UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on...

43
UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES TO: FROM: AUTHORITY THIS PAGE IS UNCLASSIFIED AD469176 Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited. Distribution authorized to U.S. Gov't. agencies and their contractors; Administrative/Operational Use; JUL 1965. Other requests shall be referred to Office of Naval Research, Arlington, VA 22203. ONR ltr 28 Jul 1977

Transcript of UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on...

Page 1: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

UNCLASSIFIED

AD NUMBER

LIMITATION CHANGESTO:

FROM:

AUTHORITY

THIS PAGE IS UNCLASSIFIED

AD469176

Approved for public release; distribution isunlimited.

Distribution authorized to U.S. Gov't. agenciesand their contractors;Administrative/Operational Use; JUL 1965. Otherrequests shall be referred to Office of NavalResearch, Arlington, VA 22203.

ONR ltr 28 Jul 1977

Page 2: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

THIS REPORT HAS BEEN DELIMITED

AND CLEARED FOR PUBLIC RELEASE

UNDER DOD DIRECTIVE 5200,20 AND

NO RESTRICTIONS ARE IMPOSED UPON

ITS ÜSZ AND DISCLOSURE.

DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A

APPROVED FOR PUBLIC RELEASE;

DISTRIBUTION UNLIMITED,

Page 3: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

Technical Report No. 27

THEORY OF MICROPOLAR FU/IDS

r i c ;

cr

by

A. Cemal Eringpn

to

Office of Naval Research

Department of the Navy-

Contract Nonr-1100(23)

School of Aeronautics, Astronautics and Engineering Sciences

Purdue University

Lafayette, Indiana

July 1965

DDC

JJ \J t

Reproduction in whole or in part is permitted

for any purpose of the United States Government

.: '

Page 4: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

MARKING

The classified or limited status of this report applies

to each page, unless otherwise marked.

Separate page printouts MUST be marked accordingly.

THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS INFORMATION AFFECTING THE RATIONAL DEFENSE OF THE UNITED STATES WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE ESPIONAGE LAWS, TITLE 18, U.S.C., SECTIONS 793 AND 794. THE TRANSMISSION OR THE REVELATION OF ITS CONTENTS IN ANY MANNER TO AN UNAUTHORIZED PERSON IS PROHIBITED BY LAW.

NOTICE: When government or otter drawings, specifications or other data are used for any purpose other than in connection with a defi- nitely related government procurement operation, the U. S. Government thereby incurs no responsibility, nor any obligation whatsoever; and the fact that the Government nay have formulated, furnished, or in any way supplied the said drawings, specifications, or other data is not to be regarded by implication or otherwise as in any manner licensing the holder or any other person or corporation, or conveying any rights or permission to manufacture, use or sell any patented invention that may in any way be related thereto.

%

Page 5: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

...

THIS DOCUMENT IS BEST QUALITY AVAILABLE. THE COPY

FURNISHED TO DTIC CONTAINED

A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF

PAGES WHICH DO NOT

REPRODUCE LEGIBLYo

Page 6: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

UNCLASSIFIED Security Clarification

DOCUMINT CONTROL DATA - UD (Btmtitf nlmmmitlcmtt*n •# mi: *•«> a# *t«(itei am? IplMiaJ «wfaMan wise aa mtomä a*an I i »wm« npoti im emmmUfd)

I. ORIGINATING ACTIVITY (Coipotmn mt«*t)

Purdue University, Lafayette, Indiana

la. nmpont »ICUAITY C LAMINATION

Unclassified a» OROU»

3 RSRORT TITLI

Theory of Mi crcpolar Fluids

4 DISC AIRTIVI MOTH (Typ» mi raaart ana htcktmlrm mmtwrn)

Research Report I AUTHORS (Ltmtnmmm. tint nmmm, MHmi)

Eringen, A. Cemal

•■ RIRORT DATI

July, 1965 7a- TOTAL MO. OF »AaKt

35 IM

4 a. CONTRACT ON «KANT NO

a. PROJBCT NO.

N0NR-1100(23)

064-410

mrt>

No. 27

• ft. OJMlRRtRORT NOftJ (AnTo*W€

iOAVA ILASIUTY/LIMITATIOM NO TIC M

Qualified requesters inKy obtain copies of this report from DDC.

11- lUPPLlMfNTAIIY NOTlt It. t»0«tORIMO a* LIT AR Y ACTIVITY

Office of Naval Research, Washington, DC

13 ABSTRACT

Equations of motion, constitutive equations and boundary

conditions are derived for a class of fluids named micropolar

fluids. These fluids respond to micro-rotational motions and

spin inertia and therefore can support couple stress and distri-

buted body couples. Ihermodynamical restrictions art4 studied

in detail and field equations are obtained for the density,

velocity vector and micro-rotation vector. The system is

solved for a channel flow exhibiting certain interesting

phenomena.

