Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

83
Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors Carl Haber Physics Division Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL 1

Transcript of Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Page 1: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors

Carl HaberPhysics Division

Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL1

Page 2: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Suggestions for further reading

R.N.Cahn and G.Goldhaber, The Experimental Foundations of Particle Physics, Cambridge, 1989

W. Blum and L. Rolandi, Particle Detection with Drift Chambers, Springer-Verlag, 1993

T. Ferbel, Experimental Techniques in High Energy Nuclear and Particle Physics,World Scientific, 1992

R.P. Shutt, Bubble and Spark Chambers Volumes 1 and 2, Academic Press, 1967

J.Orear, Notes on Statistics for Physicists, Cornell Laboratory for Nuclear Science note CNLS 82/511

Particle Data Group, The Review of Particle Properties, European Physical Journal C 15, (2000) p.157-204

D.H. Perkins, Introduction to Particle Physics, 4 Ed edition (2000) Cambridge Univiversity Press

A.S. Grove, Physics and Technology of Semiconductor Devices, (1967) John Wiley & Sons; ISBN: 0471329983

R.Ruchti, Scintillating Fibers for Charged Particle Tracking, Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science, 46, (1996) 281-319

J.Va’vra, in Instrumentation for Experimental Particle Physics, AIP Conference Proceedings 422, edited by Herrara Corral and Sosa Aquino, Woodbury, NY, 1998

H. Spieler, Semiconductor Detector Systems, Oxford Science Publications, 2005

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL2

Page 3: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Outline

• Physics motivation• Colliding beam experiments• Tracking fundamentals• Semiconductor detectors• Radiation issues• Future directions

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL3

Page 4: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Introduction• Particle physics progresses by increased beam energy

and luminosity.• Experiments in particle physics are based upon three

basic measurements.– Energy flow and direction: calorimetry– Particle identification (e,µ,π,K,ν…) – Particle momentum: tracking in a magnetic field

• Ability to exploit increased energy and luminosity are driven by detector and information handling technology.

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL4

Page 5: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Searching for Particles

• Event rates are governed by– Cross section σ(Ε) [cm2] - physics– Luminosity [cm-2s-1] = N1N2 f / A

• N1N2 = particles/bunch• f = crossing frequency• A = area of beam at collision

– Nevents = σ Ldt– Acceptance and efficiency of detectors

• Higher energy: threshold, statistics• Higher luminosity: statistics

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL5

Page 6: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Experimental Program• Series of accelerators with

increasing energy and luminosity

• 25 years: domination of colliders• Proton colliders

– “broadband” beams of quarks and gluons, - “search and discovery” and precision measurements

• Electron colliders– “narrowband” beams, clean,

targeted experiments and precision measurements

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL6

Page 7: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL7

Page 8: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

CERN SppS Collider 1980-88CERN ISR ~1975

CERN LHC 2008-?Fermilab Tevatron 1985-2009

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL8

Page 9: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Hadron Collider HistoryMachine C.M.S.

EnergyLuminosity Year Role Detector

Innovations

ISR 31 GeV 2 x 1032 1970’s Exploratory, IVB search

W, Z, jets

Top quark

Higgs,…?

SppS 640 GeV 6 x 1030 ’80 -’88

High rate electronics

Hermetic and projective calorimeters, magnetic trackingPrecision tracking, advanced triggers

Tevatron 1.9 TeV 1030-1032 ’85 -’08

LHC 14 TeV 1033-1035 ’08 - ? Fast detectors, radiation resistances

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL9

Page 10: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Proton collider event structure• Most interesting physics is

due to hard collision of quark(s) or gluon(s)

• That production is central (and rare) and “jet” like

• Remaining “spectators” scatter softly, products are distributed broadly about the beam line and dominate the average track density

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL10

Page 11: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Outer muonchamber (blue)

Solenoidalmagnet coil(purple)

Inner muonchamber (yellow)

Hadroncalorimeter (dark blue)

Electromagnetic calorimeter(red)

beampipe

Central drift chamber

Silicon microvertexdetector

ab

de

fg

c

muon

pion

photon

electron

a: beampipe b:vertex tracker c: central tracker d: solenoid coil e: electromagnetic calorimeter f: hadronic calorimeter/muon filter g: muon tracking chambers

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL11

Page 12: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL12

Page 13: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Tracking

• The process of sampling a particle's trajectory and determining its parameters. – Momentum– Direction– Decay points

• High energy– Small fraction of energy deposited in instrument

• The trajectory should be disturbed minimally by this process.

