky; ,Ug;gNjh vd;w Miz vJTk; egp(]y;) mtu;fshy; gpwg;gpf;fg;gltpy;iy vd;gNj cz;ik!

48. ,ilj;jufu; ,y;iy!?

''xU $l;lj;jpw;F i\fhf ,Ug;gtu;> xU ck;kj;jpw;F mDg;gg;gl;l egpiag; Nghd;wtuhthu;.''

,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp ,g;D `pg;ghdpy; cs;sJ. ,jpy; ,lk; ngWk; mg;Jy;yh,g;D cku; ,g;D fh]pk; vd;gtu; gytPdu; vd ,g;D`pg;ghd; mtu;fNs $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; jhd;khypf;(u`;) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;ljhff; $Wfpd;wdu;. Mdhy; ,tu; mthplk; vijAk; Nfl;ljpy;iy vdTk;,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. `hgpo; ,g;D`[u; mtu;fSk; jkJ (j`;jPGj; j`;jPg;) E}ypy; ,J,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

gpw rKjhaj;jpypUe;J te;J ,];yhkpar; rKjhaj;jpdu; te;J Nru;e;j Neha;fspy; N\F-KuPJ vd;gJk;xd;whFk;. ,iwtdpd; Vn[z;l; vd xUtid kf;fs; ek;Gtu;. me;j ek;gg;gLk; Vn[z;ilNa N\Fvd;W miog;gu;.

,e;j N\F jd;id Vw;f tUNthUf;F jPl;ir toq;Fthu;. jPl;ir ngWk; egu;fs; KuPJ vd;Wmiof;fg;gLtu;. ,e;j N\Ffs; jq;fspd; KuPJfSf;F-rPlu;fSf;F Nghjpf;Fk; Nghjidapy;Fu;Md;-`jPi] ePq;fs; tpsq;fNt KbahJ. ntspg; nghUisj; jhd; ePq;fs; mwpayhk;. cs;nghUisehq;fNs tpsq;Fk; Mw;wy; ngw;wtu;fs; vd;W $Wtu;. ,ij ek;Gk; rPlu;fs; Fu;MidAk;-`jPi]Ak;jpwe;Nj ghu;f;f khl;lhu;fs;.

N\Ffspd; fhypy; tpOtu;. N\FfSf;F kiwthd Qhdk; cz;L vd ek;Gtu;. N\Ff;F njhpahky;vijAk; nra;a khl;lhu;fs;. kWikapy; jq;fis N\Ffs; nrhu;f;fj;jpy; Nru;g;ghu;fs;. N\Ffs;njhohky;> Nehd;G itf;fhky; ,Ug; gijNah> ngz;fsplk; jdpj;J ,Ug;gijNah Fiwahff;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

42 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 43: Weak hadiths in tamil

fUjkhl;lhu;fs;. ,Wjpapy; N\Ffis flTshf-flTspd; mtjhukhf-flTspd; Fzq;fisg; ngw;wtuhf-flTspd; Vn[z;lhf fUJk; kdepiyf;Fj; js;sg;gLthu;fs;.

ahNuDk; N\F gw;wpAk;> mJ gpj;jyhl;lk; vd;gJ gw;wpAk; njhpa Muk;gpj;J> ntspNawptplf; $lhJ vd;wNehf;fpy; $wg;gl;lJ jhd; Nkw;fz;l ngha;r;nra;jp.

N\F vd;w mugpr; nrhy;Yf;F 'Kjpatu;'> 'mwpQu;' vd;w mstpy; jhd; nghUs; nfhs;s KbANk jtpu>FU vd;W nghUs; nfhs;s KbahJ. xUNtis FU vd;Nw $wpdhYk; xU FUit egpf;Fr; rkkhffUjKbAkh? egp vDk; me;j];j;ij my;yh`; ehbatu; kl;LNk mila KbAk;. mJTk; egp(]y;)mtu;fSld; Kbe;Jtpl;lJ.

Nghypr; nra;jpia cUthf;fp> N\F vd;gtiu egpahf;fp Gjpa rpj;jhe;jk; xd;iw ,tu;fs;cUthf;fpaijj; jtpu NtW ve;jg; gaDk; ,e;jr; nra;jpahy; cUthftpy;iy vd;gij czu;e;J>Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd;gijAk; cs;sj;jpy; epiy ngwr; nra;Nthkhf!

49. muG kf;fis ntWf;fyhkh?

''Fiw\pfis Nerpg;gJ <khdhFk;. mtu;fis ntWg;gJ ,iw kWg;ghFk;. mNugpaiu Nerpg;gJ<khdhFk;. mtu;fis ntWg;gJ ,iwkWg;ghFk;. mugpfis tpUk;gpdhy; mtd; vd;idtpUk;gpatdhthd;. mugpfis ntWg;gtd; vd;id ntWj;jtd; Mthd;.''

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,ij md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. cifyP mtu;fs;> mo;O/`ghvDk; E}ypYk;> jg;uhdP mtu;fs; jdJ 'my;mt;]j;' vDk; E}ypYk; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; k`;fy; ,g;D khypf;> i`]k; ,g;D [k;kh]; MfpNahu; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sdu;.,jpy; k`;fy; vd;gtu; gytPdu; vd ,khk; j`gP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. NkYk; i`]k; vd;gtu; `jP]; JiwmwpQu;fshy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd;W j`gP mtu;fSk;> e]aP mtu;fSk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

md];(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf ]hgpj; vd;gtu; topahf i`]k; kl;Lk; jhd; $Wfpwhu; vd jg;uhdP$Wfpd;whu;fs;. i`]kpd; `jP];fs; rhpahdit my;y vd cifyP mtu;fs; $Wfpd; whu;fs;. ,tu;gytPdkhdtu; vd ,g;D KaPd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

mugpia tpl mugp my;yhjtNdh> mugp my;yhjtid tpl muG nkhop NgRgtNdh rpwe;jtd; ,y;iy vdegp(]y;) mtu;fs; kf;fh ntw;wpapd; NghJ> gpufldg;gLj;jpa Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; ,J khw;wkhfcs;sJ. vdNt ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd;W $WtNj rhpahFk;.

''mugpfis tpUk;GtJ <khdhFk;. mtu;fis Nfhgg;gLj;JtJ eatQ;rfkhFk;.''

,J egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; ngauhy; `hfpkpy; gjpT nra;ag; gl;Ls;sJ. ,e;j `jP]pYk; k`;fy; ,g;Dkhypf;> i`]k; ,g;D [k;kh]; Mfpa ,U gytPdu;fNs ,lk; ngw;Ws;sdu;.

Kdh/gpf; jdk; (eatQ;rfk;) vDk; Fzhjprak; <khd; nfhz;Ltpl;ljhf ebf;Fk; ,iwkWg;ghsu;fsplNk ,Uf;Fk;. ,e;j Kdh/gpf; jdk;> muG nkhop Ngrpa kf;fsplKk; ,Ue;jjhf `jP];fspy;fhz;fpNwhk;. Kdh/gpf;Ffspd; jiytd; mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D cig ,g;D rY}y; vd;gtd; mugp nkhopNgrpa mugp jhd;. muG nkhop NgRgtid ntWg;gJk;> Nfhgg;gLj;JtJk; jhd; Kdh/gpf; vd;why; muGnkhop NgRgtNd Kdh/gpf; vd;W vg;gbf; $wKbAk;? Kdh/gpf; jd;ikf;Fk;> nkhopf;Fk; rk;ge;jk;,y;iy vd;gNj cz;ik.

,J kl;Lky;y Kdh/gpf; ahu;? vd;gij gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{k; njspTgLj;JfpwJ.

''Kdh/gpf; (eatQ;rfdpd;) milahsk; %d;whFk;. Ngrpdhy; ngha; NgRthd;. thf;FWjp je;jhy;khWgLthd;. ek;gpdhy; Nkhrb nra;thd;'' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lit vd;gJ tpsq;Fk;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

43 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 44: Weak hadiths in tamil

50. ghu;rp nkhop rpwe;jjh?

''my;yh`;tpd; mu;i\r; Rw;wpAs;s (J}a;ik kpFe;j thd)tu;fspd; nkhop ghu;rp nkhopahFk;. my;yh`;,yFthd tp\aj;ij nrhy;y ehbdhy; ghu;rp nkhopapy; t`P mwptpg;ghd;. f\;lkhd tp\aj;ijr;nrhy;y ehbdhy; mugp nkhopapy; t`P mwptpg;ghd;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ckhkh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.

,e;j `jP]py; [`;gu; ,g;D [{igu; my;̀ dgP vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpd;whu;. ,tiug; gw;wp Fd;Ju;mtu;fs; $Wk;NghJ ]Pg< vd;gtu; fOij xd;wpy; gazk; nra;J nfhz;bUe;jhu;. mthplk; ePq;fs; vq;Nfnry;fpwPu;fs;? vd;W Nfl;Nld;. mjw;F mtu;fs; [`;gu; ,g;D [{igu; vd;gtd; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kPJ400 `jP];fis ,l;Lf; fl;bAs; shdhk;. mtdplk; rz;ilaplg; NghfpNwd; vd;W $wpdhu;fs; vdf;Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

',e;j egd; `jP]; vwpag;gl Ntz;Lk;' vd mg+]u;M $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',td; `jPi] vLj;Jf;nfhs;sNt $lhJ' vd ,khk; e]aP> jhuFj;dP MfpNahu; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',td; ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtd;' vd,g;D`pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

,NjNghy; m`;kj;> a`;$g;> ,g;D R/g;ahd;> ,g;D mjP mg+eaPk;> ,g;Dy; kj;adP> mg+jh¥j;> myP ,g;D[{d;Jg;> a`;ah MfpNahUk; ,e;j egiuf; fLikahf tpku;rpf;fpwhu;fs;. vdNt ,e;j `jP];gytPdkhd-,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahFk;.

xt;nthU J}jiuAk; mtd; r%fj;jhUf;F mtu; tpsf;fpf; $Wtjw;fhf mtu;fSf;Fhpa nkhopapNyNa ehk;mDg;gp itj;Njhk;. (my;Fu;Md; 14:4)

mjhtJ vy;yh nkhop NgRk; egu;fSf;Fk; me;j me;j nkhop NgRk; egpkhu;fs; J}ju;fshf te;Js;sdu;vd;gijNa ,e;j trdk; $Wfpd;wJ. ,e;j tifapy; mugp nkhop Ngrpa kf;fsplk; mugp nkhop Ngrpaegp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,iwj; J}juhf mDg;gg;gl;lhu;fs;. ,jdhy; muG nkhopapNyNa ,iwr; nra;jpte;jpUf;f Ntz;Lk;.

egp(]y;) mtu;fNshL ,iwj;J}ju; nghWg;G Kw;Wg; ngWtjhYk;> mtu;fNs vy;yh nkhop NgRk;kf;fSf;Fk; nghJthd ,iwj;J}ju; vd;gjhYk; cyfk; KOJk; cs;s Fu;Md; %ynkhopahd mugpnkhopapNyNa cs;sJ. ghu;rp nkhopapy; ,wq;fp ,Ue;jhy; ghu;rp nkhop trdk; vq;Nf vd;w Nfs;tp vOk;.,jpypUe;Nj Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha; vd;W tpsq;fyhk;.

mugp nkhopapy; Fu;Md; cs;sjhy; mugpnkhopf;Fj; jdpr; rpwg;G vd;gJk; fpilahJ vd;gijAk; Ghpe;Jnfhs;s Ntz;Lk;.

vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l ngha; vd;gJ Cu;[pjkhfpwJ.

