UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF...

99
7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O… http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 1/99 Mppbkaex CRA Cmkagddl Bxjbrpts Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib = df 55

Transcript of UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF...

Page 1: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 1/99

Mppbkaex

CRA Cmkagddl Bxjbrpts

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib = df 55

Page 2: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 2/99

CRA Cmkagddl 1???+1 WBV.=Jcmptbr 7

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 7 df 55

Page 3: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 3/99

JCM_QBW 7+ NDWQIMIBB M__WDVM@

7.= WD@B DF NDWQIMIBB+ Qcb mutcdrety td pmrtejepmtb ek tcb AerbjtBkadrsbnbkt prdirmn es m preve`bib, irmktba dk tcb gmses dfabndkstrmtba qum`efejmtedks, bxpbrebkjb mka bxpbrtesb+ Qcbpreve`bib es nmektmekba gy rbjdnnbkaeki fdr ndrtimib eksurmkjbbkadrsbnbkt dk`y tcdsb ndrtimibs wcejc nbbt CRA iueab`ekbs+ MAerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt ndrtimibb nust jdkaujt ets gusekbssdpbrmtedks ek mjjdramkjb wetc mjjbptba sduka ndrtimib `bkaekiprmjtejbs, btcejs mka stmkamras+

7.7 B@EIEGE@EQU WB]REWBNBKQZ+ Bmjc dffejb df m ndrtimibb #nmekdffejb mka grmkjcbs% nust gb mpprdvba gy tcb CRA Feb`aDffejb#s% td wcejc et ektbkas td sugnet ndrtimibs fdreksurmkjb+ Qcbrb es dkb bxjbptedk td tces ibkbrm` ru`b+ Mndrtimibb wcejc cms gbbk mpprdvba fdr Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt ek mt`bmst dkb CRA Feb`a Dffejb, nmy prdjbss mka sugnet strbmn`ekbrbfekmkjb jmsbs td mky CRA Feb`a Dffejb mftbr kdtefyeki tcbdffejb df ets ektbktedks+ Ztrbmn`ekb rbfekmkjbs mrb absjregba

ek Jcmptbr 1 df CRA Cmkagddl 1=22+=+

Qd gb mpprdvba ms m Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt ndrtimibb, mk mpp`ejmktnust nbbt mka nmektmek tcb fd``dweki rbquerbnbkts8

M+ Nust gb m CRA.mpprdvba ndrtimibb+ Qces ekj`uabs supbrvesbandrtimibbs, kdk.supbrvesba ndrtimibbs mka idvbrknbktm`ekstetutedks+ Ndrtimibbs mpprdvba gy CRA dk`y ms `dmkjdrrbspdkabkts mrb kdt b`eieg`b td gb Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbktndrtimibbs< gut, nmy pmrtejepmtb td tcb `enetba bxtbktabsjregba ek pmrmirmpc 7.=: +

G+ Kdk.supbrvesba ndrtimibbs nust cmvb m kbt wdrtc ek mssbtsmjjbptmg`b td CRA df mt `bmst !72?,???+

J+ Cmvb fevb ybmrs bxpbrebkjb ek tcb dreiekmtedk df seki`bfmne`y ndrtimibs, dr cmvb m prekjepm` dffejbr wetc mnekenun df fevb ybmrs nmkmibrem` bxpbrebkjb ek tcbdreiekmtedk df seki`b fmne`y ndrtimibs+

A+ Cmvb dk stmff mk ukabrwretbr wcd nbbts tcb qum`efejmtedksstmtba ek pmrmirmpc 7.1 df tces jcmptbr mka cmssujjbssfu``y jdnp`btba m Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt trmekekiprdirmn+

B+ Cmvb abvb`dpba mka enp`bnbktba m ]um`ety Jdktrd` _`mk wcejcmjjdnndamtbs tcb dghbjtevbs stmtba ek pmrmirmpc 7.6 df tces

jcmptbr+

F+ Cmvb smtesfmjtdre`y jdnp`btba tcb prb.j`dseki jmsb rbvebwpcmsb df Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt+

5$337.=

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT7.: WB]REWBA ADJRNBKQZ+ Mky dffejb df m ndrtimibb #nmek dr grmkjc%

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib : df 55

Page 4: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 4/99

wcejc ektbkas td sugnet ndrtimibs fdr eksurmkjb bkadrsbnbktnust mpp`y fdr mpprdvm` td tcb CRA Feb`a Dffejb#s% ek tcbhuresaejtedks wcbrb tcby ad gusekbss #sbb bxjbptedk kdtba ekpmrmirmpc 7.7%+ Qcb fd``dweki adjunbkts, ms mpp`ejmg`b, nustgb sugnettba+

M+ Mpp`ejmtedk fdr Mpprdvm`+ Qcb ndrtimibb es td jdnp`btbFdrn CRA.21==7, Mpp`ejmtedk fdr Mpprdvm` Ms AerbjtBkadrsbnbkt Ndrtimibb mka Kdnekmtedk df Rkabrwreteki_brsdkkb` #Mppbkaex =%+ Qcb ferst pmrt jdkjbrks gmsejndrtimibb b`eiege`ety, ekj`uaeki qum`efyeki stmtus mkaseki`b fmne`y dreiekmtedk bxpbrebkjb+ Ef tcb ndrtimibb#kdt kbjbssmre`y tcb pmrteju`mr grmkjc% cms kdt cma fevbybmrs seki`b fmne`y dreiekmtedk bxpbrebkjb, tcb mpp`ejmtedknust gb jdnp`btba td scdw sujc bxpbrebkjb gy prekjepm`dffejbrs+

G+ ]um`ety Jdktrd` _`mk+ M jdpy df tcb ]um`ety Jdktrd` _`mk+

J+ Kdnekmtedk mka Wbsunb df Rkabrwretbr+ Bmjc mpp`ejmtedk fdr

ndrtimibb mpprdvm` es td ekj`uab m kdnekmtedk df tcbekaeveaum`#s% td sbrvb ms tcb ndrtimibb)s ukabrwretbr#s%+

Qcb kdnekmtedk ekj`uabs m vbrefejmtedk gy tcb _rbseabkt drVejb _rbseabkt #dr dtcbr mutcdrezba jdrpdrmtb dffejbr% tcmttcb kdnekbb cms tcb mutcdrety td geka tcb jdrpdrmtedk mkatcb kdnekbb cms gbbk fduka td nbbt tcb qum`efejmtedks dfpmrmirmpc 7.1 df tces Jcmptbr+

M rbsunb nust gb sugnettba fdr bmjc ukabrwretbr kdnekmtba+Fdrn CRA.5726:, Mpp`ejmtedk fdr Fbb _brsdkkb` Abseikmtedk,nmy gb usba ek `ebu df m rbsunb+ Ycbtcbr tcb rbsunb dr CRAfdrn es usba, ekfdrnmtedk prdveaba nust j`bmr`y scdw tcmttcb kdnekbb nbbts tcb qum`efejmtedks df pmrmirmpc 7.1 dftces Jcmptbr+

A+ Kdnekmtedks mka Wbsunbs df Qbjckejm` _brsdkkb`+ Ms pmrt dftcb mpp`ejmtedk, tcb ndrtimibb es td mavesb CRA wcbtcbr drkdt ndrtimibb stmff we`` gb usba td pbrfdrn mpprmesm`s,ekspbjtedks mka ndrtimib jrbaet mkm`ysbs+ Ms wetc tcbukabrwretbr, m rbsunb dr Fdrn CRA.5726: es td gb sugnettbafdr bmjc kdnekbb+ Qcb rbsunb dr tcb Fdrn CRA.5726: nustj`bmr`y scdw tcmt tcb tbjckejemk nbbts tcb mpp`ejmg`bqum`efejmtedks df pmrmirmpc 7.9 df tces Jcmptbr+ Ycbkuseki m rbsunb, ekj`uab tcb ekfdrnmtedk rbquerba dk FdrnCRA.5726:+ Qcmt fdrn es mppbkaba td CRA Cmkagddl 1?7?+=+

B+ Rsb df Fdrn CRA.5726:, Mpp`ejmtedk fdr Fbb _brsdkkb`Abseikmtedk+ Ycbk useki Fdrn CRA.5726: td qum`efypbrsdkkb`, tcb fdrn nmy gb ndaefeba+ Etbns =1, =2, 77 mka71 nmy gb ab`btba+ Ek etbn 7:, jbrtefejmtedks m, g mka jnmy gb ab`btba+ Ef gbeki usba fdr tcb mpprdvm` df mkukabrwretbr, tcb tdp df tcb fdrn scdu`a gb sd kdtba+

5$337.7

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 1 df 55

Page 5: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 5/99

1???+1 WBV.=JCI.7

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

#7.:%F+ Bveabkjb df _redr CRA Mpprdvm`+ Dkjb dkb dffejb df m ndrtimibb

cms gbbk mpprdvba gy m CRA Feb`a Dffejb, bveabkjb df tcmtmpprdvm` we`` fmje`etmtb sugsbqubkt mpprdvm` td ad gusekbss ekdtcbr CRA dffejbs+ Zene`mr`y, ef ndrtimibb tbjckejm` stmffektbka td qum`efy wetc ndrb tcmk dkb CRA Feb`a Dffejb, dkjb tcbferst mpprdvm` cms gbbk dgtmekba, bveabkjb df tcb mpprdvm` we``fmje`etmtb sugsbqubkt mpprdvm`s+ Ef m Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbktukabrwretbr cms m`rbmay gbbk mpprdvba gy dkb CRA Feb`a Dffejb,tcb Abpmrtnbkt we`` irmkt mutdnmtej mpprdvm` df tcb ukabrwretbrek mky CRA Feb`a Dffejb wcbrb tcb `bkabr es mpprdvba td adgusekbss+

=% Ndrtimibb Mpprdvm`+ Bmjc sugsbqubkt mpp`ejmtedk nust

ekj`uab mk bxbjutba mpp`ejmtedk fdrn #Mppbkaex =% ekmaaetedk td m jdpy df tcb mpprdvm` `bttbr frdn mkdtcbr CRAFeb`a Dffejb+

7% Rkabrwretbr Mpprdvm`+ JCRNZ we`` rbjdikezb mkyukabrwretbr)s mpprdvm` ek m`` CRA dffejbs+ Dkjb mkukabrwretbr cms dgtmekba mpprdvm` mka m JCRNZ eabktefejmtedkkungbr, et we`` gb mutdnmtejm``y rbjdikezba ek bmjc Feb`aDffejb wcbrb m `bkabr cms gbbk mpprdvba td ad gusekbss+

:% Qbjckejemk Mpprdvm`+ M jdpy df mkdtcbr dffejb)s `bttbrmpprdveki tcb mpprmesbr dr ekspbjtdr scdu`a gb sugnettbawetc tcb mpp`ejmtedk fdrn+

7.1 RKABWYWEQBW+ Qcb ndrtimibb nust cmvb dk stmff m fu``.tenb bnp`dybb tdsbrvb ms ukabrwretbr+ Qcb ukabrwretbr nust gb m jdrpdrmtb dffejbrwetc seikmtdry mutcdrety dr dtcbrwesb mutcdrezba td geka tcb ndrtimibbek nmttbrs ekvd`veki tcb dreiekmtedk df ndrtimib `dmks+ Qcbukabrwretbr nmy gb bnp`dyba gy dk`y dkb ndrtimibb, mka tces fukjtedknmy kdt gb jdktrmjtba dut gy tcb dreiekmteki ndrtimibb+ Qcbukabrwretbr nust nbbt tcb qum`efejmtedks mka mssunb tcbrbspdksege`etebs wcejc fd``dw+

M+ ]um`efejmtedks+

=% Ibkbrm`+ Qcb ukabrwretbr nust gb m rb`emg`b mka rbspdkseg`bprdfbssedkm` sle``ba ek ndrtimib bvm`umtedk+ Qcb

ukabrwretbr nust gb mg`b td abndkstrmtb ces dr cbr lkdw`baibmka bxpbrebkjb rbimraeki tcb prekjep`bs df ndrtimibukabrwreteki+

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

7.:

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT1???+1 WBV.=

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 2 df 55

Page 6: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 6/99

JCI.7

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

#7.1M+%7% @djmtedk df Rkabrwretbr+ CRA cms kd rbquerbnbkt rbimraeki

tcb `djmtedk df tcb ukabrwretbr #e+b+ nmek dffejb dr grmkjcdffejb%+

:% Bxpbrebkjb+ Qcb ukabrwretbr nust cmvb m nekenun df tcrbbybmrs fu``.tenb rbjbkt bxpbrebkjb #dr bquevm`bkt bxpbrebkjb%rbvebweki gdtc jrbaet mpp`ejmtedks mka prdpbrty mpprmesm`s+Bxpbrebkjb rb`mtba sd`b`y td ndrtimib jrbaet dr mpprmesm`rbvebw jdukts fdr dkb.cm`f df tcb tdtm` rbquerbnbkt+

Qces bxpbrebkjb scdu`a cmvb gbbk wetc mk ekstetutedkm` ekvbstdrdreiekmteki fdr ets dwk pdrtfd`ed dr purjcmseki tcbsb typbs dfndrtimib `dmks, dr wetc mk dreiekmtdr sb``eki tcbsb typbs dfndrtimib `dmks td ekvbstdrs+ Bxpbrebkjb nmy m`sd ekj`uab qum`etyjdktrd` rbvebws fdr ekvbstdrs, btj+

Qcb Ndrtimib Gmklbrs Mssdjemtedk df Mnbrejm #NGM% jdursb'Mpprmesm` Qbjckequbs fdr Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt Rkabrwretbrs'nmy gb sugstetutba fdr dkb fu`` ybmr df fu``.tenb bxpbrebkjbrbvebweki mpprmesm`s+

Qcb kdnekbb)s rbsunb nust ievb abtme`ba absjreptedks df hdgbxpbrebkjbs tcmt abndkstrmtb lkdw`baib df prekjep`bs,prmjtejbs, mka tbjckequbs df ndrtimib ukabrwreteki,ekj`uaeki8 #=% rbm` bstmtb mpprmesm`, #7% ndrtimib jrbaetbvm`umtedks, #:% fmjtdrs mffbjteki prdpbrty vm`ubs mka rbm`bstmtb trbkas+

G+ Feb`a Dffejb Wbvebw df Rkabrwretbr ]um`efejmtedks+ Bmjcukabrwretbr)s jrbabktem`s nust gb mkm`yzba mka tcb ukabrwretbrmpprdvba ek mt `bmst dkb CRA Feb`a Dffejb wcbrb tcb `bkabr esmpprdvba td ad gusekbss wetc tcb Abpmrtnbkt+ Qcb Feb`a Dffejbnust abtbrnekb tcmt tcb ukabrwretbr cms tcb bxpbrebkjb mka dtcbrqum`efejmtedks ms rbquerba mgdvb+ Qcb Feb`a Dffejb nust jdktmjtrbfbrbkjbs, fdrnbr bnp`dybrs, btj+, td abtbrnekb tcb vm`eaety dftcb ukabrwretbr)s bxpbrebkjb j`mens+ Ef tcb ukabrwretbr)sbxpbrebkjb ekj`uabs mavmkjba baujmtedk, ekj`uaeki jd``bib.`bvb`jdursbs dr spbjem`ezba trmekeki frdn prdveabrs sujc ms tcbNdrtimib Gmklbrs Mssdjemtedk dr dtcbr CRA Feb`a Dffejbs, tcbmpprdveki Feb`a Dffejb nmy rbquerb vbrefejmtedk tcmt tcbukabrwretbr sujjbssfu``y jdnp`btba tcb jdursb#s%+ Qcb Feb`aDffejb nmy m`sd rbqubst m prb.mpprdvm` nbbteki wetc tcb

ukabrwretbr, bspbjem``y ef tcbrb es mky ukjbrtmekty rbimraekibxpbrebkjb dr bxpbrtesb+

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

7.1

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT1???+1 WBV.=

JCI.7

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 6 df 55

Page 7: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 7/99

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

#7.1G+%Ek maaetedk, tcb CRA Feb`a Dffejb rbvebwbr nust jcbjl td nmlbsurb tcmt tcb ukabrwretbr cms kdt cma smkjtedks tmlbk mimekst cendr cbr dr dtcbrwesb gb `estba dk CRA)s Zuspbkaba mka Abgmrnbkt`est, @enetba Abkem` df _mrtejepmtedk @est, dr mppbmr dk CRA)Jrbaet M`brt Ektbrmjtevb Vdejb Wbspdksb Zystbn+

J+ Wbspdksege`etebs+ CRA `ddls td tcb ukabrwretbr ms tcb fdjm`pdekt df tcb Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt prdirmn+ Qcb ukabrwretbr nustmssunb tcb fd``dweki rbspdksege`etebs+

=% Jdnp`emkjb wetc CRA ekstrujtedks, tcb jddraekmtedk df m``pcmsbs df ukabrwreteki, mka tcb qum`ety df abjesedks nmabukabr tcb prdirmn+

7% Qcb rbvebw df mpprmesm` rbpdrts, jdnp`emkjb ekspbjtedks mkajrbaet mkm`ysbs pbrfdrnba gy fbb mka stmff pbrsdkkb` td

bksurb rbmsdkmg`b jdkj`usedks, sduka rbpdrts mka jdnp`emkjbwetc CRA rbquerbnbkts+

:% Qcb abjesedks rb`mteki td tcb mjjbptmge`ety df tcbmpprmesm`, tcb ekspbjtedks, tcb guybrs jmpmjety td rbpmy tcbndrtimib mka tcb dvbrm`` mjjbptmge`ety df tcb ndrtimib `dmkfdr CRA eksurmkjb+

1% Qcb ndketdreki mka bvm`umtedk df tcb pbrfdrnmkjb df fbb mkastmff pbrsdkkb` usba fdr tcb Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt prdirmn+

2% Mwmrbkbss df tcb wmrkeki seiks tcmt nmy ekaejmtberrbiu`mretebs, mka mk mge`ety td abtbjt frmua, ms wb`` mstcb rbspdksege`ety tcmt ukabrwreteki abjesedks mrb pbrfdrnbawetc aub ae`eibkjb ek m pruabkt nmkkbr+

7.2 RKABWYWEQEKI _WDJBARWBZ+ Qcb ukabrwretbr)s rd`b mka rbspdksege`etymrb jretejm` b`bnbkts df tcb Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt prdirmn+

Qcb ukabrwretbr bxbjutbs tcb Rkabrwretbr Jbrtefejmtedk wcejc bkmg`bsCRA td bkadrsb tcb ndrtimib `dmk wetcdut m abtme`ba tbjckejm`ukabrwreteki rbvebw+ Qcb ukabrwretbr jbrtefebs tcmt cb cms pbrsdkm``yrbvebwba tcb mpp`ejmtedk adjunbkts mka fekas jdnp`emkjb wetc tcbmpp`ejmg`b rbquerbnbkts+ Dkb df tcb ukabrwretbr)s rbspdksege`etebs,ms stmtba ek tcb prbvedus pmrmirmpc, es tcb jddraekmtedk df m`` pcmsbsdf tcb ukabrwreteki df tcb ndrtimib `dmk+ Qces rd`b bkmg`bs tcbukabrwretbr td bksurb tcmt pruabkt ukabrwreteki prdjbaurbs mrb

fd``dwba+

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

7.2

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT1???+1 WBV.=

JCI.7

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 9 df 55

Page 8: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 8/99

CRA Cmkagddl 1???+1, Mppbkaex :+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 3 df 55

Page 9: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 9/99

M__BKAES :

RKABWYWEQBW JBWQEFEJMQEDK

Qcb ukabrwretbr bxbjuteki fdrn CRA.21==: cms pbrsdkm``y rbvebwbatcb mpprmesm` rbpdrt #ef mpp`ejmg`b% mka jrbaet mpp`ejmtedk, ekj`uaeki tcbmkm`yses pbrfdrnba dk tcb ndrtimib jrbaet mkm`yses wdrlscbbt, mkajbrtefebs, fdr mka dk gbcm`f df tcb ndrtimibb, tcmt tcb ndrtimib jdnp`ebswetc CRA ukabrwreteki rbquerbnbkts ms jdktmekba ek m`` dutstmkaeki CRAcmkagddls mka Ndrtimibb @bttbrs, mka es ek jdnp`emkjb wetc tcb mpp`ejmg`brbiu`mtedks absjregba gb`dw+ Qcb ndrtimib `dmk es b`eieg`b fdr ndrtimibeksurmkjb ukabr tcb Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt prdirmn+ Qces ukabrwretbrjbrtefejmtedk es ek maaetedk td mky jbrtefejmtedks rbquerba df tcbndrtimibb, tcb ndrtimidr, dr gdtc dk fdrn CRA.575??.M+ Ef m rbquerbnbktfrdn 71 JFW _mrt 7?: es ekjdrpdrmtba ek m aeffbrbkt rbiu`mtedk gyjrdss.rbfbrbkjb #b+i+, 7?:+1? ek Jbrtefejmtedk = es jrdss.rbfbrbkjba ek77=+=%, m rbfbrbkjb td tcb _mrt 7?: rbquerbnbkt ek m jbrtefejmtedk scm``

m`sd gb abbnba m rbfbrbkjb td bmjc ekstmkjb wcbrb tcb rbquerbnbkt esekjdrpdrmtba gy jrdss.rbfbrbkjb+ Bmjc df tcb gb`dw.`estba jbrtefejmtedks

mpp`y td tcb `dmk sugnettba fdr bkadrsbnbkt, bxjbpt td tcb bxtbkt tcbjbrtefejmtedk etsb`f abfekbs tcb setumtedk td wcejc et mpp`ebs+

#=% Qcb ndrtimiba prdpbrty es `djmtba ek m jdnnukety wcbrb tcb cdusekistmkamras mka `djmtedk nbbt tcb rbquerbnbkts df 71 JFW 7?:+1? dr7:1+6: #jdkadnekeuns%+

#7% Qcbrb es `djmtba dk tcb ndrtimiba prdpbrty m awb``eki uket abseikbaprekjepm``y fdr rbseabktem` usb fdr kdt ndrb tcmk fdur fmne`ebs, msrbquerba gy 71 JFW 7?:+:3, dr fdr b`bvbk fmne`ebs ef 77?+7? esmpp`ejmg`b+

#:% Qcb ndrtimib es bxbjutba gy m ndrtimidr wcd es td djjupy tcb awb``ekims m prekjepm` rbseabkjb #ms absjregba ek 71 JFW 7?:+=3#f%#=% dr7:1+79#b%#=%% dr, ef tcb ndrtimidr es m kdk.djjupmkt, tcb ndrtimidres b`eieg`b ukabr 71 JFW 7?:+=3#f%#:%, 7:1+79#b%#:%, dr es purjcmsekitcb awb``eki frdn CRA+

#1% Qcb ndrtimidr)s ndktc`y ndrtimib pmynbkts we`` kdt gb ek bxjbss dfces dr cbr rbmsdkmg`b mge`ety td pmy, ms rbquerba betcbr ukabr 71JFW 7?:+7=, 7?:+12#a% #I_Ns%, 7?:+19#m% #IBNs%, 77?+=, dr7:1+:6 #jdkadnekeuns%+

#2% Qcb ndrtimidr)s ekjdnb es mka we`` gb mabqumtb td nbbt tcb pbredaejpmynbkts rbquerba td mndrtezb tcb ndrtimib sugnettba fdr eksurmkjb,ms rbquerba ukabr 71 JFW 7?:+::, dr 7:1+26 #jdkadnekeuns%+

#6% Qcb ndrtimidr)s ibkbrm` jrbaet stmkaeki es smtesfmjtdry, ms rbquerbaukabr 71 JFW 7?:+:1, dr 7:1+29+

_mib =

=7$57

TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

#9% Qcb gue`aekis dk tcb prdpbrty sbjurba gy tcb ndrtimib jdnp`y wetc

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 5 df 55

Page 10: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 10/99

7?:+=9#b% mka prdpbrty stmkamras essuba gy CRA ms rbquerba gy tcbmpp`ejmg`b prdvesedks df 71 JFW pmrt 7??, sugpmrt Z, fdr prdpdsbajdkstrujtedk, mka 7?:+:5, 7?:+2?#a% #ef m Zbjtedk 7?:#l%ndrtimib%, 77?+=2 #urgmk rbkbwm`%, 7:1+72#a% #ef m jdkadnekeunuket% dr tcb stmkamras sbt fdrtc ek CRA cmkagddl 15?2+= fdrbxesteki jdkstrujtedk ms mpp`ejmg`b+

#3% Ek jmsbs wcbrb tcb ndrtimiba prdpbrty es sughbjt td m hukedrndrtimib dr `ebk, tcb mpp`ejmg`b rbquerbnbkts df 71 JFW 7?:+:7#g%,#j% dr #a%, dr 7:1+22#g%, #j% dr #a% #jdkadnekeuns%, mrb nbt+

#5% Fdr m jdkadnekeun uket, tcb ndrtimiba prdpbrty es ek m prdhbjt tcmtcms gbbk mpprdvba gy CRA mka m`` dtcbr rbquerbnbkts ukabr 71 JFW7:1+76 mrb nbt+

#=?% Ek tcb jmsb df prdpdsba dr kbw jdkstrujtedk ek m kbw sugaevesedk,tcb prdpbrty jdvbrba gy tcb mpp`ejmtedk fdr eksurmkjb nbbts tcbrbquerbnbkts df 71 JFW 7?:+=7+

#==% Qcb prdpbrty jdvbrba gy tcb ndrtimib es kdt `djmtba ek mk mrbm tcmt

es prbj`uaba frdn rbjbeveki Fbabrm` fekmkjem` mssestmkjb pursumkt tdtcb Jdmstm` Gmrrebr Wbsdurjbs Mjt #_ug+ @+ 59.:15%+

#=7% Ef tcb ndrtimib `dmk es fdr rbcmge`etmtedk ukabr Zbjtedk 7?:#l%,tcb ndrtimib m`sd nbbts tcb rbquerbnbkts df 7?:+2?#j% #awb``ekimt `bmst dkb ybmr d`a%, 7?:+2?#a%#7% #nbbts bkbriy jdksbrvmtedkstmkamras%, mka 7?:+2?#b% #es mk mjjbptmg`b resl%+

#=:% Ef tcb prdpbrty es `djmtba ek mk d`abr abj`ekeki urgmk mrbm mka estd gb eksurba ukabr Zbjtedk 77:#b% df Kmtedkm` Cduseki Mjt, et m`sdnbbts tcb maaetedkm` rbquerbnbkts df 71 JFW 7?:+1:m+

Z_BJEFEJ JBWQEFEJMQEDKZ FDW ZBJQEDK 7:2#r% NDWQIMIBZ+ Qcbjbrtefejmtedks jdktmekba ek Etbns #=% tcrduic #=:% ad kdt mpp`y tdndrtimibs eksurba ukabr Zbjtedk 7:2#r%+ Qcb jbrtefejmtedks wcejc admpp`y mrb tcb fd``dweki8

#=1% Qcb ndrtimidr nbbts m`` tcb b`eiege`ety rbquerbnbkts df 71 JFW7:2+=7?7#g%#6%#e% tcrduic #veee%+

#=2% Qcb ndktc`y pmynbkts df prekjepm` mka ektbrbst mt tcb 7:2#r% ektbrbstrmtb dk tcb ndrtimib sugnettba fdr eksurmkjb mrb `bss tcmk tcbndktc`y pmynbkts df prekjepm` mka ektbrbst dk tcb ndrtimib gbekirbfekmkjba+

#=6% Qcb jdnputmtedk df tcb mndukt df mssestmkjb pmynbkts wcejc tcbZbjrbtmry we`` pmy dk gbcm`f df tcb ndrtimidr wms jdnputba ek

mjjdramkjb wetc tcb fdrnu`m jdktmekba ek 71 JFW 7:2+=7=?#m%+

_mib 7

=7$57

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib =? df 55

Page 11: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 11/99

CRA Cmkagddl 1?6?+= Wbv.=Jcmptbr 6

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib == df 55

Page 12: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 12/99

JCM_QBW 6JCMKIBZ ZRGZB]RBKQ QD M__WDVM@

6.= Wbpdrteki Gusekbss Jcmkibs+ M ndrtimibb es rbquerba td kdtefy tcbAbpmrtnbkt wetcek m spbjefeba kungbr df gusekbss amys df mky gusekbssjcmkib tcmt mffbjts ets stmkaeki ms mk mpprdvba ekstetutedk, dr wcejc jcmkibstcb ekfdrnmtedk dk wcejc et wms dreiekm``y mpprdvba+ Ibkbrm``y,kdtefejmtedk jdksests df m `bttbr td FCM, seikba gy mk bxbjutevb dffejbr dftcb ndrtimibb+ Jbrtmek jcmkibs nmy rbquerb maaetedkm` adjunbktmtedk+Qcb kdtejb nust gb sbkt dr fmxba td tcb Aerbjtdr, @bkabr Mpprdvm` mkaWbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk+ Fme`urb td kdtefy CRA nmy `bma td prdjbssekiab`mys dr smkjtedks gy tcb Ndrtimibb Wbvebw Gdmra+

Qypb df JcmkibAmys_mrmirmpcJcmkib df cdnb dffejb `djmtedk dr tb`bpcdkb kungbr=?6&*37?5<7Jcmkib df grmkjc dffejb `djmtedk dr tb`bpcdkb kungbr=?6&*37?5<:Qbrnekmtedk df _rekjepm`. Mutcdrezba Mibkt Wb`mtedkscep=?6&*37?5<1Qbrnekmtedk df @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt.Zpdksdr Mirbbnbkt=?6&*37?5<2_brnessedk fdr Zupbrvesba @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt td sbrvejbYcbk Mpprdvm`

Wbquerba6&*37?5<6Jcmkib df Fesjm` Ubmr=?6&*37?5<9Jcmkib df kmnb=?6&*37?5<3Jcmkibs td 'Adeki Gusekbss Ms' #'agm'% kmnb=?6&*37?5<5@dss df AB ukabrwretbrEnnbaemtb6&*37?5<=?Jcmkib df sbkedr dffejbr=?6&*37?5<==Jcmkibs ek m pmrtkbrscepEnnbaemtb6.=7Jcmkib df scmrbcd`abr, dwkbrscep, dr jdktrd`=?6&*37?5<=:Jcmkibs ek jcmrtbr dr Fbabrm` Qmxpmybr EA Kungbr=?6&*37?5<=1Jcmkib ek jcmrmjtbr df gusekbss #prekjepm` mjtevety%=?6&*37?5<=2Jdkvbrsedk df ndrtimibb typbYcbk Mpprdvm` Wbquerba6&*37?5<=6Qypb df JcmkibAmys_mrmirmpcNbribr dr jdksd`eamtedk=?6&*37?5<=9Zm`b dr mjquesetedk=?6&*37?5<=3Qbrnekmtedk df Zupbrvesedk=?6&*37?5<=5Qbrnekmtedk df feab`ety gdka dr B&D eksurmkjb=?6&*37?5<7?Kbt Ydrtc Abfejebkjy:?6&*37?5<7=@equea Mssbts Abfejebkjy:?6&*37?5<77Dpbrmteki `dss:?6&*37?5<7:Gmklruptjy dr `equeamtedk:?6&*37?5<71Vd`uktmry wetcarmwm`k$m6.72M`` dtcbr gusekbss jcmkibs=?6&*37?5<76

6.7 Jcmkib df Cdnb Dffejb @djmtedk dr Qb`bpcdkb Kungbr+ QcbAbpmrtnbkt nmektmeks tcb fd``dweki maarbssbs fdr tcb cdnb dffejb df mndrtimibb8

( Ibdirmpcej Maarbss, Maarbss wcbrb tcb dffejb es pcysejm``y `djmtba<( Nme`eki Maarbss, Maarbss td wcejc CRA jdrrbspdkabkjb es sbkt<( _rbneun Maarbss, Maarbss df tcb dffejb td wcejc prbneuns mrb td gbge``ba<( _mybb Maarbss, Maarbss es usba td nme` Mavejb df _mynbkt `bttbrs<( Jdkaetedkm` mka Fern Jdnnetnbkt #JCRNZ% Maarbss, Maarbss CRAwe`` usb td jdkaujt gusekbss rb`mteki td mpp`ejmtedks fdr eksurmkjb< mka( Bkadrsbnbkt Maarbss, Maarbss td wcejc tcb jdkfernmtedk we`` gb sbkt dfpmynbkt df tcb ñdkb.tenbö ndrtimib eksurmkjb prbneun+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib =7 df 55

Page 13: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 13/99

M+ Maarbss Jcmkibs+ Ndrtimibbs upamtb m`` df tcber maarbssbs vem tcberFCM Jdkkbjtedk mjjdukt+ Cdwbvbr, tcby nmy kdt jcmkib tcb ñZtmtbö pmrtdf tcb Ibdirmpcej Maarbss df tcb cdnb dffejb+ Ef mk dffejb cms rb`djmtba tdm aeffbrbkt Ztmtb, tcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet m rbqubst td tcb @bkabrMpprdvm` mka Wbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk td upamtb tcb maarbss+ M ndrtimibbwcdsb maarbss ek ekjdrrbjt fdr ab`evbry df ets FCM JdkkbjtedkJddraekmtdrÆs rbiestrmtedk ekfdrnmtedk, scdu`a sugnet m rbqubst fdrjdrrbjtedk td tcb @bkabr Mpprdvm` mka Wbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk+

G+ Qb`bpcdkb mka Fmx Kungbrs mka Bnme` Maarbss+ Gbjmusb FCMdftbk cms m kbba td jdktmjt ndrtimibbs gy tb`bpcdkb dr fmx dr gy bnme`, mndrtimibb nust upamtb tces ekfdrnmtedk tcrduic tcb @bkabr Mpprdvm`fukjtedks df tcb FCM Jdkkbjtedk+ Qcb kungbrs mrb m`sd aesp`myba dksbmrjcmg`b `ests df FCM mpprdvba ndrtimibbs dk CRAÆs wbg setb+

6.: Jcmkib df Grmkjc Dffejb @djmtedk dr Qb`bpcdkb Kungbr+

M+ Yetcek tcb Zmnb Ztmtb+ Qcb ndrtimibb nust upamtb tcb maarbssbsfdr bmjc grmkjc tcrduic tcb @bkabr Mpprdvm` fukjtedks ukabr tcb FCMJdkkbjtedk+

G+ Qd Mkdtcbr Ztmtb+ M ndrtimibb jmkkdt jcmkib tcb ñZtmtbö pmrt dftcb Ibdirmpcej Maarbss df m grmkjc dffejb+ Ef mk dffejb cms rb`djmtba td maeffbrbkt Ztmtb, tcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet m rbqubst td tcb @bkabrMpprdvm` mka Wbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk td upamtb tcb maarbss+

6.1 Qbrnekmtedk df _rekjepm`.Mutcdrezba Mibkt Wb`mtedkscep+ Ef m_rekjepm`$Mutcdrezba Mibkt rb`mtedkscep es tbrnekmtba gy betcbr pmrty, tcbkbetcbr pmrty nust m`sd tbrnekmtb tcb rb`mtedkscep ek FCMÆs systbns vem tcb@bkabr Mpprdvm` fukjtedks ukabr tcb FCM Jdkkbjtedk+

6.2 Qbrnekmtedk df @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt.Zpdksdr Wb`mtedkscep+ Ef m`dmk jdrrbspdkabkt$spdksdr rb`mtedkscep es tbrnekmtba gy betcbr pmrty, tcbkbetcbr pmrty nust m`sd tbrnekmtb tcb rb`mtedkscep ek FCMÆs systbns vem tcb@bkabr Mpprdvm` fukjtedks ukabr tcb FCM Jdkkbjtedk+ Gbjmusb m `dmkjdrrbspdkabkt nust cmvb mt `bmst dkb spdksdr, `dss df m`` spdksdrs esirdukas fdr FCM td wetcarmw tcb `dmk jdrrbspdkabkt)s mpprdvm`+ Ek sujcjmsbs, tcb `dmk jdrrbspdkabkt cms :? amys td bstmg`esc m rb`mtedkscep wetc mt`bmst dkb kbw spdksdr+ Ef tcb `dmk jdrrbspdkabkt fme`s td bstmg`esc m kbwZpdksdr rb`mtedkscep, tcbk ets FCM mpprdvm` we`` gb wetcarmwk+

6.6 _brnessedk fdr Zupbrvesba @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt td Zbrvejb+ Rpdkmpp`ejmtedk td tcb Abpmrtnbkt, m supbrvesba `dmk jdrrbspdkabkt nmy gbirmktba pbrnessedk td sbrvejb ets dwk FCM.eksurba ndrtimibs+ Qcbñmpp`ejmtedkö jdksests df m `bttbr td tcb @bkabr Mpprdvm` mka WbjbrtefejmtedkAevesedk+ Ibkbrm``y, pbrnessedk es irmktba dk`y wcbk tcb ndrtimibb cmsjdkvbrtba frdn m supbrvesba ndrtimibb mka cms mk dutstmkaeki pdrtfd`ed df

FCM.eksurba ndrtimibs+

6.9 Jcmkib df Fesjm` Ubmr+ M ndrtimibb es m``dwba td jcmkib ets fesjm`ybmr+ Qcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet m wrettbk rbqubst td tcb @bkabr Mpprdvm`mka Wbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk+ CRA nmy, mt ets aesjrbtedk, rbquerb tcbndrtimibb td sugnet fekmkjem` stmtbnbkts mka m jdnputmtedk df mahustba kbtwdrtc jbrtefeba gy ets nmkmibnbkt+ Qces rbquerbnbkt abpbkas dk tcb `bkitcdf tenb sekjb tcb ndrtimibb `mst sugnettba muaetba fekmkjem` stmtbnbkts tdtcb Abpmrtnbkt+ Bvbry pbreda nust bvbktum``y gb muaetba+ Ek kd jmsb nmyndrb tcmk =3 ndktcs b`mpsb gbtwbbk tcb amtbs df muaetba fekmkjem`

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib =: df 55

Page 14: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 14/99

stmtbnbkts+

6.3 Jcmkib df @bim` Kmnb+ Fdr m jcmkib df kmnb, m ndrtimibb nustsugnet tcb fd``dweki td tcb @bkabr Mpprdvm` mka Wbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk

M+ Mjjbptmg`b adjunbktmtedk scdweki tcb kmnb jcmkib, sujc ms8

( Qcb mnbkanbkt td ets mrtej`bs df ekjdrpdrmtedk<( Wbsd`utedk gy tcb ndrtimibb)s Gdmra df Aerbjtdrs< mka( Jcmrtbr mnbkanbkt fdr m supbrvesba ekstetutedk+

G+ Ycbk rbquerba gy tcb Ztmtb, bveabkjb tcmt tcb kmnb jcmkib cms gbbkmjjbptba gy tcb Ztmtb ek wcejc tcb cdnb dffejb es `djmtba+

6.5 Jcmkibs td ñAdeki Gusekbss Msö #agm% Kmnb+ M ndrtimibbsnmlbs jcmkibs td ets ñadeki gusekbss msö tcrduic tcb FCM Jdkkbjtedk mkajbrtefy et cms tcb mpprdpremtb mpprdvm` td usb tcb agm kmnb+ M`tcduic mndrtimibb nmy cmvb ndrb tcmk dkb ñagm,ö bmjc cdnb dr grmkjc dffejb es`enetba td dkb ñagmö kmnb ek tcb FCM Jdkkbjtedk+ Zbb pmrmirmpc 7.1,rbimraeki kmnbs ekj`uaeki rbstrejtba wdras sujc ms ñkmtedkm`ö dr

ñFbabrm`+ö

6.=? @dss df Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt Rkabrwretbr+ Ef m ndrtimibb wetcAerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt #AB% mutcdrety `dsbs ets dk`y AB ukabrwretbr, et nustennbaemtb`y dgtmek mka rbiestbr m qum`efeba rbp`mjbnbkt+ Yetcdut mrbiestbrba AB ukabrwretbr, tcb ndrtimibb we`` gb ukmg`b td ukabrwretb FCMndrtimibs+ Ef et es ukmg`b td dgtmek mka rbiestbr m rbp`mjbnbkt, tcbk tcbndrtimibb nust betcbr bktbr ektd m _rekjepm`.Mutcdrezba Mibkt rb`mtedkscepdr jdkvbrt td `dmk jdrrbspdkabkt stmtus+ Fdr _rekjepm`.Mutcdrezba Mibkts,sbb jcmptbr 2 _mrt G+ Fdr jdkvbrsedk, sbb pmrmirmpc 6 =6+

6.== Jcmkib df Zbkedr Dffejbr+ Ef m ndrtimibb cms mk maaetedk drsugstetutedk df m prekjepm`, ekj`uaeki gut kdt `enetba td jcmernmk df tcbgdmra, prbseabkt, vejb prbseabkt, aerbjtdr, dr @@J nbngbr, tcb ndrtimibbnust kdtefy CRA df tcb jcmkib+ M Wbseabktem` Ndrtimib Jrbaet Wbpdrtnust gb sugnettba dk tcb kbw ekaeveaum`+ M supbrvesba ndrtimibb drsupbrvesba `dmk jdrrbspdkabkt adbs kdt cmvb td jdnp`y wetc tcb jrbaetrbpdrt rbquerbnbkt+

6.=7 Jcmkib ek m _mrtkbrscep+ Ef m nmkmieki ibkbrm` pmrtkbr wetcarmwsdr es rbndvba frdn tcb pmrtkbrscep, m kbw nmkmieki ibkbrm` pmrtkbr nustgb sugstetutba mka tcb Abpmrtnbkt nust gb ennbaemtb`y kdtefeba df tcbjcmkib+ Qcb ndrtimibb nust ennbaemtb`y kdtefy tcb Abpmrtnbkt df mkymnbkanbkts td tcb pmrtkbrscep mirbbnbkt tcmt wdu`a mffbjt tcbpmrtkbrscep)s mjtedks ukabr mky df tcb ndrtimib eksurmkjb prdirmns+ Kbw`ymanettba pmrtkbrs nust mirbb td tcb nmkmibnbkt df tcb pmrtkbrscep gy tcbabseikmtba nmkmieki ibkbrm` pmrtkbr+ Gbfdrb m pmrtkbrscep es tbrnekmtba,

m`` FCM eksurba ndrtimibs cb`a gy tcb pmrtkbrscep nust gb trmksfbrrba tdmk mpprdvba ndrtimibb+

6.=: Jcmkib df Zcmrbcd`abr, Dwkbrscep, dr Jdktrd`+ Ycbkbvbr mkekaeveaum` dr bktety, tcmt prbvedus`y dwkba `bss tcmk 72 pbrjbkt df vdtekistdjl df m ndrtimibb, mjquerbs vdteki stdjl rbsu`teki ek dwkbrscep df 72pbrjbkt dr ndrb, tcb ndrtimibb nust kdtefy CRA+ M rbsunb mkaWbseabktem` Ndrtimib Jrbaet Wbpdrt nust gb sugnettba dk mky sujcekaeveaum`< fdr m gusekbss bktety, m jdnnbrjem` jrbaet rbpdrt, dr m Auk &Grmastrbbt rbpdrt, nust gb sugnettba+ Ef m ndrtimibb)s jdktrd``eki

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib =1 df 55

Page 15: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 15/99

dwkbrscep jcmkibs, m kbw mpp`ejmtedk mka fbb nmy gb kbjbssmry+ Qcbndrtimibb scdu`a jdktmjt tcb @bkabr Mpprdvm` mka Wbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedkek mavmkjb td abtbrnekb wcmt we`` gb rbquerba+ M jcmkib df dwkbrscep drjdktrd` rbsu`teki frdn m nbribr dr jdksd`eamtedk es jdvbrba ek pmrmirmpc6 =9< m jcmkib df dwkbrscep dr jdktrd` rbsu`teki frdn mjquesetedk df tcbndrtimibb es jdvbrba ek pmrmirmpc 6 =3+

6.=1 Jcmkib ek Jcmrtbr dr Fbabrm` Qmxpmybr Eabktefyeki Kungbr+

M+ Jcmkib Wbsu`teki ek Kbw Fbabrm` Qmxpmybr Eabktefyeki Kungbr+ Efm ndrtimibb rbekjdrpdrmtbs tcb mpprdvba ekstetutedk, jcmkibs tcbekstetutedk)s jcmrtbr, jcmkibs tcb Ztmtb wcbrb tcb jdnpmky es ekjdrpdrmtbadr dtcbrwesb jcmrtbrba, dr jdnp`btbs mky dtcbr jcmkib tcmt rbsu`ts ek tcbjdnpmky rbjbeveki m aeffbrbkt Fbabrm` Qmxpmybr Eabktefyeki Kungbr, tcbndrtimibb es rbquerba td sugnet m kbw mpp`ejmtedk fdr ndrtimibb mpprdvm`mka pmy tcb fbb fdr m kbw ndrtimibb mpprdvm` ms spbjefeba ek pmrmirmpc7 9+ Ef m kbw ndrtimibb eabktefejmtedk kungbr es essuba, CRA we`` `bmvbtcb d`a ndrtimibb eabktefejmtedk kungbr mjtevb fdr mpprdxenmtb`y 12 amystd m``dw jdnp`btedk df prdjbsseki df `dmks ek prdjbss ukabr tcmteabktefejmtedk kungbr+ Ycbk m kbw ndrtimibb eabktefejmtedk kungbr es

essuba, tcb ndrtimibb nust jbmsb dreiekmteki jmsbs ukabr tcb d`a kungbr+

G+ Jcmkib Kdt Wbsu`teki ek Jcmkib df Fbabrm` Qmxpmybr EabktefyekiKungbr+ Ef tcb jcmkib adbs kdt rbsu`t ek m kbw Fbabrm` QmxpmybrEabktefyeki Kungbr, tcbk tcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet tcb fd``dweki td tcb@bkabr Mpprdvm` mka Wbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk8

=+ Jbrtefejmtedk ms td tcb kmturb df tcb jdkvbrsedk mka tcmt tcbrb cmsgbbk kd jcmkib ek tcb Fbabrm` Qmxpmybr Eabktefyeki Kungbr dr abpdsetdreksurmkjb #ek tcb jmsb df m supbrvesba ndrtimibb%+

7+ Jbrtefejmtedk tcmt tcb ekstetutedk we`` jdktekub td jdnp`y wetc tcbmpprdvm` rbquerbnbkts df tces Cmkagddl+

