US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring...

59
6/20/2014 1 US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa, and Mark Winter US EPA Region 2 – Edison, NJ

Transcript of US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring...

Page 1: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

1

US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program

Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support

Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa, and Mark Winter

US EPA Region 2 – Edison, NJ

Page 2: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

2

Page 3: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

3

Ambient Air Monitoring Group

Page 4: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

4

Programs Supported

Ambient Air Monitoring Networks • SLAMS • PAMS • NCore • Air Toxics (NATTS) • Particulate Matter (PM10 , PM2.5 ,PM10-2.5 , Speciation) • Lead

Community Studies, Special Projects, Citizen Science

Emergency Response

Training Programs

Contract & Grants

LDAR Program

Who Are Our Customers?

Region 2 States & Locals (NY, NJ, PR, VI, SRMT)

Region 2 Air Programs Branch (APB)

EPA-OAQPS (National Ambient Air HQ)

Region 2 Communities (EJ/Citizen Science)

Other EPA Regions (Region 1 and 3 primarily)

Region 3 State and Local Agencies

Gas Vendors (PGVP)

Emergency Response

Academic Institutions (Rutgers, UMDNJ, Suny-Albany)

Page 5: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

5

Where Do We Do Our Work?

Laboratory - 40% Field – 25% Office – 35%

Office Work

Review, Approve, Develop QAMPs, QAPPs, & SOPs

TSAs of State and Local Air Monitoring Grantees

Support OAQPS through QA Workgroups, Regulatory Proposals, Technical Guidance Document reviews, etc.

FOIA Requests

Conference Calls, Workgroups, Regional and National Meetings

Reporting and Documentation of Field Efforts

Capital Equipment Procurements. Purchase Requests, and Administrative Tasks

Page 6: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

6

Office Work Tracking Matrix - 2014 Q1

CY-2014: Ambient Air Monitoring Program (Office Activities)

States/Locals Citizens Science States/Locals Citizen Science States/Locals Citizens Science

Technical Systems

Audits (TSAs)Project Plans QAPPs

Date TitleSOPsState/Local/

OtherQuarte

r Quality Mgmt.

Plans (QMPs)

10-Jan AQA Ambient Air Monitoring, Fuel Samling & Stack Testing QMP PREQB 1

12-Feb Breathing Living and Learning in Akwesasne Community: Tools for

Improving Indoor Air Quality in the Home QAPP

SRMT 1

27-Mar AQA Ambient Air Monitoring, Fuel Samling & Stack Testing QMP PREQB

(Final version approved 4/1/2014 for a period of 5 years)

Q1-

CY

-14

/Q2

-FY-

14

Field Work

TTP Performance Audits

Performance Evaluation Program (PEP) for PM2.5 – Contractor Oversight, Certification of State Agencies

Siting Criteria Evaluation

Finding Monitoring Sites for New/Relocated Stations

Citizen Science – Site Evaluation, Instrument Evaluation, and Auditing

Emergency Response – Locating Sampling Sites, Sampling and Analysis, QA Auditing

Page 7: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

7

Field Activity Tracking Matrix – 2014 Q2

CY-2014: Gaseous Ambient Air Monitoring Program (Field Activities)

Audit # O3 CO SO2 NOx CO-trace SO2-trace NOx-trace NOy Existing Site Proposed SiteQuarte

r

Date

State/Local/

OtherSiting Criteria EvaluationsNPAP TTP Audits

Site Name

1-Apr NYSDEC Queens College NCore Station 1 1 1 1 1 1

2-Apr NYSDEC Queens College NCore Station 1

8-Apr NYSDEC Holtsville -LI 1 1 1 1

9-Apr NYSDEC Riverhead -LI 1 1 1

9-Apr NYSDEC Babylon -LI 1 1 1

10-Apr NYSDEC Ike Park -LI 1 1 1

7-May NYSDEC White Plains 1 1 1

21-May NYSDEC Nicks Lake 1 1 1 1

22-May NYSDEC Piseco Lake 1 1 1 1

Q2

-CY-

14/

Q3

-FY-

14

TTP Downtown CO Monitoring

Page 8: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

8

Siting Criteria Violation

Siting Criteria Violation

Page 9: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

9

Pre-Build Site Inspection Downwind of Power Plant

Power Plant Stacks

Sampling @ Ground Zero – World Trade Center, 9/11 Response

Page 10: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

10

Sampling @ Ground Zero Perimeter – World Trade Center, 9/11 Response

Citizen Science – Analyzer Evaluation

Page 11: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

11

PM2.5 Collocation Audit

Laboratory Work

TTP System Services • Maintenance/Calibration/Verification of EPA R2 TTP systems • Annual Certification/Comparison of State and Contractor Systems in Regions 1, 2, and 3 • Quarterly 03 verification of R3 TTP Audit System • National TTP System Inter-Comparisons • Design of Audit Instrumentation & Audit Spreadsheets

