UCLA DM2012 BigBOSS Tarle!"#$%&'%-22$?+00(>+)(1+,$ US Groups: Brookhaven National Laboratory...
24
!"# %&' %()*+, -./&00(1+, 23#/4)+./+3&/ 25)6#* 7%&'%-228 9)#'+)* !()0: ;,&6#).&4* +< =&/"&'(, -, >#"(0< +< 4"# %&'%-22 ?+00(>+)(1+, ;?@A B= CDEC =()&,( F#0 G#*H ?A I#>)5()* CCH CDEC
Transcript of UCLA DM2012 BigBOSS Tarle!"#$%&'%-22$?+00(>+)(1+,$ US Groups: Brookhaven National Laboratory...
!"#$%&'$%()*+,$-./&00(1+,$23#/4)+./+3&/$25)6#*$7%&'%-228$
9)#'+)*$!()0:$;,&6#).&4*$+<$=&/"&'(,$-,$>#"(0<$+<$4"#$%&'%-22$?+00(>+)(1+,$
;?@A$B=$CDEC$=()&,($F#0$G#*H$?A$I#>)5()*$CCH$CDEC$
!"#$J(45)#$+<$B()K$L,#)'*$•! ;?@A$B=$EMMN$O).4$)#3+)4$+<$(//#0#)(1,'$
5,&6#).#$72?P$(,F$Q&'"RS8$•! TU$V$DWXCH$T=$V$DWCN$7NCY$?B=8$?+,O)Z#F$>*$
?=%GH$@22$
•! ?+.Z+0+'&/(0$/+,.4(,4$U[$L6+06&,'$./(0()$O#0F[$$\$V$P]^$_$D$B#6&(1+,$<)+Z$9G[WW$
•! A`#)$Ea$*#().H$,+$.(1.<(/4+)*$4"#+)#1/(0$#b30(,(1+,$"(.$#Z#)'#FW$
•! B()K$L,#)'*$!(.K$I+)/#$7CDDc8$"(.$/"()4#F$4"#$3(4"$<+)\()FW$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$245F*$#6+051+,$+<$\d$\7S8V\D$e$\(7ER(8$
–! =50130#$!#/",&f5#.d$gW! %()*+,$A/+5.1/$-./&00(1+,.$7%A-8$h$'#+Z#4)*$ggW! ?05.4#).$R$J@$')(6&4(1+,(0$')+\4"$gggW! 253#),+6(#$R$'#+Z#4)*$giW! j#(K$@#,.&,'$7j@8$h$'#+Z#4)*$e$J@$
')(6&4(1+,(0$')+\4"$
–! J#\$4#/",&f5#d$$iW! G#F."&`$23(/#$B&.4+)1+,.$7G2B8$F#Z+,.4)(4#F$
7CDDNRCDEE8$h$@$k$J@$')(6&4(1+,(0$')+\4"$
%&'%-22$\&00$510&S#$>+4"$%A-$7'#+Z#4)*$+,0*8$(,F$G2B$7')+\4"$+,0*8$\&4"&,$4"#$.(Z#$F(4($.#4$$4+$)#(/"$24('#$gi$<+)$%A-$\&4"$')+5,FR>(.#F$#b3#)&Z#,4W$
!! B#O,#.$I&'5)#$+<$=#)&4$7I+=8$(.$l)#/&3)+/(0$+<$4"#$()#($+<$4"#$#))+)$#00&3.#$#,/0+.&,'$4"#$MmY$?@$&,$4"#$\R\($30(,#Wn$P)+')#..&6#$3)+')(Z$4+$&Z3)+6#$I+=$
24('#$g$$7CDDc$K,+\0#F'#8$24('#$gg$$7#b&.1,'$#b3#)&Z#,4.8$7omD8$24('#$ggg$$7,#()$4#)Z$#b3#)&Z#,4.$pb$
>#q#)$4"(,$24('#$gg8$24('#$gi$$7EDb$>#q#)$4"(,$24('#$gg8$
!"#$%&'%-22$?+00(>+)(1+,$
