Transcript Griesa Julio 22, 2014

7/21/2019 Transcript Griesa Julio 22, 2014

1/57

1

E7mrnmlm

1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

1 SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

2 ------------------------------x

2

3 NML CAPITAL, LTD, !" #l, 3

$ Pl#%n"%&&',

$

( ) *+ C .7+ /TP0

(

THE REPULIC OF AR0ENTINA, Ar4m!n"

7 D!&!n5#n"

7

+ ------------------------------x

+

. N!6 Yr8, NY

. 94l: 22, 2*1$1* 1*;3* #m

1*

11 !&r!;

11

12 HON THOMAS P 0RIESA,

13

13 D%'"r% ADELMAN LLP

2* A""rn!:' &r In"!r!'"!5 P#r"%!' A4r!l%4' C#=%"#l P#r"n!r'

21 #n5 l4! An!l

21 Y; EDWARD A FRIEDMAN

22 DANIEL RAPPORT

22

23

23 0ISON DUNN > CRUTCHER LLP

2$ A""rn!:' &r Pl#%n"%&& NML C#=%"#l, L"52$ Y; MATTHEW D MC0ILL

2(

SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, PC

/212 +*(-*3**


2/57

2

E7mrnmlm

1 APPEARANCES

2

2 MILER0 LLP

3 A""rn!:' &r #r!l# =l#%n"%&&'

3 Y; MICHAEL C SPENCER $

$

( DAIS POLK > WARDWELL LLP

( A""rn!:' &r C%"%?#n8

Y; KAREN E WA0NER

9AMES L KERR

7

7

+ LATHAM > WATKINS LLP

+ A""rn!:' &r "@! E4r n5@l5!r'

. Y; CHRISTOPHER 9 CLARK

. CRAI0 A ATCHELOR

1*1*

11 REED SMITH LLP

11 A""rn!:' &r T@! #n8 & N!6 Yr8 M!lln, #' In5!n"4r!

12 Tr4'"!!

12 Y; ERIC A SCHAFFER

13 NEIL 0RAY

13

1$

1$ LEI LUARSKY > FEI0ENAUM LLP

1( A""rn!:' &r 9PMr#n C@#'! #n8 NA

1( Y; ANDREA LIKWORNIK WEISS

1 ALAN H SCHEINER

117

17 MOR0AN LEWIS > OCKIUS LLP

1+ A""rn!:' &r Cl!#r'"r!#m #n8%n

1+ Y; 9OHN M ASSOS

1.

1.

2* 0REENFIELD STEIN > SENIOR LLP

2* A""rn!:' &r E4r


3/57

3

E7mrnmlm

1

2 /C#'!

7 MR FRIEDMAN; Y4r Hnr, E56#r5 Fr%!5m#n n ?!@#l&

+ & #ll & "@! =l#%n"%&&' I 6%ll #55r!'' "@#" m"%n Im

. 6%"@ "@! &%rm & Fr%!5m#n K#=l#n S!%l!r > A5!lm#n, #""rn!:'

1* &r "@! A4r!l%4' #n5 l4! An!l =l#%n"%&&' Mr C@!n n

11 ?!@#l& & NML #n5 I #n5 "@!r =l#%n"%&&'


4/57

$

E7mrnmlm

1 Ar!n"%n! l#6 #n5 =#:#?l! %n Ar!n"%n# T@%' m"%n &r

2 r!


5/57

(

E7mrnmlm

1 !x!r1 #ll & "@'! --

17 THE COURT; T@!: "@r4@ "@! %n5!n"4r! "r4'"!!,

1+ r%@"B1. MR FRIEDMAN; N" &r "@! 9#=#n!'! #n5 "@! Ar!n"%n!

2* l#6 !x


6/57

E7mrnmlm

1 "@r4@ "@! %n5!n"4r! "r4'"!!, #r! "@!:B

2 MR FRIEDMAN; Y4r Hnr, %' #?'l4"!l:

2* T@! '!

22 Hnr' F!?r4#r: 23 r5!r "@#" '=!


7/57

7

E7mrnmlm

1 T@! =%n" & "@#" =#r#r#=@ !n%n%n # )%l#"%n &

2 "@! =#r% =#''4 =r)%'%n %' "@#" 6@!n 6! l8 #" "@%' 4n%)!r'!

