Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

12
2&& /20)/,/(9 2".$) /' 2#/2*$5,452& '2/- &."*33".$& 4/ "*-#"5,4 &6*,,& "9 /.3 2#/2 2&&7/2+ .6*2/.-&.4", 2"$4*$& .42/%5$4*/. *85 @1DD5B>C ?6 7B?GD8 9> @<1>DC 1>4 DB55C 81F5 CE775CD54 D? ?2C5BF5BC D81D D85B5 =1I 25 E>45B<I9>7 BE<5C 1>4 D85B56?B5 >1DEB1< <1GC D81D 45D5B=9>5 @<1>D 7B?GD8 BD9CDC 1>4 C395>D9CDC 81F5 @?>45B54 D85C5 =ICD5B95C 1>4 C9>35 D85 6<?G5B9>7 ?6 (5>19CC1>35 D8?E78D 1DD5=@DC 81F5 255> =145 5>F9C9?> 9>85B5>D @B?@?BD9?>C 9> >1DEB5 7?F5B>9>7 D85 C81@5 ?6 <9F9>7 D89>7C 9>3<E49>7 DB55C D C55=C 1C 96 D85 CDE4I ?6 6?B= =?B@8?<?7I 81C 255> C53?>4 >1DEB5 D? D85 7B51D ?2C5BF5BC 1>4 D85B5 9C 1 >?2<5 <9>5175 9> D89C 6B?= #5?>1B4? 1 ,9>39 1>4 89C @9@5=?45< 1>4 1B51@B5C5BF9>7 D85?B95C D? ?5D85 1>4 89C 3?>35@D ?6 S@<1>D =5=?BIT ?5D85 3?>C945B54 D85 89CD?BI ?6 5F5>DC 16653D9>7 1 @<1>D D? 25 SGB9DD5> 9>T 9DC 6?B= D85B56?B5 96 =?B@8?<?79CD <51B>D D? B514 D89C 85 G?E<4 25 12<5 D? 9>D5B@B5D D85 6?B=1D9F5 B5<1D9?>C89@C 16653D9>7 @<1>DC 1 ,9>39TC 1>4 ?5D85TC 3?>35@DC 81F5 @B?F54 4EB12<5 9> 49665B5>D G1IC 1>4 ?665B @1D8C 6?B 5H@<?B9>7 B5<1D9?>C89@C 25DG55> 7B?GD8 @1DD5B>C 1>4 @8IC9?<?7931< @B?35CC5C *85 5=5B79>7 49C39@<9>5 ?6 DB55 =?B@8?<?7I 4B1GC ?> D85C5 1>4 ?D85B 7B51D @89<?C?@85BC 1>4 ?2C5BF5BC ?6 >1DEB5 B7E12<I =?B5 D81> 1>I ?D85B 1C@53D ?6 1B2?B93E<DEB5 =?B@8?<?7I ?G5C 9DC 45F5<?@=5>D D? 1 3?>F5B75>35 25DG55> 1BD 1>4 C395>35 -89<5 DB55 =?B@8?<?7I 81C 255> CDB?>7 9> 3?>D9>5>D1< EB?@5 9> B9D19> 9DC 9>6<E5>35 ?> 1B2?B93E<DEB5 81C 255> <9=9D54 9> @1BD 4E5 D? B5CDB93D54 1F19<129<9DI ?6 >7<9C8 DB1>C<1D9?> ?6 9=@?BD1>D D5HDC ?> D85 CE2:53D <C? 1C 51B<I G?B; 6?3EC54 ?> DB?@931< DB55C 1>4 6?B5CDC @5B81@C GB?>7<I B54E354 9>D5B5CD ?> D85 21C9C D81D D89C =1D5B91< G1C >?D B5<5F1>D D? D5=@5B1D5 B9D9C8 3?>49D9?>C 1>4 DB55 C@5395C ?G5F5B 9=@?BD1>D EB?@51> 3?>D5=@?B1BI DB55 =?B@8?<?79CDC 1<<5 (19=21E<D 1>4 (?<?66 81F5 @E2<9C854 1 CE2CD1>D91< 2?4I ?6 G?B; *89C 81C =E38 D? ?665B 1CC5CC=5>D =5D8?4C ?> =?B@8? @8IC9?<?7931< 21C9C G9D8 9=@?BD1>D DB55 =1>175=5>D 9=@<931D9?>C *B55 =?B@8?<?7I 9>3?B@?B1D5C 1B389D53DEB1< 29?=5381>931< 1>4 @8IC9?<?7931< 1C@53DC ?6 D85 DB55 1C G5<< 1C 1B51C ?6 C395>35 1>4 =1D85=1D93C CE38 1C 6B13D1<C 3?>4E39F5 D? 3?=@ED5B =?45<9>7 D? 5>81>35 E>45BCD1>49>7 ?6 DB55 7B?GD8 "5I G?B4C $?B@8?<?7I (19=21E<D 1 ,9>39 ?5D85 1<<5 92?>1339 8I4B1E<93 4B9F5> 1B389D53DEB5 @9@5D85?BI 1B51@B5C5BF9>7 BE<5 1H9?= ?6 E>96?B= CDB5CC @1@5B @B5C5>D54 1D S2&& /20)/,/(8 "24 )&/28 2"$4*$& *"(./34*$3 "."(&-&.4 +>9F5BC9DI ?6 D85 -5CD ?6 >7<1>4 B9CD?< D8 !E>5 9> D85 *B55G?B; >F9B?>=5>D1< 'B13D935 S>>?F1D9?>C 9> B2?B93E<DEB5T C5=9>1B C5B95C

Transcript of Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

Page 1: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

�2&&��/20)/,/(9 � ���2".$)�/' �2#/2*$5,452& '2/-��&."*33".$&�4/ �"*-#"5,4�

�&6*,,&��"9������/.3����������2#/2�������

�2&&7/2+��.6*2/.-&.4",��2"$4*$&

�.42/%5$4*/.

*85 @1DD5B>C�?6�7B?GD8�9> @<1>DC�1>4�DB55C 81F5�CE775CD54�D?�?2C5BF5BC�D81D�D85B5�=1I�25

E>45B<I9>7� BE<5C� 1>4� D85B56?B5� >1DEB1<� <1GC� D81D� 45D5B=9>5 @<1>D� 7B?GD8 �BD9CDC� 1>4

C395>D9CDC�81F5�@?>45B54�D85C5�=ICD5B95C�1>4��C9>35�D85�6<?G5B9>7�?6�(5>19CC1>35�D8?E78D�

1DD5=@DC�81F5�255> =145�5>F9C9?>�9>85B5>D @B?@?BD9?>C 9>�>1DEB5 7?F5B>9>7�D85�C81@5�?6

<9F9>7� D89>7C� 9>3<E49>7 DB55C D� C55=C� 1C� 96 D85� CDE4I� ?6� 6?B=� �=?B@8?<?7I� 81C 255>

C53?>4�>1DEB5�D?�D85�7B51D�?2C5BF5BC 1>4 D85B5�9C�1 >?2<5�<9>5175 9>�D89C 6B?= #5?>1B4? �1

,9>39 �1>4�89C @9@5�=?45< 1>4 1B51�@B5C5BF9>7� D85?B95C� D? �?5D85 �1>4� 89C 3?>35@D ?6

S@<1>D�=5=?BIT����?5D85 3?>C945B54 D85 89CD?BI�?6�5F5>DC�16653D9>7�1�@<1>D D?�25 SGB9DD5>

9>T 9DC 6?B=� D85B56?B5�96�=?B@8?<?79CD�<51B>D�D? B514 D89C�85�G?E<4�25�12<5�D?�9>D5B@B5D�D85

6?B=1D9F5�B5<1D9?>C89@C�16653D9>7�@<1>DC

�1�,9>39TC�1>4 �?5D85TC 3?>35@DC�81F5�@B?F54�4EB12<5�9>�49665B5>D�G1IC�1>4�?665B�@1D8C

6?B� 5H@<?B9>7� B5<1D9?>C89@C� 25DG55> 7B?GD8� @1DD5B>C� 1>4� @8IC9?<?7931<� @B?35CC5C *85

5=5B79>7�49C39@<9>5�?6�DB55�=?B@8?<?7I�4B1GC�?>�D85C5�1>4�?D85B�7B51D�@89<?C?@85BC�1>4

?2C5BF5BC� ?6� >1DEB5��B7E12<I =?B5� D81>� 1>I�?D85B� 1C@53D� ?6� 1B2?B93E<DEB5 =?B@8?<?7I

?G5C�9DC�45F5<?@=5>D�D?�1�3?>F5B75>35 25DG55> 1BD�1>4�C395>35

-89<5�DB55�=?B@8?<?7I�81C�255> CDB?>7�9>�3?>D9>5>D1<��EB?@5� 9>��B9D19> 9DC 9>6<E5>35 ?>

1B2?B93E<DEB5 81C�255>�<9=9D54��9>�@1BD�4E5�D? B5CDB93D54�1F19<129<9DI ?6��>7<9C8�DB1>C<1D9?>

?6�9=@?BD1>D D5HDC�?>�D85�CE2:53D��<C?�1C�51B<I�G?B;�6?3EC54 ?>�DB?@931<�DB55C�1>4�6?B5CDC

@5B81@C� GB?>7<I� B54E354� 9>D5B5CD� ?>� D85� 21C9C� D81D� D89C� =1D5B91<� G1C� >?D� B5<5F1>D� D?

D5=@5B1D5� �B9D9C8� 3?>49D9?>C� 1>4� DB55� C@5395C� �?G5F5B�� 9=@?BD1>D� �EB?@51>

3?>D5=@?B1BI DB55� =?B@8?<?79CDC ��1<<5�� (19=21E<D� 1>4� (?<?66�� 81F5 @E2<9C854� 1

CE2CD1>D91< 2?4I� ?6� G?B;� *89C 81C =E38� D?� ?665B 1CC5CC=5>D� =5D8?4C� ?> =?B@8?�

@8IC9?<?7931< 21C9C G9D8� 9=@?BD1>D DB55� =1>175=5>D� 9=@<931D9?>C *B55� =?B@8?<?7I

9>3?B@?B1D5C�1B389D53DEB1<��29?=5381>931<�1>4�@8IC9?<?7931<�1C@53DC�?6�D85�DB55�1C�G5<<�1C

1B51C ?6� C395>35� 1>4�=1D85=1D93C CE38� 1C 6B13D1<C 3?>4E39F5� D?� 3?=@ED5B�=?45<9>7� D?

