UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s...

87
UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES www.messycity.com @kevinklink

Transcript of UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s...

Page 1: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES

www.messycity.com@kevinklink

Page 2: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

APERITIVO

Page 3: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 4: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 5: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 6: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 7: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 8: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

Julia Child, (1990):

"Everybody is overreacting. If fear of food continues, it will be the death of gastronomy in the United States. Fortunately, the French don't suffer from the same hysteria we do. We should enjoy food and have fun. It is one of the simplest and nicest pleasures in life.”

Page 9: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 10: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 11: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 12: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 13: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 14: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 15: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 16: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 17: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 18: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 19: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 20: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

“The most enlightened preservationists are trying to restore more than buildings. They wish to restore a sense of community and of humane and civilized values in an age of bigness and speed and, too often, of loneliness, fear and conflict.”Mills Lane – Savannah, GA

Page 21: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 22: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

1980 1990 2000 2010

Preference for Urban Living among 25-34 Year-olds

Source: “The Young and Restless in the Nation’s Cities” October 2014

Page 23: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

Source: International Council of Shopping Centers, 2019

Page 24: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

America

Page 25: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 26: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

1932

Page 27: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 28: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

PRIMO

Page 29: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

Household Income comparison

Region - 63,404Downtown - 43,592KCMO - 50,136Jack. Co. - 50,652

Regional cities peak population

Minneapolis 1950 521,718Minneapolis 2018 425,403Milwaukee 1970 717,099Milwaukee 2018 592,025

Page 30: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 31: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

UTOPIA DIDN’T TURN OUT SO WELL

Page 32: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 33: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 34: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 35: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 36: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 37: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 38: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

SECONDI

Page 39: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 40: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

Public Space

Page 41: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 42: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 43: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

“The Bicycle is a wealth-producingfountain of youth”

Page 44: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

44

Page 45: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

45

Page 46: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 47: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 48: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 49: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 50: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 51: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

DOLCE

Page 52: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 53: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 54: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 55: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

KCMO Population Growth

Page 56: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 57: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

• RESIDENTIAL SCALE

• SIMPLER CONSTRUCTION

• MORE AFFORDABLE (IRC vs IBC)

• MORE SOCIALLY-ORIENTED

• IDEAL FOR WALKABLE PLACES

• UP TO 4 UNITS ARE EASY TO MORTGAGE / HOUSE-HACK

• ELEGANTLY BLENDS RICH, MIDDLE CLASS AND POOR

Page 58: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 59: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

house townhouse ADU

duplex triplex 4-plex

Live/work Mixed-use

DIY / SMALL INVESTORS / HOUSE HACKERS

Page 60: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 61: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 62: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

CHANGE IS REALLY EASY & POPULAR

Image by MetroQuest

Page 63: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 64: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 65: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

“Make no little plans - they have no magic to stir men’s blood.”

Daniel Burnham

“It should be understood, however, that such radical changes as are proposed

herein cannot possibly be realized immediately. Indeed, the aim has been to anticipate the needs of the future as well as to provide for the necessities of

the present; in short, to direct the development of the city towards an end that must seem ideal, but is practical.”

Page 66: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 67: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 68: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 69: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 70: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

BIG VISIONS ARE IMPORTANT

Page 71: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 72: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 73: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

A low-speed priority zone?

KCMO - 319 sq. miles (8.3%)

Region - 7,900 sq. miles (.33%)

Page 74: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

“There are only 3 great American cities – New York, San Francisco and New Orleans. The rest are

Cleveland.”

-Tennessee Williams

Page 75: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 76: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

“Good enough is not good enough” – Michael Stern

Page 77: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

DIGESTIVO

Page 78: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

“I’m an urbanist.

I think our cities and towns suck.

And we deserve better.”

-Kevin Klinkenberg

Page 79: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on.

Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time to shift from being reactive and fearful to proactive

and hopeful.

Page 80: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

3 human-centered focus areas for planners and economic developers

1. Great urban public spaces

2. Micro-mobility

3. Enabling House Hacking / Incremental

Development

www.messycity.com

Page 81: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 82: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 83: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

Public Space

Page 84: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

Public Space

Page 85: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time
Page 86: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES

www.messycity.com@kevinklink

Page 87: UNDERSTANDING MESSY CITIES - wisconsin.planning.org-Kevin Klinkenberg. The world of the 50s/60’s is over. We need to move on. Change is here, and going to come faster. It’s time

A recipe for messy cities, for the pros1. Focus where success is most likely

2. Create a compelling vision

3. Do the Math & Show the Value

4. Understand we aren’t like the coastal cities

5. Savor your small parcels & create more

6. Scrum the details with your total team - city management, infrastructure, planning ++

7. Adopt changes and let them evolve. Be messy.

www.messycity.com