Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear...

25
Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St´ ephane P´ erennes To cite this version: Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St´ ephane P´ erennes. Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model. RR-3827, INRIA. 1999. <inria-00072831> HAL Id: inria-00072831 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072831 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destin´ ee au d´ epˆ ot et ` a la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´ es ou non, ´ emanant des ´ etablissements d’enseignement et de recherche fran¸cais ou ´ etrangers, des laboratoires publics ou priv´ es.

Transcript of Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear...

Page 1: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model

Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, Stephane Perennes

To cite this version:

Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, Stephane Perennes. Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in theLinear Cost Model. RR-3827, INRIA. 1999. <inria-00072831>

HAL Id: inria-00072831

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00072831

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinee au depot et a la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publies ou non,emanant des etablissements d’enseignement et derecherche francais ou etrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou prives.

Page 2: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

ISR

N IN

RIA

/RR

--38

27--

FR

+E

NG

ap por t de r ech er ch e

THÈME 1

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Tight Bounds for Broadcastingin the Linear Cost Model

Bruno Beauquier — Olivier Delmas — Stéphane Pérennes

N° 3827

Décembre 1999

Page 3: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:
Page 4: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65

����������� �����������������������������������������! #"$���� %���'&������()*�� ,+

-/.10�2�34-/57680�9:0�;<5=.?>A@CBED<;GF:;<5=.�H�5IDKJL6NM?O!@CP:QSR=T�UV682�5XWYRI.15=2�2�5=ME>

Z\[^]�_a`abdcfe%gihj`ikmlon!`qpYhjrohspt]�_a`ihuVvtwyxs`�p{z7|}wIw=~

e,km~�~8wmvjp%��`�vj`1��[�`�v���[�`��8���=�=�I�Acf�Yg1�q`�_ ��vt`/b1�m�=��c���b{~Nky�m`1h

�����i�������m�m� Z\[��}h ��wmvt����wm�^hj�}��`�v�h���vtw=k=����k=hsp�~^vjwmpjwo�qw=|}h _*km�o`�wy�{hjl^����`ihth��}�m`��qwm_a_ l�������k�pt��w=� t¡�¢o£8¤�¥ ���Xpj[�`�¦¨§ £8©�ªy a«�¡S¥­¬ _awo�o`�|¯®\pj[^`�pt��_a`��^`�`i��`i�Eptw�hj`��^�Ak!_a`ihthjkm�m`�wy�°|}`��^�ypj[²±³��h{�o`�´^��`1�k=hYµ·¶¸±°¹»º{¼½�·pj[���h{_/wo�o`i|<¾8pt[�` «�¡�¿/¿/¢o£ § «�ª�¬ § ¡�£$¬ § ¿a© wm�Cky�7r?km|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_'ÁÂ�}h{`qno~�vt`ihthj`i�EkmhYpj[�`hjl�_ÂÃdÄAÅjµ*¶AÆÇÄAÅj¹»¾7�%[�`ivj`dÃ{ÄL�}hCpj[^` £N¢o¿*Èt©� d¡sÉd j¡y¢o£8¤�¥ ky�^�ÊÆÇÄËpj[�` ¬¯ jª�£^¥�¿ § ¥�¥ § ¡�£X«�¡S¥­¬ wm��pj[�`km|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_Eº�¼½�/wmv��o`�v�pjw��o`1h��}�m�/ky��`�ÌÊ�q�}`��Ip°ky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_Ívt`iky|}�}Î��}���{kd�m�}�m`i���qw=_a_�l�������kypj�}wm� ~^k�pjpj`�vt��¾��pCky~^~N`1kyv�h�pj[^kyp°_/�}���}_a��Îi������ÃdÄËkm�^�/ÆÇÄ$kmvj`%km�=pt���^wm_a�}���=w=ky|�hiº:Ï�`,hsptl^�or pj[���h�pjv�km��`qÐÑwyÒÊ��hjhjl�`��Gwmv�^vjwIkm���ikmh�pd~�vtwyptwo�qwm|�hiº*zol�vj~^vj��h��}���=|�r=¾:h�lN��[Ók?�=`���`ivtkm|�pt[�`�w=vj`�pj����km|°hsptl^�orX[Nkmh�km|�_aw=h�p���`��=`�v��8`�`i���wm��`=º·¼½�Ópj[�`�|���pj`ivtkypjl�vt`m¾�wm��|}r²pj[�`!ps�ÔwAw=~�~8w=hj�Àpt`Ê�}hthjl�`ih�kmvj`�km�­ptl^ky|}|}r²�qw=�^hj�}�o`ivj`1�»®/_/�}���}_a��Îi�����pt[�`��7l�_��8`�v%wm��vtwml^�^��h\�}��pt[�`���k=h�`Õwm��hj[�wmvjp%_/`1hjhtky�=`ihi¾7wmv%_a���^��_a�}Î��}���apj[�`Õptvtkm�^hj_/��hth��}wm�?�qw=h�p,�}�pt[�` �ikmhj`�wm�°|}kmvj�=`�_a`ihthjkm�m`ihiºdÖ{l�vdvt`ihjl�|Àp�h{��wm�^��`�vt�Epj[�` �Gl�|}|�rIн�qw=����`i�qpj`1�A×EÐÑ��wo�o`ihY��`qps��wmvt�?Ø?Ù�¾�%��pj[Ú×ÜÛ#ݯÞ�¶�ßmà¯áC¾C�}�Ëpj[^`?�^�}�o�}vt`i�­pt��w=�^ky|,ÞÇâ%~8wmvjpth _awo�o`mºËÏ�`·�o`�vt�}�m`�pj�}�m[Ip/�8wml^�^��h/wm�Lpj[�`��wm_a_�l^���}�ik�pt��w=�Ópj�}_/`!�Gwmv ��vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}���E���4Ƴ¶äã·vjw=l��^��hi¾�wml�v |�w���`�v��Nw=l��^��h�[�wm|��o�}���A�Gw=v ky�7r�^`qps��wmvt�8º

