Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment et al. -- Petitioner's Motion For Leave to...

7/23/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment et al. -- Petitioner's Motion For Leave to Proceed in Forma P

1/24

Cl .

EC ]DN

Ru pr ng n Blurt li t jn tl etnf S th tn k

G H V B ^ R E R H EH D [ H R D E C K ] L C ,

_nt e t elcnr ,

Y .

[ E A A E H G G L V V E R N C M N H Y L V N C ] N V ] H E C G N C ] A A B ilrg nray tfb [ E A A E H G

G L V V E R H K N C B U ) , J N I I G N H M N h cm R H V H D [ E C E H V R @ E ,

V n s p l c m n c t s .

Lc _nt e t elc ilr [re t li Bnrt elrhre tl tdn ^ce tnm Rth tns

Blurt li Hppnhas ilr tdn Rnblcm Berbue t

G L ] E L C I L V A N H Y N ] L _ V L B N N M E C I L V G H _ H ^ _ N V E R

Gr. Ghrbus E sh e hd [hsd eck tlc

rl Rn

_nt e t elcnr

>= Flnrug Rtrnnt , Hpt . 9G

Frll` ayc , CU 886?9

9=9) >?=-9=5;

d u g h c r ekdts .h r n h g u s t O k g h e a . b l g


2/24

] FAN LI BLC ]NC]R

] H F A N L I B L C ] N C ] R ] H F A N L I B E ] N M H ^ ] D L V E ] E N R e

A N K H A R ] H C M H V M V N K H V M E C K EC I L V G H _ H ^ _ N V E R

( EI_ )

8

F V E N I N T _ A H C H ] E L C [ D U G V . [ H R D E C K ] L C ' R EC I L V G H _ H ^ N V _ E R R ] H ] ^ R

R D L ^ A M D H Y N C N Y N V F N N C V N Y L @ N M F U _. @ N Y E C B H R ] N A H C M ] D N R N B L C M

B E V B ^ E ] 6

R ^ _ V N G N B L ^ V ] B A N V @ R ' V N I ^ R H A ] L H B B N _ ] G V . [ H R D E C K ] L C ' R J ^ A U 84 ,

6 ? 8> G L ] E L C ] L M E R X ^ H A E I U A L N F A L N F A A _ B L C R ] E ] ^ ] N R H C L F R ] V ^ B ] E L C

L I J ^ R ] E BN H C M Y E L A H ] N R G V . [ H R D E C K ] L C ' R B L C R ] E ] ^ ] E L C H A V E K D ] R ] L

M ^ N _ V L B N R R H C M N X ^ H A _ V L ] N B ] E L C ^ C M N V ] D N A H [ 9

C L ] H V E Z N M H I I E M H Y E ] M N G L C R V H ] E C K G V . [ H R D E C K ] L C ' R E C M E K N C ]

R ] H ] ^ R 5

_ V H U N V R I L V V N A E N I 8 ?

B L C B A ^ R E L C 8 6


3/24

]HFAN LI BE]NM H ^]DL VE]ENR

Bhsn Ahw

Mn ctlc v . Dn rch cmn z. >?= ^.R . 6> (855 6) 8

C n e t z ` n Y [ea a e hg s . =5? ^ .R . 285 (8545) 8

Vl wn Nc tn r t h ecg nc t . Ecb . v . [e a a e hg G l g s H kncby . Ecb . , Cl . 54 BY 46;6 , 6??> [ A 66 422

(R.M.C . U. Jhc . > , 6?? >), hii m , 89; I . Hp p x 66; (6m B er . 6??>) , bnrt, mncen m , >=5 ^ .R . 44 ;, 86;

R.Bt. 642, 899

A Nm 6m

8>6 (6? ?9) 8?

Blcstetutelcha _rlveselcs

> t d H g n c m g n c t l i

^ .R .

Blc st e tu t elc 4 , 88

8= td Hgncmgnc t l i

^ . R .

Bl cst e tu t elc 4 . 88

Rthtutns

Beve a Vekd ts Hbt li 8499, =6 ^.R .B. 8548 6

Beve a Vek dts Hbt li 85 9=, =6 ^.R .B. 6?? ?n nt snq 6

Mn prevh t elc li Vek dts , =6 ^.R .B. 8542 >

Mn prevh t elc li Vekd ts ^c mnr Blal r li Ah w, 84 ^.R .B. 6=6 2

Ml ccna ay Hbt , Kncnrha Fu secns s Ah w 2 =? nt snq. 6

Inmn rha Hrfe t rh t el c Hbt li 856>, 5 ^.R .B. 8nt snq 6

@u @aux @ahc Hb t l i

8 4 ; 8 ,

=6 ^. R .B. 854>(2 ) 6 ,>

C nw U lr` Be ty Du gh c Vekd t s Ahw, Cn w Ulr` Hm eg gst rh t e vn Bl mn 4 -8?8

nt. snq

6

C nw U lr` R th tn Du gh c Vekd t s Ahw , C nw Ulr` Nxnb u t evn Ahw 65? nt. snq 6

Lfs t rubt elc li Just ebn , 84 ^.R .B. 8>?2 9 , 8?

Rdn rg hc Hct e t rust Hbt , 8> ^.R .B. 8nt snq 6

ee


4/24

Ahw Hrtebans

Ans a e n [. Hfrhgslc . ]dn Jumkn s Ntdebha Muty tl Vnplrt G esblcmubt fy Ltdnr Jumkns hcm

Ahwynrs hcm ets Niinbt lc Jumebeha Ecmnpncmncbn. Dlis t rh Ah w Vn venw : Yla . 6>: Ess . 2 , Hrt eb an = .

(855;) 5

Jlsnpd J . Hcba enc .

Frlhmnr Es Fnttnr: ]dn Ecdnrnct _lwn rs li Inmnrha Blurts.

9 = C U ^ H c c u h a

Rurvny l i Hg nr e bhc Ah w 2; , =; (6??4) 5

] d l g h s N . F h ` n r.

]dn Ecdnrnct _lwnr ]l Egplsn Rhcbtelcs: Dlw H Inmnrha Jumkn Es Ae`n H

4??-_lucm Klreaah, 8= Vn v. Aet ek. 85> (8 55 =) 5

R tnpdnc Ke a a n rs. Alwnreck ]dn Fhr: Dlw Ahwynr Mesbepaecn Ec Cnw Ulr` Iheas ]l _rltnbt ]dn

_ufaeb. C nw Ulr ` ^cevnrse ty Jlurcha li Ankes ah t elc h cm _uf a eb _la eby , Yla . 8; , Cl . 6 , (6?8= ) . ..5

Ju a ns Alfn a hcm Fhrfh rh [lavlv e t z . ]dn Ncilrbngnct li Bevea Vekdts Rthtutns: ]dn Vnhkhc

Hmg ecestrhtelc s Vnblrm. 5Fahb ` A. J . 6>6 (854 9) 5

J u m e td H . G b G l r r l w . ]dn (I)uteaety li Vuans: Vnkuahteck Httlrcny Blcmubt Ec Inmnrha Blurt

_rhbtebn. >4 RG ^ Ah w Vn v enw 2 , 6? (6??>) 5

J u m e t d H . G b G l r r l w . Vuan 88 hcm Inmnrhaezeck Ahwynr Ntdebs. Fr ekdhg Uluck ^c evn rs e t y Ah w

Vnv enw . (8558) 5

Mhc en a J . Gnhmlr , Ecdnrnct .Jumebeha Hutdlrety ec tdn Blcmubt li Bevea Aetekhtelc, ;2 ]nx . A. Vn v.

