Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)
Transcript of Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)
![Page 1: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
title:author:
publisher:isbn10|asin:printisbn13:ebookisbn13:
language:subject
publicationdate:lcc:ddc:
subject:
![Page 2: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
InthisthirdvolumeoftheOnceandfutureChurchSeriesandsequeltohisbookTheOnceandfutureChurch,LorenMeadpicksupwhereheleftoff.IfGodiscallingthechurchtoreshapeitself,wheredowebegin?Onwhatbasisshouldwebuild?Thedecliningnumbersofdenominationalmembershipandrecentnationalsurveysonchurchattendancesuggestthatthechurchisnolongerasourceofhopeorcompellingresourcetohelppeopledealwiththeturmoiloftoday'schangingworld.Andyet,thegoodnewsofthechurchissuchthatitshouldbewhatpeopleareclamoringfor.Whatisitaboutourinstitutionsandourselvesthatmaybecausingustobeineffectiveinthewayweliveoutourcallingasthechurchandasself-professedbelievers?Lorenfocusesonwhatheseesastheessentialtaskandage-oldcallofthechurchlivingandbreathingthegoodnewspromiseofspiritualtransformationforalltosee.Heexploreshowweasthechurchmayneedtochangeasinstitutionsandasindividualswithintheinstitutions.EveryonewhohasreadtheOnceandfutureChurchwillwanttoexplorethisnextstepasLorenchallengesyoutoexaminethetransformationsinherentingod'scalltoustorenewHischurch.
![Page 3: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Pagei
TransformingCongregationsfortheFuture
LorenB.Mead
![Page 4: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Pageii
ThePublicationsProgramofTheAlbanInstituteisassistedbyagrantfromTrinityChurch,NewYorkCity.
Copyright©1994byTheAlbanInstitute.Allrightsreserved.Reprinted1995and1997.
Thismaterialmaynotbephotocopiedorreproducedinanywaywithoutwrittenpermission.
LibraryofCongressCatalogCard#93-74587
ISBN1-56699-126-9
![Page 5: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Pageiii
Ingratitudetofourofmyteachers
MissCarrieCain,PinopolisTerryHolmes,NashotaandSewaneeAndyPenick,ChapelHillVernaDozier,Washington
EachpushedmefurtherthanIwantedtogo.
![Page 6: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Pageviii
Itmattersalot.Asimplestatementwithdeeproots.Religiouscongregationsdomatter.Theymatterpersonallytomillionsofpeoplewhofindasourceofmeaninginacongregation.Theymattertothosewhoweekbyweekmaketheirwaytotheirreligiousobservancesandcontributemoremoneytochurchesthantoanyothersetofinstitutionsinthecountry.Theymattertothosewhotakethevalueslearnedinthosecongregationsintotheirbusinessrelationshipsandcontinuetomakepossibleaneconomicsystemthatisdependentuponpromisesandthekeepingofone'sword.Theymattertothosewhoworkhardtobuildcaringrelationshipsintraditionalfamiliesandinnewformsofcommunity.Theymattertothosewhobuildtownsorcountiesornationsthatdowhatisrightformostpeoplewithoutbeingcoercivetothosewithoutpower.Theymattertothosewhocareaboutthedevelopmentofthenextgenerationoftheyoungthoseinfamiliesandthosewhohavenofamilies.
Peopleraisedinreligiouscongregationsmakethisasocietythatcaresaboutjustice,althoughitoftenfallsshort.PeopleraisedinreligiouscongregationsmakethisasocietythatrecognizesaresponsibilityinBosniaandSomalia,althoughwemaybeconfusedaboutpreciselywhatweoughttodothere.Peopleraisedinreligiouscongregationshelpushaveahealthyskepticismabouthumanperfection,remindingusofhowourownsocietyhaspermittedpracticesleadingtoneargenocideofNativeAmericans,condoningAfrican-Americanslaveryformorethantwocenturies,exilingJapanese-Americancitizenstoconcentrationcamps,andallowingradioactiveexperimentationonothercitizens.Religiouscongregationsconditionustoaskquestionsofrightandwrongaboutpublicpolicy.Throughourhistorythefirstquestionsaboutinjusticeoftenhavebeenraisedincongregations.AfterattemptstojustifyinjusticeasGod'swill,thosecongregationsledustodebateandfinallyrejectthepractices.
Congregationshavepowerandthatpowercanhaveenormously
![Page 7: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
creativeinfluenceinleadingustowardanever-morehumanesociety.CriticsandobserversofAmericansocietysincedeToquevillehavenotedthisroleofcongregations.Wedowelltoremember,however,thattheydohavedemonicpotential.Congregationscancareandteachustocare,buttheycanalsobeplaceswhereprejudicesarenourishedandgrudgespassedalongtofuturegenerations.
Yes,congregationshavepower,enormouspower.Theymatter.I
![Page 8: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Pageix
donotplantoarguethispointfurther,butyoudeservetoknowthatIstartwiththisassumption.
Againstthisbackground,thefactthatourchurchesandthecongregationsthatmakethemupareintroubleisaconcernnotjusttothereligiouscommunity.Itisamatterofconcernforthehealthofthesocietyitself.
InthisbookIcontendthatthestormbuffetingthechurchesisveryseriousindeed.Muchmoreseriousthanwehaveadmittedtoourselves,andmuchmoreseriousthanourleadershaveyetcomprehended.Theproblemsarenotminor,callingforadjustmentsorcorrections.Theyareproblemsthatgototherootsofourinstitutionsthemselves.WhatIamdescribinghereisnotsomethingwewillfix.Itisastateofexistenceinwhichwemustlearntoliveevenasweseeknewdirectionsforfaithfulresponse.
InmyearlierbookTheOnceandFutureChurch,
1Iexploredsomereasonsforourbeingwhereweare.InmysubsequentbookMoreThanNumbers,2Igaveperspectivesaboutandtoolsforcongregationsinthistimebetweentwoages.InthisbookIwanttotakeuptheargumentofTheOnceandFutureChurchandpushfurtherahead,delvingdeeperintothenatureofthestormweareinandmakingsuggestionsforthefuture.EverythingIsayhasbeeninfluencedbythehundredsofpeoplewhohaveworkedwithmeinconferencesandcorrespondedwithme.Manyhaveaskedquestionsorgivenmefeedback,makingpointsIhadneverthoughtabout.Icanthereforeclaimlittleinthesepagesasbeingoriginalwithme.
Inchapter1IbeginwithadiscussionoftheseriousstormIseebuffetingthechurches.Thestormissoserious,Ibelieve,thatitmarkstheendof"businessasusual"forthechurchesandmarksaneedfor
![Page 9: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
ustobeginagainbuildingchurchfromthegroundup.
Theheartofmyargumentwillbeinchapters2and3,inwhichIbegintorestateforourtimethebasicfunctionsofcongregationswhatthereligiousenterpriseincongregationsisreallyabout.IwillgivethebestcluesIhaveabouttheprocessthatisattheheartofcongregationallifeaprocessIcalltransformation.IamawarethatIamcallingforaradicallydifferentunderstandingofmission,ofevangelism,andofhowindividualcongregationalmembersarecalledtoliveitout.
Thatisfollowedbyachapterabouttheimplicationsforregionaljudicatoriesandachapterthatidentifiesroadblocksinandguidepostson
![Page 10: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Pagex
theroadahead.Ihavetriedtoincludepracticalsuggestionsthroughout.ThefirstappendixisaneducationaldesignIusetohelppeopleworkonsomeoftheseideas.ThesecondappendixgivestherawdataforthegraphsIuse.
Ifmyfinalchapterfeelssermonic,forgiveme.Ideeplybelievethatthestormweareinpresentsthegreatestopportunitythechurchesandreligiousleadershaveeverhad.Barnone.Ialsobelieveitisadeeperchallengeandthreatthanreligiousleadershavefacedinmanycenturies.Weareinserioustroublethatwewillnotgetoutofsoonoreasily.Whenwegetclearofthisstorm,ourreligiousinstitutionsmaybearlittleresemblancetothosewithwhichwegrewup.
IhavetwoothercommentsaboutwhatIamdoingandwhy.InmybooksIhaveneverusedmuchofthelanguageusuallyfoundintheologicalworks.SomereadershavecomplainedthatIamnotadequately"theological"inmyapproach.Thatparticularcriticismconfoundsme.Thesubstanceofmyconcernandmymethodarebothfirmlybasedinadeeptheologicalframework,butIapproachthingsinductively,doingtheology,asTerryHolmesandIusedtodescribeit,"fromthegroundup."Inanothercontext,IdescribedthewayIworkandthinkas"operationaltheology."
3Idonotplantochangethatapproachnow,butIapologizeifmylanguageaboutcongregationsdoesnotfulfillyourexpectations.InthisbookIaminvitingyoutodoecclesiology"fromthegroundup."
Finally,Iwanttoinviteyouintothisbookasintoaconversation.YouknowthingsIdonotknow,andIbegyoutobringyourknowledgetothetable.Letyourideasworkwithmine,testthem,arguewiththem.IknowIhavealimitedpointofviewandthatyouhavemuchtoadd.Myinsightscomeoutofmylifeexperienceandbearthevaluesand
![Page 11: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
limitsoftheirorigin.AlthoughIwroteTheOnceandFutureChurchoutofmyownexperience(primarilymainlineProtestant),Iwasdelightedthatsomanyfromverydifferentbackgroundsfoundithelpful.ThosewhohavefounditmosthelpfuldidwhatIhopedtheywoulddo:Theytranslateditintotheirownsituations;theyusedittoignitequestionstheyhadabouttheirowncongregations.IhavehadrabbistellmehowhelpfulmyuseofthetermChristendomwastotheminunderstandingtherelationshipoftheircongregationstotheirworld.Pastorsofindependentcongregationshavetoldmeaboutthe"connectionalism"theydiscoveredamongcongregationsthatweretechnically"nonconnectional."
![Page 12: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Pagexi
Sojoinmeinaconversation.IhopethatwhatIhavetosayoutofmylife,experience,andcommitmentswillhelpyouilluminatepointsofyourlife,experience,andcommitments.Myexperiencewillnottellyouwhattodo,butyoucanholdyourexperienceuptomine,testmyideastoseehowtheytranslateoriftheytranslate.Ifyoudothatwork,Ithinkourconversationwillhelpyoudiscoverthingsthatshouldbeonyouragenda.
Ispeakoutofmyownfaith,too.IoftenusewordsofthatfaithbecausetheyarehowIknowtoexpresswhatIperceivetobetrue.Ihavetriednottouselanguagethatwilloffendthoseofotherfaithpositions,butIhavenottriedtohomogenizemylanguagetodoso.Ifmywordsdocauseoffensetoyourwayofunderstandingorspeakingyourtruth,IasktwothingsofyouthatyouacceptmyapologyforanyinsensitivityandthatyougobacktowhatoffendedyouandtrytoreachthroughthewordstowhatIamtryingtosay.
IdeeplybelieveGodcallsusseverallytomoveintothefuture.Ibelieveweneedoneanotherifwearetohearourowncallclearly.WehearbestindialoguewithoneanotheraswellaswithGod.IwillsaywhatImeanasclearlyasIcan,butIknowthatmyvisionisdistorted,nomatterhowhardItry.IhopeyouwilldiscoverthingsIdonotknowasyouinteractwithwhatIhavetosay.Ihopeyouwilldiscoverthingsyoudidnotknow.Forbothofusthisdialogueislikelytoholdsurprises.Thisisintrinsic,Ibelieve,intheprocessofrevelation.
Thisisnotanoptimisticbook.Iseemuchthatisdifficultaheadofus.Ido,however,speakfromadeepandabidinghope.ThefaithIlearnedinacongregationinSouthCarolinainthe1930sisdesperatelyneededinthe2030s.Thatfaithhasbeenbuiltupandtransformedbylifeexperiences,byrelationships,andbylearning,butinmanywaysitsbasicsareunchanged.ButthefaithIreceivedinthethirtieswasclothesinaworldviewofanow-pastage,andits
![Page 13: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
institutional''deliverysystem''reflectedthatage'sunderstandingofhowtodothings.TheinstitutionalformsinwhichIlearnedfaithandthestructuresforcarryingitonhavebeenhardtochange.Manyofthemcontinueastoday'sstructures,althoughtheystoppedworkinginsomeplacesyearsago.Manyofushaveworkedhardtoreinventthoseformswithmixedsuccess.
Godcallsustoadauntingtask:totakethosestructuresandthoseresourcesoffaithandre-presenttheminformsthatwillcarrythemintothenextcentury.IamastonishedthatGodwouldinviteusintosucha
![Page 14: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Pagexii
taskofco-creation.Godobviouslyseespotentialinusthatwehaveahardtimeaccepting.AndIbelievethatpotentialcanbeapproachedonlyasweinourdifferencesenterintodialoguewitheachother.Thisbookismyattempttoworkatthattask.
LORENB.MEADWASHINGTONASHWEDNESDAY,1994.
![Page 15: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Page1
Chapter1TheStormWeArein:It'sWorseThanWeThought
TheStormaboutNumbers:MembershipLosses
Thoseinwhathavebeencalledmainlinechurchesarefeelingparticularlydefensiveandsensitiveaboutmembershiplosses.Fast-growingcongregationsanddenominationslookonthetraditionalbellwethersMethodist,Lutheran,Episcopal,Presbyterian,Congregationalandsay,"Main?Morelikesidelinethesedays."Mainlinerswince.Sometimeswetrytokidourselvesaboutthenumbersbytalkingabouthowwethinkthey've"bottomedout."
Reasonsforthedeclinesareasnumerousasthecommentators.Ihaveheardreasonsrangingfrom"itsbecauseofallthesocialministriesthemainlinegotinvolvedininthesixties"to"it'sbecausethemainlineisnotasaggressiveinitssocialministriesasitwasinthesixties."Thepolarizationbetweensocialliberalsandconservativesplaysitselfoutinthisdebatewithconservativesseeingtheproblemastoomuchliberalismandtheliberalsseeingtheproblemastoomuchconservatism.Eachsideaccusestheotherofdivisiveness.
"Toomuchconcernforpoliticalcorrectness,"scoffstheconservative."That'swhyeverybodyisleaving!"
"Fascistpietism,"accusestheliberal,"turnsoffthepeoplewhowanttomakeadifferenceatthispointofhistoricchange."
Respectedresearchersstatethatthechurch-membershiplossesillustrateauniversallawofAmericanreligion:Sect-likereligionssells;church-likereligiondies.Theircriticsreply,looselytranslated,
![Page 16: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
"Horse-hockey."(Iamsureyoucanrecognizethehighintellectuallevelofanddeepphilosophicalbasisforthisdebate.)
![Page 17: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Page2
Itishardtogetcleardatathatisnotfilteredthroughsomeone'sideologicalpresuppositions.Itisalsoclearthat"churchnumbers"isafluidcrapgame.Manypeopleconsiderthemselves"members"butarenotlistedinthechurchstatistics.ManypeoplefeelfreetotellacensusreportorsurveyrecorderthattheyarePresbyteriansorCatholics,buttheyhaveneverhappenedtomentionittothelocalPresbyterianorCatholicchurch!KirkHadaway,researchofficerfortheUnitedChurchofChrist,hasafelicitousnameforthegroup:"mentalmembers"!
1MorerecentresearchbyHadawayandhiscolleaguePennyMarlerofSamfordUniversityindicatedthatperhapsonlyhalfofthepeoplewhotellpollsterstheygotochurchactuallyshowuponSunday.Soweareinalandofmuchdata,someofitconflicting,muchofitcloselytouchedbystrongbiasesininterpretation.Further,wordssuchasmemberandattenderhaveambiguousmeanings.Inourworkwehavelocatedpeoplewhoneverdarkenthechurchdoors,buttheyhavestrongemotionaltiestoacongregationordenominationforwhichtheycareagreatdeal.Stillotherssomehowcreptontothechurchrollsandsimplydonotcareafigaboutthechurch.Anumberofthesepeople,forreasonsofchurchadministration,havebeentakenofftherolls.Somewhoareonprobablyoughttobetakenoff,andsomewhoareoffprobablystilloughttobeon.Some,whohavebeenoffforyearsandyears,discoverinalifecrisistheneedtoreconnect.
Thereisambiguityinwhatweknow.Notallmainlinecongregationsarelosingmembers,andnotallpartsofthecountryarelosingtothesamedegree.Mainlinedenominationscanboastsomerapidlygrowingcongregationsthematchforalmostanyspecificlocalgrowthclaimedbyanyotherdenomination.Insomejudicatoriesgrowthoccursroutinelyalmostacrosstheboard.Statisticsgetskewedwhenone
![Page 18: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
judicatorywithtwolargecongregationsandmanysmallonesreportssignificantgrowthwhichwaslimitedtothosetwocongregationswhilesixtyotherseachexperiencedlosses.Thetruthoneexperienceslocallyismorecomplicatedthanthestatistics.
Thefactremains.Membershiplossistheoverallpictureinthemainlinedenominations.Thereisnoquestion.Denominationalexecutivesandleadersannouncemembershipinitiatives,"decadesofevangelism,"programswithaggressivegrowthtargets.Inspiteofthat,thecurvescontinuedownward.
TheoverallstatisticsasreportedannuallyintheYearbookofAmeri-
![Page 19: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Page3
canandCanadianChurchesshowremarkablyconsistentcurvesinseveraldenominationsoverthepastfewdecades.2ForsimplicityIwillillustratewithcurvesfortheEpiscopal,Lutheran,Presbyterian,UnitedMethodist,andUnitedChurchofChristdenominations.3
EpiscopalianMembership1950-1990
0003-02.GIF
ELCAMembership1950-1990
![Page 20: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Page4
PresbyterianMembership1950-1990
UMCMembership1950-1990
![Page 21: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Page5
UCCMembership1950-1990
Notethatthecurvesarerelativelycongruentinshapeanddirection.Theygoupanddownatsimilarpointsalongthescaleofyears.
Thatisnottosaythatthedenominationshavesimilarnumbersofmembers.TheMethodistcurvebeginsatwelloverninemillionmemberswhiletheUnitedChurchofChristbeginsatabitundertwomillion.MethodistcantakewrycomfortinthefactthattheyarefailingfromahigherbeginningpointthanthePresbyteriansandEpiscopalians.Theyhaveabiggercushionunderneaththem.
AsIhaveshownthesefivegraphstopeopleofmanydenominationsaroundthecountry,Ihavesensedtheirsurprise.Yousee,beforeseeingallthesedifferentcurves,eachgroupwasawareonlyofitsowndownwardcurve.Eachhadgenerallythoughtthatitalonehadaproblem:thatitalonehaddonesomethingwrong.Cause-and-effectthinkinghadledeachtofindsomeoneorsomethingtoblametoexplaintheproblemtheythoughtnobodyelsehad.EpiscopaliansblamedasocialministryprogramcalledGeneralConventionSpecialProgram(GCSP)ofthelatesixties.Orthenewprayerbook.Orthenewhymnbook.Ortheordinationofwomen.PresbyteriansarestillblamingthecontroversyaboutAngelaDavis.OrthemovetoLouisville.SomeMethodistsarestillblamingBishopOxnamorthe
![Page 22: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
racismprogramoftheWorldCouncilofChurchesinthesixties.IimagineUCCmembersprobablystillblameGovernor
![Page 23: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Page6
WinthropforhispoliciesintheMassachusettsBayColony!Lutheransaresureit'sbecausetheyreunitedandmovedtoHigginsRoad.
Closertohome,peopleblamedtheirownpastor,bishop,orexecutive,ifnotsomeparticularpracticetheydisliked."It'sthenewhymns!""It'sthatmotiontheypassedatthegeneralassembly!""OurministerusesthenewversionoftheBible.That'stherootofit."
4Stillothersblamedtheusualcatchallpermissiveness.
Thefivecurvestogethersuggestthatweareinvolvedinsomethinglargerthanwehadthought.Ananalysisoftheproblemcarriedoutinternallywithinasingledenominationissimplynotadequate.Solutionsdesignedasonedenomination'sresponsetoitsproblemwilloverlookwhatmaybethekeyfactorsbecausethemostimportantfactorinthedeclinesmaybeoutsideanyofthedenominations.Itmayevenbethateffortsdesignedtodealwithonedenomination'sproblemanyprogramdesignedforonedenominationwillsimplybewastedeffort.Somethingisgoingonthatisbiggerthananyofthedenominations.Itisthis"somethingelse"thatmakesmetalkaboutthestormweareallin.
AninterestingbookfromanearlierperiodUnderstandingChurchGrowthandDeclinedifferentiatedbetweenfoursetsofvariablesthataffectgrowthcurves.5Itclaimedthatmakingsenseofthecurvesthemselvesrequiresustoanalyzeeachoffourquitedifferentfactors:(1)nationalcontextualtrendsfactorsrelatedtothechangesinthesocialandintellectualcharacterofthelargercommunity,thenation;(2)localcontextualtrendsthingsgoingoninthelocalcommunityandshapingthelivesoflocalresidents;(3)nationalinstitutionaltrendsnationalchangesspecifictoeachofthedenominationalfamiliesandoftendifferentfromthoseofotherdenominations;(4)local
![Page 24: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
institutionaltrendsthatinvolvewhatishappeningspecifictothecongregationoneislookingat.
Theseresearcherssuggestthatgrowthordeclinecurvesneedtotakeaccountofallfourvariables.Theyargueagainsttoosimpleortooquickajudgmentaboutwhere"thetrouble"maybe.
Churchleadershavehadallthisinformationbeforethemforatleastadecadenow.IntheninetiesarticlesinTime,Newsweek,andmanylocalnewspapershavemadeAmericanlaypeopleawareoftheproblem.Thisawakeningoftheordinarycongregationalmemberhasmovedthemembershipissueontothefrontburnersofconversationandactionandputtheprofessionaldenominationalleadersonthedefensive.
![Page 25: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Page7
IamremindedofthesimilarkindofpublicoutcryearlyinthesixtiesfollowingpublicationofJohnRobinson'spopularpaperbackHonesttoGodandthesubsequentinterviewintheSundayTimesofLondon.IdeasthathadbeenbandiedaboutforagenerationortwointheologicalseminariesofEnglandweresuddenlydumpedintothepublicarena.Thelaitywasshockedandupset.
Lossesofmembershiphavemovedoutoftheprivatepreserveoftheresearchersandthechurch'sprogramprofessionalsandsuddenlybecomepublicproperty.Andthepublicchurchmembersisconcerned.Clergyanddenominationalleaders,particularlyamongthemainlinedenominations,areonthedefensive.
Whatcanbesaidaboutthesecurvesofincreasinganddecliningmembership?
RightaftertheSecondWorldWarthemainlinedenominationsexperiencedaremarkablegrowthofmembership,almostacrosstheboard,andthatincreasepeakedbytheearlysixties.Sinceabout1965therehasbeenastrongandcontinuousdeclineinmembershipinmainlinedenominations;somehavelostfrom20to40percentoftheirmembers.
Thatisnotthewholestory.Statisticscanmislead,andthesecurvesdo.Theypresentapicturesignificantlymoreoptimisticthanfactswarrant.Theymeasurethesheernumberofmembersontherollsofthesedenominations,nottherelationshipofthenumberofmemberstothenumberofpotentialmembers.ThreeresearchersraisethisquestionintheirinterestingbookVanishingBoundaries:TheReligionofMainlineBabyBoomers.
6Itismisleadingtolookatthesheernumberofmemberswithoutcomparingthemtogeneralpopulationstatistics.Itisasifanautomobilecompanyweretotellitsstockholdershowmanyofitscars
![Page 26: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
werecurrentlyontheroadwithouttellinghowmanyweresoldinrelationshiptothenumberofpotentialbuyersoutthereinthemarket.
InVanishingBoundariesHoge,Johnson,andLuidensraisetheadditionalquestionsofwhatishappeninginthesocialenvironmentinwhichthechurchesexist.7Thatinformationisevenmoreunsettlingforpeopleinmainlinechurchesthantherawmembershipcharts.
Again,thegraphsIincludedearlierinthechapterpointtorapidgrowthofthemainlinechurchesaftertheSecondWorldWar,followedbyaperiodofrapidlosses.Noonelikestoseereducednumbersandstrength.Thatwouldbetrueevenifthepopulationremainedstable.Ifthemembershiplossesoccurredataperiodofrapidgeneralpopulation
![Page 27: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Page8
growth,thelosseswouldbemuchmoreserious.Andthatiswhathappened.
ButasfarasIknow,nooneuntilHoge,Johnson,andLuidensevertalkedaboutit.OncetheVanishingBoundariesmanuscriptbecameavailable,otherresearchershavemadethesamepoint.
8
Intheyearschartedabove,thenumberofpotentialmembersofchurchesdidnotremainstable.Actuallyitincreasedsignificantly.Theactualpopulationofthecountrygrewbyconsiderablymorethanathirdinthoseyears.Hadthedenominationalmembershipcurvesincreasedbyathirdtheywouldhavebeenholdingtheirown.Thedownwardcurvespeaksforitself.Buttheiractuallosseswhencomparedtothepotentialinthepopulationareatleast30percentworsethanthegraphs.Thegraphswehave,disturbingastheyare,aremisleadingandsignificantlymoreoptimisticthanthefactswarrant.
Letmeputitbaldly.Whatappearedtobeacleardeclineinnumbersbeginstolookmorelikeanosedive.ThereisthecurvethatdescribesthepopulationoftheUnitedStatesbetween1950and1990:
PopulationoftheUnitedStates1950-1990
![Page 28: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
![Page 29: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Page9
Foraperiodroughly1945-1965theEpiscopaliansandPresbyteriansexperiencedasignificantperiodofunusualgrowth,growthwithoutprecedentforthem.AlthoughallthedenominationsIciteexperiencedsolidgrowthintheyearsfollowingWorldWarIIandthebabyboom,thegrowthoftheEpiscopalandPresbyterianchurchesoutstrippedthepopulationgrowthforafewyears.Forawhilethosedenominationsexperiencedcomparativelymoremembersandconsequentlymoremoneythanpreviously.(LaterIwillcommentonmanyconsequencesofthisperiodofunusualgrowth.)
9
EpiscopalianMembershipasaPercentageofthePopulation1950-1990(PleasenotethatthefiguresonwhichthesegraphsarebasedcanbelocatedinAppendixB,page128.)
![Page 30: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Page10
ELCAMembershipasaPercentageofthePopulation1950-1990
PresbyterianMembershipasaPercentageofthePopulation1950-1990
![Page 31: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Page11
UMCMembershipasaPercentageofthePopulation1950-1990
UCCMembershipasaPercentageofthePopulation1950-1990
![Page 32: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Page12
Thepostwarincreaseofthegeneralpopulationhadtwomainingredientsthebabyboomandimmigration.Andneitherofthesegivesmuchcomforttomainlinechurches.Researchindicatesthatpostwarmembersofmainlinechurcheshadfewerchildrenthanmembersinpreviousgenerations,andthecongregationsarenotadequatelyholdingeventhosediminishednumbersofyoungmembers.
10Itisalsotruethatthemainlinedenominationshavenotgenerallybeenintheforefrontofeffectiveevangelizationofimmigrantpopulations.
Whenallissaidanddoneaboutthenumbersgame,themainlinedenominationsfacesignificantbadnews.Ibelievethenewsasreflectedinmarketshareisconsiderablyworsethanwehaveletourselvesbelieve.Asonelooksatnumbersofmembers,itisclearthatthechurchesareinthemiddleofastormofconsiderableproportions.
That'snotallthebadnews.
TheMoneyGame
Intheareaoffinancingreligiousinstitutions,thepictureismixedbutoverallnomoreencouragingthanthemembershiptrends.Oneverypositivepieceofnewsisthatmainlinechurchmembershaverisentonewlevelsofgenerosity.Althoughtherehasbeenasignificantdeclineinmembership,theloyalmembersleftaremoreandmoregeneroustotheirreligiousinstitutions.Per-membergivinghasrisenmorerapidlythaninflation.Intheshortterm,moredollarsarebeinggivenbyfewermembers.Asanexample,theEpiscopalChurch,whichmovedtosupporttithingatallpolicylevels,hashadastrongresponsetoaconcertednationaleffort.
Butinthelongterm,resourcesarelikelytodeclinesharplyifpresent
![Page 33: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
membershiptrendscontinue.
Iwilloutlinesomesignificantproblems.
Thememberswhogiveareolderaswellasfewerthaninpreviousgenerations.Thegiversarenotbeingreplaced.Thefullimpactofthiswillnotbeknownforadecadeortwo,butitisanominousbitofnews.Theyoungergenerationofmembers,perhapscaughtinthetensionoflowerfamilyincomesandhighercosts,doesnotyetseemtohaveboughtintothelevelofgenerositythatmarksitselders.Certainlythatpressureisacutewheresingle-parentfamiliesareinvolved.Changesinsociety
![Page 34: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Page13
thathaverequiredmanyfamiliestodependontwopaycheckshaverestrictedtheavailabilityoffundingforchurchprograms.
Ofcoursecongregational-institutionalexpensesarerisingatleastasfastasincome.Inmanylocationscostsarerisingfasterthanincome.Theresult?Asqueezeincongregationalbudgetsforatleastthepasttwodecades,acrunchinthebudgetsofthosedependentoncongregationalofferings(includingregionaljudicatorybudgets),andchroniccrisisandperiodicemergenciesinnationalbudgets.
Theprognosisforthosewhodependoncongregationalfinancialsupportiscloudy,tosaytheleastschools,colleges,seminaries,benevolentagencies.Onecanunderstandtheaggressivewaythoseinstitutionsareemphasizingplannedgivingandendowment.
Thecloseranagency'sorinstitution'stiestothelocalchurch,themorelikelyitistofindsupport.Denominationalleaderstendtoseethisasreflectiveofnarrowparochialism;Idonotagree.Theproblemsimplyisthatcostsarerisingmorerapidlythanincome.Iseenoevidencethatitwillgetbetter.
Denominationafterdenominationhasengagedinsystematicbudgetcuttingeveryyearfortwentyyears.
11Wedonotseemtonoticeituntilthereisacataclysmicshortfall,ashasoccurredwithLutheran,Presbyterian,andEpiscopalchurchesintheearlyninetieswithmajorstafflayoffs.Lookingatthestatisticsandthetrends,Iwonder,Whowillbenextyear'svictim?Remainingdenominationalstaffseemtobesaying,withcrossedfingers,''Thankheavenitwasthemandnotus.Besides,wefixedtheproblemwhenwebottomedoutlasttime.''
Mystatisticsdonotdealwiththeemotionaltolltakenonconscientiousstaffpeopleinjudicatoryanddenominationaloffices
![Page 35: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
whofaceannualcutsintheresourcestheyneedtodothejobstheyfeelcalledtodoandwanttodowell.MostofthetalentedstaffpeopleIknowinnationalofficeshavefacedyearafteryearofdecreasingbudgets,withdollarincreaseslessthaninflationandwithsalaryincreasesonholdalmosteveryyear.Manyofourtalentedpeoplesitinofficeswithoutthefundstomountprogramsorevencallmeetings.Thishassomethingtodo,also,withtheadversarialclimatethatdevelopsbetweencongregationsandtheirregionalandnationalbodies.
Aviciouscircleexists.Denominationalstaffpeopledesignprogramstorespondtowhattheyhearcongregationsneeding.Theyannouncethenewprogramsbasedonwhattheyhopebudgetswillfund.
![Page 36: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Page14
Thenincomeshortfallsmakenonewmoneyavailabletoproducetheprogramsalreadyannouncedandexpectedbycongregations.Nobodytakesresponsibilityfortheshortfall.Denominationalstaffsometimesmutterabout"havingtomakebrickswithoutstraw."Wehavebeenaskingthemtodoexactlythatformorethantwentyyears,andwehavebeencomplainingaboutthequalityofthebricksatleastaslong.Everybodyseemstrapped,victimized.Thefactisthatthereisnomoneyandwedonotknowhowtocutback.
TheinterrelationshipofcostsandbudgetswasdramaticallypresentedtomerecentlybyaPresbyterianfriend."Ourexperiencein1991wasthatnationalmissiongivingdeclinedexactlyinproportiontotheincreaseinmedicalinsurancepaymentsfortheclergy."Aslocalcostsincrease,moneyiskept"athome,"notsent"abroad."WhenHartfordSeminaryandTheAlbanInstitutecollaboratedonastudycomparing1970-1980churchstatisticsinNewEnglandandtheMiddleAtlanticStatesto1970-1980censusdata,wefoundthatincometocongregationsstayedslightlyaheadofinflationforthosetenyears,butthatthecongregations'givingtootherinstitutionsbeyondthemselvesdidnotkeepupwithinflation(althoughactualdollaramountsdidincrease.)
12
Inlarge,"successful"congregations,itmightbeeasytooverlookthegrass-rootsimplicationsofsuchbudgetsqueezing.ButthelocalimportofthiscrunchisdescribedbyRev.GayJenningsinanunpublishedreportbasedonherworkintheEpiscopalDioceseofOhio.Inthisreportshehasanarrowfocus,theeconomicviabilityofthe"standard"modelparishstructurethatsomanycongregationsstruggletosupport.
Itisnolongerpossibletoassumethatasignificantmajorityof
![Page 37: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
congregationshavetheresourcestoemployafull-timeseminarytrainedpriestaswellassupportbuildingfacilities,program,andoutsidegiving.ChuckWilsonandWesFrensdorffpublishedastudyconcludingthatthebudgetthresholdforthisfullcomplementisbetween$75,000and$85,000.In1992,theDioceseofOhiohasconcludedthatthebareminimumneededisapproximately$80,000.That'sthemagicnumber.FortypercentoftheonehundredandelevencongregationsintheDioceseofOhiohavebudgetsoflessthan$80,000.Almosthalfourcongregationsarenear,at,orbelowtheleveloffinancialviability.13
![Page 38: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Page15
Shegoesontoputherexperienceinperspective:
In1982,onlysevenOhiocongregationswereservedbyclergyonapart-timebasis.Today(1992)thirty-threeofourcongregations,orjustaboutthirtypercent,areservedeitherbyclusterclergyorbi-vocationalclergy.TheDioceseofOhioisnotanunusualdiocese.Wearenotabliponthecurve.Andwearenotapoordioceseeither.
Whatthistalentedstaffpersonissayingisechoedacrossthecountryindifficultlocaldecisionsasconditionschange,makingitimpossibleforreligiousinstitutionstocarrythefinancialresponsibilitiestheyhaveinthepast.LetmebeclearIamnotupsetthatwearebeingforcedtofacedifficultdecisionsandmakechanges.AtthispointIamsimplynotingthatthefinancialsqueezeishavingimpactincommunityaftercommunity,denominationafterdenomination,yearafteryear.Itisapartofthebigpicture,andthenewsisnotgood.Thisisallpartofthestormwearein.
TheSecular-SocietyGame
IhavealreadymentionedtheHoge-Johnson-Luidensresearch,publishedasVanishingBoundaries.ThisempiricalstudyofsixhundredPresbyteriansraiseslargequestionsforthoseofuswhowouldpositionthechurchesasaresourcetothecomingcentury.Iwillsummarizesomeoftheirwork.
Between1989and1991theseresearcherslocatedabout500upper-agebabyboomers(peoplewhowerejustunderforty-twoatthetimeoftheresearch)and,forcomparison,125peoplefromaslightlyoldergroup.AllwerePresbyterians,andallhadgonethroughthePresbyteriansystemasyoungpeopleuptoandincludingbeingconfirmed.Withalotofpersistenceandhelpfromlocalcongregations,theresearcherscontactedmostofthoseonthetargetlistsfortelephoneinterviews.
![Page 39: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Thefullresultsofthesefascinatingconversationscanbefoundintheirbook.Forourpurposesitisusefultonotethatasmiddle-ageadults52percentofthe625werestillactivelyinvolvedinchurchlife;48
![Page 40: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Page16
percentwereincategoriesdefinedas"unchurched,"butonly8percentofthetotalweredefinedas"nonreligious."
Whathadledtopeople"droppingout"ofchurchlife?
Clear,definitiveanswersdidnotcomeout.Butresearchersmadesomeconclusionscontrarytothecommonwisdomespousedindenominationaldebates.
First,itisnottruethatmanymainlinekidshavemovedtoconservativeorfundamentalistchurches.Atleastthisisnottrueofthesamplewestudied.
Second,itisnottruethattheseyoungpeoplehaveleftbecausetheyweresoreatdenominationalleadersorpolicies.Inreality,fewknowaboutthesemattersandfewcare.Themajorityaren'tinterestedindenominationalpoliticsorevendenominationalidentity.