J DD.?!». 1473 UlCIASSPTEa

KSSBf tJESKSSm

Page 7: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

UNCLASSIFIED

"Security Clastificatioo 14

KEY WORDS LINK A

ftOLK

LINK B LINK C RQLC WT

Micropolar media

Couple stress

Micromechanics

Pipe Flow

Non-Newtonian

Micro-gyration

Spin inertia

INSTRUCTIONS

1. ORIGINATING ACTIVITY: Enter the «en« and sddress of the contractor, subcontractor, panto«, Department of De- fense activity or other organization (corporate author) issuing the report.

2«. REPORT SECURITY CLASSIFICATION: Enter the over* all security classification of the report. Indicate whether "Restricted Data" ia included. Marking la to be in accord- ance with appropriate security regulations.

2b. OROUP: Automatic downgrading ia specified in DoD Di- rective 5200.10 and Armed Force« Industrial Manual. Enter the group number. Also, when applicable, the« that optional markings have been used for Group 3 end Group 4 as author* . iced.

3. REPORT TITLE: Enter the complete report title in all capital letters. Title» in ail caaea should be unclassified« If a mo-anlnccful title cannot be selected without clessifice- , tton, show title classification in all capitals in parenthesis immediately following the title.

4. DESCRIPTIVE NOTES: If appropriate, enter the type of report« e.g., interim, progress, summary, annual, or final. Give the incluaive dates when a specific reporting period ia covered.

5. AUTHOR(S): Enter the name(a) of authort» aa shown on or in the report. Enter laat name, first name, middle Initial. If rrditary, show rank and branch of service. The name of the principal - thor ia an abaolute minimum requirement

6. REPORT DATE; Enter the date of the report aa day, month, year, or month, year. If more than one date appears oa the report, use date of publication.

7a. TOTAL NUMBER OF PAGE» The total page count should follow normal pagination procedures. La., entev the number of pages containing information.

76. NUMBER OF REFERENCES: Enter the total number of references cited in the report.

•a CONTRACT OR GRANT NUMBER: If appropriate, ecter the applicable number of the contract or grant under which the report was written.

66. 8c. a id. PROJECT NUMBER: Enter the appropriate military department identification, auch aa project number, aubproject number, ayatom numbers, teak number, etc

9a. ORIGINATOR'S REPORT NUMBER(S): Eater the offi- cial report number by which the document will be identified and controlled by the originating activity. Thia number asset be unique to thia report. 96. OTHER REPORT NUMBER» S). If the report haa assigned any other report «umfcars fetrher by the originator or by the sponsor), alee eater thia numburfa).

10. AVAILABILITY/LIMITATION NOTICES: Eater aa? Ü&v ttetiees on farther dtseemauattea of the report, other than those}

imposed by security classification, utiing standard statemetsts auch aa:

(1J "Ooaiiftexi i«Hr**»£*^* t—^: .>l_X?i^vrf.r>,«P of thia report from DDC" '^ ~

(2) "Foreign announcement and us semination of thia report by DDC ia not authorized."

(3) "U. S. Government age&ciea may obtain coplea of thia report directly from DDC. Other qualified DDC uaera shall request through

»» ii -» ■ »i ' ' ■ . ..- . ■■ HI •

(4) "U. S. military agencies may obtain copiea of thia report dtre-^ly frQ-5 DDC Other qualified uaera shall request through

(5) "All distribution of thia report ia patrolled. Qual- ified DDC uaera shall request through

If the report haa beep f oral abed to the Office of Technical Services, Department of Commerce, for aala to the public, radi- cate thia fact sad eater the price, if known.

1L SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES; Use for additional eaplnaa» tory notes.

IX SPONSORING MJUTARY ACTIVITY: Enter the name ef the departmental project office or laboratory sponooriag (pay* ing tor) the reaearch and development. Include

13. ABSTRACT: Entei aa sbetruct giving a brief ami summary of the document indicative of the report, even it may also appear elsewhere in tht body of the technical re- port. If additional apace ia required, a con tin istlon sheet ahall he attached-

It ia highly desirable the» the sbstract of classified re aerie be uaclaetiifled. Bach paragraph of the abetract ahall ead with aa Indication of the military security classification of the in- formation ia the pariigraph, represented aa (TSK (§). (C). er (V)

There la no limitation oa the length of ihs abetract. Bow ever, tht suggested length is from ISO lo 225 woato.

14. KEY WORDS: Key words are technically lasaiisiiffjl «seme or short phrases that characterise s report and may ha) oeed aa Indes entries for cataloging the report. Key worda meat he selected so that no security classification is eenirod- keen« flera. auch an equipment model doaigaetioa, trade MM, mUieeey project code aame, geographic location, may be need aa hay worda hut will he followed by aa indication of technical cea- tast. The eaaignmeot of links, rales, and weigtua ia aetJaaal

DD F-5tst i JAH a« t473(BACK) .K

Secvf i! •' ClaeaiG cation

- Ä 1 .

Page 8: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

THEORY OF MICROPOLAR FLUIDS

A. Cemal ErIngen

Purdue University

ABSTRACT:

Equations of motion, constitutive equations and boundary conditions

are derived for a class of fluids named micropolar fluids. These

fluids respond to micro-rotational motions and spin inertia and

therefore, can support couple stress and distributed body couples.

