TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana...
Transcript of TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana...
![Page 1: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam Failure
Presented by: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN
University of Illinois at [email protected]
Presented to:
51st Geotechnical Engineering ConferenceUniversity of Kansas
Lawrence, KansasNovember 14, 2019
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
1/58
![Page 2: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Fundao Failure Outline
• 5 November 2015 Failure• Chronology of events• Field observations• Subsurface investigation• Effect of blasting and earthquakes• Slope stability analyses• Summary
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
2/58
![Page 3: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
2015 Fundao Tailings Dam Failure
Left photo: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/feb/28/brazil-dam-collapse-samarco-fundao-mining Right photo: lindsaynewlandbowker - WordPress.com
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
19 deaths
3/58
![Page 4: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
2015 Flow Failure
Photo from: bbc.com
Photos from: abc.net.auT.D.Stark-Slides-©
4/58
![Page 5: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zy41SxJsSbM
2015 Flow Failure Videos
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0PWRiEWMTY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WMHqSp7lse8
•1:00 – 1:45
•3:36 – 4:17
•5:14 – 6:10
5/58
![Page 6: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Flow of Tailings
Fundao
Image from: https://www.samarco.com/en/rompimento-da-barragem-de-fundao/
5.5 M m3 of tailings traveled 537 km to mouth of Doce River
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
6/58
![Page 7: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Photo from: miningreview.com
Flow of Tailings
17+ deaths and 16+ non fatal injuries
Tailings entering Atlantic Ocean
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
7/58
![Page 8: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
2D Cross-Sections - 02
(Morgenstern et al., 2016)
116 Piezometers & Water Levels
8/58
![Page 9: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Piezometric Level
T.D.Stark-Slides-© (Morgenstern et al., 2016)
A-A’ 02
9/58
![Page 10: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Piezometric Surface
T.D.Stark-Slides-© (Morgenstern et al., 2016)
10/58
![Page 11: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Kα
Blanket Drains
funneling seepage flow(Morgenstern et al., 2016)
11/58
![Page 12: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Kα
El. 826 m blanket drains
El. 860 m blanket drains
Blanket Drains
(Morgenstern et al., 2016)
12/58
![Page 13: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Witness Location and Description
#1: worker standing on plateau, felt it begin to move beneath him and crack around him, detaching from the setback slope, and moving downstream.
#2, #3, and 5: slope movement having propagated “from the bottom up” on the lower benches, not from the crest down, placing the seat of movement at lower elevations.
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
02
(Morgenstern et al., 2016)
13/58
![Page 14: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Witness Location and Description
#9: Avalanche of mud-like tailings cascaded down. The starter dam had no movement
#5: Crack open up along crest of left abutment setback and propagating in both direction
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
#5
(Morgenstern et al., 2016)
14/58
![Page 15: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Left Abutment Overview
White dashed line represents crack locationa small bulldozer on bench at El. 875 m moving or being pushed outward
T.D.Stark-Slides-© (Morgenstern et al., 2016)
15/58
![Page 16: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Outline
• 5 November 2015 Failure• Chronology of events• Field observations• Subsurface investigation• Effect of blasting and earthquakes• Slope stability analyses• Summary
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
16/58
![Page 17: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Pre-Failure CPT and SPT locations
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
02
(Morgenstern et al., 2016)
17/58
![Page 18: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Cross-Section 02– Left Abutment
CrackScarp
FUND15-SPTFUND06-CPT FUND16-CPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
FUND 07-CPT
SandSlope SandPlateau SandToe
Cross-Section 02– Left Abutment18/58
![Page 19: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Sand tailings and slime particle distribution
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Boundaries for most liquefiable soil (Ishihara et al., 1989)
19/58
![Page 20: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Sand tailings and slime particle distribution
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Boundaries for most liquefiable soil (Ishihara et al., 1989)
20/58
![Page 21: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Composition of Sand tailings and slime
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Sand tailings mainly comprise loose sand and silt, high potential to liquefy
