Using Mentoring to Grow Business Analystsnnds.no/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/Janet-Wood.pdfUsing...
Transcript of Using Mentoring to Grow Business Analystsnnds.no/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/Janet-Wood.pdfUsing...
1. The Problem
2. Mentoring and Coaching
3. How to get started
4. What actually happened
5. Key Success Factors
6. Potential Traps
7. What’s Next
8. Did it work?
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 2
Agenda
The ProblemWhy do we need Business Analysts?
And why do they need to be mentored?
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 3
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 4
Why do we Need BAs?
As proposed by the project sponsor
As designed by the senior systems analyst
As installed at the user’s site
As specified in the project request
As produced by the programmers
From Guide to Good Programming Practice, Editors: B L Meek and P M Heath (1979).Retrieved from www.businessballs.com.
What the user wanted
∗ What the customer NEEDS, not what they WANT
∗ Solving business problems
∗ Meeting strategic objectives
∗ Project failure reasons
∗ Costs of correcting errors
Why do we need BAs?
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 5
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 6
Project Failure Reasons
Failure Reason %
Incomplete Requirements 13.1
Lack of User Involvement 12.4
Lack of resources 10.6
Unrealistic Expectations 9.9
Lack of Executive Support 9.3
Changing Requirements 8.7
Lack of Planning 8.1
No longer needed 7.5
Lack of IT Management 6.2
Technological Illiteracy 4.3
All other reasons 9.9
100
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 7
Project Failure Reasons
Failure Reason %
Incomplete Requirements 13.1
Lack of User Involvement 12.4
Lack of resources 10.6
Unrealistic Expectations 9.9
Lack of Executive Support 9.3
Changing Requirements 8.7
Lack of Planning 8.1
No longer needed 7.5
Lack of IT Management 6.2
Technological Illiteracy 4.3
All other reasons 9.9
100
44
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 8
Project Failure Reasons
Failure Reason %
Incomplete Requirements 13.1
Lack of User Involvement 12.4
Lack of resources 10.6
Unrealistic Expectations 9.9
Lack of Executive Support 9.3
Changing Requirements 8.7
Lack of Planning 8.1
No longer needed 7.5
Lack of IT Management 6.2
Technological Illiteracy 4.3
All other reasons 9.9
100
44
17
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 9
Costs of Correcting Errors
The later in a project that a requirements error is detected, the more it costs to fix.
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 10
Management Expectations“BAs gather requirements”.
Cartoon copyright 2010 by Modern Analyst Media LLC,and reproduced with their permission.
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 11
Management Expectations
BAs are just:
∗Requirements gatherers
∗Documenters, scribes
∗A tick-in-the-box on a project plan
∗Source of business data
My favourite:
“Just get the requirements so we can get this project started.”
∗ Analyst/programmers – get requirements, code them∗ Systems analysts – get requirements, design solution∗ Early systems development – anything was an
improvement
∗ Now – more complex problems, more complex solutions∗ Expect to “find” BAs who understand the business
environment AND can talk to IT
∗ Where do these BAs come from?
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 12
Why BAs?
∗ You become good at a job after a lot of experience.
∗ Experience is usually gained by making mistakes.
∗ But we can’t really afford to let BAs make mistakes on our important projects.
∗ It takes AT LEAST 5 years to get a BA with 5 years’experience.
∗ We need good, experienced BAs NOW.
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 13
Training vs Experience
Mentoring and Coaching
What’s in a name?
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 14
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 15
Mentor
Greek legend tells us that, when Odysseus went off to fight in the Trojan wars,he left an old and trusted friend to look after and educate his son, Telemachus.
This friend was called …
Mentor
A mentor is:
∗A subject matter expert in the field in which he or she is providing mentoring
∗An experienced practitioner in that field
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 16
Coach
A coach provides“positive support, feedback and advice to an individual … to improve their personal effectiveness in the business setting.”
A coach is a person who has been trained as a coach – they do not need to be experts in the field that their “clients” are working in.
Their expertise is in coaching.
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 17
Who is being Mentored?
