IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THESECOND JUDICIAL CIRCUIT INAND FOR LEON COUNTY, FLORIDA.

The Estate of LUCILLE WILLIAMS,by and through DOROTHY MAEWILLIAMS, Personal Representative,

Plaintiff,

vs.

TANDEM HEALTH CARE OFFLORIDA, INC.,

Defendant.1

CASE NO. 2000 CA 002890

Condenserd

THE DEPOSITION OF: PERRY STARER, M.D.

TAKEN AT INSTANCE OF: The Defendant

DATE: Thursday, September 28, 2006

TIME: Commenced: 10:05 a.m.Concluded: 2:45 p.m.

LOCATION:

REPORTED BY:

Law Offices of KAY SIMPSON1983 Centre Pointe BoulevardTallahassee, Florida

LIZ CLEARY, RPRNotary Public in and forState of Florida at Large

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERSPost Office Box 306 * Tallahassee, Florida 32302Phone (850) 222-5508 * Fax (850) 222-2428

sHEET2 P八GE 2 }

l App亡ARAN0巴s'

2Representi

3J八ME'

4 ,，让．k.. &, 0r1.N‘洲

’ 了．r、1p・．尸卜

SRepresent

7：叭AR丫

6 ,.03

尺・，，犷・‘・n七n0 全’，・p有・．:,t’什

J八MES 民，尸民已巨M八N．巴SQUIREWilkes &Mc曰u0hOn.Nerti, 1)ai. M・bry, SuIte 800

了amps,尸lend自 33e09

尺・，，犷・・0:,dI,0t’，・0母寸・：、dant

MAR丫K. SIMPSON,八1-rORNEY 八下！．尸、vv’・030.ntre Point・曰oulevard,3U ite200

下aUahasBee. Flonds 3230右

10

11

"2

,3

14

,5 ．叼O巴x

，・，丫巴M pA

'7 W""N已息s: p住尺民丫昌’八只巴只，M.0.

18 亡城．．、，:,．权0：、bvM0.6..,..0,, 厄x.,,"n・肋0n0Y :"'r，尸r・．’”．六

1. -吸J.1'1.r 已衬．.，、月n・．0.'0丫．丫，・申衍’“专 -'" --10r 巨汉．.，幼．,. -on -v F r．「r.

曰“J 卜’．'nn'r‘万“:’劝n0砚’0n0y 'v“八”’了川

2I CERTIFICA了巨OF R巨PORT三R

22

23

24

25

pA0巴

FxarrNn.tlon by Ms・ Simpson一七xJmt aDo叹Dy.,lvIr.厂r,,m色， I-吸里 trier' x.IYu nauon Dy' V15. oPm-1,.prI．一Furtfl,r, X"Ifl4n.0夕n byJvIr. l-'I,,manruruier' ,ontineucin .ylyle. OPLflP压on

4.0105109

109

112

Depo of PERRY STARE民M,D., 9/28/06P八GE 4

！ 茂posrnc2 ereupon, 3 PERRYSTARE民M.D. 月was caled协比de伪阳d耐kbeia侧姗洲II, was5 exaniied咧les加d as仍bs: 6 EX朋A11ct7 BY MS. SMPSON: 8 Q 禅习目 yu翻eyournamefrN'therecord,pIease9 APeflystare', S-I弄R毛R. IO Q .Sbr仃．n nan 陈KaySiiipsonaod!represerl竹臼众：11｝犯浦、c日了e‘「枷翻l．的c．介d幻0浦lll陡加软成栩 12 腼beefi 1ed aN there by伽EaleoftueWams. !3Yoive had丫（盯depotion taken before, coned? 14 八Thafs correct, !5 QS 州价丫细物闭th maskigyou甲e咖nsaidl6yooa了e- morn responses协those甲犯翻 ns, coi7 A ！该衡如rid that仍 Q An ,tbe陀彻e,y und“由ndthaHt1siportaid19l同卿喇“喊亩侧j衅 questn before州attempttogea20 卿 re resoonse扔政．coned? 21 A Yes. 22 Q UtanythieIa欢youaquesIn姻you don23 nderstand,peaseteI僻you如加幽‘即住朋阅hi? 24 AAgreed. 25 Q 眺舫俪脱怕assume拟Iyou respond to a

’。月・‘。内。

1

2

3

4

5

8

7

0

.

10

11

,2

13

14

布5

1已

I了

15

,0

20

2I

22

23

24

25

一

PAGE3

已XHIBJT LIST

NO. D已SCRIPTIQN PAG已

Composite of meterie豁ent to Dr. Starerfrom Wilkes & McHuih 72 Dr. Starer's handwritten notes "'

3 Notic. of serving 户leInti忙协answers toDefendant'. lnterro-gator1e' 38

4 PlaintIff. flrwt amended answers toDefendant's int.rrog.torles 闷

D.f.ndant's amended notIc. of takingdapusition 65

Anticte wrttt.n by D. r. S,'tarer, Cjre

nursing home patient 。fthe70

7 Dr.3tar.广．0v 72

Testimonial hIstory of expert with....Dr. Starer 73

43

3

9 今月七月性’了’”・：进争。of head ctmpu钾d tomoqrephy'"olDen丫psue nte .us1ein.n9 ’二飞少or "’妞U

叮翻吸J口1a 0耳

p：了．、 Composite of 票 ctea Dr.. Starer. found In hisresearch pertinent to Lucille VIilIiama case 95

l尸八GE 5

51 questnthatyouuride油刘the que滋沁n? 2 AYes,th. 3 Q 翔减污卯 urcurrentpressi,naIad&ess? 4 A EI ur Hospital Center, BUM-H朴时T,79015 Bioadway,NewYorkj1ew丫欧川73. Th 'orieaddresswhichl6 conreco初e.!ouessmaiL 妇以lW袱tosendmesomethrna.! 了卜ave other喇resses. 8 Q 帅al‘加加成剐传确！吵reaoi you? , A 愉home address10 Q Wiat枯thaladdress? " A 侧‘碎件孙Avenue, Nunibef 1OF, New Yak, 12 New?诚10003. 13 Q Thnt‘丫训rp 嘴ession,Dr.Starer? }4 八 ！amal加翻nW曲a匆e・如认衬1enme15 喇asu匕s俄妇卜的吟内tr公medme16 Q Ney阅bo 血ethfled 价any disc礴自es? 17 A Yes,}am. 18 0 lnM以dcip sareyooboaidcetIIed? lg A Internal med'newth additional ced11intnn m加 oer 比 med访e. 21 Q 姗tat gef州房 med云习e? 22 A Gena愉盯喇访e污加oali000fthe23prdp眺 c4 hiternal med吻e协thoerpopubIi000,r24 叭 d蒯ua卜wh仇e ssme or骊 miar oroberns as an25Ed蒯喊

l

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

∼——SHLET 3 PAGE 6二’epo of FIRKY STARER.,M邊馱，9128/06

PJ、GE 8

! Q 〕州關鯽1er,ses m the State of Flonda? 2 A Nojdo臘 3 Q 飾啣mfessional I nses, hi',doyou ho ? 磚 八 ―關”ai en"！。D！闖e m 州蒲州mez織e價 。N叫Torx. 6 Q M 伏eckenses? 7 A 脈―me細〕ad『神s配ense8 Q P (1essIiaI ease 仙have been retained as an9 expert喃ess畝既present case;祕 t回叩仃馴盪？ 10 A TheLuc&險ms case. vet!！ 。以踟稱神抑烈re伯訕ed as an expert喻essh!2 中侈開斗？

13 A ―媚映「州he烈teller I recever1,勸ough！引ni汰havebeen contacted 的“記a翻併” before that, !5So娥e臘伯s dated !B.2哪學 16 Q SovouI uUhavebeen瞰擁edasanexDerlwness!7 畝娥熔case n州re州加aday or two (細州6.2既：is!6 !hat卹rr戲？ 19 A I'meii磁g, yet20 Q Loo&ingaIUie i翰16, 2(X冷 tefter, appears細 2!you were forwarded records訪誡are listed∥ that絨er;' 〞that coned? 23 ATh北correct. 24 Q' ryoufonwardedanyrecords佣,Ai 18,2006 that25 計e州臘d畝胡】a！以ter?

d》、內，〞、,

! A 紹衙as-k！讓懈．協認群mthh"had. d u 口州j！細vean e! en劉廈做謝or 即！加！】馴1電補 3 ”豳tfs counsel or小e〔由tejLi,燻點斷爾館 4case? 5 A I'mnot 淡膩ewh州目Is. 6 Q t youhavesome雊ofconacts 婉喊# 7 ternofwen 寧mm齡闔expedwitnessE惦case? B A 陽．alhave are these tellers. 9 Q 嚇州 rethetern,Jyouragreemnttoserveasan10 ex州twnessm慵case? " A rmnnt劉化論dw鸛驢ddas劉山lwoui舶d12 abeerexptanatn13 M凡FREEMAN -bhk幼es磁動他丫價！州謐d。袱」 枓 diaroe for your I動】跑， !5 。 丫圓！吧州l動'io oaid for臘1面e壇e刨av, corred? !6 A rm 儲他袖咧皺！荊衛袖閑了么動袖聞the口雙∼ 17 。 觔d丫團胎！州i柏‘lhhe號作k齡vounr卹記e!6 畝僅〕““州蜘硎！斗贓】。爺即戲閔”哺！嗡h 惰口總． 19 州了ed? 20 An細！，時understandg,鄉． 刨 Q Hv面you get paid? 22 A 抽at他－ 23 Q Imson 面 that匕apoorquestn. Doyousubmit然 翰呶s forv叩『！訕ie? 25 A -haven州嘛，鄉，

PAGE 7

' A 甌油麒傳鹹『eceiiga 辦，asiefromwhat2 is他叫hthe teller. 3 Q Now,yourcounselprrto細depo ion, or unseI4 fortheEstatedMiss llms, handed me a吋d南譏nat5 w!)idiappearslobes劍鸞卹脾＄p閒d開辟物故was sent to you;' 6 中at correct? 7 A -don't know wtal he handed you. 8 Q Youhaveasetd細fie瞬 9 A 〝―由

！。 鼯SI網倒：I'd 勵to have幗顫marked as11 儀煎瀾） oslteExhib ",p細。驕． 12 (EXHIBIT 1 MARKED FOR僅網9以”叩〕 13 Q t IhrespedtoConositeExt鋼！海烈page of14 Core叫eExht！認蝕初18, 2006 knleryou referred 勿》 巧c叩ed? 16 A Thafscorred. 17 0 lsaItbec es《買〕ndencethalvouhavereceeh!8connec蜘哺汕為casem達ed補hsiCompou廬eExh州？ 19 A T!)ereison emwtihis袱here. 加 。 以袖！刈誡？

21 A Thalis細b'avel arranoements that was sent. 22 。q險小即some comun翻ten ieaardins加州 "anranoements,胎a州加rcorres 鷓nce―回you have rece圃 24 肌connect祕n州hyour wo物！！韶（冷閔州啼dwthin25ConoteE贓引？

PAGE 9

憤 Q How面丫馴』d甘弟放¥狽耳他補？

2 ABv細how. 3 Q H much面ycuc臉，perho& 4 A $200. 5 QH初由you缺p ack州he抽稱you have spenhn6 pedormig - servx物this case? 7 A Irenien謐erhowmanyhours爍worked. 6 Q )you祈馳祉d州〕anywhere? 9 ANo10 Q 緬manyh 化have州womkedupunthoniig汕 !！臨coom I吻？ !2 A Th辦咖, 13 Q H淵觸取h以。savevouvteddurio蝕month of！磚Se休enber? 15 A -don't break doun that 州州st do cunatte. 161州add叩the number of heuns17 Q So田叮衛肥o1iworkanotherhour,you州adrU18 upm your head? 19 A That'sexacthowIdo織,鄉唱 'u q LO0 月砌不∼‘併none以關叮1瀆跚日r引几ai和」 21 d noirece'eanymaIer storev劍behveen蝕dates of22 向盼！縱嚇and SeiAen加7,2曬，幗correct? 23 A Yestmrscorred. 24 Q Hownianyheursddyouspendrenviig蝕mlonnafn25 小戲isdel*sdinff 鯽18,2006絨啊wthis padd

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850)121•sS"

Depo of PERRY STARER, M.D., 9128106SHEET 'I P八GE 10 件 P/kGE 12

10} Cot oseExhltht1? 2 A ！咖，recall. 3 Q H〔附湘nhou份油vevousoentrevienathe4 ibnna nv4bis袱edin触Se01emberl, 20O6fterw劝 5 眺 duded如Comoo }e叻汉1? 6 A rmsorr,｝如飞reca比 了 QKow盯日叫t esbeveyou been retained书即ex网 8vness切俪晰kes&McHuah加frm? 9 A Ivt havetoestimate.}adua匆don1tia10 thi Pmbabmorethanten.lxgldon1flmknorethan2O}1th爬s. I'me而tiag. 12 Q 腼献熟麒用卿have州ben钾峪价以nectnwih13 ex详d喇阴弱serv 叻州havep 似蒯onbeMofttie14 晰玫es &Md翻ighwtmnn? 15 A !nevei'thought about attachiig Ito onetin.! }6don、枷eafiaure, 17 Q 喇粕ufrmnaanvrecordswitftvoutodav叻h卿ukt仍 e谧ab w 日fure? 19 八 ｝don'tk卿钧ose records. 加 Q Hou面卿卿阔州祀n恻件翻m改州tw欣倪岛 21 serv从esfor加V es&Md-tugh 加firm? 22 ABy改ecL23 0 山似！ of瀚．丫以万喇叭1co游傲舫的aveartbass24“枷知知！论翻do that? 25 八 ！have朗a助unton1

!SentelT日冷了．2 6? 2 A There比a1so加fierSeotemb 25, 200Bwhh3 sts nome addlbnal materis. Is伽目j ge in衅 4时d. 5 眼下REEM月明：肠‘趁doesnthc众取｝00(a口0v6 ofthate改her. saheded卿ember25thfronme. l Youcan州more copes蒯团助姻tofl8 MS.S湘PSON: Let nieTnaeacoy. 0 (BREAKv叭sTAKEN.), }0BY MS. SIMPSON: }} Q DtS怕r叮，州atwereyou 分旅ed协do叭 connection12 wht 洲v沈syoupr份记ed 也怡口犯？ 13 A ！嘴3舫kedtore,ewthecasearddeteniTe茸hore14 weanvdamaoes. 15 0 " oaskedvoutodothat? 16 A }may 喊rementer ead because I was contaded}7 白1正妇卜bva "！以钱放日彻口祀丫l恤1伽洲e“怕．here now. 侣！kn I掀ew卜aMr. LanceR.s．“伪喇卜eve been拍 snmebodyetsevAospoke协moinlia匆，butt如’recalthet20 name. 21 0 M1endthou翩sneak whh Mr. Reeis? 22 A Pr咖脚oriortothe 她 fterofSeotente叮012006. 23 Q Wasiwithindays01thatiotter? 24 A !be细eso. 25 Q 比附阳叮位1es喇 you 钾翔上晰M卜Re ?

