United States v. Rojadirecta.org and Rojadirecta.com - Government Opposition to Motion to Certify...

8/3/2019 United States v. Rojadirecta.org and Rojadirecta.com - Government Opposition to Motion to Certify Order for Interlocutory Appeal

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-v-rojadirectaorg-and-rojadirectacom-government-opposition 1/13



mfhsa eshj hsgvkfdq ed Afnfkcfs 0*3?88* hda svjfa qmhq ~hkf ahy ed _vfsqe =?'~ keqied qe

ai~ki~~$ Id gshdqidg qmhq keqied hda ai~ki~~idg qmf Nekpjhidq* qmf Nevsq svjfa qmhq qmf

Gefsdkfdq mha deq ~v`ìnifdqjy pjfa qmhq qmf Selhaisfnqh Aekhid Dhkf~ wijj`vjjy id`sidgfa h

nepysigmq$ -Afn$ 0* 3?88 Qs$ hq 1?+18)$ Id hddevdnidg iq~ svjidg* qmf Nevsq aia ~qhqf* mewffs<

Wiqm sf~pfnq qe qmf ~fneda fjfkfdq* hd #hnq e` id`sidgfkfdq*# qmf

gefsdkfdq hjjfgf~ qmhq Selhaisfnqh Aekhid Dhkf~ #pvspe~f`vjjy

hggsfghqfa f}qsfkfjy ~pfniìn Rijjfghj[ nedqfdq hda hnqifjy

esghdi|fa qmf khqfsihj id h env~fa* jeginhj khddfs$# Qmf

gefsdkfdq'~ hjjfghqied~ hq qmi~ ~qhgf hsf ~v`ìnifdq qe ~mew aisfnq

id`sidgfkfdq cfnhv~f qmf Aekhid Dhkf~ nedavnq idejfa h

ejiqiedhj h~pfnq$ Ffd i` nsikidhj nepysigmq id`sidgfkfdq nhddeq

cf ch~fa ed hjjfghqied~ e` #nedqsicvqesy id`sidgfkfdq# + hda I ae

deq ~e meja + qmf gefsdkfdq'~ hjjfghqied~ hsf ~qijj hafxvhqf$ Qmf

gefsdkfdq hjjfgf~ qmhq Selhaisfnqh Aekhid Dhkf~ ai~~fkidhqfa

qmf nepysigmqfa wesb~ cy pseiaidg jidb~ wminm wmfd njinbfa qeeb

qmf v~fs qe h dfw widaew cfhsidg qmf VSJ #selhaisfnqh# qmhq

csehanh~q vdjhw`vj nepif~ e` jif ~qsfhkidg ffdq~ `sek hdeqmfs

wfc~iqf$ Qmi~ i~ h ~v`ìnifdq hjjfghqied hq qmi~ lvdnqvsf qmhq

Selhaisfnqh Aekhid Dhkf~ ai~qsicvqfa qmf nepysigmqfa wesb~$

Qmhq '~ id phshgshpm 81-n) e` qmf nekpjhidq$

-Afn$ 0*3?88 Qs$ hq 1?)$ Qmf Nevsq hj~e gshdqfa jfhf qe hkfda* hda hnnesaidgjy* qmf

Gefsdkfdq ìjfa hd hkfdafa nekpjhidq -qmf #Hkfdafa Nekpjhidq#) ed Lhdvhsy 0* 3?83$ Hq

psf~fdq* _vfsqe =? mh~ dfiqmfs hd~wfsfa qmf Hkfdafa Nekpjhidq des ìjfa h keqied qe ai~ki~~$

_vsfjy h~ h khqqfse`

psenfavsf* _vfsqe=?'~

keqied i~ deq psepfsjy csevgmq hq qmi~qikf$ Cfnhv~f qmi~ Nevsq gshdqfa _vfsqe =?'~ keqied qe ai~ki~~ qmf Nekpjhidq* hda qmf id~qhdq

keqied wh~ ìjfa cfèsf qmf Gefsdkfdq ìjfa hda ~fsfa iq~ Hkfdafa Nekpjhidq* _vfsqe =?'~

sfxvf~q ès nfsqiìnhqied e` h xvf~qied nednfsdidg h dew+ai~ki~~fa pjfhaidg nevja cf afdifa h~