84?> , 84?> (855 >) 5

Jln A. Rnaek. ]dn Vnhkhc Justebn Mnphrtgn ct hcm Bevm Vekdts: [aeht [nct [rlck< 854> ^. EEE.

A. Vnv . ;4> (854 >) 5

Hch ays e s : Inmn rh a Ahw l i H t tl rcny Blcmub t . R t rub tu rn l i Inmn rh a Vu ans Klv nrc eck H t tl rcny

Blc mub t . G ll rn ' s Inmn rh a _ rhb t e bn - B ev e a. (6?8>) 5

g


5/24

Ilr tdn il a alweck rnhslcs fnalw, E -

prl sn

pn t e t e lcn r Ghrbus E sh e hd [hsd eck tlc - sufge t t d e s

Glt elc tl _ rlbnnm Ec Ilrgh _hupnr e s pu rsuhc t t l Ruprngn Blur t Vu an 25 hcm hs` tdht tdn

nxt rhlrmechry rn a eni rnqunstnm ec td es glt elc, hs wna a hs gy pnt e t elc ilr h wre t li bnrt elrhre , fn

krhctnm .

Ankh a R thcmhrm Vnkhr m eck Ec Ilr gh _hupn r e s ( EI_ )

Ec Cn e t z`n v . [e a a e hgs . =5? ^ .R . 285 (8545) , t dn Ruprngn Blur t l i t dn ^c e t nm R t h t n s l i Hgnr e bh

sthtnm:

]dn inmnrha ec ilrgh phupnres s th tu tn , nchbtnm ec 8456 hcm prnsnct ay blme i enm hs 64 ^.R .B.

8 5 8 > ,

es mnsekcnm tl ncsurn tdht ecmeknct a e t ekhcts dhvn gnhceckiua hbbnss tl tdn inmnrha

blu rts . . . ]l wh rm td es ncm, 858>(h) h a alws h a e t ekhct tl bl gg nc bn h b ev ea lr br egech a hb t elc ec

inmnrha blurt ec ilrgh phupnres fy ie a eck ec kllm ihetd hc hiiemhvet stht eck, ectnr ha eh, tdht dn es

uchfan tl phy tdn blsts li tdn ahwsue t .

Em . h t 26=. ]l prnvnct subd hfusevn lr bhpt elus a e t ekht elc , 858>(n)(6) hutdlrezns inmnrha blurts tl

mesg ess tdn bhsn h t hcy t egn e i tdn blurt mn tnrg ecns tdht (H) tdn h a ankht elc li plvnrty e s uct ru n0

lr (F) tdn hbt elc lr hppnha (e ) es irevlalus lr gha eb elus0 (e e) ihe as tl sthtn h baheg lc wdebd rndni

ghy fn krhctnm0 lr ( e e e ) snn`s glcnthry rn a eni hkhecst h mnincmhct wdl es eggucn irlg subd rnaeni

(ngpdhs e s hmmnm)

Ec Mnc tlc v . Dnrchcmnz , >?= ^ .R . 6> (8556) , td n Ruprngn Blurt s th tnm:

PEWc lrmnr tl rnspnbt tdn blckrnsselcha klha li hssureck nquha e ty li blcsemnrh t elc ilr h a a

a e t ekhcts , tdn ec e t eh a hssnssgnct li tdn ec ilrgh phupnres p ah ec t e iis ihb tuha h a ankht elcs gust fn

wnekdtnm ec tdn p ah ec t e iis ihvlr. H i ecmeck li ihb tuha ir evlaluscnss e s hpprlpreh tn wdnc tdn

ihbts h a anknm r e sn tl tdn anvna li tdn e rrh t elcha lr tdn wd la ay ecbr nmefan , wd ntdnr l r clt tdnrn hrn

jumeb eh a ay clt ebnhfan ihbts hvhe ahfan tl blct rhmeb t tdng. Hc ec ilrceh phupnres blgpahec t ghy

clt fn m esgessnm, dlwnvnr, s egpay fnbhusn tdn blurt i ecms tdn p ah ec t e iis h a ankht elcs uca e`nay .

Rlgn egprlfhf an h a a nkh t elcs gekd t p rlpn r ay fn m e splsnm l i lc sugghry jumkgnc t , fu t t l

mesgess tdng hs ir evlalus we tdlut hcy ihbtuha mnvnalpgnct e s tl m esrnkhrm tdn hkn l am ecsekdt

tdht ghcy h a ankht elcs gekd t fn s t rhckn, fut t run0 ilr t ru td es h awhy s s t rhckn. R t rhcknr tdhc

iebi elc. Alr m Fy rlc , Ml c Juhc, bhctl TE Y, s thczh 8?8 (]. R tniihc , N. R tniihc

b

[. _rht t nms .

85;;).

Em . h t 6>-69.

8


6/24

Freni Nxpahchtelc [dy Gr. [hsdecktlc s Ec Ilrceh _hupnres Rthtus Rdluam Dhvn Cnvnr

Fnnc Vnvl`nm fy _. @nvec Bhstna hcm Rnblcm Berbuet

Lc Mnbngfnr 66, 6?8?,8 imnm h mntheanm 4?-phkn Blgpahect wetd tdn Rlutdnrc Mestrebt li Cnw

U l r `

haankeck tdht gy ilrgnr ngpalynr [eaaehg Glrres Ncmnhvlr Nctnrthecgnct AAB (ilrgnray

`clwc hs tdn [eaaehg Glrr es Hkncby) - tdn lamnst hcm ahrknst thanct hkncby ec Dla aywllm - whs

ectnctelchaay nckhkeck ec h phttnrc hcm prhbtebn li mesbregecht eck hkhecst Hirebhc Hgnre bhcs

sphcceck 886 ynhrs, ghecthececk ngpalygnct prhbtebns, plaebens hcm prlbnmurns tdht brnhtnm h

kahreck mesphrhtn egphbt hkhecst quhaeienm Hirebhc Hgnrebhcs irlg fneck dernm hcm/lr prlgltnm tl

dekdnr-sthtus, dekdnr-phyeck plsetelcs subd hs Hknct hcm Hknct ]rhecnn, prn hcm-plst dereck

ecmevemuha mesphrhtn trnhtgnct, rnthaehtelc hcm hemeck & hfntteck bahegs hkhecst DV pnrslccna Jnii

Gnhmn hcm Rhrhd [ecehrs`e (clw `clwc hs Rhrhd Yhc Dlvnc) ec velahtelc li Rnbtelc 8548 li tdn

Bevea Vekdts Hbt li 8499, =6 ^ . R . B . 8548 ( Rnbtelc 8548 ), ]etan YEE li tdn Bevea Vekdts Hbt li

859=, hs blmeienm, =6 ^.R.B. 6???n tl 6???n-8; ( ]etan YE E ), tdn Cn w Ulr` Rthtn D ug hc

V e k d t s Ahw , Cn w Ulr` Nxnb utev n Ahw 65? nt. snq. (tdn CU RD VA ) hcm tdn Cn w Ulr` Bety

Dug hc Vekdts Ahw, Cn w Ulr` Hmgecestrhtevn Blmn 4-8?8

nt. snq.

(tdn CUBD VA ).' Hitnr

sufgetteck hc Hiiemhvet mntheaeck gy burrnct iechcbeha setuhtelc. Bdeni Jumkn Alrntth H. _rns`h

krhctnm gy ec ilrgh phupnres rnqunst lc Jhcuhry =, 6?88 .

