Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other...

26
Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University College of Education [email protected]

Transcript of Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other...

Page 1: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to

Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories?

Robert DayThe Ohio State University

College of Education [email protected]

Page 2: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

"I passed all the other courses that I took at my university, but I could never pass botany. This was because all botany students had to spend several hours a week in a laboratory looking through a microscope at plant cells, and I could never see through the microscope. I never once saw a cell through a microscope.”

"My Life and Hard Times" James Thurber, former student of the OSU Plant Science Department.

Page 3: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Some visual processing problems Visual agnosia (Oliver Sacks) Pareidolia Perceptual scotoma Ambiguous images and perceptual flip

Page 4: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Pareidolia links Definition and earliest citation Some examples More examples Fossil on the moon?

Page 5: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Ilove

Paris in the the spring time

Page 6: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Ilove

Paris in the the spring time

Page 7: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.
Page 8: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.
Page 9: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Dissertation Objectives Document the visual difficulties that can be a barrier to

learning in undergraduate biology students.

Find out what students see, what they think they see, how they go about making sense of their observations and why they sometimes can’t see anything at all.

Try to connect the phenomenon to established learning theory.

Suggest teaching and learning strategies that will help to efficiently transform novice biological observers into experts.

Page 10: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Possible Influencing Factors Eyesight (resolution / acuity) Language and semantics Direct and indirect content knowledge Innate visual cognitive abilities Multiple intelligences (Gardener) Learning style Teaching approach (constructivist, behaviorist

etc)

Page 11: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Possible Influencing Factors (2) Socio-cultural factors Gender, biological / social Motivation Lifestyle and previous visual environment Neurological issues Metacognition Other factors

Page 12: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

What is conceptual change?

For review of Posner’s (1982) model go here.

What is a concept?

Page 13: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

For psychologists / philosophers, a concept is how the human mind constructs a category.

Page 14: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Yeah but…..

What is a category?

Page 15: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Classical category: E.g. even numbers > divisible by 2 Defined by rule(s) that are entirely

necessary and sufficient for membership

Family resemblance category E.g. “chair” Not easily defined by rules

Page 16: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Problem with F.R category: No necessary and sufficient conditions Infinite way they could be organized Especially problematic for biologists

because of nested, indistinct hierarchy. Fallacy of dichotomous keys.

Page 17: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Do “conceptual change” educators use the word “concept” in the same

way as philosophers and psychologists?

Probably not. Suspect educators are talking about webs

of concepts connected by relationships and processes > schemas or conceptual ecology

Page 18: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

According to Posner et. al. conceptual schemas change by accommodation or

assimilation Assimilation: This occurs when you fit some new

information into an existing structure or conceptual understanding.

Accommodation: This occurs new information cannot easily be fit into an existing structure or conceptual understanding. Instead, the new information requires a transformation and reorganization of the conceptual ecology.

Page 19: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Is perceptual flip the same as Posner’s conceptual change?

Probably not exactly……but……

Perceptual change is similar and it often leads to conceptual change.

Page 20: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Example 1 “seal donkey” in ocean moving, swimming? splashing making a noise (bark?) therefore alive? seals bark & swim seals live in ocean

Page 21: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Seal donkey anomalies: Not swimming gracefully Appears to rising out of water > illogical Noise not like a seal Rear fins out of water – illogical Eyes seem to be releasing steam “Fins” don’t look right

Page 22: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Post perceptual flip seal >donkey fins > ears > must be concave not flat swimming > drowning barking > braying natural event > unusual happy animal > animal in distress no further action necessary > action may

be required to save drowning donkey

Page 23: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Example 2 “sponge squirt”

Page 24: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Interesting things to note…. Many optical illusions involve images of living

things.

Cognitive scientists often describe perceptual categorization problems involving living things.

A special part of the brain is implicated in the process of recognizing living things.

Page 25: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

And yet….. Biological science educators appear not to

have studied the pedagogic implications of the unique cognitive challenges found only in their discipline?

Page 26: Visual Cognition in Undergraduate Biology Labs; Can it be Connected to Conceptual Change and Other Learning Theories? Robert Day The Ohio State University.

Rationale for this Research Alert biology instructors to the problem Increase student performance and practical skills Alert biological researchers and medical imagers

to issues related to reliability of graphical data Expedite postgraduate novice-expert

transformation Integration of neurology and psychology with

educational science Expand conceptual change theory Implications for societal scientific literacy and

environmental awareness