51. mugp jhd; nrhu;f;f nkhopah?

''my;yh`;tpw;F Nfhgkhd nkhop ghu;rpahFk;. ghu;rp nkhop i\j;jhdpd; nkhopahFk;. nrhu;f;f nkhopmugpahFk;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,e;j `jP]py; ,g;D]pahj; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpd;whu;.

',td; j[;[hy; Nghy; ngha; $Wk; fpotd;. ,tidg; gw;wp Fiw $whky; ve;j E}Yk; vOjf;$lhJ'vd;W ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tdJ `jP]; epuhff;fg;gl Ntz;Lk;' vd;W ,g;D mjP$Wfpd;whu;fs;.

ghu;rp nkhopiag; gpbf;fhj xU mNugpad; ,ij ,l;Lf; fl;bapUf;f Ntz;Lk;. my;yh`;tplk;cUtj;jhNyh> nkhopahNyh> md;igNah> Nfhgj;ijNah xUtd; mile;J nfhs;s KbahJ vd;gNjepiy.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

44 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 45: Weak hadiths in tamil

my;yh`;tplk; cq;fspy; rpwe;jtu;> cq;fspy; ,iwar;r Kilatu;fs; jhd;. (my;Fu;Md; 49:13)

,iwar;r czu;T cs;std; kl;LNk ,iwad;igg; ngw KbAk; vd jpUf;Fu;Md; $Wk;NghJ> mugpnkhopNgrpatd; rpwe;jtd; vd;Wk;> mk;nkhop nrhu;f;f nkhop vd;Wk; $WtJ mgj;jkhFk;.

nrhu;f;fj;jpy; cyfk; Njhd;wpaJ Kjy; mopAk; tiu ,Ue;j kf;fspy; gyu; ,Ug;gu;. mtu;fspy; gy;NtWnkhop NgRk; kf;fSk; ,Ug;gu;. mtutu; njhpe;j nkhopapy; jq;fSf;fpilNa Ngrpf; nfhs;tu; vd;gJ jhd;rhpahf ,Uf;f KbAk;. muG nkhopNa nghJ nkhop vd ve;j xU Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpAk; ,y;iy.vdNt mugp nrhu;f;fthrpfspd; nkhop vd;gJk; mgj;jNkahFk;.

%]htpw;F Ntjj;ijf; nfhLj;Njhk;. mt;Ntjj;jpy; gD} ,];uNtyu;fSf;F Neu;topia itj;Js;Nshk;.(my;Fu;Md; 3:4)

muGk;> ghu;]pAk; my;yhj nkhopapy; toq;fg;gl;l jt;uhj; Ntjk; ,wq;fpa nkhop Nkhrk; vd;W $wKbAkh?,ju egpkhu;fs; Ngrpa nkhopfisj; jhd; Nkhrk; vd;W $w KbAkh? vdNt nkhopf;F vd jdpr;rpwg;GVJk; ,y;iy vd;gJ cz;ik!

Mifahy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp> ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l ngha;r; nra;jp vd;gJ cWjpahfpd;wJ.

52. tpahghhpAk; tptrhapAk; nfl;ltu;fsh?

''kdpju;fspy; nfl;ltu;fs; tpahghhpAk;> tptrhapAk; jhd;.''

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,t;thW $wpajhf md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp 'kt;@Mj;' vDk; jdJE}ypy; ,g;Dy; [t;]P gjpT nra;Js;shu;.

,r;nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ahnud;Nw njhpahj gyu; ,lk; ngWfpd;wdu;. ,J egp(]y;)mtu;fspd; ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd ,g;Dy; [t;]P> Råj;jp MfpNahu; Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;.

''xU K];ypk; kuj;ij el;L my;yJ (VNjDk; gapiu) tptrhak; nra;J> mjpypUe;J gwitNah>kdpjNdh> tpyq;fpdNkh rhg;gpl;Ltpl;lhy; mJ mtd; nra;j ju;kkhf (fzf;fply;) MFk;'' vd egp(]y;)$wpdhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

''epyk; itj;jpUg;gtu;> mjpy; tptrhak; nra;al;Lk;'' vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP

Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fspy; tptrhak; nra;tJ gw;wp egp(]y;) mtu;fs; typAWj;jpAs;sdu;. tptrhapfshfgy egpj;Njhou;fs; ,Ue;Js;sdu;. ,JNghy; egp(]y;) mtu;fNs tpahghuk; nra;Js;shu;fs;.egpj;Njhou;fspy; gyu; tpahghhp fshf> ngUk; tzpfuhf ,Ue;Js;sdu;. nrhu;f;fthjp vd milahsk;fhl;lg;gl;l mg;Ju;u`;khd; ,g;D mt;/G (uyp) mtu;fSk; $l xU ngUk; tzpfNu!

vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jpapy; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirf; FsWgbfSk;> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpfSf;FKuz;ghLk; cs;sJ. vdNt ,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahfpwJ. ,J gytPdkhd nra;jp vd;gij tplegp(]y;) mtu;fspd; ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd;W $WtNj rhpahFk;.

53. egp(]y;) mtu;fis Nehpy; re;jpj;j ed;ik ngw...

''ehd; ,we;jg; gpd; xUtu; `[; nra;a te;J> vd; fg;iu ]pahuj; nra;jhy;> mtu; vd;id capUld;(Nehpy;) re;jpj;jtu; Nghyhthu;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; nra;jp> jg;uhdP(fgPu;> mt;]j;>]fPu;) kw;Wk; jhuFj;dP> ig`fP> ,g;D mjP(fhkpy;) Mfpa E}w;fspy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

,r;nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsu; iy]; ,g;D mg+Riyk; vd;gtu;%is Fok;gpatu; Mthu;. ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; `g;]; ,g;D Riykhd; vd;gtu; ngUk; ngha;au; vd;W,e;j `jPi] gjpT nra;Js;s ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. `g;]; `jPi] ,l;Lf;fl;Lk; egu;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

45 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 46: Weak hadiths in tamil

vd ,g;Dy; fuh]; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. NkYk; ,tu; gytPdu; vd jg;uhdP> ig`fP MfpNahUk;$Wfpd;whu;fs;. vdNt ,J Mjhukw;w nra;jpahFk;.

Mdhy; ,ij Mjhukhff; nfhz;L rpyu; `[;[{f;Fr; nrd;Wtpl;L kjPdh nry;fpd;whu;fs;. kjPdhtpy;mlf;fk; nra;ag;gl;Ls;s egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; fg;iu ]pahuj; nra;fpd;whu;fs;. ,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd`jP]{f;F khw;wkhf Tk; cs;sJ.

%d;W gs;spthrYf;Nf jtpu NtW vq;Fk; (ed;ikia ehb) gazk; Gwg;glf;$lhJ. 1) k];[pJy; `uhk;2) vdJ ,e;jg; gs;spthry; 3) k];[pJy; mf;]h vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> e]aP

ed;ik fpilf;Fk; vd;w ngaYk; egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; fg;iu ]pahuj; nra;jhy; mtu;fis Nehpy; re;jpj;jed;ik fpilf;Fk; vd;w ngaYk; ,JNghd;w gazk; Nkw;nfhs;tJ $lhJ vd;gijNa Mjhug;g+u;tkhd`jP]; $Wfpd;wJ.

`[;[{ nra;Jtpl;L> kjPdh gs;spapy; njhOjhy; mjpf ed;ik cz;L vd;w ngay; jhd; kjPdh nry;yNtz;LNk jtpu kjPdhtpy; egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; fg;iu [pahuj; nra;a gazpj;jy; vd;w ngay; gazk;nry;tJ $lhJ.

54. K`k;kJk;> K`k;kjpd; je;ijAk; nrhu;f;fk; nry;tu;?

''xUtUf;F Foe;ij gpwe;J> mjw;F guf;fj;ij ehb mtu; K`k;kj; vd;W ngahpl;lhy; mtUk;> mtd;Foe;ijAk; nrhu;f;fj;jpy; ,Ug;ghu;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ckhkh(uyp) mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp> ,g;D Gifu; mtu;fspd;'/go;Y ,];K`{ m`;kj;> K`k;kj;' vDk; E}ypy; cs;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; `hkpj; ,g;D K`k;kj; vd;gtu; VohtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWfpd;whu;.,tu; ,];̀ hf; ,g;D a]hu; topahf ,ij mwptpf;fpd;whu;. ,];̀ hf; topahf `hkpj; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lnra;jpfis mwptpg;ghu; vd;W j`gP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,g;D ifåk; mtu;fs; ,J jtwhd nra;jp vd;W$Wfpd;whu;fs;.

ngaLtjd; Nehf;fk;> kdpju;fs; xUtUf;nfhUtu; mwpKfk; nra;J nfhs;sj;jhd;. ,ijAk; ,r;nra;jpgho;gLj;J fpwJ. vy;NyhUk; K`k;kj; vd;w ngay; ,Ue;jhy;> vg;gb mwpKfk; nra;J nfhs;tJ?,jpypUe;J ,J ngha;r; nra;jp vdmwpayhk;.

K`k;kj; vd ngau; cs;stUk;> mtUf;F itj;j mtd; je;ijAk; K`k;kj; vd;w ngaUf;fhfNtnrhu;f;fk; nry;thu; vd;Wk; ,r;nra;jp $WfpwJ. ,jdhy; K`k;kj; vd;W ngaUs;stu; ve;j ew;nraYk;nra;a Ntz;bajpy;iy. Vd;? mtd; je;ijAk; $l ew;nray; nra;a Ntz;bajpy;iy vd;whfptpLfpd;wJ.

<khd; nfhz;L ew;nray; nra;fpwtu;fs; jhd; nrhu;f;f thrpfshtu;. mtu;fs; mjpNy epue;jukhf,Ug;ghu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 2:82)

FUlDk;> ghu;it cs;stDk; rkkhfkhl;lhu;fs;. (mt;thNw <khd; nfhz;L) ew;nray; nra;NjhUk;>jPNahUk; (rkkhf khl;lhu;fs;). kpff; FiwthfNt ePq;fs; rpe;jpf;fpwPu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 40:58)

'epr;rakhf my;yh`; cq;fspd; cliyNah> ciliaNah ghu;g;gjpy;iy. cq;fspd; cs;sq;fisAk;>nray;fisANk ghu;f;fpwhd;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.E}y;: K];ypk;

ew;nray; nra;jhy; jhd; nrhu;f;fk; fpilf;Fk; vd;W trdq;fs; kw;Wk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; $Wk;NghJ K`k;kj; vd;W ngau; cs;sjhNyNa Rtu;f;fk; nry;yyhk; vd;gJ vt;tsT nghpa Kuz;!

egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; ngau; K`k;kj; MFk;. Mdhy; mtu;fSf;F ngahpl;L kfpo;e;j mtd; jhNah> nghpaje;ijNah> ghl;ldhNuh Vd;? gpwf;Fk; Kd; ,we;j je;ijNah nrhu;f;fthrpfs; my;yu; vd;gJ jhd;cz;ikahFk;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

46 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 47: Weak hadiths in tamil

vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp Gide;j nra;jp vd;gNj cz;ik.

55. egp(]y;) ,Wjp egpah? ,y;iyah?