:+ Jbrtefejmtedk tcmt tcb kbw`y jcmrtbrba bktety we`` jdktekub td gbrbspdkseg`b fdr tcb mssbts mka `emge`etebs df tcb fdrnbr ekstetutedk+ Qceswdu`a ekj`uab mky prdg`bns fduka sugsbqubkt`y gy tcb Abpmrtnbkt ek tcbdreiekmtedk dr sbrvejeki df mky Qet`b EE ndrtimibs dreiekmtba dr sbrvejba gytcb ekstetutedk predr td tcb madptedk df tcb kbw jcmrtbr+

1+ Jdpy df tcb kbw jcmrtbr mka m jdnp`btb absjreptedk df tcb jcmkibs+Ek `ebu df tcb mgdvb, tcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet m kbw mpp`ejmtedk fdrndrtimibb mpprdvm` mka pmy tcb fbb fdr m kbw ndrtimibb mpprdvm` msspbjefeba ek pmrmirmpc 7 9+

J+ Zpbjem` Jmsbs+ Qcbrb nmy gb ekstmkjbs wcbrb tcb Fbabrm` QmxpmybrEabktefyeki Kungbr nmy kdt jcmkib, gut tcb jcmkib ek tcb gusekbss bktety es

sujc tcmt CRA nmy rbquerb m kbw mpp`ejmtedk+

6.=2 Jcmkib ek Jcmrmjtbr df Gusekbss #_rekjepm` Mjtevety%+ Ef tcbrb es mjcmkib ek tcb jcmrmjtbr df mk mpprdvba kdk.supbrvesba ndrtimibb)sgusekbss sujc tcmt et nmy kd `dkibr qum`efy ukabr tcb ñprekjepm` mjtevetyöru`b #sbb pmrmirmpc 7 79#A% dr 7 75#J%, ms mpp`ejmg`b mka71íJFWí7?7+9#m% dr 7?7+3#m%#7%, ms mpp`ejmg`b+%, mka tces jcmkib ekjcmrmjtbr es pbrnmkbkt, et nust wetcarmw frdn tcb prdirmn+ Ef tcb jcmkibes tbnpdrmry, et nust kdtefy tcb Abpmrtnbkt mka prdveab td tcb Abpmrtnbktm Jdrrbjtevb Mjtedk _`mk abtme`eki cdw et we`` rbbstmg`esc ndrtimib `bkaeki

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib =2 df 55

Page 16: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 16/99

ms ets prekjepm` mjtevety+

6.=6 Jdkvbrsedk df Ndrtimibb Qypb+ M ndrtimibb tcmt jdkvbrts etsstmtus frdn dkb typb td mkdtcbr aureki ets fesjm` ybmr nust jdktekub tdjdnp`y wetc m`` mkkum` rbjbrtefejmtedk rbquerbnbkts+ Qd jdkvbrt etsndrtimibb typb, m ndrtimibb nust jdnp`btb m kbw CRA fdrn ==9?=,Mpp`ejmtedk fdr Mpprdvm`, FCM @bkabr mka$dr Iekkeb Nmb NdrtimibGmjlba Zbjuretebs Essubr, mka pmy m kdk.rbfukamg`b !:?? jdkvbrsedk fbb+ Mndrtimibb dr `dmk jdrrbspdkabkt nust abndkstrmtb tcmt et cms mabqumtb kbtwdrtc td nbbt tcb rbquerbnbkts df tcb typb df ndrtimibb td wcejc et esjdkvbrteki+ Qcb jdkvbrsedk mpp`ejmtedk mka ets suppdrteki adjunbktmtedknust gb sbkt tcb Aerbjtdr, @bkabr Mpprdvm` mka Wbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk+Qcb kdk rbfukamg`b !:?? jdkvbrsedk fbb nust gb nme`ba td CRA)s `djlgdx maarbss scdwk ek pmrmirmpc 7 9, tdibtcbr wetc ets trmksnettm` fdrn+Qcb ndrtimibb)s =? aeiet FCM eabktefejmtedk kungbr fdr ets cdnb dffejbnust gb eksbrtba ek tcb nbnd sbjtedk df tcb jcbjl mka tcb trmksnettm` fdrn+

M+ Zupbrvesba Ndrtimibb td Zupbrvesba @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt+ Ek tcestypb df jdkvbrsedk, tcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet8

( Qrmksnettm` `bttbr, scdweki tcb ndrtimibbÆs EA kungbr, kmnb, maarbssmka kmturb df rbqubst<( Jdpy df tcb jcbjl fdr tcb jdkvbrsedk fbb mka tcb trmksnettm` fdrn<( Zpdksdr @bttbr, ek wcejc tcb spdksdr mirbbs td spdksdr tcb supbrvesba`dmk jdrrbspdkabkt mka purjcmsb m`` FCM ndrtimibs dreiekmtba gy tcbsupbrvesba `dmk jdrrbspdkabkt mka ukabrwrettbk gy tcb Zpdksdr< mka( Jbrtefejmtedk tcmt m`` FCM.eksurba ndrtimibs cb`a dr sbrvejba cms gbbktrmksfbrrba td mkdtcbr FCM ndrtimibb tcmt es mpprdvba td sbrvejbFCM.eksurba ndrtimibs< dr m rbqubst fdr pbrnessedk td cd`a dr sbrvejbFCM.eksurba ndrtimibs+

G+ Zupbrvesba @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt td Zupbrvesba Ndrtimibb+ Ek tcestypb df jdkvbrsedk, tcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet8

( Qrmksnettm` `bttbr, scdweki tcb ndrtimibbÆs EA kungbr, kmnb, maarbssmka kmturb df rbqubst<( Jdpy df tcb jcbjl fdr tcb jdkvbrsedk fbb mka tcb trmksnettm` fdrn<( Bveabkjb df brrdrs mka dnessedks eksurmkjb fdr m nekenun df !:??,???<mka( Bveabkjb df m feab`ety gdka fdr m nekenun df !:??,???+

J+ Zupbrvesba Bktety td Kdk.supbrvesba Bktety+ Ek tces typb dfjdkvbrsedk, tcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet8

( Qrmksnettm` `bttbr, scdweki tcb ndrtimibbÆs EA kungbr, kmnb, maarbssmka kmturb df rbqubst<( Jdpy df tcb jcbjl fdr tcb jdkvbrsedk fbb mka tcb trmksnettm` fdrn<

( M kbw CRA fdrn ==9?=, Mpp`ejmtedk fdr Mpprdvm`, FCM @bkabr mka$drIekkeb Nmb Ndrtimib.Gmjlba Zbjuretebs Essubr< mka( Qcb smnb adjunbktmtedk ms fdr m kbw mpp`ejmtedk fdr mpprdvm` wetc m``tcb rbquerba adjunbktmtedk fdr tcmt typb df ndrtimibb+

A+ Kdk.supbrvesba Ndrtimibb td Kdk.supbrvesba @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt+Ek tces typb df jdkvbrsedk tcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet8

( Qrmksnettm` `bttbr, scdweki tcb ndrtimibbÆs EA kungbr, kmnb, maarbssmka kmturb df rbqubst<

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib =6 df 55

Page 17: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 17/99

( Jdpy df tcb jcbjl fdr tcb jdkvbrsedk fbb mka tcb trmksnettm` fdrn<( Zpdksdr `bttbr scdweki bveabkjb df mk mjjbptmg`b fukaeki mirbbnbkt< mka( Jbrtefejmtedk tcmt m`` FCM.eksurba ndrtimibs cb`a dr sbrvejba cms gbbktrmksfbrrba td mkdtcbr FCM ndrtimibb tcmt es mpprdvba td cd`a mka sbrvejbFCM.eksurba ndrtimibs+

B+ Kdk.supbrvesba @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt td Kdk.supbrvesba Ndrtimibb+Ek tces typb df jdkvbrsedk, tcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet8

( Qrmksnettm` `bttbr, scdweki tcb ndrtimibbÆs EA kungbr, kmnb, maarbssmka kmturb df rbqubst<( Jdpy df tcb jcbjl fdr tcb jdkvbrsedk fbb mka tcb trmksnettm` fdrn<( Jdpy df ets ndst rbjbkt muaetba fekmkjem` stmtbnbkts mka, ef tcbsb mrb ndrbtcmk sex ndktcs d`a, nmkmibnbkt jbrtefeba fekmkjem` stmtbnbkts mkajdnputmtedk df mahustba kbt wdrtc+ #sbb pmrmirmpc : 7#M%#6%<( Bveabkjb df mk mjjbptmg`b fukaeki prdirmn+ #sbb pmrmirmpc 7 79+J%<( Bveabkjb df brrdrs mka dnessedks eksurmkjb fdr m nekenun df !:??,???<mka( Bveabkjb df m feab`ety gdka fdr m nekenun df !:??,???+

Dkjb tces jdkvbrsedk es mpprdvba, tcb ndrtimibb we`` kd `dkibr cmvb mkyspdksdrs mka kbbas td jdktmjt tcb mpprdpremtb Cdnbdwkbrscep Jbktbr fdrdgtmekeki mpprdvm` ms m AB ndrtimibb ef tcby wesc td ukabrwretb seki`bfmne`y `dmks+

F+ Jdkvbrsedk td Ekvbsteki Ndrtimibb+ Ek tces typb df jdkvbrsedk, tcbndrtimibb nust sugnet8

( Qrmksnettm` `bttbr, scdweki tcb ndrtimibbÆs EA kungbr, kmnb, maarbssmka kmturb df rbqubst<( Jdpy df tcb jcbjl fdr tcb jdkvbrsedk fbb mka tcb trmksnettm` fdrn<( M kbw CRA fdrn ==9?=, Mpp`ejmtedk fdr Mpprdvm`, FCM @bkabr mka$drIekkeb Nmb Ndrtimib.Gmjlba Zbjuretebs Essubr<( Bveabkjb tcmt et nbbts tcb rbquerbnbkts spbjefeba ek pmrmirmpc 7 :?#G%,rbimraeki `bim` mutcdrety td purjcmsb eksurba ndrtimibs mka mvme`mge`ety dffukaeki< mka( Jbrtefejmtedk tcmt m`` sbrvejeki df FCM.eksurba ndrtimibs cms gbbktrmksfbrrba td mkdtcbr mpprdvba FCM ndrtimibb tcmt es mpprdvba td sbrvejbFCM.eksurba ndrtimibs+

I+ Jdkvbrsedk frdn Ekvbsteki Ndrtimibb+ Ek tces typb df jdkvbrsedk,tcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet8

( Qrmksnettm` `bttbr, scdweki tcb ndrtimibbÆs EA kungbr, kmnb, maarbssmka kmturb df rbqubst<( Jdpy df tcb jcbjl fdr tcb jdkvbrsedk fbb mka tcb trmksnettm` fdrn<( Zugnet tcb smnb adjunbktmtedk ms fdr m kbw mpp`ejmtedk fdr mpprdvm`

wetc m`` tcb rbquerba adjunbktmtedk fdr tcmt typb df ndrtimibb< mka( Ef jdkvbrsedk es td m `dmk jdrrbspdkabkt, jbrtefy tcmt m`` FCM.eksurbandrtimibs cb`a dr sbrvejba cmvb gbbk trmksfbrrba td mkdtcbr FCMndrtimibb tcmt es mpprdvba td cd`a mka sbrvejb FCM.eksurba ndrtimibs+

6.=9 Nbribr dr Jdksd`eamtedk+ Nbribrs jmk tmlb m vmrebty df fdrns+

M+ Qwd dr Ndrb CRA$FCM.Mpprdvba Ndrtimibbs Nbrib+

=+ Kdk.surveveki Bktety+ Qcb kdk.surveveki bktety nust8

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib =9 df 55

Page 18: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 18/99

m+ Zugnet m `bttbr seikba gy mk bxbjutevb dffejbr ekfdrneki tcbAbpmrtnbkt tcmt et es nbrieki wetc mkdtcbr bktety+ Qcb `bttbr nust8

( Ekaejmtb wcejc ndrtimibb we`` survevb<( _rdveab tcb ndrtimibb eabktefejmtedk kungbrs fdr bmjc ndrtimibbekvd`vba<( _rdveab tcb amtb tcb nbribr djjurrba dr we`` djjur< mka( Wbqubst tbrnekmtedk df ets mpprdvm`+

g+ Ef tcb kdk.surveveki ndrtimibb wms m Zpdksdr df FCM.mpprdvba`dmk jdrrbspdkabkts, et nust kdtefy ets `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts df ets rbqubst fdrtbrnekmtedk+

j+ Dkjb tcb kdk.surveveki bktety jbmsbs td bxest dr ets mpprdvm` estbrnekmtba, wcejcbvbr jdnbs ferst8

( Et nmy kdt mjjbpt mky kbw mpp`ejmtedks fdr Qet`b EE ndrtimibs<( Et nmy kd `dkibr purjcmsb Qet`b EE ndrtimibs<( Et nmy kd `dkibr sbrvejb Qet`b EE ndrtimibs< mka

( Et nmy kd `dkibr sugnet j`mens td tcb Abpmrtnbkt+

a+ Ycbk tcb kdk.surveveki ndrtimibb cd`as m pdrtfd`ed df Qet`b EEndrtimibs, et nust mrrmkib td trmksfbr tcb `dmks td tcb surveveki ndrtimibbdr sdnb dtcbr mpprdvba FCM ndrtimibb mpprdvba td sbrvejb FCMndrtimibs+ Zbb pmrmirmpcs 6.=9#M%#7%#b% mka #f%+ Qcbrb es m jdktekubadg`eimtedk td pmy eksurmkjb prbneuns aub mka td nbbt m`` dtcbr dg`eimtedksmssdjemtba wetc tcb eksurba ndrtimibs+

7+ Zurveveki Bktety+ Qcb surveveki bktety nust8

m+ Zugnet m `bttbr absjregeki tcb nbribr mka jbrtefyeki tcmt =% mky `dmkjdrrbspdkabkts kdt jdktekueki wetc spdksdrscep cmvb gbbk kdtefeba, 7% m```dmk jdrrbspdkabkts df tcb kdk.surveveki ndrtimibb we`` gb spdksdrba gytcb surveveki ndrtimibb dr :% tcb kdk.surveveki ndrtimibb wms kdt tcbspdksdr df mky `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts+

g+ Zugnet m jdpy df tcb adjunbkt wcejc bveabkjbs tcb nbribr+ Msupbrvesba ndrtimibb, nust sugnet m jdpy df tcb `bttbr frdn tcbsupbrvesdry mutcdrety wcejc mpprdvba tcb nbribr+

j+ Zugnet m `est eabktefyeki bmjc df tcb kdk.surveveki bktety)s grmkjcdffejbs wcejc we`` rbnmek dpbk ukabr tcb muspejbs df tcb surveveki bktety,mka pmy tcb grmkjc dffejb rbiestrmtedk fbb spbjefeba ek pmrmirmpc 7 9+

a+ Wbiestbr bmjc df tcb kdk.surveveki bktety)s `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts, efmky, tcmt tcb surveveki bktety we`` jdktekub td spdksdr ek tcb FCM

Jdkkbjtedk+ Zpdksdrscep es kdt mutdnmtejm``y trmksfbrrba+ Bmjc df tcbkdk.surveveki bktety)s `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts, fdr wcejc tcb surveveki bktetywe`` kdt jdktekub spdksdrscep, nust gb ievbk :? amys wrettbk kdtejb gy tcbZpdksdr+

b+ Ef tcb surveveki ndrtimibb mjquerbs dk`y m pdrtedk df tcbkdk.surveveki ndrtimibb)s Qet`b EE ndrtimibs, dkb df tcb pmrtebs nustsugnet m Ndrtimib Wbjdra Jcmkib trmksmjtedk fdr bmjc ndrtimib tcmt we``kdt gb mjquerba gy tcb surveveki ndrtimibb+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib =3 df 55

Page 19: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 19/99

f+ Ef tcb surveveki ndrtimibb mjquerbs m`` df tcb kdk.survevekindrtimibb)s dutstmkaeki Qet`b EE ndrtimibs, et es kdt kbjbssmry td sugnetNdrtimib Wbjdra Jcmkibs+ M`` `dmks we`` gb trmksfbrrba td tcb survevekibktety gy CRA wcbk tcb nbribr es prdjbssba+

G+ Mk Mpprdvba Ndrtimibb Nbribs wetc m Kdk.mpprdvba Ndrtimibb+

=+ Kdk.mpprdvba Ndrtimibb Zurvevbs+

m+ Qcb kdk.surveveki ndrtimibb nust jdnp`y wetc tcb prdvesedks dfpmrmirmpc 6 =9#M%#=%+

g+ Ef tcb surveveki ndrtimibb wescbs td dreiekmtb dr cd`a Qet`b EEndrtimibs dr sugnet j`mens fdr ndrtimibs prbvedus`y cb`a gy tcbkdk.surveveki ndrtimibb, et nust gbjdnb FCM.mpprdvba+ Qd gbjdnbmpprdvba, et nust fd``dw tcb mpprdvm` prdjbaurbs df tces Cmkagddl+ Qcbndrtimibb scdu`a ekj`uab wetc ets mpp`ejmtedk m `bttbr absjregeki tcbnbribr, mka, ef mpp`ejmg`b, ets ektbktedks rbimraeki tcb kdk.survevekindrtimibbÆs dutstmkaeki Qet`b EE ndrtimibs mka spdksdrba `dmkjdrrbspdkabkts+ Ennbaemtb`y mftbr gbjdneki mpprdvba, tcb ndrtimibb

scdu`a rbiestbr bmjc df tcb kdk.surveveki bktetyÆs grmkjc dffejbs wcejcwe`` rbnmek dpbk ukabr tcb muspejbs df tcb surveveki bktety, mka pmy tcbgrmkjc rbiestrmtedk fbb spbjefeba ek pmrmirmpc 7.9+ Qcb ndrtimibb nustrbiestbr bmjc df tcb `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts et es spdksdreki ek tcb FCMJdkkbjtedk+

7+ Mpprdvba Ndrtimibb Zurvevbs+ Qcb surveveki ndrtimibb nust8

m+ sugnet m `bttbr absjregeki tcb nbribr+

g+ Zugnet m jdpy df tcb adjunbkt wcejc bveabkjbs tcb nbribr+ Msupbrvesba ndrtimibb, nust sugnet m jdpy df tcb `bttbr frdn tcbsupbrvesdry mutcdrety wcejc mpprdvba tcb nbribr+

6.=3 Zm`b dr Mjquesetedk+ Qcb sm`b dr mjquesetedk df m FCM.mpprdvbandrtimibb nmy tmlb tcb fdrn df stdjl, mssbts dr dpbrmtedks gbeki mjquerbadr sdnb jdngekmtedk df tcbsb+ Qcb ndrtimibb nmy jbmsb td bxest,gbjdneki pmrt df tcb mjquereki jdnpmky, et nmy jdktekub ms m sugseaemry drmffe`emtb df tcb mjquereki jdnpmky, dr nmy gbjdnb mk ekabpbkabktjdnpmky+ Bmjc df tcbsb es cmka`ba aeffbrbkt`y+

M+ Mk Mpprdvba Ndrtimibb Mjquerba gy Mkdtcbr MpprdvbaNdrtimibb+ Qcb kbjbssmry mjtedk abpbkas updk wcbtcbr tcb mjquerbandrtimibb we`` jbmsb td bxest dr we`` jdktekub ms m sugseaemry dr mffe`emtb dftcb mjquereki ndrtimibb+

=+ Jdktekumtedk ms Zugseaemry dr Mffe`emtb+ Ef tcb ndrtimibb gbeki

mjquerba we`` jdktekub td dpbrmtb ms m sugseaemry dr mffe`emtb df tcb mjquerekindrtimibb, tcb mjquereki ndrtimibb nust sugnet m `bttbr absjregeki tcbtrmksmjtedk ekj`uaeki tcb kmnbs df m`` pmrtebs, tcber FCM ndrtimibbeabktefejmtedk kungbrs, mka tcb amtb df tcb mjquesetedk+ Qcb `bttbr nust m`sdbxp`mek tcmt tcb mjquerba bktety we`` jdktekub ms m sugseaemry dr mffe`emtb dftcb mjquereki bktety+ Qcb mjquerba ndrtimibb nust kdtefy tcb Abpmrtnbktgy `bttbr tcmt et cms gbbk mjquerba mka we`` jdktekub td dpbrmtb ms msugseaemry dr mffe`emtb df tcb mjquereki ndrtimibb+ Qcb mjquerba ndrtimibbnmy jdktekub td dpbrmtb ukabr ets bxesteki Qet`b EE ndrtimibb EabktefejmtedkKungbr+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib =5 df 55

Page 20: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 20/99

7+ Aessd`utedk df Ndrtimibb+ Ef tcb ndrtimibb gbeki mjquerba we`` gbaessd`vba,

m+ Qcb kdk.surveveki bktety nust sugnet m `bttbr seikba gy mkbxbjutevb dffejbr ekfdrneki tcb Abpmrtnbkt df abtme`s rbimraeki etsmjquesetedk mka rbqubsteki tbrnekmtedk df ets mpprdvm`+ Qcb ndrtimibb nustjdnp`y wetc tcb prdvesedks df pmrmirmpcs 6 =9#M%#=%+

g+ Qcb surveveki bktety nust sugnet td CRA m jdpy df tcb mrtej`bs dfaessd`utedk mka m `bttbr absjregeki tcb mjquesetedk mka, ef mpp`ejmg`b, etsektbkaba aespdsetedk dr sm`b df FCM eksurba `dmks cb`a dr sbrvejba gy tcbkdk.surveveki ndrtimibb+ Qcb `bttbr nust m`sd jbrtefy tcmt =% mky `dmkjdrrbspdkabkts kdt jdktekueki wetc spdksdrscep cmvb gbbk kdtefeba, 7% m```dmk jdrrbspdkabkts df tcb kdk.surveveki ndrtimibb we`` gb spdksdrba gytcb surveveki ndrtimibb dr :%ítcb kdk.surveveki ndrtimibb wms kdt tcbspdksdr df mky `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts+ Qcb surveveki ndrtimibb nust jdnp`ywetc pmrmirmpcs 6 =9#M%#7%#j% tcrduic #f%+

G+ Mk Mpprdvba Ndrtimibb Mjquerba gy mk Bktety tcmt es Kdt

Mpprdvba+

=+ Mjquereki Bktety Wbquerbs Mpprdvm` td _mrtejepmtb ek _rdirmn+ Eftcb mjquereki bktety wescbs td gb mg`b td dreiekmtb, cd`a, dr sbrvejb Qet`b EEndrtimibs, et nust mpp`y fdr mpprdvm` ukabr tcb mpp`ejmg`b prdvesedks dftces Cmkagddl+

Ef tcb mjquerba ndrtimibb we`` kdt gb jdktekueki ms m sugseaemry dr mffe`emtb,tcb mjquereki bktety scdu`a ekj`uab wetc ets mpp`ejmtedk m `bttbr absjregekitcb mjquesetedk mka, ef mpp`ejmg`b, ets ektbktedks rbimraeki tcb kdk.survevekindrtimibbÆs dutstmkaeki Qet`b EE ndrtimibs mka spdksdrba `dmkjdrrbspdkabkts+ Ennbaemtb`y mftbr gbjdneki mpprdvba, tcb ndrtimibbscdu`a rbiestbr bmjc df tcb kdk.surveveki bktetyÆs grmkjc dffejbs wcejcwe`` rbnmek dpbk ukabr tcb muspejbs df tcb surveveki bktety, mka pmy tcbgrmkjc rbiestrmtedk fbb spbjefeba ek pmrmirmpc 7.9#M%+ Qcb ndrtimibb nmyb`bjtrdkejm``y rbiestbr bmjc df tcb `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts et es spdksdreki drfd``dw tcb m`tbrkmtb prdjbaurbs absjregba ek pmrmirmpc 2.=7+

7+ Mjquerba Ndrtimibb td Jdktekub ms Zugseaemry dr Mffe`emtb+ Ef tcbmjquerba bktety we`` jdktekub td dpbrmtb ms m sugseaemry dr mffe`emtb df tcbmjquereki ndrtimibb, et nmy jdktekub td dpbrmtb ms m Qet`b EE ndrtimibbukabr ets dwk kmnb, wcbtcbr dr kdt tcb mjquereki bktety gbjdnbsFCM.mpprdvba+ Qcb ndrtimibb nust sugnet m `bttbr absjregeki tcbmjquesetedk mka ets futurb dpbrmteki stmtus+

:+ Mjquerba Ndrtimibb Jbmsbs td Bxest+ Ef tcb mjquerba bktety we``jbmsb td bxest, et nust jdnp`y wetc tcb prdvesedks df pmrmirmpc

6 =3#M%#7%#m%+

J+ Qcb Mpprdvba Ndrtimibb Gbjdnbs Ekabpbkabkt+ Ycbk mkmpprdvba ndrtimibb, wcejc cms gbbk m sugseaemry dr pmrt df m `mribr bktety,gbjdnbs ekabpbkabkt, et nust kdtefy CRA mka prdveab abtme`s df tcbjcmkib+ Gmsba dk tces, CRA nmy rbquerb maaetedkm` ekfdrnmtedk+ Fdrjcmkibs ek sbkedr dffejbrs, aerbjtdrs, dr dwkbrscep, tcb ndrtimibb nustsugnet adjunbktmtedk ms spbjefeba ek pmrmirmpcs 6 == mka 6 =:+

A+ Qcb Mpprdvba Ndrtimibb Mjquerbs mk Bktety tcmt es Kdt Mpprdvba+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 7? df 55

Page 21: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 21/99

Ef tcb mjquerba bktety we`` dpbrmtb ms m sugseaemry dr mffe`emtb df tcbmjquerekindrtimibb mka wescbs td gb mg`b td dreiekmtb, cd`a dr sbrvejb Qet`b EEndrtimib, et nust mpp`y fdr mpprdvm` ukabr tcb mpp`ejmg`b prdvesedks df tcesCmkagddl+

6.=5 Qbrnekmtedk df Zupbrvesedk+ M supbrvesba ndrtimibb es rbquerba tdkdtefy tcb Abpmrtnbkt ek wreteki wetcek =? gusekbss amys mftbr tcbtbrnekmtedk df supbrvesedk gy ets supbrveseki mibkjy+ Ef tcb ndrtimibbqum`efebs fdr mpprdvm` ms mkdtcbr typb df ndrtimibb, et nust sugnet m kbwmpp`ejmtedk, wetc tcb mpprdpremtb kdk.rbfukamg`b fbb, fdr mpprdvm` tdpmrtejepmtb ek tcb Abpmrtnbkt)s ndrtimib eksurmkjb prdirmns+

6.7? Qbrnekmtedk df Feab`ety Gdka dr Brrdrs mka Dnessedks Eksurmkjb+ Efm ndrtimibb)s feab`ety gdka dr brrdrs mka dnessedks eksurmkjb es tbrnekmtbamka tcb ndrtimibb es ukmg`b td dgtmek m kbw pd`ejy wetcek tbk gusekbssamys, td jdktekub ms m FCM mpprdvba ndrtimibb, et nust jdkvbrt td m `dmkjdrrbspdkabkt #sbb pmrmirmpc 6 =6%+

6.7= Kbt Ydrtc Abfejebkjy+ Mk mpprdvba ndrtimibb nust nmektmek mt

`bmst tcb nekenun rbquerba mahustba kbt wdrtc mt m`` tenbs+ Ef mt mky tenb etfm``s gb`dw tcb rbquerba nekenun, tcb ndrtimibb nust kdtefy tcb @bkabrMpprdvm` mka Wbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk mka sugnet m Jdrrbjtevb Mjtedk_`mk+ Fme`urb td jdnp`y es irdukas fdr mk manekestrmtevb mjtedk gy tcbNdrtimibb Wbvebw Gdmra+

6.77 @equea Mssbts Abfejebkjy+ Mk mpprdvba ndrtimibb nust nmektmekmt `bmst tcb nekenun rbquerba `equea mssbts mt m`` tenbs+ Ef mt mky tenb etfm``s gb`dw tcb rbquerba nekenun, tcb ndrtimibb nust kdtefy tcb @bkabrMpprdvm` mka Wbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk mka sugnet m Jdrrbjtevb Mjtedk_`mk+ Fme`urb td jdnp`y es irdukas fdr mk manekestrmtevb mjtedk gy tcbNdrtimibb Wbvebw Gdmra+

6.7: Dpbrmteki @dss+ M ndrtimibb nust sugnet fekmkjem` stmtbnbktswetcek :? amys df tcb bka df bmjc fesjm` qumrtbr ek wcejc tcb ndrtimibbbxpbrebkjbs mk dpbrmteki `dss df 7? pbrjbkt dr irbmtbr df ets kbt wdrtc+ Qcbektbren fekmkjem` stmtbnbkts nmy gb betcbr muaetba dr uk.muaetba, mka tcbndrtimibb nust jdktekub td sugnet tcbn ukte` et scdws mk dpbrmteki prdfetfdr twd jdksbjutevb qumrtbrs, dr ukte` ets kbxt mkkum` rbjbrtefejmtedk gyFCM, wcejcbvbr es `mtbr+

6.71 Gmklruptjy dr @equeamtedk+

M+ Gusekbss+ M ndrtimibb nust sugnet m stmtbnbkt df Mahustba KbtYdrtc wetcek :? amys df jdnnbkjbnbkt df vd`uktmry dr ekvd`uktmrygmklruptjy, jdksbrvmtdr scep, rbjbevbrscep dr mky trmksfbr df jdktrd` td mFbabrm` dr Ztmtb supbrvesdry mibkjy+ M jurrbkt dreiekm` Auk mka Grmastrbbt

dr gusekbss jrbaet rbpdrt nust gb sugnettba+ CRA nust gb kdtefeba df bmjcjcmkib df stmtus ek tcb gmklruptjy prdjbbaekis+ CRA rbsbrvbs tcb reict tdrbquerb tcb ndrtimibb td sugnet jdurt adjunbkts+

G+ _brsdkm`+ Ef mk dffejbr dr prekjepm` df tcb ndrtimibb jdnnbkjbsvd`uktmry dr ekvd`uktmry gmklruptjy, wetcek :? amys tcb ndrtimibb nustkdtefy CRA+ M jurrbkt dreiekm` jrbaet rbpdrt fdr tcmt dffejbr dr prekjepm`nust gb sugnettba+ CRA nust gb kdtefeba df bmjc jcmkib df stmtus ek tcbgmklruptjy prdjbbaekis+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 7= df 55

Page 22: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 22/99

6.72 Vd`uktmry Yetcarmwm` df CRA$FCM Mpprdvm`+ M ndrtimibb nmyrbqubst m vd`uktmry wetcarmwm` df ets FCM mpprdvm` gy sugnetteki wrettbkkdtefejmtedk, seikba gy m sbkedr dffejbr, td tcb @bkabr Mpprdvm` mkaWbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk+ Qcb rbqubst we`` kdt gb cdkdrba wce`b tcbrb es mkmanekestrmtevb mjtedk dr Ndrtimibb Wbvebw Gdmra mjtedk pbkaeki mimeksttcb ndrtimibb+ Mky ndrtimibb wcdsb mpprdvm` es vd`uktmre`y wetcarmwknmy rbmpp`y fdr FCM mpprdvm` mt mky tenb mftbr ets wetcarmwm`+

6.76 M`` Dtcbr Gusekbss Jcmkibs+ Mky dtcbr gusekbss jcmkib tcmt mffbjtsm ndrtimibb)s mpprdvm` stmtus dr ets jdkaujt df gusekbss wetc tcbAbpmrtnbkt nust gb rbpdrtba ek wreteki td tcb @bkabr Mpprdvm` mkaWbjbrtefejmtedk Aevesedk wetcek =? amys+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 77 df 55

Page 23: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 23/99

CRA Cmkagddl 1?6?+= Wbv.7Jcmptbrs 7.5, 7.7:, 9.: ‚ 9.6

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 7: df 55

Page 24: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 24/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 7.2

M+ Wbquerbnbkt+ M supbrvesba dr kdk.supbrvesba ndrtimibb dr `dmkjdrrbspdkabkt nust nmektmek `equea mssbts df 7? pbrjbkt df ets mahustba

kbt wdrtc dr !=??,??? wcejcbvbr es `bssbr+ Zupbrvesba mpp`ejmkts mrbkdt rbquerba td vbrefy `equea mssbts ek tcber mpp`ejmtedk, gut nmy gbmslba td vbrefy jdnp`emkjb aureki mpp`ejmtedk prdjbsseki+

G+  Mjjbptmg`b+ Jmsc mka jmsc bquevm`bkts jdkstetutb `equea mssbts+ Jmscekj`uabs jmsc dk cmka, jcbjleki mjjdukts, smvekis mjjdukts, mkajbrtefejmtbs df abpdset+  Jmsc bquevm`bkts mrb rbmae`y nmrlbtmg`b

ekvbstnbkts, b+i+ sbjuretebs rbmae`y jdkvbrteg`b ektd jmsc+ Qd gb

jdkseabrba m `equea mssbt, tcb jmsc dr jmsc bquevm`bkt nust kdt gbrbstrejtba dr dtcbrwesb rbsbrvba fdr mky purpdsb dtcbr tcmk tcb

pmynbkt df m jurrbkt `emge`ety+

J+ Rkmjjbptmg`b+ FCM adbs kdt jdkseabr m `ekb df jrbaet dr `dmks drndrtimibs cb`a fdr rbsm`b gy tcb ndrtimibb td gb `equea mssbts+

7+9 Mpp`ejmtedk Fbbs+ M`` fbbs mrb kdkrbfukamg`b #QD_%

M++ Fbb Mndukt+

=+ Ndrtimibb Mpprdvm` + Qcb fbb es !=,??? bxjbpt fdr tcdsbbktetebs m`rbmay mpprdvba ms m Qet`b E `bkabr, idvbrknbktm`ekstetutedks dr kdk.abpdsetdry kdt.fdr prdfet bktetebs+

7+ Grmkjc Dffejb Wbiestrmtedk+ Qcb fbb es !:??, bxjbpt fdridvbrknbktm` ekstetutedks dr kdk.abpdsetdry kdt.fdr prdfetbktetebs+

G+ Fbb _mynbkt+ Qcb mpp`ejmtedk fbb nust gb nme`ba td CRA―s `djlgdxtdibtcbr wetc tcb CRA fdrn,  Mpp`ejmtedk Fbb fdr Qet`b EE Ndrtimibb

 Mpprdvm` td tcb fd``dweki maarbss8

R+Z+ Abpmrtnbkt df CRA

_+D+ Gdx =536=5Mt`mktm, IM :?:31

Jdpebs df tcb jcbjl mka mpp`ejmtedk fbb fdrn nust mjjdnpmky tcb FCM

`bkabr mpp`ejmtedk fdrn+ Ef kdt, m jdpy df tcb frdkt mka gmjl df tcb

jmkjb``ba jcbjl we`` gb rbqubstba+

7.3 Dpbrmteki Bxpbksbs+ #QD_%

M ndrtimibb nust pmy m`` ets dwk dpbrmteki bxpbksbs+ Qces ekj`uabs

bxpbksbs df ets nmek mka grmkjc dffejbs ekvd`vba ek dreiekmteki dr sbrvejekimky FCM eksurba ndrtimibs+ Dpbrmteki bxpbksbs ekj`uab, gut mrb kdt `enetba

td, bquepnbkt, furketurb, dffejb rbkt, dvbrcbma, bnp`dybb jdnpbksmtedk, mkasene`mr bxpbksbs+

7.5 Bnp`dybbs mka Dffejbrs+ #QD_%

Mk mpprdvba ndrtimibb nust bnp`dy trmekba pbrsdkkb` tcmt mrb jdnpbtbkt td

pbrfdrn tcber msseikba rbspdksege`etebs+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 71 df 55

Page 25: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 25/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 7.6

M+ Bnp`dybbs+ Bnp`dybbs mrb tcdsb ekaeveaum`s wcd mrb ukabr tcbaerbjt supbrvesedk mka jdktrd` df mk FCM mpprdvba ndrtimibb mka

wcbrb tcb ekaeveaum`s mrb bxj`usevb`y bnp`dyba gy tcb FCM mpprdvbandrtimibb ek tcb ndrtimib `bkaeki mka rbm` bstmtb feb`as+ Qcbndrtimibb nust abndkstrmtb tcb bssbktem` jcmrmjtbrestejs df tcb

bnp`dybr.bnp`dybb rb`mtedkscep updk ekquery gy tcb Abpmrtnbkt+\Zbb m`sd pmrmirmpcs 7.5#A% mka 7.5#I%^

Jdnpbksmtedk df bnp`dybbs nmy gb dk m sm`mry, sm`mry p`us

jdnnessedk, dr jdnnessedk dk`y gmses mka ekj`uabs gdkusbs+ M``

jdnpbksmtedk nust gb rbpdrtba dk Fdrn Y.7+ Bnp`dybbs wcdpbrfdrn ukabrwreteki mka `dmk sbrvejeki mjtevetebs nmy kdt  rbjbevb

jdnnessedks+

G+ Dffejbrs+ Ekaeveaum`s mrb dffejbrs fdr tcb purpdsbs df FCMrbquerbnbkts ef tcby gbmr tcb jdrpdrmtb tet`b df Vejb _rbseabkt dr ceicbr

mka m`sd ekj`uab Grmkjc Nmkmibrs+ M ndrtimibb nust cmvb dkb dr

ndrb dffejbrs wetc mutcdrety dvbr tcb ndrtimibb―s `dmk dreiekmtedk mkasbrvejeki dpbrmtedks+ Mk dffejbr es betcbr m jdrpdrmtb dffejbr, dr m

prekjepm` df m kdk.jdrpdrmtb bktety, wcd cms mutcdrety td `bim``y geka

tcb jdrpdrmtedk dr bktety+  Ek tcb jmsb df m idvbrknbkt ekstetutedk, tcesrd`b wdu`a gb fe``ba gy m abseikmtba stmff pbrsdk#s%+  Mt `bmst dkbdffejbr nust spbka fu`` tenb nmkmieki mka aerbjteki tcb ndrtimibb―s

dpbrmtedks+ Qcmt dffejbr nust cmvb m nekenun df tcrbb ybmrs

mjjbptmg`b bxpbrebkjb ek tcb ndrtimib mjtevetebs fdr wcejc tcbndrtimibb es sbbleki mpprdvm`+ Wb`bvmkt trmekeki nmy gb sugstetutba

fdr sdnb df tcb rbquerba bxpbrebkjb+ Mk mpp`ejmkt nust sugnet, wetcets mpp`ejmtedk, jurrbkt rbsunbs adjunbkteki tces bxpbrebkjb+ Ek

abtbrnekeki tcb mjjbptmge`ety df mk dffejbr―s bxpbrebkjb, tcb

Abpmrtnbkt we`` jdkseabr8

x Bxpbrebkjb ek dreiekmteki seki`b fmne`y mka nu`tefmne`yndrtimibs<

x Bxpbrebkjb ek sbrvejeki seki`b fmne`y mka nu`tefmne`yndrtimibs<

x Bxpbrebkjb ek ekvbsteki fukas ek rbm` bstmtb ndrtimibs<

x Bxpbrebkjb ek nmkmieki dtcbr ekaeveaum`s pbrfdrneki tcbsbsbrvejbs< mka

x Bxpbrebkjb ek rbm` bstmtb sm`bs dr grdlbrmib adbs kdt qum`efy+

M Grmkjc Nmkmibr―s jdnpbksmtedk nmy gb gmsba updk tcb ‐kbt„ prdfet

df tcb grmkjc+ Fdr bxmnp`b, tcb FCM mpprdvba ndrtimibb nmy jd``bjt

tcb rbvbkub frdn tcb grmkjc, pmy tcb grmkjc bxpbksbs, mka tcbk pmytcb grmkjc nmkmibr tcb rbnmekeki rbvbkubs, ef mky, ms m jdnnessedk+Zujc mk mrrmkibnbkt es, bssbktem``y, mk m`tbrkmtevb jdnpbksmtedk

prdirmn fdr tcb grmkjc nmkmibr mka es mk mjjbptmg`b mrrmkibnbkt ef m`` dtcbr grmkjc rbquerbnbkts mrb nbt+

J+ Jdnpmkebs wetc Hdekt Dffejbrs+ Ef m ndrtimibb cms mky df tcb smnb

dffejbrs, stdjlcd`abrs, pmrtkbrs, dr nbngbrs ms mkdtcbr bktety, tcbdffejbrs nmy rbprbsbkt ndrb tcmk dkb bktety ef8

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 72 df 55

Page 26: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 26/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 7.9

=+ Qcbrb es m j`bmr mka bffbjtevb sbpmrmtedk df tcb twd bktetebs, mka

ndrtimidrs lkdw mt m`` tenbs bxmjt`y wetc wcejc bktety tcby mrbadeki gusekbss+

7+ Qcbrb es m au`y mppdektba dr b`bjtba sbkedr dffejbr, wetc tcbrbquerba nekenun tcrbb ybmrs df mjjbptmg`b bxpbrebkjb,abseikmtba td jdkaujt bxj`usevb`y tcb mffmers df tcb ndrtimibbaureki kdrnm` gusekbss cdurs+

A+ Jdktrd` mka Zupbrvesedk df Ztmff + #QD_% M ndrtimibb nust bxbrjesbjdktrd` mka rbspdkseg`b nmkmibnbkt supbrvesedk dvbr ets cdnb dffejbmka grmkjc bnp`dybbs+ Jdktrd` mka supbrvesedk nust ekj`uab, mt m

nekenun, rbiu`mr mka dkideki rbvebws df bnp`dybb pbrfdrnmkjb mkadf wdrl pbrfdrnba+

B+ Zeikmtdry Mutcdrety + #QD_% Mky bnp`dybb wcd seiks mpp`ejmtedks fdr

ndrtimib eksurmkjb dk gbcm`f df tcb ndrtimibb nust gb m Vejb_rbseabkt, dr gb mutcdrezba td geka tcb ndrtimibb ek nmttbrs ekvd`vekitcb dreiekmtedk mka sbrvejeki df eksurba ndrtimibs+

F+ Jdkaujteki Ndrtimibb Gusekbss+ #QD_% Aureki ces$cbr kdrnm` autycdurs, bnp`dybbs, wcd mrb ekvd`vba wetc FCM trmksmjtedks, nmy

jdkaujt dk`y tcb gusekbss df tcb ndrtimibb+

I+ Fu`` Qenb, _mrt Qenb mka Dutseab Bnp`dynbkt+ #QD_% M ndrtimibbnmy bnp`dy stmff fu`` tenb dr pmrt.tenb #`bss tcmk tcb kdrnm` 1? cdur

wdrl wbbl%+ Qcby nmy cmvb dtcbr bnp`dynbkt ekj`uaeki

sb`f.bnp`dynbkt+ Cdwbvbr, sujc dutseab bnp`dynbkt nmy kdt gb ekndrtimib `bkaeki, rbm` bstmtb, dr m rb`mtba feb`a+ Aerbjt bkadrsbnbkt

ukabrwretbrs mrb ekj`uaba ek tces prdvesedk+ Mk ukabrwretbr nmy kdtwdrl dk m pmrt.tenb gmses fdr mky dtcbr ndrtimibb, bvbk ukabrwretekijdkvbktedkm` ndrtimib `dmks+ Mk ukabrwretbr nmy kdt ukabrwretb`dmks fdr m pmrbkt dr sugseaemry df tcb ukabrwretbr―s mpprdvba

bnp`dybr+  M aerbjt bkadrsbnbkt ukabrwretbr―s mutcdrety es tcrduic tcb

bnp`dybr mka adbs kdt bxtbka ukabr mky jdrpdrmtb ‐ungrb``m+„ 

7.=? Ekb`eieg`b _mrtejepmkts+ #QD_%

Mk mpp`ejmkt es ekb`eieg`b fdr mpprdvm` ef tcb ndrtimibb dr mky dffejbr, pmrtkbr,aerbjtdr, prekjepm`, dr bnp`dybb df tcb mpp`ejmkt ndrtimibb es8

 M+ Zuspbkaba, abgmrrba, ukabr m `enetba abkem` df pmrtejepmtedk

#@A_%, dr dtcbrwesb rbstrejtba ukabr 71 JFW _mrt 71 dr 72 dr 

ukabr sene`mr prdvesedks df mky dtcbr Fbabrm` mibkjy<

G+ Rkabr ekaejtnbkt fdr, dr cms gbbk jdkvejtba df, mk dffbksb tcmt 

rbf`bjts mavbrsb`y updk tcb mpp`ejmkt―s ektbirety, jdnpbtbkjb dr 

fetkbss td nbbt tcb rbspdksege`etebs df mk mpprdvba ndrtimibb<

J+ Zughbjt td ukrbsd`vba fekaekis jdktmekba ek m CRA dr dtcbridvbrknbktm` muaet, ekvbsteimtedk, dr rbvebw<

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 76 df 55

Page 27: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 27/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 7.=6

7.7: ]um`ety Jdktrd`+ #QD_%

M ndrtimibb nust nmektmek m wrettbk ]um`ety Jdktrd` _`mk fdr tcb dreiekmtedk

mka sbrvejeki df FCM eksurba ndrtimibs+ Qcb ]um`ety Jdktrd` _`mk mka etsenp`bnbktmtedk nust nbbt tcb rbquerbnbkts sbt fdrtc ek jcmptbr 9+ Ndrtimibbs mrb rbquerba td rbpdrt td CRA mky frmua, e``bim` mjts, errbiu`mretebs

dr ukbtcejm` prmjtejbs+

7.71 Wbquerbnbkt td Kdtefy CRA df Jcmkibs Zugsbqubkt td Mpprdvm`+ #QD_%

M ndrtimibb nust kdtefy tcb Abpmrtnbkt ek wreteki wetcek m spbjefej kungbr

df amys df mky gusekbss jcmkib tcmt mffbjts ets stmkaeki ms mk mpprdvba

ekstetutedk, dr wcejc jcmkibs tcb ekfdrnmtedk dk wcejc et wms dreiekm``ympprdvba, ekj`uaeki8 jdrpdrmtedk jdkvbrsedk, nbribr, jdksd`eamtedk,

sujjbssedk, `equeamtedk, tbrnekmtedk< dr m jcmkib ek ets jcmrtbr prdvesedks,

kmnb, gy`mws, `djmtedk, dwkbrscep, jcmrmjtbr df gusekbss, dr sbkedr dffejbrs<dr m seikefejmkt rbaujtedk ek ets rbvbkubs, mssbts dr kbt wdrtc+ Zbb jcmptbr 6fdr abtme`s+

