Righthaven Copyright Infringement Complaint against Jerry Ryburg, et al.
Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
Transcript of Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
1/16
EXHIBIT 1
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 1 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
2/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
!
:-0;
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
3/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
"
.55
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
4/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
#
@.1 /
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
5/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
!"
K]EUEdS DQMK]IQZ DLOVK _]DK TUB TDQZDQO eVSK SDIG K]DK
SVZZESKS KO K]E 4OVUK K]DK 0 QEEG KO ]EDU RUOJ
+EJONUDKIN :QGEUZUOVQGB
T3B ,51.?@X ;]DQb MOV2 ^OVU ?OQOUB
;?< 4,:3;X @EK JE JDbE IK NHEDU K]DK K]E
4OVUK IS DHSO QOK ]EUE KO RIQG RDVHK _IK] TUB 4OOQS OU
TUB 4]VB
0 GO RIQG IK SIZQIRINDQK2 ]O_EFEU2 K]DK IQ DHH OR
K]IS 77 DQG 0 77 0dFE UEDG DQG UEUEDG K]IS SEQKEQNE RUOJ
K]E SKDKEJEQK IQ K]E UESPOQSE2 DQG 0 gVOKE RUOJ K]E
SENOQG PDZEX 0K IS NEUKDIQHM VQGEUSKDQGDLHE ]O_ @ONDH
3VHE '7!B! NOVHG ]DFE DUZVDLHM LEEQ UEDSOQDLHM NOQSKUVEG
KO QOK UEgVIUE K]E GISNHOSVUE OR 1KEP]EQS TEGIDdS
IQKEUESK IQ DQM UENOFEUMB
0 _DS IJPUESSEG K]DK MOV _EUE DLHE KO ZEK K]UEE
]EGZE _OUGS OU gVDHIRIEUS _IK]IQ K]E SPDNE OR ROVU _OUGS
IQ K]DK SEQKEQNE DQG _OQGEUEG IR JDMLE MOV UDQ OVK OR
K]EJB
;]DK SIZQIRINDQK2 0 ZVESS2 KO JE IS IS K]DK _E
GOQdK ]DFE DQM DRRIGDFIK RUOJ TUB 4]V OU TUB 4OOQSX
,QE2 K]DK K]EM JDGE D JISKDbEW K_O2 K]DK K]EM GIGQdK
VQGEUSKDQG IKW K]UEE2 K]DK K]EM GIGQdK VQGEUSKDQG @ONDH
3VHE 'B!7!B >VK2 JOUE IJPOUKDQKHM2 0 GOQdK ]DFE DQM
EFIGEQNE K]DK K]EM EFEQ bQE_ DLOVK K]E UEHDKIOQS]IPW
K]DK K]EM _EUE RDJIHIDU _IK] K]E KEUJS DQG NIUNVJSKDQNES
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 5 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
6/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
!#
OR K]E SKUDKEZIN DZUEEJEQKB
.Q DUZVJEQK K]DK K]EM DUZVDLHM NOVHG ]DFE
UEDSOQDLHM NOQSKUVEG KO QOK UEgVIUE K]DK2 IQ K]E 4OVUKdS
OPIQIOQ2 IS2 RUDQbHM2 HVGINUOVSB
3VHE 'B!7!2 K]E PVUPOSE OR IK2 K]E PUIJDUM
PVUPOSE OR IK2 IS KO JDbE SVUE K]DK K]E 4OVUK LENOJES