SRP O3 Verifications

Gas Flow Verifications

Protocol Gas Verification Program (PGVP)

PM2.5

Page 12: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

12

EPA R2 PM2.5 Weighing Room

Lab Activity Matrix – 2014 Q1

TTP-Systems S/L Used Standards S/L New Standards Cylinders CO NO/NOx SO2 Ambient Trace

16-Jan NYSDEC 1

22-Jan R-2 (V3.00 TTP) 1

24-Jan R-2 ( API 401) 1

28-Jan R-3 Contractor 1

28-Jan PADEP (49i) 2

3-Feb R-1 (TTP System) 1

6-Feb R-1 1

10-Feb NYSDEC (TTP System) 1

11-Feb NYSDEC 1

20-Feb Delaware DNR (49i) 1

3-Mar R-1 (TTP Environics 9100) 1

4-Mar R-1 TTP (NOy) 1

5-Mar R-1 TTP (trace CO Analyzers) 1

5-Mar R-1 (Definers) 2

11-Mar West Virginia (APOA 360 &370) 2

12-Mar West Virginia (APOA 360) 2

12-Mar Airgas -Chicago CC255986 1

12-Mar Airgas -LA CC219870 1

12-Mar Airgas -Port Arthur CC209017 1

13-Mar Airgas -Chicago CC269049 1

13-Mar Airgas -Port Allen CC1388 1

13-Mar Airgas -LA CC331791 1

18-Mar Airgas -Chicago CC423564 1

18-Mar Airgas -Port Allen CC423125 1

18-Mar Airgas -LA B32014 1

18-Mar State of Mayrland (49C-PS) 1

19-Mar State of Mayrland (49C-PS) 1

20-Mar State of Mayrland (49C-PS) 1

24-Mar State of Mayrland (49C-PS) 1

24-Mar Allegheny County DOH (49C-PS) 1

26-Mar SRMT (API 700E) 1 1

26-Mar SRMT (API 400A) 1

26-Mar SRMT (API T-400) 1

26-Mar SRMT (Definer hi) 1

26-Mar SRMT (Definerlow) 1

27-Mar SRMT -SO2 1

27-Mar SRMT -NOx 1

ML-800 Gas Flow

VerificationsQuarte

r

Q1

-CY-

14/

Q2

-FY-

14

Date State/Local/OtherSRP #3 Verifications PGVP TTP Systems Certifications Standards

Comparisons

CY-2014: Gaseous Ambient Air Monitoring Program (Lab Activities)

Page 13: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

13

O3 Standard Verifications – NIST Standard Reference Photometer #3

1 of 11 maintained/operated by EPA

Certified annually against EPA RTP SRP # 7

Generates and measures O3

EPA SRP Network

Page 14: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

14

SRP Guidance Documents

Transfer of O3 Verification Authority – From NIST to the Field Analyzer

Page 15: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

15

O3 Verification Citation and QA Requirements

SRP O3 Verification Procedure

Most verifications done are for State primary O3 standards (Level 2)

O3 instruments previously verified @ R2 are run 3x on one day

New instruments require 6 verification runs on 6 different days (6 x 6)

Each run consists of 8 points; pre and post zero, 6 upscale concentrations

O3 can be generated by R2 EPA (for analyzers)

O3 can be generated by the State/Local Agency (for calibrators)

Analyzers can be driven to EPA R2 and left for testing

Shipment via UPS/FedEx/etc., only with Pelican 1660 case or equivalent

Page 16: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

16

Verification Results

Acceptance Criteria: Traditionally slope 1.00 ± 0.03, intercept ± 3 ppb at all points all runs

New Acceptance Criteria for Level 2 Standard: ± 3% bias at all points and all runs

If criteria are not met, instrument can not be used as the State Level 2 standard