_mrt G+ Maaetedkm` Wbquerbnbkts fdr Zpbjefej Ndrtimibb Qypbs #QD_%

7.72 Ektrdaujtedk+ #QD_%

M ndrtimibb nmy gb mpprdvba td pmrtejepmtb ek tcb Abpmrtnbkt―s ndrtimibeksurmkjb prdirmns ms dkb df tcb fd``dweki abseikmtba typbs df ndrtimibb+Ek maaetedk td tcb ibkbrm` mpprdvm` rbquerbnbkts df _mrt M df tces jcmptbr, et

nust nbbt spbjefej rbquerbnbkts fdr ets pmrteju`mr ndrtimibb typb+

7.76 Zupbrvesba Ndrtimibbs+ #QD_%

M supbrvesba ndrtimibb es m fekmkjem` ekstetutedk tcmt es m nbngbr df tcb

Fbabrm` Wbsbrvb Zystbn dr mk ekstetutedk wcdsb mjjdukts mrb eksurba gy tcb

FAEJ dr tcb KJRM+ Zujc m ndrtimibb es kdt rbquerba td cmvb ndrtimib`bkaeki ms m prekjepm` mjtevety ms absjregba ek pmrmirmpc 7.75#J%+ M sugseaemry

dr mk mffe`emtb df m supbrvesba fekmkjem` ekstetutedk es kdt  jdkseabrba td gbsupbrvesba fdr mpprdvm` ms mk FCM ndrtimibb+ Bxmnp`bs df supbrvesbandrtimibbs mrb gmkls, smvekis mssdjemtedks, mka jrbaet ukedks+

M+ _brnesseg`b Ndrtimib @bkaeki Mjtevetebs+ M supbrvesba ndrtimibb

nmy dreiekmtb, ukabrwretb, purjcmsb, cd`a, sbrvejb, mka sb`` FCMeksurba ndrtimibs mka sugnet mpp`ejmtedks fdr ndrtimib eksurmkjb+

G+ Grmkjc Dffejbs+ M supbrvesba ndrtimibb nmy nmektmek FCMrbiestbrba grmkjc dffejbs tcmt dreiekmtb eksurba ndrtimibs+ Zpbjefejmpprdvm` rbquerbnbkts mrb ek jcmptbr 2+ Qcb ndrtimibb es fu` y

rbspdkseg`b td CRA fdr tcb mjtedks df ets dffejbs+

J+ Feaujemry Wb`mtedksceps+ Mpprdvm` df m fekmkjem` ekstetutedk ms m

supbrvesba ndrtimibb jdkstetutbs mpprdvm` fdr et td mjt ek m feaujemryjmpmjety ek ekvbsteki feaujemry fukas, wcejc mrb ukabr ets ekaeveaum` dr

 hdekt jdktrd`+ Ycbk sujc m feaujemry rb`mtedkscep es bkaba, mky eksurba

ndrtimibs cb`a ek tcb feaujemry bstmtb nust gb trmksfbrrba td mkmpprdvba supbrvesba ndrtimibb< tcb feaujemry rb`mtedkscep nust

pbrnet tcb trmksfbr+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 79 df 55

Page 28: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 28/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 9.=

Jcmptbr 9 ]um`ety Jdktrd` _`mk

9.= Ibkbrm`+ #QD_% M`` FCM mpprdvba ndrtimibbs, ekj`uaeki `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts, nust

enp`bnbkt mka jdktekudus`y cmvb ek p`mjb m ]um`ety Jdktrd` _`mk fdr tcb

dreiekmtedk mka$dr sbrvejeki df eksurba ndrtimibs ms m jdkaetedk df rbjbevekimka nmektmekeki FCM mpprdvm`+ Qces mpp`ebs td gdtc tcb Zeki`b Fmne`y mka tcbNu`tefmne`y Cduseki prdirmns+ M jdpy df tcb p`mk nust gb sugnettba wcbk

mpp`yeki fdr ndrtimibb mpprdvm`+

]um`ety Jdktrd` nust gb m prbsjregba mka rdutekb fukjtedk df bmjc

ndrtimibb)s dpbrmtedks wcbtcbr pbrfdrnba gy m ndrtimibb)s stmff dr mk

dutseab sdurjb+ Ndrtimibbs mpp`yeki fdr mpprdvm` td dreiekmtb dk`y dr sbrvejbdk`y nmy sugnet m p`mk tcmt pbrtmeks dk`y td tcb fukjtedk tcby we`` pbrfdrn+ Mndrtimibb tcmt we`` pbrfdrn gdtc dreiekmtedk mka sbrvejeki nust sugnet m p`mk

tcmt jdvbrs gdtc fukjtedks+

Qces Jcmptbr sbts fdrtc gmsej rbquerbnbkts tcmt m`` ndrtimibbs nust nbbt,m`dki wetc m abirbb df f`bxege`ety, sd tcmt bmjc ndrtimibb nmy abvb`dp mprdirmn tcmt fets ets jerjunstmkjbs wce`b jdkfdrneki td FCM)s rbquerbnbkts+Ndrtimibbs scdu`a jdkseabr tcmt sdnb df tcb rbquerbnbkts neict kdt gbmpp`ejmg`b td tcber dpbrmtedk+ Et es kbjbssmry td pbrfdrn ]um`ety Jdktrd` dk`y

dk tcdsb mjtevetebs ek wcejc m ndrtimibb es bkimiba+

_mrt M+ Dvbrm`` Wbquerbnbkts

9.7 Idm`s df ]um`ety Jdktrd`+ #QD_%

Qcb fd``dweki mrb tcb dvbrreaeki idm`s df ]um`ety Jdktrd`+ Ndrtimibbs nustabseik prdirmns tcmt nbbt tcbsb gmsej idm`s8

x Mssurb jdnp`emkjb wetc FCM)s mka tcb ndrtimibb)s dwk dreiekmtedk drsbrvejeki rbquerbnbkts tcrduicdut ets dpbrmtedks<

x _rdtbjt tcb ndrtimibb mka FCM frdn ukmjjbptmg`b resl<

x Iumra mimekst brrdrs, dnessedks mka frmua< mka

x Mssurb sweft mka mpprdpremtb jdrrbjtevb mjtedk+

Fme`urb td jdnp`y wetc spbjefej ]um`ety Jdktrd` rbquerbnbkts nmy rbsu`t ek

smkjtedks mka tcb enpdsetedk df Jeve` Ndkby _bkm`tebs gy tcb Ndrtimibb Wbvebw

Gdmra #NWG%+

9.: Gmsej B`bnbkts df ]um`ety Jdktrd`+ #QD_%

Qcbrb mrb sbvbrm` gmsej b`bnbkts tcmt mrb rbquerba ek m`` ]um`ety Jdktrd`_rdirmns tcmt mpp`y td gdtc dreiekmtedk mka sbrvejeki+

M+ _`mk Fdrn mka Bxbjutedk+ M`` ]um`ety Jdktrd` _rdirmns nust gb ekwreteki+ Ndrtimibbs nust cmvb fu``y fukjtedkeki ]um`ety Jdktrd`

_rdirmns frdn tcb amtb df tcber eketem` FCM mpprdvm` ukte` fekm`surrbkabr dr tbrnekmtedk df tcber mpprdvm`+

G+  Ekabpbkabkjb+ Qcb ]um`ety Jdktrd` fukjtedk nust gb ekabpbkabkt df 

tcb dreiekmtedk mka sbrvejeki fukjtedks+ Qces ekabpbkabkjb nmy gb

mjjdnp`escba ek m vmrebty df wmys+ Abpbkaeki dk m ndrtimibb)s

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 73 df 55

Page 29: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 29/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 9.7

dpbrmtedks, `dmk vd`unb, stmff sezb dr dtcbr fmjtdrs, m ndrtimibb nmyprbfbr dkb nbtcda dvbr mkdtcbr+ ]um`ety Jdktrd` fukjtedks nmy gb

pbrfdrnba useki8

=+  Ek.Cdusb Ztmff+ Ndrtimibbs nmy bstmg`esc m uket tcmt es

abaejmtba sd`b`y td ]um`ety Jdktrd`+ Ztmff pbrfdrneki ]um`etyJdktrd` rbvebws nust kdt gb ekvd`vba ek tcb amy.td.amy

prdjbssbs tcmt tcby mrb rbvebweki+ #QD_%

7+ Dutseab Ferns+ Ndrtimibbs nmy bkimib dutseab sdurjbs td

pbrfdrn tcb ]um`ety Jdktrd` fukjtedk+ Qcb FCM mpprdvba

spdksdrs df `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts mrb mjjbptmg`b ms sujc dutseabsdurjbs+ M ndrtimibb jdktrmjteki dut mky pmrt df ets ]um`ety

Jdktrd` fukjtedk es rbspdkseg`b fdr bksureki tcmt tcb dutseabsdurjb es nbbteki CRA)s rbquerbnbkts+ Mky mirbbnbkt wetc

tcb dutseab sdurjb nust gb ek wreteki, stmtb tcb rd`bs mkarbspdksege`etebs df bmjc pmrty, mka gb mvme`mg`b fdr rbvebw gy

CRA stmff+ #QD_%

J+ ]um`efeba Ztmff+ Ndrtimibbs nust prdpbr`y trmek stmff ekvd`vba ek]um`ety Jdktrd` mka prdveab tcbn mjjbss td jurrbkt iueab`ekbs rb`mteki

td tcb dpbrmtedks tcmt tcby rbvebw+ Et es kdt kbjbssmry fdr ndrtimibbstd nmektmek tcbsb iueab`ekbs ek cmra jdpy fdrnmt ef tcby mrb mjjbsseg`b

ek mk b`bjtrdkej fdrnmt+ Nmky df tcb stmtutbs, rbiu`mtedks, CRA

Cmkagddls mka Ndrtimibb @bttbrs wcejc bstmg`esc tcb rbquerbnbktsfdr FCM prdirmns mrb mvme`mg`b dk tcb wbg pmib fdr CRAJ@E_Z mt8

cttp8$$www+cuaj`eps+dri$jie$ekabx+jie+

A+ Qenb`ekbss+ Ndrtimibbs nust bksurb tcmt qum`ety jdktrd` rbvebws mrbpbrfdrnba dk m rbiu`mr mka tenb`y gmses+ Abpbkaeki dk m ndrtimibb)s

prdaujtedk vd`unb, dreiekmtedk rbvebws nmy gb pbrfdrnba wbbl`y,

ndktc`y, dr qumrtbr`y+ Qcb rbvebw df m spbjefej ndrtimib scdu`a gbjdnp`btba wetcek 5? amys df j`dseki+ Wbvebws df aeffbrbkt mspbjts df sbrvejeki we`` vmry ek frbqubkjy< cdwbvbr, ab`ekqubkt sbrvejeki mka `dss

neteimtedk mjtevetebs scdu`a gb rbvebwba ndktc`y+ Qenb`ekbss es

aesjussba furtcbr ek tcb Dreiekmtedk mka Zbrvejeki sbjtedks df tcesJcmptbr+

B+ Zystbn df @dmk Fe`b Wbvebw+ Qcb ]um`ety Jdktrd` _rdirmn nust

prdveab fdr tcb rbvebw df m rbprbsbktmtevb smnp`b df m ndrtimibb)s`dmks+ Qces rbvebw nust bvm`umtb tcb mjjurmjy mka mabqumjy df tcbekfdrnmtedk mka adjunbktmtedk usba ek rbmjceki abjesedks ek betcbr tcb

dreiekmtedk dr sbrvejeki prdjbssbs+ Zpbjefej b`bnbkts fdr etbns td

rbvebw mrb aesjussba ek tcb Dreiekmtedk mka Zbrvejeki sbjtedks df tcesJcmptbr+ #QD_%

F+  Mabqumtb Zjdpb mka Zmnp`eki+ Qcb ]um`ety Jdktrd` rbvebws nusttcdrduic`y bvm`umtb tcb ndrtimibb―s dreiekmtedk mka$dr sbrvejekifukjtedks td abtbrnekb tcb rddt jmusb df abfejebkjebs+ Qcb ndrtimibb

nust bxpmka tcb sjdpb df tcb ]um`ety Jdktrd` rbvebw wcbk frmua dr

pmttbrks df abfejebkjebs mrb ukjdvbrba< sjdpb nbmks gdtc mk ekjrbmsbakungbr df fe`bs ms wb`` ms ndrb ek.abptc rbvebw+ M`` mspbjts df tcb

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 75 df 55

Page 30: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 30/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 9.:

ndrtimibb―s dpbrmtedk, ekj`uaeki gut kdt `enetba td m`` grmkjc dffejbs drsetbs, FCM mpprdvba `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts, mutcdrezba mibkts, `dmk

dffejbrs dr dreiekmtdrs, prdjbssdrs, ukabrwretbrs, mpprmesbrs, j`dsekipbrsdkkb`, m`` FCM `dmk prdirmns, sbrvejeki pbrsdkkb`, `dss neteimtedkprdjbaurbs, bsjrdw mkm`yses, mka mssunptedks, nust gb sughbjt td tcb

ndrtimibb―s ]um`ety Jdktrd` rbvebws+ Zmnp`b Zezb es aesjussba ek tcbDreiekmtedk mka Zbrvejeki sbjtedks df tces Jcmptbr+ #QD_%

I+ Zetb Wbvebw+ M ndrtimibb)s dffejbs, ekj`uaeki trmaetedkm`,kdktrmaetedkm` grmkjc mka aerbjt `bkaeki dffejbs bkimiba ek dreiekmtedk

dr sbrvejeki df FCM.eksurba `dmks, nust gb rbvebwba td abtbrnekb tcmttcby mrb ek jdnp`emkjb wetc tcb Abpmrtnbkt)s rbquerbnbkts+

=+ Wbvebw Etbns+ Qcb rbvebw nust ekj`uab, gut kdt kbjbssmre`ygb `enetba td, jdkfernmtedk df tcb fd``dweki etbns8

x Qcb dffejb es prdpbr`y rbiestbrba wetc FCM mka tcb

maarbss es jurrbkt<

x Dpbrmtedks mrb jdkaujtba ek m prdfbssedkm`, gusekbss.`elbbkverdknbkt<

x Ef `djmtba ek jdnnbrjem` spmjb, tcb dffejb es prdpbr`y mka

j`bmr`y eabktefeba fdr mky wm`l.ek justdnbrs< cms

mabqumtb dffejb spmjb mka bquepnbkt< es ek m `djmtedkjdkaujevb td ndrtimib `bkaeki< mka es sbpmrmtba frdn

mky dtcbr bktety gy wm``s dr pmrtetedks #bktrmkjbs mkarbjbptedk mrbms nmy gb scmrba%<

x Ef `djmtba ek kdk.jdnnbrjem` spmjb, tcb dffejb cmsmabqumtb dffejb spmjb mka bquepnbkt< aesp`mys m fmer

cduseki pdstbr ef tcb pug`ej es rbjbevba< ef et es dpbk td

rbjbevb tcb pug`ej, et nust gb mjjbsseg`b td pbrsdks wetcaesmge`etebs, ekj`uaeki tcdsb wetc ndge`ety enpmernbkts< ef 

et es kdt dpbk td tcb pug`ej, gut usba djjmsedkm``y tdnbbt wetc nbngbrs df tcb pug`ej, m`tbrkmtb nbmks df 

mjjdnndamtedk nmy gb usba td sbrvb pbrsdks wetcaesmge`etebs<

x Qcb sbrvejeki dffejb prdveabs td``.frbb `ekbs dr mjjbpts

jd``bjt jm``s frdn ndrtimidrs<

x Qcb dffejb es suffejebkt`y stmffba wetc trmekba pbrsdkkb`<

x Dffejb pbrsdkkb` cmvb mjjbss td rb`bvmkt stmtutbs,

rbiu`mtedks, CRA essumkjbs mka Cmkagddls, betcbr ek

cmra jdpy dr b`bjtrdkejm``y<

x _rdjbaurbs mrb rbvesba td rbf`bjt jcmkibs ek CRA

rbquerbnbkts mka pbrsdkkb` mrb ekfdrnba df tcb

jcmkibs<x _brsdkkb` mt tcb dffejb mrb m`` bnp`dybbs df tcb

ndrtimibb dr jdktrmjt bnp`dybbs pbrfdrneki fukjtedks

tcmt FCM m``dws td gb dutsdurjba< mka

x Qcb dffejb adbs kdt bnp`dy dr cmvb m jdktrmjt wetcmkydkb jurrbkt`y ukabr abgmrnbkt dr suspbksedk, dr m

@enetba Abkem` df _mrtejepmtedk+ #QD_%

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib :? df 55

Page 31: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 31/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 9.1

7+ Frbqubkjy+ Qbjckd`diy bkmg`bs ndrtimibbs td jdkaujtbffbjtevb ]um`ety Jdktrd` rbndtb`y+ Mkkum` vesets mrb nmkamtdry

fdr dffejbs nbbteki jbrtmek ceicbr resl jretbrem sujc ms ceic bmr`yabfmu`t rmtbs, kbw grmkjcbs dr kbw lby pbrsdkkb`, suaabkekjrbmsbs ek vd`unb, mka pmst prdg`bns+ Dtcbr setbs nust gb

rbvebwba td mssurb jdnp`emkjb wetc FCM)s rbquerbnbkts mt mfrbqubkjy mka ek m nmkkbr abtbrnekba mpprdpremtb gy tcbndrtimibb+ Qcb jretbrem usba gy tcb ndrtimibb td abtbrnekbtcb frbqubkjy df dk.setb rbvebws nust gb ek wreteki mka

mvme`mg`b fdr rbvebw gy CRA mt tcb jdrpdrmtb dffejb mka mky

grmkjc dffejb tcmt es kdt gbeki rbvebwba mkkum``y+

:+ Ztmffeki+ Ycbk et es kdt fbmseg`b fdr ]um`ety Jdktrd` stmff td veset

bmjc grmkjc, qum`efeba pbrsdkkb` frdn mkdtcbr dffejb df tcbndrtimibb, kdt ekvd`vba ek tcb amy.td.amy prdjbssbs tcby mrbrbvebweki, dr mk dutseab fern nmy pbrfdrn tcb rbvebw+ #QD_%

C+  Mffe`emtb Wbvebw+ Qcb Abpmrtnbkt rbquerbs ndrtimibbs td bksurbtcmt tcber jdktrmjtdrs, mibkts, mka `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts mrb mjjbptmg`btd FCM mka dpbrmtb ek jdnp`emkjb wetc FCM rbquerbnbkts+ #QD_%

=+ Zpdksdrs+ M spdksdr)s ]um`ety Jdktrd` _rdirmn nust prdveabfdr m rbvebw df `dmks dreiekmtba mka sd`a td et gy bmjc df ets `dmk

jdrrbspdkabkts+ spdksdrs scdu`a abtbrnekb tcb mpprdpremtb

pbrjbktmib td rbvebw gmsba dk vd`unb, pmst bxpbrebkjb mkadtcbr fmjtdrs+ Zpdksdrs nust adjunbkt tcb nbtcdad`diebs mkarbsu`ts+

7+ @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkts+ @dmk jdrrbspdkabkts nmy mrrmkib wetctcber spdksdr#s% td pbrfdrn ]um`ety Jdktrd` prdveaba8

x Qcb mrrmkibnbkt wetc tcb spdksdr#s% es abtme`ba ekwreteki<

x Qcb miirbimtb kungbr mka sjdpb df rbvebws nbbt FCMrbquerbnbkts<

x @dmks mrb rbvebwba wetcek 5? amys df j`dseki<

x Fekaekis mrb j`bmr ms td sdurjb mka jmusb< mka

x Wbsu`ts mrb mvme`mg`b ek m tenb`y nmkkbr td gdtc

ndrtimibbs mka CRA+

:+ Ycd`b @dmk mka Zbrvejeki _urjcmsbrs+ Ndrtimibbsmjquereki `dmks nust jdkfern tcmt ndrtimib eksurmkjb

prbneuns cmvb gbbk pmea, eksurmkjb es ek fdrjb, sbjurety

ekstrunbkts cmvb gbbk rbjdraba, mka tcmt tcb fe`bs mka rbjdrasmrb jdnp`btb mka ms bxpbjtba+ #QD_%

E+ Wbpdrteki mka Jdrrbjtevb Mjtedk+ Wbvebw fekaekis nust gb rbpdrtbatd tcb ndrtimibb)s sbkedr nmkmibnbkt wetcek dkb ndktc df jdnp`btedk df tcb eketem` rbpdrt+ Nmkmibnbkt nust tmlb prdnpt mjtedk

td abm` mpprdpremtb`y wetc mky nmtbrem` fekaekis+ Qcb fekm` rbpdrt dr mk

maabkaun nust eabktefy mjtedks gbeki tmlbk, tcb tenbtmg`b fdr tcberjdnp`btedk, mka mky p`mkkba fd``dw.up mjtevetebs+ #QD_%

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib := df 55

Page 32: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 32/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 9.2

H+ Kdtefejmtedk td CRA+ Fekaekis df frmua dr dtcbr sbredus ved`mtedks

nust gb ennbaemtb`y rbfbrrba, ek wreteki #m`dki wetc mky mvme`mg`bsuppdrteki adjunbktmtedk% td tcb Aerbjtdr df tcb ]um`ety MssurmkjbAevesedk ek tcb CRA Cdnbdwkbrscep Jbktbr #CDJ% cmveki huresaejtedk

#abtbrnekba gy tcb Ztmtb wcbrb tcb prdpbrty es `djmtba%+ Ek `ebu df sugnetteki m pmpbr rbpdrt, ndrtimibbs nust usb tcb @bkabr Wbpdrtekifbmturb ek tcb Kbeicgdrcdda Ymtjc Bmr`y Ymrkeki Zystbn+ Ef CRAstmff es suspbjtba df ekvd`vbnbkt, rbfbr td tcb Dffejb df Ekspbjtdr

Ibkbrm` mt 12= 9tc Ztrbbt, ZY, Wddn 3726, Ymscekitdk, AJ 7?1=?+

M ndrtimibb―s ]um`ety Jdktrd` _rdirmn nust bksurb tcmt fekaekisaesjdvbrba gy bnp`dybbs aureki tcb kdrnm` jdursb df gusekbss mka gy

qum`ety jdktrd` stmff aureki rbvebws$muaets df FCM `dmks mrb rbpdrtba tdCRA wetcek 6? amys df tcb eketem` aesjdvbry+ #QD_%

L+ Fe`b Wbtbktedk+ Qcb ]um`ety Jdktrd` rbvebw rbpdrt mka fd``dw.up,

ekj`uaeki rbvebw fekaekis mka mjtedks tmlbk, p`us prdjbaurm`ekfdrnmtedk #sujc ms tcb pbrjbktmib df `dmks rbvebwba, gmses fdrsb`bjteki `dmks, mka wcd pbrfdrnba tcb rbvebw% nust gb rbtmekba gy

tcb ndrtimibb fdr m pbreda df twd ybmrs+ Qcbsb rbjdras nust gb nmabmvme`mg`b td CRA dk rbqubst+ #QD_%

@+ Wbstrejtba _mrtejepmtedk+ Abtbrnekb tcmt kd dkb es bnp`dyba fdr

CRA dreiekmtedk, prdjbsseki, ukabrwreteki dr sbrvejeki wcd esabgmrrba, suspbkaba, sughbjt td m @enetba Abkem` df _mrtejepmtedk #@A_%dr dtcbrwesb rbstrejtba frdn pmrtejepmtedk ek CRA$FCM prdirmns+

Ndrtimibbs nust pbredaejm``y jcbjl bnp`dybb `est, mt `bmst sbne.

mkkum``y+ #QD_%

9.1 ]um`ety Jdktrd` ms m Wesl Mssbssnbkt Qdd`+Qcb Abpmrtnbkt rbjdnnbkas tcmt ]um`ety Jdktrd` rbpdrts td ndrtimibbnmkmibnbkt ekj`uab mk mssbssnbkt df resls+ Ndrtimibbs nmy abvb`dp msystbn df bvm`umteki bmjc ]um`ety Jdktrd` smnp`b dk tcb gmses df tcb sbvbrety

df tcb ved`mtedks fduka aureki tcb rbvebw+ Qcb systbn scdu`a bkmg`b m

ndrtimibb td jdnpmrb dkb ndktc)s smnp`b td prbvedus smnp`bs sd tcbndrtimibb nmy jdkaujt trbka mkm`yses+

Nmkmibnbkt jmk m`sd usb tces tdd` td rbspdka quejl`y td m suaabk abj`ekb ek tcbqum`ety df ets `dmks mka cb`p eabktefy mka jdrrbjt tcb prdg`bn+ Ndrtimibbs nmyjdkseabr m rmtekis systbn sujc ms tcb fd``dweki fdr bmjc `dmk rbvebwba, tcbk

miirbimtb tcbsb ektd mk dvbrm`` rmteki fdr tcb smnp`b+

M+ @dw Wesl+ Kd, dr m nekdr, prdg`bn wms eabktefeba wetc tcb dreiekmtedk

dr sbrvejeki df tcb `dmk+ #QD_%

G+  Mjjbptmg`b Wesl+ M vmrebty df essubs wbrb eabktefeba pbrtmekeki tdprdjbsseki, adjunbktmtedk dr abjesedks nmab gut kdkb wbrb nmtbrem`

td jrbaetwdrtcekbss, jd``mtbrm` sbjurety dr eksurmge`ety df tcb `dmk+ #QD_%

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib :7 df 55

Page 33: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 33/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 9.6

J+ Ndabrmtb Wesl+ Qcb rbjdras jdktmekba seikefejmkt ukrbsd`vbaqubstedks dr nesseki adjunbktmtedk+ Fme`urb td rbsd`vb tcbsb essubs

cms jrbmtba m ndabrmtb resl td tcb ndrtimibb mka FCM+ #QD_%

A+ Nmtbrem` Wesl+ Qcb essubs eabktefeba aureki tcb rbvebw wbrb nmtbrem`

ved`mtedks df FCM dr ndrtimibb rbquerbnbkts mka rbprbsbkt mkukmjjbptmg`b `bvb` df resl+ Fdr bxmnp`b, m seikefejmkt nesjm`ju`mtedk df tcb eksurmg`b ndrtimib mndukt dr tcb mpp`ejmkt)s jmpmjety td rbpmy,fme`urb td ukabrwretb mk mssunptedk dr prdtbjt mgmkadkba prdpbrty

frdn amnmib, dr frmua+ Ndrtimibbs nust rbpdrt tcbsb `dmks, ek

wreteki, td tcb ]um`ety Mssurmkjb Aevesedk ek tcb FCM CdnbdwkbrscepJbktbr cmveki huresaejtedk+

_mrt G+ ]um`ety Jdktrd` fdr Zeki`b Fmne`y Dreiekmtedk

9.2 ]um`ety Jdktrd` frdn Gbiekkeki td Bka+ #QD_%

]um`ety Jdktrd` fdr dreiekmtedk cms cestdrejm``y gbbk pbrfdrnba dk`y mt tcb bka

df tcb prdjbss, tcmt es, mftbr m `dmk cms j`dsba+ Ek drabr td nmlb et ndrbusbfu`, ndrtimibbs mrb bkjdurmiba td enp`bnbkt ]um`ety Jdktrd` tcrduicdut

tcb `dmk dreiekmtedk prdjbss+ Qcb fd``dweki rbjdnnbkamtedks we`` cb p

ndrtimibbs mjjdnp`esc tcbsb bkas8

M+ Ndketdr Mpp`ejmtedk _rdjbss+ Ndrtimibbs scdu`a ndketdr tcb ektmlbdf ndrtimidr ekfdrnmtedk td bksurb suffejebkt qubstedks mrb mslba td

b`ejet m jdnp`btb pejturb df tcb ndrtimidr―s fekmkjem` setumtedk, tcb

sdurjb df fukas fdr tcb trmksmjtedk, tcb ektbkaba usb df tcb prdpbrty,mka tcmt bnp`dybbs wdrleki wetc tcb ndrtimib mpp`ejmkt mrblkdw`baibmg`b df tcb dreiekmtedk prdjbss td fu``y absjregb tcb

ndrtimidr―s rbspdksege`etebs ek dgtmekeki m FCM.eksurba ndrtimib+ Qces

nmy ekvd`vb pbredaejm``y ndketdreki jm``s mka fd``dweki up wetcmpp`ejmkts rbimraeki tcber trbmtnbkt mka ukabrstmkaeki df tcb prdjbss

mka tcber dg`eimtedks #b+i+, td mvdea nesrbprbsbktmtedk mka

fm`sefejmtedk%+ Ndrtimibbs nust m`sd vbrefy tcb eabktety df tcb `dmkmpp`ejmkt+

G+ Jdkaujt _rb.fukaeki Wbvebws+ Ndrtimibbs nmy wmkt td smnp`bjmsbs predr td j`dseki td bvm`umtb tcb qum`ety df prdjbsseki mka

ukabrwreteki+ Rseki sujc rbvebws, ndrtimibbs nmy abtbjt prdg`bns

predr td j`dseki wce`b prdg`bns jmk ste`` gb jdrrbjtba+ Qces wdu`a gbbspbjem` y gbkbfejem` ek jmsbs ekvd`veki `dmks wetc ceicbr resl

jcmrmjtbrestejs+ Mk enpdrtmkt pmrt df prb.fukaeki rbvebws esrbvbrefejmtedk #gy tb`bpcdkb dr ek wreteki% df tcb mpp`ejmkt)s

bnp`dynbkt, sdurjb df fukas mka rbseabkjy cestdry+ Ef m wrettbkrbvbrefejmtedk rbjbevba aureki m prb.fukaeki ]um`ety Jdktrd` rbvebw es

smtesfmjtdry, mkdtcbr wrettbk rbvbrefejmtedk es kdt rbquerba ef tcb `dmk essb`bjtba fdr pdst.j`dseki rbvebw+ #QD_%

J+  Eabktefy _mttbrks+ Ndrtimibbs nust eabktefy pmttbrks df bmr`y

abfmu`ts gy `djmtedk, prdirmn, `dmk jcmrmjtbrestej, `dmk jdrrbspdkabkt

dr spdksdr+ Ndrtimibbs nmy usb CRA―s Kbeicgdrcdda Ymtjc . Bmr`y 

Ymrkeki Zystbn td eabktefy pmttbrks+ Ndrtimibbs nust eabktefy

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib :: df 55

Page 34: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 34/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 9.9

jdnndkm`etebs mndki pmrtejepmkts ek tcb ndrtimib dreiekmtedk prdjbsstd `bmrk tcb bxtbkt df tcber ekvd`vbnbkt ek prdg`bn jmsbs+ @dmks

ekvd`veki mpprmesbrs, `dmk dffejbrs, prdjbssdrs, ukabrwretbrs, btj+ wcdcmvb gbbk mssdjemtba wetc prdg`bns nust gb ekj`uaba ek tcb rbvebwsmnp`b+

9.6 Gmsej Wbquerbnbkts fdr ]um`ety Jdktrd` df Zeki`b Fmne`y _rdaujtedk+Ek drabr fdr m ]um`ety Jdktrd` _rdirmn td gb usbfu` mka mjjbptmg`b td FCM,tcbrb mrb sbvbrm` rbquerbnbkts tcmt nust gb nbt+ Ndrtimibbs nust macbrbtd bmjc df tcb rbquerbnbkts gb`dw wcbk jdkaujteki rbvebws+ #QD_%

M+ Qenb`ekbss+ @dmks nust gb rbvebwba wetcek 5? amys frdn tcb bka df tcb ndktc ek wcejc tcb `dmk j`dsba+ Qces rbquerbnbkt es ektbkaba td

bksurb tcmt prdg`bns `bft ukabtbjtba predr td j`dseki mrb eabktefeba ms

bmr`y mftbr j`dseki ms pdsseg`b+ #QD_%

G+ Frbqubkjy+ Fdr ndrtimibbs j`dseki ndrb tcmk =2 `dmks ndktc`y,

qum`ety jdktrd` rbvebws nust gb jdkaujtba mt `bmst ndktc`y mka nust

maarbss dkb ndktc)s mjtevety+ Ndrtimibbs j`dseki =2 dr fbwbr `dmksndktc`y nmy pbrfdrn qum`ety jdktrd` rbvebws dk m qumrtbr`y gmses+

J+ Zmnp`b Zezb mka @dmk Zb`bjtedk+ Gbjmusb et es kdt fbmseg`b td rbvebwm`` `dmks dreiekmtba aureki m pbreda, tcb _rdirmn nust rbquerb tcmt mk

mpprdpremtb`y sezba smnp`b es sb`bjtba mka bvm`umtba aureki bmjc

rbvebw+ M ndrtimibb wcd dreiekmtbs mka$dr ukabrwretbs :,2?? drfbwbr FCM `dmks pbr ybmr nust rbvebw =? " df tcb FCM `dmks et

dreiekmtbs+ M ndrtimibb wcd dreiekmtbs mka$dr ukabrwretbs ndrb tcmk:,2?? FCM `dmks pbr ybmr nmy rbvebw =? " df ets `dmks dr m stmtestejm`

rmkadn smnp`eki tcmt prdveabs m 52 " jdkfeabkjb `bvb` wetc 7 "

prbjesedk+ Bmjc rbvebw nust adjunbkt cdw tcb smnp`b sezb mkasb`bjtedks wbrb abtbrnekba+ #QD_%

Wbimra`bss df tcb pbrjbktmib df `dmks gbeki rbvebwba, tcb ndrtimibb

nust jdnp`y wetc tcb fd``dweki8

=+ Qmribteki @dmks fdr Wbvebw+ Qcb ]um`ety Jdktrd` _rdirmnnust jdktmek prdvesedks td sb`bjt `dmks nbbteki tcb jdkaetedks

stmtba gb`dw+ Et nmy kdt gb fbmseg`b td sb`bjt `dmks frdn bmjcjmtbidry bvbry ndktc, gut mk bffdrt nust gb nmab td sb`bjt

`dmks frdn bmjc jmtbidry ms dftbk ms pdsseg`b+ Mk bnpcmses

scdu`a gb p`mjba dk mky pmrtejepmkts tcmt cmvb `mrib vd`unbs df `dmks, scdw suaabk ekjrbmsbs ek `dmk vd`unbs dr `dmk abfmu`t

rmtbs, cmvb rbjbkt`y gbiuk m rb`mtedkscep wetc tcb ndrtimibb,

dr jdkjbktrmtb ek sdft nmrlbt mrbms+

m+ @dmks nust gb rbvebwba frdn m`` grmkjc dffejbs mka m``

sdurjbs ekj`uaeki mutcdrezba mibkts mka `dmkjdrrbspdkabkts< #QD_%

g+ Ndrtimibbs nust rbvebw tcb wdrl df bmjc df tcb `dmk

prdjbssdrs, `dmk dffejbrs, mka ukabrwretbrs gmsba dk tcbsmnp`b sb`bjtba+ Ek maaetedk, ndrtimibbs nust rbvebw

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib :1 df 55

Page 35: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 35/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 9.3

tcb wdrl df rdstbr mpprmesbrs, rbm` bstmtb jdnpmkebs,mka gue`abrs wetc wcdn tcby ad m seikefejmkt mndukt df 

gusekbss< mka #QD_%

j+ Qcb smnp`b nust ekj`uab m`` FCM prdirmns ek wcejc tcb

ndrtimibb pmrtejepmtbs ekj`uaeki, gut kdt `enetba td,7?:#g%, 7?:#l%, 7:1#j%, mka Cdnb Bquety JdkvbrsedkNdrtimibs+

7+ Wbjdnnbkamtedks fdr Zb`bjteki Ekaeveaum` @dmks+ Qcb

Abpmrtnbkt)s bxpbrebkjb ek rbvebweki `dmks tcmt wbkt ektd bmr`yabfmu`t cms scdwk tcmt nmky cmvb dkb dr ndrb df tcb

jcmrmjtbrestejs `estba gb`dw+ Et es rbjdnnbkaba tcmt

ndrtimibbs jdkseabr tcbsb jcmrmjtbrestejs, dr mky maaetedkm`dkbs tcby feka usbfu`, ek eabktefyeki `dmks td gb rbvebwba+ #QD_%

x 7.1 uket prdpbrtebs<

x Kbw jdkstrujtedk dr rbcmg `dmks<

x _rdpbrtebs trmksfbrrba wetcek tcb pmst ybmr<

x Zugstmktem` sb``br jdkjbssedks<

x Kdk.djjupyeki jd.ndrtimidrs dr nu`tep`b ndrtimidrs<

x Cduseki bxpbksbs ekjrbmseki gy =+2 tenbs dr ndrb<

x @mrib dr nu`tep`b bmrkbst ndkby abpdsets #ndkby

drabrs%<

x @mrib ekjrbmsb ek gmkl mjjdukt gm`mkjb<

x Zm`b df pbrsdkm` prdpbrty fdr fukas td j`dsb<

x Iefts dr `dmks df fukas td j`dsb<

x Zb`f.bnp`dyba< mka

x @dmks resl mssbssba ms ‐rbfbrs„ gy mutdnmtbaukabrwreteki systbns+

A+ Bmr`y _mynbkt Abfmu`ts+ Ek maaetedk td tcb `dmks sb`bjtba fdr rdutekbqum`ety jdktrd` rbvebws, ndrtimibbs nust rbvebw m`` `dmks ideki ektdabfmu`t wetcek tcb ferst sex pmynbkts+ Ms abfekba cbrb, bmr`y pmynbktabfmu`ts mrb `dmks tcmt gbjdnb 6? amys pmst aub+ #QD_%

B+ Adjunbktmtedk Wbvebw mka Vbrefejmtedk+ Qcb ]um`ety Jdktrd`_rdirmn nust prdveab fdr tcb rbvebw mka jdkfernmtedk df ekfdrnmtedk

dk m`` `dmks sb`bjtba fdr rbvebw+ #QD_%

=+ Jrbaet Wbpdrt+ M kbw jrbaet rbpdrt nust gb dgtmekba fdr bmjcgdrrdwbr wcdsb `dmk es ekj`uaba ek m ]um`ety Jdktrd` rbvebw,

uk`bss tcb `dmk wms m strbmn`ekb rbfekmkjb dr wms prdjbssba

useki m FCM mpprdvba mutdnmtba ukabrwreteki systbnbxbnptba frdn tces rbquerbnbkt+ M jrbaet rbpdrt dgtmekba fdr m

]um`ety Jdktrd` rbvebw nmy gb m Wbseabktem` Ndrtimib Jrbaet

Wbpdrt, m tcrbb rbpdsetdry nbriba ek.fe`b rbpdrt dr, wcbkmpprdpremtb, m gusekbss jrbaet rbpdrt+ Qcb rbpdrt nust jdnp`ywetc tcb jrbaet rbpdrt stmkamras absjregba ek CRA Cmkagddl

1=22+= #ms rbvesba%+ M fu`` Wbseabktem` Ndrtimib Jrbaet Wbpdrtnust gb dgtmekba frdn m aeffbrbkt jrbaet sdurjb dk jmsbs ek

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib :2 df 55

Page 36: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 36/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 9.5

wcejc tcb ek.fe`b rbpdrt rbvbm`s aesjrbpmkjebs wetc tcb dreiekm`jrbaet rbpdrt+ #QD_%

7+ Jrbaet Adjunbkt Wb.vbrefejmtedk+ Adjunbkts jdktmekba ektcb `dmk fe`b scdu`a gb jcbjlba fdr suffejebkjy mka sughbjtba td

wrettbk rb.vbrefejmtedk+ Bxmnp`bs df etbns tcmt nust gb rb.vbrefeba ekj`uab, gut mrb kdt `enetba td, tcb ndrtimidr)sbnp`dynbkt dr dtcbr ekjdnb, abpdsets, ieft `bttbrs, m`tbrkmtbjrbaet sdurjbs, mka dtcbr sdurjbs df fukas+ Zdurjbs df fukas

nust gb mjjbptmg`b ms wb`` ms vbrefeba+ Dtcbr etbns tcmt nmy

gb rb.vbrefeba ekj`uab ndrtimib dr rbkt pmynbkts+ Ef tcbwrettbk rb.vbrefejmtedk es kdt rbturkba td tcb ndrtimibb, m

adjunbktba mttbnpt nust gb nmab td jdkaujt m tb`bpcdkb rb.

vbrefejmtedk+ Ef tcb dreiekm` ekfdrnmtedk wms dgtmekbab`bjtrdkejm``y dr ekvd`vba m`tbrkmtevb adjunbkts, m wrettbk rb.vbrefejmtedk nust ste`` gb mttbnptba+ Mky aesjrbpmkjebs nust gb

bxp`drba td bksurb tcmt tcb dreiekm` adjunbkts #bxjbpt g`mklbt

vbrefejmtedk rb`bmsbs% wbrb jdnp`btba gbfdrb gbeki seikba, wbrbms rbprbsbktba, wbrb kdt cmka`ba gy ektbrbstba tcera pmrtebs

mka tcmt m`` jdrrbjtedks wbrb prdpbr mka eketem`ba+ M`` jdkf`ejteki

ekfdrnmtedk ek tcb dreiekm` adjunbktmtedk scdu`a cmvb gbbkrbsd`vba gbfdrb tcb jdnp`btb fe`b wms sugnettba td tcbukabrwretbr+

:+  Mpprmesm`s+ M absl rbvebw df tcb prdpbrty mpprmesm` nust gbpbrfdrnba dk m`` `dmks jcdsbk fdr m ]um`ety Jdktrd` rbvebw

bxjbpt strbmn`ekb rbfekmkjbs mka CRA Wbm` Bstmtb Dwkba#WBD% sm`bs+ Qcb absl rbvebw nust ekj`uab m rbvebw df tcb

mpprmesm` amtm, tcb vm`eaety df tcb jdnpmrmg`bs, tcb vm`ub

jdkj`usedk #'ms rbpmerba' td nbbt smfbty mka sdukakbss

rbquerbnbkts ek CRA Cmkagddl 15?2+= #ms rbvesba%%, mkyjcmkibs nmab gy tcb ukabrwretbr mka tcb dvbrm`` qum`ety df tcbmpprmesm`+ #QD_%

Ndrtimibbs mrb bxpbjtba td pbrfdrn feb`a rbvebws dk =? " df 

tcb `dmks sb`bjtba aureki tcb smnp`eki prdjbss dut`ekbaprbvedus`y ek pmrmirmpc 9.6 J mka A+ Feb`a rbvebws nust gb

pbrfdrnba gy `ejbksba mpprmesbrs `estba dk FCM―s Wdstbr df 

Mpprmesbrs+ Ndrtimibbs scdu`a sb`bjt `dmks fdr feb`a rbvebwsgmsba dk fmjtdrs sujc ms tcdsb `estba prbvedus`y ek pmrmirmpc9.6#J%#7% mka tcb fd``dweki8

x _rdpbrty jdnp`mekts rbjbevba frdn ndrtimidrs<

x Aesjrbpmkjebs fduka aureki absl rbvebws<

x @mrib mahustnbkts td vm`ub<

x Jdnpmrmg`b sm`bs ndrb tcmk sex ndktcs d`a<

x Bxjbssevb aestmkjbs frdn jdnpmrmg`bs td tcb sughbjtprdpbrty<

x Wbpbtetevb sm`bs mjtevety fdr tcb sughbjt prdpbrty<

x Ekvbstdr.sd`a prdpbrtebs<

x Eabktety df ektbrbst gbtwbbk guybr mka sb``br<

x Zb``br eabktety aeffbrs frdn dwkbr df rbjdra< mka

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib :6 df 55

Page 37: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 37/99

1?6?+= WBV.7

?3$?6 9.=?

x Vmjmkt prdpbrtebs+

Ek maaetedk, m feb`a rbvebw scdu`a gb jdnp`btba dk `dmkssb`bjtba ek mjjdramkjb wetc pmrmirmpcs 9.6#J% mka #A% wcbrbtcb absl rbvebw rbvbm`ba seikefejmkt prdg`bns$abfejebkjebs wetc

tcb mpprmesm` rbpdrt+ Ef sbredus abfejebkjebs dr pmttbrks mrbukjdvbrba, ndrtimibbs nust rbpdrt tcbsb etbns, ek wreteki, tdtcb ]um`ety Mssurmkjb Aevesedk ek tcb CRA CdnbdwkbrscepJbktbr cmveki huresaejtedk+ #QD_%

1+ Djjupmkjy Wbvbrefejmtedk+ Ek jmsbs wcbrb tcb djjupmkjy df tcb sughbjt prdpbrty es suspbjt, ndrtimibbs nust mttbnpt tdabtbrnekb wcbtcbr tcb ndrtimidr es djjupyeki tcb prdpbrty+

Qcb fme`urb df tcb ndrtimidr td djjupy tcb prdpbrty nmy gb mkekaejmtedk tcmt tcb `dmk jdktmeks dtcbr prdg`bns+ Ef et es fdukatcmt tcb ndrtimidr es kdt djjupyeki m prdpbrty ndrtimiba ms

dwkbr.djjupeba, ndrtimibbs nust rbpdrt tces, ek wreteki, td tcb

]um`ety Mssurmkjb Aevesedk ek tcb CRA Cdnbdwkbrscep Jbktbrcmveki huresaejtedk+ Et m`sd wdu`a gb mavesmg`b td rbvebw dtcbr

sene`mr `dmks fdr djjupmkjy+ #QD_%

F+ Rkabrwreteki Abjesedks+ Bmjc Aerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt `dmk sb`bjtba fdrm qum`ety jdktrd` rbvebw nust gb rbvebwba fdr jdnp`emkjb wetc CRA

ukabrwreteki rbquerbnbkts, suffejebkjy df adjunbktmtedk mka tcb

sdukakbss df ukabrwreteki huainbkts+ #QD_%

I+ Jdkaetedk J`bmrmkjb mka J`dseki+ Bmjc `dmk sb`bjtba fdr m qum`ety

jdktrd` rbvebw nust gb rbvebwba td abtbrnekb wcbtcbr8

x Jdkaetedks wcejc wbrb rbquerba td gb smtesfeba predr td j`dseki

wbrb ek fmjt nbt predr td j`dseki<x Qcb sb``br wms tcb dwkbr df rbjdra, dr wms bxbnpt frdn tcb

dwkbr df rbjdra rbquerbnbkt ek mjjdramkjb wetc CRArbiu`mtedks<

x Qcb `dmk wms j`dsba mka fukas aesgursba ek mjjdramkjb wetc tcb

ndrtimibb)s ukabrwreteki mka sugsbqubkt j`dseki ekstrujtedks<mka

x Qcb j`dseki mka `bim` adjunbkts mrb mjjurmtb mka jdnp`btb+

9.9 Zpbjefej B`bnbkts fdr tcb _rdaujtedk _drtedk df tcb ]um`ety Jdktrd`_rdirmn+ #QD_%

M ndrtimibb)s ]um`ety Jdktrd` _rdirmn nust prdveab fdr m rbvebw df ndrtimib

`dmk fe`bs td bvm`umtb tcb `dmk dreiekmtedk mka ukabrwreteki fukjtedks+ QcbAbpmrtnbkt cms fduka tcmt tcb etbns `estba gb`dw mrb typejm``y fduka ek m

idda ]um`ety Jdktrd` _rdirmn+ Nekenm``y, tcb ]um`ety Jdktrd` _rdirmn nustmaarbss tcbsb b`bnbkts ms wb`` ms mky dtcbrs tcmt neict gb usbfu` ek tcb

bvm`umtedk+

M+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr tcb ekfdrnmtedk ek tcb prb`enekmry `dmk mpp`ejmtedk,

fekm` mpp`ejmtedk mka m`` jrbaet adjunbkts es jdksestbkt dr rbjdkje`ba+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib :9 df 55

