P1

TITT tt 3rI

1. 3Id —1242/2014/1L.

2. 31'.IIeI 9I-1243/2014/jlqL

3. 3JLjçv H51I-1244/2014/19t

4. 3'd

5. 3e1 H4I-1246/2014/ui1L

6. 31Lle1 247 2014 wzrv. 7. 3ILv1 *I-1248/2014/W4.

o iii *ekTTjg L014~-\rj cp

ioi: TE:rf;T PIc1), zq\ 'iiqitg, wqv 1 31)c1I2

61.-lill

'1Rlct5 31Ictc1,

'fl'i1*TE -'T—Fqv I

rr rri,

*.VLE, i cq

1cp 11:1Ct ...31'c1R1

{ufq 1"iicp :16.02.2017

MOM

1. 3j2 cc ir zi 34k 34c t—cft, l4 ftlRqcf)

-~j-MV ftFr# 374 "ic1'q 3r5rr' i5WF 'illII) TT Tftff 31j)ft4 z1lI

k'iicp 05.05.2014 * 1c !4*c,c1 ?T'T t, ftRi# ZTqcfM2ff CJCI

3Bct'1, IycizfrI rTr (fT 31T1 '1if7 3fT15T"

5T 'ii I T) TT ' I '.i TPE g Rci Ic1 qR 3TIrZPT, 2003 (f~lt 3ffit

"11l1i" qT9T 31III) it ThT 25, 55, 61 zr ii 31c14c1 YIRd 31II * 71 Cf)9 ZI ¶T[ RINRuf 1 3f5U TT Zr1T41 &I

cc tT 3i4) 3ipi f 31T4 R1ci 1I ti 2. T !1cNUñ [24 tI I1C4IIc1 f *imi

PPTci I rr T * fuf çcp q -:11I CTA t

TT*I

3 T24 TtT T !,lcPk * f5 'iHk1c5 C4i1iIcp 3rI5rt

f CfrcIL.1Cit11 ¶T1, 'ii (fF 31T '\1it1 &ft5T'

15T iIII) It cii T IIicp 30.08.2012 * TTUM Ri TMT I

UrfcT 3I1T 3TtI1 cp ThT 75(1) * ii 91èi irr c157 Nq;5)\yi c '1cpvi Z {) t TfT-qfT c1I IUI 3flf

1t fi I 3T#M4 cb1- -I'- TT 2006-07 t 2012-13 1TT

Zifl {u I 4W M T jc 3 qMT TfJT f TT T Ic1 P7I -4 tt --5rEt 4A ICI c1I Z5't cpV)

t1Id ,ui) 4,1 1 6 tit i -i'i

* WT Rcii fTTr TT ciI1I \-'iIdI t 3)eiI

..icuii scPI * fr' IIc1 Tfm gRci frr # 7T ct'i Hci)

e1IIc1k. ................. 2 /-

- 2 - 4i *iI (1 —7) —1242 1248/2O14/'iii

f t 4j1pc1 Zj[ C1I Tj i4

cPI tRtUf tqIIc1 Tt c4cI T t i1Ic1I rt cc1 clli'1 I5T

*1IItccl 1R * T1 cPclI * YlIc1 3T#M4 cp) 9M 3T t *c1lIIcc1

f m 1id) t a 141 * T1f51TI €uicIc1I

;51Ic i cPk VgZfff I1" I5T 1cPLl qt IcP'l 45't 1bi 'iilcfl t tT ct1

ciiii Ict) TT Scfc1 cII'1' Icl 3tT 1i jiIc Z Zf5T 511/3iYc'i RbI 'ilhiI 1TT1 Tf1TI FEN

ii.fcp iIf 39fT5T fTUT

NI-ciRdZA T{ fuj 'f4 C)4-4 j

T5TT 15T ftwq Pi 'iihll 3kl)zLl 31[11r %P tJ 4

Rici izr I .iRici it C1I1 Ict1 tR 12.5 iRici r Wt c1I'l ZP %ft W 12.5 qRici it -TT t -4R 3TR~ftff