5>81>35�E>45BCD1>49>7�?6�DB55�7B?GD8

"5I� G?B4C�� $?B@8?<?7I�� (19=21E<D�� �1� ,9>39� �?5D85�� �1<<5�� �92?>1339�� 8I4B1E<93�

4B9F5>�1B389D53DEB5��@9@5�D85?BI��1B51�@B5C5BF9>7�BE<5��1H9?=�?6�E>96?B=�CDB5CC

���@1@5B�@B5C5>D54�1D�S�2&&��/20)/,/(8����"24�����)&/28����2"$4*$&���*"(./34*$3��

�"."(&-&.4� +>9F5BC9DI�?6�D85�-5CD�?6��>7<1>4���B9CD?<� ��D8�!E>5� ���� 9>�D85

*B55G?B;��>F9B?>=5>D1<�'B13D935 S >>?F1D9?>C�9>��B2?B93E<DEB5T C5=9>1B�C5B95C

Page 2: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

�#3&26*.(��/2-

$?B@8?<?7I� 9C� D85� CDE4I� ?6� D85� =1>I� 1>4� F1B954� 6?B=C� ?6� D89>7C� >� 29?<?7I� D89C

C@5396931<<I�B565BC�D?�D85�6?B=�?6�?B71>9C=C�-85>�G5�3?>C945B�DB55�=?B@8?<?7I��G5�31CD

?EB�=9>4� ?>� D85� DB55� 1C� 1 29?<?7931<� 5>D9DI�� C@5396931<<I� ?>� D85� F9CE1<� @B?@5BD95C� ?6� 9DC

CDBE3DEB5� 1>4� 6?B= $?B@8?<?7I� @B?F945C� 1� B1D9?>1<� 21C9C� 6?B� =1;9>7� D85� B5<1D9?>C89@

25DG55>� D85� 9>D5B>1<� 1>4� 5HD5B>1<� @B?@5BD95C� ?6� 1>� ?B71>9C=� 5H@<939D�� @B?F949>7� 1

D85?B5D931<�21C9C� 6?B�E>45BCD1>49>7� D85� 6?B=1D9F5�@?G5BC�?6�?B71>93� CDBE3DEB5C�(1D9?>1<

=?B@8?<?7I� D85B56?B5� C55;C� D? =1;5� 9>D5<<9792<5� 6B?=� CICD5=1D93� 5F945>35� D85 <1GC� ?6

@B?35CC5C�9>6<E5>39>7 ?B71>93 6?B=

-89<5� DB55�=?B@8?<?7I 81C�255>�45F5<?@54�1C 1�CDE4I�49C39@<9>5� 1C�1B2?B93E<DEB9CDC�G5

C9=@<I�=1;5�5H@<939D�1�>1DEB1<� D5>45>3I�D?�?2C5BF5�6?B=�9>�D85�G?B<4�G5�9>8129D��B?=

9>61>3I� D85� 1DDB92ED5C� 1>4� AE1<9D95C� ?6� D85� G?B<4� G5 ?2C5BF5 9=@<939D<I� 9>6?B=� ?EB

@5B35@D9?>C�1>4�5@9CD5=?<?7I�*89C� 9>D5B>1<9J1D9?>�?6 D85�?2C5BF54�G?B<4� 9C�5CC5>D91<� D?

?EB�129<9DI D?�B5C@?>4�D?�1>4�3?==E>931D5�12?ED�D85�G?B<4�G5�<9F5�9>�*85B56?B5��D?75D85B

G9D8�?EB�9>61>D�C5<F5C��G5 1B5�1<<�>1DEB1<�=?B@8?<?79CDC > C5>C?BI�D5B=C��G5�1B5�D1@@9>7

1 8E=1>�613E<DI�D81D�79F5C�D85�31@139DI�D?�49CD9>7E9C8�C81@5C�1>4�S1>>?D1D5T�1>4�S3<1CC96IT

D85C5� C?� D81D� G5� 1B5� 12<5� D?� =1;5� 3?=@1B9C?>C� 1>4� B53?7>9J5� 651DEB5C� 9>� D85� >1DEB1<

G?B<4�*89C� 6EB>9C85C�EC�G9D8� D85�129<9DI� D?�1C3B925 49665B5>D� DI@5C�?6�=51>9>7 1>4� D8EC

49CD9>7E9C8�25DG55>� D85�49665B5>D�F9CE1<� 6?B=C 1DD13854� D? 49665B5>D� C@5395C�?6� DB55C�1>4

@<1>DC *85�=?B5�12<5�G5�1B5�D?�B53?7>9J5�1>4�4569>5�CE38�AE1<9D95C��D85�25DD5B�5AE9@@54

G5 1B5�D?�3?==E>931D5�12?ED�D85�6?B=�?6�D89>7C�D8B?E78�1F19<12<5�=5491

*85� 6?B=1<� CDE4I� ?6�=?B@8?<?7I� 1>4� D85� 9>85B5>D� D5>45>3I� D?� B5C@?>4� D?� 6?B=� 9>� D85

>1DEB1<� G?B<4 4B1GC� ?> 2?D8� 15CD85D93� 1>4� C395>D9693 613E<D95C� >� D85� 1B2?B93E<DEB1<

49C39@<9>5� D89C B5C?>1D5C�G9D8�=1>I�?6�D85�B51C?>C�G8I�D8?C5�G8?�81F5�253?=5�9>F?<F54

G9D8� DB55C� 1B5� 4B1G>� D?� D89C� 695<4� ?6 CDE4I D� 3?E<4� 25� 3?>C945B54� D81D� =?45B>

1B2?B93E<DEB5� ?B979>1D54� G9D8� D85� B5>19CC1>35� =9>4�� G8938� C?E78D� D?� 2B9>7� ?B45B� D?� 1

G?B<4 @B5F9?EC<I�493D1D54�2I�B5<979?EC�CE@5BCD9D9?> 1>4�G8938�9C�C?�G5<<�5H@B5CC54�9>�D85

G?B;C�?6�#5?>1B4?�41�,9>39��G8?�?2C5BF54�1>4�31D1<?7E54�D85�>1DEB1<�G?B<4�D8B?E78�89C

1BD 1<C? 1DD5=@D54�D?�1>1<IJ5�9DC�3?>D5>D� D8B?E78� D85�1@@<931D9?>�?6�=1D85=1D93C��1>4�1C

CE38�=978D 25�3?>C945B54�D?�25�1�6?E>49>7�61D85B�?6�3<1CC931<�@<1>D�1>4�DB55�=?B@8?<?7I

(5>19CC1>35 >1DEB1<�@89<?C?@8I C?E78D�D?�E>45BCD1>4�E>45B<I9>7�@B9>39@<5C�7?F5B>9>7�D85

6E>3D9?>9>7� ?6� >1DEB5� G89<5� 1<C?� 1DD5=@D9>7 D? E>96I� D85C5 ?2C5BF1D9?>C G9D8

=5D1@8IC93C�*85�DB55�2531=5�1�=5D1@8?B� D85�DBE>; B5@B5C5>D9>7 D85�@8IC931<�G?B<4�1>4

D85� 2B1>385C =?B1<C�� =54939>5�� 1>4� =5381>93C �1B<I� F95GC� ?6� D85C5� 1BB1>75=5>DC

3?>C945B54� 9D�5CC5>D91<� D81D�=5D1@8IC93C �B5@B5C5>D54�2I� D85�B??DC�?6� D85� DB55� C8?E<4�25

D85� @B9=1BI� 6?E>41D9?>� ?>� G8938� D85� =?B5� =1D5B91<� 1C@53DC� �DBE>;� 1>4� 2B1>385C�� 1B5

5CD12<9C854 -89<5 D?41I G5� =1I� 69>4� D85C5� 9451C� 1>138B?>9CD93�� D89C� >?>5D85<5CC

9<<ECDB1D5C D85� ?B979>1<� 3?>F5B75>35� ?6� D85� 1BDC� 1>4� C395>35C�� 2?D8� ?6�G8938� 9>6?B=� DB55

=?B@8?<?7I�

�B95C38���������� �)&��$*&.$&�".%��)*,/3/0)8�/'�4)&��2(".*3-� �F?<C�%5G�/?B;���$)��(5@B9>D�54�

?B979>1<<I�@E2<9C854�2I��41=�1>4��81B<5C��<13;��#?>4?>�������������(ECC5<<��� �)&��2/#,&-3�/'��/%&2.��)*,/3/0)8 ��������&+'��+)�

Page 3: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

*85 @CI38?<?7931<� 31@139DI� D?� ?2C5BF5� 6?B= 9C� 9>85B5>D<I� <9>;54� D?� ?D85B� 1C@53DC� ?6

C5>C?BI�5H@5B95>35�1>4�9>D5<<53DE1<�@B?35CC5C�*89C�81C�1>�15CD85D93�1>4�C@1D91<�49=5>C9?>

1D�D85�=13B?�<5F5<�1>4��9>�29?<?7931<�D5B=C��=1I�25�<9>;54�D?�@8IC9?<?7931<�@B?35CC�1D�D85

=93B? <5F5< *85�5H@<?B1D9?>�?6 B5<1D9?>C89@C�25DG55> DB55 6?B=��CDBE3DEB5��@8IC9?<?7931<

@B?35CC5C 1>4� 6E>3D9?> 1B5� 1C@53DC� ?6� D85� 3?=@<5H� CDE4I� ?6� DB55� =?B@8?<?7I� *8EC�

=?B@8?<?7I� 9>� DB55C�3?>C945BC� D85 C81@5�1>4�49C@?C9D9?> ?6�CD5=� B??D��2B1>38 1>4� DG97

1BB1>75=5>DC� 1C�G5<<�1C 381B13D5B9CD93C�?6 2E4� <516� 6<?G5B 1>4�6BE9D

*B55�=?B@8?<?7I D1;5C 9>D?�3?>C945B1D9?>�?2C5BF1D9?>�?6�D85�DB55�1D�49665B5>D�CD175C�9>�D85

1759>7� @B?35CC� 1>4� 8?G C81@5� 1>4� 7B?GD8� @1DD5B>� 381B13D5B9CD93C =1I� F1BI� 6B?= 1

3?>F5>D9?>1<� =?45<� ?6� D85� C@5395C� 1D� 1� 79F5>� 175� E>45B� 49665B5>D� 29?D93� ?B� 129?D93

3?>49D9?>C�'8IC9?<?7931< 9>6<E5>35C ?6�9>3B51C54�<978D��5H@?CEB5��<?149>7��5D3 1D�1�=13B?�

<5F5<�=1I 16653D�D85�C81@5�1>4�7B?GD8�@1DD5B>C ?6�D85 DBE>;�1>4�2B1>38 CICD5= 1>4�=1I

<514�D?�S4917>?CD93CT D81D�9>�DEB> 9>6?B= =1>175=5>D�3?>C945B1D9?>C *85�=?B@8?<?7931<

@5B35@D9?>C�?6�$1DD853;�1>4��B5<?5B�

5H5=@<96I� D89C� 3?>F5B75>35�25DG55>� C395>35� 1>4

1BD� G85B59>� D85 9>D5B@B5D1D9?>� ?6 F9CE1<� B5@B5C5>D1D9?>C ?6� 141@D9F5� 7B?GD8 9>� DB55C 9C

3?>C945B54�D?�B56<53D�1 @?CC92<5 E>45B<I9>7�<1G�?6�>1DEB5� SD85�1H9?=�?6�E>96?B=�CDB5CCT

-85B51C =?B@8?<?7931<� ?2C5BF1D9?>C ?6� 7B?GD8� 456?B=1D9?>C =978D� 1D� ?>5� D9=5� 81F5

255>�3?>C945B54�D?�9>4931D5 1>�9>5F9D12<5 45C97>�G51;>5CC5C�9>�D85�>1DEB1<�1B389D53DEB5�?6

D85� DB55� @5B35@D9?>C�?6�29?=5381>93C 133?B49>7� D? 141@D9F5� 7B?GD8�?665B� 1>� 1<D5B>1D9F5

1>4� @?D5>D91<<I� =?B5� EC56E< F95G D81D 3?>C945BC =?B5� CE2D<5 B5<1D9?>C89@ 25DG55>

=5381>931<�6?B=�1>4�6E>3D9?>�

�&."*33".$&�4/��2&3&.4��"9��/20)/,/(9

$?45B>� DB55�=?B@8?<?7I 81C 2?BB?G54� 6B?= =1>I� ?D85B� C@85B5C� ?6� C395>35� 9>3<E49>7

6B13D1<�75?=5DBI D? =?45<�DB55 2B1>389>7�CDBE3DEB5C�*85 3?>35@D ?6�6B13D1<C 5=2?495C�D85

>?D9?>�D81D DB55C�1B5�3?=@?C54�?6�C5<6�C9=9<1B ?B�SB53EBC9F5<I�3?>CDBE3D54T 5<5=5>DC��5138

?6�G8938�3?>D19>C 1�=9>91DEB5�?6�D85�5>D9B5�45C97> �?>F5BC5<I��;>?G<5475�?6 D85�45C97>

BE<5C ?6�1>I�@1BD�3?E<4�25�EC54�D? 3?>CDBE3D D85�G8?<5 *89C�1@@B?138�D?�=?B@8?<?7931<

=?45<9>7�?665BC�1�=5D8?4�6?B 75>5B1D9>7�9>3B5=5>D1<��S?B71>93T�7B?GD8�G9D8?ED�D85�>554

6?B�45D19<54�;>?G<5475�?6 1>1D?=93 3?=@?C9D9?> ?B�@8IC9?<?7931< @B?35CC

�*(�����.�&8"-0,&�/'�"�'2"$4",�*3�"�'&2.�,&"'�%&3*(.���"$)

*.%*6*%5",�,&"',&4�2&*4&2"4&3�4)&�&.4*2&�,&"'�

�$1DD853;�������B5<?5B���������� �)&��/%8��".(5"(&�/'��2&&3 ���)".%#//+�'/2�'"*,52&�".",83*3

�(B5C51B38�6?B��=5>9DI�*B55C ���*85�)D1D9?>1BI�&66935��#?>4?>�#?>C41<5����� ���� �2&&��/20)/,/(8�*.��&,"4*/.�4/��&$)".*$",����)83*/,/(*$",��"$4/23� >�@B5CC

Page 4: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

*85�D5>45>3I�6?B�DB55 @1BDC D?�B56<53D�1>4 =9=93�D85 5>D9B5�DB55�6?B= 81C�255>�CDE4954�1>4

5H@B5CC54� 9>� D5B=C� ?6� SB59D5B1D9F5� 7B?GD8T� *89C� 9>85B5>D� @B?@5BDI 81C� 255>� CDE4954� 9>

D5B=C� ?6 1> 5>5B75D93� CICD5= D81D� 9C� 9>6<E5>354� 2I� D85� >554� D?� 3?>C5BF5� G1D5B� 6<?G

D8B?E78�DB1>C@?BD1D9?>�@1D8C��G89<5 ?@D9=9J9>7 @?D5>D91<�6?B�CEB6135�12C?B@D9?> ?6�5>5B7I�

-85D85B #5?>1B4?�41�,9>39 3?E<4�25�3?>C945B54�D?�25 1�6?E>49>7�61D85B�?6�1B2?B93E<DEB5

?B� >?D�� 6B?=� 1�=?45B>� @5BC@53D9F5� 85� 3<51B<I� D??;� 1�=?B@8?<?7931< F95G��5� 5H@<?B54

>1DEB1<� @1DD5B>C� 9> DB55 7B?GD8� 1>4� 6?B=� 1>4� 1CCE=54� D81D� D85B5� G1C� 1� B5<1D9?>C89@

25DG55> D85 @1BDC�?6�D85�DB55�6B?=�D85�C9>7E<1B DBE>;�D?�D85 =5=25BC�?6�D85 =?B5�3?=@<5H

2B1>38�CICD5= �5�3?>D5=@<1D54 S1�>1DEB1<�?B45BT� 1�<1G�?6�>1DEB5 D81D G?E<4�25 31@12<5

?6�259>7 5H@B5CC54 9> =1D85=1D931< D5B=C 1>4 @B5493D9>7 D85 @B?@?BD9?>C 1>4�49CDB92ED9?>

?6�2B1>38 7B?GD8 1>4 @?C9D9?>�?6�<516 9>C5BD9?>

(5>19CC1>35 @19>D5BC 5H@<?B54�CE38�>1DEB1<� B5<1D9?>C89@C�1>4�C?E78D� D?�5H@B5CC� D85C5�1C

1>�9>85B5>D�15CD85D93�@B54931D54�?>�D85�=1D85=1D93C�?6�D85�D9=5�*85�C@9B1< 1BB1>75=5>DC

1>4�D85�C@139>7�?6�2B1>385C�?> D85�DBE>; G5B5�D5CD1=5>D�D? CE38 S49F9>5T @B?@?BD9?>C *89C

3?>:?9>9>7�?6� C395>35� 1>4�1BD� 9C� 5F945>D� 9>�@19>D9>7C�?6� D85� D9=5�1>4 9C B56<53D54� 9>� D85

�?<45>�)53D9?>�?B�$51>��25<95F54�D?�25 5=2?4954 9> D85�B1D9?������� �9>3?B@?B1D9>7�D85

@B9>39@<5� D81D� D85�G8?<5� 9C� 3?>D19>54� 9>� D85�@1BDC� 1>4�F935�F5BC1� *89C 3?>35@D� 9C EC54

D?41I� 9>�E>45BCD1>49>7� @8I<?D1H9C 1>4� 9C 5H@B5CC54 =1D85=1D931<<I 9>��92?>1339�

B1D9?C

D81D�4569>5�>1DEB1<�7B?GD8�6?B=C CE38�1C D85�F?BD5H�?6�>1ED9<EC�C85<<C�1>4�D85�C@9B1< C554

3?>5C�1>4 ?6�2B1>38�9>C5BD9?>C�

�*(��� �/20)/,/(*$",�0"44&2.3 *.�"�0*.&�$/.&� �*#/."$$*�.5-#&23 "2&�$/.3*%&2&%�4/

&-#/%9 "�$/%& %&3$2*#*.( 30*2",�(2/74) ".%�)/7�4)*.(3�"2& /04*-",,9 ;0"$+&%< *.