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL13

Page 14: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Method• Charged particles ionize matter along their path.• Tracking is based upon detecting ionization trails.• An “image” of the charged particles in the event.

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL14

Page 15: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Specifications• Performance on reconstruction of track parameters• Defined in terms of:

– parameters of the system (layout, magnetic field, etc)– performance of position sensing elements.

• Initially evaluate with simple parametric analyses.• Full simulation• Performance of position sensing elements

– hit resolution, timing resolution, effects of data transmission

– defined by physics of detecting medium/process and general considerations such as segmentation and geometry.

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL15

Page 16: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Technology

• Old: Emulsions, cloud, and bubble chambers– Continuous media– Typically gave very detailed information but were

slow to respond and awkward to read out• New: Electronic detectors, wire chambers,

scintillators, solid state detectors– Segmented– Fast, can be read out digitally, information content

is now approaching the “old” technology

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL16

Page 17: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

770 microns15 microns

15 microns

n=1.59n=1.49

n=1.42

fiber

cladding

track

mirror

scintillating section clear section photon detector

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL17

Page 18: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Technical Background

• Define tracking parameters• Basic constraints on performance

– Geometry– Material– Point resolution

• Point resolution and multi-hit response– The problem of 2D

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL18

Page 19: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Trajectory

θ

z

x

y

x*

y*

z*

φ D

Rx0,y0

z0

• Charged particle in a magnetic field B=Bz

• 3D Helix : 5 parametersC = half curvature

(1(sgn)/R)z0 = offsetD = signed impact

parameter (distance of closest approach)

Azimuth φ = angle of track at closest approach

θ = dip anglex = x0 + Rcosλy = y0 + Rsin λz = z0 + Rλ tanθ

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL19

Page 20: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL20

Simple case: Measure sagitta s of track with radius R, over projected arc length L (cm, KGauss, MeV/c), assuming R>>L

θθθ cos3.08

8 using

cos83.0

cos3.0

2

22

BLsp

pp

sLR

sBLBRp

sagitta

∆=⎟⎟

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ ∆⇒===

where ∆s is the error on the sagitta measurement.

Effect of material: multiple scattering

21

22

02

222

cos8.52

cos316)(

⎟⎟

⎜⎜

⎛⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ ∆+⎟⎟

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ ∆=

=⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ ∆⇒=∆

MCSsaggitaTOTAL

MCS

MCS

pp

pp

pp

LXBppLs

θθσ s

Page 21: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Momentum resolution

0.01

0.1

1

10

100

Del

ta P

/P

1000

0.1 1 10 100 1000

B=15 KG, Delta s=0.1 mmL=100 cm

momentum GeV/c

P error %Delta P/PCO2LArIronθcos3.0

8 2BLsp

pp

sagitta

∆=⎟⎟

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ ∆

21

22

0 cos8.52

⎟⎟

⎜⎜

⎛⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ ∆+⎟⎟

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ ∆=

=⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ ∆

MCSsaggitaTOTAL

MCS

pp

pp

pp

LXBpp

θ

•Minimize sagitta error•Maximize B,L•Minimize material

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL21

Page 22: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

( ) ( )

( ) ( ) ( )

xxya

xyby

yby

ybb

xbyxxxyyyya

xyy

xxyyb

bxay

yyyxx

∆+=

∆=⇒⎟

⎞⎜⎝

⎛∂∂

+⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎝

⎛∂∂

=

−=⎟⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

∆+

−−+==

∆−

=−−

==

+=

==

812

221

21212121

21intercept

212121slope

errors with points, measured 2,1planest measuremen 2,1

22

22

2

δδ

δδδδδ

δ

for good resolution on angles (φ and θ) and intercepts (d, z0 )•Precision track point measurements•Maximize separation between planes for good resolution on intercepts•Minimize extrapolation - first point close to interaction