å·æIçÇèté�ê ��ë��m� ��wm_a_�l^���}�ik�pt��w=����`�ps�Ôw=vj�ohi¾7��vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}���^¾I|}����`1kyv,��w=h�piºì�ídîsï�ð<î�í1ñSîsñaò�óSôKð¯õ<ò�ö½ð°÷�øNð<ùSúûô�ü�ò�üyîsõ�ý:õKú ð<ð<îsí óqþdð<ùSî�ô<îsö�÷­í1ñ ò�ÿið¯ùS÷­õVùSò�ô�óyî�îsí�ò�ösösîsü1ð¯îsñ úûídð¯ù1î������������� ��

����������������������� ����� �!� "#���%$��� ��&���� '���(�)��*��� �"+���������,����-%�.��"/"0� ���&)���������1����"324�5�67�!��8�9�$�;:=<>�?�@<0A B7C�DFE

G ù1úûô�ýÇ÷­õ'H,ù�ò�ô�óyîsî�ídü�ò�õKð<ú¨ò�I5I þYô¯ÿSü1üm÷­õGð<î�ñdó�þ,ð<ùSîVì3JLK�MON G úûí,ð¯ùSî�ø�õ<ò�P%îsýÇ÷­õ'H,÷�øoð<ùSî>J�õ<îsíSö¯ù QRK ô¯õ<ò�î�IûúoüSõK÷�S<îsö½ð�.��"/"0� ���&)���������%T3� UV�� ������W"/X=�!�Y<Z24����&)���([=����\��� ]�XÇò�íSñdó�þ,ð<ùSî>J�õ<îsíSö¯ù%MO^OM G üSõ<÷FS<îsö½ð`_a<.:>bc<cE

d=NWeLf>fag úûô»ò?SK÷­úûíqðÇüSõK÷�SKî�ö½ð»ý:ú ð<ù\ð¯ùSî>h@^OM3N\ò�í1ñ,ð<ùSî3i�íSú jqîsõKô¯ú ð þ%÷�øk^�úûösî�Q;Ni÷­üSùSú¨ò°ì�íqð<úûüm÷�IûúûôOl�K�m7NnI¨ò�óy÷­õ¯òtð<÷­õGþo)Ep QRP,ò�ú5I�qZrFs�t�u�vWwkx�s7y�zFu7{�u|�y�tZ}�~��7yF��� zFvVyZxR�7y�t7y�v�vVyW����� |�v7t�|FzZx���tE

� e7ò��Çõ<ú��3i�íSú jqîsõKô¯ú ð'���Ç÷­õKñSî�ò�ÿ1ï����am�� ��ös÷­ÿSõKôÕñSî�I¨ò�e7úûó4�sõ<òtð¯úû÷­í��am�m��7��� G ò�Iûî�í1ö�î�hÇîsñSî½ï(�3J�õ¯ò�í1ö�î�E p Q�P,ò�ú5I�q��� |���|�y�tLx��Vy ��� zV�F� � zF�7t�|�x�u���Ww�t��7y�z�u7�LxR��t�E

Page 5: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

������� %������� %���X����+���� ��������������� %� &����"�i� �%� �q��

��� ����� � ��� `�ptvtkS��ky�}|o�qw=�^h����o]ivj`\�o`ih�~�vtwyptwo�qwm|}`ih��o`%�o��ÒÇl^h��}wm�ahj`\��g�vtwml�|�ky�Ip�`i��� ¬½ª���©­¥ hjl^����`ihth��}�m`1hhjwmlNh�|�`!_/wo�o]i|�`X¦¨§ £ � ª §  t© �ol4�qw��op �o`��qwm_a_ l�������k�pt��w=�Ú® |}`*pj`i_a~^h��^gi�q`1hjhtky�}vt`/~8wml^v�`��7�=w�rm`�v�l^�_a`1hjhtky�=`Õ��`�|}wm���=l�`�l�v{±Ú`ih�p{�ogq´N����~NkyvYµ·¶L±°¹»º,�dky�^h{�q`�_awo�o]�|}`m¾8|}` ¬Ñ©�¿��^¥ ¤m©*«�¡y¿ ¿/¢o£ § «�ª�¬ § ¡�£��� l��Úky|}�mw=vj��pj[^_/`Eh � `�n7~^vj�}_a`?~Nkyva|}kÓhjwm_a_a`·Ã Ä ÅIµ$¶ Æ Ä Åm¹»¾\w�!¸Ã Ä `ih�p*|�` £8¡y¿*Èq j©²¤�" � ¬Ñª��o©q¥`�pdÆ Ä |�` «�¡$#o¬Y¤=©a¬< tª�£�¥­¿ § ¥�¥ § ¡y£ �o`/|%� ky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_a`=º�&V�²�7l�`/��`/��wm�^��`��mw=��v{l��²km|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_a`�`�Ì*�ikm��`vtgikm|���htky�IpÔl��Eht��[�g�_*k/�o`��qwm_a_ l�������k�pt��w=���ow=����g=¾o��|�km~�~^kyv�k('�p*)=l^`d_a�}���}_/��hj`�v%Ã Ä `�p%Æ Ä hjwm�Ip%�o`ihw=�oxs`i�qpj���Kh�ky�Ipt����w=_a�+)Il�`1h�º-,Ywml^h�g�pjl^����w=�^h�|}`Ê�qwm_a~�vtwm_a��hÕ��gi��`ihthjkm��vt`/`��Ipjvt`Ê�q`1h��o`�l�n��qw��opth��^ky�^h|}`Ê��k=�ovt`Ê�o`*|}k·���ÀÒÇl^hj��w=��º�¼½|�h.� kS�m]ivj`/)Il�� l���`*pt`�|}|�`Êg�pjl^��`*pj[�giwmvt�+)Il�`a�=g���givtkm|�`a��� kE~�v�k�pj�0)Il�`�_a`i�=px�km_*ky��hÔg�pjgd`��Ipjvt`�~^vj��h�`=ºV�{km�^h�|}k |���p�ptg�v�k�ptl�vj`=¾oh�`il�|�`i_a`��Ip%|�`1h���`�lon!�ikmh�`qn7pjv21�_a`1h�hjwm�Ip%�qw=�^h����ogivjg1hY®_a�}���}_/��htk�pj�}wm�A��l·��wm_ ��vj`���� g�ptky~8`ih{��ky�Nh,|}`���k=h,�o`�_a`ihthtky�m`1h%�qw=l�v�p�h�¾Nwml·_a�}����_a��hjkypj�}wm�A�olA��w3�op��`�pjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=�A��ky�NhY|}` �ikmhd�o`�_a`ihthtky�m`1h%|}wm���Ih�º�,,w=h{vtgihjl�|Àp�k�p�hY�qw=�^�q`ivj�^`��Ip{|}`�vtgihj`ikmlA�qwm_a~�|}`qpØ Ù ¾okS�m`1�%×'Û�ݯÞ\¶Óßmà¯á°¾ohjwml^h°|�`{_/wo�o`ÕÞIÐÑ~Nw=v�p�hV�����o��vt`i�qpj�}wm���^`�|¯º4,Ywml^hÔ�og�vt�}�mwm�Nh°�o`ihC�Nw=vj�^`ihV´N��`ihhjl�v°|}`%pt`�_a~^hC��`,�qwm_a_ l�������k�pt��w=�a~Nw=l�vC|�k��o��Ò8l^hj�}wm�*`��*ÆE¶?ãYg�ptky~8`ihi¾I|�`1hV�Nw=vj�^`ihV�}�o�Gg�vt�}`�l�vt`ihVg�ptkm�=p��km|}km��|�`1h\��ky�^h%pjwml�p\vtgihj`ikml�º

