Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
Transcript of Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 1/43
BEST PRACTICES IN CONSTRUCTIONINDUSTRY SEMINAR (BPCI 2008)
“ TOLLED ROAD-PAST, PRESENT &FUTURE “
By:
Y. Bhg. Dato’ Ir. Haji Mohamad Razali B. OthmanDirector General
Malaysian Highway Authority
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 2/43
CONTENT
-INTRODUCTION
-HIGHWAY DEVELOPMENT
-PAST
-PRESENT-FUTURE
-CONCLUSION
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 3/43
INTRODUCTION
• Road privatization policy started in 1983
North Klang Straits Bypass (NKSB) By Shapadu Comp. Ltd. (1983)
Jalan Kuching Highway by Kamunting Corporation (1986)
North – South Expressway (1989)
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 4/43
HIGHWAY DEVELOPMENT
219
485
960
1,220
1,507
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
81-85 (4th
plan)
86-90 (5th
Plan)
91-95 (6th
Plan)
96-00 (7th
Plan)
01-05 (8th
Plan)
Period of Malaysian Plan
T o t a l l e
n g t h ( k m )
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 5/43
Total Road Length in Malaysia ('000 km)
10.4
77.2
14.5
64.3 65.2
18.0
38.9
-
20.0
40.0
60.0
80.0
100.0
55 65 75 85 95 99 `07
Year
T o t a l L e n g t h
( ' 0 0 0 k m )
From the Bar chart showed the increase of the road length in Malaysia (excluding
rural & village road) from 66,391 kilometers to 77,240 kilometers in 2007.
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 6/43
PAST
• Federal Government decided to embark
construction of a toll expressway (1977)
• The decision was based on :
From Bukit Kayu Hitam to Johor Bahru known as
North – South Expressway
•The general Transportation Study of Malaysia (1967-1968)
•The Malaysian Highway feasibility Study (1970-1971)
•Feasibility study and Toll Application (1977-1979)
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 7/43
MAIN OBJECTIVE
HAVING THE
HIGHWAY
Provide an efficient network
system of highway
Accelerate economic growth
Supplement the existing
Federal Route 1
Help to alleviate traffic
congestion along Federal
Route 1
Facilitate fast anduninterrupted movement of
traffic
Provide a smooth,
comfortable and safe ride
Using international standards
•Able to reduce vehicle operating
cost
•
Reduce traveling time
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 8/43
PRESENT
TOLL HIGHWAYS
Under Planning:
•2 nos of highway
Under Construction:
•7 nos of highway
Under Operation:
•23 highways operated by 17Concession Company
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 9/43
Bil HighwayRoute No.
Highway Length
1. E1 North – South Expressway 823.0 Km
2. E36 Penang Bridge 13.5 Km
3. E8 Kuala Lumpur –
Karak Highway 60.0 Km4. E15 Butterworth – Kulim Expressway 16.8 Km
5. E5 Shah Alam Expressway 35.0 Km
6. E6 North – South Expressway Central Link 48.0 Km
7. E29 Seremban – Port Dickson Expressway 22.7 Km
8. E3 Malaysian – Singapore SecondCrossing Expressway
44.7 Km
9. E11 Damansara – Puchong Highway. 40.0 Km
10. E7 Cheras – Kajang Highway 11.7 Km
11. E9 Sungai Besi Expressway 16.7 Km
Highway In Operation :
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 10/43
Cont..Highway In Operation :
Bil HighwayRoute No.
Highway Length
12. E12 Kuala Lumpur – Ampang Elevated Highway 7.4 Km
13. E23 Western Kuala Lumpur Traffic DispersalScheme
26.0 Km
14. E18 Kajang Traffic Dispersal Ring Road 37.0 Km
15. E10 New Pantai Expressway 19.6 Km
16. E35 Shah Alam – Kuang Expressway 25.0 Km
17. E8 East Coast Highway (Phase1) 169.0 Km
18. E30 North Klang Straits Bypass 8.0 Km
19. E30 New North Klang Straits Bypass 7.5 Km20. E17 Butterworth Outer Ring Road 12.1 Km
21. E38 Storm Water Management And Road Tunnel(SMART)
3.06 Km
22.- Jln Cheras, Sambungan Timur-Barat,
Lebuhraya Sungai Besi (Lebuhraya Metramac)25.0 Km
23. E20 Kuala Lumpur – Putrajaya Highway 26.0 Km
TOTAL LENGTH : 1507.56 Km
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 11/43
Highway In Operation :
NORTH - SOUTH EXPRESSWAY (PLUS) ( 848 KM )
TOLL PLAZAS - OPEN 7 NOS., CLOSED - 60 NOS.
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 12/43
(before upgrading)
KUALA LUMPUR - KARAK HIGHWAY (KL-KARAK) ( 60 KM )
TOLL PLAZAS (OPEN) - 2 NOS.
Highway In Operation :
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 13/43
WESTERN KL TRAFFIC DISPERSAL SCHEME (SPRINT) (26 KM)
TOLL PLAZAS – 3 NOS. INTERCHANGES – 13 NOS.