Vertex Resolution

x1 x2

y1

y2

a

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL22

Page 23: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

xxya

yyyxx

∆+=

==

812

errors with points, measured 2,1planest measuremen 2,1

δδ

δ

for good resolution on angles (φ and θ) and intercepts (d, z0 )•Precision track point measurements•Maximize separation between planes for good resolution on intercepts•Minimize extrapolation - first point close to interaction•Material inside 1st layer should be at minimum radius (multiple scattering)

Vertex Resolution: Material

x1 x2

y1y2

a

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL23

Page 24: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Correct treatment of errors utilizes fitting and parameter estimation techniques such as the least squares method.

χ 2 = ( yi − F( xi ;αi , j = 0

N

∑ )) Eij− 1 ( y j − F( x j ;α ))

with ∂χ 2

∂α k

= 0

Eij ≡ error matrix, if points are uncorrelated then

E ij =

σ 02 0 .... 0

0 • .... 00 .... • 00 .... .... σ n

2

⎜ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜

⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟

note: elements are additive, errors can be combined.

if F ( x i;α ) can be written in the form F ( x i; α ) = α nn

∑ fn (x i )

where the fn ( x i ) are a linearly independant set, the parameters α can be found by a matrix inversion,

α = V g

where gm = y jjk

∑ fm (x k )E jk− 1

and Vmn−1 = fm ( x j )

jk∑ fn ( xk ) E jk

−1

and the errors 2 (or covariances) of the α m ,

α mα n[ ]= α mα n − α m α n are given by the elements of Vmn

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL24

Page 25: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Point Resolution: Segmentation

• Discrete sensing elements (binary response, hit or no hit), on a pitch p, measuring a coordinate x

• Discrete sensing elements (analog response with signal to noise ratio S/N) on a pitch p, where f is a factor depending on pitch, threshold, cluster width

12p

x =σ

)(~SNfpxσ

p

x

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL25

Page 26: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Multi-hit performance• Binary response (hit or no hit), on pitch p, two hit separation

requires an empty element. – Wide pitch most hits are single element, separation = 2p– Narrow pitch double element hits, separation = 3p

• Analog response: can use local minima in a merged cluster

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL26

Page 27: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

2D• The problem of 2 dimensions:

– crossed array of n elements each on pitch p gives equal resolution on both coordinates.

• m hits m2 combinations with m2 – m false combinations– Small angle stereo geometry, angle α

• False combinations are limited to the overlap region but resolution on second coordinate is worse by 1/sin(α)

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL27

Page 28: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

2D

• Pixel structure: n x m channels– Ultimate in readout structure– Expensive in material, system issues, technology

• Pixels and strips can also be thought of as 2 extremes of a continuum (super-pixels, short-strips,…..)– Some potential for optimizations of performance vs.

complexity but needs to be analyzed on a case by case basis• Novel 2D structures with 1D readout which rely on

assumptions about hit characteristics

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL28

Page 29: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Semiconductor Detectors

• Since mid-80’s use of position sensitive “silicon detectors” became widespread

• Can resolve track positions to ~10 microns• Used to measure momentum and identify

secondary vertices due to decays of primary particles

• Handle high particle rates and radiation dose

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL29

Page 30: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL30

• Semiconductor band structure energy gap• Asymmetric diode junction: example p(+) into contact with n

(NA >> ND)• Space charge region formed by diffusion of free charges,

can be increased with "reverse bias“

Silicon Detectors

p+ nV=0 VRB>0

W

( ) ( )

bias reverse applied V) 0.8(~ potentialin built

101e

1 material n type ofy resistivit

11.9 mobility,electron 5.02 :idthjunction w

0

==

Ω−≈==

==

+=+=

RBBI

D

RBBIRBBI

VV

cmkN

VVmVVW

µρ

εεµρµµρε

Page 31: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Response to Ionization

• Electron-hole pairs formed in the depletion zone drift under the influence of the electric field