Third,itisnottruethattheyhaveleftduetoattitudesaboutcongregationalchurchlife(asopposedtobelieffactors).
14
Mostofthesedropoutsdidnotdropoutprimarilybecauseofsomethingthereligiousinstitutionwasdoingorwasnotdoing.Rather,itissimplyasifthechurchsomehowslippedofftheirradarscreens.Itceasedtobeimportanttothem.
Theresearchershypothesizethatthemostimportantfactorinthedropoutisnotsomethingthechurchesaredoingornotdoing;itisthecharacteroftheculturesurroundingthecongregations.
Thisinformationisstartlinganddismayingtochurchleaders.Itsuggeststhatthethingsweknowhowtodobesthavelittletodowithwhostaysorwhogoes.Weknowhowtodevelopprograms.Apparentlythispopulationisnotinterestedinprograms.Itsuggeststhattheverywayweorganizeourselvestorespondtotheproblemof
![Page 41: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
churchdropoutsmayhaveverylittleimpactonthepeoplewhodropout.
Theculturalenvironmentmaybemoredeterminativetomembershiplossesthanthecharacterofwhatthecongregationisanddoes.Thatseemstobethelessonofthisparticularpieceofresearch.Ithelpsusgetperspectiveonthefactthat80percentofthepeopleinAlabamabelongtoachurchwhileonly15to20percentofthepopulationdoessoinCaliforniaandOregon.Ihaveahardtime,muchasIlovemyfriendsin
![Page 42: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Page17
Alabama,believingthattheyarefourorfivetimes"better"thanmycard-carryingchurchfriendsinCalifornia.What'soutsidethecongregationmaybemoredeterminativeofcontinuingmembershipthanwhat'sinside.Canthisalsobetrueoftheattractionofnewmembers?Mightitalsobeshapedmorebytheenvironmentthanbywhatwedoinsidethechurches?
Butiftheissueoflosingmembersissogreatlyamatterofthesocialenvironment,how,then,doweaddressit?
Iamnotconvincedthattheresearchershavethefinalwordonthisone.Istheremoreweneedtoknow?Yettheirresearchraisesthestakesforusinreligiousinstitutions.Ourverywaysofdoinganythingaboutthedeclinesmaybeinquestion.Whatdowealwaysdotofixsomethingthathasgonewrong?Analyzeitanddevelopaprogramtofixit.
Whathappensiftheproblemdoesnotrespondtoprogram?Thatistheprovocativequestionraisedbythisresearch.
Intheareaofmembershiplosses,wearenotdealingwithsomethingthatisresponsivetoanewprogramevenaverygoodprogram.Weareengagedinabasicinteractionbetweenreligiousinstitutionsandthenatureofoursocialenvironment.Theresearchershaveliftedtheproblemtoanewlevelofdifficultyandcalledustomovebeyondournarrowanswerstoaddresslargerissuesthanwehaveheretoforehadthegutstoface.
IfIamright,wedonotneedanewsetofprograms.Weneedchurcheswithanewconsciousnessofthemselvesandtheirtask.Thestructureswehaveinheritedhaveshownlittlecapacityforsuchradicalrethinkingoftheiridentity.
Thatismorebadnewsforthereligiousstructureswenowhave.Thatisanotherpartofthestormweface.
![Page 43: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
SomeUnexplodedBombsThatAreLyingAround
IwanttodescribeafewthingsthatIseelyingaroundthechurchesorthesocietywiththepotentialforhavingenormousimpactintheyearsahead.Myvisionisnarrow:Iamthinkingaboutthemintermsofhowtheymaywellaffectourreligiousstructures.Itmayactuallybegoodforsomeofthesebombstogooff;thesocietyandthechurchesmightfare
![Page 44: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
Page19
whereIlive,churcheshaveseriousproblemsattemptingtoexpandorrelocate.Similarly,aslocalcommunitiesandthefederalgovernmentfinditharderandhardertobalancebudgets,theyaresuretoreconsiderthetaxexemptionsofchurchproperty.Churcheswillsimplyhavetopaythecostsofpoliceandfireservices.Thiswillbeespeciallytrueaspropertyownerswhohavenothingtodowithchurchestakeajaundicedviewofagroupthatseemstobegettinga"freeride"onthebacksoftheirownhighertaxes.Thismanynothappenforyearsinsomeplaces,butIthinkthepressuresareinevitable.
Myfather,asmall-towndoctor,neverchargedaclericofanyfaithforprofessionalservices.Thatpracticewasmirroredbydrugstoresanddepartmentstoresandmanylocalmerchants.Thosepracticeswereawaythatsociety'svaluesquietlysubsidizedreligiousactivity.Howquicklythosepracticeschange.Theyseemquaintjustonegenerationlater.Theonly"pastoraldiscount"IcountonisfreeparkingattwolocalhospitalswhenImakepastoralcallswearingmyclericalcollar.Pastors'familieshaveadaptedtochangeslikethis,partlybytherapidincreaseoftwo-incomefamiliesinthemanseorrectory.
Whatwouldhappeninyourcongregationifthepastor'shousingallowancebecamefullytaxable?Manycongregationswouldtrytofindawaytoincreasethepastor'sincomebyseveralthousanddollarstocompensateforlostpurchasingpower.Wherethecongregationsimplydidnothavetheresourcestodoso,thepastorwouldfaceasignificanteffectivedecreaseofincome.ThathasalreadyhappenedinrelationshiptoSocialSecuritytaxes.WhenclergybecameeligibleforSocialSecurityseveraldecadesago,theyweredeclared"self-employed"forSocialSecuritypurposes.Congregationswiththemeanstodosooftengivean"allowance"equaltohalftheSocialSecuritytax(theamountregularlypaidbyanemployer).Incongregationsthatcouldnotprovidethispayment,theclergytooka
![Page 45: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
significanthit.Somespousesdecidedtoseekemployment.Suchchoiceshaveeconomicimplicationsforallcongregationsandforthesupportofclergy.Whenmoneyisshort,hardchoiceshavetobemade.
Whatwouldhappenifallchurchpropertyexcepttheworshipspacewereputonthetaxrollsofthetown?(Thisisalreadyhappeninginsomeplaces,withargumentonlyoverwhatconstitutes"worshipspace.")Whatwouldhappentoacongregation'sabilitytomakemissiongiftsoutsidethecongregation?Whatwouldhappentotheabilitytopaysalaryincreases?
![Page 46: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Page21
pieceofalargercategoryofpotentiallyexplodingcommoditycoststhatcouldhavesimilarimpact.Doesanyoneremember1972,whenoilpricesdoubledanddoubledagaininafewmonths?Doyourememberthestrugglewithchurchbudgetsthathadbeenhonedandfinallybalancedandthenblownoutofthewater?Inourhigh-techagethereispotentialforotherunexpectedbombsofcosttoexplode.
Themedicalcostbombisalreadygoingoff,andithaspotentialforcontinuingimpactonthechurches.Theremaybeothers.Theyarebadnews.
Litigation
Mygenerationgrewupinaworldinwhichnoonewouldhavedreamedofsuingthechurchforanything.Wenowinhabitaworldinwhichpeoplewhofalloffthecurbinfrontofthechurchthinkaboutsuing.Manypastorswonderiftheyshouldcarrymalpracticeinsurance.Judicatoriesarealreadyswampedbyunexpectedlegalcosts.Theburstofsexualmisconductcasesofthelateeightiesandtheninetiesisalongoverduecalltoaccountingforprofessionalbehavior,butitbringsinitswakeunexploredthicketsofliabilityandcost.Evensuchroutinethingsasextendingacalltoanewpastormayrequireexpensiveprivateinvestigationsofpersonalbehavior.Itdoesnotseemthatthesecostswilldiminish,andtheycouldskyrocket.
TheologicalEducationandUnemployedClergy
Wehaveinventedanenormouslyexpensiveformofprofessionaltheologicaleducation,thegraduatesofwhicharepricedoutofthefinancialreachofmoreandmorecongregations.Wearenotaloneinthis.Otherprofessions(legalandmedical,tonamebuttwo)havedevelopedsimilarovercapacityfortraining.Mycrystalballdoesnottellmewhatmighthappeninthisrealm,butInoteitasanimportantworryforusall.Wheneverthereissuchanexcessofcapacityfor
![Page 47: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
trainingincomparisonwiththemarketforservices,thereiscauseforconcern.
Itisdifficulttoarticulatethefullproblem.Manydenominationsreallydonotknowhowmanycandidatesforordinationareinthepipeline
![Page 48: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
Page23
Conclusion
Badnewsisnevermuchfuntothebearerortothereceiver.MyhunchisthatmuchofwhatI'vewrittenisnotatotalsurprisetomyreader.IdonotbelieveIamexaggeratinginsayingthatweareindeedinthemiddleofstormyseas.Thesituationthechurchesareinismuchworsethanwehavebeenledtothinkbyleaderswhistlinginthedark,tellingusthatthetroubleshave''bottomedout''orthat"weareturningaround."AsIseeit,wewillnotgetoutofthesecomplexissuesinthesimplisticwayswehaveusedbefore.Thisisnotsomethingwecangenerateaprogramtofix.Aprojecttoincreasechurchmembershipwillnotwork.Notwillanewimprovedstewardshipprogram.Thisnewsisbadnewspreciselybecausewhatwehavedoneinthepastisnolongersufficient.Whatweknowhowtodoisnotgoingtostillthestorm.Thisisnotgoodnews.
Andyet,IwritethisbookbecauseofmyconfidenceinthereligiouscommunityanditsdedicationtotryingtolistentoandfollowGod.Iwantthisbooktohelpusendourshallowoptimismthateverythingwillturnoutallright.IwantthisbooktohelpusfaceGod'scalltoreshapeourlivesandourinstitutionsinfaithfulnesstoGod'scallintothefuture.Thisisnotanoptimisticcallforusto"fixit."Itisastatementthatweare,indeed,inthemiddleofavaststorm,theendofwhichweshallnotsee.
![Page 49: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Page24
Chapter2TheHeartoftheMatter:TheApostolicTaskoftheChurch
GoingtotheRoots:TheGoodNewsandItsProclamationbyJesus
Ifthechurchesareinthemiddleofstormytimes,facingperhapsunprecedentedchallengesoverthenextfewgenerations,itisimportantthatwebeclearaboutwhatweneedourcongregationstobe.Ifwearetotransformthecongregations,wefirstneedtogetclearaboutwhyweneedthemandwhatweneedthemtobeforus.Earliergenerationshadassumptionsaboutwhatcongregationswere.Thoseassumptionsworkedforhundredsofyears,helpingChristianmenandwomencarryoutwhattheyunderstoodmissiontobeintheirtime.Thoseassumptionsledtotheestablishmentofinstitutionsandstructuresinadditiontocongregations,allshapedbythechurch'sconcerntobuildChristendom.
1
Thoseassumptionsnolongerworkinourtimes,leadingtoincreasingtroubleinourcongregationsandintheinstitutionsaroundthem.Inaddition,thestormweareinhasledusintoconfusionaboutthewaythatliesahead.Weoftenfeellost,andwithsomedesperationweclingtofamiliarpartsofthepast.Withthatlostdesperationwesometimesdefendourcongregationsandourotherreligiousinstitutions.
Butforwhatpurpose?That'stheimportantquestion.Forwhat?Thequestionpushesustolooktotherootsofwhatweneedcongregationsfor.
![Page 50: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
Onecanvisitcongregationsthatseemtoexisttopreserveeighteenth-andnineteenth-centurymusic.Ilovemusicenoughtohopesomebodytakesonthattask,butI'mnotsurethat'swhatIwantcongregationsfororthatthatiswhattheyhavetocontribute.Docongregationsexist
![Page 51: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
Page25
sotheycanpreservegenteelsocialstructures?I'mnotopposedtothat,ifsomepeoplewanttodoit,butI'mnotsurethat'swhatweneedcongregationsfor.Aretheytopreserveanethnicheritagefromthepast?Again,Ithinkthat'sagoodthing,butI'mnotsureweneedcongregationstodothat.DoweneedthemtoprovidemeetingplacesforAlcoholicsAnonymous?Doweneedthemsoeverycommunitywillhaveapaidpastoralcounseloravailabletothosewhocannotpayforatherapist?Doweneedthemtoprovideameetingplaceforpeopleconcernedforcommunitybetterment?Ihavenoquarrelwithanyofthoseasbyproductsofcongregations,butnoneofthemseemsbigenough,frankly.NoneofthemcarriesbyitselfthekindofpowerthatcomesfromconnectingwithGod'spurposesandintentions.Theyareniceenoughinthemselves,buttheyhardlyprovidethekindofenergythatturnssocietiesupsidedown.
Whatarecongregationsfor?Iwanttoaddressthatissuefirst.ThatiswhatImeanbygoingtotheroots.Oncewedothat,wecanworkonhowtomakecongregationsmovetowardfulfillingtheirpurposes.
IfthebadnewsthatsurroundsusisaspervasiveasIsuggest,itisallthemoreimperativethattheeffortswemaketoshapethefuturefocusontheessentials.Forme,goingbacktotherootsistogobacktothestorythatremainsnormativeformethebiblicalrecordand,withinthat,thestoryofJesus.
TheheartofthematterbeginsinagospelstoryinwhichJesusgoestohisownrootsofmeaning.HequotesfromtheHebrewscriptures,aprimarysourceofhisownspiritualnurture,astheyareofours.
Luke'ssettingisfamiliar.Jesushasreturnedtohishometownafteraseriesofeventsthatmightnowbecalledavocationalcrisis.Whateverhehadbeenandknownbefore(andtherecordisthin)probablyafteraperiodinadesertcommunity,thisyoungman,JesusofNazareth,hashadalife-changingencounterwithaprophetattheRiverJordan.The
![Page 52: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
impactofhisencounterwithJohntheBaptistsenthimtoaprayerfulsolitudeinthehillstograpplewithGod'swillforhim.Whatactuallytookplacethereinthehills,wewillneverknow;therecordedstoryofhischoicesandoptionsisaseriesofpoeticimagesthatprobablygobacktosecond-orthird-handinterpretationsofstorieshetoldsomeofhisfriends,perhapsatnightbyacampfire.Fromwhatwelaterlearnoftheyoungman,wecanbeassuredthatwhenhewentuptothehillstosortouthislife,hedidwhathedidatothermomentsofcrisis:Hereflected
![Page 53: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
Page26
onthelawandtheprophets,onthegreatwritingsthatheknewbyheart.Hethoughtandrethoughtthestoryofhispeopleintheirlove-haterelationshipwithGod.Heprobablyhummedthetunesofthepsalmsorranthroughtheminhisheadthewaywedowithfavoritehymnsorsongs.Heprayed.HewrestledwiththemessageofJohntheBaptist.Ashestruggledwithwhohewasandwascalledtobe,itisclearthathereturnedagainandagaintothewordsofIsaiah,particularlytowhatourbiblicalscholarscallSecondIsaiah.
WhenhesubsequentlywenthometoNazareth,hometohisfamilyandfriends,tohishomesynagogue,thosewordsofIsaiahhauntedhim.Hechosethetexttoreadasthewelcomedhomeguest:
TheSpiritoftheLordisuponmebecausehehasanointedme;hehassentmetoannouncegoodnewstothepoor,toproclaimreleaseforprisonersandrecoveryofsightfortheblind;toletthebrokenvictimsgofree,toproclaimtheyearoftheLord'sfavour.(Luke4:18)
Theimpactwasdramatic.Inthecontext,hisfriendsandfamilyandneighborsrecognizedaproclamationofidentity.This,myfriendsandneighbors,iswhatIamallabout.Althoughtheylaughedhimoutoftownforhispresumption,weknowhespokethetruthbecausetherestofhislifetestifiedtothisclaim.HereinNazarethhe"talkedthetalk."Fortherestofhislifehewalkedthisverywalk.Whenheleftthesynagoguethatday,hestartedfulfillinghismission,andhedidnotstopuntilhewasstoppedonGolgotha.Whatdidhedo?Heannouncedgoodnews;heactedoutgoodnews;hedemonstratedgoodnews.Thegoodnewsofliberation.HeshowedthatGod'srulewasapresentrealitywithintheworld,thatithadthepowertoovercomeallthebadnewsoftheworld,allthebadnewsofillness,rejection,sin,andoppression.Thisiswhathedemonstratedtherestofhislife.
![Page 54: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Whenwesomedaysortourselvesoutwewhofollowthisman,wewhofollowthetraditionofthispeople,wewholooktothesameLordwhospoketoAbrahamandSarahIthinkwewilldiscoverthatthisiswhatwearecalledtobeabout.ThisvocationJesusclaimedinNazarethpointstothevocationtowhichwearecalled,thevocationintowhichourcongregationsarecalledtodiscovertheirownidentity.Hisidentityled
![Page 55: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
Page27
himtoidentifywithandspeaktothepainofhisworld.Heinviteshisfollowerstothatsamevocationofdemonstratingandproclaiminggoodnews.
Ifwe,too,aretohavearoleinitsproclamation,itiscriticalforustogetagoodfixonwhathemeantbygoodnews,andhowheseemstohaveinterpretedIsaiah'smessage.
Wearenotcalledtocopythespecificsofwhathedidinfirst-centuryPalestine;wecannotre-createthoseconditions.
2Butthestoriesaboutwhathedidandhowhetriedtocommunicatehisliberatingmessageofgoodnewsshouldgiveuscluesforourownlives.Withthisinmind,letuslookatthreeshortgospelstoriesthattellushowhedidit.Let'sconsiderthestoriesasiftheymightberecordedbydifferentonesinourcommunity.I'llparaphrasethefirststoryasmightamoreliberaltheologicalcolleague.
ParaphraseofLuke4:31-37:JesusHealsaDemon-PossessedMan
OnceuponatimeJesuswascalledontospeakatthecongregationinCapernaum,acityinhishometerritory,throughwhichhisreputationhadspread.Thecongregantswereastonishedwiththepowerofhisteachingbecausehemincednowordsandstatedclearlywhatthescripturesmeant.Therewasno"asRabbiSo-and-Sosays....andontheotherhand,RabbiThis-and-That,speakingfortheJerusalemconsensus,putsitthisway...."Hedidnothemandhaw,buthespokeclearlyandauthoritatively.
Well,therewasawell-knowntroublemakerinthecongregation,contentious,bitter,constantlydisruptingthecommunityandinjectingpoisonintowhateverhewaspartof.Heshowedupandbegantopullhisoldtricks.Prettysoonthewholecongregationwasinanuproar.Heinterrupted,madepersonalattacks,questionedeachspeaker'smotives,andwasgenerallydisruptive.
Jesusspokedirectlytohim."Stop.Bequiet.Icommandyou!"Theman
![Page 56: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
wassoastonishedthathefellsilent.Hewasspeechless.Noonehadeverspokensodirectlytohimorcalledhimtoaccountforhisbehavior.Hesatdown.Thatveryeveninghebegantoreexaminehislife.Yearslaterbothheandothersrememberedthatmomentasacrucialturningpointinhislife.
![Page 57: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
Page28
Ifyouwish,youmaytakeoffenseatthisalmostclassicallyliberalinterpretation.Takecomfort.IalmostwentsofarastosuggestthatJesusconvincedthemantogotoatwelve-stepprogram!Iamwellawarethatthisisnottheonlyinterpretationpossible,andIuseothermodeswithsomeoftheotherstories.ThistellingsuggestssomethingofwhatmayhavehappenedinthatsynagogueinCapernaum.Perhapsitwasmuchmoredramatic,perhapsnot.
ThepointaboutJesus'encounterwiththisdemon-possessedmanisclear,nomatterhowweinterprettheactions.Jesusdirectlyaddressedthatman'spain,hispeculiarissuesordemons.Thiswasnomatterofmasspsychology.Hespokenogeneralities.IfJesus'taskwastobringgoodtidings,ashehadannouncedinNazareth,thenitwasgoodnewshighlyspecifictothisman'sbadnews.Thismanwasintrouble,andJesusspokedirectlytothetrouble.Werethereactualdemonslivinginthatman?Iftherewere,Jesusspoketothemandtookpoweroverthem.Ismypaleliberalversionmorepalatabletoouragethanthetraditionaltranslations?TherecordindicatesthatJesusdealtwithwhateverthepathologywas.Theman'slifewastransformedatthepointofhispain.Jesusrecognizedandaddressedwhateverwasdestroyingthisman'slife.Theresult?Themanwasliberatedfromthedemon-possessedlifehehadpreviouslysuffered.
ThisstoryisamodelofhowJesusactedinsituationaftersituation.Helookedtothespecificpaininfrontofhim,andherespondedtothatpainwithgoodnewsrelatedtothepain.Thatistheessenceofhisministryandtheheartofthetaskofcongregationsandofeveryonewhowouldfollowhim.
Letuslookatanotherstory.
ParaphraseofMark8:1-9:TheHungryPeople
AsJesus'reputationspread,largecrowdsgatheredwhereverhewas
![Page 58: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
expectedtoteach.Onedayanenormouscrowdaboutfourthousandshowedupinthecountryside.Theywerestillaroundthreedayslater,andJesuswasconcernedthattheymightnotmakeithomewithoutsomesustenance.Whenhisfriendsaskedwhatintheworldhecoulddoaboutit,heaskedwhatresourcestheycouldlayhandson.Whentheysaidtheyhadsevenloavesandafewfish,he
![Page 59: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
Page29
tookwhattheyhad,blessedthefood,brokeit,andfedthepeople.Toeveryone'sastonishment,therewasplenty.Asamatteroffact,whentheycollectedthefragmentsleftover,theyfilledsevenbasketsafterfourthousandpeoplehadeaten.Thenhesentthemallhome,full.
Thisstoryistoldinamoreconventionalstyle.Butinitsownwayitmakesthesamepointastheformer.Jesuspaidattentiontothespecificcharacterofwhatwasinfrontofhim,andheresponded.Hehadgoodtidingstoproclaim,andhedidthatforthreedays.Butattheendhebecameawareofanareaofneedthathehadnotaddressed:physicalneedforfoodsopeoplewouldnotgetsickonthewayhome.Prosaic?Yes,butveryrealtoanyonewhowashungryandheadedhomeafterthreedaysata"conference."Jesustunedintothespecificneedthebadnewsexperiencedbythatparticulargroup,andherespondedtoit.
Thoseofuswholiveinsacramentalreligiousculturescanrichlyembellishthestoryimagesofeucharisticworship,phrasessuchasbreadoflife,meaningsofthemysticnumberseven.Butforthepurposeoftryingtofigureoutwhatitmeanstobeamessengerofgoodnews,itisenoughtonotethatJesushadnodifficultyunderstanding"goodnews"asservingupbreadandfishtohungrypeople.Whatseemstomatterisidentifyingaspecificneedandrespondingtoit.Whenhebroughtgoodnews,itseemedtohavedirectrelationshiptopainortobadnews.Thepeoplewerehungryandhegotbreadforthem.
Let'slookatanotherstory,thisonefromJohn'sgospel.
ParaphraseofJohn2:1-11:TheMarriageWine
EarlyinJesus'ministryheandhisdiscipleswereinvitedtoawedding,probablyofafriendofhismother'sbecauseshefeltsomeresponsibilityforhowthereceptionwent.Itwasafestiveoccasion,andtheguestsratheroutdidthemselveswiththerefreshments.Jesus'mothernoticedthatthe
![Page 60: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
winewasgivingout,andshetookherconcerntoherson.Jesusseemedatfirstreluctanttorespondinsuchasetting,perhapsthinking,asIamsureIwould,thatthisisarelativelytrivialmatter,hardlyworthgettinghotandbotheredabout.Butthemotherknewthesonandtoldtheservantstodowhateverhe
![Page 61: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
Page30
asked.Seeingtheenormouspotsstandingthereforritualpurification,Jesustoldtheservantstofillthemwithwater.Theydid.Bucketafterbuckettheypoureduntilallsixwerefull.ThenJesustoldthemtoservethewatertotheguests.Incredibly,thewaterturnedouttobewinethefinestkindofwine.Sofine,indeed,thattheguestscommentedonittothehost.I'msureJesus'motherwasnotsurprised.
Asastory,thisdoesn'thavehighdrama.Thereisnothingoflifeordeathatstakehere.Whatistheworstthatcouldhavehappened?Someembarrassmentoverashortageofwine?Adressing-downofthewine-stewardforunderestimatingtheheatofthedayorthenumberofbottlesneededforthecrowd?Inthescaleofthings,thisisnobigdeal.Jesushelpedsomepeoplehaveamoreenjoyablewedding.Yes,thereareothermeanings.Thereistheaffirmationofmarriage.TherearehintsoftheeucharisticwineandforeshadowingofJesus'death.Theremaybeambiguity,also.Isthelineaboutchangingtheritualpurificationwaterintowineanotherofthechurch'santi-Semiticput-downsofJewishfaithandcommunity?(Somehowweshouldhavelearnedbynowthatitisnotnecessarytoputothersdowntoaffirmwhatoneis!)
Forourpointtryingtounderstandthetasktowhichreligiouscongregationsarecalledbythiswanderingrabbionceagainthemeaningisclear:Jesusrespondedtotheneedofthepeoplearoundhim.Hedidnotwriteoutagreatcheck.Hedidnotgetanothermusicalgroup.Hedidnotorganizegamesfortheguests.Hedidnotpreach.Theywereshortofwine;heprovidedwine.Hegavethemgoodtidingswine.Nobigdeal.
Threestories.Therearemanyotherslikethemthroughoutthegospels.EveryoneIcanthinkofunderlineswhatIampullingoutofthesethree.Jesusalwaysmadegoodtidingsavailableintermsofthreecharacteristics.
![Page 62: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
1.ForJesus,goodnewswasalwaysindialoguewithbadnews.Goodnewsisprofoundlycontextual.Forablindman,goodnewsissight.Foralameperson,goodnewsistheabilitytoleapanddanceorevenwalk.Fortheguilt-ridden,goodnewsisbeingforgiven.Forthepersoninprison,goodnewsisgettingoutofprison.Forthelonely,goodnewsiscommunity.Forthepersonorsocietycrushedbyoppression,goodnewsisfreedom.Forapersonpossessedbydemons,goodnewsis
![Page 63: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
Page31
tobereleasedfromtheirpower.Forhungrytravelers,goodnewsisfoodbeforetheyfacethejourneyhome.Foramarriagerunningshortofwine,goodnewsisafewbucketsofgoodwine.
2.Therefore,goodnewscomesinmanyforms.Itisnotonethingoronewayofdoingthingsoroneconcept,even.Goodnewscomesinasmanypackagesasdoesbadnews.
3.ThesestoriesleadmetothinkaboutJesus'respectforboundaries.Eachpersonisallowedfreedom.Thedemon-possessedcomestoJesusandbegstohavehistormentended.Thehungrylookuptobefed.ThemotherasksJesusforhelp.Jesus'interventionsarenotcoercivebutresponsive.Herespondstoopenness;hedoesnotcomewithhisbagoftrickstodohisthinginspiteofthosearoundhim.Inonecase,heevencheckswithalamemanbeforetryingtohealhim."Doyouwanttogetwell?"heasks.Helistens,andwherepeoplewillopenuptheirbadnews,hisgoodnewsisready.Hedoesnotforceofpushhisgoodnews,butheneverholdsitback.
Theseareimportantcluesforthepurposeofourcongregationsifwewouldtrytobuildcongregationsthatgenerategoodnewsforourworld:communitiesthatlivegoodnews,thatturnoutbearersofgoodnews;congregationsthataregoodnewstobepartof;communitiesthataredeeplyresponsivetoallkindsofneeds,thatareabletorecognizetheinfinitekindsofhurtandpainthatwearecalledtoaddress;communitiesthatrespectandhonorthepersonalandgroupboundariesbywhichwesecureouridentities.OurcongregationsarecalledtobecommunitiesthatfollowJesusinbringinggoodnewstothepainoftheworld.
Nosmalltask.
LetmebeclearthatIknowIamwalkingonslipperyground.Thesewordsandphrasesgoodtidings,goodnews,andevengospelhaveall
![Page 64: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
beentranslatedintothewordevangelismfromtheGreekeuangelion.Goodnews.WhatIamtalkingabouthereisafarcryfromwhatdenominationsandchurchestalkaboutasevangelism.Indeed,Ifindmuchofwhatchurchesdointhatnamesingularlywrong-headedandmisleading.ThebiblicalconcepttowhichIamtryingtobetrueisawordofreachingout,notofgatheringin.
Imaybearguingforareinventionofevangelism.Iamarguingthatthisbusinessofcommunicatinggoodtidingsisattheheartofwhatourcongregationsmustbeabout,anditiswhatourcongregationsneedtobehelpingeachoneofusdo.
![Page 65: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
Page32
Letusexplorehowwemightbetterrethinkthiscentraltaskofeverycongregation.
ProclaimingGoodNewsinOurTime
TwoModels
GrowingupasaChristianintheSouth,IexperiencedaworldthatthoughtofitselfasChristendom,eventhoughitsactuallifewasfar,farlessthanthat.ButinthatworldIwasexposedtotwogiantsoffaith.
Althoughmostpeoplearoundmehadanaversiontoatleastoneofthetwo,frommyearliestexposuretothemIunderstoodthatbothwereevangelistsandbothweregiants.Imetonlyoneofthem,andheisnowdead.AlthoughIseetheotherontelevisionoccasionally,wehavenevermet.BothweresouthernersandProtestantslikeme,soIfeltregionalkinshipwiththem.Onewasblack;theotheriswhite.BothwereBaptists,thepredominantfaithoftheworldIknew,fardistantfrommyownlow-churchEpiscopaltraditions.
OvertheyearsIwatchedthem,learnedfromthem,andadmiredthem,butIkeptwonderinghowtheycouldbesodifferent,havesuchdifferentmessages,andyetstillrepresenttomewhatevangelismwasallabout.
MartinLutherKing,Jr.,representedthepropheticstrandofourheritage,standingstrongagainstoppression.ManypeopleinthewhitecultureinwhichIgrewup,peopleIcaredabout,thoughthewasthetoolofthedevil.Othersthoughtthesunroseandfellonhim.Asachildofmyculture,Istartedoutwiththeformergroupandhadtodosomegrowingtodiscoverthathewasatrueprophetforme.OneofthetreasuresofmylifeistheworncopyoftheLetterfromtheBirminghamJailIfoundinmyfather'seffectsafterhisdeath.Idid
![Page 66: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
notknowwhatmyfatherthoughtofMartinLutherKing,Jr.,untilIfoundthatletterfilledwithmyfather'sappreciativemarginalnotes.
BillyGrahamistheothergiant.ThepeoplewithwhomInormallyconsortgenerallyleaningliberalinpoliticsandtheologyhavesuchlowregardforhimthatIrarelybringuphisnameintheircompany.WiththosefolksIkeepBillyGrahamasmyprivateclosetsaint!EarlyinhisministryIsometimeswonderedabouthisseemingblindnesstothe
![Page 67: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
Page33
propheticdimensionsoffaith,butIwaswillingtoleaveittoGodtosortouttheflawsofeitherofmygiants.
Isimplyknewthatpersonalfriendsandacquaintanceshadheardandhadtheirliveschangedbythegoodnewsoneortheotherofthesetwomenhadspoken.IsawevidencethattheyhadbroughtgoodnewstosituationsinwhichIhadpreviouslyseenthebadnews.Thatfitmyunderstandingofevangelism.TheirwordsandactionscarriedthepresenceofGod'skingdomintosomelivesandsituationswithwhichIhadpersonalknowledge.
ForyearsIacceptedthefactthatmyadmirationofthetwodefiedrationality;whattheywerewasmoreimportantthanwhetherornottheyfitintomycategories.Strugglingwiththeirdifferentgiftsasevangelists,however,ledmebeyondtraditionalwaysofthinking.
Ifbothofthemwereevangelists,ifbothofthemwerebearersofgoodtidings,thenourdefinitionsaresimplyinadequate.Evangelistsarenotjustonethingandalwaysthesame.Thetruthismorecomplexthaniscomfortable.MyfirstcluecamewhenIrecognizedthatKingandGrahamwerespeakingfromthesamegospel,butthateachhadadifferenttarget.Theysawthebadnewsdifferently.Jesussawgoodnewsascontextual,andthatgoodnewsdifferedinrelationshiptothebadnewsbeingexperiencedatanytime.WhatIwasfacingwastwopeople,eachofwhomwascommittedtothegospel,buteachofwhomsawadifferentkindofbadnews.
BillyGrahamspeakstothebadnewsheseesashelooksatthehumancondition.HeseesthathumanbeingsturnawayfromGod,separatethemselvesbytheiractionsortheirvalues,andbuildbarriersagainstGod'spresenceintheirlives.Heseessuchself-centeredlifeasleadingtoseparationfromoneanotherandfromGod;indeeditleadstomoralandspiritualdeath.AlthoughGrahamhasaplaceforthecommunityoffaithinhismessage,itisnotcentralbecauseheseesthebadnews
![Page 68: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
assofocusedintheindividual'schoiceofturningfromGod.TheissuesoflifeanddeathinvolveaprofoundlyindividualisticencounterbetweeneachpersonandthegraceofGodinJesus.Grahamunderstandsthatthesicknessesofsocietycomefromtheprofoundseparationthatbeginsasonewomanoronemanturnsagainstthegrainoftheuniverse,choosingtoturnawayfromGod'sever-readylove.
ThatisthebadnewsthatBillyGrahamaddresseswithhisgoodnews.Heproclaimsthathumanbeingsdonothavetobecondemnedto
![Page 69: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
Page34
separationanddeath.HespeaksthemessagethatChristthroughhiscrossandresurrectionhasbrokendownthewallsofseparation,makingpossibletruecommunitywithone'sfellowsandwithGod.AllonemustdoisplacetrustinChrist.GrahamwitnessestotheGod-givenpowertoturnfromthedeathofself-centerednesstoreallifecenteredinGod.
Ifyoulivewiththatbadnews,ifthatwayoflivingburdensyourheartandlife,BillyGrahamarticulatesincrediblygoodnewsforyou.PeopleIknowandlovehavehadtheirlivestransformedbythismessage.Ifthatisnotwhereyouare,themessagewilllikelyleaveyoucold.
MartinLutherKing,Jr.,knewandpreachedthatsamedoctrineinmostofhissermonstohiscongregationsinMontgomeryandAtlanta,butthatisnotthemessageforwhichheisbestknown,norwasitthegoodnewsthatmademeknowhimasanevangelist.Kingsawaverydifferentdimensionofbadnews.Hesawcorporatesystemswherebyonegrouptakesoppressivepoweroveranother,destroyingthehumanityofboththeoppressorandtheoppressed.Hespokeinthecontextoftheissuesbetweentheblackandwhitepeopleofthenation,buthesawthelargerissuesofclassandpowerandwealthasequallyoppressive.Hesawmorethanoneformofslavery,andherecognizedallofthemasbadnews.Hesawthespiritualpowerofourcorporatedemonsnationalism,racism,classismandhesawthepaintheybrought,bindingupAmericansandVietnamese,blacksandwhites,richandpoor.
TothatspecificbadnewsKingpreachedgoodnewsthatwasquitedifferentfromthatpreachedbyGraham.HesawandproclaimedthatGod'slovemeansliberationnotonlyofthesoul,butalsoofhumansociety.Kingdemonstratedthatboththeoppressedandtheoppressorcanenterintoliberation,andthatindeedonepartycannotbefreed
![Page 70: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
withouttheother.HesawthisliberationasdependentuponthepowerofGod'slove.Hehelpedusseethatthroughlovethepowerofnonviolencecouldovercomethebadnewsoffear,hate,oppression,andviolencewithinthestructuresofsociety.
Forthosesufferingfromoppressionandsocialdiscrimination,andforthosewhooppressanddiscriminate,MartinLutherKing,Jr.,spokegoodnews.Hisvisionofthebadnewsandhisarticulationofthegospelhastransformedmanylivesandhaschangedtheshapeofhistory.
Again,King'swayofstatingthegoodnewsisverydifferentfromGraham's,yetbotharegroundedinthestoryofJesus.Theyspeakdifferentmessagesoutofthesamegospelbecausetheyaddressdifferentsituations.Thedifferenceisinhowtheyseethebadnews.
![Page 71: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
Page36
Onthiscontinuum,Graham'svisiontendstofocusontheleft.King'svisiontendstotheright.Neithermancanbecapturedbyasingle"location,"yetitmakessensetotalkabouteachhavingacharacteristicfocus.