Thermodynamical restrictions are studied in detail and field equations are

obtained for the density, velocity vector and micro-rotation vector.

The system is solved for a channel flow exhibiting certain interesting

phenomena.

Page 9: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

- *.<vtt .„rr.«^^»i ? *"•*--,» -* f.« - •, ».*■ - ' .*,- „ T,,^r„

1. INTRODUCTION

1 2 The theory of microfluids introduced by Eringen ' deals with

a class of fluids which exhibit certain microscopic effects arising

from the local structure and micro-motions of the fluid elements.

These fluids can support stress moments and body moments and are

influenced by the spin inertia. The theory of microfluids are,

however, too complicated even in the case of constitutively linear

theory and the underlying mathematical problem is not easily amenable

to the solution of non-trivial problems in this field«

A subclass of these fluids is the micropolar fluids which exhibit

the micro-rotational effects and micro-rotational inertia. This

class of fluids possesses certain simplicity and elegance in

their mathematical formulation which should appeal to mathematicians.

The micropolar fluids can support couple stress and body couples only.

Physically they may represent adequately the fluids consisting of

dijile elements. Certain anisotropic fluids, e.g. liquid crystals

which are made up of dumbbell molecules, are of this type. In fact,

animal blood happens to fall into this category. Other polymeric

fluids and fluids containing minute amount additives may be repre-

sented by the mathematical model underlying micropolar fluids.

3 k Recent experiments with fluids ' containing extremely small

amount of polymeric additives indicate that the skin friction near a

lA. C. Eringen, Int. J. Engng. Scl, £, 205 (196k)•

2 A. C. Eringen, "Proc. XI Intern. Congress of Appl. tech." Springer-

Verlag (1965)-

Page 10: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

■ v.- .' ■•-.--< '+::~-<Oirj;-m~r&,l%;:[. . ■ v,-?/•• -.-:"■ ■.', y;;-^:':- ■.^■■'•''.>•->'■i*'^' 'v;;:.-vv-Vo■■

rigid body in such fluids are considerably lower (up to 30-35^)

than the same fluids without additives. The classical Wavier-Stokes

theory is incapable of predicting these findings since it contains

no mechanism to explain this new physical phenomena. At the Naval

Hydrodynamic Conference at Bergen last year, September 1964, the

author suggested thav the microfluid theory may contain Just the

right mechanism required. While it is too early to make the final

conclusion on this question, the problem of channel flow worked

out in this paper is a positive indication of this conjecture.

In Arts. 2 and 3 we give a resume of the theory of microfluids

formulated in Ref. 1. The theory of micropolar fluids is developed

in Art. 4. In Art. 5 the thermodynamics of such fluids are studied

and the restriction on the viscosity coefficients are obtained.

In Art. 6 we give the field equations and boundary conditions and

present the similarity parameters. The last section of the paper

(Art. 7) is devoted to the solution of the problem of channel flow

of micropolar fluids.

3 ^J. V. Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/

U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0.

V. M. Vogel and A. N. Bitterson, "An Experimental Investigation of the

Effect of Additives Injected into the Boundary Layer of an Underwater

Body," Pacific Naval Lab. of the Defense Res. Board of Canada, ifct. 64-2.

A. C. ErIngen, Proc

September 10, 1964.

5 A. C. ErIngen, Proc. 5th Symposium on Naval hydrodynamics, Bergen,

Page 11: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

2. IAWS OF MOTION

In our previous work, Ref• 1, we formulated a theory of micro-

fluids whose behavior is governed hy a set of laws of motion and a

constitutive theory. Some of these laws are new to the mechanics

of continua and others are modifications and extensions of the well-

known principles of mechanics. Theee are

Conservation of mass:

|£ ♦ (p vk)>k * 0 in T (2.D

Balance of momentum:

w + piti -;.} - ° in y (2-2)

Balance of first stress moments:

*i - 8»i+ w+p(ii» - v • ° in v <2-3>

Conservation of energy:

* a \l vJ,k + (Vl " tki) VkJ + \tm w+ \,t ♦ *

in *y (2.»)

Principle of entropy:

s or . ph - ( *) -* > 0 in ^ (2.5)

Inequality (2.5) ie exioaatized to be valid for all Independent pro-

ceeeee. In these equation»

Page 12: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

,,„;,.,w... .s^sa*SS»^^"- ^•■■■:-'.---«fi^.:.-'T.'-^

*kl

f|

8ki

• a. im

c

*k

h

1

0

mass density

velocity vector

stress tensor

body force per unit mass

micro-stress average

the first stress moments

the first body moments per unit mass

inertial spin

internal energy density per unit mass

gyration tensor

heat vector directed outward of the body

heat source per unit mass

entropy per unit mass

temperature

Throughout this paper ve employ a rectangular coordinate system

x , x2 , Xw and the Bulerian representation, Fig. 1. All vectors

and tensors are referred to a set of spatial rectangular coordinates

so that no need arises for differentiating their co variant, contra variant

and mixed components from each other. An index followed by a comma

represents partial differentiation with respect to space variable x.

and a superposed dot indicates material differentiation» e.g.

