8/3/2019 Veterinary Ethics_Case Studies_Animal Welfare_Frank Busch

1/3

3> Xg~gs`dksp ^`mgu

S@EL FS QFFS" FW^ FH PFWS NFFS6HSKDJ CWUELQlN" MSEXU

jolwfc

n`uewuugu ylp kd`mkb ygbb-cg`di ulfwbn df~

cg ng~gsm`dgn cp lfy hk~ kd fydgsu ykbbg~ `u"

kdn lfy ~lg bf~ fh bfcu~gsu ekd cg `mqsfxgn

^L@U ks~`ebg `u k efd~`dwk~`fd

fh ekug u~wnp qsgugd~k~`fdu

sgiksn`di xg~gs`dksp g~l`eu

`uuwgu ~lk~ mkp cg gdefwd-

~gsgn cp qs`xk~g qske~`~`fdgsu$

@~ `u lfqgn ~lk~ ~l`u ugs`guf ekug u~wn`gu y`bb gdefws-

kig qks~`e`qk~`fd kdn n`uewu-

u`fd kmfdi efbbgkiwgu" kdn

~lk~ sgkngsu y`bb ulksg ufmg f

~lg`s g~l`ekb n`bgmmku uf ~lk~

~lgug mkp cg qsgugd~gn kdn

n`uewuugn d w~wsg ks~`ebgu$ @ pfw

yfwbn b`jg ~f ulksg fs n`uewuu

ekugu" qbgkug ugdn pfws {wgu-

~`fdu" efmmgd~u fs es`~`{wgu ~f

cAxg~g~l`eu$efm

Ekug u~wnp fdgKd gbngsbp eb`gd~ qsgugd~u lgs

;3-pgks-fbn ueldkwzgs" yl`el

`u g|l`c`~`di ckn csgk~l$ Eb`d`-

ekb g|km`dk~`fd sgxgkbu ugxgsg

qgs`fnfd~kb n`ugkug ku ~lg ekwug

f ~lg lkb`~fu`u$ Pfw sgefmmgdn

g|~gdu`xg ebgkd`di kdn g|~ske-

~`fd f ugxgskb ugxgsgbp n`ugkugn

~gg~l$ Nwg ~f ~lg qk~`gd~u kig"

~lg knxkdegn fskb qk~lfbfip kdn

~lg dggn fs eksgwb mfd`~fs`di

wdngs igdgskb kdkgu~lgu`k" ~lg

gu~`mk~gn efu~ f ~lg qsfegnwsg

`u cg~yggd 571 kdn >71$ lgeb`gd~ `u fd k |gn `defmg kdn

nfgu df~ jdfy lfy ulg y`bb

qkp fs ~l`u$ Pfw ugdn ~lg nfi

lfmg fd fskb kd~`c`f~`eu kdn kuj

~lg eb`gd~ ~f efd~ke~ pfw sgiksn-

`di lgs nge`u`fd ku ~f ylg~lgs

~f if klgkn y`~l uwsigsp$ Pfw

uwuqge~ ulg y`b b ngeb`dg fs

dkde`kb sgkufdu$

^lg dg|~ nkp" k qsfm`dgd~

cwu`dguumkd efmgu `d y`~l k

dgks ngd~`ekb ekug f qgs`fnfd~kb

n`ugkug `d l`u kign qffnbg$ Pfw

kik`d g|qbk`d ~lg dggn fs ebgkd-

`di kdn g|~ske~`fd" cw~ ~lg fydgs

ngeb`dgu fd ~lg uqf~" ukp`di ~lg

qs`eg `u ~ff l`il$ Ku pfw sghge~

fd lfy pfw ulfwbn cg ngkb-

`di y`~l ~l`u qks~`ewbks fydgs"

pfw sgmgmcgs ~lg qgdu`fdgs

sfm ~lg nkp cgfsg$ Ulfwbn

~lg dkde`kb u~k~wu f ~lg fydgs

ng~gsm`dg pfws kqqsfkel ~f ~lg

ygbksg f k qk~`gd~ ,H`iwsg ;)6

N`uewuu`fdNguq`~g k y`nguqsgkn qwcb`e qgs-

egq~`fd ~lk~ xg~gs`dks`kdu lkxg knw~p ~f ~sgk~ kbb kd`mkbu" sgiksn-

bguu f k eb`gd~u dkde`kb u`~wk~`fd"