3 & !x

21 r!


/212 +*(-*3**


8/57

+

E7mrnmlm

1 4n54?"!5l: &%n! l!#l r!#'n%n, #n5 ' &r"@

2 MR FRIEDMAN; Y4r Hnr, I "@%n8 "@!r! %' #n

3 %m=r"#n" =%n" &

1 E4r

2$ I 6#n"!5 " m#8! &r :4r Hnr'


9/57

.

E7mrnmlm

1 THE COURT; T@%' 5!' n" "@r4@ "@! %n5!n"4r!

2 "r4'"!!, 5!' %"B

3 MR FRIEDMAN; T@#" %'

17 Ar!n"%n# 6#' =r@%?%"!5 &rm =#:%n !x


10/57

1*

E7mrnmlm

1 m#""!r Y4 #r! "#l8%n #?4" "@! 7 & "@#"

+ MR FRIEDMAN; Y4r Hnr, &%r'" l!" m! '#:, %& I m#:,

. %" %' n" # m%n4"! '%"4#"%n T@! US 5ll#r-5!nm%n#"!5

1* !x

13 THE COURT; S#: "@#" ##%n

1$ MR FRIEDMAN; T@! 4n%)!r'! & !x

23 THE COURT; I 5%5n" r!#l%! "@! =!r

2$ 6#: :4 "#l8 #?4" T@!r! %' # l" " 5 "5#: W! 6%ll ?!

2( ?#


11/57

11

E7mrnmlm

1 )!r: m4

1$ #&&%5#)%"' "@#" 6! =r!'!n"!5 " "@! C4r" A" "@#" =%n"

1( =#:m!n" ?: "@! r!=4?l%< #n5 " "@! ?n5@l5!r' %'

22 =r

2( '%"4#"%n In "@! "@!r '%"4#"%n =#:m!n" %' m#5! " #n8 &


/212 +*(-*3**


12/57

12

E7mrnmlm

1 N!6 Yr8, #n5 "@!n #n8 & N!6 Yr8 m4'" m#8! "@! =#:m!n" "

2 n! & "@! 5!='%"r%!', #n5 =#:m!n" ?: Ar!n"%n# %' n"

3

11 4n5 !)!r:"@%n "@#" @#' ?!!n 5n! %n "@%'

17 '4?!

2( C%"%?#n8 Ar!n"%n#, %" %' "r!#"!5 5%&&!r!n"l: D


13/57

13

E7mrnmlm

1 #' A

2( ?: "@!


14/57

1$

E7mrnmlm

1 6#n"' 6%"@4" %m=l%

. THE COURT; I 5n" m!#n "@#" :4 '@4l5 @#)! %" 56n

1* " "@! l#'" 5ll#r r =!', ?4"


15/57

1(

E7mrnmlm

1 THE COURT; O&

23 %5!n"%&%!5 %n :4r Hnr' #m!n5!5 F!?r4#r: 23 r5!r T@!

2$


16/57

1

E7mrnmlm

1 T@! !&&!2* "@'! =#:m!n"' @#)! " "@! =r!'!n" %''4! H!r! %' 6@#" I #m

21 "#l8%n #?4" T@! r!=4?l%< #""!m="!5 " =#: "@! %n"!r!'" n

22 "@! !x


17/57

17

E7mrnmlm

1 %n5!n"4r! "r4'"!!, #n5 "@! #n8 & N!6 Yr8 )!r:, )!r:

2 r!'=n'%?l: '"==!5 #" "@#" =%n", r!

1$ 5ll#r-5!nm%n#"!5 !x


18/57

1+

E7mrnmlm

1 6%"@ * T@! '%m=l! =%n" %' "@#" "@! #m!n5!5 F!?r4#r: 23 r5!r

21


19/57

1.

E7mrnmlm

1 THE COURT; S#: "@#" mr! 'l6l: 0 )!r "@#" )!r:

2

1$ MR FRIEDMAN; S4r!

