tmi12032.pdf

7
 Financial burden of health care for HIV/AIDS patients in Vietnam Bach X. Tran 1,2 , Anh T. Duong 3 , Long T. Nguyen 3 , Jongnam Hwang 1 , Binh T. Nguyen 3 , Quynh T. Nguyen 4 , Vuong M. Nong 2 , Phu X. Vu 6 and Arto Ohinmaa 1,5 1 School of Public Health, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada 2 Institute for Preventive Medicine and Public Health, Hanoi Medical University, Hanoi, Vietnam 3 Authority of HIV/AIDS Control, Ministry of Health, Hanoi, Vietnam 4 University of Nantes at Foreign Trade University, Hanoi, Vietnam 5 Institute of Health Economics, Alberta, Edmonton, Canada 6 Department of Health Economics, Hanoi School of Public Health, Hanoi, Vietnam Abstract  objective  To assess the out-of -pock et (OOP) payments for health-ca re service s of HIV/AIDS patients, and identify associated factors in Vietnam. methods  Cross-sectional multisite survey of 1016 HIV/AIDS patients attending 7 hospitals and health centres in Ha Noi, Hai Phong and Ho Chi Minh City in 2012. results  HIV/AIDS patients used inpat ient and outpati ent care on average 5.1 times (95% CI  = 4.7   5.4) besides ART services. Inpatient care cost US$ 461 on average and outpatient care US$ 50. Mean annual health-care expenditure for HIV/AIDS patients was US$ 188 (95% CI  = 148   229). 35.1% of households (95% CI  = 32.2   38.1) experienced catastrophic health expenditure; 73.3% (95% CI  = 70.6   76.1) of households would be affected if ART were not subsidised. Being a patient at a prov incia l clini c, male sex, unstable emplo ymen t, being in the poor est income quintil e, a CD4 count of  <200 cells/mL and not yet receiving ART increased the likelihood of catastrophic medical expense. conclusions  HIV/AIDS patient s in Vietn am frequent ly use medica l services and incur OOP payments for health care. Scaling up free-of-charge ART services, earlier access to and initiation of ART, and decentralisation and integration of HIV/AIDS-related services could reduce their nancial burden. keywords  HIV/AIDS, antiretroviral treatment, cost, out-of-pocket expenditure, nancial burden, Vietnam Introduction Over the past decade, antiretro viral treatment (ART) has been rapidly scaled-up in develo ping countries with sub- stantial supports from global health initiatives (Vella et al.  2012). With ART patients can achieve suppression of HIV replication, improve their health and quality of life and continue to be productive (Gardner  et al.  2010; Tran 2012). Although ART has been subsidised, out-of- pocke t (OOP) paymen ts for HIV/AIDS care remain high and could affect treatment compliance and outcomes (Duraisamy  et al.  2006; Moon  et al.  2008; Riyarto  et al. 2010). Therefore, understanding the nancial burden of HIV/AIDS is necessary to develop protective mechanisms, and improve efciency of the health-ca re system. In Vietnam, an estima ted 320,000 people have HIV/ AIDS, and 30% require ART at the treatment eligibility criterion of a CD4 count of  <250 cells/ml (Ministry of Health 2008) . Patie nts with HIV/AIDS are provi ded free- of-charge antiretroviral drugs, CD4 cell count tests and medications for opportunistic infections. However, some HIV/AIDS-re lated services are not covered, such as viral load tests, hospital admission fee or diagnosis and treat- ment of comorbid diseases. Patients also bear the costs of other health-care services, which are high and can push these economica lly vulner able people into poverty. The economic impact of the ART programme is still modest: rstly, because of its moderate coverage, which was 50% by 2010. Secondly, patients usually seek health care and initiate ART very late, when their immune system has deteriorated with severe comorbid diseases (Do  et al. 2012). Third ly, as the majority of HIV/A IDS patients engage d in high-risk behavio urs such as drug injectio n and sex work, they often lack stable jobs and steady incomes, and are less capable to pay for health-care ser- vices (Tran et al.  2011, 2012a,b). Although OOP health 212  © 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Tropical Medicine and International Health doi:10.1111/tmi.12032 volume 18 no 2 pp 212  218 february 2013