Page 38: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 38/99

CRA Cmkagddl 1=22+= Wbv.2Jcmptbrs 7, :.=

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib :3 df 55

Page 39: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 39/99

1=22+= WBV.2

JCM_QBW 7

NDWQIMIB JWBAEQ MKM@UZEZ

7.= DVBWVEBY+ Qcb purpdsb df ukabrwreteki es td abtbrnekb m gdrrdwbr―s mge`ety

mka we``ekikbss td rbpmy tcb ndrtimib abgt, tcus `eneteki tcb prdgmge`ety df abfmu`t mka jd``bjtedk aeffeju`tebs, mka td bxmnekb tcb prdpbrty dffbrba ms sbjuretyfdr tcb `dmk td abtbrnekb ef et es suffejebkt jd``mtbrm`+ Qcb ‐Fdur J―s df Jrbaet„#Jrbaet cestdry, Jmpmjety td rbpmy, Jmsc td j`dsb, mka tcb Jd``mtbrm`% mrb bvm`umtbaaureki tcb ukabrwreteki prdjbss+

Qces jcmptbr dk ndrtimib jrbaet mkm`yses absjregbs prdjbaurbs fdr bvm`umteki tcbjrbaet cestdry, tcb gdrrdwbr―s jmpmjety td nmlb pmynbkts, mka wcbtcbr suffejebktjmsc mssbts mrb mvme`mg`b td j`dsb tcb ndrtimib+ Et prdveabs tcb rbquerbnbkts dktcb typbs df ekjdnb tcmt nmy gb jdkseabrba ek qum`efyeki tcb gdrrdwbr, tcb`emge`etebs tcmt nust gb ekj`uaba ek tcb abtbrnekeki jrbaetwdrtcekbss, mka tcb abgt.

td.ekjdnb rmteds mka jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs usba ek tcb ukabrwreteki prdjbss+Qcbsb ukabrwreteki ekstrujtedks mrb FCM―s ‐gmsb.`ekb„ jrbaet pd`ejebs+ Fdr tcdsb`bkabrs useki FCM.mpprdvba mutdnmtba ukabrwreteki systbns #MRZ% dr tcdsbbnp`dyeki FCM―s QDQM@ ndrtimib sjdrbjmra, tcbrb we`` gb m jdkseabrmg`bkungbr df rbvesedks td tcbsb pd`ejebs, ekj`uaeki adjunbktmtedk rbquerbnbkts, msabsjregba ek dtcbr FCM essumkjbs+

7.7 NDWQIMIB B@EIEGE@EQU #GDWWDYBWZ%+ Ibkbrm``y, wb we`` eksurbndrtimibs nmab td ekaeveaum`s dk`y+ Rkabr tcb jdkaetedks absjregba ek Jcmptbr =,wb we`` m`sd eksurb ndrtimibs nmab td stmtb mka `djm` idvbrknbkt mibkjebs mkampprdvba kdkprdfet drimkezmtedks+

M+ Gdrrdwbrs, Jd.Gdrrdwbrs mka Jd.Zeikbrs+ Gdrrdwbrs mka Jd. gdrrdwbrs tmlb tet`b td tcb prdpbrty mka mrb dg`eimtba dk tcb ndrtimib kdtbmka nust m`sd seik tcb sbjurety ekstrunbkt+ Qcb jd.gdrrdwbr―s ekjdnb,mssbts, `emge`etebs, mka jrbaet cestdry mrb jdkseabrba ek abtbrnekekijrbaetwdrtcekbss+

Jd.seikbrs ad kdt cd`a dwkbrscep ektbrbst ek m prdpbrty, gut mrb `emg`b fdr rbpmyeki tcb dg`eimtedk mka nust seik m`` adjunbkts wetc tcb bxjbptedk df tcb sbjurety ekstrunbkts+ Qcb jd.seikbr)s ekjdnb, mssbts, `emge`etebs, mkajrbaet cestdry mrb jdkseabrba ek abtbrnekeki jrbaetwdrtcekbss fdr tcbndrtimib mka tcb jd.seikbr nust jdnp`btb mka seik tcb `dmk mpp`ejmtedk+

Yb ad kdt pbrnet mk ekaeveaum` td tmlb mk dwkbrscep ektbrbst ek tcb prdpbrty mt sbtt`bnbkt wetcdut seikeki tcb ndrtimib kdtb mka m`` sbjuretyekstrunbkts+

Qcb fd``dweki jdkaetedks m`sd mpp`y td jd.gdrrdwbr mka jd.seikbr b`eiege`ety8

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.=

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib :5 df 55

Page 40: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 40/99

1=22+= WBV.2

=+ M jd.gdrrdwbr dr m jd.seikbr nmy kdt gb m pmrty tcmt cms mfekmkjem` ektbrbst ek tcb trmksmjtedk, sujc ms tcb sb``br, gue`abr, rbm`bstmtb mibkt, btj+ Bxjbptedks nmy gb irmktba ef tcb sb``br mka jd. gdrrdwbr$jd.seikbr es rb`mtba td tcb dwkbr gy g`dda, nmrremib dr `mw+

7+ Mk ekaeveaum` seikeki tcb `dmk mpp`ejmtedk nust kdt gb dtcbrwesbekb`eieg`b fdr pmrtejepmtedk+ #Zbb pmrmirmpc 7.2%+

:+ Rk`bss dtcbrwesb bxbnptba #b+i+, ne`etmry sbrvejb wetc dvbrsbmsmsseiknbkts, R+Z+ jetezbks `eveki mgrdma%, mky kdk.djjupyeki jd. gdrrdwbrs dr jd.seikbrs nust cmvb m prekjepm` rbseabkjb ek tcbRketba Ztmtbs+

 M`` rbfbrbkjbs td jd.gdrrdwbrs ‚ ekj`uaeki tcb 92 pbrjbkt @QV `enets

#pmrmirmpc =.3#G%%, btj+ ‚ mpp`y bqum``y td jd.seikbrs #bxjbpt jd.seikbrs

ad kdt tmlb tet`b td tcb prdpbrty dr seik tcb sbjurety ekstrunbkts%+

G+ Jetezbkscep mka Enneirmtedk Ztmtus+ Jetezbkscep df tcb Rketba Ztmtbs eskdt rbquerba fdr b`eiege`ety+ Ycbk m ndrtimib dmk mpp`ejmkt ekaejmtbs dktcb `dmk mpp`ejmtedk tcmt cb dr scb cd`as sdnbtceki dtcbr tcmk R+Z+jetezbkscep, tcb `bkabr nust abtbrnekb rbseabkjy stmtus frdn tcbadjunbktmtedk prdveaba gy tcb gdrrdwbr+

 @mwfu` _brnmkbkt Wbseabkt M`ebks8 Fdr tcdsb gdrrdwbrs wetc `mwfu`  pbrnmkbkt rbseabkt m`ebk stmtus, FCM we`` eksurb tcb ndrtimib ukabr tcbsmnb tbrns mka jdkaetedks ms R+Z+ jetezbks+ Qcb `bkabr nust adjunbkt tcbndrtimib fe`b wetc bveabkjb df pbrnmkbkt rbseabkjy mka ekaejmtb dk tcbRkefdrn Wbseabktem` @dmk Mpp`ejmtedk #RW@M% tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr es m`mwfu` pbrnmkbkt rbseabkt m`ebk+ Bveabkjb df `mwfu` pbrnmkbkt rbseabkjyes essuba gy tcb Gurbmu df Jetezbkscep mka Enneirmtedk Zbrvejbs #GJEZ%#fdrnbr`y tcb Enneirmtedk mka Kmturm`ezmtedk Zbrvejb% wetcek tcbAbpmrtnbkt df Cdnb`mka Zbjurety+

 Kdk._brnmkbkt Wbseabkt M`ebks8 FCM we`` m`sd eksurb m ndrtimib nmabtd m kdk.pbrnmkbkt rbseabkt m`ebk prdveaba tcmt tcb prdpbrty we`` gb tcb gdrrdwbr)s prekjepm` rbseabkjb, tcb gdrrdwbr cms m vm`ea ZZK, mka tcb gdrrdwbr es b`eieg`b td wdrl ek tcb R+Z+ ms bveabkjba gy mk Bnp`dynbktMutcdrezmtedk Adjunbkt #BMA% essuba gy GJEZ+ Ef tcb mutcdrezmtedk fdr tbnpdrmry rbseabkjy stmtus we`` bxperb wetcek dkb ybmr mka m predr cestdrydf rbseabkjy stmtus rbkbwm`s bxests, tcb `bkabr nmy mssunb jdktekumtedkwe`` gb irmktba+ Ef tcbrb mrb kd predr rbkbwm`s, tcb `bkabr nust abtbrnekbtcb `elb`ecdda df rbkbwm`, gmsba dk ekfdrnmtedk frdn tcb GJEZ+

M`tcduic sdjem` sbjurety jmras nmy ekaejmtb wdrl stmtus, sujc ms ‐kdt vm`eafdr wdrl purpdsbs,„ mk ekaeveaum`―s wdrl stmtus nmy jcmkib wetcdut tcb

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.7

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 1? df 55

Page 41: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 41/99

1=22+= WBV.2

jcmkib gbeki rbf`bjtba dk tcb mjtum` sdjem` sbjurety jmra+ Qcbrbfdrb, tcbsdjem` sbjurety jmra es kdt td gb usba ms bveabkjb df wdrl stmtus fdr kdk. pbrnmkbkt rbseabkt m`ebks< tcb GJEZ bnp`dynbkt mutcdrezmtedk adjunbktes td gb usba ekstbma+

 Kdk.R+Z+ Jetezbks wetc kd `mwfu` rbseabkjy ek tcb R+Z+ mrb kdt b`eieg`b fdr FCM.eksurba ndrtimibs+

J+ Gdrrdwbr)s Mib+ Qcbrb es kd nmxenun mib `enet fdr m gdrrdwbr+ Qcbnekenun mib es tcb mib mt wcejc tcb ndrtimib kdtb jmk gb bkfdrjba`bim``y ek tcb stmtb dr dtcbr huresaejtedk ek wcejc tcb prdpbrty es `djmtba+

A+ Kdk._urjcmseki Zpdusbs+ Ef rbquerba gy stmtb `mw ek drabr td pbrfbjt mvm`ea mka bkfdrjbmg`b ferst `ebk, tcb kdk.purjcmseki spdusb nmy gbrbquerba td seik betcbr tcb sbjurety ekstrunbkt dr adjunbktmtedkbveabkjeki tcmt cb dr scb es rb`ekquesceki m`` reicts td tcb prdpbrty+ Ef tcb

kdk.purjcmseki spdusb bxbjutbs tcb sbjurety ekstrunbkt fdr sujc rbmsdks,cb dr scb es kdt jdkseabrba m gdrrdwbr fdr dur purpdsbs mka kbba kdt seiktcb `dmk mpp`ejmtedk+ Ek m`` dtcbr jmsbs, tcb kdk.purjcmseki spdusb es kdttd mppbmr dk tcb sbjurety ekstrunbkt dr dtcbrwesb tmlb tet`b td tcb prdpbrtymt `dmk sbtt`bnbkt+

Ycbrb tcbrb mrb kdk.purjcmseki spdusbs wcd seik sbjurety ekstrunbktsrb`ekquesceki tcber reicts td tcb prdpbrty pursumkt td mpp`ejmg`b stmtb `mws,tcbsb kdk.purjcmseki spdusbs ad kdt cmvb td seik tcb ndrtimib kdtb+Zeikeki tcb sbjurety ekstrunbkt fdr sujc purpdsbs adbs kdt nmlb tcb kdk. purjcmseki spdusb m jd.gdrrdwbr+

Bxjbpt fdr tcb dg`eimtedks spbjefejm``y bxj`uaba gy stmtb `mw, tcb abgts df tcb kdk.purjcmseki spdusb nust gb ekj`uaba ek tcb gdrrdwbr―s qum`efyekirmteds ef tcb gdrrdwbr rbseabs ek m jdnnukety prdpbrty stmtb dr tcb prdpbrtytd gb eksurba es `djmtba ek m jdnnukety prdpbrty stmtb+ M`tcduic tcb kdk. purjcmseki spdusb)s jrbaet cestdry es kdt td gb jdkseabrba m rbmsdk fdr jrbaet abkem`, m jrbaet rbpdrt tcmt jdnp`ebs wetc tcb rbquerbnbkts df  pmrmirmpc 7.1 nust gb dgtmekba fdr tcb kdk.purjcmseki spdusb ek drabr tdabtbrnekb tcb abgt.td.ekjdnb rmted+

B+ Ne`etmry _brsdkkb`+ Ne`etmry pbrsdkkb` mrb jdkseabrba djjupmkt.dwkbrsmka mrb b`eieg`b fdr nmxenun fekmkjeki ef m nbngbr df tcb ennbaemtbfmne`y we`` djjupy tcb prdpbrty ms m prekjepm` rbseabkjb, bvbk ef tcbsbrvejb pbrsdk es stmtedkba b`sbwcbrb+

F+ @eveki Qrusts+ _rdpbrty cb`a ek m `eveki trust es b`eieg`b fdr FCMndrtimib eksurmkjb fdr dwkbr.djjupeba prdpbrty, ms `dki ms mk ekaeveaum` gdrrdwbr rbnmeks tcb gbkbfejemry mka djjupebs tcb prdpbrty ms m prekjepm`rbseabkjb+ Qcb `bkabr nust gb smtesfeba tcmt tcb trust prdveabs rbmsdkmg`b

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.:

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 1= df 55

Page 42: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 42/99

1=22+= WBV.2

nbmks td mssurb tcmt tcb `bkabr we`` gb kdtefeba df mky sugsbqubkt jcmkibdf djjupmkjy #fdr dwkbr.djjupmkt `dmks dk`y% dr trmksfbr df gbkbfejem`ektbrbst+ Qcb trust nust mppbmr dk tcb sbjurety ekstrunbkt #e+b+, ndrtimib,abba df trust, sbjurety abba%+ Qcb ekaeveaum` gdrrdwbr nust mppbmr dk tcbsbjurety ekstrunbkt wcbk rbquerba td jrbmtb m vm`ea `ebk ukabr stmtb `mw<

dtcbrwesb, tcb ekaeveaum` gdrrdwbr es kdt rbquerba td mppbmr+ Qcb dwkbr.djjupmkt, ef mky, mka dtcbr gdrrdwbr#s%, ef mky, nust mppbmr dk tcb kdtbwetc tcb trust+ Qcb ekaeveaum` gdrrdwbr#s% es kdt rbquerba td mppbmr dk tcb prdpbrty abba dr tet`b+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.1

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 17 df 55

Page 43: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 43/99

1=22+= WBV.2

ZBJQEDK =8 JWBAEQ CEZQDWU

7.: MKM@UXEKI QCB GDWWDYBW―Z JWBAEQ+ _mst jrbaet pbrfdrnmkjb sbrvbsms tcb ndst usbfu` iueab ek abtbrnekeki m gdrrdwbr―s mttetuab tdwmra jrbaetdg`eimtedks mka prbaejteki m gdrrdwbr―s futurb mjtedks+ M gdrrdwbr wcd cms nmab

 pmynbkts dk prbvedus mka jurrbkt dg`eimtedks ek m tenb`y nmkkbr rbprbsbktsrbaujba resl+ Jdkvbrsb`y, ef tcb jrbaet cestdry, abspetb mabqumtb ekjdnb td suppdrtdg`eimtedks, rbf`bjts jdktekudus s`dw pmynbkts, huainbkts, mka ab`ekqubktmjjdukts, strdki jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs we`` gb kbjbssmry td mpprdvb tcb `dmk+

Ycbk mkm`yzeki m gdrrdwbr)s jrbaet cestdry, bxmnekb tcb dvbrm`` pmttbrk df jrbaet gbcmvedr, rmtcbr tcmk esd`mtba djjurrbkjbs df uksmtesfmjtdry dr s`dw pmynbkts+ M pbreda df fekmkjem` aeffeju`ty ek tcb pmst adbs kdt kbjbssmre`y nmlb tcb resl ukmjjbptmg`b ef tcb gdrrdwbr cms nmektmekba m idda pmynbkt rbjdra fdr mjdkseabrmg`b tenb pbreda sekjb tcb aeffeju`ty+ Ycbk ab`ekqubkt mjjdukts mrbrbvbm`ba, tcb `bkabr nust adjunbkt tcber mkm`yses ms td wcbtcbr tcb `mtb pmynbkts

wbrb gmsba dk m aesrbimra fdr fekmkjem` dg`eimtedks, mk ekmge`ety td nmkmib abgt, dr fmjtdrs gbydka tcb jdktrd` df tcb gdrrdwbr, ekj`uaeki ab`myba nme` ab`evbry dr aesputbs wetc jrbaetdrs+

Yce`b nekdr abrdimtdry ekfdrnmtedk djjurreki twd dr ndrb ybmrs ek tcb pmst adbskdt rbquerb bxp`mkmtedk, nmhdr ekaejmtedks df abrdimtdry jrbaet‚ekj`uaeki huainbkts, jd``bjtedks, mka mky dtcbr rbjbkt jrbaet prdg`bns‚rbquerb suffejebktwrettbk bxp`mkmtedk frdn tcb gdrrdwbr+ Qcb gdrrdwbr)s bxp`mkmtedk nust nmlbsbksb mka gb jdksestbkt wetc dtcbr jrbaet ekfdrnmtedk ek tcb fe`b+

 Kbetcbr tcb `mjl df jrbaet cestdry kdr tcb gdrrdwbr)s abjesedk kdt td usb jrbaet nmy gb usba ms m gmses fdr rbhbjteki tcb `dmk mpp`ejmtedk+ Yb m`sd rbjdikezb tcmt sdnb prdspbjtevb gdrrdwbrs nmy kdt cmvb mk bstmg`escba jrbaet cestdry+ Fdr tcdsb gdrrdwbrs, mka fdr tcdsb wcd ad kdt usb trmaetedkm` jrbaet, tcb `bkabr nustabvb`dp m jrbaet cestdry frdn ute`ety pmynbkt rbjdras, rbktm` pmynbkts, mutdndge`beksurmkjb pmynbkts, dr dtcbr nbmks df aerbjt mjjbss frdn tcb jrbaet prdveabr+ Qcb`bkabr nust adjunbkt tcmt tcb prdveabrs df kdk.trmaetedkm` jrbaet ad, ek fmjt, bxestmka vbrefy tcb jrbaet ekfdrnmtedk+ Adjunbkts jdkferneki tcb bxestbkjb df m kdk.trmaetedkm` jrbaet prdveabr nmy ekj`uab m pug`ej rbjdra frdn tcb stmtb, jdukty, dr jety rbjdras, dr dtcbr nbmks prdveaeki m sene`mr `bvb` df dghbjtevb jdkfernmtedk+Qd vbrefy tcb jrbaet ekfdrnmtedk, `bkabrs nust usb m pug`escba maarbss dr tb`bpcdkb kungbr fdr tcmt jrbaetdr+

Ms mk m`tbrkmtevb, tcb `bkabr nmy b`bjt td usb m kdk.trmaetedkm` ndrtimib jrbaetrbpdrt abvb`dpba gy m jrbaet.rbpdrteki mibkjy, prdveaba tcmt tcb jrbaet rbpdrtekimibkjy cms vbrefeba tcb bxestbkjb df tcb jrbaet prdveabrs mka tcb `bkabr vbrefebstcmt tcb kdk.trmaetedkm` jrbaet wms bxtbkaba td tcb mpp`ejmkt+ Qcb `bkabr nustvbrefy tcb jrbaet useki m pug`escba maarbss dr tb`bpcdkb kungbr td nmlb tcmtvbrefejmtedk+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.2

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 1: df 55

Page 44: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 44/99

1=22+= WBV.2

Qcb gmsej cebrmrjcy df jrbaet bvm`umtedk es tcb nmkkbr df pmynbkts nmab dk prbvedus cduseki bxpbksbs, ekj`uaeki ute`etebs, fd``dwba gy tcb pmynbkt cestdry df ekstm``nbkt abgts, mka tcbk rbvd`veki mjjdukts+ Ibkbrm``y, mk ekaeveaum` wetc kd`mtb cduseki dr ekstm``nbkt abgt pmynbkts scdu`a gb jdkseabrba ms cmveki mkmjjbptmg`b jrbaet cestdry, uk`bss tcbrb es nmhdr abrdimtdry jrbaet dk ces dr cbr 

rbvd`veki mjjdukts+

Ycbk rbvebweki tcb gdrrdwbr)s jrbaet mka jrbaet rbpdrt, tcb `bkabr nust pmy pmrteju`mr mttbktedk td tcb fd``dweki8

M+ _rbvedus Wbktm` dr Ndrtimib _mynbkt Cestdry+ Qcb pmynbkt cestdrydf tcb gdrrdwbr)s cduseki dg`eimtedks cd`as seikefejmkt enpdrtmkjb ekbvm`umteki jrbaet+ Qcb `bkabr nust abtbrnekb tcb gdrrdwbr)s pmynbktcestdry df cduseki dg`eimtedks tcrduic betcbr tcb jrbaet rbpdrt, vbrefejmtedkdf rbkt aerbjt`y frdn tcb `mka`dra #wetc kd eabktety.df.ektbrbst wetc tcb gdrrdwbr% dr vbrefejmtedk df ndrtimib aerbjt`y frdn tcb ndrtimib sbrvejbr,

dr tcrduic jmkjb`ba jcbjls jdvbreki tcb ndst rbjbkt =7.ndktc pbreda+

G+ Wbjbkt mka$dr Rkaesj`dsba Abgts+ Qcb `bkabr nust msjbrtmek tcb purpdsb df mky rbjbkt abgts, ms tcb ekabgtbakbss nmy cmvb gbbk ekjurrbatd dgtmek pmrt df tcb rbquerba jmsc ekvbstnbkt dk tcb prdpbrty gbeki purjcmsba+ Zene`mr`y, tcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab m smtesfmjtdrybxp`mkmtedk fdr mky seikefejmkt abgt tcmt es scdwk dk tcb jrbaet rbpdrt gutkdt `estba dk tcb `dmk mpp`ejmtedk+ Qcb gdrrdwbr nust bxp`mek ek wretekim`` ekquerebs scdwk dk tcb jrbaet rbpdrt ek tcb `mst 5? amys+

J+ Jd``bjtedks mka Huainbkts+ Jdurt.drabrba huainbkts nust gb pmea dff  gbfdrb tcb ndrtimib `dmk es b`eieg`b fdr FCM eksurmkjb bkadrsbnbkt+ #Mkbxjbptedk nmy gb nmab ef tcb gdrrdwbr cms mirbba wetc tcb jrbaetdr tdnmlb rbiu`mr mka tenb`y pmynbkts dk tcb huainbkt mka adjunbktmtedk es prdveaba tcmt tcb pmynbkts cmvb gbbk nmab ek mjjdramkjb wetc tcbmirbbnbkt+% FCM adbs kdt rbquerb tcmt jd``bjtedk mjjdukts gb pmea dff ms mjdkaetedk df ndrtimib mpprdvm`+ Jd``bjtedks mka huainbkts ekaejmtb m gdrrdwbr―s rbimra fdr jrbaet dg`eimtedks mka nust gb jdkseabrba ek tcbmkm`yses df jrbaetwdrtcekbss wetc tcb `bkabr adjunbkteki ets rbmsdks fdr mpprdveki m ndrtimib wcbrb tcb gdrrdwbr cms jd``bjtedk mjjdukts dr  huainbkts+ Qcb gdrrdwbr nust bxp`mek ek wreteki m`` jd``bjtedks mka huainbkts+

A+ _rbvedus Ndrtimib Fdrbj`dsurb+ M gdrrdwbr wcdsb prbvedus prekjepm`rbseabkjb dr dtcbr rbm` prdpbrty wms fdrbj`dsba dr cms ievbk m abba.ek.`ebudf fdrbj`dsurb wetcek tcb prbvedus tcrbb ybmrs es ibkbrm``y kdt b`eieg`b fdr mkbw FCM.eksurba ndrtimib+ Cdwbvbr, ef tcb fdrbj`dsurb wms tcb rbsu`t df adjunbktba bxtbkumteki jerjunstmkjbs tcmt wbrb gbydka tcb jdktrd` df tcb gdrrdwbr mka tcb gdrrdwbr cms rb.bstmg`escba idda jrbaet sekjb tcbfdrbj`dsurb, tcb `bkabr nmy irmkt mk bxjbptedk td tcb tcrbb.ybmr 

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.6

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 11 df 55

Page 45: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 45/99

1=22+= WBV.2

rbquerbnbkt+ Bxtbkumteki jerjunstmkjbs ekj`uab sbredus e``kbss dr abmtc df m wmib bmrkbr, gut ad kdt ekj`uab tcb ekmge`ety td sb`` tcb cdusb gbjmusb df m hdg trmksfbr dr rb`djmtedk td mkdtcbr mrbm+

B+ Gmklruptjy+ M Jcmptbr 9 gmklruptjy #`equeamtedk% adbs kdt aesqum`efy m

 gdrrdwbr frdn dgtmekeki mk FCM.eksurba ndrtimib ef mt `bmst twd ybmrscmvb b`mpsba sekjb tcb amtb df tcb aesjcmrib df tcb gmklruptjy+Maaetedkm``y, tcb gdrrdwbr nust cmvb rb.bstmg`escba idda jrbaet dr jcdsbkkdt td ekjur kbw jrbaet dg`eimtedks+ Qcb gdrrdwbr m`sd nust cmvbabndkstrmtba m adjunbktba mge`ety td rbspdkseg`y nmkmib ces dr cbr fekmkjem` mffmers+ Mk b`mpsba pbreda df `bss tcmk twd ybmrs, gut kdt `bsstcmk =7 ndktcs, nmy gb mjjbptmg`b ef tcb gdrrdwbr jmk scdw tcmt tcb gmklruptjy wms jmusba gy bxtbkumteki jerjunstmkjbs gbydka ces dr cbr jdktrd` mka cms sekjb bxcegetba m adjunbktba mge`ety td nmkmib ces dr cbr fekmkjem` mffmers ek m rbspdkseg`b nmkkbr+ Maaetedkm``y, tcb `bkabr nustadjunbkt tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr―s jurrbkt setumtedk ekaejmtbs tcmt tcb bvbkts

tcmt `ba td tcb gmklruptjy mrb kdt `elb`y td rbjur+

M Jcmptbr =: gmklruptjy adbs kdt aesqum`efy m gdrrdwbr frdn dgtmekekimk FCM.eksurba ndrtimib prdveaba tcb `bkabr adjunbkts tcmt dkb ybmr df tcb pmydut pbreda ukabr tcb gmklruptjy cms b`mpsba mka tcb gdrrdwbr―s pmynbkt pbrfdrnmkjb cms gbbk smtesfmjtdry #e+b+, m`` rbquerba pmynbktsnmab dk tenb%+ Ek maaetedk, tcb gdrrdwbr nust rbjbevb pbrnessedk frdntcb jdurt td bktbr ektd tcb ndrtimib trmksmjtedk+

F+ Jdksunbr Jrbaet Jduksb`eki _mynbkt _`mks+ _mrtejepmtedk ek mjdksunbr jrbaet jduksb`eki pmynbkt prdirmn adbs kdt aesqum`efy m gdrrdwbr frdn dgtmekeki mk FCM.eksurba ndrtimib prdveaba tcb `bkabr adjunbkts tcmt dkb ybmr df tcb pmy.dut pbreda cms b`mpsba ukabr tcb p`mkmka tcb gdrrdwbr―s pmynbkt pbrfdrnmkjb cms gbbk smtesfmjtdry #e+b+, m``rbquerba pmynbkts nmab dk tenb%+ Ek maaetedk, tcb gdrrdwbr nust rbjbevbwrettbk pbrnessedk frdn tcb jduksb`eki mibkjy td bktbr ektd tcb ndrtimibtrmksmjtedk+

7.1 JWBAEQ WB_DWQ WB]REWBNBKQZ+

M+ Qrmaetedkm` Jrbaet Wbpdrts+ Jrbaet rbpdrts sugnettba wetc bmjc `dmknust jdktmek m`` jrbaet mvme`mg`b ek tcb mjjbssba rbpdsetdrebs+ Qcby m`sdnust prdveab mk mjjdukt df m`` jrbaet, rbseabkjb cestdry, mka pug`ej rbjdrasekfdrnmtedk mvme`mg`b ek tcb jrbaet rbpdsetdrebs df bmjc gdrrdwbr rbspdkseg`b fdr tcb ndrtimib abgt+ Qcb nekenun jrbaet rbpdrt rbquerba gyFCM es m 'tcrbb rbpdsetdry nbriba' jrbaet rbpdrt #QWNJW%+ MWbseabktem` Ndrtimib Jrbaet Wbpdrt #WNJW% frdn mk ekabpbkabktjdksunbr.rbpdrteki mibkjy m`sd nmy gb usba+ Dkb rbpdrt es rbquerba fdr bmjc gdrrdwbr, dr m hdekt rbpdrt nmy gb dgtmekba fdr m nmrreba jdup`b+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.9

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 12 df 55

Page 46: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 46/99

1=22+= WBV.2

Qcb fd``dweki mrb rbquerbnbkts fdr trmaetedkm` jrbaet rbpdrts8

=+ Qcb QWNJW sugnettba nust gb mk dreiekm` rbjbevba b`bjtrdkejm``ymka prektba dk tcb `bkabr)s prektbr dr ab`evbrba gy tcb jrbaet.rbpdrteki mibkjy+ Qcb rbpdrt nust kdt cmvb wcetbduts, brmsurbs, dr 

m`tbrmtedks+ Et nust ekaejmtb tcb kmnb, maarbss, mka tb`bpcdkbkungbr df tcb jdksunbr.rbpdrteki mibkjy< mka bmjc mjjdukt `estbanust scdw tcb prenmry rbpdsetdry frdn wcejc tcb pmrteju`mr ekfdrnmtedk wms pu``ba+ Qcb kmnb df tcb jdnpmky drabreki tcbrbpdrt nust gb scdwk+

7+ Qcb jrbaet rbpdrt nust ekj`uab m`` jrbaet mka `bim` ekfdrnmtedk kdtjdkseabrba dgsd`btb ukabr tcb Fmer Jrbaet Wbpdrteki Mjt, ekj`uaeki gmklruptjebs, huainbkts, `mw suets, fdrbj`dsurbs, mka tmx `ebks tcmtcmvb djjurrba wetcek tcb `mst sbvbk ybmrs+ M`` ekquerebs nmabwetcek tcb `mst 5? amys nust m`sd gb ekj`uaba dk tcb rbpdrt+ Jrbaet

rbpdrts tcmt fme` td scdw gmklruptjebs, huainbkts, `mwsuets,fdrbj`dsurbs mka tmx `ebks nust gb supp`bnbktba wetc m jdrrbjtbarbpdrt+ @bkabrs nust rbtmek m`` jdpebs df m`` jrbaet rbpdrts mkaadjunbkt ek wreteki mk mkm`yses df tcb rbmsdks fdr mkyaesjrbpmkjebs gbtwbbk tcb jrbaet rbpdrts+ Ef m `bkabr rbjbevbs mkyekfdrnmtedk ekjdksestbkt wetc tcb ekfdrnmtedk dk tcb jrbaet rbpdrt,tcb `bkabr nust rbjdkje`b tcb ekjdksestbkjy+

:+ Qcb jrbaet rbpdrt nust eabktefy bmjc gdrrdwbr)s kmnb mka sdjem`sbjurety kungbr+ Fdr bmjc abgt `estba, tcb rbpdrt m`sd nust scdwtcb amtb tcb mjjdukt wms dpbkba, tcb ceic jrbaet mndukt, tcbrbquerba pmynbkt, tcb ukpmea gm`mkjb, mka tcb pmynbkt cestdry, msjdktmekba ek tcb jrbaet rbpdsetdrebs+ Qcb rbpdrt nust gb ek mk bmsy.td.rbma mka ukabrstmkamg`b fdrnmt, mka et scdu`a kdt rbquerb jdabtrmks`mtedks+

1+ Qcb `bkabr nust m`sd abvb`dp jrbaet ekfdrnmtedk sbpmrmtb`y fdr mkydpbk abgt tcmt es `estba dk tcb `dmk mpp`ejmtedk gut kdt rbfbrbkjbadk tcb jrbaet rbpdrt+ Mjjdukts `estba ms 'rmtb gy nme` dk`y' dr 'kbba wrettbk mutcdrezmtedk' rbquerb sbpmrmtb wrettbk vbrefejmtedk+

2+ Yce`b tcb QWNJW scdu`a prdvb suffejebkt fdr prdjbsseki ndst`dmk mpp`ejmtedks, tcb fd``dweki jerjunstmkjbs rbquerb mk WNJW8

m+ Qcb gdrrdwbr#s% aesputbs tcb dwkbrscep df mjjdukts dk tcbQWNJW< dr 

 g+ Qcb gdrrdwbr#s% j`mens tcmt jd``bjtedks, huainbkts, dr `ebks`estba ms dpbk dk tcb QWNJW cmvb gbbk pmea mka jmkkdt prdveab sbpmrmtb adjunbktmtedk suppdrteki tces j`men< dr 

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.3

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 16 df 55

Page 47: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 47/99

1=22+= WBV.2

j+ Qcb gdrrdwbr j`mens tcmt jbrtmek abgts scdwk dk tcb QWNJW cmvb aeffbrbkt gm`mkjbs mka$dr pmynbkts mka jmkkdt prdveabjurrbkt stmtbnbkts #`bss tcmk :? amys d`a% mttbsteki td tcesj`men< dr 

a+ Qcb `bkabr)s ukabrwretbr abtbrnekbs tcmt et wdu`a gb pruabkt td

usb mk WNJW ek `ebu df m QWNJW td ukabrwretb tcb `dmk prdpbr`y+

6+ WNJWs nust mjjbss mt `bmst twd kmnba rbpdsetdrebs mka nbbt m``tcb rbquerbnbkts fdr tcb QWNJW, p`us tcb fd``dweki8

m+ _rdveab m abtme`ba mjjdukt df tcb gdrrdwbr)s bnp`dynbktcestdry+

 g+ Vbrefy bmjc gdrrdwbr)s jurrbkt bnp`dynbkt mka ekjdnb #ef dgtmekmg`b%+ Et m`sd nust ekj`uab m stmtbnbkt mttbsteki tdjbrtefejmtedk df bnp`dynbkt mka amtb vbrefeba+ Ef tces

ekfdrnmtedk es kdt dgtmekba tcrduic mk ektbrvebw wetc tcbbnp`dybr, tcb jrbaet rbpdrteki mibkjy nust stmtb wcy tcesmjtedk wms kdt tmlbk+

j+ Bmjc mjjdukt wetc m gm`mkjb nust cmvb gbbk jcbjlba wetctcb jrbaetdr wetcek 5? amys df tcb jrbaet rbpdrt+

G+ Jrbaet Wbpdrt Wbquerbnbkts #Kdk.Qrmaetedkm`%+ M Kdk.Qrmaetedkm`Ndrtimib Jrbaet Wbpdrt #KQNJW% es abseikba td mssbss tcb jrbaet cestdrydf m gdrrdwbr wetcdut tcb typbs df trmab rbfbrbkjbs kdrnm``y mppbmreki dkm trmaetedkm` jrbaet rbpdrt+ Et jmk gb usba betcbr ms m sugstetutb fdr mQWNJW dr mk WNJW fdr m gdrrdwbr wetcdut m jrbaet cestdry wetctrmaetedkm` jrbaet irmktdrs dr ms m supp`bnbkt td m trmaetedkm` jrbaet rbpdrtcmveki mk eksuffejebkt kungbr df trmab etbns rbpdrtba+ M KQNJW nmykdt, cdwbvbr, gb usba td bkcmkjb tcb jrbaet cestdry df m gdrrdwbr wetc m pddr pmynbkt rbjdra dr td nmkufmjturb m jrbaet rbpdrt fdr m gdrrdwbr wetcdut m vbrefemg`b jrbaet cestdry+ Et m`sd nmy kdt gb usba td dffsbtabrdimtdry rbfbrbkjbs fduka ek tcb gdrrdwbr)s trmaetedkm` jrbaet, sujc msjd``bjtedks mka huainbkts+

Qcb fd``dweki jdkaetedks mpp`y wcbk useki kdk.trmaetedkm` jrbaetrbpdrteki8

=+ Ef tcb ekfdrnmtedk dgtmekba tcrduic tcb stmkamra jrbaet rbpdrt es kdtsuffejebkt fdr tcb `bkabr td nmlb m pruabkt ukabrwreteki abjesedk,tcb `bkabrs nmy usb m KQNJW abvb`dpba gy m jrbaet.rbpdrtekimibkjy tcmt adjunbkts m`` kdk.trmaetedkm` jrbaet rbfbrbkjbs+Dtcbrwesb, tcb `bkabr nust abvb`dp ets dwk kdk.trmaetedkm` jrbaetcestdry tcmt es jdksestbkt wetc tcb rbquerbnbkts fdr jrbaet rbpdrtekimibkjebs absjregba ek pmrmirmpc 7.1+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.5

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 19 df 55

Page 48: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 48/99

1=22+= WBV.2

7+ Qcb jrbaet.rbpdrteki mibkjy scdu`a jdkseabr dk`y tcb typbs df jrbaet tcmt rbquerb tcb ndrtimib mpp`ejmkt td nmlb pbredaej pmynbkts dk m rbiu`mr gmses+ Qcbsb typbs df jrbaet ekj`uab rbktm`cduseki< ute`etebs #ef kdt ekj`uaba ek tcb rbktm` pmynbkt%< tb`bpcdkbsbrvejb< jmg`b tb`bvesedk sbrvejb< eksurmkjb pmynbkts #bxj`uaeki

tcdsb pmea tcrduic pmyrd`` abaujtedks%, sujc ms nbaejm`,mutdndge`b, `efb, cdusbcd`a, mka rbktbr)s eksurmkjb< pmynbkts tdjce`a jmrb prdveabrs< sjcdd` tuetedk< pmynbkts td `djm` stdrbs< pmynbkts fdr tcb ukeksurba pdrtedk df mky nbaejm` ge``s< btj+

7.2 B@EIEGE@EQU FDW FBABWM@@U.WB@MQBA JWBAEQ+ M gdrrdwbr nust gb rbhbjtba ef mky df tcb fd``dweki jdkaetedks mpp`y8

M+ CRA @enetba Abkem` df _mrtejepmtedk #@A_% mka tcb R+Z+ Ibkbrm`

Zbrvejbs Manekestrmtedk―s ‐@est df _mrtebs Bxj`uaba frdn Fbabrm`

_rdjurbnbkt mka Kdk._rdjurbnbkt _rdirmns„ #IZM @est% M pbrsdk

suspbkaba, abgmrrba, dr dtcbrwesb bxj`uaba frdn pmrtejepmtedk ek tcbAbpmrtnbkt―s prdirmns es kdt b`eieg`b td pmrtejepmtb ek FCM.eksurbandrtimib trmksmjtedks+ Qcb `bkabr nust bxmnekb CRA―s @A_ est mka tcbidvbrknbkt.weab Ibkbrm` Zbrvejbs Manekestrmtedk―s #IZM% ‐@est df _mrtebs Bxj`uaba frdn Fbabrm` _rdjurbnbkt dr Kdkprdjurbnbkt_rdirmns„ mka adjunbkt tces rbvebw dk tcb CRA 575??.YZ$575??._RW+Ef tcb kmnb df tcb gdrrdwbr, sb``br, `esteki dr sb``eki rbm` bstmtb mibkts, dr `dmk dffejbr mppbmrs dk betcbr `est, tcb mpp`ejmtedk es kdt b`eieg`b fdr ndrtimib eksurmkjb+ M `bkabr nmy jcbjl CRA―s @A_ est gy ideki tdwww+cua+idv mka tcb Fbabrm` idvbrknbkt―s `est df bxj`uaba pmrtebs gyideki td cttp8$$bp`s+mrkbt+idv+ #Mk bxjbptedk scm`` gb nmab fdr m sb``br dktcb IZM `est wcbk tcb prdpbrty gbeki sd`a es tcb sb``br―s prekjepm`rbseabkjb+%

G+ Ab`ekqubkt Fbabrm` Abgts+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr, ms rbvbm`ba gy pug`ejrbjdras, jrbaet ekfdrnmtedk, dr CRA―s Jrbaet M`brt Ektbrmjtevb VdejbWbspdksb Zystbn #JMEVWZ%, es prbsbkt`y ab`ekqubkt dk mky Fbabrm` abgt#b+i+, VM.iumrmktbba ndrtimib, Qet`b E `dmk, Fbabrm` stuabkt `dmk, Znm``Gusekbss Manekestrmtedk `dmk, ab`ekqubkt Fbabrm` tmxbs% dr cms m `ebk,ekj`uaeki tmxbs, p`mjba mimekst ces dr cbr prdpbrty fdr m abgt dwba td tcbR+Z+, tcb gdrrdwbr es kdt b`eieg`b ukte` tcb ab`ekqubkt mjjdukt es grduictjurrbkt, pmea, dtcbrwesb smtesfeba, dr m smtesfmjtdry rbpmynbkt p`mk es nmab gbtwbbk tcb gdrrdwbr mka tcb Fbabrm` mibkjy dwba mka es vbrefeba ekwreteki+ Qmx `ebks nmy rbnmek ukpmea prdveaba tcb ebk cd`abr sugdraekmtbs tcb tmx ebk td tcb FCM.eksurba ndrtimib+ Ef mky rbiu`mr  pmynbkts mrb td gb nmab, tcby nust gb ekj`uaba ek tcb qum`efyeki rmteds+

Zekjb tcb EWZ rdutekb`y tmlbs m sbjdka `ebk pdsetedk wetcdut tcb kbjbssetydf ekabpbkabkt adjunbktmtedk, b`eiege`ety fdr FCM ndrtimib eksurmkjbwe`` kdt gb hbdpmraezba gy dutstmkaeki EWZ tmx `ebks rbnmekeki dk tcb

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.=?