keeq$ _vfsqe =? mh~ deq ~evgmq qe nmhjjfdgf qmf Hkfdafa Nekpjhidq id hdy why* hda qmi~ Nevsq

mh~ qmv~ mha de ennh~ied qe ned~iafs qmf ~v`ìnifdny e` qmf hjjfghqied~ nedqhidfa qmfsfid$ Qmv~*

ed qmhq ch~i~ hjedf* ai~ki~~hj e`_vfsqe =?'~ keqied wevja cf fdqisfjy psepfs$

3

Nh~f 8<88+np+?18>9+_HN Aenvkfdq >= @ijfa ?8%3?%83 _hgf 1 e` 8>



HSGVKFDQ

I$ _VFSQE =?'^ KEQIED ^MEVJA CF AFDIFA @ES @HIJIDG QE KFFQ QMF

^QSIDGFDQ SFXVISFKFDQ^ E@ 3= V$^$N$ § 8393-c)

H~ ~fq èsqm kesf `vjjy cfjew* _vfsqe =? mh~ deq + cfnhv~f iq nhddeq + f~qhcji~m qmhq

f}nfpqiedhj nisnvk~qhdnf~ hsf psf~fdq es eqmfswi~f efsnekf qmf ~qsedg psf~vkpqied hghid~q

idqfsjenvqesy hppfhj~$ Kesfefs* _vfsqe =?'~ keqied i~ wmejjy wiqmevq kfsi q cfnhv~f iq ~ikpjy

`hij~ qe kffq qmf ~qsidgfdq sfxvisfkfdq~ e` ^fnqied 8393-c) e`Qiqjf 3=$ îkpjy pvq* _vfsqe =?

nhddeq nedidnf qmi~ Nevsq qmhq qmf i~~vf iq ~ffb~ qe mhf nfsqiìfa qe qmf ^fneda Nisnviq Nevsq e`

Hppfhj~ -8) idejf~ h xvf~qied e` pvsf jhw2 -3) hcevq wminm qmfsf i~ h ~vc~qhdqihj gsevda ès

ai``fsfdnf e` epidied2 hda ->) i~ ~e nedqsejjidg qmhq iq~ sf~ejvqied wevja khqfsihjjy hahdnf qmf

vjqikhqf qfskidhqied e` qmi~ jiqighqied$ Id jigmq e` qmf~f afìnifdnif~* qmi~ Nevsq ~mevja afdy

_vfsqe =?'~ keqied$

Qmfsf i~ h #ìsk nedgsf~~iedhj pejiny hghid~q idqfsjenvqesy es 'pifnfkfhj' hppfhj~$#

Hcdfy $ Vdiqfa ^qhqf~* 1>8 V$^$ 068*060 -8977)$ H dhssew hda jikiqfa f}nfpqied qe qmhq pejiny

i~ fkceaifa id Qiqjf 3=* Vdiqfa ^qhqf~ Neaf* ^fnqied 8393-c)* wminm pseiaf~* id pfsqidfdq phsq<

Wmfd h ai~qsinq lvagf* id khbidg id h niij hnqied hd esafs deq

eqmfswi~f hppfhjhcjf vdafs qmi~ ~fnqied* ~mhjj cf e` qmf epidied qmhq

~vnm esafs idejf~ h nedqsejjidg xvf~qied e` jhw h~ qe wminm qmfsf

i~ ~vc~qhdqihj gsevda ès ai``fsfdnf e` epidied hda qmhq hd

ikkfaihqf hppfhj `sek qmf esafs khy khqfsihjjy hahdnf qmf

vjqikhqf qfskidhqied e` qmf jiqighqied* mf ~mhjj ~e ~qhqf id wsiqidg id

~vnm esafs$

3= V$^$N$ § 8393-c)$3 Nfsqiìnhqied vdafs qmi~ psei~ied #i~ sf~fsfa ès qme~f nh~f~ wmfsf hd

3 Qmf ^fneda Nisnviq mh~ sfpfhqfajy khaf njfhs qmhq idqfsjenvqesy hppfhj~ ~mevja cf

f}nffaidgjy shsf$ @es id~qhdnf* id Befmjfs $ Chdb e`Cfskvah Jqa$* 8?8 @$>a =0> -3a Nis$

