Untitled document.docx€¦ · Web viewmany people would . not consider them normal.....
Transcript of Untitled document.docx€¦ · Web viewmany people would . not consider them normal.....
Nguyen 1
William Nguyen
Instructor Sara Alvarez
WRD 110-011
15 December 2013
Chinese International Student Community at UK
Introduction
The Chinese international student community at UK brings diversity to UK. The students
come from a different culture and speak a different language. I developed an interest in the
Chinese community because I have deep ties with this group. The Chinese take their academic
success seriously, but other students view them as outsiders. They suffer with many issues within
their community such as social loneliness and homesickness. They often do not feel welcome in
their host country. In order to understand more about this community, I developed an
ethnography about Chinese international students at UK with the goal of proposing solutions to
help this community.
Community Overview
Every year, more and more Chinese students come to America because they believe the
United States offers the best education. According to an article in the Washington Post, 157,558
Chinese students currently study at American universities (Johnson). International students spend
more than $21 billion on tuition, books, and living expenses (Johnson). Seventy percent of
international students’ primary funding comes from their family, personal funds, and their
governments (Johnson). International students do not take many university resources and
usually pay more significant amount than regular students. UK actively recruits students
overseas. International students provide significant amounts of money to the university. By
Picture 1: “Chinese students usually flock
together”. They usually do activities
together, or with Chinese community in
Lexington. (UK Chinese Student and
Scholar Fellowship)
Nguyen 2
contrast, according to many international students, the university does not provide service up to
par with the money international students pay.
Chinese international students develop tight bonds within their community. Even though
they have tight bonds, they still consider themselves outsiders to general students’ population.
They doubt the intentions of American students. They usually do activities together and cook
traditional Chinese foods. When I did this ethnographic study about the Chinese community at
UK, I had to work very hard to get into the Chinese students’ community. Chinese students on
campus don’t usually share their emotions with outsiders. I considered myself an insider because
I share cultural roots with Chinese students. I understand much of Chinese traditional culture and
many of their concerns. I imagine it would be hard for Chinese students to assimilate to
American culture.
Because of this difficult connection with the other students, Chinese students usually turn
to Facebook or Weibo (China’s Facebook version) in
their free time. They surf Facebook and interact with
their friends back home. They feel less lonely when
they use social networks to connect with their
friends. Unlike its American counterpart that values
autonomy, Chinese culture values family and
friendships. Chinese students usually feel lonelier in
American universities than when they were at home.
The feeling of loneliness may have a significant effect
on their well-being. Chinese students have reservations
about seeking professional help because they believe
Nguyen 3
many people would not consider them normal. “Loneliness burrows deep: ‘When we drew blood
from our older adults and analyzed their white cells,’” John Cacioppo writes, “‘we found that
loneliness somehow penetrated the deepest recesses of the cell to alter the way genes were being
expressed’”(Marche). The university may not have noticed the trend of loneliness among
Chinese students, and they have very little to no resources to help these students cope with
loneliness. When Chinese students turn to social networks, they signify their loneliness. “But
surrogates can never make up completely for the absence of the real thing.”(Marche).
In Chinese culture, people usually respect seniority. Chinese students at the University of
Kentucky follow the tradition closely. Chinese students usually select the oldest one as their
leader. The leader helps the younger member with moving to a new place, guides them in
cultural assimilation, and teaches them how to behave in the American environment. Younger
students believe that older students have more experiences in dealing with “American issues,” so
naturally they usually come to them to ask for help with either school issues or friendship issues.
Older students will share their experiences and give advice to younger students and help them
overcome obstacles. The leader provides guidance for the younger students through difficulties,
and after that, the younger students will become leaders when they get older, and the cycle
continues.
