Use of Foreign Fire Insurance Tax Money · 2018-01-12 · disburse foreign fire insurance (FFI) tax...
Transcript of Use of Foreign Fire Insurance Tax Money · 2018-01-12 · disburse foreign fire insurance (FFI) tax...
Division of LocaL Government & schooL accountabiLity
o f f i c e o f t h e n e w y o r k s t a t e c o m p t r o L L e r
2017-MS-5
Use of Foreign Fire Insurance Tax Money
In the cities of: Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse and Yonkers
thomas p. Dinapoli
Page
AUTHORITY LETTER 1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 2
INTRODUCTION 5 Background 5 Objective 7 Scope and Methodology 7 CommentsofOfficials 7
USE OF FOREIGN FIRE INSURANCE TAX MONEY 8 Recommendations 12
APPENDIX A FFI Use Requirements by Entity 14APPENDIX B ResponseFromOfficials 16APPENDIX C Audit Methodology and Standards 17APPENDIX D How to Obtain Additional Copies of the Report 18APPENDIX E LocalRegionalOfficeListing 19
Table of Contents
11Division of LocaL Government anD schooL accountabiLity
State of New YorkOffice of the State Comptroller
Division of Local Governmentand School Accountability January 2018
DearOfficials:
TheOfficeoftheStateComptroller’sgoalsincludeenablingandencouragingentitiesthatreceiveanddisburseforeignfireinsurance(FFI)taxmoneytoproperlyaccountfor,useandprotectthismoney.
Followingisareportofouraudit,entitledUseofForeignFireInsuranceTaxMoney.ThisauditwasconductedpursuanttotheStateComptroller’sauthorityassetforthinArticleV,Section1oftheStateConstitutionandArticle3,Section33-a1oftheNewYorkStateGeneralMunicipalLaw.
Thisaudit’sresultsandrecommendationsareresourcesforofficials touseineffectivelymanagingoperations.Ifyouhavequestionsaboutthisreport,pleasefeelfreetocontacttheStatewideAuditsoffice,aslistedattheendofthisreport.
Respectfullysubmitted,
Office of the State ComptrollerDivision of Local Governmentand School Accountability
State of New YorkOffice of the State Comptroller
1 ThissectiongenerallyauthorizestheComptrollertoinspectandexaminetherecordsandaccountsofanyentityreceivinganddisbursingFFItaxmoney,withrespecttofundsreceivedafterJanuary1,1976.
2 Office Of the New YOrk State cOmptrOller2
Office of the State ComptrollerState of New York
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
NewYorkStateimposesa2percenttaxrateonthepremiumsoffireinsurancepolicieswrittenbycertainout-of-stateinsurersagainstlossordamagebyfireonpropertylocatedintheState.2Ingeneral,these“foreign”fireinsurance(FFI)fundsareremittedannuallytotheNewYorkStateDepartmentofFinancialServices(DFS),anddistributedtoentities.3 AccordingtotheDFSwebsite,recipientsofFFImoney includefiredepartments,firecompanies,benevolentassociationsand theFiremen’sAssociationoftheStateofNewYork(FASNY).In2016,DFSdisbursedover$44millionofFFItaxmoney.4Exceptasotherwiseprovided,theFFItaxmoneymaybeusedforanypurpose,whichthemembersofthefiredepartmentorcompanydeterminetobefortheuseandbenefitofthedepartmentorcompanyasawhole.
Unless a special lawenactedby theStateLegislatureor apre-1989 local lawprovidesotherwise,thedistributionanduseofFFI taxmoneyisgovernedbyInsuranceLawSections9104and9105.Generally,InsuranceLawprovidesthattheFFItaxmoneymaybeusedforanypurpose,whichthemembersofthefiredepartmentorcompanydeterminetobefortheuseandbenefitofthedepartmentorcompanyasawhole.However,eachentity’suseofFFI taxmoneydependsonthespecificlawapplicabletoit.
The treasurerorotherfiscalofficerof thefiredepartmentaffordingfireprotectioncoverage to theinsuredpropertiesreceivestheFFItaxmoney.5OurauditfocusedontheuseofFFItaxmoneybysixentities:theCityofBuffalo(Buffalo),theCityofRochester(Rochester),theSyracuseFireDepartmentAssociationInc.(Syracuse),theBuffaloFirefightersTwoPercentFund(BuffaloTPF),theRochesterFirefightersTwoPercentCommittee(RochesterTPC)andtheMutualAidAssociationofthePaidFireDepartmentoftheCityofYonkers,NewYork,Inc.(Yonkers).Allfirecompaniesrepresentedbythesixentitiesauditedwerestaffedbypaidfirefighters.
2 InsuranceLawSections9104and9105,SpecialActs,pre-1989locallawandCityCharter3 Not all FFI money is remitted to DFS for distribution to entities; some funds are remitted directly to the City of Buffalo bytheinsurancecompanies.Insurancecompaniesremitted$2.1milliontotheCityofBuffalodirectly,asperInsuranceLaw9104andCityCharterArticle25duringourauditperiod.
4 TotalexcludesNewYorkCity.ThefiredepartmentsintheStatemaintainlistsofstreetsthattheyserve,whichdeterminestheallocationoffunds.