5�ê �1� è �36 � �?� vtgihj`ikyl�n!�o`��qwm_a_ l�������k�pt��w=��¾��o��Ò8lNh��}wm��¾N�qw3��p,|��}��gikm��vt`mº

Page 6: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�:§���� ¬��Y¡y¢o£8¤�¥CÉq¡� ��, j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ § £ � �

� ������*�E�!�C���q �

Ïä[^`��!h�pjl^��rI�}���/�����Gwmvt_akypj�}wm�Ê�o��hth�`i_/�}�^kypj�}wm�Ê�}�!�qw=_a_�l�������kypj�}wm�*��`�ps�Ôw=vj�ohi¾mwm� pj`��?�qw=�^h����o`ivj`1�*kyvt`~^vjwmpjwo�qw=|}h%_*k=�o`�wy�°hjl^����`ihth��}�m`���wm_a_�l^���}�ik�pt��w=�  t¡�¢o£8¤�¥ �%��pj[Ak·¦¨§ £Ç©�ª�  _aw7��`�|��Gwmv,pt[�`���wm_a_�l��^�ÀÐ�ik�pt��w=� «�¡�¥�¬ ®Vpj[�`�pj�}_/`��^`�`i��`i�?pjwÊhj`��N�?ka_a`1hjhtky�=`dwm�°h��}Î�`�±L�Gvtwm_ka�^w7��`�pjwÊkm��wypt[�`�v%��hY�o`�´^��`1�k=hCµa¶A±C¹»¾I�%[^`�vt`{µ�hsp�ky�^��hC�Gwmv�k�h�ptkmv�pjЯl�~apt��_a`d�%[��}|�`d±°¹Êvt`�~�vt`ihj`��Ip�h�pj[�`Õ�qwIhspÔwy�:hj`��^�o�}���/±Ë����pthwm�°��k�p�k*���²kÊ��[^ky�^��`�|��%�Àpt[A�^km�^�o�%���7pj[Ëß�S¹»º,Z\[�` «�¡S¥­¬,¡sÉaª! t¡�¢o£8¤ ��hY��`q´^��`1�Akmh,pj[�` _*k�no��_ l�_wm�Vpj[�`a�qwIhspdwy�Ckm|�|�pj[�`a�qw=_a_�l�������kypj�}wm�^hd�ow=��` �ol^vj�}���Êpt[���hYvtwml��N�»º{¼½��h�lN��[XkÊ_awo�o`�|}�}Îik�pt��w=��¾8pj[�`� ê � � � � �G�=�o��� ê �Í��� � æAwm��ky�7rXkm|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_ Á ��ky���8`*`qno~�vt`ihth�`1�Xkmhdpt[�`*h�l^_ Ã Ä ÅyµX¶ÚÆ Ä Å�¹»¾�%[^`�vt`\Ã Ä ��h�pj[�` � ���A� æ � ê�� � ê ����ë�� km�^�/Æ Ä pt[�` ���������(���G�i��� ê ��� ê ��� wy�8pj[^`,ky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_Eº�Z\[^�}h|}�}��`ikmvV_/wo�o`i|^wm�Npt[�`Y�qw=_a_�l�������kypj�}wm�a�qwIhsp°��hVwy� pt`��al^hj`i�a�}�/pj[�`,|}��pj`�v�k�ptl�vt`\km�^�/vj`��G`�vt`��^��`ih�ptw�ky|}�mwmÐvt��pj[�_a���\�Ôw=vj���iky�a�8`%�Gwml��N� �}��� ��¾I���Ѻ�Ïä[�`��aptvjr7�}���Õpjw���`ihj���=�akm�awm~opt��_*ky|Nky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_�~8`�vj�Gwmvt_a���^�k��m�}�m`i�Ê�qwm_a_ l�������k�pt��w=�Ê~^kyp�pj`ivj�:¾=��p\km~�~8`ikyv�hVpt[^k�p�_a�����}_a��Îi���^�/ÃdÄLkm�^�*Æ»Ä4kmvj`{wy� pt`�� ªy£^¬ § £8¡�¿ § «�=w=km|}hiº�¼½���Kkm�qpi¾��}��pj[�`Õ|}�Àpt`�v�k�pjl^vj`Õ_*ky�7rÊkyl�pj[�w=vth�wm~�pj�}_/�}Î�`Õw=��|�r!wm��`Õwy��pj[�`1h�`dps��w ~Nkyv�ky_a`qpt`�v�hC�7r��wm�^hj���o`�vt���^� w=��`Õwy��pj[�`Õps��w `�n7pjvt`�_*ky|��ikmhj`ihi®