Transcript of tmi12032.pdf

  • Financial burden of health care for HIV/AIDS patients in

    Vietnam

    Bach X. Tran1,2, Anh T. Duong3, Long T. Nguyen3, Jongnam Hwang1, Binh T. Nguyen3, Quynh T. Nguyen4,

    Vuong M. Nong2, Phu X. Vu6 and Arto Ohinmaa1,5

    1 School of Public Health, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada2 Institute for Preventive Medicine and Public Health, Hanoi Medical University, Hanoi, Vietnam3 Authority of HIV/AIDS Control, Ministry of Health, Hanoi, Vietnam4 University of Nantes at Foreign Trade University, Hanoi, Vietnam5 Institute of Health Economics, Alberta, Edmonton, Canada6 Department of Health Economics, Hanoi School of Public Health, Hanoi, Vietnam

    Abstract objective To assess the out-of-pocket (OOP) payments for health-care services of HIV/AIDSpatients, and identify associated factors in Vietnam.

    methods Cross-sectional multisite survey of 1016 HIV/AIDS patients attending 7 hospitals andhealth centres in Ha Noi, Hai Phong and Ho Chi Minh City in 2012.

    results HIV/AIDS patients used inpatient and outpatient care on average 5.1 times (95%CI = 4.75.4) besides ART services. Inpatient care cost US$ 461 on average and outpatient care US$50. Mean annual health-care expenditure for HIV/AIDS patients was US$ 188 (95% CI = 148229).35.1% of households (95% CI = 32.238.1) experienced catastrophic health expenditure; 73.3%(95% CI = 70.676.1) of households would be affected if ART were not subsidised. Being a patient ata provincial clinic, male sex, unstable employment, being in the poorest income quintile, a CD4 count

    of

  • payments prevail among patients with HIV/AIDS, there is

    little evidence on the economic impact of HIV/AIDS in

    Vietnam. In this study, we sought to evaluate the finan-

    cial burden of health care for HIV/AIDS patients in a

    multisite survey. Specifically, we assessed the rate of

    health service use and OOP health payments of HIV/

    AIDS patients, and identified associated factors.

    Methods

    Study settings and participants

    We conducted a cross-sectional multisite survey in Ha

    Noi, Hai Phong and Ho Chi Minh City from January to

    February, 2012. These cities were selected because they

    experienced the countrys largest HIV epidemics, and they

    have been implementing comprehensive HIV/AIDS inter-

    ventions. The present study is a part of a greater effort,

    namely the 2012 HIV Service Users Survey, to assess the

    effectiveness and performance of HIV/AIDS services to

    inform policy development in Vietnam (Tran 2012). In

    each city, we selected study sites based on the following

    criteria: (i) Central, provincial and district clinics were

    involved; (ii) hospitals/health centres have been providing

    ART services; and (iii) there was a sufficient number of

    HIV/AIDS patients in each clinic. There were seven sites

    purposively selected, including one central hospital

    (National Hospital of Tropical Diseases), three provincial

    hospitals (Dong Da, Viet Tiep and Ho Chi Minh Hospital

    for Tropical Diseases) and three district health centres

    (Tu Liem, Binh Tan and Le Chan District Health Centres).

    As constructing a sample frame was not possible due to

    confidentiality; we selected patients on a convenient basis.

    Subjects were HIV-positive inpatients and outpatients

    who were registering for care or taking ART at selected

    sites. All patients present at the clinics during the study

    period were invited to participate in the survey, and gave

    written consent if they agreed. We recruited patients until

    a sufficient sample size of at least 100 was reached per site.