5 Ifthefiredepartmentdoesnothaveatreasurerorotherfiscalofficer,thentheFFItaxmoneyispaidtothefiscalofficeroftheauthoritieshavingjurisdictionorcontrolofthefiredepartment.Inamulti-companyfiredepartment,thetreasurerorfiscalofficerreceivingtheFFItaxmoneyistodistributetheamountreceivedtothecompaniesconstitutingthefiredepartment,proportionatetothenumberofactivemembersineachfirecompany.However,InsuranceLawdoesnotprecludethefirecompaniesfrompayingallorpartofthe2percentmoneytothefiredepartment.TheproprietyofaCitytransferringcustodyoftheFFItaxmoneytoaTrustisoutsidethescopeofthisaudit.
33Division of LocaL Government anD schooL accountabiLity
Historically,theseentitiesorthecitiesinwhichtheyarelocatedwerereceivingFFItaxmoneyandgenerallysupposedtobeusingittofundfirefighterpensionfundsorcareforindigentanddisabledfirefighters.TheStateLegislaturehasnotenactedchanges to thespecialactsgoverninghowtheseentities use their foreign fire insurance taxmoney for decades,while in contrast there have beenchanges in pension benefits aswell as provisions for firefighterswith disabilities. (Subsequent tothe issuance of the draft audit report, an amendmentwasmade that provides that FFI taxmoneyreceivedbytheMutualAidAssociationofthePaidFireDepartmentoftheCityofYonkersInc.beusedinaccordancewithInsuranceLawSections9104and9105.)6 We note that in the past the unions representingthepaidfirefightersinBuffalo,SyracuseandRochesterhavecommencedlegalactionsagainsttheirrespectivelocalcitiesforaccesstoanduseoftheFFItaxmoneyforthebenefitoftheirmembers.
Scope and Objective
TheobjectiveofourauditwastodeterminewhetherFFItaxmoneywasspent inaccordancewithspecialactlegislation,citychartersorotherapplicablelaws,fortheperiodJanuary1,2014throughOctober5,2016.
Audit Results
FFItaxmoneywasnotalwaysusedinaccordancewiththelaws.WhileallsixentitieshadaprocessinplaceforadministeringFFItaxmoney,officialsinYonkers,SyracuseandBuffalodidnotalwaysuseitaccordingtotheirspecificspecialact,citycharterorotherapplicablelaws.Positively,RochesterappearedtouseitsallocationofFFItaxmoneyproperly.TheRochesterTCPandBuffaloTPFalsoappearedtousetheirFFItaxmoneyproperly,butdidnotalwaysmaintainadequatedocumentationforexpenditures.
Duringtheauditperiod,thesixentitiesauditedreceivedalmost$8millioninforeignfireinsurancetaxmoney.Ofthat,over$1.9million,or24percent,wasnotusedinaccordancewithstatutoryauthorityorpreviousOSCopinions.Forexample:
• Yonkers did not use FFI taxmoney totaling $1.4million for the audit period for the careof indigent and disabledfiremen and their families, as required by its special act, becausethe officials told us theywere unaware of the legislation. Rather, themoneywas used toreimbursecostsrelatedtoactivefiremenandfamilymembers’healthbenefits,socialeventsandadministrativecosts.
• Syracusepaid$390,826 inFFI taxmoney to “TheSyracuseFireDepartmentAssociationSupplementalRetirementFundInc.,”whichsubsequentlydisbursed themoneyasone-timecashpaymentstoindividuals.ThisOfficehaslongexpressedtheviewthatSections9104and9105ofInsuranceLawdonotauthorizeafiredepartmentorcompanytomakeFFItaxmoneyavailableforthepersonaluseofindividualfirefighters.7IndividualCityfirefighters,incertain
6 Chapter308oftheLawsof1912,asamendedbychapter920oftheLawsof1962,waslastamendedonDecember18,2017,byChapter499oftheLawsof2017.
7 Seee.g.OSCOpnNo.2000-6andcitationstherein.
4 Office Of the New YOrk State cOmptrOller4
instances,mayhavereceivedasmuchas$27,000fromFFItaxmoneyuponretirement,withpaymentstotaling$610,848to33individualsfortheauditperiod.8
• Buffalopaid$26,180inFFItaxmoneyduringourauditperiodtoabeneficiarywhodiedin1983.Paymentswerefraudulentlycollectedbythedaughterofthedeceased.WhilefundingoffiremenpensionshadbeenprovidedforbytheCityCharter,allpaymentstothisbeneficiaryshould have endeduponher death, 34years ago.Over time, the daughter of the deceasedbeneficiaryfraudulentlycollectedpaymentstotaling$291,070fromtheCity.
Officialsindicatedtheywerefollowingpastpracticeoragreements,orwereunawareofthespecificrequirementsrelatedtotheuseoftheFFItaxmoney.WithouteffortsbyofficialsandtrusteestouseFFItaxmoneyconsistentwithStatelaw,thepurposeofthelawisnotenforced.
Comments of Officials
Theresultsofourauditandrecommendationshavebeendiscussedwithofficialsandtheircomments,whichappearinAppendixB,havebeenconsideredinpreparingthisreport.