The person who is being mentored is called:
∗a mentee?
∗a protégé / protégée?
∗a mentoree?
∗Mostly I say “the person who is being mentored”.
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 18
So am I Mentoring or Coaching?
∗ You will always end up doing some of each.
∗ A BA mentor expects to show people how to do Business Analysis, but, since a BA is an employee of an organisation, youwill end up giving tips on how to succeed in the organisation –more properly the task of a coach.
∗ But no matter what you call it, or what you call the people involved, let’s get down to how it happens.
How to get started
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 19
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 20
What’s the problem?
∗ As with any problem, a Business Analyst asks:
∗ What is the real problem?
∗ Who is affected by it?
∗ What will a successful solution look like?
∗ Why do we need to solve it?
∗ What happens if we don’t fix it?
∗ And similar questions
∗ So, set up meetings and ask the questions.
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 21
What the BAs think
“They must think that we sit around doing nothing all day …
Don’t they know that we want to do a good job?”
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 22
What management thinks
“They must think that we LIKE giving them too much work …
Do they think we’re slave drivers?”
Copyright Geoff Watson 1985
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 23
But …
After talking to both groups, they were all in the same boat
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 24
And, in fact …
Copyright Geoff Watson 1985
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 25
The team’s concerns
∗ Unreasonable timelines – imposed from “above”
∗ Lack of support – management weren’t fighting for them
∗ Areas of development∗ Facilitation / running JAD sessions
∗ Modelling
∗ Requirements elicitation
∗ Other pain points∗ No input to setting deadlines
∗ Stakeholders – lack of availability, commitment
∗ Stakeholders trying to get BAs to define the requirements
∗ Changes in priorities, projects getting cancelled, projects put on hold to get something else done first.
∗ In other words – the problems all BAs have everywhere
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 26
Management View
∗ Team history – lost most experienced BAs
∗ Took responsibility for additional business areas
∗ Team size – 5, fell to 3, grew to 8
∗ Experience – mostly 2 – 5 years’ experience
∗ Deadlines externally imposed, but must be met
∗ Not getting feedback on projects or issues, not knowing where they were until deadline missed
∗ Incomplete documents sent out resulting in rework
∗ New process, templates, tools, standards imposed
∗ In other words – the problems all management has everywhere
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 27
So, what do we do about it?
Identify the major issues to be addressed:
∗Stakeholders – how to identify, how to manage
∗Timelines – how to estimate and manage time, how to influence setting of deadlines
∗Project priorities – setting and managing
∗Specific development areas
∗Selling the value of Business Analysis
∗Problems with tools, processes, templates
And propose a programme to address these issues
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 28
The Mentoring Proposal
∗ Team Mentoring∗ Group discussions to resolve general issues∗ Presentations on specific topics∗ Work through templates and processes to improve them
∗ Mentoring by Example – “Apprenticeship”∗ Join project team and take on a lead BA role∗ Work together on documents and models∗ Observe mentee in BA situations and provide feedback
∗ Individual Mentoring∗ One-on-one sessions to discuss and resolve specific individual issues∗ Must be scheduled, recurring meetings with a standard agenda
∗ Phasing out Mentoring∗ There must be a planned end to the mentoring∗ Aim to hand over the mentoring to the more senior BAs – may need to
mentor them prior to hand-over
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 29
Prepare Documentation
∗ Mentoring Ground Rules
∗ Mentoring Agreement
∗ Mentee Prep
∗ Mentor Prep
∗ Mentoring discussion record
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 30
Mentoring Ground RulesMentoring Ground Rules
Definition of mentoring: Mentoring is a relationship orchestrated to provide professional and personal support to a junior in the role. The mentor uses their experience in a facilitative manner to support the development of the mentee. Mentoring is used to assist individuals at specific times of development or transition and lasts for a defined period of time. The relationship provides an opportunity for both to develop and benefit from the process. What is Mentoring?