    Measures

    Socio-economic background and HIV-related characteris-

    tics of patients were collected using face-to-face interviews

    with structured questionnaires. Monthly household

    income was self-reported including all sources of each

    household members income in 2011, such as salary,

    wages, pensions, relatives supports, interests and reve-

    nues. Households expenditure was estimated including

    recurring expenses in the last month (e.g. food, utility,

    rent, education and others), and non-recurring expenses in

    the last 12 months (e.g. construction, health care,

    furniture, travels, community events and others). Seven

    hundred and ninety (77.8%) patients responded to the

    questions regarding household expenditure. The OOP

    health expenditure of household included the total

    expenses for health-care services of all family members

    including HIV-positive individuals. Healthcare service

    utilisation of HIV-positive individuals included any inpa-

    tient and outpatient care received during the past

    3 months, excluding regular HIV outpatient clinic visits

    for ARV medications. The 3-month recall of health service

    use was commonly applied in previous national surveys

    (Chaudhuri & Roy 2008). For the convenience of report-

    ing, we converted the frequency of health service use for

    1 year. Although patients at different disease stages or

    periods of ART could use healthcare services differently,

    this conversion did not distort the mean rate of use. Unit

    costs were estimated for the last inpatient- and outpatient

    care. Patients were asked about any expenses incurring

    during their last use of healthcare services. It included

    (i) medical expenditures (non-ARV medications, lab tests,

    hospital fees and others) and (ii) non-medical expenditures

    (transportations, accommodation and special meals if

    any). OOP health payments for HIV/AIDS patients were

    estimated by multiplying the rate of health service use by

    the mean costs of each visit. All expenditures and incomes

    were converted from Vietnam Dong to US$ using the

    exchange rate in 2011 (1 US$ = 20,500 Vietnam Dong).

    Data analysis

    Analysis of variance test was used to examine the differ-

    ences between means. Household expenditure categories

    were presented in both means (95% CI) and medians (in-

    terquartile ranges). Catastrophic health expenditure was

    defined at the threshold of 40% total households

    monthly non-subsistence expenditure (Xu et al. 2003).

    Multivariable logistic was used to determine correlates of

    experiencing catastrophic OOP health expenditure. Zero-

    inflated Poisson models were constructed to examine the

    correlates of the rate of health service use. Candidate

    independent variables included socio-economic and HIV-

    related characteristics of respondents at the time of the

    interview. Collinearity was examined using the variance

    inflation factors. We applied a stepwise forward model

    building strategy that selected variables based on the log-

    likelihood ratio test at a P-value 0.2 (Hosmer & Lemeshow 2000).

    Ethics

    This is a part of the research project on Cost and cost-

    effectiveness of HIV/AIDS care and treatment policy

    2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 213

    Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 18 no 2 pp 212218 february 2013

    B. X. Tran et al. Financial burden of HIV in Vietnam

  • options in Vietnam. The use of data was approved by

    the Authority of HIV/AIDS Control, Ministry of Health

    of Vietnam. Ethical approval was granted by the Univer-

    sity of Albertas Health Research Ethics Board.

    Results

    The response rate was 85-90% in different clinics. We

    interviewed 1016 patients, accounting for 17% of total

    HIV patients in selected sites. Mean age was 35.4

    (SD = 7.0) years, 36.2% were female, 45.0% had com-pleted high school, 64.0% were living with spouses or

    partners and more than 70% were freelancers or had sta-

    ble jobs. The mean monthly household income was US$

    346.5 (SD = 293.1) or US$ 99.6 (SD = 79.6) per capita(household size was 3.8 people). Besides ART, HIV/AIDS

    patients reported an average number of inpatient and

    outpatient care of 0.3 and 4.8 times in the past

    12 months, respectively. As shown in Table 1, patients at

    central clinics reported a significantly lower rate of health

    service use (1.8 times) than those at provincial (5.8 times)

    and district (5.9 times) clinics (P < 0.01). Patients whowere on the 1st year ART and who had not yet received

    ART also had a higher rate of health service use.