1b i I I mMci ft I I Ic1 31f1R19it ThT 61 *

.111Q.1 tR [Iff 9 q)U ]{ 55 * [T 1Ni 'i1i.i' 15T 3IkYUI PII Ph

~[ ZT9-4 f~,hjO aTF~T R-lict) 05.05.2014 zf~ Kxirt f~-)t, f~Fi~') ff;;5~ zl~

cp TT 31ff19 Zft 1TT 83 * FT WO 4R cti * TT W*cJd it

, I3iicpi 1Iciui flNui) 4 4i1..ii TPIT

w w. . . fif. ft~~h 44 aTft fkfffw

rrf rt'r

1242/14 118/3T4 III/ 15.04.13 06-07 18,63,060 14,53,187 37,27,120 70,43,367

1243/14 119/3Tt1t JH/*U 15.04.13 07-08 3,06,880 2,02,541 6,13,760 11,23,181

1244/14 120/31ft Ifl/te 15.04.13 08-09 1,71,960 92,858 3,43,920 6,08,738

1245/14 121 /art IH /tU 15.04.13 09-10 2,37,793 99,873 4,75,586 8,13,252

1246/14 122/3i4 III/* 15.04.13 10-11 80,000 24,000 1,60,000 2,64,000

1247/14 123/314t IH/tU 15.04.13 11-12 88,000 15,840 1,76,000 2,79,840

1248/14 124/34 ffl/tU 15.04.13 12-13 j 1,06,000 6,360 2,12,000 T 3,24,360

4. 39RTtIt m I1 4T ir I

5. 1 * cih1 3I4)c'II * &fThiT 54T 1ii f iii

3vcc141 1I'LlIc TT #ffd fq cii, -mr

22(viii)(g) 19 1T T f /1cc 1T3t WT Lç x 1

ifl 11c

3f tf{ M UrF tfiTT tR fl I1 Jzz1

zr 1I1 ji u1b ki * I 4 ckcn *cict'i

ñr 1i

trfr trIiir * ZT;Xff F cfrIYuI iFici rrrr ti Urqfc)5 zp#Meff

1) r4 ti P-wR WcTff 74 3Tf~rcçj

T5T fU4 1TTtIT*I

ci'IIc1k. ................ 3

- 3 - *isii (1-7) —1242 1248/2014/11

\tk11 -I-lIc'N 4 1 -9 4I1 i{ 1I 41 3'1TtT

c1J (17 lc)* 1 489) it 3TFT !.1I 1e'i tcP1 31)ck 1'lcrI, iiic

R.iicp 10 3-Il-c1 2009 5T ZT 1I Rii fcf Z4ff

• 3çJ2 444 I5 TT 1'1c q '1cpi * UT V '314 CI)