IseeeachofusashavingaroleasarespondertoGod'sworldandthebadnewsthatfloodsacrossitsface.Atthispointinyourlife,wherewouldyouplaceyourselfonthiscontinuum?Weseeandrespondtodifferenttypesofpain.Oneofusisconcernedaboutthewelfaresystem;anotherwantstohelpaparticularmanatthesubwaystop.Itisnotthatwhatothersseeislessormoreimportant,butjustthatweseesomehurtsandnotothers.Somethingsgrabus;othersdonot.
Isuggestweeachmayhaveagiftednessinwhatweperceivethecriticalbadnewstobe.Wearedrawntograpplewithit,worryaboutit,andseektounderstandthegoodnewsthatspecificallyaddressesit.Whytheattraction?Ihavenoidea.PerhapsourownexperienceoflifeorofthepowerofGodopensusuptothatparticulardimensionmorethantoanyother.Perhapsourownweaknessfocusesoureyesandattentionupononedimensionofthegoodnewsthatmostgiveslifetous.Perhapswediscoveredgoodnewsaswelivedthroughcatastrophicbadnewsandwereforeversensitizedtothatpain.
Abasicthemeofthisbookisthattheabilityto"see"badnewsrelatestoourdiscipleship.Thewillingnessto"dosomething"aboutitrelatestoourapostleship.
Isuggestthattheinnerpulltorespondismuchmorethanapulloranattentiongrabber.Itisnolessthanourperceptionofcall.Itisouropendoortothegoodnewswehavetoshare.(SeetheAppendixAforaneducationaldesignIusetohelppeopleworkwiththeseideastolocatedifferentperceptionsofbadnewsintheirlives.)
Jesus'good-newsproclamationhadthreecharacteristics:Itisrelated
![Page 72: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
tospecificbadnews;itappearedincontextuallyappropriateforms;anditwasrespectfulofindividualityandpersonalboundaries.
Isitreallyasurprisethateachofusiscalledtoourownvisionofthepainoftheworld,thateachofushasavoicetospeaksomethinguniquetoaspecialrealityoftheworld?
Ibelievethatthisindividualsensitivityisacluetowhereourcalltoservicemaylie.Amongallthepossiblethingsoutthereintheworldthatcausepainandhurt,therearesomeperhapsonlyafewthatclaimus,thatcallustobringgoodnews.Isometimessaythateverypaininthe
![Page 73: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
Page37
worldhasaspecialkindofVelcroonit,andthateachofushasgrownapatchofourownspecialbrand,also.Wecanbumpintoallsortsofpainoutthere,butwedonotresponduntilthereisamatch.Thenwehavenooption.Weareseizedbythepainthatmatchesourcall,andwemustact.
Thereisnomagicinthisunderstandingofvocation.Nevertheless,Ithinkthispull,thissenseofbeingseized,isGod-givenandhelpsussortoutwhatwewilldowithourlives,whatjobswetrytotake,andwhatcauseswesignupfor.
Congregationshaveastakeinthisdynamicbecausetheirtaskistohelpusbecomecarriersofgoodnews.TrainingindiscipleshipinvolvesincreasingthesensitivitywehavetothepainoftheworldatthesametimethatwearemoredeeplyengagedinthegoodnewsoftheJesusstorylivedoutinourcongregation.Moreaboutthatlater.
AMoreWholisticModelofProclaimingGoodNews:AMapofEvangelism
Anotherdimensiontothissimplecontinuumbroadensourunderstandingofwhatitmeanstobeaproclaimerofgoodtidings.
AsIthoughtaboutthedifferencesbetweenBillyGrahamandMartinLutherKing,Irealizedthatthecontinuumdescribedaboveidentifiesonlyoneofseveraldimensions.Ittargetsthebadnewsbutignorestheframeworkwithinwhichoneiscalledtoserve.
GrahamunderstandstheresponsetothebadnewsofestrangementfromGodtobearticulatedandactedoutina"religious"contextandwith"religious"language.Consequentlyhespeaksofsinandsalvation;hiscallstoactionaretomake''adecisionforChrist";themovementheurgesisintoreligiouscommunityandsustenance.
King,fromaverysimilarreligioustradition,cametorepresenta
![Page 74: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
responseinthe"secular"contextwith"secular"language.Whereheperceivedsystemsoppressingthehumanspirit,hecalledforactionmostlyinthesocialarenaoutsidereligiousinstitutions.Consequentlyhespokelanguageofoppressionandfreedom;hiscallstoactionweretomeetviolencewithnonviolenceoncitystreets;themovementheurgedwaswithinthesecularsocialstructures,thejudicialsystemsthepoliticalandeconomicrealms.
Thisbringsmetoaverybroadmapofwhatiscalledforifweareto
![Page 75: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
Page38
beacommunityproclaiminggoodtidings.Insteadofalinearcontinuum,Iseeamapthatincludesgreatdiversityofvocations,notjustonewaytoproclaimgoodtidings.IseeamapthatencompassesalargervisionforthereligioustaskofcongregationsthanIgenerallysee.HereIoutlinethatmapasagridthatincludesaverticalcontinuumsuggestingthedifferentstyleswithwhichonemightrespondfromareligiousstyletoasecularstyle.
Isharethisschematicasapointertotruth,notastruthitself.Likeallschematics,itoversimplifiesandexaggerates.ButitisausefultooltopointtothekindsofworkIthinkcongregationsarecalledtoenhance.Thispicturecanhelpusenlargeourvisionofthefieldofevangelism,thearenainwhichwearecalledtobebearersofgoodnews.
Again,canyouplaceyourselfonthismap?Whatbadnewsmostfrequentlygrabsyourattention?Andhowdoyouusuallyrespond?Iamsureone'spointofsensitivityandresponsechangesfromtimetotime.Solocationissimplyanapproximationofwhereoneisrightnow.
Asonthecontinuum,thereisno"bad"placeonthisgrid,norisonequadrant"better"thantheothers.BillyGraham'scalltoevangelismis
![Page 76: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
![Page 77: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
Page39
notbetterthanMartinLutherKing's.NorisKing'sbetterthanGraham's.Theyaredifferentperceptions,differentcallings.Indeed,asIpointedoutinthecaseofKing'spreachingasopposedtohis"public"ministry,itispossibleforonepersontorespondinmorethanonewaytothehurtsoftheworld.Atdifferentlifeseasonswemaylocateourselvesmoreinoneareathananother,onlytodiscoverourselvespulledorcalledtoanotherwayatanothertime.AsIhavealreadysuggested,KingministeredinhiscongregationsinastyleonemightidentifywithquadrantA.WithinhisleadershipoftheSouthernChristianLeadershipConference,hislocationonthemapwasmoretowardquadrantD.
Eachofthequadrantspointstoadifferentsetofsensitivitiestovocationandevangelism.Letuslookatthembriefly,onebyone.
QuadrantA.Peoplewhoselifeandfaithstoriesmakethemparticularlysensitivetoanindividual'sneedsandwhohaveaninternalcompasssetwithinreligiouscategorieswouldlikelyfindthemselvesinquadrantA.Suchpeople,onemightspeculate,wouldbringstrengthtoone-on-oneteachingandcareministries.Theymightbeattheheartofacongregation'sministryofintercessoryprayer,butevenmoresoofcontemplativeprayer.Thesepeoplearesensitivetospirituallostnessandyearningandgenerallyunafraidtospeakdirectlyfromawellspringoffaith-languageandfaith-experience.Suchpeoplewouldbefrustratedanduselessinmostcommitteesandwouldfleesocialprojectsliketheplague.Somemightmakegiftedspiritualdirectors.IlocatemuchofBillyGraham'sministryinthisquadrant.
QuadrantB.Thesepeopleareawareofhowpeopleneedeachother.Theyaretirelessinsupportingthecongregation'scorporateactivities.Theytendtosupportdenominationalprogramsandinstitutions,suchascollegesandseminaries,andcounselingcentersandcareprogramsestablishedbythecongregationordenomination.Theyaregenerally
![Page 78: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
goodmembersofworshiptaskforcesandheavysupportersofstudyprogramsthemorebiblicalthebetter.Pastorsandrabbisinchargeofcongregationsneedto"spendsometime"inthisquadrant,whetherornotitisthecenteroftheirlives.Muchofmyownlifesomefortyyearsofworkingin,with,andforcongregationstellsmethatthisishometerritoryforme,althoughIhaveperiodsinwhichIhavefocusedelsewhere.
![Page 79: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
Page40
QuadrantC.WhatIcalltheanonymoussaintsdwellinthisquadrant.Ithinkofpeoplewhogothroughlifedoingwhatneedstobedone,someoftheminquitehumblecircumstancesandsomeinprominentroles,butwhoneversaymuchaboutit.IknowagarbagecollectorinWashingtonwhorunsaneveningtutoringprogramforblackjunior-highkids.IthinkDagHammarskjoldmayhavebelongedherehislifeandworkasaninternationalstatesmanundergirdedbyaremarkablebutunspokenspirituallife.Ithinkofmyfather'slife-longministryasadoctorandcommunityleaderwhorarelysaidmuchabouthisfaith.Thesemaybethepeoplewhoshowupatearlymorningservicesbutneverserveontheboard.Theyareknowninthecommunitybyhowtheytreatpeopleandmakeadifference,buttheyareembarrassedtobeaskedmuchabouttheircongregation.Mostpeopletheyworkwithmaynotevenknowtheybelongtoacongregation.
QuadrantD.TheseIcallsecularsaints.Theyseetheprimaryfocusoftheirlivestobeservicetothehurtsofsociety.Somearearticulatewithpropheticpower,whileothersarefoot-soldiersinonerevolutionoranother.Suchpeopleoftengetirritatedattheslowpaceofthecongregationinbeingableto"getonwithit,"andtheycanbeseverecriticsofthevaluesincorporatedinadenominationalbudget.Theircenterofgravityisnotthecongregationorthedenomination,buttheircompulsiontorespondtosocialneeds.Morethanafewofthembecomereligious"alumni,"actuallyleavingreligiousstructuresandlifetotrytochangethecharacteroftheworldwithoutacontinuinglinktoacongregation.Isuspectthatmanywhopopulateenvironmentalassociationswouldfindthemselveshere.Suchpeopleoftenleavethereligiouscommunitybecauseofthevaluestheylearnedinthatverycommunity;theyareunableto"wait"forthecongregationorchurchleaderstorespondtothepressingneedstheyseeintheworld.
Useyourimagination,foramoment.Lookatthatgridall
![Page 80: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
quadrantsandyouwillbelookingatthewholerealmofbadnews.Youcandifferentiate,aswehave,amongdifferentkindsofbadnewsanddifferentneedsforgoodnewsinthelivesofpeopleandthestructuresofsociety.ItisamapoforawindowontheneedsforGod'sgoodnews,forevangelism.Lookingoutthatwindow,weseethefieldswhitewithharvestasnearasourimagination,asvariedasourcallings.Thevariety
![Page 81: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
Page41
ofneedsoutthererepresentsourneedtosendanapostolateasvariedastheneeds.
3
Intermsofthequalitiesrepresentedbythesequadrants,congregationsneedtobeascomprehensiveaspossible,notbecausediversityisamodernfixation,butbecausetheneedswefaceareacrosstheboard.Acongregationthatlackspeoplefromanyoneofthesequadrantswilllacksomethingtheministryneedsforitshealth.Acongregationthatoverbalancesitselforitsprograminonequadrantdoessoatthecostofmissingimportantareasofneed.
Ibelievethetaskofcongregationsistodotwothingsatonce:(1)tohelpmoreandmorepeoplelookthroughthatwindowtotheworldtoidentifywhatneedscallouttothem,and(2)tonurtureandstrengtheneachpersonandsendeachouttouseuniquegiftstorespondasonlyheorshecan.Asmembersidentifytheircallsandarenurturedandsent,wewillseethedevelopmentoftheapostolateofthefuturechurch.
Congregationsofthefutureneedtobecongregationsthatnurturevarietiesofsensitivitiestothebadnewsoftheworldandrespondtothosemanyformsofpain.Thesewillbecongregationsopentomorethanonepointofview.
Everymemberofthechurchstandsbeforeanimaginarywindow,facingalltheneedandhurtoftheworld.Most,butnotall,ofusfeelapulltoengagewithsomeofthatpain,whetheritisphysicalpainorhomelessness,ignoranceorspitefulness,hungerorillness,guilt,asenseoflostness,hopelessness,ordespair.
Acongregation'staskistohelpustoknowandclaimthepowerwehave,commitourselvestoengagethepainoftheworld,andthento
![Page 82: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
managetheprocessbywhichwearetransformedfrompassiveonlookerstosentpeopleapostles.OurcongregationsaretheretohelpeachofusgraspandbegraspedbythegoodnewsthatGodhasuniquelyforeachofus,andthentoempowerustogooutassentpeopleapostlestothepainoftheworldasbearersofourownspecialversionofthegoodnews.
ThestoryofJesusleadsustobecomedisciplesandapostlescarryingforththekindofgoodnewsthatJesusmodeledagoodnewsthatisprofoundlycontextual,touchingthedifferentkindsofpainpresentatanyplace;agoodnewsthatcomesinmanyshapesandsizes;agoodnewsthatalwaysleavestherecipientfreetoacceptorrejectit.Congregations,then,areabouthelpingusallbecomedisciplesandapostles.
Therootofitallistransformation.Thetransformationofeachofus
![Page 83: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
Page42
intoadisciplewhoselifehasbeentouchedandshapedbyJesus'goodnews.ThetransformationofeachofusintoaspecialpartoftheapostolateJesusiscallingintobeingtoproclaimhisreignoverall.
![Page 84: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
Page43
Chapter3TheTaskoftheCongregation:TransformationPreparingDisciplesandApostlesInthelastchapterwestoodbeforeanimaginarywindowthatlookedoutovertheworld,andwespeculatedaboutalltheneedsoutthereforcommittedactionandcaring.Thatwindowlooksoutacrossthelandscapeoftheworldinwhichthevarietyofhumanandsocialbadnewscallsforthosesenttobringeuangelion,goodnews.Thatisthefieldfortheactionoftheapostolate.
Lookingoutthatwindowontotheworldonecanseeavastcacophonyofhurtsandpain,inhumanityandinjustice.Theabilitytoseetheworld'spainasafieldforengagementcomesonlytothoseimpelledbyareligiousvision.Havingsuchavisioniswhatittakestobecomeanapostle.Helpingtransformordinarypeopleintoapostlesinvolvesfirsthelpingthemdiscovertheirdiscipleship.
Inthischapterwewillstartbyreversingthewindowperspective.Havingstoodbehindthewindowlookingoutintotheworld,nowwestepoutsideandlookbackthroughthesamewindow.Nowwefocusontheinnerlifeofthecongregationitself.Whatneedstohappentheretosupportandsendapostlesintotheworld?Havinglookedatthecriticalfunctionsthatbuildupdisciples,wecanthenaddresstheprocessbywhichdisciplesaretransformedtoentertheapostolate.
Aswelookedoutthewindow,ourfocuswasontheapostolatetheworkofchurchmembersintheworld,bearingwitnesstothekingdomofGodandseekingtobringittorealityinthemidstoftheworld'spain.Asweturnaroundandlookbackthroughthesamewindowfromtheworldintothecongregation,ourfocusisonthoseprocessesthatcalloutdiscipleshipandnurtureeachpersonineverdeeper
![Page 85: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
discipleship.
IntheNewTestament,buildingonthetraditionsoftheHebrew
![Page 86: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
Page44
scriptures,particularlythepropheticliterature,Jesusannouncedthebeginningofanewkindofhumancommunity.HecalleditthekingdomorreignofGod.WithinthatrealmhedescribedwhatIsaiahandJeremiahdreamedofaplacewherethepoorwerecaredfor,thesickhealed,wheretheblindreceivedsightandwidowsweresupported.Aplacewherethosewhowerelamecouldcometoleapwithjoyandwherethosewhowereinprisonoroppressedwouldbreakfreeoftheirprisons.
1
Jesusannouncedthatthiskingdomhadalreadybegun,andhisactionswerebasedontherealityofthekingdom.Inhisannouncementofthenewsocietyandinhisactions,therewaspower.Thenewsocietybeganasheacted.TheWordledtotheactions.Morethanthat,heinvitedhisfellowsandfollowerstoactinthepowerofthatkingdom.
Theydid.IthinkoftheremarkablestoryinActs3.PeterandJohn,goinguptothetemple,runintoalamebeggarattheBeautifulGate.Thestorypicksupdrama.Theirpursesareempty,andtheyhavenothingvisiblewithwhichtheycanrespondtohisneed.Isthebeggaroutofluck?No.Peteractsinthepowerofthenewkingdom.Hesays,"Ihavenomoney,butIcangiveyousomethingelse.Getupandwalk."Youknowthestory.Thelamemangotupandwalked.I'mconvincedthatthelamemanwasstupefiedtofindhimselfcured.IthinkPeterwas,too.Thegoodnewsseizedhimasheactedforthenewworld.Hehadthepowertoengagethedemonsoftheworldbeforeheknewhehadthepower.Hewasapotentialapostleuntilheactedasanapostle.Itwashissteppingouttoactforhealingthatmadehisapostolatereal.
HadPeternotactedonthepresumptionofthekingdom,thelamemanwouldnothavewalked,thepowertocurewouldnothaveappeared,
![Page 87: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
andPeterwouldnothavebecomeanapostle.WhatmadePeteractbeyondhisknowledge?Whatmadehimgobeyondhispreviousfaith?IhavenoanswerstothissetofquestionsbecauseIthinkweareontheedgeoftherelationshipbetweenone'sfaithandthatinwhichonehasfaith;itisnotfullyamatterofPeterorofGod,butofalife-dialoguebetweenthem.Wecanusepalelanguagevocation,faith-response,leapoffaithbutIamnotsurewewillevercapturethemystery.GodofferedPetertheoption,andPetertookit.ThekingdomappearedwhenPeteractedinitspower.
Ithinkthetaskofthelocalcongregationistohelpordinarypeoplebecomeengagedinthatmystery,peoplewillingtomaketheleapfromtheknowntotheunknownasPeterdid;peoplewhoactonthebasisof
![Page 88: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
Page45
thenewsociety,whoclaimthepowerofthatkingdom,whothenactforpeaceandjusticeandloveandhealing.Thecongregation'staskistocallthatfaithforthinusandsendustoactwithnopositiveassurancethatanythingatallwillhappen.
Inallthecomplexitiesofhistory,inalltheencounterswithorganizationalrealities,inallthetheologicaldebatesandphilosophicalanalyses,Ithinkwehavelostsightofthatsimplefocusoffaith.Ihavenoideaifcongregationswillgrowordeclineiftheyactonthatfocus,andfranklyIdon'tgiveadamn.ButIknowtheywilllosetheirsouliftheydon't.Thatpartissimple.
Howtodoitisnot.
IwanttomakeitclearthatthereismuchmysteryinwhatIwanttotalkabout.Iwilldescribeestablishedwaysbywhichwehavedevelopeddisciplesandprocessesoftransformation.Iwillbeginaconversationabouthowwemaygofurtherinourcongregations.ButIconfessthatIdonothavefinalanswers.Thismaybelikereadingadialoguebuthavingascriptthatincludesonlyonecharacter'slines.Thereisanotheractorwhospeaksandmovesinwayswedonotcontroloralwaysunderstand,butofcoursethatpartyiskeytothedialogue.(InJesus,mytraditionteachesandIbelieve,thetwosidesofthedialoguespokewithonevoiceandactedwithonewill.)
Aswethinkaboutthismysteriousprocessoftransformationbywhichpeoplebegintoactascitizensofthenewsociety,Iwanttoexplorefourfunctions,traditionaltocongregationallife:(1)thecommunitywithinthelargersocietywhattheearlychurchcalledkoinonia;(2)thelife-givingprocessessummarizedasproclamationwhattheearlychurchcalledkerygma;(3)thelore,thetradition,thestories,andtheirtransmissionwithpowerwhattheearlychurchcalleddidache;(4)theroleofservingwhattheearlychurchcalleddiakonia.Eachofthesefunctionsisameansforthetransformationofordinarypeopleinto
![Page 89: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
disciplesandanecessarysupportforalifeofdiscipleship.Thestrongerthesefunctions,themorelikelythecongregationistobeanactiveapostolatereachingouttothebadnewsoftheworld.
![Page 90: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
Page46
Koinonia:TheCongregationAsCommunity
Theregularoscillationofthechurchpersonbetweentheoutwardlifeofthepublicandtheinnerlifeofthecongregationisthestageformuchtransformation.Facingoutward,congregationsopenuptoapublicworldinwhichtheirmembersengage,areinfluenced,andexertinfluence.Facinginside,congregationsareanenvironmentforgrowthandsupport.Inkoinoniaamemberofacongregationlivesinthetensionofreligiousheritageandpublicarena.
Theoutwardengagementofthecongregationwiththepublicisacriticalissuefortoday'sworld.ParkerPalmerhasopenedupforusavisionofwhatthatpublicworldisorshouldbe:
Theword''public"meansallthepeopleinasociety,withoutdistinctionorqualification.Apublicschoolisaplacewherenochildisbarredfromentering,aplacewherethecommoncultureofapeoplecanbepassedalongtothenextgeneration.Apersoninpubliclifeisonewhosecareerinvolvesaccountabilitytothepeopleasawhole,onewhocarriesapublictrust.Eventheweakerphrase,apublicfigure,meansapersonwhoselifeisvisibletoallwhocaretowatchit.Wheninformationappearsinthepublicpressitisavailabletoeveryone,andapubliclibrarycollectsandstoressuchinformationsothatitwillbeavailabletopersonsyetunborn.Andthewordisusedinlessgrandioseways,asintheEnglish"pub"orpublichouse,whichisagatheringplaceforthewholecommunity.
2
Onereadsthisdescriptionwithnostalgiabecausepublichasmanynegativeconnotationstoday.Palmerexploreswhythisrichconceptofadeepbondthatcanbringadiversepeopletogetherhasdegeneratedintoatermthatmakesusthinkofinterestgroupscompetingwithoneanotherforaplaceatthe"publictrough."Hesuggeststhattherichpotentialofthewordpublichasbeenerodedbyourwillingnessto
![Page 91: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
giveawaythecareandmaintenanceofourcommonlifetoexternal,impersonal,oftenpoliticalstructures.Heargues(asdoRobertBellahandhiscolleaguesinHabitsoftheHeart3)thatthepublicrealmbecomesaseaofcompetitiveforcesandsocietybecomesaconglomerationofaggressiveanddefensiveorganizationsandpeoplelockedintocompetitionforresources.
Withapublicvisionoflifelimitedbywhatthelawallows,we
![Page 92: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
Page47
createaself-fulfillingprophecy.Palmercontinues:''fewerandfewerpeopleventureintopublicwithoutbeingwell-armed(figurativelyandliterally!)Smallwonderthatmoreandmorepeopleretreatfromthepublicarena...intothesanctuaryofprivatelife."Societyandgovernmentcannotgenerateavisionofa"publiclifeofvarietyandbreadth,alifeinwhichthehumanimpulsetowardcommunityisdrawnoutandencouraged."Governmentcananddoeshelpcompetinggroupsbalancetheirdifferentinterests;itcanprotectthosewhocannotprotectthemselves;itcanpunishthosewhooffendthepublicorder;butitcannotproduceavisionofwhatitmeanstoliveincommunity.Itcannotgeneratecommunity.
Palmer'sinsightsechobiblicallanguageinPaul'sconvoluteddiscussionsoflawandgrace.Societycandefineitselfandsetlimits,butweallyearnforacommunityinwhichweknowthatwearecaredforandvaluedinourselves.Societycanhelpusdefendourprerogatives,butitcannothelpusreachouttoothers(orothersreachouttous.)Societycandefinewhatisfairandlegal,butitcannotmakeourheartscareforothers,particularlythosewhoaredifferentfromourselves.Lawisessentialforlifetogether,butitisincompleteinitself.Wewantandneedmorethansocietybyitselfhastogive.
Onthemostmundanelevel,publiclawcandefinegrossmisconductasfelonies,butlawcannoteliminatethepatternsthatleadtofelonies.Itcanlockuppeoplewhocommitfelonies,butitcannotproducepeoplewholovetodogoodandwholovemercyandcareabouttheirneighbors.Somebelievetheproblemofcrimeinoursocietycanbesolvedbystiffersentencesandbetterlawenforcement.Inthisconversationaboutpubliclifewecansayquiteclearlythatyoucannothireenoughpoliceandyoucannotbuildenoughjailstoproduceapubliclifeofmeaningandvalue.Thatisadeadend.Thoughperhapsnecessary,itwillnotleadtoavision,ahope,andactionforarealmthatisgovernedbyself-givingratherthanself-aggrandizement.
![Page 93: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/93.jpg)
Thelargersocietyneedsthecommunitygracesthatarevitaltochurch-congregationalkoinonia.Ascitizensbecomediscipleswithinthecongregation,theybuildthepotentialtobecarriersofgracewithinthepublicrealm.Congregationsarelaboratoriesthatcanprepareusforpubliclivingandservice.Incongregationscitizenscanbegeneratedasprovocateursofgracewithinasocietyshapedbylaw.
![Page 94: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/94.jpg)
Page48
TheFeaturesCharacteristicofaGoodCongregation
Palmerlaysouttenfeaturesthathesaysarecharacteristicofpubliclifeasitshouldbe.Howcaneachopenuptoustheopportunitytomovecreativelybackandforthbetweenourtwoworlds?
Thesetencharacteristicsofthepublicandmyreflectionsonthemsuggestthewealthofthegiftsthatcongregationsbringtoanation(oraworld)thatseekstobecomecommunity.Indeedthesecongregationalgiftsmaybeessentialtothebuildingofaviablepubliclife.Atthesametime,thisisnoone-waystreet.Adialoguewiththesecharacteristicsofthepublicworldmayprovidenewdepthtothelifeofcongregations.
Theworddialogueiscriticalinthisdiscussionofkoinonia.Thiscallsforengagement.engagementthatbringsstrengthtoeachworld.
InPalmer'spublic:
1.Strangersmeetoncommonground.Dareweassumethatstrangersbringgifts,notthreats?Intoday'soutsideworldwearetaughttosteerclearofthestranger."Don'tmakeeye-contact!"Butithasn'talwaysbeenthisway.Inourcongregationswehavealaboratoryforreachingoutbeyondourselvesandourfamilies.Cancongregationsopenusuptoatleastcivilitytothosebeyondourcommunityoffamilyorfriends?Darewethinkofthepossibilityofapublicworldruledbythevaluesofhospitality?Canourcongregationsdemonstratethatpossibilitytoeachofuspersonallyandtrainusforthatkindofpubliclife?Cancongregationsraiseupdiscipleswholiveapostolicallyinthepublicworld?
2.Fearofthestrangerisfacedanddealtwith.Wedohavefearsaboutpeoplewhoarenot"likeus."Wehaveallsortsofstereotypesandprejudices,allkindsofunexploredmythsabout"others."Suchparanoiacripplesthesocialorderandsetsdiscriminatoryprocessesin
![Page 95: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/95.jpg)
stone.Allcongregations,eventhemostseeminglyhomogeneous,havewithinthemamixtureofagesandsexes,pointsofviewandbackgrounds.Canourcongregationsbeseenassafeplaceswherewecanreachacrossboundaries,wherewecansupportexperimentation?Indeed,manycongregationshaveahistoryofsendinggroupsofmembersintoothercommunitiestoworkandsocializewithotherspoundingnails,diggingditches,orstitchinglayettes.Withinthesafetyofacongregationalwork-group,theindividualdisciplecanmoreeasilyjointhestranger-communityincommonwork.Canourcongregationsbecomeintentionallaboratoriesforexposingustopeopleoutsideourgroups?
![Page 96: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/96.jpg)
Page49
3.Scareresourcesaresharedandabundanceisgenerated.Inoursocietythisessentialcharacteristicofpubliclifemaybeasthreatenedasany.Weseemtobeasocialorderinwhichtherichgetricherandthepoorgetpoorer.Whoistheretospeakforandactonanothervision?Whowillspeakifnotthechildrenofthescriptures,theBookinwhichpoetsandprophetsmadeitcrystalclearthatGodhasaspecialconcernforthepooramongus?InthelastdecadeIdonotthinkIhaveseenacongregationofanysort,bigorsmall,richorpoor,thatdoesnottakearegularofferingorotheractiontogetfoodtopeoplewhodonothaveenough.Inourlargercitiesaveryhighpercentageofhungrypeoplewhoreceiveafreemealgetthatmealatalocalcongregation.Itissomuchapartofourlifethatwedon'trealizehowunusualouractionsare.Sharingresourcesisjustwhatlifeis"supposedtobe."Thereisnobigdeal,nobrassbands.Itisjustwhoweareandwhowearetryingtobecome.Asweactonourvision,wearesayingsomethingtooursocietyaboutwhatpubliclifeoughttobe.Weareactinginthepowerofthenewsociety.Inthepublicrealmoursocialorderspeakswithfearofdiminishingresources:Ifyougetyours,thereislessforme.Ourbiblicalheritagespeaksofabundance,notscarcity:Themoreyouhave,thebetterIwillbe.Canwebringthisconsciousnesstotheworldweinhabit?Canwenurtureitinourcongregations,orarewe,too,goingtobecomelockedintoscarcitythinking?Intheyearsimmediatelyahead,asresourcesaremoreandmorelimitedinourreligiousinstitutionallife,aseveryonearoundusinchurchesandinthepublicrealmistalkingofcuttingbudgets,wemayhaveamoreandmoredifficulttimewitnessingtoabundanceasdisciples.Therewillbetestsofourdiscipleship!
4.Conflictoccursandisresolved.Ourcongregations,whateverelsetheyare,areseethingpoolsofconflict.Wehavedifferentwaysofdecoratingaltars,andwefightaboutit.Wehavedifferentideasaboutwhothepastorshouldbe,andwefightaboutit.Sometimesourfights
![Page 97: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/97.jpg)
aredonnybrooks,butmoreoftentheyarethetight-lipped,controlled,hard-to-finishtype.Thegrudge-generatingkind.Somefightsturnintofeudsthatlastgenerations.Sometimesthoseoutsidecongregationsaremorecomfortablethanweindealingwithdifferences.We"religious"folkhaveawayofcallingGodintothefighttohelpusdestroytheopposition.
Buttimesarechanging.Wearetryingtolearnhowtoreachconsensus,howtorebuildwhenfightsfractureourcommunities.Ourtradition
![Page 98: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/98.jpg)
Page50
bringsperspectivesaboutforgivenessandreconciliationthathelpusreachouttooneanotherforcommunity,notjustcessationofhostility.Aswedealwithourdifferences,welearnaboutreachingbeyondhostilityinthepublicworldtowardadifferentvisionofsociety.Canwelearntouseourownspiritualresourcesofforgivenessandreconciliationwithinourowncommunities,learningtobearwitnesstothesamepowerintheworldoutsideourcongregations?
5.Lifeisgivencolor,texture,drama,afestiveair.Everyactofworshipshouldbealaboratoryincelebrationofcommunity.Itisinterestingtonotethatreligiouscommunitiesinventeddramaandmusicandprobablypublicfestivalsallpointingtotherichpossibilitiesofcommunitybeyondfearandconflict.Thesedimensionsinourcongregationsandinourcommunitiesgiveusopportunitiestodramatizeaonenessandcommonalitywithothers.AchurchonEaster,atownparkontheFourthofJulybothspeaktowhatcommunitymeans,andourpresenceinvolvesusinthatcommunity.Congregationsneedtohelptheirmembersengageincelebrationsofcommunityandengagethepublicinitscelebrationsthatpursueavisionofwhatthelargercommunityiscalledtobe.
6.Peoplearedrawnoutofthemselves.Thelockeddoorsandbarredwindowsofcityliving,theresidentialsectionsprotectedbyarmedguardsandattackdogstheserealitiesspeakvividlyoftheisolationtowardwhichoursocietypushesus.Congregationscannotleavethisasthelastword:Wehaveamandatetoreachoutandtobringin.Webearahightraditionofhospitality.Inthatsensecongregationsarecounterculturaloratleastcountertothewaythecultureisdrifting.Ascongregationsreachouttotheisolated,theybecomeplaceswheretheisolatedcanengagewithothers.Inasocietywithstrongpressurestowardprivacy,thepublicrealmneedscongregationstohavevisiontorootpeopleoutoftheirhiddenalonenessandtrainthemforcommunity.Membersofcongregationsneedtobecomeneighborhood
![Page 99: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/99.jpg)
leadershelpingcitizensenterthelivesoftheirneighbors.
7.Mutualresponsibilitybecomesevidentandmutualaidpossible.Ihavealreadynotedthematter-of-factnesswithwhichcongregationsassumetheyaresupposedtodosomethingaboutthehungry.Manycongregationshavealistofpeopletoprayforthesick,theshut-ins,thegrieving.Andmanyhavecadresdeployedweeklytotakeflowerstothesick,totakeelementsoftheEucharisttothosewhocannotgettochurch,
![Page 100: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/100.jpg)
Page51
tocallonpeopleinthehospital.ThechurchIwalkbyonthewaytomyofficehasawholesetofparkingplacesreservedforthreehoursdailyforthosewhocometotakeMeals-on-Wheelstoshut-ins.Takingresponsibilityforoneanotheristakenforgrantedinourcongregationsbutnotinourpublicarenas.Inthisareacanourordinarycommunitylifebeabeacontooursocietyatthesametimethatitpreparesustoofferthesegiftsofserviceoutsideourcongregationalbounds?Andshouldnotcongregationalmembersbeamongthosewholeadandcarryouteffortstorebuildneighborhoodsandencouragecitizenstocareforoneanother'ssafetyandsecurity?
8.Opinionsbecomeaudibleandaccountable.Inthis"characteristicfeatureofpubliclife"Imustadmitthatcongregationshaveasmuchormoretogainfromastogivetothepublic.Themodestpoliticalsystemswithincongregationsneedtobeopeneduptothecandorwithwhichpublicfiguresarticulateanddefendpositions.Congregationswouldbestrengthenedbymoresuchaccountability.HavingsaidthatIalsonotethatcongregationsandtheirmembersdohavemuchtocontribute.Theygenerallyhaveafeelforthelegitimacyofopposition,fortheultimatevalueofthosewhoopposeoneanother.Congregationscanbringadimensionofcivilitytopubliccontention.
9.Visionisprojectedandprojectsareattempted.Peopleincongregationsareregularlyexposedtotranscendentvisionsofwhatlifeissupposedtobe.Theyseemindefatigableintryingtoaddresshurtsandpainstheysee.Iftheyaretobefaulteditisbecauseofthequixoticnatureofsomeoftheirprojectsgoingupagainsthumanevil(orcityhall)withwaterpistols.YetaninvaluablegiftcongregationsbringtopubliclifemaybethewaytheirhopeisgroundedtheologicallyinthisconceptionofGod.Congregationsbringpersistencetothetable.BecausetheirvisionsaregroundedinanunderstandingofGodandGod'spurposes,congregationsarenotaslikelyasthegeneralpublictodriftawayfromimportantvisionssuch
![Page 101: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/101.jpg)
ascaringforeachperson.CongregationsaregroundedinasenseofGod'spurposeandmovementthroughhistorysomethingthatdoesnotfadeafterafewdefeats,asdoespoliticaloptimism.Thereisabigdifferencebetweenoptimismandhope.Congregationsbringthelatter.Inagun-floodedsociety,congregationsknowaboutaworldinwhichswordsareturnedintoplowshares.Inasocietyofgangsanddrugs,congregationswitnesstoaworldinwhichthelambandthelioncandwelltogether.Webringvisions.Thatispartofwhatweare.
![Page 102: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/102.jpg)
Page52
10.Peopleareempoweredandprotectedagainstpower.Thechecksandbalancesofgoverningstructuresshouldprovideaframeworkthatprotectsthecitizenagainstunwarrantedassumptionsofpower.Atthesametime,thesestructuresgivespaceandscopeforacitizen'sgiftstobeshared.Congregations,intheirlifeofworship,actoutandcelebratetheimportanceoffreelygivengiftsshapedandconformedbystructuresofauthorityandcustom.Theyalsounderstandthelimitsofhumanintegrity,thepresenceofsinfulness,andthenecessityforlargerframesofvalue.