    In Table 2, the monthly household expenditure was US$

    289 (95% CI = 262; 317), of which 47% was food, 5%was health care for HIV/AIDS individuals and 6% was

    health care for other members. There were 33.8% HIV/

    AIDS patients reported having inpatients care, and 32.0%

    having outpatient care over the past 3 months besides

    monthly visits to HIV/AIDS outpatient clinics to receive

    ARV medications (Table 3). The cost of inpatient and out-

    patient care was US$ 461 and US$ 50 on average. Direct

    medical costs accounted for about 60% of the total, half of

    Table 1 Characteristics of respondents and frequency of healthcare service utilisation

    N %

    Heath service utilisation rate per year

    Outpatient Inpatient All

    Mean 95% CI Mean 95% CI Mean 95% CI P-value

    Level of health service administration

    Central 201 19.8 1.4 0.92.0 0.3 0.20.5 1.8 1.22.4 0.00Provincial 406 40.0 5.4 4.85.9 0.4 0.30.5 5.8 5.26.4District 409 40.3 5.8 5.26.3 0.2 0.10.2 5.9 5.46.5

    IDU

    No 548 53.9 4.9 4.45.4 0.3 0.20.3 5.1 4.75.6 0.42Yes 468 46.1 4.6 4.15.1 0.4 0.30.4 5.0 4.45.5

    HIV/AIDS stages

    Asymptomatic 126 12.4 4.8 3.85.7 0.2 0.10.3 4.9 4.05.8 0.14Symptomatic 508 50.0 4.8 4.35.3 0.3 0.20.4 5.1 4.65.6AIDS 382 37.6 4.7 4.15.3 0.3 0.30.4 5.0 4.45.6

    CD4 cell count

    200 249 24.5 4.8 4.15.5 0.5 0.40.7 5.4 4.76.1 0.54200 < cd4 350 249 24.5 5.6 4.86.3 0.2 0.10.3 5.8 5.06.5350 < cd4 500 194 19.1 4.5 3.75.3 0.2 0.10.2 4.7 3.85.5>500 109 10.7 4.3 3.35.3 0.2 0.10.3 4.6 3.55.6Not reported 215 21.2 4.2 3.55.0 0.3 0.20.4 4.5 3.85.3

    Length of ARTNone 114 11.2 5.2 4.36.1 0.2 0.10.4 5.4 4.56.4 0.081 year 196 19.3 4.8 4.05.6 0.6 0.40.7 5.4 4.66.21; 2 144 14.2 4.4 3.55.3 0.2 0.10.3 4.6 3.85.52; 4 270 26.6 4.8 4.15.5 0.2 0.20.3 5.1 4.35.84; 7 292 28.7 4.7 4.05.4 0.2 0.20.3 4.9 4.25.6

    Household expenditure quintiles

    Poorest 158 15.6 5.2 4.26.1 0.3 0.20.4 5.5 4.56.4 0.04Poor 158 15.6 4.1 3.24.9 0.3 0.20.4 4.4 3.65.2Middle 158 15.6 4.9 3.95.8 0.3 0.20.4 5.1 4.26.1Rich 158 15.6 4.0 3.24.9 0.4 0.30.6 4.4 3.65.3Richest 158 15.6 3.6 2.84.4 0.3 0.20.4 3.9 3.14.7Not reported 226 22.2 6.2 5.47.0 0.3 0.20.3 6.4 5.67.2

    214 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd

    Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 18 no 2 pp 212218 february 2013

    B. X. Tran et al. Financial burden of HIV in Vietnam

  • which was medications (excluding ARV) as the greatest

    proportion of the total costs. The mean total expenditure

    for healthcare services for HIV/AIDS individuals was US$

    188 (95% CI = 148229) per annum or US$16 per month(Table 3). There were 35.1% (95% CI = 32.238.1)households with catastrophic OOP payments for health

    care. In a scenario of non-ART subsidy where patients bear

    ART costs, the proportion of household experiencing cata-

    strophic health expenditure would be 73.3% (95%

    CI = 70.676.1). In other words, the free-of-charge ARTprogramme had prevented 52.1% HIV-affected house-

    holds from catastrophic OOP health expenditure.

    Table 4 presents the correlates of catastrophic OOP

    health expenditure and the expected differences in the

    rate of health service use in various patient groups.