% S
and,
Silt
, and
Cla
y21/58
![Page 22: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Pre-Failure Blasts & Earthquakes
Table 2.1: Pre-failure mine blasts and earthquakes on 5 November 2015 (Atkinson, 2016)
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Local TimeMoment
Magnitude Mw
Distance from
FundaoIndentification
PHGA DurationReference(g) (second)
1:01:49 PM 2.1 2.6 km mine blast 0.0001g <5 Dowding (1996)
1:06:06 PM 2.3 2.6 km mine blast 0.00004 <5 Dowding (1996)
2:12:15 PM 2.2 <2 km earthquake (foreshock) 0.06 70 Atkinson
(2016)
2:13:51 PM 2.6 <2 km earthquake (main shock) 0.08 80 Atkinson
(2016)
2:16:03 PM 1.8 <2 km earthquake (aftershock) 0.06 60 Atkinson
(2016)
22/58
![Page 23: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Blast induced ground motion
Magnitude 2.3 (2.1) is equivalent to 620 kg (330 kg) of TNT.Distance of 2.6 km
R = distance,c = particle propagate velocityW = weight of TNT per delayρ = density of rock/soil
M = 2.45 + 0.73*Log(Y)
Blasts had no significant impactT.D.Stark-Slides-©
23/58
![Page 24: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Pre-Failure Blasts & Earthquakes
Local TimeMoment
Magnitude Mw
Distance from
FundaoEvent
2:12:15 PM 2.2 <2 km earthquake (foreshock)
2:13:51 PM 2.6 <2 km earthquake (main shock)
2:16:03 PM 1.8 <2 km earthquake (aftershock)
3:45 PM Dam Failure
Pre-failure earthquakes on November 5, 2015 (Atkinson, 2016)
Eyewitness Accounts:- Shaking strong enough to cause computer to fall from tabletop and minor structural
cracking (Morgenstern et al., 2016)- Viviane Rezende – 2nd eqk shook truck on dam- Daviely Silva – Desk shaking & broken glass- MMI ~ 5 to 6
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
24/58
![Page 25: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Pre-Failure Blasts & EarthquakesEyewitness Accounts of 11/5/15 Earthquakes:- Shaking strong enough to cause computer to fall from tabletop and minor structural
cracking (Morgenstern et al., 2016)- Viviane Rezende – 2nd eqk shook truck on dam- Daviely Silva – Desk shaking & broken glass- MMI ~ 5 to 6- M ~ 4 to 5
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
https://earthquakenepal2015.weebly.com/the-richter-scale-and-modified-mercalli-intensity-scale.html
25/58
![Page 26: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
26/58
Cumulative Moment Magnitude from ru
Moment magnitude/Richter magnitude SandSlope SandPlateau SandToe
Hypo central
distance and magnitude
2 km 3.4/ 3.5/ 3.45/5 km 4.2/ 4.3/ 4.2/
10 km 4.8/ 5.0/ 4.9/
Reference: Atkinson, G. (2015). Ground Motion Prediction Equation for Small-to-Moderate Events at Short Hypocentral Distances, with Application to Induced-Seismicity Hazards. Bull. Seism. Soc. Am., 105, doi: 10.1785/0120140142
![Page 27: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Cross-Section 02– Left Abutment
CrackScarp
FUND15-SPTFUND06-CPT FUND16-CPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
FUND 07-CPT
SandSlope SandPlateau SandToe
Cross-Section 02– Left Abutment27/58
![Page 28: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Pre-Failure CPT Data-FUND 06-CPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Tailings SandSlope:Depth = 4.25 m
(Morgenstern et al., 2016)
28/58
![Page 29: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Pre-Failure CPT Data-FUND 06-CPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
29/58
![Page 30: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Pre-Failure Site Response Analysis
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
SandSlope
SandSlope
Tailings SandSlope:Depth = 4.25 m
30/58
![Page 31: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Magnitude Scaling Factor
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Idriss and Boulanger (2014)
31/58
![Page 32: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Kσ
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Idriss and Boulanger (2014)
• CRRL(σ’0=?) = CRRL(σ’ =1 tsf) *(Kσ)σ’0 = insitu effective vertical stress
32/58
![Page 33: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Cross-Section 02– Left Abutment
CrackScarp
FUND15-SPTFUND06-CPT FUND16-CPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
FUND 07-CPT
Kα
SandSlope SandPlateau SandToe
33/58
![Page 34: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Kα
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Idriss and Boulanger (2010) K0 = 0.45 and Q = 10
34/58
![Page 35: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Kα
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Idriss and Boulanger (2010)
35/58
![Page 36: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Pre-Failure CPT Data-FUND 06-CPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
FS
FS
36/58
![Page 37: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Pre-Failure CPT Data-FUND 06-CPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Tailings SandSlope :- Apparent fines content ~ 10%- Clay size fraction < 2% (Morgenstern et al., 2016)- Silt deposit has no cohesion
37/58
![Page 38: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Excess Pore Pressure Ratio
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Marcuson, W. F., Hynes, M. E., and Franklin, A. G., (1990). “Evaluation and use of residual strength in seismic safety analysis of embankments.” Earthquake Spectra, 6(3), 529–72.