i1 -i IThIT T ctcl I 1 i -i 3TTT5 I5TT fCFM

311k qft q*4 q'CpY I'N Yi, 1r3T 3ft

' 1i *c R1 -i I Ri I t t 9T RT TIT# Ict tTt £1TT 51 *

3)ui {bI \)IIdI t 3fff 15cpUj cjc c)cpç fwfm {J

• 1cPc1I * f f5 3'1cPI 4ii1ict'i.ii TcF aT#M4 cI *c1cP') II

3T1: !T117T &1IT PT cflj qr)cpI qr 3Ttm2ff ct *

9'Ic c'1cr * W?1T * 1y'ci

3TEA TO z WffOff 4 ZVTTcM iiicii * Pu1i (2013) 3

541 4*c,c1 WZ ?152TT 14I f * Rr

tR I* cPIIcci Tej 497c[T *, 9TT Zt2TT 1i f I2.1f ct) [

?r . t ict Tuq i iR frur &1rt

* rr ct -i f2tym TrqT '-i) i c cci &f * I ' cici -ci Tt7 fi -\5:rA t

cN * 1cck cI 1ct 3jL ç ct),,qt UM jur

Iiicp 21 31I*c1 2012 T2P ZPU li1Rci 1i f5 'qi 4c4i' 4r

TT ilIclI 9 t t ftT 3Tf1[ TT qrftff 3II # 3e1i cP4) *

I l C , [F T1 f '1 d I * 3I11FtF Tff\m I Y u 3Jfj

i1Tici *1

6. 1C? 1 11c1 wq2ff fTT it Rii 'kict1 3T1rfm fthui 3I1T T 3Q11 &1E!5T * 15T TT1 Wxt g 31 cpI

t * f -z1T f iift urti c

* GHcl * \3\4zA Tff 31Th1 I 3TT:

Rt c J'< T c c'1 TT cL1 ci 61 T q5l<

IIrd 3ThIIIc1 *1 '36 ZT fT f fI5 aMN it 9I1eul

3pTrTf tt1T vhdl t I ZfR 3TT W#1 TT c1'cii t clIc1 cci6Il 5T

T 1i cci6I) - c 3IILI W t

tr liT * I '3 - Z fT 1 411 '-I 4 'z3 tJ ci 1-I I I I

rr Ll,I1 fio r flfft fT * -3dc &T * 1 CPII 3'1cPI

9I.lcI c4ci6I 1c1dI *, 4Rcp #0 kci U fio * 4cp.UI - 1I14

3tzld111 -1ILlIe1L1 ftlT * m P1'-I 6*c1'$c1 ,1c77 Auu1cV.II 1TTfl1T

3: )cI 3T'1 IRvh 1TI • 0411CIFT.................4

I

- 4 - 3{4k1 *ici (1-7) —1242 1248/2014/l

7.

it Trt i, 1RSIi qc1c r ci 1 -u

3I * 1'I &1R[[ TT cc1 -.ii1cp q tt I'-c1 T d'94-1h1 3cicP.1

1i I10 11kUI it fr tftf

\1N1 3Rlc1 S1cc1 ttuT ti

(i) FThT k 2003 TM-2(6) c—c t.iiRcp cti1ii r r

3Tf1fRN Cci'1V1 ZT TRII t 3ft--z Tff4 cLIIYk, ciuFikrIcp, fWai wrzf

ii[ki Tff 'i1I I () 'V1T 'icp -1 t1) Z1T cI-lk r41fd1 vq 1ff Pil-IILJI Ei5T

Tftff / ct I -i T cii eli wO ?T 91 3T2I1T wM

* f*ii 111 c15c1i t tft T'4 51Z cici'HRl cPeiiLl 3t)

T9iTr 'wi*i lT P1ci ift zji

'11T, lIi'cii, PiIcicii # Ici b11/MT 31Tf 1T5

(ii) UM-2(15) 1T1 (Goods): 14hIt1i' 1Tt, r(r?1), qrq zuFm (c1ic1

cp9) —f ,j—*e'Ici 15t - iRNi, iRii,

IIL c1*cJ ?t 514—i1ki (—cct) .rtic')

1;i- 31 1T T 31T R TRff 1 1TT cPeli I

(iii) UM-2(17) 3ITTftE (Input Tax) : )ccj c21c161') TT 3Ttt1 c.iciii-i * Y.rIIcci c4cJ 11 1TT 1T cPRB ]Rff 3TJ1T cf 1TT ti1

37 (1c tcN-i) cPeflLIi I

• (iv) 1TT 2—(40) 'EI -I) ' 'LI c2-1 I '-I I I ci c{ (TaxableTurnover): *1 cP el c'L ci ci (Toatal

turnover) cic')I?i'1 -4c.i' * z4Ic1 c24'.1IIcc1 Z15T 91'T fiTT q

c21cil) -( rt r 311fmij it 31thT IdI t, I .l—cLIi(4kicIcI cPeIiiI I

(v) .TrT —2(41) c2.lIt-1I'IcicI (Turnover): T1Tf T5T 1 flT *IcPeI Ictc1-4 (Sale

price) c4ci1 111 ST 3t1 Rii UM 4(2) * 3T9 T5—'Lil '1TE T 5T I 4 IIIcl 'it, c24IqIcic cpiLlhI