��� � ¡� ­¬a¿a©q¥�¥�ª � ©­¥�� § � © � µ"! ±°¹�#Xâ ¼½�Úpt[���h��ikmhj`m¾,ÃdÄ Å�µ��}hÊpj[�`²|�`1km�o�}���$pt`�vt_ wm��pj[�`�qw=_/_ l�������kypj�}wm��pj�}_a`mº�$,`i�^�q`=¾�w=��|�rXpj[�`!�Il^_��8`�v�wm�\vtwml^�^��h���hÕpjwX�N`Ê_a�}���}_/�}Î�`1�»º&%·ky�7rkylopt[�wmv�h�[^kS�m`�~�vtwm~8w=hj`i����vtw=k=����k=hsp�ky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_*h�wm~opt��_*ky|7�%��pj[ pj[^kypVvj`1h�~8`i�qp � h�`i`Cpt[�`%h�l�vt�m`iroh��b�'o¾�b=b(�¯¾�pj[�`��8w7wm�&�}b*)��Ѿopt[�`���[^ky~�pj`�v+�}bi�,��wmv\pj[^`Õpj[�`1h�`1h+� �^¾N���-#­º

�/.:ªy  � ©�¿*©­¥�¥�ª � ©­¥0� § � © ��±°¹1!#µ2#Yâ ¼½�Êpt[��}h%�ikmhj`m¾7wm�^|�rapt[�`dpjv�ky�^hj_a�}hth��}wm���qw=h�p\�}h�ptw �8`Õ_/�}�oÐ��_a�}Î�`1�»ºÊZ:`1��[����0)Il�`ihi¾�|}���=`/~^��~8`�|}���^`i�Óky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_*h{l^hj�����13j�o��hGxsw=���Ip54*h�~Nky�����}���?pjvt`�`1h�¾:`��^hjl�vt`ka��`ikmvj|}r!w=~opj�}_*ky|:��w=h�p%�Gwmv%_a`ihthtky�m`dptvtkm�^h�_a��hjhj�}wm� � hj`�`0� ��¾�bS�7¾:b,6����GwmvY[Ir7~8`�v��ql��8`���`�ps�Ôw=vj�wmv+� )�¾��,�»�Gwmv��mvt����h�¾okm�^�&�}b�'o¾»b�)��Ç�Gwmv%k �m`��^`�v�ky|Çh�l�vt�m`ir7#­º4,,wypt`Ypt[^k�p\pt[��}h\�7�}�^�Êwm�:wm~�pj�}_akm|���psrky|}��kSroh��}_/~^|��}`ih,k/|�kyvt�m`d�7l�_��8`�v%wm����wm_a_�l��^�}�ik�pj�}wm��vjw=l��^��hiº

zowm_a`/kmlopj[^wmv�h{��wm�^hj�}��`�vt`i�Akm|}hjwÊ�Kkm_/�}|}��`1h{wm�Ôky|}�mw=vj��pj[^_ahdÁ*Ý98»à,�o`�~8`��N�o���^��w=�²hjwm_a`�~^kmvtkm_a`qpj`iv:8� �GwmvV`�nokm_a~�|�`=¾��GwmvV~^��~8`�|}���^`i�aky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_*h;8al^hjl^ky|}|}r�vj`i~�vt`ihj`��Ipth�pj[^`\hj�}Î�`%wy�8~^km���=`qp�h�¾yk=hjhjl�_a���^�{pt[^k�pkm|�|�~^km���=`qp�h\[^kS�m`Õpt[�` htky_a`�hj��Îi`Êâ h�`i`�pj[�` h�l�vt�m`ir<�}b�',�Vky�N�!pt[�` k=hjhjwo�q��k�pt`i�?vj`��G`�vt`��^��`ih=#­º�¼½�·pj[^�}h�ikmhj`m¾Spt[�`\�Kky_a�}|�r/Á*Ý>8�à�l^h�`1hVÃ{ÄYÝ>8�à�vjw=l��^��h��%��pj[*k{pjv�ky�^hj_a�}hthj��w=� �qwIhspVÆ»Ä,Ý98»àtº�Ïä��pj[��}�Êk{�Kky_a�}|�r=¾=kmhpt[�`%�Gl��N�­pj�}wm�NhCÃdÄ,Ý>8�à�ky�N�aÆÇÄYÝ>8�à:[^kS�m`\l^hjl^km|�|}r km�*wm~�~8w=hj�Àpt`%�N`i[^kS�7��w=vi¾ypj[�`,w=~opj�}_*ky|?8Ê_/�}���}_a��Îi�����pt[�`��qw=_a_�l�������kypj�}wm�!pj�}_/`��iky�E�8`���[�w=hj`��!�Gwmv%�m�}�m`i�?µÔ¾^±Úky�N��¹»º

$Y`�vt`m¾:�}��wmv��o`�vdpjw·�o`1h��}�m��wm~�pj�}_akm|°ky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_*hÕky�N�AptwEh�pjlN�orApt[��}h�pjv�km�o`�ЯwmÒ�¾»��`a~�vjwo��`�`i�²�}�k��o��Ò8`ivj`i�=pd��kSr=º+@d�}�m`i�·pj[^` �7l�_ �N`iv{wm�°vjw=l��^��hi¾Ç�Ô`�pjvtr�ptw��o`�pj`ivj_a�}��` � k�pÕ|�`1kmh�pYptwÊ´^�^�²k*pt���=[=p`1hspt��_*kypj�}wm�/wy�A#�pt[�`%_a�����}_�l^_�ptvtkm�^h�_a��hjhj�}wm� ��w=h�pVwy�8km�7r�ky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_�vj`1ky|}��Îi�����{pj[^`,�qwm_a_ l�������k�pt��w=�~Nk�p�pt`�vt�a�%�Àpt[����apt[���h°�m�}�m`i�a�Il^_��8`�v°wm�Çvtwml^�^��hiº�BÚ�=`���`ivtkm|opj[�`iwmvt`qpt�}�iky|�h�pjl^�oraky�8wml�pCh�l^��[Êkdptvtk=�o`qÐwmÒ?[Nkmh�ky|}_/wIhsp���`��=`�v��N`i`��?�owm��` � `�no��`�~op\�}�<�C6,�-#Ckm�^�apj[^`�vt`q�Gwmvt`Y�^w�wm~�pj�}_akm|Ç~�vjwmpjwo�qw=|^�\kmhÔ�7��w��%��^lop,���?pt[�`���k=h�`dwy�Vh�[^wmvjp\w=v\|}kmvj�=`d_a`1hjhtky�=`ihi¾=�7r!w=~opj�}_a��Îi���^�/w=��|}r*pj[�`�|}`ik=�o�}���/pj`�vt_Eº