Literature Review on the Community
Many people outside the Chinese student community incorrectly assume that Chinese
students have naturally bright minds and get excellent grades. This stereotype creates unrealistic
expectations for the Chinese student community. Chinese students usually work hard, but
sometimes they cannot achieve the unrealistic goals they set for themselves. Being a Chinese
international student himself, Ching Wei understood how stress affects his well-being. In
Nguyen 4
“Acculturative Stress, Perfectionism, Years in the United States, and Depression Among Chinese
International Students,” Wei, Mallen, Hepper and Liao explore stress factors in the Chinese
student community. These authors state that “research has consistently indicated that Asian
(including Chinese) international students experience more acculturative stress than European
international students because the former may experience more cultural differences than the
latter” (Wei et al. 385). In the study, Wei discusses the factors that are responsible for the
differences between the stresses of Chinese international students compared to other
international students. Wei confirms that Chinese students incorporate their families’ pride and
their success into academic achievements. These heavy expectations cause Chinese students to
feel helpless and lonely.
Furthermore, loneliness presents another major issue for Chinese international students.
According to Wei, his study illustrated strong connections between mental health and stress. In
the study, Wei explores the connection between the length Chinese international students stay in
the U.S. and the stress they experience. They put forward the following explanation: “For
example, during the students’ period in the U.S., it is reasonable to expect that high maladaptive
perfectionism (i.e.., failure to meet one’s own expectation for performance) may enhance the
negative effect of acculturative stress on depression” (Wei et al. 385). Maladaptive perfectionism
refers to the inability to distinguish between expectation and performance. Wei emphasizes that a
longer length stay in the U.S. serves as a buffer for accumulative stress. Chinese students who
stay in the U.S. a longer time usually experience less stress compared to new students. New
Chinese international students have higher expectations of themselves because of the high scores
and grades they receive back home, so they tend to believe that they will excel in the U.S. As
Wei explains, “This sense of failure can be very distressing and threatening for Chinese
Nguyen 5
international students because they tend to have good academic achievement in their home
countries.”(Wei et al. 386). Through this explanation, they emphasize the effect of unrealistic
expectations. Being unable to achieve these expectations can damage Chinese international
students’ well-being, but Chinese international students usually ignore the obstacles like
language barriers. Wei explains that new Chinese international students usually think working
hard can get the good grade.
In the research, Wei suggests a solution: “it may be important to increase international
students’ awareness of how acculturative stress, maladaptive perfectionism, and the interaction
of these variables are related to their depression at different time points of their stay in the U.S”
(Wei et al. 392). The international students, especially Chinese students, should learn to
understand their limitations. Chinese students should also learn to adapt to the American culture
and environment. Susan, an international academic advisor, stated that Chinese international
students’ learning styles cannot help them at American universities. She points out that, “Many
Chinese students failed to acknowledge American universities’ standards. They tend to do well
on tests. However they lack attendance or homework” (Garnett). Wei’s research sparks my
interest because I also experience issues similar to Chinese international students. When I do not
have the grade I want in school, I tend to suffer from depression, and I doubt my abilities to
achieve success.
Wei and Liao in “Acculturative Stress, Perfectionism, Years in the United States, and
Depression Among Chinese International Students” speak Chinese natively. They worked as
insiders who, with the help of two other American authors who served as outsiders, developed a
study to focus on the stress of Chinese students. The researchers clarify their methods, stating,
“two of the authors, who are bilingual in English and Chinese, discussed and translated these
Nguyen 6
measures from English into Chinese” (Wei et al. 387). The study has multiple views on the
Chinese student community. Therefore, the study avoids much bias toward Chinese students.
In addition, Chinese students undergo vulnerability for many problems, including the
challenges of integration, which can also contribute to depression. Mollie Dollinger, a journalist
from Tealeafnation, argues that “many Americans still hold negative stereotypes of Asians, at a
time when Chinese international students’ [enrollment] in American universities [is] increasing
each year ” (Dollinger). These stereotypes can hinder Chinese students from making friends at
the American universities. Dollinger has an education consulting company in Chongqing, China
that helps Chinese students to study in the U.S.
