Traffic Light Legend - Stanford University Light Legend NOTE: Colored borders around graphs indicate...

16
AHU 1 Cody Wiesen Jordana Viuker 1

Transcript of Traffic Light Legend - Stanford University Light Legend NOTE: Colored borders around graphs indicate...

AHU 1

Cody Wiesen

Jordana Viuker

1

System Diagram

2

BUILDING SYSTEM FLOOR COMPONENT ZONE

Y2E2 AHU 1

BASEMENT

1ST FLOOR

2nd FLOOR

3rd FLOOR

CV B-1-3 ECV B-12-18 VAV B-1-4 EVAV B-12-14

B12 Teaching Lab

B19 Materials Storage

B26 Equipment Room

B27 Equipment Room

ECV 1-12-1 CV 1-1-3

103A Food Service

111 Lecture

ECV 2-12-1 CV 2-1-3

220 Men’s Room 293 John Kunz’ Office

SF 3-1 ECV 3-12-1 CV 3-1-4

Plenum

318 Men’s Room

324 Open Office

LEGEND

System served (arrow points away from it)

System serving (arrow points to it)

3

GREEN LIGHT: System functioning as intended. No attention necessary and no risk of personal or financial harm. YELLOW LIGHT: Data indicate system performance is not as expected. Professional attention advised and possible risk of personal or financial harm. RED LIGHT: Data indicate that either sensors or system not functioning as expected. Professional attention necessary, as there is probable risk of personal or financial harm.

Traffic Light Legend

NOTE: Colored borders around graphs indicate lowest level of proper system functioning (i.e. if there is any yellow within the data, a yellow border is applied and likewise if there is any red, a red border is applied).

4

kunz
Sticky Note
good

Hot Water

Previous Graph - Colored entirely green - Hard to read - 60 minute interval

Revised Graph - Green border - Easier to read - 1 minute interval - More accurate analysis

5

kunz
Sticky Note
Revised generally better for reasons stated.Why is analysis more accurate?Need to state functional intent of system, of each point explicitly to assess whether behavior conforms to intent. Assumed intent is implicit ...
kunz
Sticky Note
Unmarked set by kunz
kunz
Sticky Note
Previous = earlier in quarter, right? Nice example here and below of revisiting your work as quarter progresses.

Chilled Water Flow Before

After

Before Further Investigation - Incomplete status assessment - Unsolved yellow lights After Further Investigation - Complete status assessment! - Yellow lights turned green - Insignificant discrepancy 6

Before

After

1

Before Further Investigation - Neglected areas of concern - Undeserving status assessment

After Further Investigation - Exposed area of concern - Discrepancy significant - Complete status assessment!

Hot Water Flow

7

kunz
Sticky Note
Nice example of value of expanding level of detail

Heating in Representative Office 371

All Clear - Interval at 1 minute

makes an already clear graph even clearer

- Heating system in 371 is working perfectly

- Status assessment: GREEN!

8

1

2

2

Before

After Before Verification - Unsolved yellow lights - HW turns on too early After Further Investigation - Time series plot refutes problem - Problem in SEEIT: not in the system - Status assessment: Green!

HW Flow in Representative Office 371

9

kunz
Sticky Note
Explanation of 1, 2?

Heat Recovery

2009 problem: • Heat recovery

cooling mode doesn’t coincide with coil cooling mode

2011 update: • Cooling coil valve

no longer open when heat recovery bypass damper is open

10

Supply vs. Return Temp.

2009 problem: • Active beam hot

water supply & return water temps reversed & values inconsistent with hot water system level temperatures

2011 update: • Hot water supply &

return temps have correct relationship; correct system temperature level

11

Heating Coil Valve Position

2009 problem: • Heating coil valve

cycles open and closed rapidly

2011 update: • Problem fixed

12

Wiki Explained

• Step 1: Click “Group 3”

13

Wiki Explained Cont’d.

• Step 2: Use our table of contents to navigate

• One continuous page for your convenience

14

Recommendations

• All inconsistencies marked as “yellow” should be further examined to determine whether they are “red” or “green.”

– Hot Water Flow Rate vs. Active Beam Heating Valve Position

15

kunz
Sticky Note
Others?

Thank you.

Questions?

16