(vi) l'r4 t 31NTPT TS4T Iff IER (Tax on maximum retail

price) YZFT & TFI 3T2T1T 7T.3TR.tft ti 01(4

FR 9: c I TMT ift 1 cP I ' tr c? T{t uç: T 3ITf:

iiiT c.ii t.iii cid IIIel 9t {b.0 lIt.lhi I

8. ¶WF * &IWT * aT~UF qT zTtw2ff

31ThT * T ?frli t I 11TN tZ 3T11IN, 2003 it 'c1TT 2(1 1)

P-1I1k :-

ciciI) (Dealer) 3IIi'Ll C4Ic1 t 31't 9T I51 si'lg,

cP R 15T c1i ci ki qt4Rvt 3TTE1T 'k1P1

clic'Il, II1Iel nt 7T I

iRiRici 5R cp TTk //9/cPI1el 4:t

ffTT iici ITiii1-

H iI ci I..................5

- 5 - pj *ici (1-7) —1242 k 1248/2014/i

(ti) TM 2(35) 1ct) WT4 ciIcn t frt TrRI &k 1 Zn F ii IT cj Zn T 3ZT

R c1 Ri fr k ()TaTiff, cpj~m, Tt4 qT

IIk qftr c1(f4cp 41c1 Zn 1ci gm 41I1icp

({Iivi) zft 3ft 1Tf q51 tq#4 -qT f ç uJ cp r Wo cpc1I

jA

() 4)elI 4lcPclI ?i 1 1ci Zn 341c1 ffF T

9TT Z c1i1 cp'c1j f{

T2J1T 3dc 1) VffPili cl 19 cpc

() 1 (tff 'c)

r zn { ç u m WO qT#1 cflej( Zn 4A,

Aci4ci PPI1d 3TT1T 9, qft 3T 1 Zn 311T

(tq) ccI'

() - 'c cp i zn i I -i ct zr fii-r zg

cpI11c ft r &1c, *M, 'dk'1I Zil uI c cçfl t, tflT 5r4 m i o041c4\I1cp TFftftf4 cIII 3T2IEIT 19T cJcN1IFp flfMR f~

qII TT fiPil ci1p TTftf4Rr * cPc1I Zn 3ITT

ctc1I T 3ft cIi Zn '1cPc Zn 3TT 1 ieIi M1?1 Lt) cl nRci *frtcpciir,

CJ 3fr 4c

* RTT Uft 9M qt Qq \4k'iI I Zn Ic1uI cP T T)7 ct7c1I

tC rzf t .3.Jq4 fklt c1cp TFftf cIUi 3T41T frr ciciif

i1Fi * i'c1I t 3ft Zn cP'<cli 3 Zn

94 Zn 3TZ 1*1I f # ecH1 !11I91 !4IRc1 * cpc

q<U— 9T °.i 1i 15ft 7F,3WTFT -'l t, 1955 It .3 RJ

'3i Ic cPc1I ft T tnfTT * 311I cc T

11T9T 'ilI.II I

9• \3ctcT I5t * f5 i1

2003 it 11T 2(35) tfrfi f çp * J:~R Rb 1t !ictm

c1I 3TfffRN * 3II zrf * tVF ?c1I V9t * 31c II 1Mci

ci fcFT 'MI 11 I21T TIFT t, 2003 it ThT 2(11) * 31c14ci tt 1cik TQ1T31 * ThT 2(35) # qpflIMO 1api Tfa4c46 jt * cLf') Th[ 'MI1II I