No adjustment of monitoring can be done based on verification results

Verification of Previously Verified Level 2 O3 Standard

Date: March 19, 2013

Guest: State of Maryland

Guest Instrument: Thermo 49CPS-74539-376

EPA Instrument: NIST Standard Reference Photometer #3

EPA Analyst: Avi Teitz & Mustafa Mustafa

EPA Guest

Value Value

0.05 0.20

398.11 400.00

298.17 300.00

198.17 200.00

119.50 120.40

79.63 80.30

35.17 35.30

14.79 15.10

0.03 0.10

Regression:

(SRP) x 1.005153 + 0.209607516 = Guest

EPA Guest

Value Value

0.03 0.10

397.58 400.00

297.64 300.00

198.37 200.00

118.00 120.00

79.42 80.10

34.44 35.10

14.83 15.00

0.13 0.20

Regression:

(SRP) x 1.006304 + 0.318950208 = Guest

EPA Guest

Value Value

0.05 0.20

396.54 400.00

297.16 300.00

197.88 199.80

118.82 120.00

79.38 80.23

34.77 35.60

14.73 15.10

0.00 0.30

Regression:

(SRP) x 1.008204 + 0.284060666 = Guest

Verification Status: PASS

To pass a verification, the slope must be ± 3% of 1.000

Run #3

SRP Ozone Verification

Run #1

Run #2

Page 17: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

17

Verification of New O3 Level 2 Standards

Guest:

Guest Instrument:

EPA Instrument:

EPA Analyst:

Run# 1 (2/11/2013) Run# 4 (2/15/2013)

EPA Guest EPA Guest

Value Value Value Value

0.05 0.20 0.02 0.10

758.76 759.10 718.38 720.90

420.40 420.30 418.70 420.00

312.50 312.70 284.92 285.70

218.82 219.10 196.60 197.60

118.37 118.40 119.14 119.30

56.33 56.70 69.40 69.49

26.51 26.90 30.26 30.20

0.09 0.50 0.02 -0.01

Regression: Regression:

(SRP) x 0.999872025 + 0.257185258 (SRP) x 1.003518962 + -0.06954

Run# 2 (2/12/11) Run# 5 (2/21/2013)

EPA Guest EPA Guest

Value Value Value Value

0.02 0.00 -0.01 -0.10

706.89 704.30 712.05 715.50

492.27 491.40 407.48 409.40

323.82 323.30 301.21 302.80

201.87 201.50 206.00 206.80

128.69 128.40 119.29 120.00

74.64 74.60 68.52 69.00

32.92 32.80 35.59 35.90

0.02 0.10 -0.01 0.20

Regression: Regression:

(SRP) x 0.99686958 + 0.155465764 (SRP) x 1.004669619 + 0.082294

Run# 3 (2/13/2013) Run# 6 (2/22/2013)

EPA Guest EPA Guest

Value Value Value Value

-0.09 0.20 -0.07 0.20

710.00 711.30 719.57 722.20

465.87 467.10 409.52 411.56

347.09 348.00 320.75 322.40

231.28 231.70 196.60 197.60

103.98 104.20 123.15 123.70

59.77 59.90 77.58 78.00

22.21 22.20 33.87 33.90

0.01 0.10 -0.02 0.30

(SRP) x 1.001936172 + 0.091510483 (SRP) x 1.003710506 + 0.214525

Verification Status:

Avi Teitz & Mustafa Mustafa

To pass a verification, the slope must be ± 3% of 1.000

PASS

SRP Ozone Verification (New Instrument)PA DEP

Thermo 49i-PS (used as analyzer) s/n# 1027344617

NIST Standard Reference Photometer #3

Gas Flow Verification – Importance of Flow Measurement Accuracy

Flow – Flow – Flow

Flow and Co Based system for TTP

PGVP system predicated on flow

Flow measurements in PM monitoring

Flow dilution systems in GPT and most air monitoring systems

Sample Collection

Page 18: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

18

Flow Verification - Activities

Flow verifications and generation of calibration curves only – no adjustments to hardware

Verify flow standards, e.g., Bios Definer 220’s, DC-Lite, DC-1, Tetracals, etc.