D_DUE2 DS SOOQ DS POSSILHE2 OR DQM QEEG KO UENVSE IKSEHR
LENDVSE OR DQM NOQRHINK OR IQKEUESKB >VK IKdS K]E
FIOHDKIOQ OR K]E UVHE2 IQ DGGIKIOQ KO DHH OR K]E OK]EU
K]IQZS K]DK KOOb PHDNE IQ K]IS NDSE DQG DQM OK]EU NDSES
K]DK K]E 4OVUK ]DS IQ RUOQK OR IK 77 DQG 0 K]IQb K]EUE
DUE 77 0 K]IQb K]EUE DUE OU _EUE #$ NDSES K]DK _EUE
DSSIZQEG KO JE LM 3IZ]K]DFEQ IQ K]IS NDSEB 0 GO QOK
VQGEUSKDQG K]E DUZVJEQK K]DK DQ DZUEEJEQK _]EUELM
1KEP]EQS TEGID ZOK ]DHR OR DQM UENOFEUM OU SEKKHEJEQK
NOVHG DQM 77 IQ DQM _DM LE NOQSKUVEG DS QOK ]DFIQZ D
GIUENK PENVQIDUM IQKEUESKB
.QG2 DZDIQ2 0dJ QOK ]EUE KO SDQNKIOQ TUB 4OOQS OU
TUB 4]VB .QG 0 _IHH KEHH MOV QO_ K]DK 0 GO QOK K]IQb
K]DK K]E 4OVUKdS SDQNKIOQ PO_EU IS HIJIKEG KO SDQNKIOQ
TUB 4]V OU TUB 4OOQSB ;]E 4OVUK GOES ]DFE K]E UIZ]K KO
SDQNKIOQ DQ DKKOUQEM _]EQ ]E FIOHDKES IKB
0 GOQdK ]DFE DQM EFIGEQNE K]DK K]EM IQKEQKIOQDHHM
bEPK K]IS RUOJ K]E 4OVUKB >VK 0 ]DFE D HOK OR EFIGEQNE
K]DK 3IZ]K]DFEQ IQKEQKIOQDHHM bEPK IKB ;]IS IS QOK DQ
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 6 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
7/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
!$
ISSVE OR QEZHIZEQNE2 IQ K]E 4OVUKdS FIE_B 0K ZOES KO
K]E EFIGEQNE OR DQ IQKEQKIOQDH DFOIGDQNE OR GISNHOSIQZ
IQROUJDKIOQ DQG SPENIRIN GIUENK SKDKEJEQKS NOQKUDUM KO
K]DKB
0 K]IQb 0 ]DFE SVRRINIEQK IQ]EUEQK PO_EU KO
SDQNKIOQB .QG 0 K]IQb 3VHE !! ZIFES JE EFEQ DGGIKIOQDH
PO_EU KO SDQNKIOQ ROU FIOHDKIOQ OR K]IS UVHE VQGEU K]ESE
NIUNVJSKDQNESB
4OVQSEH K]DK _DS UEPUESEQKIQZ 3IZ]K]DFEQ2
TUB 4OOQS DQG TUB 4]V2 _EUE LOK] IQ7]OVSE NOVQSEH2 IR
MOV _IHHB
TUB AILSOQ2 _]O KOOb OFEU DQG 0 K]IQb _DS NOVQSEH
DK K]E KIJE K]DK K]E 1.. _DS GISNHOSEG IS K]E 4
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
8/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
!%
K]E DZUEEJEQKB ?E SIZQEG K]E DZUEEJEQKB ?E NEUKDIQHM
bQE_ K]E DZUEEJEQK DQG IKS NOQKEQKSB ?E ]DS D
SIZQIRINDQK DJOVQK OR EcPEUIEQNEB .K HEDSK K]DK IS
UEPUESEQKEG KO JEB 0 K]IQb K]IS ]DS LEEQ PDUK OR D
NOQNEUKEG ERROUK KO ]IGE 1KEP]EQS TEGIDdS UOHE IQ K]IS
HIKIZDKIOQB
5HDIQKIRR NHDIJEG K]DK IK ]DG FDUIOVS EcNHVSIFE
UIZ]KS _]EQ IK bQE_ K]DK K]E DLIHIKM KO EcEUNISE K]OSE
UIZ]KS _EUE UEKDIQEG EcNHVSIFEHM LM 1KEP]EQS TEGIDB 0K
NOQSKDQKHM DQG NOQSISKEQKHM UERVSEG KO PUOGVNE K]E
DZUEEJEQKB .QG IK _DSQdK VQKIH DRKEU K]E 4OVUK OUGEUEG