8 As determined by vendor records
55Division of LocaL Government anD schooL accountabiLity
Background
Introduction
The recipients of foreign fire insurance (FFI) money include firedepartments, fire companies, benevolent associations and theFiremen’s Association of the State of New York (FASNY). FFIis generated from a tax that is imposed on the premiums of fireinsurance policies written by certain out-of-state insurers againstlossordamagebyfireonpropertylocatedintheState.9 The insurer willcollectandremitthetaxmoneygenerallytoNYSDepartmentofFinancialServices(DFS)which,inturn,distributestheproceedstotheproperrecipients.ThestatewideFFItaxmoneydisbursedbyDFSfor2014throughJune2016totaledapproximately$126million(Figure1).10
9 ThefiredepartmentsintheStatemaintainlistsofstreetsthattheyserve,whichdeterminestheallocationoffunds.
10Insurancecompaniesremitted$2.1milliontotheCityofBuffalodirectly,asperInsuranceLaw9104andCityCharterArticle25
Figure 1: FFI Tax Money Disbursed by DFSa
Year Number of Disbursements Dollar Amount
2014 1,984 $37,071,312
2015 1,985 $44,506,325
2016 1,984 $44,417,199
Total 5,953 $125,994,836
a Excludes New York City
Thetaxesimposedareintendedtodirectlybenefitthefiredepartmentmembership or fire companies providing the service. Except asotherwiseprovided,theFFItaxmoneymaybeusedforanypurposethat themembers of thefire department or company determine tobefortheuseandbenefitofthedepartmentorcompanyasawhole,providedtheexpenditureisnotillegalorcontrarytopublicpolicy.
UnlessaspeciallawenactedbytheStateLegislatureorapre-1989locallawprovidesotherwise,thedistributionanduseofFFItaxmoneyisgovernedbyInsuranceLawSections9104and9105.ThetreasurerorotherfiscalofficerofthefiredepartmentaffordingfireprotectioncoveragetotheinsuredpropertyreceivestheFFItaxmoney.Ifthefiredepartmentdoesnothaveatreasurerorotherfiscalofficer,thentheFFItaxmoneyispaidtothefiscalofficeroftheauthoritieshavingjurisdictionorcontrolofthefiredepartment.Inamulti-companyfiredepartment,thetreasurerorfiscalofficerreceivingtheFFItaxmoneyis to distribute the amount received to the companies constituting the
6 Office Of the New YOrk State cOmptrOller6
firedepartment,proportionate to thenumberof activemembers ineachfirecompany.However,InsuranceLawdoesnotprecludethefirecompaniesfrompayingallorpartofthe2percentmoneytothefiredepartment.11
WeauditedsixentitiestodeterminewhethertheyusedFFItaxmoney12 appropriatelyduringtheperiodJanuary1,2014throughOctober5,2016.Ourauditfocusedonthepotentialuseofabout$8millioninFFItaxmoneyreceived13(Figure2).
11TheproprietyoftheCitytransferringcustodyoftheFFItaxmoneytoaTrustisoutsidethescopeofthisaudit.
12IncludesanyunspentFFItaxmoneynotpreviouslyspentandremainingintheentities’bankaccount,andspentduringtheauditperiod
13DFSremittedFFItaxmoneyin2014,2015andthroughtheendoffieldworkin2016.TotalsincludeamountsfrominsurerswhoremittedFFItaxmoneydirectlytotheCityofBuffalo,pertheCityCharter.TheTownofBrightonremittedFFItaxmoney to theCityofRochester in theamount received fromDFS, as theCityofRochesterprovidesfireprotectionservicesfortheTown.RochesterTPCFFItaxmoneyrevenueisreceivedfromtheCityofRochesterand,assuch,isincludedintherevenueanddisbursementtotalsoftheCityofRochester.
Figure 2: Revenues and Stipulation of Use Requirements
EntityFFI Tax Money Revenues (January 1, 2014 through
October 5, 2016)
Stipulation of Use Requirementsa
City of Buffalo (Buffalo) $ 2,181,392 City Charter
Buffalo Firefighters Two Percent Fund (Buffalo TPF) $ 605,392 Insurance Law 9105
Syracuse Fire Department Association Inc. (Syracuse) $ 952,719 Insurance Law 9104 and
9105
City of Rochester (Rochester) $ 1,832,349 Court-Approved Agreement
Rochester Firefighters Two Percent Committee (Rochester TPC)
$ 620,000 Court-Approved Agreement
Mutual Aid Association of the Paid Fire Department of the City of Yonkers, New York, Inc. (Yonkers)
$ 1,795,567 Special Act of 1912, amended in 1962
Totals $ 7,987,419
a See Appendix A for detail.
Each entity’s use of FFI tax money depends on the specific lawapplicable to it.All fire companies represented by the six entitiesauditedwerestaffedbypaidfirefighters.Historically,theseentitiesorthecitiesinwhichtheyarelocatedwerereceivingFFItaxmoneyandgenerallysupposedtobeusingittofundfirefighterpensionfundsorcareforindigentanddisabledfirefighters.TheStateLegislaturehas
77Division of LocaL Government anD schooL accountabiLity
Comments ofOfficials
Objective
Scope andMethodology
not enacted changes to the special acts governing how these entities usetheirforeignfireinsurancetaxmoneyfordecades,whileincontrastthere have been changes in pension benefits aswell as provisionsforfirefighterswithdisabilities. (Subsequent to the issuanceof thedraft audit report, an amendmentwasmade that provides thatFFItaxmoneyreceivedbytheMutualAidAssociationofthePaidFireDepartmentoftheCityofYonkersInc.beusedinaccordancewithInsuranceLawSections9104and9105.)14 We note that in the past theunionsrepresentingthepaidfirefightersinBuffalo,SyracuseandRochester have commenced legal actions against their respective localcitiesforaccesstoanduseoftheFFItaxmoneyforthebenefitoftheirmembers.