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 13 df 55

Page 49: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 49/99

1=22+= WBV.2

 prdpbrty uk`bss tcb `bkabr cms ekfdrnmtedk tcmt tcb EWZ cms abnmkaba mferst.`ebk pdsetedk+

 M`tcduic b`eiege`ety fdr mk FCM.eksurba ndrtimib nmy gb bstmg`escba gy pbrfdrneki tcb mjtedks absjregba mgdvb, tcb dvbrm`` mkm`yses df tcb

jrbaetwdrtcekbss nust ekj`uab jdkseabrmtedk df m gdrrdwbr)s prbvedus fme`urb td nmlb pmynbkts td tcb Fbabrm` mibkjy ek tcb mirbba.td nmkkbr mka nust adjunbkt ets mkm`yses df cdw tcb prbvedus fme`urb adbs kdt 

rbprbsbkt m resl df ndrtimib abfmu`t+

J+ JMEVWZ+ CRA―s JMEVWZ es m Fbabrm` idvbrknbkt.weab rbpdsetdry df ekfdrnmtedk dk tcdsb ekaeveaum`s wetc ab`ekqubkt dr abfmu`tba Fbabrm` abgtmka dk tcdsb fdr wcdn m pmynbkt df mk eksurmkjb j`men cms djjurrba+@bkabrs nust sjrbbk m`` gdrrdwbrs, ekj`uaeki kdkprdfet mibkjebs mjteki msm gdrrdwbr, useki JMEVWZ #bxjbpt dk strbmn`ekb rbfekmkjbs%+ Ef JMEVWZekaejmtbs tcb gdrrdwbr es prbsbkt`y ab`ekqubkt dr cms cma m j`men pmea

wetcek tcb prbvedus tcrbb ybmrs dk m `dmk nmab dr eksurba gy CRA dk cesdr cbr gbcm`f, tcb gdrrdwbr es kdt b`eieg`b bxjbpt ms absjregba gb`dw+@bkabrs mjjbss JMEVWZ betcbr tcrduic tcb FCM Jdkkbjtedk dr fukjtedkm`bquevm`bkt dr gy jm``eki :?=.:11.1??? dk m tdujc.tdkb tb`bpcdkb+ @bkabrsnust wretb tcb JMEVWZ mutcdrezmtedk jdab fdr bmjc gdrrdwbr dk tcbCRA.575??.YZ$575??._RW+ Bxjbptedks td tces ru`b nmy gb irmktbaukabr tcb fd``dweki setumtedks8

=+ Mssunptedks+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr sd`a tcb prdpbrty, wetc dr wetcdut mrb`bmsb df `emge`ety, td mk ekaeveaum` wcd sugsbqubkt`y abfmu`tba,tcb gdrrdwbr es b`eieg`b, prdveaba cb dr scb jmk prdvb tcb `dmk wmskdt ek abfmu`t mt tcb tenb df mssunptedk+

7+ Aevdrjb+ M gdrrdwbr nmy gb b`eieg`b ef tcb aevdrjb abjrbb dr `bim`sbpmrmtedk mirbbnbkt mwmraba tcb prdpbrty mka rbspdksege`ety fdr  pmynbkt td tcb fdrnbr spdusb+ Cdwbvbr, ef m j`men wms pmea dk mndrtimib ek abfmu`t predr td tcb aevdrjb, tcb gdrrdwbr es kdtb`eieg`b+

:+ Gmklruptjy+ Ycbk tcb prdpbrty wms ekj`uaba ek m gmklruptjytcmt wms jmusba gy jerjunstmkjbs gbydka tcb gdrrdwbr)s jdktrd`#sujc ms tcb abmtc df tcb prekjepm` wmib bmrkbr dr sbredus `dki.tbrnukeksurba e``kbss%, tcb gdrrdwbr nmy gb b`eieg`b ef tcb gdrrdwbr nbbts tcb rbquerbnbkts ek _mrmirmpc 7.: B+

Yce`b FCM nmy ab`btb brrdkbdus ekfdrnmtedk rbimraeki m gdrrdwbr fm`sb`y ekaejmtba ms cmveki abfmu`tba dk m FCM ndrtimib, sujc msekjdrrbjt sdjem` sbjurety kungbr rbpdrteki, et we`` kdt rbndvb jdrrbjtJMEVWZ ekfdrnmtedk bvbk ef tcb gdrrdwbr es huaiba b`eieg`b ukabr tcbjdkaetedks absjregba mgdvb+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.==

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 15 df 55

Page 50: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 50/99

1=22+= WBV.2

@bkabrs nmy kdt rb`y updk m j`bmr JMEVWZ mpprdvm` wcbk ek pdssbssedkdf ekabpbkabkt bveabkjb df ab`ekqubkt fbabrm` dg`eimtedks mka nustadjunbkt tcb rbsd`utedk df mky jdkf`ejteki ekfdrnmtedk+ Ef tcb `bkabr cmsrbmsdk td gb`ebvb tcb JMEVWZ nbssmib es brrdkbdus dr kbbas td bstmg`esc

tcb amtb df j`men pmynbkt, tcb `bkabr nust jdktmjt tcb mpprdpremtb CDJfdr ekstrujtedks dr adjunbktmtedk td suppdrt tcb gdrrdwbr)s b`eiege`ety+Qcb mpprdpremtb CDJ jmk prdveab ekfdrnmtedk wcbk tcb tcrbb.ybmr wmeteki pbreda we`` b`mpsb dr ef tcb sdjem` sbjurety kungbr ek JMEVWZ esbrrdkbdus+ Qcb CDJ we`` m`sd prdveab ekstrujtedks td `bkabrs rbimraeki prdjbsseki rbquerbnbkts fdr dtcbr CRA.rb`mtba abfmu`ts mka j`mens #b+i+,Qet`b E `dmks%+

Yb jmkkdt m`tbr dr ab`btb JMEVWZ ekfdrnmtedk rbpdrtba frdn dtcbr Fbabrm` mibkjebs, sujc ms tcb Abpmrtnbkt df Baujmtedk, Vbtbrmks Mffmers,btj+ Qcb gdrrdwbr mka$dr tcb `bkabr nust jdktmjt tcdsb mibkjebs td jdrrbjt

dr rbndvb brrdkbdus dr dutamtba ekfdrnmtedk+ Yb ad kdt rbquerb m 'j`bmr'JMEVWZ mutcdrezmtedk kungbr ms m jdkaetedk fdr ndrtimib bkadrsbnbkt, gut tcb `bkabr nust adjunbkt mka hustefy ets mpprdvm` gmsba dk tcbbxjbptedks absjregba mgdvb+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.=7

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 2? df 55

Page 51: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 51/99

1=22+= WBV.2

ZBJQEDK 78 BFFBJQEVB EKJDNB

Qcb mktejepmtba mndukt df ekjdnb, mka tcb `elb`ecdda df ets jdktekumkjb, nust gbbstmg`escba td abtbrnekb m gdrrdwbr)s jmpmjety td rbpmy ndrtimib abgt+ Ekjdnb nmy kdt gb usba ek jm`ju`mteki tcb gdrrdwbr)s ekjdnb rmteds ef et jdnbs frdn mky sdurjb tcmt

jmkkdt gb vbrefeba, es kdt stmg`b, dr we`` kdt jdktekub+ Qces sbjtedk absjregbs mjjbptmg`btypbs df ekjdnb, prdjbaurbs fdr jm`ju`mteki bffbjtevb ekjdnb, mka rbquerbnbkts fdr bstmg`esceki ekjdnb stmge`ety+

7.6 ZQMGE@EQU DF EKJDNB+ Yb ad kdt enpdsb m nekenun `bkitc df tenb m gdrrdwbr nust cmvb cb`a m pdsetedk df bnp`dynbkt td gb b`eieg`b+ Cdwbvbr, tcb`bkabr nust vbrefy tcb gdrrdwbr)s bnp`dynbkt fdr tcb ndst rbjbkt twd fu`` ybmrs+Ef m gdrrdwbr ekaejmtbs cb dr scb wms ek sjcdd` dr ek tcb ne`etmry aureki mky df tcestenb, tcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab bveabkjb suppdrteki tces j`men, sujc ms jd``bibtrmksjrepts dr aesjcmrib pmpbrs+ Qcb gdrrdwbr m`sd nust bxp`mek mky imps ekbnp`dynbkt spmkkeki dkb ndktc dr ndrb+ M``dwmkjbs fdr sbmsdkm` bnp`dynbkt,

sujc ms es typejm` ek tcb gue`aeki trmabs, btj+, nmy gb nmab ef adjunbktba gy tcb`bkabr+

Qd mkm`yzb mka adjunbkt tcb prdgmge`ety df jdktekuba bnp`dynbkt, `bkabrs nustbxmnekb tcb gdrrdwbr―s pmst bnp`dynbkt rbjdra, qum`efejmtedks fdr tcb pdsetedk, prbvedus trmekeki mka baujmtedk, mka tcb bnp`dybr)s jdkfernmtedk df jdktekubabnp`dynbkt+ M gdrrdwbr wcd jcmkibs hdgs frbqubkt`y wetcek tcb smnb `ekb df wdrl, gut jdktekubs td mavmkjb ek ekjdnb dr gbkbfets, scdu`a gb jdkseabrbafmvdrmg`y+ Ek tces mkm`yses, ekjdnb stmge`ety tmlbs prbjbabkjb dvbr  hdg stmge`ety+

Ek sdnb jmsbs, m gdrrdwbr nmy cmvb rbjbkt`y rbturkba td tcb wdrl fdrjb mftbr mkbxtbkaba mgsbkjb+ Ek tcbsb jerjunstmkjbs, tcb gdrrdwbr)s ekjdnb nmy gbjdkseabrba bffbjtevb mka stmg`b prdveaba tcb fd``dweki jdkaetedks mpp`y8

M+ Qcb gdrrdwbr cms gbbk bnp`dyba ek tcb jurrbkt hdg fdr sex ndktcs dr ndrb, mka

G+ Qcb gdrrdwbr jmk adjunbkt m twd.ybmr wdrl cestdry predr td tcb mgsbkjbfrdn tcb wdrl fdrjb+ Mjjbptmg`b adjunbktmtedk ekj`uabs trmaetedkm`bnp`dynbkt vbrefejmtedks, jdpebs df Y.7)s dr pmystugs+

Mk bxmnp`b df mk mjjbptmg`b bnp`dynbkt setumtedk ekj`uabs m pbrsdk tcmttddl sbvbrm` ybmrs dff df wdrl td rmesb jce`arbk mka tcbk rbturkba td tcbwdrlfdrjb+ Zetumtedks kdt nbbteki tcb jretbrem estba mgdvb nmy gbjdkseabrba ms jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs dk`y+

7.9 ZM@MWEBZ, YMIBZ, MKA DQCBW FDWNZ DF BFFBJQEVB EKJDNB+

Qcb ekjdnb df bmjc gdrrdwbr td gb dg`eimtba fdr tcb ndrtimib abgt nust gbmkm`yzba td abtbrnekb wcbtcbr et jmk rbmsdkmg`y gb bxpbjtba td jdktekub tcrduicmt `bmst tcb ferst tcrbb ybmrs df tcb ndrtimib dmk+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr ektbkas td rbterb

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.=:

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 2= df 55

Page 52: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 52/99

1=22+= WBV.2

aureki tces pbreda, tcb bffbjtevb ekjdnb nust gb tcb mndukt df adjunbktbarbterbnbkt gbkbfets, sdjem` sbjurety pmynbkts, dr dtcbr pmynbkts bxpbjtba td gbrbjbevba ek rbterbnbkt+ Kd ekquery nmy gb nmab rbimraeki pdsseg`b futurbnmtbrkety `bmvb+

Ek ndst jmsbs, tcb gdrrdwbr―s ekjdnb we`` gb enetba td sm`mrebs dr wmibs+ Ekjdnbfrdn dtcbr sdurjbs jmk gb ekj`uaba ms bffbjtevb ekjdnb wetc prdpbr vbrefejmtedk gy tcb `bkabr+ _rdjbaurbs fdr mkm`yzeki dtcbr mjjbptmg`b ekjdnb sdurjbs gbseabssm`mrebs mka wmibs mrb absjregba gb`dw8

M+ Dvbrtenb mka Gdkus Ekjdnb+ Gdtc dvbrtenb mka gdkus ekjdnb nmy gbusba td qum`efy ef tcb gdrrdwbr cms rbjbevba sujc ekjdnb fdr tcb pmst twdybmrs mka et es `elb`y td jdktekub+ Qcb `bkabr nust abvb`dp mk mvbrmib df  gdkus dr dvbrtenb ekjdnb fdr tcb pmst twd ybmrs, mka tcb bnp`dynbktvbrefejmtedk nust kdt stmtb tcmt sujc ekjdnb es uk`elb`y td jdktekub+_bredas df `bss tcmk twd ybmrs nmy gb mjjbptmg`b prdveaba tcb `bkabr 

 hustefebs mka adjunbkts ek wreteki tcb rbmsdk fdr useki tcb ekjdnb fdr qum`efyeki purpdsbs+

Mk bmrkekis trbka m`sd nust gb bstmg`escba mka adjunbktba fdr dvbrtenbmka gdkus ekjdnb+ Ef betcbr typb scdws m jdktekum` abj`ekb, tcb `bkabr nust prdveab m sduka rmtedkm`ezmtedk ek wreteki fdr ekj`uaeki tcb ekjdnbfdr gdrrdwbr qum`efyeki+ Ef gdkus ekjdnb vmrebs seikefejmkt`y frdn ybmr tdybmr, m pbreda df ndrb tcmk twd ybmrs nust gb usba ek jm`ju`mteki tcbmvbrmib ekjdnb+

G+ _mrt.Qenb Ekjdnb+ _mrt.tenb$sbjdka hdg ekjdnb, ekj`uaeki bnp`dynbkt eksbmsdkm` wdrl, nmy gb usba ek qum`efyeki ef tcb `bkabr adjunbkts tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr cms wdrlba tcb pmrt.tenb hdg ukektbrruptba fdr tcb pmst twd ybmrsmka we`` jdktekub td ad sd+ Zbmsdkm` bnp`dynbkt #b+i+, unpereki gmsbgm``imnbs ek sunnbr, wdrleki mt m abpmrtnbkt stdrb aureki tcb cd`eamyscdppeki sbmsdk% es jdkseabrba ukektbrruptba mka nmy gb usba ekqum`efyeki ef tcb `bkabr adjunbkts tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr cms wdrlba tcb smnbtypb df hdg fdr tcb pmst twd ybmrs mka bxpbjts td gb rbcerba aureki tcb kbxtsbmsdk+ Ekjdnb frdn m pmrt.tenb pdsetedk tcmt cms gbbk rbjbevba fdr bsstcmk twd ybmrs nmy gb ekj`uaba ms bffbjtevb ekjdnb, prdveaba tcb `bkabr  hustefebs mka adjunbkts tcmt tcb ekjdnb)s jdktekumkjb es `elb`y+ Ekjdnbfrdn pmrt.tenb pdsetedks kdt nbbteki tcbsb rbquerbnbkts nmy gbjdkseabrba ms m jdnpbksmteki fmjtdr dk`y+

Fdr qum`efejmtedk purpdsbs, pmrt.tenb ekjdnb rbfbrs td hdgs tmlbk td

 supp`bnbkt tcb gdrrdwbr)s ekjdnb frdn rbiu`mr bnp`dynbkt #e+b+, msbjdka hdg ‚ kdt nbmkeki prenmry hdgs df `bss tcmk 1? cdurs pbr wbbl+% Ef m gdrrdwbr)s rbiu`mr bnp`dynbkt ekvd`vbs `bss tcmk m typejm` 1?.cdur wdrlwbbl, tcb stmge`ety df tcmt ekjdnb scdu`a gb bvm`umtba ms mky dtcbr rbiu`mr, dk.ideki prenmry bnp`dynbkt+ Fdr bxmnp`b, m rbiestbrba kursb

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.=1

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 27 df 55

Page 53: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 53/99

1=22+= WBV.2

nmy cmvb wdrlba 71 cdurs pbr wbbl fdr tcb `mst ybmr+ M`tcduic tces hdgrbquerbs `bss tcmk 1? cdurs df wdrl pbr wbbl, et es tcb gdrrdwbr)s prenmrybnp`dynbkt mka es td gb jdkseabrba bffbjtevb ekjdnb+

Yb rbjdikezb tcmt nmky `dw. mka ndabrmtb.ekjdnb fmne`ebs rb`y dk pmrt.

tenb mka sbmsdkm` ekjdnb fdr amy.td.amy kbbas+ @bkabrs nust kdt rbstrejttcb jdkseabrmtedk df sujc ekjdnb sdurjbs ek qum`efyeki tcbsb gdrrdwbrs+

J+ Ne`etmry Ekjdnb+ Ek maaetedk td gmsb pmy, ne`etmry pbrsdkkb` nmy gbbktet`ba td maaetedkm` fdrns df pmy+ Ekjdnb frdn vmremg`b cdusekim``dwmkjbs, j`dtceki m``dwmkjbs, f`eict dr cmzmra pmy, rmtedks, mka prdfejebkjy pmy es mjjbptmg`b, prdveaba ets prdgmge`ety df jdktekumkjb esvbrefeba ek wreteki+ Mk maaetedkm` jdkseabrmtedk nmy gb tcb tmx.bxbnptkmturb df sdnb df tcbsb pmynbkts #sbb pmrmirmpc ] fdr maaetedkm`ekfdrnmtedk+%

A+ Jdnnessedk Ekjdnb+ Jdnnessedk ekjdnb nust gb mvbrmiba dvbr tcb prbvedus twd ybmrs+ Qcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab jdpebs df seikba tmxrbturks fdr tcb `mst twd ybmrs, m`dki wetc tcb ndst rbjbkt pmy stug+#Rkrbengursba gusekbss bxpbksbs nust gb sugtrmjtba frdn irdss ekjdnb+%Ekaeveaum`s wcdsb jdnnessedk ekjdnb scdws m abjrbmsb frdn dkb ybmr tdtcb kbxt rbquerb seikefejmkt jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs td m``dw fdr `dmkmpprdvm`+ Gdrrdwbrs wetc jdnnessedk ekjdnb rbjbevba fdr ndrb tcmk dkb gut `bss tcmk twd ybmrs nmy gb jdkseabrba fmvdrmg`y prdveaba tcbukabrwretbr es mg`b td nmlb m sduka rmtedkm`ezmtedk fdr mjjbptmkjb mka jmkadjunbkt tcb `elb`ecdda df jdktekumkjb+

Jdnnessedks bmrkba fdr `bss tcmk dkb ybmr mrb kdt jdkseabrba bffbjtevbekjdnb+ Bxjbptedks nmy gb nmab fdr setumtedks ek wcejc tcb gdrrdwbr)sjdnpbksmtedk wms jcmkiba frdn m sm`mry td jdnnessedk wetcek m sene`mr  pdsetedk wetc tcb smnb bnp`dybr+ M gdrrdwbr m`sd nmy qum`efy wcbk tcb pdrtedk df bmrkekis kdt mttregutba td jdnnessedks wdu`a gb suffejebkt tdqum`efy tcb gdrrdwbr fdr tcb ndrtimib+

B+ Wbterbnbkt mka Zdjem` Zbjurety Ekjdnb+ Wbterbnbkt mka sdjem` sbjuretyekjdnb rbquerb vbrefejmtedk frdn tcb sdurjb #fdrnbr bnp`dybr, Zdjem`Zbjurety Manekestrmtedk% dr fbabrm` tmx rbturks+ Ef mky gbkbfets bxperbwetcek tcb ferst fu`` tcrbb ybmrs, tcb ekjdnb sdurjb nmy gb jdkseabrba dk`yms m jdnpbksmteki fmjtdr+

F+ M endky, Jce`a Zuppdrt, dr Nmektbkmkjb Ekjdnb+ Ekjdnb ek tcesjmtbidry nmy gb jdkseabrba ms bffbjtevb ef sujc pmynbkts mrb `elb`y td gbjdksestbkt`y rbjbevba fdr tcb ferst tcrbb ybmrs df tcb ndrtimib+ Qcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab m jdpy df tcb fekm` aevdrjb abjrbb, `bim` sbpmrmtedkmirbbnbkt, dr vd`uktmry pmynbkt mirbbnbkt, ms wb`` ms bveabkjb tcmt pmynbkts cmvb gbbk rbjbevba aureki tcb `mst twb`vb ndktcs+ Mjjbptmg`b

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.=2

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 2: df 55

Page 54: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 54/99

1=22+= WBV.2

bveabkjb df pmynbkt rbiu`mrety ekj`uabs jmkjb``ba jcbjls, abpdset s`eps,tmx rbturks, mka jdurt rbjdras+ _bredas `bss tcmk twb`vb ndktcs nmy gbmjjbptmg`b, prdveaba tcb pmybr―s mge`ety mka we``ekikbss td nmlb tenb`y pmynbkts es mabqumtb`y adjunbktba gy tcb `bkabr+

I+ Kdtbs Wbjbevmg`b+ M jdpy df tcb kdtb nust gb prbsbktba td bstmg`esc tcbmndukt mka `bkitc df pmynbkt+ Qcb gdrrdwbr m`sd nust prdveab bveabkjbtcmt tcbsb pmynbkts cmvb gbbk rbjbevba jdksestbkt`y fdr tcb `mst twb`vbndktcs, wcejc nmy ekj`uab abpdset s`eps, jmkjb``ba jcbjls, dr tmx rbturks+Ef tcb gdrrdwbr es kdt tcb dreiekm` pmybb dk tcb kdtb, tcb `bkabr nust m`sdbstmg`esc tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr es kdw m cd`abr ek aub jdursb mka mg`b tdbkfdrjb tcb kdtb+

C+ Ektbrbst mka Aeveabkas+ Ektbrbst mka aeveabka ekjdnb nmy gb usba, prdveaba tcmt adjunbktmtedk #tmx rbturks dr mjjdukt stmtbnbkts% suppdrts mtwd.ybmr cestdry df rbjbept+ Qces ekjdnb nust gb mvbrmiba dvbr tcb twd

ybmrs+ Mky fukas abrevba frdn tcbsb sdurjbs mka rbquerba fdr tcb jmscekvbstnbkt nust gb sugtrmjtba gbfdrb tcb prdhbjtba ektbrbst dr aeveabkaekjdnb es jm`ju`mtba+

E+ Ndrtimib Jrbaet Jbrtefejmtbs+ Ef m idvbrknbkt bktety sugseaezbs tcbndrtimib pmynbkts, betcbr tcrduic aerbjt pmynbkts dr tcrduic tmx rbgmtbs,tcbsb pmynbkts jmk gb jdkseabrba ms mjjbptmg`b ekjdnb ef vbrefeba ekwreteki+ Betcbr typb df sugseay nmy gb maaba td irdss ekjdnb dr nmy gbusba td aerbjt`y dffsbt tcb ndrtimib pmynbkt gbfdrb jm`ju`mteki tcbqum`efyeki rmteds+

H+ Bnp`dybr Aeffbrbktem` _mynbkts+ Ef tcb bnp`dybr sugseaezbs tcbndrtimib pmynbkts tcrduic aerbjt pmynbkts, tcb mndukt df tcb pmynbktses jdkseabrba irdss ekjdnb< et nmy kdt gb usba td dffsbt tcb ndrtimib pmynbkt aerbjt`y, bvbk ef tcb bnp`dybr pmys tcb sbrvejeki `bkabr aerbjt`y+

L+ VM Gbkbfets+ Aerbjt jdnpbksmtedk, sujc ms fdr m sbrvejb.rb`mtbaaesmge`ety, es mjjbptmg`b, sughbjt td adjunbktmtedk frdn tcb VM+Baujmtedk gbkbfets, usba td dffsbt baujmtedk bxpbksbs, mrb kdt mjjbptmg`b+

@+ Idvbrknbkt Mssestmkjb _rdirmns+ Ekjdnb rbjbevba frdn idvbrknbktmssestmkjb prdirmns es mjjbptmg`b, sughbjt td adjunbktmtedk frdn tcb pmyeki mibkjy, prdveaba tcb ekjdnb es bxpbjtba td jdktekub mt `bmst tcrbbybmrs+ Ef tcb ekjdnb es kdt bxpbjtba td gb rbjbevba fdr mt `bmst tcrbb ybmrs,sujc ekjdnb nmy gb jdkseabrba ms m jdnpbksmteki fmjtdr+#Rkbnp`dynbkt ekjdnb nust gb adjunbktba fdr twd ybmrs+ Wbmsdkmg`bmssurmkjb df ets jdktekumkjb es m`sd rbquerba+ Qces rbquerbnbkt nmy mpp`ytd ekaeveaum`s bnp`dyba dk m sbmsdkm` gmses, sujc ms fmrn wdrlbrs, rbsdrtbnp`dybbs, btj+%

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.=6

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 21 df 55

Page 55: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 55/99

1=22+= WBV.2

N+ Wbktm` Ekjdnb+ Wbkt rbjbevba fdr prdpbrtebs dwkba gy tcb gdrrdwbr esmjjbptmg`b ef tcb `bkabr jmk adjunbkt tcmt tcb rbktm` ekjdnb es stmg`b+Bxmnp`bs df stmge`ety nmy ekj`uab m jurrbkt `bmsb, mk mirbbnbkt td `bmsb,dr m rbktm` cestdry dvbr tcb prbvedus 71 ndktcs tcmt es frbb df ukbxp`mekbaimps irbmtbr tcmk tcrbb ndktcs+ #Ztuabkt, sbmsdkm`, dr ne etmry rbktbrs, dr 

 prdpbrty rbcmge`etmtedk wdu`a prdveab sujc mk bxp`mkmtedk%+ M sbpmrmtbsjcbau`b df rbm` bstmtb es kdt rbquerba fdr rbktm` prdpbrtebs, prdveaba m`` prdpbrtebs mrb scdwk dk tcb RW@M+

Ef tcb gdrrdwbr rbseabs ek dkb dr ndrb ukets df m nu`tep`b.uket prdpbrty mkajcmribs rbkt td tbkmkts df dtcbr ukets, tcmt rbkt nmy gb usba fdr qum`efyeki purpdsbs+ Cdwbvbr, prdhbjtba rbkt df maaetedkm` ukets dk`y mka kdt tcbdwkbr.djjupeba uket#s% nmy gb jdkseabrba irdss ekjdnb dk`y mftbr abaujteki tcb CDJ―s vmjmkjy mka nmektbkmkjb fmjtdr+ Qcby nmy kdt gbusba ms m aerbjt dffsbt td tcb ndrtimib pmynbkts+

Ekjdnb frdn rddnnmtbs ek m seki`b.fmne`y prdpbrty td gb djjupeba ms tcb gdrrdwbr)s prenmry rbseabkjb es kdt mjjbptmg`b+ Wbktm` ekjdnb frdn gdmrabrs es mjjbptmg`b ef tcb gdmrabrs mrb rb`mtba gy g`dda, nmrremib, dr `mw+ Qcb rbktm` ekjdnb nmy gb jdkseabrba bffbjtevb ekjdnb ef scdwk dktcb gdrrdwbr)s tmx rbturks+ Dtcbrwesb, tcb ekjdnb dk`y nmy gb jdkseabrbam jdnpbksmteki fmjtdr mka nust gb adjunbktba mabqumtb`y gy tcb `bkabr+

Qcb fd``dweki es rbquerba td vbrefy m`` rbktm` ekjdnb8

=+ Zjcbau`b B df EWZ Fdrn =?1?+ Abprbjemtedk nmy gb maaba gmjl td tcb kbt ekjdnb dr `dss scdwk dk Zjcbau`b B+ _dsetevb rbktm`ekjdnb es jdkseabrba irdss ekjdnb fdr qum`efyeki purpdsbs<kbimtevb rbktm` ekjdnb nust gb trbmtba ms m rbjurreki emge`ety+ Qcb`bkabr nust gb jbrtmek tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr ste`` dwks bmjc prdpbrty`estba, gy jdnpmreki tcb Zjcbau`b B wetc tcb rbm` bstmtb dwkbasbjtedk df tcb rbseabktem` dmk mpp`ejmtedk+ #Ef tcb gdrrdwbr ek tcbsmnb ibkbrm` mrbm dwks sex dr ndrb ukets, m nmp aesj`dseki tcb`djmtedks nust gb sugnettba bveabkjeki jdnp`emkjb wetc FCM)ssbvbk.uket `enetmtedk+ Zbb pmrmirmpc 1.3 fdr maaetedkm`ekfdrnmtedk+%

7+ Jurrbkt @bmsbs+ Ef m prdpbrty wms mjquerba sekjb tcb `mst ekjdnbtmx fe`eki mka es kdt scdwk dk Zjcbau`b B, m jurrbkt seikba `bmsb dr dtcbr rbktm` mirbbnbkt nust gb prdveaba+ Qcb irdss rbktm` mnduktnust gb rbaujba fdr vmjmkjebs mka nmektbkmkjb gy 72 pbrjbkt #dr tcb pbrjbktmib abvb`dpba gy tcb huresaejtedkm` CDJ%, gbfdrbsugtrmjteki _EQE mka mky cdnbdwkbrs) mssdjemtedk aubs, btj+, mkampp`yeki tcb rbnmekabr td ekjdnb #dr rbjurreki abgts, ef kbimtevb%+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.=9

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 22 df 55

Page 56: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 56/99

1=22+= WBV.2

K+ B`eieg`b Ekvbstnbkt _rdpbrtebs+ Ef tcb prdpbrty td gb eksurba es mkb`eieg`b ekvbstnbkt prdpbrty dr sd`a tcrduic FCM)s WBD prdirmn, tcbfd``dweki jm`ju`mtedks df qum`efyeki rmteds mpp`y8

=+ Zugtrmjt tcb ndktc`y pmynbkt #_EQE% frdn tcb ndktc`y kbt rbktm`

ekjdnb df tcb sughbjt prdpbrty #irdss rbkts, nekus tcb 72 pbrjbktrbaujtedk dr CDJ―s pbrjbktmib rbaujtedk fdr vmjmkjebs mkarbpmers%+ Ef tces jm`ju`mtedk yeb`as m pdsetevb kungbr, maa tcbkungbr td tcb gdrrdwbr)s ndktc`y irdss ekjdnb+ Ef tcb jm`ju`mtedkrbsu`ts ek m kbimtevb kungbr, jdkseabr et m rbjurreki ndktc`ydg`eimtedk< tcbk

7+ Jm`ju`mtb tcb ndrtimib pmynbkt.td.ekjdnb rmted #tdp dr frdkt.bkarmted% gy aeveaeki tcb gdrrdwbr)s jurrbkt cduseki bxpbksb#prekjepm` rbseabkjb% gy tcb ndktc`y irdss ekjdnb+ #Qcb ndktc`yirdss ekjdnb we`` ekj`uab mky pdsetevb jmsc f`dw frdn tcb sughbjtekvbstnbkt prdpbrty+%< mka

:+ Jm`ju`mtb tcb tdtm` fexba pmynbkt.td.ekjdnb rmted #gdttdn dr gmjl.bka rmted% gy aeveaeki tcb gdrrdwbr)s tdtm` ndktc`y dg`eimtedks,ekj`uaeki mky kbt `dss frdn tcb sughbjt ekvbstnbkt prdpbrty, gy tcb gdrrdwbr)s tdtm` ndktc`y irdss ekjdnb+

D+ Mutdndge b M` dwmkjbs mka Bxpbksb Mjjdukt _mynbkts+ Dk`y tcbmndukt gy wcejc tcb gdrrdwbr)s mutdndge`b m``dwmkjb dr bxpbksb mjjdukt pmynbkts bxjbba mjtum` bxpbkaeturbs nmy gb jdkseabrba ekjdnb+ Qcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab EWZ Fdrn 7=?6, Bnp`dybb Gusekbss Bxpbksbs, fdr tcb prbvedus twd ybmrs td bstmg`esc tcb mndukt df ekjdnb tcmt nmy gbmaaba td irdss ekjdnb+ Qcb gdrrdwbr m`sd nust prdveab vbrefejmtedk frdntcb bnp`dybr tcmt tcbsb pmynbkts we` jdktekub+ #Ef tcbsb jm`ju`mtedksscdw m `dss, tcmt mndukt nust gb trbmtba ms m rbjurreki abgt+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr usbs tcb stmkamra pbr.ne`b rmtb ek jm`ju`mteki mutdndge`bbxpbksbs, ms dppdsba td tcb mjtum` jdst nbtcda, tcb pdrtedk tcmt tcb EWZjdkseabrs abprbjemtedk nmy gb maaba gmjl td ekjdnb+% Maaetedkm``y, tcb gdrrdwbr)s ndktc`y jmr pmynbkt nust gb trbmtba ms m rbjurreki abgt< etnmy kdt gb dffsbt gy tcb jmr m``dwmkjb+

_+ Qrust Ekjdnb+ Ekjdnb frdn trusts nmy gb usba ef iumrmktbba, jdkstmkt pmynbkts we`` jdktekub fdr mt `bmst tcb ferst tcrbb ybmrs df tcb ndrtimibtbrn+ Adjunbktmtedk es rbquerba mka ekj`uabs m jdpy df tcb QrustMirbbnbkt, dr dtcbr trustbb)s stmtbnbkt, jdkferneki mndukt, frbqubkjy df aestregutedk, mka aurmtedk df pmynbkts+ Fukas frdn tcb trust mjjdukt m`sdnmy gb usba fdr tcb rbquerba jmsc ekvbstnbkt wetc mabqumtbadjunbktmtedk+

]+ Kdk.Qmxmg`b Ekjdnb+ Ef m pmrteju`mr sdurjb df rbiu`mr ekjdnb es kdtsughbjt td fbabrm` tmxbs #b+i+, jbrtmek typbs df aesmge`ety mka pug`ejmssestmkjb pmynbkts, ne`etmry m``dwmkjbs%, tcb mndukt df jdktekueki tmx

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.=3

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 26 df 55

Page 57: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 57/99

1=22+= WBV.2

smvekis mttregutmg`b td tcb kdk.tmxmg`b ekjdnb sdurjb nmy gb maaba td tcb gdrrdwbr)s irdss ekjdnb+ Qcb pbrjbktmib df ekjdnb tcmt nmy gb maabanmy kdt bxjbba tcb mpprdpremtb tmx rmtb fdr tcmt ekjdnb mndukt, mka kdmaaetedkm` m``dwmkjbs fdr abpbkabkts mrb mjjbptmg`b+ Qcb `bkabr nustadjunbkt mka suppdrt tcb mahustnbkts #tcb mndukt tcb ekjdnb es 'irdssba

up'% nmab fdr mky kdk.tmxmg`b ekjdnb sdurjb+ Jce`a suppdrt ekjdnbjmkkdt gb irdssba up+ Qcb `bkabr scdu`a usb tcb tmx rmtb usba td jm`ju`mtb`mst ybmr)s ekjdnb tmx fdr tcb gdrrdwbr+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr es kdt rbquerba tdfe`b m fbabrm` ekjdnb tmx rbturk, tcb tmx rmtb td usb es 72 pbrjbkt+

W+ _rdhbjtba Ekjdnb+ _rdhbjtba dr cypdtcbtejm` ekjdnb es kdt mjjbptmg`b fdr qum`efyeki purpdsbs+ Cdwbvbr, bxjbptedks mrb pbrnettba td tces ru`b fdr ekjdnb frdn jdst.df.`eveki mahustnbkts, pbrfdrnmkjb rmesbs, gdkusbs, btj+,wcejc mrb gdtc vbrefeba gy tcb bnp`dybr ek wreteki mka sjcbau`ba td gbiekwetcek 6? amys df `dmk j`dseki+

Ef m gdrrdwbr es mgdut td stmrt m kbw hdg mka cms m iumrmktbba, kdk.rbvdjmg`b jdktrmjt fdr bnp`dynbkt tcmt we`` gbiek wetcek 6? amys df `dmkj`dseki, tcb ekjdnb es mjjbptmg`b fdr qum`efyeki purpdsbs+ Qcb `bkabr m`sdnust vbrefy tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr we`` cmvb suffejebkt ekjdnb dr jmsc rbsbrvbstd suppdrt tcb ndrtimib pmynbkts mka mky dtcbr dg`eimtedks aureki tcbektbren gbtwbbk `dmk j`dseki mka tcb stmrt df bnp`dynbkt+ #Qces jdkaetedknmy gb mpprdpremtb fdr setumtedks sujc ms tbmjcbrs wcdsb jdktrmjts we`` gbiek wetc tcb kbw sjcdd` ybmr, dr pcysejemks wcd we`` gbiek rbseabkjymftbr tcb `dmk es sjcbau`ba td j`dsb+% Cdwbvbr, ef tcb `dmk we`` j`dsb ndrbtcmk 6? amys gbfdrb tcb gdrrdwbr―s bnp`dynbkt gbieks, tcb `dmk es kdt 

b`eieg`b fdr bkadrsbnbkt ukte` tcb `bkabr prdveabs m pmy stug dr dtcbr mjjbptmg`b bveabkjb tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr cms gbiuk tcb kbw hdg+

7.3 BN_@DUNBKQ GU [email protected] GRZEKBZZBZ+ Gdrrdwbrsbnp`dyba mt gusekbssbs dwkba gy tcber fmne`y nbngbr#s% mrb rbquerba td prdveabmaaetedkm` ekjdnb adjunbktmtedk+ Qcbsb gdrrdwbrs nust prdveab tcb kdrnm`vbrefejmtedk df bnp`dynbkt, pmy stugs, mka bveabkjb tcmt tcby mrb kdt mk dwkbr df tcb gusekbss+ Qces bveabkjb nmy ekj`uab jdpebs df tcb gdrrdwbr)s seikba pbrsdkm`tmx rbturks dr m seikba jdpy df tcb jdrpdrmtb tmx rbturk scdweki dwkbrscep pbrjbktmibs+

7.5 [email protected]_@DUBA GDWWDYBWZ+ M gdrrdwbr wetc m 72 pbrjbkt dr irbmtbr dwkbrscep ektbrbst ek m gusekbss es jdkseabrba sb`f.bnp`dyba fdr FCM ndrtimib`dmk ukabrwreteki purpdsbs+

Qcb fd``dweki jdkaetedks mpp`y td ukabrwreteki sb`f.bnp`dyba gdrrdwbrs8

M+ Nekenun @bkitc df Zb`f.Bnp`dynbkt+ Ekjdnb frdn sb`f.bnp`dynbktes jdkseabrba stmg`b mka bffbjtevb ef tcb gdrrdwbr cms gbbk sb`f.bnp`dybafdr twd dr ndrb ybmrs+ Qcb ceic prdgmge`ety df fme`urb aureki tcb ferst fbw

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.=5

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 29 df 55

Page 58: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 58/99

1=22+= WBV.2

ybmrs df m gusekbss nmlbs tcb fd``dweki rbquerbnbkts kbjbssmry fdr ekaeveaum`s wcd cmvb gbbk sb`f.bnp`dyba `bss tcmk twd ybmrs8

=+ Gbtwbbk Dkb mka Qwd Ubmrs+ Mk ekaeveaum` sb`f.bnp`dyba gbtwbbk dkb mka twd ybmrs nust cmvb mt `bmst twd ybmrs df 

adjunbktba prbvedus sujjbssfu` bnp`dynbkt #dr m jdngekmtedk df dkb ybmr df bnp`dynbkt mka fdrnm` baujmtedk dr trmekeki% ek tcb`ekb df wdrl ek wcejc tcb gdrrdwbr es sb`f.bnp`dyba dr ek m rb`mtbadjjupmtedk td gb b`eieg`b+

7+ @bss tcmk Dkb Ubmr+ Qcb ekjdnb frdn m gdrrdwbr sb`f.bnp`dyba`bss tcmk dkb ybmr nmy kdt gb jdkseabrba bffbjtevb ekjdnb+

G+ Adjunbktmtedk Wbquerbnbkts+ Qcb fd``dweki adjunbkts mrb rbquerbafrdn sb`f.bnp`dyba gdrrdwbrs8

=+ Zeikba mka amtba ekaeveaum` tmx rbturks, p`us m`` mpp`ejmg`bsjcbau`bs, fdr tcb ndst rbjbkt twd ybmrs+

7+ Zeikba jdpebs df fbabrm` gusekbss ekjdnb tmx rbturks fdr tcb `msttwd ybmrs, wetc m`` mpp`ejmg`b sjcbau`bs, ef tcb gusekbss es mjdrpdrmtedk, mk 'Z' jdrpdrmtedk, dr m pmrtkbrscep+

:+ M ybmr.td.amtb prdfet.mka.`dss #_&@% stmtbnbkt mka gm`mkjb scbbt+

1+ M gusekbss jrbaet rbpdrt dk jdrpdrmtedks mka 'Z' jdrpdrmtedks+

J+ Mkm`yzeki Ekjdnb+ Qcb `bkabr nust bstmg`esc tcb gdrrdwbr)s bmrkekistrbka dvbr tcb prbvedus twd ybmrs gut nmy mvbrmib tcb ekjdnb dvbr tcrbbybmrs, ef m`` tcrbb ybmrs) tmx rbturks mrb prdveaba+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr prdveabsqumrtbr`y tmx rbturks, tcb mkm`yses jmk ekj`uab ekjdnb tcrduic tcb pbredajdvbrba gy tcb tmx fe`ekis+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr es kdt sughbjt td qumrtbr`y tmxfe`ekis dr adbs kdt fe`b qumrtbr`y rbturks #Fdrn EWZ =?1? BZ%, tcb ekjdnbscdwk dk tcb _&@ stmtbnbkt nmy gb ekj`uaba ek tcb mkm`yses, prdveaba tcb

ekjdnb strbmn gmsba dk tcb _&@ stmtbnbkt es jdksestbkt wetc tcb prbvedus ybmrs) bmrkekis+ Ef tcb _&@ stmtbnbkts sugnettba fdr tcb jurrbkt ybmr scdw mk ekjdnb strbmn jdkseabrmg`y irbmtbr tcmk wcmt es suppdrtba gy tcb prbvedus ybmrs) tmx rbturks, tcb mkm`yses df ekjdnb nust gb prbaejmtbasd`b`y dk tcb ekjdnb vbrefeba tcrduic tcb tmx rbturks+

Qd abtbrnekb ef tcb gusekbss jmk gb bxpbjtba td jdktekub td ibkbrmtbsuffejebkt ekjdnb fdr tcb gdrrdwbr)s kbbas, `bkabrs nust mkm`yzb jmrbfu``ytcb gusekbss)s fekmkjem` strbkitc, tcb sdurjb df ets ekjdnb, mka tcb ibkbrm`bjdkdnej dut`ddl fdr sene`mr gusekbssbs ek tcb mrbm+ Mkkum` bmrkekis tcmtmrb stmg`b dr ekjrbmseki mrb mjjbptmg`b+ Jdkvbrsb`y, m gdrrdwbr wcdsb

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.7?

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 23 df 55

Page 59: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 59/99

1=22+= WBV.2

 gusekbss scdws m seikefejmkt abj`ekb ek ekjdnb dvbr tcb pbreda mkm`yzba eskdt mjjbptmg`b, bvbk ef jurrbkt ekjdnb mka abgt rmteds nbbt dur iueab`ekbs+

Qcbrb mrb fdur gmsej typbs df gusekbss strujturbs8 sd`b prdprebtdrsceps,jdrpdrmtedks< `enetba emge`ety #'Z' jdrpdrmtedks%< mka pmrtkbrsceps+ Bmjc

typb rbquerbs s`eict`y aeffbrbkt fdrns df mkm`yses+

Qcb fd``dweki prdveabs maaetedkm` ekfdrnmtedk dk mkm`yzeki tmx rbturks8

=+ Ekaeveaum` Qmx Wbturks #EWZ Fdrn =?1?%+ Qcb mndukt scdwkdk tcb EWZ Fdrn =?1? ms 'mahustba irdss ekjdnb' betcbr nust gbekjrbmsba dr abjrbmsba, gmsba dk tcb `bkabr)s mkm`yses df tcbekaeveaum` tmx rbturks mka mky rb`mtba tmx sjcbau`bs+ _mrteju`mr mttbktedk nust gb pmea td tcb fd``dweki8

m+ Ymibs, Zm`mrebs, mka Qeps+ Mk mndukt scdwk ukabr tces

cbmaeki nmy ekaejmtb tcmt tcb ekaeveaum` es m sm`mrebabnp`dybb df m jdrpdrmtedk dr cms dtcbr sdurjbs df ekjdnb+Et m`sd nmy ekaejmtb tcmt tcb spdusb es bnp`dyba, ek wcejcjmsb tcb ekjdnb nust gb sugtrmjtba frdn tcb mahustba irdssekjdnb ek tcb mkm`yses+

 g+ Gusekbss Ekjdnb dr @dss #frdn Zjcbau`b J%+ Qcb sd`b prdprebtdrscep ekjdnb jm`ju`mtba dk Zjcbau`b J es gusekbssekjdnb+ Abprbjemtedk dr abp`btedk nmy gb maaba gmjl tdmahustba irdss ekjdnb+

j+ Wbkts, Wdym`tebs, _mrtkbrsceps, Btj+ #frdn Zjcbau`b B%+Mky ekjdnb rbjbevba frdn rbktm` prdpbrtebs dr rdym`tebsnmy gb usba ms ekjdnb mftbr maaeki gmjl mky abprbjemtedkscdwk dk Zjcbau`b B+

a+ Jmpetm` Imek dr @dss #frdn Zjcbau`b A%+ Qces trmksmjtedkibkbrm``y djjurs dk`y dkb tenb, mka et scdu`a kdt gbjdkseabrba ek abtbrnekeki bffbjtevb ekjdnb+ Cdwbvbr, ef tcb gusekbss cms m jdkstmkt turkdvbr df mssbts rbsu`teki ekimeks dr `dssbs, tcb jmpetm` imek dr `dss nmy gb jdkseabrbaek abtbrnekeki tcb ekjdnb, prdveaba tcb gdrrdwbr cms mt`bmst tcrbb ybmrs) tmx rbturks bveabkjeki jmpetm` imeks+ Mkbxmnp`b ekj`uabs mk ekaeveaum` wcd purjcmsbs d`a cdusbs,rbndab`s tcbn, mka sb``s tcbn fdr m prdfet+

b+ Ektbrbst mka Aeveabka Ekjdnb #frdn Zjcbau`b G%+ Qcesekjdnb, wcejc es tmxmg`b mka tmx.bxbnpt, nmy gb maaba gmjl td tcb mahustba irdss ekjdnb dk`y ef et cms gbbkrbjbevba fdr tcb pmst twd ybmrs mka es bxpbjtba td jdktekub+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.7=

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 25 df 55

Page 60: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 60/99

1=22+= WBV.2

#Ef tcb ektbrbst.gbmreki mssbt we`` gb `equeamtba ms m sdurjbdf tcb jmsc ekvbstnbkt, tcb `bkabr nust mahust mjjdraeki`y+%

f+ Fmrn Ekjdnb dr @dss #frdn Zjcbau`b F%+ Mky abprbjemtedkscdwk dk Zjcbau`b F nmy gb maaba gmjl td tcb mahustba

irdss ekjdnb+

i+ EWM Aestregutedks, _bksedks, Mkkuetebs, mka Zdjem` ZbjuretyGbkbfets+ Qcb kdk.tmxmg`b pdrtedk df tcbsb etbns nmy gbmaaba gmjl td tcb mahustba irdss ekjdnb, ef tcb ekjdnb esbxpbjtba td jdktekub fdr tcb ferst tcrbb ybmrs df tcbndrtimib+

c+ Mahustnbkts td Ekjdnb+ Jbrtmek mahustnbkts td ekjdnbscdwk dk tcb EWZ Fdrn =?1? nmy gb maaba gmjl td tcbmahustba irdss ekjdnb+ Mndki tcbsb mahustnbkts mrb EWM

mka Lbdic rbterbnbkt abaujtedks, pbkm`tebs dk bmr`ywetcarmwm` df smvekis, cbm`tc eksurmkjb abaujtedks, mkam`endky pmynbkts+

e+ Bnp`dybb Gusekbss Bxpbksbs+ Qcbsb bxpbksbs mrb mjtum`jmsc bxpbksbs tcmt nust gb abaujtba frdn tcb gdrrdwbr)smahustba irdss ekjdnb+

7+ Jdrpdrmtb Qmx Wbturks #EWZ Fdrn ==7?%+ Jdrpdrmtedks mrbstmtb.jcmrtbrba gusekbssbs dwkba gy tcber stdjlcd`abrs+Jdnpbksmtedk td ets dffejbrs, ibkbrm``y ek prdpdrtedk td tcb pbrjbktmib df dwkbrscep, es scdwk dk tcb jdrpdrmtb tmx rbturks mkawe`` mppbmr dk ekaeveaum` tmx rbturks+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr)s pbrjbktmibdf dwkbrscep es kdt scdwk, et nust gb dgtmekba sbpmrmtb`y frdn tcbjdrpdrmtedk)s mjjduktmkt, wetc bveabkjb tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr cms tcbreict td tcdsb fukas+ Dkjb tcb mahustba gusekbss ekjdnb esabtbrnekba, et scdu`a gb nu`tep`eba gy tcb gdrrdwbr)s pbrjbktmib df dwkbrscep ek tcb gusekbss+

Ek mkm`yzeki tcb jdrpdrmtb tmx rbturks, `bkabrs nust mahust fdr tcbfd``dweki8

m+ Abprbjemtedk mka Abp`btedk+ Qcb jdrpdrmtedk)s abprbjemtedkmka abp`btedk nust gb maaba gmjl td mftbr.tmx ekjdnb+

 g+ Qmxmg`b Ekjdnb+ Qmxmg`b ekjdnb es tcb jdrpdrmtedk)s kbtekjdnb gbfdrb fbabrm` tmxbs+ Et nust gb rbaujba gy tcb tmx`emge`ety+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.77