38/58
![Page 39: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Pre-Failure CPT Data-FUND 06-CPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Tailings SandSlope :- Apparent fines content ~ 10%- Clay size fraction < 2% (Morgenstern et al., 2016)- Silt deposit has no cohesion
39/58
![Page 40: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Witness Location and Description
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
#5
#4: waves developed in the central portion of the reservoir, accompanied by cracks forming on the left side and blocks of sand moving up and down on the left abutment setback
waves
Sand boils
(Morgenstern et al., 2016)
40/58
![Page 41: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Pre-Failure CPT Data-FUND 16-CPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Tailings SandToe:- Apparent fines content ~ 10% & Depth = 3.76 m
41/58
![Page 42: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Pre-Failure CPT Data-FUND 16-CPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
FS
FS
FS
Depth = 3.8 m
42/58
![Page 43: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Pre-Failure SPT Data-FUND 15-SPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Tailings SandPlateau:- Apparent fines content ~ 10%- Clay size fraction < 2% (Morgenstern et al., 2016)- Silt deposit has no cohesion
(Morgenstern et al., 2016)
43/58
![Page 44: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
Pre-Failure SPT Data-FUND 15-SPT
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
FS
FS
Depth = 5.0 m
44/58
![Page 45: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
Cross-Section 02 – Main Shock
CrackScarp
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
ru = 0.11ru ~ 0.5ru = 0.3
Static ru =0.17 SandSlope SandPlateau SandToe
45/58
![Page 46: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Cross-Section 02 – Fore and After Shocks
CrackScarp
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
ru = 0.07ru ~ 0.2ru = 0.13
Static ru =0.17 SandSlope SandPlateau SandToe
46/58
![Page 47: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
Cross-Section 02 – Total ru Values
CrackScarp
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
ru = 0.42ru ~ 1.00ru = 0.73
Static ru =0.17
SandSlope and SandToe => liquefied strength
SandSlope SandToe SandPlateau
47/58
![Page 48: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
Pre-Failure Blasts & EarthquakesTable 2.1: Pre-failure blasts and earthquakes on 11/5/ 2015 (Atkinson, 2016)
Failure 1.5 hours after shaking – NO seismic coefficient (Marcuson et al., 2003)
Local Time
Moment Magnitude Mw
Dsitance from Fundao
Identification ru for SandToe
ru for SandPlateau
ru for SandSlope
1:01:49 PM 2.1 2.6 km mine blast 0 0 0
1:06:06 PM 2.3 2.6 km mine blast 0 0 0
Static ru 0.17 0.17 0.17
2:12:15 PM 2.2 <2 km earthquake
(foreshock) 0.13 0.07 0.2
2:13:51 PM 2.6 <2 km earthquake
(main shock) 0.3 0.11 0.5
2:16:03 PM 1.8 <2 km earthquake
(aftershock) 0.13 0.07 0.2
3:45:00 PM
Dam Failure
ru increase 0.56 0.25 0.9
Total ru=static+dynamic 0.73 0.42 1
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
48/58
![Page 49: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Figure . excess pore water pressure generation during cyclic loading with CSR =0.05 (reprinted from Morgenstern et al., 2016)The first solid points represent the pore pressure generation after 30 cycles loading with CSR =0.01. Some amount of pore water pressure is built up on three test within a few cycles with CSR = 0.05. Comment: The value of first red solid point is inconsistent with that presented on the table on page 2 of attachment D5
Excess pore water pressure
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
49/58
![Page 50: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
Critical state line – SandSlope
Liquefied
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
50/58
![Page 51: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
Critical state line – SandPlateau
Not Liquefied
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
51/58
![Page 52: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
Critical state line – SandSlope
Liquefied
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
52/58
![Page 53: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
Outline