Mnspetn gy lfjnbtelcs tl tdn ncilrbnhfeaety li twl ghcmhtlry, prn-mesputn hrfetrhtelc

hkrnngncts E sekcnm hs h blcmetelc li ngpalygnct, inmnrha mestrebt jum kn _. @nvec Bhstna ekclrnm

gy ankha hrkugnc ts, nrrlcnlus hppaenm tdn Inmnrha Hrfetrhtelc Hbt li 856> hcm essunm h Rthy

Lrmnr blgpnaa eck tdn bhsn ectl hrfetrhtelc lc Juay 6?, 6?8 8. Ec lr hrlucm tdn tegn Hrfetrhtlr

E ilrghaay hmmnm bahegs li hctetrust velahtelcs ucmnr tdn Rdncchc Hctetrust Hbt, 8> ^.R.B. 8 nt snq.

hcm Mlccnaay Hbt, Kncnrha Fusecnss Ahw 2=?nt snq. hs wnaa hs bahegs l i blcspe rhby tl ectnrinrn wetd

td ndughc rekdts li Hir ebhc Hgnrebhcs ec velahtelc li tdn@u @aux @ahc Hbt li

8 4 ; 8

=6 ^.R.B.

854> 2)

wdnc 8sufgettnm gy Mnghcm ilr Hrfetrhtelc wetd tdn Hgnrebhc Hrfetrhtelc Hsslbehtelc lc Jucn

8>

6?86.

6


7/24

Mhv em A. Krn klry whs sbdnmuanm tl e ssun d es lg cef us i echa mnb es elc, E eci e)rgnm inmnrha jum kn

_ . @nvec Bhstn a fy an t tnr lc Infruhry 64, 6?8= tdht wlu am fn i e aeck h gl t elc wd ebd slukdt d es

mesquha e i ebh t elc , hcm wl uam fn hmmr nsseck tdn lvnrha a pht tn rc li irhum uplc tdn Bl urt tdht

h t t l rcnys i rlg Alnf & Alnf AA_ wnrn nckhkgk g lc fndh a i l i [e a a e hg Glrr e s t l ncsu rn t dh t

Hir e bhc Hgnr e bhc d t ekhc t s bdh a a nckgk [e a a e hg Glrr e s ' e c s t e t u t e lch a ay rhb e s t ngpalygnc t hcm

fusecnss prhbt ebns wluam fn mnprevnm li tdne r iu a a blcst e tu t elcha hcm s th tu tlry r ekdts ucmnr tdn blalr

li tdn ahw ec v el ah t elc li 84 ^.R .B. 6=6. Ht i erst , Bhstn a nc mlrs nm g y an t tnr hcm sn t h sbdn muan ec

wdebd tdn phrt ens wnrn tl sufget tdne r p anhmecks. Lc Ghrbd ; , 6?8=, Alnf & Alnf AA_ ht tlrcny

Bdres t ehc Bhrflcn sufget tnm h an t tnr tl Bhstn a s th t eck tdht Hrfe t rh tlr Krnklry 's _hrt eh a I echa Hwhrm

wh s clt h i echa Hw hrm . Lc G hrb d 8?, 6?8 =, 6?8 =, Bhstn a e ssunm hc Lrm nr wd ebd fhsebha ay tl am

g n blu am cl t sufge t t dn p rlplsnm Glt elc hcm tdh t dhm tl blct ecun hrfe t rh t eck ec kll m ih e td .

Lc Gh rbd 8;, 6?8= - 5? mhys hi tnr Hrf e t rh tlr Mhv em A. Krn klry e ssunm des _hrt eh a I ec ha

Hwhrm - E sufge t t nm h vl augeclus , 5; -phkn I rhum ^plc tdn Blur t Glt elc , wd ebd slukd t

nx t rhl rm ech ry rnaeni ecbaumeck tdn m esquha e i ebh t elc li fltd inmnrha jumkns hssekcnm tl tdn bhsn

hcm /l r t dn m esquh a e i ebh t elc l i h t tl rcnys Gebd hn a _ . Zw nek hcm Bd r e s t e hc Bhrf lcn l i Alnf & Alnf

A A_ mun tl irhum uplc tdn Bl urt hcm dekday ucntdebha hcm breg echa hb t ev e ty . ] w l mhys ah tnr ,

Alnf & Alnf AA_ ie anm h Glt elc tl dlam gn ec Blctngpt . Lc Ghrbd 6;, 6?8=, Bhstn a e ssunm hc

Lrm nr rniuseck tl m esquha e iy d egs na i hcm s th tnm tdht Pv j enw nm hs h tl th a e ty , hc l fjnbt evn ,

m es ec tnrnstnm lfsnrvnr iu a ay ecilgenm li tdn ucmnray eck ihbts wluam clt nctnrth ec s ekce i ebhct mluft

tdht just ebn wluam fn mlc n ec td es hb t elc hfsnct rnbush a li tdn ucm nrsek cnm. Lc Hpre a 8? , 6? 8= ,8

sufg e t t nm h Gl t elc ilr Vnblcs emn rh t elc , wd ebd whs cl td eck g lrn tdhc h blcmnc snm vn rs elc l i gy

G hrbd 8;, 6?8= panhm eck.


8/24

Hi tn r Rbdchmnr AA_ h t tl rcny hcm HHH flhrm l i m e r nb tl r ] egltdy @. Anwes m e sgessnm gy

bhsn we td prnjumebn hcm lc tdn gn r e t s lc Jucn 6>, 6?8 =, tdn Hp pna ann s slukdt tl blci e rg An we s '

i rhumuanct ay prlburn m Iecha Hw hrm lc Juay 2 , 6?8= . Lc Juay 86, 6? 8= ,8 sufg et tnm h an t tnr tl

Bhstna s th t eck tdht tdn hrkugn cts rh esnm ec gy Gh rbd 8;, 6?8= hcm Hp r e a 8? , 6?8= G lt el cs

m ehgnt r e bh a ay lpplsn Pm W hcm vl em P nm W hcy ' a nkh a ' h rkugnc t pu t i l r td fy [GN Nctn r t h ecgnc t hcm

Aln f & Aln f AA _ hcm tdh t t dn e r glt elcs sdlu am fn mnc enm . Bhs t n a t dnc p r n tncmnm tl f r nh` m lw c

tdn hrkug ncts rh esnm ec gy G hrb d 8;, 6?8 = Irhum ^pl c tdn Blur t hcm Hpr e a 8? , 6?8 = Gl t elc ilr

Vnblcsemnrht elc ec tl ilur phr ts . Dn sth tnm:

Ec lpplse t elc tl tdn mnincmhcts ' glt elc tl blci e rg tdn hwhrm, [hsdecktlc prlvemns ilur

hrkugncts hs tl wdy tdn hrfe t rh a hwhrm sdluam fn snt hsemn. I e r s t , [hsdecktlc hrkuns tdht

Hrf e t r h tl r Krnklry whs egprlpn r ay r nglv nm hcm , blcsnqunc t ay , h aa l i Hrf e t r h tl r Anw es ' l rmn r s ,

ecbaumeck vhbht eck Hrfe t rh tlr Krnklry 's phr t eh a hwhrm, hrn vlem . Rnblcm, [hsdecktlc hssnr ts

tdht Hrfe t rh tlr Krnklry hcm Hrfe t rh tlr Anwes 's mnbes elcs tl ncilrbn tdn hrfe t rh t elc hkrnngnct

wnrn ec ghceinst m esrnkhrm li tdn ahw. ]derm , [hsdecktlc hrkuns tdht tdn ihe aurn tl mesbalsn

tdn h a a nknm rn ah t elcsd ep fntwnnc lppls eck blucsn a hcm hc HHH ngpalynn

fehsnm tdn

hrfe t rh a prlbnnmeck ec tdn mnincmhcts ' ihvlr . I echa ay , dn hssnr ts tdht tdn lpplseck blucsna dhs

f n n c nckhkeck ec h phttnrc li fhm ihe td a e t ekht elc whr r hc t eck tdn e r r nglvh a hcm shcb t elcs .

