Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in...

23
1 September, 18, Rome , Italy Tunnel-Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias Anomaly Andrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA

Transcript of Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in...

Page 1: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

1  

September, 18, Rome , Italy

Tunnel-Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias Anomaly

Andrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy

in collaboration with

Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA

Page 2: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Giaver formula for tunnel current

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

2  

The image cannot be displayed. Your computer may not have enough memory to open the image, or the image may have been corrupted. Restart your computer, and then open the file again. If the red x still appears, you may have to delete the image and then insert it again.

The image cannot be displayed. Your computer may not have enough memory to open the image, or the image may have been corrupted. Restart your computer, and then open the file again. If the red x still appears, you may have to delete the image and then insert it again.

Zero bias anomaly in disordered metal (Altshuler, Aronov, 1979)

Page 3: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Fluctuation Renormalization of the density of states (E. Abrahams, M. Redi and E. Woo, 1970,

C. Di Castro, C. Castellani, R. Raimondi, A.Varlamov, 1990)

Page 4: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Manifestation of the SF DOS in tunneling conductivity (A.Varlamov, V. Dorin, 1983)

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

4  

Sum rule:

Page 5: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Δ Δ*

T>Tc T<Tc

Fluctuation pseudogap in tunneling conductivity

Page 6: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

6  

B. Sacepe, C. Chapelier, T. I. Baturina, V. M. Vinokur, M. R. Baklanov, M. Sanquer, 2010

Khachaturov, Chernyak, Belogolovsky, 1986

Fluctuation pseudogap in tunneling conductivity : Experimental confirmations

Page 7: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Diagrammatic approach (Varlamov, Dorin, 1983, Richardson, 1997)

Page 8: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

The equivalence with Giaver formula

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

8  

iων è eV+iδ

Page 9: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Tunnel fluctuoscopy

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

9  

Tunnel current:

We only need first order in transparency and fluctuations:

Page 10: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

10  

We use the following dimensionless parameters

à Two different contributions which need to be analytically continued

with °E=exp(°e)≈1.78…

Page 11: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Regular part

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

11  

Anomalous part

Page 12: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

12  

Page 13: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Complete result

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

13  

Full fluctuation contribution to the tunneling current:

with

Page 14: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Anomalous contribution at small voltages

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

14  

Page 15: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

conductance near Tc0

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

15  

The central peak disappears near t=1.36

Page 16: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

near Hc2(0)

16  

Page 17: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

17  

Page 18: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Tunneling conductance at h=0, near Tc0

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

18  

The non-linear behavior of the second term of the tunnel current is responsible for the fine structure (local maximum) at the center of the gap.

Temperature and voltage dependence of the tunneling conductance due to superconducting fluctuations. The overall behavior of both terms of the tunnel current results in a pronounce pseudo-gap structure of the conductance near the superconducting region.

1  

Page 19: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Tunneling conductance at t=0.05 above hc2(0)=0.69

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

19  

3  

Page 20: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

20  

conductance near hc2(t)

Page 21: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

21  

tunneling conductance plotted for t=s*x and h=s*hc2(x) for x2[0;1] and s=1.1 (2 different views)

ß view from “Tc0” to “Hc2(0)”

2  

Page 22: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

Pseudogap structure in experiments

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

22  

B. Sacepe et. al., Nature Comm.. 140, 1 (2010).

Tunneling conductance STM measurements on 3.6nm (a) 5nm (b) thick TiN films (»¼10nm). Tc=1.27K (a) or 0.98K (b)

Page 23: Tunnel- Fluctuoscopy: Fluctuation Induced Low-Bias AnomalyAndrey Varlamov SPIN-CNR, Italy in collaboration with Andreas Glatz, Valerii Vinokur (ANL), USA . Giaver formula for tunnel

ZBA in intrinsic Josephson Junctions

(V. Krasnov et al.) unpublished, 2013

Fluctuoscopy  of  Disordered  Two-­‐Dimensional  Superconductors  

23  

dI/

dV

(Ha

b=

16T

) /

dI/dV

(Hc=

16T

)dI/

dV

(Ha

b=

16T

) /

dI/dV

(Hc=

16T

)

dI/

dV

(Ha

b=

16T

) /

dI/dV

(Hc=

16T

)

Fig.3. The ratio of dI/dV in parallel fieldto that in the perpendicular field of 16 T.It shows clearly the superconductingparts of the spectra, which are suppressed by the c-axis field but less so by the field in the ab-plane. (a) a full-scale view at different T close to Tc.

(a)

(b)

(c)

peak

(c) Zoom-in into the zero-biasarea. The zero-bias peak is seen up to 95K, few degrees, corresponding to T/Tc~1.06

(b) Zoom-in into the peakarea. The residual of the superconducting peak is seenabove Tc~90K up to ~115K, corresponding to T/Tc~1.28.