'M *7 dvk 3T + \,t *i (2.6)

Page 13: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

■■•. ■ -.-.

Here and throughout this paper repeated indices denote summation

over the range (l, 2, 3).

For the spin inertia ve have the kineraatical relation (Jtef. 1,

eq. 5.5)

\l s Sal ^mk + Vnk Vmn) (2*7)

where i . « i, is called micro-inertia moments and according to

the lav of conservation of micro-inertia, they satisfy the partial

differential equations (Ref. 1, eq. 2.l6)

km + i v_ - i_ v_ - i,_ 0 in f (2.8) i T ± V — A V — JL V dt km,r r rm rk kr rm

Expressions (2.1) to (2.5) and (2.8) are valid at all parts of the

body B having volume y and surface j , except at finite

number of discontinuity surfaces, lines and points. At the surface

C/ of the body we have the boundary conditions

tki \ r tg on & (2.9) I

\tm\ ' \m on y (2-10)

where £ is the exterior normal to $f and t. and \ are

respectively the surface tractions and surface moments acting on $f •

Ve note that while equations (2.1), (2.2) are well-known from

the classical continuum mechanics, equations (2.3), (2.M and (2.8)

Page 14: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

are new. The first two of these equations (eq. 2.3 and 2,k) reduce

to classical results •

when Aj. = i = v ■ 0 * Equation (2,3) is, however, mich

more general than (2.11) and is the result of the new principle of

balance of first stress moments as against the limited axiom of balance

of moment of momentum of the classical theory. Equations (2.8) have,

of course, no counterpart in the classical continuum theory.

If we exclude the heat conduction phenomena, in the present

theory, the determination of motion requires the determination of the

nineteen unknowns

p(*,t) , ita (ac,t) , vk(ac,t) , v^ (*,t) (2.12)

as against the four unkn»- JS v and p of the classical theory.

A. C. Bringen, "fenllnear Theory of Continuous Media/ McOraw Kill (1962).

Page 15: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

3. CONSTITUTIVE EQUATIONS OF WJCROFLÜIDS

In Ptef. 1 we also gave a set of constitutive equations for micro-

fluids. For a non-heat conducting medium these are expressed as

relations between (t,, , s . , \, ) and the objective quantities

bki •- \,i*\i (5-2)

\tm '- VW,. <3'3>

and p and i . Of these <£ is the rate of deformation tensor

and £ and a. are two new tensors respectively called micro-

deformation rate tensor of second order and gyration gradient. Both

of these latter quantities transform like absolute tensors under any

rigid motion of the frame of reference, i.e. they are objective.

Hence they are suitable for use as the independent constitutive

variables.

For ehe present work we produce here only the results of the

linear constitutive theory of micro-isotropic fluids (i.e. i. ■ i 6. ). Km Km

For the nonlinear theories the reader is referred to Ref. 1.

i = [.¥ ♦ X tr 4 ♦ *o tr (fc-£)] I ♦ 2u4 * *0(fe-4) ♦ ^tf-ft) (3^)

Page 16: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

8

£ = [-IT + A tr 4 + no tr (t-4)] I ♦ 2u Ä + 5X (fc-fcT-24) (3.5)

kirn 1 (rl Vr + 72 V + '3 arrm) 8W + (r4 aJrr + ', *rir

6 rr/' km w7 krr '8 rkr '9 rrk' £m

+ 710 akim * 711 Sml * 712 aikm + 713 amki + rl^f ftimk

* 715 \ft (3.6)

where £ is the unit tensor and A , A , u , u , u , 1 , J ,

and 7 to 7.- are the viscosity coefficients. Also tr denotes

trace and a superscript T indicates transpose, e.g.,

I a 10 0 0 10 0 0 1

trbki 5 bkk > bki ■ b £k

The equation of state for these fluids can be shown to have

the form

€ = c(l,p" ) (3.7)

so that the thermodynamic pressure w and the temperature 6 are

defined by

T : - dp T 'n,i e i 37 'p,i (3.8)

For a detailed treatment on thermodynamics see Ref. 1. For the thermo-

dynamics of micropolar fluids see section 3 below.

Page 17: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

For non-heat conducting media, the nineteen unknowns (2.12)

must satisfy the thirteen partial differential equations obtained by-

substituting (2.7) and (3.*0 to (3.6) into (2.1) to (2.3) and the

six equations (2.8) so that ehe number of independent equations are

equal to that of unknowns. Equations so obtained are nonlinear in

the inertia terms and highly complicated otherwise. The purpose of

the present paper is to give a new theory applicable to a large

class of fluids falling within the framework of the microfluid

theory presented above, however possessing adequate mathematical

simplicity to make the engineering problems tractable.

Page 18: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

10

k. MICROPOIAR FLUIDS

A microfluid will be called micropolar if for all motions

Micropolar fluids exhibit only micro-rotational effects and can

support surface and body couples. Fluid points contained in a

small volume element, in addition to its usual rigid motion, can

rotate about the centroid of the volume element in an average sense

described by the gyration tensor v . No micro-stretch of particles

are, however, allowed (v' is skew-symmetric). Ihus micropolar

# fluids consist of a kind of dumbbell molecules.

We now proceed to show that a class of microfluids satisfying

(4.1) exists. The theory of such fluids is the subject of the

remainder of this paper.