1( THE COURT; Y4 @#)! '#%5 "@%' #?4" "@r!! "%m!' I

1 6#n" " &ll6 4= S4mm#r%! "@! =r)%'%n' & "@! F!?r4#r: 23

17 4'" n

1+ MR FRIEDMAN; S4r! T@!r! #r! "6 %m=r"#n"1. =r)%'%n' On! %' =#r#r#=@ 2/# P#r#r#=@ 2/# '#:' "@#"

2* %& "@! r!=4?l%< m#8!' # =#:m!n" n #n: & "@! !x

2( THE COURT; Ar! "@! ?n5' 6! #r! "#l8%n #?4" %n "@%'


/212 +*(-*3**


20/57

2*

E7mrnmlm

1 m"%n !x


21/57

21

E7mrnmlm

1 ?#'%' &r "@! r5!r T@! =%n%n 5!'

$ + r "@! C## 6@%

1 C%"%?#n8 Ar!n"%n# %' # ?r#n


22/57

22

E7mrnmlm

1 r!#'n' "@#" 6! @#)! #r"%


23/57

23

E7mrnmlm

1 '@4l5 n" ?! r!#

3 "@!'! ?n5', !)!n "@4@ "@!: #r! !x

1 5!

2$ THE COURT; W%"@4" 54?" F


24/57

2$

E7mrnmlm

1 !x

2 MS WA0NER; T@#" %'

1* "r#n'&!r' &4n5' " "@! #n8 & N!6 Yr8 M!lln, 6@%


/212 +*(-*3**


25/57

2(

E7mrnmlm

1 )!r:

11 #r! ?#'!5 n :4r Hnr' r5!r

12 THE COURT; I 6%ll r!'!r)! 5!


26/57

2

E7mrnmlm

1 THE COURT; O&


27/57

27

E7mrnmlm

1 THE COURT; W@#" :4 6!r! 4'" '#:%n

2 MR FRIEDMAN; I #=l%! W@#" I 6#' '#:%n "@%'

3 m%n4"! 6#' "@#" 6%"@ r!'=!

7 5%'"r%?4"! "@! &4n5' " !x

2$ THE COURT; W@#"!)!r "@! #m4n" 6#' " 6@#"

2( %n'"%"4"%n r ?#n8 r 6@#"!)!r, 6@ 6#' %" =#%5 "B


/212 +*(-*3**


28/57

2+

E7mrnmlm

1 MR FRIEDMAN; A' 6! 4n5!r'"#n5 "@!

+ 9#=#n!'! l#6

. S, "@! !x"!n" & 4r 8n6l!5! #?4" "@! r!=4?l%

1 "@%n' T@!r! #r! "6 "@%n' "@#" I @#)! %n m%n5 "@#" @#)!

17 r#%'!5 %''4!' On! %' "@! #""!m=" ?: "@! r!=4?l%< " m#8!

1+ =#:m!n" " "@! !x


29/57

2.

E7mrnmlm

1 M: 4n5!r'"#n5%n %' "@#" "@! "6 "@%n' #r! 5%&&!r!n"

2 In "@!r 6r5', "@! r!=4?l%< 6#' "r:%n " =#: "@! %n"!r!'" "

3 "@! !x

11 '#%5 "@%' 1( "%m!' "5#:, ?4" =l!#'!, ##%n, 6@#" "@!r

12 =#:m!n"' 6!r! m#5! %n "@!

23 MR FRIEDMAN; I& 6! =4" #'%5! C%"%?#n8 #n5 %& 6! =4"

2$ #'%5! "@! #n8 & N!6 Yr8, "@! nl: "@!r %n&rm#"%n 6! @#)!

2( %' 21 m%ll%n "@#" %' ?!%n @!l5 ?: 9PMr#n C@#'! #n8 %n


/212 +*(-*3**


30/57

3*

E7mrnmlm

1 9#=#n, 6@!r! %" 6#' r!

2 !x

23 MR FRIEDMAN; I ?!l%!)! "@#" "@! #m4n" =#%5 "

2$ C%"%?#n8 %n Ar!n"%n# %' 'm!6@!r! ?!"6!!n 2** m%ll%n #n5

2( 3** m%ll%n I 5n" @#)! #n !x#


31/57

31

E7mrnmlm

1 THE COURT; D :4 8n6 6@!r! "@#" mn!: %' n6 n

2 5!='%"B

3 MR FRIEDMAN; In =#r", :!', :4r Hnr P#r" & "@#"

$ mn!: %' n6 n 5!='%" %n "@! #


32/57

32

E7mrnmlm

1 m#:, "@%' %' # )!r: "!