."452&�

�(19=21E<D�� '� ������ �)83*/,/(*$",� �*"(./3*3� *85� @B?35549>7C� ?6� D85� C53?>4� �EB?@51>� 3?>7B5CC� 9>

1B2?B93E<DEB5��,5BC19<<5C� �����)5@D5=25B��������)?395D5��B1>319C5�4T�B2?B93E<DEB5��1<<5�����&<45=1>>��������*?=<9>C?=��'��������� �2/0*$",��2&&3����/2&343 �".�"2$)*4&$452",

".",83*3� )@B9>75B�,5B<17��%5G�/?B;��+)��

#5?>1B4? �92?>1339�G1C�1�� D8

�5>DEBI�=1D85=1D9391> >�=1D85=1D93C�� D85��92?>1339�>E=25BC�6?B=�1

C5AE5>35� 4569>54� SB53EBC9F5<IT� 2I� >E=25BC� CD1BD9>7� 6B?=� J5B?�� G85B5� 5138� ?>5� 9C� D85� @B?4E3D� ?6� D85

@B5F9?EC�DG?�<?G5B�?B45B�>E=25BC��6?B=9>7�1>�9>3B5=5>D1<�C5AE5>35������������ ��������������� �� 5D3�&>5�?6

D85� @B?@5BD95C ?6� �92?>1339� >E=25BC� 9C� D81D� >E=25BC� 12?F5� �� 1@@B?H9=1D5� D?� ����� D9=5C� D85� @B53549>7

>E=25B ��?<45>�$51>��C55��??D>?D5���

�� 7?<45>�B1D9? 9C�4569>54�2I�DG?�AE1>D9D95C G85B5 D85�CE=�?6�D85�DG?�9C 9>�5AE1<�@B?@?BD9?>�1C�D85 <1B75B

@1BD�1C�D85�<1B75B�@1BD�9C�D?�D85�C=1<<5B�@1BD�*8EC�96��1��9C�D85�<1B75B�1>4��2��9C�D85�C=1<<5B�D85>�1���21�� 1� 2�

Page 5: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

�/&4)& ".%�4)& #&(*..*.(3 /' -/%&2. 0,".4�-/20)/,/(9

�<1CC931<�=?B@8?<?7I D5>454�D?�6?3EC�=?B5 ?>�D85 3?>>53D9?> 25DG55>�6?B=C�D81>�?>�D85

=?B@8?75>93�?B�141@D9F5 @B?35CC5C D81D�9>6<E5>35 D85=��1>4�1B5�?2F9?EC<I�@B5��1BG9>91>

$?B@8?<?7931<� CDE4I� 9>� 9DC� BE<5�C55;9>7� =5D8?4� 1DD5=@DC� D?� 45B9F5 CD1>41B4C 6?B

3?=@1B9C?> 25DG55>� ?B71>9C=C� D?� @B?F945� 1� 21C9C� 6?B� 3<1CC96931D9?>� 6?B� 1<<� ;9>4C� ?6

@EB@?C5C��@1BD93E<1B<I�D8B?E78�D85�945>D96931D9?>�?6�651DEB5C�D81D�1B5�C9=9<1B��8?=?<?7?EC�

=?B@8?<?7931<�3?BB5C@?>45>35��1>4 D8?C5�D81D�1B5 1D�F1B91>35�6B?=�8?=?<?795C �<1CC931<

=?B@8?<?7I� D85B56?B5 2E9<D� ?> 1> �B9CD?D5<91>� =?45< @5B359F9>7 >1DEB5� 9>� D5B=C� ?6

9451<9J54 6?B=C�,1B91D9?>C 6B?=�D85�9451< 9>4931D54 1�49CC?>1>35�9>�B5<1D9?>�D? 1> 9451<�

!?81>>� �?5D85 ��������� � =978D� 25 B571B454 D?� 25 1� 61D85B� ?6 S=?45B>T @<1>D

=?B@8?<?7I �?5D85 G1C�1�@?<I=1D8� 1 @<1IGB978D 1>4 1ED8?B�?6�D85�3<1CC93�G?B; �"534�

1C�G5<<�1C�1 @89<?C?@85B��@?5D�1>4�2?D1>9CD �E9<49>7�?>�@B5F9?EC�2?D1>931<�3?>35@DC�?6

D85� <516� 259>7� 1� CE@@B5CC54� 2B1>38�� 85 45F5<?@54� D85 @5B81@C� 3EB9?EC 9451 ?6 D85� <516

259>7 D85� =?CD� 6E>41=5>D1<� 6?B=� 9>� @<1>DC D81D 1<<� ?D85B� CDBE3DEB5C 1B5 45B9F54 6B?=�

3?>359F9>7 1�DB1>C6?B=1D9?>1<�@B?35CC G85B52I @<1>D�?B71>C �C5@1<C��@5D1<C��CD1=5>C� 5D3�

1<<�B5<1D5�D?�D89C 3?==?> <516 1B385DI@5 *85�<516�9>�89C�F95G�G1C�1�75>5B1<9J54�@<1>�6?B

D85�S8?=?<?7IT�?6�1<<�?D85B�?B71>C *85�S5F5BID89>7�9C�<516T�3?>35@D�=978D�25�3?>C945B54

D?�25�B54E3D9F5 2ED��?5D85TC�F95G�G1C�=?B5�3?=@<5H�D81>�D89C�� 9>�D81D�85�3?>359F54�?6

=?B@8?<?7I 4I>1=931<<I�-89<5�<51F5C�B5C5=2<5�?>5�1>?D85B��5138�C@5395CT� <516�31>�25

3<51B<I� 945>D96954 �EBD85B=?B5�� 9>� D1;9>7� D85� <51F5C� 7B?G9>7� ?>� 1>� 9>49F94E1<� C8??D� 9>

D859B�C5AE5>35�6B?=�?<45CD�D?�I?E>75CD� D85 <516�C5B95C��G89<5�C8?G9>7�3<51B<I�D81D�5138�9C

C9=9<1B�D?�D85�?D85B��1<C?�45=?>CDB1D5C�1>�E>45B<I9>7 @B?7B5CC9?>�*89C�D85=5�9C�45CDB?I54

96�D85�?B45B�?6�<51F5C�9C�C8E66<54

�?5D85�1B7E5C�D81D 1�>1DEB1<�?B45B�?6�3?>D9>E?EC�=?F5=5>D�31>�25�@5B359F54 1>4�D81D��2I

5HD5>C9?>�� 96� G5� 3?E<4� 25� CE669395>D<I� DB19>54�� G5� G?E<4� 25� 9>� 1� @?C9D9?>� D? 25DD5B

E>45BCD1>4� D85� 4I>1=93 <965�89CD?BI� ?6� 1>� 9>49F94E1<� @<1>D�� SGB9DD5>� 9>D?T� 9DC� 6?B= �5

D5B=54�D89C�=?B@8?<?7931<�B53?B4�S@<1>D�=5=?BIT 1>4�89C�F95GC�?6�C395>D9693�@5B35@D9?>

=978D� 25� 3?>C945B54� D?� C9D� G9D8� =?45B>� 3?>35@DC� ?6� D85 (&34",43 �9>� G8938� D85� G8?<5

B5@B5C5>DC�C?=5D89>7�?6�D85�5CC5>D91<�381B13D5B9CD93C�?6�D85�@1BDC���

�?5D85TC 3?>35@D�?6 S4I>1=93�?B45BT 1>4 S@<1>D =5=?BIT <9>;C�=?B@8?<?7I�G9D8�9>D5B>1<

@8IC9?<?7931<�@B?35CC��

��?5D85�6EBD85B�45F5<?@54 D89C� D85=5�2I�3?>C945B9>7�D81D� 9>�D85

31C5�?6�D85�C5AE5>D91<�?B45B�?6�<51F5C��D85�E>45B<I9>7�DB5>4 1@@51BC�75>5B1D54�>?D�2I�D85

9>49F94E1<�<51F5C�2ED�2I�D85�=?F5=5>D�9DC5<6��9>4931D9>7�D?�89=�1�<1G�?6�>1DEB5�D81D� 1719>

96�E>45BCD??4��3?E<4�25�EC54�D?�75>5B1D5�>5G�6?B=C�

>�89C�C395>35�� D85�B53?7>9D9?> ?6

�)?�9D�3?E<4�25�C194�D81D�=?B@8?<?7I�=978D�81F5�B??DC�5F5>�213;�D?��

D8�5>DEBI����@89<?C?@8I��G9D8

�B9CD?D<5TC�F95G�?6�D85�S5CC5>35T�?6�1�D89>7�259>7�D85�49CD9>3D9F5�AE1<9D95C�G9D8?ED�G8938�9D�31>>?D�25

E>45BCD??4�?B�49C3ECC54��

(?>1<4����B14I� �/2-�".%��"53&�*.��/&4)&�3��/20)/,/(8 9>��=B9>5����1>4�0E3;5B����!�54C� �/&4)&

".%�4)&��$*&.$&3 ����&"002"*3",���/34/.��45%*&3�*.�4)&��)*,/3/0)8�/'��$*&.$&��F?<���� �?B4B538D��������

'?BD=1>>����������� �/&4)&�".%�4)&��/.$&04�/'��&4"-/20)/3*3�(5945<�'E2<9C89>7��?=@���?CD?>��9>�

�/&4)&�".%�4)&��$*&.$&3 �)') ����

�B25B���������� �)&�."452",�0)*,/3/0)8�/'�0,".4�'/2-� �1=2B9475��+"���1=2B9475�+>9F5BC9DI�'B5CC

Page 6: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

D89C�@B?35CC�B5F51<C�1�=1>965CD�AE1<9DI�9>�D85�6?B=�D81D��G89<5�259>7�C5>CE1<<I�@5B359F54�

9C�>?>5D85<5CC�3?>4E39F5�D?�?2:53D9F5�1>1<IC9C��

�*(� � �)&� = 20',".:&�� �/&4)&<3

"2$)&490",� 0,".4 $/.$&04� '/2-�� '2/-

7)*$)� ",,� 0,".43� "2& %&2*6&%�� �)*3� -*()4

#&�$/.3*%&2&%�4/�#&�"�-/20)/,/(*$",�0,".4

0"4&.4�

�&/."2%/<3�-/20)/,/(*$",�$/.$&043�/'�4)&�42&&�".%�*43�2&,"4*/.3)*0�4/�)9%2/,/(9

#5?>1B4? 41�,9>39 3?>C945B54 D81D D85 B1=96954�45C97>�?6 DB55 1B389D53DEB5�G1C 9>6<E5>354

2I�8I4B?<?7I�1>4 6E>3D9?>54�D8B?E78�>1DEB1<<I�4569>54 B1D9?C CE38�D81D�?F5B1<<�1B51C�1B5

3?>C5BF54 1>4�B5@<931D54�6B?=�C53D9?>�?6�89785B�?B45B�@1BDC� D?�<?G5B�?B45B�@1BDC *8EC�

9<<ECDB1D54� 9>� 1� C;5D38� 6B?=� 89C� >?D52??; �C55� �97� ���� 96� =51CEB54 1D 1>I� ?>5 <5F5<� ?6

2B1>389>7 D85 D?D1<�3B?CC�C53D9?>1<�1B51 ?6�5138�2B1>38 G?E<4�25 5AE1< D? =51CEB5C�D1;5>

1D�1>I ?D85B�<5F5<��

*89C�85�B571B454�D?�25�1 =1D85=1D931< 5H@B5CC9?>�?6�1 895B1B38931<

<9>;� 25DG55>� <?G5B� ?B45B� 1>4� 89785B� ?B45B� 2B1>385C�� 95 D85� CE=C� ?6� D85� 491=5D5BC� ?6

389<4�2B1>385C 1B5 5AE1<�D?�D81D�?6�D85�?B979>1D9>7�89785B�?B45B�CD5=��1>4�D85B56?B5�D?�D85

?B979>1D9>7�DBE>;�491=5D5B��*89C�BE<5�G?E<4�1@@<I 1D�5F5BI�CD175�?6�85978D��C55��97�����C

D89C�1@@<95C�D?�D85�3B?CC�C53D9?>1<�1B51C�1D�D85C5�@?9>DC�9D 9C ;>?G>�1C D85�S1B51�@B5C5BF9>7

BE<5T

��*89C�=5D8?4931<�1@@B?138�D?�@5B359F9>7�1>4�?2C5BF9>7�>1DEB5�1C�1�G1I�?6�=1;9>7�@<1>D�6?B=�9>D5<<9792<5

2531=5�;>?G>�1C�1�S�?5D851> )D5@T�2ED�G1C�=?B5�6?3ECC54�?>�B5149>7�D85�4I>1=93�E>45B<I9>7�@B?35CC

75>5B1D9>7�6?B=�B1D85B�D81>�D85�SC>1@C8?DT�1@@B?138�?6�D1;9>7�5F945>35�1D�1>I�?>5�D9=5�1C�4569>9>7�6?B=�1C

1>�9>4931D9?>�?6�1�CD1D93�3?>49D9?>��

(938D5B�!�'��������*85�#9D5B1BI�-?B;C�?6�#5?>1B4?�41�,9>39� �F?<C�&H6?B4 +>9F5BC9DI�'B5CC��#?>4?>

Page 7: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

�*(52& � �&/."2%/ %"�!*.$*<3�$/.$&04�/'�4)&

;"2&"�02&3&26*.(� 25,&< ��*$)4&2� � �� 0,"4&

����� �2&&� #2".$)*.(� 0"44&2.3� *.� &"$)� /'� 4)&

"2$3�*.%*$"4&�4)"4�4)& 4)*$+.&33�/'�#2".$)&3�*3

&15",� 4/� /.&� "./4)&2� ".%� 4/� 4)&� 4/4",� 425.+

4)*$+.&33�

�/��&/."2%/�%"�!*.$*��"�42&&�7"3�"�2*6&2�/.�&.%�

�1�,9>39 ?2C5BF54 D81D���<<�D85�2B1>385C�?6�1�DB55�1D�5F5BI�CD175�?6�9DC�85978D�G85>�@ED

D?75D85B�1B5�5AE1<�9>�D893;>5CC�D?�D85�DBE>;U�<<�D85�2B1>385C�?6 G1D5B 1D�5F5BI�CD175�?6

9DC�3?EBC5��96�D85I�1B5�?6�5AE1<�B1@949DI��1B5�5AE1<�D?�D85�2?4I�?6�D85�=19>�CDB51=���

>�41

,9>39TC�F95G�D85 DB55 B5@B5C5>DC 1>�9>F5BD54�B9F5B�CICD5=� G85B5 D85�895B1B38931<

1BB1>75=5>D 9C B56<53D54�9>�CDB51=�>5DG?B;C� G9D8 89785B�?B45B E@CDB51= 3?=@?>5>DC

6<?G9>7�9>D? <?G5B�?B45B�3?>6<E5>35C�-89<5�6<?G�B1D5C�=1I�381>75��D85�F?<E=5�?6�G1D5B

1D�1>I�?>5�3ED�?66�@?9>D�9> 89C 3?>35@DE1< B9F5B �G9D8�9DC�?G>�2B1>389>7�DB92ED1B95C� G?E<4

3?>D19>�D85�C1=5�1=?E>D�?6�G1D5B��5�1@@<954�D85C5�D8?E78DC�D? ?2C5BF1D9?> ?6�DB55C�

G8938�9>6<E5>354�1DD5=@DC�D?�45C97>�D85�>?D9?>�?6 D85�S@5B653D�DB55T *89C�G1D5B 6<?G

=?45< 81C�255> CE2C5AE5>D<I 6?B=1<9J54 9>�D5B=C�?6�1 S@9@5�=?45<�D85?BI�?6�D85�DB55��

T�

G8938 9C�21C54�?>�D85�1CCE=@D9?>�D81D�1�E>9D�?6�6?<9175�9C�3?>C945B54�D?�B5AE9B5�1�3?>CD1>D

1=?E>D�?6�3?>4E3D9>7�D9CCE5 #5?>1B4? 6EBD85B=?B5 3?>359F54�?6�D85�DB55�1C�3?=@?C54�?6

1�2E>4<5�?6�@9@5C�D81D�C5@1B1D5�1D�49665B5>D�@?9>DC�9>D?�DB92ED1BI�2B1>385C��1C�96�D85�DBE>;�9C

9>�B5F5BC5�D85�B535@D9?>�B5C5BF?9B�6B?=�<?G5B�?B45B�DB92ED1B95C���G9D8�5138�2E>4<5�?6�@9@5C

CE@@?BD9>7�1�B5<1D54�@B?@?BD9?>�?6�6?<9175��

D� 9C�1@@1B5>D� D81D #5?>1B4?�41�,9>39�81C� 9=@13D54�E@?>�=?B@8?<?7931<�@5BC@53D9F5C�?6

DB55C��@1BD93E<1B<I� 6B?=�89C 1B51�@B5C5BF9>7�8I@?D85C9C�*89C�31>�25� D8?E78D�?6�1C 259>7

21C54 ?> D85� @B9>39@<5C� ?6 8I4B1E<93�4B9F5> 1B389D53DEB5 1>4� B5C51B38 45=?>CDB1D5C D81D

DB55 8I4B1E<93C 9>6<E5>35C 2B1>38 1B389D53DEB5 B56<53D9>7 1>� 1B51�@B5C5BF9>7� BE<5�-89<5

D89C�9C�D85�31C5� D85B5�9C�C?=5�5F945>35 D81D�D85B5�9C�1�D5>45>3I�D?�6?B�D85�3B?CC�C53D9?>1<

1B51 D? 9>3B51C5C C<978D<I 1D D85 @5B9@85B1< 5HD5>D G85B5 3B?G> DG97�D9@C @B?<965B1D5�12?ED

D85� DB135BI 9>� 3?=@1B9C?>� G9D8� D85� <?G5B� 3B?G>��

D� 9C� 51C95B� D?� C55� 8?G� 41� ,9>39

��(938D5B� ! ' ������ �)&��/4&#//+3�/' �&/."2%/�%"��*.$*� �?F5B B5@B9>D�6B?= D85�?B979>1<�����

549D9?>��

$K;5<K��$�� �� �� �&2*6"4*/.�/'�34&-�4"0&2�'2/-�4)&�0*0&�4)&/28�*.�"�$"2#/.�#",".$&�'2"-&7/2+� *B55

'8IC9?<?7I�� ����R�����,93D?B91���1>141��

09==5B=1>>�$�� ������ !8,&-�3425$452&�".%�4)&�"3$&.4�/'�3"0�)@B9>75B�,5B<17���5B<9>���5B=1>I��

�B1DCE��(������� �&/."2%/� "3� *3& �2&&3��/.3&26&��2/33��&$4*/.",��2&"��&30*4&��&33&,��425$452&!?EB>1<�?6�/?E>7� >F5CD971D?BC