别左”洲25

12 1

P入t3E 11

11

{，擂 re瓢o 粼彗onMhtheexpert3 A }riaarneI由‘ ｝回姗eveMhinot000therand hanG4 政勿theaC伪如切减‘ 5 0 蒯you g We what lO99foim 卯 U wouki receWetoyour6 accountant correct? 7 Amars correct. s o 彻wouki beabletogoand a欢州raccountanhior};coies those 1099rnis1

correct?A lwouhooeso, 11 ．几r粗斑物l』怕加your嘿帕！阳ur accountant略朋 12！留e伽recors怕rt能傀l加onimevouarer阂比的协

l月 八 ｝wo喇hone卜es几劝喊抽voamv了柳rds,ye

16 0 Or.Starer.俪coud renorter hank,a you what hasif DeenmareOasbxflU2t0州‘aeposzn. anyouteiime侣 州tatExhI宜2 & !9 A Th飞boksea侧介‘阴腼咖下en n01s. 20 0 'Miend山认Jprepare these袱瞬 21 A 劝祀 senoteshavebeenpreparedovecthe目蜘 22 months!notall以伽saneh加 23 0 ！腼kwe owered th , Doctor, but I want to make2耳swe,日may reeWedanyme1e油协rev thata旧not25 re edeh伽卜fterdadJu份18,2以6andthe ttecda1ed

P八GE 13

飞3! A ！响城卜习，・秘的喻him once or卜｝虎 e,佣帕＊ 2 once, 3 0 出丫e ou嘛nwIhMr.Freeman? 4 AYes, 5 QVen dKJ you侧 speak协Mr. Freeman? 6 A l枷物owexath.t知ja加I a改bv袖即伽 7 助er s sent, 已 0 H"e始触别ert喊we姗ebaviigcopEed. 9 A ｝咖、piipoiit exact扮when 迁cane.!beI沁ve 政

10 wou日腼ebeen,onceaga ,"thi 邮beforethe Se材enber 25, "2006 $ter. 12 眼.FREEMAN:腼．so the record 落 dear. are we13 aoinato剔that健 fterb Ext动1? }4 MS. SIMps侧:丫肠．we're .ao 协arid the10 be扭emaeu .z1月卫 nerastne 哪叭朋！”阳e16 Ext双1. 17 MR．「R〔EMAN: Thats, }6BY MS. SIMPSON: 19 0 蹄日t呐咖 shaveyoufOrmedirittiscase, 20 氏 . Starer? 21 A 丁！tat there were damaoes 'm th比 case. 22 0 川以翻哪s油犯扣 udetermiiedthattherearem23 也‘case? 24 A 丁hat there was阶tmnecessary闹uction叭取or a25 晚叻劝榷 sud时狱1：伽陀棍sass01enmmeM'e,

!!11 !!!

j6‘乃’6。‘・通・‘

..J'

!

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-550$

SHEET 5 PPGE 14

14幗細陳購s帥and劉賺狗1andth erewasassofa向n面ddeath.

Q 鯽other dan袖gesw1勸州ekee×州hltus聯？

5 A ―蘭嚇ave州〕祀！hiwhhwoubcomeunderthose6 oeneralareas. but-tmnkt回Drettv much cove戚as be ns川『e仿珊mnow. 8 Q YA'iat is the factual basG for your啊m―團there9 vas閭unnecessarv叫ud 舅南氈∼既細e you州」

！。assume that means in the lengthdMS’犧n細’恥，晚 ！他expectancy? 12 A Y 亂Ba州！膩以”爾review 細reco瞧muevw!3j細med l細伯！鵬，哨own exoerience.縱馴訕〕叩JflTi14 切瓤既 Ther 服norea r 句rM .Wms句dieoo15 March仰叨exc 伏緬thesubduralhernatoma州chwas16 馳州血吻befahe e！血. !7 。丫側膠“似劍medal細咖化申Miatmedal!6 黝a！礪劇you cons盧？ 19 A lw 憤tobeas臘iulasoosbte. Vatlhaveread加 over細years, ”啊riot recall exact坤mhat 呱even on21 revierJany館9 -co 化翻d一lcou"n"findanythiigthatfl wou"iidiate組this卿manwood havedied訓hat time23 ex叩飲the subdural bematori , 24 -“喊fr)d日叮areash細細咖re補h鉑“ 乃that meone州刃has幗can臘fonc勸價小atmedioal

;head falire ch ng邐een ahrilided tu a dilatedurdi,n p.thy. She had ti Nood pressure. Therewasa3 dscusson ot me re劇戲suflency.肉他there was a肋a4 pahioryof開濺二b州obnonwh幼攔resectionrs 1999. 6789

1011!2

滌3!4!51617!819202-他 232425

-

!6

Q YsM陽惱anssutieduledtobe內cedooafeed卹 tube閱Fthuaiy 29,2000?

A lbefeve嚇團神edrngtubem hernosev h圃 been 伯烈〞eda記細e蹤sad開s nofhanga1ubeprd 畝 小rough a d爾甽route州圈time, yes. Q APEGIube? A Theoercutaneouse咖准無aastronoaw tube. PEG 加， 0 Basedonvowreviewofthe胎a！鵬．州1▼was there

ais .son併p ig閒“閑開鵬加”切亂―憫use an aaoo物 for簽aPEG tube?

A ―勸物劍面硎re 皺ofthe細aturewou" lilomi this.即eviewc4the records Iid記ated吻誰may havehaooened. 。Ai他曠Wsthat? A lwauttomakese-urider andll iediori. There

was cancer曲dshe was喊eatina her me出to comi糾加涌 賺咖面園been chosendthe tube fee卹throi幼the noseThis had now been discoi似劍“憎ew莽nowad汰 an細取川gdthe a啤，and -believe whh Ms州胎 ma1 as to哺ether or劇嘛alternate州同咖叫bethosen.

PAG乞 15

15!h勸作卿咖加ved團at that也neallM料 2 Q \Men wouki Miss鯈嗎have died? 3 A There祕的 reasontobeievethatshewoidhavedied4 m細manner開March 牌，2000, and certa吻 I wouki have5 exoededMrtohaveco而團化細a meanioaful隴絃at6 絕誠戲陶．】！hsJ喊加 oer. 7 0 贓your underutand 比翻reduced 勵 8 戲叫ancv祕an 酌』e酌b比wsu閱協Doint nilme? 9 A -donUnowat細leaal nuances. but uben asked伯 how 開“日久闐nsuffer or be白maaed. hav岫 one's鼯而！鹹

12 Q " atex閱向nceandhamma面you have喲henab細 !3 ▼佣晌面e闐顱廈劍1它〝勵exne中rica? 神 A -have been iortunatelorlbegreal陶州▼d時 !5came雨work臟 people補。日蹬喇併！who are concerned about16 heendof e,who內m爍a幣叩chigtheendofWe. I17 haveseenDeoDle廄kria lives. -haveseeopeopled . My18d緻併ad晚a闐mvacadenuicurs嗎veivotteri鬨團es御 nirngIormee闐併職aavancea orectwes,竿maig20 ones願 lt'swhatl面． 2! 0 潤 atm lc)r娥祕nsdMiss鯈「石have as of22 February 29,2咖？ 23 A 謝“鷓廟闐抽 wastt以the劇臘eah陳鉀併 以頭e而“馱膩¥神討（日）由】榭田¥卹伽―聞！晌幼was related to25 adeepvenousthrombosis月de 潤―目“hadco嘐咖e

h.》《。，.

，•

PAG已 17

1了 ! 0 Mi嚇州eha由ofv劍實唬顫小dMiss馴ms2 頭啊eda險ofenjoyTnenIc4晚？ 3 AMiss訪bis園加。otenfiaItoeniov鼯，This4 熔 seeniiineiesumo州anerian買賺而ers月闈‘歡rim5 細me&aliecords. And協e was喊made av由比to6 贓「S娩d 州have t贓。。加“unilvhcontimieto鈾刻to7 continue eniov the館ias蝕wouki wailed伯have似'se. 8 0 贓yo萬咖物―臘無伯ma凶the ability9 toeniov晚嚼〞勃劇？ 10 A 1course.Ifshe's喊由e,then細比c臼柚細 !!evenh瞼勵幗the糊」“never戰侃復rice. and I臘is！黝珊thiscase. Buta}ohthe thath團化jher We the！坤ecious time that she團lefi she was a stateJpa ,a14 由抽d闈鬨edco憫b瞼esa闐w鈴喊日letoop劉龍ewhat!5 ―勵〕伶補s絨to險〝 16 0 Andyouropnionwhrespedto加unnecessary!7reduction「We is加到 upon小e柏d小絨Miss陶ms d副 誰8on March！各2以0? !9 A Yes. 20 0 Basedon細mednalcondkionstt Miss鯈鵬劂 2’芻of 2/29t2000向加險闔誡3加日朋喜coufri the have22 ufferedapulrnonaiyernboli&n剎倒sudden" 23 A 州n sedthefireipaa Bsedonwhatshehad24 呷rtoFdruary29,2仰？觸州h咖owid have, nre州 25 細n喊“elbecauseof輪，顱xal hematoma seconday to

——、

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850)112-5508

Depo of PERRY STARER, MJ)., 9/28/06SHEET 6 PAGE 18 ! P)GE 20

!8} head加叨怕secondaiy协the acddt2 Q 蚀e呱ta众rno about muse ci death here at this3 四at l肠e,Docto.脚on que翻n俄 based on the mecaI4 coodons姻M姚随ms侧as时Februa邝29.2咖，prior5 拓the如祀she姚 she伪喇卜ave刻reredao iionaiv七 enom翻aao jooeniaianv朋ie.伪rrecrr

s a目ninaveueneaa们um . nenninaveoeu伪a四mona即 g 创油o俪 at another time? 10 Q Yes. '! AMyund 曲画闪匕合名ed阅therecordsisshewasbeirig12 treated 'm ordertol万 ere俄 another pumriary eno1ism, and this"3fr喇柑姗戏 nre hkejtban not wcdd have reduced her 时 l4n ，匆刀atedhef献of a pu:’翻脚effibosm. !5 QTreatment can neier con脚ety eliminate the 飞胶ot日 16 pu加on娜eniboism, can 1? 杆 八比cani, but site now has hada！姚伯犷户‘帐naiy18・油ofsm目 ent 周, an intervenl加 nude叻肋W0引目 19 咖 n a川加 reducethe risk. And伽！sainme既卜than扮 喊the 0喻切拚即osm nrooaviv似旧！饮nave announceaz1 拙a构a1书拟g舫’etooxrneireaimeunanawascareiu叮 nmon砍oed, 23 Q 丫叫闭渊the Jury that Miss墉ms would not24 haeddst喇翻加without晚珊加向to潮 Qood姗without25 anyoflierdir4renthere介确any 01 The晰ermedial

;experienced Miss V tams?AM 别四。ndoth。邵mptome

3 whhd价n'fledthe甲朋州her e. 4 Q 腼由柳幻脚t同M眺’ane长peenced卿？ 5 A 八though the doqjecitation is袱”磁『习orous, when6 isdocumenfed协以甘are de叮 ptns of卯价 and there are;repods havgpaito ngtheacdde01onFebnay)29

2000. The rea l epriortothat1butwe're

!focust腮lonFebniary29,2000Q SoM thatcausedherpnp o February 29, 2000?A atl erringtowasshehadsomebackpafroniaprevbusfalandthatbewne u i:;',itwoukt14 appear, th secondf onFebniary29,20OO15 Q Dthebackpacauseherde01h

?16 A Thebackpaicaedherpaat. Asfarasl11 un dldnotcau herdeath.

{；。0 M。思恕the留i nneotinwththebalijury caused her death, d it, , Starer? 20 杆REEMAN: Obd to the俪m, noth啊叙 21 recehed.

22 MS.S黔: lwilldarythequestiQn.23 BY MS. SIMPSON: 24 Q

L

25

加

PAGE 19

}g1 co th; w 纂skmonths,canyou

?I A l toareasonableden med lce怕ty3 烟shewoui袱have died the way thed风a very rap妇犯，e们飞咖iwcoosciusness. M 叮e like扮伽nnot,wihthe5 medi到咖眺喃劝 we晚nt油dand beideated勃 6 叫喇have hadad盯efe奋1t佣抚omet佃nshed47 0 M 喃at 扯比怕d a[basisforthat呐n? 8 A The眼d日加娜 atsbehadcon9esie噢0’侧姗l丫舰出侧“性n花‘洲ommu啤‘treating娜was

{}as 各 . eiwss.儡ep 儡dec1leand plankttw'2palienisdeath. 13 To创mp1yi,whatweTetaIri1g翻此“声以龙骆 "‘勿岭wt仙can he卿nediorasoppose引oa'dden death、5secondary协胡叭钊’协之head wound,协the crushh!g湘 !6vial organ,价ttiscazethebrn. 11 Q HdMS amS'Iafl脚been fltormedth iewas18d！们g? 19 M良FREEMAN: Letniemake曲神以totheforntCa时ou20 wedfvwttatD 耐时价1e you're ta&nci about? 21 0 PdortoFebwary29,2仰， 欢 A ！如、recaD姗川喊曲l习seu刹n any冷 d讼切ue油nNIev加“伽mater饱日d由seea24 discussenwheresomeonesdshe'aotehd痴（!. 25 QV姻 isyouropmon 哟日rd“姆pain创”以盯 errnq

...

" ～ 、

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

P八GE 2飞

21｝ 八潮t喊｝W书abie协asceilait frommy r 枷‘the:records or the autopsy repod

,Q Soju 1or ' - thisquesiionIbehlevethalth grthisbwsuitisrelatedbpan

;and suffenng MissY n receed asused her death. 日resu "an'mjury

7 Andas1underatan ,ancorreotmermwrong

,8 y th usedherdeathwasthesubdural9 heniatorna?

10 MR. FREEMNl: Let meobd. ldenthkthalis11 theontyissueithecase. Youputthatasapredate

.12 B danerthe n13 A ldon ezad aspeotsofthis14 are. rnusi 'zi' ' easpenencedlb 11 皿！Lnyou 阴10 ai 犷聪qu 切siowa16 caused瀚rieathand causedtier pail欲thesame tine,劝即！ };coudothat l'mju gbu留dtheque n.Q Yes,thaliswhatIwoutdhkeyoubdo1or irposes!9 'thisque目bo, lnyourop价n,witaIEjurycaused20 Miss WlI旧rns death?

21 A lnno霍麟tniun 院t需wi*ticausedthe22 autesubdumlheniatomacausedherdeath.

:o Now燕黔翼rundersiandrngthat Miss Williams expedenced as a restil 01tbe i uiy to herhead whh caused the dunil hemetoma?