• - -

I Ici I.................6

- 6 - i1ei *ii (1-7) —1242 1248/2014/'J11

10. -RO ZF9 t9T t f5 c5Il TT [I TMT c1151') T IcN4 WVTIRTM tid

2003 MT 2(35) * i4ci IcP.1 m • 3IThT T 91I

1 (Sa1e)/IcP nt c cp1j *cii zr 3iciPiIci ;3T2A *iIc1 (ti1i

cp ) t c[1 c411 151 3T 5[ uI/IuJ

1cP, Ic1I'i frc.) Zfl 3T;;u f4TA e'IIc1N qRiLbcl icci

1ictc

() 1b 3TT it YIc1I * ftcii * 14 1 I5T 3frc1LJI fi

zmfm Ic1I-i i) zff 31 1I 4icNl 1I4?eI * c1 t,

&?r) i—i iT 1bci' Ic1I'1 * 11) 44)

(14)),

if c!4fc1 t ciRcI T iT/ic/ zqqw fcFt R1ir 3TE[1T * f/f9T 3TrfT 5T tt ct4)i 1T ,3TRT1r Ic1N

ZIT 3PT R ii.i * qZ t,

() 1) f1T * 3Ic14c1 Pi1ici 410 -1 T Ci41Li1 * 'H TZT

3ftT i q i:zft z 1 .cpc 3mQTfRT jcmi T

3TZT 1) c11I'1 s4?iq- c'i * ic

(q) 91T it 1LclJ 1 1 T (ifi) IT WffzFT VCTF

trr, Tr• 1Ic(P 44 Vt 3T2T1T f, 3iirfrrr Icili (19

Zff 3TRT 1 N 119c * 6

11. c1 I TT cfl i'I 5T ?i P cP -1 I TZff ,

• t ZIT 9'1, Tffct fp jj

1rM WcPk 3T IcP T clI1 * 31I2 * Zw 3Icc1

pc1I * c1I TT cIIl'I * tT S4I'.c1cP0I qr T fziT i1Ic1I

* ui i* 'lIc1I *i i WctI iqcj 1I'1 T cii*cici1 cP6lI .1ftcP * tff[ tm *,

• g 31cPIT9T cPlI 5FM 4cIcU 5T c1I t TTfT T 4I'.c100I IcP *

PzFw C1Il w *cii1ki t'T viuT 15T ift ff9T 'ilidi t11T zrf :5FEt -gm P1i i -ni qt 1n 7mT * r Wr VTft vr TTrm

WT ff1R ct4cii viict, ciiui W1 ct1I wr RI.H silIclI

• *1 zt i 'Fici fl1i * f5 5/1ccil.i 4T31't TT

ff1f4T 'Wt . 29 zr 30 IN .54tUtj) * TIMT&N 3IftPT q cj

t) IIdk. ................. 7 I------ V

- 7 - Wli *isii (1-7) —1242 t 1248/2014/*4

TO 9 29 30 * 3Tr1T t[ u) 'c cni q5T [çp [)

TTt !i1b.ii TF6 31yii) 'iici) t j JJJJ cW.14) --It WT4 tR

trr fii ui fj t i ciiii zr frfm c c1c 1lcu i1cii rfrzTi * 1T 1i'i I*c1 CC1I 311T1 1T1T \3clvt cli.-J i5T

c1cz1Ic1 CH6'- ) ZFT I1cP.4 WZ 3TEFT ttT

I I lcPI' # 394 Ict TTZrId W4 3If5r T ZT 1TZ1T TFT f tu)