TheobjectiveofourauditwastodeterminewhetherFFItaxmoneywasspentinaccordancewithspecialactlegislation,citychartersorotherapplicablelaws.
WeexaminedtheuseofFFItaxmoneyreceivedbythesixauditedentitiesfortheperiodJanuary1,2014throughOctober5,2016.
We conducted this performance audit in accordance with generally acceptedgovernmentauditingstandards(GAGAS).Moreinformationon the standards and the methodology used in performing this audit areincludedinAppendixBofthisreport.Unlessotherwiseindicatedinthisreport,samplesfortestingwereselectedbasedonprofessionaljudgment,asitwasnottheintenttoprojecttheresultsontotheentirepopulation.Where applicable, information is presented concerningthe value and/or size of the relevant population and the sample selectedforexamination.
The results of our audit and recommendations have been discussed withofficialsandtheircomments,whichappearinAppendixB,havebeenconsideredinpreparingthisreport.
14Chapter308of theLawsof1912,asamendedbychapter920of theLawsof1962,waslastamendedonDecember18,2017,byChapter499oftheLawsof2017.
8 Office Of the New YOrk State cOmptrOller8
Use of Foreign Fire Insurance Tax Money
FFI tax money is a benefit to members of fire departments, firecompanies, benevolent associations and FASNY.The intent of thebenefitisspecifiedbylegislativeactions,suchasspecialacts(over250prescribing theuseofFFI taxmoney),State laws, local laws,municipal charters or court-approved agreements (seeAppendixAforrequireduseforthesixentitiesweaudited).
As previously mentioned, the six entities (Buffalo, Syracuse,Rochester,RochesterTPC,BuffaloTPFandYonkers)receivedabout$8millionofFFItaxmoneyduringourauditperiod,anddisbursedover$6.6millionofitduringthatsameperiod(asshowninFigure3below).
Figure 3: Uses of FFI Tax MoneyEntity Used By Amount Used Examples of Uses (Expenditures)
Buffalo City $2,181,392 City’s general fund; 10% FASNY; sole beneficiary of Firemen's Pension Fund
Buffalo TPF Firefighters $543,536 Cable service, furniture, coffee, exercise equipment, donations, boots, uniforms, appliances, newspapers and water service
Syracuse Firefighters $701,857
Administration (salaries and taxes), supplemental retirement, functions, professional fees, service awards, calendars, crisis management, intervention team training, catastrophic, beverages at fires, station subsidies (coffee and condiments) and miscellaneous
Rochester City $739,608 Reimbursement to City for linen services, firehouse repairs, small equipment, snowplow services and uniforms, audit services
Rochester TPC Firefighters $996,652a
Coffee, spices, tea, condiments, small utensils, kitchen supplies, water, televisions, exercise equipment, newspapers, cable service and furniture; legal and accounting, and building-related such as purchases related to land, engineer and design service and legal fees
Yonkers Firefighters $1,482,139
Health benefit costs for members and family: vision exams, maternity/adoption benefits, reimbursements for medical and prescription, gym membership, group life insurance, administrative payroll and operational costs, bank service costs, parties, races and sports teams, dinner dance, newsletter, hospitality, professional fees, coffee, condiments and calendars
Totals $ 6,645,184a Total includes $226,902 specific to the Building Fund expenditures
ThelargestannualexpendituresofFFItaxmoneyincluded:
• The transfer of about $650,000 to the City of Buffalo forgeneralfundexpenditures;
99Division of LocaL Government anD schooL accountabiLity
• Reimbursementof healthbenefit costs of activefirefightersand their family members in Yonkers for items such as vision exams, medical and prescription copays and deductiblereimbursements,physicalincentiveprogramsandmaternity/adoptionbenefits,whichaveragedabout$320,000peryear;
• AnannualsupplementalretirementbenefitdisbursementpaidinSyracuseofabout$195,000.
Wereviewedtheentities’expendituresofFFItaxmoneytodeterminewhether theyhadused it inaccordancewithuse requirements.Wefound inconsistencies such as not following the requirements of an entity’s special act, cash paymentsmade to individual firefighters,disbursementstoadeceasedpensionbeneficiaryandgiftsthatwerenotnominalinvalue. Inconsistent With Use Requirements – Disbursements made by three entities(Buffalo,SyracuseandYonkers), totaling$1,900,467,werenotusedinaccordancewiththerequiredspecialact,citycharterorotherapplicablelawspecifictotheentity(Figure4).Forexample:
• YonkersdidnotuseFFI taxmoneyfor thecareof indigentanddisabledfiremenandtheirfamiliesinaccordancewithitsspecialact.Rather,itexpendedover$1.4milliontoreimbursecosts related to active firemen and familymembers’ healthbenefits, social events and administrative costs for theAssociation’s operation and payroll. Officials told us theywereunawareofthelegislation.
• Syracusepaid$390,826inFFItaxmoneyto“TheSyracuseFire Department Association Supplemental Retirement Fund Inc.,”whichsubsequentlydisbursed themoneyasone-timecash payments to individuals. Individual City firefighters,incertaininstances,mayhavereceivedasmuchas$27,000fromFFItaxmoneyuponretirement,withpaymentstotaling$610,848to33individualsfortheauditperiod.15ThisOfficehas long expressed the view that Sections 9104 and 9105of Insurance Law do not authorize a fire department orcompanytomakeFFI taxmoneyavailablefor thepersonaluseof individualfirefighters.16 Asaresult,wequestion theappropriatenessoftheuseofFFItaxmoneypaid.