P_@ B Iecha Lrmn r , 8= , W Ec lcn why lr hcltdnr , dn lg et tnm pnr t ecnct ihbts hcm gesh ppa enm tdn ahw

ec lrmnr tl mncy ha a li tdnsn hrkugncts , hcm tdnc ilr nxt rh prltnbt elc, dn krhctnm [ea a ehg Glrr es

hcm Alnf & Al nf 's Juay 8?, 6?8= G lt elc ilr h Ie a eck Ecjucbt elc, rnvl`nm g y ec ilrg p upnres

sth tus h a tdlukd gy nblclgeb b e rbugsthcbns dhvn lcay wlrsncnm secbn i e a eck gy Blgpahect we td

tdn Rlutdnrc Mest r eb t li Cnw Ulr` ec Mnbngfnr li 6?8? hcm prnjumebnm gy hppnha fy s th t eck tdht

e t wl uam clt fn gh mn ec kllm ih e td .

Lc Lbtlfnr 2 , 6?8=,8 i e anm h >=-phkn Inm. V. Bev . _ . 9? Irhum ^plc tdn Blur t Glt elc.

G y iecha pan hm eck whs sufg ettnm tl rnhaek c tdn rnblrm ec tdn mernbielc li trut d hcm wret tn c ec h

why hs ei E wnrn sufgett eck hc hppnha mernbtay tl tdn hppnaahtn blurt mun tl tdn ihbt tdht e t whs

dekday uca e`nay tdht Bhstn a wluam ec d es ahst Lrmnr , hb`clwanmkn des wrlckmleck secbn e t wluam


9/24

ua t eghtnay supplrt tdht

dn dhs

ec tnct elcha ay mnprevnm

gn

li gy blcst e tu t elcha

hcm

sthtutlry rekdts

ec v el ah t elc li =6 ^ .R .B . 8542 hcm =6 ^ . R . B .854> 2). Gy p r eghry klh a whs tl mnglcs t rh t n

tdht ei Ememd h v n tl hppnh a Bhs t n a ' s vh r elus Lrmn rs , gy hppnh a wlu am fn g h m n ec nx t rng n kllm

ihetd

. 6

E i gy glt elc snn` eck tl rnvnr sn td es ghc einst ec just ebn whs clt k rhc tnm , E hs`nm Bhstn a

ec

tdn

ha tnrcht evn ,

tl

rns tl rn

gy EI_

sth tus

sl

tdht E bluam sufg et

gy

hppnha

ec

blcs emn rhf an kllm

ihe td tl tdn hppna ah tn blurt .

E

ecbaumnm

hc

upmhtnm , clthreznm Hiiemhve t mnth e a eck gy ecmeknct s th tus

hs hc nxd ef e t tl gy Inm. V. Bev. _. 9? I r h u m ^ p l c tdn Blur t Glt elc . Lc L b t l f n r 66, 6?8=, _.

@nvec Bhstn a e ssunm

h twl

phkn Lrmn r , mncy eck

tdn

nc t e rn Glt elc

hs

fn eck we tdlu t gnr e t

hcm

rniusnm tl rnstlrn gy c ilrg p upnres sth tus fhsnm lc h s t h t ngnc t ghmn ec tdn illtcltn li g y

G l t e l c . F h s n m lc Bhs t n a ' s egprlv emnc t rn splcsn hcm rnpnhtnm rniusha tl h b ` c l w a n m k n lr rnsl avn

gy b a h egs l i i rhum uplc tdn Blu r t hkh ecs t Alnf

&

A l n f A A _ ,

et es

banhr tdht et wh s egp rhbt ebh fan

ilr gn tl glvn i e rs t ec tdn mes t r eb t blurt hcm nxpnbt Bhstn a ilur ynhrs ah tnr , tl h b ` c l w a n m k n des

n r rl rs

hcm

egphrt eh a ay updlam

tdn ahw hcm

^.R. Blcste tutelc. '*

R ecbn

E whs

uchf an

tl

hiilrm

tdn

$>?> ie a eck

inn tl

sufge t

gy

C l t e b n

li

H p p n h r h c b n ,

E

sufge t t nm hc Nxpnm e t nm Glt elc tlV n s t l r n Ec Ilrg h _hupnr e s R t h tus , Ruspncm I e a e ck Ec jucb t elc

S Albha Vuan 6=.8 rnquerns tdht td es Gl telc emnct e i ens tdn rnanvhct ihbts hcm g h ` n s h s d l w e c k li d`nay

gnr e ths tlnhbd essuntdn hppna ahct ectncms tlprnsnc t lc hppnh a .

SE sthtnm: E bhc ieaaec tdn fahc`s Pblcthecnm ec gy Lbtlfnr 2 ,6?8=Gl t e l c W ec gy hppnha tl tdn Rnblcm

Berbue t lr 'ucmnr lhtd ' fnilrn h juey treha g h snphehtn hbt elc wdnc sun _. @nvec Bhstna ilr ectnct elcha ay

mnpr ev eckgn li gy rekdts ucmnrtdn blalr li ahw.

_ursuhc t Inm .V.H p p ._. 4(h)(8)(B),hphrty gust lrmechre ay glv n ie rs t ectdn mes t r ebt bl urt ilr hc lrmnr

suspncmeck. . . hc ecjucbt elc wde an

hc

hppnh a

es

pncmeck. ' * _ursuhct tl Inm.

V.

H p p .

_.

4(h)(6) ,

h

gl t e l c

ilr

tdn rna eni gnct elcnm ec Vuan 4(h)(8)ghy fn g h m n tl tdn blurt li hppnh a slr tl lcn li e t s jumk ns . ]dn

glt elc gus t (e) sdlw tdht glveck i e rs t ec tdn mes t e ebt blurt wluam fn egprhb t e bhf an 0 lr

(ee) sthtn tdht, h

gltelc dhveck fnnc ghmn tdn mestrebt blurt mncenm tdn gltelc lr iheanm tl hiilrm tdn rnaeni rnqunstnm

hcm sthtn hcy rnhslcs kevncfy tdn mestrebt blurtilr etshbtelc. Inm. V.Hpp.

_.

4(h)(6)(H) (ngpdhses

hmmnm). ]dn gltelc gust hasl ecbaumn: (e) tdnrnhslcs ilr krhct eck tdn rna eni rnqunstnmhcm tdn ihbts rnaenm

lc 0 (ee)lrekechas lrblp ens lihiiemhvets lr ltdnr swlrc s thtngncts supplrt eck ihbts sufjnbt tl mesputn0hcm

( e ee ) rnanvhct phrts li tdn rnblrm. Inm.V. Hpp. 4(h)(6) .