K]DK IK LE GISNHOSEG DQG K]EQ VQSEDHEG K]DK K]EM SKDUKEG
DGJIKKIQZ K]EIU UEDSOQSB
;]EUE _DS2 IQ RDNK2 IQ K]E 77 IQ 1KEP]EQS TEGIDdS
UEPHM KO K]EIU JOKIOQ 77 IQ SVPPOUK OR K]EIU JOKIOQ KO
GISJISS2 K]DK K]EM SKDKE2 DQG 0 gVOKE2 h1KEP]EQS TEGID
]DS QEFEU LEEQ IGEQKIRIEG OU GISNHOSEG DS D PDUKM _]O
]DS D GIUENK PENVQIDUM IQKEUESK IQ K]E OVKNOJE OR DQM
3IZ]K]DFEQ NDSE2 DQG ROU ZOOG UEDSOQ2h NHOSE gVOKEB
;]E UEPUESEQKDKIOQS DLOVK K]E UEHDKIOQS]IP DQG
K]E UIZ]KS OR 3IZ]K]DFEQ _EUE JISUEPUESEQKDKIOQSB ;]EM
_EUE JISHEDGIQZB .QG K]DK 77 K]E RDIHVUE KO GISNHOSE
K]EJ 77 DQG MOV NDQ SPEDb DQG DUZVE K]DK K]EUEdS QO NDSE
HD_ OU K]EUE DUE QO 77 K]EUEdS QO GERIQIKIOQ IQ K]E UVHE
K]DK HDMS OVK _]DK D GIUENK PENVQIDUM IQKEUESK ISB 0
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 8 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
9/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
!&
GOQdK bQO_ ]O_ JOUE GIUENK MOV NDQ ZEKB ;]E RDNK K]DK
IK ]DS KO ZO KO 3IZ]K]DFEQ RIUSK DQG K]EQ ZO KO 1KEP]EQS
TEGID2 IQ K]E 4OVUKdS FIE_2 GOES QOK UEJOFE IK RUOJ
LEIQZ D GIUENK PENVQIDUM IQKEUESKB 0K _DS K]EUEB ;]EM
]DG K]E UIZ]K KO ]DFE 77 K]EM ]DG K]E UIZ]K2 DNKVDHHM2
KO SEKKHE NHDIJS OQ K]EIU O_QB
.QG K]E 4OVUK RIQGS IK KUOVLHIQZ2 gVIKE RUDQbHM2
IQ DHH OR K]E NDSES K]DK 0dJ D_DUE OR RIHEG IQ K]IS
GISKUINK2 DQG 0dFE HOSK NOVQK DS KO ]O_ JDQM K]EUE _EUE2
K]DK QOK OQHM _EUE K]E KEUJS OR K]E DZUEEJEQK GISNHOSEG2
LVK K]DK K]EUE _DS D NOQSISKEQK2 UEPEDKEG RDIHVUE KO
IGEQKIRM 1KEP]EQS TEGID DS ]DFIQZ DQM IQKEUESK IQ K]IS
HD_SVIKB
.QG IK ISQdK EQOVZ] KO SDM2 _EHH2 K]E 4OVUK
S]OVHG ]DFE LEEQ OQ QOKINE OR IKB ;]E 4OVUK ]DS K]E
UIZ]K KO DNNEPK K]E UEPUESEQKDKIOQS JDGE LM D PDUKM
K]UOVZ] NOVQSEHB .QG _]EQ IK RIQGS K]DK K]OSE
UEPUESEQKDKIOQS DUE QOK KUVE DQG2 ]DFIQZ HOObEG DK DHH
K]IS EFIGEQNE2 RIQGS K]DK K]EM DUE IQKEQKIOQDHHM VQKUVE2
K]E 4OVUK REEHS K]DK K]EUE IS D QENESSIKM OR DQG RIQGS
K]DK K]EUE IS DQ OLHIZDKIOQ OQ K]E 4OVUK KO SDQNKIOQ
1KEP]EQS TEGIDB
0dFE ZIFEQ D HOK OR K]OVZ]K DS KO _]DK bIQG OR
SDQNKIOQ IS UEgVIUEGB 0 DPPUENIDKE K]E RDNK K]DK
NOVQSEH ]DS DKKEJPKEG KO UENKIRM K]E PUOLHEJ K]DK ]DS
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 9 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
10/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
!'