mfu~ umkbb kd`mkb qske~`egu ksg

swd kdn wde~`fd ku cwu`dguugu

k efdegq~ ~lk~ mgmcgsu f

~lg qwcb`e f~gd dn n`ewb~ ~f

keegq~$ ^lg qsgxk`b`di sfmkd~`e

x`gy f ~lg xg~gs`dks`kd ku ~lg

efmqkuu`fdk~g iwksn`kd kdigb f

kbb ,u`ej) kd`mkbu" ylf `u kcbg ~f

qsfx`ng sgg ~sgk~mgd~" u `defm-

qk~`cbg y`~l kdp cwu`dguu efdegq~

`d xg~gs`dksp qske~`eg;$

Kb~lfwil xg~gs`dksp qske~`eg

`u dfy wdngsu~ffn ~f cg k cwu`-

dguu" `~ ebgksbp `u k cwu`dguu y`~l

k n`gsgdeg? mwel f ~lg nk`bp

~kuju sgxfbxg ksfwdn lfy ~lgqske~`~`fdgs ekd m`d`m`ug ~lg

`mqke~ f ~lg dkde`kb u~k~wu f

~lg eb`gd~ fd ~lg ygbb-cg`di f

~lg qk~`gd~$ Sfbb`d qf`d~u fw~

ufmg f ~lg u~sk~gi`gu ~lk~ qske-

~`egu kdn qske~`~`fdgsu ekd efmg

wq y`~l ~f fxgsefmg nk`bp qsg-

n`ekmgd~u d qske~`eg3$

Efbbgkiwgu kqqsfkel ~l`u

qsfcbgm `d xks`fwu ykpu$ @d

ufmg ekugu" uwel ku k ske~wsg d

k ek~" ~lgp qsfx`ng bguu g|qgdu`xg

~sgk~mgd~ mfnkb`~`gu ~lk~ ksg

ygbb kcfxg ~lg ~lsgulfbn fs

kng{wk~g eksg cfdg q`dd`di

kdn qbk~`di mkp cg ~lg ifbn

u~kdnksn" cw~ mkp df~ kbykpu cg

sg{w`sgn fs kng{wk~g sguwb~u$

Mkdp xg~gs`dks`kdu wdngs~kjg

k egs~k`d kmfwd~ f yfsj k~ efu~"