Highway In Operation :
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 14/43
AMPANG-KL ELEVATED HIGHWAY (AKLEH) ( 7.4 KM )
TOLL PLAZAS OPEN -1 NO.
Highway In Operation :
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 15/43
PRESENT CONSTRUCTION
• Most of present toll highways – urban area
• Through heavily populated area
•
Mitigation measure needed in solvingproblem
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 16/43
• ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEM (SENAI – DESARU
EXPRESSWAY)
MITIGATION MEASURES:
•Safeguarding water Catchment from contaminated spillage
SDE highway alignment traverses through Sg. Layang Water Catchment
Pollutant Removal System (PRS) sited at strategic location
The objective to remove the chemical/pollutants from the surface runoff,
preventing them from reaching the water catchment
PRS essentially comprises 4 component:-Grass Swale
Grass Pollutant Trap
Oil / grease / chemical Filtration
Retention
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 17/43
MITIGATION MEASURES:
Pollutant Removal System
Process
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 18/43
•LAND USE PROBLEM
•Land scarcity
•
Space constraint – urban area
•Increase usage of highway by local commuter – cause congestion
•The experience of dealing with the problem:-
•DUKE Highway
•SPRINT Highway
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 19/43
• DUKE HIGHWAY PROJECTMITIGATION MEASURES:
LIMITATION OF RIGHT OF WAY (R.O.W)
Redesigning the
drainage system to
suite the R.O.W
condition
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 20/43
• DUKE HIGHWAY PROJECTMITIGATION MEASURES:
LIMITATION OF RIGHT OF WAY (R.O.W)
Application of
Reinforcement
Concrete wall for a
spacious carriageway
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 21/43
ii) Reconfiguration of InterchangesMITIGATION MEASURES:
LIMITATION OF RIGHT OF WAY (R.O.W)
•Reconfiguration of interchanges
(eg: Sentul Pasar Interchange)•Advantages :-
•No acquisition for drainage
reserve
•Providing free flow of water
•No interfacing with flood
mitigation structure
*Interchange Design to skirt around the Existing detention pond by JPS as a flood
mitigation measure
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 22/43
iii) Sharing of TNB power line reserveMITIGATION MEASURES:
LIMITATION OF RIGHT OF WAY (R.O.W)
Existing Reserve = 40 m
13.4 m10 m
13.4 m
1.6m1.6m
6 m
6 m
6 m
12 m
•Original proposal – separate reserve
for highway and TNB power lines
•Benefits:-
•29 houses & 5 shops not to be
acquired
•
Live line maintenance from thedeck
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 23/43
• SPRINT HIGHWAY PROJECTMITIGATION MEASURES:
•Designed using innovative methods to minimise land use and disruption to
the environment during construction.
•700 m Bored tunneling construction
method through a hill as a direct
access through Penchala
•To preserve the ecology and
environmental
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 24/43
• SPRINT HIGHWAY PROJECTMITIGATION MEASURES:
•Designed using innovative methods to minimise land use and disruption to
the environment during construction.
•First in Malaysia to feature double
deck structure
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 25/43
• Traffic congestion problem at toll plazas
MITIGATION MEASURES:
•Introduction of Electronic Toll Collection (ETC) occurs after
completion of the NSE in Sept. 1994.
•
Earlier stage of implementation, less number of highway usersusing this system.
•Number had increase yearly due to the increase in number of
highway users which resulted to traffic congestion at toll plazas
especially during peak hours and festive seasons.
•Starting from 1 July 2004, Government decided to use only one
ETC system namely Touch & Go.
•It can be used for other purposes such as public transport and
public parking.
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 26/43
• Traffic congestion problem at toll plazasMITIGATION MEASURES:
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
T O T A L T R A F F I C
( m i l l i o n )
YEAR
TNG & Smart Tag
Total Traffic
Comparison between the use of Electronic Toll System (ETC)
and total number of traffic
Only 41%
use ETC
(TnGo &
smart Tag)
ISSUES
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 27/43
Mitigation measures:
•Preparing GuidelineMitigation measures:
•Government compensation
•Re-evaluating C.A and
renegotiate the term
Mitigation measures:
•Coordination between
Government agencies
and private company
•Improve C.A
Mitigation measures:
•Impose penalty
•Established KPI
ISSUES
TOLL
•A sensitive issues and become
major problem in the country
LAND
•Land cost much higher than
estimated in implementation
stage
IMPROVEMENT TO
CONCESSION AGREEMENT
•Set-up committee to re-
evaluate the existing C.A and
improve it.