EcISKEGB 0K GOES QOK N]DQZE OU DRRENK K]E 4OVUKdS
OPIQIOQ DS KO _]EK]EU OU QOK IK _DS DQ DNNIGEQK OU D
JISVQGEUSKDQGIQZ DS OPPOSEG KO LEIQZ DQ IQKEQKIOQDH 77
0dHH NDHH IK RDIHVUE KO GISNHOSE2 ROU _DQK OR D SKUOQZEU
KEUJ2 DHK]OVZ] 0 K]IQb D SKUOQZEU KEUJ IS eVSKIRIEGB
>VK DS PDUK OR K]E SDQNKIOQ2 K]E 4OVUK IS ZOIQZ KO OUGEU
K]DK EFEUM NDSE 3IZ]K]DFEQ ]DS IQ DQM eVUISGINKIOQ IQ
K]IS NOVQKUM JVSK LE PUOFIGEG _IK] D NOPM OR K]IS
4OVUKdS GENISIOQ DLOVK K]E DZUEEJEQK2 K]E OQE OQ
SKDQGIQZ2 DQG K]DK K]E DZUEEJEQK LE GISNHOSEG KO PDUKIES
K]DK 3IZ]K]DFEQ ]DS SVEGB
;]E 4OVUK IS DHSO ZOIQZ KO OUGEU D JOQEKDUM
SDQNKIOQ DZDIQSK 3IZ]K]DFEQ2 IKSEHR2 IQ K]E DJOVQK OR
i%2*** DQG OUGEU K]DK @ONDH 3VHE 'B!7! _IHH LE PUOPEUHM
NOJPHIEG _IK]2 EIK]EU UEKUOSPENKIFEHM OU PUOSPENKIFEHM2
IQ DHH NDSES K]DK DUE RIHEG LM 3IZ]K]DFEQ _IK] UESPENK
KO K]IS DZUEEJEQKB
0S K]EUE DQMK]IQZ 77 MES2 NOVQSEHf
0QNIGEQKDHHM2 K]DK JOQEKDUM SDQNKIOQ _IHH LE PDIG
_IK]IQ K_O _EEbS KO K]E NHEUb OR NOVUKB
T3B T.-A.-,X ^OVU ?OQOU2 eVSK D NOVPHE POIQKS
OR NHDUIRINDKIOQB .QG 0 VQGEUSKDQG K]DK MOV _IHH LE
ISSVIQZ D _UIKKEQ OPIQIOQ LDSEG VPOQ _]DK _E 77 LDSEG
VPOQ K]IS ]EDUIQZ2 0 DSSVJEf
;?< 4,:3;X 0dJ QOK SVUE 0 _IHH2 NOVQSEHB
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 10 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
11/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
!(
0dHH ZIFE K]DK SOJE NOQSIGEUDKIOQB
T3B T.-A.-,X ,bDMB YEHH2 IQ FIE_ OR K]DK
VQNEUKDIQKM2 0dG eVSK 77
;?< 4,:3;X 0R 0 GO ISSVE D _UIKKEQ OPIQIOQ2
NOVQSEH2 0dJ DHSO ZOIQZ KO GIUENK K]DK IK LE PUOFIGEG2
RIHEG IQ EFEUM OK]EU NDSE K]DK 3IZ]K]DFEQ ]DS DZDIQSK
DQMLOGM OQ K]IS 77
T3B T.-A.-,X ,bDMB
