Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015...

32
SINTEF ICT Unpatchable: Living with a vulnerable implanted device @MarieGMoe @iamthecavalry #safersoonertogether Marie Moe, PhD, Research ScienAst at SINTEF Safer|Sooner|Together

Transcript of Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015...

Page 1: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

SINTEF  ICT  

Unpatchable:    Living  with  a  vulnerable  implanted  device  

@MarieGMoe  @iamthecavalry  #safersoonertogether  

Marie  Moe,  PhD,  Research  ScienAst  at  SINTEF  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 2: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Lorenzo  Franceschi-­‐Bicchierai,  Vice  Motherboard  

 SomeAmes,  hackers  make  the  worst  paAents…    

Page 3: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

The  stairs  that  almost  killed  me  Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 4: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

How  the  heart  works  

hOps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6RbN5lPqIU    

Page 5: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Electrical  system  of  the  heart  

Page 6: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Pacemaker  

hOps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-­‐f2FKmMneXY    

Page 7: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Leadless  pacemaker  Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 8: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

The  future?  Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 9: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

TrusAng  machines  Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 10: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

 The  Internet  of  Medical  ”Things”  is  real,  

 and  my  heart  is  wired  into  it…  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 11: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Remote  monitoring  

Page 12: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

PotenAal  threats  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Device  is  vulnerable?  

Access  point  is  vulnerable?  

Mobile  network  is  compromised?  

Server  at  vendor  is  compromised?  

Web  site  that  doctor  logs  in  to  is  vulnerable?  

Page 13: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

   

”We  need  to  be  able  to  verify  the  so`ware  that  controls  our  lives”  

Bruce  Schneier  on  “Volkswagen  and  CheaAng  So`ware”  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 14: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Pacemakers  are  vulnerable  

Source:  Daniel  Halperin,  Thomas  S.  Heydt-­‐Benjamin,  Benjamin  Ransford,  Shane  S.  Clark,  Benessa  Defend,  Will  Morgan,  Kevin  Fu,  Tadayoshi  Kohno,  and  William  H.  Maisel.  Pacemakers  and  implantable  cardiac  defibrillators:  SoIware  radio  aKacks  and  zero-­‐power  defenses.  In  Proceedings  of  the  29th  Annual  IEEE  Symposium  on  Security  and  Privacy,  May  2008.  

Page 15: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Source:  hKp://www.vice.com/en_uk/read/i-­‐worked-­‐out-­‐how-­‐to-­‐remotely-­‐weaponise-­‐a-­‐pacemaker  

 

Page 16: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Source:  hKp://www.wired.com/2015/06/hackers-­‐can-­‐send-­‐fatal-­‐doses-­‐hospital-­‐drug-­‐pumps/  

Page 17: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Source:  hKp://www.fda.gov/MedicalDevices/Safety/AlertsandNoZces/ucm456815.htm  

 

Page 18: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Medical  devices  do  get  infected    

Source:  hKps://securityledger.com/wp-­‐content/uploads/2015/06/AOA_MEDJACK_LAYOUT_6-­‐0_6-­‐3-­‐2015-­‐1.pdf  

Page 19: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Default  or  hard-­‐coded  passwords  

Source:  hKp://www.pcworld.com/arZcle/2987813/thousands-­‐of-­‐medical-­‐devices-­‐are-­‐vulnerable-­‐to-­‐hacking-­‐security-­‐researchers-­‐say.html      

Page 20: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Malicious  so`ware  updates  

Source  :  Dr.  Kevin  Fu:  "On  the  Technical  Debt  of  Medical  Device  Security”,  hKp://www.naefronZers.org/File.aspx?id=50750  

Page 21: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Cloud  safety?  

hOps://t.co/XndBSPbAta    

Page 22: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

PotenAal  impact  

PaAent  privacy  issues  

BaOery  exhausAon  

Device  malfuncAon  

Death  threats  and  extorAon  

Remote  assassinaAon  scenario…  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 23: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Why?  

Legacy  technology  

No  so`ware  updates  Long  lifeAme  of  devices  

No  security  tesAng  or  monitoring  

Medical  devices  are  ”black  boxes”  

Proprietary  so`ware  

More  connecAvity  

Lack  of  regulaAons  Increased  aOack  surface  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 24: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

 “Malicious  intent  is  not  a  prerequisite  to  paAent  

safety  issues”    ScoO  Erven,  Security  Researcher  at  ProAviA  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 25: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

How  to  solve  it?  

Security  research  

InformaAon  sharing  Third  party  collaboraAon  Coordinated  disclosure  

Vendor  awareness  

RegulaAon  Procurement  

Safety  by  design  Security  tesAng  

Security  risk  

monitoring  

Security  updates  Incident  response  Cyber  insurance  Resilience  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 26: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

The Cavalry isn’t coming… It falls to us Problem  Statement  

Our  society  is  adopAng  connected  technology  faster  than  we  are  able  to  secure  it.  

Mission  Statement  To  ensure  connected  technologies  with  the  potenAal  to  impact  public  safety  and  human  life  are  worthy  of  our  trust.  

 Collec;ng    exisAng  research,  researchers,  and  resources    Connec;ng    researchers  with  each  other,  industry,  media,  policy,  and  legal  

 Collabora;ng    across  a  broad  range  of  backgrounds,  interests,  and  skillsets    Catalyzing    posiAve  acAon  sooner  than  it  would  have  happened  on  its  own  

 Why    Trust,  public  safety,  human  life    How    EducaAon,  outreach,  research    Who    Infosec  research  community        Who    Global,  grass  roots  iniAaAve    What  Long-­‐term  vision  for  cyber  safety    

Medical   AutomoAve   Connected  Home  Public  

Infrastructure  

Safer|Sooner|Together  hOps://iamthecavalry.org  @iamthecavalry  

Page 27: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

 “There  will  be  bugs”  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Joshua  Corman  of  I  am  The  Cavalry  

Page 28: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Debugging  me  

 

 

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 29: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

   

You  can’t  patch  me!  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 30: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

The  benefit  outweighs  the  risk  

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 31: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

Credits  

Alexandre  Dulaunoy  (@adulau)  Éireann  LevereO  (@blackswanburst)  Joshua  Corman  (@joshcorman)  

Claus  Cramon  Houmann  (@ClausHoumann)  ScoO  Erven  (@scoOerven)  Beau  Woods  (@beauwoods)  Suzanne  Schwartz  (US  FDA)  

Family  &  Friends    

Safer|Sooner|Together  

Page 32: Unpatchable - Hack.luarchive.hack.lu/2015/2015-10-21-Keynote-Hack-lu-Marie-Moe.pdf · 21/10/2015  · SINTEFICT’ Unpatchable:! Living!with!avulnerable!implanted!device! @MarieGMoe!@iamthecavalry!

SINTEF  ICT  

Thank  you!    

[email protected]  hOps://www.iamthecavalry.org  

@MarieGMoe  @iamthecavalry  #safersoonertogether  

Safer|Sooner|Together