Condition (4.1) implies that

a, , ■ -a., (4.2) kim /km

Calculating K . and -X . from (3.6) and equating them and

using (4.1)2 and (4.2) we find that if (4.1) is to be valid for all

motions we must have

The present work complements our previous work, Ref. 2, on a similar

suDject.

Page 19: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

ll

77 - r8 ■ o (4.3)

710 " 712 + 711 ■ 713 " °

so that

In view of skew-symmetry conditions (4.1) the independent number

of v and K. are respectively 3 and 9. ftius it is natural

to introduce two new sets of variables v and DL . by

Vr '- Kki VW ' vk/ * erW Vr <*•«

where €, . is the alternating tensor. Here the axial vector v KID 1

will be called micro-rotation vector and a,_ the couple stress

tensor. Ine sign convention for m. is identical to that of the

stress teiisor and is shown on Fig. 2. Similarly we introduce micro-

* lnertial rotation o and body couple I hy

The couple stress, body couple and micro-inertial rotation intro-

duced here are identical to those defined in Ref. 6, Art» 31.

Page 20: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

12

ar 5 "€rki°ki ' aki s -2crW ^r (^7)

* s -6bJ,, , I, . s -26 . . 1 (4.8) r - rki ki ' ki rki r v '

Now multiply (2.3) by € . and use (4.5) to (4.8) Since

s . ■ s. this results in mi im

mrk,r + «Mr *Jr + p(,k " V ' ° (^9)

Similarly using (4.5) and (4.6) in (2.4) we may replace the equation

of energy by

<* - \l (vi,k - W V + \l V + «k,k + ph (4-10>

An alternative but useful form to (4.10) is obtained by using

i,k ki ki ki kirn m

where

. 1 (vu , - v# . ) (4.11) wki = r uk,i - vi,k

and i> the classical spin tensor/ w is the verticity vector. Ifeüee

" = \l d<k - \l «Mr {ur + V + "ki V + qk,k + °h (4-12>

Page 21: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

13

The boundary conditions (2.10) are similarly replaced by

m . n lrknr ' \ on y <*.13)

where m. ■ €.- X is the surface couple vector acting

on £r . Next we turn our attention to the constitutive equations.

Equation ().^) can be put into the form

\t '- (-*+ \ vr,r> \t * »V <VM + Vl,*] + Kv ^i>k-«Wrvr) (*•*>

where we set

u - |i + u, 5 Li K *o Kl pv , 2(^ - n ) 5 % (fc.15)

An alternative form to (^.1*0 is

tu, ■ (-TT + X d ) 6U, + (2u + K ) <L . - K CWJ (« + V ) (^.16) ki v rr ki *v v Ki v klr r r '

If we multiply (h.k) by c - and use (U.5) and (4.6) this

equation can be transformed into

Kl v r,r kl v k,l v 1,K (>.17)

where

av ' 2(7i2 • V > ev ! 2<'a - V

\ ! 2(71 - 72 * 710 - \Z • 71U + *„> (*.18)

Page 22: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

Ik

We now substitute (4.16) and (4.17) into (4,12) to calculate the

rate of internal energy.

P€ s -7T ± . + A d., d,. + (2u + K ) d, . d kk v il kk pv v ki £k

♦ 2Kv (wk + vk)(u,k ♦ vk) + dv v^ vif|

+ ßv \l V/,k + 7v V V + qk,h + ph (^19)

The assumptions of micro-isotropy and the skew-symmetry of

V' when used in (2.8) gives

gr a 0 or i = const * j/2, on material lines (4.20)

Finally we give an expression of the inertial rotation

r rki ki rki 4k nk In'

using (4.1) this reduces to

Summarizing the results: Basic equations of motion (2.1), (2.2),

(4.9) energy (4.10) and the constitutive equations (4.14) and (4.17)

constitute a proof that the micropolar fluids may exist as a subclass

of microfiulds whenever (4.3) i£ satisfied. The thermodynamic restric-

tions on the viscosities are studied in the following article

i

Page 23: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

15

5. THERMODYNAMICS OF MICROPOLAR FLUIDS

In this paper we are primarily concerned with the non-heat

conducting microfluids. In accordance with the principle of equi-

presence (Ref. 6, Art. kk) every constitutive dependent variable

must be a function of the same list of variables until contrary is

shown to be the case. In harmony with this practice then the

equation of state of micropolar fluids must have the general form

c ■ «(1, P'\ dw, bu, Vm) (5.1)

The dependence on i is dropped since i « const along a material

line. We proceed to show that the dependence of € on 4 , fe and

a_ can be eliminated on the ground of the second law of thermodynamics

(2.5). Eliminating (q. . + ph)/0 between (4.10) and (2.5) we get

«* ■ ?} + \ \t <*j,k - \tr V + I \t Vl,k + ^ * ° (5'2)

Using (5*1) this becomes

pr • pn (1 - V W + T rTT p * 6 (5TT dk/ * 5D77 bk/ * 3a— ak/m}

op k/ ki k/m

This inequality must be satisfied for all Independent changes of *) ,

Page 24: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

... ., *;^:«.ay>'.^ ?™r&m'W

16

• • • 4 9 fe > & and e u • Since it is linear in these quantities, it

cannot be maintained for all independent variations of these quanti-

ties unless

I . * . 0 , * -- 0 (5.3) *(w) *üi ^V

\ - 0 (5.1*)

»r I - »£!•«* + »*kl W,l: - W V + »Vl V * ° «5.6)

where through (2.1) we replaced p by -P^Vk • In (5«3) a paranthesis

enclosing indices indicates the symmetric part, e.g.