This issue presents major challenges in Chinese student community, so Lee and Rice
began to focus on the relationship between integration and cultural differences in their research.
Jenny Lee studied in the U. S as an international student, while Charles Rice researched on many
issues that relate to international student communities. Lee researches on this issue, so that she
can discover what the root of this integration problem is. Lee put forward the issue: “Wilton and
Constantine found that because of language and cultural factors, Latin American and Asian
students have greater levels of stress than other international students” (Lee and Rice 385). The
research tries to determine how the university can improve the well being of the students. Lee
and Rice find that the cultural differences and integration problems have a positive correlation.
Chinese students come from Eastern culture. Some American students do not like Eastern
behaviors, so they avoid the Chinese students.
Coupled with the integration problems Chinese students experience on campus,
universities do not provide enough resources for international students to accommodate their
needs. Lee and Rice affirm, “Kher describes how many support services at their U.S institution,
Nguyen 7
including admission, registration, residence life, and dining do not [accommodate] international
students despite the greater needs such students have as compared to native students” (Lee and
Rice 386). Lee and Rice argue that Chinese international students do not receive the adequate
services when in fact they need more support than regular students. UK should add more
resources to support international students.
In order for international students to achieve success, they should master the language.
Wing Chui went to the U.S to study so he would have an insider perspective on the importance
of English in the U.S. for Chinese international students. In the interview, Christy Ganchero,
who assisted with the English as a Second Language, or ESL, program, states that “the number
one way to learn English effectively is to talk with people who speak English.” Weak English
skills hamper international students’ ability to succeed and integrate. Unfortunately, American
universities do not focus on the ability to use the language. They prioritize academics over the
ability to master the language. In the research that focuses on surrounding factors affecting
Chinese international students, Chui declares that “Universities which only focus on the
academic needs of international students therefore ignore important factors in their potential
success or failure in the new educational context” (Chui et al. 34). Chui explains that
universities usually encourage the Chinese international students on academic achievement, but
the university forgets other factors such as financial or emotional support that affect Chinese
international students’ well-being. I chose Chui’s research because it focuses on the
shortcomings of the university. He points out factors such as financial issues and emotional well-
being that affect the Chinese community greatly, while universities usually ignore or put very
minimal emphasis on these factors.
Nguyen 8
Connecting with Informants and Research in the Community
During the scholar review on the Chinese students’ community, I found many issues with
this community that need to be addressed. In order to learn more about the community, I worked
with different informants in the community including Chinese students, the president of the
Chinese Student Scholars and Fellowship, and the UK faculty who work with Chinese
international students. I wondered what happens when Chinese students study abroad in the US.
How do Chinese students deal with the loneliness they experience? I did some research on
campus activities and found out that Chinese Students Scholars and Fellowship helps newcomers
at UK through the Christian faith. The group connected through Christian churches that existed
in a variety of locations in China and Lexington. I decided to sit down and do an interview with
the Chinese Student Scholars and Fellowship’s president. I emailed the president, Liang Chen,
to request an interview. He held reservations about the interview; he felt concerned about the
prospects of the interview and questioned whether or not I have permission from UK to conduct
the research. I explained my class project to him. He lost his reservations when he found out that
I worked on an ethnographic study about Chinese students at UK. I interviewed him at his office
in Gatton College.
A common belief is that Chinese students value their family and community over their
personal needs. When I interviewed Chen, pictures of his family and of his church involvement
filled the room. Chen’s office illustrates that his family and his community’s involvement
represent an important part of his identity. His office’s decoration reinforces my opinion that
Chinese students display strong family orientation. He seemed laid back and talked about his
family before we did the interview. He talked about his wife who likes to take care of the family.