Page 8: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

3?>35@DE1<9J54�DB55�=?B@8?<?7I�9>�D5B=C�?6�2?D8�G1D5B�6<?G�1>4�1B51�@B5C5BF9>7�=?45<C

1C�85�?2C5BF54�7B?GD8 1>4�C5@1B1D9?>� 6B?=�89785B�?B45B�@1BDC� D?� D8?C5� 6E>3D9?>9>7�1D�1

<?G5B�?B45B

�1�,9>39TC @5B35@D9?>C�?6�2B1>38�=?B@8?<?7I�1>4� D85� 9>85B5>D�@B?@?BD9?>1<9DI�25DG55>

89785B�1>4�<?G5B�?B45B�@1BDC 81F5�CDB?>7�B5C?>1>35�G9D8�D85 C?�31<<54 @9@5�=?45<��

�5

9=179>54� D89C 9>� D5B=C� ?6� 1� >E=25B� ?6 2E>4<54 CDB9>7C �@5B81@C�G5�=978D� 9=179>5� D85

CDB9>7C�1B5�=?B5�<9;5�1�2E>38�?6�692B?EC�S@<1CD93T�CDB1GC��D81D�1D 5138�>?45��@?9>D�?6�2E4�

2B1>38�?B979>�� D85� CDB9>7C�1B5�49F9454�25DG55>� D8?C5� D81D� B5=19>� 9>� D85� DBE>;�1>4� D8?C5

C=1<<5B�2E>4<5C D81D 25>4�1G1I�1>4�C5@1B1D5�1D D85�>?45� D? 6?B= 1 2B1>38��3?>C945B9>7

D81D�2B1>38�D893;>5CC 9C 49B53D<I�45@5>41>D�?> D85 2B1>389>7�1>7<5 C?�D81D�D85 <5CC�13ED5

D85�1>7<5 25DG55>�D85�2B1>38�1>4�D85 @1B5>D CD5= D85 7B51D5B D893;>5CC�?6�D85 >5G�2B1>38

*85B56?B5 85� 3?>C945BC� D81D� G1D5B� 6<?G� 9C� 1� @B9=1BI� 9>6<E5>35� E@?>� DB55� =?B@8?<?7I

�5BD19>�B5C51B38�81C�9>4554�5>4?BC54�41�,9>39TC�1B51�@B5C5BF9>7�BE<5��D8?E78�D89C 1@@51BC

=?B5�1@@B?@B91D5�D?�?@5>�7B?G>�3?>49D9?>C �

*85�@9@5�=?45<�3?>C945BC�D85�=?B@8?<?7931<�9=@<931D9?>C�49B53D<I�B5<1D54�D?�D85�G1I�D81D

D85�3B?CC�C53D9?>1<�1B51���)���?6�C1@G??4�9>�1>I�DB55�@1BD 9C�@B?@?BD9?>1<�D?�D85�6?<91B�?B

69>5�B??D�29?�=1CC�C5BF54�2I�9D �C�CE38��=1>I�CDE495C�81F5�255>�E>45BD1;5>�9>�1DD5=@DC

D?�AE1>D96I�D85 45B9F1D9F5��<?G5CD�?B45B�B??DC�1>4�C8??DC *89C�DB1>C<1D5C�=?B@8?<?7931<<I

D?�1�DB55�=?45<�G9D8�2B1>385C 13D�1C�C=1<<5B�DB55C�D81D�1B5�SB??D54�9>D?�D85 DBE>;T��G8938

2E9<4C�9>�1�F95G�?6�1�CICD5=1D93� 9>D5B>1<<I�B57E<1D54 895B1B38931< @1DD5B>�*89C 45D5B=9>5C

D85� 8I4B1E<93� 1B389D53DEB5 9> D81D 9>�2E9<D� =5381>931<� 613D?BC� 9>6<E5>35� D85� G1I� DB55C

45F5<?@�1>4�7B?G��1>4�E<D9=1D5<I� D859B�=?B@8?<?7931<�@B?@5BD95C�1D�2?D8� D85�=13B?�1>4

=93B?� <5F5< *85C5� 613D?BC� B5<1D5� D?� S81B4�G9B54T� 3?>49D9?>C� D81D� DB55C� 1B5� B5AE9B54� D?

B5C@?>4� D?�)D5=�3B?CC�C53D9?>1<�1B51� 9C� 9>85B5>D<I�@B?@?BD9?>1<� D?� D85�1B51�?6� 6?<9175� 9D

CE@@?BDC �?G5F5B�� 2B1>38 CDB5>7D8� 9C 49B53D<I� B5<1D54� D? D85 3B?CC�C53D9?>1<� 1B51 1>4

D85B56?B5 9C� @B?@?BD9?>1<� D? D85� CAE1B5� ?6� 9DC� 491=5D5B G89<5� 2B1>38 G5978D� 9C� 1� 3E293

6E>3D9?> ?6�2B1>38 491=5D5B C?� D81D�G5978D�G9<<� D5>4� D?� 5H3554 CDB5>7D8�*?� B5C@?>4� D?

D85C5� 29?=5381>931<� 651DEB5C� ?6� 7B?GD8� DB55C� 81F5� 5F?<F54� D?� 133?==?41D5

@8?D?CI>D85D93�CICD5=C �

��1>4�D859B G1D5B�3?>4E3D9>7�1>4�=5381>931<�6E>3D9?>C�1>4 D85C5

1B5�9=@?BD1>D�9>�45D5B=9>9>7 @1DD5B>C�?6�8I4B1E<93 DB55�1B389D53DEB5

��)89>?J1;9 &4�", ������� ���5".4*4"4*6&��.",83*3�/'��,".4��/2- ��)&��*0&�-/%&,�4)&/28������"3*$�".",83*3�

!1@1>5C5�!?EB>1<�?6��3?<?7I � �

$3�E<<?8��"�1>4�)@5BBI��!)�� ����� �"44&2.3�*.�)8%2"5,*$�"2$)*4&$452&�".%�4)&*2�*-0,*$"4*/.3�'/2

42".30/24�&''*$*&.$8��*B55�'8IC9?<?7I �� �

(ECD��)�1>4�(?<?66����� �� �� �&%5$&%�0)/4/38.4)&3*3�*.�/,%�/"+���5&2$53�2/#52� �4)&�*-0"$4�/'�$2/7.

".%�)8%2"5,*$�"2$)*4&$452&�*B55�'8IC9?<?7I ��

)D5B3;��� &4�", � ����� �2&&�(2/74) �$/.3&15&.$&3�/'�,&"'�42"*43�'/2�7)/,&�42&&�0&2'/2-".$&��'B?35549>7C

?6��D8

>D5B>1D9?>1<�-?B;C8?@�?>��E>3D9?>1<�)DBE3DEB1<�'<1>D�$?45<C

Page 9: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

�"*-#"5,4�".%�4)&��2&.$)�3$)//,�/'�42&&�-/20)/,/(9

*B55�=?B@8?<?7I 81C 35BD19><I 45F5<?@54 1�<9DD<5 ?F5B�D85 35>DEB95C�C9>35�41�,9>39 �G8?

4954 9>� ������ >� D85 DG5>D95D8 35>DEBI 9D� 81C� 6<?EB9C854� 1C 1� G5<<�5CD12<9C854 >9385

3?>35@D 9>� �B5>38� 1B2?B93E<DEB5 1>4� 9C� EC54 6?B� DB55� 1CC5CC=5>D� 1>4� =1>175=5>D

5<C5G85B5� 9> =19><1>4� �EB?@5� *85�=19>� @B?@?>5>D� � '95BB5� (19=21E<D�� 1� C395>D9CD� 1>4

D51385B� 81C� 45F5<?@54� 1 C9=@<96954� D5>�CD175� 45F5<?@=5>D1<�=?45<� 6?B� 1759>7� 9>� DB55C

D81D� D1;5C�2?D8�12?F5�7B?E>4�1>4�B??D�1B389D53DEB5� 9>D?�3?>C945B1D9?>�*89C� 9C�EC54�1C�1

@?G5B6E<� D??<� 6?B 2E9<49>7 E@�1�@93DEB5�?6� D85�5F?<F9>7�1>4�381>79>7 3?=@<5H9DI ?6� D85

B??D��DBE>;�1>4�2B1>38�6?B=�1C�D85�DB55�175C�6B?=�C554�D?�C5>5C35>35

-89<5� D89C� C38??<� ?6� 1B2?B93E<DEB5� 9C 9>� �B1>35� 1>4� 5<C5G85B5� EC54� D?� 1CC9CD� G9D8

9>D5B@B5D9>7� D85� C97>96931>35� ?6 DB55� 6?B= 9D� 9C� >?D� G5<<� ;>?G>� 9>� �B9D19> �?>D9>5>D1<

�EB?@51>� DB55� =?B@8?<?79CDC 9>3<E45� ?D85B 5H@?>5>DC 9>� �B1>35 ��8B9CD?@85� �B5>?E�

�1D85B9>5��E31D9<<?>��/F5C��1B17<9?���<1E45��45<9>� '1C31<��5>?I5B�� (?5<?6�&<45=1>

9>� D85� %5D85B<1>4C� 1>4� �>4B51C� (?<?66 �1D� D85� >CD9DED5� ?6� �?B5CD� �?D1>I� 1>4� �?B5CD

0??<?7I� 9>��5B=1>I

'B?65CC?B �1<<5 @E2<9C854� ?>� 1B389D53DEB1<� 1>1<IC9C� 9>� D85� <1D5� >9>5D55>� C9HD95C� 1>4� 89C

G?B;� 81C� 9>6<E5>354� 2?D1>9CDC� 1>4� D1H?>?=9CDC �5� 5H@<?B54� ;5I� 1B389D53DEB1<� DI@5C� 9>

2?D8� <9F9>7� @<1>DC� 1>4� 6?CC9<C�� 9<<ECDB1D54�G9D8 DB55�=?45<C� 9>3?B@?B1D9>7� D85� B59D5B1D9F5

@B?35CC *89C� C5<6�C9=9<1B9DI� 1@@B?138� D?� DB55C� B5C?>1D5C� G9D8 #5?>1B4? 1>4� �?5D85TC

=?45<C�� 1C�G5<<� 1C� D85� <1D5B� 6B13D1<� D85?BI =@<939D� 9>� D89C� 8978<I� 45D19<54� CDE4I� 9C� D85

9=@?BD1>35�?6 81F9>7�;>?G<5475�?6�D85�7B?GD8�@B?35CC5C�D8B?E78?ED�D85�1759>7�?6�1�DB55

�1<<5TC�@9?>55B9>7�G?B;�6EBD85B�6?3EC54�?>�D85�45D19<54�5H@<?B1D9?>�?6�D85�=1>I�1C@53DC

E@@5B� 31>?@I�� @B9>39@1<<I� 9>� B19> 6?B5CDC�� EC9>7� 89C� C@5391<<I� 45C97>54� S2<9=@�2?B>T

9>6<1D12<5�B16D -89<5�=E38�B5C51B38 9>�D85 695<4�9C�2?BB?G54�6B?=�5CD12<9C854�CICD5=C 1>4

CDE495C� ?6� 2?D1>931< 1>4 8?BD93E<DEB1< =?B@8?<?7I� C?=5 81F5 6?3EC54 ?> ?B>1=5>D1<

DB55C� ?D85BC�81F5�CDE4954�=?B@8?<?7931<�1C@53DC�?6 DB?@931<�DB55C��G89<5�CD9<<�?D85BC�81F5

?2C5BF54 ?B381B4 DB55C

$?B5�B535>D<I (19=21E<D 81C 6?3EC54 ?>�B??D�1B389D53DEB5�-89<5�D85B5�9C�>?D�1�7B51D�451<

?6� 1F19<12<5� @E2<9C854 <9D5B1DEB5 9> �>7<9C8�� 1 ;5I� @E2<9C854� D5HD �@5B81@C 496693E<D� D?