}

Depo of PERRY STARER, M.D., 9128/06SHL已T 7 P八GE 22

22! A Sec 豳帥細，鹹州臉natoma咖erve『ocd2 pa畝iltie head,"e×可竄柚兀d 團誡『。丫∼and 戲eao園a3！鈴知d瀾w . 磚 N懈．I"xd耐翱d 砍a滕n瀾萬ebthesuf1erig5 1i細this d臘勵鈴wel」d閒know黝此 6 蝕que n you are as 畝9, because協闐w贓move o to the7 細勸柚很細a哺▼勿卹刖刊n口柑a闐resohee闐d廳 8 sues齡she向嚇awe had. 9 Q Doyooknowwhether無矚為had any攔of廳

，。洶es? !" A 蹺 weren givenanop凶dun柑for hertobn叩that12 叩，囫base翻州叫r ¥啣‘d"jthenater臨劃tome, !3 己鯽為翻cedat Ihi嘮were絨unieso般ed 煎her既 14 QAnd繡撾were they? 15 A Shewasawomanvhagreai妨股回加“This16 祕卻oenabont,h《鯽she wou" eny a#endig ctiwth.觔dalso17 here‘蝕•．卜 4I I I S 油echa 個she rees heav吋 ！晌雨而勿gain better quaW州晚There was闐 19 叩休 duniypr 以細df er怕誡飲“ne絨whthe加 中RMflJ1 Or沁have herbi魚叫her鄴瀾j記h . 2! And hat is anher aspect, because I is 物日變 22 咖enved他漁叫hehn。s.The俗而坤them勁叫d臼idif23 eykr,ewshewasgorig圳總！回morning, I吻wouki have24slayediTh油口harsw4we―州thatopi勸發（纖 25 Q But加開闈saren、somethig細卸expe1 has to

! Q vMa1factsddyourevi 憶畝daled幗 2M匕s"amswashe向any閃nh瞼head 簽日『e蛐da3 subdural henialoma? 4 A -d山e，祕細moor么and del論10！回wlh" 5u除廟面g of the mechan蘭償asub 劍heniatoma,盈at is6 ons膩ent 囫―館＊州卹tt be a彌9nen eaboutthe陶ch aI record引rov劂. 8 0 Yes.thatwastheauestn. Yatrecordsor面er9 i1oniiatb曲辦oureviewedv 嚇'ndicale to woo thai10 MIss Wams園pam 畝險head, wi勸was oue州he factors!!you listed,郃訂收康州he subdural hematoma'? 12 A 咖want to be as con神a as poss•闢e because over13 the鄉rslhaveredandatteud闐細duresonsubduralhernatoma, 14 幼thatabolor俗n 啊Ion, 15 Butspecilicalty韶b細伯c劍dswasproved,I -16 re dthenurngdocIiientat吻recordftom,ndentheh Care.-'7 伯台dthe stharge州e from Ta廳ni版臉Care.―『卹d啼越‘ 18 called攔Taudern rehab dali, record of freatments ide. the!9saeech theraov in l assessment,adischarae鋤關寫丫介馴】】 20 〕．Smith. And -also boked誡細Florida oensthicident21 repot勿a州eo4fer為訓revewed the test d22Dorotlw"ams. 23 QVatui細nursina docunientat加hdaaIedlovou24 紹MissV1Jiarns團開hh臘head認aresu州the25 subd刻hemaloma?

PAGE 23

23'te物坤ret團 2 MR.FREEMNl:0ecttothe1orrn. 3 A Icouldte物贓asathwith parents. -4cou壯tlIy勿las a human being 囫I couki also te物 5 贓asan expert晚 cause Ihave s即 more otlen than靦

“嗦irequests [or closure, for tan'Iy, brspUua買y肌叫 7 啦啡ntsandm小epa細廢併mycoagues8 Q 觸州amui喊er? 9 巷 Iarnr aniriister. Iama肉sian. ;! ;And you are not a

pctiiatr以, corred

?I am an internist. !2 QSo you are i tasvd似鹹r州？ !3 A 比m喊aDSVct勸祖．細胡h鉑m以， 14 。Do you面mental heath counseling? 15 A l ukineedthatd而鹹 16 Q 統you a tensed mental heath counsth? 17 A 阮a晚nsed咖s輛幼a叫don物（期師ala18 ense面祀砌I health cour,se必r rs. 19 Q You don b'ow whether there are rubs and regulat s加 wi汕eState訂｝)g由regulat卹me個heath counselors? 21 A -d閒雙k1wthosenites. 22 Q 嘛州assume, also, hen you woukink闔w whether23丫側紉u他鑲驢勵”闐e，切飛d?

24 A IdonThiow 面there晚such 贓刻鈿物州． 25 -cananseer也絨que馱馳〕n.

! PAGE 25

25; A Unlor1unate the nursing documentation record Is

niiinialintsenlries. ThereisaienUyalB: am , about險 !iwanth to eatand an entry at 915a.m. about herwanling to

Ldown. ftdo painiiUe head. Itdoes indoate, theugh, that something is changing or not qute

i htwIh her. 7 0 Fistofa炒there娜notation in the no咖 6documentan小驢you rev d wh訪Sa( that細個鵬園 9paai『h嚇ead which you自低•砌勸娩劉闐”園翰袖toma?

;! A U黜teI there nqstretc驟e翁 ;!nursing documentationdow . 神州由where headache認州仰黝”戴閱

!4 Q s蝕an劍朮of food他喊Miss鯈鵬ate at

!;；認；．梁無from；渠 con! of food the norm ate atTandem? 17 A 吻reckdiof the recordswas憶Iseenistohe

；玀o recal reathg that the weuki eat ten per*whereas at 8: a.ni. on February 29th t are wimg that state a few bites, which seemed signcar4ly lsssthanlen percent. 2之 儿ida切也e俺，面卹docume而lion細繡馳she

23 isnoteadngshe at嚮nstrafingadiangein24 consciousness. Sotdoesseerntobeadeviatioofromher25 由鷓喊

! 2345676910讒1!2

-

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

Depo成PERRY STARER., M.D., 912S106SHEET 8 P八6巳 26 P八G巳 28

26! 0 例丫0ureview卜er dau喇盯K幽晌ePauls testh2 vliereinMsPauIte'iIedthat咖咖tt salne留 nounl咖 3 日俪，s喇forbrea比s右仇at mom血10? 4 A I have her te如众Where,｝由fl 『e铭’ 5 朗c汀油相洲eme吐协ouah. 6 'You don't伯伪’aque欲价about袖etheriwas日可 id瀚哪腼fl叙nom 月y决：蒯Ms酬斌咖 3 A }adu街由叭renlefliber仇欲exacIg QAndyou dont havea叮way of quantifying whether the10 俪Mesreco 划we陀moreor ssth 触俪nercentIlnonna加evaluated L 劝e！飞少能名、面you? 12 A }amix晒at the wt确chart.帅 enthere'nany13 1tep 心es叻劝renthatde'0飞加e,youhavetobokat14 more For日hpctUre. L 均kilg 欲another sect 叻ere卿 15 钾that ie' tha哪durlig this!eengJ per【d that seems16 to州吵that sornethig'qule Gitereil here. 11 Q0Ms’愉服a ys take a nap川the mornings！已．俪ie ate份eakia哟 19 Ak'o咖tolhetentimo叮酬眺atheiiePatd, ntie20 ”川hat劝e never took a nao U城！添‘ nuniia. not喃训 z1 膝mere vn 抵 .1L u v诵怕t0目menurngriotessnu23 人 ｛donI recal seema docunien1atn on nap口r . 24 Q I th叭k wee estabthed you dkin't see any胜1cl m25 触flu面gdocumentation肋吐旧如盆ed栩MsVbamswas

} Q 劫d材以映阳阅e 侣廿祀犷e(0目份fg卯 2 A “州栩叙闷山月认g翻吻饥．测伽nh3 伽！t耐份明s~）洲，咖喃s~ve.

1 0 Andwhatreferencethereto thargy?2 A U M gthenMandthenm

3 th mg ewasetha oonshewasuriespon4 0 th iitherecordsthat5 Ms' ams was nonresponsi& 6 A The翩翻长翩讼1h伽records? Y以加tat 'no7 al洲川t加僻d阎remrdsorever1hiig!have? 8 0Eve确响that you have. 9 八 Because some比姗议ten 扣触dschame suninarr. 10wh劝l・1est触web翰o about thai she's unresoonsie? 11 Q 丫既 ,2 A 加侧！回康e的 the nui劝udocomenbon姻 }3she doesn't responc:whd山uk1J耐・了勃协协beunresponsie, !4Is城｝l:加a川． 15 Q Yt咧丝Ms哑ms卯协咖印？ 15 MftFfEEMfN:Oted幻the term. 1了 八 I'm not sire可ntlewenl协deep or became letharg'6 {ca! elyovwt)en湘妇p1 down or aged 协thy down. 's Q 八！川when帅s钧at? 20 八儿cordiag协the nu咧 documeMatn lea刘： 219:15a.m.淞iv1aled that姗w翻砚edbbvdown蒯叙was左 assisted协bed. 23 0 彻monbxedafeeInaoI.w." atfadual24 basisdoyou have俪物恤习姻MissY%ams网afeegof25‘哺

PAGE 27

!corn幽i1i'iaOfDa'lfl抽her head 喊chvouaftribute切仇e2 subdu阁卜即韧句ma. 3 A !cton'trecaheerg do n姗班a onoihead pali・ 4 伽nursina documentation records. , U I知you see anvuiuia 川ne哪姗嗯neirom ianoemb mr1at you姗闭口maatea Ii议MISS V.Ina nan oeen1 corn 防咖 of oain in herhead before叙went to aleep? 廿 八 i能陀恰a汉瓜en袱11！旧tSI玲coi下阳men川nos以iomer仗a.！抢皿伪anea翻祀．阅wesn以叨翻别 10 !eeigv峨went ba改 to网around 10加a.mn. !} Q Mythinq else? 12 八 In that pa 初 r document ldon't recal seemg飞3anv!!1助 else. 14 Q 丫阅幻的卿知ed at the Tandem rehab da 碑网 15 Wasthereanylti吻ri the Tandem rehab崎report vA1ch wou16 r目dtha1M跳’佰an朽washavingpaii叭herheadrethtedto11加subdural hernatonia? 18 A uerethed 叨抑“margy,not咧paii

鄙sam腮ngyIoInosuDauralnomaIona,too20 no eccatheadpain. i,. v 碑钾呷a嘿阳a"pa rmnv.！训noeoti you nan iooeo爪speecnuieranyne・ uyou溉anyinir些 t e re鱼ted忆head pail rebtedlo伽翻‘归“herna娜? z耳 八 uice again,几wasarerereace 协祀tna哪,呱nea025 pain. 乃

27 ( PAGE 之白

{ A ffIsa 黯e.I iess being,nt t th sfeeginosityt rdsanyooe,呵捆she3 膝日d喻械习 poorty. 4 0 Andwhatls伽faU目加‘奴 yourstatement that

;th 尸feeiig瓢enlatbn鱿915am. inthe nursing刊ocmiment record I城咖喃stired. and腼is翻lobe

8 conthed票；TandmHe 糯；亲 notewherethere9 isastatem h er gan erafee1igoino110 be初we几 11 Q iai does伽note say? 12 A Thenot 卿swasnof创e伯“!ee响realwel, 13 wanted协卯back to bed, 14 0 At915?

}; A Th 黯ssysabodl00Oa,m.orso0 This fall occurred someehere arourd 3:15「the{;morning; thal correct?A Thatistrue.

19 Q Istherean 翻dkalbn'm anyofthernaterials佰 川丫ounave「留 omatMIssv mssunereuan丫，inn ner21 head thargy," eefgpoodybetween22 that mornmg

? 315a,nt anda加a爪

23 A 丫e乳 24 0 姗 akisthal? 25 A Thatisthe阳吻offensefmddenl report.

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

夏》epo of PERRY STARE私吵1., 9/28/06SHEET 9 PAGE 30

叩

！。爛而―does the。什ease reoort say? z A ―賜化州t叨m 熔化知。t!tDY 併。開！頂b劍較oum

3 鉑vsthatt隴！瀾！娩『斗×〕ke補hBe血*Havnes.wtiowas蝕

4 叫間閒。州w！踟躑¥鬨勝紛亂〞物認州1"

5o&esmood蝕off cer wr遺es. 1-tavnes examined”細ms。細加別閃闐v齡叩nes. viiims口卹ineuoianeaaacne7 顛da驢e!e郡id．開 8 Q Other抽噸！晚（朮院rvcAedowi"that report, 9 胎蝕re anv id":abon m anvIhiQ you rv汰d that between'";'bam. and。 W aim MISSv物ms-！羽any par『ner neaa or

權！鱸noortr由鉑d必日，刻ural hematoma? 祝 隨《才壯跚朋： ei me憫肥韻cjectioriY圍say any煙3 i'id以訕闐．keyov 細魚動iga力以處any 面化舅之繳油the,4 『”閱鵝叩幟dto * 15 MS. StMPSON；丫昤． 16 A 恥州」 are總向仰was簾headache documented in the17 records allandeni t細th Care? 18 Q L 贈闈ke馭”，戲e叩U 馴稱waven晌．You19 州weda以J潤袖中kThey weredl ed 浪the Uers加！抽叢”」oroie引閱are田U叩朋eu”賺1.仞飛中 z〕 八 ―叫l劇開orm縱『榭n朧19叫萬瀾嗷取 〞 Q Mdthec intjte騙〕onyasweIasmadaI23recoidsin幗州fonm加? 24 A 1he師nite曲踟y．蝕'rc州ent repod! and the25medeahecordsl yes.