KoinoniaandaCongregation'sCriticalDistinctiveIdentity
Congregationalcommunitylifehasalwaysbeenunderstoodasthelocusoftheordinarychurchmember'sgrowthanddevelopment.Thisistruedespitethefactthatforathousandyearsormoreithasbeenassumedthatone"pickedup"andabsorbedfromthesocietyone'sknowledgeoffaithandgroundinginone'sheritage.ThewholeworldofChristendomratherthanthelifeofthecongregationitselfwasthe"teacher"ofthefaith.Itwassomethingthathappenedwithouthavingtopayattentiontoit,asonemight"pickup"decay-proofteethbydrinkingfluoridatedwater.ThatwasbasicallytheChristendomassumption.Communityreligiousfestivals,thelegalcodificationofavaluesystem,andthecharacteroflifeinthesocietywasunderstoodtogroundandrootoneadequatelyforspiritualgrowth.Duringthisperiodthefaith-communitysufferedalossitsabilitytodistinguishitselffromitsenvironment.Asthefaith-communitywasswallowedupintheculturalenvironment,itlostitssenseof"distance"bywhichitcouldunderstanditsdistinctiveidentityandthedistinctivenatureofwhatithadtooffertoandreceivefromtheenvironment.Socialscientistsdescribethisasthelossofasenseofboundary.Acommunitywillhavelittletoofferalargersocietyifitcannotdistinguishitselffromthatsociety,anditwillnotlongmaintainitsdistinctiveheritageifitcannottrainnewmembersinwhatisspecial
![Page 103: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/103.jpg)
aboutthecommunityitself.
Ifourcongregationsaretonurturetheirmembers,empoweringthemtobedisciplesandapostles,wemusttakeahardlookatasurprisinggapbetweentheexperiencesordinarypeoplehaveofGodandtheexperiencetheyhaveoftheirlocalcongregations.Overthepasttwo
![Page 104: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/104.jpg)
Page53
decadesanumberofresearchershavebeensurprisedtodiscoveraverylargenumberofpeoplewhohavehadwhattheyidentifyasdirectexperienceswithGodortranscendence.
4Ofcourse,thereisambiguityinthereports,butthesurprisehasbeeninthewidespreadnatureofthephenomenon.
SeveralofusdiscoveredandJeanHaldanelaterdiscoveredindependentlythatpeopledonotconnectthoseexperienceswiththereligiouscongregationstowhichtheybelong.Haldanepointedoutthatordinarypeoplewhohaveextraordinaryspiritualexperiencesoftendonotthinkthattheircongregationsorclergywouldbeinterestedinorabletohelpinterpretsuchexperiences.Itisasifpeoplehaveseparateddeeppersonalreligiousexperiencefromcongregationallife.Theyfeelthatthecongregationexpectstheirsupportandattendanceatworshipandactivities,butthatthecongregationhasnointerestintheirreligiousexperience.
Iknowthatseemsabsurd.Butitisasignofhowmuchwemustdotorethinkthecharacterofcommunitywithinourcongregations.Congregationsmustletgooftheirpreoccupationwithprogramsandactivitiesiftheycannotalsobeahomeinwhichreligiousexperienceandreligiousyearningiswelcomedandnurtured.Weneedcongregationswithasenseofcommunityinwhicheachperson'sexperienceofGodisaffirmedoratleastbroughtintotheopen.
Congregationsneedtoprovidespaceforintimatestorytellingthatencouragesmemberstosharethosedeepexperienceswithoneanother.Weneedtodevelopspiritualdirectorsineverycongregationtheministryseenasamatterofcourse,notonlyandalwaysasafunctionof"professionals."WeneedcongregationsthattaketheexperienceofGodasthenorm.Weneedcongregationsthat
![Page 105: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/105.jpg)
expecthealingtobepartofone'sfaith-life,whetherornotoneusestheordinarymedicalarts.HealingmaybeaslifechangingwiththehelpofBlueCross/BlueShieldasitcanbewiththehelpoflayingonofhands.Ourcongregationsneedtobetheplaceswherealloftheseexperiencesareseenasrelatedtoalifeoffaith.
Leftoutsidetheworshippingcommunity,suchexperiencescanleadtoallkindsofpsychicpathology.Paulwasobviouslybothdrawntoandnervousaboutsuchexperienceintheearlychurch.Hewroteappreciativelyofthepowerofspeakingintongues,buthewasalsoeagerthatsuchgiftsbebroughtunderthedisciplineofthecommunity.Thecongregation-communityhaslittlechanceofinfluencingsuchpractices
![Page 106: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/106.jpg)
Page54
towardhealthifitrefusestopayattentiontothelackofthisnecessarypartofkoinonia.
AtthispointIsimplynoteacontinuingcongregationalweaknesstheirinabilitytoidentifyandcommunicatetomemberstheirdistinctnature.Thisinabilityhandicapsourcongregationsinfulfillingtheirpurposeandmissiontotheirmembersandtotheoutsideworld.
KoinoniaWrap-Up
Congregationalmembersliveinthetensionoftheirtwoworlds.Theymovebackandforthascitizensoftworealmsthepublicandthereligiouspotentiallyenrichingeach.Withinthecongregation,theyinhabitacommunitythatcelebratesandtriestounderstandGod'srealmofshalom.Withintheirownbounds,congregationsarecommunitiesofgrowthandsupport.Thismakesthemakeyresourceforthetransformationofeachmember.Inthisareawehavemuchworktodoifcongregationsaretofulfilltheirfunctionofmakingdisciples.Whendisciplesmoveintothepublicrealm,asapostlestheybearwiththemthemarksofGod'srealm.
Asonelooksfromthecongregationoutwardtotheworld,onecanseethe"goodnews"oftheverypresenceofthecongregationasitrelatestoandinthatlargerworld.Inthemidstofapubliccommunitythatisincreasinglydividedandantagonistic,wherecontentionistherule,itisgoodnewstoseeislandsofcommunitythatlivebyadifferentsetofvalues.Congregationscanassistinthetransformationofsocietysimplybybeingplaceswhereadifferentkindofcommunitylifeisexperiencedandwitnessedto.Thisabilitytoincarnatecommunityisfarmoreimportantasgoodnewsintheworldthancongregational"outreachprograms."Inthissense,congregationsarecommunitiesthatcanbetransforminginfluencesinandexamplesfortheworldoutside.
![Page 107: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/107.jpg)
Congregationsremainoneofthekeyplaceswhereself-centeredcitizensmaybetransformedintodisciplesreadyandeagertobecomebearersofgoodnewstotheneedsoftheworld.AndfromtheseplacesthepowerofGod'scommunitycanbegintransformingasocietyintoacommunity.
Koinonia,longakeycharacteristicofthecongregation,remainsakeytothecongregation'sabilitytobeatransformingrealityformembersandforsociety.
![Page 108: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/108.jpg)
Page55
Kerygma:TheProclamationofGoodNews
Congregationshavetraditionallybeentheplaceswhereasapeoplewehavebeengroundedinourstoryandinitsmeanings.Storycamefirst,literally.BoththeHebrewscripturesandtheNewTestamentexistedasstoriesrecitedincommunitylongbeforeanythingwaswrittendown.Congregationsgavebirthtoscriptures.Incongregationsthestorytellerwasaskedtotellthestories,andthosecongregationspassedthestoriesalong,sometimesbendingthemabitinthepassing.Thereisnowaytogodeeperintoourheritagethanthroughthestoriesfaithfulpeoplepassedonthroughtheircongregationstofuturegenerations.
Thestorieshavealwayshadtransformingpower.NathantoldastorytoKingDavid,asimplestoryofarichmanwithmanyflocksandashepherdwithonepreciouslamb.WhenNathandescribedhowtherichmantooktheshepherd'soneewelamb,Davidwasoutragedatthecharacter'saggression.WhenNathan,referringtoDavid'ssinagainstUriahandGod,said,"Thouarttheman,"Davidheard.Thestorycarriedpowertoconvictandtotransform.
Jesustoldstoriesthathavebeenretoldgenerationaftergeneration,andthestorieshavenewpowerineachgeneration.ThestoryoftheGoodSamaritanhasspokentoprisonersofwarandtheircaptors.ItspoketoFlorenceNightingale.Itspoketomeasayoungmanaboutracialinjustice.Inthesedays,itspeakstomenandwomenwhobearresponsibilityforpolicyaboutethnicstrifeintheformerYugoslavia.ThatsimplestoryleadstosleeplessnightsforpolicymakerstwothousandyearsafterJesustoldittohisfollowers.Iwillhavemoretosayaboutstorybelow,butfirstIturntoaspecialwayinwhichcongregationshavecometoencounterthetransformingpowerofstories.
![Page 109: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/109.jpg)
ChurchesspeakofthepoweroftheWordtotransformlife.Theyunderstand"thepoweroftheWord"tomeanscripture,yes,butalsoprofoundreflectionuponit.Theyhaveexperienceditstransformativepowerintheactofpreaching.Inresponsetothatstrange,familiaractivityofpreaching,forgenerationaftergeneration,gatheredcongregationshavebeentransformedbythespokenword.
Whoknowswhatallhappensinpreaching?PhillipsBrooks,perhapsthebestEpiscopalpreacher
6sinceJohnDonne,spokeofitas"truthcommunicatedthroughpersonality."WilliamDols,executivedirectoroftheEducationCenter,speaksof"Maieuticpreaching,"likeningthetask
![Page 110: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/110.jpg)
Page56
ofthepreachertothatofamidwife:Apreacherassiststhehearertobringforthnewmeaningfromthestory.
Clearlythereismorethanrationalityinvolvedwhenacongregationrespondstogoodpreaching.Therelationshipbetweenthepreacherandthepreached-toisanessentialcomponentofwhathappens.Moreisinvolvedthanmeetstheeyeorstrikestheear.
Wherepreachinghastransformingeffect,thereisagivingandatakingofpower.Theonewholistensholdspowerthatcanbegivenorwithheld.Thehearercangiveorwithholdthatpower.Whenitisgiven,thepreacherisfreedtogobeyondrecitationtoproclaimtruthwithauthority.Insuchacasetheseedfallsonfertileground.Ifthehearerchoosestowithholdpower,holdingbackfromtheexperience,buildingwallstocloseoutanycommunication,theWordwillbeheldback.Theseedwillfallonbarrengroundandwillfailtobringfruit.
Inmyexperiencemorehearersarereadytogivethatpowerthanpreachersaretoclaimit.Thereisamomentearlyinthepreachingeventinwhichsomedeeppartsofthelistenerareopeneduptothepreacherasoneisnotroutinelyopeneduptoaneighbororafriendorevenaspouse.Thatmomentisaninvitationtotransformationandanopportunityforadialoguefromdepthtodepth.
Ifthepreacherreachesfromauthenticdepthsandtouchesthoseopenplaceswithrealstoriesoffaith,somethinghappens.Transformationcananddoeshappen.
Alltoooftenwepreachers,soinsecureinourselves,arebusyexplainingwhywearethereoringratiatingourselveswithajokeorbonmot.Wherewesucceed,wealleviateourownanxiety;afewpeoplewillrememberourbrilliantrepartee,butthemomentfortransformationmaydisappear.Preachingisdramaticengagement,notpublicspeaking.Thebusinessofpreachingistransformation,not
![Page 111: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/111.jpg)
transmissionofinformation.
Inthatdialoguebetweenpreacherandlistener,thepreacher'sroleasanidentifiedreligiousleadergenerallyhelpstheprocessoftransformation,butitisnotessential.Thefactthatthepreacherisusuallyaclergypersonsetsthisactivityapartfromordinaryconversation.Thatreligiousrolesetsthispieceofcommunicationwithinaframeworkofmemory,relationship,andexpectationthatoftenpredisposesthelistenertoopentheinnerdoor,butdoesnotguaranteethatthedoorwillstayopenforlong.Anymemoryofreligiousleaderswehaveknownorevenheardaboutaffectsouropenness.Ourpresentandpastrelationships
![Page 112: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/112.jpg)
Page57
withpastors,rabbis,andpriestsperhapsnotevenofourownfaithcommunitywillaffectouropenness.ExpectationsaboutwhatwewantandhopeforinrelationshiptoGodaffecthowwelistenandapproachthismoment.Ourownmemory,relationships,andexpectationsareheldthereinthepreachingmomentinthecommunitythatsurroundsus,whereeachotherlistenerisbringingthosesamedimensionsofexperiencetothespokenword.
Theresultisamoment,perhapsmore,ofcredibilitycredibilitythathasbeenearnedbygenerationsoffaithfulpastorswhoseinfluencecontinuestoleadmanylistenerstobeopentotheWordofGod,trustingthattheywillnotintentionallybeexploitedbythisparticularpreacher.Thatcredibilityremains,inspiteofnegativeexperiencesmanyofushavehadwithscoundrelsmasqueradingasclergy.Thatcredibilityisapreciouscommodityineverycongregationandforeverypastor.Wheretherehasbeenpersonalexploitationofthecongregationoritsmembersbyclergyinthepast(Iamincludingthesensationalmaterialthatgetsinthepapersandalsothemanylessdramaticwaysinwhichclergymaymisuserelationshipsortheirpositionoftrust),thenewpastorandthepeoplehaveamajorjobofrebuildingtrust,evenforsosimpleathingasbringingbackpowertothepreachingministry.Clergydomorethanprivatedamagetothemselvesandtheparticularpersonorpeoplewithwhomtheybreakthiskindoftrust;theyviolatetheframeworkwithinwhichgospelcanbepreachedandbelieved;theyfracturethetrustthatmakesitpossibleforonetospeakandanothertohear.Whereliabilitycanbeproved,theworstpunishmentsthecourtscanmeteoutareminorcomparedtothedamagetotheheartofreligiouscommunity.
Thepreachingweknowincongregationsisordinarilyanactivitywithinthecontextofworship.Buttraditionally,preachinghasexistedasamuchlargerengagement.AmospreachedbyusingaplumblinetodemonstrateGod'sdesireforjustice.Jeremiahwalkedthestreetsof
![Page 113: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/113.jpg)
Jerusalemcarryingayokeonhisshoulderstoillustratethefateofthenationifitdidnotturnfromitsways.PeopleoffaithhavealsodemonstratedtheWordintheiractions.ThedemonstrationsorganizedbyMartinLutherKingandtheSCLCwereproclamationsoftheWord,asareBillyGraham'scrusades.
CongregationsIknowdemonstratedtheWordbygoingtoSouthFloridaafterHurricaneAndrewandrepairinghouses.MyownparishsentagroupofyoungpeopletoHondurastobuildscreendoorsand
![Page 114: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/114.jpg)
Page58
installthemthisinaplacewherethereweredisease-carryinginsectsanditwastoohottosleepwithacloseddoor.ManypeopleIknowparticipateina''gratepatrol,''handingoutsandwichestohomelesspeoplewhosleeponthesubwayventilationgratesincoldweather.
Althoughdifferentinmanywaysfromtraditionalpreaching,alltheseactivitiesbecomedialogical.ThosewhogoastheproclaimersoftheWordalwaysarechangedbythosetowhomthey"speak."Thosewhocarryamessagediscoverthattheyarechangedbythosewhoreceiveit,thatpowerandgoodnewsflowbothways.
Yettheordinarytaskofpreachingbelongsintheheartofthecongregation.Itisoneofthegivens.Itisthere,weekafterweek.Inthecongregationyoumustbeabletocountonthistransformingactivitybeingregularlypracticed,regularlyavailable.InGod'sgoodtime,thisordinarygiftbecomesextraordinary.
Theeffectivenessofthepreachingwillalwayshaveelementsofmysterybecauseofthethreepartiesinvolvedthelistener,thepreacher,andGod.Eachpartyhasitsownpersonalhistoryanduniquerelationshiptootherparties.Andofcourse,themysteryismagnifiedbythecharacterofthelifeofcommunityinthecongregationitself.
Mysteryisalsokeytotheotherprimarykerygmaticactionofcongregationstheactofremembrance,theactofthanksgivinginwhichChristiansrelivetheLastSupper.Herealsothreeactorstheparticipant,thecelebrant,andGodmakethisamomentoftransformationunlikeothertransactions.Withwidevariationsinspecifictheologicalinterpretationsofthisdramaticaction,Christiansthroughthegenerationshavefoundthatthisactplacesthemwithinthehistoryofsalvationinanuniqueway,nurturingalifeoffaithandacommitmenttoactionwithinthebelieverandthebelievingcommunity.Thingshappentherethatsimplydonothappeninotherplaces.Heartsaretouched,intentionsformed,commitmentsmade,
![Page 115: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/115.jpg)
restorationsexperienced,foundationsrediscovered,relationshipsreborn.
Inkerygmathefaiththatgroundsthechurchisrecounted,spoken,andre-enactedinsuchawaythatfaithcomesalivewithinthecongregation.
AskoinoniaistwothingsatonceapowertosupportthedevelopmentofdisciplesandasigntosocietyofGod'sintentthatweliveincommunitysoKerygmaisbothasourceoftransformingpowertothoseinthecongregationandanimpellingforceintheirencounterswiththeoutsideworld.
![Page 116: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/116.jpg)
Page59
Didache:TheTeaching
Koinonia,kerygma,andnowdidachedescribekeyfunctionsofthecongregationasadisciple-makingsystem.
7Noneofthesefunctionsisfullyseparablefromtheothers.Teachingoccursincommunityanditscontentistheproclamationandstoriesoftheheritage.
Intoday'schurchesministriesofteachinginsidethecongregationstandinurgentneedofrepairandrenovation.Educationalministriesmaybethemostroutinedeficiencyfoundincongregations.ThegenerationsthatgrewupintheparadigmofChristendomcouldmakeassumptionsthat"everyone"knewwhatitmeanttobeamemberofthecongregation.Today,witheventheillusionofChristendomlonggone,oureducationalministriesstillassumeapopulationofreligiousliteracy.Thelevelofinformationabout,muchlesscomprehensionof,thereligiousheritagehasgrownappallinglylow.Witheachgenerationtheleveldecreases.
Thestoryistoldofarelativelyrecentexaminationofcandidatesforordination.Thefirstcandidatewasasked,"WhoisthepatriarchAbraham?"Thecandidatescratchedhishead,hesitated,thensaid,"Wasn'thethefirstpresidentoftheUnitedStateswhowontheRevolutionandfreedtheslaves?"Thecommitteeturnedwarilytothesecondcandidate:''WhatisthereligiousmeaningofChristmas?"Shespokeupquickly,"That'swhenalltheangelsmaketoysforSantatodeliverinthechimneys!"Thethirdcandidatewasusheredintoadepressedcommittee.''WhathappenedonGoodFriday?"theyasked."Ohyes,"thecandidatesaidthoughtfully,"that'swhenJesusdiedonthecross.""Wonderful!"thecommitteechairsaid.Thecandidatewarmedtothesubject."Andtheyburiedhiminatombandrolledina
![Page 117: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/117.jpg)
stoneforadoor."Committeemembersglowed."Andonthethirddaytheyrollawaythestoneandhecomesout.Ifheseeshisshadow,hegoesbackinandtherearesixmoreweeksofwinter."
Awidespreadlackofagraspofthefaithmakesitalmostimpossibleforthecongregationtoestablishasetofstandardsforitsteachingministriesormakedemandsuponitsleaders.Withoutknowledgeofthestorythatsetsthereligiouscongregationapart,thereisnobasisforcallingforadifferentstandardbywhichmembersaretoact.Aboundaryofknowledgehelpsmembersofthecommunitydistinguishthemselvesfromthepagansocietyaroundthem.Theestablishmentofsuchaboundaryis
![Page 118: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/118.jpg)
Page60
necessaryforcongregationalmemberstodifferentiatebetweenthemoralandethicalstandardsoftheirfaithandthecustomsofthepagansocietyinwhichthosememberslive.Equallyproblematic,thislackofknowledgemakesitimpossibleforparentstonurturetheirchildrenintheirheritage.
Wesimplymustinvestmajorenergyacrosstheboardtobuildadulteducationtobringthisgenerationofadultsonboardthebiblicalstoryandtheheritageoffaith.Weneedtoexpandthenetworkofcapableteachersineverycongregation.Thismaybethemostimportanttaskoftheclergyforthenextgeneration.
Oneareaofeducationisgettingsomeattentiontheeducationforthenewcomerorthenonmember.Denominationsaswellascongregationshaverecognizedthattheentrypointisacriticalopportunityforthenewmembertobebroughtintowhatitreallymeanstobelongtothisfaith-family.Themainlinedenominationsaregenerallyweakindealingwithoneparticularkindofnewcomerthecompletestrangertofaith,onenotnurturedinadifferentdenominationalfamily.Theseclergyandcongregationstendtohaveeducationalsystemsgearedtowardnurturingpeopletowardmaturity,buttheyarenotverycompetentatleadingpeoplethroughconversionexperiences.Thisdeficitmustbefilled.
Pastoralcareduringlife-criseshaslongbeenastrongsuitofcongregationsandthetrainingofpastoralleaders.Congregationstodayneedtolook,however,tothegapsintheirsensitivityandcaring.WhyhavepeopleturnedoutsidethechurchtoprogramssuchasAA,ParentswithoutPartners,andthemanytwelve-stepprograms?Theseprogramsaddresshumanneedsforcareandsupportthatarebasicallynotincludedinthecongregation'smenu.Intheshortruncongregationscanbegratefulforthesecaringministriesandworktosupportthemandprovidethemmeetingspaces.Doingsowillextend
![Page 119: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/119.jpg)
theministriesofthecongregation,usingpeoplewhogenerallyknowsomethingaboutthesubject.Inthelongrunweneedtosendourpastoraltheologianstoschoolwithdevelopmentalpsychologists,studentsofsocialtrends,andfuturiststoanalyzethenewtensionsofmodernlifeandtobegininventingthepastoralcaresystemsthatfitthechangingneedsascongregationalmembersfacethecrisesofnewpatternsoflife.
Inallofthis,theworkofdidacheistohelpopenupthescriptures,thestories,theloreofthefaithsothattheyarealiveandknown.WhenJesus'lifewasturnedupsidedowninhisencounterwithJohnthe
![Page 120: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/120.jpg)
Page61
Baptist,hismindheldthewordsofthepsalmsmemorizedfromweeklyanddailyrecitation.HehadheardstoriesoftheMaccabeesfromtheoldpeopleofhisvillage.HismotherhadtaughthimstrangestoriesofherownencounterswithGod.HeknewthewordsofIsaiahandhadstruggledwiththeirmeanings.Hehadheardotherstoriesfromhisrabbis.Sowhenhismomentoftransformationandcalloccurred,hehadathisdisposalthewordsandimagestodefinehisvocationandshapehiswork.Hehadtherawmaterialreadyathand.
Withoutsuchrawmaterialfromtherichdialogueofpeoplewiththestoriesofthefaith,therereallyisnocommunityoffaith.WithoutcontinuousgroundinginthestorythatistheStory,thereisnogoodnewsforustopassalong.Withoutcontinuousgroundinginthestory,thereisnopurposeforthecongregation,nowaytoinspireeachpersontoreachouttothebadnewsthatcallseachtobeaproclaimerofgoodnews.WeneedcongregationsinwhichthewordsofthepsalmsandthestoriesofJesusareintheordinarycurrentoflife,availableaspeoplefacedailyopportunities,andalsowhencrisesoccur.
Everycongregationmustbeacenterofteachinginanerainwhichthestoriesofthefaithhaveslippedawayfromtheconsciousnessofthewidercommunity.Everyadultshouldbeseriouslyengagedwiththescripturesonaweek-by-weekbasis.Andeachcongregationneedstobecallingouttheteachingskillsofmoreofitsleaderssothatthestoryoffaithiscompellinglypresentedtothenewandthelong-termmember,theyoungandtheold.
Itisthebusinessofthecongregationtoorderitslifesothateachofusispreparedforoursideofthedialoguewiththeoutsideworld,equippedasJesuswasattheRiverJordanknowingthesongsandstoriesofthefaithandreadytorespond.
![Page 121: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/121.jpg)
![Page 122: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/122.jpg)
Page62
Diakonia:TheServingRole
FewimagesaremoredramaticthanthatofJesuswashingthefeetofhisdisciples.Fewfitsopoorlyourimageofleadershipandauthority.MostofushaverealsympathyforPeter'sdrawingbackfromaJesuswhowouldwashhisfeet.Wearemorecomfortablewithaleaderwhoismoreauthoritativeandovertlypowerful,eventhoughculturallywenowfeelmorerebelliousagainstsuchauthoritythanformergenerations.Wemayfeelthatindependentspiritandyetweliketoknowwherewestand,whichmeanswetakesomecomfortinhavinganauthoritywhocallstheshots.Peterwasrighttofeelthreatened.We,too,aremoreateasewiththekindofleaderwhosefeetwemustwashthanwithaleaderwhowashesours.
Butitisjustthisimageoftheservantasleaderthatwebringasagifttoourworldandasavocationforourselves.InChristendomwehadourflirtationwithpower,sensingthatourcallwastobuildempiresandkingdomsshapedbyourperceptionofGod'swill.Wehaveorganizedcrusades,wagedbattles,andbuiltnetworksofpower.Wehavedrivenourselvesandoursocietytoestablishthecontrolsofpowerandlaw.Wehaverarelytriedthewayofpowerlessness,theleadershipofservanthoodinspiteofJesus'clearandoften-repeatedinjunctions.Hisfollowers,hetellsus,willbecomeaslittlechildren,willserveoneanother,willwashoneanother'sfeet,willnotlorditoveroneanother.LikeJamesandJohn,wearemorecomfortablejostlingoneanothertoseewhogetstheseatsofprivilege.Notmanyofourelectionsofchurchleadersfailforlackofcandidates.
Howelsewilltheyserve?AsJesusdemonstrated,bygoingtotheplacesofhurtandbringinghealing,bygoingwhereverthereisbadnewstoproclaimgoodnews.
Inourtimetheshapeofservantleadershipseemstocalllessforgreat
![Page 123: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/123.jpg)
crusadesofmassesofpeoplethanthecommittedactionsofdisciples,onebyone.Crusadeswereforatimewhenempireswerebeingbuilt,whenwebelievedinempiresoffaith.ThemessageofdiscipleshipandservicetodayisclosertoJesus'messagethatthekingdomofGodiswithinandamongyou.Thetaskofserviceisforonetransformedhearttosearchoutthefeetthatonesetofhandsiscalledtowash.Onebyone.
Forcongregationsthismeansfewergreatcampaignsofsocialchangeandmoreopportunitiesforeachmembertodiscovergiftsof
![Page 124: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/124.jpg)
Page63
servingandcallsforservice.Myargumentisbasedontheassumptionthateachofusis,indeed,giftedforservingandcalledtospecificservice.
Thetaskofservantleadershipisprimarilyoutsidethecongregationinthecommunitythatsurroundsthecongregation.Thisapostolicministrypresentsspecialneedsfortraininginthecongregation.Withinourcongregations,weneedmoreandbetterunderstandingofthecommunity.Ifweintendtoservewell,weneedtheskillsofcommunityanalysisandtheabilitytounderstandtheeconomicanddemographictrendsaffectingtheworldoutsidethecongregation.Theservantleaderoutsidethecongregationneedsalltheskillsavailabletoserveintheambiguouscommunityworld.
Incomingyears,effectiveservantleaderswillneedtodrawtogethertolearnfromoneanotherafterengagementwiththestructuresofthesociety.IntimethismaybecomesocustomarythatourordinaryBibleclassesandadultstudygroupswillroutinelyengageincommunityanalysisandreflectiononworkinthecommunity.Fornow,weprobablyneedtodevelopsomeneweducationalresourcestohelpservantleadersfindtheirwayinthisstrangeandchangingworld.
Koinonia,kerygma,didache,anddiakoniathese,then,arethekeyfunctionsthatcongregationsarecalledtoprovideforthechurchofthefutureastheyhavebeenforcongregationsofthepast.
TheDynamicsofTransformation:FromDiscipleshiptoApostolateandBack
Thesefourfunctionsareneededtobringpersonstothefullnessofdiscipleship.Weseethemaswelookinsidethechurchthroughourimaginarywindow.If,asIsuggestedabove,welookoutofourimaginarywindow,weseethewholeworldasquadrantsofneed,fourplacesinwhichpeopleoffaitharecalledtogivethemselvestothe
![Page 125: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/125.jpg)
world.Theflowbackandforthbetweendiscipleshipandapostleshipcontinuesthroughoutone'slife,witheverdeepergroundinginthelifeofdiscipleship.
Idiagramthemodelinthisway:
![Page 126: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/126.jpg)
Page65
dynamicresultsintransformationcomesfromBruceReed,presidentoftheGrubbInstituteofLondon.
8
Reedcallshistheorythetheoryofoscillation,buildingonresearchandtheoriesinpsychodynamics,anthropology,andtheology.Hedescribestheprocessofhumanlivingasacontinuouscyclingbackandforth(oscillation)betweentwopolesofdependence.Onepole,inwhichhumanbeingsengagetheworldanditsforces,makeinterventions,andcarryoutplans,representslifewithinternalizedresourcesofcompetenceanddirection.Thisisanalogoustomycategoryofapostolate,theworldoutsidethewindow,theworldintowhichthefaithfulpersonissenttorespondtopainandneed.Theotherpolerepresentslifewhenitbecomesdepletedbytheengagementandneedstoreestablishitsrelationshipofdependenceonitsgroundofexistence.ThatpoleisrelatedtowhatIhavecalledtheinsideofthewindowthearenaofdiscipleship.
Theoscillationbetweenthesepolesisthestoryoflife,Reedcontends.Theeffectivenessofengagedlifegrowsonlyoutoftheabilitytodependonstrengthfrombeyondoneself.Toattempttolivealwaysintheengagedmodeistoinviteburnoutandincreasinglyineffectiveaction.Tolivealwaysinreceptivityanddependenceleavesonewithdrawnfromserviceintheworld.
Therhythmofengagementandwithdrawal,eachleadingtotheother,isitselfthecongregation'sstructureoftransformation.Thecongregationreceivesitspeopleastheyreturnfromaweek'sengagementwiththepowersoftheworld,wherevereachhasserved.TakingthosepeopleintothecorporateactivityofworshipgivesthembacktheircitizenshipintherealmofGodandtheirdependenceonGodandoneachother.Theactivityofworshiponceagainplaces
![Page 127: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/127.jpg)
theminorderedrelationshiptothedependabilityofGodandreadiesthemforrenewedengagementwiththeworld.
Lookingatthismodel,Iseetwocriticalareasforcongregationalinitiative.Thecongregationneedstoseethateachmemberreturningfromtheapostolateisgreetedbymanyopportunitiestoexperiencekoinonia,kerygma,didache,anddiakonia.Thecongregationneedstomanagethetransitionsfromapostolatetodiscipleshipandfromdiscipleshiptotheapostolate.
Thecongregation'sresponsibilityfortheapostolate,contrarytomodernchurchdiscussion,isseverelylimited.Ithasaroleinhelpingmembersanalyzetheneedsoftheworldandithasaroleinhelping
![Page 128: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/128.jpg)
Page66
membersreflectontheirministries,butithaslittlerole,corporately,inengagingthatworld.ThetemptationtodojustthatisamajortemptationtobuildreligiousempiresinthemodelofChristendom.BruceReedsuggeststhatsucheffortsareactuallythetemptationtosecularismusingthetoolsofthekingdomofthisworldandrejectingthespiritualtoolsofthekingdomJesusproclaimed.
9
Letmebeevenmoreexplicit,usinganillustrationfromchapter2,whereIdescribedamaporgridthatexploresthebreadthofwaysandstylesforbeingaconveyorofgoodnews.AtthispointIwillillustrateonthegridthe"locations"ofindividualpeopleinamythicalcongregation.Each#istheself-selectedpositionchosenbyonecongregationalmember.Ihaveusedthisgridwithanumberofgroups,andalthoughthisplacementisfictional,itisnotunlikethepatternIfindtypicalofmanymainlinecongregations.Idiscoverthatcongregationswithadifferentorientationoftengiveaquitedifferentprofile.Remember,thisisattemptingtographone'sself-perceptionofwhatkindofbadnewstendstograbone'sattention,andwhetheroneisdrawntoactonthatbadnewsthroughreligiousorsecularstructures.10
![Page 129: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/129.jpg)
![Page 130: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/130.jpg)
Page67
I'vefoundthattrackingacongregationonsuchagridisvaluableforexploringpossibilitiesandrelationships,buthardlyprovidesaccuracyorpredictability.Itisateachingandreflectiontool,notaplanningtool.Havingsaidthat,Ifindthatithelpstodiscusshowcongregationsaretransformativecommunitiesandhowthattransformationhappens.(SeetheAppendixAforinstructionsforusingthisgridto"map"acongregation.)
WheredoesthemythicalcongregationI'vegraphedconcentrate?Whatkindsofbadnewswouldcatchattentionthereandwhatkindsofprogramswouldsuchacongregationprobablybegoodatmounting?Conversely,whataretheblindspotsofthatcongregation?Wherewoulditbeslowtoperceiveandinadequateinrespondingtoneed?
Withthemajorityofpeopleconcentratedontherightsideofthegrid,thiscongregationwillbe"athome"ingroupactivitiesandwillunderstandtheneedtodevelop"programs."Ifthisgroupconcentratedheavilyontheleftside,thequestionof"programs''wouldbemoot.Theywouldnotnaturallythinkaboutworkingthatway.
Thiscongregationhasfewmembersintheupperleft-handquadrant;thelargestclusterisinthelowerright-handquadrant,representingthosewhoaregraspedbysocialconcernsandtendtoseektodealwiththeminthesecularstyle.
Insuchacongregationleaderswouldprobablyhavenaturalpassiontoengagewithotherstoaddresscommunityconcernsperhapshomelessnessorhunger.Theywouldseesuchengagementasobvious.Necessary.Theymighthaveahardtimeunderstandingwhyeveryonedidnotsharethesamepassion.
Inthiscongregationthereisalsoanobviouslowconcentrationintheupperleft-handquadrant.Thosewholocatedthemselvestherewouldnotbegreatlytakenwiththe"majority"passionforprogramsto
![Page 131: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/131.jpg)
alleviatesocialpain.
Supposethatisthequadrantthepastorisattractedto.Thepastor'ssermonswouldprobablyreflectthegoodnewsshefeelssokeenly;thelifeofprayerandcontemplationisthecriticalgoodnewsneededbythecommunity.Manyontheboardmightthinkofthemas"pious"sermons.Thepastormightbeconfusedbytherebeinglittleresponsetoherconvictiontofeedthelifeofprayerandcontemplationinthemidstofthebusynessofthecommunity.Theboardmightbemoreconcernedabouttheneedforasolidinterchurchcounciltoencouragemorelow-costhousingandsoupkitchens.
![Page 132: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/132.jpg)
Page68
Thepointisthateachpointonthediagramrepresentsalegitimatebutverydifferentunderstandingofwhatgoodnewsneedstobeaddressedtowhatbadnews.
11
Thetaskofthecongregation,andconsequentlytheconcernofcongregationalleadership,looksveryinterestingagainstthisbackdrop.Managingthetransformationprocessinvolvesasensitivitytothediversityofvocationsthatmembersfeelcalledto.Unlikemodelsofleadershipfromanearliertime,thetaskisnottogetalltheenergyofthecongregationfocusedinonemissionalthrustbuttobuildasdiverseasupportsystemandsendingsystemaspossible.Inthecongregationnotedabove,leadershipshouldbeconcernedaboutwhatneedstobedonetonurturethefewintheupperleft-handquadrant.Perhapsleadersshouldbewonderingwhatsuchunderrepresentationmeansinthecongregation'slife.Someoneneedstoconsiderhowtobringstrengthtothatundevelopedareaofcongregationallife.Doesthatlack,forexample,suggestanareaofspiritualblindness?
Managingthemomentoftransformationfromapostleshiptodiscipleshipandbackagainisimportantifwearetobestrengthenedtoengagetheworld'sbadnews.Religiousleadersandcongregationshavenomoreimportanttaskthantohelpeachofusinthemovementfromdiscipleshiptoapostleshipandback,continuallydeepeningourawarenessofourgiftsandofourcall.Thebetterthatflow,thebettereachofuswillbeinproclaiminggoodnews.
Alltoooftenwedonothaveadequatetoolstodiagnosewhatwefeelcalledtoaddressortoidentifyourownpersonalresources,thegiftsandtoolsavailabletousthroughourheritageandfaith.Insteadofpurposefulaction,weendupinembarrassedsilenceorconfusion,
![Page 133: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/133.jpg)
wishingwecouldturnthewholethingovertosomebodyapastorwhocandealwithitforus.