<k .1 /dc ds %

Since any function € of a symmetric tensor d , can always be

expressed as a function d/ ,v f© see from (5.3) that € must be

independent of 4 , fc and a, . Using (**.l6) and (^.17) the inequality

(5.6) is further reduced to

pr i i [A d^.d., + (2u + K ) d_d,^ ♦ 2* (w, + vj(u, +v )♦ v v kk ££ ^v v' kl Ik v N k k k k

3 vu . v. . + 0 v, , v. . ♦ 7 v. . v, . ] > 0 (5.7) v k,k /,/ v k,i i,k 'v J,k l,k - w '

• ! If I .1 (5.5)

Page 25: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

17

We have thus proved

Iheorem 1. Ihe necessary and sufficient conditions for the local

Clauaius-Duhem inequality (2.5) to be satisfied for all independent

processes are: (i) e must be independent of 4 t t and a, ;

(ii) temperature 0 and pressure TT must be defined by (3*8) and

(iii) inequality (5.7) must be satisfied for all possible motions.

We now investigate the restrictions emanating from the satisfaction

of (5.7) for all independent & , w + v and v, . It is clear

that for all values of <& irrespective of u> + v and v we

must have the classical conditions

, (5A + 2u + K ) > 0 , JL > 0 e w v v v - ' e —

which are necessary and sufficient for the non-negativeness of the

terms containing & . Similarly we must also have

K /$ > 0 v' -

in order that pT be non-nagative for all values of u> + v .

Finally the conditions in a , ß and 7 are obtained by making

the last three terms in (5.7) non-negative, i.e.

This expression can be written as a quadratic form In a nine dimen-

sional sp»c*; i.e.

Page 26: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

18

aiJ yi yJ * ° ' alJ - aji

where

yi " vi,i » y2 ■ v2,2 . y3 > v3>3

y7 s V > y8 s v . y9 - vlj5

an - a22 - a53 - I (ov + ßv + >V> » a12 ■ ai3 = V6

a^5 ■ a67 " a89 ' ßy/6

\k ' a55 = »66 * a77 = a88 = aQ9 3 V6

all other a = 0 .

The characteristic values *± of a are obtained by solving the

equation

w(,u-|V

The nine roots for a are

al ' a2 ' a3 • \ - ßv

au = a5 . a6 . a? - a8 - 7y +

aQ » Ja + 0 +r 9 v Kv 'v

v= I . VA

Page 27: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

.

19

In order that the a y y > 0 to be satisfied for all y we

must have

(rv - ßv)/e > o , (rv + ßv)/e > o

(3av + ßy + 7y)/e > o

Hence

Theorem 2. The necessary and sufficient conditions for the inequality

(5.7) to be satisfied for all motion are

(3\ + 2"v + \)l* > o , uv/e > o , Ky/e > o

(3ay + 2r5)/e > o , -7y/e < ßy/e < yje , 7y/e > o (5.8)

These are the conditions on the viscosity coefficients. In general

ve also have 6 > 0 .

Corollary. The necessary and sufficient condition for the local

ClausJus-DuheL inequality to be satisfied for all independent processes

are (5.8). This result is clear as a combination of Theorems 1 and 2.

Page 28: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

,.,,,, ,:^u-«, -> - %. ^r,-W.HPt —■>-■.- «**< -vf-" - .„,.,_

20

6. FIELD EQUATIONS

The differential equations satisfied by p , v and v are given by

(2.1) and combinations of (4.1^)and (4.17) with (2.2) and (4.9), i.e.,

-*k + (\ + uv> vi,ki + W + V' \it + Kv €Um v»,i

+ P(fk - vk) =0 (6.2)

(Q,v + V Vi,ki + \ vk,*i + V 6k/m \,l * 2"v vk

+ P(*k - J \) * o (6.3)

where a superposed dot indicates the material differentiation, i.e.

The partial differential equations (6.1) to (6.3) are the field

equations of the micropolar fluids. Under appropriate initial and

boundary conditions they are capable of predicting the behavior of

such fluids in a unique fashion. The existence and uniqueness

theorems must of course be proven in order for the underlying mathe-

matical problem to be "veil-posed." Presently we only suggest some

Page 29: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

21

initial and boundary conditions.