Verify mass flow controllers in calibrators and GPT devices such as: • Thermo 146 series • API 703E and 700 • Environics 9100 and 6100

Flow Equipment Standards and Instrumentation @ EPA R2

BIOS DryCal ML-800 – Region 2 primary flow standard • Cell #44 - Range of 500 cc/min to 50 L/min, accuracy of reading = 0.15% • Cell #10 - Range of 5 cc/in to 500 cc/min, accuracy of reading = 0.15% • Cell #3 Range of 0.5 cc/in to 50 cc/min, accuracy of reading = 0.25%

• Cells and base are calibrated annually by the vendor, annually • Calibration involves dismantling, reassembly, upgrades, and primary recalibration from scratch • Cost of $5000 annually • Annual comparison with NYSDEC MOL-BLOC primary flow standard, annually

Definer 220’s (3 pairs of High and Low flow) – used in the field

BGI TriCal and TetraCal

Roots Meter (@ Rutgers Atmospheric Sciences)

Bubble Meters in 1L, 100cc, and 10 cc burets

Page 19: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

19

Flow Verification Procedure

Flow Verification Results Guest flow standards are evaluated for accuracy within ± 2% Guest mass flow controllers are calibrated/verified for accuracy and linear regression curves are generated.

Date: April 4, 2013

Guest: St. Regis Mohawk Tribe (SRMT)

Guest Flow System: API 700 Calibrator, s/n 656 with:

Bios Definer 220 hi-flow s/n 119262 and low-flow s/n 119305

EPA Primary Flow Standard: Region 2 BIOS ML-800, s/n 105428

EPA Analyst: Mustafa Mustafa & Avi Teitz

Hi Flow

SRMT API 700 Target Flow

(cc/min)

API 700E Actual

Flow (cc/min)

BIOS ML800

Standard Flow

Reading

(cc/min)

SRMT Definer

220 Standard

Flow Reading

(cc/min)

% Difference Definer

220 vs. ML-800

10000 9948.00 9994.20 10113.00 1.19%

5000 4941.00 5004.42 5059.63 1.10%

2500 2440.00 2518.63 2542.60 0.95%

Low Flow

SRMT API 700 Target Flow

(cc/min)

API 700E Actual

Flow (cc/min)

BIOS ML800

Standard Flow

Reading

(cc/min)

SRMTDefiner

220 Standard

Flow Reading

(cc/min)

% Difference Definer

220 vs. ML-800

100 99.60 100.14 101.04 0.90%

75 74.70 75.92 75.05 -1.15%

50 49.70 50.02 50.41 0.77%

25 24.60 25.24 25.44 0.78%

12.5 12.20 12.79 12.95 1.19%

ML-800 Flow Verification

SRMT Bios Definer 220 (hi flow), s/n 119262 vs. EPA ML-800-44 (hi-flow), s/n 104396

SRMT Bios Definer 220 (low flow), s/n 119305 vs. EPA ML-800-10 (low-flow), s/n 105328

Page 20: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

20

Protocol Gas Verification Program

Protocol Gas Verification Program – Guidance Documentation

Page 21: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

21

PGVP – Brief History

ORD initially did cylinder verifications for accuracy (1980’s)

ORD divests from verifications (early 1990’s)

Cylinder verifications done by EPA R2 for our States by direct proportion method (1990- on)

OAQPS initiated PGVP Program in 2010

R2 & R7 recruited to effort by OAQPS

R2 Developed the methodology, SOPs, and spreadsheets for the program

R2 Laboratory audited and certified for operation by ORD/OAQPS

2013 totals – 37 cylinders, 44 assays

PGVP – Program Mechanics Verifications conducted quarterly, depending on demand

Cylinders arrive either from States or directly from vendors

Turnaround time of 2 weeks

• Flow calibrations • Leak check • Analyzer Calibration • Protocol assay • Calculations • Chain of Custody • Shipping

Acceptance Criteria • ± 4% accuracy of vendor certificate = PASS • ± 2%-4% = Caution

Results and certificates forwarded to EPA-OAQPS

Solicitation of verifications, follow-up of assay results, reporting, and funding done by EPA-OAQPS

ORD audits every 3 years

Annual open house for vendors and interested parties

Page 22: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

22

PGVP - SOPs

Dehumidification and Polishing of Zero Air

Page 23: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

23

Dehumidification and Polishing of Zero Air

CO Scrubber for Zero Air

Page 24: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

24

Final Scrubbing of Zero Air

CO/SO2/NOx Benches in R2 Air Laboratory

Page 25: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

25

PGVP – Assays

PGVP Results

Page 26: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

26

PGVP Results

PGVP – Boxing Up

Page 27: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

27

PGVP – Boxing Up

Through The Probe (TTP) Program

Citation for authority

Guidance documents and SOPs

Page 28: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

28

TTP Services

Calibration and Maintenance of R2 systems • Quarterly O3 Line Loss • Quarterly O3 Analyzer Verification