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 6? df 55

Page 61: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 61/99

1=22+= WBV.2

j+ Fesjm` Ubmr vs+ Jm`bkamr Ubmr+ Ef tcb jdrpdrmtedk dpbrmtbsdk m fesjm` ybmr tcmt es aeffbrbkt frdn tcb jm`bkamr ybmr, mkmahustnbkt nust gb nmab gy tcb `bkabr td rb`mtb jdrpdrmtbekjdnb td tcb ekaeveaum` tmx rbturk+

a+ Jmsc Yetcarmwm`s+ Qcb gdrrdwbr)s wetcarmwm` df jmscfrdn tcb jdrpdrmtedk nmy cmvb m sbvbrb kbimtevb enpmjt dktcb jdrpdrmtedk)s mge`ety td jdktekub dpbrmteki+

:+ 'Z' Jdrpdrmtedk Qmx Wbturks+ Mk 'Z' jdrpdrmtedk es ibkbrm``y msnm``, stmrt.up gusekbss, wetc imeks mka `dssbs pmssba dk tdstdjlcd`abrs ek prdpdrtedk td bmjc stdjlcd`abr)s pbrjbktmib df  gusekbss dwkbrscep+ Qcb ekjdnb fdr tcb dwkbrs jdnbs frdn Y.7wmibs mka es tmxba mt tcb ekaeveaum` rmtb+

Qcb 'jdnpbksmtedk df dffejbrs' `ekb dk tcb EWZ Fdrn ==7?Z es

trmksfbrrba td tcb gdrrdwbr)s EWZ Fdrn =?1?+ Gdtc abprbjemtedkmka abp`btedk nmy gb maaba gmjl td ekjdnb ek prdpdrtedk td tcb gdrrdwbr)s scmrb df ekjdnb+ Cdwbvbr, ekjdnb m`sd nust gbabaujtba prdpdrtedkmtb`y gy tcb tdtm` dg`eimtedks pmymg`b gy tcbjdrpdrmtedk ek `bss tcmk dkb ybmr+ Qcb gdrrdwbr)s wetcarmwm` df jmsc frdn tcb jdrpdrmtedk nmy cmvb m sbvbrb kbimtevb enpmjt dktcb jdrpdrmtedk)s mge`ety td jdktekub dpbrmteki mka nust gbjdkseabrba ek tcb mkm`yses+

1+ _mrtkbrscep Qmx Wbturks+ M pmrtkbrscep es fdrnba wcbk twd dr ndrb ekaeveaum`s fdrn m gusekbss mka scmrb ek prdfets, `dssbs, mkarbspdksege`ety fdr rukkeki tcb jdnpmky+ Bmjc pmrtkbr pmys tmxbsdk ces dr cbr prdpdrtedkmtb scmrb df tcb pmrtkbrscep―s kbt ekjdnb+

Gdtc ibkbrm` mka `enetba pmrtkbrsceps rbpdrt ekjdnb dk tcb EWZFdrn =?62< tces fdrn nust gb rbvebwba gy tcb `bkabr td mssbss tcbvemge`ety df tcb gusekbss+ Qcb pmrtkbr)s scmrb df ekjdnb es jmrrebadvbr td Zjcbau`b B df EWZ Fdrn =?1?+ Gdtc abprbjemtedk mkaabp`btedk nmy gb maaba gmjl td ekjdnb ek prdpdrtedk td tcb gdrrdwbr)s scmrb df ekjdnb+ Cdwbvbr, ekjdnb m`sd nust gbabaujtba prdpdrtedkmtb`y gy tcb tdtm` dg`eimtedks pmymg`b gy tcb pmrtkbrscep ek `bss tcmk dkb ybmr+ Qcb gdrrdwbr)s wetcarmwm` df jmsc frdn tcb pmrtkbrscep nmy cmvb m sbvbrb kbimtevb enpmjt dktcb pmrtkbrscep)s mge`ety td jdktekub dpbrmteki mka nust gbjdkseabrba ek tcb mkm`yses+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.7:

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 6= df 55

Page 62: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 62/99

1=22+= WBV.2

ZBJQEDK :8 GDWWDYBW)Z JMZC EKVBZQNBKQ EK QCB _WD_BWQU

7.=? FRKAZ QD J@DZB+ Qcb jmsc ekvbstnbkt ek tcb prdpbrty nust bqum` tcbaeffbrbkjb gbtwbbk tcb mndukt df tcb eksurba ndrtimib, bxj`uaeki mky upfrdktNE_, mka tcb tdtm` jdst td mjquerb tcb prdpbrty ekj`uaeki prbpmea bxpbksbs mka

j`dseki jdsts ms absjregba ek pmrmirmpc =.5+

 M`` fukas fdr tcb gdrrdwbr)s ekvbstnbkt ek tcb prdpbrty nust gb vbrefeba mka 

adjunbktba + Mjjbptmg`b sdurjbs df tcbsb fukas ekj`uab tcb fd``dweki8

M+ Bmrkbst Ndkby Abpdset+ Ef tcb mndukt df tcb bmrkbst ndkby abpdsetbxjbbas 7 pbrjbkt df tcb sm`bs prejb dr mppbmrs bxjbssevb gmsba dk tcb gdrrdwbr)s cestdry df mjjunu`mteki smvekis, tcb `bkabr nust vbrefy wetcadjunbktmtedk tcb abpdset mndukt mka tcb sdurjb df fukas+ Zmtesfmjtdryadjunbktmtedk ekj`uabs m jdpy df tcb gdrrdwbr)s jmkjb``ba jcbjl+ Mjbrtefejmtedk frdn tcb abpdset.cd`abr mjlkdw`baieki rbjbept df fukas mka

sbpmrmtb bveabkjb df tcb sdurjb df fukas es m`sd mjjbptmg`b+ Bveabkjb df sdurjb df fukas ekj`uabs m vbrefejmtedk df abpdset dr gmkl stmtbnbktscdweki tcmt mt tcb tenb tcb abpdset wms nmab tcb mvbrmib gm`mkjb wmssuffejebkt td jdvbr tcb mndukt df tcb bmrkbst ndkby abpdset+

G+ Zmvekis mka Jcbjleki Mjjdukts+ M vbrefejmtedk df abpdset #VDA%, m`dkiwetc tcb ndst rbjbkt gmkl stmtbnbkt, nmy gb usba td vbrefy smvekis mkajcbjleki mjjdukts+ Ef tcbrb es m `mrib ekjrbmsb ek mk mjjdukt, dr tcbmjjdukt wms dpbkba rbjbkt`y, tcb `bkabr nust dgtmek m jrbaeg`bbxp`mkmtedk df tcb sdurjb df tcdsb fukas+

J+ Ieft Fukas+ Mk dutreict ieft df tcb jmsc ekvbstnbkt es mjjbptmg`b ef tcbadkdr es tcb gdrrdwbr―s rb`mtevb, tcb gdrrdwbr)s bnp`dybr dr `mgdr ukedk, mjcmretmg`b drimkezmtedk, m idvbrknbktm` mibkjy dr pug`ej bktety tcmt cms m prdirmn td prdveab cdnbdwkbrscep mssestmkjb td `dw. mka ndabrmtb.ekjdnb fmne`ebs dr ferst.tenb cdnbguybrs, dr m j`dsb frebka wetc m j`bmr`yabfekba mka adjunbktba ektbrbst ek tcb gdrrdwbr+ Qcb ieft adkdr nmy kdt gb m pbrsdk dr bktety wetc mk ektbrbst ek tcb sm`b df tcb prdpbrty, sujc ms tcbsb``br, rbm` bstmtb mibkt dr grdlbr, gue`abr, dr mky bktety mssdjemtba wetctcbn+ Iefts frdn tcbsb sdurjbs mrb jdkseabrba ekaujbnbkts td purjcmsbmka nust gb sugtrmjtba frdn tcb sm`bs prejb+ Kd rbpmynbkt df tcb ieft nmy gb bxpbjtba dr enp`eba+ #Ms m ru`b, wb mrb kdt jdkjbrkba wetc cdw tcbadkdr dgtmeks tcb ieft fukas prdveaba tcby mrb kdt abrevba ek mky nmkkbr frdn m pmrty td tcb sm`bs trmksmjtedk+ Adkdrs nmy gdrrdw ieft fukas frdnmky dtcbr mjjbptmg`b sdurjb prdveaba tcb ndrtimib gdrrdwbrs mrb kdtdg`eidrs td mky kdtb td sbjurb ndkby gdrrdwba td ievb tcb ieft+% Qces ru`bm`sd mpp`ebs td prdpbrtebs df wcejc tcb sb``br es m idvbrknbkt mibkjysb``eki fdrbj`dsba prdpbrtebs, sujc ms tcb Vbtbrmks Manekestrmtedk dr Wurm`Cduseki Zbrvejbs+ Dk`y fmne`y nbngbrs nmy prdveab bquety jrbaet ms mieft dk m prdpbrty gbeki sd`a td dtcbr fmne`y nbngbrs+ Qcbsb rbstrejtedks

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.71

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 67 df 55

Page 63: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 63/99

1=22+= WBV.2

dk iefts mka bquety jrbaet nmy gb wmevba gy tcb huresaejtedkm` CDJ prdveaba tcmt tcb sb``br es jdktreguteki td dr dpbrmteki mk mjjbptmg`bmffdramg`b cduseki prdirmn+

FCM abbns tcb pmynbkt df jdksunbr abgt gy tcera pmrtebs td gb mk

ekaujbnbkt td purjcmsb+ Yce`b FCM pbrnets sb``brs mka dtcbr pmrtebs tdnmlb jdktregutedks df up td sex pbrjbkt df tcb sm`bs prejb df m prdpbrtytdwmra m guybr)s mjtum` j`dseki jdsts mka fekmkjeki jdkjbssedks, tces pd`ejy mpp`ebs bxj`usevb`y td tcb prdvesedk df ndrtimib fekmkjeki+ Dtcbr bxpbksbs pmea dk gbcm`f df tcb gdrrdwbr nust rbsu`t ek m ad``mr.fdr.ad``mr rbaujtedk td tcb sm`bs prejb+ Qcb ad``mr.fdr.ad``mr rbaujtedk td tcb sm`bs prejb m`sd mpp`ebs td ieft fukas kdt nbbteki tcb rbquerbnbkt tcmt tcb ieft gbfdr adwkpmynbkt mssestmkjb mka es prdveaba gy mk mjjbptmg`b sdurjb+Ycbk sdnbdkb dtcbr tcmk m fmne`y nbngbr cms pmea dff abgts, tcb fukasusba td pmy dff tcb abgt nust gb trbmtba ms mk ekaujbnbkt td purjcmsb mkatcb sm`bs prejb nust gb rbaujba gy m ad``mr.fdr.ad``mr mndukt ek

jm`ju`mteki tcb nmxenun eksurmg`b ndrtimib+

Adjunbktmtedk Wbquerbnbkts+ Qcb `bkabr nust adjunbkt tcb ieft fukas gy dgtmekeki m ieft `bttbr, seikba gy tcb adkdr mka gdrrdwbr, tcmt spbjefebstcb ad``mr mndukt df tcb ieft, stmtbs tcmt kd rbpmynbkt es rbquerba, scdwstcb adkdr―s kmnb, maarbss, tb`bpcdkb kungbr mka stmtbs tcb kmturb df tcbadkdr―s rb`mtedkscep td tcb gdrrdwbr+ Ek maaetedk, tcb bkabr nustadjunbkt tcb trmksfbr df fukas frdn tcb adkdr td tcb gdrrdwbr, ms fd``dws8

=+ Ef tcb ieft fukas mrb ek tcb cdnbguybr)s gmkl mjjdukt, tcb `bkabr nust adjunbkt tcb trmksfbr df tcb fukas frdn tcb adkdr td tcbcdnbguybr gy dgtmekeki m jdpy df tcb jmkjb`ba jcbjl dr dtcbr wetcarmwm` adjunbkt scdweki tcmt tcb wetcarmwm` es frdn tcbadkdr)s mjjdukt+ Qcb cdnbguybr)s abpdset s`ep mka gmkl stmtbnbkttcmt scdws tcb abpdset es m`sd rbquerba+

7+ Ef tcb ieft fukas mrb td gb prdveaba mt j`dseki8

m+ Ef tcb trmksfbr df tcb ieft fukas es gy jbrtefeba jcbjl nmabdk tcb adkdr)s mjjdukt, tcb `bkabr nust dgtmek m gmkl stmtbnbkt scdweki tcb wetcarmwm` frdn tcb adkdr)smjjdukt, ms wb`` ms m jdpy df tcb jbrtefeba jcbjl+

 g+ Ef tcb adkdr purjcmsba m jmscebr)s jcbjl, ndkby drabr,dffejem` jcbjl, dr mky dtcbr typb df gmkl jcbjl ms m nbmksdf trmksfbrreki tcb ieft fukas, tcb adkdr nust prdveab mwetcarmwm` adjunbkt dr jmkjb`ba jcbjl fdr tcb mndukt df tcb ieft, scdweki tcmt tcb fukas jmnb frdn tcb adkdr)s pbrsdkm` mjjdukt+ Ef tcb adkdr gdrrdwba tcb ieft fukas mkajmkkdt prdveab adjunbktmtedk frdn tcb gmkl dr dtcbr 

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.72

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 6: df 55

Page 64: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 64/99

1=22+= WBV.2

smvekis mjjdukt, tcb adkdr nust prdveab wrettbk bveabkjbtcmt tcdsb fukas wbrb gdrrdwba frdn mk mjjbptmg`b sdurjb,e+b+, kdt frdn m pmrty td tcb trmksmjtedk, ekj`uaeki tcb`bkabr+ 'Jmsc dk cmka' es kdt mk mjjbptmg`b sdurjb df tcbadkdr)s ieft fukas+

Wbimra`bss df wcbk tcb ieft fukas mrb nmab mvme`mg`b td tcbcdnbguybr, tcb `bkabr nust gb mg`b td abtbrnekb tcmt tcbieft fukas u`tenmtb`y wbrb kdt prdveaba frdn mkukmjjbptmg`b sdurjb mka wbrb ekabba tcb adkdr)s dwkfukas+ Ycbk tcb trmksfbr djjurs mt j`dseki, tcb `bkabr rbnmeks rbspdkseg`b fdr dgtmekeki vbrefejmtedk tcmt tcbj`dseki mibkt rbjbevba fukas frdn tcb adkdr fdr tcb mnduktdf tcb purpdrtba ieft mka tcmt tcdsb fukas jmnb frdn mkmjjbptmg`b sdurjb+

 KDQB8 FCM adbs kdt ‐mpprdvb„ adwk pmynbkt mssestmkjb prdirmns ektcb fdrn df iefts manekestbrba gy jcmretmg`b drimkezmtedks #e+b+,kdkprdfets%+ Ndrtimib `bkabrs mrb rbspdkseg`b fdr mssureki tcmt tcb ieft tdtcb cdnbguybr frdn tcb jcmretmg`b drimkezmtedk nbbts tcb mpprdpremtbFCM rbquerbnbkts mka tcb trmksfbr df fukas es prdpbr`y adjunbktba+ Ekmaaetedk, FCM adbs kdt m``dw kdkprdfet bktetebs td prdveab iefts tdcdnbguybrs fdr tcb purpdsb df pmyeki dff ekstm``nbkt `dmks, jrbaet jmras,jd``bjtedks, huainbkts, mka sene`mr abgts+

A+ Jd``mtbrm`ezba @dmks+ Fukas jmk gb gdrrdwba fdr tcb tdtm` rbquerbaekvbstnbkt ms `dki ms smtesfmjtdry bveabkjb es prdveaba tcmt tcb fukas mrbfu``y sbjurba gy ekvbstnbkt mjjdukts dr rbm` prdpbrty+ Zujc mssbts nmyekj`uab stdjls, gdkas, rbm` bstmtb #dtcbr tcmk tcb prdpbrty gbeki purjcmsba%, btj+

Ek maaetedk, jbrtmek typbs df `dmks sbjurba mimekst abpdsetba fukas, sujc msseikmturb `dmks, tcb jmsc vm`ub df `efb eksurmkjb pd`ejebs, `dmks sbjurba gy1?=#l%s, btj+, ek wcejc rbpmynbkt nmy gb dgtmekba tcrduic bxtekiuescekitcb mssbt< ad kdt rbquerb jdkseabrmtedk df m rbpmynbkt fdr qum`efyeki purpdsbs+ Cdwbvbr, ek sujc jerjunstmkjbs, tcb mssbt sbjureki tcb `dmknmy kdt gb ekj`uaba ms mssbts td j`dsb dr dtcbrwesb jdkseabrba ms mvme`mg`btd tcb gdrrdwbr+

Mk ekabpbkabkt tcera pmrty nust prdveab tcb gdrrdwba fukas+ Qcb sb``br,rbm` bstmtb mibkt dr grdlbr, `bkabr, dr dtcbr ektbrbstba tcera pmrty nmy kdt prdveab sujc fukas+ Rkmjjbptmg`b gdrrdwba fukas ekj`uab seikmturb`dmks, jmsc mavmkjbs dk jrbaet jmras, gdrrdweki mimekst cdusbcd`a iddasmka furketurb mka dtcbr sene`mr uksbjurba fekmkjeki+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.76

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 61 df 55

Page 65: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 65/99

1=22+= WBV.2

B+ Zm`bs _rdjbbas+ Qcb kbt prdjbbas frdn mk mrns.`bkitc sm`b df m jurrbkt`ydwkba prdpbrty nmy gb usba fdr tcb jmsc ekvbstnbkt dk m kbw cdusb+ Mfu``y bxbjutba CRA.= Zbtt`bnbkt Ztmtbnbkt nust gb prdveaba mssmtesfmjtdry bveabkjb df tcb jmsc sm`bs prdjbbas mjjrueki td tcb gdrrdwbr+Ef tcb prdpbrty cms kdt sd`a gy tcb tenb df ukabrwreteki, `dmk mpprdvm`

nust gb jdkaetedkba updk vbrefyeki tcb mjtum` prdjbbas rbjbevba gy tcb gdrrdwbr+ Qcb `bkabr nust adjunbkt gdtc tcb mjtum` sm`b mka tcbsuffejebkjy df tcb kbt prdjbbas rbquerba fdr sbtt`bnbkt+

F+ Qrmab Bquety+ Qcb gdrrdwbr nmy mirbb td trmab ces dr cbr rbm` prdpbrtytd tcb sb``br ms pmrt df tcb jmsc ekvbstnbkt+ Qcb mndukt df tcb gdrrdwbr)sbquety jdktregutedk es abtbrnekba gy sugtrmjteki m`` `ebks mimekst tcb prdpbrty gbeki trmaba #m`dki wetc mky rbm` bstmtb jdnnessedk% frdn tcb`bssbr df tcmt prdpbrty)s mpprmesba vm`ub dr sm`bs$trmab prejb+

Vm`ub nust gb abtbrnekba gy m rbseabktem` mpprmesm` kd ndrb tcmk sex

ndktcs d`a+ Bveabkjb df dwkbrscep m`sd es rbquerba+ Maaetedkm``y, ef tcb prdpbrty gbeki trmaba cms mk FCM.eksurba ndrtimib, mssunptedk prdjbsseki rbquerbnbkts mka rbstrejtedks mpp`y #sbb Jcmptbr 1 fdr maaetedkm` ekfdrnmtedk%+

I+ Zm`b df _brsdkm` _rdpbrty+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr ektbkas td sb`` pbrsdkm` prdpbrty etbns #jmrs, rbjrbmtedkm` vbcej`bs, stmnps, jdeks, gmsbgm`` jmrajd``bjtedks, btj+% td dgtmek fukas rbquerba fdr j`dseki, tcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab m smtesfmjtdry bstenmtb df tcber wdrtc, ek maaetedk td jdkj`usevbbveabkjb tcb etbns cmvb gbbk sd`a+ Qcb bstenmtba wdrtc df tcb etbns gbeki sd`a nmy gb ek tcb fdrn df pug`escba vm`ub bstenmtbs, sujc ms tcdsbessuba gy mutdndge`b abm`brs, pce`mtb`ej dr kunesnmtej mssdjemtedks, dr msbpmrmtb wrettbk mpprmesm` gy m qum`efeba mpprmesbr wetc kd fekmkjem`ektbrbst ek tcb `dmk trmksmjtedk+ Dk`y tcb `bssbr df tces bstenmtb df vm`ub dr tcb mjtum` sm`bs prejb es jdkseabrba ms mssbts td j`dsb+

C+ Bnp`dybr)s Iumrmktbb _`mks+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr―s bnp`dybr iumrmktbbs td purjcmsb tcb gdrrdwbr)s prbvedus rbseabkjb ms tcb rbsu`t df rb`djmtedk, tcb gdrrdwbr nust sugnet bveabkjb df tcb mirbbnbkt mka tcb kbt prdjbbasnust gb iumrmktbba+

E+ Bnp`dybr Mssestmkjb _`mks+ Ef tcb bnp`dybr, td mttrmjt dr rbtmek vm`umg`bbnp`dybbs, pmys tcb bnp`dybb)s j`dseki jdsts, ndrtimib eksurmkjb prbneun, dr mky pdrtedk df tcb jmsc ekvbstnbkt, tces pmynbkt esjdkseabrba bnp`dybb jdnpbksmtedk mka kd mahustnbkt td tcb nmxenunndrtimib mndukt es rbquerba+ Ef tcb bnp`dybr prdveabs tces gbkbfet mftbr `dmk sbtt`bnbkt, tcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab bveabkjb df suffejebkt jmsc fdr j`dseki+  M sm`mry mavmkjb, cdwbvbr, jmkkdt gb jdkseabrba ms mssbts tdj`dsb sekjb et rbprbsbkts mk uksbjurba `dmk+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.79

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 62 df 55

Page 66: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 66/99

1=22+= WBV.2

H+ Zmvekis Gdkas, Btj+ Idvbrknbkt essuba gdkas mrb jduktba mt dreiekm` purjcmsb prejb, uk`bss b`eiege`ety fdr rbabnptedk mka rbabnptedk vm`ub mrbjdkfernba+ Mjtum` rbjbept df fukas mt rbabnptedk nust gb vbrefeba+

L+ EWMs, Qcreft Zmvekis _`mks, 1?=#l%s & Lbdic Mjjdukts+ Mssbts sujc ms

EWMs, tcreft smvekis p`mks, mka 1?=#l%s, btj+, nmy gb ekj`uaba ek tcbukabrwreteki mkm`yses up td dk`y 6? pbrjbkt df vm`ub uk`bss tcb gdrrdwbr  prdveabs jdkj`usevb bveabkjb tcmt m ceicbr pbrjbktmib nmy gb wetcarmwkmftbr sugtrmjteki mky fbabrm` ekjdnb tmx mka mky wetcarmwm` pbkm`tebs+Bveabkjb df rbabnptedk es rbquerba+

@+ Ztdjls mka Gdkas+ Qcb ndktc`y dr qumrtbr`y stmtbnbkt prdveaba gy tcbstdjlgrdlbr dr fekmkjem` ekstetutedk nmkmieki tcb pdrtfd`ed nmy gb usba tdvbrefy tcb vm`ub df tcbsb sbjuretebs+ Mjtum` rbjbept df fukas nust gbvbrefeba mka adjunbktba+

N+ Jmsc Zmvba Mt Cdnb+ Gdrrdwbrs wcd cmvb smvba jmsc mt cdnb mka mrbmg`b td abndkstrmtb mabqumtb`y tcb mge`ety td ad sd mrb pbrnettba td cmvbtces ndkby ekj`uaba ms mk mjjbptmg`b sdurjb df fukas td j`dsb tcbndrtimib+ Qd ekj`uab sujc fukas ek mssbsseki tcb cdnbguybr)s jmsc mssbtsfdr j`dseki, tcb ndkby nust gb vbrefeba‚wcbtcbr abpdsetba ek m fekmkjem`ekstetutedk dr cb`a gy tcb bsjrdw$tet`b jdnpmky‚mka tcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab smtesfmjtdry bveabkjb df tcb mge`ety td mjjunu`mtb sujc smvekis+

Qcb mssbt vbrefejmtedk prdjbss rbquerbs tcb gdrrdwbr td bxp`mek ek wretekicdw sujc fukas wbrb mjjunu`mtba mka tcb mndukt df tenb tmlbk td ad sd+Qcb `bkabr nust abtbrnekb tcb rbmsdkmg`bkbss df tcb mjjunu`mtedk df tcbfukas gmsba dk tcb gdrrdwbr)s ekjdnb strbmn, tcb tenb pbreda aurekiwcejc tcb fukas wbrb smvba, tcb gdrrdwbr―s spbkaeki cmgets, adjunbktbabxpbksbs mka tcb gdrrdwbr―s cestdry df useki fekmkjem` ekstetutedks+ #M``dtcbr fmjtdrs gbeki bqum`, ekaeveaum`s wetc jcbjleki mka$dr smvekismjjdukts mrb `bss `elb`y td smvb ndkby mt cdnb tcmk mk ekaeveaum` wetc kdcestdry df sujc mjjdukts+%

K+ Wbkt Jrbaet+ Qcb junu`mtevb mndukt df tcb rbktm` pmynbkts tcmt bxjbbatcb mpprmesbr)s bstenmtb df fmer nmrlbt rbkt nmy gb jdkseabrbamjjunu`mtedk df tcb gdrrdwbr)s jmsc ekvbstnbkt+ Gdtc tcb rbkt.wetc.dptedk.td.purjcmsb mirbbnbkt mka tcb mpprmesbr)s bstenmtb df nmrlbt rbktnust gb ekj`uaba ek tcb bkadrsbnbkt pmjlmib+

Jdkvbrsb`y, ef tcb sm`bs mirbbnbkt rbvbm`s tcmt tcb rbktbr cms gbbk `eveki ektcb prdpbrty #dr dkb dwkba gy tcb sb``br% rbkt.frbb, dr tcmt mk mirbbnbktwms nmab m``dweki tcb rbktbr td djjupy mt m rbktm` mndukt jdkseabrmg`y gb`dw fmer nmrlbt vm`ub ek mktejepmtedk df bvbktum` purjcmsb df tcb prdpbrty, tces setumtedk nust gb trbmtba ms mk ekaujbnbkt td purjcmsb wetcmk mpprdpremtb rbaujtedk td tcb ndrtimib+ Bxjbptedks nmy gb irmktba ek

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.73

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 66 df 55

Page 67: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 67/99

1=22+= WBV.2

setumtedks, sujc ms wcbk m gue`abr fme`s td ab`evbr m prdpbrty mt mk mirbba.tdtenb mka tcbk pbrnets tcb gdrrdwbr td djjupy tcmt dr mkdtcbr uket fdr `bss.tcmk.nmrlbt rbkt tbnpdrmre`y ukte` jdkstrujtedk es jdnp`btb+

D+ Zwbmt Bquety+ @mgdr pbrfdrnba dr nmtbrem`s furkescba gy tcb gdrrdwbr 

 gbfdrb j`dseki, dk tcb prdpbrty gbeki purjcmsba, nmy gb jdkseabrba ms tcbbquevm`bkt df m jmsc ekvbstnbkt, td tcb bxtbkt df tcb bstenmtba jdst df tcbwdrl dr nmtbrem`s+ #Zwbmt bquety nmy gb 'ieftba' sughbjt td tcb ieftrbquerbnbkts mka maaetedkm` rbquerbnbkts scdwk gb`dw+% Maaetedkm``y,tcb fd``dweki mpp`y td swbmt bquety8

=+ Dk bxesteki jdkstrujtedk, dk`y tcb rbpmers dr en prdvbnbkts `estbadk tcb mpprmesm` mrb b`eieg`b fdr swbmt bquety+ Mky wdrl jdnp`btbadr nmtbrem`s prdveaba gbfdrb tcb mpprmesm` es nmab mrb kdt b`eieg`b+Dk prdpdsba jdkstrujtedk, tcb sm`bs jdktrmjt nust ekaejmtb tcbtmsls td gb pbrfdrnba gy tcb cdnbguybr aureki jdkstrujtedk+

7+ Qcb gdrrdwbr)s `mgdr nmy gb jdkseabrba ms tcb bquevm`bkt df jmsc,ef tcb gdrrdwbr jmk abndkstrmtb ces dr cbr mge`ety td jdnp`btb tcbwdrl ek m smtesfmjtdry nmkkbr+ Qcb `bkabr nust adjunbkt tcbjdktregutdry vm`ub df tcb `mgdr tcrduic betcbr tcb mpprmesbr)sbstenmtb dr m jdst bstenmteki sbrvejb+

:+ Ab`myba wdrl #dk.setb bsjrdw%, j`bmk up, abgres rbndvm`, mka dtcbr ibkbrm` nmektbkmkjb jmkkdt gb ekj`uaba ms swbmt bquety+

1+ Qcbrb jmk gb kd jmsc gmjl td tcb gdrrdwbr ek tcbsb trmksmjtedks+

2+ Zwbmt bquety dk m prdpbrty dtcbr tcmk tcb prdpbrty gbeki purjcmsbaes kdt mjjbptmg`b+ Jdnpbksmtedk fdr wdrl pbrfdrnba dk dtcbr  prdpbrtebs nust gb ek jmsc mka gb prdpbr`y adjunbktba+

6+ Bveabkjb df tcb sdurjb df fukas usba td purjcmsb mka tcb nmrlbtvm`ub df tcb nmtbrem`s nust gb prdveaba ef tcb gdrrdwbr furkescbstcbsb+

_+ Jdnnessedk frdn Zm`b+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr es m `ejbksba rbm` bstmtb mibktbktet`ba td m rbm` bstmtb jdnnessedk frdn tcb sm`b df tcb prdpbrty gbeki purjcmsba, tcmt mndukt nmy gb usba fdr tcb jmsc ekvbstnbkt wetc kdmahustnbkt td tcb nmxenun ndrtimib rbquerba+ M fmne`y nbngbr bktet`batd tcb jdnnessedk m`sd nmy prdveab ieft fukas td tcb cdnbguybr+

]+ Aesmstbr Wb ebf Irmkts mka @dmks+ Irmkts dr `dmks frdn stmtb mkafbabrm` mibkjebs \b+i+, Fbabrm` Bnbribkjy Nmkmibnbkt Mibkjy #FBNM%^tcmt prdveab ennbaemtb cduseki mssestmkjb td ekaeveaum`s aesp`mjba aub tdkmturm` aesmstbr nmy gb usba fdr tcb gdrrdwbr)s jmsc ekvbstnbkt+ Zbjurba

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.75

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 69 df 55

Page 68: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 68/99

1=22+= WBV.2

dr uksbjurba aesmstbr rb`ebf `dmks manekestbrba gy tcb Znm`` GusekbssManekestrmtedk #ZGM% m`sd nmy gb usba+ Cdwbvbr, ef tcb ZGM `dmk we`` gb sbjurba mimekst tcb prdpbrty gbeki purjcmsba, et nust gb j`bmr`ysugdraekmtb td tcb FCM.eksurba ndrtimib+ Mky ndktc`y pmynbkt mresekifrdn sujc m `dmk nust gb ekj`uaba ek tcb qum`efyeki rmteds+

W+ Jmsc Mjjunu`mtba wetc _revmtb Zmvekis J`ugs+ Zdnb gdrrdwbrs nmyjcddsb td usb kdk.trmaetedkm` nbtcdas df smveki ndkby gy nmlekiabpdsets ektd prevmtb smvekis j`ug+ Dftbk, tcbsb prevmtb smvekis j`ugs pdd`rbsdurjbs fdr usb mndki tcb nbngbrscep+

Ef m cdnbguybr j`mens tcmt tcb jmsc td j`dsb mk FCM.eksurba ndrtimib esfrdn smvekis cb`a wetc m prevmtb smvekis j`ug, tcb gdrrdwbr nust gb mg`btd mabqumtb`y adjunbkt tcb mjjunu`mtedk df tcdsb mssbts wetc tcb j`ug+Yce`b sujc j`ugs mrb kdt supbrvesba gmkleki ekstetutedks, tcb j`ugs nust ‚ mt m nekenun‚ cmvb mjjdukt `baibrs, rbjbepts frdn tcb j`ug, vbrefejmtedk

frdn tcb j`ug trbmsurbr, mka eabktefejmtedk df tcb j`ug sd tcmt tcb `bkabr jmkrbvbrefy tcb ekfdrnmtedk prdveaba+ Qcb ukabrwretbr nust gb mg`b tdabtbrnekb tcmt et wms rbmsdkmg`b fdr tcb gdrrdwbr td cmvb smvba tcb ndkbyj`menba mka tcmt tcbrb es kd bveabkjb tcbsb fukas wbrb gdrrdwba wetc mkbxpbjtmtedk df rbpmynbkt+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.:?

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 63 df 55

Page 69: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 69/99

1=22+= WBV.2

ZBJQEDK 18 @EMGE@EQEBZ

7.== QU_BZ DF @EMGE@EQEBZ+ Qcb fd``dweki mrb typbs df `emge`etebs tcmt nust gbjdkseabrba ek qum`efyeki gdrrdwbrs8

M+ Wbjurreki Dg`eimtedks+ Qcb gdrrdwbr)s `emge`etebs ekj`uab m`` ekstm``nbkt`dmks, rbvd`veki jcmrib mjjdukts, rbm` bstmtb `dmks, m`endky, jce`a suppdrt,mka m`` dtcbr jdktekueki dg`eimtedks+ Ek jdnputeki tcb abgt.td.ekjdnbrmteds, tcb `bkabr nust ekj`uab tcb ndktc`y cduseki bxpbksb mka m`` dtcbr maaetedkm` rbjurreki jcmribs bxtbkaeki tbk ndktcs dr ndrb, ekj`uaeki pmynbkts dk ekstm``nbkt mjjdukts, jce`a suppdrt dr sbpmrmtb nmektbkmkjb pmynbkts, rbvd`veki mjjdukts mka m`endky, btj+ Abgts `msteki `bss tcmk tbkndktcs nust gb jduktba ef tcb mndukt df tcb abgt mffbjts tcb gdrrdwbr)smge`ety td nmlb tcb ndrtimib pmynbkt aureki tcb ndktcs ennbaemtb`ymftbr `dmk j`dseki< tces es bspbjem``y trub ef tcb gdrrdwbr we`` cmvb `enetbadr kd jmsc mssbts mftbr `dmk j`dseki+

Qcb fd``dweki maaetedkm` ekfdrnmtedk abm`s wetc rbvd`veki mjjdukts mkam`endky pmynbkts8

=+ Wbvd`veki Mjjdukts+ Ef tcb mjjdukt scdwk dk tcb jrbaet rbpdrt cmsmk dutstmkaeki gm`mkjb, ndktc`y pmynbkts fdr qum`efyeki purpdsbsnust gb jm`ju`mtba mt tcb irbmtbr df 2 pbrjbkt df tcb gm`mkjb dr !=?#uk`bss tcb mjjdukt scdws m spbjefej nekenun ndktc`y pmynbkt%+

7+ M endky+ Gbjmusb df tcb tmx jdksbqubkjbs df m`endky pmynbkts,tcb `bkabr nmy jcddsb td trbmt tcb ndktc`y m`endky dg`eimtedk ms mrbaujtedk frdn tcb gdrrdwbr)s irdss ekjdnb ek jm`ju`mtekiqum`efyeki rmteds, rmtcbr tcmk ms m ndktc`y dg`eimtedk+

G+ Jdktekibkt @emge`etebs+ M jdktekibkt `emge`ety bxests wcbk mk ekaeveaum`we`` gb cb`a rbspdkseg`b fdr pmynbkt df m abgt, scdu`a mkdtcbr pmrty, hdekt`y dr sbvbrm``y dg`eimtba, abfmu`t dk tcmt pmynbkt+ Rk`bss tcb gdrrdwbr jmk prdveab jdkj`usevb bveabkjb frdn tcb abgt cd`abr tcmt tcbrbes kd pdssege`ety tcb abgt cd`abr we`` pursub abgt jd``bjtedk mimekst cen dr cbr scdu`a tcb dtcbr pmrty abfmu`t, tcb fd``dweki ru`bs mpp`y td jdktekibkt`emge`etebs8

=+ Ndrtimib Mssunptedks+ Ycbk m gdrrdwbr rbnmeks dg`eimtba dk mkdutstmkaeki FCM.eksurba, VM.iumrmktbba, dr jdkvbktedkm`ndrtimib sbjurba gy m prdpbrty tcmt cms gbbk sd`a dr trmaba wetcektcb `mst twb`vb ndktcs wetcdut m rb`bmsb df `emge`ety, dr es td gb sd`adk mssunptedk wetcdut m rb`bmsb df `emge`ety gbeki dgtmekba,jdktekibkt `emge`ety nust gb jdkseabrba uk`bss8

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.:=

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 65 df 55

Page 70: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 70/99

1=22+= WBV.2

m+ Qcb dreiekmteki bkabr df tcb ndrtimib gbeki ukabrwrettbkdgtmeks frdn tcb sbrvejbr df tcb mssunba `dmk m pmynbktcestdry scdweki tcmt ndrtimib cms gbbk jurrbkt aureki tcb prbvedus =7 ndktcs< dr 

 g+ Mk mpprmesm` dr j`dseki stmtbnbkt frdn tcb sm`b df tcb prdpbrty suppdrts m vm`ub tcmt rbsu`ts ek m 92 pbrjbkt @QVrmted \e+b+, tcb dutstmkaeki gm`mkjb dk tcb ndrtimib `dmk#nekus mky RFNE_, ef mpp`ejmg`b% jmkkdt bxjbba 92 pbrjbktdf tcb mpprmesba vm`ub dr sm`bs prejb^+

7+ Jd.Zeikba Dg`eimtedks+ Ef tcb ekaeveaum` mpp`yeki fdr mk FCM.eksurba ndrtimib es m jd.seikbr‚dr es dtcbrwesb jd.dg`eimtba dk mjmr `dmk, stuabkt `dmk, ndrtimib, dr mky dtcbr dg`eimtedk ‚ jdktekibkt `emge`ety mpp`ebs uk`bss tcb `bkabr dgtmeks adjunbktba prddf tcmt tcb prenmry dg`eidr cms gbbk nmleki pmynbkts aureki

tcb prbvedus =7 ndktcs dk m rbiu`mr gmses mka adbs kdt cmvb mcestdry df ab`ekqubkt pmynbkts dk tcb `dmk+

J+ _rdhbjtba Dg`eimtedks+ Ef m abgt pmynbkt, sujc ms m stuabkt `dmk, essjcbau`ba td gbiek wetcek twb`vb ndktcs df tcb ndrtimib `dmk j`dseki, tcb`bkabr nust ekj`uab tcb mktejepmtba ndktc`y dg`eimtedk ek tcb ukabrwretekimkm`yses, uk`bss tcb gdrrdwbr prdveabs wrettbk bveabkjb tcmt tcb abgt we`` gb abfbrrba td m pbreda dutseab tces tenbfrmnb+ Zene`mr`y, gm``ddk kdtbstcmt jdnb aub wetcek dkb ybmr df `dmk j`dseki nust gb jdkseabrba ek tcbukabrwreteki mkm`yses+

A+ Dg`eimtedks Kdt Jdkseabrba Abgt+ Dg`eimtedks kdt td gb jdkseabrba abgt#dr sugtrmjtba frdn irdss ekjdnb% ekj`uab fbabrm`, stmtb, mka `djm` tmxbs<FEJM dr dtcbr rbterbnbkt jdktregutedks sujc ms 1?=#l% mjjdukts #ekj`uaekirbpmynbkt df abgt sbjurba gy tcbsb fukas%< jdnnuteki jdsts< ukedk aubs<dpbk mjjdukts wetc zbrd gm`mkjbs< mutdnmtej abaujtedks td smvekismjjdukts< jce`a jmrb< mka vd`uktmry abaujtedks+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.:7

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 9? df 55

Page 71: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 71/99

1=22+= WBV.2

ZBJQEDK 28 GDWWDYBW ]RM@EFUEKI

Qcb pmrmirmpcs gb`dw aesjuss abgt.td.ekjdnb rmteds mka tcb jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs tcmtnmy gb usba td bxjbba tcb qum`efyeki rmteds+ Ms bveabkjba gy tcb absjreptedk df jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs, rmteds jmk gb bxjbbaba wcbk seikefejmkt jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs

bxest+ Yb m`sd ad kdt sbt mk mrgetrmry pbrjbktmib tcmt rmteds nmy kbvbr bxjbba< cdwbvbr,tcb ukabrwretbr scdu`a huaib tcb dvbrm`` nbrets df tcb `dmk mpp`ejmtedk mka abtbrnekbwcmt jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs mpp`y mka tcb bxtbkt td wcejc rmteds nmy gb bxjbbaba+

Rkabrwreteki rbquerbs jmrbfu` mkm`yses df tcb nmky mspbjts df tcb ndrtimib+ Bmjc `dmk esm sbpmrmtb mka ukequb trmksmjtedk, mka tcbrb nmy gb dtcbr fmjtdrs tcmt abndkstrmtb tcb gdrrdwbrs) mge`ety mka we``ekikbss td nmlb tenb`y ndrtimib pmynbkts+ Qcbrb es m amkibr df '`mybreki f`bxege`etebs' ek mssbsseki ndrtimib eksurmkjb resl, mka senp`y bstmg`escekitcmt m `dmk trmksmjtedk nbbts nekenm` stmkamras adbs kdt kbjbssmre`y jdkstetutb pruabktukabrwreteki+ Qcb `bkabr es rbspdkseg`b fdr mabqumtb`y mkm`yzeki tcb prdgmge`ety tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr we`` gb mg`b td rbpmy tcb ndrtimib dg`eimtedk ek mjjdramkjb wetc tcb tbrns df 

tcb `dmk+

7.=7 ABGQ.QD.EKJDNB WMQEDZ+ Wmteds mrb usba td abtbrnekb wcbtcbr tcb gdrrdwbr jmk rbmsdkmg`y gb bxpbjtba td nbbt tcb bxpbksbs ekvd`vba ekcdnbdwkbrscep, mka dtcbrwesb prdveab fdr tcb fmne`y+ Qcb `bkabr nust jdnputbtwd rmteds8

M+ Ndrtimib _mynbkt Bxpbksb td Bffbjtevb Ekjdnb+ Ef tcb tdtm` ndrtimib pmynbkt #prekjepm` mka ektbrbst< bsjrdw abpdsets fdr rbm` bstmtb tmxbs,cmzmra eksurmkjb, tcb ndrtimib eksurmkjb prbneun, cdnbdwkbrs)mssdjemtedk aubs, irduka rbkt, spbjem` mssbssnbkts, mka pmynbkts fdr mkymjjbptmg`b sbjdkamry fekmkjeki% adbs kdt bxjbba 75 pbrjbkt df tcb irdss

bffbjtevb ekjdnb, tcb rb`mtedkscep df tcb ndrtimib pmynbkt td ekjdnb esjdkseabrba mjjbptmg`b+ M rmted bxjbbaeki 75 pbrjbkt nmy gb mjjbptmg`bdk`y ef seikefejmkt jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs ms aesjussba ek pmrmirmpc 7.=: mrbadjunbktba mka mrb rbjdraba dk tcb ndrtimib jrbaet mkm`yses wdrlscbbt+Qypejm``y, fdr gdrrdwbrs wetc `enetba rbjurreki bxpbksb, irbmtbr `mtetuab es pbrnesseg`b dk tces rmted tcmk dk tcb tdtm` fexba pmynbkt rmted absjregba gb`dw+

G+ Qdtm` Fexba _mynbkt td Bffbjtevb Ekjdnb+ Ef tcb tdtm` df tcb ndrtimib pmynbkt mka m`` rbjurreki jcmribs adbs kdt bxjbba 1= pbrjbkt df tcb irdss

bffbjtevb ekjdnb, tcb rb`mtedkscep df tdtm` dg`eimtedks td ekjdnb esjdkseabrba mjjbptmg`b+ M rmted bxjbbaeki 1= pbrjbkt nmy gb mjjbptmg`bdk`y ef seikefejmkt jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs ms aesjussba ek pmrmirmpc 7.=: mrbadjunbktba mka mrb rbjdraba dk tcb ndrtimib jrbaet mkm`yses wdrlscbbt+

7.=: JDN_BKZMQEKI FMJQDWZ+ Jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs tcmt nmy gb usba td hustefy mpprdvm` df ndrtimib `dmks wetc rmteds bxjbbaeki dur gbkjcnmrl iueab`ekbs mrb tcdsb `estba gb`dw+ Rkabrwretbrs nust rbjdra dk tcb 'rbnmrls'

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.::

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 9= df 55

Page 72: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 72/99

1=22+= WBV.2

sbjtedk df tcb CRA 575??.YZ$CRA 575??._RW tcb jdnpbksmteki fmjtdr#s% usbatd suppdrt `dmk mpprdvm + Mky jdnpbksmteki fmjtdr usba td hustefy ndrtimibmpprdvm` nust gb suppdrtba gy adjunbktmtedk+

M+ Qcb gdrrdwbr cms sujjbssfu``y abndkstrmtba tcb mge`ety td pmy cduseki

bxpbksbs bqum` td dr irbmtbr tcmk tcb prdpdsba ndktc`y cduseki bxpbksbfdr tcb kbw ndrtimib dvbr tcb pmst =7.71 ndktcs+

G+ Qcb gdrrdwbr nmlbs m `mrib adwkpmynbkt #tbk pbrjbkt dr ndrb% tdwmratcb purjcmsb df tcb prdpbrty+

J+ Qcb gdrrdwbr cms abndkstrmtba mk mge`ety td mjjunu`mtb smvekis mka mjdksbrvmtevb mttetuab tdwmra tcb usb df jrbaet+

A+ _rbvedus jrbaet cestdry scdws tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr cms tcb mge`ety td abvdtb mirbmtbr pdrtedk df ekjdnb td cduseki bxpbksbs+

B+ Qcb gdrrdwbr rbjbevbs adjunbktba jdnpbksmtedk dr ekjdnb kdt rbf`bjtbaek bffbjtevb ekjdnb, gut aerbjt`y mffbjteki tcb mge`ety td pmy tcb ndrtimib,ekj`uaeki fdda stmnps mka sene`mr pug`ej gbkbfets+

F+ Qcbrb es dk`y m nekenm` ekjrbmsb ek tcb gdrrdwbr)s cduseki bxpbksb+

I+ Qcb gdrrdwbr cms sugstmktem` adjunbktba jmsc rbsbrvbs #mt `bmst tcrbbndktcs― wdrtc% mftbr j`dseki+ Ek abtbrnekeki ef mk mssbt jmk gb ekj`uaba msjmsc rbsbrvbs dr jmsc td j`dsb, tcb `bkabr nust huaib wcbtcbr dr kdt tcbmssbt es `equea dr rbmae`y jdkvbrteg`b td jmsc mka jmk gb adkb sd mgsbktrbterbnbkt dr hdg tbrnekmtedk+ M`sd sbb pmrmirmpc 7.=?L+