''ehd; egpkhu;fspy; ,Wjpahdtd;. vdf;Fg; gpd; ve;j egpAk; ,y;iy. my;yh`; ehbdhNy jtpu.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md];(uyp) mwptpf;Fk; nra;jpia ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fs; jdJkt;@Mj; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghs uhf K`k;kJ ,g;D ]aPj; m\;\hkP vd;gtu; ,lk;ngWfpd;whu;. ,tu; ']dhjpfh' nfhs;ifAilatuhf ,Ue;j jhy; ,tiu mg+[`;/gu; nfhiy nra;jhu;fs;vd;Wk; ,tu; ,l;Lf; fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpfis mwptpg;gtu; vd;Wk; ,khk; m`;kj; ,g;D `d;gy;$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu;> ]dhjpfh nfhs;if fhuzkhf rpYitapy; miwag;gl;lhu;' vd ,khk; GfhuP$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tuJ `jP];fs; Gwf;fzpf;fg;gl Ntz;bait vd mg+]u;M $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;Fg; gpd; egp fpilahJ vd;gJ ,];yhkpaf; nfhs;if ,e;jf; nfhs;ifiacWjpg;gLj;Jk trdq;fSk;> `jP];fSk; Vuhskha; cs;sd.

...vdpDk; K`k;kj; my;yh`;tpd; J}juhfTk; egpkhu; fspd; ,WjpahdtuhfTk; cs;shu;. (my;Fu;Md;33:40)

''vd; rKjhaj;jpy; rpy $l;lj;jpdu; ,iz itg;gtu; fSld; NrUthu;fs;. rpiyfisAk; $ltzq;Fthu;fs;. NkYk; vd; rKjhaj;jpy; Kg;gJ ngha;au;fs; Njhd;Wthu;fs;. ,tu;fs; midtUk;jd;id egp vd;Nw thjpLthu;fs;. ,e;j epiy Vw;gLk; tiu kWik ehs; tuhJ. ehd; jhd; ,Wjp egp.vdf;Fg; gpd; egp fpilahJ'' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf ]t;ghd;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> jpu;kpjP

''gD} ,];uNtyu;fsplkpUe;J njhlu;e;J egpkhu;fs; tUgtu;fshf ,Ue;jhu;fs;. xU egp ,we;Jtpl;lhy;mjw;Fg; gfukhf ,d;ndhU egp tUthu;. Mdhy; vdf;Fg; gpd;dhy; ve;j egpAk; fpilahJ'' vdegp(]y;) $wpajhf mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

,e;j trdk; kw;Wk; `jP];fs; egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;Fg; gpd; egpNa fpilahJ vd;W njhpspthfmwptpf;fpd;wd. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jpapy; 'my;yh`; ehbdhNy jtpu' vd;w thu;j;ij jpl;lkpl;LGide;jjhFk;.

,jdhy; jhd; rpyu; jq;fis egp vd;W thjpl;ldu;. Mdhy; ,tu;fspd; thjk; vLglhky; NghdJvd;gNj cz;ik. fhjpahdp kjj;ijr; Nru;e;NjhUk; ,ijNa Mjhu khff; nfhz;Ls;sdu;.

Mdhy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jhd; ,Wjp egp vd;gjpy; vs;Kid mstpw;Fk; re;Njfkpy;iy. vdNtNkw;fz;l nra;jp ''Gide;jJ. ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ'' vd;gNj cz;ikahFk;.

56. gpufhrpf;Fk; ,Us;?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> ntspr;rj;jpy; ghu;g;gijg; Nghy; ,UspYk; (,Uf;Fk; nghUl;fisj; njspthfg;)ghu;g;ghu;fs;.''

,t;thW Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; nra;jpia ,khk; ig`fP jdJ 'jyhapYd;DGth' E}ypy; gjpTnra;Js;shu;fs;. ,g;D mjP mtu;fspd; E}ypYk; cs;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; gytPdk; cs;sJ vd ,ijg; gjpT nra;j ,khk; ig`fP mtu;fNs $wTk;nra;fpd;whu;fs;. ,jpy; Ie;jhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf mg;Jy;yh ,g;D KfPuh ,lk; ngWfpd;whu;. ',tu;mbg;gilaw;w nra;jpfis mwptpg;gtu;' vd cifyP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',td; `jP];fs; kWf;fg;glNtz;bait' vd ,g;DåD]; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ' vd j`gP $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; MwhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf Kmy;yh ,g;D`pyhy; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpd;whu;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

47 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 48: Weak hadiths in tamil

,td; `jP];fs; iftplg; glNtz;bait vd ,khk; GfhuP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; ngha;au;fspy;gpugy;akhdtu; vd ,khk; KaPd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; ,l;Lf;fl;bf; $Wgtu; vd ,khk; e]aP$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,JNghyNt jhuFj;dP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; ek;gpf;ifahd egu;fspd; ngaiug;gad;gLj;jp ,l;Lfl;lg;gl;l nra;jpfisf; $Wgtu; vd;W ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

Nkw;fz;l nra;jp NghyNt ,g;D m]hfpu; E}ypYk; NtW mwptpg;ghsu; thpirAld; xU nra;jp,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ. mjpYk; FsWgb epiwe;j> Kftaw;w mwptpg;ghsu;fs; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sdu;.

,e;jr; nra;jpapy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,Ul;Lg; gFjpapy; nrd;why; me;j ,lNk gpufhrpj;J tpLk; vd;gJNghy; $wg;gLfpd;wJ. Mdhy; ,jw;F Neu; khw;wkhd nra;jpia gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];$Wfpd;wJ.

ehd; xU ehs; ,uT ntspNa nrd;Nwd;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jdpNa ele;J nrd;Wnfhz;bUe;jhu;fs;. (re;jpu xspapdhy; Vw;gl;l mtu;fspd; gpk;g) epoypd; gpd;dhy; ehd; ele;J nrd;Nwd;.mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jpUk;gp vd;idg; ghu;j;J tpl;L> ,J ahu;? vd;W Nfl;lhu;fs;. ehd; mg+ju;vd;Nwd;. ,ij mg+ju;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

jd; mUNf ,Uspy; ele;J te;j jd; Njhou; mg+ju;(uyp) mtu;fis ,Uspd; fhuzkhf ahu; vdj;njhpahky; ahu; mJ vd;W Nfl;l gpwNf tpsq;fpAs;shu;fs; vd;W ,e;j `jP]; $WfpwJ. ',Us;xspahFk;> me;j xspapy; ghu;g;ghu;fs;' vd;gJ ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd;gJ cWjpahfpd;wJ.

57. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; VO Jzpfshy; fgdplg;gl;lhu;fsh?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;F VO Jzpfshy; fgdplg;gl;lJ.''

,r;nra;jpapy; myP(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L m`;kj;> ,g;D mgP i\gh> ,g;D mjP> g];]hu; MfpaE}w;fspy; cs;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf mg;Jy;yh ,g;D K`k;kJ ,g;D mfPy; vd;gtu;,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,td; `jP];fs; Gwf;fzpf;fg;gl Ntz;Lk; vd ,khk; m`;kj; ,g;D `k;gy; (u`;)$Wfpwhu;fs;. ,td; `jP];fis Mjhukhff; nfhs;sf;$lhJ vd;W ,g;DKaPd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ehd;Fegu;fspd; `jP];fs; iftplg;gl Ntz;bait. ,e;j ehd;fpy; ,tUk; xUtu; jhd; vd ,g;D ciadh$Wfpwhu;fs;.

`jP];fis mwptpg;gjpy; ,g;D mfPy; cq;fSf;F tpUg;gkhdtuh? M]pk; ,g;D cigJy;yh`;th? vd;W,g;D KaPd; mtu;fsplk; ehd; Nfl;Nld;. ,UtiuAk; ehd; tpUk;Gtjpy;iy vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs; vd,khk; K];ypk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

'',tu;> mwptpg;ghsu; thpirfis Kuz;gl;Lf; $Wthu;'' vd mg+]u;M $Wfpwhu;fs;. ',tuhy;mwptpf;fg;gLgtw;wpy; ngUk;ghyhdit E}jdkhf ,Uf;Fk;' vd [Pu;[hdp $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu;epidthw;wy; ,y;yhjtu;' vd fjPg; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu; gytPdu;' vd mg+`hjk;> ,khk; e]aP$Wfpd;whu;fs;.

,g;gb ,jd; %d;whk; mwptpg;ghsu; `jP]; Jiwapduhy; fLikahf tpku;rpf;fg;gLtjhy; ,JgytPdkhtNjhL> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; Kuz;gLfpwJ.

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vkd; ehl;ilr; Nru;e;j kpUJthd %d;W Jzpfshy; fgdplg;gl;lhu;fs;. mjpy;rl;ilNah> jiyg;ghifNah ,y;iy vd Map\h(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> e]aP

vdNt VO Jzpfshy; fgdplg;gl;ljhf tUk; nra;jp rhpahdjy;y.

58. ]`u; Neuk; vJtiu?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ve;j Neuj;jpy; ]`u; nra;tPu;fs; vd `{ijgh(uyp) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;Nlhk;.#hpad; cjpg;gjw;F Kd; fhiy Ntisapy; vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;.''

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

48 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 49: Weak hadiths in tamil

]u;,g;D i[]; mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp e]aP E}ypy; ,lk;ngWfpwJ.

,jd; ,uz;lhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk; M]pk; ,g;D g`;jyh vd;gtu; gw;wp ,g;D ]`;J mtu;fs;$Wk;NghJ ',tu; ey;ytu; jhd;. MdhYk; `jP]py; mjpfk; jtW nra;gtu;' vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.a`;$g; ,g;D Rg;ahd; mtu;fNsh ,td; `jP];fs; FsWgb cs;sit vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. ',tu; Qhgfrf;jpapy; Nkhrkhdtu;' vd mg+]u;M $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,td; `jP];fspy; Gwf;fzpf;fg;gl Ntz;baitcs;sd vd ,g;D fuh]; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu; jd; tho;ehspd; ,Wjpapy; %is Fok;gpatu;' vd`k;khj; ,g;D ]ykh $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,td; kdd rf;jp FiwthdJ vd jhuFj;dP $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

,tu; gw;wp tpku;rdk; rhpapy;yhjjhYk;> Mjhug; g+u;tkhd Fu;Md; trdj;jpw;Fk; egpnkhopf;Fk; khw;wkhfcs;sjhYk; ,r;nra;jp gytPdg;gl;L tpLfpwJ.

g[;hpy; nts;isf; fapW fUg;Gf; fapiw tpl;Lk; (,uit tpl;Lk; mjpfhiy fpof;fpd; nts;is) cq;fSf;FnjspthFk; tiu cz;Zq;fs;. gUFq;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 2:187)

ehq;fs; egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ]`u; nra;Nthk;. gpwF (g[;u;) njhOiff;Fr; nry;Nthk; vd i]j;,g;D ]hgpj; (uyp) $wpdhu;fs;. ,uz;Lf;Fk; kj;jpapy; vt;tsT NeukpUf;Fk;? vdf; Nfl;Nld;. ehd;Ik;gJ trdq;fs; (XJk; msT) vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;:GfhuP> jpu;kpjP

]`u; vd;gJ g[;Uj; njhOiff;Fk; Kd;G vd;wpUf;Fk;NghJ g[;Uf;Fg; gpd; vd;W $WtJ ngha; vdtpsq;fyhk;.

59. nts;is epwr; Nrtiy cz;zhjPu;?