TT ffff;q 'T it Ic1 T I cii '1 c -CFT. UJ fGM cli t[ 5fU

* fzrr 2TT, i ciiui * 3T41 cti4Ii i' cp R;i1I irr eTT i c1c

3T1T1N, 1988 it "CTPT 51 ici'-t WT ZT f T

t r TTrm 3ft4 t 3TtTT TT !R1T 1i I -t WT WEFT I t 4

' 5T -c 4) f 11 1R1Tf it ETM 50 31c1 id Cli 1 T5T

• IcP'L1 fcfft 3TT c'i1 CPC?, 1c fl' 1ii'i ccii .yjJcfl

cii p< u TJ c cli f 1TffT t iP]T 0'd014 I

cic-lt1Id 3TTE 1tU1 iIi ,IM if * 9Tff Clii I5T qCpUJ qR

fi TMT I T wcrI T t *cli1kcl 3T(f ctI2ff zFT et T1IT I 3TtM4 i

t fk Tii ciii wr zflj 1iCClNS419)cI (r1t) WT qR Ri izrri Tcf 7F f: 1i cpI4cii) 3T#M4 -9-M 1eii2ff -4

4j ç cI -I 9) c'l W5 qR, 3TT f cli 5[ R cP -1 Rb -1 I T

fcf

ciiT * Rci * qRuim *cii ft ii rfr m * qu itu gI

-- f5 \3lIci'1 *1 cpkuI pT 1IR1 * frç R1ci -;:rt Rbi 7Tm * igqft iciij,*ii c4(4i) gm cii-iI * fwfm t 31T T/iRi 5T 3g4iI

RkiI '.IlciI *, zrg RIciu1ci 91 * ETT RIcN4 5T Tf RIcN.l

TTtT ft ZFT RI 1 il RI * cr i cii 'CH z5t rr r tItWW- 2(11)*31k VcT . *, wr wr R)

TT Rb c411 * 5R7 tT, i ciCPci1 * N1 cfrI-'I Rbi W 1cpdi t I 3m: 3frf[ T 3I11R cli-1 * RIN1

Cli R 00I * efflccli [ VO t Tj-ilclI *1 c'-IciI) TT Zi 4j1c

Zi~ ct)d T ftqM Rbi t * 3TfTfT * WTR * tct)d cii * T I 'ii 119 tz 3Tft)fPf * TT ') d '

im 3FFf c)1 ccii) ciit c c c fft

el'Wd1i .................8

I

- 8 - *iii (1-7) —1242 1248/2014/.il1

clIi tActp ctI : qRiLod -Ct -kc c1Ii 5' R & m

TE clIE.1 T5T I1 cJ '-'IRlI *1 t fiftr

12. 1i fcF aAtM4

UT C1I6 4[ [çpL 1B TJ !T9 I1cP c

1N 3vcic141 '- I.IIç * "ii1ct Id 4)'S'I 1T5 fTO q5T icp.i Rbii

"Whether sale of pledged ornaments for consideration falls in the course of trade or business of the bank. It is no dout true that banks have to act on instruction of the borrower. In the present case, we are not concerned with the provision of section 176 of the contract Act, 1872. We are concerned with the definition of the word "sale" under the 1963 act. When a bank sells the pledged ornaments it is not acting as an agent of the borrower even under the 1949 Act. When the bank sells the goods pledged with them they do not act as the agents of the borrower. As pledgees, the banks, acting under section 176 of the contract act, 1872 have a right to sell the goods. That sale is not as agents but that sale is in exercise of the statutory power under the 1949 Act. No doubt the sale is on behalf of the pledgor, however the sale is in exercise of the statutory power (Dy. CCT v. A.R.S) Thirumeninatha Nadar Firm (1968) 21STC 184 (MAD). To the same effect is the judgment of the Punjab and Haryana high court in high channel video v. enclave electronics (1999) 116 STC 131 (P&H).Further, on reading the provisions of the 1949 Act, one finds that every bank is required to maintain its balance sheet in form 'A' of the Third schedule quoted above. The prescribe form indicates that non-banking assets acquired by the banks even in satisfaction of claims,are required to declare their holdings. The prescribed form of balance sheet indicates that banks are required to show on the asset side non-banking assets acquired by