CONGESTION
•Growth development -
generated traffic &
saturated
•Bottleneck and user’s
behaviour
ISSUES
CUSTOMER
SATISFACTION
•Engage consultant
to get feedback from
customer
80% as a benchmark, improve
some complain and comment
from customer
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 28/43
• Land issue
•Land cost – critical components and big impact to overall project cost
•Planning stage – estimated land cost
•Implementation stage – land cost are higher than estimated•Due to affected lots converted their status (plantation to residential /
commercial)
•Solution :
•MHA currently preparing new guideline in handling the unacceptable increase in
the land cost
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 29/43
•Toll issue
•Sensitive issues and major problem in the country
•Toll rate and frequency toll rate review – agreed in the Concession Agreement (C.A)
•Toll rate agreed – must be sufficient to cover capital expenditure (CAPEX),
operating expenses (OPEX), financial obligations and returns to the promoters.•No increment toll rate as stipulated - Government must compensate
concessionaires
•Major issues – acceptable & affordable toll rate
•Solution:
•Currently MHA re-evaluating all the existing C.A term for affordable toll rate
•Action taken – concession period extension, toll rate restructuring
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 30/43
• Congestion issue
•Congestion contribution:-
•Development in the vicinity of the highway
•Existing bottleneck•Users behavior - weaving
•Effect – stress, waste of fuel, waste of time, emits smoke
•Solution:
•Coordination between government agencies and private company
•Improvement to C.A prior to traffic congestion problem
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 31/43
• Improvement to Concession Agreement
•MHA planning department set-up a committee – to re-evaluate & improve C.A
• Solution:•To impose LAD – project completed as schedule
•To impose penalty – non compliance and non conformity
•Established Key Performance Indicator (KPI) – standardize work performance
•May instruct Concession Company to review the traffic forecast
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 32/43
• Customer (Highway User’s) Satisfaction•Overall satisfaction Index of the Highway for the year 2007 reflected that Malaysian
road users were satisfied (rated as ‘four star’/’good) With scored for all highways
between (66%-85%)
•Survey base on five major area as listed below:
•Highways Management
•Toll Plaza Management
•Ronda Services
•Rest Service Area
•Lay By service
• From the finding, mitigation measures to improves the Costumer Satisfaction Indexwill carried out by Concession company
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 33/43
FUTURE
FLEXIBLE TOLL
SYSTEMS
TRAFFIC MODEL
STUDY
TENDERING OF
NEW HIGHWAY
FLAT TOLL RATE
MULTI LANE FREE
FLOW (MLFF)
SHADOW TOLL
MHA’S TRAFFIC
MONITORING
CENTRE
FUTURE
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 34/43
• Future highway development programme
•Government still embark on privatisation programme through:-
•Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT)•Private Finance Initiative
•Reviewing the Highway Network Development Plan (HNDP)
•Viable project for privatisation
•Impact on National economy
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 35/43
• Flexible Toll Systems
•Toll discount on non peak hour
•10% discount starting 1 Jan 2009 for NSE and ELITE highway
•Discount period from 12.00 am to 7.00am
•Massive traffic congestion due to accident / festivals season
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 36/43
• Flat Toll Rate
•One toll rate until the end of the concession period
•No toll rate increment
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 37/43
• Multi Lane free Flow (MLFF)
•Latest toll electronic collecting system in Malaysia
•Will encourage smooth traffic movement
•Capacity of peak hour transition rate – 2200 vehicle per lane per hour
•Government in process of trial – December 2008•Toll Plaza Penchala, Damansara – Puchong Highway
•Toll Plaza Batu 3, federal Highway 2
•Expert involved in the trial:-
•Mitsubishi Group and Kapsch Com
•Objective of the trial:-
•Study system effectiveness in term of safety and practicality aspect
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 38/43
• Shadow Toll
•Has been implemented in several countries in Europe
•Modified version need to be look before applying in Malaysia
•Method:-
•No toll paying by user at toll booth
•Government pay to the Company based on number of traffic
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 39/43
• Tendering of new Highway in Malaysia
•Implementing an open tender concept for new privatized highway
•To ensure transparency – reasonable and competitive price
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 40/43
• Traffic Model study for Klang Valley and its
conurbation
•A study for the new traffic model
•Basically to develop Traffic Demand Forecasting Model
•Finding and analysis – Land use, Socio-economic Framework, traffic survey
•Will assist Government in evaluating and choosing viable road project
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 41/43
• MHA Traffic Monitoring Centre
•Collecting and disseminating traffic
information in real time basis on toll
highway to the public
CONCLUSION
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 42/43
CONCLUSION
•Improvement have been done to make sure the toll highway are built of the best
quality, maintain and operated in the best conditions.
•Continuous negotiation and discussion between Government and Concession
Company in all stages are an important for the successful of project.
•Innovation and optimisation in the design, construction, operation and maintenance
has resulted in having a highway of the best quality and at reasonable price.
•When dealing in urban construction – need to reduce impact on social and
environmental.
•Win-win situation between Government and Private sector:
•Government – get infrastructure early, quality•Private sector – get the reasonable return from the investment
•Future- to fulfill the customer satisfaction
•Way forward-MHA TMC as a National Traffic Information Centre
•MHA as a Public Sector Comparator (PSC) to concession companies
8/3/2019 Tolled Road - Past, Present & Future
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tolled-road-past-present-future 43/43
THANK YOUTHANK YOU
TERIMA KASIH