15Pervendorrecords16Seee.g.OSCOpnNo.2000-6andcitationstherein.
10 Office Of the New YOrk State cOmptrOller10
• Buffalopaid$26,180inFFItaxmoneyduringourauditperiodtoadeceasedbeneficiarywhodiedin1983.Paymentswerefraudulentlycollectedbythedaughterofthedeceased.WhilefundingfiremenpensionshadbeenprovidedforbytheCityCharter,allpayments to thisbeneficiaryshouldhaveendeduponherdeath,34yearsago.Overtime,thedaughterofthedeceasedbeneficiaryfraudulentlycollectedpaymentstotaling$291,070fromtheCity.17
• Syracuse purchased gifts18 totaling $1,322 (net ofreimbursement)forsuchitemsasringsandwatches.Thegiftswereforindividualmembersbasedonyearsofservice.Thesegiftswerenot nominal in value,which is inconsistentwithInsuranceLaw.
17The family member admitted that she had stolen benefits from the City ofBuffalo'sFiremen'sPensionFundthatwasintendedforherlatemother,whohaddiedin1983.InApril2017,thefamilymemberpledguiltyandwasconvictedofthecrimeofGrandLarcenyintheThirdDegree,aclassDfelony.Inaddition,shesignedaconfessionofjudgmentfortheentireamountstolen.
18Officialstoldusthatthememberisallowed$200forthegift;anyvalueoverthatamountistobereimbursedbythemember.
Lack of Supporting Documentation – To determine whether the use ofFFItaxmoneywasappropriate,weexamined439disbursements,totaling over $2 million, of which 73 disbursements (Syracuse,RochesterTPC,BuffaloTPFandYonkers),totalingover$644,000,lacked supporting documentation and information to help ensure accurateuseofFFImoney.
Figure 4: Use of FFI Money Inconsistent With Requrirements
$26,180 $0
$392,148
$0 $0
$1,482,139
$0
$500,000
$1,000,000
$1,500,000
$2,000,000
$2,500,000
$3,000,000
Buffalo Rochester Syracuse Rochester TPC Buffalo TPF Yonkers
Figure 4: Use of FFI MoneyInconsistent With Requirements
FFI Money Received Inconsistent Use
1111Division of LocaL Government anD schooL accountabiLity
Figure 5: Lack of Adequate Supporting Documentation
EntityTested
No or Inadequate Supporting Documentation
for Expenditure
Number Dollars Number Dollars
Buffalo TPF 187 $141,422 15 $7,299
Rochester 65 $806,403 0 0
Syracuse 33 $573,648 9 $542,826
Rochester TPC 82 $304,468 29 $57,564
Yonkers 72 $230,277 20 $36,831
Totals 439 $2,056,218 73 $644,520
Note: Buffalo does not track FFI directly to expenditures. See Appendix A regarding firemen’s
pension fund assets used in the City’s general fund.
Disbursements should be sufficiently supported to provide enoughinformationforanapprovertoreviewtherequestforappropriateness,accuracyandconsistencywithallowedusesofFFItaxmoney.
We found that 366 disbursements totaling $1,411,698 wereappropriately documented. However, there was no supportingdocumentationfor33disbursementstotaling$566,348atfourentities(Syracuse,RochesterTPC,BuffaloTPF andYonkers). Further, 40disbursements, totaling $78,172, had inadequate documentation(RochesterTPCandYonkers).Statementsorsummarysheetswithoutinvoices or receipts to show the reason for the purchase or detail of services or goods limits the ability of an approver to determine whetherexpendituresareforanappropriateFFItaxmoneyuse.Forexample,a$6,090disbursement(Yonkers)bycreditcard,reportedas“Good&Welfare,”wasbrokendownamongmultipleentitiesbutdidnotincludesupportingdocumentationoftheitemspurchased.Figure6 shows the dollar value of disbursements tested for supportingdocumentation.
Insomeinstances,disbursementswereatransferofFFItaxmoneytoathirdpartyforsubsequentdisbursementbythatthirdparty,whichis inconsistent with Insurance Law. For example, Syracuse’s ninedisbursementswerepayabletotheLocalUnion($142,500),SyracuseFireDepartmentSupplementalRetirementFundInc.($390,826)andtwoindividuals($5,000and$4,500).Toassesstheuse,wereconciledmost of the disbursements to vendor records showing the payments wereforaportionofannualevents,one-timeretirementpayments,beveragesatfirescenesandtrainingforcounselors.
12 Office Of the New YOrk State cOmptrOller12
Officialsindicatedtheywerefollowingpastpracticeoragreementsorwereunawareof the specific requirements related to theuseoftheFFI taxmoney.Withoutsufficientdocumentation, transparencyiscompromised.Further,officialsandtrusteescannotensurethatFFItaxmoneyisusedinamannerconsistentwithStateandlocallaws,municipalchartersorcourt-approvedagreements.
Statepolicymakersshould:
1. Revisit the intent and structure of the FFI tax program todetermineifitisoperatingasintended.
Officialsshould:
2. Ensure thatall foreignfire insurancemoney isdisbursed inaccordancewithStatelaw,specialactlegislation,municipalcharterorcourt-approvedagreement.
