Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In...

53
Mentore Vaccari, Francesco Vitali CeTAmb, UNIVERSITY OF BRESCIA Waste reuse and recycling

Transcript of Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In...

Page 1: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Mentore Vaccari, Francesco Vitali

CeTAmb, UNIVERSITY OF BRESCIA

Waste reuse and recycling

Page 2: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Contents

1. General issues

2. Plastic recycling

3. Metal recycling

4. Paper recycling

5. Organic waste recycling

2

Page 3: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

What is waste?

An item is viewed as waste as soon as it has become

worthless to the initial owner.

“One man’s waste is another man’s treasure”

Popular saying

3

Page 4: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Waste hierarchy: 3R rule4

Page 5: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

First of 3R - Reduce

Success depends more on human behavior

Technology, policy and other measures take second place

5

Page 6: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Stages in the SWM system

Waste recycling

ReuseWidespread at domestic level Plastic containers, metals, organic matter

Recycling

Usually performed by the informal sector

Inorganic materials (e.g. plastic, metals and paper)

6

Page 7: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recyclable materials

Paper

Plastic

Aluminium and metals

Organic matter

Other recyclable materials are: iron and steel, tin cans, non-ferrous metals, textiles and glass

7

Page 8: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Stages in the SWM system

Waste recycling

• Informal recycling is widespread

• Informal does not mean unorganized

• Such activities are often in conflict with formal services if they are not coordinated

• Waste-pickers are mostly driven by poverty, are a social fringe group and exposed to high health risk

• Recycling further along the waste cycle worsens working conditions.

• Recycling is a function of market

8

Page 9: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Informal recycling

Characteristics of the informal sector

Small-scale

Labour-intensive

Largely unregulated and registered

Low-technology in manufacturing or provision of services

Often carried out by individuals or family groups

9

Page 10: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Informal recycling

Economic impact of waste pickers

In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23 million / year in lower imports of raw material, and reduced need for collection, transport and disposal equipment, personnel and facilities. (Medina, 2005)

Informal recycling systems can bring significant economic benefits:

Steady, reliable supply of secondary raw materials

Stimulation of manufacture of low-cost, affordable products from recycled materials

Generates less pollution than obtaining virgin materials

Scavenging reduces the amount of wastes that need to be collected, transported and disposed of (→ cost savings, less air pollution from fewer collection trucks, life extension of landfills)

10

Page 11: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of plastic waste 11

Plastic Waste Recoveryin Developing Countries

Page 12: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of plastic waste

Environmental impacts of plastic

Harmful smoke

Blockage of drainage systems

Persistence in the environment (likely for 500 – 1000 years)

Page 13: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of plastic waste

Why recycle plastic?

Recycling recovers the raw material, which can be used to make new plastic products.

Reasons to start plastic recycling in developing countries:

Imported Raw materials are very expensive!

Labour costs are lower

Trasportation costs are often lower

It is suited to taking on small-scale recycling activities

Page 14: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of plastic waste

Plastic from raw and recycled materials

Material Price of raw material (€/t)

Price of recycled material (€/t)

LDPE 1300 - 1330 20 - 378

HDPE 1160 - 1200 100 - 650

PET 1250 - 1300 220 - 430

Page 15: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of plastic waste

Plastic from raw and recycled materials

Energy used to recycle plastic bottles is 8 times less than the energy

required manufacturing the same virgin polymer!

Page 16: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Types of recyclable plastic

Low density polyethylene

- LDPE

High density polyethylene

- HDPE

Polypro-pylene-

PP

Polyvinylchloride- PVC

Polyethylene terephthalate

- PET

Page 17: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of plastic waste: sorting

Simple tests

Page 18: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: recycling process

Overview of processes which can take place in a plastic recycling plant: with each step the value of the waste material increses, as the value of plastic as a secondary resource depends on its purity and composition

Page 19: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of plastic waste: collection

House-to-house collection:

combined with other materials

plastic only, but all types ofpolymers

certain objects only

Collection at a central point

Other ways:

informal collection in return for payment

regular collection from shops, hotels, restaurants,etc.

Page 20: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of plastic waste: baling

Baling:

After collecting and sorting the plastic material the option exists to sell the material to (other) processing units. Especially when transporting distances are considerable, it is important to compact waste to improve handly and save costs during transport.

Page 21: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: cleaning

A. Washing

B. Drying

manually

mechanically

manually

mechanically

The plastics can be washed at various stages of reprocessing: before, after, or even during sorting.