8990)* qmf Nevsq e`Hppfhj~ deqfa qmhq id 8991 hda 8996 nekcidfa* edjy >6 keqied~ ès jfhf qe

hppfhj wfsf ìjfa* hda e` qme~f edjy = wfsf gshdqfa$ Ia$ hq =00$

>




idqfskfaihqf hppfhj khy heia pseqshnqfa jiqighqied* Befmjfs p$ Chdb e`Cfskvah Jqa$* 8?8 @$>a

=0>*=06+00 -3a Nis$ 8990)* hda #kv~q cf ~qsinqjy jikiqfa qe qmf psfni~f nedaiqied~ ~qhqfa id qmf

jhw*# Bjidgme``fs p$ ^$D$N$ Hnmijjf Jhvse* 938 @$3a 38*36 -3a Nis$ 899?)2 ~ff hj~e Khsqfd~ p$

^kiqm Chsdfy* Idn$* 3>= @$ ^vpp$ 3a 690* 0?? -^$A$D$Y$ 3??3) -#^fnqied 8393-c) wh~ deq

idqfdafa qe epfd qmf `jeeaghqf~ qe h h~q dvkcfs e` hppfhj~ `sek idqfsjenvqesy esafs~ id esaidhsy

jiqighqied* es qe cf h fminjf qe pseiaf fhsjy sfifw e` ai`ìnvjq svjidg~ id mhsa nh~f~R*[# hda* h~ h

sf~vjq* nfsqiìnhqied i~ psepfs edjy qe #heia pseqshnqfa hda f}pfd~if jiqighqied#)$

#Haaiqiedhjjy* qmf phsqy ~ffbidg hd idqfsjenvqesy hppfhj mh~ qmf cvsafd e` ~mewidg

f}nfpqiedhj nisnvk~qhdnf~* qe efsnekf qmf gfdfshj hfs~ied qe pifnfkfhj jiqighqied hda qe ~mew

qmhq qmf nisnvk~qhdnf~ whsshdq h afphsqvsf `sek qmf ch~in pejiny e` pe~qpedidg hppfjjhqf sfifw

vdqij h`qfs fdqsy e` h ìdhj lvagkfdq$# Id sf Fdsed Nesp$* 3??= WJ 3=8973* hq ,> -^$A$D$Y$ Lhd$

36* 3??=) -idqfsdhj xveqhqied~ ekiqqfa)2 ~ff hj~e Neepfs~ & Jycshda p$ Jif~hy* 1>7 V$^$ 10>*

176 -897=) -edjy #f}nfpqiedhj nisnvk~qhdnf~ Rwijj[ lv~qi`y h afphsqvsf `sek qmf ch~in pejiny e`

pe~qpedidg hppfjjhqf sfifw vdqij h`qfs qmf fdqsy e` h ìdhj lvagkfdq#)$ Ffd id nh~f~ wmfsf qmf

phsqy sfxvf~qidg nfsqiìnhqied kffq~ qmf ~qhqvqesy nsiqfsih* qmf ai~qsinq nevsq sfqhid~ #cseha

ai~nsfqied qe afdy nfsqiìnhqied$# Nfdqvsy _hn$* Idn$ p$ Mijqed Meqfj~ Nesp$* 671 @$ ^vpp$ 3a >09*

>7? -^$A$D$Y$ 3??=)$

@idhjjy* qmf ^fneda Nisnviq mh~ mfja qmhq nmhjjfdgf~ qe qmf ~v`ìnifdny e` h pjfhaidg hsf

deq gfdfshjjy qmf hppsepsihqf ~vclfnq~ e` idqfsjenvqesy sfifw* h~ #h sffs~hj Red idqfsjenvqesy

hppfhj[ hq ke~q nevja jfha edjy qe h sfkhda ès sfpjfhaidg* wiqm pe~~icijiqif~ e` `vsqmfs

idqfsjenvqesy hppfhj~ qmfsfh`qfs$# Geqqf~khd p$ Gfdfshj Keqes~ Nesp$* 30= @$3a 891* 890 -3a Nis$

8969) -f}pjhididg `vsqmfs qmhq #Ri[q wevja ~ffk h}iekhqin qmhq hppfhj~ nmhjjfdgidg psf+qsihj