- Q 爛喃atd爾Miss點龍 ams say w健h閔冷d協that? 2 A Therearere飴rence向her testimonyto3 Lu勵W!framste翻Dom!W爛陽憶瞼h州was州力叫ttte呵amund,開d翻she was hurting戲llteb45 娩驪稱鹹wtierethe had oaii'm 細back州ore. Mdthere件aq州汰咖州he加如州he headache竊闐irs比抽 7 framed between 7:叩 a.m.翻8:15am. The陰 isaI addttorraI8 testimonyfromoor吻伯“細about險麒tend州o9 Luthe 徹ms'臟because險head was hurting如moth, So

!！緲櫺dn comb the ha 1 her motheree? 12 A Md醒ton狗，there is a no(ahon from L , JO.s nb誰3 肌the csthge他織says du卹）紛小驢娥畝陶關啊驢綺 14 con 加州c4a headacheandthenwentto園at!"a.m. I'm15 notquot陶ex 〞，圃贓 wTdes that the coffiplamefi" 16 headache. 17 QMv他鈿e晚? !8 A -!―由水――奮ars引cai付．、kj肉hI now. ,9 MR. FREEMAN: Do1佣mi闐可縱飴he a break? 20 MS.SIMPSON:偽內朧ahead. 2! {BR〔朕綁TAK州j〞BY MS州MPSCtt23 Q 氏s讒柑聯，when d" you form the卯訕細S州you24 Fisted for朕叫t? 25 A -dot knowexadtywtien I formed them. You're

P八G名 31

3唱 ! 0 Let'sexciude細inddentreoodwchvou困關 2 陶what細j！記併wrute down, Other勸關the incklent report, 綿there anvfl咖hany oft隱！伯！ eria匕t臘you rev劂物絨 4wo劇幼ow小誠”州物Tis was expenencg甽戶"or5 fee齣000rtr rethed to細而'V協'I嚇劃州ween6 3：」5a．爪a闐6加a，爪物dn觀憎卹 7 A Youesayinaanyoi細maledals. Thats, fluB 關翻勸ndma.a例！！加翻Ireeed. 9 0 觔¥！嫵以herthantheiidd囉波絨， 怕 A fl 嘯爾s陽闐ti”緘eab1.andhewas甽

12 reference協加1hsomeJ蝕ma鉑徊州have where Se聯a靦 13 BafvBc irii匕Ie瀾細！。under oath1 where be•s aue伽刪 !4abov股小際喊回ton, 15 。He〝 ,esttoned agaE what Miss Haynes saii圳mean16 細（涌！記er wasn袖ere, correct? 17 A Riaht.tt swhvhewasauestin麒勸ev as馱ed.街e18 v00000fKientt贓無Havnes used the word headache to you19 alter他Havnesfl加伯馳―、ata嘛儻．伯te作以叩肌me陶mine加 onFebrua 踟？觔d細offi ．開丫e n袖•affi.*觔d2！面計material幗―revia dyouwno1勵化know abot盧 as22 威？ 23 Q Yesa州卹other than reiated to州織 the officer之4 開膩

25 A 丫既噸vealso佃testimonyJDo 州嘛ais

! PAG蒞： 33

33

；中隊腦there am閑絨喲即一―don't know how勿開洲

! Q D 攀tonspOrtoSeitenter25,2006whenyou edth kHerfrom es&McHughutheinciientreodfromLeonCountySherifsO lte yfromanu dlvidoais,anddepoton testiuuony from a number c( idrduab

?A IwshIc orehe uL nsheg'm to beI mdandIdon'tthinkevercompietehysoIdtd. AsI okal the fist pieces of maler , that is the beginmg c an0 .

12s涮含es誌霖mbfonnprtorto13 S ter25aridthenw#haddltionalmaterial祉卹mbo州er

！灘geft. ButIcon'taduafrackFmsucha rigorous nuanrerforyou.Q JyouhotdthupEntonsthalyougaveme1odayithe month of 4 2006? ;A Piiorlo驗tthecasekfidnthaveanyopiensaboetthe se ed1aIy. In havehadkheasenddea boofMbice!MIIanisbecause

21 -dsl nof know about her向bJu翰 of 2006〞一QThat劇 ri't have anyIhug伯由”飲the傳 iestbn. 23 Tfiequethoawasldilyoulormllie叩inonsthat you have gwen24us here today during the monthjrn2以冷？ 25 A -diinl have訓he materials. I陶hi have formed

凡〝》4 。戶‘膩•

!

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850)之2么s5。8

Depo of PERRY STAR覓kM，。．,9/28月6SHEET 10 PAG巳 34 ∼ ！ P八GE 35

34― 閱體jthe onns, bul 細涔r taIIoftheni, 2 Q Didyou rm蝕c抽動k”寫矚you臘約wen us I re3 tod圳咖the monthj August 2006? 4 A 鍬e娜h,―仿嚴g總例日州論e即，啜侃 stht6 Q 恥團er dated Se肉咖25, 2006 seen to have7 transnMed蝕加kdI比 aIerI you臘e here開the table8 wth仰Io(始yt回you rev記wed;別磁corre ? 9 A !sthementh !！頁以甽州hme. Wsn4怕 the加馱dthe mater I 回―revwed. ht'sthebukj出e!!mate lv 訕土認叩the細b絀，准 12 0 PortoSe肉加25,2006,州回nat rev屹wed any13 tesmonyn臨case other than the deposkiori traiiscr!td14 (）馴油獻圳小ede卯s．加觔開叮刈。「卸他Stewa哎; 15 胎幗cone16 A 魷―咖『珊鉑剌細臘州records硎the17 Tandetn Health Care records, 18 Q Doctor,啤州 ucoukllstesitottrequestiona19 hft1ecser,州and! m州 oommunate a litUe better and we20 n瀾g11geI加咖this a 瞰細fastec. MyquestiondinThave21 郵hIg勿由州hnedicthecords. Thequestknwas-22 MR FREEMAN:物，let me卹a second. kistasUhe23 queion.無觔柑細stateme州圈h&s nat缺011924 ma黝doe馴】、坤the coninui州ion process. 25 Tylo細enbherquesI .除晌吵

PAGE 35

35' respond, hs been vy coopemtie ―勸’陽貢化see us2 get流卹the wrong toot3 MS. SIMPSON:向州！勸'leitter. I ist齣keiher4 l'mas igvefy.vety阿quesIPns c 喲暱閑帕not5 00flflfflK沁聯叮戚．beca -seem to誠a qu叫'on6 andthenlseein卹dan an斗erthaldoesn'l reblelo the7 qu 嗡m加可youdon'tw血stand n （事estion, please已 ！dme,黝絨s物thatquestion甲戲 9 升怔1TNESS:！憫m協apoioge 面―upset you. MylO tect吶ue is to勿an 化pttresethequest 1物clea『 11 細―understandt hIUiat，麒才嘴pteaseitorm'2 賺， 13 MS.SIMPSON: Ivu appreciate州you tny to！磚 an r細）肥喊k閱〕！！細！-a汰not the auestion鈴 15 rep廄sed 坼you. And伽U勸iiderstand州uestioo16 -ask，國tel me and I哺beahdtorevttra州for!7 you. Okay? !8 兀肥以劑ESS:勣 19 BY MS. SIMPS州: 20 0 Th uestio 膩priortoSeatener25,20O6,the21 on、tesltimn吻細formofdenositionsthatvou園revwed及 we哺練爾！On t「nsotdOrson Srndh and細【紹pos'on23transcn廬jDr,洶司Stewait:的d嗡了麒？ 24 A T！磁認切“喊 25 0 Thankyou.Andthose耐erials, the deposition

哺月九乙丹，〞4

b■

0》。已••，。《

2-.

h•磚》徒必

!i',！誰

! PAG名 3?

- testimony at Dr. Snith and the deposbn transc圳 2〕〞Slewaitvoudd州『ece決甩月滷““州動伯afiecSe伏e們蝕r7伯 32006, correct? 4 A Thatiscorrect. 5 Q Yhenwereyou臘asked to form opinns vh仲sped to Msv儉m damages? 7 A ―日咖豳緬thcal州劉1小畝面！刁肥Wasused. S Q 偽棘晚- tiodriyouspeak嚇個about? 9鴨鴉Mr. Reiis? 10 A lknowhsooketo險．Reiosaboulit. Vethersemeone唱leise團contacted 鵬before and broi中that嗎―咖、險《瀾 !2 內朧蹴臘 13 〔Ex丑個叮S MARKED F佩IENTRCA11ONj14 Q I b 句shvyou州tIhaveniarkedasExhlt3巧 to your deposihion and幗askyou面仰have劊辟”即細 !6 飲umentbefore? !7 A 1〕韶他誠劍神似開黴貧？

18 Q YesUs. 19 惑 ―哺bo&Ihro卹膩 20 Q 關酌 u'降加蔔r ,Ooctor,ust幼you can2! n唧！了a鉑,I'm!diQa樹erested油ean erto22 咖 esttonNumbers4,亂and 6. 23 A 〕all細”血rat that you have oresented to me. the2磚on翰parts!mcaHseek 匕叨ncunukimvlae,州勸祕 25 le here. Nowouwant聯伯臘絨 馴斯胎questions?

37! QYes儿oak誡the aner勿。紛誠訕、！知細4. l AS袖“-read細qe瀾加? 3 Q 化丫叫『嘛，

4 A Okay,I'veread 離， 5。 飧re丫側coo 剎懶hrewed協（油為神翻瀾」加46 of PIain1fsanversIo蝕Defen細龍Eiterroaatoons? 7 A -have戲seen協document. ittiarsvAialvou areB 郃紛闐n拾．統 youa由闐開州】磁her I have seen this賺肥瀾加? 9 0 甌niaue血】is偶衫叩油ete瀾話edyouhaven't1Ose 復So nw auestion is. dio anyone from州臘乙劇伽h園

!2 開¥。！冷from州臘&Md―叩h“丫卹叩orbelor嚇叮咸4,2006權3and ask you the馴劇細聯Jthe!a由他鹼劉！則騰feoor ！。 ！仲翻 and the勁勃縱咖ot 面ixs? 15 A Ba划 ou nwrevlewatnwovinatesand咖臨惚 16 them,貢，丫叮獸e翰訪戲小戲happened, because IdrIm17 notesdlscuss蝕conlrlMion for細death of Miss Lucle化 &ms, Bnticannat誡thshmeadu狗唧J咖―spoke19 toaboutthat. 加 QAnd面you spoke勿州句erson, did you嚇them韶 21jAugust權劍蒲州you he 珊嘀（陰唧刎悶 22M酗腦ams'damaaes? 23 A ！勸〝冷儿幼aabco油manes戲幗。騰． 24 More likely I縐ssoea緬咖唬日州會h」―必．而如！!!, 25 Q 抽other ds,細蝕bditaihemaloma則贊d險

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

sHEET 11 PA戒3E 36

1death? 2 A Thefa1causna加孰dural hemaloma cau咖腼 3d佣｝h' 4 Q 蒯万you w notice a'so 价 response to Queshon5 Nunte以there' a atemeflt拟the grounds br Perry Starer, 6M,0.、ooiraoosaf妙the facts coi佃．ied明】i叭物emed浏 7recdsstedbeI期,as戚as h backgrourxl, tral甸，and6 experience.加 yousee栩? g A 丫眠｝rb. 10 Q Mth0se由cumentswecetheoii扮documents th you}!had as时October4, 20%, ccrect? 12 眼FREEMAN: You nieanAugu ? 13 0 l sonv.Mou4.2哪， 14 A To伽目c(flN recoPcti0ii. yes. 15 0 ffvouvu"turnandIookat触ans r $0 Question16！佃ter6'ConoeExh婉3,翻相tauestion跳伽 17P防！‘!s仍由1衡幼c 斌 causes of actions, comp姗s18 优 m以dma1ters叭hhPlaint1fs姗finn膝retalied伦 sev晚s of the以 per120 A Shou !read加即钊祀r，初？ 21 Q Yes,可youvu目read伽an er, because then Iwant22 协ask丫佣scn o喇onsMout t23 A 以av.I\'ereadi. 24 Q MkMa价功the second parag咖of the an溯er25 th e astatement. E ,Starer腼been retaned 勿

1

1

!

，

・

“

！

月

l

"”〕4

，。凡。．了‘

36

Depo"FERRY SThRE吸珍IL,, 9/28/06P八GE 40

! A 绷sioe of an瞰m沁蒯日 center? 2 Q 丫es. 3 A 尚．lwanttodthiethat.俪newer operaled伽膝of a脚ital or medraI school setli1g. 5 Q Haweyoueveqxadicedh娜由协01俪than6 New丫叭？

八Q

了 八 No, S Q 触you a member of the Ainerian Matnt Pssociation? 9 A No, 10 0 Have you ever been retaed 句the V1kes & McHugh脚 }i 俪IODrOV康exoerl响essse、加叭con阁劝喻．case12 叻劝iovoWeda越如ntrng home and the patient!3de,eb0抽asubdural hemaloma? 14 A !donI recal加锐d鹉．,I actuaI 如竹侧 15 可 I have漱from愉cuse. 16 Q 吻州阳C日’ g咖ex1te如协yn忱口seof17 拍0论 sD,1ac絮oe侧D 侧甘Lawsonv.HeaIhManagement!3Inc.,叭蜘4, 2005? 19 A }recat the name Lawson.!don、 mmberthosetv20 iid扮kit比．PeIhODS侧was献伽name of加redenI21 U .mesD.LawsonandOonna1awson,ascoadninistratos22 onbehalltheEstateofBarbara比加Lawson? 23 A 山l加 ml．月 ndoessoundfaii自r. 24 Q Hav 州创盯rItenanyai1比dealngvAth25subdu阁卜emalomas?

了吕 A

护、：:．叮！耘

PAGE 3,

39仲lain研忿coun洲书日nexnerL' and钧即Uwe a时of2 case&辘阳卿c佣 suledwfthrespedtoprov浦ng也eanswer3 tothatinterrocatoiv? 4 八 No,}don、recaIlbegoon 划． 5 0 And 可I'mco门tingconer功，there appear to be fe'cases listed here? l A ｝哺coijntthemaswel, One,t ,three,fo了, 8fwe cases. yes. 0 0 MIbeveyoutomeeadierthatyoube翻eyou10 had比即retainedby丫伦es&Msk动in excess cl ten cases. }} A 丫es!2 QSois己甘协sa晰妇桃犷does not aooear协

14 PL 眠Kloemo exa 喻at妇！粉书怕璐retanea器的 ib er眯百‘ixn绷casesare，爪协me期！口l服a'叶v很e" 16 M*uoh'sd百（es.andlthouahtttwssmorethan吻，恻I甘 甘论哭a限朗mere are,阳n！创e化匀’似印． 18 Q Haveyoubeenretaied卜the Defendant in a wsui！匀WI-协providir expeft servioes? 20 A }have been contacted 勿Defendants. but'never went21 翁far as drafting a reod件咖吻ed s称渝 22 Q Venwereyoucontaded勿Dendants? 23 A }don飞recaI 比niM have been a fewyearsago. 24 Idon'thaieanymoreirdormationoethat25 0 Have州ever been engaged ii prtvate pradioe7

一 PAGE 41

411 八5-吻addressing subdural hematomas,阴．}have2 not. 3 Q Aft 劝肋0山山 u卜av ver weninanvcase腼 月been on晚佃树伽P脑研叭也e鲡su政，correct? 6 八 Th砒 correct. 6 0 t)劣e枷sions and syniotorns 01 a subdural了卜ematoma? 3 A 比can be伽翩nofldheadade,fae知｝,ed 触 ，自份l，记盆benewobocdth叙 }｛钊0

“阳 Seures,c 目th ea钩nor 'n om01

subdural hematoma? 日

}; A It's .I黯韶黯；赢 14 ceateafocus01seure.怕etakinoabe成acutesubdtt!5hernatoma? 16 0 Yes. 11 八 拍nihtbepossi18 0 Dizziness? 19 A 0位z“、es比ave nonsoec北desai4ion.bnta2021 ofacutes创咧hamatonta. 22 0 0oriontafion? 23 AQuceaaain.日chanoe in consc沁旧！essand alerhiess24 and orientation couki be a闲nand symptom拼’创“阎hematorna. 25 Qknnes ?