• them in satisfaction of claims. Similary, in form 'B' of the Thired schedule under profit and loss account, banks are required to show income from non-banking assets and profit from sale of such assets.In our view,therefore sale of pledged assets takes place in the course of banking business.Therefore as stated above,the banks in selling the goods pledged to them did not act as agent of the borrowers/pledgors and that their sale was in exercise of statutory power under the 1949 Act.Further in our view it is no dout true that under section 8 of the 1949 Act. banks are prohibited from trading in goods. However if one reads

• Section 8 along with the third schedule to the 1949 act it is clear that dealing in non-banking assets is a banking business and the expection made in section 8 which allows banks to realize security and which allows banks to engage in trade in order to realise security, falls within the banking whenever undertaken. When a pledged article is old in an auction, the bank recovers not only its dues but also recovers interests and its other charges.This realisation falls within the parameters of the Third schedule to the 1949 Act. In the circumstances,we are of the view that sale of pledged ornaments falls within the course of banking business under the 1949 Act. In the circumstances, such transactions are taxable under section 2(viii) (q) read with section 5 of the 1963 act. We also find merit in the contention advanced on behalf of the department (the respondents here in) that the very object of the kerela finace act 1998 was to introduce clause (g) in section 2 (viii) in order to get over the judgments of the highcourt which took the view that sale of pledged goods did not fall in the course of banking business. We have quoted clauses (g). That clause makes it very clear that even if the sale of pledged ornaments takes places outside the banking business, the 1963 act would cover even such transaction.

- eiIIc1k..................9

- 9 - *iii (1-7) —1242 1248/2014/'i1

Therefore once such transaction fall under said 1963 act.banks become "dealers" and they are liable to pay sales tax under the said 1963 Act. It is true that the definition of the word "sale" under section 2(xxi) of the 1963 act does include mortgage,hypothecation.charge or pledge, however the important point to be noted is that the definition of the word "sale" under the 1963 act is not the same as under section 2(xxi) in the 1963 act is very similar to section 2(g) of the central sales tax Act,1956 which is held to be having a very wide meaning as compared to the definition of the word "sale" in section 4 of the sale of goods Act, 1930 (State of Maharastra v. Embee corp. (1997) 7SCC 190). Further when charges or pledge is enforces that enforcement is by way of sale of the pledged or hypothecated goods; that sale is for consideration and, therefore, it falls within the ambit of section 2(xxi) of the 1963 act."

13. cbk 14.i t ci 1iu1-i _ctq7 RCi) TIM 7~

iii1 * RlcN 'T 91T IT *1 c1R 1TT fs iii

vrift * Tt[ '3cl1 i f~ cp TzT;cT C1Il 1'J. tT[ *1

14. 3TOMeff Zl 31 1I'1'- 1 7UrzIc19 I1Ie1.l 15T 111cP cI -c1 (1966) 17

tE 489 -1 '-PI'd fo ii r 3TT ?r

445 fo q 3TT t Yc1 15T *, 3z1c11 RlIc T * "We are accordingly of the view that the intention of the appellants in obtaining

the higher purchase and the allied agreements was to secure the returned of loan advanced to their customers, and No real sale of the vehicle was intended by the customer to the appellant."

15. v,7Ri WcPk 3ct1 11uic4 x.I-c1 3T *T I)J2 19M qq c1i*c1IlcP

TZ1T * f ju q lI cicj cp

c cN cHl 451 i'i 31tT lTT cPclI f: c1Itj T5t 14c'1 * tEll * 21T ElT * RrNII cII f * E1 9

* T1 fr * qii •4 flmtT4 \3• z1c111 vqi4Icll * qAzo jrx_ I -c1 -c1 t45 to 3T4 # 4RII1c1 Rii * 31Tll '(t1 Y)I1

fro * PIUILI 5T, 3i-f i 1ii t 16. 2010 NTN (Vol.44)-368 [WEST BENGAL TAXATION TRIBUNAL]

ICICI bank ltd. v/s Joint commissioner,sales tax, central section Kolkata and others fct

- definition scope of - banking companies as well as non-Banking finance companies are dealer under section 2(1 1)-baning companies as well as non banking finance companies are dealers under section 2(11) of West Bengtal Value Added tax 2003 and are liable to pay tax on the sale of hypothecated goods/vehicles for satisfaction of calims under the Hypothecation agrrement.