fs fs df elksig$ F~lgsu ngxgbfq

bfdi-~gsm qkpmgd~ qbkdu fs

eb`gd~u y`~l dkde`kb n`ewb~`gu$

Gxgd ~fnkp" f~lgsu keegq~ cks~gs

f iffnu fs ugsx`egu `d b`gw f

mfdg~ksp qkpmgd~$ Ufmg yfsj

y`~l ygbksg elks`~`gu fs gu~kcb`ul

wdnu ylgsg kbwgd~" isk~gwb

eb`gd~u wdngsys`~g ~sgk~mgd~ fs

kd`mkbu cgbfdi`di ~f ~lg `mqfx-

gs`ulgn5$ Kdf~lgs ykp" sgbk~`di

qs`mks`bp ~f bksigs xg~gs`dksp

gd~gsqs`ugu" u ~f gu~kcb`ul k eb`d`e

u~kgn fd k sf~k~`di xfbwd~ksp

cku`u fs g|kmqbg" fdg gxgd`di

k mfd~l cp n`gsgd~ eb`d`e`kdu$

^lg dg~ sguwb~ u k sgg eb`d`e fqgd

fd k sgiwbks cku`u$

Mfu ~ qske ~ ` ~ `fdgsu gg b

fcb`ign ~f lgbq ku mwel ku qfu-

u`cbg ~fyksnu ~lg dkde`kb kuqge~

sgiksn`di ~lg ~sgk~mgd~ f kd`-

mkbu$ @u ~l`u cgekwug f fws ugb-

`mqfugn cw~ kbuf qsfguu`fdkb

nw~p ~f eksg fs cgekwug yg

lkxg cgefmg lwmkd`u~u cfsd

fw~ f fws kuu`idgn ufe`g~kb fcb`-

ik~`fd ~f lgbq kd`mkbu6

Hfs ufmg eb`d`e`kdu" ~lg

jdfybgnig ~lk~ cg`di wdkcbg ~f

qsfx`ng kng{wk~g mgn`ekb eksg

fs kd kd`mkb ekd cg k mkofs

yfwdn ~f kd `mqfxgs`ulgn qgs-ufd> mkp yfsj ku k ek~kbpu~$

Sfbb`d sgmksju ~lk~ ~lg jgp

efdegq~wkb qf`d~ `u ~lk~ owu~ ku

~lg `dkc`b`~p ~f qkp fs ~sgk~mgd~

ulfwbn df~ esgk~g kd `mqgn`mgd~

~f lwmkd lgkb~l eksg" dg`~lgs

ulfwbn `~ qsgebwng ~sgk~mgd~

fs kd`mkbu$7 Ku xg~gs`dks`kdu

efd~`dwg ~f ngkb y`~l ~lgug elkb-

bgdigu `d qske~`eg" ufmg y`bb

wdnfwc~gnbp keg qsfguu`fdkb

kdn mfskb u~sguu" yl`el @ lkxg

qsgx`fwubp kbbwngn ~f8$

Lfy ulfwbn ~lg ygkb~lp eb`-

gd~" ylf y`bb df~ uqgdn ~lg

sg{w`u`~g mfdgp fd ~sgk~mgd~"

cg kqqsfkelgn96 Lgsg" Sfbb`d

sgmksju ~lk~ ~lg kc`b`~p ~f ngqbfpfdgu Kguewbkq`kd kw~lfs`~p< y`~l

uweeguu u qkskmfwd~$

Sgiksn`di fws elfugd ekug

uegdks`f" g|qbk`d`di ~lk~ ~lg

ngd~kb efdn`~`fd y`bb ekwug qk`d

kdn uwgs`di ~f ~lg kd`mkb mkp

ekwug ~lg eb`gd~ ~f sg~l`dj l`u

qfu`~`fd0$ Mfsg `mqfs~kd~bp"

`d ku mwel ku pfw" ~lg qske~`-

~`fdgs" lkxg k nw~p ~f `dfsm ~lg

fydgs;1" ~lg fydgs lku k nw~p ~f

eksg fs l`u kd`mkb;;$

G{w`qqgn y`~l ~lg dgy Kd`-

mkb Ygbksg Ke~;3" `~ `u gku`gs ~f

efdsfd~ ~lg khwgd~ eb`gd~ kdn

`du`u~ fd kqqsfqs`k~g ~sgk~mgd~"

gxgd ` ~lg eb`gd~ nfgu df~ ugg

kdp xkbwg d uwel ~sgk~mgd~$

Ekug u~wnp ~yf@d ufmg efwd~s`gu" efduwmgsu

qsggs ~f x`gy kd kd`mkb kb`xg

`mmgn`k~gbp cgfsg `~ `u j`bbgn ~f

gduwsg ~lk~ ~lgp sgeg`xg k sgul

kdn ylfbgufmg qsfnwe~ sfm

~lg mksjg~$ Ifxgsdmgd~-mkd-

nk~gn kd~gmfs~gm kdn qfu~-

mfs~gm `duqge~`fd qsfegnwsgu"

~fig~lgs y`~l mfngsd sgs`i-

gsk~`fd ~geld`{wgu" lkxg mkng

~lgug efduwmgs kd~gmfs~gm

`duqge~`fdu wddgeguuksp$

Lfygxgs" `d mkdp mfngsd

mksjg~u" `~ `u kul`fdkcbg ~f n`u-

qbkp b`xg ul kdn eswu~kegkdu `d

umkbb lfbn`di ~kdju fs efduwm-

gsu ~f x`gy qs`fs ~f qwselkug$

Nf uwel n`uqbkpu sgqsgugd~ uwc-

u~kdnksn kd`mkb ygbksg6 Ylk~efd~`dwgn fd qkig 38

Mfu~ qske~`~`fdgsu ggb fcb`ign ~f lgbq

ku mwel ku qfuu`cbg ~fyksnu ~lg hdkde`kb

kuqge~ sgiksn`di ~lg ~sgk~mgd~ f kd`mkbu$

@u ~l`u cgekwug f fws ugb-`mqfugn cw~ kbufqsfguu`fdkb nw~p ~f eksg fs cgekwug yg lkxg

cgefmg lwmkd`u~u cfsd fw~ f fws kuu`idgn

ufe`g~kb fcb`ik~`fd ~f lgbq kd`mkbu6

QF@D^-FH-X@GY

Hws~lgs `dhfsmk~`fd `u kxk`bkcbg hsfm?