49C3?F5B� 9C�G?BD8�DB13;9>7�4?G>�D9D<54 �"��&34*/.��&3��2#2&3��;/2.&-&.4 ��.&�-&4)/%&

%;".",83&�&4�%&�%*"(./34*$�%&�,"�0"24*&�"&2*&..& �(19=21E<D�'��*1>7EI�$����5BDB1>4�

�������� (5FE5 �?B5CD9OB5��B1>M19C5�.#,�� *89C ?665BC 7E941>35 D? E>45BCD1>49>7�D85

B5<1D9?>C89@� 25DG55>� S=?B@8?<?7931<� 45F5<?@=5>DT� 1>4� S@8IC9?<?7931<� 175T� 9>� DB55C

�>?D85B� �B5>?E� ������� :�"�4"*,,&�%&3�"2#2&3�%�/2.&-&.4; � ���54� @B?F945C 7E941>35

6?B� 3?>C945B9>7� @BE>9>7� 1>4�=1>175=5>D� ?@D9?>C� 6B?=� E>45BCD1>49>7� D85� B5<1D9?>C89@C

25DG55>�DB55�=?B@8?<?7I�1>4�DB55�29?<?7I

Page 10: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

�2&&�-/20)/,/(9��"(&*.(�".%�0)93*/,/(*$",�$/22&,"4*/.3

(19=21E<DTC�=?B@8?<?7931<� 9>D5B@B5D1D9?>�1C� 1@@<954� D? 1B2?B93E<DEB1<�4917>?C9C� B5AE9B5C

69BCD�D81D�D85B5�9C�1>�E>45BCD1>49>7�?6 =?B@8?<?7931<�CD175 ?6�45F5<?@=5>D�?6�D85�DB55��95

9DC�2B1>389>7�49C@?C9D9?>��1B389D53DEB5��@1DD5B>C� ?B45B�1>4�49CDB92ED9?>�?6�7B?GD8�?6�@1BDC

?6�D85�DB55�9>�B5<1D9?>�D?�?>5�1>?D85B��*85�E>45BCD1>49>7�?6�D85�DB55�G9D89>�D85�@1BD93E<1B

45F5<?@=5>D1< CD175 ?6� 7B?GD8� 31> 25� 3?>C945B54 D?� 9>6?B= DB51D=5>D� ?@D9?>C� �5

B53?7>9J5C� D81D� D85 "24 /'� 42&&� "33&33-&.4 1>4� =1>175=5>D� 9C� 21C54� ?>� @B5493D9F5

?ED3?=5C�*85B56?B5�D85�56653DC��ECE1<<I�B5=5491<��D81D�1B5�9>D5>454�>554�D?�25�CD1D54�1>4

D85>�9>D5B@B5D54�9>�D85�<978D�?6�D85�5F5>DE1<�B5CE<D 2?D8�9>D5>454�1>4�13DE1< >�D89C�C5>C5

1<<� 1B2?B93E<DEB1<�=1>175=5>D� @B?@?C1<C� 1B5� 5H@5B9=5>D1<� *85� @B?@5B�G1I� D?� 5F1<E1D5

1>4�144�D?�;>?G<5475 D85> 9C�D8B?E78�CICD5=1D93 B53?B49>7� 9>D5B�3?==E>931D9?>�G9D89>

D85�@B?65CC9?>��B5F95G�1>4�B5�9>D5B@B5D1D9?>

*89C DB55�=?B@8?<?7I 1@@B?138�1CC5BDC�D81D�1�C5D�?6�;5I�=?B@8?<?7931< CD175C�31>�25�EC54

D? ?2C5BF5�D85�DB55�1C�9D�7B?GC�9>�1�>E=25B�?6�C5DD9>7C��D8?E78�9>�1�75>5B93�C5>C5�D85B5�1B5

?F5B1B389>7�@1DD5B>C�D81D�31>�25�4B1G>�6B?=�1�DI@931<�B1>75�?6�45F5<?@=5>D1< CD175C�6B?=

SC554� D?� C5>5C35>35T� �I� <51B>9>7� 12?ED� D85C5� 7B?GD8� CD175C� 1>� E>45BCD1>49>7� 31>� 25

13895F54�D? 45D5B=9>5�D85 DI@5�?6�C@539693�6E>3D9?>9>7�?6�1�DB55� <9>;9>7 9DC @8IC9?7>?=I

D?�9DC�@8IC9?<?7931<�175��9> (19=21E<DTC�31C5�85�EC5C�89C D5>�CD175C�?6�=?B@8?<?7931<�175�

*89C�D85>�@B?F945C�1�=?B@8?<?7931<�21C9C�6?B 4917>?C9>7�DB55�3?>49D9?> 1>4 6?B�@B5493D9>7

6EDEB5�45F5<?@=5>D D? 45D5B=9>5 =1>175=5>D ?@D9?>C

(19=21E<DTC =5D8?4�6?3EC5C ?>�D85�G1I�D81D�2B1>38�1>4�B??D�1B389D53DEB5�9C�9>6<E5>354 2I

D85 4?=9>1>35 �

?6�D85 1@931< =5B9CD5=C �

�*85�5H@B5CC9?>�?6�1@931<�4?=9>1>35�1>4�8?G

D89C�=1I�381>75 B56<53DC D85�=1>I�5HD5B>1<�9>6<E5>35C E@?>�7B?GD8�D81D�1B5�3EBB5>D�1D�D85

D9=5� ?6� ?2C5BF1D9?> �5� 45C3B925C� D85� G1I� D81D 1D� D85� 69BCD� @81C5� ?6� 7B?GD8� D85� 1@931<

=5B9CD5=C� 9C�4?=9>1>D�1>4� D85�@1DD5B>�?6� <1D5B1<�2B1>389>7� 9C�@B5493D12<I�C5AE5>D91<� 6?B

D85�C@5395C ��97�������� �

>�D85�C53?>4�@81C5�?6�7B?GD8��C53?>4�?B45B�2B1>385C��D8?C5�45B9F54�6B?=�D85�69BCD�35>DB1<

CD5=��1>4�D89B4�?B45B�2B1>385C��45B9F54�6B?=�C53?>4�?B45B�<9=2C���97 �������B5@<931D5

D?�1>� 9=@?BD1>D�5HD5>D� D85�7B?GD8� 6?B=�?6� D85� 69BCD� CD175�*8EC 9>� D89C�G1I <?G5B�?B45B

2B1>385C 79F5 D85�1@@51B1>35�?6�1�C5@1B1D5�S=9>9T�DB55

�'B53545>35�9>�B5<1D9?>�D?�2B1>385C�25<?G�1>4�3?>DB?<�?6�45F5<?@=5>D�6?B�D85�25>569D�?6�D85�D5B=9>1<

�<5149>7��C8??D �

*85 E>49665B5>D91D54�D9CCE5�1D�D85�D9@�?6�1�CD5=�?B�B??D�6B?= G8938�>5G�35<<C�1B5�45B9F54

� �

�*(���

<<ECDB1D9?>�?6�B1=96931D9?>

6B?=�C9>7<5�CD5=����� 6B?=

89785B�?B45B� D?� 69BCD� <?G5B

�C53?>4��?B45B�2B1>38�� ��

C53?>4�?B45B�D?�D89B4�?B45B

2B1>385C� ����579>>9>7� ?6

<?CC� ?6� 1@931<� 4?=9>1>35

���

Page 11: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

*85C5� B5@<931D9>7� 6?B=C� (19=21E<D� B565BC� D?� 1C 2&*4&2"4*/.3�

1>4� D5B=C 38,,&04*$

B59D5B1D9?>C� 1C� D8?C5� B59D5B1D9?>C� D81D 1@@51B� D?� B5@<931D5� D85� @1B5>D� CD5=�

�� G89<5 1<C?