IfourcongregationsaretohelpmembersbetransformedfrompassiveonlookerstoactiveparticipantsincommunicatingGod'sgoodtidings,theyhavelargeresponsibilitiesinalltheseareas.
Ourcongregationshavethetaskofhelpingmembersperceivewhatisgoingonaroundthem.BeingtruetothemapIhavelaidout,theneedisnotonlytheoneliberalshavebeendescribingforthepastdecadeasocialanalysisofsocietybutalsotheonetheconservativeshavepaidlipservicetobuthavenotaddressedindepththespiritualvacuumofhumanslivinginaone-storyworld.Thesocialanalysisofsocietythat
![Page 134: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/134.jpg)
Page69
ourliberalscallforsoundslikethethinkingofsixtiesradicalsdressedupinpoliticallycorrectlanguage,chasingafterthenewesttrendswilly-nilly,payingmoreattentiontoTheNewRepublicandRollingStonethantoJeremiah.IthasathinandGodlesstaste.Similarly,Ithinkthepersonalanalysisofneedofferedbyconservativesissimplisticandnarrow,owingmoretonineteenth-centurymoralityandpietythantobiblicalfaith.
Weneedmorefromeachofthesefamiliesinthechurches.Ourcongregationsneedtoprovidemuchmoreanddeeperengagementinbothdirectionstowardsociety'stransformationandtowardpersonaltransformation.
Thatistheirbusinesshelpingpeoplefindtheirplaceinthedynamicofgoodnews,beingtransformedfrompassiveobserversofmissiontoactiveparticipantsinit.
Thisisnotacalltoactivismanditisnotacalltocontemplation.Itisastatementthateachofusiscalledtoanengagedministryinwhichfaithfulnessofsomewillleadtosocialactivity,fromdo-goodismtoadvocacyandpoliticalaction,groundedinourreligiousheritage.ForothersitwillmeanacontemplativeorpersonalinvolvementwithGod'spurposesforindividuals,oneatatime.Congregationsneedtobeabletohelpusfindourplaceinthekindofengagementtowhichwearecalled.
Consideragainthemapofmissionabove:Thepointrepresentingeachpersonisbestunderstoodasbeinginorbitaroundthecenter,representingthefullnessofministry,withallquadrantsactiveandstrong,eachpartbalancedandrelatedtothewhole.
Thereismore.InthemapIhaveshownandtheinmythicalcongregationIusedtoillustratemypoint,eachpersonissymbolizedbyaparticularpointonthemap.Inmyexperiencethatisinadequate.
![Page 135: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/135.jpg)
Thatspaciallocationmayholdtrueatthetime,butpeoplechange.One'scallandresponsetothecalldiffersfromtimetotime.Fromourownstoriesweknowthatwehavegrownandchangedinhowweseeandengageinourministries.Soitisforallwhoseektoproclaimgoodtidings.
Aprimarytaskofthecongregationistobeareliablecenteraroundwhichthevarietyofitsmemberscanorbit,asitwere.Thestrongerthecenter,thestrongereachindividualcanbeinholdingtruetothatmoment'ssenseofcallandmission.Thestrongerandmorereliablethecenter,themoresecuretheindividualcanbeinexploringnewaspectsofcallandmission.Isayevenmore:Thestrongerthecenter,thefurther
![Page 136: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/136.jpg)
Page70
outtotheextremesinministrycanindividualmembersbeencouragedandsupported.Perhapsthestrongestmissioncongregationsofthefuturewillnotbethosewiththegreatest,mostvisibleprojectsorservices,buttheonesthatcansustaintheirpeopleinthemostdiverseandextremeministriesofserviceandcaringonecanimagine.
Thisisadifferentunderstandingthanmostpeoplehaveoftheroleofthecongregation,butIthinkitiswhatiscalledforintheemergingage.Thecommonunderstanding,andthesourceofmuchcongregationalstrife,isthatthetaskofthecongregationistoaffirmoneplaceorquadrantonamapastherightplace,andtoprogramthingstoencourageeveryonetoseemissionasdefinedbythatposition.Clergytendtothinkthattheirconceptionofthemissionisthecorrectone;theyseetheirjobasgettingthecongregation'sprogramtoreflectthatsenseofmission.
Idonotbelievetheclergy'srolehastodowiththatatall.Theclergyhavearighttoclaimaspecialplacewithinthemapofmission,butnorighttotrytobringthecongregationtothatplace.Theclergy'sroleistohelpthecongregationestablishandholditscenter,whichisthenormativecenterofthereligioustraditioninitsfullness,notthenormativecenterofthatclergyperson'sparticularvision.Thecongregationneedssotocenteritslifeinitsreligiousgroundingthatitprovidesasecureplace,abletoaffirmandstrengthenmembers'variousministries,eventhosethatvarywildlyfromoneanother.Inthisview,acongregationmightwellbesuspiciousifitbecametoouniforminitsunderstandingofmission,iftoomanybegantoagreethatrealmissioninvolvedperceivingandactingprimarilyinanyoneofthequadrantsofthemap.Apastor'staskmightwellbetotrytoinitiatestrengthinaquadrantwherethecongregationislackingstrength,evenwhenitisaquadrantdifferentfromwherethepastorlocatesmission.
![Page 137: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/137.jpg)
Holdingthecenter,then,isthetaskofthecongregation.Itisatasknotofdoingbutofbeing.Itmeansexploringandreflectingonthedeepestpartsoftheheritage,experiencingthepresenceofGod,centeringinworship,livingandbreathingthescriptures.Itmeansbuildinganinterpersonalcommunitywithinwhicheachpersoncanbenurturedandstrengthenedaswellaschallengedandsent.ItmeanstakingveryseriouslythediversityofGod'scalltomission,acallthatisdirect,different,andevolvingforeachindividual.Itmeanstakingseriouslythecomplexityanddiversityofthegoodtidingscalledforbytheneedsoftheworld.ItmeanstakingseriouslytheuniquesetofgiftseachpersonhastomediatebetweentheneedsoftheworldandthegoodnewsofGod.
![Page 138: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/138.jpg)
Page71
Ibelievethattobeachallengingmissionforthecongregation.Isit,however,apearlofsuchgreatpricethatwecanriskchangingtheoperatingstructuresofourcongregationsforit?Ibelievewemust.
![Page 139: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/139.jpg)
Page72
Chapter4TheRoleoftheJudicatoryEverycongregationissurroundedbydenominationalstructuresdesignedtosupportandstrengthenthetotalmissionofthechurch.
1Asthestormdescribedinchapter1hasgathered,andasclarityaboutwhat''totalmission"actuallymeans,judicatories,likecongregations,havefoundtheirroleconfusedanduncertain.
IntheprevioustwochaptersIhaveattemptedtogototherootsofwhatcongregationsneedtobeaboutasafirststeptoourreinventingthemforourtime.Whatistrueforcongregationsisalsotrueforthejudicatorystructuresaroundthem.InthischapterIwanttobegintheconversationaboutwhatjudicatoriesneedtobeforusaswetrytoweatherthestormandreconstructachurchforthenextcentury.2
OurJudicatories
Ourdifferentdenominationalgroupingsandecclesiologicalbackgroundsgiveusahundredwaysforcongregationstobeconnectedtoandcommunicatewithoneanother.OftenwehavebecomesoenamoredbyourownsystemthatwespendourtimearguingitssuperiorityortryingtofindevidenceinscripturethatwhatweinheritedthroughourconvolutedhistoryisreallywhatGodintendedinthebeginning.3
SomeoftheconnectionalsystemssuchastheCatholicandtheUnitedMethodisthaveclear,sharpdelineationsofrelationship,role,andauthority.Youcaneasilyfindoutwhomakeswhatdecisionsandwhen.Whenyouaskquestions,peoplerespondbyquotingthebookoforder.OtherssuchasthePresbyterianandEpiscopalsystemshave
![Page 140: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/140.jpg)
![Page 141: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/141.jpg)
Page73
cleardefinitionsbutlivewiththemmorecasuallyuntilthereisafight.Presbyterianswillsometimesquotetheirbookoforder,butEpiscopalianstendtogetprettyvagueandsay,"Itmustbeinthecanonssomewhere."Stillothers,suchasBaptistsandcongregationalists,takeprideintheirindependentwaysbutstillfindmodelsofcommunityandinterrelationshipthataremutuallysupportive.Theirhabitsofrelationshipandcommonheritageprovidethestructurethatmeetstheirneeds.
SomepeopleareconcernedwiththecollapseofnationalstructuresinAmericanmainlinedenominations.AlthoughIamawareofthedifficultiesonthenationallevel,Iseethoseproblemsasbeingaminorconcernwhencomparedtotheweakeninginthestructuresofthemiddlejudicatories.ThosestructuressimplyarenotworkingwellinanyofthedenominationsI'mfamiliarwith.Thoughlessvisiblethantheproblemofthenationalstructures,themiddlejudicatorywoeshavemorepervasivelong-termimplications.Mostoftheessentialworkofthechurchesthemakinganddeployingofapostlesgoesonwithoutmuchregardtonationalpoliciesanddirectionsandcouldprobablysurvivethedemiseofthosestructureswithoutmuchtrouble.Thatisnotsooftheregionalstructures.
Regionalmiddlejudicatoriesaretheclosestresourcetocongregationsandusuallyhavearesponsibilityforthecareofthosecongregations.Dependingonthedenominations,judicatoriesaregivenvaryingamountsofpowertointerveneinthecongregation,butthedenominationaldifferencesarelessthantheecclesiologistsclaim.CatholicandMethodistsystemshaveclearauthoritytostepintothecongregation,wheretheycandoprettydrasticthingsremoveapastororaboardortakeotherdisciplinaryaction.Ontheotherhand,congregationalistdenominationsgivethejudicatoryverylittlepowerforintervention.Infact,forbothofthesesystems,"reality"issomewhereinbetweentheconnectionalandcongregationalrhetoric.
![Page 142: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/142.jpg)
Thequalityoftherelationshipbetweenthejudicatoryandthecongregationspeaksvolumesabouthowfarthejudicatoryintervenes.Wherelittletrustexistsbetweenjudicatoryandcongregation,CatholicandMethodistbishopsknowtheyhavebeeninafightwhentheyhavesimplysetouttodowhattheyhavethelegalauthoritytodo.Ontheotherhand,wherethetrustishighandbuiltonexperience,anexecutiveoftheUnitedChurchofChristoraBaptistconventioncanmovewithmoreauthoritythanthebookallowstohelpatroubledcongregationsortitselfout.Thein-betweendenominations,
![Page 143: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/143.jpg)
Page74
suchastheEpiscopalandPresbyterianchurches,workhardatthetrustissuebutcangetintohotwaterbymakingassumptionsthattheofficeofthebishoportheauthorityofthepresbyterycarriesmoreweightthanitdoes.
Thejudicatories'accessibilitytothecongregationisthefunctionalissueIwanttofocuson.Judicatoryofficesarerelativelyclosetothecongregations.(IseethebishopofMontanaandthepresbyteryexecutiveofAlaskarollingintheaislesatthispoint.AndonejudicatoryexecutiveinCanadatellsmeitisninehoursbycarfromoneendofhisregiontotheother!)Thejudicatoryisgenerallythefirstofficecalledwhenthereisacrisisofsomesort.Judicatoriesarethefirstback-upsystemforcongregations.
4
Inchoosingtostartthisdiscussionbyfocusingonreconstructingthefunctionofthejudicatory,Iamobviouslyexcludingtwootherpossiblestartingpoints:denominationaltraditionandorganizationalprecedent.WhydoIexcludedenominationaltradition?Becausetoooftenthetheologicalorecclesiologicaldefinitionofthejudicatory'srolehasbecomeareligiousjustificationforcurrentorganization.Ifnotthat,thenthelanguageoftheheritagehasbeenbenttosupportstructuresclearlynotenvisionedbythosewhofirstworkedoutthemeaningofthepolity.WhydoIexcludeorganizationalprecedent?Ifindthatstartingtheremakesitimpossibletoquestionthesacredcowsofthesystem.Startingineitherofthosetwoplacesmakesittooeasytorationalizewhatwealreadydoandmakesitvirtuallyimpossibletoinitiatechangeatabaselevel.
Theremaybeanevenmoreimportantreasontoworkatreconstructingourdenominationallinks:Thisrelationshipbetweencongregationandjudicatoryiswherethelossoftrustmosturgently
![Page 144: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/144.jpg)
handicapsourreligiousinstitutions.
WhatCongregationsNeedfromJudicatories
OverthepastdecadeIhaveobservedjudicatoriesofmanysortsastheytriedtoprovidesupporttocongregations.EachyearattheBishopandExecutiveLeadershipInstitute,5Ihaveachancetolearnfromthreeorfourdozenworkingexecutivesorbishops.Iamdeeplyindebtedtosomethreehundredofour"alumni"whohavesharedtheirwisdomandtheir
![Page 145: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/145.jpg)
Page75
questions.OutofthoseexperiencesIhavedevelopedalistofwhatcongregationsneedfromjudicatories.Rephrased,thesefunctionswouldanswerthisquestion:Whatdoesajudicatoryexecutiveneedtobegoodat?Inthespringof1993IrevisedandreworkedthatlistwiththehelpofagroupofPresbyterianexecutivesataconferenceatGhostRanch.HereIsharethislistwithyou.
CongregationsNeedHelpWhenTheyGetinTrouble
Anyonewhohasworkedcloselywithcongregationsknowsthatfromtimetotimeeventhebestofthemgetinsomekindoftrouble.
AtTheAlbanInstituteweareparticularlyconsciousoftheexplosivefightsthatbreakoutfromtimetotimeinallkindsofcongregationsforallkindsofreasons;atthisjuncturecongregationsorjudicatoriesoftencallonusforhelp.
7Churchfightsbreakoutatunpredictablemomentsandcanrangefromminortiffstomajorshoot-outs.Wehavediscoveredthatchurchfightsofteneruptasasurprise.Thepeopleinthecongregationmaynotrecognizetheconflictforwhatitis.Thepastormaybeawayor,worse,mayhaveflippedintopanic.Nobodyispreparedtodealwithithelpfully.Afirstsymptomoftheconflictisoftenthesigningofapetitionaboutsomething,followedbyacarefullywordedultimatumfromthepastor.Withinabriefdayortwo,thefirstvisiblesymptommayhaveledtoall-outwar.Ajudicatorythatisalertcanoftendodamagecontrolandbringtheconflicttoaconstructiveoutcome.
Churchfightsarejustoneofdozensoftroublesacongregationmightface.Oftenenoughthedenomination'sbookoforderorcanonhasproceduresforthemorecommonproblems,butonceagainthepeopleofthecongregationoftendonotknowaboutthoseprocedures.Whatareyousupposedtodowhensomebodymisappropriatesfunds?What
![Page 146: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/146.jpg)
areyousupposedtodoifamajorprogramofthechurchcollapsesonyou?Whatdoyoudoifsomebodysaysyouaregoingtoreceiveabequest?Whatdoyoudoifthehighwaydepartmentwantstobuildaroadthroughyourchurchbuilding?Whatdoyoudoifsomeonethreatensalawsuit?Whatdoyoudoifthepastorhasmisbehavedandtheboardknowsit?Whatdoyoudoifthepastorhasmisbehavedandthelocalpaperknowsit?Whatareyousupposedtodoiftheboardcannotgetaquorumtodoitswork?Whatareyousupposedtodoifyoususpectthepastorhas
![Page 147: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/147.jpg)
Page76
becomeanalcoholic?Whatareyousupposedtodoifnobodycanfindtheofficialrecordsofthecongregation?Whatareyousupposedtodoifacongregationtakesanose-diveinfinancialreceipts?
Otherswhoworkwithorincongregationswillhaveotheritemsontheirlists.Youcanbesureofonething:Thelistislong.Congregationscanhavethesamedifficultiesasanyotherorganization,buttheproblemscanbeexacerbatedbytwoscenarios:(1)ahabitofspeakingaboutplainthingsintheologicaldouble-talk(ascrew-upincommitteeassignmentscanbecome"aviolationofmyvocationalcommitments"),and(2)thelikelihoodofanappealtoahighercourtGodinawaythatescalatesadifficultyintoaconfrontationofGoodandEvil(whenyouthoughtyouwerejustworkingonthebudget!)
Judicatoriesneedtodevelopacapacitytohelpcongregationsclarifywhat'satthebottomofthetroubleandworkoutastrategyfordealingwithit.Idonotthinkthejudicatoryneedstobeabletosolvetheproblems.Notatall.Butthejudicatoryneedstohavearelationshipwiththecongregationinwhichthecongregationrespectsthejudicatoryanditsadvice.Insomecasesjudicatorieswillhavedirectanswers,butinmostcasestheycanhelpmostindiagnosingtheproblemandinadvisingthecongregationasitdealswiththeproblemorsecuresotherhelpindoingso.
Congregationsneedthejudicatorytobeclearaboutwhatkindsofsituationsitcanprovidehelpforandwhatkindsshouldbereferredtooutsiders.Let'sbehonest.Thatcallishardforajudicatorytomakeifitthinksitmustsolveeverythingthatcomesalongorifithasanunrealisticideaofwhatitslimitsofenergyandskillare.Ifajudicatoryexecutiveisinsecureoranxious,hemaybeunabletopermitoutsiderstohelp.Heislikelytoattemptanin-depthinterventioninatwo-hourmeetingbecausethatisallthetimehecan
![Page 148: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/148.jpg)
spare.Wehavefoundthatsomekindsofinterventionsa"hotfight,"forexamplecantakesixtotenfulldaysofcarefulworktomovetoresolution.Insuchacasethejudicatoryexecutivedoesnothelpthecongregationbytryingtoforceaquickfixwhichusuallyexacerbatestheproblem.
AUnitedMethodistcongregationIknowaskeditsdistrictsuperintendenttohelpitdesignalong-rangeplanningprocess.Asheworkedwithleadersofthecongregation,theDSpickeduptheiranxietyaboutmixedsignalstheyweregettingfromtheirpastorabouthisleavingorstaying.TheDSwasabletohelpthemmakeabetterdiagnosisoftheir
![Page 149: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/149.jpg)
Page77
problemsothattheycouldclarifytheirrelationshipwiththepastor.Thenthelong-rangeplanningstartedtogetofftheground.Thatcongregationwasstrengthenedbyajudicatoryexecutivewhodugbelowthesurfaceissueandhelpedthemdealwithadeeperissue.
ADisciplescongregationinanurbansettingstruggledwithkeepingupasoupkitchenwithincreasinglyburned-outvolunteers.Whentheydiscusseditwiththeirjudicatoryexecutive,shehelpedthemgotoothercongregationsofotherdenominationsandaskforhelp.Theexecutivealsopointedthepastortowardacourseinwhichhecouldlearnmoreaboutthecareandfeedingofvolunteers.
Theseillustrationsaredeliberatelyundramatic.Buttheyillustratethekindsofquestionsajudicatoryhasgottorecognizeasimportantandbepreparedtohelpacongregationwith.
Ipredictthatthestormierthefuturegets,themorejudicatorieswillhavetheirhandsfull.Twotroublespotsarelikelytoincreaseexponentiallyoverthenextdecadecallsforhelpinconflictmanagementandwithfinancialshort-fall.Judicatorieswilldowelltoincreasetheirskillsandlocatetrustworthyalliesinthesetwoareaspeoplewhocanbecalledintoaddtotheavailableresources.Theyneedtohavealarge''adjunctstaffpeoplewhosesalariestheydonotpay,butwhomtheycancallinfor"piecework."ThatisoneofthemostproductiverolesTheAlbanInstituteplays,backinguptheenergiesandskillsofjudicatoryleaders.
Fromtimetotime,congregationsneedhelp.Judicatoriesneedtobereadytoprovidecounseland/orresources.
CongregationsNeedtoBeLeftAlone
Forthemostpart,whencongregationsarenotactivelyaskingforhelp,judicatoriesneedtoleavethemalone.Mostcongregationshaveprogramsinplaceandenergyharnessedtotheirtasks.Most
![Page 150: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/150.jpg)
congregationshaveaprettygoodworkingrelationshipwiththeirpastors.
Ifsuchisthecase,congregationsoughttobeleftalonemostofthetimetogetonwiththeirwork.Istatethisinelegantlyasmybiastowardneglect.PerhapsIwouldnothavesuchabiasinothergenerations,butnowisthetime....
Judicatoriesoftenoperateasiftheywerebeingremissiftheyarenot
![Page 151: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/151.jpg)
Page78
callingalotofmeetings,workingwithalotoftaskforces,andsponsoringmanyjudicatoryactivitiesforlaityandclergytobeengagedin.Mostcongregationsdonotneedit.
Igetnervousaroundjudicatoriesthataretoolinguptodevelopmissionstatementsandlong-rangestrategicplans.Maybeitisagoodideasometimes,butmaybeitisorganizingtodosomethingnobodyneedstohavedone.Thepersonbeingservedinmuchjudicatoryactivityisthejudicatoryitselforitsstaffmemberswhoneedtoexercisetheircreativity.
Mypointhereistoencourageajudicatorytooperatestrategicallyintermsofitsprimarytaskstrengtheningthecongregationswithinitsbounds.Thatmeansnottreatingallcongregationsalike,butdifferentiatingamongthembeingpreparedtomakestronginterventionswhereneeded,andtoleaveothersalone.
CongregationsNeedtoBeJackedUpWhenTheyAreOffBase
Congregationsneedsomebodywhocaresenoughaboutthemtotellthemwhentheyaregenuinelyoffbase.Whenpovertyaboundsintheirneighborhoods,somebodyneedstoraisequestionsiftheyplanopulentnewbuildings.Whenchildrenandfamiliesareatrisk,congregationsneedtobebroughtupshortiftheydropday-carecentersonwhichtheircommunitieshavecometorelyorpulloutofcoalitionsforfamilyaidorsupportforthepublicschoolsystems.Congregationsneedtobecalledtoaccountiftheyneglectopportunitiestosupportmissioneffortsoutsidetheirownlocalprograms.Congregationsneedtobejackedupwhentheyareirresponsibleintheirrebellionagainsttheirowndenominationalstructures.Congregationsneedtobecalledtoaccountwhentheymisusetheirstaffsorpaysubminimumwages.Congregationswithsignificantfinancialresourcesneedhelplearningtobegoodstewards.Warning:Theyprobablywillnotaccepthelpfromthejudicatory
![Page 152: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/152.jpg)
itself.(Theyprobablydonottrustthejudicatory,oftenforgoodreason.)Thismeansthejudicatoryneedstobesuretheyhaveaccesstoresourcesthecongregationswilltrust.
WhenIsaycongregationsneedsomebodytoholdthemaccountable,Idonotmeanthatthejudicatoryshouldseeitselfascallingtheshotsinalltheareasdescribedhere.Thepointisthatsomebodyneedstoget
![Page 153: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/153.jpg)
Page79
involved,askquestions,ifnecessaryputcongregationsonthedefensive,andmakethemthinkthroughwhattheyaredoing.Iftheytaketimetoreflect,checktheirstatusanddirectionoftheirmission,andthengoahead,Ithinkthejudicatoryhasdonethejobcalledfor.Idonotbelievethejudicatoryhastheresponsibilityofalwaysbeingrightorevenobeyed.
CongregationsNeedPastoralCare
Ispeakhereaboutthecorporatepastoralcarethatcongregationsneedintheirlifetogether.Ofcoursethepastorhasataskhere,butsomethingsneedanotherdimensionofcare.
Congregationsneedgrief-carewhenfacingthelossofapastororakeylayleader.Congregationsneedcarewhenthebuildingburnsdownorisflooded.Congregationsneedcarewhenabiglocalbusinessgoesbelly-uporalocalcatastrophestrikesahotelburnsdownoraplanecrashes.Thecongregationneedspastoralcareafterafiercecongregationalbattle.Congregationsneedlotsofcarewhentheyhavebeenbetrayedbythemisbehaviorofaclergyperson.Theymayevenneedcarewhenthereisprominentmisbehaviorbyaclergypersonofanothercongregation,eveninanotherdenomination.
Goodpastoralcaregiversoftenseeneedsthoseneedingcaredonotsee.Pastorsrecognizegriefandneedtobeaggressivein"movingin,"eventhoughthegrievingpersonmaynot"want"attention.Pastorsknowthatsometimeswithdrawalisasignofdepression.Similarly,judicatoryexecutivesneedtobewillingtobeabitpushywhentheyknowhelpisneededsuchaswhenapastorleavesandgriefhitsthecongregation.Thisisoneplace(thereareothers)wherecongregationscoverovertheirfeelingswithallsortsofself-importantverbiagelikethechildwhotellstheparent,"Icandoitmyself.''Parentsneedtobeonthelookoutforthechildwhoisinvolvedinsomethinghereallycannothandlebyhimselfandbewillingtostepin.So,too,with
![Page 154: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/154.jpg)
judicatoryexecutivesandbishopsandtheirstaffs.
Myfocusonthenegativeexperiencesthattriggeraneedforcareshouldnotnegatetheneedforthejudicatorytobethereforthemomentsofcelebrationandthemarkingofmilestones.Therearetimesandcommunitiesthatneedamessageofcongratulationswhenthehigh-school
![Page 155: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/155.jpg)
Page80
teamwinsorcomesinsecondinthestatebasketballtournament.Orevenwhenafunddrivegoesoverthetop.
CongregationsNeedPastoralCareforTheirPastors
Nooneneedstounderlinethepressurepastorsareundertoday.Asparadigmsofministrychange,clergyarealsobuffetedbyfinancialpressures,insecurityregardingtheirprofessionalfutures,andadiminishedpublicimageoftheirroleinsociety.
Themultiplicityofchangesthathavesimultaneouslyhitclergyleavethemstressedandfeelingburnedoutastheytryhardertoaccomplishtheirworkwithreducedresources.AlltoooftenIfindclergyalmostimmobilizedtheyaresoawareoftheirpainandneed.Wheninthatstate,theyforgetwhattheyhavelearnedinpastoralcarethatpastoralcaredoesnotequalpatsonthebackandhand-holding.
Thepastoralcareclergyneedfromtheirjudicatoriesisthekindthatgetsthemtobethefirst-classprofessionalleaderstheyintendtobe.Ihaveworkedwithclergyfordecades,andIfindthemhappiesttacklingtheirwork,solvingproblems,makingtheirbrickswhetherornotanybodygetsthemthestraw.Judicatoriesneedtoavoidinfantilizingtheirclergy,thinkingofthemas"poorsweetbabies"needingconstantcare.Clergy,likeeveryoneelse,canbecomebottomlesspitsofneedsiftheirleaderspandertothoseneeds.
8
Judicatoriesdoneedtobeawareoftheheavystressesandtrytoseethatresourcesareavailablefortheclergypersontemporarilyoverwhelmed,seriouslydepressed,orill.ButIwouldurgeabiastowardhealth,givingclergyadditionalchallengesandresources,notsympathy.Evenwheretherearedifficulties,clergyneedtobeencouragedtotakeactionfortheirownhealth.Havingagoodlistof
![Page 156: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/156.jpg)
opportunitiesforprofessionaleducationandasolidscholarshipfundismoreimportantthanplanningaclergydevelopmentprogramthatisfullyfundedbythejudicatory.9
Wedoneedtorecognizetheextraordinarypressuresonclergy.Theoldertheyare,themorerevolutionstheyhavelivedthrough.Whatisexpectedofthemhaschanged180degrees.Oncethefront-linetroopsofacrusade,theyhavebecomethemesssergeantsinanarmytheydonotcontrol.Theirroleascommunityleaderoftenhasbeeneroded.The
![Page 157: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/157.jpg)
Page81
clarityabouttheirworkhasdisappeared.Theycatchmorecriticismthanpreviousgenerationsofclergy.Mostofthemweretrainedforanotherrole,anotherinstitution,anotherhistory,anotherworld.
Judicatoriesexercisepastoralcarebyhelpingthesededicatedpeoplepulluptheirsocksandstockingsandpitchinasthecompetentlearnerstheycanbe.
CongregationsNeedHelpwithLeadershipDevelopment
Manycongregationsdonotadequatelytrainnewleadersandseetoeffectiveleadershiptransitionsforlaityorclergy.Themostseriousgapisintheinadequatetrainingsupportjudicatoriesgivewhenclergyandlayleadersarestartingupanewleadershipteam.Everyjudicatoryneedstogiveprioritytoensuringthateverypastormovingintoanewpositionhastrainingorconsultativeassistancetoputtogetheranewworkingteamofclergyandlaity.Iseethisasthemoststrategicopportunitytoraisethelevelofeffectiveleadershipinacongregation.Everyjudicatoryneedstohavesuchaprograminplaceeveryyear.Itshouldbeabuilt-inexpectation.AtTheAlbanInstitutewehavehelpedEpiscopaliansandLutheransbeginsuchprograms.
Alesseropportunityisavailableeveryyearwhennewboardmembersareselectedforthecongregation;everysuchchangeisanopportunityfornewteambuildingforthecongregationleadership.
10Mostcongregationsarelefttofendforthemselvesatthesetransitionaltimes,withtheresultthatfewcongregationalboardsoperateveryeffectively.Largecongregationsneedteambuildingandtrainingfortheirstaffs.Eventhoughtheyhaveresourcesathand,theyoftenforgettodoit.Judicatoryexecutivesneedtopushthemtoactonthisneed.Ifthereareseveralsuchcongregationsinthejudicatory,annualorbiannualstaff-buildingconferencescanbeveryhelpful.
![Page 158: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/158.jpg)
Smallcongregationsmayhavelimitedabilitytotrainleaders.Somefailtoseethecommunitybenefitsofsuchtraining.Inmanysmallercommunities,thechurch-basedleadershiptrainingisvirtuallytheonlyleadershipdevelopmentavailableinthewholecommunity.TheAlbanInstitutehasfoundthatwhenweworkwithasmall-townchurchtoresolveconflict,thewholecommunitygainsresourcesfordealingwithotherconflicts.Leadershiptrainingincommunicationskills,inhowto
![Page 159: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/159.jpg)
Page82
managesmallgroups,inhowtodesigneffectivemeetings,inhowtoputtogetheraneducationaldesignallareneededineverycongregation.Yetonlythelargestmegachurcheshavetheresourcestodoitforthemselves.
Somejudicatorieshavebeenabletobrokerthetrainingresourcesavailableinlargercongregationsforuseinsmallerones.Largecongregationsoftenhavemorestaffresourcesthandoesthejudicatory.
CongregationsNeedTechnicalAssistance
Manycongregationshavelimitedresourcesoftechnicalknow-howinmanagingtheirownlivesorinteractingwiththeoutsidecommunity.
Basicplanningskillsandknowledgeabouthowinstitutionsworkareimportantforcongregationsinchangingtimes.Forinstance,techniquesforfundraisingandfundmanagementcanhelpcongregationsordertheirlives,butsomeonehastoseethatthoseresourcesareavailable.Someoftheissuesaddressedearlierinthischapterhavetodowithtechnicalassistanceknowledgeaboutconflictmanagement,forexample,orunderstandingtheimpactofgriefoncorporategroups.
Congregationsoftenalsoneedhelpfromoutsidetounderstandwhatisgoingonintheworldinwhichtheyminister.Fewofthemhaveskillsinreadingdemographicoreconomictrendsintheirtownorcounty.Informationandinterpretationisoftenavailable,buttheydonotknowhowtoaccessit.Someone"outside"mayhavetohelpcongregationsconnectwiththisknowledgeifitistohelpthemwiththeirministries.Ajudicatoryofficethathasalistofphonenumbersofcountyplanningagenciesineachcountycanreallyhelpitscongregationsthatwanttoplanforthefuture.
Mostcongregationsalsoneedagreatdealofhelpinprofessional
![Page 160: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/160.jpg)
techniquesforfundraising.Fewcongregationsareabletogivemembersadequatehelpinplannedgiving,butjudicatoriescanlocatesuchresourcesandmakethemavailable.
![Page 161: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/161.jpg)
Page83
CongregationsNeedaSenseofTheirPlaceinaLargerMission
Toomanycongregationsgetlockedintothelocalsenseofmissionwithsuchenthusiasmthattheyturntheirbacksonneedsbeyondtheirboundaries.Thisisbothgoodandbad:goodinthatitoftenisanewandimportantcommitmentofdirect,hands-on,grass-rootsactionthatproceedsfromtheirfaith;badinthatitdisengagesthemfrommissionconcernsthatgenuinelybelongtothemandhaveaclaimonthem.
Thejudicatoryhasaspecialresponsibilitytohelpthecongregationwidenthehorizonofitsconcernformission.Thejudicatoryhasadifficult,slipperypathtofollowpushingcongregationstorespondtomoredistantmissionresponsibilities,whilenotusingthatsimplytojustifythejudicatorybudget.Muchofthesuspicionofcongregationstowardtheirdenominationalstructurescomesfromadiscomfortthatallthetalkabout"mission"isjustaploytogarnermoneytopaybureaucrats.Or,whatmaybemoredestructiveoftrust,thatthejudicatoryisjustinterestedinitsownpetprojects,mostofwhichdonotlooklikemissiontothepeopleinthepew.Thishasdugusintoaholeinwhicheventhemosthigh-mindedpleasofchurchleadersarelikelytofindconsiderablesuspicionamongmanygenerouscontributorswhocareformissionandcareforthechurch.Insuchaclimate,judicatoriesdigevendeeperholeswhentheyholdeverbiggerandmorefrequent"extramissiongiving"campaignsinwhichtheydisguisethefactthattheyareraisingmoneytocontinuedoingwhatpeoplehavedecidedtheyarenotenthusiasticaboutdoing.
Eventhoughpastpracticeshavedamagedtrustandcredibility,judicatorieshavearesponsibilitytoworkatwideningthevisionofthelocalchurch.Sotheyhavetorebuildtrust.That'snotabadthingtobeworkingon.Ifthejudicatorydoesnothelpthecongregationlookbeyonditsbounds,itwillbedamagingthecongregation.Yes,thetaskisdifficultandtherearepatternsfromthepastthatwillhauntus.No
![Page 162: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/162.jpg)
matter.Idonotsuggestabiastowardinaction.
CongregationsNeedSomeoneWhoListensandListensandListens
Themostimportantthingacongregationneedsmaybesomebodyoutsidewhojustlistensandpaysattention.Someonewhoreadsitsweeklybulletinandpicksupsignals.Someonewhoknowsthegroupwell
![Page 163: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/163.jpg)
Page84
enoughtorecognizewhenitneedssomekindofintervention.Someonewhoisnotafraidtofollowuponhunchesthatthingsarenotgoingwellorperhapswhenthingsneedcelebrating.
Ihave,then,goodnewsandbadnewsforthosewhoworkinjudicatoryoffices,whethertheybebishops,executives,regional/areaministers,superintendents,moderators,or...somenameIhaven'tyetheard.
Thebadnewsiswhatmostofyoualreadyknowinyourbones.Theoldsystemisnotworking.Itisbasedonorganizationalassumptionsandfunctionsdesignedforanotherageandanotherwayofthinking.Itisbasedonsetsofloyaltiesandunderstandingsofauthoritythatdonotholdtoday.Whatmaybeworse,thefinancialunderpinningsofthejudicatoryarethreatenedalmosteverywhere,andthatthreatwillnotbedealtwithadequatelybyworkingharderattheno-longer-workingsystem.
IhopeIambeingveryclearthatthebadnewsisverybadandveryurgent.TheeffectivenessofeveryregionaljudicatoryIknowisinserioustroubleanditisnotgettingbetter.Idramatizemypointbyaskingjudicatoryexecutiveshowtheywilldotheirjobsinfiveyearswhentheyhavehalfthestafftheyhavenow.Iaskthemwheretheirsuccessorswillgetsalariesfrom.
Thegoodnewsisgoodnewsindeed.Theneedforwhatajudicatorycanprovideissharpandreal,evenifitmaybedifferentfromthefunctionscalledforinpastgenerations.Itisalsotruethatthefunctionsareneededbythepartofthesystemthathastheresourcestopaythecostsifconvincedthatthefunctionsarefocusedonhelpingmissionhappen.Theconnectionbetweencongregationsandjudicatoriesisofenormousself-interesttoeachnotsimpleselfishself-interest,butaself-interestinseekingtocarryouttheircalloffaith,tomakeadifferenceintheworldandforthekingdomofGod.