1




svjidg~ vpmejaidg pjfhaidg~ hghid~q afkvssfs nevja deq cf f``fnqif id csidgidg dfhsfs qmf

qfskidhqied e` jiqighqied2 ed qmf nedqshsy* qmfy edjy ~qikvjhqf qmf phsqif~ qe kesf hda gsfhqfs

psf+qsihj ~phssidg hphsq `sek qmf kfsiq~$ #)$

Mfsf* _vfsqe =? nhddeq kffq qmf ~qsidgfdq sfxvisfkfdq~ e` ^fnqied 8393-c) es hsgvf qmf

psf~fdnf e` f}nfpqiedhj nisnvk~qhdnf~ qe lv~qi`y hd idqfsjenvqesy hppfhj$

H$ Qmf Xvf~qied _vfsqe =? ^ffb~ Qe Nfsqi`y Aef~ Deq _sf~fdq H _vsf #Xvf~qied

e` Jhw# Vdafs ^fnqied 8393-c)

H qmsf~meja sfxvisfkfdq ès nfsqiìnhqied vdafs ^fnqied 8393-c) i~ qmhq qmf esafs qe cf

nfsqiìfa psf~fdq~ h #xvf~qied e`jhw$# H #xvf~qied e`jhw# h~ v~fa id qmf ~qhqvqf #kv~q sf`fs qe h

pvsf xvf~qied e` jhw qmhq qmf sfifwidg nevsq nevja afniaf xvinjay hda njfhdjy wiqmevq mhidg qe

~qvay qmf sfnesa$# Nfdqvsy _hn$* Ijjn$* 671 @$ ^vpp$ 3a hq >78 -fkpmh~i~ haafa) -idqfsdhj

xveqhqied~ ekiqqfa)2 ~ff hj~e Hmsfd|mej| $ Ca$ e`Qs$ e`Vdip$ eÌjj$* 389 @$>a 071* 070+77 -7qm

Nis$ 3???) -~hkf)2 Ned~vc Afjhwhsf JJN $ ^nmhmid Fdgfdmhsih Jikiqhah* 170 @$ ^vpp$ 3a >?6*

>?9 -^$A$D$Y$ 3??7) -~hkf)2 Ai`fjinf p$ V$^$ Hiswhy~* Idn$* 1?1 @$ ^vpp$ 3a 9?7* 9?= -F$A$ Ph$

3??6) -^fnqied 8393-c) i~ cf~q ~viqfa ès v~f id h ai~pvqf qmhq idejf~ #h dhssew xvf~qied e`pvsf

jhw wme~f sf~ejvqied wijj cf nekpjfqfjy ai~pe~iqif#)$

Ki}fa xvf~qied~ e` jhw hda `hnq* cy nedqsh~q* hsf deq hppsepsihqf ès nfsqiìnhqied* h~ qmfy

dfnf~~hsijy wevja sfxvisf qmf hppfjjhqf nevsq qe sfifw qmf sfnesa hda hppjy qmf jhw qe h ~pfniìn

~fq e` `hnq~$ ^ff ^$F$N$ $ @is~q Lfs~fy ^fn$* 6=7 @$ ^vpp$ 6>6* 6>0 -^$A$D$Y$ 89=1) -mejaidg qmhq

wmfsf hd hppfhj #wevja dfnf~~hsijy psf~fdq h ki}fa xvf~qied e` jhw hda `hnq* deq h nedqsejjidg

i~~vf e`pvsf jhw*# qmf ai~qsinq nevsq'~ esafs wh~ #deq hppsepsihqf ès nfsqiìnhqied pvs~vhdq qe 3=

V$^$N$ § 8393-c)#)2 ~ff hj~e Nfdqvsy _hn$* Idn$* 671 @$ ^vpp$ 3a hq >78+73 -afnjididg qe nfsqi`y

6




ès idqfsjenvqesy hppfhj cfnhv~f qmf esafs psf~fdqfa h ki}fa xvf~qied e` jhw hda `hnq)2 Id sf

Hkchn @id$ Gsevp* Idn$ ^fn$ Jiqig$* 09> @$ ^vpp$ 3a 318*3=6 -^$A$D$Y$ 3?8?) -~hkf)2 ^qedf p$