Certifications of TTP Systems • R1, R3, and NYSDEC Systems Annually • Comparisons w/ R7 and other EPA Regions @ RTP, NC

Field audits of ambient air monitoring stations • 20% of NY/NJ/PR stations annually • Oversight -> troubleshoot -> document fixes

Field Audits of Ncore stations using trace level concentrations

Design, Build, Test, and Improve TTP systems

TTP Audits - Tracking 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

CO 12-May

O3 12-May 30-Oct

SO2 12-May

NOx 15-Aug 14-Apr

O3 15-Aug 14-Apr

SO2 15-Aug 14-Apr

O3 13-May 14-Nov

SO2 13-May 14-Nov

O3 9-Aug 22-Apr 7-Nov

NOx 9-Aug 22-Apr 7-Nov

SO2 9-Aug 22-Apr 7-Nov

O3 6-Oct 25-May

SO2 6-Oct

Colliers Mills 34-029-0006 O3 17-Apr 19-May

O3 n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a 18-May

NOx n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a 18-May

SO2 n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a 18-May

CO 16-Aug 13-Apr

NOx 16-Aug 13-Apr

CO 27-Oct

SO2 27-Oct

CO 20-Jun 20-Jun 28-Oct 13-Nov

NOx 20-Jun 20-Jun 28-Oct 13-Nov

SO2 20-Jun 20-Jun 28-Oct 13-Nov

Flemington 34-019-0001 O3 15-Apr 10-Apr

Freehold 34-025-2001 CO 29-Apr

NOx 26-Apr

CO 20-May 26-Apr

SO2 20-May 26-Apr

NOx 12-May

O3 12-May 10-Apr

NOx 29-Apr 3-May

O3 29-Apr 3-May

Monmouth University 34-025-0005 O3 1-May 26-May

Morristown 34-027-0003 CO 21-Oct

trace -CO 20-Nov

O3 2-Dec 20-Nov

NOy 25-Nov

NOx 20-Nov

trace -SO2 20-Nov

CO 28-Apr

SO2 28-Apr

NOx 23-Jun 7-Aug 11-May

O3 23-Jun 7-Aug 11-May 6-Nov

NOx 26-Jun 20-Apr 19-Apr

O3 11-Jun 20-Apr 19-Apr

Ramapo 34-031-5001 O3 30-Apr 7-Apr

CO 21-Jun 14-Aug 1-May

NOx 21-Jun 14-Aug 1-May

O3 21-Jun 14-Aug 1-May

SO2 21-Jun 14-Aug 1-May

R-2 NPAP TTP Audits: NJDEP

discontinued

Site Shut Down

Rider University - PAMS 34-021-0005

Leonia 36-001-0012

Newark Firehouse - NCore 34-013-0003

discontinued

discontinued

discontinued

discontinued

Site Shut Down 6/30/2011

10-Year Cycle 2006 - 2015

Elizabeth - Broad St. 34-039-0003

PollutantSite Name Site ID

East Orange 34-013-1003

Ancora State Hospital 34-007-1001

Bayonne 34-017-0006

Brigantine 34-001-0006

discontinued

discontinued

Rutgers University - PAMS 34-023-0011

Chester 34-027-3001

Clarksboro 34-015-0002

Columbia WMA 34-041-0007

Perth Amboy 34-023-2003

Millville 34-011-0007

Jersey City - Kennedy Blvd. 34-017-1002

Elizabeth Trailer TPK Exit 13 34-039-0004

Camden Spruce St. 34-007-0003

Page 29: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

29

TTP Version 1.0 Truck and Trailer

TTP Version 1.0 Instrument Rack

Page 30: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

30

TTP Version 1.0 Manifold Close-up

TTP Version 1.0 Disadvantages

• Safety Hitch-Up/Release

In Traffic/In Transit

• Access to Sites Terrain

Metro Traffic/Bridge and Tunnels

Homeland Security Issues

• Operational Overhead Trailer Maintenance

Generator Maintenance

HVAC system

Fuel

Aging of Instruments

Page 31: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

31

Essentials for Compact System

• Maintain identical capabilities

• Audit identical parameters • Flow Rates (15 LPM minimum) • Day of audit verification of system operation