“Because my wife brings my lunch here, I go downstairs for a few minutes.” (Chen). He studies
Nguyen 9
at UK as a graduate student, and he has his family with him. Chen illustrates a deep commitment
to his religion. He tries to help other Chinese students through the religious services. His
churches organize a group to try to help new students. The churches have branches in China, so
they have contact with other Chinese students through the Christian faith. Christian principles
help Chen try his best to help his brothers and live in harmony among the love of his brothers.
Chen describes the purpose of his organization:
“We give free rides to others. We pick some students up from the airport. We tour some
students around campus. Each Friday, we have fellowship or Bible study. We have free
food and free dinner and sing some songs”(Chen).
The Christian Chinese students get help through religious service and worshipping. Chen and his
groups pick up new students at the airport and help them adjust to American culture. The group
helps students find new apartments and teaches them how to succeed academically at UK. At the
end of the interview, Chen differentiated his group from the Chinese Association group.
Members of his group connect through Christian faith in contrast to the Chinese Student’s
Association, a secular group.
The Chinese students’ community set up the Chinese Students Association to help
newcomers at UK. Nevertheless, the Association failed to renew its charter as a UK
organization. The Association used to get the names of new Chinese students from UK.
However, because of a new privacy law, UK no longer gives the names of Chinese students to
the Association. The Association’s contact information seems outdated, and the new contact
information does not respond to inquiries. I have requested several interviews, but the contact
has never responded to my inquiries about the interview. The Chinese Association‘s website
confuses many new members and certainly posts a challenge to a novice computer user. The
Nguyen 10
website presents information in Mandarin Chinese and much of the information on the website
seems outdated.
I cannot rely on the Chinese Students Association’s websites, so I turned to contact
Bridges to International Students, which connects students from many walks of life. Students
who come from different parts of the world participate in the programs. They discuss what
challenges them at UK as well as their spiritual connection with a higher being. This program
has connected many international students, creating many friendships. I joined this program
because of the affability of the organizer, Edward Lee, and how they go a long way to help
international students. I go to the meetings regularly and have made many friends from this
program. I have met many Chinese students at Lee’s programs. They all seem very happy and
outgoing.
I interviewed a student, Yixing Jin, who went there regularly. Jin likes my research about
Chinese students. He seemed happy that he could help me finish my assignment. He believed the
assignment has great meaning. We discussed different subjects during our meetings. We wanted
to learn from each other’s differences. Jin majors in geography and has a dream to travel around
the world. He has many American friends and his fondness for American culture shocked my
traditional beliefs about students at UK. He openly embraces his condition, and he makes the
best of it. He thinks he belongs to the world. He is fascinated with Lexington traditions such as
Keeneland. His homesickness challenges his enjoyment of UK experiences. I had a lively
discussion with him about his future. He showed great enthusiasm about UK, and UK inspired
him significantly. He offered his view on why UK constitutes a great fit for him:
“Why didn’t you study in China?”
Picture 2: “Bridges to International
Students”. The program connects
many international students together
despite their cultural differences or
faiths.
Nguyen 11
“Because I’m a geography major. I want to go to different places, so the easiest way is to
come here.”
“Why do pick UK instead of other college?”
“Because I do research about horses. It is the world horse capital. So I chose Lexington.”
“How do you make friends?”
“I make friend not based on nationality not depend on Chinese or not.”(Jin)
The interview happened in an environment where we can
really trust each other. We shared with each other what
we strongly believe in. We didn’t judge; we understood
each other’s differences. We discussed how we can find
companionship with each other. Jin has enjoyed the
peacefulness the program has brought to him. Even
though his Islamic beliefs put him in a minority
category, he tolerates other religions and seeks to
understand them. Most of the Chinese Students who
join this program become more open to outsiders and
have considerably more positive experiences with UK.
Many enjoy each other’s company, and they do not act reserved or shy. The program‘s director
has done a wonderful job of connecting students. We see each other as a family.