}

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

s"EET 12 PA。E '2

42! A Men p泊b知俗间Ps以川日occur2 Q Nausea and voni 嘟 3 A Th canoccur. 4 Q Ins脚to娜 ieak c slurred 匆 eedi? 5 八 “阳，affect the印each mechan抓 6 Q Atax 优闭icuJyW习 lu嘟 7 AM留Lacon伽bra叭． these thrnas can haooen. yes. i u uoeseve叩ne ao e'penences a suoaurai nemaoma nave,aheadache? 10 A 下！ ren 川beDeoote咖don、 have headaches!! Q O泪MssW始nishavecrebra1atrophy? 12 八 丫as,价at was described. 13 QMdp以劝书浦h留．bratafr叻v,Iv dtakea14 帅“peiod时ttmef l触日引g叭ebraithexes1pressure15 ori加俪n．吠u匕n'ti?

{{ A Irs 瓷,0 R a D b协for阳rsonstosufferfron1. !8 洲d叫 her间oma anti卜・犯的＄犷叫枷性，伪脱d? !g A Dcoo”比possbe. 20 0 You would aoree. vu目n you, Dr. Starer, that a21 person vAio had c*rebral atrophy coui Dave b论ed时in the brain22 houtiricreaseduitraaan Ipressure朗d南泌卿喇伽佑 23 截 pectedwithastdurslhematoma? -24 人Aperson nM卜别行.-rmtrng协！脸了期协，飞hey25coukl加日拍伪了穷目a0op 即0no symptoms because" me

加创刀

Depo of PERRY STARE民M.D., 9/28/06P入GE 44

;the page. Do you see that?A YesIseethat

:lhQth question on x hefore Seember 5,2006

?A ua Idor recaitheth that

: o 暮 erftomMr,Reisd gooutuMIli7thA｝鳄嘿1 cannotrcaInowthetin!nthe phoneMdI u aIsonethattheredoesn1tseemtobe

i蒸egrounds1 ropoonwhich atthemtheprr page. s 'Thegrouidsforsop the nt iedwhitheme recordsstedbw.asweOash vu.,.i i d, }{"i 糯踩thefld?conect?A That athays. 飞0 u - inereareniany01肥；o aenso ieimny sieal9lIiere均欲are cantered m the September两orthe加s耽inber 25th fier, are there? 21 A 尚，廿lere are riot.

:M『0l Havey 黔nanycasebekxewhereMr. Freeman was the attorney for *es & McHugh?A Notthatrniaware . 25 Q "hreaped协the amended answer俪明 ears佣

P八GE 43

}（泊叮的阁以侧价

2 QYes, 3 A ndepends训hom川hbieedlngthere认 But,yes,I4 _s_. 5 Q Andyouwouklagree俪the elder扮日佗ss tke引0相．沙e劝咖份or symr1oms of creased iifraci'an I pressure了 IromasuDaulEet侧以泊aue拍cereorat alr甲飞y, wouxrni IOU? 8 MR. FREEMAN:伪日to the form. , A 伽oues&in niohtbesavmatDat -可I understand10 伽口侧加．丫以介．时相because加elderkmavbemore

12 beIessIOrey怕have symptoms. And!wou侧 say,yes, (s}；详0 M 价ed溯envuaavevourtemonvinthe15 Lawsonca酬ou口树协功川鹅叻hweuldsh tDatmanv16 喇e南喇油朽l油城劝洲no sv 训oms喃a龙瞅f"anU immcran旧i D姆O! 18 A }dont recat exact扮，but that does sound coned!' (E 书BIT4MARKEDFO1 IDENT1CAfl 1.) 20 Q Netd!’阴目跳协show you what!have marked as21 ExMjd4anda 卯u汀卯uC却晚爪介Uatdocument22 A ！彻、recal seeing th' document More, 23 Q ThenIwou"askyouiyouwould山喊your24a11er翻南,eshoriNumber4. Daiwrstobeanamerided25 w erat伽veryendofQ.esbonNunibec4. Irson报top at

P八（3￡ 吐5

( Exhibit 4 to Qieion Nun加4. are the o 'iions栩you nave tol melodaveat伽『e叼伪扣腼肠耐damaQes阮only3 opirnons栩柳have formed? 4 MR.FREEMAfl:Le$meob totheform.rmncLqte5 }understand 砚．Aiey a ng咖喃团er映genyou' a树腼oo翻1沁．1s划ay?

7 MS. SIMPSON: Tha1 orettv much触auestion. 8 A SoI'mnotocrossconebteit励伽amended9 即瀚f?

10 0 ｝囚want to make sure in 肋 ht of栩amended11 an箱ththere 袱some oomion von have loroollen or we议 naveni ta蓝加枷l演挑ii resve0 10似！「期irni彼 1万 八 ！J！脱国a阅．}De侧e赚！1.l帕劣翎帅功！ 14 铆触 thoutezrler衅opinions闷be encompassed勿栩． !5 0 Just so we're dear,}believe}asked you what'6 叩monsycu网lormed, andyoosaid 砚was目划油mages in行 thscase. NKI!asked you what opmionsyou had regar面g18 damages, and州gave me unnecessary redudion 价 e, ss of19 enj0'nentolJe,脚列suffering, and厉翻d习而d20 death.八“than }took each one of those and asked you油时the21 taduatha's悦cetoreachofthoseo户im22 A !dan1r创1en宜er可weadua呀wed through it I, 23 dIdorementergMngyoutJiose卿幻书‘ 24 0 Isthere娜other opinion佰you iMend to proffer25 栩weharenot・"P 'N ：・I today?

"J ‘・

6

45l

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850)222侧550g

Depo of PERRY STARER., M.D., 9/28/06SHEET 13 PAGE 46 ! PAGE 48

46! A ―爾協I want to 比as aurate as加蠍．-zn蔔m購a鯽aq【贓怕nat開閱〕卹叩伶．咫i降rev鰓！間 莽recofflssomeU'1rigeIsenu丫侃併才tome.匕娥as I”間陰T n1執州，―爍勵9e幗these日伯．”化nopu1jons5 0 關腳revw細CT hits that wece take州 6 M,V nnafter ie憫stakentoTa勸asseeMemor7 版p羲aP8 A C"T磚×魚乏ed T膩gra肉jhe head? 9 Q 丫既 10 A -thinotactua吋see the面， thaIs what州 !!are as馱為ig. 12 0 Yes.閑you read the repod? 13 A ―加馳ve-saw there州“日r eren購 to 細 14ned州recoi么 15 Q 贓州rop nh絨細爍adadtel目州rdemed16 怕開觔 rth 州be鯽e為飲小勸dmthere 吟勝 '7caused眸the馱刻”圓henoma韶op90 bMsv物ms'BhrtR her head? 19 A irs叫卹her head加廈caused the馱緘劍 20 爍ntatoma, Idoi物iowltowto蜘sethal out, 21 0 MendkltttesubduraIhematomastait? 22 A Moe鼠etvthan 麒油e爍曲甽aitedve¥ctose乃 加the個1祕dtheheadtraun . But-wouto 卹咖bPineed伯as' 以奴州稱由r絀tion.細v如as數抽州enthehematomawas齣腳毗飲med o Mien dd the pie綢細顫g郎鹹蛐幼

怕

纖etiiiethatthe bleedha afledMienthe bteedii beoan? ? A 陶Nn《解muna 加onimntontheLawsoncase向 3thattdon、recaI細de他胎刎噸ven憤圃ad冷價e祕 4 rev神wtherecords叫totoday modertoa erques[ions5 There吻m比differences, there may麒trsg向 6 tobed.ficuI飲m 勿comntoaaMi嗨d險caseMthout7 爍蔔ga騰化爐d么閑】翻險v辭間蝕！ec併由肉lottie6 qued【n9 0 In幗case you呎 re askJ.黝you know if an

！吋itmecfiate價膩咸“抽veF觸州日劉vbodlealonar Andvotr'!anver was, 'I 勸物榭‘、絨〕磁ter吋wouJ併not,闐．Ian

饞2unkr1州1尸 13 MR.FREEMAN:偽州to the form. !4 A 1柚化abitdad叩」wou“壯tohe齡伯 15reveeL 十細劊”魚食緬seciKrn吻askd about a16 闈啣（卹闐s栽啼勸吃向啤derertfrom the17 quebn that you asked me. 頂6 Q There' no ran啣（dgnOSnsmthq鷥爺to壇9when the bleeding began, correct? 2O ACorr麒 21 Q Mdvoucannoflelfrom蝕CT scans州were taken22 畝Tallahassee Menlorla田噸a！咖！】bebleed汕 beo 細〕 23，叩？ 24 A 〕柚CT a 」廈 doesntteIyouthat蛐awaoi ii泌 鵬case. sposs a。辟．袱矓閔s柏騰袖鵑n 戲

初

PAGE 47

；嘲 the hematonta began?0 Aslunderstandtandcorreclnie 可t'mwrona. buta3 別鬨州herTieloma resulafrom助！州團叩between the aura, 4 蝕呱6戲W晌州小e！耳勸，硎！晚araCh闐她，！晚圃d細 5 曬,themenuiges? 6 A Acechonofbl 減fresh bkod under the dura7 n祇徊〝瓣！爍叫undethn 叩，yes-8 Q Andthat 緘月訓bie闐詢u'a黝resu麗S嶼a9 stratth叩orte蠱fiigjthveftisinthesubduralspace? ;! A Right. There amagetoavesseIand there

theboodbegisbcoIed. 洛

12 0 Aridm臨〔ancew 絀1淵Ms *amswas翻onj3開訓oao山nt叩《萬以邊？ 14 八 ‘蒲was加閑g謝m,劉K臘as切叩匐n. 15 0 助幼他 anancoagubnt,cocrect? 16 A Tha!scorred. 17 。Awl州”def蝕use of幗鉑fm嚇toodthners, 18 aItakefromyourprrde卹m? 19 A Ih iksaimreaccuratedescri咖n、 20 0 You 勸、have anyway of kn(nng when the bleed魄 21 betweenthedumaodthem 咖byerath 、stan1ed,doyou? 及 A -canac遺Hyou with 仰oercer4叫面！丫．but-”。”絨vounre“統than靦who磁benan. 24 QHow 齲casedirer鹹而m蝕Lawson case whet25 州攔！臉〝youdrinoth誡為？討嘛thethitedthe做unit

PAG已 49

49!context of other th igs

.Q e obecteevidencemthcasewh ow when the bteedg adualy began, are you

?A Iw knoui ndition,knoustgthed a te t gulated,t theruasadden;Lrau theh 竅u

ertheyaotindthesubiluralhematoma, with He mptonts that ace described, more eI thaned an at the timethaithe headtrauma occurred,

;veny chose to L0 Pr bM 豔黔stesthnonythatebehen7: d8:l5 mothertoldhershe團a

；讜戰an*or 'nIonsteathIIedborreponled tj anyone other than Trooper soand teimny worefenedb bout h MthMsHaynesThat;!y,vUK snow utat MlsS vwtantsit no 徹開reaoaae併姘柏。山∥ ！么八 叩州吃牙ex〔黑x 洲胛ny 個胛〞””ny ano

-;a環uoingb ergeaiu acxoiins reportdescripIo? 併閒喝ilaynes

20 021 te th en纖,atMiatertieshe22 there,tiermotheroompbstedofaheadathe. ; Prkir to that time, are you aware of any

ec1t ay f yne therecordoriromanyoneetseat thetadlity that M nts com ned of a headadie?

!

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

——s下J下二ET 工4 王叭0E 50Depo of PERRY STARER, M.D,, 9/28/06

p八GE 52

501 A Unfortunateithere‘喊0mo以e doaime侧盆o. 2 下！祀）而e.e义峨udiiawhat you have囚砚emed,Idd碱侧 3 anydocumentati阅1'ah咧adie ii the recocdsat the ea血 4 morning卜ours5 0 Youmenti1ed姻you网anovmnreQan1Q画 6 蒯su行晌gretedto伽siix知川加matoma,a耐州n1en13n树 了卿价the head, thargy, and日1eeI of feellg poo ? 6 A 彻， 9 Q 、愉习t件闹‘恤1 ediM眺Wi妇n experience画 10 m伽had・・时 sstaitwh旧mm加head. " A 日a犯d训 n reiwofaI忱records. oa叻 ithe1211枷喇ocourinmeeanvrnornranours翻aunun能iater13 n众 ninohos匆rnherearound10Oa.m, BOO aim. maybe ever as14 e翁掀的刁．爪The doxiet*ahon侣毗a ys书r砂ous}5 舫砚coo目加． 16 Q So幻mewherebeweenthetie3OOto10加am. s"7your呐kx that Mss 愉脂刊（・妇‘～・pa 爪her head? 18 A Scm erebe1 enthatpe闹,yes. !g 0 饰欲详初 of恤讹喇M招s墉neperience加目hgy? 21 A 11sssdescnbed 以刚welliried as occurring in22 the laternrninc腼rs. ftseerns协he around the time of23 匕‘eak伯， ,油劝由城wIdoc'tkn 叻at tire I was. 24 0 So 旅 wu目 he somewhere around the珊to9加 25 perindinthemorning?

P九G它 51

51l A 找就邢！加rs喊减宙份”翻wasso,ed ！娜｝喻 2 由n竹n 麒a 扮，！如,咖 was eal初力around尽加a阅a3 theta阔makes a r e侧e's tharg( durEg the teeduig4 ner训． 5 0 伪n gwhalperiodof俪d泪 Ms嘴ams

6 periencefee；耀咧。。四协！。丝叨There"aisoasigge’卿黔 I“吧甲v母哪）份砰明严 ，城10日．爪or即即o:u a.爪bIJI mere 双inaurwi10 d 月1帕lationuithedmaflabout腼feens. so we have to use11 叻月l ehave咧卯W油叻aththemo喊me 厅probae!2 scenar13 0 So栩appears to be缺me between, halyoo told14 me, between 9:15 and 10加m伽morning? 15 A 网扭1帕hargy蒯a feeling poor observatbo 勿the!6 以月wers, 甘 0 Haveyouhadai'conversationswlhanyof18 MsWha耐俪目萝members? ！仑 A No,lttaver , 20 0 伽Sec4ember践2 她erthathoaitof21 cmooe时汉1indatisthatthosema知铂卜were侧eral22 Expressed协you? 23 A Yes. 24 0 帅 nd目youreceiethem? 25 八 Tuesday, the 26th of September.