HFS^ NFNIG KD@MKB LGKB L" Hbkdngsu Sfkn" Ufw~lkmq~fd" UF51 >[L ^gbgqlfdg 1;> ( ; kdn lku dfy bkwdelgn `d ~lg WJ_wbxke < Cfx`u" kd ghhge~`xg ek~~bg xkee`dg kik`du~C^X ugsf~pqg

8/3/2019 Veterinary Ethics_Case Studies_Animal Welfare_Frank Busch

2/3

38 Xg~gs`dksp ^`mgu

`u ~lg u~k~wu {wf f efduwmgs

jdfybgnig kcfw~ ~lg efmmgse`kb

~skng kdn ~lg lkdnb`di f ~lgug

kd`mkbu fs ffn6

N`uewuu`fd

Efmmgse`kb ksm`di mfu~bp efd-

egsdu k gy isfwqu f ngekqfneswu~kegkdu" dkmgbp uls`mqu"

sgulyk~gs qskydu kdn eskpul

,H`iwsg 3)" bfc-

u~gsu kdn eskcu$

^lgsg ksg kbuf

ufmg dfd-ngek-

qfn isfwqu" uwel

ku Ks~gm`k" kdn

xks`fwu efqgq-

fnu ksg sk`ugn ku

ffn fs `ul bks-

xkg$ Mks`dg kdn

cskej`ul yk~gs

uls`mqu mkjg wq

~lg mkofs qfs~`fd

f ~lg yfsbnu

eswu~kegkd ksm`di" ufw~l-gku~

Ku`k cg`di ~lg bgkn`di mksjg~$Fxgskbb" eswu~kegkdu dfy

mkjg wq ebfug ~f fdg-fws~l f

~lg yfsbnu k{wkewb~wsg esfq;5"

kdn ~l`u mfu~bp cgdg~u ~lg ngxgb-

fq`di yfsbnu gefdfm`gu;>$

Uknbp" ku Y`ej`du kdn Bgg

qf`d~ fw~;>" ~lg knxkdegu `d

eswu~kegkd ksm`di `d ~lg qku~

lkxg ~kjgd qbkeg mfu~bp ~lsfwil

~s`kb-kdn-gssfs ~pqgu f mkdkig-

mgd~ ufmg~`mgu y`~l iskxg

efdug{wgdegu$ Keefsn`di ~f ~lg

kw~lfsu" fdg sgkufd fs ~l`u `u

~lk~ fws wdngsu~kdn`di gxgd f

ksmgn kdn dfd-ksmgn eswu~k-

egkdu cku`e c`fbfip u u~`bb ng-

e`gd~" guqge`kbbp ylgd efmqksgn

y`~l ~lg ul uqge`gu ~lk~ lkxg

cggd ksmgn fs egd~ws`gu;7$

Mfu~ eswu~kegkd ksm`di u~`bb

efdu`u~u f fqgd" ku fqqfugn ~febfugn upu~gmu ,yl`el ksg dfy

`desgku`dibp ngxgbfqgn)" ylgsg

g | e l k d i g f

x`swugu kdn f~lgs

kigd~u f n`ugkug

y`~l`d ~lg gdx`-

sfdmgd~ `u mfsg

b ` j g b p $ Y ` ~ l ` d

~lg nfmgu~`ek-

~`fd qsfeguu" ~lg

ngu`sgn ngxgbfq-

mgd~ ~fyksnu"

kdn ugbge~`fd fs"

gxfbw~`fdks`bp uwu-

~k`dkcbg ksm`di

u~sk~gi`gu;8 efd-

~`dwgu ~f cg n`ewb~$ ^lg ukmg

`u ~swg sgiksn`di ~skn`~`fdkb kis`-ewb~wsg" yl`el @ lkxg kbbwngn ~f

cgfsg d ~l`u ugs`gu$

^lkdjwbbp" g~l`ef-gdx`sfd-

mgd~kb `uuwgu sgbk~gn ~f k{wk-

ewb~wsg ksg ik`d`di mfsg k~~gd-

~`fd$ ^l`u `u df~ fdbp cgekwug

f efku~kb ksm`diu dgik~`xg

gdx`sfdmgd~kb `mqke~ kdn ~lg

ke~ ~lk~ mfsg sgugksel kdn

cg~~gs fxgskbb sgiwbk~fsp qfb`e`gu

ksg mqbgmgd~gn;9" cw~ `~ `u kbuf

nwg ~f qwcb`e gdb`il~gdmgd~ kdn

qsguuwsg$ Lfy k elkdig d ufe`kb

g~l`eu" qwcb`e qgsegq~`fd kdn

efduwmgs ngmkdn ekd `mqke~

fd cwu`dguu u~sk~gip u m`ssfsgn"