On the other hand, UK has an ESL program that helps international students assimilate to
the American atmosphere. The program helps students who struggle with English and American
life. The college tries to connect many students together as a group. Christy Ganchero,
undergraduate student assistant with the program, illustrated great enthusiasm about the
Nguyen 12
interview when I emailed her. Christy studied as an undergraduate student, so she connects more
with a student. Christy shares many characteristics with other international students. She assists
international students with their needs, while she has much similar interest with them. She
believes that projects held the important meaning and agrees to do interview via email. She has
worked with many international students and she understands their conditions. She expresses her
eagerness to help me with my ethnographic study. In her opinion, Chinese students usually hang
out together because of their native language. Chinese students have trouble with speaking and
talking in English. Their method of learning significantly differs from other students. Naturally,
they hang out with their group and enjoy each other’s companionship. The college tries to mix a
healthy group of international student together. The college forces Chinese students go out of
their comfort zone, and make learning a survival skill. The intensity of the program at UK drives
students to connect. They meet five hours a day five days out of the week. They must interact
with each other in class. During the interview, Christy emphasize on what of the following UK
offer to International student:
“What difficulties do you notice in Chinese students who are just starting to learn
English?” I asked.
“Generally, the Chinese students I have helped struggle with speaking and listening
skills. Specifically, beginning English language Chinese students have trouble with
articles “a” and “the”, and with “he” and “she”.”
“Are there any differences in the way Chinese students learn English versus the way
other students learn English?”
Picture 3: “The portable dictionary device”. It is a much needed tool in Chinese students’ community.
Nguyen 13
“From my experience, Chinese students often learn vocabulary first. Many of the Chinese
students I have met are very successful in reading and writing, good in grammar, yet
don’t achieve good speaking scores.”
“How do they learn English effectively?”
“The number one way to learn English effectively is to talk with people who speak
English. Forcing yourself out of your comfort zone makes learning English a survival
skill, not just a class.”
“Do Chinese students often travel in groups together?”
“I think all students who are in a foreign country have the temptation to travel with
people speaking their native language.”(Ganchero)
The program builds a strong foundation in life and provides the tools for Chinese students to live
in the US. Her responses changed my traditional views about the ESL program. This program
not only teaches student English but also teaches life lessons. From Christy’s email and
responses, I understand faculty deeply care about international students and want them to
succeed. I have learned that program offers more of life based stimulation for international
students. It gives international students the independence they need, while guiding them through
the right way.
The Portable Dictionary Device
Even though, Chinese students have many problems,
they have cultural artifacts that hold them together. Chinese
students come to America relied heavily on portable dictionary.
Portable dictionary have proven to be useful inside the
classroom and everyday life. Chinese students can use it to
Picture 4: “Red Envelopes”. Gift given on special occasions such as New Year, Birthday,etc.
Picture 5: “The rice cooker”. Rice cookers offer a convenient way to cook rice.
Nguyen 14
assimilate to American lifestyle and succeed academically. Chinese students want to succeed in
American university and to assimilate to American culture.
Red Envelopes
In addition to portable dictionary devices, red envelopes
play an important role. Traditionally, an older Chinese person
gives the red envelope to a younger one. Chinese students have
many creative ways to use red envelopes. Chinese students called
the red envelopes “Hongbao”. Hongbao means that “the storm of
luck” will come to the receiver. Chinese students give red
envelopes to their friends to illustrate that they appreciate their
friendship and show that they have confidence in their friends’
abilities.
The Rice Cooker
In additions to these two culture artifacts, the rice
cooker has considerable influence in the Chinese student’s
community. Chinese students usually eat rice as a main part of
their diet. A rice cooker offers a convenient way to cook rice.
With a rice cooker, Chinese can spend more time with their
friends while having the warm bowl of rice. The creator of the
rice cooker invented it to fit the busy life of the Chinese
student while also reducing the risk associated with cooking rice such as fire hazard.