• 5 November 2015 Failure• Chronology of events• Field observations• Subsurface investigation• Effect of blasting and earthquakes• Slope stability analyses• Summary
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
53/58
![Page 54: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Cross-Section 02 – Total ru Values
CrackScarp
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
ru = 0.42ru ~ 1.00ru = 0.73
Static ru =0.17 SandSlope SandPlateau SandToe
SandSlope and SandToe => liquefied strength
54/58
![Page 55: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
Light Blue, Pink and Magenta Layer ru
Each dynamic event generates excess pore water pressure that reduces shear resistance along left abutment
ru = 0.13 /0.07/0.2
Static ru = 0.17
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Initial Condition: ru=0.17
Final State:ru = 0.73/0.42/1.0
ru = 0.3 /0.11/0.5
ru = 0.13 /0.07/0.2
55/58
![Page 56: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
Limit Equilibrium Input Parameters
Material Type Color Strength
Typecohesion
(kPa)φ (°)
Liquefied su/σv' Ratio
ru
Sand Tailing Mohr-Coul
omb 33
Compacted Sand Mohr-Coul
omb 5 35
Foundation Mohr-Coul
omb 40
SandToe
Mohr-Coulomb 22 0.03
SandPlateau
Mohr-Coulomb 22 0.42
SandSlope
Mohr-Coulomb 22 0.03
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
56/58
![Page 57: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
Global Stability
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Initial Global FS ~ 2.0
After Shallow Movement FS <1.0
SandSlope SandPlateau
SandToe
57/58
![Page 58: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
Summary
• Tailings dam stability- consider dynamic loads
• Fundao Tailings Dam Failure- accumulation of excess pore-water pressures
• Tailings Dam Failure usually results in an EnvironmentalProblem
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
58/58
![Page 59: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam Failure
Presented by: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN
University of Illinois at [email protected]
Presented to:
51st Geotechnical Engineering ConferenceUniversity of Kansas
Lawrence, KansasNovember 14, 2019
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
59/58
![Page 60: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
60/58
![Page 61: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
Panel’s failure mechanism
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Lateral extrusion of slime leading to collapse loose sand above it
61/58
![Page 62: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
Mobilized Instability Ratio
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
62/58
- Static ru = ?- γ*h = 52 m (18.0 kN/m3) = 936.0 kPa - u = 40 m (9.81 kN/m3) = 392.4 kPa- Static ru = 392.4 kPa/936.0 kPa = 0.42 - Static ru = 0.42
- MIR = Δσ/σ’m- Δσ = σ’1 − σ’3- σ’m = σ’1 + σ’2 + σ’3
![Page 63: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
Mobilized Instability Ratio
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
63/58
- FSLiq = ?- FSLiq = 3 to 4- Seismic ru = 0.0 to 0.1 - Static ru = 0.42 - Total ru < 0.7 so NO liquefied strength
- MIR = Δσ/σ’m- Δσ = σ’1 − σ’3- σ’m = σ’1 + σ’2 + σ’3
![Page 64: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
Horizontal displacement contours
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Low shear strength was assign to slime layer. Global failure surface will not match that from field observation
64/58
![Page 65: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Stability Analysis & Mobilized Instability Ratio65/58
![Page 66: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
Slime configuration in Section 01
Predominantly slimes – 100% slimes properties;Mixed sand and slimes – 50:50 sand and slimes properties; Interbedded slimes – 20% slimes properties and 80% sand properties; and Isolated slimes – 100% sand properties
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Little slimes near slope – field observations
66/58
![Page 67: TIMOTHY D. STARK & JIALE LIN University of Illinois at Urbana …ceae.ku.edu/sites/ceae.ku.edu/files/docs/The Fundao... · 2019. 11. 22. · Dynamic Analysis of Fundao Tailings Dam](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060916/60a9d62a28ee1e5b8d6b4a69/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
Mobilized Instability Ratio
T.D.Stark-Slides-©
Figure 6-6 Mobilized Instability Ratio
Global Stability67/58