3. DisburseFFItaxmoneyonlyaftersupportingdocumentationis provided, reviewed and approved as a benefit to themembership.
Figure 6: Supporting Documentation (Dollar Value of Disbursements)
$1,411,698
$566,348
$78,172
Figure 6: Supporting Documentation(Dollar Value of Disbursements)
Appropriate Documentation No Documentation Inadequate Documentation
Recommendations
1313Division of LocaL Government anD schooL accountabiLity
4. Consultwithcounsel,asappropriate,torecoupFFItaxmoneyinappropriatelypaid.
14 Office Of the New YOrk State cOmptrOller14
APPENDIX A
FFI USE REQUIREMENTS BY ENTITY
CityofBuffaloandBuffaloTPF(BuffaloFirefightersTwoPercentFund) – The City Charter requires aforeignfireinsurancetax,similartoInsuranceLawSection9104,tobepaidto“thedirectorofthetreasuryofthefiremen’spensionfundofthecityfortheuseandbenefitofthedepartmentoffire.”19 AccordingtotheCityCharter,theCitymustusetheFFItaxtopay10percentoftheamountitreceivestotheFiremen’sAssociationoftheStateofNewYork(FASNY)forthesupportormaintenanceoftheVolunteerFiremen’sHomeatHudson,andspecificallyrequiresthedirectorofthetreasury(CityTreasury)tocredittheremaining90percentoftheproceedstothe“firemen’spensionfundoftheCityofBuffalo.”20Whenthefinalobligationsofthefiremen’spensionfundtoitsbeneficiarieshavebeenmet–i.e.,presumableuponthedeathofthelastpensionbeneficiary–thebalanceoftheassetswouldbeturnedovertotheCity’sgeneralfund.21ABuffaloFirefighters“TwoPercentFund”wasestablishedpursuanttoan“AgreementandDeclarationofTrustoftheBuffaloFirefightersTwoPercentFund”(TrustAgreement)22 forthepurposeofreceivingmoneyfromtheCitygeneratedbySection9105ofInsuranceLaw.Thisfundisadministeredbythreetrustees,whoareresponsibleforthereceiptanddisbursementoftheFFItaxmoneytothecompaniesoftheBuffaloFireDepartmentforthebenefitofthemembers.TheTrustAgreementprovidesthattheTrusteesapproveanddisbursepaymentsthattheybelieveareconsistentwithInsuranceLawSection9105.
Syracuse(SyracuseFireDepartmentAssociationInc.)–ThespecialStatelegislationenactedin1905generally provided that FFI taxmoney received by theCity be paid to theCity’sComptroller astreasurerofthe“firemen’spensionfund.”23However,notwithstandingthisspecialStatelegislation,asaresultof1991litigation,membersoftheCityFirefighters’Union(paidfirefighters)areentitledtoshareinthedistributionoftheFFItaxmoney.24Subsequenttothelitigation,theCityandUnionenteredintoa“StipulationofSettlementandDiscontinuance”Agreement(StipulationAgreement).AccordingtotheStipulationAgreement,thebalanceoftheFFItaxmoney,overaperiodoftime,istobepaidtotheAssociation.25ItalsoappearsthattheFFItaxmoneyreceivedbytheAssociationaretobeusedinaccordancewithSections9104and9105ofInsuranceLaw.26
19CityCharterSection25-1420CityCharterSection25-1821CityCharterSection25-11provides,inpart,that“whenthefinalobligationofsuchfundshallhavebeenmet,thebalanceofitsassets,ifany,shallbeturnedovertothegeneralfundofthecity,andthereuponsaidpensionfundshallterminate.”
22TheCityofBuffaloisnotapartytotheTrustAgreement.AccordingtotheTrustAgreement,theTrusteesaretoplacethe2percentmoneyreceivedintoaseparateaccountforeachfirecompany.
23TheSpecialActLegislationset forth inSections6and7ofChapter683of theLawsof1905was latercodifiedasSections13-58and13-59oftheSyracuse“CodeofOrdinances.”
24SeeSyracuseFirefightersAssociationLocal280vsFiremen’sRetirementFundoftheCityofSyracuse,datedJuly9,1991,andSyracuseFirefightersAssociationLocal280,supra,IndexNo.89/5767,orderdatedJuly25,1991.
25It is not clearwhether the StipulationAgreementwas approved or ordered by theCourt, or otherwise has bindinglegaleffect.Forpurposesofthisreport,however,wehaveassumedtheproprietyofcustodyofFFItaxmoneybytheAssociation.
26TheCourtOrderdidnotaddresshowtheFFItaxmoneymaybeusedbythepaidfirefighters.Therefore,intheabsenceofaspecialactorlocallawaddressingtheissue,itisourviewthattheFFItaxmoneyreceivedbytheAssociationbeusedinaccordancewithSections9104and9105ofInsuranceLaw.
1515Division of LocaL Government anD schooL accountabiLity
CityofRochesterandtheRochesterTPC(RochesterFirefightersTwoPercentCommittee,Inc.) – In May2002, theRochester FirefightersAssociationLocal 1071 union (Local 1071) commenced anactionagainst theCityseeking,amongother things,adeclarationbythecourt that InsuranceLawSections 9104 and 9105 supersede and preempt certain provisions of theCityCharter relating tothereceiptanduseofforeignfireinsurancereceivedbytheCity.27 After 10 years of various court proceedings,inAugust2012asettlementagreement(Agreement)betweentheCityandLocal1071wasapprovedbythecourttosettleallmatterssurroundinglitigationregardingtheCity’s“TwoPercentFund.”