;?< 4,:3;X .HOQZ K]ESE ISSVESB
T3B T.-A.-,X ,bDMB ^OVU ?OQOU2 eVSK ROU
POIQK OR NHDUIRINDKIOQ2 MOVdFE JEQKIOQEG D NOVPHE LDSES
ROU MOVU SDQNKIOQ PO_EUW DQG IKdS QOK KO N]DHHEQZE MOVU
SDQNKIOQ PO_EUS2 LVK KO NHDUIRM K]E UENOUGB
^OVdFE JEQKIOQEG 3VHE !!2 MOVdFE JEQKIOQEG K]E
IQ]EUEQK PO_EU2 DQG MOVdFE JEQKIOQEG K]E HONDH UVHEB
;]ESE SDQNKIOQS K]DK MOV eVSK EQVJEUDKEG2 GO K]OSE RDHH
VQGEU2 OQE2 DHH OU 77 OQE SPENIRIN SDQNKIOQ PO_EU OU
VQGEU DHH MOVU IQ]EUEQK PO_EU 77
;?< 4,:3;X 0dJ IQFObIQZ DHH OR K]EJ2 NOVQSEHB
T3B T.-A.-,X ,bDMB ;]DQb MOV2 ^OVU ?OQOUB
.QG D SENOQG POIQK OR NHDUIRINDKIOQ IS K]DK MOV
SDIG K]DK PDUKIES 77 DHH PDUKIES _]O DUE SVEG KO LE
PUOFIGEG _IK] D NOPM OR K]E DZUEEJEQK2 K]E SKUDKEZIN
DHHIDQNE DZUEEJEQKB
;?< 4,:3;X ;]DK _IHH QOK DPPHM KO K]OSE NDSES
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 11 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
12/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
!)
K]DK ]DFE LEEQ GISJISSEG2 VQHESS K]EUEdS ZOIQZ KO LE DQ
DPPEDH IQ K]OSE NDSESB
T3B T.-A.-,X ,bDMB 1O DHH 77 ESSEQKIDHHM DHH
PEQGIQZ JDKKEUS2 _OVHG K]DK LE 77
;?< 4,:3;X ^ESB
T3B T.-A.-,X ,bDMB .QG _OVHG MOVU OUGEU
IQNHVGE 77 SIQNE DS K]E 4OVUK2 0dJ SVUE2 IS D_DUE2 _E
]DFE D NHDUIRINDKIOQ DQG _E ]DFE _]DKdS QO_ D UESKDKEG
FEUSIOQ OR K]E 1..2 UESKDKEG DQG DJEQGEG FEUSIOQ2 _OVHG
MOV HIbE K]OSE PUOFIGEG DS _EHHf
;?< 4,:3;X -OB
T3B T.-A.-,X CVSK K]E 1..f
;?< 4,:3;X .QG QO 77 DQM UEFISIOQS2
DJEQGJEQKS DRKEU K]E RDNK2 IQ K]E 4OVUKdS FIE_2 IS
IUUEHEFDQK KO K]IS ISSVEB
T3B T.-A.-,X ,bDMB ;]DQb MOV2 ^OVU ?OQOUB
;?< 4,:3;X ;]DQb MOVB
.QM gVESKIOQS RUOJ OK]EU GEREQGDQKf
T3B ,51.?@X 0K JDM DHSO LE VSERVH ROU SOJE OR