US Groups: Brookhaven National Laboratory Carnegie Mellon University Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory Johns Hopkins University University of Kansas Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory University of Michigan National Optical Astronomy Observatory New York University The Ohio State University University of Pittsburgh SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory University of California, Berkeley University of California, Santa Cruz/Lick Observatory University of Utah Yale University
Non-U.S. Groups: Ewha Womans University, Korea French Participation Group
APC, IAP- Paris; CPP, CPT, LAP Marseille; CEA, IRFU – Saclay
Spanish Participation Group IAA, Granada; IAC, Tenerife; ICC, Barcelona; IFT, Madrid; U. Valencia
Shanghai Astronomical Observatory UK Participation Group
Durham, Edinburgh, UC London, Portsmouth University of Science and Technology of China
%()*+,$A/+5.1/$-./&00(1+,.$
!"#$%&$'()*+,-+$".$/012111$3+",-$45!67$
j=AP$
!"(3$8"*+-$
9(+$8"*+$
a$
A4$4"#$.5)<(/#$+<$0(.4$./(q#)&,'$7SVEDNN8$4"&.$&.$($l.4(,F()F$)50#)n$5.#F$4+$#.4(>0&."$4"#$r(4,#..$+<$4"#$5,&6#).#W$$!"#.#$E]EDm$0#6#0$r5/45(1+,.$')+\$&,4+s$
2+5,F$\(6#.$4)(6#0$(4$!/]tp$5,10$)#/+Z>&,(1+,W$$!"#$.+5,F$"+)&S+,$(4$)#/+Z>&,(1+,$.#4.$4"#$!Eu$/"()(/4#)&.1/$(,'50()$./(0#$+<$4"#$?=%W$$
%()*+,$A/+5.1/$-./&00(1+,.$
=(3$+<$'(0(b&#.$4+F(*$
2B22$
m$
s$0()'#$./(0#$r5/45(1+,.$7EmD$=3/$/+RZ+6&,'8$$&,$4"#$3)#.#,4$'(0(b*$F&.4)&>51+,sW$
!"(3$8"*+-$
9(+$8"*+$
%()*+,$A/+5.1/$-./&00(1+,.$
=(3$+<$'(0(b&#.$4+F(*$
2B22$
c$
2B22$'(0(b*$/+))#0(1+,.$
L&.#,.4#&,$#4$(0WH$CDDm$
!"(3$8"*+-$
9(+$8"*+$
s$(,F$/(,$>#$.##,$(.$($3#(K$&,$4"#$3+\#)$.3#/4)5Z$+<$4"#$'(0(b*$/+))#0(1+,$<5,/1+,$4+F(*W$$
!"#$3+\#)$+<$.3#/4)+./+3*$
:;"<)(<=%(>3$4#?%.%=@7$-A,*+3$B$C"(D-$
E#+F.,%-F%#)F$-A,*+3$
I500$3+\#)$+<$%A-$+,0*$3+..&>0#$\&4"$.3#/4)+./+3&/$.5)6#*.$•! gZ('&,'R+,0*$.5)6#*.$.Z#()$.&',(0$+,$.(Z#$./(0#$(.$%A-$•! I+=$)#F5/#F$v$mb$
%#,&4#S$#4$(0$
%A-$./(0#$