Page 22: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: size reduction

Cutting:

Initial size reduction of large objects

Shredding:

Suitable for smaller pieces

Product of shredding: pile of coarseirregularly shaped plastic flakes whichcan then be further processed

Agglomeration:

Cutting, preheating and drying of softplastic waste

Page 23: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: pelletizing

Plastic flakes

Plastic spaghetti

Pellets

Page 24: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: pelletizing

Plastic flakes

Plastic spaghetti

Pellets

A pelletizer in Hargeisa

Page 25: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: pelletizing

Pellets

Page 26: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: further processing

Extrusion moulding

Soft PVC tube

Production of pipes, tubes

Page 27: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: further processing

Injection moulding

Production of miscellaneous itemsShoe soles

Page 28: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: further processing

Blow moulding

Production of bottles

Page 29: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: further processing

Page 30: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: recycling process

Page 31: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: recycling process

Price of plastic at different steps of the process (€/kg)

HDPE

0.35 after collection

0.54 after baling

0.8 after pelleizing

LDPE

0.2 after collection

0.24 after baling

0.45 after shredding

0.82 after pelletizing

Page 32: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste plastic: recycling process

Price of plastic at different steps of the process (€/kg)

PET

0.3 after collection

0.32 after baling

0.52 after shredding

0.89 after pelletizing

Separation bycolour:

Clear and light bluePET is far morevaluable thancoloured PET

Page 33: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of plastic waste: examples from Senegal, Mauritania and Burkina Faso

Page 34: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of metal waste 34

Metal Waste Recoveryin Developing Countries

Page 35: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of aluminium and iron

Konyo Konyo Market (Juba, Sudan)

AIRCHARCOAL

BYCYCLE WHEEL

35

Page 36: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of aluminium and iron

Konyo Konyo Market: Iron

36

Page 37: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of paper waste 37

Paper Waste Recoveryin Developing Countries

Page 38: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Types of waste that can be recovered

Recycling of waste paper

Main grade Examples Value

Printing and writing Computer printout, computer cards, printers trimmings, school and letter papers, “pams”

medium

Kraft sacks Resale as sacks high

Corrugated cardboards Waste paper low

Cartons Waste paper – Sale as cartons medium

Newspaper Printed - Unprinted medium

Mixed waste paper Dirty - Clean low

Source: Vogler, 1981

38

Page 39: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

The cheapest way is by putting it into a sack, but this does not hold enough to be profitable.

The next step is a hand-cart, small enough for one person, or a bigger one for a large enterprise.

Recycling of waste paper

Ways of collecting waste paper

39

Page 40: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Manufacture of egg and fruit boxes from old cartons

Manufacture of paper bags and funnels

Waste paper as a fuel (also after briquetting)

Recycling of waste paper

Direct re-use of waste paper

40

Page 41: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste paper

Baling process and presses

Baling means squashing the paper in square-shape bundle and tying it up with wires or strings.

Makes the transport cheaper

Makes the storage cheaper

Adds value to the product

Advantages of baling

No long transportation

No need for storage

No need to lift the bale

Not desirable when

41

Page 42: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste paper

Small-scale paper making plant

Machine Action

Raw material Waste paper or agricultural waste

Digester Cooking with caustic soda or lime

Hollander beater Breaking down to basic fibres, washing and bleaching

Cylinder mould machine Making the pulp (water is sucked out through a drain)

Cutting roll Peel of the pulp in sheets

Hydraulic press Squeezed between smooth rollers

An Indian example

42

Page 43: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of waste paper

Small-scale paper making plant

Hollander beater

Cylinder mould machine

Hydraulic press

43

Page 44: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Organic Waste Recoveryin Developing Countries

44

Page 45: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of organic waste

Problems related to dumping of organic waste

Leachate (pollution of soil, surface- and groundwater)

Attraction of animals

Uncontrolled methane production

Shortening of landfill lifespan

Page 46: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

46

Organic Recycling Activities

Page 47: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of organic waste: composting

What is composting?

Composting is an aerobic process that converts waste into a humus-likematerial through microbial action on the organic portion of the solid waste.If carried out effectively, the final product is stable, odour-free, does notattract flies and can act as a soil fertilizer.

Page 48: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of organic waste: composting

Processes during composting

Page 49: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of organic waste: composting

Main advantages of composting

Minimize waste amounts in

dump sites and landfills

Reduce waste management costs

(e.g. transportation, disposal)

Improve nutrient and humus

content and soil condition of

agricultural land

Reduce environmental impact of

waste

Comply with national legislation

and policy

Low-cost composting techniques

available

Creates employment

Page 50: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of organic waste: composting

Some methods of composting

Windrow composting

windrow with a triangular cross-sectionmanual or mechanical turning

Barrel (or box) composting

concrete or steel barrel one or a group of families

Biodegradable waste is biologically decomposed by microorganisms under aerobic conditions and generation of heat in about 6-8 weeks

Page 51: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of organic waste: composting

Some methods of composting

Vermicomposting

is a process where pre-composted wasteis fed to earthworms, which digest thematerial. The worms can digest halftheir weight in waste per day.

Page 52: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of organic waste: composting

Types of composting schemes

Backyard Composting

Community-Based Neighborhood Composting

Composting on Institution or Company Premises

Medium Scale Composting Enterprises

Centralised Waste Treatment Facilities

Page 53: Waste reuse and recycling · 2015-12-23 · Informal recycling Economic impact of waste pickers In Bangkok, Jakarta, Karachi and Manila, scavenging saves each city at least US$ 23

Recycling of organic waste: composting

Lessons learnt

Support by population

Profit

Support by local authority

Reasons for success

Neighborhood resistance

Financial losses

Local authority resistance

Reasons for potential failure

Social factors Financial factors

Institutional factors