>


10/24

h c m V n g l v n H aa _ r n j u m eb n _ n c m e c k K l l m - I h e t d H p p n h a l c C l v n g f n r 6 8 , 6?8= we td t dn Rnblcm

Berbue t , snn`eck ec phrt , tl dhvn gy

ec ilrg p upnres

sth tus rnstlrnmS hcm/lr tl dhv n gy hpp nha

t rhcsinrrnm tl hcltdnr b e rbue t .

Lc Ghrb d 88 , 6 ?8 > , Rnblcm Be rbu e t hppn a a h t n j umk ns Mncc e s Jhblfs hcm Vhyg lcm J .

Ald enr , Jr. hcm Rlutdn rc Mest r eb t li C nw Ulr ` mes t r eb t jum kn Ahu rh ]hyalr Rw hec mncenm gy hpp nha

ec twl snctncbns. ]dny rniusnm tl rnstlrn gy ec ilrgh phupnres s th tus hcm blcbaumnm tdht gy hppnha

ahb`PnmW hc hrkuhfan fhses ec n e tdnr ahw lr ec ihbt . ' '

R ecbn gy i echcbeh a b e rbugsthcbns dhvn lcay wlrsncnm lvnr tdn ahs t i evn ynhrs hcm clcn li

rhy ankha hrku gn cts rh esnm tdrluk dlut gy bhsn hcm hppnh a dhvn fnn c ir evlalus PlrW gha eb e lus ,

_.

@nvec Bhstn a sdluam dhvn cnvnr rnvl`nm gy EI_ s th tus hcm tdn Rnblcm Berbue t sdluam clt dhvn

ncilrbnm Bhstn a ' s mnbes elc. Ilr tdnsn rnhslcs h alcn , tdn mnbes elcs li tdn alwnr blurts hrn b anhray

nrrlc nlus hcm sdluam fn v e t eh tnm fy tdn Rupr ng n Blurt mun tl irhum upl c tdn Blurt fy tdn B lur t .

Ruprngn Blurt ' s Vniush a ]l Hbbnpt Gr. [hsd ecktlc ' s Ju ay 84 , 6?8> Glt elc tl Me squh a e iy

Aln f Aln f AA _ Blcst e tu tns Hc Lfs trubt elc l i Just e bn hcm Yel ah t ns G r. [ hsd ec ktlc ' s

Blcst e tu t elch a Vekdt s ]l Mun _rlbnss hcm Nquha _rltnb t elc ^cmnr tdn Ahw.

Hatdlukd E spnct tdn ierst sexty mhys mrhit eck h pnteielc ilr h wret li bnrt elrhre , E sufgettnm twl

G ltel cs lc Juay 8 4 , 6? 8> we td tdn Ruprng n Blurt snn`eck nxt rhlrmec hry rn a eni tl blrrnbt tdn

gesb hrr ehk n li just ebn tdht dhs th`nc pahbn tdrlu kdlu t td es cnhray i evn ynhr a e t ekht elc . ]d n i erst

Inm. V. Hpp. _. Vuan 6 =(h)(8 ) me rnbts tdht h phrty tl h mes t r ebt -blurt hbt elc wdl mnse rns tl hppnha ec il geh

phu pnr es gu st iean h g ltel c ec tdn mestrebt bl urt hcm sthtns tdht tdn phrty gu st htthb d hc hiiemhvet tdht: (H)

sdlws ec tdn mnthe a prnsbrefnm fy Ilcc = li tdn Hppncmex li Ilccs tdn phrty 's echfe a e ty tl phy lr tl kevn

snbure ty ilr inns hcm blsts 0 (F) bahegs hc nct e t angnct tl rnmrnss 0 hcm (B) s thtns tdn essuns tdn phrty ectncms

tl prnsnct lc hppnh a . Ec Vuan 6 =(h)(>) , e t s thtns tdht P t Wdn glt elc g ust ecbaumn h blpy li tdn hii emhve t i eanm

ec tdn mes t r ebt blurt hcm tdn mes tr ebt blurt 's s thtng nct li rnhslcs ilr e ts hbt elc. _ursuh ct tl Albha Vuan 6 =.8

li tdn Rnblcm Berbue t : H gltelc ilr anhvn tl hppnha ec ilrgh ph upn res . . .g ust ecbaumn (8 ) tdn hii emhve t

prnsbrefnm fy IVH_ 6=(h)(8) , hcm (6) h s thtngnct tdht emnct e i ens tdn rnanvhct ihbts hcm gh`ns h sdlweck li

a e`nay gnre t hs tl nhbd essun tdn hppna ahct ectncms tl prnsnct lc hppnha .

Lc Ghrbd 6> , 6?8>,8 i e anm h Gltelc ilr Vnblcsemnrht elc hcm lc Jucn 8 8 , 6?8>,8 i e anm h Gltelc tl Vnbha a

& Rthy tdn Ghcmhtn. Fltd wnrn mncenm fy tdn Rnblcm Berbue t we tdlut tdn essuhcbn li hc ntdebha jumebeha

lpecelc.

9


11/24

panhmeck whs h =? phkn Gltelc tl Mesquhaeiy Alnf & Alnf AA_ Mun ]l Irhum ^pl c tdn Blurt

pursuhct tl Rupr ngn Blurt Vuans 4S hcm 68S hcm tdn snblcm panhmeck whs h =? phkn Glte lc tl

_rlbnnm Ec Ilrgh _hupnres & Hppaebhtelc Ilr Nxtncselc ]l Rufget _ntetelc Ilr [ret li Bnrtelrhre

pursuhct tl Ruprngn Blurt Vuans 82(>) hcm 25/* Recbn h krhcteck li Gltelc tl Mesquhaeiy Alnf &

Alnf AA_ fy tdn Ruprngn Blurt wluam mesplsn li tdn nctern bhsn PhcmW wluam hiinbt tdn iecha

jumk gnct tl fn nctnrnm pursuhct tl Ruprngn Blurt Vuan 68(6)(f) , E hs`nm ilr hc nxtncselc tl

sufget tdn pntetelc hs h why tl blvnr haa fhsns secbn tdnrn whs h strlck ae`naedllm tdht tdn Ruprngn

Blurt wluam sdlw mninrncbn tl Bhstna hcm tdn Rnblcm Berbuet's nrrlcnlus mnbeselcs, prlvemn Alnf

& Alnf AA_ wetd tdn prnsugptelc tdht tdny wnrn fneck dlcnst hcm ntdebha hcm mncy gy bahegs

wetdlut prlvemeck hc ntdebha jumebeha lpecelc.

Ruprngn Blurt Vuan 4.8 sthtns:

[ d n c n v n r

h gngfnr li

td n

Fhr

li tdes

Blurt

d h s . .

nckhknm ec blcmubt ucfnblgeck h gngfnr li

tdn Fhr li tdes Blurt, tdn Blurt weaa nctnr

hc

lrmnr suspncmeck tdht gngfnr irlg prhbtebn

fnilrn

td esBlurthi ilrm eck tdn gng fnrhclppl r tuc e ty tlsdlw

bhusn ,

wetdec =?mhys ,wdyh m e sfhrgn c tlrmnr

sdluam clt fn nctnrnm. ^plc rnsplcsn, lr ei cl rnsplcsn es tucnay ieanm, tdn Blurt weaa nctnr hc

hpprlpr e h t n

lrmnr, (ngpdhses hmmnm)

hcmRuprngn Blurt Vuan 4.6 sthtns:

Hitnr rnhslchfan cltebn hcm hc lpplrtucety tl sdlw bhusn wdy mesbepaechry hbtelc sdluam clt fn

th`nc, hcm hitnr h dnhreck ei ghtnreha ihbts hrn ec mesputn, tdn Blurt ghy th`n hcy hpprlprehtn

mesbepaechry hbtelc hkhecst hcy httlrcny wdl es hmgettnm tl prhbtebn fnilrn et ilr blcmubt

ucfnblgeck h gngfnr li tdn Fhr lr ilr iheaurn tl blgpay wetd tdnsn Vuans lr hcy Vuan lr lrmnr

li tdnBlurt, (ngpdhses hmmnm)

R upr n g nBlurt Vuan68.8sthtns tdht

PnWvnr3'

gltelc tl tdn Blurt sdhaabanhray sthtnetspurplsnhcm tdn

ihbts lc wdebd et es fhsnm hcm ghy prnsnct ankha hrkugnct ec supplrt tdnrnli.