fs g|kmqbg" cp k elkdig d u~sk~-

gip sgiksn`di ~lg Ylfbg Hffnu

uwqgsmksjg~ elk`d `d Kmgs`ek"

yl`el ckddgn ~lg ukbg f b`xg

ulgbbul d 3118;$

Pg~" ku k{wkewb~wskb`u~u jdfy"

ul ksg k~ bgku~ ku uwuegq~`cbg ~f

u~sguu ku kdp f~lgs ffn kd`mkb37$

Qske~`egu uwel ku ~lg ugy`di wq f

eksq mfw~lu nws`di b`xg ~skduqfs~

,~f kxf`n ekdd`ckb`um) kdn bgkx`di

kd`mkbu fs ~ff bfdi fd k`sqfs~

swdykpu ,ekwu`di ~lgm ~f n`g

nwg ~f fxgslgk~`di) ksg `uuwgu

yksskd~`di wsigd~ sgmgnp$

Cgks`di `d m`dn ~lg sgbgxkd~

gx`ngdeg" efdn`~`fdu fs uwel

kd`mkbu d b`xg mksjg~u ksg wdke-

egq~kcbg kdn uwcu~kdnksn" ku

mwel fs k{wk~`e kd`mkbu ku fs

c`snu kdn mkmmkbu$ Ebgksbp" ~l`u

efdebwu`fd m`b`~k~gu `d kxfws

f ug~~`di ue`gd~``ekbbp ckugn

u~kdnksnu fs ~lg eksg kdn mk`d-

~gdkdeg f ~lgug kd`mkbu$

Sfbb`du u~kdeg u ~lk~ f k ygb-

ks`u~ fs dgy ygbks`u~ 38$ Yg fyg

k ngegd~ b`g kdn k lwmkdg ngk~l

~f kbb kd`mkb b`g ,`debwn`di ul)

~lk~ yg elffug ~f efduwmg$

Sfbb`d uggmu efd~gd~ ~lk~

~lg `dnwu~sp ekd ugb sgiwbk~g

`~ugb kqqsfqs`k~gbp39$ Cw~ ku

y`~l ~lg qsfnwe~`fd f kbb kd`mkb

qsfnwe~u" ~lg knkig fw~ f

u`il~" fw~ f m`dn wdfs~wdk~gbp

u~`bb lfbnu ~swg$

u~sguu$ Mfskb u~sguu qks~`ewbksbp

ks`ugu fw~ f k wdnkmgd~kb efdh`e~

cg~yggd fdgu sgkufdu fs if`di

`d~f kd`mkb yfsj kdn ylk~ fdg `u `d

ke~ nf`di fs cg`di kujgn ~f nf$ Ugg

ff~df~g ~yf$

9$ Feeku`fdkbbp" fdg gdefwd~gsu k

,ygkb~lp) eb`gd~ ylf x`gyu ~lg kd`mkb

ku k qfuuguu`fd fs u~k~wu upmcfb kdn

df~ k km`bp mgmcgs fs efmqkd`fd$

@d ~l`u ekug" gefdfm`eu qbkp k x`~kb

sfbg kdn ~lg eb`gd~ yfwbn ksiwg ~lk~

ke{w`s`di k dgy kd`mkb yfwbn cg ~lg

qsggssgn mg~lfn f ngkb`di y`~l ~lg

u`~wk~`fd$

9:

kdn Jb`dicfsi N O kdn Jb`dicfsi O

,3119)$ Gge~`xg efmmwd`ek~`fd `d

xg~gs`dksp qske~`eg kdn ~kbj`di y`~l

xg~gs`dksp eb`gd~u kcfw~ mfdgp" ^lg

Xg~gs`dksp Eb`d`eu fh Dfs~l Kmgs`ek

,Umkbb Kd`mkb Qske~`eg)59,;)? 90-05$

;1$ Xg~gs`dks`kdu lkxg k nw~p ~f

`dfsm kcfw~ ~lg qks~`ewbks dggnu f

~lg kd`mkb kdn `~u uqge`e cglkx`fwsu"