    Increased likelihood of incurring catastrophic health

    expenditures was observed in patients at provincial

    clinics, males, those with unstable jobs, those in the poor-

    est income quintile, people with CD4 counts less than

    200 cells/mL, and those not yet receiving ART. In the

    post-estimation of Zero-inflated Poisson model, patients

    who were at provincial and district clinics, female, with

    unstable jobs, with CD4 counts less than 350 cells/mL,

    or who had taken ART for more than 2 years had signifi-

    cantly higher expected rates of health service use than

    their counterparts.

    Discussion

    This study examined OOP expenditure and healthcare

    service utilisation of HIV/AIDS patients in Vietnam.

    Although ART services are offered free-of-charge, HIV/

    AIDS patients had to pay US$ 188 a year for their health

    care. This OOP health payment was catastrophic for

    more than one-third of HIV-affected households. The

    rate of health service use and its associated financial bur-

    den were heterogeneous across central, provincial and

    district clinics, and significantly associated with disease

    severity and the duration of ART.

    The mean income per capita of this patient sample (US

    $99/month) was close to the national mean income

    Table 2 Household monthly expenditures (US$)

    N Median p25 p75 Mean 95% CI

    % of

    total

    expenses

    Food 790 122 73 146 135 128143 47Household utility 790 15 7 24 21 1923 7Rent 790 0 0 0 8 610 3Education 790 8 0 39 25 2328 9Other 790 0 0 24 24 2028 8

    Health care

    For others 790 2 0 12 17 1419 6For HIV/AIDS patients 790 0 0 6 16 1220 5

    Non-recurring expenses

    Construction 790 0 0 0 31 1052 11Furniture 790 0 0 0 4 26 1Travel 790 0 0 0 1 02 0Community events 790 2 0 8 7 68 2

    Total expenditure 790 218 141 320 289 262317 100Expenditure per capita 790 62 42 94 84 7790

    Table 3 Average costs per an inpatient and an outpatient care(US$)

    Inpatient care

    (n = 343,33.8%)

    Outpatient care

    (n = 325,32.0%)

    Mean 95% CI Mean 95% CI

    Costs for an inpatient and an outpatient care

    Total 461 419502 50 4061Direct non-medical costsBoarding and lodging 105 90120 9 612Transportation 67 5777 14 1019

    Direct medical costs 289 262315 29 2235Medication (excl. ARV) 159 119204 14 624Lab tests 31 2341 11 715User fee 64 4387 1 02Others 34 2149 4 26

    Average annual costs for health care for an HIV/AIDS patient

    Times of service used 0.3 0.30.3 4.8 4.45.1Total direct medical cost 54 4166 57 3479Total direct cost 90 69111 98 65131

    Total annual costs 188 148229

    2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 215

    Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 18 no 2 pp 212218 february 2013

    B. X. Tran et al. Financial burden of HIV in Vietnam

  • per capita in 2011 (US$ 108/month). The OOP health pay-

    ment for HIV/AIDS patients in this study was higher than

    that of the general population, which was about US$ 10

    per household in the 2008 Vietnam Living Standards Sur-

    vey, or about US$ 40 per household in another estimate

    (Van Minh 2011; Nguyen et al. 2012). The percentage of

    households that experienced catastrophic health expendi-

    ture due to HIV/AIDS care (35.1%) was substantially

    higher than that of the general Vietnamese population

    (5.7%) (Van Minh 2011). In fact, the OOP health payment

    for an HIV/AIDS patient was as high as the total health

    expenses of all other family members, and approximated

    40% of the average costs for ART services (US$ 452, Tran

    BX, 2012b).

    As for health service use, we observed a smaller rate of

    outpatient care, but higher rate of inpatient care and

    OOP health payments in this study than in another

    household survey in 2010 (US$ 131.9/year) (Glandon

    2011). The difference may be explained by the fact that

    we selected patients based on their clinic attendance.