The Agreement generally provides for the 2 percent FFI money to be distributed between the City and theRochesterTPC.28 The Agreement also distinguishes between 2 percent FFI money received by theCitybeforeandafterthedateoftheAgreement.Forexample,theAgreementgenerallyprovidesthat30percentoffutureFFItaxmoney(i.e.,FFImoneyreceivedafterthedateoftheAgreement)beallocatedtotheCityforthebenefitofallactivefirefighters,and70percentoffutureFFItaxmoneyallocatedtotheRochesterTPCforthedistributionandbenefitofallactivefirefighters.TheCityistoestablishandmaintainaseparatebankaccountfortheCity’s30percentshareofthe2percentFFImoneyandaseparatebankaccountforthefirefighters’70percentshare.TheCitymaintainscustodyoftheFFItaxmoneyintheseseparateaccounts,pendingdisbursement.
Inaddition, theAgreementprovides,amongother things, that theCityallocate$3million,held ina separate trustaccount in thenameof theCityTreasurer, for thepurchase, leaseorconstruction,furnishingandmaintenanceofabuildingforthebenefitofactivefirefightersandtheRochesterTPC.TheCityTreasurerdisbursesmoneyfromthisfund(BuildingFund)totheRochesterTPCaftertheCityCouncilapprovesthe“realestateagreement”fortheconstruction,purchaseorleaseofabuilding.Otherbuilding-relateddisbursementsarepaidupontheCityTreasurer’sreviewandapproval.
Yonkers(MutualAidAssociationofthePaidFireDepartmentoftheCityofYonkers,NewYork,Inc.) –TheAssociationisresponsibleforadministeringthereceiptanduseofFFItaxmoneyreceivedeachyear,asrequiredbythespecialact.29ThespecialactrequirestheFFItaxmoneytobeusedforthecareofindigentanddisabledfiremenandtheirfamilies.TheAssociationisanot-for-profitcorporation.ItiscomposedofpaidfirefightersfromtheCityofYonkersFireDepartment.Anindependentwelfaretrust(Trust),alsoknownastheTrustFundorWelfareFund,wasestablishedasavehicletoreceiveandacceptFFIpaymentsforthepurposeofprovidingtheYonkersprofessionalfirefightersandtheirfamiliesanddependentswithvariousbenefits.30
27 See Montesano v Madison,12Misc3d1197(A),aff’d45AD3d1352,lvdismissed10NY3d782.Seealso,Sections8B-11oftheRochesterCityCharter,establishinga“Firefighters’InsuranceFund”forthereceiptof2percentfunds.TheCityTreasurermaintainsthe2percentmoneyreceivedbytheCityinanaccountreferredtoasthe“TwoPercentFund.”
28According to theAgreement, theRochesterTPC is to be “organized under theNot-For-ProfitCorporationLawoftheStateofNewYorkwiththelegalcapacitytoownpropertyandexecutecontractsrelatedtothemanagementanddisbursementofTwoPercentFunds.”
29SeeChapter308oftheLawsof1912,asamendedbychapter920oftheLawsof1962.ThespecialactwasamendedonDecember18,2017,subsequenttoauditfieldwork,byChapter499oftheLawsof2017.TheamendmentprovidesthatFFItaxmoneyreceivedbytheMutualAidAssociationofthePaidFireDepartmentoftheCityofYonkersInc.beusedinaccordancewithInsuranceLawSections9104and9105.
30SeeAgreementandDeclarationofTrust,datedJune41986.Forpurposesofthisreport,wedidnotaddresswhethertheAssociation,consistentwithitsspecialact,hadauthoritytotransfercustodyoftheFFItaxmoneytotheTrust.
16 Office Of the New YOrk State cOmptrOller16
APPENDIX B
RESPONSE FROM OFFICIALS
We provided a draft copy of the global report to all six entities we audited and requested a response from each. We received responses from three entities: the City of Buffalo, the Syracuse Fire Department Association Inc., and the Rochester Firefighters Two Percent Committee Inc. The Buffalo Firefighters Two Percent Fund, the City of Rochester, and the Mutual Aid Association of the Paid Fire Department of the City of Yonkers, New York, Inc. did not respond.
Two of the three entities that responded (the Syracuse Fire Department Association Inc. and the Rochester Firefighters Two Percent Committee) generally disagreed with our findings and recommendations specific to them. Their responses also were not global in nature. Therefore, comments that were specific to the findings at these two entities are not included here. Each entity’s individual report includes its response to our audit of the specific entity.
The following global comment was excerpted from the response of the City of Buffalo, which generally agreed with our findings and recommendations.
City of Buffalo − “. . . Receipt of Foreign Fire Insurance money greatly benefits our firefighters in a number of ways. These funds provide continual assistance to the day to day operations of our hardworking Firefighters.”
1717Division of LocaL Government anD schooL accountabiLity
APPENDIX C
AUDIT METHODOLOGY AND STANDARDS
Weperformedthefollowingauditprocedurestocompleteourauditobjective:
• We reviewed the applicable special act, law, charter and/or court-ordered agreement todeterminewhetherthereisauthoritytoreceiveanduseFFImoney.