%&'%-22$•! %A-$Z#(.5)#.$4\+$.4(,F()F$)50#).$
–! (,'50()$F&(Z#4#)$F&.4(,/#$BA7S8$–! 0&,#R+<R.&'"4$7Q5>>0#$/+,.4(,4$Q7S88$
•! %+4"$()#$.5>R3#)/#,4$Z#(.5)#.$4"(4$&Z3)+6#$\&4"$S$7$$$$$$$$$8$
~ V
G#F."&`$23(/#$B&.4+)1+,.$
•! !+"-A,+-$<,"*)."G%(">$<,%8.?$–! 0&,#()$')+\4"$70()'#R./(0#$.f5(."&,'8$–! ,+,R0&,#()$')+\4"$7'(0(b*$/05.4#).8$
•! H+;%(-.,".+D$8).?$–! iiB2$.5)6#*$795SS+$!"#$%#CDDN8$–! j&''0#w$.5)6#*$7%0(K#$#4$(0$CDEE8$
G#(0$23(/#$
G#F."&`$23(/#$B&.4+)1+,.$
•! !+"-A,+-$<,"*)."G%(">$<,%8.?$–! 0&,#()$')+\4"$70()'#R./(0#$.f5(."&,'8$–! ,+,R0&,#()$')+\4"$7'(0(b*$/05.4#).8$
•! H+;%(-.,".+D$8).?$–! iiB2$.5)6#*$795SS+$!"#$%#CDDN8$–! j&''0#w$.5)6#*$7%0(K#$#4$(0$CDEE8$
G#F."&`$23(/#$
%-22$R$$A$24('#$ggg$P(4"O,F#)$<+)$%&'%-22$•! 2B22$ggg$#b3#)&Z#,4$R$EDDD$O>#).$)#RZ(3$<+/(0$30(,#$4+$
.3#/4)+')(3".W$•! EDDD$.3#/4)(])#F."&`.$3#)$+>.#)6(1+,$•! EWm$Z&00&+,$'(0(b&#.$DWEm$_$S$_$DWX$•! EcDHDDD$x2-.$CWE$_$S$_$pWm$•! B#O,&16#$%A-$S$_$DWX$>*$CDEa$•! P(4"O,F#)$S$v$C$5.&,'$QR(>.+)31+,$4+$x2-.$•! P05'$30(4#.$F+$,+4$./(0#$4+$v$DWm$Z&00&+,$+>y#/4.]*#()$•! J+4$3+..&>0#$4+$+>.#)6#$z.$+)$6+05Z#$)#f5&)#F$<+)$24('#$gi$
%&'%-22$+,$4"#$=(*(00$(4${PJ-$
http://bigboss.lbl.gov!
5%,,+F.%,$>+(-+-$/I$J9K$
B111$,%C%GF$LC+,$#%-)G%(+,-$%($M=;$&%F">$#>"(+2$&NOPB$
M1$-#+F.,%<,"#?-$Q$/$F?"((+>-$+"F?$
E+>+F.+D$&%,$RS",<+$EF)+(F+$T,%<,";-$T,%*)D)(<$U+8$9C-+,*)(<$5"#"C)>)G+-$&%,$.?+$!"3">>$O;$$V+>+-F%#+$%($W)X$T+"YPZ$
B11$?%A,-$)($B$3+",-$4[1M\$]$[1[17$$EA,*+3$",+"$MO2111$-^$D+<$T,+F)-)%($,+D-?)_-$`a@$b$1P11M4Mc@7d$%&$%*+,$[1$;)>>)%($<">"e)+-$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$4Sfg-$1PB$b$@$b$M$h$iSg-$1PB$b$@$b$MP\7$.%$
•!!+"-A,+$6j9$&+".A,+$•!V,"F+$;"X+,$#%8+,$-#+F.,A;$".$-;">>$-F">+-$•!H+.+F.$,+D-?)_$-#"F+$D)-.%,G%(-$
5%(-.,")(.-$%($+",>3$D",Y$+(+,<3$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$"(D$FA,*".A,+$
•!S3=k$&%,+-.$)($.?+$-#+F.,"$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$%&$l$\112111$^A"-",-$8).?$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$[P[$b$@$b$/PB$•!V,"F+,$mE9-$1PB$b$@$b$/PB$