    High OOP payments for HIV/AIDS care, excluding ART,

    were also found in other settings. In China, they ranged

    from US$ 13 to 3939 in 2006 depending on disease

    stages (Moon et al. 2008). In India, OOP direct costs for

    HIV/AIDS care were US$ 244 in 2002. In terms of health

    service utilisation, our findings were in line with previous

    studies which found that the rates of health services use

    decreased significantly in patients with better

    immunological status (Luseno et al. 2010; Yehia et al.

    2010). Moreover, women had a higher rate of outpatient

    care than men. Drug users also used healthcare service

    more often than non-drug users because they can have

    Table 4 Correlates of catastrophic out-of-pocket (OOP) and healthcare service use

    Catastrophic OOPExpected differences in health service use, times/year (Coef., 95% CI)

    AOR, (95% CI) Inpatient care Outpatient care Total

    Level of clinics (central)Provincial 0.7 (0.5; 1.0) 0.0 (0.2; 0.3) 1.2 (0.2; 2.5) 2.6* (1.4; 3.7)District 0.2 (0.4; 0.0) 0.6 (0.7; 2.0) 2.0* (0.8; 3.3)

    Female vs. male 0.4* (0.3; 0.6) 0.0 (0.2; 0.3) 0.6 (0.0; 1.2) 0.7* (0.1; 1.4)Education: High school vs. below 0.3* (0.5; 0.1) 0.3 (0.9; 0.3) 0.2 (0.8; 0.4)Marital status (single)Live with spouse/partner 0.8 (0.6; 1.1) 0.2 (0.5; 0.0) 0.1 (0.7; 1.0) 0.2 (0.7; 1.1)Separated, divorced, widow(er) 0.0 (0.6; 0.6) 0.8 (1.8; 0.1) 0.8 (1.8; 0.2)

    Employment (unemployed)Stable jobs 0.0 (0.2; 0.3) 0.2 (1.1; 0.6) 0.5 (1.4; 0.4)Unstable jobs 1.7 (1.0; 2.9) 0.1 (0.1; 0.3) 0.0 (0.9; 1.0) 0.2 (1.3; 0.8)

    Income per capita (poorest)Poor 0.4* (0.3; 0.8) 0.0 (0.2; 0.3) 1.5* (2.4; 0.5) 1.3* (2.3; 0.4)Middle 0.6* (0.3; 0.9) 0.0 (0.3; 0.2) 1.2* (2.2; 0.3) 0.8 (1.8; 0.2)Rich 0.3* (0.2; 0.5) 0.0 (0.3; 0.3) 0.5 (1.4; 0.4) 0.1 (1.1; 0.8)Richest 0.4* (0.2; 0.7) 0.2 (0.4; 0.1) 0.1 (1.1; 0.8) 0.5 (0.5; 1.5)

    HIV stages (asymptomatic)Symptomatic 0.3* (0.1; 0.6) 1.3* (2.5; 0.0) 0.6 (1.8; 0.6)AIDS 1.3 (0.9; 1.8) 0.0 (0.1; 0.2) 1.1 (2.3; 0.1) 0.3 (1.5; 0.9)

    IDU vs. Non-IDU 0.3* (0.1; 0.6) 0.3 (1.1; 0.5) 0.2 (1.0; 0.5)CD4 (a 200)200 < cd4 350 0.6* (0.4; 0.9) 0.5* (0.7; 0.2) 0.7 (0.4; 1.7) 0.0 (1.1; 1.0)350 < cd4 500 0.4* (0.3; 0.7) 0.3* (0.6; 0.1) 0.6 (1.7; 0.4) 1.2* (2.3; 0.2)>500 0.5* (0.3; 1.0) 0.2 (0.5; 0.1) 0.9 (2.1; 0.3) 1.4* (2.6; 0.3)

    ART (not-yet)1 year 0.4* (0.2; 0.7) 0.4 (0.9; 0.1) 0.6 (0.3; 1.5) 0.1 (0.9; 1.0)1; 2 0.4* (0.2; 0.7) 0.6* (1.1; 0.2) 0.2 (0.6; 1.1) 0.0 (1.0; 0.9)2; 4 0.3* (0.2; 0.5) 0.5 (0.9; 0.0 1.8* (0.9; 2.7) 1.4* (0.4; 2.4)4; 7 0.3* (0.2; 0.6) 0.5* (1.0; 0.0) 2.5* (1.6; 3.5) 2.2* (1.1; 3.3)Constant 6.4* (2.9; 13.8)

    Reference group.Adjusted odd ratio.*P < 0.05.