Initial conditions at t • 0

p(&0) = PO(X)

vkU>0) = vk(x) (6.5)

\(£,0) - vk(ac)

where p , v and v are to be prescribed throughout

Boundary conditions at a rigid boundary

xte^t) -- ZB

(6.6) *UB,t) = vB

vhere £_ is a point on a rigid boundary having prescribed velocity

y_ and prescribed micro-rotation vector v_. Conditions (6,6) express

the assumption of adherence of the fluid to the solid boundary.

Boundary conditions involving prescribed forces and moments

In place of (6,6) we may prescribe boundary forces and moments as

expressed by (2.9) and (U.13), i.e.

(6.7)

Other types of mixed conditions are possible. The final Judgement

on these questions requires theoretical work on the question of

Page 30: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

22

existence and uniqueness and experimental work on the flow conditions.

Equations (6.1) to (6.3) are expressed in rectangular coordinates.

Vector expressions of these equations useful for work in other systens

of coordinates are

g£ + 2 • (P x) s 0 (6.8)

(\ + 2uv + ^v) 2 2 • X - (nv + ^v) 2 x 2 x x + Ky v x v - 2 7T

+ P£ • Pt g| -xx (2x v) + |2(Z2)] (6.9)

(av + \ + 7V) 2 2 • 2 - rv 2 x 2 x x + *y 2 x x

- 2*v v + pi : pjv (6.10)

where v does not possess as simple an expression as x • There

is, however, no particular difficulty in calculating it through its

tensorial form, cf. [2, 17, also Appendix].

We note that for K = a « ß «= y =0 and vanishing £

through (6.3) we get v ■ 0 and (6.2) reduce to the celebrated

Navier-Stokes equations. Note also that for K ■ 0 the velocity

X and the micro-rotation are uncoupled and the global motion is

unaffected by the micro-rotations.

The classical Stokes conditions 3A + 2u »0 for the micro- v v

polar fluids have the corresponding form

3Xy + 2uv + KV - 0 (6.11)

Page 31: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

23

to which we place no great faith.

For an incompressible fluids p = const , 2 * Z s 0 and

IT is replaced by an unknown pressure p to be determined from

the boundary conditions.

The similarity parameters of the micropolar fluids are obtained

by non-dimensionalizing equations (6.1) to (6.3). Thus let L and

T be respectively some characteristic length and time and

jc s jc/L , t = t/T , 7 = v/vo , v = V/VQ

7T ■ TT/TT0 , p = p/p0 , f * j/f0 , J = j/Jo (6.12)

are where TT , p , v , v , f and J /some reference values of ir , o ' o o o ' o uo '

P , \x\ * l-VI , l£l and J respectively. Substituting (6.12) into (6.1)

to (6.3) and using (6.4) we get the non-dimensional equations

OF n_ 2£ + (J?.). * 0 (6.13)

3 AF K »K

1 l,kt 2 k,ii 3 k/m m,l 4 ,k

+ ?("6 r* * "5 ^ ■ X' 7i} ' ° (6-lM

■, v. . . + a, v. J4 + m_ €. , v . - 2m, V. l J,ki 2 k,// 3 kim m,l ™ k

+ ?(»6Ik-n5| -V.v,) ■ 0 (6.15) i

Page 32: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

. .

2k

where

n. = (A + Li )/p v L , n0 i (u + K )/p v L , n « K v /p v 1 - v v Kv ' o o ' 2 v*v v" o o ' 3 v o'Ho c

n, = 7T /p v , nc = L/T/ , nc = f L/v c

4 0' op ' 5 ' o 6 o ' o

DL, = (a + ß )/p J v , m0 s j /p j v , m- = K/P J v •"1 - v Kv//Ko o o ' 2 'v/Kcro o ' 3 v/Hoüo o

mi, ; K L/p j v , ra_ = n, , nu = i L/j v v 4 v ' oo o ' 5 3 o " o/uooc (6.16)

Of these n , np are the reciprocal Reynold numbers, n. , n_

and n^ are well-known from the Navier-Stokes theory. The present

theory introduces six new numbers namely n, , m. , HL , DL ; m.

and ni£ . For a given fluid m is proportional to mp so that the

only new parameters are

n_ ■ K v /p v i BU ■ 7 /p J v j m, ■ K L/p J v 3 v o' o o ' 2 'v' ouo o ' 4 v /hcro o

m, s m./m- = v L/v , iiv = I L/j V V 3 V 3 o ' o ' 6 o,uooc (6.17)

"Hie four of these new similarity parameters represents the relative

importance of rotational viscosities to the inertia terms and the

fifth m, the relative micro-rotation velocity to the velocity.

Page 33: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

25

7. FLOW OF MICROPOIAR FLUIDS IN A CIRCUIAR PIPE

Here we give the solution of the field equations (6.8) to (6.10)

for a steady motion of micropolar fluids in a circular channel. The

appropriate coordinate system for this problem is the cylindrical

coordinates (r, B, z) with z taken along the axis of the pipe. For

a steady flow we seek to determine the velocity and micro-rotation

components

v ■ v = 0 , v ■ w(r) r0 z

Cp m m m 0 , <P' ■ <?)(r) r z u

(7.1)

Equation of continuity (6.8) is satisfied identically for p « const.

and (6.9) and (6.10) with £ ■ £ = 0 give p ■ p « 0 and ,r ,6

(li + K ) (rw')' + K (rv)' - rp (7.2) V V ,z

7 (V + r" v)1 - K w' - 2* v « 0 (7.3)

where a superposed prime indicates differentiation with respect to r.