Whether banking companies/Non banking companies are dealer under section 2(11) of west Bengal value added tax 2003 and liable to tax when have sold the pledged goods though for satisfaction of their claim" 17. 3T4M4 Wv-rWM * C-F f c5 N11

Tug clI'1 5T : fct) iit fqvs 6flc

• 0 * 3T14ElT &RT ii1 Ic1 4i fcfT4 *

cpkUI 4 xc11 vqlIe14 * -411cp ci t45 fo * 1U1Ll q;t tzqt g ift zTtm2ff l*cjc1

-'L4I1cp i -ci'i 5T 9k141 ZT#M4 c1Il !Elt 9 e Icicii ti 3TTI% cpc1I *

c'l'IIclk.................. 10

- 10 - ili *isii (1-7) —1242 t 1248/2014/i 18. 3TT TrzF 3T. zFT fE 11T tz fPT9, 2006 * 18 31TT1

cli c 1i 1T TMT eIT I ¶1 Tq tl 31 ) C'1T2 4I i ) 9M ju rr

cFM

cpj.uj 3T 1CR CP1T Gfri& t, 1T VHC}5T 3J2 _

eIiI) T 3t fft*c1 fi c'li s*ccj mi.Th rrr

3t .IiLlIQi * "411Ct) ici (2007) 10 c*jct 535(M.) ?I cc1 cik*1 l'-lii )c)3it 3lTftT fbii t fcF —All Transaction dully

recorded in books of account- no mala fide intention of not paying tax-Mere rejection of explanation of assessee as not acceptable does not attract penalty- 19. Icfr4 Z15"t IRui c1 tR ftfci.!1 3qU ?{ WF *

r t'4 ' zzIclJ-1 -iIoi.i fiu1 (2009) 23 1c'I 249 cWU

ll'-T 3ft tzm 31Yc kH 43 qT 4 tT 158,

NiI cPc1 t[R T tRci fu &tJ 1s1i 1320/2013/Rt.j) c)3 iii R-i l t *11I fo fIU1.!4 [1JCP 26.06.2014 TT

ti 31it &qi irffm itz 3T-rw cle1I 7 Li& 621 9I1r4 cie11 3J "l1Ie1l 1I1ct, Ic1 ii1 CC1I' '19-c1 dc2 cl6k \j-jcj

dcPf5*,

20. wrfcf * f tR iir.i.- \ztt1c141 fufj (2009) 23 *1&

249 c4WJ1 1CPi l'llt 3#c dI1I' tZM '319 cl'c 43 qIJ 4 4Ur 158 W TfrT \3sl I1I1k t—

"So far as the question of penalty is concerned the items which were not included in the turnover were found incorporated in the appellant's account books, where certain items which are not included in the turnover are disclosed in the dealer's own account books and the assessing authorities includes these items in the dealers' turnovers disallowing the exemption penalty cannot be imposed. The penalty levied stands set aside."

3: 91r1.-j)g \rcc1' - .lRlidiI TT !.Jyjfci UT4WU * &Rft

,411 1i ui I *cl 1T i I '-I I ffFqiJ5 Tcftlff erM * I 3T: WI * f9 t

34 ifTzrr * fu *ffT UT wtcbI fi 'rHciI I

17. 4?cicl: y'jcçj ft4j * 3TE1R tR 3T1IT4 gM 'dRl'i I '.ii 31 c ii Rci * f t

*C11C)I 7jiici1 *1

- 1tJ14 3g9TZTT TFZ1TI

I -m- - () (hffr)