• Drift time determined by mobility and field– ~7 ns to cross 300 microns

• Drifting charge is a current which can be measured

p+ nV=0 e-

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL31

VRB>0h+h+

h+ e-

e-

Page 32: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Planar Processing• Using micro-lithographic techniques arrays of diode

structures can be patterned on silicon wafers.• The “Silicon Microstrip” detector was introduced in

the late 1970’s and is the basis of all precision types in use today

Al readout strip

oxide layer

p+implant

high resistivity n material

n+layer

Al contact

25-200 microns

200-300 micronsall other layers of 1 micron scale

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL32

Page 33: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

6 mm

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL33

Page 34: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

2D Pixel StructureCharge sensitive Preamp + shaping,signal processing, pipelines, digitization

Single sided configurationPixel readout

Diagram courtesy of Z.Li and V.Radeka

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL34

Page 35: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Signal Processing Issues

• Signal: expressed as input charge, typically 25,000 electron-hole pairs (4 fC)

• Gain: determined by feedback and capacitance

• Noise: various sources, must be small compared to signal (S/N > ~10)

V bias

R bias

integrator shaper

t rise TM

V out

n+

np+

oxideCb

G

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL35

Page 36: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Leakage Current

• Leakage current– DC component blocked

by oxide capacitor– Before (after) radiation

damage ~ 1 nA (1 ma) – AC component is seen

by pre-amp: noise source

V bias

R bias

integrator shaper

t rise TM

V out

n+

np+

oxideCb

G

areajunction density trap

velocityermalcarrier thsection crossion recombinat

ionconcentratcarrier intrinsic2

)(

==

===

=

ANv

n

WANvenI

T

thermal

i

TthermaliL

σ

σ

( ) kTEL

aeTTI 2/2 −∝Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL

36

Page 37: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Noise

• Fluctuations ~ Gaussian σN– Leakage Current– Preamp “input noise charge”,

white noise, decreases with pre-amp current, increases with faster risetime where a,bare constants and CD is the detector capacitance

– Bias resistor: source of thermal noise

V bias

R bias

integrator shaper

t rise TM

V out

n+

np+

oxideCb

G

MLEAKN TI∝σ

DN bCa +∝σ

BIASN R

1∝σ

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL37

Page 38: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

pre-ampleakage

(ignore scale, just an example)

Signal readout is a (delicate) balance “between” S/N, speed, power,…

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL38

Page 39: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Readout Electronics

• Large channel count and complexity require custom readout chips (ASICs)• On-chip complexity increases with process evolution• Speed and noise performance have kept up with requirements but S/N

always remains an issue.• Mixed analog-digital signals on the same chip

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL39

Page 40: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Historical Note• First silicon tracker for a hadron collider was proposed ~1985 by the INFN Pisa

group for CDF at Fermilab the “SVX”– 4 layers of silicon microstrips, 2-7 cm radii– 50K channels– Expected luminosity was 1029 (100 nb-1), (dose ~few KRad)– Primary purpose was to discover top by (real) W tb– Not expected to do any significant B physics

• Many were skeptical about this application– “it will flood the rest of the detector with secondaries” – “it will be impossible to maintain required mechanical precision”– “it will be inefficient”– “it will burn up due to radiation”– “it will be unreliable or never work at all”– “anyway there is no physics to do with it…”

• This device was crucial to the discovery of the top quark by CDF and opened up the field of precision B physics at hadron colliders.

• All collider detectors now include silicon tracking

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL40

Page 41: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL41

Page 42: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

1995-2005Top Quark 10th Anniversary

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL42

Page 43: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL43

Page 44: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Developmentgeneration year luminosity ∆T channels dose readout

1CDF SVX

1990 1029 3.5 µs

3.5 µs

128 ns

25 ns

12 ns (?)

50K 25 Krad 3 µm CMOS

2CDF SVX*

1995 1030 100K 100 Krad 1.2 µm RHCMOS

3Run 2

2000 1032 500K 1 Mrad, 1013 .8 µmRHCMOS

4CERNLHC

2008 1034 106 strips108 pixels

10 Mrad1015

.25 µm CMOSCommercialBiCMOS

5SuperLHC

2015 1035 107 strips109 pixels

100M 1016 0.13 µm CMOSCommercial

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL44

Page 45: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

CERN ATLAS tracker (4th generation, beam in 2008)

2 m.