-31/(0$?+))#/4+)$
?C$
?p$
AB?E$
I+/(0$P0(4#$I&>#)$A/45(4+).$•! =(',&O#.$<]CWE$
=(*(00$3)&Z#$<+/5.$$4+$<]aWm$7EXWEZ$LI@8$
•! pu$I+i$•! !\+$3)&.Z$>(.#F$
>)+(F>(,F$(4Z+.3"#)&/$F&.3#).&+,$/+Z3#,.(4+).$753$4+$cDu$<)+Z$S#,&4"8$
•! 9#+Z#4)&/$>05)$_$DWm$()/.#/$IjQ=$30(/#.$_$XD$|Z$IjQ=$.3+4$+,4+$ECD$|Z$O>#)$+6#)$#,1)#$EZ$<+/(0$30(,#W$
?E$
AB?C$
?a$
I&>#)$P+.&1+,#).$•! mDDD$EC$ZZ$O>#)$3+.&1+,#).$
Z+5,4#F$+,$/5)6#F$EZ$<+/(0$30(,#$
•! }R}H$)R}$k$r#b45)#$3+.&1+,#)$3)+4+4*3#.$#b&.4$76()&+5.$+31+,.$5,F#)$.45F*8$
23#/4)+')(3".$•! mDDD$O>#).$<##F$ED$
.3#/4)+')(3".$
•! !")##$/"(,,#0.$$–! G#F$7NDDRMND$,ZH$G$v$aDDD8$
–! i&.&>0#$7cCDRNaD$,ZH$G$v$pDDD8$
–! %05#$7pcDRccD$,ZH$G$v$EmDD8$
•! ?5))#,4$"&'"$)#.+051+,$'(0(b*$Z(3.$()#$.3().#$(,F$0()'#0*$Z&..&,'$&,4#)Z#F&(4#$)#F."&`.$
%&'%-22$2/&#,/#$G#(/"$
%&'%-22$2/&#,/#$G#(/"$•! 6)<69EE$8)>>$+(>",<+$,+D-?)_=-#"F+$;"#-$.%$[O$;)>>)%($$•! M1Q$>",<+,$.?"($EHEE$c$EHEE=::$c$69EE$•! U+F+--",3$&%,$E."<+$:K$D",Y$+(+,<3$&,%;$6j92$fEH$
CWm$Z&00&+,$x2-.$
EN$Z&00&+,$L@9.$
a$Z&00&+,$@G9.$
%&'%-22$2/&#,/#$P#)<+)Z(,/#$•! %A-$F&.4(,/#$./(0#$
#))+)$~G]G$4+$_$EY$<+)$$$$DWm$_$S$_$pWDW$$
•! =#(.5)#$Q7S8$4+$EWmY$53$4+$S$V$CWmW$$
•! ?+,.4)(&,$')+\4"H$~N7S8$<7S8$\&4"$_$CY$)#0(16#$#))+)$
•! =#(.5)#$'(0(b*$3+\#)$.3#/4)5Z$4+$_$EY$53$4+$S$V$EWm$
AFF&1+,(0$9+(0.$•! g,r(1+,d$/+,.4)(&,$
.3#/4)(0$&,F#b$(,F$&4.$)5,,&,'$4+$_$EY$
•! =#(.5)#$�ZÄ$\&4"$~$_$DWDCa$#i$
24('#$gi$BL$<)+Z$%A-$7'#+Z#4)&/$3)+>#8$
24('#$gi$BL$<)+Z$G2BW$
7')(6&4(1+,(0$')+\4"8$
24('#$gi$BL$<)+Z$%A-$7'#+Z#4)&/$3)+>#8$
9(0(b*$3+\#)$.3#/4)5Z$7k$>&.3#/4)5Z8$RRR$�ZÄH$3)&Z+)F&(0$
.3#/4)5Z$(,F$,+,R9(5..&(,&1#.$
%&'%-22$B()K$L,#)'*$I+=$$
•! %&'%-22$3)+y#/1+,.$>(.#F$+,$%A-$e$G2B$–! gZ3)+6#Z#,4.$3+..&>0#$\&4"$Z+)#$0&,#()$Z+F#.$7KZ(b$V$DWpD$"=3/RE8$
–! BL!I$I&'5)#.R+<R=#)&4$
–! P)&+).$<)+Z$I&'5)#R+<R=#)&4$2/&#,/#$j+)K&,'$9)+53$7I+=2j98$