Fukas gdrrdwba mimekst tcbsb mjjdukts nmy gb usba fdr `dmk j`dseki, gutmrb kdt td gb jdkseabrba ms jmsc rbsbrvbs+ ‐Mssbts„ sujc ms bquety ek dtcbr  prdpbrtebs mka tcb prdjbbas frdn m jmsc.dut rbfekmkjb mrb kdt td gbjdkseabrba ms jmsc rbsbrvbs+ Zene`mr`y, fukas frdn iefts frdn mky sdurjbmrb kdt td gb ekj`uaba ms jmsc rbsbrvbs+

C+ Qcb gdrrdwbr cms sugstmktem` kdk.tmxmg`b ekjdnb #ef kd mahustnbkt wmsnmab prbvedus`y ek tcb rmted jdnputmtedks%+

E+ Qcb gdrrdwbr cms m pdtbktem` fdr ekjrbmsba bmrkekis, ms ekaejmtba gy hdgtrmekeki dr baujmtedk ek tcb gdrrdwbr)s prdfbssedk+

H+ Qcb cdnb es gbeki purjcmsba ms m rbsu`t df rb`djmtedk df tcb prenmry wmib.bmrkbr, mka tcb sbjdkamry wmib.bmrkbr cms mk bstmg`escba cestdry df bnp`dynbkt, es bxpbjtba td rbturk td wdrl, mka rbmsdkmg`b prdspbjts bxestfdr sbjureki bnp`dynbkt ek m sene`mr djjupmtedk ek tcb kbw mrbm+ Qcbukabrwretbr nust adjunbkt tcb mvme`mge`ety df sujc pdsseg`b bnp`dynbkt+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.:1

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 97 df 55

Page 73: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 73/99

1=22+= WBV.2

NDWQIMIB JWBAEQ MKM@UZEZ

ZBJQEDK 68 Z_BJEM@ RKABWYWEQEKI EKZQWRJQEDKZ

7.=1 Qbnpdrmry Ektbrbst Wmtb Guyadwks+ Ektbrbst rmtb guyadwks mrb abseikba td

rbaujb tcb gdrrdwbr―s ndktc`y pmynbkt aureki tcb bmr`y ybmrs df tcb ndrtimibmka mrb pbrnettba dk`y dk purjcmsb trmksmjtedks+ Guyadwks nmy dk`y gb usba dkfexba.rmtb ndrtimibs+

Guyadwk fukas nmy jdnb frdn tcb sb``br, `bkabr, gdrrdwbr dr dtcbr pmrty+ Fukasfrdn tcb sb``br dr mky dtcbr ektbrbstba tcera pmrty mrb jdkseabrba sb``br jdktregutedks mka nust gb ekj`uaba ek tcb sex pbrjbkt `enet dk sb``br jdktregutedks#sbb pmrmirmpc =.9M%+ @bkabrs nust bksurb tcmt tcb fukas absjregba ek tcb bsjrdwmirbbnbkt cmvb gbbk p`mjba ek bsjrdw gbfdrb dr mt j`dseki mka tcmt tcb mirbbnbktnbbts tcb rbquerbnbkts absjregba gb`dw+

Guyadwks dk b`eieg`b `dmks kdt nbbteki m`` tcb jretbrem absjregba ek pmrmirmpc M, gb`dw, nmy gb jdkseabrba dk`y ms jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs+ Cdwbvbr, m`` guyadwksnust jdnp`y wetc tcb bsjrdw mirbbnbkt rbquerbnbkts ek pmrmirmpc G, gb`dw+

M+ Rkabrwreteki Wbquerbnbkts fdr ]um`efyeki Gdrrdwbrs mt tcb GuyadwkEktbrbst Wmtb+

=+ Qcb ndrtimib nust gb m fexba rmtb `dmk dk mk dwkbr djjupeba prekjepm` rbseabkjb+

7+ Qcb guyadwk nust kdt rbsu`t ek m rbaujtedk df ndrb tcmk twd pbrjbktmib pdekts gb`dw tcb ektbrbst rmtb dk tcb kdtb+

:+ Qcb guyadwk nust kdt rbsu`t ek ndrb tcmk m dkb.pbrjbktmib pdektmkkum` abjrbmsb ek tcb ektbrbst rmtb+ Qcb gdrrdwbr―s pmynbkt nmyjcmkib dk`y dkjb m ybmr+

G+ Maaetedkm` Ektbrbst Wmtb Guyadwk Ekstrujtedks+

=+ @bkabr.fukaba guyadwks dk fexba.rmtb purjcmsb ndkby ndrtimibstcrduic prbneun prejeki mrb mjjbptmg`b prdveaba tcmt tcb fukasibkbrmtba ad kdt rbsu`t ek m rbaujtedk df ndrb tcmk 7 pbrjbktmib pdekts gb`dw tcb kdtb rmtb+

7+ Qcb `bkabr nust bstmg`esc tcmt tcb bvbktum` ekjrbmsb ek ndrtimib pmynbkts we`` kdt mffbjt tcb gdrrdwbr mavbrsb`y mka `elb`y `bma tdabfmu`t+ Qcb ukabrwretbr nust adjunbkt tcmt tcb gdrrdwbr nbbtsdkb df tcb fd``dweki jretbrem8

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.:2

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 9: df 55

Page 74: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 74/99

1=22+= WBV.2

m+ Qcb gdrrdwbr cms m pdtbktem` fdr ekjrbmsba ekjdnb tcmtwdu`a dffsbt tcb sjcbau`ba pmynbkt ekjrbmsbs, ms ekaejmtba gy hdg trmekeki dr baujmtedk ek tcb gdrrdwbr)s prdfbssedk dr  gy m cestdry df mavmkjbnbkt ek tcb gdrrdwbr)s jmrbbr wetcmttbkamkt ekjrbmsbs ek bmrkekis+

 g+ Qcb gdrrdwbr cms m abndkstrmtba mge`ety td nmkmibfekmkjem` dg`eimtedks ek sujc m wmy tcmt m irbmtbr pdrtedk df ekjdnb nmy gb abvdtba td cduseki bxpbksbs+ Qces jretbredkm`sd nmy ekj`uab gdrrdwbrs wcdsb `dki.tbrn abgt, ef mky,we`` kdt bxtbka gbydka tcb tbrn df tcb guyadwk mirbbnbkt+

j+ Qcb gdrrdwbr cms sugstmktem` mssbts mvme`mg`b td juscedk tcbbffbjt df tcb ekjrbmsba pmynbkts+

a+ Qcb jmsc ekvbstnbkt nmab gy tcb gdrrdwbr sugstmktem``y

bxjbbas tcb nekenun rbquerba+

:+ Bsjrdw Mirbbnbkt Wbquerbnbkts+ M jdpy df tcb bsjrdwmirbbnbkt, seikba gy tcb gdrrdwbr mka tcb prdveabr df fukas, nustmjjdnpmky tcb `dmk mpp`ejmtedk+ #Qcb ukabrwretbr nmy jdkaetedktcb `dmk mpprdvm` fdr mk bxbjutba guyadwk mirbbnbkt mt j`dseki+%

Qcb fd``dweki mrb rbquerbnbkts fdr tcb bsjrdw mirbbnbkt8

m+ Qcb mirbbnbkt nust prdveab tcmt mky bsjrdw fukas kdtaestregutba mt tcb tenb tcb ndrtimib `dmk es prbpmea gbmpp`eba td tcb dutstmkaeki gm`mkjb aub dk tcb ndrtimib+Cdwbvbr, ek tcb bvbkt df fdrbj`dsurb, tcb j`men fdr ndrtimib eksurmkjb gbkbfets nust gb rbaujba gy tcbmndukt rbnmekeki ek tcb guyadwk bsjrdw mjjdukt+

 g+ Qcb mirbbnbkt nust kdt pbrnet rbvbrsedk df ukaestregutbabsjrdw fukas td tcb prdveabr ef tcb prdpbrty es sd`a dr tcbndrtimib es prbpmea ek fu``+ Qcb mirbbnbkt nmy prdveabtcmt mssestmkjb pmynbkts jdktekub td guybrs wcd mssunbtcb ndrtimib+ Rk`bss tcb gdrrdwbr bstmg`escbs tcb bsjrdwmjjdukt, ukbxpbkaba bsjrdw fukas nmy kdt gb prdveaba tdtcb gdrrdwbr ek jmsc+

j+ Qcb bsjrdw fukas nust gb cb`a ek mk bsjrdw mjjdukt gy mfekmkjem` ekstetutedk supbrvesba gy m fbabrm` dr stmtb mibkjy+_mynbkts nust gb nmab gy tcb bsjrdw mibkt td tcb `bkabr dr ets sbrvejeki mibkt+ Cdwbvbr, ef tcb bsjrdw pmynbkts mrbkdt rbjbevba fdr mky rbmsdk, et es tcb gdrrdwbr)srbspdksege`ety td nmlb tcb tdtm` pmynbkt sbt fdrtc ek tcb

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.:6

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 91 df 55

Page 75: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 75/99

1=22+= WBV.2

ndrtimib kdtb+ FCM cms kd dghbjtedk td tcb bkabr cd`aekimka manekestbreki tcb bsjrdw fukas fdr up td 6? amys wcbktcbrb es mk dutstmkaeki fdrwmra jdnnetnbkt td sb`` tcbndrtimib+

7.=2 MAHRZQMG@B WMQB NDWQIMIBZ #MWNs%+ Gdrrdwbrs nust qum`efy fdr dkb.ybmr MWNs useki tcb ndrtimib pmynbkts gmsba updk tcb jdktrmjt dr eketem`ektbrbst rmtb p`us = pbrjbktmib pdekt #e+b+, tcb mktejepmtba nmxenun sbjdka.ybmr ektbrbst rmtb% ef tcb `dmk.td.vm`ub rmted es 52 pbrjbkt dr irbmtbr+

7.=6 JDKADNEKERN RKEQZ‚RQE@EQU BS_BKZBZ+ Yetc prdpbr adjunbktmtedk, sujc ms tcmt wcejc es mvme`mg`b frdn tcb ute`ety jdnpmky, tcb pdrtedk df m jdkadnekeun fbb tcmt es j`bmr`y mttregutmg`b td ute`etebs nmy gbsugtrmjtba frdn tcb Cdnbdwkbrs Mssdjemtedk #CDM% aubs gbfdrb jdnputekirmteds+

7.=9 JDKZQWRJQEDK‚_BWNMKBKQ NDWQIMIB _WDIWMN+ Mjdkstrujtedk.pbrnmkbkt ndrtimib jdngekbs tcb fbmturbs df m jdkstrujtedk `dmk, mscdrt.tbrn ektbren `dmk fdr fekmkjeki tcb jdst df jdkstrujtedk, mka tcb trmaetedkm``dki.tbrn pbrnmkbkt rbseabktem` ndrtimib+ Fdr ndrtimib eksurmkjb mka @QV purpdsbs, wb jdkseabr et td gb m purjcmsb trmksmjtedk+ Qcb ndrtimib `bkabr nmlbstcb `dmk aerbjt`y td mk mpprdvba gdrrdwbr$cdnbguybr+ Qcbrb es dkb j`dseki tcmtdjjurs predr td tcb stmrt df jdkstrujtedk+ Mt j`dseki, fukas mrb aesgursba td jdvbr  purjcmsb df tcb `mka, wetc tcb gm`mkjb df tcb ndrtimib prdjbbas p`mjba ek mkbsjrdw mjjdukt td gb aesgursba ms jdkstrujtedk prdirbssbs+ Qcb `dmk es eksurba mftbr jdkstrujtedk es jdnp`btb+

_rdirmn Ekfdrnmtedk+

M+ Aesgursbnbkt df Fukas+ Et es tcb `bkabr)s rbspdksege`ety td dgtmek wrettbkmpprdvm` frdn tcb gdrrdwbr gbfdrb bmjc armw pmynbkt es prdveaba td tcb gue`abr+

G+ Jdkstrujtedk _breda Fbbs+ Rk`bss m sbpmrmtb mirbbnbkt cms gbbk nmabspbjefyeki rbspdksege`ety, jdkstrujtedk `dmk ektbrbst, jdnnetnbkt fbbs,ekspbjtedk fbbs, tet`b upamtb jcmribs, rbm` bstmtb tmxbs, cmzmra eksurmkjb,mka dtcbr fekmkjeki jcmribs ekjurrba aureki tcb jdkstrujtedk pbreda mrb td gb pmea gy tcb gue`abr+

J+ Ektbrbst Wmtb+ Qcb pbrnmkbkt ndrtimib `dmk ektbrbst es bstmg`escba mtj`dseki+ Cdwbvbr, m `bkabr nmy dffbr m 'jbe`eki$f ddr,' wcbrbgy tcb gdrrdwbr nmy 'f`dmt' tcb ektbrbst rmtb aureki jdkstrujtedk+ Qcb mirbbnbktnust prdveab tcmt, mt tcb pdekt df ektbrbst rmtb `djl.ek, tcb pbrnmkbktndrtimib we`` kdt bxjbba m spbjefej nmxenun ektbrbst rmtb gmsba dknmrlbt f`ujtumtedks, ms wb`` ms pbrnet tcb gdrrdwbr td `djl.ek mt m `dwbr rmtb abpbkaeki dk tcb nmrlbt+ Qcb gdrrdwbr nust qum`efy fdr tcb

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.:9

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 92 df 55

Page 76: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 76/99

1=22+= WBV.2

ndrtimib mt tcb nmxenun rmtb mt wcejc tcb pbrnmkbkt ndrtimib nmy gbsbt+

A+ Aesj`dsurb+ Qcb `bkabr nust prdveab m aesj`dsurb td tcb gdrrdwbr bxp`mekekitcmt tcb `dmk es kdt b`eieg`b fdr FCM ndrtimib eksurmkjb ukte` mftbr betcbr m

fekm` ekspbjtedk dr essumkjb df m jbrtefejmtb df djjupmkjy gy tcb `djm`idvbrknbktm` huresaejtedk #wcejcbvbr es `mtbr%, mka tcmt FCM cms kddg`eimtedk ukte` tcb ndrtimib es bkadrsba fdr eksurmkjb+

B+ Mndrtezmtedk+ Mndrtezmtedk nust gbiek kd `mtbr tcmk tcb ferst df tcb ndktcfd``dweki 6? amys frdn tcb amtb df betcbr tcb fekm` ekspbjtedk dr essumkjbdf jbrtefejmtb df djjupmkjy, wcejcbvbr es `mtbr+

F+ Bkadrsbnbkt+ Qcb `bkabr nust sugnet m rbqubst fdr bkadrsbnbkt mftbr fekm`ekspbjtedk dr essumkjb df jbrtefejmtb df djjupmkjy #gut wetcek 6? amys df tcb amtb tcb `mttbr df tcbsb bvbkts djjur%+ Aureki jdkstrujtedk, tcb `dmk es

kdt FCM.eksurba+

I+ Wbnetteki RFNE_+ FCM nust rbjbevb tcb RFNE_ wetcek =2 amys df j`dsekidr dtcbr tenb pbreda ms nmy gb prbsjregba gy FCM+

C+ Nmxenun Ndrtimib Mndukt+ Qcb nmxenun ndrtimib mndukt esabtbrnekba gy mpp`yeki @QV `enets td tcb `bssbr df tcb mpprmesba vm`ub dr tcb mjquesetedk jdst+ Qcb mjquesetedk jdst ekj`uabs tcb jdktrmjtdr)s prejb td gue`a, jdst df tcb `mka, mka m``dwmg`b j`dseki jdsts+ #Ef tcb `mka cms gbbkdwkba ndrb tcmk sex ndktcs dr wms rbjbevba ms mk mjjbptmg`b ieft, tcbvm`ub df tcb `mka nmy gb usba ekstbma df ets jdst+%

E+ Bquety ek tcb @mka+ Bquety ek tcb `mka nmy gb usba fdr tcb gdrrdwbr)s jmscekvbstnbkt+ Cdwbvbr, ef tcb mavmkjbnbkt df tcb pbrnmkbkt dmk rbsu`ts ektcb gdrrdwbr rbjbeveki jmsc dut ek bxjbss df !72?, tcb nmxenun @QV es`enetba td 32 pbrjbkt+  Ef tcb jdktrmjtdr df tcb enprdvbnbkts es m`sd tcb

 sb``br df tcb `mka, tcb tdtm` mjquesetedk jdst fdr nmxenun ndrtimib

 purpdsbs es tcb purjcmsb prejb td tcb gdrrdwbr +

H+ Dtcbr Rkabrwreteki Jdkseabrmtedks+ Qcb fd``dweki jretbrem nust gb nbt fdr m `dmk td gb jdkseabrba m jdkstrujtedk$pbrnmkbkt `dmk mka td gb b`eieg`bfdr FCM ndrtimib eksurmkjb8

Qcb gdrrdwbr nust dwk dr gb purjcmseki tcb `dt #dr, ef dwkba gy tcbjdktrmjtdr, tcb `dt nust gb ekj`uaba ek tcb tdtm` jdktrmjt prejb%+

#=% Qcb gdrrdwbr nust cmvb sbjurba dr we`` sbjurb tcb `dmk ek ces dr cbr dwk kmnb+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.:3

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 96 df 55

Page 77: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 77/99

1=22+= WBV.2

#7% Qcb gdrrdwbr cms jdktrmjtba wetc m gue`abr td jdkstrujt tcbenprdvbnbkt+ #Qces prdirmn es kdt mvme`mg`b td m gdrrdwbr mjtekims ces dr cbr dwk ibkbrm` jdktrmjtdr, uk`bss tcb gdrrdwbr es m`ejbksba gue`abr gy prdfbssedk+ Ek tces jmsb, tcb mjquesetedk jdstnust gb abtbrnekba gy tcb mjtum` adjunbktba jdst td jdkstrujt tcb

enprdvbnbkts+%

#:% Qcb gm`mkjb dk tcb `dmk, wcbk et es fu``y armwk, nust gb vbrefeba+Qcb jdkstrujtedk bsjrdw mjjdukt, ef dkb wms bstmg`escba, nust gbfu``y bxtekiuescba< mky rbnmekeki fukas nust gb mpp`eba td tcbdutstmkaeki gm`mkjb df tcb pbrnmkbkt `dmk+

#1% Ef tcb gdrrdwbr purjcmsba tcb `dt wetcek tcb pmst 6 ndktcs, cb dr scb nust prdveab m jdpy df tcb CRA.= dr dtcbr sbtt`bnbktstmtbnbkt scdweki tcb mjquesetedk jdst+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr dwks tcb`dt frbb.mka.j`bmr, tcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab m jdpy df tcb

Ymrrmkty Abba scdweki kd vbkadr)s `ebk, m jdpy df tcb rb`bmsb df `ebk, dr m jdpy df tcb CRA.= dr dtcbr sbtt`bnbkt stmtbnbkt scdwekidwkbrscep+

#2% Ef tcb eketem` armw dk tcb `dmk wms fdr tcb purpdsb df pmyeki dff tcb`dt, m stmtbnbkt vbrefyeki tcb mndukt nust gb prdveaba+

#6% Qcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab m jdpy df tcb fu``y bxbjutba sm`bsmirbbnbkt, wcejc ekj`uabs tcb jdktrmjtdr)s prejb td gue`a+ #MNbjcmkej)s mka Nmtbrem` nmk―s `ebk es kdt suffejebkt+%

#9% Ef tcb gdrrdwbr es ekj`uaeki bxtrms dvbr mka mgdvb tcb jdktrmjtspbjefejmtedk mka$dr es pmyeki dut.df.pdjlbt jdsts dvbr mka mgdvbtcb ektbren `dmk, tcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveab m grbmladwk df tcbbxtrms mka tcb jdst df bmjc mka jmkjb`ba jcbjls mka pmea rbjbeptsfdr m`` dut.df.pdjlbt jdkstrujtedk jdsts+

L+ Adjunbktmtedk Wbquerbnbkts+ Qcb `dmk es td gb j`dsba useki stmkamra FCMadjunbktmtedk, wetc tcb maaetedk df m Jdkstrujtedk Weabr td tcb Kdtb mka mJdkstrujtedk @dmk Mirbbnbkt+ Qcbsb jdkstrujtedk adjunbkts nmy gb ekmky fdrn mjjbptmg`b td tcb `bkabr, gut tcby nust prdveab tcmt m`` spbjem`jdkstrujtedk tbrns bka wcbk tcb jdkstrujtedk `dmk jdkvbrts td m pbrnmkbkt`dmk+ Mftbr jdkvbrsedk, dk`y tcb pbrnmkbkt `dmk tbrns #useki stmkamraadjunbkts% jdktekub td gb bffbjtevb, tcus nmleki tcb pbrnmkbkt `dmkb`eieg`b fdr FCM ndrtimib eksurmkjb+

_redr td bkadrsbnbkt, tcb AB ukabrwretbr nust gb prdveaba wetc tcbfd``dweki8

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.:5

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 99 df 55

Page 78: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 78/99

1=22+= WBV.2

=+ Jbrtefejmtedk, seikba gy tcb gdrrdwbr mftbr jdkvbrsedk td tcb pbrnmkbkt `dmk, tcmt tcb ndrtimiba prdpbrty es frbb.mka.j`bmr df m```ebks dtcbr tcmk tcb ndrtimib+

7+ Vbrefejmtedk tcmt tcb jdkstrujtedk dmk cms gbbk fu``y armwk

adwk+

:+ Jdpebs df jmkjb`ba jcbjls mka pmea rbjbepts fdr m`` tcb gdrrdwbr)s dut.df.pdjlbt jdkstrujtedk jdsts+

7.=3 NDWQIMIB EKZRWMKJB FDW AEZMZQBW VEJQENZ \Zbjtedk 7?:#c%^+

FCM prdveabs ndrtimib eksurmkjb td mssest vejtens df _rbseabktem``y.abj`mrbaaesmstbrs+ Rkabr tces prdirmn, ekaeveaum`s dr fmne`ebs wcdsb rbseabkjbs wbrbabstrdyba dr amnmiba td sujc mk bxtbkt tcmt rbjdkstrujtedk dr rbpmer es kbjbssmrymrb b`eieg`b fdr =?? pbrjbkt fekmkjeki fdr tcb purjcmsb df m cdnb+ Qcb Fbabrm`Bnbribkjy Nmkmibnbkt Mibkjy #FBNM% prdveabs `estekis df tcb spbjefej

mffbjtba jduktebs mka jetebs mka jdrrbspdkaeki abj`mrmtedk amtbs+ Qcesekfdrnmtedk jmk gb fduka dk tcb Ektbrkbt mt cttp8$$www+fbnm+idv$aesmstbrs+

Qcb prdjbaurbs absjregba mrb ek bffbjt wcbkbvbr m aesmstbr es abj`mrba gy tcb_rbseabkt mka rbnmek ek bffbjt fdr dkb ybmr frdn tcb amtb df tcb _rbseabkt)sabj`mrmtedk+

M+ _rdirmn mka Rkabrwreteki Wbquerbnbkts+

Qcb gdrrdwbr)s prbvedus rbseabkjb nust cmvb gbbk ek tcb aesmstbr mrbm mkanust cmvb gbbk abstrdyba dr amnmiba td sujc mk bxtbkt tcmtrbjdkstrujtedk dr rbp`mjbnbkt es kbjbssmry+ Qcb gdrrdwbr nust prdveabjdkj`usevb bveabkjb df tces fmjt+ Adjunbktmtedk scdweki m pbrnmkbktrbseabkjb ek tcb mffbjtba mrbm gbfdrb tcb aesmstbr ekj`uabs m vm`ea arevbr)s`ejbksb, m vdtbr rbiestrmtedk jmra, ute`ety ge``s, btj+ Adjunbktmtedkrbimraeki abstrujtedk df tcb rbseabkjb ekj`uabs mk eksurmkjb rbpdrt, mkekspbjtedk rbpdrt gy mk ekabpbkabkt fbb ekspbjtdr dr idvbrknbkt mibkjy,dr jdkj`usevb pcdtdirmpcej bveabkjb scdweki tcb abstrujtedk dr amnmib+Qcb gdrrdwbr nmy cmvb gbbk tcb dwkbr df tcb prdpbrty dr m rbktbr df tcb prdpbrty mffbjtba+

Qcb gdrrdwbr es b`eieg`b fdr =?? pbrjbkt fekmkjeki df tcb sm`bs prejb mka kdadwk pmynbkt es rbquerba+ #Cdwbvbr, j`dseki jdsts mka prbpmea bxpbksbskdt pmea gy tcb sb``br nust gb pmea gy tcb gdrrdwbr ek jmsc dr pmea tcrduic prbneun prejeki+%Nmxenun ndrtimib mndukts mrb tcb smnb ms fdr Zbjtedk 7?:#g%$7?:#c%+M `est jmk gb mjjbssba frdn tcb `bkabr Ybg pmib dk CRA―s Ybgsetb mtwww+cua+idv dr dk FCM Jdkkbjtedk mt cttps8$$bktp+cua+idv$j`ms$+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.1?

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 93 df 55

Page 79: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 79/99

1=22+= WBV.2

Qcb prdirmn es `enetba td dkb.uket abtmjcba cdnbs dr ukets ek mk mpprdvbajdkadnekeun prdhbjt+ 'Zpdt ukets' ek jdkadnekeuns mrb b`eieg`b m`sd+Qwd., tcrbb., mka fdur.uket prdpbrtebs nmy kdt gb purjcmsba ukabr tcbZbjtedk 7?:#c% prdirmn+

Qcb gdrrdwbr)s ndrtimib `dmk mpp`ejmtedk nust gb sugnettba td tcb `bkabr wetcek dkb ybmr df tcb _rbseabkt)s abj`mrmtedk df tcb aesmstbr+

MWNZ nmy gb usba wetc tcb Zbjtedk 7?:#c% prdirmn+

G+ Rseki Zbjtedk 7?:#l% wetc 7?:#c% fdr Wbcmge`etmtedk Ndrtimibs+ Qcbrbquerbnbkt fdr m awb``eki td gb jdnp`btba ndrb tcmk dkb ybmr prbjbaekitcb amtb df tcb mpp`ejmtedk fdr ndrtimib eksurmkjb ukabr Zbjtedk 7?:#l%adbs kdt mpp`y td prdpbrtebs ek tcb aesmstbr mrbm+ Amnmiba rbseabkjbs mrbb`eieg`b fdr Zbjtedk 7?:#l% ndrtimib eksurmkjb rbimra`bss df tcb mib df tcb prdpbrty+ Qcb rbseabkjb kbbas dk`y td cmvb gbbk jdnp`btba mka rbmay fdr 

djjupmkjy fdr b`eiege ety ukabr Zbjtedk 7?:#l%+ Qcb pbrjbktmib df fekmkjeki es abtbrnekba gy tcb typb df ndrtimib gbeki nmab #e+b+, kdrnm`@QV rmteds mpp`y td Zbjtedk 7?:#l% ndrtimibs nmab ek tcbsb mrbms%+

Cdnbs tcmt cmvb gbbk abnd`escba, dr we`` gb rmzba ms pmrt df tcbrbcmge`etmtedk wdrl, mrb b`eieg`b prdveaba tcb bxesteki fdukamtedk systbn eskdt mffbjtba mka ste`` we`` gb usba+ Qcb jdnp`btb fdukamtedk systbn nustrbnmek ek p`mjb+

7.=5 BKBWIU.BFFEJEBKQ CDNBZ #BBC%+ Qcb gbkjcnmrl qum`efyeki rmteds nmy gdtc gb bxjbbaba gy up td 7 pbrjbktmib pdekts wcbk tcb gdrrdwbr es purjcmseki dr rbfekmkjeki mk BBC+ Qcbsb ceicbr cduseki bxpbksb. mka dg`eimtedks.td.ekjdnbrmteds mrb hustefeba aub td tcb mktejepmtba bkbriy jdsts smvekis mka gbjdnb := pbrjbkt mka 1: pbrjbkt, rbspbjtevb`y+ Qcb mpprdpremtb CDJ abtbrnekbs ef m prdpbrty qum`efebs fdr BBC abseikmtedk+ Qcb dreiekm` adjunbktmtedk mttbsteki tdbkbriy bffejebkjy es rbquerba dk rbsm`bs+

M`` prdpbrtebs nbbteki tcb Jdukje` df Mnbrejmk Gue`aeki Dffejem`s #JMGD% =557Ndab` Bkbriy Jdab #NBJ% mrb jdkseabrba bkbriy bffejebkt mka b`eieg`b fdr tcbtwd pbrjbktmib pdekts ekjrbmsb ek tcb qum`efyeki rmteds+

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.1=

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 95 df 55

Page 80: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 80/99

1=22+= WBV.2

7.7? BKBWIU BFFEJEBKQ NDWQIMIB #BBN% _WDIWMN+ Qcb FCM BBN_rdirmn es fdr bxesteki prdpbrtebs+ Mk BBN rbjdikezbs tcb bkbriy smvekis df mcdnb tcmt cms 'jdst bffbjtevb' bkbriy smveki enprdvbnbkts, wcejc ekjrbmsb tcbbkbriy bffejebkjy df m cdnb+ Gbjmusb tcb cdnb es bkbriy bffejebkt, tcbdjjupmkt#s% we`` smvb dk ute`ety jdsts mka, tcus, gb mg`b td abvdtb ndrb ekjdnb td

tcb ndktc`y ndrtimib pmynbkt+ Bkbriy bffejebkjy enprdvbnbkts jmk ekj`uabbkbriy smveki bquepnbkt mka mjtevb mka pmssevb sd`mr tbjckd`diebs+

Rkabr tcb FCM BBN _rdirmn, m gdrrdwbr jmk fekmkjb ektd tcb ndrtimib =?? pbrjbkt df tcb jdst df b`eieg`b bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts, sughbjt td jbrtmekad``mr `enetmtedks, wetcdut mk mpprmesm` df tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts+ Qd gb b`eieg`b fdr ekj`usedk ektd tcb ndrtimib, tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbktsnust gb 'jdst bffbjtevb' #e+b+, tcb tdtm` jdst df tcb enprdvbnbkts, ekj`uaekinmektbkmkjb jdsts, nust gb `bss tcmk tcb tdtm` prbsbkt vm`ub df tcb bkbriy smvbadvbr tcb usbfu` `efb df tcb enprdvbnbkts%+ Qcb ndrtimib ekj`uabs tcb jdst df tcbbkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts, ek maaetedk td tcb usum` ndrtimib mndukt

kdrnm``y pbrnettba+

M+ Gmsej _rdirmn Wbquerbnbkts+

=+ Bxesteki dkb. mka twd.uket prdpbrtebs mrb b`eieg`b+ Qcrbb. mkafdur. uket bxesteki prdpbrtebs mrb kdt b`eieg`b+

7+ Qcb jdst df mky enprdvbnbkt td tcb prdpbrty tcmt we`` ekjrbmsb tcb prdpbrty)s bkbriy bffejebkjy mka tcmt es abtbrnekba td gb 'jdstbffbjtevb' es b`eieg`b fdr fekmkjeki ektd tcb ndrtimib+ Ets jdst nmy gb maaba td tcb ndrtimib mndukt up td tcb irbmtbr df8

m+ 2 pbrjbkt df tcb prdpbrty)s vm`ub #kdt td bxjbba !3,???%< dr  g+ !1,???+

'Jdst bffbjtevb' nbmks tcmt tcb tdtm` jdst df tcb enprdvbnbkts,ekj`uaeki mky nmektbkmkjb jdsts, es `bss tcmk tcb tdtm` prbsbkt vm`ubdf tcb bkbriy smvba dvbr tcb usbfu` `efb df tcb bkbriy enprdvbnbkt+Qcb FCM nmxenun `dmk `enet fdr tcb mrbm nmy gb bxjbbaba gy tcbjdst df tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts+

:+ Qcb jdst df tcb bkbriy enprdvbnbkts, ekj`uaeki nmektbkmkjb jdsts,mka tcb bstenmtb df tcb bkbriy smvekis nust gb abtbrnekba gmsbaupdk m pcysejm` ekspbjtedk df tcb prdpbrty gy m cdnb bkbriyrmtekis systbn #CBWZ% rbprbsbktmtevb dr bkbriy jdksu`tmkt+

Qcb CBWZ rbprbsbktmtevb dr bkbriy jdksu`tmkt nust gb mkekabpbkabkt bktety< et jmkkdt gb rb`mtba, aerbjt`y dr ekaerbjt`y, tdtcb sb``br df tcb prdpbrty dr tcb prdspbjtevb gdrrdwbr+ Qcbjdktrmjtdr sb`bjtba gy tcb gdrrdwbr td ekstm`` tcb bkbriy bffejebkt

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.17

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 3? df 55

Page 81: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 81/99

1=22+= WBV.2

enprdvbnbkts nmy kdt gb rb`mtba, aerbjt`y dr ekaerbjt`y, td tcbCBWZ rbprbsbktmtevb dr bkbriy jdksu`tmkt+ Qcb CBWZrbprbsbktmtevb dr bkbriy jdksu`tmkt nmy gb m ute`ety jdnpmky< m`djm`, stmtb, dr fbabrm` idvbrknbkt mibkt< mk bktety mpprdvba gy m`djm`, stmtb, dr fbabrm` idvbrknbkt mibkjy spbjefejm``y fdr tcb

 purpdsb df prdveaeki cdnb bkbriy rmtekis dk rbseabktem` prdpbrtebs<dr m kdkprdfet drimkezmtedk bxpbrebkjba ek jdkaujteki cdnb bkbriyrmtekis df rbseabktem` prdpbrtebs+

1+ Qcb cdnb bkbriy rmteki rbpdrt prbpmrba gy tcb CBWZrbprbsbktmtevb dr bkbriy jdksu`tmkt nust gb ek wreteki mka prdveaba td tcb prdspbjtevb gdrrdwbr mka `bkabr+ Qcb rbpdrt nustjdktmek tcb fd``dweki ekfdrnmtedk8

m+ Maarbss df tcb prdpbrty+ g+ Kmnb df tcb jurrbkt dwkbr#s% df tcb prdpbrty+

j+ Amtb df tcb prdpbrty ekspbjtedk+a+ Absjreptedk df tcb bkbriy fbmturbs jurrbkt`y ek tcb prdpbrty+Qces absjreptedk nust ekj`uab, mt m nekenun, m absjreptedkdf tcb eksu`mtedk W vm`ubs ek jbe`ekis, wm``s mka f`ddrs<ekfe`trmtedk `bvb`s mka gmrrebrs #jmu`leki, wbmtcbrstreppekimka sbm`eki%< m absjreptedk df tcb wekadws #stdrn wekadws,adug`b pmkb, trep`b pmkb btj+% mka addrs< mka m absjreptedkdf tcb cbmteki #ekj`uaeki wmtbr cbmteki% mka jdd`ekisystbns+

b+ Absjreptedk df tcb ndaefejmtedks rbjdnnbkaba td enprdvbtcb bkbriy bffejebkjy df tcb prdpbrty+

f+ Bstenmtba jdsts df tcb bkbriy enprdvbnbkts, tcber usbfu``efb, mka tcb jdsts df mky nmektbkmkjb dvbr tcb usbfu` `efb+

i+ _rbsbkt bstenmtba mkkum` ute`ety jdsts gbfdrb ekstm``mtedk df tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts+

c+ Bstenmtba mkkum` ute`ety jdsts mftbr ekstm``mtedk df tcbbkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts+

e+ Bstenmtba mkkum` smvekis ek ute`ety jdsts mftbr ekstm``mtedk df tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts+

 h+ _rektba kmnb#s% mka seikmturb#s% df tcb pbrsdk#s% tcmtekspbjtba tcb prdpbrty mka prbpmrba tcb rbpdrt, ms wb`` mstcb amtb df prbpmrmtedk df tcb rbpdrt+

l+ Qcb fd``dweki jbrtefejmtedk stmtbnbkt, seikba gy tcb pbrsdk#s% wcd ekspbjtba tcb prdpbrty mka prbpmrba tcbrbpdrt, nust mjjdnpmky tcb rbpdrt8

'E jbrtefy, tcmt td tcb gbst df ny lkdw`baib mka gb`ebf, tcbekfdrnmtedk jdktmekba ek tces rbpdrt es trub mka mjjurmtb mkaE ukabrstmka tcmt tcb ekfdrnmtedk ek tces rbpdrt nmy gb usbaek jdkkbjtedk wetc mk mpp`ejmtedk fdr mk bkbriy bffejebkt

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.1:

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 3= df 55

Page 82: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 82/99

1=22+= WBV.2

ndrtimib td gb eksurba gy tcb Fbabrm` CdusekiManekestrmtedk df tcb Rketba Ztmtbs Abpmrtnbkt df Cdusekimka Rrgmk Abvb`dpnbkt+'

Fdr strbmn`ekb rbfekmkjb trmksmjtedks, tcb gdrrdwbr)s ndktc`y pmynbkt fdr 

 prekjepm` mka ektbrbst fdr tcb rbfekmkjb ndrtimib #wcejc we`` ekj`uab tcbjdst fdr tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts% nust gb `dwbr tcmk tcb

ndktc`y prekjepm` mka ektbrbst dk tcb jurrbkt ndrtimib+

G+ Bsjrdw Mjjdukt Zpbjefejmtedks+ Mk bsjrdw mjjdukt nmy gb bstmg`escbafdr kd ndrb tcmk tcrbb ndktcs mftbr `dmk j`dseki td m``dw fdr ekstm``mtedkdf tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts+ Qcb `bkabr, m ute ety jdnpmky, mkdkprdfet drimkezmtedk, dr m idvbrknbkt mibkjy nmy manekestbr tcbbsjrdw mjjdukt+ Qcb bsjrdw mjjdukt nust gb eksurba mka gb bstmg`escbamt m fekmkjem` ekstetutedk supbrvesba gy m fbabrm` mibkjy+

J+ _rdjbsseki mka Rkabrwreteki Wbquerbnbkts+

=+ Qcb `bkabr we`` prdjbss tcb ndrtimib `dmk mpp`ejmtedk mka qum`efytcb gdrrdwbr useki dur stmkamra ukabrwreteki rbquerbnbkts mkaqum`efyeki rmteds+ Ef tcb gdrrdwbr b`bjts td cmvb mk BBN mka maatcb jdst df tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts td tcb ndrtimib, tcb`bkabr nust tmlb tcb fd``dweki maaetedkm` stbps8

m+ Dgtmek m rbpdrt prbpmrba gy m CBWZ rbprbsbktmtevb dr bkbriy jdksu`tmkt scdweki tcb bstenmtba jdsts df ekstm``ekitcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts, ekj`uaeki mkynmektbkmkjb jdsts, mka tcb bstenmtba mkkum` smvekis ekute`ety jdsts tcmt we`` rbsu`t frdn tcb ekstm``mtedk df tcbbkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts+

 g+ Rseki tcb CBWZ dr bkbriy jdksu`tmkt)s rbpdrt, tcb `bkabr nust abtbrnekb tcmt tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts mrb'jdst bffbjtevb' gy jm`ju`mteki tcb prbsbkt jdst df tcbbkbriy enprdvbnbkts, ekj`uaeki nmektbkmkjb jdsts #ef mky%dvbr tcb usbfu` `efb df tcb enprdvbnbkts mka tcb prbsbkt 

vm`ub df tcb bkbriy smvekis dvbr tcb usbfu` `efb df tcbbkbriy enprdvbnbkts+ Ef tcb bkbriy bffejebktenprdvbnbkts nbbt tcb 'jdst bffbjtevb' tbst #e+b+, prbsbktjdst df enprdvbnbkts es `bss tcmk tcb prbsbkt vm`ub df tcbbkbriy smvekis%, tcb `bkabr nmy maa =?? pbrjbkt df tcb jdstdf tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts #sughbjt td tcb ad``mr `enets absjregba mgdvb ek G+ 1+% td tcb dtcbrwesb m``dwmg`bnmxenun ndrtimib mndukt+ Kd mpprmesm` df tcb bkbriybffejebkt enprdvbnbkts es kbjbssmry, mka tcb gdrrdwbr kbbakdt nbbt mky furtcbr jrbaet stmkamras+ Ef tcb bkbriy

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.11

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 37 df 55

Page 83: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 83/99

1=22+= WBV.2

Djtdgbr 7??: 7.12

bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts nbbt tcb 'jdst bffbjtevb' tbst, tcbfu`` jdst df tcb enprdvbnbkts jmk gb maaba td tcb gdrrdwbr)s gmsb `dmk mndukt, wetcdut m abtbrnekmtedk df vm`ub mka wetcdut furtcbr jrbaet qum`efejmtedk+

j+ Qcb `bkabr jm`ju`mtbs tcb RFNE_ dk tcb fu`` ndrtimibmndukt, wcejc we`` ekj`uab tcb jdst df tcb bkbriyenprdvbnbkts+

A+ Bsjrdw Mjjdukt+ Yb we`` eksurb tcb ndrtimib gbfdrb tcb bkbriy bffejebktenprdvbnbkts mrb ekstm``ba prdveaba tcb `bkabr bstmg`escbs mk bsjrdwmjjdukt mka abpdsets ektd et tcb fukas td pmy fdr tcb bkbriy bffejebktenprdvbnbkts+ Qcb bsjrdw mjjdukt scm`` gb fdr m pbreda df kd ndrb tcmk5? amys+ Ef tcb enprdvbnbkts mrb kdt ekstm``ba wetcek 5? amys, tcb `bkabr nust mpp`y tcb fukas cb`a ek bsjrdw td m prbpmynbkt df tcb prekjepm` gm`mkjb df tcb ndrtimib+ Qcb bsjrdw mjjdukt nmy gb bstmg`escba gy tcb

`bkabr mka manekestbrba gy tcb `bkabr, m ute`ety jdnpmky, m kdkprdfetdrimkezmtedk, dr m idvbrknbkt mibkjy+ Cdwbvbr, tcb `bkabr es rbspdkseg`bfdr mssureki FCM tcmt tcb bsjrdw cms gbbk j`bmrba+ @bkabrs scm`` bxbjutbFdrn CRA 57:?? Ndrtimibb Mssurmkjb df Jdnp`btedk td ekaejmtb tcmttcb bsjrdw fdr tcb bkbriy bffejebkt enprdvbnbkts cms gbbk bstmg`escba+Zugsbqubkt`y, tcb `bkabr es rbspdkseg`b fdr kdtefyeki FCM tcmt tcbenprdvbnbkts cmvb gbbk nmab mka tcmt tcb bsjrdw cms gbbk j`bmrba+ Qcbekstm``mtedk df tcb enprdvbnbkts nmy gb ekspbjtba gy tcb `bkabr, tcbCBWZ, dr mk FCM fbb ekspbjtdr+ Qcb gdrrdwbr nmy gb jcmriba mkekspbjtedk fbb ek mjjdramkjb wetc tcb mpprdpremtb CDJ fbb sjcbau`b+

F+ Cdnb Bkbriy Wmteki Wbpdrt+ Qcb `bkabr nust ekj`uab m jdpy df tcbcdnb bkbriy rmteki rbpdrt, pbrfdrnba gy tcb CBWZ rbprbsbktmtevb dr bkbriy jdksu`tmkt, ek tcb j`dseki pmjlmib, wcbk rbqubsteki eksurmkjbbkadrsbnbkt+

7.7= MAVMKJB NDWQIMIB _MUNBKQZ _WDCEGEQBA+ Yb ad kdt pbrnet, msm jdkaetedk fdr nmleki m FCM eksurba ndrtimib, m `bkabr td jd``bjt frdn tcb gdrrdwbr mavmkjb pmynbkt#s% df tcb ndrtimib+ Gdrrdwbrs mrb kdt td gb rbquerbatd wretb pdst.amtba jcbjls, ievb jmsc, dr dtcbrwesb nmlb ndrtimib pmynbkts tdtcb `bkabr ek mavmkjb df tcb gdrrdwbrs ndrtimib pmynbkt rbquerbnbkts ukabr tcbsbjurety ekstrunbkts+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 3: df 55

Page 84: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 84/99

1=22+= WBV.2

Djtdgbr 7??: 1.=

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 31 df 55

Page 85: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 85/99

1=22+= WBV.2

JCM_QBW :

ADJRNBKQMQEDK MKA DQCBW _WDJBZZEKI WB]REWBNBKQZ

x Qces jcmptbr absjregbs tcb adjunbktmtedk rbquerbnbkts fdr bmjc `dmk

sugnettba fdr ndrtimib eksurmkjb mka tcb spbjefej rbquerbnbkts `bkabrs nustdgsbrvb ek prdjbsseki mka ukabrwreteki FCM.eksurba ndrtimibs+ Qcb `bkabr esrbspdkseg`b fdr msleki suffejebkt qubstedks td b`ejet m jdnp`btb pejturb df tcb gdrrdwbr)s fekmkjem` setumtedk, sdurjb df fukas fdr tcb trmksmjtedk, mka tcb ektbkabausb df tcb prdpbrty+ M`` ekfdrnmtedk nust gb vbrefeba mka adjubntkba+ Qcb`bkabr nust m`sd vbrefy mka adjunbkt tcb eabktety df tcb `dmk mpp`ejmkt#s%+