• Weinterviewedofficialsandstaffinvolvedintheadministration,receiptanduseofFFImoneyforgeneralbackgroundinformationandpolicies/proceduresinplace.
• We reviewed agreements and records specific to the entities authority to receive and useFFImoney;andminutes, receipts,financial reports andotheravailabledocumentationandcorrespondencerelatedtoFFImoneyandwhichaddressesfinancialactivity.
• We reviewed the available documentation for information concerning approvals on FFI expenditures.
• Wereviewedcanceledchecksandsupportingdocumentation,suchasinvoicesforindividualexpendituresrelatedtoFFIdisbursements,todeterminecompliancewiththelaw,specialact,Charterand/orcourt-orderedagreement,asappropriate.
• We determined reliability of reported FFI disbursements for our audit scope period and reviewed accounting for the FFI money to determine whether money was deposited into the bankaccounts.
• Weselected439disbursements,totaling$2,056,218,outofabout$8millionFFItaxmoneyreceived.All disbursementswere traced to supporting source documentation to determinewhetherFFItaxmoneywasappropriatelyusedandproperlysupported.WereconciledsampledFFIdisbursementstoreporteddisbursementclassifications.
WeconductedthisperformanceauditinaccordancewithGAGAS.Thosestandardsrequirethatweplanandperformtheaudittoobtainsufficient,appropriateevidencetoprovideareasonablebasisforourfindingsandconclusionsbasedonourauditobjectives.Webelieve that theevidenceobtainedprovidesareasonablebasisforourfindingsandconclusionsbasedonourauditobjectives.
18 Office Of the New YOrk State cOmptrOller18
APPENDIX D
HOW TO OBTAIN ADDITIONAL COPIES OF THE REPORT
OfficeoftheStateComptrollerPublicInformationOffice110StateStreet,15thFloorAlbany,NewYork12236(518)474-4015http://www.osc.state.ny.us/localgov/
Toobtaincopiesofthisreport,writeorvisitourwebpage:
1919Division of LocaL Government anD schooL accountabiLity
APPENDIX EOFFICE OF THE STATE COMPTROLLER
DIVISION OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTAND SCHOOL ACCOUNTABILITYAndrewA.SanFilippo,ExecutiveDeputyComptroller
GabrielF.Deyo,DeputyComptrollerTraceyHitchenBoyd,AssistantComptroller
LOCAL REGIONAL OFFICE LISTING
BINGHAMTON REGIONAL OFFICEH.ToddEames,ChiefExaminerOfficeoftheStateComptrollerStateOfficeBuilding,Suite170244 Hawley StreetBinghamton,NewYork13901-4417(607)721-8306Fax(607)721-8313Email:[email protected]
Serving:Broome,Chenango,Cortland,Delaware,Otsego,Schoharie,Sullivan,Tioga,TompkinsCounties
BUFFALO REGIONAL OFFICEJeffreyD.Mazula,ChiefExaminerOfficeoftheStateComptroller295MainStreet,Suite1032Buffalo,NewYork14203-2510(716)847-3647Fax(716)847-3643Email:[email protected]
Serving:Allegany,Cattaraugus,Chautauqua,Erie,Genesee,Niagara,Orleans,WyomingCounties
GLENS FALLS REGIONAL OFFICEJeffreyP.Leonard,ChiefExaminerOfficeoftheStateComptrollerOneBroadStreetPlazaGlensFalls,NewYork12801-4396(518)793-0057Fax(518)793-5797Email:[email protected]
Serving:Albany,Clinton,Essex,Franklin,Fulton,Hamilton,Montgomery,Rensselaer,Saratoga,Schenectady,Warren,WashingtonCounties
HAUPPAUGE REGIONAL OFFICEIraMcCracken,ChiefExaminerOfficeoftheStateComptrollerNYSOfficeBuilding,Room3A10250VeteransMemorialHighwayHauppauge,NewYork11788-5533(631)952-6534Fax(631)952-6530Email:[email protected]
Serving:NassauandSuffolkCounties
NEWBURGH REGIONAL OFFICETennehBlamah,ChiefExaminerOfficeoftheStateComptroller33AirportCenterDrive,Suite103NewWindsor,NewYork12553-4725(845)567-0858Fax(845)567-0080Email:[email protected]
Serving:Columbia,Dutchess,Greene,Orange,Putnam,Rockland,Ulster,WestchesterCounties
ROCHESTER REGIONAL OFFICEEdwardV.Grant,Jr.,ChiefExaminerOfficeoftheStateComptrollerThePowersBuilding16WestMainStreet,Suite522Rochester,NewYork14614-1608(585)454-2460Fax(585)454-3545Email:[email protected]
Serving:Cayuga,Chemung,Livingston,Monroe,Ontario,Schuyler,Seneca,Steuben,Wayne,YatesCounties
SYRACUSE REGIONAL OFFICERebeccaWilcox,ChiefExaminerOfficeoftheStateComptrollerStateOfficeBuilding,Room409333E.WashingtonStreetSyracuse,NewYork13202-1428(315)428-4192Fax(315)426-2119Email:[email protected]
Serving:Herkimer,Jefferson,Lewis,Madison,Oneida,Onondaga,Oswego,St.LawrenceCounties
STATEWIDE AUDITSAnnC.Singer,ChiefExaminerStateOfficeBuilding,Suite170244 Hawley Street Binghamton,NewYork13901-4417(607)721-8306Fax(607)721-8313