![Page 164: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/164.jpg)
WilliamMcKinney,widelyknownteacher,leader,researcher,andconsultantwhoworksatHartfordSeminary,wasrecentlyaskedtoanalyzetheroleplayedbypeoplewhoworkedregionallyinaproject(runbytheCenterforCongregationsinCommunityMinistryatMcCormickSeminaryinChicago)tosupportlocalcongregationsastheygotinvolvedinsocialministryprojectsintheMidwest.Thesesupportpeoplewerenotactingasjudicatoryexecutives,butIseeMcKinney'sfindingsasbeingusefultoourjudicatorydiscussion:McKinneydescribedtheirroleasthatof"persistentfriends."Thesepeopleworkedfortheprojectbutwereexternaltothecongregations,bringingskillsand
![Page 165: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/165.jpg)
Page85
challengestothem.Theyproddedthecongregations,advisedthecongregations,"heldhands"withthecongregations,helpedthecongregationsfindresources,foundwaysforthemtoovercomedivisionsandconflicts,showedthemhowtoplan,andalsostoodbyandwatched.Theydidnotgiveuponthecongregationswhentheygotinself-defeatingpatterns.Theykeptcomingbackandcomingback,callingthecongregationstohigherexpectations.
Yesterday'smodels,inwhichexecutivesactedasiflordingitovercongregationswasthebestwaytohelpthem,workinfewerandfewerplaces.Theynolongergenerateloyaltyorproduceresultsastheydidinadifferentworld.Similarly,themodelsinwhichtheexecutivesstoodbackonlytocomeinwithapologywhenbloodwasonthewallsdonotdojusticetothecriticaldevelopmentalneedscongregationshavetoday.
Wecanclarifytheexecutiveroleonlyasweunderstandthelifeofcongregationsandthefunctionsneededifcongregationsaretobeengagedintheirworkofreachingoutintohumanlivesandcommunities.Thischapterhasbeenanattempttobeginlookingatthosefunctions"fromthegroundup."
McKinney'sphrase"persistentfriend"isagoodplacetostart.ThemodelofthoseChicagoprojectleadersisinstructive.Aslongastherearecongregationsthatseektomakedisciplesandsendthemintothecommunityasbearersofgoodnews,thosecongregationswillneedpersistentfriendswhochallengeandsupportthemintheirtask.
![Page 166: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/166.jpg)
Page86
Chapter5RoadblocksandDirectionsfortheJourneyThoseofuswhoseektoreinventourreligiousstructuresforthenextgenerationareawareofthecomplexandresistantforcesweface.
1Itoftenseemsthatwhenwetakeonestepahead,weslipbacktwo.Our"newproject"endsupputtingusinmoretroublethanwewereinbefore.Howmanyimportantattemptshavebeenmadeinhowmanycreativeways?Andyetthewindsofthestormareunabated.Wesometimeswonderifoursheerstubbornnesskeepsourhopesalive.
IcannotnumberthewiseandcommittedcolleaguesIhaveseenchargeupthehill,yearafteryear,allwithconviction,mostwithgreatplans,allabsolutelycertainthatthistime,thistime,theywouldsucceed.IhearthatconvictioninthevoicesofthosewhophonemetotellofthegreatplantheyhavedevelopedandIrememberhowexcitedsomeonewasthirtyyearsagowhotriedthatveryplaninChicagoorintheBayArea.Ihaveamemorybankfulloffailedefforts.Nonefailedbecauseofstupidity.Nonefailedbecauseoflackoffaith.
Perhapsweunderestimatedtheproblemsthatstoodintheway.PerhapsweunderestimatedthepoweroftheOpposition.Perhapswewerenaive.Ihaveafeelingthatoneofourmostpowerfulidolsis"MyNewIdea,""TheNewProgram,"oreven"TheNewSystem.''MartinMartyoncetoldmethatmyworkwithcongregationshadremindedhim"thattherearenobigdealsanymore."
Someofushavenochoicebuttochargeupthathillagain.AsLutherputitinamoreovertlytheologicalsense,we"candonoother."Andwhatcanwebegintodothatisdifferent?Wecanmoreconsistently
![Page 167: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/167.jpg)
trytolearnfromourexperienceandmapoutthoseforcesthatconsistentlygetinourway.InthischapterIwanttonamesomeofthemajorimpedimentsaheadofusandthecluesIhaveformovingahead.Iam
![Page 168: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/168.jpg)
Page87
awarethatmanyoftheobstaclesareconnectedtotheothers.Weareunlikelytobeabletosolvethemonebyone;wewillhavetodealwiththewholesystematonce.
2
WeHaveDugOurselvesintoaFinancialHole
OneofthemajorprophetsofthetwentiethcenturyisashadowyfiguredescribedbyWoodwardandBernsteinintheirstoryofWatergate.DeepThroat,astheynamedthemanwhospokefromtheshadowsoftheparkinggarage,said,''Followthemoney!"Theydid,andtheybroughtdownapresident.
DeepThroat'sadvicetothereportersisaguidelineforlookingatproblemsanddirectionsinanyinstitution;ithasgreatrelevanceforthedifficultywehaveindealingwithcongregationsandintryingtochangethem.Let'sdiscussseveralareasinwhichourrelationshiptomoneyiscripplingourabilitytodowhatwesaywewanttodotorenewourinstitutionallife.Leadersofchurches,especiallyclergy,uselanguageallthetime,oftentoobscureratherthanclarify.ButhereIwilluseunvarnishedlanguage,sayingthingsmoredirectlythaninourchurchystyle.ForgivemeifIoffend.
WeHaveConsistentlyMisappropriatedFunds
Iprobablyhaveyourattention.Thepointisthatchurchesconsistentlyuselargeamountsofmoneyinwaysthedonorsdonotunderstandorapproveof.
Thereisnocriminalintent.Thisiswhathappens:Thosewhogivetotheircongregationsdosoforavarietyofmotivesandinavarietyofstylesfromthosewho"paytheirdues"tothosewhowantto"makeanimpression"tothosewhogiveinsimplegratitudetoGod.Butthereis
![Page 169: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/169.jpg)
animplicitcontractinallcasesthattheresourceswillbeusedtosupportthepurposesandconcernsofthereligiouscommunity.Peoplewhogivetochurchesexpectthatthemoneywillbeusedforthepurposesthemissionofthatchurch.Notmanypeoplewhogivedosostatingnarrowrestrictions,althoughsomedo.Mostpeoplearepreparedtotrusttheirleadersandgivesomelatitudeinhowthefundsarespent.They
![Page 170: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/170.jpg)
Page88
knowthatitmaybeimportanttosupportsomethingstheyarenotenthusiasticabout.Theyexpectthattheirmoneywillbeusedtomakeadifferenceinsomethingimportant.
Butinthepastfewgenerationsagaphasgrownbetweenwhat"mission"meanstothespendersofthemoneyandthegiversofthemoney.
3
IfirstsawthismisappropriationinactionsomeyearsagoasaparishpastorinNorthCarolinainajudicatorythatprideditselfontheforward-lookingandextensiveministryitsupportedintheregionaluniversitiesandcolleges.Wehadclearplanstoplaceafull-timecollegechaplaininasmanykeyplacesaspossible.Theareahadmanyfineinstitutionsofhigherlearning,parentsofcollegestudentswereinallthecongregations,andfewparisheshadanyquestionsaboutsupportforthisvitalwork.Whathappened?Overarelativelyshortperiodoftime,thefunctionofthecollegechaplainschanged.Atfirstcollegechaplaincywasbasicallyaone-on-onepastoralministrynotunlikeyouthministryinacongregation.Then,respondingtopressuresandneedstheydiscoveredoncampus,chaplainsbegantoworkatministrytoeducational,institutionalstructuresandthenatministrytostructuresofsociety.Inmanywaysthiswasarequirementofthetimethesixtieswhentobeintouchwithstudentlifeonehadtobeconcernedfortheissuesthatengagedstudents.Collegechaplains,iftheyweretobeintouchwiththeirstudents,felttheyhadtobecounselinggroupsthatwereplanningdemonstrationsandgettingout"wheretheactionwas,"notplanningchurchsuppersandliturgiesandvisitingdormrooms.
Thehindsightofafewdecadesmakesiteasytoarguefororagainstthatchangeof"jobdescription."Somethingsweregained,otherslost.
![Page 171: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/171.jpg)
Thatisnotthepoint.Thisis:Thesupportersofcollegeministriesthoughtthattheyweresupportingtheoldermodelofministry.Atannualconventionafterannualconvention,supportforcollegeministrywascalledforbydenominationalleaderswhothemselvesknewthattheworkhadchanged,butthoseleadersdidnotmentionthechangestothelaity.Manyofthedonorsdidnotknowthechangehadoccurred.
Oftenthedonorsdiscoveredthechangebyreadinganewspaperaccountofacollegechaplainmakingaspeechinthemiddleofacontroversialmeetingordemonstration.Morethanonechaplaingotfired.Manydonorsfeltbetrayed.Otherdonorsprobablythemajorityrecognizedthechangeandcametoacceptitbutlostalittletrustinthesystem.Thepeoplewhohadthepowertosetthepolicydidnotworkathelpingthedonorunderstandhowthemissionhadchanged.
![Page 172: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/172.jpg)
Page89
WhatIhavedescribedhereinonesmallstoryaboutcollegeministryhasbeenhappeningforagenerationinmanyotherareasofmissionwork.Denominationalandregionalleadershavegenuinelystruggledtofindmoreeffectivewaystodotheworkofministry,developingimaginativeandimportantnewdirectionsofmission.Buttheyhaveallowedterriblegapstodevelopbetweenwhattheyaredoingandwhatthedonorsthinktheyaredoing.Tothedonor,suchagapcanfeellikebetrayalofatrust.
Thepointisnotwhethertheirprogramswereright.(Mybiasisthatmostoftheeffortshavebeenwellmotivatedandontarget.)Thepointisthatwehaveallowedgapstodevelopthathaveerodedtrust.
Thepublicmediaoccasionallystepintothisgaptothedismayofreligiousleaders.EverydecadeorsoReader'sDigestpublishesanarticleaboutwhattheWorldCouncilofChurchesortheNationalCouncilofChurchesoroneoranotherofthedenominationsisreallydoingwiththedonationsitreceives."Thepeopleinthepew"givealoudcrybecausetheyhavenotknownthattheirchurchleadershavechangedprograms.Thechurchleadersgetequallyupset,thinkingthatimportantmissionconcernsarebeingundercut.Bothhaveapoint.Butagain,mypointliesinthefactthatourreligiousleadershavenotfeltaccountablefortheirchoices.Intheirenthusiasmforimportantmissioninitiatives,theyhaveactedlikeintellectualelites.Attheirworst,someofthemhaveactuallyfeltcontemptforthenarrowvisionofsomeofthedonors,andtheyhavefeltjustifiedinusingthefundsinwaysthosedonorswouldneversupport.
Theprophetictaskofthechurchoftenrequiressometostepoutbeyondthecommondenominatorofunderstanding.Butprophetsunderstandthatthereiscosttothatsteppingout,andtheyhavetoexpecttopayit.Manypeopleexpectdenominationalleaderstoexertpropheticleadership,butnooneseemstounderstandthatprophets
![Page 173: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/173.jpg)
rarelyhavebeenknowntoleadinstitutions.Samsonisrightlyhonoredasapropheticjudge,butlookwhathappenedtohimwhenthewallsfelldownonhim.IsometimescallthispatternofdenominationaluseoffundstheSamsonsyndromeofleadership.ItmaydosomedamagetothePhilistines,butit'shardontheprophet,too.
Ourproblem?Ourwayofoperatinghasledtosignificantlossoftrustinoursystems.
![Page 174: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/174.jpg)
Page90
WeRefusetoPayAttentiontotheDisasterThatIsApproaching
Congregationsandtheirreligioussystemshavetheirheadsinthesandintermsoftheirfuturesupport.Iseeabrickwallthirtyyearsdownthepike.Idon'thearanybodyelsetalkingaboutit.
Alloftheevidencewehavepointsinonedirection:Youngergenerationsdonotcontributetoreligiousinstitutionsasgenerouslyasdidtheirelders.Publishedstudiesofthephilanthropicgivingofbabyboomersarenotencouraging,althoughafewoptimistshopethattheirbehaviorwillchangewhenthemortgageispaidupandtuitionpaymentshavecometoanend.
Iseelittleevidencethatthedenominationsareexercisedaboutthisproblemorbeingaggressiveintryingtoovercomeit.Withalltheprofesseddesireforexpandingthediversityofthechurches,denominationsareavoidingtheproblemofresearchanddevelopmentofwaystoincreasegivingamongamorediverserangeofgroupsandgivers.
Morethanthat,thedonorbaseofthemainlinedenominationscontinuesitsdependenceuponamonochromeconstituencywhite,middleagedorolderchurchmembers.Thedonorbaseisagingandisnotexpandinginnumbers,diversity,orage.Thisaloneshakesmyconfidenceinourdenominationalleadership.Itisonethingtotrytochangethingsandfail;itisanothernottotry.
Intheforeseeablefuture,demandforfinancialresourcesislikelytocontinuetooutstrip"supply."Indeed,Ibelievefinancialresourceswillcontinuetodiminish.Intimesofdiminishingresources,anyproject,program,orministrythatisnotself-supportingwillbeintrouble.Subsidiesofanykindwillbehardtocomeby.Churchleadershipwillincreasinglybeconcernedwithstaffandprogramcuts.Inevitablecutbackswillalwaysengenderconflictbetweenthosewhosepriorities
![Page 175: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/175.jpg)
differ.Wealreadyseethisbeingworkedoutinhundredsofjudicatorybudgetdebatesandinallthenationaldenominationaldebates.
Thereissomegoodnewsandsomebadnewsintherelianceofourinstitutionsontheirprovendonorbase.
Thegoodnewsisthegrowthofstrongpledgedannualgivingoverthepastgeneration.Mainlinechurchmembersnowtalkaboutproportionalgivingandeventithing.Anincreasingnumberpracticeoneortheother.Somemainlinedenominations,likemine,theEpiscopalChurch,haveexperiencedremarkablegrowthofpledgedgivingwithstrongleadershipfromthetopdownandfromthebottomup.
![Page 176: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/176.jpg)
Page91
Someofthebadnewsisrelatedtothat.Mostofourdenominationsaresodependentonthissinglesourceoffundingthattheyputalltheirfund-raisingenergyintoit.Theyseemtopaylittleattentiontothefactthatthepoolofgiversisdeclining,makingthisashort-termstrategy.Theirsuccesskeepsthemfromdevelopingotherapproaches.Thedenominationsseemtohaveforgottenthatpledgingitselfisarelativelyrecentpractice.Alltheeggsseemtobeinthatonebasket.Otherbasketsareneeded.
Themostperplexingneglectisofplannedgiving.
4Denominationsandcongregationsthatarestronginsupportoftithingblanchwhenthewordendowmentcomesup.Iwonderwhyitissosalutarytogive10percentofone'ssalarytoone'scongregationandatthesametimesodangeroustogive10percentofone'sestatetothecongregation.Thereseemstobeatheologicalpositionofsomesortstakedoutontheoldsaw,"Theonlywaytokillachurchistogiveitanendowment."Clergy,almosttoaperson,areenergeticallysuspiciousofendowments.Fewclergyareopentotheirparishionerswhowanttoleavesubstantialsumstotheircongregations.Fewofusseemtorealizethatformostofitshistorymostofthechurchwasfinancedprimarilythroughresourcesgainedbybequest.Afewjudicatoriesandcongregationshaveappointedplanned-givingofficers,butlackofinterestintheirworktendstomarginalizethemanddecreasetheireffectiveness.
WhileIhaveneverheardofaseminary,acollege,ahospital,orevenasymphonyorchestrasaying,"Wewouldbeunfaithfultoourtraditionsifweacceptedresourcesforthefuture!(theonlyhealthyhospitalisonewhosepatientsbearthefullloadofthecosts),"Ihearthatregularlyfromcongregationsandfromclergy.Thesituationmaybeworse.Iknowofseminaries(withaggressivedevelopment
![Page 177: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/177.jpg)
programs)thatteachstudentsthatendowmentsarebadforcongregations.Thesameseminarieshaveaggressiveplannedgivingprogramsfortheirownsupport.
Congregations(orjudicatories)withsignificantendowmentsdohavesomespecialchallenges.5Managingtheendowmentitselftakesenergy.Therearebiganddifferentproblemsofpriorities.Stewardshipeducationisdifficultinsuchcongregations.Morethanadecadeofworkingwithendowedcongregationshashelpedmeseethattheproblemstheyfaceareformidable.Icannotunderstandwhythissofrightensmostchurchleaders.Itisasifchurchleaders,particularlyclergy,assumethatmoneyitselfisevilastrangetheologicalpositionforthose
![Page 178: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/178.jpg)
Page92
whosescripturesincludethestoryJesustoldaboutthetalents.Icanunderstandanxietyaboutadifficulttask;IcannotexcusethecopoutsIseeinthisarea.
Thefactisthatallcongregationsareendowedalready.Someofthemareheavilyendowedeventhoughtheydonotadmitit.Theyhavebuildingsgiventhembypastgenerations.(Oftenthecurrentusersofthebuildingarenotedonlyforthefactthattheyareinadequatelymaintainingthatendowment.)Theyhaveformsoforganizationandaheritageoffaiththatisanendowmentfrompastgenerations.Theyhaveastoryofministrythattheydidnotinvent.Evenmostwithtreasurersandboardswhoplead"poormouth"haveacertificateofdepositortwostoredawaysomewhereorasizable"reservefund."
Theirfearof"admitting"theirendowmentisinstructive.Itsuggestshowthreateningitistoadmitone'sgifts.Italsosuggeststhatonecanavoidresponsibilityandaccountabilityifonedeniesthegiftedness.
Neglectingplannedgivingisbadenough,butwehavemoreonourheads.
Thisgenerationofchurchmembershasspentuptheendowmentsofpreviousgenerations.Formergenerations,lovingtheirchurchesandactingingoodfaithoutofthebestinsighttheyhad,builtaninfrastructureforthatchurch'smission.
6Theinfrastructureincludesgreatbuildingsforworship.Formergenerationsrecognizedtheneedforchurch-affiliatedseminaries,colleges,andschools.Theybuiltgreatnationalcommissionsandboardstoshapemissioneffort.Noneofitwaseasy.Andtheybuiltthemforus.
Ourgenerationisusingupthosegifts,spendingthemprodigally.Ofcoursethosewhowentbeforemademistakesinwhattheythoughtwe
![Page 179: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/179.jpg)
mightneed.Theydidnotknowthatwewouldhaveahardtimepayingtheheatbillsforsomeofthestonemonsterstheybuilt.Butwhatgiftstheytriedtosetasideforus!Theybuiltforthefuturetheythoughtwehadinstore.Ourgenerationseemsintentuponcomplainingabouttheirmistakesanddismantlingtheinfrastructuretheybuilt.Wehavebuiltveryfewinstitutionsforthenextgeneration.Informergenerations,somewouldhavetorndowntheinappropriatebuildingsandbuiltbetterones.Wesitaroundandcomplain.
Insteadofmakingprovisionforthechurchforfuturegenerations,thisgenerationofchurchleadersisbeingprodigalwiththegiftsofthepast.Itisonlyinthechurch'sinstitutionsofeducationthatIseesignsof
![Page 180: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/180.jpg)
Page93
awarenessthatfundsforthefuturemustbegenerated.(InthoseinstitutionsIsuspectthattheenergyforseekingendowmentscomesfromtheirrootsinthefinancialquagmiresofhighereducationratherthantheirheritageinthechurches.)
Wedonothavemuchtimetodoaturnabout.In1993LarryCarr,presidentofthePresbyterianFoundation,saidthatwithinthenextseventeenyears$6trillionwillchangehands,asonegeneration'sresourcesarepassedalongtothenext.Thiswillbethelargesttransferofresourcesinhistory.Thatmeansthatinthoseseventeenyearsthemostgeneroussupportersthechurchhaseverhadwillbeamongthosewhoseresourceswillpasstootherhands.Withinthenexttwodecades,thecurrentgenerationoftitherswillbereplacedbyagenerationthathasnotyetbeenconvincedthattithingisagoodidea.
Unlesswechangeourbehaviorradically,ourcurrentgenerationofgeneroussupportersofthechurchwillbetoldtotaketheirgiftselsewhere.Ifthechurcheseverhadanopportunitytodevelopresourcesforthefuture,thetimeisnow.Thetimeisnotlikelytoreturn.Theclockisticking.
Iseealmostnooneinthechurchespayinganyattention.Wearenotsufferingfromsomeinevitabledeclineofresources;wearecommittinginstitutionalsuicide.ItiswhatElisabethKubler-Rosscalleddenial.
Continuingthishead-in-the-sandapproachwillbedisastrousfinancially.ItisevenworsewhenwerealizethatouravoidanceofthisissuealsorepresentsouravoidanceofeveryAmericanChristian'sprimaryspiritualproblembeingwealthy.HereIammakingthecasefortheinstitutionalproblemwehave.Thereisadeeperproblemmoredirectlyrelatedtoourmission.Ouravoidanceofthisissueispartofalargeravoidanceattheheartofourspiritualtaskaschurches.AlmostallAmericansarerich.Evenourpoorestareinfinitelybetteroffthan
![Page 181: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/181.jpg)
thepoorelsewhereintheworld.AprimaryspiritualtaskofchurchesistohelpAmericansdealwiththedilemmasofwealth.Ouravoidanceoftheissueofendowmentsisasymptomofouravoidanceofthatlargerspiritualtask.Achurchthatcannotfacethesinandgraceinvolvedinendowmentsiscrippledindealingwiththesinandgracewithwhicheveryoneofitsmembershastolivedaily.HereIamnotarguingthatgreatissue.Iamspeakingtothenarrowinstitutionalconcern:Wearecommittinginstitutionalsuicide.
![Page 182: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/182.jpg)
Page94
WeHaveFailedtoEnfranchisetheLaity
Thelaityhasneverhadinstitutionalpowerinthechurches.
7
Letmedefendthatoverstatement.MostpeopleinProtestantdenominationspointtosignificantareasinwhichthelaitydoes,indeed,havegreatpowerwithintheinstitution.Someofthosedenominationscanpointtohistoricalmomentsorevenlegalentitlementtodaythatsupportassertionofpowerbythelaity,sometimesatthemostcriticalpointsoftheinstitution'slife.Idonotdenythosearguments.Idonotdenythatlaypeopledofrequentlyshiftthebalanceandaffecttheoutcomearoundissuesunderdebate.Butchurchesareinstitutionstheordinaryoperationsanddecisionsofwhichareguidedbyclergy.Churchesareclergy-runorganizations.
Itisasituationcomparabletothis:Thejusticesysteminthiscountryisalawyer-runoperation.Orthis:Themedicalsystemisrunbydoctors.InneithercaseamIsayingthatthesystemisnecessarilybadjustthateachisrunbytheprofessionalgroupthathasthemostatstakeinthearrangementsofthesystem.
Mostofusknowextraordinarylawyerswholivesacrificiallivestobuildajustsocietyinwhicheveryoneistreatedwellunderthelaw.Mostofusknowdoctorswhohavegiventheirlivesandhealthtobringhealingtoothers.That'snotthepoint.Thelegalsystem,thejusticesystem,isrunbylawyerswhomakealivingfromthelaw.Overtimetherestofushavebeguntowonderifthatsystem,asitisplayedoutinAmericanlife,reallyisasystemthatwecantrusttooperateforthebenefitofthosewhoarenotlawyers.Similarlymoreandmorepeoplearewonderingifourmedicalsystemisworkingtothebenefitofthepublicandifthedecisionmakingshouldcontinueto
![Page 183: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/183.jpg)
beruledbythosewhostandmosttobenefitfromit.
Largequestionsarebeingraisedacrossoursocietyaboutbothoftheseareas.Thelaityhasneverhadpowerinthelegalsystem.Perhapsthelegalsystemistooimportanttotoomanypeopletobeleftinthehandsoflawyers.Thelaityhasneverhadpowerinthehealthsystem.Perhapsthehealthsystemistooimportanttotoomanypeopletobeleftinthehandsofdoctors.
Oursocietyhasnotyetcomeclearabouteitherofthesequestions,butthereisagrowingawarenessthatthedecisionsmadeinthepastinboththosesystemshavenotturnedouttobeasgoodforsocietyastheyhavebeenforlawyersandfordoctors.
![Page 184: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/184.jpg)
Page95
Icouldpointtoanevenmoredramaticillustration.Asanationwehavebeguntowonderifitiswisetoletthosewhoareorganizedtopromotetheuseofgunsmakenationalpolicyaboutgunsinthehandsofthepublic.Yearsagowhenourgovernmentwasbeingformed,webecameclearthatwaranddefensewastooimportanttoallowpolicytobemadebythegenerals;wemandatedpoliticalleadershipforourwarefforts.
Thechurches'powersystemhasgrownintowhatwenowcallclericalism.Itisapowersystemthathasgrownupbecauseitmadereligiousinstitutionsstrongandeffectiveoverthecenturies.Butithasbecomeasystemthatissobusyprotectingthepastthatitnolongerservesthefuture.Itisapowersysteminwhichtheprimarydecisionsaboutthechurches'futuresaremadebytheprofessionalclassthathasthemostatstakeinthosedecisionsprofessionally,personally,andfinancially.Inothersituationswecallthisconflictofinterest.Theself-interestskewstheinstitutiontowardtheconcernsoftheclergy.Weneedtoknowthatsomepeoplelooksuspiciouslyatourrulesaboutminimumsalariesforclergy,oursubsidyofclergytraining,andourdefinitionthattheminimalcongregationalframeworkincludeonepaidclergyperson.Ihavehearditsaidthatthechurchsometimesoperatesprimarilyasanemploymentsystemforclergy.
IamsayingthisasbluntlyasIcan.IdonotforamomentdenythequalityoftheclergyIknow.Ofcoursetherearebumsandcharlatansinthecrowd,butIknowmore,thousandsmore(Imeanthatliterally!)whoareself-givingandliveoutadedicationthatinspiresme.Iadmirenoprofessionalclassmoreforitscontributionstobuildingcommunityandtouchinghumanlives.Iclaimthatprofessionalclassasmyown,andIamproudofit.
Butsomepartofmeknowsamorecomplexreality.Thedecision-makingprocessesofreligiousinstitutionsaremostlycontrolledby
![Page 185: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/185.jpg)
clergy.Iamnottalkingaboutthespecificvotingprocessesorthegenuinelydemocraticintentofchurchleadersandclergy.Iamtalkingaboutthearrangementsaroundthevotingthewayclergyarepaidtogotodenominationalmeetingsyearafteryear,gainingexpertiseandpowerinthesystem.Iamtalkingaboutthewayclergyareleanedonandtrustedforadvicebylaydelegates.Iamtalkingaboutthesystemsofrotatingmembershiponcongregationalboards,asystemthateffectivelydestroyslaypowerinfavoroftheclergy.Iamtalkingaboutthe"oldboy"
![Page 186: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/186.jpg)
Page96
systemsfromseminaryintowhichwomenclergyareonlybeginningtofindtheirwayandwhichshapesomanyappointmentstodecision-makingroles.Iamtalkingaboutthewaytheprofessionalclasssystematicallydrawskeylayleadersintoitself,sendingthemofftoseminarytobeco-optedintothepowerclass.Iamtalkingaboutthewayclergycanaffordtobethereatthemidweekmeetingswhenthedecisionsaremade.Thearrangementsmultiplytheirpower.
FewoftheclergyIknow,andprobablynoneoftheextraordinaryclergyIknow,believeinorwantthekindofpowerIhavedescribedinthelastparagraph.Mostofthemabhorsuchself-servinginterpretationsofwhatthesystemdoes.
Whichismypoint.Thisisapowersystemthatislargerandmorepowerfulthanthepeopleinit.Itisasetofcustomsandarrangementsgrownupthroughtheyearsthatonepersonhaslittlepowertochange.ItisthekindofdemonicpowerthatSaintPaulwarnsagainstwhenhetalksabout''principalitiesandpowers"(Eph.6:12KJV).Thereisakeytruthaboutsuchpowerswhentheyareuncontrolled.Allofthemdrawtheirpowerfromthegoodinthem,butgoodbecomesdemonic.Lucifer,wemustrememberfromourmythology,wasthemostbeautifuloftheangels,whichmadehimthemostpowerfulwhenhefelltobecometheAdversary.
Thedevelopmentofclergyoverthecenturieshasbeenoneofthegreatestachievementsofthechurches.Clergyhavebeenattheheartofthegrowthoftheologiesandschoolsandsacrificiallivingofallkinds.Eachofushasbeennurturedbyourrelationshipwithgreatclergy.
Thatispreciselywhyclericalismissopowerful.Whenclergybecomeapowersystem,thesystemisclericalism.Ittakespowerandauthorityuntoitself,awayfromthechurchitisintendedtoserve.Thatmakesitdemonic.
![Page 187: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/187.jpg)
Thesamecanbesaidofanyism.Ourusualproblemwithunderstandingthissimplespiritualtruthisthatwegenerallylikesomeofthesedemons.Inourcommonparlance,wedisapproveofbaddemonssuchasracism,sexism,ageism,andweexcoriatethosewhoactintheirpower.Butnotthedemonswelike!Allthe"politicalcorrectness"talkisabouthowwechoosecertaindemonstoattack,whileharboringourowndemonsaspersonalpets.
Thechurchofthefuturemustbreakthepowerofclericalism.Thecontinuationofdecisionmakingbasedonthewelfareofoneprofessional
![Page 188: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/188.jpg)
Page97
groupwillbefinanciallyandorganizationallydisastrous.Morethanthat,itwillincreasinglyfocusclergyasfunctionariesinadysfunctionalinstitution,whenweneedclergywhocanleaduswithreligiousauthority.
Thechurchofthefutureneedsclergywhocanleadusintodeepplaces,whocanteachustheenduringstoryofthepeopleofGod.Wedonotneedthemtobemanagersofaninstitution.
Clergybythemselvescannotandwillnotrelinquishtheirpower.Therewillbenochangeuntilthelaitytakesthelead.Thechurchistooimportanttobeleftinthehandsoftheclergy.
WeHaveBuiltUnhealthyDependencySystems
Overthegenerationsinstitutionsandgroupswithinthechurcheshavebecomestratifiedintolevelsofpower.Asinmosthistoricinstitutions,thosestratificationsbecamehierarchical,withthoseconsideredmostimportantatthetopandthoselessimportantatthebottom.Whoknowshowitgotstarted?Somereadthedevelopmentaspartofaconspiracyofmalestodominatefemales.Theymayberight.Somereaditasadialecticofhistory.Theymayberight.Somereaditasasimplefunctionaldevelopmentofsociety.Theymayberight.
Whereveritcamefrom,itleavessomeobviousproblemsforthosewhowantreligiousinstitutionstoweatherthestormsofchangewehavedescribed.Thereareemotionalovertonestothehierarchicalstructuresthatdevelopedinthechurches,overtonesthatcomplicateourconcerntomakethestructuresmoreresponsivetotoday'sneeds.
OneofthesimplestandmosthelpfulinsightsintothisstructuralproblemwasgivenbyThomasHarris,inhisbookI'mO.K.You'reO.K.,apopularself-helpbookofseveralyearsback.
8Inthatbook,Harrisusedourfamilialexperiencesaschildrenand
![Page 189: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/189.jpg)
parentstodescribepatternsofreactionindependencysystems.Iwanttousehismodeltopointtosimilarpatternsinthehierarchicalstructuresofchurches.
Harrisremindsusofthecharacteristicmessageswereceivedfromparentscommandsorexhortationstodosomethingweusuallydidnotwanttodo.Hedescribesthosemessages,collectively,asasetoftapeswerecordinmemory.Thetapessaythingssuchas:''Cleanyourplate.Putonyourgaloshes.Don'teverdothatagain!Stopthat!Behaveyourself.Sitstillandlisten.Dowhatyouaretold."Mostofuscanaddtothelistfromourexperience.
![Page 190: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/190.jpg)
Page98
Thosecollectiveexperiencesarerecordedinourmemory,Harrissuggests,asourownmemory-cassetteof"parenttapes."Hesuggeststhattheybecometheemotionalframeworkweuseindealingwithourownchildren.Whenpushcomestoshoveinourrelationshipwiththosedependentuponus,weusuallyflipbacktousethoserememberedtapes.
Holdon.There'smore.Inresponsetotheparenttape,thechilddevelopsasetofemotionalandverbalanswers:"Idon'twantto.Iwon't.Makeme.It'snotfair.Jimmydoesn'thaveto,whyshouldI?Youcan'tmakeme."
Thosebecomeour"childtapes."Harrissaysthesetapesgoundergroundinourconsciousnessbutpopoutatunexpectedplaces.Wemaybesecureprofessionaladultsbutwhenafellowworkersays,"Youbettergetthatreportinontime,"adormantchildtapeistriggeredtofeelsayswho?Weactuallyrespondwithsomethinglike"Youdon'thaveauthoritytogivemethatassignment!"Actingoutofrememberedemotions,wegivearationalversionofachildishresponse,probablytriggeringourfellowworkertoevenmoreparentalpatterns:I'llmakeyoudoit,transmutedinto"Well,I'llseeitgetsonyourperformancereport!"
Mostofuscanrecognizethedynamic.Oftenwedeploreourownbehaviorandknowwearecomplicatingthingswhenwerespondthatway,butwealmostcannothelpit.Insomesituationsorrelationshipswejustfeeldrivenbythosetapes.Theytakeover.Ihaveworkedwithsomepeoplewhohavejustsetmeoff.Whentheywalkintheroom,I'mreadytotellthemwhyIwon'tdowhattheywantmeto,evenbeforeIknowwhattheywant.ThenthereareothersIknowarenotgoingtodowhatIwant,soinmyanxietyIapproachthemveryparentally.
Harrissaysthatoneofthefewwaystobreakoutofthese
![Page 191: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/191.jpg)
unproductiveexchangesisforsomeonetointervenewiththe"adulttape,"whichstatesfactsorasksfordataandtriestosolveproblems.
9Itattemptstofocusattentionontheissueathandanditseekscollegialityindealingwithit.IntheexchangeInotedaboveaboutgettingareportinontime,itmighthelpifanotherfellowworkersaid,"Waitaminute.Whoneedsthereport,andwhendowehavetohaveitready?Whatdoyouneedtogetitdone?"Harrissays,andexperiencesupportshim,thatjustasaparenttapecantriggerachildtape(andachildtapecantriggeraparenttape)anadulttapecannudgepeoplewhoarebehavingparentallyorchildishlytogetbackintofunctionalbehavior.
Whatdoesallthishavetodowithchurchesandourneedtotransformthem?Quiteabit.
![Page 192: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/192.jpg)
Page99
ThehierarchicalstructuresthatchurchesdevelopedovertheyearshavebeenoverlaidbyemotionalinteractionsthatcloselyfittheHarrismodel.Thepeople,theoffices,thestructuresatthe"higher"levelsoftencommunicatewiththe"lower"levelsusingparenttapes."Youmustdothis,orwewillreportyoutotheannualconference.Getyourcontributionsinontime.Whereisyourannualreport?"Pastorsrelatetolaypeopletoofrequentlyoutoftheirparenttapes:"Gettochurchontime.Notenoughofyouhaveincreasedyourpledges.Itisyourresponsibilitytovisitthesick."
10
Weshouldnotbesurprisedbythechildishresponses:ignoringthemessages;resentingthemessageandcriticizingthemessenger;draggingfeet;beinglate;notcarryingthroughonpromises.
Thenwecompoundtheproblem.Werewardthecongregationsthatdowhattheyareasked,asiftheywerethe"goodchildren."They'retheonesthatdon'tgetknownaroundthejudicatoryofficeasbeing"problems"therecalcitrantchildrenyounevercancounton.Onthecongregationallevel,theobedientlaypeoplebecomethemodelleaders.Theoneswhoaskdifficultquestionsatparishmeetingsaresoonseenas"troublemakers."Somecongregationsandsomepeoplebecomeadolescentchildrenwhoactout;theyrunawayfromdenominationalresponsibility;theystayhomeandpout;theytaketheirmarblesandgohome.
TheconnectionsIdescribehereareimpressionistic,buttheyarereal.Relationshipsinourorganizationalstructuresareoverlaidbyemotionalbaggagefrompastpersonalandorganizationalexperience.Oftencongregationsarerespondingemotionallytothewayabishoporapastororanationalboardactedyearsago.
![Page 193: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/193.jpg)
Thereisnothing"bad"inouractingthisway.Itisonlybadifwedonotrecognizethepatternswhenwecanandtrytominimizeunhelpfulresponses.Itisbadonlyifouremotionalbaggageblocksusfromexaminingtherealissuesweneedtodiscussandsettle.