–! %A-$724('#$ggg8$<)+Z$QL!BLÅ$e$j&''0#w$–! 2J$724('#$ggg8$I+=2j9$(..5Z31+,.$<+)$24('#$ggg$2J#$
J%!$
%&'%-22$7KZ(b$V$DWEm$"$=3/RE8$ apD$
e$%A-$724('#$ggg8$ apX$
e$2J$724('#$ggg8$ acc$
%&'%-22$7KZ(b$V$DWpD$"$=3/RE8$ ccE$
e$%A-$724('#$ggg8$ ccX$
e$2J$724('#$ggg8$ cME$
%&'%-22$7%A-$e$G2B8$e$@22!$7j@8$•! I+=$>#q#)$4"(,$.3(/#Ç$
–! g,F#3#,F#,40*$6#)&O#F$>*$jIgG2!$2/&#,/#$B#O,&1+,$!#(Z$/(0/50(1+,.$+<$BL!I$I+=$
I&'W$)#3)+F5/#F$<)+Z$jIgG2!$2/&#,/#$B#O,&1+,$!#(Z$)#3+)4$$"q3d]]\O).4W'.</W,(.(W'+6]./&#,/#]jIgG2!Ég,4#)&ZÉG#3+)4W3F<$
%&'%-22$
?+,/05.&+,.$•! %&'%-22$&.$($')+5,FR>(.#F$24('#$gi$BL$#b3#)&Z#,4$4"(4$<+/5.#.$+,$
%A-$(,F$G2BW$–! CD$Z&00&+,$'(0(b&#.$e$CWm$Z&00&+,$x2-.$–! %A-d$9#+Z#4)*H$EY$3)#/&.&+,$DWm$_$S$_$EWcH$S$V$CRp$–! G2Bd$9)(6&4(1+,(0$')+\4"H$CY$3)#/&.&+,$Ñ$m$)#F."&`.$–! J#54)&,+$Z(..#.$(4$DWDCa$#i$–! g,r(1+,$3)+>#$510&S&,'$Z+)#$Z+F#.$4"(,$P0(,/K$
•! %#q#)H$I(.4#)H$?"#(3#)Ç$–! %&'%-22$&.$($')+5,FR>(.#F$#b3#)&Z#,4$"&'"0*$/+Z3#116#$\&4"$.3(/#$
#b3#)&Z#,4.W$–! G#.504.$>*$CDCD$–! ÖÖ$<(/4+)$+<$v$pD$>#0+\$ÖÖÖÖ$.3(/#$#b3#)&Z#,4.$
•! 2/&#,/#$&Z3)+6#F$>*$+6#)0(3$\&4"$&Z('&,'$.5)6#*.$7BL2H$@22!WW8$•! lI500$.K*n$(,F$/+Z30#4#$+6#)0(3$\&4"$@22!$.5)6#*$()#($&,$,#b4$F#/(F#$
3+..&>0#$>*$)#R.&1,'$%&'%-22$&,$.+54"#),$"#Z&.3"#)#W$
Lb4)($20&F#.$
%#*+,F$%A-d$J#54)&,+$=(..$
•! J#54)&,+$+./&00(1+,$Z#(5)#.$ÜZC$+<$,#54)&,+$Z(..#.W$
•! %&'%-22$3+\#)$.3#/4)5Z$<)+Z$'(0(b*$Z(3.$Z#(.5)#.$�ZÄ$4+$DWDCa$#i$
•! =(*$>#$.5á/&#,4$4+$$)#.+06#$"&#)()/"*$3)+>0#Z$$
%#*+,F$%A-d$g,r(1+,$•! %&'%-22$\&00$.5>.4(,1(00*$&Z3)+6#$+5)$K,+\0#F'#$+<$4"#$.0+3#$+<$4"#$
3)&Z+)F&(0$.3#/4)5ZW$
–! ?+Z>&,#.$\&4"$P0(,/K$–! 2&',&O/(,/#$\&00$F#3#,F$+,$4"#$,5Z>#)$+<$Z+F#.$&,$%&'%-22$7KZ(b8$
•! %&'%-22$\&00$"(6#$"&'"$.#,.&16&4*$4+$,+,R9(5..&(,&1#.$&,$4"#$#()0*$;,&6#).#W$
–! P0(,/K$.#,.&16&4*$<J@V$mH$%&'%-22$<J@V$pWM$–! %&.3#/4)5Z$+<$%&'%-22$Z(*$&Z3)+6#$4"&.$<5)4"#)$
P(k)" k /k0( )ns + 12#s ln(k / k0 )
" = # + fNL #2 $ # 2( ) + ...