6

! 0 肋l卿d日丫s日00丫训姗孙 eda踌theitormahon栩 2 匕 r d 翻theSeatenter25.2006目ter? 3 A 丫es. 4 0 Houma爪腼佑d记vousoendsinTuesdavrevievia5 伽介翎解讼伪欲污目・dh加翻口ember巧．2姗助的 6 A IcoUJ坷and e助铂teIhat Fronul2to！枷urs. 1 Q lfwecould以atComposde Exhi Nuniber2油youS have that? 9 A 丫e公 10 0 The翩page, and I think you sad all of these are11 yournofesthal州made in fli比口se;‘杨C"red? !2 A Yes,Ihat 衅卜a州姗云姆Those are衅r tes. 13 0 Mmend目voupceoare撅侧oaceofE对翻2? ｝礴 A 仆‘国oewareoared幽翻健． 15 0 So栩阴喇愉ebeenouSevtember2l? !e AYe轰 17 Q Fiow咖吐伽朋‘0冈page.whendiyouprepare姻 讯l侧镇，

伯 A !d叨、recalv南翩！l片ep习传d 趁．网lknowla次触d20 to 1 in the眼cOuDof days. 21 0 ViRien翻丫u oreoare伽thidoaoe? 22 A That.imayhavep陀归间afwweesago：脚ohabty23 even iiger劝朋栩‘Th page响Madualbesometh侧 24 神had打（月”日喇甫戈哭orinageneraBe.!can't tel25 you exad扮．

52

、

尸AC￡ 53

! 0 腼a协dthe tourth page? 2 ATh冷was脚曲鱼坤声e钾！eda翩mtl1sago. Nowim3 guesslmg,but已k义＊sIesanokIer障 4 0 Howaboutpagefe? 5 A Paoeliye.onceaaaitl喇have协esbnate.城趁 七脚长s姗is an oer page”助明rit nave naa someladdlions.}wgobacand喇th冰as Ithink of th哆 or& unMson bg. TAspagehasbeen即0*闪ge树 "c例n. 10 0 Page卿 '! ATh污a切bos触sanoldeipage. Itmaygo12 backwee叙s. !3 QPace洲朗？ ！月 A 书场s pag 污morerecent 胜probabty was created 盯 15 the勿成two or three邮． 飞6 0 Page e习淤 17 A Ukese,膝page污 a younger page and has beenlacreatedhthe目 two or three娜． !' Q 尸age nine? 加 A 介匕page贻o"er,肠旬比・俪weezo妓 21 0 Pagelen? 22 A Pagetenis间俪of page nine, so the same answer23 applies. 24 Q Pagell? 25 A Th污alsohoks e胡oer page to me.

53!

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

SHEET 15 PAGE 54

541 0 Pagel2? 2 A Ths anre佗atpe,possibmore呻伽 3 妇 sltwoorthreedavs. 礴 u 川创协的me曰t帅 or娜能0日vs溯戈．ame5 喃 hmeSe讨e1 er25th 湘rnraton, cvrrect? 6 A 1飞戒价即训丽脂卿啊翔谈取

7 QPaoelS? 8 A Th污dsoisanewerpageit伽图couple ot days. g Qp日ge！礴is page枷‘page御 10 A That'scorred, 11 Q Pagel5? 12 A 「祖ee们贻沁劝nd既，！口叭回vou tuaI13 when.陇gene阁notes. 14 0 Mdpage淤 15 八The sane. AttheendI和喊州d‘即n random kieasanl}6facts. Thenet湘 pagesa份a助Iiard协ace. ”了 M ,Mpsq闷里吻枷、悦怕瘾ashoftbreat飞6 （田饭从赞S TAXEN.) 份B丫Ms.5即SON: 20 0 Dr.Starer.withrespe物C叫oe Exhibit 2, what21 dothenotesonpageonerefled? 22 A rm not sure 可！u映rstand the quesberi. 23 Q lsth谧洲random notes腼卿took? Isitin24 记气” dtoany闪比currean杨yowrotethOforna1n25 d伪姗？帅翻causedyon协create page one时Conipo咖助以2?

加

PAGE 55

551 A ！姗Iunderand. Thereasoni“以“怡sto2 a meafram t whhto*协伽restofthe notes. 3 Th1swhy1网砚mthe top. The加侧沁防here then refer4 tootherpaits 叫notes. 5 0 洲祀 ed时youcorneupwith伽Ms on page one of6 Compo 盆eExhitt2杨are undeded? 乙A Iniadethemup.idon1欣Jx i但m 臼sany协mg. 吕BullW日’翻丫1)9幻’毗ot l(甲’:s or areas嘴0枕翻n日冈 gtharsh il口me叩with those phrases.

}｝协Q谓youeverlest1leddamages? 川a case borewlth respect}2 色 ｛帅劝donreca咚！nN"ave..' ~ i3 q Fr(myorreYiewollrereco哆dKI Miss V翻咚 l4recarve娜画medKalinl tmen3 ooa.m. and 1U:(X) a.m. on!52{2，撇？ }6 八 丫es11 0 Vialoai1n祀daliand记叙receWe? 18 A 脚revievi of the medkaI records,}see there is a19 documnt！加嘴Tv !1川beiiao扮en, 20 Q 灿enwasth叮丫犯l双姗en? 21 A RefeniiotonwnotesJs呱． hthe3:15a.ni. 22 note. 以川”P0翻钾g喊ameaC伪「at・『e日劝gbyong23 at加med Ireoords.比 eemsbbeaerthe3加ain, 243:15 aim event. 25 0 lsU嵌e娜讯血anththewasgwenai paii

t

互》epo of PERRY STARERI M.D., /2S/O6P八GE 56

1 nedia1inafier3:15a.m.? 2 A }knowthere污somere知ences 的脱c 伽 刊e叫ons that a以甘幼walked in wili medme, pass 纷 pain4 喇添.butl咖溯～l彻、耐洲、0以her5 documenta 加 of the cain medca加愉ry6 Q !believe州refeer 协M眺PauFsdepos&ionleaner.加卿hate拟there硫h州？ 6 A 丫es, we加vethedep劝ion姗e. 9 Q lthiiklhadaskdvouear rabordwhelhervou俪 10 reviewedMissPau1sdeoosdnabout腼testimnv where咖

12 咖on the dherniomngswhen姗wasthere. Doyourec13 that? 14 A }r创川也e，犯月加．禅． !5 Q ~~Uyouweukflook橄卿翁加22,也似功 !:page袱 Fe吕：嘴娜卿咚depo洲 .恻理卿咧 U！叮e口Ii口柳Wa风0饥1万’“兀see爬 v oe we penmern pi. !8 八ctay,Isee仇威se* yes均 Q 加th ’侧川 lend to indicate that愉伽I瀚 20 thouaht the水about加幼meanmunl姻l！翔11细帆湘 ziusu娜0且wnens0ewasme犯，c以re《万尹 22 八 ib比what瀚由0喇erissa自0 叭价‘ 23 deoosition. 24 Q 吻 uhavea‘飞丫reasonhd efevePssPauI? 25 A Idon竹oow.}have no reason tod'beliere. These

%

P八GE 57

; s,somattoiesyou read through thewholedeposkn andyouf

adarfrationofsomething, Butbasedonwhatlwas

own. Isee what she savs. 4 0 Mdvou瀚1、niakeanvnotesfrom脂sPaurs5 de加sionofan丫thiioto加印ntiaiv. d" you? 6 A Ldonrecmakgnotestothecon1raryto姻 7ca由“arstatemerl.的． 8 0 thresuedbcaaethreeofConmos孟eExhit2.翻 gyou usethatpage权四明sesof伯而i 娜“州ronmnsm!0th 口鸽？

11 A l'msareeier黔ndenotesonandlread12 sornehow med n,so,yes,lwousayso. 13 QHow喇theionnahonwthth 娜胭名阅pagetliee！礴仍而伽加锡仗柳嘴the opmmns you卜．怜g份ent吻？ }5 八 ！don't kr,c时(sgc明协be easy协叨旧侧钧at16 详ocess. But certa呻th' contributed田away协n)yopw)3ns1了a伙醉晚e!ectancy. 侣 Q And how相仇is咖rniatncom！树e to拟 怕琳自功？ 20 A Herewehaveorevious 时． r,., e:｛广is叻来湘腼

21 someseriousevents, ld ；翼bsaylhepageretledsniy22 readingofftwchat. Th sisonenotaibris. Bulfron23 th陈. as I sit here now. rm recaina栩帕suooeds to me24 th"awa伯nwhohasase咖smecaIp*em.aoesto加 韵nospeaitor民is ueanea 101 t, is 测卿Iron)服

57

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

Depo of PERRYsTAR且久M乃•，9/28/06SHEET 16 PAGE 58 ! F;;GE 60

58!hosoal勿小e ×entveretheactua黝was嚇化oo andz !ay分a 抓獵a州】）闐ram州”。。ace.往snowsn記！伯！ 到病狹！。suryie these tha胎gesandd必喊d州ram翻'iese oro偌sses. 5 Q 統”嘛叫pane threej Coniosite Exh靦 2? 6 A msorry,t吻 ges ucUether. I'msosony.-7wask沁馱月細詢ace fotr甲 名 Q 蝕戚k”懈勿the time we get勿page four. 9 MR. FREEMAN: Page four, the Talahassee Menrial!! Hospdal record summary

.A Th theregutbnsand 龍gave關a1?framoddwt袒t熔他胎豳伯物be州orla 勿the g ernnent13 戲臼角韶equ狗d晚開dd咱啤．msome waytft' does14 c卹伽伯伯時叩州睡 '5 a 以以in膩調併•坷that reder1s&e entitled 勿 '6the中•屋丫o e? 11 A RNIges關theareasntconcem. It陳贈 、6 翰膩閑m畝the government比胡 so concerned, arid 訪絨喝勃叫嶼 '9 抽量蛐助的bo切9小rough the reco鳴I'm小觔緬gabout刈臟 21 。So page初山日！購州talked about, you niade a〞臘dMs臘耐卹med油IP『。。細蔆併萬伯r亂胎！圈 23 correct? 24 Av知！-w開“物was加n戰h闐her transfer nnte25 州細1幼 ews爍勵gnmedfromlatlahassee除關劍Hospat伯

j- “

《

盧

J

AQAQ 5hat?

6 A M丫ocard l討細（加、．n側you have 鉑關t勵ord niyo7 t ce,so榆吃isgi刈tobeffhea劇由此狀自mage8 secondary瞬）$$jbbodftm朮could be cakd a head

」！中休鯽。wa”嘐顫戶州面youk×魚at the ∼“

!" ec！呷I以7馴下,胛eaaoT.see 啊aWve．興m.9頃s．”州en!lU4鋼Pyou sorn 吃！肥s歡m荒，叨，乎日∥嚀q馴，取鵬 iz case mere were no!' waves crime eiecrro a悶iam.

;; Q S醞ponatremia?A A sdni vel. 15 Q Eght hyp叫加嚇州商鑰c《馴細y雊sse16 加p緻conge汝on,藺 at油at? 17 A ―勸跚他tonisieadanvone Mvrniessriheie, 1匕！伯婦s a闔。紛閔繃稱加袖馴〕訓關州補啊nave物

加hioco以h！開加謝魚． 21 ． 以州誌隴州（《刈刃edmn? 22 A ―仇ink here州細！”劉言e、．J;'；睡、ao．胎 乃吻”J館爍a而 reduced in面I fu州汕）．畝州加鷥 24 flv他mavhavebackeduo油細ver and Uiats咖！蝕 25hepat比啼關g化•A闐ti 歟名嗡eJthe1rernv

Lung iedion

驟ne hem *ysis."“娩 m ys ?The co hing up bbod, Six吃爾要ivemyoc 劍油叻〕n．〞朮

叩

PAGE 59

權 Tandem. And小胎胎a臘“誡was cmv油d．翱憤dh啊 2cond勸號that也1祕． 3。iid嘛絨叫emsdkt州wredoun鹹were noted4 osi幗加nsfer瀾ie誡？ 5 A oyouwaii奮訂記to read the tat? 6 Q Please. 7 A Number!.Severeca他勸叫。pathyTwo 巒s*e8 puinlorialy e嶼n. Three, Renal su 匹ency.卜叩『織． 9Pneumo喊F#ieMen州ysis. SiNoriQwaven1yocardal

!！塭謬ponatrema. EMj1ypoprothmmbusecondyfopaswehepat coogeson. And nineis,NoCRT'2 Q y〝膩熔severeca n Pan祝 !3 Asevere吃川州卹叩aBly 麒mat well'4•黝磚•In ”絨ptiraseI but one cou必伯聽trom it that there-5,s？騰卹airmentnttheheatlp」咩．.ftinctlori. - 16 U Aod 膩•stedinthetransterneassevere? 17 A Yes離 18 。 The second目細〕 a masswe outm 饗丫 enix細Th19 衛 at比 a masse culmonarv eoiborn? 泌 A A叩u】襠鸞¥馴〕繡藤aclot to the山闐a闐a21 mass"e one明geststhata匕rge州jthe bng,affeded 勿 22 the clot.

的 ∼ PP、GE ,1

61！頃咖抽付別龍u唧k離a飛ded館c。州切加dd"sj

2 -

?!AGE

61insutupo edthecoagutlon usc4thepat rit. Ihiktha ioiesenlence

sayiigQ NineisnoR174 A 鯽understandrng bavaig rev祕wed some c4the5 leat群柑,州dmeens in the event that the head is化鯽 6 爍齣g捆蝕is喊伯have exte叫con磚'ressionsto the1 theat. ffthereisady郵hm分 of the he試翻is not to be8 由m)d1 ted贓h細．”.k，加可there is比athino9 orobem."is麒to have加tube out而瞼kmas硎have怕 the mach爾b，喇iefor險． -- Q 〞made細decision thatthecewotdhenoCRT? 12 A 喻！ cilectioniseemedlobea波decision, -祕膩！！懈！！識！冊即買- mere 馴啊劇馴！es沁騰i習j！劉

14 開ne叩a卹 in mispracess 顯。！知懈砌邇絨some州〕電 lbL1I1Rv憫矚a膠瓖叩衫排啤”馴個冷妒鴿險neaincare'6proxy. 17 Q 囫MnsV慟msherseImakethedeclscn州“ 18 wanted noCRI? 19 A l勸、聞記mbersee輪ganacturecord吻Jlhat加 convers 噸州consav喃cer蝕】柑州io made細at誡emeot. 21 Q 氏Starer, do you treat catients州臟刻ural22 hematoma? 23 A 鱸ehad“方1！闐個『濤？勸，丫es由 24 QBidareyou細！神誡動習向勃「顫those persons乃 州蔔havea馱鹹萬d!ematoma?