Specifically,weneedtobeawareofhowpervasivetheseemotionaltriggersare,andweneedtobealerttowhenweorourcolleaguesaremovingintoinappropriatebehavior.Weneedtohelponeanotherrelateasadult-to-adultsowecandealwithwhatisreallygoingon.Aslongaswearetrappedinparentalorchildishtapes,wearebeingemotionallyreactivetoothers;wearenotmakingconsciouschoicesorexploringwhatneedstobedone.
Therearestructuralthingsthatcanhelp.Elsewhere11Ihavepointed
![Page 194: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/194.jpg)
Page100
outthatweneedmoreaccountabilityinourrelationshipsinreligiousorganizations.Pressingforclarityaboutexpectationstendstomoveonetowardadultrelationshipswherewhatistobedoneisthoughtthrough,defined,andspelledout.Parent-childagreementsareoftenoverlaidwithunwrittenexpectationsandundefinedemotionalcontracts.Volunteerswithinacongregationneedtogetsomeclarityaboutwhatisexpectedofthemandwhatresourcestheycancountontodotheirjobs.Otherwisetheyarepushedintothechildishpositionofhavingtofantasizewhatisexpectedagainstthebackdropthatonecanneverdoenough.Itisnowonderthatvolunteersburnoutandgrowresentfulofhowtheyhavebeentreated.
Thecontinuationofunhealthyformsofdependenceisabarriertothekindsofreligiousinstitutionsweneed.Beingawareofthissimpleanalysisofrelationalpatternsmayhelpusgetoutofemotionalreactionswhenourparenttapesorourchildtapesaretriggered.Andeveniftheawarenessdoesnothelpuscontrolourownreactions,theconceptcanbearesourcetohelpusrecognizethesepatternsinothers.
WeHaveBecome"Fundamentalists"intheWayWeViewOurStructures
12
Inchurches,perhapsmorethananyotherplace,wemakeidolsoutofourstructures.Webecomefundamentalistsabouttheformsbywhichwedowhatwedo.Wearefundamentalisticaboutwhatapastoris,abouthowacongregationshouldbeorganized,aboutwhatabishoporanexecutiveis,abouthowoneeducatesreligiousleaders.Theformsbecomeholy,andanyonewhosuggestschangesinthosestructuresisseenasaheretic.
Iseeparallelpatternsinhowweviewtheinsidesofthebuildingswe
![Page 195: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/195.jpg)
useforreligiouspurposes.Afteragenerationortwoofuse,thefurnituretakesonmeaning.Whatwasboughtasachairforthepastortositonwhenwaitingtopreachbecomesthepastor'schair,andwoebetideanyonewhosuggeststhatitbereplaced.13Orevenmoved.Whereitisbecomesimportant.Youcantellwhentheprocessiswellalongbecausethingslikepastors'chairsstarthavingbrassplaquesattachedandtheybecomememorialstosomebody.Bythenyouaredeadifyoutrytomoveit.
![Page 196: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/196.jpg)
Page101
Differenttraditionshavedifferentareasofrigidity.AskthoseinCatholichierarchicalrolesabouttheauthorityofthepriestorbishop,andyouarelikelytoheararesponsebasedonmorphologicalfundamentalism,asthisphenomenonhasbeencalled.AskanEpiscopalianwhythelaityshouldnotcelebratetheEucharist,andyoudiscover"thebeast."AskaPresbyterianwhythepresbyteryexecutivecannotinterveneinaclergy-laycongregationaldispute,andyouwillseewhatIamtalkingabout.AskaUnitedMethodistbishopaboutitinerancyoraBaptistorCongregationalistwhytheircongregationscannotagreeonacommonpolicy....Yougetthepicture.
Despitethesedifferences,weshareaterribledifficultyinbeingabletoacceptchangeinhowwearestructured,evenwhenwebecomeawarethatthestructuresarenowworkingwell.
14Wearecomfortablewiththeoldways.We've"grownaccustomedtoherface."Thathappenseverywhere.Businessesandcorporationshavetroublechangingthingspeoplehavegottenusedto.Butreligiousinstitutionsmayhaveitmoredifficultthanothers.
Anotherparagraphaboutfurnituremaybeinstructive.WhenIgotanewofficechair,Ifeltamomentarypang.Ilovedtheoldone.TedEastmansoldittomeeighteenyearsago.Mybottomwascomfortableinit,andIknewwhichofthecasterswouldfalloffifyoupickedthechairup.Butafteronedayinthenewchair,whichreallydidfeelbetterandworkedbetter,Ilostmyloyalty.Butifyouweretoremovethebishop'schairfrommyparishchurchandreplaceit,IthinkI'dremembertheoldoneSundayafterSundayforyears.Theychangedthealtarrail(Ireallydidnotliketheoldone;itwasdark;thebrassfittingskeptfallingoff;itthreatenedtocollapse;anditscolordidnotfittheotheraltarfurniture),andaftersixmonthsIstillresentthenewone.
![Page 197: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/197.jpg)
Ourcurrentchurchstructuresarestranglingus,butwelovethem.Morethanthat,theyfeelholytous.TochangethemfeelslikedisloyaltytoGodeventhoughweknowit'sjustachair,justanorganizationalarrangement,justaleadershipposition.
![Page 198: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/198.jpg)
Page102
WeHaveNotRecognizedtheComplexityoftheChangeProcess
Itrustweagree:Wemustrenewourchurchesforthefuture.Indoingso,perhapsourmostdifficultobstacleisourverycomplexrelationshiptochangeitself.HereIwanttodescribeonestrategicframeworkforapproachingchangeandtwowaysofunderstandingreactionsthatblockmanychangeefforts.ButIwanttobeginbyputtingtheissueofchangeintoperspective.
MyPerspectiveonChange
Frankly,whenitcomestochange,I'drathernotdealwithit.ButIhaveto.TheworldIliveinsimplywillnotsitstill.Tomaintainsomekindofequilibriumandhavesomecontroloverwhat'sgoingon,IhavetomakefairlyfrequentadaptationsifIwanttostayintouchwithmyworld.
IfIwereinarowboatinthemiddleofalake,Icouldliebackandenjoythesunandthemotionoftheripples.Frankly,I'dlikethat...mostofthetime.
If,however,Iwereinacanoeinthemiddleoftherapids,mylifewouldhavetobeverydifferent.Iwouldhavetobealertforrocksunderthesurface.Iwouldhavetopaddletoavertdisasterorsteertosaferwater.
Inthefirstscenario,Icouldgoalongtimenotworryingaboutchangeunlessastormcameup.Inthesecond,changeisamatterofcourse.Onekindofbehaviorworksonthelake.Thesamebehaviorisdisastrousifusedintherapids.
Intoday'sworldthechurchesareintherapids.Theyarenottheonlyones.Actually,allourinstitutionsareexperiencingsimilarturbulence.Businesscorporationsthattrytomaintainthepracticesthatbroughtthemtothetopinthesixtiesorseventiesseeupstartcompanies
![Page 199: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/199.jpg)
cuttingintotheirmarkets.Manysuchcorporationswillfallapartinthenineties.Somehavebegunto.
Frommyperspective,overthenextfewdecadesthereligiousstructuresthatfailtochangeandlearntoadaptwillbelikethebuggy-whipmanufacturersofthenineteenthcentury.
Thechangesneededinreligiousinstitutionsmaybeevenmore
![Page 200: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/200.jpg)
Page103
urgentandfundamentalthanthoseneededinbusiness.Onthewhole,businessesarerequiredtomaintainsomeflexibilitytorespondtotheircustomers.Butreligiousleadershavenotbeensensitiveeventothatorganizationalimperative.Thisneglecthasputusinthepositionofhavingseveredislocationsinthecredibilityandeffectivenessofourinstitutionsatthenational,regional,andlocallevels.Thefurthertheordinarylaymemberofthecongregationisfromaninstitutionalstructure,themorelikelytherewillbealackofcredibility.
Letmebeclear.Iholdnobriefforchangingourbasicmessage.Iamabitfundamentalisticatthispoint.Idonotbelievethebasicmessageofthechurchescanorshouldchange.Butifourcongregationsaretobefaithfultotheirrevelation,theyhavetoworkregularlyathowthatunchangingtruthneedstobepresentedinachangingtime.Theyneedtoworkatrethinkingthestructuresandpatternsthatpreservedthosetruthsinthepasttoseewhatstructuresandpatternscandothesameinourtime.
Inthelanguageofmytradition,Idonotbelievethegospelitselfchanges.Buttobefaithfultothatunchanginggospelinachangingworld,Ihavetopayalotofattentionto(1)whatischangingaroundmeand(2)howIneedtoadaptinresponse.Religiousleaderswhoagreewithmeonthispointmustbesureoftwothings:(1)thattheyareseentobeproclaimersofthegospel,notofchange;and(2)thattheykeeptheirfocusonthatgospel;thereisnootherwaytodistinguishbetweenthatwhichcanandshouldbechangedandthatwhichbearsthestampofthetruth.Inlesselegantlanguage,ifyouarebathingababyithelpstobeveryclearaboutwhothebabyiswhenyouneedtothrowoutthebathwater!
AlthoughIreferheretotheorganizationalnecessityofdealingwithchange,myperspectiveisgroundedmuchmoredeeplyinwhatIunderstandtobeGod'swillandGod'scall.Ibelievethattheturmoil
![Page 201: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/201.jpg)
aroundusisatleastpartlyGod'sinvitationtoustojoinintheNewCreation.Indeed,IunderstandwhatisgoingonasaworkingoutofGod'shope.Assuch,weareinvolved,aswedealwithchange,witheschatology.Isometimesdescribemyworkwithcongregationsandchurchbodiesas"operationaleschatology."
![Page 202: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/202.jpg)
Page104
AStrategicApproachtoChange
OneofthemultipurposetheoriesofchangeIhaveusedovertheyearsisthesimpleanduniversallyapplicableframeworklaiddownbybehavioralscientistKurtLewin.
15Lewinsuggeststhatorganizationsarerarely,ifever,atapointoftotalconsensusaboutwhattheyareandhowtheyshouldoperate.Instead,organizationsareinastateoforganizedcompromise,wheretheforcesforchangeandtheforcesagainstchangeareinequilibrium.Thisequilibriumisdynamic,notstable.Withinacertainrange,thewholesystemcanadapttominorshiftsandchanges.Butthereisasenseofmutualoftenunspokenagreementthattheequilibriumwillnotbechangedinabasicway.(Althougheveryoneinthecongregationknowsthattheorderoftheserviceislikelytohavesomechangesfromtimetotime,everybodyknowsyoubetternotmesswiththeeleveno'clockhour!)Thatunspokenagreementisapowerfulforcetokeepchangewithinlimits.Itmakesforthestatusquobeingakindofhomeostasis.Ifchangesareintroducedthatviolatethatunspokenagreement,afteraperiodoftimethingswillprobablyreverttotheoriginalhomeostasis.
Hereisadiagramofasysteminhomeostasis:
![Page 203: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/203.jpg)
![Page 204: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/204.jpg)
Page105
Overtimethisstatusquobecomescomfortable,andthedifferentconcernsareaccommodatedfairlywell.Thewidemarginsofthehomeostaticsystemindicatesomespaceformakingadjustmentsinonedirectionoranotherwithouttriggeringanxiousresponses.Neitherthepeoplewhopushforchangenorthosewhoopposeitgetalltheywant,buttheyhaveenough;andthesystemrests.
Thisunderstandingofanorganization'sequilibriumledLewintoidentifythreestagesonemustgothroughtobringchangeintoanorganization.Onemust"unfreeze"theequilibrium.Thenonemustinstallthechange(withalltheadaptationsofpracticeandtrainingoforganizationalmembers).Thenonemust"refreeze"intoanewhomeostasisthatincludesthechange.
Mostattemptstoinstallplannedchangeinreligioussystemsfailbecausetheoldsystemsareneverunfrozen.Adenominationorajudicatorywillannounceagreatnewideaorprogramthatisboundtomakeabigdifference.Theannouncedprogramisthenimplementedtounanimouslackofenthusiasmbycongregationsthatalreadyhaveenoughontheirplatesandwantanothernewprogramthewaytheywantanewmortgage.Yearafteryearthisgoesontotheincreasingfrustrationoftheprogramdesignersmostofwhomareprettygoodatdesign.Thehomeostasisnevergetsbrokenopen.
16
Theprocessofinstallingachangeisgenerallydonewithlittlerespectforthepreexistinghomeostasisahomeostasisthatincludesahealthyrespectforcompromise.Mostreligiousinstitutionsinstallchangesbystrongadvocacyofaparticularpointbythepeoplewhohavepowerandwantthatchangeinstalled.
Thehomeostasisisupsetbyastronginterventionoftenbythenew
![Page 205: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/205.jpg)
pastorpushingthesysteminthedesireddirection.Hereiswhatgenerallyhappenswhenchangeisintroducedthisway:
![Page 206: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/206.jpg)
Page106
Yes,thereischange.Thestronginputpushesthesysteminthedesireddirection.Butlookattheunintendedby-productsofthiskindofchangeeffort.First,thoseopposedtothechangearestartledandwakeuptothefactthatthetrucehasbeenbroken.Theirenergymultipliesastheydefendtheirterritory,requiringgreaterandgreaterpressurefromthepastororanothernewintervenerjusttokeepthingsinplace.Notinfrequentlysomeofthepeopleonthe''change"sidedeserttheship;theydonotwanttogetinvolvedinawar!Thechangeagentismoreandmorealone,workingharderandhardertokeepthegainsmadeinthefirstpush.Butthereismore.Lookattheboundariesofthesystem.Theyhavebecomeconstricted.Theroomformaneuveringandeasycompromiseisgone.Probablyanythingthatgetsproposednowwillbethesubjectofsuspiciousnit-picking.Trusthasbeendisruptedandoppositiontochangemobilized.Thelatestagesofsuchachangeeffortarerarelycomfortable.Indeed,whenthepastorfinallygivesuporhasaheartattackfromthepressure,thehomeostasiswillprobablybereestablishedprettymuchwhereitwasbefore,exceptthattrustlevelswillbelowerwhenthenextpastorarrives.
Lewinsuggeststhatthereisabetterwaytoconsiderchange,awaythatislessconfrontativeandmorecollaborativeandgivesmorepromiseofdevelopingsustainablechangewithoutlossoftrust.Hereisadiagramofhissuggestion:
![Page 207: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/207.jpg)
![Page 208: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/208.jpg)
Page107
Lewinencourageschangeagentsinsteadtodocarefuldiagnosisoftheequilibrium,identifyingproponentsofchangeandopponentstochange,analyzingtheforcesinvolved.Bothsidesofthehomeostasisareincludedintheplanningandthinkingaboutwhatisneeded.Bydoingsotheeffortisbroadened,andthelegitimateconcernsofpotentialopponentstothechangearebroughtintotheconversationearlyenoughtomakesignificantimpactonwhatisactuallyplanned.Theentiresystem,notjustthosehell-bentforachange,worksonplansandstrategies.Thosewhousethisapproach(itiscalled''forcefieldanalysis")findthattheresultingchangeeffortshaveahighsurvivalrate.Thetrustinthesystemcanactuallyexpandwhenthisisdonewell.Andthenewhomeostasishasachanceofbeingasstableasthelast.
WhatLewincallsrefreezingisuniversallyignoredinchangeeffortsinreligiousinstitutions.Theinstitutionsactasifonceachangeissetinplace,oppositionnolongerexists.Refreezingachangedsysteminvolvestrainingpeopleinthebehaviorsneeded,makingperiodicevaluationstotakeintoaccountwhathasgonewrong,andlisteningtoopposition,everseekingtoimprovethequalityofthenewhomeostasis.Again,collaborativeplanningandstrategizingare
![Page 209: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/209.jpg)
helpful,makingforahealthieraftermathtochange.
![Page 210: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/210.jpg)
Page108
ThePersonalDimensionofResponsetoChangeGrief
ElisabethKubler-Ross'sbookOnDeathandDying
17isawonderfulguidetohowpersonalresponsestolosscaninfluenceaperson'soragroup'sabilitytodealwithchange.
Becauseeverychangeinvolvesloss,everychangetriggersgrief.Themoreoneisattachedtothatwhichischanged,themoreintenseone'ssenseoflossandneedtogrieve.Almostanythingthattouchesreligiousmemoriesormeaningstouchesverystronganddeepfeeling.Thatiswhyperfectlyrationalpeoplewillroarwithangerwhensomeonemovessomethingassimpleasachairinthesanctuaryofachurch.Thatiswhystrong,ablepeoplecanbecomefranticandpanic-strickenwhentheyhearthattheirpastorhasbeencalledtoanotherjobevenpeoplewhodidnotparticularlylikethepastor.Itisasifthereligiousfactoractsasamagnifyingglassforlosses.Theresponsesareoftenmultipliedoutofproportionto"reality."
Kubler-Rossnotesseveralcharacteristicresponsestolossdenial,bargaining,anger/guilt,depression,acceptance.Individualresponsesarenotsequentialandmayrecurincycles.Havingreachedsomelevelofacceptanceofaloss,onemaystillreverttoseasonsofangerordepression.Sheteachesusthatgrievingtakestime;intimeonecanmovebeyondthegrief.
Religiousleaderswhodealinchangeneedtobeawareoftheneedtoministertoallthoseresponses.Change,andrespondingtoit,mustbeunderstoodtobeverytime-consuminganddeeplyemotional.Changeisnotsimply"fixingsomething."Itrequiresrealpastoralcareandspiritualdiscernment.
Pastorsoftenseetheirworksoexclusivelyasmanagingthechangeprocessthattheydonotrecognizehowcriticalitistoministertothe
![Page 211: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/211.jpg)
spiritualneedsthatblockpeoplefrombeingabletoacceptchange.Actually,thereismorethanenoughchangeandgriefinanyone'slifeevenifthepastorinstitutesnochangeswhatsoever.
IfInoteacharacteristicfaultofreligiousleadersitisthattheyrespondtothesymptomandconsequentlymisstheopportunitytodealwiththelargerreligiousissuewhetheritbethefearoftheunknown,thethreatofdeath,orthequestionofultimatemeaning.Religiousleadersrespondasiftheexpressedangerordepressionweretheissue,whentheissuesaredeeper.
![Page 212: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/212.jpg)
Page109
Also,manypastorsworryaboutthisorthatangryparishioner,thepoor,depressedpeoplewhohavegivenuponlife,orthe"churchrats"whoareconstantlyunderfoot,tryingtodoanythingandeverythingtopleasethepastor.Theyoverlooktheneedsofthegrim-facedstoicwhoavoidsthinkingaboutchangebybecomingtherock-ribbedbulwarkofthestatusquo.PastorsIknowseethesecharacteristictypesintermsofhowtheyaffectthecongregation'sprogram,notintermsoftheirsubstantialspiritualneedastheyfacethelossoffamiliarandvaluedpartsoftheirlives.
Pastorsandchurchleaderswhounderstandthechangesneededintheirsystemsandhaveworkedhardtogettheminstalledhavedonelessthanhalfthejob.Themoreimportantpartisthereligious,pastoral,andspiritualtaskofnurturing,pushing,andsupportingpeopleastheyseetheirworldchange.Inthelongrun,oneofthemostimportantfunctionsofareligiousorganizationisasalaboratoryinwhichpeoplearegivenanopportunitytodiscoverGodintheprocessoflivingwithchangeandloss.Tootightafocusonthechangeitselfshort-circuitsthatdeeperpastoraltask.
Manychurchmemberscarrysubstantialloadsofunresolvedgrief.Itcomesfromavarietyofplacesdisappointmentsoverlostopportunities,remembrancesoflostlovedones,bitternessaboutrealorimaginedunfairness,alienationorasenseofhavingbeenleftoutorleftbehind.Everyonehasapersonalversionofthissenseofloss,andeveryonecarriesitalongsidehisorherpersonalstrengthsandweaknesses.Similarly,asasocietywebearasenseoflossasapeoplelossofthememoryofakinder,gentlernationthanweseetoday,lossofourdreamsofwhatthenationmightbecome,lossofcertainhopes.
Inthatcontext,whatgoesonincongregationsaswelearntodealwithchangeis,infact,adoorwayforGracetoenterintohiddengriefsin
![Page 213: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/213.jpg)
personallives,touchingthoseunhealedplaceseachofushas.Dealingwithchangeandtheemotionsitraisesinourcongregationscanpotentiallyconnectus(ashealingconduits)tothepainandgriefthatwracksoursociety.
Understandingchangeasopportunityforspiritualministryinthiswaydepthministrytoindividualmemoryandlife,andbreadthministrytosociety'spainshouldputanewdimensiononthehasslesofmovingchurchfurniture,winningorlosingparishelections,andapproachingdifficultplanningissues.
![Page 214: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/214.jpg)
Page110
OrganizationalDimensionsofChangeShockandAdaptation
Anotherimportanttheoryabouttheorganizationaldimensionofchangegivesuscluestowhatisgoingoninreligiousinstitutionsandmaysuggestdirectionsforthefuture.
Writinginarecessionarytimesomeyearsago,Fink,Beak,andTaddeo
18describedhoworganizationstheyworkedwithfacedcrises.TheresponsepatterntheydiscoveredinthoseorganizationsiscongruentwithwhatKubler-Rossdiscoveredinpeoplewithonedifference.Kubler-Rosssaidthattheemotionalresponsesshefoundinthosefacingdeathdidnotfollowaclearsequence.Onestagedidnotleadtothenextinasequentialorfullypredictableway.Fink,Beak,andTaddeoseemtosuggestthatthefourstagesoftheresponsepatterntheyidentifiedinorganizationsfollowoneanothersequentially.Theorganizationsthatdonotmoveonfromonestagetothenextmaysimplynotsurvivetotellthestory.Organizationsmaynothaveadequateidentitytorecyclethroughstagesthathavenotbeencompleted.
Fink,Beak,andTaddeodescribefoursequentialstagesfortheorganizationsthatsurmountcrises:shock,defensiveretreat,acknowledgment,andgrowthandadaptation.
Inmostorganizationsshockistheimmediateresponsetocrisis.Manyofthepeopleintheorganizationshareavisceralunderstandingthatsomethingisseriouslywrong.Duringshocktheorganization'smembersfragment,andalmosteveryonemovesintoastanceoftakingcareofhimself,distancingselffromothers.Peopleorgroupsareblamed,andangerisbitter,oftenfocusedonspecificactorsinthedrama.Communicationsgetmuddledandtrustdisappears.Fights
![Page 215: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/215.jpg)
breakoutamonggroupsandindividuals.Noonehasenergytothinkaboutthefuture.Iftheleaderspanicalongwitheveryoneelse,theotherscanbeparticularlydemoralized.Oneofthehopefulorganizationaldynamicsisthatdifferentgroupshitshockatdifferenttimes.Forexample,iftheleadersseethecrisisearlyenoughanddealwiththeirownshock,theyarebetterabletohelpwhenshockhitsthetroops!Throughouttheprocess,itisbestifleaderscandealwiththeirownissuesearlyandmobilizeotherlevelsoftheirgrouptomoveontothenextstage.
Defensiveretreatisadifficultstage.Itismarkedbyimpositionoftightcontrols,a"clampingdown."Budgetsmaybeslashed.Peoplegetfired.19Althoughthisperiodrarelysolvesanybasicproblems,itcan
![Page 216: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/216.jpg)
Page111
keepthegroupfromtotaldisintegration.Sometimesthebudgetcutsandstaffterminationsbringcoststemporarilyundercontrolandpreserveenoughfinancialviabilitytoallowthecompanytosurvive.Butaprolongedperiodofshockanddenialmayhaveledtosuchadepletionoffinancialreservesthateventhisshort-termstrategyistoolate.Thebettertheleadershavebeeninprocessingtheirownshock,themorelikelytheywillbeabletoholdthingstogether.Whendefensiveretreathitstheorganization'sleaders,manyothersmaybeexperiencingtheinitialshockofhearing"thenews."Thisisnotatimethatreallyfacesthefuture;atthispointthesurvivorsbegintofindnewpatternsofworkingtogether.Youcanexpectan"ingroup"andan"outgroup"withcontinuingsuspicionbetweenthem.Flowofinformationisoftenrigidlycontrolled.Anythingtheorganizationstartedrightbeforethecrisisanewprogram,anewmanagementsystem,anewbookkeepingsystemmaybethefirstthingthrownout,eventhoughithasmuchpromise.Thegroupmayreverttopreviousbehaviorandpreviousstructures.Leadersaretemptedtodemandloyaltytothesystemandtoimposeauthoritarianleadershipstyles.
Fink,Beak,andTaddeosaythatacknowledgmentcomestomanywhosurviveshockanddefensiveretreat.(Somedonotsurviveeither.)
Thismarksaturntowardthefuture.Acknowledgmentrepresentstheorganization'sturningthecornerfromangerandblametoasearchforanswers.Herewetrytofindoutwhatwemustnotdo.Insteadof"who'stoblame?"thequestionis"whatwentwrong?"anditisaskedtofigureouthowtoavoidthesamemistakesinthefuture.Acknowledgmentoftenincludesanewlookattheenvironmentandtheorganization's"customers"todeterminewhatsignalshadbeenmissed.Thisstagequestionshowthingshavebeendoneinthepastandthinksaboutnewpaths.Leadershipoftenrelaxesabitfromitstightneedtocontroleverythingandeverybody.Personalrelationshipsamongcolleaguesbecomelessanxiousandsuspicious.Peoplebegin
![Page 217: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/217.jpg)
towanttoworktogetheroncommontasks.
Institutionsthatmakeitthroughtheacknowledgmentstagecanmoveintothefourthstagegrowthandadaptation.Thisiswhentheorganization'scopingmechanismskickbackin.Thefocusisthefuture,notthepast.Thepurposesandvisionoftheorganizationarereexaminedandpeoplesetouttobuildforthefuture.Oftennewmythsbuildupabout"thetimewenearlywentunder."
![Page 218: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/218.jpg)
Page112
Thesetheories,basedinbusinessorganizations,arenottotallydescriptiveofwhatgoesoninreligiousorganizationsfacingcrisis.ButIseemanyparallels.Myowndiagnosisisthatmostofthenationalstructuresofthemainlinechurchesareinshock,withafewgivingsignsofhavingmovedtodefensiveretreat.OfthemoreconservativeProtestantchurchesandtheRomanCatholicChurch,Iseesignsofsomepeopleandgroupsmovingintoshock,butoveralllittleresponsetotheenvironmentalchangesaroundthem.
Inthemainlinechurches,aprolongedshockanddenialstageamongleadershasseriouslyerodedthefinancialbaseformovingaheadintodefensiveretreat.Regionalstructuresofthechurchesseemevenmorethreatened,butalltoofewleadersatthatlevelhavebeguntofacethecrisis.
Conclusion
InearlierchaptersIhavenotedthekeytaskscongregationsmustaddresstofulfilltheirpurposeandthefunctionscongregationsneedfromdenominationalsystemsiftheyaretofulfillthatpurposeinthemidstoftheseriousstormweface.Ofcourserespondingtothesechallengeswillsetchurchesonanewcourseofrethinkingandreconstructingthingsthatareverybasictotheirlives.
InthischapterIhavelaidoutthemoredifficultorganizationalissuesthatblockourmovingahead.Rightnowwecanbegintoaddressanyoneoralloftheseobstacles,andIhavegivensomecluesastohowandwheretostart.
Iwrapthissectionupwithonefinalsoberingchallenge:Thequestionofreinventingthechurchonoursidemaycomedowntowill.
![Page 219: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/219.jpg)
![Page 220: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/220.jpg)
Page113
Chapter6TransformationandCongregationsTwenty-fivehundredyearsagoJerusalemwaslaidwastebyanenemyfromBabylon.Theconquerorsdestroyedthecitythathadnurturedrebellionandresistanceoncetoomanytimes.ThetemplethatdatedbacktoDavid'ssonwasdestroyed,withthestonesofitsfoundationleftliketheruinsofCoventryCathedralaftertheSecondWorldWar.ThegatesofthegreatcityofJerusalemwerepulleddownaswerethewallsthathadprotectedthecitizens.Agreatdreamofanationheldtogetherasapoliticalstatewithinaframeworkofreligiousvocationseemedtobegoneforever.
Jeremiahlivedasacommunityleaderandaprophetduringthelastdaysbeforethatcityfell.Attimesviewedasanationalwisemanandhero,atothertimesvilifiedasatraitorandfool,JeremiahreadthesignsofthetimesagainsthisunderstandingofGod'swill,andhecalledforrepentanceandchange.Asthepeoplecontinuedinasuicidalcourse,Jeremiahreadtheirfateandspokeoftheinevitabledestructiontocome.
Then,withtheenemyatthegate,withthedestructionhehadforeseenimmediatelypresent,Jeremiahchangedhismessageandcourseofaction,thisalsobasedonthisfaithandhisunderstandingofGod.Aseveryoneelselookedatdestruction,JeremiahannouncedthatGodwouldbringnewlifetothecityandtothefieldsthatsurroundedit.Hepredictedthatthevineyardsandorchardswouldagainbefruitfulandthatthecitywouldflourish.
Withhisknownworldobviouslycomingtoanend,JeremiahpurchasedafieldinthevillageofAnathothasademonstrationofhisconfidenceinthefutureandinGod'spromises.
![Page 221: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/221.jpg)
WecanunderstandJeremiah'stime.Althoughthereisnoarmycurrentlyatthegate,muchofourcivilizationseemstobeunderthreat,if
![Page 222: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/222.jpg)
Page114
notactuallyincollapse.Oursociety,likeJeremiah's,isemergingfromasenseofreligiousandpoliticalunityandclarityintoacacophonyofvoicesandpowers.CalledtoserveGod'sworld,wehavelosttheclarityofourvocationandofourdirection.Thestructuresofoursocietyandfaithhavefailedtokeepusfocusedonthatvocationofservice,andoftenthosestructuresofserviceandmissionhavebecomeself-serving.RatherthanbeingservantsofGod'spurposesintheworld,wehavetoooftenbecomeservantsofthestructuresthemselves.
MyfirstmessageabouttransformingcongregationsisthatwemustdoasJeremiahdid:Inspiteofthewisdomoftheworld,wearecalledtocommitourselvesunreservedlytothefutureofGod'spromises.InJeremiah'scase,thatcommitmenttooktheprosaicformofmakinganinvestmentinrealestate.Inourtime,itmaybejustasprosaic.Wearethegenerationwhosegifttothefuturemaynotbeacompletevisionofthenewsocietyoreventhenewchurch,buttheexampleofholdingsteadyandfaithfulasthelandmarksoftheworldwehaveknowndisintegrate.Ourtaskistogoonholdingon,studyingandteachingthestoryofthefaith,actinginservicetotheworld,trustingGodinthemiddleofambiguity,refusingtobackawayfromGod'sclaimuponus.Ifweholdsteady,Godwillprovidethevisionwhenthetimeisright.
Asforthenewsocietyandthenewchurch,wewillseeonlythebeginningsoftransformation.Jeremiah'sactionsspokethentohiscontemporaries,andtheyhavespokentopeopleoffaithforthesetwenty-fivehundredyears.Hemayhaveboughtthatfieldasaspecificwitnesstous.AkingnamedCyruswastoopenthedoorforthereturntoJerusalem.JeremiahboughtthefieldlongbeforeCyruswasborn.Jeremiahdiedlongbeforethatfieldhaditsfirstcrop.
Thefirststepintransformationhastodowithattitude.(We'llgettotasksinaminute.)Weneedasimplecommitmenttothefuture,
![Page 223: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/223.jpg)
obediencetoGod'spromise.ThereisadifferencebetweenthecommitmentIproposeandwhatthechurchesseemtobedoing.Jeremiah'scommitmentwasnotadenialofthedestructionofJerusalemandtheexileofthepeople.Ourcommitmentmustbelargeenoughtoacknowledgethewindsofthestormweareinandgothroughthestorm,notpretenditisunreal.ThelifeofGod'speoplewasfundamentallyreshapedbytheyearsinexile.Aswemoveintoahistoricalarenainwhichthechurchisnolongerthecenter,inwhichChristendomandCrusadesaretermsofthepast,wehavenewpagestowriteaboutwhatchurchisandhowwecanserve.Wewillknowitonlybygoingahead.
![Page 224: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/224.jpg)
Page115
TwoorthreegenerationsafterthefallofJerusalem,theexilesinBabylonwerestartledtolearnthatanewkinghadopenedthedoorforthemtoreturntorebuildtheirbelovedcityandtheirtemple.ThebookofEzra,Nehemiah,Haggai,andZechariahpreservesomeofthestoryofthattimeandtheflavorofapeoplestrugglingtorebuildanation.
Thestorycanbeinstructivetous,particularlyiftheirtaskisanalogoustothatwhichwefaceinourtime.Perhapstheclearestmessageisthatnoteveryoneinthatdaywasenthusiasticaboutthetaskoftransformation.Historicalrecordssuggestthatthefirstexilestoreturnwithenthusiasmtorestorethekingdomandthetemplewaitednearlytwentyyearsbeforetheystartedtobuild.Inthepressofotherthingsgettingcropsplantedandharvested,gettingfamiliesstarted,worryingabouttradeanddefensetheyforgotwhattheywentbacktodo.
Thefaithreasonsforreturninghometookbackseattothedetailsofmakingaliving.Andeventhatdidnotwork.Theircropsfailed,theirvineyardsdidnotproduce.Thepeoplegrumbledandfoughtastheylostdirection.
ThepropheticvoicesofHaggaiandZechariahcalledthepeoplebacktotheirrealtaskoffaithfulness.Twotaskswerelaidoutand,intime,accomplished:Thecity'swallswererebuiltwithitsgatesrestored,andinthecenterofthecityanewtemplewasraisedupfromtheruinsoftheold.
Thosetwotasksarecentralforustoday:rebuildingthecitywallandrestoringthetemple.
RebuildingtheWall
Thefirsttaskinourtransformationistherebuildingofthecitywall.ThecitywallofJerusalemdistinguishedwhatwasinsidethecityfrom
![Page 225: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/225.jpg)
whatwasoutside.Ithelpedthecityestablishitsidentity.Soforusinourcongregationallife.Wemustclarifywhatmakesusdifferent,sothatwecanundertakeourvocationasapostles.Thisrequriesustoestablishtheauthenticityanddistinctivenessofourcongregationssothatwelivevisiblyinourfaith,shapedbythebiblicalheritage,notbytheleastcommondenominatoroflocalvaluesandmorality.WemustbuildcongregationswherepeopleknowandfollowJesus,notthelatestpolls.
Thosecongregationsmustbecomecentersthatcanprovidespacefor
![Page 226: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/226.jpg)
Page116
genuineencounter,whereonemaybeconfrontedandsupportedinthedeepexperiencesoflife.Thesecongregationsmustbecommunitiesthatcanhelpeachofusdiscoverourgiftsandourspecialvocationtoserveoursociety.Rebuildingthewallmeansclarifyingtheboundaryofthecommunityandcontinuingtomaintainit.Itinvolvesgettingclearerandcleareraboutwhatisinsideandwhatisnotinsidethecommunity.Inourtraditionitmeansactivelywelcomingthosewhocometothecongregation,butcarefullytrainingtheminthestoriesofthefaith.
Withinourtraditon,thewall,theboundary,isnotforthepurposeofseparationbutofservice.Thefunctionoftheboundaryisnottoexcludebuttohelpthecommunitystrengthenitsidentityanditscommitmenttoserving.Thepurposeofthecommunityistoincreaseitsabilityforeachtoreachoutbeyondtheboundary.Theintegrityofthewallistohelpthecommunityinitscontinuingefforttodiscernitsmissionandthatofeachmember.
Congregations,followingtheexampleofthosewhoreturnedfromexileinBabylon,havefirstthetaskofrebuildingthecitywallsothatthepeoplecanonceagaingrasptheiridentityinthisalienandconfusingworld.Thewalldefinesthecommunitythatisatraininggroundfordisciples.Itestablishesthecommunitythatsendsitsmembersoutinserviceandreceivesthembackforhealingandnurture.Thewallistohelpthecommunityintensifyitsthrustoutbeyondthewall.
Wearecalledtoreestablishtheboundarybetweenourcongregationsandthesocietyaroundthem,gettingclearabouttheculturaldistancebetweenfollowersofthevaluesofthisworldandfollowersofthegospel.Wearepowerlesstochangeourselvesandtheworldifweareconfusedaboutwhatourcommunitystandsfor.