3 4n5!r'"#n5 "@#" :4r Hnr 6%ll n" l8 )r#?l: 4=n "@%'

$ m"%n #n5 6%ll, I #n"%

13 " m#8! "@! &%r'" m"%n #n5 @#)! "@! =r%r%": "@#" !' 6%"@

1$ %" I '#: 6%"@ &4ll 4n5!r'"#n5%n "@#" --

1( THE COURT; H#' "@#" ?!!n =#r" & "@! ?r%!&%n ?!&r!

1 m!B

17 MR FRIEDMAN; N, :4r Hnr T@%'


33/57

33

E7mrnmlm

1 " =4" "@#" m"%n n "@! r!


34/57

3$

E7mrnmlm

1 THE COURT; Hl5%n 6@!r!B

2 MR FRIEDMAN; T@! #n8 & N!6 Yr8 %' @l5%n

3 (3. m%ll%n #" "@! #n8 & N!6 Yr8' #

12


35/57

3(

E7mrnmlm

1 6! #r! @l5%n "@#" mn!: #' "@!

13 MS WA0NER; Y4r Hnr, m#: I ?! @!#r5 &r n!

1$ mm!n"B

1( THE COURT; O&


36/57

3

E7mrnmlm

1 THE COURT; An:?5: !l'!B

2 MR CLARK; C@r%' Cl#r8 &r "@! !4r ?n5@l5!r' I&

3 %" =l!#'! "@! C4r", I "@%n8 %& 6! #55r!''!5 4r m"%n ?!&r!

$ "@! #n8 & N!6 Yr8', %" m%@" m#8! mr! l%


37/57

37

E7mrnmlm

1

2* %" =!r#"!' 'l!l: %n !l%4m I" 5!' n"@%n %n "@! Un%"!5

21 S"#"!' I" 5!'n"


38/57

3+

E7mrnmlm

1 r!4%r!' # =#r": " )%l#"! "@! l#6 & %"' &r4m '"#"! r "@!

2 l#6 & "@! =l#

1* THE COURT; I 6%ll

1$

2( W! 64l5


39/57

3.

E7mrnmlm

1 "

$ "@!r! #r! '!r%4' %''4!' "@#" #r%'! 4n5!r "@! %n4n


/212 +*(-*3**


40/57


41/57

$1

E7mrnmlm

1 MR FRIEDMAN; Y!'

2 THE COURT; L8, & #ll "@! %''4!' 6! @#)!, #n5 "@!r!

3 #r! # l" & %''4!', %" '!!m' " m! "@%' '4r!l: '@4l5 ?! #?l!

$ " ?! #r!!5 n T@! r!=4?l%< #""!m="!5 " =#: %n"!r!'" T@#"

( #""!m=" 6#' %m=r=!r W! "#l8!5 #?4" "@#" m#n:, m#n: "%m!' 4" mn!: #

2* :4r Hnr' r5!r #n5 #''!r"%n "@#" %" @#' =#%5 #n5 6%ll

21


42/57

$2

E7mrnmlm

1

(

23 "@#" I 64l5 ?!


/212 +*(-*3**


43/57

$3

E7mrnmlm

1

1( MR SCHAFFER; Y4r Hnr, I ?!l%!)! "@! #n'6!r %' 6!

1 @l5 "@! mn!: r%@" 6@!r! %" %', "@#" 6! 5 !x#


44/57

$$

E7mrnmlm

1 %n"!r!'"!5

7 "@! r!=4?l%< #' & "@! !n5 & 94l: I "@%n8 ?!

.

21 5n" 8n6 @6 m#n:, ?4" 45m!n"' 6!r! ?"#%n!5 T@!r! r!#ll:

22 6#'n" #n: =='%"%n !n!r#ll: " =r

2$ ##%n'" "@! r!=4?l%< %n )#r%4' #m4n"' 945m!n"'

2( In 2**( #n5 2*1* "@! r!=4?l%< m#5! &&!r' " !x


45/57

$(

E7mrnmlm

1 "@! !x%'"%n ?n5' &r n!6 ?n5' 6%"@ # l6!r %n"!r!'" r#"!',

2 #n5 ' &r"@ I" %' m: %n&rm#"%n "@#" m#:?! .* =!r

( "@!: 6!r! n" 6%ll%n " %)! 4= "@'! 45m!n"' %n !x

11 !&&r"' 6!r! 4n'412 T@! r!=4?l%< 5!' n" @#)! # '4?'"#n"%#l '"r! &

13 #''!"' & #n: 8%n5 %n "@! Un%"!5 S"#"!' 6@%

1+ "@!: 6!n" 4= " "@! C4r" & A==!#l', ?#'%

2( r!