    216 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd

    Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 18 no 2 pp 212218 february 2013

    B. X. Tran et al. Financial burden of HIV in Vietnam

  • more severe comorbidities and poorer treatment out-

    comes (Tran et al. 2012c,d).

    Several policy implications arise from these results. First

    of all, although ART is provided free-of-charge, a large

    proportion of HIV/AIDS patients had high demand for

    health care, and still faced catastrophic healthcare costs.

    This emphasises the importance of a wide-scale expansion

    of ART services along with impact mitigation pro-

    grammes to improve health status and reduce economic

    vulnerability of HIV/AIDS patients. Also, other protective

    financial mechanisms, for instance, health insurance or

    community-based funding sources, should be in place.

    Secondly, patients who had better immunological status,

    beyond the threshold of CD4 = 350 cells/mL, also usedand paid less for healthcare services than other patient

    groups, suggesting an earlier initiation of ART. Besides, in

    the breakdown of unit costs, transportation accounted for

    15% and 28% of an inpatient and outpatient care, respec-

    tively. This cost could be reduced by decentralising HIV/

    AIDS-related services are to district level and putting more

    integrative and comprehensive service delivery for HIV/

    AIDS care, support and treatment in place.

    The strengths of this study included the involvement of

    multiple sites with a relatively large number of respon-

    dents. Although these sites were not selected by a statisti-

    cally derived algorithm and not nationally representative,

    they are in different geographical regions and levels of

    health service administration. However, the study was

    subject to several limitations. First, we approached

    patients during their visits to clinics; thus, the sample

    might exclude patient groups who did not access to

    healthcare services, for example, those who were not yet-

    tested, or who did not yet know their HIV diagnosis, and

    who were severely ill and stayed at home. Second, esti-

    mates of spending for the last inpatient and outpatient

    care were self-reported by patients that could be biased

    and unverifiable without patients medical records. Simi-

    larly, the household income and expenditure, which was

    based on respondents recalls, could be under-reported

    (Riyarto et al. 2010). Finally, the scope of this cost analy-

    sis included only direct costs incurred by HIV/AIDS

    patients, excluding ART and other indirect costs. Not-

    withstanding, the study contributes to the understanding

    of the economic impact of HIV/AIDS, and supports the

    development of HIV/AIDS policies in Vietnam.

    In conclusion, use and OOP payment for healthcare

    services of HIV/AIDS patients were high and even

    catastrophic to more than one-third of affected house-

    holds. Scaling up free-of-charge ART services, earlier

    access to and initiation of ART, and decentralisation and

    integration of HIV/AIDS-related services could reduce the

    financial burden of HIV care and treatment in Vietnam.

    References

    Chaudhuri A & Roy K (2008) Changes in out-of-pocket pay-

    ments for healthcare in Vietnam and its impact on equity in

    payments, 1992-2002. Health Policy 88, 3848.Do TN, Nguyen TM, Do MH, et al. (2012) Combining cohort

    analysis and monitoring of HIV early-warning indicators of

    drug resistance to assess antiretroviral therapy services in Viet-

    nam. Clinical Infectious Diseases 54(Suppl 4), S306S312.Duraisamy P, Ganesh AK, Homan R et al. (2006) Costs and

    financial burden of care and support services to PLHA and

    households in South India. AIDS Care 18, 121127.

    Gardner EM, Hullsiek KH, Telzak EE et al. (2010) Antiretrovi-

    ral medication adherence and class- specific resistance in a

    large prospective clinical trial. AIDS 24, 395403.Glandon D (2011) Measuring Health Service Utilization and

    Out-of-Pocket Spending Among People Living with HIV/AIDS

    in Vietnam. The 38th Annual International Conference on

    Global Health. Available at: http://www.healthsystems2020.

    org/content/resource/detail/2903/ (Accessed July 27, 2012).