''nts;isr; NrtYf;F ePq;fs; fz;zpak; mspAq;fs;. Vnddpy; mJ vdf;Fj; NjhodhFk;. my;yh`;tpd;giftDf;Fk; (i\j;jhDf;Fk;) giftdhFk;. nts;isr; Nrty; ,Uf;Fk; ve;j tPl;ilAk; i\j;jhNdh#dpak; nra;gtNdh neUq;fkhl;lhu;fs;.''

,J egp(]y;) mtu;fshy; $wg;gl;L> md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fg;gl;L 'ig]y;' vDk; jdJ E}ypy;`h]pkP gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; Kmy;yy; ,g;D Gify; mtu;fSk;> Ie;jhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; \{/g;ghk;vd;gtUk; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;fs; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsu; K`k;kJ ,g;D K`;]pd; vd;gtd;je;ij ngau; ,];̀ hf; vd;gjhFk;. ,td; jhj;jh ngau; jhd; K`;]pd;. ,Ug;gpDk; jhj;jh(ghl;ldhu;)ngaNyNa ,izj;J miof;fg;gLfpwhu;. ,e;j K`k;kJ ,g;D K`;]pd; vd;gtu; ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu; vdjhuFj;dP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ',e;j egu; ngha;au;' vd i`]kP $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

,e;j ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp %yk;> nts;isr; Nrtiy mWj;J cz;zf; $lhJ vd;gJ Nghy; GhpaKbfpwJ. ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lf; $ba eguhy; Gide;j nra;jp vd;gjhy;> ,ij eilKiwg;gLj;jNtz;bajpy;iy. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; ,J Kuz;gl;Lk; cs;sJ.

kpUfq;fspy; tp\g;gw;fs; cs;sij cz;zTk;> gwitapy; $a efk; cs;sij cz;zTk; egp(]y;)mtu;fs; jil nra;jhu;fs; vd ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

Nrty; vd;gJ Nfhop ,dkhFk;. Nfhop gwit ,dk; vd;gjhy; $a efk; ,Ue;jhy; kl;LNkrhg;gplf;$lhJ. $a efk; ,Ue;J jd; fhyhy; kpjpj;J cz;Zk; gof;fk; cs;sjy;y Nfhop. vdNtNfhopiaAk; mjd; Mz; ,dkhd NrtiyAk; cz;zj; jilapy;iy. Nfhopia egp(]y;) mtu;fs;rhg;gpl;Ls;sjhf `jP]; $WfpwJ.

''ehd; mg+%]h(uyp) mtu;fsplk; te;Njd;. mtu; Nfhop rhg;gpl;Lf; nfhz;bUe;jhu;. mg;NghJ> mtu; 'ePAk;,ij rhg;gpL!' egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfhopiar; rhg;gpLtij ehd; ghu;j;Js;Nsd;'' vd;W $wpdhu;fs; vd]`;jkpy; [u;kpa;aP vd;gtu; $Wfpwhu;fs;. E}y;: jpu;kpjP

Nfhop tif cz;zyhk; vd;gjpypUe;Jk;> nts;isr; Nrtiy kl;Lk; cz;zf;$lhJ vd;w tpjptpyf;FMjhug;g+u;t khd `jP];fspy; ,y;iy vd;gjhYk; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha; vd tpsq;fyhk;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

49 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 50: Weak hadiths in tamil

60. ghtpfSld; Nru;e;Jz;zy;!?

''ghtq;fs; kd;dpf;fg;gl;l xUtDld; Nru;e;J (mku;e;J) xUtd; rhg;gpl;lhy; mtDk;kd;dpf;fg;gLthd;.''

,r;nra;jpia mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapd;wp rpy E}w;fspy; gjpthfpAs;sJ. ,ij cWjpg;gLj;j gpd;tUk;Jizr; nra;jpAk; cs;sJ.

xU ey;ybahu; egp(]y;) mtu;fisj; jd; fdtpy; fz;lhu;. '',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! (Nkw;fz;lthW)ePq;fs; $wpdPu;fsh?'' vd;W Nfl;lhu;. ehd; ,g;gbf; $wNt ,y;iy. MdhYk; ,g;NghJ ,ijf;$WfpNwd; vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;.

eh]pUj;jPd; my;ghdP mtu;fs; jd;> 'my;m`hjP]{y; saP/gh> ty;kt;@M' vDk; E}ypy; 315tJ `jP]hfgjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd ,g;D `[u;> ,g;Dy; fa;apk; MfpNahu;Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;.

mjhtJ ,r;nra;jpapd; fUj;J Fw;wthspfSld; ghtpfSld; Nru;e;J cz;gJ $lhJ vd;gJ jhd;.,J rhj;jpakhFkh?

,iw kWg;ghsu;fSf;F cjhuzkhf E}`pd; kidtpiaAk;> Y}j;jpd; kidtpiaAk; my;yh`;Vw;gLj;jpAs;shd;. ,e;j ,UtUk; ek; ey;y mbahu;fspy; ,U ey;ybahu;fspd; kidtpauhf ,Ue;jdu;.MdhYk; ,e;j ,UtUk; jq;fspd; fztUf;F Nkhrk; nra;jdu;. (my;Fu;Md; 66:10)

egpkhu;fspd; kidtpau; ,iwkWg;ghsu;fshf-ghtpfshf-Fw;wk; nra;gtu;fshf ,Ue;Js;sdu;. ,tu;fSld;,Ue;jNghJ egpkhu;fs; mtu;fSld; Nru;e;Jz;Zk; epiy Vw;gl;bUf;Fk;. Fw;wkw;wtu;fSld; Nru;e;Jz;zNtz;Lk; vd;wpUf;Fkhdhy; ,tu;fSf;Fk; mJ nghUe;Jk; jhNd!

Ke;ija egpkhu;fSf;F ,J flikapy;yhky; ,Ue;jp Uf;fyhk;. ekf;F ,J flikahf ,Uf;fyhNkvd;w Nfs;tp voyhk;. ,jw;F gpd;tUk; trdk; gjpyhf mikfpwJ.

ePu; mwpahj xd;iw vdf;F ,iz itf;f cd;id (cd; ngw;Nwhu;) epu;g;ge;jk; nra;jhy;> me;j,UtUf;Fk; fl;Lg; glhNj! (Mdhy; kw;w fhhpaq;fspy;) mtu;fSld; ,t;Tyfpy; ey;ytpjkhf ,U!(my;Fu;Md; 31:15)

ngw;Nwhu; ,iz itg;Nghuhf> ,iz itf;fj; J}z;LNthuhf - Fw;wk; nra;gtu;fshf ,Ue;jhy; mjpy;kl;Lk; mtu;fSf;F fl;Lg;glhNj! ,ju fhhpaq;fspy; (cz;gJ cl;gl) ,ize;J ,zf;fkhf tho; vd,t;trdk; $WfpwJ.

'Fw;wthspfshf cs;s ngw;NwhUf;F cztspj;jhYk;> Nru;j;Jz;zhNj' vd;W $wpapUf;f Ntz;Lk;.Fw;wthspapd; Fw;wj;jpy; gq;Nfw;ff;$lhJ vd;gJ jhd; flikNa jtpu> Fw;wthspAld; gofNt $lhJvd;W ,];yhk; $wNt ,y;iy.

NkYk; xUtid Fw;wthsp vd;Nwh> Fw;wkw;wtd; vd;Nwh ehk; Ghpe;J nfhs;s KbahJ. ,d;W Fw;wk;nra;gtd; ehis ey;ytdhf Mfyhk;. ey;ytd;> Fw;wthspahf khwyhk;. ek; fz; Kd; Fw;wthsp Nghy;njhpe;jtd; my;yh`;tplk; cau;e;jtdhf Mfptplyhk;. Fw;wthsp> Fw;wkw;wtd; vd;gij mwpe;jtd;my;yh`; kl;Lk; jhd;. ,ijAk; $l xUtd; epiy gw;wp kWikapy; jhd; ehk; njhpe;J nfhs;s KbAk;.

vdNt ghtq;fs; nra;ahjtd; vd vtiuf; $w KbAk;? ,jpypUe;Jk; $l ,r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJvd;gJ GhpAk;. ,r;nra;jpia fdtpy; cWjpg;gLj;jpa ey;ybahu; ahu;? tpguk; ,y;iy. egp(]y;) mtu;fisNehpy; fz;ltu; kl;LNk fdtpYk; fhzKbAk; vd;gJ rl;lk;. egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; xU ey;ybahu;fz;ljhf $WtJk; ngha;!

epiwT nra;ag;gl;l ,];yhj;jpy; FiwT ,Ue;jJ NghyTk;> ,e;jf; Fiwia gpd;du; egp(]y;) mtu;fs;rhp nra;jJ NghyTk; ,e;jf; fdtpd; fUj;J mikfpwJ. ,J egp(]y;) mtu;fisFiwTgLj;JtjhfNt mikfpwJ. vdNt ,e;j nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;gjpy; re;Njfkpy;iy.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

50 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 51: Weak hadiths in tamil

61. ukshdpy; Vw;gLk; fLk; rg;jk;?

''ukshd; khjj;jpy; (fLikahd) rg;jk; Vw;gLk; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. ',iwj;J}ju;mtu;fNs! mJ Vw;gLtJ> ukyhdpd; Muk;gj;jpyh? eLtpyh? filrpapyh?' vd;W egpj;Njhou;fs;Nfl;lhu;fs;. '(mJ) ukyhd; khjj;jpy; eLg;gFjpapy; elf;Fk;. nts;spf;fpoik ,uT ukyhdpd; ghjp,uthf ,Uf;Fk;NghJ> thdj;jpypUe;J (fLk;) rg;jk; Vw;gLk;. ,jd; %yk; 70>000 Ngu;%u;r;irahfptpLthu;fs;. 70 Mapuk; Ngu; g+kpf;Fs; nrhUfg;gLthu;fs;. 70 Mapuk; Ngu; FUluhthu;fs;. 70Mapuk; Ngu; nrtpluhthu;fs;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpaJk;> ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! cq;fspd;rKjhaj;jpy; cs;stu;fs; ghJfhg;G ngWNthu; mJ rkak; vg;gb ele;J nfhs;tu;?' vd;W kf;fs;Nfl;lhu;fs;. 'mJ rkak; jd; tPl;bypUe;J nfhz;L ][;jh nra;J ghJfhg;Gj; Njb> my;yh`{ mf;gu;vd rg;jkpl;Lf; $Wk; egu; jhd; ghJfhg;Gg; ngWthu;'' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;. gpwF kw;nwhU rg;jk;Vw;gLk;. mJ i\j;jhdpd; mywy; MFk; vd;Wk; $wpdhu;fs;.

ig&]; mj;ijyk; vd;gtuhy; mwptpf;fg;gLk; ,r;nra;jp ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fspd; 'kt;@Mj;' E}ypy;cs;sJ.

,r;nra;jpia mwptpf;Fk; ig&]; mj;ijyk; vd;gtu; egp(]y;) mtu;fis ghu;j;jjpy;iy. Mdhy; mtu;egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mwptpf;fpwhu;. ,JNghy; ,uz;lhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk; cigjh,g;D mg+ Yghgh vd;gtu;> ,e;j ig&]; mj;ijykPiag; ghu;j;jjpy;iy.

ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; ,];khaPy; ,g;D mah]; mtu;fSk;> Ie;jhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; mg;Jy; t`;̀ hg;,g;D o`;̀ hf; vd;gtUk; gytPdu;fshtu;. 'mg;Jy; t`hg; vd;gtu; ,];khaPy; vd;gthplkpUe;JGJikahd nra;jpfis mwptpg;gtuhthu;' vd mg+m`;kj; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

mwptpg;ghsu;fspd; thpirapy; ngUk; gytPdk; ,Ug;g NjhL> ,e;j `jP]; ,Jtiu ele;Jtpl;ljw;FMjhukhfTk; ,y;iy. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpapUg;gJ cz;ikahdhy; 1450 Mz;Lfs; fle;Jtpl;lJ. 15k;ehs; ,uT nts;spf;fpoik vdTk; te;Js;sJ. Mdhy; ',g;gb xU g+fk;gk;-,b Kof;fk;-ngU rg;jk;Vw;gl;L 70>000 Ngu; ,we;Jk; 70>000 Ngu; g+kpf;Fs; cs;spOf;fg;gl;Lk;> 70>000 Ngu; FUlhfpAk; 70>000 Ngu;nrtplhfpAk; Nghapdu;' vd;w ve;jf; Fwpg;Gk; ,y;iy. ,Jkhjpahd rk;gtk; ele;jpUf;Fkhdhy; tuyhw;Wf;Fwpg;G fshf gjpT nra;ag;gl;bUf;Fk;. 'xU Ntis ,dp elf;fyhk; jhNd. ,Jtiu elf;ftpy;iyvd;gjhy; elf;fNt elf;fhJ vd;whfptplhJ jhNd' vd;w Nfs;tp vof;$Lk;. Mdhy; ukyhd; khjk;mUs; epiwe;j khjk; vd Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; $Wfpd;wJ.

'ukshd; (khjk;) te;jhy; nrhu;f;fj;jpd; thry;fs; jpwf;fg; gLfpd;wd. eufthry;fs; milf;fg;gLfpd;wd.i\j;jhd;fs; tpyq;fplg;gLfpd;wdu;' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij mg+`{iuuh(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

ukshd; khjk; mUs; epiwe;j khjk; vd ,d;Dk; gy `jP];fs; mwptpf;fpd;wd. Mdhy; 'mJ Mgj;jhdkhjk;. mJ vg;NghJ elf;Fk;? ,g;NghJ ele;JtpLNkh' vd;W vjpu;ghu;g;ig Vw;gLj;jp ftiyailar;nra;Ak; khjk; vd;gJ Nghy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp $WfpwJ.

,e;j fhuzj;jpw;fhfTk;> mwptpg;ghsu; thpir gytPdkhf cs;sjhYk; ,r;nra;jpAk; gytPdkhd nra;jpahfcs;sJ.

62. ukshd; vd;W $wf;$lhjh?

''ukshd; vd;W $whjPu;fs;. ukyhd; vd;gJ my;yh`;tpd; ngau;fspy; xd;whFk;. vdNt ePq;fs; \`;Uukyhd; (ukyhd; khjk;) vd;W $Wq;fs;.''

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L ,r;nra;jp ,g;D mjP>,g;Dy; [t;]P MfpNahd; E}w;fspy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; %d;whk; eguhf ,lk;ngWk; mg+kp̀ ;\u; vd;gtu; `jP];fis mwptpg;gjpy;cWjpahdtu; my;y vd ,g;D KaPd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,g;Dy; [t;]P> j`gP> Råj;jp> \t;fhdP Nghd;Nwhu;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

51 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 52: Weak hadiths in tamil

,tiu ,l;Lf;fl;Lk; egu;fspd; gl;baypy; Nru;f;fpwhu;fs;.

,e;j mg+ kp̀ ;\u; rhpapy;yhj eguhf cs;sjhy; ,e;j `jP]; gytPdkhdjhFk;. NkYk; my;yh`;tpd;ngau;fspy; xd;whf ukyhd; vd;gJk; xd;W vd Fu;MdpNyh> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd egpnkhopapNyh ,y;iy.NkYk; ,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;Fk; KuzhfTk; cs;sJ.

''ukshd; te;jhy; Rtdj;jpd; thapy;fs; jpwf;fg;gLfpd;wd. eufj;jpd; thapy;fs; %lg;gLfpd;wd.i\j;jhd;fSf;F tpyq;fplg;gLfpd;wd'' vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP

''xUtu; ukshd; Nehd;G Nehw;W gpd;G \t;thypy; MW Nehd;ig Nehw;why; mtu; tUlk; KOJk; Nehd;GNehw;wtu; Nghyhthu;'' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+ ma;åg; (uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.E}y;: K];ypk;

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,q;F ukshd; khjk; vd;W $whky; ukyhd; vd;W $wpAs;sjhy; ukshd; vd;W$wyhk; vd;W mwpaKbfpwJ. vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha;ahdJ vd;gJ cWjpahfpwJ.

63. Fspg;Gf; flikahdtd; fly; ePhpy; Fspf;fyhkh?

Fspg;Gf; flikf;F fly;ePu; gad;glhJ. mjpypUe;J c@r; nra;aTk; $lhJ. Vnddpy; flYf;Ff; fPo;neUg;Gs;sJ. mjd; fPNo ,d;ndhU fly; cz;L. ,g;gb VO fly;> xU neUg;G cz;L.

,r;nra;jp mg;Jy;yh ,g;D mk;&(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf K];dj; mg;Ju;u]hf;> ig`fP> ijykP Mfpa E}w;fspy;gjpthfpAs;sJ.

,r;nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; K`k;kJ ,g;D K`h[pu; vd;gtu; ,lk;ngWfpwhu;. ,tu;,l;Lf;fl;Lk; egu; vd ,khk; j`gP> ,khk; \t;fhdP> ,khk; Råj;jp MfpNahu; Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;.

vdNt ,e;j nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahFk;. NkYk; gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;Fk; Kuzhfcs;sJ.

xU kdpju; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk;> ,iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! ehq;fs; flypy; gazk; nra;fpNwhk;. mg;NghJFiwe;j jz;zPiuNa nfhz;L nry;fpNwhk;. mjd; %yk; x@r; nra;jhy; (Fb jz;zPu; fhypahfp)ehq;fs; jhfj;Jld; ,Uf;f Ntz;baJ tUk;. vdNt ehq;fs; fly; ePhpy; c@r; nra;J nfhs;syhkh?vd;W Nfl;lhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> fly; ePu; J}a;ikg;gLj;jf; $bajhFk;. mjpy; trpg;gitnrj;jpUe;jhYk; cz;z mDkjpf;fg;gl;ljhFk; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij mg+`{iuuh(uyp)mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: e]aP> mg+jh¥j;> jpu;kpjP> ,g;Dkh[h

fly;ePhpy; x@r; nra;ayhk;> Fspg;Gf; flikahdtu; Fspf;fyhk; vd;gijNa ,e;j `jP]; $WfpwJ.

vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lit vd;gjpy; re;NjfNk ,y;iy.

64. Fspg;Gf; flikahdtd; Fspayiwapy; Fspf;fyhkh?

''Fspg;Gf; flikf;fhf Fspf;f> ,uz;L tif jz;zPu; gad;glhJ. mit fly; ePUk;> Fspayiw ePUk;MFk; ''

egp(]y;) $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.

,e;j nra;jp ,g;D mgPi\ghtpy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ. ,e;j nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; K`k;kJ,g;D K`h[pu; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; `jP];fis ,l;Lf;fl;Lk; eguhthu;. ,jdhy; jhd; ,khk;,g;Dy; [t;]P(u`;) mtu;fs; jdJ 'kt;@Mj;' (,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;lit) E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

NkYk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpfSf;Fk; ,J Kuz;gLk; tifapy; mike;Js;sJ vd;gjhYk; ,J,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahFk;.

ck;K `gPgh (uyp) mtu;fs; jk; rNfhj i[dg; gpd;j; [`;\;(uyp) mtu;fSf;Fhpa jz;zPu; njhl;bapy;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

52 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 53: Weak hadiths in tamil

mku;e;J Fspg;ghu;fs;. ,uj;jj;jpd; rptg;G epwk; jz;zPd; Nky; glUk; vd;W Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs;mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: ,g;Dkh[h

jz;zPu; njhl;b vd;gJ tPl;bd; jdp miwapDs; jhd; ,Ue;jpUf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;gij mwpayhk;.

',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! xUtu; jdpikapy; epu;thzkhf Fspf;fyhkh?' vd;W ehd; Nfl;Nld;. mjw;Fegp(]y;) mtu;fs;> 'kdpju;fsplk; ntl;fj;Jld; ele;J nfhs;tij tpl my;yh`;tplk; ntl;fczu;Tld; ele;J nfhs;s my;yh`; jFjpkpf;ftd; Mthd;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij g`;]; ,g;D`fPk; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: jpu;kpjP> mg+jh¥j;

kdpju;fsplk; ntl;fg;gl;L jdp miwapy; Fspf;f Mirg;gLtJ Nghy; mg;gb jdpNa Fspf;Fk; NghJk;epu;thzkhf Fspf;ff;$lhJ vd;gjpYk; ftdk; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk; vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs Nghjpf;fpwhu;fs;.Nfl;gtUk; $l jdpikapy; Fspf;Fk; NghJ epu;thzkhf Fspf;fyhkh? vd;Nw Nfl;fpwhu;. jdpik vd;gJjdp miw vd;gijNa Ghpa KbfpwJ. vdNt jdpNa mike;Js;s Fspayiwapy; Fspf;fyhk; vd;wMjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F Kuzhf Nkw;fz;l nra;jp mike;Js;sij mwpf!

65. m]u; njhOifia jhkjpf;fj;jhd; Ntz;Lkh?

''m]u; njhOiff;F> ghq;F $Wk; egu; ghq;F $wpdhu;. ,khkj; nra;a mtrug;gl;lhu;. mg;NghJmq;fpUe;j mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D uhgpc mtu;fs;> 'cdf;F ehrk; cz;lhfl;Lk;! m]u; njhOifiag;gpw;gLj;Jq;fs;' vd egpj;Njhou;fSf;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; fl;lisapl;lhu;fs; vd vd; je;ij $wpdhu;vd;W $wpdhu;.''

mg;Jy; th`pj; vd;gtu; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp jhuFj;dP> jhFy; fgPu;> ]fPu; (GfhuP)> k[;&`Pd;>jj;fpuJy; kt;@Mj; Mfpa E}w;fspy; cs;sJ.

,jd; ,uz;lhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; mg;Jy; th`pj; ngha;au; vdf; $Wk; `jP]; Jiw mwpQu;fs; ,tuJ`jP];fis epuhfj;Js;sdu;.

NkYk; ,tu; mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D uhgpc mtu;fisg; ghu;j;jNj ,y;iy. vdNt mthplkpUe;J,r;nra;jpiaf; Nfl;Fk; tha;g;gpy;iy vd ,khk; jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu; rpahthrpfs;topahf ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;l nra;jpfis mwptpg;gtu;' vd ,khk; ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

Mjhug;g+u;tkhd gpd;tUk; `jP];fs; $Wk; nra;jpf;Fk; ,J Kuzhf cs;sJ.