• A professional relationship
• Support for professional development
• Personal support
• A partnership lasting over a pre-determined and fixed time-scale
• A significant impact on an individual’s career One way to help in understanding what mentoring is, is to look at what mentoring is not:
• It is not an instructor/trainee relationship focusing on learning skills and techniques to perform a specific function where the instructor is in control of the learning process
• It is not a manager/employee relationship where the manager controls the outcome of the task
• It is not a friend/friend relationship, which mainly focuses on personal development usually outside work, focusing on either friend depending on the circumstances
Mentee’s goals
It is essential that the mentee considers the goals for the mentoring relationship – what are you expecting to get out of the process. These goals must be expressed as specific, measurable and realistic goals that can be met within the mentoring period. What is the format of the mentoring discussions? Initial Session
• Identify requirement & problem statement if possible
• Identify specific issues – What has been done and where the problem areas are
• Agree on next steps – what to do, when to do it, how to measure it, what needs to be delivered by next session
Following sessions:
• Review past week – What has been done and where the problem areas are, and what to do about each problem
• Review deliverables – agree on remedial actions for missed deliverables
• Agree on next steps – what to do, when to do it, how to measure it, what needs to be delivered by next session
How long will mentoring continue?
As long as it is seen to be necessary and useful by management, the mentee and the mentor. Any one of these parties can suggest that the mentoring agreement be ended, but the end will be agreed on in a discussion with all impacted parties present.
Definition of mentoring
What is mentoring – and what it is not
Mentee’s Goal
Format of Mentoring Discussions
How long will mentoring continue?
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 31
Mentoring AgreementMentoring Agreement
Agreement: This agreement is between the Mentor, _____________________________________________, and the Mentee, ________________________________________________________________. It will begin on ___________________ (date) and continue until ___________________ (date). We will meet ____________________________________________________________ (when) at the time of and for a period of __________________________________________________ , at ______________________________________________ (venue). The mentee will:
• Attend every mentoring session or give at least 24 hours’ notice for rescheduling in extreme circumstances. The mentee will be responsible for rescheduling, including booking a room and parking for the mentor.
• Prepare for each mentoring session by reviewing the deliverables from the previous session.
• Honestly report on successes and obstacles during the review period.
• Agree on corrective actions and timelines and document them.
• Discuss the work to be done by the next session, with timelines, and document these deliverables.
• Raise questions and concerns about the work and/or the mentoring process so that they can be discussed and resolved in a timely manner.
The mentor will:
• Attend every mentoring session or give at least 24 hours’ notice for rescheduling in extreme circumstances. The mentor will be available to make up any session she is responsible for missing.
• Review the mentee’s work and deliverables since the last meeting in a constructive way, identifying successes, obstacles and possible corrective actions.
• Facilitate the discussion of the work to be done and assist in setting deadlines and expectations to maximise the mentee’s chances of success.
• Raise questions and concerns about the work and/or the mentoring process so that they can be discussed and resolved in a timely manner.
Mentee’s Expectations: The mentee’s goals for this mentoring period are: 1. _______________________________________________________________________________. 2. _______________________________________________________________________________. 3. _______________________________________________________________________________. 4. _______________________________________________________________________________. 5. _______________________________________________________________________________. The signatories below agree to the above.
___________________________________ ___________________________________ Mentor Mentee
Time, date, duration and venue
Mentee’s obligations
Mentor’s obligations
Mentee’s Expectations:�SMART goals
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 32
Mentee Prep
Mentee Preparation Sheet Your partnership with your mentor can potentially be an invaluable form of personal and professional support. Making sure it is successful is a responsibility that is shared by both participants. The questions below will help you reflect on your requirements and the experiences you will bring to the relationship. 1. What within your past or present experience have you had of being mentored, given advice or
training etc?
2. What have you learned from the experiences above that will prepare you for mentoring?
3. How do you see yourself being supported by the mentor?
4. How can you support your mentor to allow them to support you?
5. What do you feel makes a successful mentoring relationship?
6. What do you think the mentor will gain from the relationship?
7. What do you want to get out of this mentorship relationship?
8. What do you think you will learn from the relationship?
9. What difficulties and constraints do you feel there will be on the mentoring relationship? How can these be resolved?
10. How much time do you feel will be required for the relationship? How will this time be found?
11. What other thoughts and questions do you feel surround the mentoring scheme? Asking questions that allow you to reflect and look at issues that may affect the mentoring relationship are important. They allow the mentor and mentee to engage in dialogue within the initial contracting stage, setting guidelines and parameters, keeping the relationship focused.