_hqnmfqq* 3??9 WJ 861106?* hq ,3 -^$A$D$Y$ Lvdf >* 3??9) -~hkf)2 Kessi~ $ @jhig* 688 @$ ^vpp$

3a 3=3*>86 -F$A$D$Y$ 3??7) -~hkf)2 @sffkhd p$ Dhq'j Cseha$ Ne$* Idn$* 899> WJ 631=6=* hq ,3

-^$A$D$Y$ Afn$ 86* 899>) -~hkf)2 Wfi~khd p$ Ahkfijjf* 7= @$S$A$ 078* 071 -^$A$D$Y$ 897=)

-~hkf)$

Qmf xvf~qied _vfsqe =? h~b~ qmi~ Nevsq qe nfsqi`y + wmfqmfs jidbidg qe hdeqmfs wfc~iqf cy

pvspe~f`vjjy hggsfghqidg jidb~ qe f}qsfkfjy ~pfniìn nedqfdq hda hnqifjy esghdi|idg qme~f jidb~

id h ènv~fa* jeginhj khddfs ~hqi~ìf~ qmf fjfkfdq e` #nepyidg# ès aisfnq nepysigmq id`sidgfkfdq

vdafs 87 V$^$N$ § 6?0-h) + i~ deq h pvsf jfghj xvf~qied* h~ sfxvisfa cy ^fnqied 8393-c)* cvq shqmfs

h ki}fa xvf~qied e` jhw hda `hnq$ Hd~wfsidg qmf xvf~qied _vfsqe =? ~ffb~ qe mhf nfsqiìfa

dfnf~~hsijy sfxvisf~ h `hnq+~pfniìn idxvisy idqe* hkedg eqmfs qmidg~* qmf dhqvsf e` qmf Selhaisfnqh

wfc~iqf* wmhq iq i~ qmf wfc~iqf hnqvhjjy aef~* wmhq pvspe~f qmf ewdfs~ e` qmf wfc~iqf mhf id

epfshqidg iq* hda mew #jidbidg# ~mevja cf vdafs~qeea id qmi~ ~pfniìn nedqf}q$ Qmf~f hsf psfni~fjy

qmf ~esq~ e`khqqfs~ qmhq qmf Gefsdkfdq i~ fdqiqjfa qe affjep qmsevgm ai~nefsy$ Hda edjy ednf

ai~nefsy i~ nekpjfqfa nhd qmi~ Nevsq + jfq hjedf qmf Nevsq e`Hppfhj~ + nednjv~ifjy sf~ejf qmf

i~~vf e`wmfqmfs qmf Selhaisfnqh wfc~iqf i~ nekkiqqidg aisfnq nepysigmq id`sidgfkfdq$ Cfnhv~f

qmf xvf~qied _vfsqe =? ~ffb~ qe nfsqi`y aef~ deq idejf h pvsf xvf~qied e`jhw* _vfsqe =?'~

keqied ~mevja cf afdifa$

0

Nh~f 8<88+np+?18>9+_HN Aenvkfdq >= @ijfa ?8%3?%83 _hgf = e` 8>



C$ Qmf Xvf~qied _vfsqe =? ^ffb~ Qe Nfsqi`y I~ Deq H #Nedqsejjidg# Xvf~qied e`

Jhw Hda Sf~ejvqied E` Qmi~ Ai~pvqf Wijj Deq Khqfsihjjy Hahdnf Qmf

Vjqikhqf Qfskidhqied E` Qmi~ Jiqighqied

îkijhsjy* _vfsqe =? mh~ `hijfa qe f~qhcji~m hdeqmfs sfxvisfkfdq e` ^fnqied 8393-c)*

dhkfjy qmhq qmf xvf~qied iq ~ffb~ qe nfsqi`y i~ h #nedqsejjidg# xvf~qied e` jhw* qmf sf~ejvqied e`

wminm wevja khqfsihjjy hahdnf qmf vjqikhqf qfskidhqied e` qmi~ jiqighqied$ H xvf~qied e` h jhw i~

#nedqsejjidg# i` sffs~hj e` qmf ai~qsinq nevsq '~ esafs wevja fiqmfs #qfskidhqf qmf hnqied* es hq h

kidikvk $ $ $ khqfsihjjy h``fnq qmf jiqighqied'~ evqnekf$# Ned~vc Afjhwhsf JJN* 170 @$ ^vpp$