• Smaller Vehicle/Simpler Vehicle

• Cheaper

TTP Version 2.0 Identical instrumentation in a compact form factor

Page 32: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

32

TTP Version 2.0 in Rolling Racks

TTP Version 2.0 Teflon Manifolds

Page 33: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

33

TTP System 2.0 - Vehicle

TTP Version 1.0 and 2.0 Vehicle Comparison

Page 34: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

34

TTP Version 2.0 Vehicle Interior

TTP Version 2.0 Load-in

Page 35: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

35

TTP V2.0 at the audit site

TTP V3.0 - Smaller, Lighter, Faster

Page 36: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

36

TTP Version 3.0 – Whiteface Summit Station

TTP Version 3.0 – Whiteface Base Station Site AWD Wheel Drive Required

Page 37: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

37

TTP 3.0 - Vehicle

TTP 3.0 Vehicle- Ports

Ports for presentation line, exhaust, and 15 amp electrical service for TTP instruments

20 amp receptacle dedicated for air conditioner (13.5 k btu)

Page 38: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

38

TTP 3.0 Vehicle - Interior

Right side detail, w ladder and ramp

Left side detail, E-track for cylinders

Racks mount to safety divider via E-Track ratchet straps

Air conditioner controls, picture face rear of van.

TTP V3.0 Racks

Rack 1 (16U size) Top to bottom: •Flow regulation to analyzers, •power filtering device, •electronics shelf, •Environics 6100, • zero air unit

Rack 2 (12U size) Top to Bottom: •Laptop w/ Envidas •Thermo 49i-PS O3 Analyzer •T-API T300U – Trace CO Analyzer

Page 39: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

39

TTP V 3.0 - Rack 1 Annotated

DESO quick connect

Nupro valve to throttle flow to analyzers

Temperature Probe

Ethernet cable to computer (comes out the front of rack)

¼” o.d x 1/8” i.d. pigtail to hook up w/ presentation line – critical for sufficient backpressure to feed analyzers

Rotameter to measure excess flow from TTP instrument flow stream – typically 300 cc/min excess

Note the use of shelves throughout – easier insert/exit of equipment & provides surfaces for mounting cables and fittings. There are 3 shelves in rack 1

Note use of foam to make sure analyzer rack mounts match rack holes

TTP V 3.0 - Rack 1 Detail

Taps directly from the mass flow controllers and before the reaction chamber -to allow for flow measurement without having to remove the calibrator from the rack

Note serial cble from 6100 is mounted to the rack shelf, eliminating cable clutter

Plumbing lines from he front of the rack to the back (TTP analyzer feed + excess manometer flow) are secured to the perforations in the sides of the shelves. These flows have to go from the back to the front and back again in order to control the flow from the front of the rack when it is mounted in the truck.

Page 40: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

40

TTP V 3.0 - Rear View of Racks 1 & 2

TTP V 3.0 - Rear View Detail of Rack 1

Environics 6100 output. 20 L/min max

output

Teflon tee 1 (rear manifold).

Feed after the NUPRO valve (comes from the front) in order to give TTP analyzers sufficient flow without excess pressure (300 cc/min excess flow)

Zero air out 30 psi; feeds tee w/ one leg to O3 Analyzer, one leg to Environics 6100 diluent air MFC.

Zero air supply line to Port 1 for dilution MFC

Feed to presentation line.

This line goes to the front to allow

connect/diconnect of presentation line from the front of he

analyzer.

Feed to DESO/Nupro valve. Feed line also goes to the front of the rack.

To O3 analyzer

TO CO analyzer

Excess flow, feeds to front panel rotameter.

Tee 2A and 2B (front manifold). Feeds TTP analyzers and excess flow.