MOM í�D m(E(FHG

Page 7: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

) �{©tªy¢��q¢ § ©� ����/© ¦ ¿aª�¥��� �  j©�£^£8©q¥

Z\[�`Ó�o`�pj`�vt_a���Nk�pj�}wm�äwm��pj[^`X_a���^��_ l�_ pjv�ky�^hj_a�}hthj��w=�³�qw=h�p�wm��ky� km|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_ l^h��}���¸kË�m�}�m`i��7l�_ �N`ivCwm�Çvtwml^�^��hCkm~�~8`ikyv�h�ptw��N`dk��o��ÌÊ�ql�|�pÔ~�vtwm�^|�`i_?º°z7wN¾m��`,vt`ih�pjvt�}�qpCwml�v�hj`�|}�m`ihVpjw�pt[�`{��wm_a_�loÐ�^�}�ik�pj�}wm�?hj��[^`�_a`d�iky|}|�`1�Ê��vtw=k=����k=hspt���^�^¾I�%[�`�vt`dk/hj�����=|�`Õhjwml�v��q`d[^kmhÔptw/hj`��^�!pj[^`Õhtky_a`d_a`ihthjkm�m`Ywm�|}`��^�ypj[/±Aptwdkm|�|Ipt[�`\wypj[^`�v���wo�o`ih��}��pt[�`���`qps��wmvt�Ǻ:Ï�`�km|}hjwdk=hjhjl�_a`°pt[^k�pV|}���^�7h�kmvj`C�Gl�|�|�н�ol�~�|}`qn � § � © �pt[�`�vt`Õ�}h%k/�����o�}vj`1�­pt��w=�^ky|Ç|}�����!�N`�ps�Ô`i`��?`ikm��[?~^km��v\wy����wo�o`�#\km�^�!pj[^kyp%k/��wo�o`��iky�Eh��}_�l�|�ptkm��`�w=l^hj|�rhj`��N�·ky�^�Evt`i��`��}�m`���kyptk*w=�Ak�pY_awIhspdÞ»â%~Nw=v�p�h�º%Ï�` ��wm�^hj�}��`�v%pt[�` �ikmhj`��%[�`�vt`�pj[^`���`�ps�Ôw=vj���}hYpj[�`��wm_a~�|}`qpt`��mv�ky~�[·Ø�ÙÍkm�^�?�Ô` kmhth�l�_a`Õpt[^k�p{× Û�ÝÑÞ�¶ ßyà¯áC¾Nk=h\pj[���h,��h\pt[�`�_*k�no�}_�l�_ �7l�_��8`�v,wm��^w7��`ihÔ�%[��}��[���ky�!�N`d�����Gwmvt_/`1�*�}�!Ƴvtwml��N��h�º�Ïä��pj[Êpt[�`ihj`d[Ir7~8wypt[�`ihj`ihi¾Ikm�7r/�^vjwIkm���ikmh�pCky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_�^`�`i�^h ª�¬ ¦ ©�ªS¥­¬ Æ vtwml��^�^h�º

¼½� pj[���h�~^ky~8`�v1¾���`Ôh�pjl^�or�pj[�`\ky�Ipj�}��w=_�rÕ�N`�ps�Ô`i`���pj[�`��7l�_��8`�v�wy�Nvjw=l��^��h�ky�^��pj[�`Ôpjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=���w=h�piº�Ïä[�`��äpt[�`��Il^_��8`�v!wm��vjw=l��^��h���h!hj_akm|�|¯¾,_awmvt`X`�n�km�­pt|�r¸wy��pt[�`A�Gw=vj_ Æ ¶ ã$�%�Àpt[ ã� ��������� ÝKÆ�à�¶!ß=¾��Ô`�h�[�w���pt[^k�pVky� `ih�pj�}_akypj�}wm��wm�opj[�`Ôpjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=���qwIhsp��}h��m�}�m`i���7r�ky��`�no~Nw=��`��Ipj��ky|��`i�qvt`ik=h�` á� ��������� ¶�� Ý �� àjº � wm�7�m`ivthj`�|}rm¾°�Gwmv*k�|}kmvj�=`��7l�_ �N`iv*wy�{`�n7pjv�kXvtwml��N��h/ã��'Æ âÍßm¾Ô�Ô`w=�^hj`�vt�m`,k�|}�}��`ikmv��o`1�qvt`ik=h�` á � ����!��� â#"*Ý ��!$ àj¾o�%[�`ivj`1kmhV�Gw=vÔ�}�Ipj`ivj_a`i���}kypj`,��ky|}l�`1hC��w pjv�km��`qÐÑwyÒ�wo�i�ql�v�h�¾pt[�`Õpjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=����w=h�p\vt`�_*km�����}���*�q|}w=hj`{pjw&% mÞǺ

Z\[�`akyvjpj���q|}`���hdwmvt�=km����Îi`i�·k=h,�Gw=|�|}w��,h�ºd¼½�²hj`i�qpj�}wm�²�Ê�Ô`/�m�}�m`�pj[�`a�o`q´N���Àpt��w=�^hÕky�^�X[7rI~8wypt[�`ihj`ihkm�^�$hj[�w�� �%[IrÓw=l�v h�pjl^��r���h���km|����Ó�Gwmv �Nwmpj[4pj[�`?hsptwmvt`qнky�^�7Я�Gwmvt�\kyv��Xky�N�Ópj[�`?�q�}vt��l���p�нh��%��pt��[�`1�vtwml�pj�}���a_/wo�o`1h�ºCϲ`�km|}hjwa���Ipjvtwo�ol^��`�k/�Gl��^�­pt��w=�·ky|}|�w��%�}���/pjwÊh�pjl^��rÊpj[^`Õpjv�km�o`�ЯwmÒA�}hth�l^`Õ�Gwmvt_akm|�|}rmº¼½�Ëhj`i�qpj�}wm�Ë�·��`Ê�=���=`Êky�$l�~�~8`�v/�8wml��^���Gw=v���vtw=k=����k=hspt���^�?�%��pj[LkE�G`�� `qn7ptvtk·vtwml^�^��hi¾��%[��}|}`Ê�Ô`��`�vt���=`°pj�}�m[Ip�|�w���`�v��8wml��^�^h��}�ah�`1�­pj�}wm� )^ºVÖYpj[�`iv�pt���=[Ip��8wml��N��h��Gwmv�_*ky�7r�`qn7pjv�k,vtwml^�^��h�kyvt`Ô�o`ivj�}�m`1��}�·h�`1�­pt��w=� 6�º�¼½�·��wm�^��|�l^hj�}wm�?�Ô`�hjl�_a_akmvj�}Î�`dwml^v%vj`1h�l�|�pth%km�^�E�o��hj��l^hjh�pt[�`��}v,ky~^~�|�����kypj�}wm�^hiº