These culture artifacts show that Chinese students can take advantage of technology, but
still link to their Chinese culture roots. They know they live in the high tech age, so they must
Nguyen 15
adapt to technology; however, they still have deep traditional value. They utilize what their
traditions into something that can fit their lifestyles while still reserve the meaning of it. They are
Chinese in American land.
Conclusion
Working with Chinese students has changed my perspective considerably. At the
beginning, I thought that Chinese doing quite well compared to other international student
groups at University of Kentucky; however, they have many problems within their community,
such as language barriers, homesickness, and loneliness. Despite these problems, they overcome
and conquer. My informants in the community always work so hard and have so little time, so I
had a hard time contacting them. When they get to know me, they open themselves and tell me
what they know about Chinese student community.
Through doing an ethnography on this community, I have developed interviewing skills.
For example, I became more extroverted and open with my emotions when interviewing
informants so they could trust me more. I learned how to set up an atmosphere where informants
could feel comfortable sharing with me. However, I need to clarify my questions more, so my
informants can understand it better. I need to work on the pace of my questions.
During the research about the Chinese students’ community, I realized that many Chinese
students cope with major avoidable issues. The university has made considerable effort to help
international students, but it comes up short. I still have some lingering questions about different
motivations for Chinese students to come here. Some come for academic reasons, while others
come for athletics to UK. Because of sportsmanship, Chinese athletes have better experiences
and have better mental health compared to other Chinese students. They have good connections
with American friends and receive a good level of support from the university, such as tutors.
Nguyen 16
Beside many setbacks Chinese international students experience on the campus, UK as a
university has improved in many ways to help international students such as campus
organizations delicate for international students. I have had an enjoyable experience working
with different groups of students on campus involved in helping international students. UK may
not provide the best resources for international students, but they have made considerable efforts
to help them. Many Chinese students have to rely on outside organizations to get to the US. UK
should use more resources like personal tutors to help Chinese students. Many Chinese students
face struggles when they come to new land. They might have trouble at first, but they come
through. However, I must do more research and gather more information to paint an accurate
picture of Chinese students.
Nguyen 17
Works cited
Chen, Liang. Personal interview. 11 Oct. 2013.
Chinese New Year Celeration. Lexington: UK Chinese Scholar and Fellowship, n.d. JPEG.
Chui, Wing H., Peter Thomas, and Mark Sherry. "International Students: A Vulnerable Student
Population." Higher Education 60.1 (2010): 33-46. Print.
Dollinger, Mollie. “Survey of Chinese Students at Indiana University Reveals Challenges of
Integration”.Telenation.com. Telenation, 05 July. 2013. Web. 07 Nov. 2013
Garnett, Susan. Personal Interview. 07 Nov. 2013.
Ganchero, Christy. Personal interview. 02 Nov. 2013.
Jin, Yixing. Personal Interview. 29 Sept. 2013.
Johnson, Jenna. “Chinese Students Enroll in Record Numbers at U.S. college”. Washington Post.
The Washington Post, 14 Nov. 2011. Web. 09 Oct. 2013.
Lee, Jenny, and Charles Rice. "Welcome to America? International Student Perceptions of
Discrimination." Higher Education 53.3 (2007): 381-409. Print.
Marche, Stephen. “Is Facebook Making Us Lonely?” Theatlantic.com. The Atlantic, May 2013.
Web. 10 Oct. 2013
Nguyen, William. Bridges to International Students. 09 Oct. 2013. JPEG.
Portable Dictionary. N.p.: n.p., Apr.-May 2012. JPEG.
Red Envelope. N.p.: n.p., 01 Dec. 2012. JPEG.
Rice Cooker. N.p.: n.p., Mar.-Apr. 2012. JPEG.
Welcome To Chinese Fellowship. Lexington: UK Chinese Scholar and Fellowship, n.d. JPEG.
Nguyen 18
Wei, Meifen, et al."Acculturative Stress, Perfectionism, Years in the United States, and
Depression among Chinese International Students." Journal of Counseling Psychology
54.4 (2007): 385-94. Print.