''ehq;fs; egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; m]u; njhONthk;. gpd;G xl;lfj;ij mWg;Nghk;. mijg; gj;J gq;Fitg;Nghk;. gpwF mij rikg;Nghk;. #hpad; kiwAk; Kd; rikj;j ,iwr;rpia cz;Nghk;'' vd ugPc,g;D fjP[; (uyp) $Wfpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; m]u; njhOthu;fs;. #hpad; (ntspr;rk;) vdJ miwf;Fs;Ns ,Uf;Fk;'' vdMap\h(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; m]u; njhOifia njhOthu;fs;. mg;NghJ #hpad; cau;e;J gpufhrkhf ,Uf;Fk;.mthyp tiu xUtu; nry;thu;. mg;NghJk; #hpad; cau;e;Nj ,Uf;Fk;. mthyp vd;gJ kjPdhtpypUe;Jehd;F iky; mstpy; ,Uf;Fk;'' vd md];(uyp) $Wfpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

ehq;fs; (njhOif Kbe;J) jpUk;gpa NghJ> md];(uyp) mtu;fs;> '',J (Neuk; gpw;gLj;jpj; njhOtJ)Kdhgpf;Ffspd; njhOifahFk;. #hpad; i\j;jhdpd; ,uz;L nfhk;Gf;Fk; kj;jpapy; tUk; tiu (mjhtJkiwAk; tiu) vjpu;ghu;j;J mku;e;jpUg;ghd;. gpwF vOe;J ehd;F trdq;fis kl;Lk; Xjp (Kbg;ghd;)my;yh`;it Fiwe;j mstpNyNa epidT $u;thd;'' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhfTk; $wpdhu;fs;.,ij ,];khaPy; vd;ghu; $Wfpd;whu;. E}y;: K];ypk;

m]u; njhOifia Kw;gLj;jpNa njho Ntz;Lk;. fhy jhkjk; nra;af;$lhJ vd rhpahd `jP];fs;$Wfpd;wd. ,e;j tifapYk; m]u; njhOifia jhkjpf;f Ntz;Lk; vdf; $Wk; nra;jp>,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

53 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 54: Weak hadiths in tamil

66. uf;mj;fspy; Xjhky;> U$c> ][;jh Kiwahf ,Ue;jhy; kl;Lk; NghJkh?

''cku;(uyp) mtu;fs;> kf;fSf;F k`;G njho itj;jhu;fs;. mg;NghJ mtu;fs; 'XjNt ,y;iy.(njhOJ Kbj;jJk;) ePq;fs; XjNt ,y;iyNa' vd;W Nfl;fg;gl;lJ. U$c> ][;jh vg;gb ,Ue;jJ?vd;W cku;(uyp) Nfl;lhu;fs;. ed;whf ,Ue;jJ vd kf;fs; $wpaJk;> mg;gbahdhy; Fw;wkpy;iy'' vdgjpy; $wpdhu;fs;.

mg+ ]ykh ,g;D mg;Ju;u`;khd; (u`;) mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp ',yy;> jy;fPRy; mghj;jPy;' Mfpa E}w;fspy;cs;sJ.

,jpy; MwhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk; ngWk; K`k;kJ ,g;D K`h[pu; vd;gtu; `jP];fis ,l;Lf; fl;Lk;egu; vd ,khk; j`gP $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

''ghj;jp̀ h #uh XjhjtDf;F njhOif $lhJ'' vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf cghjh ,g;D]hkpj; (uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> e]aP> mg+jh¥j;> jpu;kpjP> ,g;Dkh[h

Mjhug;g+u;tkhd ,e;j `jPN]h> ghj;jp̀ h #uhitNaDk; Xjpahf Ntz;Lk; vd;fpwJ. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;lnra;jpNah Xjhky; ,Ue;jhYk; guthapy;iy vd;fpwJ.

Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;Fk; Kuz;gl;Lk;> mwptpg;ghsu; ,l;Lf; fl;Lk; eguhfTk; cs;sjhy; ,ij,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;lit vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

67. fhJfs; tiu ifia cau;j;JtJ gpj;mj;jh?

''ePq;fs; cq;fspd; iffis njhOifapy; ,g;gb cau;j;JfpwPu;fsh? vd ,g;D cku;(uyp) Nfl;lhu;fs;.(,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk;) `k;khj; vd;gtu; jd; iffis fhJfs; tiu cau;j;jpf;fhl;bdhu;. my;yh`;tpd; kPjhizahf ,J gpj;mj;jhFk;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,ij tpl mjpfkhf xUNghJk; cau;j;jpajpy;iy'' vd;W ,g;Dcku;(uyp) $wpdhu;fs;. me;j msit `k;khj; jdJ khu;G tiuRl;bf;fhl;bdhhu;.

gp\;u; ,g;D `u;G $wpajhf ,r;nra;jp ',yy;'> 'Kf;j]u; ,yy;' Mfpa E}w;fspy; cs;sJ.

,jd; Kjy; mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk; K\;u; ,g;D `u;G vd;gtu; gytPdu; vd ,khk; ,g;D KaPd;>mg+`hjk;> mg+]u;M MfpNahu; $Wfpd;wdu;. ,tu; gykhdtu; my;y vd;W ,khk; m`;kj; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.vdNt ,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahFk;.

Nkw;fz;l nra;jp njhOifapy; jf;gPu; $Wk;NghJ> iffis khu;G tiu jhd; cau;j;j Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk;>fhJfs; tiu cau;j;JtJ gpj;mj; vd;Wk; $WfpwJ. Mdhy; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd gpd;tUk; `jPN]hfhJfs; tiu cau;j;jyhk; vd;W $WfpwJ.

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jf;gPu; $wpaNghJ jdJ iffis fhJfs; tiu cau;j;Jthu;fs;'' vd khypf;,g;Dy; `{it];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp gytPdkhdjhFk;.

68. Y`u;> m]hpy; Xj Ntz;lhkh?

''Y`u;> m]u; njhOifapy; XjNtz;bajpy;iy. (Vnddpy;) egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Xjpdhy; jhd; ehKk;XjNtz;Lk;. mtu;fs; nksdkhf ,Ue;jhy; ehKk; kTdkhfNt ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;.''

''Y`u; njhOifapy; Xj Ntz;bajpy;iy. Xj Ntz;Lk; vd;wpUe;jhy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; (Xjp) ekf;FNfl;fr; nra;jpUg;ghu;fs;.''

,e;j ,uz;L nra;jpfisAk; ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P(u`;) mtu;fs; jdJ,yy; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; K`k;kj; ,g;D K`h[Pu; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

54 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 55: Weak hadiths in tamil

vd ,khk; j`gP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,Nj fUj;ij ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;. vdNt ,e;j`jP]; rhpahdjy;y. NkYk; gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;Fk; KuzhfTk; cs;sJ.

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Y`u;> m]u; njhOiffspy; Kjy; ,uz;L uf;mj;fspy; ck;Ky; Fu;MidAk;(ghj;jp̀ h #uhitAk;) NtW ,uz;L #uhf;fisAk; XJthu;fs;. rpy rkak; trdq;fis (rg;jkpl;LXjp) vq;fSf;F Nfl;Fk;gb nra;thu;fs;. Y`hpd; Kjy; uf;mj;ij rpwpJ ePl;Lgtu;fshf ,Ue;jhu;fs;vd mg+fjhjh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Y`u;> m]u; njhOifapy; Kjy; ,uz;L uf;mj;fspy; #uh ghj;jp`hTk; NtW xU#uhTk; XJthu;fs;. rpy rkak; trdq;fis (rw;W rg;jkhf Xjp) vq;fis Nfl;Fk;gbr; nra;thu;fs;.gpe;jpa ,uz;L uf;mj;fspy; #uh ghj;jp̀ h kl;Lk; XJthu;fs; vd mg+fjhjh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.E}y;: K];ypk;

Y`u;> m]hpy; #uhf;fs; Xj Ntz;Lk; vd Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; $w Nkw;fz;l nra;jpfNshNtz;lhk; vdf; $WfpwJ. vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jpfs; Gidag;gl;lit vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

69. njho itg;gtu; mofhf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lkh?

''mtu;fspy; mofpa Kfk; cs;stNu (jdJ) $l;lj;jpdUf;F ,khkj; nra;a Ntz;Lk;.''

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;jjhf ,r;nra;jp ijykP> ,g;D mjP>,g;Dy; [t;]P MfpNahu; jq;fs; E}w;fspy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.

,e;jr; nra;jpapd; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk; ngWk; K`k;kJ ,g;D ku;thd; gykhdtu; my;yu; vda`;ah $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; ngha;au; vd;Wk;> ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpir ,Us; epiwe;jJ vd;Wk; j`gP$Wfpd;whu;fs;. NkYk; ,tiug; gw;wp Ky;yh myPfhuP> Råj;jp> ,g;Dy; [t;]P> \t;fhdP Nghd;Nwhu;fLikahf tpku;rdk; nra;fpwhu;fs;.

NkYk; MwhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk; ngWk; `o;ukP vd;gtu; ahnud;Nw mwpKfk;> tpguf;Fwpg;G ,y;yhjtu;Mthu;. vdNt ,e;j nra;jp gytPdkhd nra;jpahf cs;sJ. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; KuzhfTk;cs;sJ.

mtu;fspy; ey;y Kiwapy; XJgtNu (jdJ) $l;lj;jpw;F ,khkj; nra;al;Lk;. XJjypy; midtUk;rkkhd epiyapy; ,Ue;jhy; mtu;fspy; `p[;uj; nra;tjpy; Ke;jpatu;fs; ,khkj; nra;al;Lk;; `p[;uj;nra;jjpy; rkkhdtu;fshf ,Ue;jhy; egptopia mwpe;jtu; ,khkj; nra;al;Lk;. egpnkhopia mwpe;jjpy;rkkhdtu;fshf ,Ue;jhy; mtu;fspy; tajpy; %j;jtu; ,khkj; nra;al;Lk; vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;vd mg+k];¥j;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;

egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; epge;jidiaf; Fwpg;gpl;L tUk; `jP]py; mofpa Kfk; cs;stu; jhd; ,khkj;nra;ayhk; vd;w fl;lis VJk; ,y;iy vd;gjhYk;> mwptpg;ghsu; thpir rhpapy;yhjjhYk; ,J,l;Lf;fl;b $Wgtu;fshy; cUthdJ vd;W Ghpayhk;.

70. njhO Neha;f;fhd fhuzk;?

''ehd; #hpadhy; ePiu #lhf;fp itj;jpUe;Njd;. vd;dplk; te;j egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> rpte;jtNs! eP,t;thW nra;ahNj! Vnddpy; mJ njhO Nehia cz;lhf;Fk; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.''

Map\h(uyp) mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jpia jhuFj;dP> ,g;D mjP> mg+eaPk;> ig`fP MfpNahu; gjpTnra;Js;shu;fs;.

,jd; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; fhypj; ,g;D ,];khaPy; vd;gtu; ,l;Lf;fl;lf;$batu; vd ,g;DmjP$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tiug; NghyNt t`;G ,g;D t`G vd;gtUk; mwptpf;fpd;whu;. ',tNuh> fhypj; ,g;D,];khaPiy tplTk; Nkhrkhdtu;' vd ,g;D mjP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. mJNghyNt i`]k; ,g;D mjPvd;gtu; topahf mwptpf;fg;gLfpwJ. 'mtu; ngha;au;' vd ,khk; a`;ah ,g;D KaPd; $wpajhf jhuFj;dP

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

55 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 56: Weak hadiths in tamil

$Wfpd;whu;fs;.

NkYk; ,Nj `jP]; K`k;kJ ,g;D ku;thD];]`;jP vd;gtu; topahfTk; mwptpf;fg;gl;L jhuFj;dPapd;mt;]j; E}ypy; cs;sJ. ,tUk; `jP]; Jiwapduhy; epuhff;fg; gl;ltu; Mthu;. Nkw;fz;l nra;jpia,khk; khypf; (u`;) mwptpg;gjhf mg+K`k;kj; my;[{itdp vd;gtUk; ,g;D]; ]g;gh`; vd;gtUk;$Wfpd;whu;fs;. Mdhy; ,khk; khypf; $Wtjhf $Wtij ,khk; ig`fP kWf;fpd;whu;fs;.