3a hq >?92 hnnesa Bjidgme``fs* 938 @$3a hq 362 Nfdqvsy _hn$* Idn$* 671 @$ ^vpp$ 3a hq >732 ^_J

^mlppidg Jqa$ $ Gvlhshq Nmfkidf} Jqa$* 3??7 WJ 888976>* hq ,3 -^$A$D$Y$ Hps$ 83*3??7)2

Desqm @esb Chdjn $ Hcfj~ed* 3?7 C$S$ >=3* 3=9+9? -F$A$D$Y$ 8997)2 ~ff hj~e ^qevq $ Ijjidei~

@hskfs~ Id~$ Ne* ==3 @$ ^vpp$ 770* 77= -^$A$ Ida$ 8991) -#H nedqsejjidg xvf~qied e`jhw i~ h

qmsf~meja i~~vf wminm ~fsiev~jy h``fnq~ qmf why qmhq qmf nevsq nedavnq~ qmf jiqighqied - t *

ikphnqidg wmfqmfs es deq qmf pjhidqi`` mh~ h nhv~f e` hnqied vdafs h phsqinvjhs ~qhqvqf)$#)$

Kesfefs* h~ nevsq~ id qmi~ Ai~qsinq mhf sfnegdi|fa* #Rh[jqmevgm qfnmdinhjjy qmf xvf~qied e`

wmfqmfs qmfsf i~ h nedqsejjidg i~~vf e` jhw i~ ai~qidnq `sek qmf xvf~qied e`wmfqmfs nfsqiìnhqied

wevja khqfsihjjy hahdnf qmf vjqikhqf qfskidhqied e` qmf jiqighqied* id pshnqinf qmf qwe xvf~qied~

hsf nje~fjy neddfnqfa$# ^fnvsiqif~ hda F}nmhdgf Nekki~~ied $ Nsfaiq Chdbnesp* Jqa$* 8?> @$

^vpp$ 3a 33>* 337 -^$A$D$Y$ 3???) -niqidg Avpjhd Nesp$ p$ ^jhdfs* 698 @$3a 8>9* 81= d$jj -3a

Nis$ 897=))$

Ffd h~~vkidg qmhq qmf ^fneda Nisnviq wfsf qe hd~wfs qmf xvf~qied _vfsqe =? ~ffb~ qe

nfsqi`y id qmf dfghqif* qmhq wevja deq dfnf~~hsijy ai~pe~f e` qmf id~qhdq ès`fiqvsf hnqied$ Qmi~ i~

~e cfnhv~f qmf Gefsdkfdq'~ niij hnqied i~ psfki~fa ed kVjqipjf hda hjqfsdhqif qmfesif~ e`

7




jihcijiqy h~ h ch~i~ ès ès`fiqvsf dhkfjy* aisfnq hda hnnf~~esy jihcijiqy ès nsikidhj nepysigmq

id`sidgfkfdq$ Id qmf ffdq qmi~ Nevsq vjqikhqfjy svjfa qmhq qmf Gefsdkfdq mha deq afked~qshqfa

aisfnq jihcijiqy h~ h ch~i~ ès ès`fiqidg qmf Selhaisfnqh Aekhid Dhkf~* qmhq wevja ~qijj jfhf qmf

yfq vdhd~wfsfa xvf~qied h~ qe wmfqmfs qmf Gefsdkfdq'~ hjjfghqied~ e` hnnf~~esy jihcijiqy nevja

~vppesq ~vnm hnqied$ Qe cf ~vsf* qmi~ Nevsq mh~ deq yfq epidfa ed wmfqmfs qmf Gefsdkfdq'~ niij

hnqied i~ hj~e psepfs ch~fa ed h qmfesy e` hnnf~~esy jihcijiqy$ ^ff Afn$ 0*3?88 Qs$ hq 1? -#Ffd i`

nsikidhj nepysigmq id`sidgfkfdq nhddeq cf ch~fa ed hjjfghqied~ e` 'nedqsicvqesy id`sidgfkfdq' +

hda I ae deq ~e meja + qmf gefsdkfdq'~ hjjfghqied~ hsf ~qijj hafxvhqf$#)$ H~ ~vnm* h sf~ejvqied e`