K]OSE NDSES KO ]DFE D NOPM OR 3IZ]K]DFEQdS OPEUDKIQZ
DZUEEJEQKB
;?< 4,:3;X 0 LEZ MOVU PDUGOQf
T3B ,51.?@X 0K JDM DHSO LE VSERVH KO 77 ROU
K]E GEREQGDQKS IQ K]OSE NDSES KO ]DFE D NOPM OR
3IZ]K]DFEQdS OPEUDKIQZ DZUEEJEQK DHOQZ _IK] K]E
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 12 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
13/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
"*
SKUDKEZIN DHHIDQNEB
;?< 4,:3;X 0 K]IQb K]DK _DS PDUK OR JM OUGEU2
NOVQSEH2 IS K]DK K]E OPEUDKIQZ 77 _EHH2 DUE MOV KDHbIQZ
DLOVK K]E SKUDKEZIN DHHIDQNE DZUEEJEQKf
T3B ,51.?@X ;]EUEdS D SKUDKEZIN DHHIDQNE
DZUEEJEQK DS LEK_EEQ 1KEP]EQS TEGID DQG 3IZ]K]DFEQW K]EQ
K]EUEdS DHSO K]E 3IZ]K]DFEQ OPEUDKIQZ DZUEEJEQK2 _]IN]
IS K]E OUZDQIjDKIOQDH GONVJEQK ROU 3IZ]K]DFEQB
T3B T.-A.-,X ^OVU ?OQOU2 K]DKdS 77 K]E ISSVE
]EUE IS K]E RDIHVUE KO GISNHOSE 1KEP]EQS TEGID2 _]IN] IS
D PDUKM KO K]E 77
;?< 4,:3;X ^ESB 0 _IHH QOK IQNHVGE K]DK2
NOVQSEHB 0 GOQdK K]IQb IKdS UEHEFDQK KO K]ISB
T3B ,51.?@X ,bDMB ;]DQb MOV2 ^OVU ?OQOUB
T3B T.-A.-,X .QG2 ^OVU ?OQOU2 K]EUE DUE NDSES
PEQGIQZ2 SVN] DS IQ K]E +ISKUINK OR 4OHOUDGO2 _]IN]
IQFOHFE 77 GO QOK IQFOHFE 1KEP]EQS TEGID2 LVK K]EM
IQFOHFE TEGID-E_S AUOVP DS K]E ]OHGEU OR K]E _OUb K]DKdS
LEEQ DSSIZQEGB
YOVHG MOVU OUGEU UEgVIUE D PUOGVNKIOQ OR K]E 1..
OU K]E PUOGVNKIOQ OR K]E OPEUDKIFE DZUEEJEQK2 _]IN] 0
LEHIEFE ]DS LEEQ PVLHINHM RIHEG DHUEDGM IQ K]E HEDG NDSE
K]DKdS UESVHKEG IQ D SKDM OR SOJE #$ DNKIOQSf
;?< 4,:3;X 0Q 4OHOUDGO2 MOVdUE KDHbIQZ DLOVKf
T3B T.-A.-,X ^ESB .HH K]E 4OHOUDGO
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 13 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
14/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
"!