/212 +*(-*3**


46/57

$

E7mrnmlm

1 T@! r!=4?l%< "8 !)!r: '"!= %"

1+ "@!r! @#5 " ?! # r!

23 =#''4


47/57

$7

E7mrnmlm

1 %n)8%n "@! =#r% =#''4

1+ %' 'm!"@%n m4


/212 +*(-*3**


48/57

$+

E7mrnmlm

1 '=!

13 45m!n"' #n5 64l5n" '!""l!, 64l5n" !x


49/57

$.

E7mrnmlm

1 I #m #55%n " "@! =r)%'%n' "@#" I =4" 56n %n m:

2 #==%n"m!n" & "@! '=!

2( r!'l4"%n


50/57

(*

E7mrnmlm

1 T@!r! %' n

7 I '#%5 #" "@%' =5%4m ##%n %n 2**2 "@#" 6! r!

1( 5!l" #" "@! !n5 & "@%' mn"@ T@'! r5!r', I 64l5 @#)!

1 " r!m%n5 "@! C4r", #r! )!r: ?l4n" %n'"r4m!n"'

17 I 8n6 "@! C4r"' ?!

23 =#:m!n" " "@! m#5! " "@! .2 =!r

2( " 5 "@#" r!4%r!' m)!m!n" W!


51/57

(1

E7mrnmlm

1 @l54"

1* # r%@" "@#" %n !''!n

21 =!=l! I"' ""#ll: 4n5!r'"#n5#?l!

22 T@! C4r" @#' "#l8!5 #?4" #ll "@! 45m!n" @l5!r'

23 !:n5 #ll "@! 45m!n" @l5!r', "@!r! #r! =!=l! 6@ 5n" :!"

2$ @#)! 45m!n"' ?4" 6@ #l' @#)! =#r% =#''4 r%@"' 4n5!r "@!

2( C4r"' %n"!r=r!"#"%n W@#" "@%' m!#n' %' 6! @#)! " m#8! #


/212 +*(-*3**


52/57

(2

E7mrnmlm

1 l?#l &&!r " !)!r:?5: 4" 6! #l' #r!

1* T@! '!2* "@! '"#"!, %"' =r!'%5!n" T@!'! #r! n" nl: !


53/57

(3

E7mrnmlm

1 I" @#'

2* On!, I 64l5 ?! r!m%'' %n m: 54": #' # l#6:!r &r m:


54/57

($

E7mrnmlm

1 4nl%8!l:, %n

1$ "@#" #n5

2$ & "@! =r?l!m' T@! r!#'n &r @#)%n '!""l!m!n" n!"%#"%n'

2( %' " "r: " 5!#l 6%"@ "@'! =r?l!m' T@#"' 6@#" '!""l!m!n"


/212 +*(-*3**


55/57

((

E7mrnmlm

1 n!"%#"%n' #r! #?4" M'" %m=r"#n"l:, " #)%5 # 5!l"

2 #" "@! !n5 & 94l:

3 In m: )%!6, !)!r: '%nl! =r?l!m :4 #r! "#l8%n #?4"

$ %' '4'

( I" %' n" %n " ?! # '!""l!m!n" 6r%""!n %n n! =#r#r#=@ I" 6%ll 5!#l, @#)! " 5!#l, 6%"@

2* =!r'n#ll: ?! %n N!6 Yr8 r4n5 "@!

2( %n "@! n!x" :!#r I" m#: 4" "@!r! #r! 6#:' " 'm!@6 #)%5


/212 +*(-*3**


56/57

(

E7mrnmlm

1 # 5!l" T@#" %' 6@#" %' ?!%n #""!m="!5

2 I !x=!


57/57

Transcript Griesa Julio 22, 2014

Documents

Transcript of Transcript Griesa Julio 22, 2014