qmi~ i~~vf wijj deq h~ _vfsqe =? wevja jibf qe ~ff ennvs + dfnf~~hsijy sf~vjq id qmf qfskidhqied e`

qmi~ id sfk hnqied$ Id `hnq* hda xviqf qe qmf nedqshsy* hd idqfsjenvqesy hppfhj hq qmi~ ~qhgf e` qmf

jiqighqied i~ jibfjy edjy qe nsfhqf hd vdlv~qiìfa afjhy* hda qmfsfcy `sv~qshqf _vfsqe =?'~ ~qhqfa

af~isf ès h ~pffay sf~ejvqied e` qmi~ niij hnqied$

N$ _vfsqe =? Mh~ Deq F~qhcji~mfa H ^vc~qhdqihj Gsevda @es Ai``fsfdnf E`

Epidied

Id `hijidg yfq hghid qe ~hqi~`y qmf ~qsidgfdq sfxvisfkfdq~ e` ^fnqied 8393-c)* _vfsqe =? mh~

deq ~v`ìnifdqjy afked~qshqfa h #~vc~qhdqihj gsevda ès ai``fsfdnf e` epidied# id qmi~ khqqfs qe

efsnekf qmf ~qsedg psf~vkpqied hghid~q pifnfkfhj jiqighqied$ Qmf ^fneda Nisnviq mh~ cffd

njfhs qmhq '# Ri[q i~ qmf avqy e` qmf ai~qsinq lvagf $ $ $ qe hdhjy|f qmf ~qsfdgqm e` qmf hsgvkfdq~ id

eppe~iqied qe qmf nmhjjfdgfa svjidg wmfd afniaidg wmfqmfs qmf i~~vf ès hppfhj i~ qsvjy edf ed

wminm qmfsf i~ h ~vc~qhdqihj gsevda ès ai~pvqf$# Id

sf @jes* 79 @$>a3=8*3=1

-3a Nis$ 8990)

-idqfsdhj niqhqied ekiqqfa) -fkpmh~i~ id esigidhj)$ Kesfefs* qmf ^fneda Nisnviq mh~ deqfa qmhq

=

Nh~f 8<88+np+?18>9+_HN Aenvkfdq >= @ijfa ?8%3?%83 _hgf 8? e` 8>



A$ _vfsqe =? Mh~ Deq Afked~qshqfa Qmhq F}nfpqiedhj Nisnvk~qhdnf~ F}i~q Qe

Lv~qi`y _ifnfkfhj Jiqighqied

Qmf jhw i~ njfhs qmhq ai~qsinq nevsq~ mhf cseha ai~nsfqied efs hppjinhqied~ pvs~vhdq qe

^fnqied 8393-c)* hda khy f}fsni~f qmhq ai~nsfqied qe afdy hd hppjinhqied ffd wmfd qmf ~qhqvqf'~

nsiqfsih hsf ~hqi~ ifa$ H~pfd @esa* Idn$ $ @esa Keqes Ne$* 3??= WJ 80>096 hq ,3 -F$A$D$Y$

Lhd$86*3??=)$ Cfnhv~f idqfsjenvqesy hppfhj~ psejedg lvainihj psenffaidg~* haa afjhy hda

f}pfd~f* cvsafd hppfjjhqf nevsq~* hda psf~fdq i~~vf~ ès sfifw ed idnekpjfqf sfnesa~* h nevsq

~mevja gshdq hppjinhqied~ csevgmq vdafs ^fnqied 8393-c) edjy id f}nfpqiedhj nisnvk~qhdnf~$ Id sf

@jes* 79 @$>a 3=8*3=1 -3a Nis$8990)2 Jeqmihd Nh~~iayJJN p$ Shd~ek* 3?8? WJ >707087 hq ,8

-F$A$D$Y$ ^fpq$87* 3?8?)$

_vfsqe =? mh~ hj~e `hijfa qe afked~qshqf qmhq qmi~ nh~f psf~fdq~ qmf sfxvi~iqf #f}nfpqiedhj

nisnvk~qhdnf~# qe whsshdq nfsqiìnhqied$ Qe qmf nedqshsy* qe pfskiq sfifw mfsf i~ qe epfd qmf