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL45

Page 46: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Radiation Environment

• Primary source are collision products– High energy charged particles– Neutrals from interactions

• Additional component due to “accidents”• Collisions occur over extended line – many cm• Primary field falls with radius as ~r -(1-2)

• Each interaction yields ~7 particles/angular unit– Sum crossings– Sum interactions/crossing

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL46

Page 47: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Radiation Levels

• Fluence and dose have increased >104 since mid-80’s– Near future expect unprecedented dose

• 100 Mrad absorbed energy (units)• 1015-1016 particles/cm2

• Compare to: space (~1 MRad), nuclear weapons (~1013)

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL47

Page 48: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Radiation Effects: Ionizing• Incident particle interacts with atomic electrons• Measure in energy absorbed (rads (Si))• e/h pairs created, recombine or trap• Transient effect

– Actual signal formation– Single event upset condition in circuits

• Electronics: charge trapping at Si/SiO2 interface (largely controlled by rad-hard circuit designs or thinner oxides)

• Detectors: surface effects

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL48

Page 49: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Electronics

• For presently operating systems commercial radhardCMOS has provided sufficient resistance.

• For next generation plan to use commercial deep submicron CMOS– Thin oxides provide automatic hardness– Augment design rules with enclosed gate geometries to

block radiation induced leakage paths (at some circuit density penalty)

– Tests have demonstrated sufficient resistance

• Certain bipolar technologies are also radhard (analog)Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL

49

Page 50: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Radiation Effects: Non-ionizing

• Incident particle interacts with atom– Displacement damage – permanent or slow to

reverse– 2nd order effects as defects interact over time

• Depends upon particle type and energy • Measure in particles/cm2

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL50

Page 51: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Radiation Effects: Detectors

• Damage to the periodic lattice creates mid-gap states

• Increased leakage– Shot noise– Power– Heat

areajunction density trap

velocityermalcarrier thsection crossion recombinat

ionconcentratcarrier intrinsic2

)(

==

===

=

ANv

n

WANvenI

T

thermal

i

TthermaliL

σ

σ

( ) kTEL

aeTTI 2/2 −∝

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL51

Page 52: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Reverse current with fluence and time

degrees) 7every doubles(current 0@2 LHC @/1010 Flux Incident

102 Volume

1032constant Damage

21514

33

17

CAIcmparticles

cmVcm

AmpVI

α

α

≈∆⇒

−≈Φ

×≈

×−≈

Φ=∆

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL52

Page 53: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Thermal Run-away

Power density µw/mm2

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL53

Page 54: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Change in effective acceptor concentration

Effective space charge (Neff ⇒ Vfd) with fluence and time

∆Νeff(Φeq,t,T) = Na(Φeq,t,T) + NC(Φeq) + NY(Φeq,t,T)= beneficial annealing + stable damage + reverse annealing

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL54

Page 55: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

• Creation of new acceptor states or removal of donor states

– Effective change of resistivity– Semiconductor type inversion: n becomes p– Depletion voltage changes in proportion to absolute value

of number of effective acceptors higher voltage operation required

– Dramatic time and temperature dependence

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL55

Page 56: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Charge Collection• Reduction in charge collection efficiency (CCE)

– Ne,h(t) = N0 exp (-t/τtrap)– Ratio of collection and charge trapping time constants

evolves with fluence

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL56

GregorKramberger, Ljubljana

Page 57: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Methods to Control Radiation Effects

• Most represent some tradeoff• Size matters

– Smaller volumes generate less leakage current (but require more channels, power, heat…)

– Thinner detectors deplete at lower voltage (but usually means less signal)

• Temperature– Low temperature (-10 C) operation can “stabilize” reverse

annealing for < 1014

– Reduce leakage current effects

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL57

Page 58: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

• Integration time– Current noise is reduced for short shaping times at the expense of

increased pre-amp noise, power.• Biasing schemes

– Reduce value of parallel biasing resistor to reduce voltage drop due to ILeakRbias at the expense of increased thermal noise

• HV operation– Configure detectors to withstand higher voltage operation– Tolerate increased depletion voltage– Operate in partial depletion (collection issues)