DNKIOQS 77 DHH K]E 4OHOUDGO DNKIOQS2 KO JM bQO_HEGZE2 GO
QOK IQFOHFE 1KEP]EQS TEGID NOQKEQKB
0 eVSK _DQK KO JDbE SVUE K]DK _]EQ MOV SDM
PUOGVNEG IQ DHH eVUISGINKIOQS2 IKdS QOK DHH 77 QOK DHH
eVUISGINKIOQS IQFOHFE 1KEP]EQS TEGID NOQKEQKB 1O 77
;?< 4,:3;X .UE K]E DZUEEJEQKS2 K]E SKUDKEZIN
DZUEEJEQKS K]E SDJEf
T3B T.-A.-,X -OB ;]EM DUE IQ D GIRREUEQK
ROUJB ;]E NOQKEQK IS SIZQIRINDQKHM 77 IK HOObS
GIRREUEQKB 0KdS FEUM 77 K]E GONVJEQK K]DK NOQKUOHS
K]OSE DZUEEJEQKS ]DS LEEQ PUOGVNEG DQG ]DS QOK LEEQ
SEDHEGB
;?< 4,:3;X .HH UIZ]KB
T3B T.-A.-,X 1O K]E OQHM OK]EU eVUISGINKIOQ
_OVHG LE K]EUEdS D PEQGIQZ DNKIOQ IQ 1OVK] 4DUOHIQD2 DQG
K]EUE DUE K]E PEQGIQZ DNKIOQS IQ K]IS eVUISGINKIOQ K]DK
IQFOHFE 1KEP]EQS TEGIDB
;?< 4,:3;X ^OV DUE OLHIZDKEG KO K]E OQE IQ
1OVK] 4DUOHIQD2 LVK MOVdUE DHSO OLHIZDKEG KO DGFISE K]E
4OHOUDGO NOVUK OR K]IS GENISIOQB
T3B T.-A.-,X ;]DQb MOV2 ^OVU ?OQOUB
T3B 5:@A3.TX .QG2 RIQDHHM2 ^OVU ?OQOU2
@DVUEQNE 5VHZUDJB ^OV SKDKEG K]DK IR MOV ISSVEG D
UVHIQZ IQ _UIKIQZ OQ K]IS JDKKEU KOGDM2 OQ K]IS ,142
K]DK MOV _OVHG DSb K]DK IK LE PUOFIGEG KO K]E OK]EU
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 14 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
15/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 4452 443 6 #!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
""
NOVUKSB
0Q K]E DLSEQNE OR K]DK _UIKKEQ UVHIQZ2 _OVHG IK
JDbE SEQSE ROU K]E KUDQSNUIPK OR MOVU UVHIQZ2 VP KO K]E
NOHHOgVM ]EUE2 KO LE PUOFIGEG KO OK]EU NOVUKS IQ HIEV OR
D _UIKKEQ OUGEU2 KO SDFE ^OVU ?OQOU RUOJ ]DFIQZ KO _UIKE
K]E _UIKKEQ OUGEUf
T3B T.-A.-,X 0 K]IQb K]DKdS K]E
VQGEUSKDQGIQZB 0R K]EUEdS QO OUGEU2 0dJ KO PUOGVNE K]E
KUDQSNUIPK2 NOUUENKf
;?< 4,:3;X ^ESB 0 K]IQb K]DKdS D ZOOG
SVZZESKIOQB .QG K]DK _IHH LE K]E OUGEU IR IK _DSQdK
NHEDU OK]EU_ISEB
.QMK]IQZ EHSEf
T3B T.-A.-,X -O2 ^OVU ?OQOUB
T3B ,51.?@X -O2 ^OVU ?OQOUB
;?< 4,:3;X YEdHH LE IQ UENESSB
8;]E PUONEEGIQZS _EUE NOQNHVGEG DK
)X#% DBJB9
! ! !
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 15 of 16
-
8/6/2019 Transcript - July 14, 2011 Judge Hunt Sanctions Hearing (Righthaven LLC v. Democratic Underground)
16/16
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
!*
!!
!"
!#
!$
!%
!&
!'
!(
!)
"*
"!
""
"#
"$
"%
+,--. +./0+1,-2 3+32 4332 443 6#!( 7 8''%9 #")7*!#"
"#
!"#"!
0 NEUKIRM K]DK K]E ROUEZOIQZ IS D NOUUENK
KUDQSNUIPK RUOJ K]E EHENKUOQIN SOVQG UENOUGIQZ
OR K]E PUONEEGIQZS IQ K]E DLOFE7EQKIKHEG JDKKEUB
$%&'%&&
+OQQD +DFIGSOQ2 3+32 4332 443 6#!( +DKE,RRINIDH 3EPOUKEU
Case 2:10-cv-01575-JCM -PAL Document 58-2 Filed 07/20/11 Page 16 of 16