''#hpadhy; #lhf;fg;gl;l jz;zPhpy; x@r; nra;tijAk;> mjpy; Fspg;gijAk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jilnra;jhu;fs;. ,g;gbr; nra;jhy; njhONehia cz;lhf;Fk; vd;Wk; $wpdhu;fs;.''

,ij Map\h(uyp) $wpajhf jhuFj;dPapy; cs;sJ. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; Ie;jhtjhf ,lk;ngWk; mk;U ,g;D K`k;kj; vd;gtd; `jP]; kWf;fj; jf;fJ vd gjpT nra;Js;s jhuFj;dP mtu;fNsFwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; ,l;Lf;fl;Lk; egu; vd ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

,Nj `jP]; mg+jh¥j;> jpu;kpjPapYk; cs;sjhf K`k;kJ ,g;D KaPd; mj;jpkp\;fP $Wfpd;whu;fs;.Mdhy; me;j E}w;fspy; ,g;gb xU `jPN] ,y;iy.

''cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; #hpadhy; #lhf;fg;gl;lj; jz;zPiu(g; gad;gLj;Jtij) ntWj;jhu;fs;. Vnddpy;mJ njhONehia cz;lhf;Fk; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.''

,r;nra;jpia [hgpu;(uyp) $Wtjhf ,khk; \h/gP gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,jd; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsu;rjfj;J ,g;D mg;Jy;yh`; vd;gtu;> `jP]; Jiw mwpQu;fs; midtuhYk; 'gytPdu;' vd;W Fiw$wg;gLfpwhu;. NkYk; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D mg+a`;ah vd;gtu; ,l;Lf;fl;Lk; egu; vd,khk; e]aP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ehq;fs; ,tiu Fuhgh (Kw;fhyj;jpd; ngha; $Wk; Nfhagy;];) vd;Wngahpl;bUe;Njhk; vd ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D ]`;j; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. NkYk; ,tu; fj;ah> K`j]papa;ah>uhgp]pa;ah> Nghd;w nfhs;ifia Vw;wtuhthu;. ,jdhy; ,thplk; epiwa gpj;mj;fs; ,Ue;jd vd;W m[yP$Wfpd;whu;fs;.

''xUtu; #hpadhy; #lhf;fg;gl;l jz;zPhpy; Fspj;J mjdhy; Neha; Vw;gl;lhy; mtu; jd;idj; jtpuahiuAk; Fiw $wNtz;lhk;.''

,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) $wpajhf ,J cs;sJ. ,jd; Kjy; mwptpg;ghsu; o`;̀ hf;> ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp)mtu;fis re;jpj;jNj ,y;iy. NkYk; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsu; cku; ,g;D Rg;̀ { vd;gtu; ngha;au;Mthu;.

,Nj fUj;J md];(uyp) $wpajhf cifyP mtu;fs; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,jpy; ,lk;ngWk;]ythj;Jy; $gP vd;gtu; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu; Mthu;.

NkYk; ,khk; jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; 'm/g;uhj;' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. mjpy; ,lk;ngWk; [fa;ahngha;au; vd;W `jP]; Jiwapdu; Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;. ,g;D [t;]P mtu;fs; jdJ 'kt;@Mj;' vDk;E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ig`fP mtu;fs; jdJ 'k`;gh' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;J tpl;L> ,ijVw;f KbahJ vd;Wk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

,j;jiyg;gpy; tUk; ve;j `jP]{k; rhpahdjhf ,y;iy. ,J kl;Lky;y. fpuhkg;Gwq;fspy; #hpadhy;#Nlw;wg;gl;l ePu;epiyfspy; Fbf;fTk;> Fspf;fTk; nra;fpwhu;fs;. Mdhy; mtu;fs; midtUf;Fk; njhONeha; Vw;gl;ljhf Fwpg;G vJTk; ,y;iy.

eilKiwapy; epfohj xd;iw fw;gidahf;fp $Wk; fw;gid thjpay;y egp(]y;) mtu;fs;. vdNtNkw;fz;l nra;jpfs; midj;Jk; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lNj MFk;.

71. ghu;itapd; $u;ikf;F...

''mofhd ngz;fspd; Kfj;ijAk;> gRikahdijAk; ghu;g;gJ ghu;itia $u;ikahf;Fk;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; nra;jp> mg+eapkPd; 'my;̀ py;ah'tpy;,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ. ,g;D [t;]P mtu;fspd; 'kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypYk; cs;sJ.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

56 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 57: Weak hadiths in tamil

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D `{igg; vd;gtu;gytPdkhd egu;fsplkpUe;J `jP];fis mwptpg;gtu; vd jhuFj;dP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,e;j nra;jp\dhjpfhitr; Nru;e;j topnfl;l egu;fshy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd ,g;D ifåk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

(egpNa!) ,iw ek;gpf;if cs;s Mz;fsplk; mtu;fs; jq;fspd; ghu;itiaj; jho;j;jpf; nfhs;s Ntz;Lk;vd;Wk; jq;fspd; kiwTWg;igg; Ngzpf; nfhs;s Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk; ,J mtu;fSf;F gRj;jkhFk; vd;Wk;$WtPuhf! epr;rakhf my;yh`; mtu;fs; nra;gtw;iw ed;F mwpe;jtd;. (my;Fu;Md; 24:30)

topfspy; ePq;fs; mku;tij vr;rhpf;fpd;Nwd; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpaJk;> ,iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs!ehq;fs; Kf;fpag; Ngr;Rfs; Ngrpl mku;tJ Njitahfpd;wJ vd;W ehq;fs; Nfl;Nlhk;. mjw;F egp(]y;)mtu;fs;> 'ePq;fs; mg;gbj; jq;fpdhy; topf;Fhpa chpikfis toq;fp tpLq;fs;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. topapd;chpik vd;d? vd;W Nfl;Nlhk;. ''ghu;itiaj; jho;j;jpf; nfhs;sy;> jPq;F jUk; nghUl;fis mfw;Wjy;>]yhkpw;Fg; gjpy; $Wjy;> ed;ikia VTjy;> jPikiaj; jLj;jy;'' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,ijmg+]aPj;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: m`;kj;

Nkw;fz;l trdKk; `jP]{k; me;epag; ngz;fis ghu;g;gij tpl;Lk; ghu;itiaj; jtpu;f;f Ntz;Lk; vdmwptpf;fpd;wd. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;l ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpNah ngz;fisg; ghUq;fs;; ghu;it $u;ikMFk; vd;fpd;wJ. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nrajpf;Fk; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp Kuzhf cs;sijg; Ghpa KbfpwJ.

mofhd ngz;fis kidtpaiuj; jpUkzk; nra;j vj;jidNah Mz;fs; ghu;itia ,oe;jtu;fshf>ghu;itf; Fiw Vw;gl;ltu;fshf cs;sijg; ghu;f;fyhk;. ,jpypUe;Jk; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha; vdtpsq;fyhk;.

NkYk; ,r;nra;jpapy; gRikiag; ghu;g;gJk; ghu;itia $u;ikahf;Fk; vd;W cs;sJ. kjPdh tptrhak;epiwe;j gFjpahFk;. gRikf;F gQ;rkpy;iy. MdhYk; mq;F mg;Jy;yh ,g;D ck;kp kf;J}k; Nghd;wfz; FUlhf ,Ue;j egpj;Njhou;fs; ,Ue;Js;sdu; vd;gjpypUe;Jk; ,J ngha; vd tpsq;fyhk;.

72. Mz;fs; nfl;Lg; Nghf> ngz;fNs fhuzk;

''ngz;fs; nrhy;iy Nfl;ltd; njhiye;jhd;''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf Map\h(uyp) mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp> ,g;D mjP> mg+eaPk;> `hfpk;E}w;fspy; gjpthfpAs;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; gfhu; ,g;D mg;Jy; m[P]; vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtu; vd ,g;DmjP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; fzf;fpNyNa vLj;Jf; nfhs;sg;glj; jfhjtu; vd;W ,g;D KaPd;$Wfpd;whu;fs;.

,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahFk;. NkYk; ,J> egptopf;Fk; khw;wkhd nra;jpahfTk; cs;sJ.

`{ijgpa;ah cld;gbf;if Vw;gl;l NghJ ,iw kWg;ghsu;fshd kf;fhthrpfspd; epge;jidg;gb ck;uhnra;ahky; jpUk;Gk; epiy egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;F Vw;gLfpwJ. clNd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Fu;ghdpnfhLj;Jtpl;L mq;NfNa jiyiar; rpiuAq;fs; vd egpj;Njhou;fsplk; $wpdhu;fs;. ,e;j cld;gbf;ifFwpj;J> ftiyAld; ,Ue;j egpj;Njhou;fs; ftiy fhuzkhf vijAk; nra;ahky; ,Ue;jhu;fs;.

,jdhy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jd; kidtp ck;K]ykh(uyp) ,Ue;j $lhuj;jpw;Fr; nrd;W> ele;jij jd;kidtpaplk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. mg;NghJ ck;K rykh(uyp) mtu;fs; ePq;fs; mq;Nf nrd;W vtUlDk;Ngrhky; jiyiar; rpiuj;J> Fu;ghdp nfhLq;fs; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. egp(]y;) mtu;fSk; mg;gbNanra;jhu;fs;. ,ijg; ghu;j;j egpj;Njhou;fSk; jiyia rpiuj;Jf; Fu;ghdp nfhLj;jhu;fs;. E}y;:GfhuP(`jP]pd; fUj;J)

,e;j `jP]; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jd; kidtp ck;K ]ykh(uyp) mtu;fsplk; MNyhrid nra;Js;sdu;vd;gij tpsq;fplr; nra;fpwJ. ngz;fsplKk; Nfl;fyhk;. ey;y nra;jp ,Ug;gpd; Vw;fyhk; vd;gjw;Fepiwar; rhd;Wfs; cs;sd.

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

57 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 58: Weak hadiths in tamil

vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp> ngha;ahdJ vd;gij mwpf!

73. Mz;fs; eufk; nry;yf; fhuzk; ngz;fNs!

''ngz;fs; kl;Lk; ,y;yhky; ,Ue;jhy; Mz;fs; (midtUk;) nrhu;f;fk; nrd;wpUg;ghu;fs;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;J> ,g;D mjPapd; 'my;fhkpy;' E}ypy;gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; gp\;u; ,g;D `{i]d; vd;gtu; ngUk; ngha;au; vd ,g;D,uhf; Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;.

,e;j nra;jpiag; gbf;Fk; NghJ ngz;fs; vtUk; nrhu;f;fk; nry;ykhl;lhu;fs;. Mz;fisAk; nry;ytplkhl;lhu;fs; vd;gJ Nghy; Ghpa KbfpwJ. Mdhy; ngz; fspYk; ey;ytu;fs; cs;sdu;. nrhu;f;fk; nry;tu;vd Fu;Md; %yk; Ghpa KbfpwJ.

my;yh`;> <khd; nfhz;ltu;fSf;F cjhuzkhf gpu;mt;dpd; kidtpiaAk;> ,k;uhdpd; kfs; ku;ak;mtu;fisAk; $Wfpd;whd;. (ghu;f;f my;Fu;Md; 66:10>11) mjhtJ gpu;mt;dpd; kidtpAk; ku;ak; mtu;fSk;%kpd; fSf;F cjhuzkhthu;fs;. mtu;fspd; tho;itf; fUj;jpy; nfhz;L> gbg;gpid ngw Ntz;Lk;vd;W $Wfpd;whd;.