`jeeaghqf~ qe h h~q dvkcfs e` hppfhj~ `sek idqfsjenvqesy esafs~ id esaidhsy jiqighqied$ ^vnm h

sf~vjq wevja ned`jinq wiqm qmf jedg+~qhdaidg gfdfshj svjf ai~`hesidg pifnfkfhj jiqighqied$

Kesfefs* hppfhj hq qmi~ ~qhgf e` qmf jiqighqied* cfèsf `vjj affjepkfdq e` qmf `hnq~* wevja

~igdiìnhdqjy vdafskidf qmf hcijiqy e` qmf qsihj hda hppfjjhqf nevsq~ qe `vjjy ned~iafs qmf defj

i~~vf~ psf~fdqfa id qmi~ jiqighqied$ ^ f f * $ t * ^qhqf e` Nhjièsdih $ Mhsifs* 7?? @$3a 8387* 8389

-9qm Nis$ j9=>) -#RW[mfd h jfghj xvf~qied 'mh~ ~fsiev~ ned~fxvfdnf~ hda i~ hd i~~vf vped wminm

qmfsf i~ h aifs~iqy e` epidied~ $$$ Rq[mf affjepkfdqhj psenf~~ cfèsf qmf ai~qsinq nevsq wevja

pseiaf Rqmf nevsqe`

hppfhj~[ wiqm h cfqqfs èvdahqied vped wminm qe khbf Riq~[ afni~ied$'#

-xveqidg Evfnmhd Qsicf $ Sewf* 6>8$@$3a 1?=*183 -9qm Nis$8970) -Whjjhnf* 8$* nednvssidg)))2

Hjjifa _sidnf~~ Chy Ne$ $ Hqenmfk D$ Hk$* Idn$* 8993 WJ 8>63>6* hq ,3 -F$A$D$Y$ Khy 39*

8?




8993) -#RI[dqfsjenvqesy hppfhj i~ nvssfdqjy idhppsepsihqf cfnhv~f qmf `hnq~ e` qmf nh~f mhf deq yfq

`vjjy affjepfa$ Lvainihj fnedeky wevja deq cf hahdnfa cy hppfjjhqf sfifw hq qmi~ qikf$#)$

îkpjy pvq* _vfsqe =? mh~ e``fsfa de nekpfjjidg sfh~ed wmy qmf ^fneda Nisnviq wevja cf vdhcjf

qe sfifw qmi~ i~~vf ed hppfhj èjjewidg fdqsy e` h ìdhj lvagkfdq id qmi~ nh~f h`qfs qmf

affjepkfdq e` h `vjj `hnqvhj sfnesa$ Isiaffa* qmhq wevja cf qmf afniafajy psf`fshcjf nevs~f* hda

i~ wmejjy ned~i~qfdq wiqm qmf ìsk nedgsf~~iedhj pejiny hghid~q idqfsjenvqesy hppfhj~$

NEDNJVÎED

@es qmf èsfgeidg sfh~ed~* _vfsqe =?'~ keqied qe hkfda hda nfsqi`y* pvs~vhdq qe 3= V$^$N$

§ 8393-c)* qmf Nevsq'~ Afnfkcfs 0*3?88 svjidg ed _vfsqe =?'~ keqied qe ai~ki~~ qmf Nekpjhidq

~mevja cf afdifa$

Ahqfa< Dfw Yesb* Dfw Yesb

Lhdvhsy 3?*3?83

Cy<

88

Sf~pfnq`vjjy ~vckiqqfa*

_SFFQCMHSHSH

Vdiqfa ^qhqf~ Hqqesdfy ès qmf

êvqmfsd Ai~qsinq e`Dfw Yesb

Nmsi~qepm sA$ @sfy

Hdasfw A$ Geja~qfid

H~~i~qhdq Vdiqfa ^qhqf~ Hqqesdfy~

Edf ^hidq Hdasfw'~ _jh|h

Dfw Yesb* Dfw Yesb 8???7

Qfj$< -383) 0>7+337?%8669

@h}< -383) 0>7+303?

Nh~f 8<88+np+?18>9+_HN Aenvkfdq >= @ijfa ?8%3?%83 _hgf 8> e` 8>

United States v. Rojadirecta.org and Rojadirecta.com - Government Opposition to Motion to Certify...

Documents

Transcript of United States v. Rojadirecta.org and Rojadirecta.com - Government Opposition to Motion to Certify...