' �!����( *)���,+

e,`i��km|�|Çpt[^k�p,��`��qw=�^h����o`iv ¥.-�£Ç« �  j¡�£Ç¡�¢7¥ ~�vtwypjwo��wm|�hÔ_*k=�o`�wy��h�l^�i�q`1hjhj���=`d��wm_a_�l^���}�ik�pt��w=��vtwml��N��h�º/?æ10 � � ��� ê ��2 Z\[^` � ê � � ��� �G�=�o��� ê �³��� � æ!wy�°k/��vjwIkm���ikmh�p,ky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_�Á �}�·ka��`qps��wmvt�43���km��8`!`�no~�vj`1hjhj`i�$k=h65SݯÁaà�Û�ÃdÄäÅIµ²¶äÆ»ÄäÅm¹»¾°�%[�`�vt`!ÃdÄ���h�pt[�`!�7l�_ �N`iv wm�,vjw=l��^��h ky�^�ËÆÇÄ�pj[�`ptvtkm�^hj_/��hth��}wm�?�qw=h�piºVZ\[�`�_a�}���}_�l�_��vjwIkm���ikmh�pÔpt��_a`�w��=`�v%ky|}|�ky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_*h���h,�o`��^wypj`1�!�7r45�Ý73 àjº

8^wmvCkm�IraÞIÐÑ~Nw=v�p�h���`qps��wmvt���%��pj[Ê× ��wo�o`ihi¾ypt[�`%l^hjl^ky|^|�w���`�vV�8wml��N�awm�/pj[�`\pt��_a`%�Gw=v°��vtw=k=����k=hspjÐ�}���ak�_a`1hjhtky�=`{wm�:|�`i���ypt[?±L��h\`qno~�vt`ihth�`1�ÊkmhÔpj[^`Õhjl�_ wm�:pt[�`Õ|�w���`�v��Nw=l��^��h���ky|}���Ê�Gw=vÔpt[�`Õ�7l�_��8`�vwm��vtwml��N��h%ky�^�!�Gwmv\pt[�`Õpjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=�?��w=h�p � �,�Ñ®

5SÝ93 à:� ; �<�=�1���,� ×?>,Å1µ�¶ ± Þ Åi¹ � b�#B{hÊky|}vt`ikm��r$��wypt�}��`i�»¾�`qno��hspt�����Ól�~^~N`ivÊ�Nw=l��^��hÊ[^kS�m`�)Il��Àpt`AkÓ�o�ÀÒÇ`�vt`��Ip*�Gw=vj_ �%[�`�vt`·kXptvtk=�o`qÐÑwyÒkm~�~8`ikyv�hiº

K�^3M@K ì

Page 8: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�:§���� ¬��Y¡y¢o£8¤�¥CÉq¡� ��, j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ § £ � 6

Z\[�`��Gl��^�qpj�}wm�¸�o`q´^�^`i�Ë�8`�|}w��Â�%�}|�|\�8`�l^hj`q�Gl^|Ôptw²�o`ivj�}�m`?kAvt`�|�k�pt��w=�$�N`�ps�Ô`i`��Ëpt[�` £^¢o¿ÊÈj©� �¡�É t¡�¢o£8¤�¥ km�^�!pj[�` ¬¯ jª�£^¥­¿ § ¥�¥ § ¡�£Ó«t¡�¥­¬ º

/?æ10 � � ��� ê ����� `qp 3 �N`/k*´�no`1�·��`qps��wmvt�Eky�^�·ÆÍpt[�`/_/�}���}_�l�_'�7l�_ �N`iv{wm�°vjw=l��^��hY�Gwmv{��vjwIkm�7Ð�ikmh�pj�}���$�}� 3/ºÍZ\[^`���¾���Ý93��j±��jãIà��}h��o`q´N��`i�äk=hapj[�` ��� � �%� ��� �������������G�1��� ê �� ê �i� wy��ky�7rkm|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_ ��vtw=km�^��kmh�pj�}�����}� 3 k�_a`1hjhtky�=`Ywy��|�`i���ypt[?±¸ky�^���qw=_/~^|�`�pj�}��� �}�!ã æ �i���X� ê � ��ë�� ¾Ç§ � © �lNh��}���aÆ$¶Ëã/vjw=l��^��hiº

Ïä��pj[Ept[�`�~�vt`��7��w=l^h\�o`q´N���Àpt��w=��¾���`Õ[^kS�m` 5SÝ93 à � Ý<Æ˶ËãIà:Åiµ?¶���Ý93��j±��jãIà:Å�¹»¾o�Gw=v,ky�7rÊã � �^º

�Eç��Cê ��� æ ���G��� u�k=���m`qp,hj��Îi`ih%kmvj`Õkmhth�l^_/`1�Êptw*�N` � ê �8��� � � ê ��� º

Z\[���hC��wI`1hV��wmpC[�wm|��/�Gwmvt_*ky|}|�r����*~�v�km�qpj���q`=¾=kmh°_/`1hjhtky�=`ihVkmvj`%_*km��`%wy�»���Ipt`��m`iv°�7l�_��8`�v�hVwm�Ç�^�Àp�h�º$Yw��Ô`i�m`ivi¾7kmh�pt[�`ihj`��7l�_��8`�v�h%kyvt`{�=`���`ivtkm|�|}r*|�kyvt�m`m¾7pt[�`��qw=�Ipj�}�Il^�ÀpsrÊk=hjhjl�_a~opj�}wm�?_*ky�=`ih%hj`��^hj`mº

� � ê��°æ �S� ç ��� ¥�¥­¢o¿ § £ � «�¡y£^¬ § £^¢^¡�¢7¥ ��ªm«��y©q¬Ç¥ §�� ©­¥��Ǭ � ©ÇÉ�¢o£8«�¬ § ¡y£ �·§ ¥ ¦¨§ £8©�ª�  § £ ± � �¯º `mº���Ý73��t±���ãIà�Û��Ý93���ß��ãIà:Å�± � � ¡� t©t¡"!S©� �� ��Ý93���ß��ãIà{§ ¥�ª*£Ç¡�£$# § £8«� j©�ªS¥ § £ � É�¢o£8«�¬ § ¡y£�¡�É ã �

� � ê�ê��&% � `�p(' �N`?k·_a`ihthjkm�m`*wy�%|}`����mpj[˱�km�^�Ó|}`qp/Á�)+*%�8`!ky�Ëkm|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_ ��vtw=k=����k=hspt���^�Ek_a`1hjhtky�=`,'.-Çwm��|}`����mpj[·±/-Ç�%��pj[?ptvtkm�^h�_a��hjhj�}wm����w=h�p���Ý73��j±0-1�jãIàjº

� `qpYl^hY�o`���wmpj`��7r32·pj[�`Õ�Gl^�^�­pt��w=�5476894ÊÅi± �± - �Gvtwm_;: �<�j± ->= ptw?: �<�j± = º ,,wypt`Õpj[^kyp@2E�}�^�ol^��`ihkA�Gl��^�qpj�}wm�BA �Gvjw=_#pj[�`Ehj`qpawy�{hjl���_a`ihthtky�m`1h�wm�@'.-Ôpjw²pj[�`Eh�`�p/wm�{hjl���_a`ihthjkm�m`1h�wy�,' º�Ïä��pj[�Gl^�^�­pt��w=�CA#�Ô`�kmvj`�km��|�`Õptw!�o`�´^��`�hjl���_a`ihthjkm�m`1h\wy�/'Ü�Gvtwm_'hjl���_a`ihthjkm�m`1h\wy��' - º D�rÊ�Gw=|�|}w��%���^�pt[�`!htky_a`!��wm_a_�l��^�}�ik�pj�}wm�Ó~�vtwyptwo�qwm|°k=h�Á ) *\�%�Àpt[$pj[�`!��_*ky�=`ih��7rEA$¾��Ô`Êw=�optkm���$km�Ëky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_Á�)A�^vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}���(' �%��pj[A��w=h�p@��Ý73��t± - �jãIà�Å1±:�± - º $,`i�^�q`=¾���Ý93��j±��jãIà*F��Ý73��t± - ��ãIà�ÅS±:y± - ºGD�r�}�7�m`iv�pt�����/vtwm|}`ih\wy�H' - ky�N�3' ¾o��`��m`�p�pt[�`�vt`��m`ivthj`Y�}��`�)=lNky|}�Àpsr=º

,Ywypj`�k�p�|�kmh�p�pj[^kyp ky�7r�ky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_ lNh��}���Aã�¶Íß*vtwml��^�^h���km�$`�_�l^|}kypj`Êky�$km|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_ l^hj�}���·ãvtwml^�^��h\�7r!hj`��^�o�}���a`�_a~opsr�_a`ihthjkm�m`ih��ol�vt�}���*�Àp�h\|}k=hsp,vtwml^�^�»¾�hjw(��Ý93���ßI�jã%¶³ßyà J��Ý73��ißI�jã=àtº K

��æ �Ó�o��LBM BYh���Ý93��j±��jãIàC�}h\|}�}��`ikmv%���·±,¾o��`Õ�%��|}|:��wm�^hj�}��`�v\��º |¯º w^º �^º�pj[^kypY±4Û ß=º

�Eç��Cê ��� æ ���G��N Ï�`��qw=�^hj�}�o`iv�pj[�`��ikmhj`dwm��pt[�` � ê � � 6 æ � æ5O �S� � � Ø?Ù �%�Àpt[·× ��wo�o`1h�º

,Ywypj`Êpj[^kyp�pj[�`*�8`�[NkS�I�}wml^v�wy����Ý73��ißI��ãIà{h�pjvtwm�^�m|}rX�o`�~8`��N��h�w=�²pt[�`*ptwm~8wm|}wm�mrXwy�%��`qps��wmvt� 3/ºBY�7r·|��}���A�qw=�QP^���­pÕ�}hdkS�mw=�}��`i�·�}�Apt[�`/��wm_a~�|}`qpt` �=vtkm~�[�º�Z\[�`�vt`q�Gw=vj` �Ô` �%��|}|°�o`ivj�}�m` |�w���`�v{�Nw=l��^��h��km|������Gwmv,`i�m`�vtrÊ��`�ps�Ôw=vj�!�%�Àpt[A×#��wo�o`ihiº:%Ew=vj`iw��m`ivi¾okmh\`1km��[E~^km��v,wm���=`�vjpj���q`1h,��km�E��wm_a_�l^���}�ik�pt`

MOM í�D m(E(FHG

Page 9: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

� �{©tªy¢��q¢ § ©� ����/© ¦ ¿aª�¥��� �  j©�£^£8©q¥

�}�/pj[�`{�qwm_a~�|}`qpt`%�mv�ky~�[:¾�pj[�`{hsptl^�or/�}h°km|}hjwÕ��ky|}�}�/�Gw=vV�Nwmpj[apj[^`Yhsptwmvt`qнky�^�oÐ<�Gw=vj�\kyv���ky�^�/pt[�`,�q�}v��ql���p�Ðhj�%��pt��[�`1�!vtwmlopt���^�/_awo�o`1h�º

8��}�^ky|}|�r=¾��}�?w=vt��`�v�pjw*hj��_a~�|}�À�Gr?�qw=_/~^loptkypj�}wm�^h\��`Õ�%��|}|:kmhthjl�_a`{pt[^k�p1®

�Eç��Cê ��� æ ���G����� �^�o`iv%pj[�`�Þ7Я~8wmvjpth\�qw=_a_�l�������kypj�}wm�?_aw7��`m¾^× Û ÝÑÞ�¶äßmà á º

Z\[���h%��h\��wypYkS�=`�vtravj`1hsptvj���­pt���=`{[7r7~Nwmpj[�`1h���hi¾�kmh%× �}h\pt[�`�vt`��7r*pt[�`Õ_*k�no��_ l�_��7l�_ �N`iv%wy����wo�o`ih�%[^�}��[E��km���8`������Gwmvt_/`1�?�Ir�k �^vjwIkm���ikmh�p�~�vtwyptwo�qwm|»��wm_a~�|}`qpj�}���*�}��ÆÍ�qw=_a_�l�������kypj�}wm�?vjw=l��^��hiº