81F9>7�D85�31@139DI�D?�3?=@5D5�G9D8�9D�1>4�D?�253?=5�@8IC9?<?7931<<I 1ED?>?=?EC E>9DC�96

CE669395>D<I� 45F5<?@54� 1>4� 1<<?G54� D?� S2B51;� 6B55� 6B?=� D85� CICD5=T� 1C� 1�G8?<5��� DB55

3?=@?C54� ?6� =E<D9@<5� @?D5>D91<<I� 9>45@5>45>D� E>9DC 45C3B925C 9> (19=21E<DTC� D5B=C 1

DB1>C9D9?>�6B?=�1�SE>9D1BIT�D?�1�S=E<D9@<5T�DB55

�*(�

�97� 9C� D1;5>� 6B?= (19=21E<DTC =?B@8?<?7931<� 9>D5B@B5D1D9?>� ?6� 2B1>389>7� @1DD5B>C�

B56<53D9>7� D85 56653DC ?6� B5=?F9>7� 1@931<� 3?>DB?<� ?6� 2B1>385C > �97 �� ��� 9<<ECDB1D5C

9>9D91<� 2B1>38� 7B?GD8 G9D8� 2E4C� CD1BD9>7� D? 25>4 E@G1B4� 1D� 5HDB5=9D95C C8?G9>7 1

D5>45>3I�D?�SC5<6�@BE>5T�9>�<1D5B�179>7�CD175C�1>4�61<<��@B?<5@D93�B59D5B1D9?>C�� ��� C8?GC

7B?GD8� ?6� 1� <1B75� 2B1>38� 1H9C� C8?G9>7� D85� 75>5B1<� <?31D9?>� ?6� D85� <51F5C� ��97C� ���� �

(565B5>35 �

���B1>385C�1B5�6?E>4�?>�<?G5B�2B1>385C�D81D�@1BD91<<I� B5@<931D5�D85�31BBI9>7

2B1>38�� 1>4� G85>� 1C� D85� DB55� 175C D85C5 1B5� 6?E>4� 9>� D85� E@@5B� 3B?G>� D85I 253?=5

C97>96931>D�6?B�45D5B=9>9>7�2B1>38��3B?G>�C81@5�-85>�9>�D85�<1D5B�CD175�?6� D85�1759>7

@B?35CC�D85C5�B59D5B1D9?>C�31>�25�6?E>4�7B?G9>7�3<?C5�D?�D85�21C5�?6�2B1>385C�?B�49B53D<I

7B?G9>7� 6B?=� D85� DBE>;� CE38 02/,&04*$� 2&*4&2"4*/.3 81F5� D85�31@139DI� D?� D1;5�?F5B� 6B?=

@1BDC�?6�D85�3B?G>�D81D�=1I�25�<?CD�D8B?E78�41=175�1>4�D85�>1DEB1<�1759>7�@B?35CC

*8B?E78� ?2C5BF1D9?>� ?6� D85C5� @B?35CC5C �@1BD93E<1B<I� D85� B5<1D9?>C89@� 25DG55>� DB55

1B389D53DEB5� 1>4� 1759>7� =?B@8?<?79CD� 81F5� C8?G>� 3?>C945B12<5� ?@5>>5CC� 1>4� 81F5

2?BB?G54�6B?=�?D85B�49C39@<9>5C �9>3<E49>7 2?D1>I��8I4B?<?7I�1>4�1BD� D?�1BB9F5�1D =?45<C

1>4�3?>35@DC D?�45C3B925 DB55 1B389D53DEB5 9> 1> 9>3B51C9>7<I C?@89CD931D54�G1IC &>�D85

?>5�81>4�1<<?G9>7 B569>5=5>DC D?�25� 9>3?B@?B1D5 9> 45C3B9@D9?>�1>4 4569>9D9?>�?6�C81@5�

CDBE3DEB5�1>4 D85 B5<1D9?>C89@C�25DG55>� D85� DB55� 1>4� 9DC�@1BDC�� 1>4�?>� D85�?D85B� D?�1@@<I

;>?G<5475�13AE9B54�6B?=�SB5149>7T�D85�DB55TC�6?B=�D?�D85�9>D5B@B5D1D9?>�?6�@8IC9?<?7931<

CD1DEC

��&*4&2"4*/. 3?E<4�25�3?>C945B54�D?�25�D85�G1I�D81D�D85�6?B=�?6�D85�G8?<5�DB55�9C�B5@<931D54�9>�D85

1B389D53DEB5�?6�<?G5B�?B45B�CE2C9491BI�@1BDC ��8,,&04*$�2&*4&2"4*/. 9C�1�2B1>38�D81D�G85>�4?=9>1D54�2I�D85�8?B=?>5�3?>DB?<�?6�D85�1@931<�=5B9CD5=�?6

D85�89785B�?B45B�2B1>38�C8?GC�C9=9<1B�1B389D53DEB5�D?�D85�4?=9>1>D�CD5=��?G5F5B��6?<<?G9>7�B5<51C5�6B?=

4?=9>1>35�81C�D85�31@139DI�D?�1DD19>�9>45@5>45>35�1>4��1C�9D�9C�B5<51C54�6B?=�4?=9>1>35��25>4C�E@G1B4C�9>

3?=@5D9D9?>�6?B�<978D�D8EC�B5@<931D9>7�D85�@1BD�D81D�CE@@?BDC�9D �

(19=21E<D�'��*1>7EI�$����5BDB1>4����������� �"��&34*/.��&3��2#2&3��;/2.&-&.4 ��.&�-&4)/%&

%;".",83&�&4�%&�%*"(./34*$�%&�,"�0"24*&�"&2*&..&� (5FE5 �?B5CD9OB5��B1>M19C5�.#,�

Page 12: Tree Morphology - A Branch of Arboriculture from Renaissance to Raimbault

�/.$,53*/.

+>45BCD1>49>7 =?B@8?<?7931< @B9>39@<5C 85<@C� D? 3?>>53D 15CD85D93� 1@@B5391D9?> G9D8

<?7931<� @B?35CC5C >� D85� C1=5� G1I� D81D� 1� @<1>5 G9D89>� 1� C@85B5� >?� =1DD5B� 8?G� 9D� 9C

=1>5EF5B54� 9C�4569>54 2I�6E>41=5>D1< =1D85=1D931< B5<1D9?>C89@C 5H@B5CC54�D8B?E78�D85

B1D9? Q �@9�� D85B5� 1B5 E>45B<I9>7� =?B@8?<?7931< B5<1D9?>C89@C D81D� 4569>5 @1DD5B>C� ?6

7B?GD8 =@B?F9>7� D89C� 1G1B5>5CC� 85<@C 455@5> 1>4 B569>5 ?EB @5B35@D9?>C ?6 <9F9>7

CDBE3DEB5 1D 1� =13B?� 1>4� =93B?� <5F5< �9F5>� D81D 8E=1> 45F5<?@=5>D 9C 9>85B5>D<I

3?>>53D54�D?�D85�C1=5 9>6<E5>35C D81D�16653D 1<<�29?<?7931< @B?35CC5C� D85C5�B5<1D9?>C89@C

81F5�455@�B5C?>1>35�9> ?EB�B1D9?>1< =5>D1<�@B?35CC5C�1>4 15CD85D93 @5B35@D9?>C

�?D8� 1BD� 1>4� C395>35 1B5 5=254454� 9>� 4539@85B9>7 B5<1D9?>C89@C *89C� @1@5B� 5H@<?B5C

3?>35@DC�D81D�81F5�1DD5=@D54�D?�E>45BCD1>4�E>45B<I9>7�BE<5C�D81D�9>6<E5>35�1>4�7?F5B>�D85

6?B=� 1>4� 1B389D53DEB5� ?6� D85� DB55� *85 381>79>7 6?B=� ?6� D85� DB55� B56<53DC 75>5D93�

45F5<?@=5>D1<� @B?35CC5C� 1>4� B5C@?>C5C� D?� 5>F9B?>=5>D1<� 9>6<E5>35C� DC @5B359F54

5H@B5CC9?> 9C B??D54 9> 1�<?>7�5F?<F54 8E=1> B5<1D9?>C89@ G9D8 DB55C �C�D85 1@@B5391D9?>

?6� D85 =E<D9DE45� ?6 6?B=C DB55C� 1B5� 31@12<5� ?6 81C 3?>C39?EC� 1>4� CE23?>C39?EC

49=5>C9?>C�� 9=@B?F9>7 1G1B5>5CC ?6 =?B@8?<?7931< 5H@B5CC9?> <95C 1D� D85� 851BD� ?6

B569>9>7 ?EB ?2C5BF1D9?>1< 613E<DI� D? 9=@B?F5�?EB E>45BCD1>49>7 DB55C 1>4 ?EB�4917>?CD93

129<9D95C

*8?E78D� @B?35CC5C B5<1D9>7 D? DB55 =?B@8?<?7I C@1> C?=5 69F5� 8E>4B54 I51BC � D8?E78

51B<I� CD9BB9>7C� ?6� D85� S1B2?B93E<DEB1<�=9>4T 1C 5H@B5CC54� 2I 1BD9CDC� CE38� 1C�#5?>1B4?�41

,9>39 B5=19> <1B75<I�E>1@@B5391D54�1C 9>6<E5>35C 9> 3EBB5>D�1B2?B93E<DEB1< D89>;9>7 �1

,9>39 814�1 F95G�?6�8I4B1E<931<<I 9>6<E5>354� DB55�1B389D53DEB5 *85 3?>>53D9?> 25DG55>

DB55 6?B=�1>4�G1D5B B5<1D9?>C 9C�1> 9=@?BD1>D ?2C5BF1D9?> 9> E>45BCD1>49>7 D85�5H@B5CC9?>

?6 DB55�@8IC9?<?7931< @B?35CC5C �?>35@DE1<<I�(19=21E<D 1>4��1<<5 <95�9> 1 49B53D <9>5175

G9D8 41� ,9>39�9>C@9B54 51B<I� S(5>19CC1>35� 1B2?B93E<DEB5T )897?TC� >?D9?>� ?6

3?=@1BD=5>D1<9J1D9?> �

1>4 $1DD853; 1>4 ?D85BCT 1@@B5391D9?>�?6�D85 S1H9?=�?6�E>96?B=

CDB5CCT �5H@B5CC54� D8B?E78� D85 2?4I� <1>7E175 ?6� DB55C� B56<53D @1B1<<5<� ?2C5BF1D9?>C�

<1B75<I E>3?>C39?EC� D? 41�,9>39TC 1B51�@B5C5BF9>7 SCDB9>7�D85?BIT�?6�2B1>389>7

$?B@8?<?7931< CDE4I 9C 21C54� ?> 85978D5>54 ?2C5BF1D9?> ?6 D85 @8IC931<� 5H@B5CC9?>� ?6

>1DEB1<� @B?35CC5C� 4B1G9>7 ?>� 2?D8 8E=1> 1BD9CD93� 1>4� C395>D9693� 613E<D95C (5>19CC1>35

6<?G5B9>7� ?6� D8?E78D ;9>4<54 1 @1BD93E<1B ;9>4� ?6 B1D9?>1<� 1@@B?138� D?� 15CD85D93C *85

1B2?B93E<DEB1<� <5713I 6B?=� D89C 9C =?B5� 3?85B5>D<I 5H@B5CC54 1C� 1� 49C39@<9>5 9> C?=5

3?E>DB95C�1>4 3E<DEB5C D81>�?D85BC $?B@8?<?7931<� C38??<C�G?E<4�1B7E5� D81D�2I� B569>9>7

?EB 1@@B5391D9?>�?6 DB55 6?B= 1>4 B19C9>7 D89C D? 1�=?B5�3?>C39?EC�<5F5<��G5�G9<<�25 25DD5B

12<5�D? 1@@B5391D5�D859B AE1<9D95C�1>4�D?�9=@B?F5 ?EB 4917>?CD93 1>4�=1>175=5>D 129<9D95C

��9C>5B��%�!���9<=1>���������B12?C;I��!���� �� �� �2".$)��/20)/,/(8��-0"$43�/'

�/-0"24-&.4",*9"4*/.�/'��25.*.(� /5.%3��!?EB>1<�?6��B2?B93E<DEB5�� ��� ���� � ���