![Page 227: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/227.jpg)
RestoringtheTemple
Theothertasktheexilespostponedbuteventuallytookonwastherestorationofthetemple.Onecansympathize.Surelyitmusthaveseemedmoreimportanttoclearthestonesfromthefieldsandgetthecropsinbeforefocusingonthetemple.Itwasmoreimportanttogetroofsovertheheadsofthechildrenthantorebuildthealtarsandrestoretheworship.
Thescripture-storyindicatesthattheexileswerewrong.Common
![Page 228: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/228.jpg)
Page117
wisdomiswrong.Itisnotmoreimportanttodoanythingatallotherthanrestorethetemple.Ourassumptionsaboutwhatis''logical,prudent,andrational''arebasedonasetofvaluesthatarenotthesameasthevaluesofourfaith.
Thismaybethemostdifficultpointforus,livingaswedoonthechange-pointofthecenturies.Wearesopractical.Wemustseetheusefulnessofacourseofaction.Wewanttojustifyactivities,actions,orprogramsbytheir"outcomes"and"productivity."ThesestoriesfromthescripturesremindusthatwhendealingwiththethingsofGod,wearenotdealinginourfamiliarworld.TheworldofJeremiahandZechariahisaworldinwhichtwoplustwomayadduptoapple,notjustfour.Theworldoffaithmakesstrangeleapsfromonethingtoanother.DisciplescriticizeawomanforwastingexpensivelotiononJesus,andherejectstheirsocial-actionconcerns.Templesarenotveryproductive.Icanunderstandwhytheexilesleftthatuntilthe"real"workwasdone.
Toomanyofusarenotcomfortablewiththesuggestionthatsuchprioritybegiventothatwhichis"religious"asopposedtothatwhichis"efficacious."Indeed,thatverydistinctionisquestionable.Butthepointisthatwhatthechurchisismoreimportantthanwhatitdoes.
Andtheheartofthechurch'sbeingisthedeepconversationbetweenGodandGod'speoplethatthecommunityworksoutinitslifeofworshipinitstemple.Thatiswhyitiscriticaltorestorethetemple.Andthiscomesfirst.Itcomesbeforeimprovingourinstitutionalframework;itcomesbeforetrainingourclergy;itcomesbeforeorganizingprogramsforfeedingthehungryorhousingthehomeless;itcomesbeforeestablishingnonsexist,nonracistrelationships.
Thelifeofworshipandprayerisabsolutelyfirst.Itisnotanoptionalextra.Thatisthedifficultmessagefromscriptureforus.Ithinkweneedtoallowthatrealitytoconfrontusandchallengeusandour
![Page 229: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/229.jpg)
rationalizations.
Everyboneinourbodiesyearnstorecruitnewmembers,raisemoremoney,reviseourrulesoforder,andlearnhowtomarketourchurchaswellasothersmarkettheirs.Wewanttodevelopbettereducationprograms.Wewantourjudicatorytorestructureitself.Wewanttodosomereallybasiclong-termplanning.Strategicplanning.Idonotdownplaytheimportanceofthesemanyministrieswehavedevelopedovertime.NothingIsaytakesawayfromthefactthatpeopleareoftencalledtoreachoutinresponsetourgenciesthatdemandtheirresponse.
![Page 230: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/230.jpg)
Page118
Butthosewhocareforreligiousinstitutionsneedtosquareuptothefactthatrestoringthetempleistoppriority.
Conclusion
ChurchesIhaveknownformorethansixdecadesandservedprofessionallyfornearlyfourareinaseriousstorm.Thestormismostobviousinthecollapsingstructuresofsomeofthemtheonesweironicallyhavecalledmainline.IfIamright,thosesignsofstressandstrainareonlysymptomsofthelargerstormthatwillengulfpeopleoffaithinmanyotherreligiousfamiliesinthenextdecades.Thechurcheswehaveknownhavebeennurturedattheheartofoursociety.Inourtimewearemovingintoanexilefromtheheartofoursociety.Ibelievethemovementisirreversible.Thetriumphalismoftheconservativechurchestodaybecomesthemnobetterthandidthesimilarattitudeofthemainlinechurchesinthefifties.Idoubtthatthetriumphalismwilllastmuchlongerfortheonethanfortheother.
Myconcernistoseektohelpcongregationsofanykindconservative,liberal,orwhathaveyoureclaimtheessentialtaskofmakingdisciples,onebyone,andlaunchingeachofthemasanapostleintothesocietyheorshefaces,whereveritisandwhateveritmaybelike.
Todothat,congregationsneedtotransformtheirinnerlifesothattheircommunityreflectsthekoinoniaoftheearlychurch'scongregations.Theyneedasenseofcommunitythattransformsthelivesofmembers.TheyneedtodevelopaministryofkerygmawherethestoryofthepeopleofGodcomesaliveinthepoweroftheSpiritthroughtheproclamationofthegospel.Theyneedtodevelopaministryofteaching,didache,thatpresentstheage-oldstoryfreshtonewgenerationsandwithtransformingpowertothosecalledtobeapostles.Theyneednewpowertounderstandandreflectontheirservingintheworld,theirdiakonia.
![Page 231: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/231.jpg)
Thatlooksinsidecongregations,tothetransformationswemustmakeinthemsothattheymaytransformusintodisciples.Buttheendofbecomingadiscipleistobetransformedintoanapostle.Discipleshipisthepassive,butnecessarygroundingforthelifeoffaith.Apostleshipistheactivevoiceforfaithfulliving.
Iwanteverycongregationfeedingapostlesintothetownsandcities,
![Page 232: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/232.jpg)
Page119
theagenciesandthestructures,thefamiliesandtheneighborhoodsofoursociety.Iwanteverymemberofeverycongregationtoknowhim-orherselftobecalledtoaservantministry,theapostolate,andIwanteachtohavehelpdiscerninghisorhergiftsandtobetrainedandnurturedinhisorhervocation.Thatcallsforcongregationsthatcantransformordinarypeopleintoapostles.Ilookforeachcongregationtobethatkindofatransformingcongregation.
Forthattohappen,Iwanttoseethestructuresthatsurroundcongregationsthejudicatories,thenationalstructures,theseminaries,andeducationalinstitutionsbuildingskillsinnewways,readytohelptransformcongregationsfromwhattheyaretowhattheymustbeascentersofapostolicministry.Iwantallthosestructuresworkingattransformingcongregations.
TherearemoreroadblocksthanIhavelistedinchapter5.Andeachimpedimentisformidable.Therearesomethingswecandotodismantletheroadblocks,thingsIhavedescribedinthisbook,andthingsthatothersareworkingonandlearningabout.Buttransformationoccursoneperson,onecongregation,atatime,uniquely.
Thereisgreatgoodnewsinthatfact.Everycongregationisonthefrontedgeofpossibilityandcanbeginitsworkoftransformation.Thereisnotaspecialkindofcongregationorpeoplethathastheanswer.Thisisnotataskcutoutforonlythebigcongregationswithhighsteeplesandlargestaffs.ThisisnotaninvitationonlytoBaptistortoEpiscopalortoindependentcongregations.Thecallisopentoeachandtheopportunityfordiscoveryisthereforeach.Eachiscalledtostartwhereitis.
EachcongregationcanbeginnowtocommititselftofollowingGod'spurposes,comewhatmaybiggerbudgetsorsmallerones,moremembersorfewer.Eachcanmakeacommitmenttosendingapostles
![Page 233: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/233.jpg)
inservicetoitsworld.Now.
Thefutureisgenuinelyopen.Noneofushasallthewisdomortheresourcesweneedtorebuildourchurches.Butallofushaveenoughtostart.Intheend,IcansummarizewhatIknowintotwostatements:
ThetimeisrightforustomakethecommitmentJeremiahmadeacommitmentagainstallreasontothefutureandtoGod'spromises.
ThetasksbeforeusarethetasksthatfacedtheexilesreturningtoJerusalemtorebuildthewallsofthecityandtorestorethetemple.
![Page 234: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/234.jpg)
Page120
Whatliesaheadisastorm,indeed.Thewindsarestrong,andwecannotknowallthatistocome.Butinandthroughthisstorm,atransformingPowerisatworktobuildanapostolicchurch.Tobecalledtoparticipateinthattransformationisourlife.
![Page 235: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/235.jpg)
Page121
AppendixATheGood-News/Bad-NewsQuadrilateral:ADesign
Introduction
ThefollowingdesignisbasedonaneducationalmodelIhaveusedinmanydifferentsituations.Ithelpspeoplegetintouchwiththemanywayspeopleandgroupsconceiveoftheirspecialcalltoserve.Ifindithelpspeopleunderstandthediversityoftheircongregation;itlegitimizesdifferentresponsestothegospel;ithelpspeoplegetanoverallsenseoftheministryoftheirgroup;anditraiseshelpfulquestionsaboutthefunctionofthelargergroupinrelationshiptotheministryoftheindividual.MyexperiencewiththisdesignandcommentsofhundredswithwhomIhaveuseditliebeneathmuchofwhatIsayinchapters2and3.
TheBasicTheory
Iseeevangelismnotasa"program"ororganizedactivitybutasabasichumanresponsetoGod'scontinuousvocationtoeachhumanbeing.IseethatcontinuousvocationtobealmostlikeagravitationalpulltoeachofustorespondascocreatorsofGod'skingdom.ThemoreconsciousweareofGod'sgraceinourownlives,themoreconsciousandintentionalwemaybeinresponding.Ontheotherhand,whetherornotweareconsciousofthecallinanyrationalway,wemaystillbepulledintoresponseataleveldeeperthanourminds.Thoseofuswiththegiftofarticulationcannamethegoodnews.Butmanyofusproclaimthegoodnewswithoutusingwordsofexplanation.Wemaynotevenunderstand
![Page 236: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/236.jpg)
![Page 237: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/237.jpg)
Page122
whyweareimpelledtoact,andsomewhoareevangelistsmaynotevenknowinwhoseNameweperceivebadnewsandinwhoseNamethegoodnewsflows.WhereitisGod'swill,theactionofwitnessingtothegoodnewselicitstheresponseoftheoneleperwhoreturnedtoJesusfromamongthetenwhowerecleansed.Ialwayshopethat"theten"willreturn,butrememberthatforJesusonewasenough.
Iseeevangelismasprofoundlysituational.Iseeitasprofoundlyindividual.IseeitasbeinggeneratedwithineachofusasGodopensoureyesandsensitivitytothehurtsoftheworldaroundus.Iseethefocusofeachperson'sevangelismasshiftingfromtimetotime,drivenbyinnersensitivities,asenseofGrace,andtheleadingofGod.Iseeourcongregationsastheplaceswhereoursensitivitiesarenourishedandourevangelismfed,primarilybyWordandSacrament,butalsobythecommunityitself(koinonia)andtheteaching(didache).
Thisdesigninvitespeopletoreadtheirownevangelisticlocationwithinamapofevangelisticpossibility.Ithelpsthemreflectuponthatlocationinrelationshiptothelocationofothersinthegroupandtotheoverallpictureofthestrengthsandweaknessestheyperceiveintheircommunity'sopennesstoneed.
TheProcessoftheDesign
Step1:Introducetheactivitywithabriefbitoftheory,generallyadescriptionoftheimportantlinkbetweengoodnewsandbadnews,asdescribedinchapter2.TheexamplesofMartinLutherKing,Jr.andBillyGrahamhelppeopleconnecttheideawiththeirexperience.
Step2:Cautions.Iinvitepeopleintotheexerciseasanexperimentinperception,notingthatitisnotascientificstudy.IparticularlypressthepointthatIamaskingthemtorespondintermsofwheretheyaretoday,atthismoment.Inotethatyesterdayandtomorrowtheymay
![Page 238: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/238.jpg)
wellbeindifferentplaces.Ivisualizeitasastillphotographfromamovingpicture.
Step3:Twoforced-choicequestions.Iinviteno,Ipush,presseveryonetomakeonechoiceforeachoftwocontinua.Iurgealltobesimplistic,toindicatejustwheretheyseethemselvesasbeingatthismoment,ignoringcomplexities.ThenIgivethemthefirst"command":
![Page 239: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/239.jpg)
Page123
Thecontinuumrangesfromnumber1tonumber10.Iwilldescribenumber1andIwilldescribenumber10.IfwhatIdescribeisexactlywhereyouarerightnow,thenwritea1ora10.Probablyyouaresomewherebetween,sojustguess.Ifyou'recloseto1,maybeyouareat2or3;ifyou'recloseto10,maybeyou'reat7or8.Justmakeachoice.Placeyourselfonalinebetweenthesetwostatements:
Number1:TheonlywaytoknowGodisinaone-on-one,directrelationship.That'stheonlywaytoknowGod.
Number10:TheonlywaytoknowGodisinthemidstofGod'speople,thechurch.That'stheonlyway.
Afteraminuteortwo,duringwhichIquellthegrumblingandpushthemtogoonandmakeachoice,Igivethemthesecondcontinuum.Bynowtheyknowtheropes,soyoudon'thavetogiveasmuchexplanation.ThistimeImakethechoiceintermsofthealphabet,andthechoicerangesfromAtoJ.IdescribeAandIdescribeJ,andtheychoosetheirpositioninrelationshiptotheextremes.
LetterA:TheendandpurposeoflifeissotolivethatIamreunitedwithGodatmydeath.
LetterJ:Theendandpurposeoflifeistoparticipatewithbrothersandsistersinbuildingahumansocietyofshalom,wherepeaceandjusticeandlovereign.
Step4:IfIamworkingwithnewsprint,Idrawagraphwiththetwocontinuaastheaxes.(Acopyofthegraphisappended,suitableforcopyingontoanoverheadtransparencyifyoupreferthatmethod.)ThenIcallonmembersofthegrouptocallouttheirowncoordinates.Astheydoso,Imakeamarkattheappropriatespotonthemap.Thefaster,thebetter.(Ifyouhaveaconspicuousreligiousleaderofthisgrouppresent,Iusuallyaskthatpastororbishoporpresidentnottocallouthisorhercoordinates.Thisissothatpeoplewillnotstereotypetheirleader.)
![Page 240: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/240.jpg)
![Page 241: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/241.jpg)
Page124
![Page 242: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/242.jpg)
Page125
Step5:Reflectionandplenarydiscussion.SomeoftheareasinwhichIinvitediscussion:
1.Thevarietyofresponses.Allpointsonthegridarelegitimatepositions,positionsthathavebeenheldbygreatsaints.
2.Reflectonwhere"clumps"ofpeopleshowup.Whatdoesthatmean?
3.Reflectonwherethereisadearthofresponses.Whatdoesthatmean?
4.Whatdoestheoverallpatternsayaboutpossiblestrengthsofthisparticulargroupinministry?Whatthingsaretheymostlikelytobeawareof?Mostlikelytocareabout?
5.Whatdoesthepatternsayabouttheblindspotsofthisgroup?
6.Iinvitepeopletorespondtohowtheirpersonalchoicesfelt.Iparticularlyinvitethosewhosecoordinateswere"farout"fromthecenter,orinaquadrantwithfewornoothers,howitfelttocallouttheirlocations.(Youcansometimeshelpthegroupunderstandtheemotionalpressureweexertononeanothertoconform.)
Step6:Interpretation.Isummarizewhatthegrouphaslearnedintheexercise.Isometimesusemorematerialfromchapter2,thedescriptionsofthequadrants,forexample.IusuallyreferthegrouptothesimilartypologiesdevelopedbyRoozen,McKinney,andCarroll.Mymajorconcernatthispointistohelpthemthinkofthefunctionofthepastorandofthecongregationnottobringthecongregation's"center"towherethepastorwantsitortowherethemajority"clump"ofthecongregationwantsit,butto"holdthecenter,"nourishingandfeedingallthediverseministries.Itrytohelpthemidentify"lacks''intheircongregationorconsciousnessthat,ifadded,mightincreasetheoverallstrengthoftheministry.Thestrongerthecenter,inmy
![Page 243: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/243.jpg)
opinion,thegreatertheextremesthatcanbesupported.
Step7:Wildapplause.
![Page 244: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/244.jpg)
Page127
AppendixBTheStatisticsBehindtheGraphsThegraphsofthemembershipsoftheEpicsopalChurch,thePresbyterianChurch,theUnitedChurchofChrist,theUnitedMethodistChurch,andtheEvangelicalLutheranChurchinAmericawerebasedondatafromTableA1.1oftheAppendixofChurchandDenominationalGrowth,editedbyDavidA.RoozenandC.KirkHadaway(Nashville,Abingdon,1994).ThegraphsplottingtheU.S.populationwerebasedonfiguresreportedonpage361ofTheWorldAlmanacandBookofFacts:1994(Mahwah,NJ:WorldAlmanacBooks,1993).
Thespecificnumbersusedarelistedonthefollowingpage.
![Page 245: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/245.jpg)
Page128
PopulationoftheUnitedStates
1950 151,325,798
1960 179,323,175
1970 203,302,031
1980 226,542,203
1990 248,709,873
MembershipbyDenomination
EpiscopalianPresbyterianUCC UMC ELCA
19502,417,464 3,210,635 1,977,4289,653,178 3,982,508
19603,269,325 4,161,860 2,241,13410,641,3105,295,502
19703,285,826 4,045,408 1,960,60810,509,1985,650,137
19802,786,004 3,362,086 1,736,2449,519,407 5,384,271
19902,446,050 2,847,437 1,599,2128,904,824 5,240,739
DenominationalMembershipAsaPercentageofU.S.Population
EpiscopalianPresbyterianUCC UMC ELCA
1950 1.60% 2.12% 1.31% 6.38% 2.63%
1960 1.82% 2.32% 1.25% 5.93% 2.95%
1970 1.62% 1.99% .96% 5.17% 2.78%
1980 1.23% 1.48% .77% 4.20% 2.38%
![Page 246: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/246.jpg)
1990 .98% 1.14% .64% 3.58% 2.11%
![Page 247: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/247.jpg)
Page129
Notes
Introduction
1.LorenB.Mead,TheOnceandFutureChurch(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1991).
2.LorenB.Mead,MoreThanNumbers(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1993).
3.Loren.Mead,''OperationalTheology"inPatternsinParishDevelopment,ed.CeliaAllisonHahn(NewYork:SeaburyPress,1974),pp.157-58.
Chapter1
1.C.KirkHadaway,WhatCanWeDoAboutChurchDropouts?(Nashville:AbingdonPress,1990),ch.2-3.
2.KennethB.Bedell,ed.,YearbookofAmericanandCanadianChurches(Nashville:AbingdonPress,1993).ThedatafortheillustrationsalsodrawsonthefiguresfrommanysuchannualreportsaspublishedinDavidA.RoozenandC.KirkHadaway,ed.,ChurchandDenominationalGrowth(Nashville:AbingdonPress,1993),appen.,TableA1.1.ThisrawdataisnotedinAppendixB.Intheinterestsofaccuracyitmustbenotedthatinseveralyearssince1990theEpiscopalChurchhasshowedasmallnetgaininnumbers,butnotpercentofpopulation.Thisencouragingstatisticis,however,problematicinthatthedefinitionof"member"wasslightlychanged.
3.Figures1,3,and5chartdenominationscategorizedas"liberalProtestant."Figures2and4arefordenominationscategorizedas"moderateProtestant."Anysuchdesignationsinvolvedifficultjudgment
![Page 248: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/248.jpg)
![Page 249: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/249.jpg)
Page130
calls.ThesecategoriesaredescribedinWilliamMcKinneyandW.ClarkRoof,MainlineAmericanReligion(NewYork:PilgrimPress,1984).ThesamecategoriesareusedinRoozenandHadaway,ChurchandDenominationalGrowth.
4.FellowNorthCaroliniansmayrememberaclassicstoryabouthowthingshavechangedinchurcheswhenitcomestopointingfingersinblame.BunnyBoydwasanimmenselypopularprofessorofreligionattheUniversityofNorthCarolinainthefortiesandfifties,whentheRevisedStandardVersionwasfirstreleased.InbackwoodsCarolinathenewfangledlanguageforthefamiliarstorieswasashock,tosaytheleast.OneconservativepastorstagedabookburningatRockyMount.ThishittheheadlinesinnewspapersacrossthestateandcausedanuproarinProfessorBoyd'snineo'clockclass."WhataboutwhathappenedinRockyMount?"theyasked.
"Whathappened?"heresponded,nothavingcheckedthemorning'sNewsandDisturber.
Theytoldhimaboutthebookburningandhereplied,"Wonderful!"
Whenaskedtodefendhisstatement,hesaid,"Bookburningismuchbetter.Weusedtoburnthepeoplewhotranslatedit!"
5.DeanR.HogeandDavidA.Roozen,ed.,UnderstandingChurchGrowthandDecline(NewYork:PilgrimPress,1979).Seeespeciallych.14,"SomeSociologicalConclusionsaboutChurchTrends,"315-33.SeealsoAndrewGreeley,ReligiousChangeinAmerica(Cambridge,Mass.:HarvardUniversityPress,1989).
6.DeanR.Hoge,BentonJohnson,andDonaldLuidens,VanishingBoundariesTheReligionofMainlineBabyBoomers(Louisville:Westminster/JohnKnox,1994).Findingsaresummarizedinanumberofpapersandarticles,including"WhatHappenedtotheYouthWhoGrewUpinOurChurches,"Congregations,no.5(September-
![Page 250: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/250.jpg)
October1992).
7.Infairnesstotheauthors,Ineedtosaythatthisisnottheirmainpoint.Theyaredoinganimpressivestudyofwhathashappenedtobabyboomersinonedenomination.Eventhisminorpointoftheirsisanextremelyimportantnewissuefordenominationalleaderstotakeintoaccount.Howmuchmoreimpressiveistherestofthebook.
8.SeeRoozenandHadaway,ChurchandDenominationalGrowth.
9.DatainthesetwographsarederivedfromdatanotedinAppendixB.TheideaofthegraphsisderviedfromVanishingBoundaries.
![Page 251: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/251.jpg)
Page131
Twothingsshowdramaticallyhere:theperiodofanomalousgrowthbetweenabout1945and1965andthesteeperdownwardslopeofrecentchurchmembership.
10.HereHoge,Johnson,andLuidens,VanishingBoundaries,makesitsmajorcontributions.SeealsoMcKinneyandRoof,MainlineAmericanReligion.
11.ItellmydenominationalfriendsthatourbudgetreductionsremindmeofaCarolinafriendwhohadamarveloushuntingdogthathetookhuntingeverySaturday.Troublewas,thedog'stailwaslongandshaggy,anditwouldpickupcockleburs.ByMondayhewouldhavechewedthemallout,buthealsohadamassofpainfulsores.Yetthedoglovedtohunt....Sotheownersaid,"TheonlythingIcanthinktodoistomakehimabob-taileddog."Hecontinued,"ButIreallydon'twanttohurthim.SoIthinkI'lljustcutoffaninchoftailatatime!"Irestmycase.
12.ChurchMembershipStatistics:1970-1980(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1983).
13.GayJennings,unpublishedreport,EpiscopalDioceseofOhio,2230EuclidAve.,Cleveland,OH44115.SomesimilarpointsaremadeinDeanHoge,JacksonW.Carroll,andFrancisK.Scheets,PatternsofParishLeadership(KansasCity,Mo.:SheedandWard,1988).Thisbookexaminesthecostofprovidingprofessionalleadershipincongregationsoffourdenominations:Episcopal,RomanCatholic,EvangelicalLutheranChurchinAmerica,andUnitedMethodist.Theresearchwascarriedouton1984budgets,soitdealtwithoneoftheLutheranbodiesthatlaterformedtheEvangelicalLutheranChurchinAmerica.
14.Hoge,Johnson,andLuidens,"WhatHappenedtotheYouthWhoGrewUpinOurChurches,"Congregations.
![Page 252: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/252.jpg)
Chapter2
1.LorenB.Mead,TheOnceandFutureChurch(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1991),20-22.
2.ItisinterestingtonotethatsomeofJesus'waysofproclaimingthegospelarenolongeropentousbecauseotherofhisfollowersbeatustoit.Jesushealedmanylepersinhisday,andthosewhofollowhimhavecomeclosetoeliminatingleprosyaroundtheworld.
![Page 253: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/253.jpg)
Page132
3.ThetruthisprobablymuchmorecomplexthanIhavestatedhere.SeeDavidRoozen,WilliamMcKinney,andJacksonCarroll,VarietiesofReligiousPresence(NewYork:PilgrimPress,1984),aprovocativebookbasedonimportantstudiesofchurchesintheHartford,Connecticutarea.Itdescribesfourtypesofcongregationsintermsofhoweachunderstandsitsrelationshiptoitsenvironment.TheirfourcategoriesofgroupidentitiesarequiteclosetothequadrantsIhavenotedhereforindividualrelationshiptotheworld:quadrantAbeinganalogoustotheir"sanctuarychurch";quadrantBcorrespondingto"evangelisticchurch";quadrantCto''civicchurch";andquadrantDto"activistchurch.''CarlDudley'sresearchintheMidwestsuggestsanevenmorecomplexsetofcategoriesthanthese.Onewondersaboutthepossibilitythatcongregationsmay,intheirowncultures,preserveimportantanddifferentsensitivitiestogoodnews.Thismaybeanunexploredfrontierforthinkersaboutecumenism.
Chapter3
1.Ioncesawthispropheticmessageactedout.IwasinWashingtonatthetimeofHelenKeller'sdeath,andIattendedherfuneralattheNationalCathedral.Theblind,thedeaf,andthelamewerethere,celebratingherlife.Achoirfromaschoolfortheblindsanglikeangels.Sen.ListerHillofAlabamareadthelessonwithapowerfulvoicetrainedinsouthernoratory.ForthefirsttimeinmylifeIwatchedasthelessonwassigned.Ashespokeofthedeafhearing,theblindseeing,thelameleapingforjoy,wesawthegoodnewsactedoutevenaswealsoexperiencedGod'spowerinthelifeofHelenKeller.
2.ParkerPalmer,GoingPublic(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1980).Thismonographisoutofprintbutavailableasanon-demandpublicationfromTheAlbanInstitute,4550MontgomeryAve.,Suite433N.,Bethesda,MD20814-3341.
![Page 254: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/254.jpg)
3.RobertBellah,etal.,HabitsoftheHeart(Berkeley:UniversityofCaliforniaPress,1985).
4.In1972TildenEdwards,ParkerPalmer,JamesSimmons,andItalkedtoagroupoftwentylaypeopleabouttheirexperiencesofspiritualgrowth.Thepaperwewrote,SpiritualGrowth,isoutofprint(ProjectTestPattern,1973).JeanHaldanemadesimilardiscoveries,reportedin
![Page 255: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/255.jpg)
Page133
ReligiousPilgrimage(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1975).InmorerecenttimesGalluppollshavefoundamongintervieweesahighnumberofpersonalexperienceswithGod.
5.KeithRussellarguesthatKoinoniawastheprimarythingtheearlychurchhadtooffersociety.Peopleweredrawntothechurchbecauseitslivingcommunityspoketothebadnewsoftheirsociety.SeeInSearchoftheChurch(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1994).
6.AsanEpiscopalianmyself,Iamwellawarethatmanyofmynon-Episcopalfriendsunderstand"Episcopalpreacher"tobeanoxymoron!
7.FormoredetailsseeLorenB.Mead,MoreThanNumbers(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1993),ch.3.
8.Forafullerexplorationofthetheories,seeBruceReed,TheDynamicsofFaith(London:Darton,Longman,andTodd,1978).Forashorterversion,seeBruceReedandBarryPalmer,TheTaskoftheChurchandtheRoleofItsMembers(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1975).Reed'sworkingrouprelationsandthedynamicsoforganizationshasbeencriticallyimportanttomanyinthiscountry.Iamparticularlyindebtedtohim.
9.IhaveneverfullyunderstoodthefascinationcertaindenominationshaveexhibitedintheuseoftheNewTestamentroleofthedeaconasaspecialagentandrepresentativeofthechurchintheworld(whatIhavecharacterizedastheapostolate).Myownunderstandingisthatthebaptizedpersonoperatingasanapostleisthechurch'srepresentativetotheworld.
10.TheplacementsInoteherearethesortthatonegetswhenusingthedesignintheappendix.
11.DavidRoozen,WilliamMcKinney,andJacksonCarroll,Varieties
![Page 256: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/256.jpg)
ofReligiousPresence(NewYork:PilgrimPress,1984),suggeststhatcongregations"holdthecenter"asIhavedescribedinthisgrid.Thatbookalsosuggests,helpfully,thatindividualcongregationsmayhavedifferent"centers."Acongregationmayhaveacentralunderstandingofitsmessagethatcouldmakethecommunityitselffocusinoneofthequadrants.Ifso,thecongregation'staskwouldbetoholdthatcenterandprovideadependablereferencepointtowhichmemberscouldreturnforrenewaloftheirspecialcalling.
![Page 257: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/257.jpg)
Page135
annuallyforthreedozenorsopeople.Informationisavailableat1-800-486-1318.
6.GhostRanchinNewMexicoismorefamiliarlyknowntonorthernPresbyteriansas"heaven."SouthernPresbyteriansreservethattermforMontreat,NorthCarolina.
7.MystaffcolleagueSpeedLeasisoneofthepioneersamongchurchleadersindevelopingwaystoworkwithandthroughconflicts.Hiswriting,teaching,andwisecounselhavehelpeddozensofconflictsturntogrowthforthepeopleinvolved.ThepotentialforescalationalwayshitsmehumorouslywhenIreadtheprayerfoundinmanyeveningliturgies.Howmanychurcheshaveprayedthisprayer?"OGod,makeSpeedtosaveus!"
8.SeeEdwinFriedman,GenerationtoGeneration:FamilyProcessinChurchandSynagogue(NewYork:GuilfordPress,1985),aprimeresourceforjudicatoryexecutivesandbishops.
9.SeeRoyOswald,ClergySelfCare(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1991),andanyotherbooksbyOswald.
10.Twoprograms,bothinitiallybegunbytheLillyEndowment,Inc.,trytoaddresssomeofthis.OperatingoutofTrinityEpiscopalChurch,3242N.MeridianSt.,Indianapolis,IN46208,anationwideeffort(TrusteeLeadershipProgram)ishelpingtodevelopcongregationalboardsusingmodelsfromnonprofitorganizationsandeducationalinstitutions.ChuckOlsen,aPresbyterianpastor,isalsocompletingtheSetApartLayLeaderprojecttodiscovermodelsandmethodstohelpchurch-boardleadership.Contact:Dr.CharlesOlsen,15003NWSeventy-secondSt.,KansasCity,MO64512.
Chapter5
1.SeeLorenB.Mead,NewHopeforCongregations(NewYork:
![Page 258: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/258.jpg)
SeaburyPress,1972).Thiswasmyfirstattemptat"learningfromourexperience"inworkingwithcongregations.Atthattimemostreligiousstudieswereofideas,butsomeremarkablesociologistsweretryingtounderstandempiricaldimensionsofreligiousorganizations.Thestoryoftheshiftofenergyinreligiousstudiesfromdeductivetoinductivehasonlybegunandhasnotyetbeentold.
2.Ihavemoretosayaboutasystemsapproach,butthatwillhavetowaitformynextbook.
![Page 259: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/259.jpg)
Page136
3.Fordetailsofthisshiftofconsciousness,seeLorenB.Mead,TheOnceandFutureChurch(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1991).
4.IfIhadmywish,nostudentwouldgraduatefromseminarywithouthavingmadethreeorfourplanned-givingvisitstoaprospectiveseminarydonor.
5.IspeakaboutmyworkwiththefoundersoftheConsortiumofEndowedEpiscopalChurchesandthePresbyterianNetworkofEndowedCongregations.Eachofthesegroupsmeetsannuallytosharediscoveriesabouthowtoministereffectivelyascongregationswithsizableendowments.AttemptstodevelopsimilarnetworksinUnitarian-Universalist,UnitedMethodist,andUnitedChurchofChristdenominationsdidnotresultincontinuingdialogue.MyworkwithallexcepttheEpiscopalgroupwassupportedbygrantsfromtheLillyEndowment.SeeLorenB.Mead,EndowedCongregations:ProsandCons(Washington,DC:TheAlbanInstitute,1990).
6.InbuildingTheAlbanInstitute,Inc.,wehavebeenconsciousthatwewereworkingonthisfrontier.Thecharacteristicsofthatinstitute--itsfocusonbuildingaccountabilityinrelationships,searchingforanalternatewaytofundthedeliveryofskilledserviceswithinthereligiousworld,theefforttodevelopanetworkofskilledpeoplewholiveoffthesaleoftheirskills,anditsmonomaniacalfocusonthelifeofthecongregation--representourreadingofsomeofthecharacteristicsneededinotherinstitutionsweneedtobebuildingforthefutureofthechurches.
7.VernaDozier'spersonalinfluence,preaching,andteachingliebehindmythinking.
8.ThomasHarris,I'mO.K.--You'reO.K.(NewYork:Harper&Row,1969).AlthoughIwilldealherewiththeunhealthysideofwhat
![Page 260: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/260.jpg)
Harrisdescribes,notethathisbookalsodealswiththepositivememoriesthatchildhoodandparentingcanbring.
9.OneverypracticalapplicationofthisknowledgehasbeenworkedoutbymycolleagueSpeedLeas,aconflict-managementconsultant.Inaconflictsituation,themostparentalandchildishresponsesarefrequentlyincommand.Speedfindsthatoneofthemosthelpfulinterventionsisto"triggertheadult."Hegivesassignmentsthatforcethecombatantstogetoutofchildishorparentalbehavior:"Letustrytoagreeonasetofrulesforhowtocarryoutthisconflict."Or,''Hereare
![Page 261: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/261.jpg)
Page138
ofteachingmorethanfromsystematicwriting.Igotmostofmyknowledgeofthesetheoriesfromthosetowhomhehadtaughttheminseminarsandsmallgroupinteractions.Someofhisbasicthinkingisfoundinthefollowingbooks:ADynamicTheoryofPersonality(NewYorkandLondon:McGrawHill,1935)andResolvingSocialConflicts(NewYork:Harper,1948).
16.SeeMead,TheOnceandFutureChurch,ch.5.ThereIdealtwithsomeofthesedynamicsintermsof"learningpoints"and"accountability."Ithinktheoldjokeabouttheguyslammingthemulewithatwo-by-four''justtogethisattention"ismakingthesamepoint.Ifyouattempttochangesomethingwithoutgettingtheirattention,forgetit.Youarewastingtime.
17.ElisabethKubler-Ross,OnDeathandDying(NewYork:Macmillan,1969).
18.StephenL.Fink,JoelBeak,andKennethTaddeo,"OrganizationalCrisisandChange,"JournalofAppliedBehavioralSciences7,no.1:15-37.Wefirstbecameawareofthistheoryin1975-76when,withagroupofcolleagues,RoyOswaldinitiatedstudiesabouthowinstitutionsandcongregationscoulddealconstructivelywiththefinancialcrisesanddownsizingthatwasprevalentinthoserecessionaryyears.Thetheorieshavebecomeevenmoreimportantasithasbecomeclearthatdownsizingofreligiousinstitutionalstructuresisnotamatterofimmediatecrisisbutofalong-rangechangethathasmadecrisisanintrinsicelementofthereligiousworld.
19.AnextremelyvaluableadditiontoourknowledgehascomefromtheresearchofDavidM.Noer,HealingtheWounds:OvercomingtheTraumaofLayoffsandRevitalizingDownsizedOrganizations(SanFrancisco:Jossey-Bass,1993).Noer'sworkexploreshowfiringseffectthesurvivorsandmakesagoodcaseforthecriticalimportanceofattentiontothisneglectedareaoforganizationaldevelopment.
![Page 262: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/262.jpg)
Noersuggestsafour-levelmodelofinterventiontohelpreorganizationsurvivorsovercometheirwoundsandbuildconstructivenewworklives.Anyoneinajudicatoryornationalchurchofficeshouldhaveaccesstothishelpfulbook.
![Page 263: Transforming Congregations for the Future (Once and Future Church Series)](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071519/613c5f5ef237e1331c513010/html5/thumbnails/263.jpg)
Page139
Appendix
1.DavidRoozen,WilliamMcKinney,andJacksonCarroll,VarietiesofReligiousPresence(NewYork:PilgrimPress,1984).Seeespeciallythegraphonpage87.Ifyouusethisgraph,pointoutthatitissomewhatreversedfromtheoneIhavesuggested.Alsopointoutthattheirgridisgraphingcongregations,whiletheoneIpresentisgraphingpeople.