Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and...

18
Uranium Mining in Virginia Peter L. deFur, Ph.D ESC, LLC Environmental Studies at VCU NRC Study Committee member

Transcript of Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and...

Page 1: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Uranium Mining in Virginia

Peter L. deFur, Ph.D ESC, LLC

Environmental Studies at VCU NRC Study Committee member

Page 2: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Summary and

highlights

From the

NRC report

Page 3: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Complex Charge- 12 items

Page 4: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating
Page 5: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

FIGURE 3.6 Distribution of Middle to Late Proterozoic granites

and gneisses of the Blue Ridge belt, together with complexly

deformed mylonites, shear zones, and cataclasites. SOURCE:

modified from Lassetter (2010).

Page 6: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Fig. 6.2 Waste management (tailings) at JEB pit, McClean Lake in Sasketchewan

Page 7: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Virginia Physical and Social Conduct - Findings

1. Diversity

1. Geologically

2. Ecologically

3. Socio-culturally

2. Socioeconomic disparities

3. Extreme weather

Page 8: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating
Page 9: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

World-wide Occurrences- mining

Kazakhstan,

Canada,

Australia,

Namibia,

Niger,

Russia,

Uzbekistan,

United States

Page 10: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Occurrences, Resources, & Markets - Findings

1. Only Coles Hill, Pittsylvania County

2. No in situ

3. 92% Ur from 8 countries

4. Track oil price trends

5. Last 50 years

Page 11: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating
Page 12: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Mining, Processing, & Reclamation -Findings

1. Techniques depend on land characteristics

2. Hydrometallurgical

3. Mine design- pit or shaft

4. Ur mining = Hard rock mining

5. Life-cycle analysis

Page 13: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Potential Human Health Effects - Findings

1. Mining & Ur risks

2. Radon decay

3. NIOSH

4. Other radionuclides

5. General population at risk

6. Internal/external exposure

7. 230^Th and 226^Ra 8. Epidemiological studies flawed 9. Millennia of radiation 10. Silica dust & diesel exhaust 11. Miners injuries 12. Waste management 13. Cumulative risk

Page 14: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Potential Environmental Effects - Findings

1. Water, air, soil, biota quality/quantity

2. Long-term risks

3. Extreme natural events, management faults

4. Specific site modeling

Page 15: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Regulation - Findings

1. Subject to a variety of federal and state laws

2. Lack of experience in Va and eastern US

3. There is no federal law that specifically applies to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands

4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage

5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating conventional uranium processing

6. Limited public involvement

Page 16: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Best Practices

Page 17: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating
Page 18: Uranium Mining in Virginia...to uranium mining on non-federally owned lands 4. Gaps in legal and regulatory coverage 5. US federal government has only limited recent experience regulating

Questions?