• Low noise electronics– Tolerate reduced signal due to CCE and partial depletion

• Configuration– p in n substrate – simple, type inverts– n in n substrate – 2 sided process, can be operated in partial depletion

after inversion– n in p – a bit exotic, does not invert

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL58

Page 59: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL59

Udepl vs time (total fluence 1.4e14)

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

0 365 730 1095 1460 1825 2190 2555 2920 3285 3650

Time [days]

Dep

letio

n vo

ltage

[Vol

t]

2 days at 20°C, 28 days at 17°C

2days at 20°C, 14 days at 17°C

2 days at 20°C, 7 days at 17°C

2 days at 20°C

no maintenance (always -7°C)

251 V at t=3385d

218 V at t=3385d

197 V at t=3385d

174 V at t=3385d

160 V at t=3385d

Simulation of 10 year operating scenarios for silicon tracking at the LHCL= 1033-1034

Page 60: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Design of silicon strip detectors with multiple guard ringstructures to tolerate HV=500 V operation

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL60

Page 61: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

New developments• RD efforts organized at CERN

– RD42: development of diamond as detector– RD48: radiation damage to silicon– RD50: development of radiation resistant detectors– RD39: cryogenic detectors and systems– http://rdXY.web.cern.ch/rdXY

• Engineered materials• New configurations• Cryogenics• Other materials

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL61

Page 62: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Engineered Silicon

• Microscopic understanding of damage mechanisms, defects, and kinetics– Modeling– Measurements– Time and temperature dependence

• Engineer the silicon for greater radiation resistance

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL62

Page 63: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Neff: 24 GeV/c protons. No benefit with neutrons.

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL63

Page 64: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL64

3D silicon detectors were proposed in 1995 by S. Parker, and active edges in 1997 by C. Kenney.

Combine traditional VLSI processing andMEMS (Micro Electro Mechanical Systems)technology.

Electrodes are processed inside the detectorbulk instead of being implanted on the Wafer's surface.

The edge is an electrode! Dead volume at the Edge < 2 microns! Essential for -Large area coverage-Forward physics

3D Detectors 3D Detectors

1. NIMA 395 (1997) 328 2. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 464 (1999) 12243. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 482 (2001) 1894. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 485 (2001) 1629 5. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci 48 6 (2001) 2405 6. CERN Courier, Vol 43, Jan 2003, pp

23-267. NIMA 509 (2003)86-91

Page 65: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL65

12 µm

Dd

An early test structure by Julie Segal, etched and coated (middle, right), showing conformal nature of poly coat.

An electrode hole, filled,broken (accidentally) in a plane through the axis, showing grain structure (below). The surface poly is later etched off.

290 µm

coated, top

coated, bottom

uncoated

Examples of etching and coating with polysilicon.

Page 66: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

1. 3D lateral cell size can be smaller than wafer thickness, so

2. in 3D, field lines end on cylinders rather than on circles, so

3. most of the signal is induced when the charge is close to theelectrode, where the electrode solid angle is large, so planarsignals are spread out in time as the charge arrives, and

4. Landau fluctuations along track arrive sequentially and may cause secondary peaks (see next slide)

5. if readout has inputs from both n+ and p+ electrodes,

6. for long, narrow pixels and fast electronics,

Speed: planar 3D

1. shorter collection distance

2. higher average fields for any given maximum field (price: larger electrode capacitance)

3. 3D signals are concentrated in time as the track arrives

4. Landau fluctuations arrive nearly simultaneously

5. drift time corrections can be made

6. track locations within the pixel can be found

4.

4.

4.

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL66

Page 67: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Cryogenic operation

• Palmieri et al (1998) recovery of lost CCE at cryogenic temperatures

• “Lazarus Effect” due to freeze-out of traps

• R&D activity centered at CERN (RD39)

• Practical difficulty for “low mass” tracker if substantial cryogenic engineering and infrastructure is required.