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 33
Mentor PrepMentor Preparation Sheet The questions below will allow you to reflect on your past experiences and the future success of the partnership in your role as a Mentor. 1. What within your past or present experience has given you preparation for your role as a mentor? (e.g. staff development, management of staff, have been mentored, etc.) 2. What have you learned from the experiences above that will prepare you for the role of mentor? 3. How do you see yourself supporting the professional development of the mentee? 4. What types of personal support do you think you will be able to provide? 5. What support do you feel you require to allow yourself to perform as a mentor? How can this be supplied? 6. What do you feel makes a successful mentoring relationship? 7. What do you think the mentee will gain from the relationship? 8. What do you think you will learn from the relationship? 9. What do you think your organisation will learn from the relationship? 10. What difficulties and constraints do you feel there will be on the mentoring relationship? How can these be resolved? 11. How much time do you feel will be required for the relationship? How will this time be found? 12. What other thoughts and questions do you feel surround the mentoring scheme? Asking questions that allow you to reflect and look at issues that may affect the mentoring relationship are important. They allow the mentor and mentee to engage in dialogue within the initial contracting stage, setting guidelines and parameters, keeping the relationship focused.
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 34
Mentoring discussion recordMentoring Meeting Discussion Record Date: ________________________________ Mentor: ______________________________ Mentee: ______________________________ SUCCESSES: ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Progress for reporting period of _______________________ to __________________________
Project / Deliverable Due Date Status Actions
Met / Missed / On-going / Late / New
What worked / didn’t work for deadlines that were met, including:
• What did you do well to allow you to meet the deadline?
• What, if anything, could you do better?
• What new skills have you acquired? Preventive and corrective actions for missed deadlines, including:
• Why is it overdue?
• What obstacles or problems do you still have?
• What, if anything, can be done to get back on track?
• What is going to be done differently to avoid this happening again? Plans for on-going , new and missed deadlines. (below)
repeat for every deliverable in reporting period.
Work Plan for reporting period of _______________________ to __________________________
Project Task Due date Status Detailed steps
e.g. FICA e.g. Kick-off meeting Late / On-going / New
repeat for every task in reporting period
SUCCESSESProgressPlanning
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 35
Next Steps:
• Areas which need to be developed: _____________________________________________________________________________________________________
• Agreed actions for the future: _____________________________________________________________________________________________________
• Support required for development and actions: _____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Review the Relationship:
• How is the relationship working?
• What is working well?
• What if anything is not working well? How can this be resolved?
• What additional support is needed for mentor/mentee?
• What are both parties getting from the relationship?
• What constraints or difficulties are affecting the relationship? How can these be overcome?
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
Final thoughts for this session:
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
Next stepsReview the relationshipFinal thoughts
What Actually Happened
“No plan survives first contact with the enemy”
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 36
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 37
Start-up Phase
∗ Getting to know each other
∗ Identifying individual and group issues∗ Same issues coming up with different people
∗ Differentiating issues:∗ Individual weaknesses
∗ Problems with management
∗ Environmental issues
∗ “Change what I can change and
accept what I can’t”
∗ Seeing early benefits∗ Attitude changes, it’s ok to question
∗ Increasing self-confidence
• Planning – work breakdown• Tracking time spent• Need for Problem Statement• Influence without power• Frustrations with process, templates
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 38
Consolidation
∗ Regular individual sessions∗ Every second week, 1 or 2 hours
∗ Standard agenda
∗ Individual concerns
∗ Regular group sessions∗ Weekly
∗ My topics
∗ Group proposed issues to discuss
∗ Template reviews
∗ Regular management feedback∗ Need to keep checking mandate, assumptions
∗ Need to provide regular progress reports
• Context Diagrams• Review templates• Entity Relationship Diagrams – ERDs• Use case modelling and documenting • Process flow diagrams • Logical modelling & Activity diagrams• Non-functional requirements • Tips on language usage
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 39
On-the-job Training
∗ Becoming part of the team∗ Attend the requirements meetings
∗ Review requirements and documentation
∗ Lead a requirements or a review session
∗ Customising templates and processes∗ Document standards
∗ Sharing in the learnings∗ “Feel their pain”
∗ Reinforce the learning – provide feedback
∗ Sending out useful articles, blogs and downloads
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 40
Measuring Results
∗ Measuring the Mentees
∗ Difficult to define good metrics for Business Analysis
∗ Provide input to performance measures
∗ Measuring the Mentor
∗ Even more difficult!