ku ygbb ku lfy kd`mkbu ulfwbn cg

jgq~ keefsn`di ~f ~lg`s dk~wsg" dggnu

kdn cglkx`fws$ Ugg l~~q?&&g~l`eu$``~$

gnw&efngu&efg&xg~$kuufe$qsf~ge~$

kd`mkbu$l~mb

;;$ ^lg bgikb qlskug nw~p f eksg

mgkdu owu~ ~lk~? pfws eb`gd~ lku ~lg

fcb`ik~`fd ~f nf ku pfw uwiigu~ `d

pfws qsfguu`fdkb ekqke`~p$ Ku mwel

ku ~lg eb`gd~ `u kcbg ~f elffug sfm

~sgk~mgd~ fq~`fdu" lg fs ulg ekddf~

nfnig ~sgk~mgd~ ~lk~ pfw qsgues`cg$

Pfws `dn`sge~ nw~p lgsg efwbn cg"

ksiwkcbp" ~lk~ pfw ksg sgkufdkcbg kdn

qske~`ekb kcfw~ uwel uwiigu~`fdu kdn

~sgk~mgd~ fq~`fdu$ Ugg yyy$ngsk$

ifx$wj&kd`mkbl&ygbksg&ke~&`dng|$l~m kdn yyy$ngsk$ifx$wj&kd`mkbl&

ygbksg&ke~&kge~$l~m%3

;3$ Qs`fs ~f ~lg Kd`mkb Ygbksg Ke~

3118" jggqgsu fdbp lkn k nw~p ~f

Hff~df~gu

;$ ^lg @ ~lfwil~ pfw ygsg nf`di

`~ fs ~lg kd`mkbu" df~ fs ~lg

mfdgp keewuk~`fdkb mkd~sk qw~u

gxgsp qske~`~`fdgs fd ~lg nggdu`xg$

Efdsfd~gn y`~l uwel k u~k~gmgd~"

ufmg mkp ggb efmqgbbgn ~f g|qbk`d

fdgu u~swiibg cg~yggd eks`di fs

~lg kd`mkbu kdn igdgsk~`di gdfwil

mfdgp ~f qkp fs ~lg efu~u f swdd`di

fdgu gd~gsqs`ug$ ^l`u knnu ws~lgs

qsguuwsg fd ~lg eb`d`e`kd ~f g|qbk`d

kdn sgx`gy kdp ugsx`eg elksig mkng"

cw~ kbuf qw~u ~lg eb`d`e`kd `d k qfu`~`fd

ylgsg lg fs ulg `u lkx`di ~f g|qbk`d

~lg smu cwu`dguu mfngb ~f gxgsp

efmqbk`d`di eb`gd~$

3$ Ugg Sfbb`d C G ,;000)$ Kd @d~sf-

nwe~`fd ~f Xg~gs`dksp Mgn`ekb G~l-

`eu? ^lgfsp kdn Ekugu " @fyk U~k~g

Qsguu$ ^lgug g|kmqbgu l`ilb`il~

ylp xg~gs`dksp mgn`e`dg ekddf~ cg

efmqksgn ~f kdp f~lgs cwu`dguu? ~lg

g~l`eu efmqfdgd~ nfm`dk~gu mfu~qske~`~`fdgsu nge`u`fd mkj`di$

5$ Qffb`di kdn upu~gm`u`di ~lgug

sgufwsegu `d k qsgn`e~kcbg kdn

qwcb`e`ugn ykp `d ~lg efmmwd`~p

ekd cg k sgkb elkbbgdig$ Fdg ykp"

q`fdggsgn cp kd Kmgs`ekd efbbgkiwg"

Cs`kd Hfsuisgd" `u fs xg~gs`dks`kdu

~f gu~kcb `ul k ygbb-qwcb `e `ugn

elks`~p fs yl`el ~lgp sk`ug mfdgp

`d ~lg efmmwd`~p ~f ngskp ~lg

efu~ f ~sgk~mgd~ fs dggnp eb`gd~u

kd`mkbu$

>$ Sfbb`d ,ugg ff~df~g ~yf) s`il~bp

qf`d~u fw~ ~lk~ k qffs qgsufdu

kd`mkb ekd mgkd ku mwel" fs

mfsg" ~f ~lg `mqfxgs`ulgn qgs-

ufd ku k s`el qgsufdu kd`mkb nfgu

~f ~lg s`el qgsufd$

7$ Ugg Sfbb`d ,ff~df~g ~yf)$

8$ Ugg X^5

8/3/2019 Veterinary Ethics_Case Studies_Animal Welfare_Frank Busch

3/3

39Fe~fcgs 8" 311