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL67

Page 68: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Alternate Materials

• The development of precision tracking for particle physics has benefited greatly from the existence of a worldwide semiconductor industry and technology base built around the element Si

• None-the-less the question can be asked whether other materials could offer advantages

• Would require considerable fabrication capacity somewhere

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL68

Page 69: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL69

Page 70: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Diamond

• Very active R&D effort for >10 years– http://rd48.web.cern.ch/RD48/

• Most work has been on pCVD material– Significant improvement in charge collection

• New results on single crystal materials – but small samples

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL70

Page 71: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Harris Kagan http://rd42.web.cern.ch/RD42/

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL71

Page 72: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Thanks to: Alexander Oh

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL72

Page 73: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL73

Page 74: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

New Technical Directions

• In support of tracking systems which operate at very high luminosity a number of new technical directions are being explored.– Rad hard devices and electronics– Lower mass materials, supports, services– Segmentation– Large area coverage– Data readout, transmission, and processing

(triggers)

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL74

Page 75: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Segmentation• Silicon strip sensor designs and geometries• Pixel geometries• Pixel-Strip transition• Z readout methods• Front end readout electronics in evolving processes

– 0.25, 0.13… mm– SiGe

• Interconnections– bump bonding methods at finer pitch (r < 20 cm– Pixel readout of superpixel geometry

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL75

Page 76: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Interleaved Stripixel Detector (ISD) -illustration of the concept (BNL Group Z.Li)

X-cell(1st Al)

Contact to2nd Al onX-pixel

Line connecting Y-pixels

(1st Al)

FWHM for chargediffusion

X-stripreadouts(2nd Al)

Y-stripreadouts

Y-cell(1st Al)The gaps between pixels

are enlarged for clearer illustration

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL76

Page 77: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Lower Mass• Large area and precision low mass mechanics• Alignment technology (lasers, sensors)

– Drop stiffness requirements in favor of active monitoring and feedback (lesson from the telescope builders).

• Low mass electrical and mechanical components including discretes & substrates– Power distribution schemes, current mode power with local regulation,

less redundancy, grounding issues– Technologies for hybrid circuits – thick, thin films, laminates

• Cooling technology – materials, coolants, delivery systems– Simplified coolant distribution– Heat pipe schemes– Cooling integrated with FE electronics– Reduced power consumption

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL77

Page 78: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Example of reduced mass structure for silicon detectors

Silicon Sensors4mm separation

Carbon Fiber Skin

Peek Cooling channels

Embedded electricalBus cable

Hybrid electronics

Foam Core

Material/stave: • 1.8% RL • 124 grams

Includes cooling, services and most of support

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL78

Fraction of Total RL:• Hybrids 13%• Sensors 39%• Bus Cable 17%• CF/Coolant 29%

Page 79: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Large Area Coverage

• Robotic assembly and test methods• Large area and precision low mass mechanics• Project organization• Reliability and redundancy methods

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL79

Page 80: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Example of robotics & large scale organization: CMS assembly with identical systems at 7 sites to produce ~20K modules

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL80

Page 81: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Data readout, transmission, and processing

• Optical data transmission• Wireless data transmission• Pattern recognition and data reduction methods• Large area and fine line lithographic methods

– Cables to link sensors to remote front end chips– Power cables– Signal distribution networks

• Fast track trigger processors – Vertex triggers (CDF SVT)– Momentum measurement

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL81

Page 82: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Technology Development Shopping List

• Radiation resistance of silicon and other solids• Radiation hard electronics – smaller feature size IC’s• Signal processing and circuit design• Pixel architectures, monolithic and active pixel sensors• Fast CCD and CMOS imagers, rad hard• Real time fast trigger processors• Large area and precision low mass mechanics• Alignment technology (lasers, sensors)• Low mass electrical and mechanical components including discretes & substrates• Cooling technology – materials, coolants, delivery systems• Pattern recognition and data reduction methods• Reliability and redundancy methods• Large area, fine line, lithographic methods• Robotic methods for assembly and test• Wireless data transfer• Optical readout methods

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL82

Page 83: Tracking with Semiconductor Particle Detectors - Physics: Home

Conclusions

• Significant progress ~20 years to build trackers using semiconductor technology

• Much significant science done with these devices

• Progress in understanding and compensating for effects of radiation over a range of 104

• R&D underway for next generation

Nov 16, 2005 UC Davis Physics Carl Haber LBNL83