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

23 Q 恥也胄done匕『劍1a州翩訕ency.獷at that? 24 A Akldnevwhhis靦鱸緬d汕誠 25 Q Thetourth。間熔pneun 臟What誌 pneunnia?

一～ SH卫ET 17 户八GE 62Depo of PER丑Y STARE凡M.D., 9/2台IO6

P八G巳 6刁

62

！。A粼黯；;：豁糯默｛漏l3 probiem howeve以洛a p 蜘t州 o has a subthiraUmatoma4 andstgeiy腼been those哆aeatme呱that patient MI905 扔伽n 耳o别电浏seMce.肋we have bad some,刚idofli6 get, verj钾均协oae了 0 姗iefl there are patters旧the明吐that you毗们 8 who have su冈uraI hematomas, are r uro闪isi niia呀consuaeil9 州 hre联c 协Hie食careandtreatme嘟 10 A !d帕nowweMveaDoIc 刚以ocedureon

12 when}l榭e日了e比l怕叭．l抬创沁nsthatweneedtoan er.忱 13 如、l叻l份eafr 0d细的robovserv晚，sowe喇 141悦伯 eco弓怜4！肋南可wedohaveaaue a. 15 0 'vMenm触服tineyoufreatedapabel,t钩加hada怕 s 肋阁卜ematoma? 17 八Ac1ua .}don't recal由城now, 18 0 Uaveyoutreatedanyth怡year? 份 A Idon'treca民rmsony. 20 0 FIaveyoufreed畔wlhm the嵌蜘years? 21 A Iwedsayp0bab扮．butldon、 caIIthespedfics22 时aItheoatie南I卜ave seen23 Q 伪you卜ave any spe* reco椒tbn of treatiq a24 以nt协彻hada ibdu阎油帕如1n喊愉1the幽enyears? 25 A ｝翩切试成旧脱娜pa腼怡滋也污位'ne.

3J口‘"

。叨。l

1

1

‘

八之升！

} 2345678g

10111213}415!6!7!81, 2021

and 'ice they are n numbered, s the t rd page from theend Ithkthere only17pages

MR FREEMAN: doesIhaveatthetop? 。 MS. SIMPSON: llha t孙tethargyand

bbck box. weIbreakandet(lUNCH BREAK WAS TAKEN

.)BY MS SMPSON: 0 〕． Starer1Ibeevewhenwebro&ewewereta枷

卿嘿5OfConosJteExbiA2. Uaveyoukthdthat?

QinabmckeUnth翼D&uy'mn garous4ma babll1ytoeagageinatxandadivthes Doyouseethat? 0 瑚祀 ed记yoaoaithatiiformatbn? A l网done some rea ig ou thargy.}don'trecal

{ so an articleora de[iiicn from adicna . lhavesomem me,bvtladualyhavetodiecaga耐吮to see tho where cane00爪｝W翁 『ead啊e淞rab00板“a触配习d泪加日印喃e,}Was毗翻勺

22 怡．

23 Q 她也掀，爬日朋产脚伽e‘加晰浦的油俪吻

24 veoetatiie date, coma,喇 bm0 dead? 25 A Probahty.ldon 阳伪掀a断喊nld" S0r

器洲25

64

P八GE 63

631 0 I'侧功越；yuonameap・ietI'jn洲．s腼

3 auth喇掀”aaubduraIhematomawi腼the目 tenyears? 4 A Imsony 汀I dn、 answer the quesin 灿｝wou15 tu喇remen加aoatnt,Iwou目think of their r nie. Na6 1万拼11咖．书队here. Icaiin改 brii口 up an 了 ioy" a口 se. 1 0 ' iat'neuro的ay? 8 A 触you毗加nie what' as佃astheliell? g 0 姗议贻肋．d助翻eOf new彻昨 10 A Ba翻加几删目be均．咖血“日加1娜旧且祀‘优

12 0 Now,MsPai,wererredb姗depoadJon earF r, 13te 加d拟脉ndherwentlo蜘翻9加刚佰咖 14 neverwc触un．佃ft同俪ie.加you remi山脚 15 A !don1 recal that, but!seed内Moow.}don't16 seethe partwtered says如neverv &e up, though17 0 I闷bonowyourco 刚k嗦at d E a moment. 18 Canaoer以价haveaheadachehomhdtixitli日rheadarxInothave怕 asubdural hematonia? 20 A Yes. 21 0 Canao ohveaheadaieasaresuoththa22 theheadandi以he the result of pressure on伽brain蜀 以“到河日aunaurai nenwoma24 A 丫es. 25 Q tfyoucoidbok 掀阵ge15ofCompositeExh加2,

, P入GE 65

！喃成lW冠s取洲众吻成‘BuUproba饰froma 由r,袱 2 加san 溯耳仍． 3456了6910}t121314}516｝了 }8}9加2! 22232425

0 伪加目陶e of Compos1eExht12you1ve哪 somel Ofomion.渐ere翻 you oa价 that forma1Jon?

A Th"proba脚from a，卿OfaiIi*st回IwasreadEg and making notes on

.Q theartdesflialyouwerereadig vlwn you made these notes?

A }have’翔犯洲沁es1a间 ome of them may adi峋bethe ar徐 Q Coutdyoushowthosetome,卿se. 八 ('wWnessc叫 s.) 0 姗 ereddyouoaiitheartics树you洲

讲t川胶ed协me? 八 丫叨“翻1喃at i3urna七 Or w阔俪的 0That始paor卑拍勃0,Howd对 you goabout ot4aiiig

加 art涂s功at you proved to me? A 确method IdIunderao'm 喇ertoaetthoseoieces

黯易黯aco r a黯 the Wxarj of themed Isduoc. Ithiakformoofthem,ldonseethe日des胡n ,butthat叨uki比the tedinuettJI怅山” 0se.

IEXIBIT 5 MARKED「滚IDEN11ROAT1tt0 Lwu目欧etoshowvouwhatlhavemarkedas

Exhibit 5 and a幻闪可you can kier柳that document?

肠 l

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222,5508

SHEET 18 PAGE 66

防

1 AYes, 2 0 Flaveyouseen師靦5 before? 3 A 丫es4 0 -thoksabi闐細d嚇cmposeExt 盧！ 5 涵叩摑wasxedto you6 AYes1lttnk 功． 7 0 咖晚Pb．】ti1s coun觀Ifyouco*ibo州 8 ExhibitAtoExIi婉5. Youwereaskedtobnng蛐yout吻 9 somedocume噸correct? 怕 A 丫既 " QThe烈one熔a. documers, correspondence,併 !2 州erwr澀即com 州ions比tweenvoua闐細P 的研orthe!3 陶弘齡纖omev. ―切e扣囉！）鬨血with you all of憎 1磚「辦瀆！袖廈m 則鬨『••N;，。、。．〞

15 A !beleve so, ex郎fthe one on the travel16 誠間叫鵝血

17 Q Mdthosearethe加n,ents 勸we pre 疇 18 itrodocedasC嶼iositeEx以！.c“神d? 19 A Ibelieveso. 20 0 The second one' al documents, rep*價面柏f然 w尚en. mtion receed“『劊胎鸞dby you 肌connection22 wh蝕deveIxmeatda叨嘛咖or co物劇『帕d劍畝小侈 23 州州！. 24 -understand細a are some飲uments物 u dI 觔咖 25 wh you,喊a觀of alt伽sedocuments計該豳dh細

PAGE 67

67!cocre 1dennehConostteEx戲！；認幗correct? 2 AThascone3 。為他otherthan thosed。卹闈！swhioha降臘ed4。In贓e刨鹹唱and細art 1esthaIvouha譏而mea蜘 5In州eaoo.鏽黝were a面。泌誡―州〕asanexJ",aret臉e6 any面er似um 咖，evo隱 or 伯ninformation rece輪剎or州evwea凶voun coon叩期twin ue a曰訓伯C協any ooinm8 hth他case? 9 A ―州w "t勿beasacourateasnossile The怕 depos。ionsc(馴險蒲ePauIandDodhy惱ams are se悶rate

烽2 驪稱叩―加臘．

13。Le 物katConote Exlik'and see I 's on!4the鼠 !s MR 隊E〔以戶；」don、館朧認.becau州broua憤 16 thosede卹ions州e咖，so勵膩 otdn't be included m17 細絨er. 18 0 Sn罵we'red斕itosomeniater lyoureceied19 yeste肉．以誠耐喇劇yourecehe州er鯽？ 20 A 取materi thede卹n of Kattierie Paul andii 細denosition Donthv倫 s, 〞 0 叩州隱跑” anyothermatedalyeste由丫？ 23 A N觀 24 0 iemore―而sowe'resine. Otherfliantriedociiments乃 翻mater 臘ed 畝your國ers,訪ea血les州gave me,

《〝，．•8

Depo of PERRY STARE凡M.D., 9/28/06PAG笆 6B

!“細“向oos緻svou州pester由v.are他reanvot險 2reoocts併關說此翻〕naIbareceedorreviewedbv袱jh3 connection贓h“加龍勸of your opinions in胎case? 4 A 囫幗fl aware膩 5 0 Havevoua "1價edan丫！e。。．他畝connectionwhvoor6 serv晚鈿this case? 7 A No. 8 QAnd贓rest Number 4 was for at documents, repods, 9 treatises. aflioles. oub細alions. sdedules. and otheriu ”啊階1 nwaicnyoureiieauponm 併eparmg州『opinion or'!report豌hreg刻州his act加． 12 爛you gave me a臘鼠or a set of aides that!3 縱？e州刃加膩勸斗頗exhlA Isthal“細 14 晌rmation幗wouki come under個eoorv4? 15 A The『en鉑柑beotlierarhdesthatlhaveread 例er緣6 蝕”戰闖those were the ones細噸肺calet隨― 17 knowlhayereadrecent翰. ldonwant加n ead you. There18 吻絨be訓織油g幗―have read 畝細past tt 由y面my19 mind, 20 0 Requ 喊Nuiiter6wasfor滷documentswt勸州即巒丫 21 面er cases凶 er the bsl four veat論wichvouliavetesLilied22 鵝如麒州廈鹹nesse誰險bvdeoos勸n併誡州首Didv加 〞〕取g樹'youa叮餅響！（以！j隊nts．'

25 Q Youdoo'tliaveany卹贓期認myour••以×州 n? I．以

pAGE 69

! A 甌not訪 at rm aware of. -usua∼discardthemI2 鯽areevenseottome. 3 0 ) youhavea仰ca鷥s併ndnghereyouareperfornig4 er t補鷥ssserviesother加∥帖。舶戲the current line? 5 A 丫es. 6 Q 緬manfl7 A rdhaveto叫叫ebecause-don1tknowwi勸 ！嶼．少eep the 鯽卿toid州啊鉀10.嫵」 "migrn oe seve吵re圳uiai nave押weresoeaonriaii

;!have been noti蹤e been resoWed.0 atisyoisacoounth'sname? 12 A Curran,c ,R磧疋“A磚哺jastnameis劇ud∼既細e!3h誌闈d細畝劍既 14 0 爛 ereisW.Curran 加團？ 15 A NawYortC隊 !6 Q - eshewotina斤m? 17 A No,he'slguessasobpractitioner18 0 面 yo k蠟爍t州honenumber? 19 A ldonThave幗蛐me. 加 Q 〞細化臨address? 2! A lrs以ensBouhard!btd ―勸、kn( . 22 0 V 日！州幟劬eofvourinco稱h晚ve 20O5was”廟！州協ex佣戊喃iesssew娩svou o 閱？ " A lIlhavetoeslimale,and ―戚say maybe ten or

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

——SHEET 19 PAGE 70Depo of PERRY STARER,地耳！9/28/06

F八G￡ 了z

70! 0 姗阎降c日’a geo(yow 甘comef 忱ye&腼加en打由目to日 ed喊！1ess serv璐 von oro 浏? 3 A 陇c痴0协be sma除 because！枷t think}have4 r喇笼扣ed !adtua扮dool 阴甘 .潮ve响ir has been5 seff犯d, 6 Q ',Miat件溉ntage"yourincomeintheyear2004was7 re ted伯ex矢d州essse es? 8 A 妞响hlbeIeo 俘rcentorless. lwodhavetog guess.

}{,Qm Hey 黑deswhhyoubeverelevant to any sue m this case? 日” !2 八 ｝由ave one ail比喃ich I th嗦 might have some13 reIev ce. 14 Q 姗记飞渊e怡也日！? !5 八N 飞efiidaima). !6 (EXFI阶6MARKED FOR IDEN刀日CA11渊 17 QOr. Shrer, I'mg咖you 加改Exhibit6油劝 18 即p s to be an ade coautho阁勿you; is 橄correct? !g 八mars伪）了ed' 20 Q rlMiat咧d刘you have io that arhde? 21 A S沁we're gog on the re众d,}have to铆that22 wremost咐,and伽叨ier奴tor, of course, added to 吸， 23 0 帅朴伽 reabout栩art涂叻劝v叫比如比 汉r翻anttotheoresen全口时 25 A V I1,therea t时general duff劝here about

}curre1 one姻500腼uahtwlllhvoo here刚ay.

3 0 1 hrespedtoExhibit1,istt yoornic驳ajrrent4 jrricuIum vitae? 5 A Th贻then侧ourrethersin.ftorobgkshoui6 beuDdated.but!haven't done 同喊． 7 Q MiatthokJldbeputonit佰酬there? 8 A The畸lhmg}W阅目州叨政right now, there has9 been朋addonal pubatro 1j mysetand anotherdodor, but101wasn't！腼k soecfat,t relevant to Ibe case. so Id油、 uu的a1引！,e'v姗e coi侧”01树伙 iz u v 甘wasme训嗽auont13 A ma cationwaspc劝iced一ad响the14 ib 习坟owespubllshedm儿杯因“20 留记saddressi1g巧 hansentgbat朋讹翎价分l翩妇戏咖g日馆socean16 tight仃 Q Vtheewasthat出ticIe畔llthed? 侣 A "’洲the拟万侧ofNeuropsychoIo ,bdldon't1'have the W'hme刚 now

2201 }Y 黯LuceWttams,ddyou?No. Ihave rict. ;；沸dyoun ：喊edher『anymannei,corred?A No.I dnot24 0 丫训haven't reviewed翻temioovofM眺愉I'S如 器cooned切喇飞fom 翻闪your opiruioes叭仇贻case. base州？

F八GE ?1

,care of巾ee"e巾in m抽粗homes门抽了e比asect沁non2 怕低Arid the枷・日切妞good c0000喊 of吐‘「日阴ga3 se阁被丫日b浏heneedsofaOasectsofcareofthee阮ec)f4 rialient ii a nursiici home environment. 0 u !'m．妞习溯川阅价日祀ar赚”i打｝似i姗e'

6d百edipertUent协the sues youre帕物钩a加城价钧‘ 了case? 8 A TheremisMbe.Iwu目haveIosdown蒯read it9 加加IiM.!d呱want协mislead you that there isnt10 Q Vhcutread1ngit,困'e州潮are of anythiig that is11thedW 协the issues如钧贻case? 12 A Whootrevlewngitverycarefu昨,agaitheade13isa脉ok1er,lcan't腼kofaspeth 闪 rt oit that is14 duplcatedlithis0’，日以，的general,！由腼ka以of it15 does句物 16 Q 胜appears oks 欲your resume that a number of the！了afles加ty洲have authored deal wih钧eurrary加d,is!athat fair? }g A 下！诚isa俪statement, 加 QDo you have a 匆犯‘且丫ii urilary加dme&iie? 21 A IdooThiowIthereisadi 匆a certfrate for22 that, but at the山协！，门sd咖臼以of work wib patents咖 23 had u翩印d萝咖nd初． 24 0 1he目a}de.edoovow即，and I'rnreterriia25 now协Exhitk2勿Exhtit3~maybeweshouki阳比your阳成

11 ( PAGE ,3

73! A Lidle随me? 2 Q 丫es. 3 A I'm喊 avre that there is日例‘ 4 (EXtllBIT 8 MARKED F( IDEN1IACA11ON. 5 0 Or.Starer,Iwoui触to show you what I have6 1】拍比日舫 xhthit8bvourdeoo喊ion.and临ilNSs协加a7 ll th tI sabletoo伙ai伽aoLa on the kiemetand奴108 somerese省di咖wpriortesthrnislhistory. Andityou9 co咐ttintooaoe加ee. 10 眼.FREEMAN: Sicethevarenotnumbered-

}2Numbe日．．日怡日ateson.伪500毕eth ? (3 A 丫es. 14 Q re you woed as an ex间witness ii the Baleson}5case? }6 A 丫es' 11 QMdyouwereanexpedret幽ed on behaf of the}6P巨劝刃！? !0 A Yes. 加 0Case Number2is the Beavers口汾aga公喊MI. Camel21 Heafh? 22 A “溯nds俪血．ve23 0 愉 eyouretnedasanexpedwitnessisIhalcase? 24 A 丫es,!beveso, 25 Qthbeba树仇ePlehitiff?