( n g pd hs e s hmmn m )

Vuan

68 .6 ( f )

sthtns tdht h

g l t e l c

tl mesgess hs

g l l t . . . hcm

hcy gltelc tdn krhcteck li wdebd wluam mesplsn

li tdn nctern bhsn lr wluam hiinbt tdn iecha jumkgnct tl fn nctnrnm

sdha a

fn

prnphrnm

hs

rnque e nm

fy Vuan

22 . 8 . . .nxbnpt

tdht h glvhct prlbnnmeck ec ilrceh phupnres ucmnr Vuan

2

5 . . .

sdhaa

iean tdn cugfnr

li blpens

rnque rnm

ilr h pntetelc fy subd h pnrslc ucmnr Vuan

86 .6 .

(ngpdhses hmmnm).

Recbn men Banr`

l i Blur t

rniusnm tl hbbnpt gy panhmecks lr dst tdng

lc tdn mlb`nt ,

rhy pahc whs tl ecbaumn

t dnsn p anhmecks

hs

Hppnc mebns tl

gy

pnt e t elc.

Dlwnvnr,

Ruprng n Blur t Vuan

8>(6)

sthtns

tdht

Pc Wl

snphrhtn

freni ec

supplrt

li h pnterelc

ilr h wret

li bnrt elrhre

ghy fn ieanm, hcm tdn Banr` weaa clt iean hcy pntetelc ilr

h

wret li

bnrt elrhre

tl wdebd hcy supplrteck

freni e s

hccnxnm lr hppncmnm. E dhvn upalhmnm haa panhmecks

ieanm

ec

tdes bhsn, sl tdny bhc fn rnhm dnrn: dttps://www.sbrefm .blg/Gr%6?Ha`nfu-ahc lr

www.g n hkh e c s t e c e q u e t y .wl r mp r n s s . bl g .

;


12/24

Lc Juay 6=, 6?8>, Zwnek sufget tnm h an t tnr hmmrnssnm tl Just ebn Kecsfurk nbdleck

sth tng ncts gh mn ec tdn alwn r blurts : gy b ah egs wn rn ir evlal us, tdht dhm nckhknm ec h wna a -

mlbu gnc tnm d es tl ry l i fhm - ih e t d blcm ub t , hcm tdh t gy hpp a e bh t elc sdlu am fn mnc enm fnbhusn

hglck ltdnr rnhslcs, P8W ih e a PnmW tl mnglcst rh tn hc nct e t angnct tl tdn rn a eni slukdt lr ns thfa e sd wdy

PEW cnn mPnm W hmme t elcha t egn tl i e an PgyW pnt e t elc ilr h wre t li bnrt elrhre we td td es B l u rt Lc Hu kus t

8 6 8> 8 rnbnevnm h an t tnr irlg Rblt t R . Dhrre s - tdn Banr` li Blurt - mhtnm Juay 65, 6?8>, s th t eck

tdht Just ebn Kecsfurk krhctnm gn hc nxtncselc, h a alweck gn uct e a Rnptngfnr 64, 6?8> tl sufget h

pnt e t elc ilr h wre t li bnrt elrhre . Ec hmme t elc tl tdn an t tnr s ekcnm fy Bhsn Hchayst Nre` Ilssug, tdn

lrek echa hcm h blpy li tdn Glt elc tl Mesquha e iy Alnf & Alnf AA_ wnrn rn turcnm tl gn.

Lc Hukus t 4 , 6?8> ,8 rn sufge t t nm tdn twl Glt elcs t l M e squh a e iy Alnf & Alnf AA_ tdh t

wnrn rn turcnm tl gn hcm sufget tnm h 86-phkn an t tnr hmmrnssnm tl Just ebn Kecsfurk , nxpah ec eck wdy

tdn Banr` li Blurt ' s rniusha tl hbbnpt td es Glt elc vel ah tnm gy blcst e tu t elcha r ekdt tl mun prlbnss

he em nquha prltnbt elc ucmnr tdn ahw ucmnr tdn >*Shcm Hg ncm gn cts li tdn ^.R . Blc\st etu telc ,

L c Hu kus t 84 , 6?8> - snvnc mhys hitnr E rnbnevnm blci e rght elc tdh t gy phb`h kn whs mna evnrnm tl

tdn Ruprngn Blurt - Ilssug ecilrgnm gn tdht gy phb`hkn whs albhtnm . ]dn cnxt mhy, gy an t tnr

hcm tdn Glt elc tl Mesquha e iy tdht rnsufget tnm wnrn rn turcnm tl gn. Ec h an t tnr mhtnm Hukust 8; ,

6 ? 8 > , Vhpp s th tnm:

]d n prhb t ebn li td es Blurt e s tl rn ay lc tdn s th tn ecvnst ekht evn h utdlre t ens w e td rnspnbt tl h a ankn m

ht tlrcny gesblcmubt . _ursuhct tl Vuan 4 li tdn Ruprngn Blurt Vuans td es Blurt we a a th`n hbt elc

wdnc h gngfnr li tdn Fhr li td es Blurt dhs fnnc mesfhrrnm lr suspncmnm irlg prhbt ebn lr wdnc

h i ecm eck tdh t t dn gngfnr dhs nckhknm ec blcmub t ucfnblgeck h gngfnr l i t dn Fhr dhs fnnc

ghmn. Ulu gekdt blcsemnr blcthbt eck tdn s th tn fhr li tdn s th tn ec wdebd tdn ecmevemuha e s

a ebncsnm tl snn wdht tdne r blgpahec t prlbnmurn e s .