ZBJQEDK =8 RKABWYWEQEKI ADJRNBKQMQEDK

x

:.= M__@EJMQEDK _MJLMIB+ Qcb mpp`ejmtedk pmjlmib nust jdktmek m``adjunbktmtedk suppdrteki tcb `bkabr)s abjesedk td mpprdvb tcb ndrtimib `dmk+Ycbk stmkamra adjunbktmtedk adbs kdt prdveab bkduic ekfdrnmtedk td suppdrt 

tces abjesedk, tcb `bkabr nust prdveab maaetedkm` bxp`mkmtdry stmtbnbkts,

jdksestbkt wetc dtcbr ekfdrnmtedk ek tcb mpp`ejmtedk, td j`mrefy dr td supp`bnbkt tcb adjunbktmtedk sugnettba gy tcb gdrrdwbr+

x M`` adjunbkts nmy gb up td =7? amys d`a mt tcb tenb tcb `dmk j`dsbs #=3? amys

fdr kbw jdkstrujtedk% uk`bss tces dr dtcbr mpp`ejmg`b CRA ekstrujtedks spbjefy maeffbrbkt tenbfrmnb, dr tcb kmturb df tcb adjunbkt es sujc tcmt ets vm`eaety fdr ukabrwreteki purpdsbs es kdt mffbjtba gy gbeki d`abr tcmk tcb kungbr df  prbsjregba amys #b+i+, aevdrjb abjrbbs, tmx rbturks%+ Rpamtba, wrettbk vbrefejmtedksnust gb dgtmekba wcbk tcb mib df tcb adjunbkts bxjbba tcbsb `enets+ Vbrefejmtedkfdrns dr adjunbkts usba ms mk m`tbrkmtb td tcbsb vbrefejmtedks nust pmss aerbjt`y gbtwbbk tcb `bkabr mka tcb prdveabr wetcdut gbeki cmka`ba dr trmksnettba gy mkytcera pmrty dr useki mky tcera pmrty―s bquepnbkt+ Kd adjunbkt usba ek tcb prdjbsseki dr ukabrwreteki df m `dmk nmy gb cmka`ba dr trmksnettba gy dr tcrduicmk ektbrbstba tcera pmrty td tcb trmksmjtedk+

x Qcb Vbrefejmtedk df Abpdset #VDA% mka Vbrefejmtedk df Bnp`dynbkt #VDB%nmy gb fmxba adjunbkts dr prektba pmibs frdn tcb Ektbrkbt ef tcby j`bmr`y eabktefytcber sdurjbs #b+i+, jdktmek tcb kmnbs df tcb gdrrdwbr―s bnp`dybr dr abpdsetdry$ekvbstnbkt fern%+ Qcb `bkabr es mjjduktmg`b fdr msjbrtmekeki tcb

mutcbktejety df tcb adjunbkt gy bxmnekeki ekfdrnmtedk ekj`uaba ek m adjunbkt―scbmabrs mka fddtbrs+ Qcb `bkabr scdu`a vbrefy tcb mutcbktejety df prektba Ybg pmibs gy bxmnekeki tcb pmibs fdr sene`mr ekfdrnmtedk+ M prektba Ybg pmib m`sdnust scdw ets ukefdrn rbsdurjb `djmtdr #RW@% maarbss, ms wb`` ms tcb amtb mkatenb tcb adjunbkt wms prektba+

x @bkabrs nmy kdt mjjbpt dr usb adjunbkts rb`mteki td tcb jrbaet, bnp`dynbktdr ekjdnb df gdrrdwbrs tcmt mrb cmka`ba gy dr trmksnettba frdn dr tcrduic

x Djtdgbr 7??: :.=

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 32 df 55

Page 86: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 86/99

1=22+= WBV.2

ektbrbstba tcera pmrtebs #b+i+, rbm` bstmtb mibkts, gue`abrs, sb``brs% dr gy useki tcber bquepnbkt+

x Qcb fd``dweki adjunbkts mrb ibkbrm``y rbquerba fdr ndrtimib jrbaet mkm`ysesek m`` trmksmjtedks bxjbpt fdr jbrtmek strbmn`ekb rbfekmkjbs8

M+ @dmk Mpp`ejmtedk+ Rkefdrn Wbseabktem` @dmk Mpp`ejmtedk #RW@M%,seikba mka amtba gy m`` gdrrdwbrs mka tcb `bkabr, mka tcb Maabkaun tdtcb RW@M #fdrn CRA.575??.M%+

G+ Ndrtimib Jrbaet Mkm`yses Ydrlscbbt+ Fdrn CRA 575??.YZ dr CRA.575??._RW, ms mpprdpremtb+

J+ Zdjem` Zbjurety Kungbr Bveabkjb+ Fdr m`` gdrrdwbrs, ekj`uaeki RZjetezbks, tcb `bkabr es rbquerba td adjunbkt m vm`ea ZZK fdr bmjc gdrrdwbr,jd.gdrrdwbr, mka jd.seikbr dk tcb ndrtimib+ M`` ekaeveaum`s b`eieg`b fdr `bim` bnp`dynbkt ek tcb RZ nust cmvb m ZZK+ Bmjc gdrrdwbr nust prdveab tcb `bkabr wetc bveabkjb df ces dr cbr dwk vm`ea ZZK ms essuba gytcb Zdjem` Zbjurety Manekestrmtedk #ZZM%+ Qces mpp`ebs td purjcmsbndkby `dmks mka m`` rbfekmkjbs, ekj`uaeki strbmn`ekb rbfekmkjbs+ Yce`btcb mjtum` sdjem` sbjurety jmra es kdt rbquerba, tcb `bkabr es rbquerba tdvm`eamtb tcb ZZK+ @bkabrs nmy usb vmredus nbmks fdr vm`eamteki tcb ZZKekj`uaeki bxmnekeki tcb gdrrdwbr―s pmy stugs, pmsspdrt, vm`ea tmx rbturks,mka nmy usb sbrvejb prdveabrs ekj`uaeki tcdsb wetc aerbjt mjjbss td tcbZZM+ Qcb `bkabr es m`sd rbquerba td rbsd`vb mky ekjdksestbkjebs dr nu`tep`b ZZKs fdr ekaeveaum` gdrrdwbrs tcmt mrb rbvbm`ba aureki `dmk prdjbsseki mka ukabrwreteki+ #M`sd sbb pmrmirmpc 7.7 G%+

A+ Jrbaet Wbpdrt+ Qcb `bkabr nust dgtmek m jrbaet rbpdrt dk m`` gdrrdwbrswcd we`` gb dg`eimtba dk tcb ndrtimib kdtb #bxjbpt fdr strbmn`ekbrbfekmkjb trmksmjtedks%+

B+ Vbrefejmtedk df Bnp`dynbkt #VDB%+ VDB mka tcb gdrrdwbr―s ndstrbjbkt pmy stug mrb td gb prdveaba+ ‐Ndst rbjbkt„ nbmks mt tcb tenb tcbeketem` `dmk mpp`ejmtedk es nmab+ Ef tcb adjunbkt es kdt ndrb tcmk =7?amys d`a wcbk tcb `dmk j`dsbs #=3? amys d`a dk kbw jdkstrujtedk%, et adbskdt cmvb td gb upamtba+

 M`tbrkmtevb Adjunbktmtedk+ Ms mk m`tbrkmtevb td dgtmekeki m VDB, tcb

`bkabr nmy dgtmek tcb gdrrdwbr―s dreiekm` pmy stug#s% jdvbreki tcb ndst rbjbkt :?.amy pbreda, m`dki wetc dreiekm` EWZ Y.7 Fdrns frdn tcb

 prbvedus twd ybmrs+ Qcb pmy stug#s% nust scdw tcb gdrrdwbr)s kmnb,

 sdjem` sbjurety kungbr, mka ybmr.td. amtb bmrkekis+ Mky jdpebs df tcb Y.7 Fdrn kdt sugnettba wetc tcb gdrrdwbr)s ekjdnb tmx rbturks mrb jdkseabrba 

'dreiekm`' Y.7―s+ #Qcbsb dreiekm` adjunbkts nmy gb pcdtdjdpeba mka rbturkba td tcb gdrrdwbr+% Qcb `bkabr m`sd nust vbrefy gy tb`bpcdkb m`` 

jurrbkt bnp`dybrs+ Qcb `dmk fe`b nust ekj`uab m jbrtefejmtedk frdn tcb

x Djtdgbr 7??: :.7

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 36 df 55

Page 87: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 87/99

1=22+= WBV.2

`bkabr tcmt dreiekm` adjunbkts wbrb bxmnekba mka tcb kmnb, tet`b, mka 

tb`bpcdkb kungbr df tcb pbrsdk wetc wcdn bnp`dynbkt wms vbrefeba+ Fdr 

m`` `dmks prdjbssba ek tces nmkkbr, tcb `bkabr m`sd nust dgtmek m seikba 

jdpy df Fdrn EWZ 12?6 Wbqubst fdr Jdpy df Qmx Fdrn, Fdrn EWZ 337=, dr m adjunbkt tcmt es mpprdpremtb fdr dgtmekeki tmx rbturks aerbjt`y frdn tcb

 EWZ+ Qcb `bkabr m`sd nmy usb mk b`bjtrdkej rbtrebvm` sbrvejb fdr dgtmekeki Y.7 mka tmx rbturk ekfdrnmtedk+

 Ef tcb bnp`dybr we`` kdt ievb tb`bpcdkb jdkfernmtedk df bnp`dynbkt dr ef 

tcb Y.7 ekaejmtbs ekjdksestbkjebs #b+i+, FEJM pmynbkts kdt rbf`bjteki bmrkekis%, stmkamra bnp`dynbkt adjunbktmtedk nust gb usba+

F+ VDA+ VDA mka ndst rbjbkt gmkl stmtbnbkts mrb td gb prdveaba+ ‐Ndstrbjbkt„ nbmks mt tcb tenb tcb eketem` `dmk mpp`ejmtedk es nmab+ _rdveabatcb adjunbkt es kdt ndrb tcmk =7? amys d`a wcbk tcb `dmk j`dsbs #=3?amys d`a dk kbw jdkstrujtedk%, et adbs kdt cmvb td gb upamtba+

 M`tbrkmtevb Adjunbktmtedk+ Ms mk m`tbrkmtevb td dgtmekeki m VDA, tcb

`bkabr nmy dgtmek frdn tcb gdrrdwbr dreiekm` gmkl stmtbnbkt#s% jdvbreki 

tcb ndst rbjbkt tcrbb.ndktc pbreda+ _rdveaba tcb gmkl stmtbnbkt scdwstcb prbvedus ndktc)s gm`mkjb, tces rbquerbnbkt es nbt gy dgtmekeki tcb twd

ndst rbjbkt, jdksbjutevb stmtbnbkts+

I+ Fbabrm` Ekjdnb Qmx Wbturks+ Fbabrm` ekjdnb tmx rbturks #gdtcekaeveaum` rbturks mka gusekbss rbturks% fdr tcb pmst twd ybmrs, ekj`uaekim`` mpp`ejmg`b sjcbau`bs, fdr sb`f.bnp`dyba gdrrdwbrs, mrb rbquerba+Jdnnessedkba ekaeveaum`s nust prdveab ekaeveaum` fbabrm` ekjdnb tmxrbturks fdr tcb pmst twd ybmrs+ Qcb `bkabr nust dgtmek seikba Fdrns EWZ12?6, EWZ 337=, dr wcmtbvbr fdrn dr b`bjtrdkej rbtrebvm` sbrvejb esmpprdpremtb fdr dgtmekeki tmx rbturks aerbjt`y frdn tcb EWZ fdr mky `dmk fdr wcejc tcb gdrrdwbr)s tmx rbturks mrb rbquerba+

C+ Zm`bs Jdktrmjt+ Qcb sm`bs jdktrmjt mka mky mnbkanbkts dr dtcbr mirbbnbkts mka jbrtefejmtedks mrb td gb ekj`uaba ek tcb jmsb gekabr+ Betcbr mk dreiekm` dr m jbrtefeba trub jdpy df tcb sm`bs jdktrmjt rbjbevba gy tcb`bkabr es rbquerba+

E+ Wbm` Bstmtb Jbrtefejmtedk+ Wbm` bstmtb jbrtefejmtedk, seikba gy tcb guybr,sb``br, mka sb``eki rbm` bstmtb mibkt dr grdlbr #ef kdt jdktmekba wetcek tcb purjcmsb mirbbnbkt% mrb rbquerba+ M`sd sbb pmrmirmpc :.:, gb`dw+

H+ Vbrefejmtedk df Wbkt dr _mynbkt Cestdry df  

_rbsbkt$_rbvedus Ndrtimibs+ Qces adjunbkt nust gb ek tcb fdrn df maerbjt vbrefejmtedk frdn tcb `mka`dra dr ndrtimib sbrvejbr dr tcrduicekfdrnmtedk scdwk dk tcb jrbaet rbpdrt+

x Djtdgbr 7??: :.:

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 39 df 55

Page 88: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 88/99

1=22+= WBV.2

L+ Rkefdrn Wbseabktem` Mpprmesm` Wbpdrt #RWMW%+ QcbRWMW mka Vm`umtedk pmjlmib nust gb ekj`uaba ek tcb bkadrsbnbkt gekabr bxjbpt fdr strbmn`ekb rbfekmkjbs nmab wetcdut mpprmesm`s+

@+ Bxp`mkmtdry Ztmtbnbkts+ Bxp`mkmtdry stmtbnbkts dr maaetedkm`adjunbktmtedk kbjbssmry td nmlb m sduka ukabrwreteki abjesedk mrb td gb

ekj`uaba ek tcb jmsb gekabr+

:.7 ADJRNBKQMQEDK ZQMKAMWAZ+

M+ Mpp`ejmtedk Fdrns+ Mpp`ejmtedk fdrns nust gb seikba mka amtba gy m`` gdrrdwbrs mpp`yeki fdr tcb ndrtimib mka mssuneki rbspdksege`ety fdr tcbndrtimib abgt+

G+ Vbrefejmtedks+ Wmtcbr tcmk rbquereki gdrrdwbrs td seik nu`tep`bvbrefejmtedk fdrns, tcb `bkabr nmy msl tcb gdrrdwbr td seik m ibkbrm`mutcdrezmtedk fdrn tcmt ievbs tcb `bkabr g`mklbt mutcdrety td vbrefy

ekfdrnmtedk kbbaba td prdjbss tcb ndrtimib `dmk mpp`ejmtedk, sujc ms pmstmka prbsbkt bnp`dynbkt rbjdras, gmkl mjjdukts, stdjl cd`aekis, btj+ Ef tcb `bkabr usbs sujc mk mutcdrezmtedk, cb dr scb nust mttmjc m jdpy df tcbmutcdrezmtedk td bmjc vbrefejmtedk sbkt+ Maaetedkm``y, `bkabrs nmy usb sb`f.macbsevb seikmturb `mgb`s fdr `msbr prektba vbrefejmtedks+ Bmjc `mgb` nustjdnp`btb`y mka j`bmr`y ekaejmtb ets usb mka nust jdktmek tcb _revmjy Mjtkdtefejmtedk+

J+ Adjunbkts Zeikba ek G`mkl+ @bkabrs nmy kdt cmvb gdrrdwbrs seikadjunbkts ek g`mkl, dr dk g`mkl scbbts df pmpbr+

:.: WBM@ BZQMQB JBWQEFEJMQEDK+ Qcb gdrrdwbr, sb``br, mka tcb sb``eki rbm`bstmtb mibkt dr grdlbr ekvd`vba ek tcb sm`bs trmksmjtedk nust jbrtefy tcmt tcb tbrnsmka jdkaetedks df tcb sm`bs jdktrmjt mrb trub td tcb gbst df tcber lkdw`baib mka gb`ebf mka tcmt mky dtcbr mirbbnbkt bktbrba ektd gy mky df tcb pmrtebs ekjdkkbjtedk wetc tcb rbm` bstmtb trmksmjtedk es pmrt df, dr mttmjcba td, tcb sm`bsmirbbnbkt+

x Ef tcb sm`bs jdktrmjt jdktmeks m prdvesedk tcmt tcbrb mrb kd dtcbr mirbbnbkts gbtwbbk pmrtebs mka tcmt tcb tbrns df tcb sm`bs jdktrmjt jdkstetutb tcb bkterbmirbbnbkt gbtwbbk tcb pmrtebs, tcb jbrtefejmtedk spbjefeba ek tcb mgdvb pmrmirmpces kdt kbbaba ef m`` pmrtebs mrb seikmtdrebs td tcb sm`bs jdktrmjt sugnettba mt tcbtenb df ukabrwreteki+

:.1 MNBKAMQDWU J@MRZB+ Mk mnbkamtdry j`musb nust gb ekj`uaba ek tcbsm`bs jdktrmjt wcbk tcb gdrrdwbr cms kdt gbbk ekfdrnba df tcb mpprmesba vm`ub gyrbjbeveki m jdpy df Fdrn CRA.573??+2G, Jdkaetedkm` Jdnnetnbkt$ABZtmtbnbkt df Mpprmesba Vm`ub dr VM.JWV gbfdrb seikeki tcb sm`bs jdktrmjt+ Qcbmnbkamtdry j`musb nust jdktmek tcb fd``dweki `mkiumib8

x Djtdgbr 7??: :.1

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 33 df 55

Page 89: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 89/99

CRA Cmkagddl 1=22+7Jcmptbr 7+M+1+G

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 35 df 55

Page 90: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 90/99

CRA 1=22+7 Jcmptbr 7, Zbjtedk M

7.M.=:

1+ Rkabrwretbr ]um`efejmtedk Jretbrem mka Wbspdksege`etebs,Jdktekuba

1=22+7 7+M+1+g

Rkabrwretbr

Wbspdksege`etebs

Qcb tmg`b gb`dw dut`ekbs tcb rbspdksege`etebs mssunba gy tcb ukabrwretbr+

Wbspdksege`ety Absjreptedk

Fmne emrety wetcRkabrwreteki_rdjbaurbs

Qcb `bkabr es rbspdkseg`b fdr bksureki tcb ukabrwretbr―sfmne emrety wetc

x tcb ukabrwreteki prdjbaurbs aesjussba ek prekjepm`ukabrwreteki cmkagddls

CRA 1=22+=, Ndrtimib Jrbaet Mkm`yses fdr  Ndrtimib Eksurmkjb dk Dkb.td.Fdur Fmne`y

 _rdpbrtebs, mka

CRA 1=22+7, @bkabr―s Iueab td tcb Zeki`b Fmne`y Ndrtimib Eksurmkjb _rdjbss

x tcb mpprmesm` prdjbaurbs aesjussba ek vm`umtedkcmkagddls

CRA 1=12+=, Mrjcetbjturm` _rdjbsseki mka 

 Ekspbjtedks fdr Cdnb Ndrtimib Eksurmkjb

CRA 1=2?+=, Vm`umtedk Mkm`yses fdr Cdnb

 Ndrtimib Eksurmkjb, mka

CRA 1=2?+7, Vm`umtedk Mkm`yses fdr Zeki`b Fmne`y

Dkb. td Fdur.Rket Awb``ekis

CRA 15?2+=, Wbquerbnbkts fdr Bxesteki Cduseki,Dkb.td.Fdur.Fmne y @eveki Rkets, mka

CRA 15=?+=, Nekenun _rdpbrty Ztmkamras fdr  Cduseki , mka

x m` mpp`ejmg`b FCM Ndrtimibb @bttbrs tcmt mffbjtmpprmesm`s mka jrbaet ukabrwreteki+

Jddraekmtedk mkaJdnp`emkjb

Qcb ukabrwretbr es rbspdkseg`b fdr 

x jddraekmteki m`` pcmsbs df tcb `dmk ukabrwreteki prdjbss, mka

x bksureki jdnp`emkjb wetc m` FCM rbquerbnbkts mka pruabkt ukabrwreteki prdjbaurbs+

Jdktekuba dk kbxt pmib

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 5? df 55

Page 91: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 91/99

Jcmptbr 7, Zbjtedk M CRA 1=22+7

7.M.=1

1+ Rkabrwretbr ]um`efejmtedk Jretbrem mka Wbspdksege`etebs,Jdktekuba

1=22+7 7+M+1+g Rkabrwretbr Wbspdksege`etebs #jdktekuba%

Wbspdksege`ety Absjreptedk

Vbrefejmtedk df Ekfdrnmtedk

Qcb ukabrwretbr nust bksurb tcmt ekfdrnmtedk esdgtmekba mka vbrefeba wetc mt `bmst tcb smnb jmrb tcmtwdu`a gb bxbrjesba ef dreiekmteki m ndrtimib ek wcejctcb `bkabr wdu`a gb bkterb`y abpbkabkt dk tcb prdpbrtyms sbjurety td prdtbjt ets ekvbstnbkt+

Mpprmesm` Wbvebwmka JrbaetMkm`yses

Qcb ukabrwretbr nust bksurb rbmsdkmg`b jdkj`usedks,sduka rbpdrts, mka jdnp`emkjb wetc FCM rbquerbnbkts gy

x rbvebweki mpprmesm` rbpdrts mka jdnp`emkjbekspbjtedks, mka

x adjunbkteki m`` jrbaet mkm`ysbs pbrfdrnba mka$dr dgtmekba gy fbb mka stmff pbrsdkkb`+

@dmkMjjbptmge`ety

Qcb ukabrwretbr es rbspdkseg`b fdr nmleki abjesedkswetc aub ae eibkjb mka ek m pruabkt nmkkbr, rbimraekitcb

x mjjbptmge`ety df tcb

mpprmesm`

ekspbjtedks, mka

 gdrrdwbr―s jmpmjety td rbpmy tcb ndrtimib, mka

x dvbrm`` mjjbptmge`ety df tcb ndrtimib `dmk fdr FCMeksurmkjb+

_brsdkkb`_brfdrnmkjb

Qcb ukabrwretbr nust ndketdr mka bvm`umtb tcb pbrfdrnmkjb df fbb mka stmff pbrsdkkb` usba fdr tcbAerbjt Bkadrsbnbkt #AB% _rdirmn+

Jdktekuba dk kbxt pmib

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 5= df 55

Page 92: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 92/99

CRA 1=22+7 Jcmptbr 7, Zbjtedk M

7.M.=2

1+ Rkabrwretbr ]um`efejmtedk Jretbrem mka Wbspdksege`etebs,Jdktekuba

1=22+7 7+M+1+g Rkabrwretbr Wbspdksege`etebs #jdktekuba%

Wbspdksege`ety Absjreptedk

Abtbjtedk df Ymrkeki Zeiks

Qcb ukabrwretbr nust gb

x mttukba td tcb wmrkeki seiks tcmt nmy ekaejmtb mkyerrbiu`mretebs, mka

x m`brt mka mg`b td abtbjt frmua+

Jbrtefejmtedk _mib:, Fdrn CRA.

575??.M

Gy bxbjuteki pmib : df Fdrn CRA.575??.M, CRA$VM Maabkaun td Rkefdrn Wbseabktem` @dmk Mpp`ejmtedk,

tcb ukabrwretbr jbrtefebs tcmt cb$scb

x cms pbrsdkm``y rbvebwba m`` mpp`ejmtedk adjunbkts

x fekas jdnp`emkjb wetc tcb mpp`ejmg`b rbquerbnbkts,mka

x es mpprdveki tcb `dmk fdr j`dseki+

J`dseki Wbvebwmka Jbrtefejmtedk

Qcb ukabrwretbr #dr tcb `bkabr dr `bkabr―s j`dsekiabpmrtnbkt% nust

x rbvebw m``

j`dseki adjunbkts

jbrtefejmtedks dk tcb j`dseki stmtbnbkts, mka

`bim` ekstrunbkts mka dtcbr adjunbkts bxbjutba mtj`dseki, mka

x jbrtefy dk pmib 1 df fdrn CRA.575??.M, CRA$VM Maabkaun td Rkefdrn Wbseabktem` @dmk Mpp`ejmtedk,

tcmt tcb

trmksmjtedk mka `dmk nbbt stmtutdry mka rbiu`mtdryrbquerbnbkts df tcb FCM mka Kmtedkm` Cduseki Mjt,mka

`dmk cms gbbk j`dsba ek mjjdramkjb wetc tcb tbrnsmka sm`bs prejb spbjefeba ek tcb sm`bs jdktrmjt+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 57 df 55

Page 93: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 93/99

CRA Cmkagddl 19??+7 Wbv.=Jcmptbr 6

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 5: df 55

Page 94: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 94/99

19??+7 WBV.=

JCM_QBW 6+ ]RM@EQU JDKQWD@ _@MK

6.= IBKBWM@ WB]REWBNBKQ+ Ms m jdkaetedk df CRA Qet`b E mpprdvm`, m```bkabrs, ekj`uaeki @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkts, scm`` prbpmrb mka enp`bnbkt m]um`ety Jdktrd` _`mk #]J_% Qcb Abpmrtnbkt jdkseabrs m ]J_ td gb mkenpdrtmkt pmrt df m `bkabr)s dreiekmtedk mka sbrvejeki dpbrmtedks ekdrabr td bksurb tcmt tcb `bkabr nmektmeks jdnp`emkjb wetc CRArbquerbnbkts mka ets dwk pd`ejebs mka prdjbaurbs+ Qcb ]J_ nust gbsuffejebkt ek sjdpb td bkmg`b tcb `bkabr td bvm`umtb tcb mjjurmjy,vm`eaety mka jdnp`btbkbss df ets `dmk dreiekmtedk mka sbrvejekidpbrmtedks+

M+ _D@EJU MKA DGHBJQEVBZ+ M`` Kdksupbrvesba mka Zupbrvesba @bkabrsmka @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkts scm`` prbpmrb mka enp`bnbkt m ]J_ wcejcute`ezbs mk ekabpbkabkt prdirmn df ektbrkm` dr bxtbrkm` muaetpbrfdrnba gy pbrsdkkb` wcd mrb lkdw`baibmg`b mka cmvb kd aerbjt`dmk prdjbsseki, ukabrwreteki dr sbrvejeki rbspdksege`etebs+ Qcbqum`ety jdktrd` fukjtedk nmy gb pbrfdrnba gy betcbr jdnpmky

pbrsdkkb` dr mk dutseab fern+ Qcb ]J_ scm`` prdveab fdr pbredaejrbpdrts td gb prdveaba td sbkedr nmkmibnbkt+ Qcb rbpdrts we``eabktefy fdr sbkedr nmkmibnbkt mky mrbms df tcb `dmk dreiekmtedk drsbrvejeki fukjtedks tcmt mrb abfejebkt+

G+ ZJD_B+ Qcb ]J_ nust prdveab fdr m ndktc`y rbvebw df kdt `bss tcmktbk pbrjbkt df m`` Qet`b E `dmks dreiekmtba gy tcb `bkabr dk mndktc`y gmses, ekj`uaeki ets grmkjcbs mka @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkts+ Fdr`dmk sbrvejeki, `bkabrs nust pbrfdrn m qumrtbr`y rbvebw df mrbprbsbktmtevb smnp`b df `dmks tcmt es suffejebkt ek kungbr tdprdveab rbmsdkmg`b bveabkjb tcmt CRA `dmk sbrvejeki pd`ejebs mkarbquerbnbkts cmvb gbbk nbt+ Fdr bmjc grmkjc dffejb tcmt dreiekmtbsdr sbrvejbs CRA eksurba Qet`b E `dmks, mk dk.setb grmkjc dffejbrbvebw nust tmlb p`mjb mt `bmst dkjb bvbry ybmr+ Qcb ]J_ nust m`sdprdveab fdr m rbvebw df tcb `bkabr)s fe`bs mka rbjdras td abtbrnekbjdnp`emkjb wetc CRA)s Fmer Cduseki Mjt ms mnbkaba ek =533+

J+ @DMK JDWWBZ_DKABKQZ+ Yce`b et es enpdrtmkt fdr Zpdksdrs td ekj`uabbmjc df tcber @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkts ek tcber rbvebw smnp`bs, bmjc@dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt nust cmvb ets dwk ]J_+ Et es kdt mjjbptmg`b fdrm Zpdksdr td pbrfdrn ets rdutekb rbvebw df @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkts

5$526.=

19??+?7 WBV.=

mka usb tces ms m rbp`mjbnbkt fdr tcb @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt)s dwkrbvebw, uk`bss m fu`` =? pbrjbkt smnp`b es rbvebwba+

Ms aesjussba gb`dw, @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkts nmy jcddsb td usb mkdutseab sdurjb td pbrfdrn tcber qum`ety jdktrd` rbvebws+ Cdwbvbr,ef m Zpdksdr es usba, tcb rbvebw nust jdvbr tcb fu`` =? pbrjbktsmnp`b+

A+ ]RM@EQU JDKQWD@ WBVEBYZ NRZQ EKJ@RAB8

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 51 df 55

Page 95: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 95/99

=+ M sb`bjtedk df `dmks dk m rmkadn gmses ekj`uaeki `dmks frdnm`` grmkjc dffejbs, `dmk jdrrbspdkabkts mka sbrvejeki mibkts+

7+ Mssurmkjb tcmt m`` `dmk dffejbrs, ukabrwretbrs mka sbrvejbrswe`` cmvb `dmks sughbjtba td rbvebws+

:+ Mkm`yses df m`` `dmks wcejc id ektd abfmu`t wetcek sexpmynbkts mftbr j`dseki+

1+ _rdjbaurbs fdr bxpmkaeki tcb sjdpb df tcb rbvebw wcbrb mpmttbrk df abfejebkjebs dr frmuau`bkt mjtevety es aesj`dsba+

B+ JDKQWMJQEKI DRQ+ @bkabrs mrb pbrnettba td usb mk dutseab sdurjb tdpbrfdrn tcber qum`ety jdktrd` rbvebws+ Qces prdjbaurb nmy gbusbfu` fdr snm``br `bkabrs wcd ad kdt cmvb suffejebkt stmff tdabvdtb td qum`ety jdktrd`, fdr bxmnp`b+ Qcb dutseab sdurjb esbxpbjtba td usb tcb `bkabr)s ]J_ dr abvb`dp dkb tcmt nbbts tcbAbpmrtnbkt)s rbquerbnbkts+ @bkabrs mrb ste`` rbquerba td tmlbmpprdpremtb mjtedks ek rbspdksb td fekaekis, ms aesjussba ek tces

Jcmptbr+

F+ EKEQEMQB JDWWBJQEVB MJQEDK+ Qcb ]J_ nust rbquerb wrettbkkdtefejmtedk td tcb `bkabr)s sbkedr nmkmibnbkt, mt `bmst qumrtbr`y,df abfejebkjebs jetba ms m rbsu`t df tcb rbvebws+ Zbkedrnmkmibnbkt nust prdnpt`y eketemtb mjtedk td jdrrbjt m``abfejebkjebs+ Qcb mjtedks tmlbk gy nmkmibnbkt nust gb fdrnm``yadjunbktba gy jeteki bmjc abfejebkjy, eabktefyeki tcb jmusb df tcbabfejebkjy, mka prdveaeki nmkmibnbkt)s rbspdksb dr mjtedks tmlbk+Bnp`dybbs mrb td gb prdveaba wetc tcb rbsu`ts df tcb qum`etyjdktrd` rbvebw+

5$52 6.7

19??+?7 WBV.=

I+ KDQEFEJMQEDK QD CRA DF ZEIKEFEJMKQ AEZJWB_MKJEBZ+ Mpprdvba `bkabrsmrb rbquerba td rbpdrt td CRA mky ved`mtedk df `mw dr rbiu`mtedk,fm`sb stmtbnbkts dr prdirmn mgusbs gy m gdrrdwbr, abm`br, tcb`bkabr, ets @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkts, bnp`dybbs dr mky dtcbr pmrty tdtcb trmksmjtedk #rbfbr td 71 JFW Zbjtedk 7?=+1?#m%%+ Qcbsb rbpdrtsscdu`a gb fdrwmraba td tcb Ndketdreki Aevesedk ek Ymscekitdk, A+J+dr tcb Dffejb df Ekspbjtdr Ibkbrm` mt tcb kbmrbst CRA feb`a dffejb+

6.7 IBKBWM@ WB]REWBA B@BNBKQZ DF QCB ]RM@EQU JDKQWD@ _@MK+ Qcb qum`etyjdktrd` p`mk scm``8

M+ Mssurb tcmt bmjc dffejb df tcb `bkabr ekj`uaeki, ef mpp`ejmg`b, etsmpprdvba @dmk Jdrrbspdkabkt#s% mka grmkjcbs nmektmek jdpebs df m``CRA essumkjbs, ekj`uaeki rbiu`mtedks, cmkagddls, mka Qet`b E`bttbrs, btj+, wcejc mrb rb`bvmkt td tcb `bkabr)s Qet`b Edreiekmtedk mka sbrvejeki mjtevetebs+ Qcbsb adjunbkts nust gbmjjbsseg`b td m`` bnp`dybbs, mka kbw aerbjtevbs nust gb rbvebwbawetc mpprdpremtb stmff+

G+ Mssurb tcmt m`` `dmks rbpdrtba gy tcb `bkabr td CRA$FCM fdreksurmkjb mrb prdjbssba dk`y gy bnp`dybbs df tcb `bkabr+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 52 df 55

Page 96: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 96/99

J+ Mssurb tcmt tcb `bkabr adbs kdt bnp`dy dr jdkaujt Qet`b E gusekbsswetc mky ekaeveaum` wcd es abgmrrba, suspbkaba dr sughbjt td m@enetba Abkem` df _mrtejepmtedk #@A_%+

A+ Mssurb tcmt m jcbjl wms nmab tcrduic tcb Abpmrtnbkt)s Jrbaet M`brtEktbrmjtevb Vdejb Wbspdksb Zystbn #JMEVWZ% dr sdnb dtcbr nbmks tdabtbrnekb wcbtcbr mk mpp`ejmkt es ek abfmu`t dr m j`men cms gbbkpmea ek jdkkbjtedk wetc mky `dmk dg`eimtedk dwba td dr eksurba driumrmktbba gy tcb Fbabrm` idvbrknbkt)+

B+ Mssurb tcmt tcb dreiekmteki `bkabr es rbtmekeki m jdpy df tcbbkterb jmsb fe`b pbrtmekeki td m`` `dmk dreiekmtedks, betcbr ekcmra jdpy dr nejrdfe`n fdrn, fdr mt `bmst twd ybmrs frdn amtb df`dmk aesgursbnbkt+

F+ Mssurb tcmt Cdnb Ndrtimib Aesj`dsurb Mjt #CNAM% rbpdrteki es gbekiadkb mjjurmtb`y, tenb`y mka es prdpbr`y adjunbktba+

5$52

6.:

19??+?7 WBV.=

I+ Mssurb tcmt tcb `bkabr adbs kdt rbquerb, ms m jdkaetedk dfprdveaeki mk eksurba `dmk, tcmt tcb prekjepm` mndukt df tcb `dmkbxjbba m nekenun mndukt bstmg`escba gy tcb `bkabr+

C+ Mssurb tcmt qum`ety jdktrd` rbvebws mrb pbrfdrnba wetcek 5? amys df`dmk aesgursbnbkt+ Fdr `dmk sbrvejeki, rbvebws nust gb adkb mt`bmst qumrtbr`y+

E+ Mssurb tcmt pdst.aesgursbnbkt ekspbjtedks mrb jdkaujtba tdabtbrnekb tcmt enprdvbnbkts wbrb jdnp`btba dr m nmkufmjturba cdnbwms prdpbr`y ekstm``ba+

H+ Mssurb tcmt tcb `bkabr lbbps rbjdras df tcb rbsu`ts df qum`etyjdktrd` rbvebws, ekj`uaeki fekaekis mka mjtedks tmlbk, fdr m pbredadf dkb ybmr+

6.: WB]REWBNBKQZ FDW @DMK DWEIEKMQEDK+

M+ IBKBWM@+ @bkabrs mrb bxpbjtba td bxbrjesb pruabkjb mka ae`eibkjbek abtbrnekeki wcbtcbr tcb gdrrdwbr es mk mjjbptmg`b jrbaet resl,wetc m rbmsdkmg`b mge`ety td nmlb pmynbkts dk tcb `dmk dg`eimtedk+M`` adjunbktmtedk suppdrteki tcb abtbrnekmtedk df jrbaetwdrtcekbssnust gb rbtmekba ek tcb `dmk fe`b+

=+ Qcb ]J_ nust bksurb tcmt m`` `dmks jdnp`y wetc tcb mpp`ejmg`bprdvesedks df 71 JFW _mrt 7?= mka rbquerbnbkts jdktmekba ekQet`b E `bttbrs+

7+ Qcb ]J_ nust prdveab fdr tcb rbvbrefejmtedk df tcb gdrrdwbr)sbnp`dynbkt mka abpdset gy tb`bpcdkb dr ek wreteki wetc tcbbnp`dybr mka abpdsetdry+ Et nust m`sd prdveab fdr tcbrbvbrefejmtedk df ieft `bttbrs dr dtcbr sdurjbs df fukas+ M``rbvbrefejmtedks nust gb adjunbktba ek tcb `dmk fe`b+

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 56 df 55

Page 97: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 97/99

:+ M kbw ek.fe`b jrbaet rbpdrt nust gb dgtmekba mka jdnpmrba tdtcb dreiekm` fdr aesjrbpmkjebs+ M`sd, tcb jrbaet rbpdrt nustgb rbjdkje`ba wetc tcb jrbaet mpp`ejmtedk td abtbrnekb tcmtm`` `emge`etebs wbrb `estba dr prdpbr`y mahustba mkaadjunbktba+

G+ Z_BJEFEJ WB]REWBNBKQZ8 Qcb ]J_ nust prdveab fdr m rbvebw df tcb`dmk dreiekmtedk mka ukabrwreteki fukjtedks ek drabr td8

5$52 6.1

19??+?7 WBV.=

=+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr m`` ekjdnb mka bnp`dynbkt amtm es suppdrtbagy wrettbk vbrefejmtedk dr dtcbr adjunbktmtedk, bspbjem``y fdrsb`f.bnp`dyba mpp`ejmkts mka tcdsb wetc kdk.bnp`dynbkt ekjdnb+Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr tcb `dmk fe`b jdktmeks m fekmkjem` stmtbnbktdr Fbabrm` ekjdnb tmx rbturk ef tcb gdrrdwbr es sb`f.bnp`dyba+

7+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr m jdnp`btb mka jurrbkt jdksunbr jrbaetrbpdrt dk tcb gdrrdwbr mka mky jd.nmlbr dr jd.seikbr wmsdgtmekba, mka mky jrbaet ekquerebs rbpdrtba wetcek tcbprbvedus 5? amys wbrb jcbjlba+ Ef ndrb tcmk dkb jrbaet rbpdrtwms dgtmekba, abtbrnekb wcbtcbr m`` ekfdrnmtedk wms jdkseabrbagy tcb ukabrwretbr mka mky aesjrbpmkjebs wbrb rbsd`vba+

:+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr m wrettbk vbrefejmtedk df tcb sdurjb dffukas wms dgtmekba tcrduic vbrefejmtedks df abpdset, gmklstmtbnbkts, ieft `bttbrs dr dtcbr wrettbk adjunbktmtedk, wcbktcb prekjepm` gm`mkjb df tcb `dmk bxjbbas !2,??? mka tcbeketem` pmynbkt bxjbbas fevb pbrjbkt df tcb `dmk mndukt+

1+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr tcb gdrrdwbr)s bxpbksb.td.ekjdnb rmteds mrbwetcek tcb m``dwmg`b rmteds bstmg`escba gy CRA$FCM, dr tcmttcbrb mrb mpprdpremtb jdnpbksmteki fmjtdrs tcmt suppdrtmpprdvm` df tcb `dmk+

2+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr m`` jdkf`ejteki ekfdrnmtedk dr aesjrbpmkjebswbrb rbjdkje`ba mka prdpbr`y adjunbktba ek wreteki+

6+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr tcb `bkabr jdnp`btba m fmjb.td.fmjb drtb`bpcdkb ektbrvebw wetc tcb mpp`ejmkt gbfdrb nmleki m fekm`abtbrnekmtedk df jrbaetwdrtcekbss ek drabr td bksurb tcbmjjurmjy df ekfdrnmtedk ek tcb fe`b+ #Wbfbr td 71 JFW7?=+77#m% #5%%+

9+ Abtbrnekb tcmt prdpbr prdjbaurbs wbrb usba td abtbrnekbgdrrdwbr b`eiege`ety mka bvm`umteki wcbtcbr tcb `dmk prdjbbaswbrb ektbkaba td gb usba fdr b`eieg`b purpdsbs+ #Wbfbr td 71JFW 7?=+7? dr 7?=+7= ms mpprdpremtb+%

5$526.2

19??+?7 WBV.=

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 59 df 55

Page 98: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 98/99

3+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr tcb prdpbrty enprdvbnbkt `dmk fe`bs jdktmekm`` rbquerba adjunbkts, ekj`uaeki gut kdt `enetba td,jdnp`btedk jbrtefejmtbs mka ekspbjtedks df jdnp`btbaenprdvbnbkts+

5+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr bmjc nmkufmjturba cdnb `dmk fe`b jdktmeksm`` rbquerba adjunbkts, ekj`uaeki gut kdt `enetba td, mp`mjbnbkt jbrtefejmtb mka m setb.df.p`mjbnbkt ekspbjtedk+

=?+ Ycbrb tcb `bkabr mpprdvbs abm`br `dmks, abtbrnekb tcmt tcb`bkabr supbrvesbs mka ndketdrs bmjc abm`br mka vesets tcbabm`br pbredaejm``y+

m+ Abtbrnekb tcmt bmjc abm`br)s mpprdvm` es adjunbktba dk mCRA.mpprdvba fdrn seikba mka amtba gy gdtc pmrtebs+

g+ Abtbrnekb tcmt bmjc abm`br fe`b jdktmeks tcb abm`br)sjurrbkt fekmkjem` stmtbnbkt, ekj`uaeki m abtbrnekmtedktcmt tcb abm`br nbbts tcb nekenun kbt wdrtc rbquerbnbktsdf 71 JFW 7?=+79#m% #=%, mka jrbaet rbpdrts dk tcb

abm`brscep mka ets dwkbrs, prekjepm`s mka dffejbrs+

j+ Abtbrnekb tcmt bmjc fe`b jdktmeks adjunbktmtedk df tcb`bkabr)s bxpbrebkjb wetc tcb abm`br)s Qet`b E `dmks,ekj`uaeki ekfdrnmtedk dk gdrrdwbr abfmu`ts mka gdrrdwbrjdnp`mekts mka tcber rbsd`utedk+

a+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr tcb `bkabr rbvebws tcb abm`br)smavbrteseki aureki tcb tenb df mkkum` rb.mpprdvm` mkaaureki tcb sbne.mkkum` dk.setb vesets td bksurb et eskdt ekmjjurmtb dr nes`bmaeki rbimraeki tcb Qet`b E_rdirmn+

6.1 WB]REWBNBKQZ FDW @DMK ZBWVEJEKI

M+ IBKBWM@ Qcb `bkabr scm`` sbrvejb `dmks ek mjjdramkjb) wetc mjjbptbaprmjtejbs df pruabkt `bkaeki ekstetutedks+ Et scm`` cmvb mabqumtbfmje`etebs fdr jdktmjteki tcb gdrrdwbr ek tcb bvbkt df abfmu`t, mka

5$52 6.6

19??+?7 WBV.=

scm`` dtcbrwesb bxbrjesb ae`eibkjb ek jd``bjteki tcb mndukt aub+Qcb `bkabr scm`` gb rbspdkseg`b fdr prdpbr jd``bjtedk bffdrts, bvbktcduic mjtum` `dmk sbrvejeki mka jd``bjtedk nmy gb pbrfdrnba gy mkmibkt df tcb `bkabr+ Qcb `bkabr scm`` cmvb mk drimkezba nbmks df

eabktefyeki, dk m pbredaej gmses, tcb pmynbkt stmtus df ab`ekqubkt`dmks td bkmg`b jd``bjtedk pbrsdkkb` td eketemtb mka fd``dw.up dkjd``bjtedk mjtevetebs, mka scm`` adjunbkt ets rbjdras td rbf`bjtets jd``bjtedk mjtevetebs dk ab`ekqubkt `dmks+

G+ Z_BJEFEJ WB]REWBNBKQZ Qcb ]J_ nust prdveab fdr m rbvebw df tcb `dmksbrvejeki fukjtedk ek drabr td8

=+ Abtbrnekb tcmt `dmk sbrvejeki rbjdras mrb prdnpt`y bstmg`escbamftbr `dmk j`dseki dr mjquesetedk mka tcmt tcb sbrvejeki

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 53 df 55

Page 99: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF THE UNITED STATES IN OPPOSITION TO WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.’S MOTION TO DISMISS

7/28/2019 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A. Case 1:12-cv-07527-JMF APPENDIX TO MEMORANDUM O…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/united-states-of-america-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-case-112-cv-07527-jmf-appendix 99/99

rbjdras jdktmek tcb ekfdrnmtedk kbjbssmry td prdpbr`y sbrvejbtcb `dmk+ M`sd, abtbrnekb tcmt tcb gdrrdwbrs cmvb gbbkkdtefeba jdkjbrkeki tcb trmksfbr df sbrvejeki+

7+ Abtbrnekb tcrduic m rbvebw df ekaeveaum` `dmk sbrvejekirbjdras tcmt tcb mndukt df fbbs mka jcmribs enpdsba dk tcbgdrrdwbr ad kdt bxjbba tcdsb pbrnettba gy CRA rbiu`mtedks mt71 JFW 7?=+72+

:+ Abtbrnekb tcmt ekquerebs frdn gdrrdwbrs jdkjbrkeki tcberekaeveaum` `dmk mjjdukts mrb prdnpt`y rbspdkaba td+

1+ Abtbrnekb tcmt mk mkm`yses es pbrfdrnba dk m`` `dmks tcmtabfmu`t bmr`y #`bss tcmk 6 pmynbkts% td abtbrnekb tcb jmusb dftcb abfmu`t mka jdkfern tcmt tcb `dmks wbrb ukabrwrettbkprdpbr`y+

2+ Abtbrnekb tcmt gdrrdwbrs mrb prdveaba bvbry rbmsdkmg`bdppdrtukety td rbnbay m ab`ekqubkjy dr abfmu`t, ekj`uaekindaefejmtedk mirbbnbkts dr ekfdrnm` rbpmynbkt p`mks+

6+ Abtbrnekb tcmt mabqumtb jd``bjtedk mjtevetebs mka mjjurmtbadjunbktmtedk df jd``bjtedk bffdrts mrb rbjdraba+

9+ Abtbrnekb tcmt m fmjb.td.fmjb nbbteki dr tb`bpcdkb

5$526.9

19??+?7 WBV.=

ektbrvebw wetc tcb gdrrdwbr es mttbnptba gbfdrb tcb `bkabrtmlbs mky mjtedk td mjjb`brmtb tcb nmturety df tcb `dmk tdaesjuss tcb rbmsdks fdr `mjl df pmynbkt mka td abtbrnekb tcbkbjbssmry stbps td greki tcb `dmk jurrbkt+

3+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr tcb kdtejb df abfmu`t mka mjjb`brmtedk es ekjdnp`emkjb wetc tcb rbiu`mtedks #71 JFW 7?=+2?#g% mka Qet`b E@bttbr QE.1?3%+

5+ Abtbrnekb wcbtcbr tcbrb mrb suffejebkt jdktrd`s td mssurb tcmtm`` mspbjts df tcb j`mens fdr eksurmkjb gbkbfets mrb prbpmrba

e e

Jmsb =8=7.jv.?9279.HNF Adjunbkt :?.= Fe`ba ?7$=:$=: _mib 55 df 55