Page 41: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

41

TTP 3.0 Loaded, Ready, and Able

TTP 3.0 in the Field

Page 42: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

42

TTP Overseas

TTP Overseas System

Page 43: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

43

TTP Overseas System

TTP Overseas System

Pull out tray Pull out tray contents

Page 44: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

44

TTP Overseas System

Batteries + charger

Cell phone + charger

Laptop Computer + charger

GPS + Charger(s)

+ Dashboard Mount

Camera

Passport + credentials

Shipping documentation

TTP Overseas System

Cube Bin Contents of Bin

Folding Stools

Pressure regulator

w/ extra padding

Page 45: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

45

TTP Overseas Audit System – On Site

TTP Overseas System – Current Configuration

Page 46: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

46

TTP Overseas System – On Site

TTP Overseas System – On Site

Page 47: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

47

TTP Overseas System – On Site

TTP Audit Spreadsheets

Page 48: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

48

TTP Audit Spreadsheets

TTP System Certifications

Page 49: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

49

TTP System Certifications

TTP Audit Standard Operating Procedures

Page 50: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

50

2009 National Ambient Air Monitoring Conference Nashville, TN

Manifold Effects - Obstructions

Characterized by:

Low sample flow

Back Pressure

Reduction in gas concentration reported by

station

2009 National Ambient Air Monitoring Conference Nashville, TN

Manifold Effects - Obstructions spider web in line

Page 51: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

51

2009 National Ambient Air Monitoring Conference Nashville, TN

Manifold Effects - Obstructions cross section of spider web in line

2009 National Ambient Air Monitoring Conference Nashville, TN

Manifold Effects - Leaks

Characterized by:

Wave like data trace, and/or

Long equilibration times (hours)

at all concentrations

Low flow at manifold vent to atmosphere

Page 52: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

52

2009 National Ambient Air Monitoring Conference Nashville, TN

Manifold effects - Leaks Wave like data trace @ 400 ppb O3

2009 National Ambient Air Monitoring Conference Nashville, TN

Manifold Effects - Leaks Close up of data trace – chart rate @ 1”/hour

Page 53: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

53

Manifold Effects - Leaks Bad gasket seal

Manifold Effects - Leaks Bad gasket seal close up

Page 54: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

54

Manifold Effects – Condensation

Manifold Effects –Dirty Gaskets Out of round gasket (and dirty)

Page 55: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

55

Manifold Effects - Dirt

Manifold Effects - Dirt SO2 Through The Probe @ Alcoa # 1

July 28, 2009

Page 56: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

56

Manifold Effects - Dirt SO2 Through The Probe @ Alcoa # 1

July 28, 2009

Manifold Effects – Absorption SO2 Through The Probe @ Alcoa # 1

July 28, 2009

Audit

Concentration

(ppm)

Station

Concentration

(ppm)

%

Difference

0.000

0.413

0.000

0.320

n/a

-22.4

Page 57: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

57

Manifold Effects - Dirt

Manifold Effects - Dirt

Page 58: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

58

Manifold Effects – NOx Photoactivity NOx Through The Probe @ Buffalo, NY

June 5, 2006

Audit

Concentration (ppm)

Station

Concentration (ppm) NO

%

Difference

NO

0.000

0.451

0.281

0.177

0.076

NO2

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

NO

0.001

0.440

0.262

0.164

0.066

NO2

0.002

0.008

0.011

0.010

0.010

NOx

0.002

0.447

0.272

0.173

0.074

n/a

-3.3

-6.8

-7.8

-13.7

Manifold and presentation line uncovered

With only manifold uncovered, NO2 was increased by 0.003 ppm

jacketing materials Manifold Effects – NOx Photoactivity

Page 59: US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program - … · US EPA Region 2 Ambient Air Monitoring Program Laboratory, Field, and Quality Assurance Support Avraham Teitz, Mustafa Mustafa,

6/20/2014

59

-50

-40

-30

-20

-10

0

10

20

30

40

50

-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50

An

alyz

er

Re

adin

g (p

pb

CO

)

Regression Corrected Concentration (ppb CO)

Linear Regression Correction of TTP CO Analyzer Zero Cylinder ReadingsUsing Zero/Span/Precision Gases to Calculate Linear Regression

Vendor Certified Concentration = 0 ppb CO

Ideal Analyzer

TTP CO Analyzer Curve - Day 1

TTP CO Analyzer Curve - Day 2

TTP CO Analyzer Curve - Day 3

TTP CO AnalyzerCurve - Day 4

TTP CO Analyzer Curve - Day 5

Initial Zero - Day 1

Post Zero - Day 1

Initial Zero - Day 2

Post Zero - Day 2

Initial Zero - Day 3

Post Zero - Day 3

Initial Zero - Day 4

Post Zero - Day 4

Initial Zero - Day 5

Post Zero - Day 5