Ec hc n-gh e a mhtnm Huku st 84 , 6? 8> , V hp p h asl s th tnm tdht td es Blu rt mlns clt nctnrth ec g lt elc s

tl m esfhr h t tlrcnys fhsnm lc ecmevemuha rnqunsts , wn hbt lcay uplc wret tnc clt e i ebht elc irlg h

sthtn tdht hc ht tlrcny dhs fnnc mesbepa ecnm. (ngpdhs e s hmmnm)

4


13/24

Lc Rnp tngfnr 8? , 6?8> ,8 sufge t t nm hc Hpp a e bh t elc tl R t hy Nx tncs elc _ncm eck Vnsl au t elc

li G lt elc tl M e squh ae iy , w d ebd tdl rlukd ay nxp ah ec eck tdn cugnrlu s rnhslcs w dy tdn Jus t e bns dhm

tdn ecdnrn ct plw nr tl rnslav n td es G lt elc fnilrn su fget t eck h pnt e t elc ilr h wre t li bnrt elrhre . 8

b e t nm cug nrlus sl u rbns t l fu t t rn ss gy a nkh a h rkug nc t s . ' S Ec gy Rnp tngfn r 8? , 6?8> Hpp a e bh t elc

tl Just ebn Kecsfurk , prnsnc tnm i e vn h rkugnc t s t l mnglcs t rh t n wdy Byc td e h Vhpp a e nm wdnc sdn

prlb ah egn m tdht tdn Rup rng n Bl urt lc ay hbt PsW uplc wre t tnc clie i ebh t elc irlg h s th tn tdht hc

ht tlrcny dhs fnnc mesb ep a ecnm. Lc n li tdn rnhslcs e s tdht wdh t sdn s th tnm tl gn es gn ct elc nm

clw dnr n e s Rup rng n Blur t Vu an 4 . _urs uhct tl Vu an 4 hcm 68 , td es hppa ebh^lc sdlu am dhvn f nnc

hbbn ptnm fy tdn Banr` hcm gy Juay 84, 6?8 > Glt elc tl Mesquha e iy Al nf & Al nf AA _ sdluam d hvn

fnnc rnslavnm fy tdn Just ebns lc tdn Ruprngn Blurt s ecbn tdn Banr` bhcclt mntnrgecn e i hc h t tlrcny

dhs nckhknm ec blcmub t ucfn blg eck h gn gf nr l i t dn Fh r hcm tdn a lwnr inmn rh a hcm s th t n blu r t s

rniusnm tl th`n gy bah egs snrelusay . Lcn mhy hitnr e t whs rnbnevnm, tdn nct e rn phb`hkn whs rn turcnm

tl gn.

Clthr eznm Hi i emhv et Mng lcstrh t eck Gr. [ hsd ec ktlc s Ecm eknct R th tus

Recbn tdn Rup rng n Blurt dhs rniusnm tl hb` clw anmk n gy Juay 84, 6?8> Gl t elc tl _rl bnn m Ec

Ilrgh _hupnr e s hcm Glt elc tl M e squh a e iy Alnf & Alnf AA_ , E hg rnsufge t t e ck tdn cl th r e znm

]dn vhrelus ahw hrt ebans tdht

rnhm tl dnap gn mnvnalp tdn ankha hrkugncts rhesnm ec Rnptngfnr 8?, 6?8>

Hppa ebht elc ecbaumnm0 Hchayses : Inmnrha Ahw li Ht tlg ny Blcmubt . Rt rubtu rn li Inmnrha Vuans Klv ng eck

Ht tl rcny Blcmubt . G llr n ' s Inmnrh a _rhb te bn - Bev e a. (6?8>) 0 R tnpdnc Ke a a n rs. Alw nr eck ]dn Fhr: D lw

Ahwynr Mesbepa ecn Ec Cnw Ulr` Ihe as ]l _rltnbt ]dn _ufa eb. Cnw Ulr` ^cevnrs e ty Jlugha li Ankes aht elc

hcm _uf^b _la eby, Yla . 8;, Cl. 6 , (6?8=)0 Ghresh

[he]nc.

Ml ]dn Vekdt ]deck: _la ebeck tdn _rlinss elc

hcm tdn Ht t lg ny 's Muty tl Vnplr t Gesblcmubt . Hg ncb hc Fhr Hsslb eh^lc . Ghrbd

85-62 ,

6 ? 8 2 0 ] d l gh s

N. Fh`nr. ]dn Ecdnrnct _lwnr ]l Egplsn Rhcbt elcs: Dlw H Inmnrha Jumkn Es Ae`n H 4??-_lucm Klre a ah ,

8= Vnv. Ae t ek . 85> (855=)0 GbGlrrlw. ]dn (I)ut e a e ty li Vuans : Vnkuaht eck Httlgny Blcmubt Ec Inmnrha

Blur t _rhb t e bn . >4 RG ^ Ahw V nv enw 2 , 6? . 6??> 0 Jum e td H . GbG lrrlw. Vu an 88 hcm Inmnrh a ez eck Ahwynr

Ntd ebs . Fr ekdhg Uluck ^cevnrs e ty Ahw Vnv enw. (8558) 0 Ansdn [. Hfrhgslc . ]dn Jumkn 's N td ebh a Muty

tl Vnplrt Gesblcmubt fy Ltdnr Jumkns hcm Ahwynrs hcm e ts Niinbt lc Jumebeha Ecmnpncmncbn. Dlistrh Ahw

Vnvenw: Yla . 6> : Ess . 2 , He t eban = . (855; )0 Mhcena J . G nhmlr , Ecdnrnc t Jum ebeha Hutdlrety ec tdn Blcm ubt li

Bevea Aetekhtelc

;2 ]NT. A. VNY. 84?>, 84?> (855>)0 Jlsnpd J . Hcba enc.

Frlhmnr Es Fnttnr: ] dn Ecdnrnct

_lwnrs li Inmnrha Blurts.

9= CU^ H ccuha Rurvny l i Hg nr ebhc Ahw 2; , =; . 6??4 .

5


14/24

Hiiemhve t tdht whs ecbaumnm hs hc nxdefe t tl tdn ilccnr p anhmeck. Rnn Nxd ef e t H ]dnsn p a nhm ecks

sdluam dhvn fnnc hbbnptnm fy tdn Banr` li Blurt hcm rnslavnm fy tdn Just ebns lc tdn Ruprngn

Blurt fnilrn rnquereck gn tl sufget h pnte t elc ilr h wret li bnrt elrhre ec tdes bhsn. Ec lrmnr tl ie an

tdnsn mlbugncts tl tdn Ruprngn Blurt , E dhvn dhm tl flrrlw glcny irlg ihgeay hcm ir encms. Glrn

tdhc $=82 .;> dhs fnnc whs t nm hcm hs l i Rnp tngfnr 6 8 , 6?8> ,8 dhvn spnc t hc hmm e t e lch a $625 .29

lc suppa ens tl prec t hcm prnphrn tdnsn p anhmg ks tl tdn Bl ur t . Ec hmme t elc tl tdn e ssuhcbn li h

ilrgha hplalky fy tdn Banr` li tdn Blurt hcm e t s sthii E hs` tdht nhbd ecmevemuha ecvlavnm ec

blcspe r eck tl lfst rubt just ebn hcm mnprevn gn li gy blcsie tu t elcha r ekdts fn i e rnm hcm tdht E fn

rn egfursnm ilr tdn glcny e t blst gn tl prec t hcm sufget tdn p anhmecks tdny rniusnm tl hbbnpt . , p aus

puc e t e vn mhghkns .

_rhynrs Ilr Vn a e n i

Irlg tdn fnkecceck, td es ahcmghr` ngpalygnct m esbregechielc, hct e t rust hcm dughc r ekdts bhsn

dhs fnnc ec tnct elcha ay thckanm ec h wnf li prlbnmurha nrrlrs tdht rncmnrs hcy mnbes elc irlg tdn

HHH, tdn Rlutdnrc Mest r eb t li Cnw Ulr` hcm tdn Rnblcm Berbue t vlem .

_ . @nvec Bhstn a dhs nssnct eh a ay hbtnm hs blucsna ilr [ea a ehg Glrres hcm Alnf & Alnf AA_,

rncmnreck prnmntnrgecnm, lcn-semnm mnbes elcs tdht ekclrnm gy ankha hrkugncts , lge t tnm pnrt ecnct

ihbts hcm geshppa enm hcm/lr i alutnm tdn prnvhe a eck ahw. Cne tdnr li _ . @nvec Bhstn a ' s ahs t tdrnn

Lrm nrs m esbuss gy bah eg s li irhum uplc tdn Bl urt h a tdluk d dn 's shyeck tdht h a a li gy hrk ug ncts

h rn w e tdlu t gnr e t . ]dn rn es cl gnc t elc l i Vl wn Nc tn r t h egcnc t , Ecb . v . [e a^hg Gl rr e s Hk ncby .