∗ Agreed to use informal feedback
during the programme
Key Success Factors
Pre-requisites for success
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 41
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 42
Management Support
∗ Cannot start a mentoring programme without support from:
∗ Business Analysts’ line managers
∗ Mentor’s line manager if applicable
∗ Upper management
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 43
TIME, TIME, TIME
∗ For the mentor
∗ For the individual mentees
∗ For group sessions
∗ And for management
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 44
Buy-in
∗ From the staff being mentored
∗ From line managers
∗ And from upper management and the enterprise
Potential Traps
What to watch out for
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 45
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 46
Manager as Mentor
∗ May reduce candour of mentees
∗ May be perceived as performance management
∗ May create feelings of favouritism / victimisation
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 47
Expectations
∗ Mentees ∗ Expect mentor will change management attitudes
∗ Expect to get the secret of how to always get it right
∗ Management∗ Expect immediate improvements
∗ Hope that BAs will suddenly be able to deliver to timelines
∗ Mentor ∗ Can’t do job for mentees
∗ Can’t turn mentees into copies of the mentor
∗ There is no silver bullet
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 48
What can’t be changed
∗ Those who can’t and those who won’t
∗ Enterprise-wide issues
∗ Processes
∗ Environment
∗ General Business Analysis issues
∗ Unreasonable timelines
∗ Uncooperative stakeholders
∗ Unhelpful developers
What’s Next
Where to from here
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 49
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 50
For this case study
∗ Prepare senior BAs to mentor juniors
∗ Taper-off on mentoring
∗ Continue ad hoc mentoring and working alongside
∗ Put effort into standards, templates, processes
∗ Work on performance indicators
∗ Measure results
∗ Move on
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 51
For you
∗ Identify one or more mentors∗ Internal vs external
∗ Set up structure∗ Time and schedules
∗ Documentation
∗ Management buy-in and support
∗ Measurement and assessment
∗ Go for it …
Did it work?
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 52
External evaluation of requirements documentation:
∗every document that was produced during mentoring period has passed this evaluation
∗only team with this level of success
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 53
External feedback
∗ Improvement in attitude
∗ More self-confidence
∗ Looking more carefully at details
∗ Asking the right questions
∗ Prepared to challenge stakeholders to get at the real requirements
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 54
Management feedback
∗ “Mentoring sessions are empowering – empower me to be able to pride myself in trying to deliver quality requirements “
∗ “Text book smarts are not enough”
∗ “Motivates me to be more productive and track progress.”
∗ “Celebrating my successes (no matter how small) and being constantly reminded that even when I think I am not doing much that there have been milestones”
∗ “Comfort in someone understanding my ‘pain’ and having gone through the same if not similar situations”
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 55
Mentee feedback
∗ Problem Statement∗ “really helps to see early in the project what we need to focus on.”
∗ Planning∗ “Before the mentoring sessions, I was hopeless when it came to
planning … , I had no way of tracking how much I still had to do and how much I had been able to get through, so there was no way of measuring my productivity… I have recently started using my timesheets and as daunting as it can be sometimes, but I’m beginning to see the benefits of keeping track of your time and tasks.”
∗ Time sheets∗ “best highlight for me has been having an updated time log/sheet”
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 56
Specific Skills
Yes, it IS working …
But it is a work in progress.
Copyright Janet Wood 2012 57
Questions?