Mz;fspy; ey;ytu;-nfl;ltu; cs;sJ NghyNt ngz;fspYk; ey;ytu;-nfl;ltu; cz;L vd;w mstpy; jhd;ek;gpf;if ,Uf;f Ntz;LNk jtpu> midj;J ngz;fSk; Nkhrkhdtu;fs;; Mz;fis topnfLj;J eufpw;Fmioj;Jr; nry;gtu;fs; vd ek;Gjy; $lhJ.

ngz;fs; midtUk; nfl;ltu;fs; vdpy; mtu;fis eufpy; NghlNt ,iwtd; tpUk;Gthd;. Mdhy;my;yh`; ngz;fis capUld; Gijj;jJ gw;wpAk;> ,jw;F ePjp toq;FNtd; vd;Wk; 16:58> 81:8 Mfpatrdq;fs; %yk; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.

eufk; nry;y cs;s ngz;fs; jhNd> tho;e;jhy; vd;d? nrj;jhy; vd;d? vd ,iwtd; vz;zp,Ue;jpltpy;iy. khwhf mtu;fs; thog; gpwe;jtu;fs;> mtu;fs; tho;tijf; nfLj;j nfhiyfhu Mz;fs;jz;bf;fg;gLthu;fs; vdf; Fwpg;gpL fpwhd;.

vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha;ahdJ> ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;lJ vd;gij mwpNthkhf!

74. ,iwtdpd; tpNuhjpfs; ngz;fshtu;?

''ngz;fs; kl;Lk; ,y;yhky; ,Ue;jhy; my;yh`;it rhpahd Kiwapy; tzq;fg;gl;bUf;Fk;.''

,t;thW egp(]y;) $wpajhf cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp ,g;D mjPapd; my;fhkpy; E}ypy;gjpT nra;ag; gl;Ls;sJ.

,r;nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; ehd;fhk; mwptpg;ghsu; mg;Ju;u`Pk; ,g;D i]j; my;mk;kPvd;gtd; `jP];fs; epuhff;fg;gl Ntz;bait vd mg+`hjk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. Nkhrkhd ngUk; ngha;au;vd ,tiu Kg;D KaPd; fLikahf tpku;rpf;fpwhu;fs;. Gfh ,khk; cl;gl gyUk; tpku;rpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,ijg;gjpT nra;j ,g;D mjP mtu;fSk; ,J Gwf;fzpf;fg;gl Ntz;ba nra;jp vd;W $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

,e;j `jP];> ngz;fs; ,iwtid tzq;Ftij tpl;Lk; jLf;ff; $batu;fs;. mjhtJ ,iwtdpd;tpNuhjpfs; ngz;fs; jhd; vd;gJ Nghy; $Wfpd;wJ. ,J Mjhug;g+u;t khd nfhs;iff;F Kuzhdnra;jpahfTk; cs;sJ.

epr;rakhf i\j;jhd; tpUk;Gtnjy;yhk; kJghdj;ijf; nfhz;Lk; #jhl;lj;ijf; nfhz;Lk; cq;fspilNagifik iaAk; ntWg;igAk; cUthf;fp my;yh`;tpd; epidtpy; ,Ue;Jk;> njhOifapy; ,Ue;Jk;cq;fisj; jLj;J tpl;lhd;. vdNt mtw;iw tpl;Lk; ePq;fs; tpyfpf; nfhs;s khl;Bu;fsh? (my;Fu;Md;5:91)

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

58 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Umar
Highlight
Page 59: Weak hadiths in tamil

kdpju;fis topnfLf;Fk; i\j;jhd; jhd; ,iwtdpd; vjphp vd;W ,e;j trdk; $WfpwJ. Mdhy;ngz;fs; jhd; topnfLf;Fk; $l;lk; vd;gJ Nghy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp $Wfpd;wJ. ,jpypUe;Jk; Nkw;fz;lnra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;lJ vd tpsq;fyhk;.

75. k`Uf;F msTz;lh?

''gj;J nts;sp ehzaq;fSf;Fk; Fiwthf k`u; fpilahJ.''

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L ig`fP> jhuFj;dP> ,g;DmjP Mfpa E}w;fspy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ.

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; Ie;jhtjhf Kg\;\pu; ,g;D cigj; vDk; ngha;au; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,td;`jP];fs; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfshfTk;> ngha;ahdit fshfTk; ,Uf;Fk; vd ,khk; m`;kj;(u`;)$Wfpd;whu;fs;.

',tu; `jP];fspy; Kw;wpYk; ntWf;fg;gl;l gytPdu;' vd mg+`hjk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. `jP]; Jiwapy;,tu; Gwe;js;sg;gl;ltu; vd jhuFj;dP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ey;ytu; fspd; ngaiug; gad;gLj;jp ,l;Lfl;Lk;egu; ,tu;. ,td; `jP];fis> GJik `jP];fs; vDk; thpirapy; jhd; Nru;f;f Ntz;Lk; vd ,g;D`pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.

'',tu; mwptpf;Fk; nra;jpfs; ngha;ahdit. mrj;jpakhdit> ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lit'' vd ,khk; m`;kj;$wpajhf ,g;D mjP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu; `jP]; Jiw apduhy; ntWf;fg;gl;ltu;' vd ,khk; GfhuP$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,g;gb gyuhy; rhlg;gl;ltu; ,lk; ngWtjhy; ,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahfpwJ.

k`u; vd;gJ jpUkzk; nra;J nfhs;s cs;s ngz;zhy; epu;zak; nra;ag;gl Ntz;Lk;. ngz;zpd;nghWg;ghsu; k`u; gw;wp NgrpdhYk;> me;j k`iu Vw;Wf; nfhs;sTk;> kWf;fTk; chpik nfhz;lts;ngz; jhd;. ,JNghy; thq;fpa k`iu jhNd itj;Jf; nfhs;sNth> my;yJ fztDf;Fj; jpUk;gj;je;jplNth chpikAk; ngw;wts;> ngz; jhd; vd;gJ ,];yhkpar; rl;lkhFk;.

Fiwe;j gl;rk; k`u; ,J jhd; vd epu;zak; nra;Ak; chpik vtUf;Fk; ,y;iy. gj;J nts;spehzaq;fSf;F Fiwthf jug;gLk; k`iu itj;J jpUkzk; nra;jy; $lhJ vd;gJ Nghy; Nkw;fz;lnra;jp $Wfpd;wJ. mjw;F Fiwthd k`u; ,Ue;J> mij me;jg; ngz; Vw;Wf; nfhz;lhy; mJNtk`u; vd gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; $WfpwJ.

xU ngz; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; te;J> ,iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! vd;id cq;fsplj;jpy;xg;gilj;Jtpl;Nld;. (mjhtJ vd;id jpUkzk; nra;J nfhs;Sq;fs;) vd;W $wpdhu;. egp(]y;)mtu;fs; mg;ngz;zpd; gf;fk; jpUk;gp mg;ngz;iz NkYk; fPOk; vdg; ghu;j;Jtpl;L jiy ftpo;e;Jnfhz;lhu;fs;.

jdJ fUj;J tp\akhf ve;j KbTk; vLf;fg;glhjijg; ghu;j;j mg;ngz; mku;e;J nfhz;lhu;. mg;NghJxU egpj;Njhou; xUtu; vOe;J> ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs> ,g;ngz; zplk; cq;fSf;F vt;tpjj; NjitAk;,y;iynadpy; vdf;Fj; jpUkzk; nra;J itAq;fs;' vd;W $wpdhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs;'cd;dplk; (k`u; ju) vd;d cs;sJ?' vd;W Nfl;lhu;fs;.

clNd mtu;> 'my;yh`;tpd; kPJ rj;jpakhf! vd;dplk; vJTkpy;iy ,iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs!' vd;W$wpdhu;. 'cd; FLk;gj;jhhplk; nrd;W VjhtJ cs;sjh? vd;W ghu;j;Jth' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;.Ngha; te;j mtu;> ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! my;yh`;tpd; kPJ rj;jpakhf vijAk; ehd; ngw;Wf;nfhs;stpy;iy' vd;W $wpdhu;. ',Uk;G Nkhjpuk; cs;sjh?'vd egp(]y;) Nfl;lhu;fs;. mtu; nrd;WjpUk;g te;J> ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! my;yh`;tpd; kPJ rj;jpakhf> ,Uk;G Nkhjpuk; $l ,y;iy.MdhYk; ,e;j Ntl;b jhd; cs;sJ' vd;whu;. ,ij mwptpf;Fk; ]`;y; (uyp) mtu;fs; mthplk; Nkyhil$l ,y;iy vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

',e;j Ntl;bapy; ghjpia mg;ngz;Zf;Fj; jUfpNwd;' vd;W mtu; $wpdhu;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs;'cdJ ,e;j Ntl;bia itj;J vd;d nra;a KbAk;. ,ij eP mzpe;jhy; mg;ngz;zpd; clypy; vJTk;

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

59 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight
Page 60: Weak hadiths in tamil

,Uf;fhJ. mg;ngz; mzpe;J nfhz;lhy; cdJ clypy; vJTk; ,Uf;fhJ' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,ijf;Nfl;l mtUk; mku;e;Jtpl;lhu;. rig(apd; Neuk;) mjpfj;jJ. (KbT vJTk; Vw;gltpy;iy vd;gjhy;)mtu; vOe;J nrd;W tpl;lhu;. mtiu mioj;J tUk;gb egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. mtu; mioj;Jtug;gl;lhu;.

mtu; te;jJk;> 'Fu;Mdpy; VNjDk; ck;kplk; kddkhf cs;sjh?'vdf; Nfl;lhu;fs;. ',d;dpd;dmj;jpahaq;fs; vdf;Fj; njhpAk;' vd mtu; vz;zpf; fhl;bdhu;. ',tw;iw kdg;ghlkhf ePu; XJtPuh?'vd;W Nfl;lhu;fs;. mtu; Mk; vd;whu;. 'Fu;Mdpy; ePu; njhpe;J itj;Js;s ,itfSf;Fg; gfukhf,g;ngz;iz kzk; Kbj;Jj; je;Njd;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. ,J ]`;y;(uyp)mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gLfpwJ. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;

ntWnkd Fu;Md; trdq;fis k`uhf;fp> me;j k`iuAk; me;jg; ngz; kWg;NgJk; njhptpf;fhjepiyapy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jpUkzk; nra;J itj;Js;shu;fs; vd Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; $Wfpd;wJ.vdNt Fiwe;j gl;rk; gj;J nts;sp ehzaq;fshtJ k`uhf ,Ue;jhf Ntz;Lk; vd;w Nkw;fz;lnra;jp ngha; vdg; Ghpayhk;.

vr;rhpf;if!

`jP];fspd; ngauhy; åju;fs; ,l;Lf;fl;b cs;sdu; vd;gij czu;e;J nray;gl Kd;tu Ntz;Lk;.

,jw;fhf `jP];fNs Ntz;lhk; vd;w nfhs;if nfhz;L miytJ eufpNyNa Ngha;r; Nru;f;Fk;vd;gijAk; epidtpy; nfhs;f!

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

60 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

Umar
Highlight