Ecb . , Cl . 54 BY 46 ;6 , 6? ?> [ A 6 64 22 (R .M .C . U . Jhc . > , 6? ?>) , h i i m, 89; I . Hpp 'x 66 ; (6m B e r .

6??>), bnrt , mncenm , >=5 ^.R . 44;, 86; R .Bt . 642, 899 A.Nm.6m 8>6 (6??9) lr Hrfe t rh tlr Krnklry 's

E t we a a blst gn hclmenr $;>-8?? ilr gn tl ghe a tdnsn panhmecks tl lpplseck blucsna hcm tdn Ruprngn

Blurt.

8?


15/24

mnb e s elc tl hmge t spl ae h t nm , sgl` eck kuc nv emncbn `clw c hs Nxd ef e t 28 ec tl tdn nv emncbn l i

r nbl rm g gy bhsn . Bhs t n a ' s Lrmnr s h a sl cnvnr m e sbuss Alnf & Alnf ' s cugnrlus v el a h t elcs ucmnr

tdn C nw Ulr` Vu ans l i _ rl inss elch a Blc mub t hcm Cnw Ulr` Jum eb e h ry Ahw=4; Iur tdn rglrn , e t

e s h v elah t elc li mun prlbnss ilr Bhstn a tl ekclrn tdn i rhum Alnf & Alnf AA_ nckhknm ec pr elr tl

hcm mur eck td es bhsn hcm tdnc essun h i e a eck ec jucbt elc hkhecst gn wde an cnvnr lcbn hs`eck Alnf &

Al nf AA _ tl rnsplc m tl tdn pyrhg em li nvem ncb n nsthfa esdeck gy bah eg s. i Jn es tdn pnrslcei ebhi elc

li h rhbes t , blr rupt hcm mesdlclrhfan jumkn, wdebd e s supplr tnm fy tdn ihbt tdht dn turcnm h f a ecm

nyn tl Alnf & Alnf AA_'s pht tnrc li d ekday ucntdebha hcm br egecha hbt ev e ty wde an snrveck hs tdn

dnhm li tdn Kr envhcbn Blgget tnn ilr tdn Rlutdnrc Mest r eb t li Cnw Ulr` - hc lrkhcezht elc tdht

h a a nknm ay dhcm ans blg pah ec t s l i h t t lgny gesblcmu b t .

Lc snvnc me i inrnct lbbhselcs, E h t tngptnm tl hmmrnss tdnsn e ssuns we td tdn Rnblcm Berbue t

hcm nhbd t egn, gy hppnhas wn rn mncenm ec anss tdh c i evn snctncbn s. Nv nc hi tnr e t bluam clt fn

mnc enm tdht tdn Rnb lcm B erbue t dhm jur esm eb t elc tl rnvnrsn tdn nr rlrs li Bhs tn a , phcna jum kn s M ncc es

Jhblf s , Vhyg lcm Ald en r J r hcm Ahurh ]hy al r Rwh ec P tdn ah s t twl fn eck l i Hi r ebhc m n s b n c t W , mnc enm

gy hppnha fy blc baum eck tdht et ahb`Pn mW hc hrku hfan fhses ec n e tdnr ahw lr ec ihbt . ]dr luk dlu t

td es nct e rn bhsn , gy ankha hrkugncts dhvn fnnc blcses tnct , sl e t gh`ns hfslautn ay cl sncsn ilr gn

tl i e an hc hppnha tdht ahb`nm hc hrkuhfan fhses ec ahw lr ec ihbt - hi tnr tdn lcay ahwiuaay hpplectnm

hrfe t rh tlr blcbaumnm tdht [ea a ehg Glrr es m esbr egechtnm hkhecst gn fnbhusn li gy rhbn. Hcm e i E

wn rn rh es eck i r evlalus hrkug ncts , wdy w luam Gebd hna Zw nek - hc h t tlrcny we td glrn tdhc 2>

y n h r s '

nx pnr enc bn - c nnm tl nca es t gl rn tdhc ievn h t tlrcnys hcm tdrnn phrhankhas tl rnp rnsn ct

[e a a e hg Glr r e s hkh ecs t hprl

s

a e t ekhct , clc-ht tlrcny ? ; 8 = > 5

BLG

C L . ? 8 V L > ? ; 8 = > 5 / e

X ^ H A E I e N L

EC

L ^ N R C . R B L ^ C ] U

JD

G e R R E L C

NT_EVpR

J H C ^ H V U

82

6?\

a

;


20/24

Ecblgn slurbn Hvnrhkn glctday

hgluct mureck tdn phst

86 glctds

Hgluct nxpnbtnm cnxt

glctd

Ecblgn slurbn

U l u Rp l u s n U l u Rp l u s n

N g p a l y g n c t

LHG

C'G

? . ? ?

Rn a i - n gp a l y gn c t

8 ? ? . ? ?

C./H

? . ? ?

RC/H

Ecblgn i rlg rnh a p rlpnr ty ( subd hs

rnc th a e cblgn)

? . ? ?

.C/H

? . ? ?

C / H

Ec tn rns t

hcm

m ev emncms

?.??

CG

? . ? ?

g

Keits

?.??

R C/.H.

? . ? ?

SYH

H a e gl c y

Rl.ex)

C/H

?.??

R

C/H

Bde am supplr t

? . ? ?

CYH

? . ? ?

CYH

Vn t e r n gn c t ( s u b d hs slbeha snbure ty ,

pncs elcs , hccu e t e ns , e c su rhcbn)

?.(G)

C. H

?.(@) C/H

Meshf e a e ty ( subd hs slbeha snbure ty ,

e c s u r h c b n p h y gn c t s )

Rl.ul

C/.H

?.(@E

C / H

^ c n g p a l y g n c t p h y g n c t s

C /.H

(T)

C/H

_ufa e b -hs s e s t hcbn ( subd hs wna ihrn)

e el ll

C / H

aeR.LL

C/H

Ltdnr

(spnbeiy):

?.??

C/H

? . ? ?

C / H

]ltha glctday ecblgn:

lJL.LL

R

?.??

86.>.??

?,{D)

6. Aest ylur ngpalygnct destlyy

ilr

tdn phst

twl

ynhrs, glst rnbnct ngpalynr ierst. Krlss

glctday phy esfnilrn thxns lr ltdnr mnmubtelcs.)

Ngpalynr

Hmmrnss

Mhtns li ngpalygnct

Krlss

glctday phy

C/H C/H

.C/.H

?.(@)

s


21/24

2 . Aest ylur splusn's ngpalygnct destlry ilr tdn phst twl ynhrs, glst rnbnct ngpalynr ierst

(Krlss glctday phy es fnilrn thxns lr ltdnr mnmubtelcs.)

Ngpalynr

Hmmrnss

Mhtns li ngpalygnct

Krlss

glctday phy

C;H

C / H

l.g

s

=. Dlw gubd bhsd ml ylu hcm ylur splusn dhvn

Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment et al. -- Petitioner's Motion For Leave to...

Documents

Transcript of Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment et al. -- Petitioner's Motion For Leave to...