We also used p to denote hydrostatic pressure in place of TT.

From (7.1) ve solve for v'. Hence

w'- (% + \)1 («v+ 2 p,z) + cir_1 (7,1°

IJext substitute v' Into (7-3)- This gives

v" + V- (k2 + ^)v-Pr (7.5)

Page 34: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

s.

26

where

kg 2Mv + . ^ 1/2 p , «v ft (7.6) %v + \ \ 2(nv + /cv)rv dz

The general solution of (7.5) ie found to be

v • A I (kr) + B Kx(kr) - Fk"2r (7-7)

where I (p) and K (p) are modified Bessel functions of first order

and first and second kind respectively. Substituting this into

(7A), and integrating the result we obtain

w - K (u + K r1 k"1 [- A I (kr) + B K (kr)] V V V o o

1 -1 2 (7'8)

+ - ( 2uy + /cv) p^r + C1 log r + C

where I and K are modified Bessel functions of zeroth order and o o

first and second kind respectively and C is an arbitrary constant.

Both w and v must be bounded at r ■ 0. Since K (kr), K.(kr)

and log r become infinite for r ■ Ö we must have B ■ C ■ 0. We

assume that the fluid sticks to the boundary r - a, i.e.,

v(a) - 0 , v(a) - 0 (7.9)

Using (7.7) and (7.8) we determine A and C leading to the solution

Page 35: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

27

va/vo - p - jjjj}> (7.11,

where

2 . .-1 dp v S - l 2M O :r o v v dz

P » r/a (7.12)

x 6 ^* a*-^^)i/2 a v v v

Here w is the maximum velocity in the classical Poiseuille flow

which occurs at r ■ 0. The solution (710) goes into the classical

Poiseuille flow for K ■ 0 and (7.11) gives v - 0.

According to (5 »8) with 0 > 0 we have \i , K and y non-

negative. Thus A is a real number. For various values of X we

give on Fig. k plots of velocity difference from the classical

Poiseuille flow and on Fig. 5 vh/w . From Fig. h as well as Fig.

3 we see that the velocity profile is no longer parabolic. Moreover

the velocity here is smaller than that of the classical Navier-Stokes

fluids. Of course, micro-rotation v is altogether missing in the

Navier-Stokes theory.

The non-vanishing components of the stress tensor and those

of the couple stress are obtained through expressing (U.lU) and

(4.17) in cylindrical coordinates. Hence

t ■ t «t ■ - p rr 66 zz

1 dp t - - -* a p rz 2 dz

Page 36: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

<.:-*«../^^^■.^.^'i;^*■''^;-■vr•'%":■■■!^>•■?■;•■^^-^■,^

28

zr 2dz ,v+Kv !l(X) (715)

1 IAA}

- <VV mre

We note that t I t whenever K ^ 0. rz zr v

On Figs. 6 to 7 are shown the surface tractions and couples on

the fluid surface adjacent to the wall at p ■ 1 for dp/dz < 0, ß < 0

and of course y > 0. The shearing stress t has the same expression

as in the classical theory. However the existence of the distrib- (Fig. 3)

uted couples m on the fluid surface/wilü produce an effect in a

thin layer near the wall, equivalent to reduction of the surface

shear. Clearly then the present theory gives rise to a boundary

layer phenomena not present in the Navier-Stokes theory. This new

boundary layer is controlled with the parameter X.

We believe that the theory of ralcropolar fluids opens up a

very worthwhile branch of fluid mechanics. It should find important

applications dealing with a variety of fluids. It should, in

particular cast new directions in the theory of turbulence. Rich

theoretical and experimental studies are awaiting the future workers.

Page 37: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

29

Fig. 1 Coordinates

V.V

Fig. 2 Positive Couple Stress Coapooents

Page 38: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

30

CLASSICAL (PARABOLA)

1. 0 w/w

Fig. 3 Velocity Profile

Page 39: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

31

Fig. k Adverse Mlcroflov

-fLi^-v-^v^. ■ K ..-*»>--

Page 40: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

32

va/v

Flg. 5 Micro-Rotati on

Page 41: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

33

Wg. 6 Shear Stress Difference

Page 42: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

^

Flg. 7 Couple Stress

. .

Page 43: UNCLASSIFIED AD NUMBER LIMITATION CHANGES · Hoyt and A. G. Pabula, "Ifce effect of Additives on Fluid friction/ U.S. »aval Ordnance Test Station Report (19#0. V. M. Vogel and A.

35

Contributing Personnel:

Dr. A. C. Eringen, Professor

School of Aeronautics, Astronautics and Engineering Sciences

Respectfully submitted,

//. C. ZA*^*^**^' A. Cemal Eringen

Paul F, Stanley, Interim Head School of Aeronautics, Astronautics

and Engineering Sciences