    Hosmer DW & Lemeshow S (2000) Applied Logistic Regression,

    2nd edn Wiley, New York: (ISBN 0-471-35632-8).

    Luseno WK, Wechsberg WM, Kline TL & Ellerson RM (2010)

    Health services utilization among South African women living

    with HIV and reporting sexual and substance-use risk behav-

    iors. AIDS Patient Care STDS 24, 257264.

    Ministry of Health (2008) HIV/AIDS estimates and projections

    20082012 Medical Publishing House, Hanoi, Vietnam.

    Moon S, Van Leemput L, Durier N et al. (2008) Out-of-pocket

    costs of AIDS care in China: are free antiretroviral drugs

    enough?. AIDS Care 20, 984994.Nguyen KT, Khuat OT, Ma S, Pham DC, Khuat GT &

    Ruger JP (2012) Effect of health expenses on household

    capabilities and resource allocation in a rural commune in

    Vietnam. PLoS ONE 7, e47423.

    Riyarto S, Hidayat B & Johns B (2010) The financial burden of

    HIV care, including antiretroviral therapy, on patients in three

    sites in Indonesia. Health Policy Plan 25, 272282.Tran BX (2012) Quality of life outcomes of antiretroviral

    treatment for HIV/AIDS patients in Vietnam. PLoS ONE 7,

    e41062.

    Tran BX, Ohinmaa A, Nguyen LT, Nguyen TA & Nguyen TH

    (2011) Determinants of health-related quality of life in adults

    living with HIV in Vietnam. AIDS Care 23, 12361245.Tran BX, Nguyen N, Ohinmaa A et al. (2012a) Prevalence and

    correlates of alcohol use disorders during antiretroviral treat-

    ment in injection-driven HIV epidemics in Vietnam. Drug and

    Alcohol Dependence [Epub ahead of print].

    Tran BX, Ohinmaa A, Duong AT et al. (2012b) Cost-effective-

    ness of methadone maintenance treatment for HIV-positive

    drug users in Vietnam. AIDS Care 24, 283290.

    Tran BX, Ohinmaa A, Duong AT et al. (2012c) Changes in drug

    use are associated with health-related quality of life improve-

    ments among methadone maintenance patients with HIV/

    AIDS. Quality of Life Research 21, 613623.

    Tran BX, Ohinmaa A, Nguyen LT et al. (2012d) Gender differ-

    ences in quality of life outcomes of HIV/AIDS treatment in the

    2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 217

    Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 18 no 2 pp 212218 february 2013

    B. X. Tran et al. Financial burden of HIV in Vietnam

  • latent feminization of HIV epidemics in Vietnam. AIDS Care

    24, 11871196.

    Van Minh H (2011) Financial Burden of Household Out-

    of Pocket Health Expenditure in Vietnam: Findings from

    Analyses of Vietnam Living Standard Survey Data. iHEA 2011

    Congress. Available at http://chsr.org.vn/?dl_id=52/

    (Accessed July 27, 2012).

    Vella S, Schwartlander B, Sow SP, Eholie SP & Murphy RL

    (2012) The history of antiretroviral therapy and of its imple-

    mentation in resource-limited areas of the world. AIDS 26,

    12311241.

    Xu K, Evans DB, Kawabata K, Zeramdini R, Klavus J &

    Murray CJ (2003) Household catastrophic health expenditure:

    a multicountry analysis. Lancet 362, 111117.Yehia BR, Fleishman JA, Hicks PL et al. (2010) Inpatient health

    services utilization among HIV-infected adult patients in care

    2002-2007. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency

    Syndromes 53, 397404.

    Corresponding Author Bach Tran, Institute for Preventive Medicine and Public Health, Hanoi Medical University, Vietnam.

    Tel.: + 84 98 222 8662; E-mail: [email protected] or [email protected]

    218 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd

    Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 18 no 2 pp 212218 february 2013

    B. X. Tran et al. Financial burden of HIV in Vietnam