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

Depo of PERRY STARE民M.D., 9/28/06SHEET 20 P八（3E 74 P八GE 7 石

7礴

, A 丫e' ; .Q CaeNu典3,IsaysthePai1iffs网帕右．B以喇s吕 v.l megratea Me !n 行 e峰 S, InC. vre恻旧翻eo日 san;expert wrtness M tt l case

?A I nethesenanes 一 0 以 l沙习即gTun谓McjaUM加即aorcna瓜幻

7 撅tson,杯反・・几 8 A I recoane the name.姗1donrecaIbeiia. gMs D"dI翻『e伽neBO1JrKIZ. Theremia城beiu anoiner name woer wnn in' was unoer,!rec闪neme们 aftne六朋爬、｝don、recoo血eBounds. 12 Q Thenexton 呜口eNuner4,Breenth,Karenv13 HarborvaoeCareCen1er.快 revouretaiedasanexoert14 喃l ess协thcase? !5 AOnce aaainJm 袱！eca枷几Mavbe 'sn改伽 16 r ent'sname沉伽倒沁爪， Md!dant recognize the,7 班！幻mw's name. 18 撒FREEMAN: You are oki咧 Ibo Defense afioney19 QThe Pin1rs attorney Ves名M1ugh in Tanya20 A }recognize V4fires& McFh劝：以the name Breensky21 doesntre！面dm 'anvth叻anohtnow. 22 Q CaseNumber5,Canonio'Francesco? 23 A Canonko｝网received a ohone"about. so I'm24 eninderlef姻case. 25 Q 彻were re1a血ed 饰IheP 耐?

!case. 2 A Yes,lbeeve}was. 3 0 By the P1a袱Ts? 4 A 丫e' 5 Q Thenexto能治D 甘谈1Mktiath.Margaretfe6 Nu哪Home. Doyourecal姻case? 了 A T1i'oneId翻reca吐！recognize the attorney'sa name, but！彻、reca月， 9 Q Thea撅 y'snmt回恻陀 cogiiae'lhe10 Pkitif?s attorney? }} A 丫es,Doon. 12 0 CaseNuner11谧伪血D改env.Pan&aiPateIM.D.? 13 A rm『枷勿怕t触aftomesname.饰喊 14 reco 伽case at th' thne. !50 确attorney's name拟卿rec*e卜the!6P肠树s咖mev.由ht? }7 AOrn, yes. }8 0 Thenextooe治伽E物协ofDthesDuncanv.M拍而 }gBeach F俪肋Care Group, LiiIed? 加 AYes. 21 0 Mt触隋．，留sallomey贻．edasJamesR. 22 厂传・伯nc 训kes& Mdlugh? 23 AA咖脚，}don、 remen加帅了帕阅被卜油．Freeman. 2村ut that's tiat砚卿s. 25 Q 匆a如， u were retained 勿the Pbiit1f corred?

花

P八GE '5

75

八“”通’5

a”。蕊

’。月！2

，甘4

'J

八。．口J由．

l乍11 111!

Ca,

A Caceaoaii.}recoanize the attorneVs name.姗！ 翻山ecoon厄e钧ename ttIie P匕ntifE. 0 Case Number 7' Adeb Chavez v. Pebble Creek Nursiig

c即1ef? A I ren'ieniber th name, yes. 0 蒯ouwereretalied 勿the Ptainth? A 丫es. Q E勺bthhenin'z,Ernest? A "sounds fan自卜yes. Q VersuslandemFlealthCare? A 丫es.

A 丫“． 0 CaseNun加6怡卿啄r, Kara v. Serritara Lie Carer袱．！如1?

AQAA〕八。

15 0 蒯Pbittffs attorney was Brn Thompson ofisv徽es& McHugh? 11 A I'mnotrecal吻him rm now,网 that'swhatit将 曰vs.

伯 0 M 卿Weem1aed勿晚Pbi*coned? 加 A 丁hasn 『ecoledn21 QCase Number9was Hoilenc Coadv．铆i ChrisIefl Me&alCe咖r? 23 A ｝彻｝翩～行翻the name,侧！don't24 爬口 g gadeposon. Butyou・田as幻nqrne" 25 0 叮 ou wereretaliedas即expe妊闷ness如价川

!

P入G艺 ’「

! A r爪not reme袖eriig馆case．以政says P目献 2 0 Then xtone贻Sh1ev的v. HamarvaoeCare3 Center? 4 A Th污one}recallwascontactedahout价‘ 5rec* so I由rec the 帕比论， B 0 Md叭thatca毕v佣忱erelairedbvthe7 嗽es&Md1ugh加份m? 已 八 Yes. 9 Q 伪比哪‘theF liff?

lO AVes. ii Q Thenendo能‘PatFresv.Pebb抽CreekNung12 Center? 13 A I'mnotrememberiig Flares. Isttnere an attorney's14n日万说？

15 0 ｝彻物，翔lthere'．下｝盯edoesn't pearto比 "6 A }can't comnt佣相．！如'treme 加政 ！了 0 lInen翻阅 e贻Fore域hired勿mes Morgan? }6 A ｝面n、recai俪one. 怕 QThen 对以德污 theEateofMon「吻e丫． 20 〕.朋幻饭玛RayBolen? 21 A 加name F吻esoundsfaniac. Idoo'trecat左 日康，!. !recal缺name向doe. 23 0 优酬 esyouwerehied 奴川kes&McHuntn俪 2耳out of Utle Rock? 25 A ilsounds向hi

刀

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS侈50) 222-5508

Depo of PERRY STARE几地D。, 912$106SHEET 21 PAGE 78 ~ } PAGE 80

78} 0 Mdth 忱伯份pese向theP 洲济,corred? 2 A 丫es, S Q 加next one, Case Nunt" 11,污 Ceci FuqLIa Ioi俪 任ste' Wvonne引板往on喇 S Health Care CorD.? 5 A 丫es, the name sounds fan翻． 6 0 M ・thatcaseyouwerel*ed饰tbePbI s? 了 A 丫以 8 0 CaseNuner1h柳honso Harden v. CF&H Corporat幻n, 9 Da如Nurng日orne? 10 A #muathavebeena ideago. Idon、recaIth11 one.!reongne tho attomey1s name, thou 、. 12 QThe attomeVs name is the Pkiflifs attorney? IS A 丫e轰 14 Q CaeNu 比r19,thoEs eofMar#Haryv,Horizon准5cMS Flea防Care? 飞6 八Yes, }7 0Maln.甘佣were h网脚 the P intifts firm m}8con阁ion 俪廿1树口幼？ 19 A 丫es,}reca帅is one. 20 Q CaseNumber2o比瀚lor v. Er Nabors, M.D.? 21 A !r'gn吹t挽旧孺‘fteflm. rmnctreca枷 22 加旧眼‘伽a枷衅“ the peoplenvoFed,}“欣》， 23 0 书减W sthePbilifsattorney's腼thatyou24 recoone? 25 A 丫既

八夕‘八。通门户』〕内。・‘J6

。，。刁．内沙‘

g

创

! A Ib仁脚sad扮ebecause !passthet wenlgo2 itomvoffe.刚！haven't kxed at砚 rentiv. 3 0 Nexone.Case26jEd 飞Kerckv.ChristosShn? 礴 A 找凤s！留i台． 5 0 And.agaii,youwerehfred饰thePi1IIfs6 attorneys? 7 A Thescoffe8 Q （二习哭Number 27 Mare Kieber v. Mary Ann(3iietea, 9 从0.? 10 A 、的帷K触姗欲nIarhne.ve , !1 0 匆aii,yo 姗eh奋ed勿theP 而fsattomey? 12 A 丫既 13 Q 11枪nextoneis吻Lacav.PebeCreekNucsing14 Center? }5 A 丫巴．砚soundsfan血． }6 QYou were卜分．dbvtiPb以价allomev? }7 八 hafsmy recoec加. 18 0 釉nextone isjamesD.Lanev.Thonas1ynn. a19 mdcalmalp阁ecase? 20 A “响hi be触 same one as Ba 宙 a Lavon, rnthich21 case itdoessound俪自「、 22 0 伽伽deposbo that I managed to ohiai m tt t23 caseith（即侣侧朋“nyThomesBucIiananfromVkes&Md1吵 24 讯．tte Rock Misas.wes0 reseut. 25 A 下回sounds娜沈

P月G包 ’9

79! 0 CaseNumber2lis骊甸Ja :on v. Southhaven2 Nl万自”Center? 3 A ！彻'trecognke伽patnfs name, but}do4 recogn此伽P日住货sattorney5 Q 刀祀能义l加比Norma Jenkins丫，Davis Nur 嘟 6 A }d叻ren.erNomiaJenks.伽nanieof俪 7attornevseemsfan自r, P iritrs attorney. . 0 T l哈xlne目ed Cassandra 知zyt dv. ，尸re劝，leflanRe拍nent(二omniunthes? 10 A Ttiisone famt.r. 11 0 Itnotes昭von were hed 切 Mevh Farrotta of12the VIbes衣流Hugh 腼叭下日川甩 13 A } remember hi14 0 ThenextcaseisCaseNumber24,l均ssess ne气Jr}5 俪Generav.Padcw Care Center? }6 A rmnof别陀Mat this one is. 17 0 CaseNumberl5iske扮．K毛L-L-A-R, v. Barlow18 Center. Hn 祀s帕uwerehi'ed 厉the训础＆McHtiah翩in!，丁na? 20 A Rnt.1isoue‘侧rre 如ce.}remember this21 one. 22 QAndth污 a case molving nu咖 borne neg匆ence? 23 Amars叻川s习抵ve24 0 Wel,丫佣sad s Dirrefitty adive ar句‘川remember25 the case,闪解

、

PAG已 日1

｛儡 Md1酬瓢ayson黯uretomoor at at for fallsiaonose head iiiuiv“以姗 3aaoroni伯！erad加ra由洲团论s油抽？ 闷 八Tliats叻at砚拍ya here. 5 0 CaseNumber旅Janet Madden v. Heraae Gerki6 Houiiu0eveboment Dovoumember姻case? 7 A 加姗firm rm ware of, but I翻i'trecnenter8 Madden. 9 0 Case3lisBerniceM晌而v. AIf Rostvn Flatboro. 10 Inc., nursig homenegence

.污

Doyouseettiaf?11 A cognethePbittI1sattomey. ldon't12 reme theP itI.

13 0 1抽 xtoneisVMmMastenv,以ManofNu吻 }4Center.胜notes价成you were retailed 勿 V es& McHugh 认 15 下a a.伪 you inca肠at? 16 A }don't recafi伽case,袱吮即s翻决 '7 0 Case" says M翻onag卜甘．油riner Heath Care.胜 18 劝佣‘ 4res&Md h,Pboen改，禽让onalastbePbilttfzhrm, 19Do you reca晰at? 20 A Itsoundsianiar. 21 QCase!{．加洲污EvetanMlcheIv.C脚enantHealth22 Svstent 山丫 ourecaithat? 习 八 ！肥旧阳s拍11物「l的阳ecaune洲鹉“ 24 thecase. 25 0 Md,agaii,ouwee旧幽“勿ttrePb涌s?

6, }

ASSOCIATED COURT REPORTERS(850) 222-5508

SHEET 22 PAGE 82

82! A 丫既 2 Q Case翻Thomas Parentv. Crescent Manor, LLC? 3 八 ｝dont recal this iidMd喊nor do I recal the'Pb血解sa加r能认 5 QCase 36贻拍改S喊细dv.NorthPat抬or. De you6 recafi恤 case? 7 A Ire 伽naN !don't recall the details of thea ca,. 9 Q Youwerehed 勿the Plaiitfs・ that case? 10 A 丫es. " 0 Case37他l》日！别Truthv.DierksNursnciHome." i2 n*sm 似iv rerireo训I nomas匕 ucnanan ot vuces' MCII的0, }3 山vou『e伪皿！加｝? ，礴 A }don、 reca月the“川r论下川肚！do知哪the name}5Thomas日achanan. 16 Q 蒯You眼famO rwJ1i Mr. Buchanan that works at飞7 明ke"Mc日阴卜？ 16 A 丫e认 19 Q Case 38, Ellenore Vargas v. Mark Bielefe ? 20 A !reoonetheP int滁name 袱伽Defendant, 21 翻｝recoone the Ptaiihffs attorneYs name. 22 0 蒯vouwerehed 切the陌翻sn that伪幼？ 23 A 丫e乐 24 Q Case39比SamueWxnianv.HCRManorCare,andit25 nes姻卿w 传i间酬牲es&MthvghoutofTana?

0.

Depo of PERRY STARE民M.D., 9/28106P入GE 日弓

! ANo. 2 Q 叫州脱d呐 ha 伪恰认connedion晰ap阵的93 t Jay for your deposilon? 4 A ｝耐wlh Mr. Freeman. 5 0 Wendidvoumeat戚Mr. Freeman? 6 八 丫喊喇av即eniio. 7 0 ！加肋0配you me