Ïä��pj[ ky|}|Ypt[�`ihj`²[7r7~8wypj[^`ihj`ihi¾%�Ô`²�m�}�m`A�}�³pt[�`²�^`qn7p?hj`i�qpj�}wm�^h�vj`1h�l^|Àp�hÊwm� ��Ý<Ø Ù ��ß��ãIàj¾,�%��pj[× Û Ý¯Þ�¶³ßyà¯áC¾opj[Nk�p%�%��|}|��8`��o`��^wypj`1�Eh��}_a~�|�r!�Ir7� á Ý<ãIàjº

Ïä��pj[Ept[��}h,��wyp�k�pj�}wm�:¾o�Ô`Õ[^kS�=`{�}_a_/`1�o��k�pj`i|�rÇ®

� � ê��°ê ��� ��� ê ��� � á Ý ��à�ÛäÆ �

� � ê�ê��&% BYhd×#Û Ý¯Þ�¶ ßmà¯á°¾Ç`i�m`�vtr!�^w7��`�wypt[�`�v{pj[Nky�·pt[�` hjwml�v��q`��iky�A�8`��}�o�Gw=vj_a`i�Awm��|}r�w=�^�q`��l�vj�}���Xpj[�`?ÆÂvjw=l��^��h/ky�N�$_�l^h�p vt`i��`��}�m`!pj[�`��%[�wm|}`!_a`ihthtky�m`!�%[�w=hj`!|}`����mpj[L�}h�ßmº�$,`i�^�q`=¾Vpj[�`hj�}Î�`�wy�Vky�7rÊ_a`1hjhtky�=`Õhj`��IpY�ol^vj�}���*ky�7r!vtwml^�^�!_ l^h�p,�N`�`�)Il^ky|»ptw·ßm¾�km�^�Eh�w � á Ý ��à �J��º BÍ�=vj`i`i�orkm|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_ _*k�p���[��}���/pj[���h,�8wml��N�·��ky�E�8`��o`q´N��`i�·k=h��Gwm|}|�w��,hiºC�{l�vj�}���*ÆÍvtwml��^�^h\`��m`ivjr!���o�Gw=vj_a`1��^w7��`\hj`��N��h�pj[^`��%[^wm|}`%_/`1hjhtky�=`Cptw�Þ��^wypVrm`�p��}�o�Gw=vj_a`i�/��wo�o`1h�º�Z\[�`\��vtw=k=����k=hsp��}h�pt[7l^h°�qw=_a~�|�`�pj`1�km�^�!pj[�`�vt`ihjl�|�pj�}���/pjv�ky�^hj_a�}hth��}wm�?�qwIhsp%��h%Æ�º K

� � � �X %��X��?��� �����?�������������������� )����� � �� *) �a����� �� �������

$Y`�vt`m¾I�Ô`{�qwm�Nhsptvjl^�qpC�}�^�ol^�qpj�}�m`�|}r*ky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_*h°�GwmvC�^vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}�����%�Àpt[ÊãÕ`qn7pjv�k�vtwml��N��h�º�Ï�`{�}����pj��k�pj`pt[�`��}�^�ol^�qpj�}wm�E�7rÊl^hj�����/pt[�`��mvt`�`1�or*��vtw=km�^��kmh�p%ky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_ �=���=`������·uVvtwm~8w=hj�Àpt��w=�?�^º

�Ôæ � �Ó�� �� ¡y  Æ� � ªy£8¤ ã��B� � � á ÝKãIà ������ ¶�������� � ��� �������� �

� � ê�ê��&%*8^wmv�� � ��¾�|}`qp�×! ,ÛݯÞ/¶ ßyà ¾»[�`��^��`*× Û�× á º/Z\[�`a�}��`ik?�qwm�Nh���hsp�hd���Ó�o`q´N�����^�?km�km|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_��}�ÊØ�ÙÚlNh��}����Æ?¶?ãdvtwml��^�^h��Gvjw=_ km�*ky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_����ÊØ�Ù ����� l^hj�}����ÆAâAß�¶?ãVâAß\vtwml��N��h�º

Z\[�` �m`iv�pt`qn?hj`qp�"*Ý¯Ø Ù à�wy�Vpj[^` �qw=_a~�|�`�pj`��=vtkm~�[·Ø Ù �iky�·�8` hj`�`i�Akmh%pt[�` �ikyvjpj`1h���ky�E~�vtwo�ol^�­p# ßI��%Q��$%$�$ ��Þ�¶Aß'&)( # ß�!% ��$�$%$ �t× á � � &%km�^�/��ky�/�8`%vj`i~�vj`1h�`i�Ipj`i���7r�pj[�`\�Gw=|�|}w��%�}���{_*kypjvt�Àn��%��pj[ÊÞV¶Aß

K�^3M@K ì

Page 10: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�:§���� ¬��Y¡y¢o£8¤�¥CÉq¡� ��, j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ § £ � �

vtw��,h\ky�^�?× á � � ��wm|}l�_a�^hi®

"ÊÝ<Ø�Ù�à�Û�����

Ý�ß��ßmà Ý�ß�!%oà ÅiÅ�Å Ý�ß�j× á � � àÝ7% ��ßmà Ý7% �!%oà ÅiÅ�Å Ý7% �j× á � � ຺º ººº º º º ºººÝÑÞ�¶äß��ßyàÜÝÑÞ�¶äß�!%7àÜÅiÅ�Å ÝÑÞÕ¶³ßI�t× á � � à

������

Z\[�`²h�w=l�vt��`ÓÝ�ßI�ißyà�´Nvth�pÊ~^kyvjpj��pj�}wm�Nh*` )Il^km|�|}rËpt[�`A_a`ihthjkm�m`E�}�=ptw4Þ�¶�ßA~Nkm���m`�ptha`1km��[Úwy��h��}Î�`ß�7ÝÑÞd¶³ßyàt¾^�o`��^wypj`1�!�7r����Gw=v�ß �� ÚÞ�¶äß=º

� �Yl^vj�}���,pt[�`°´Nvth�p�vtwml��N�»¾1pj[�`\h�w=l�v��q`%Ý�ß��ßmà8hj`��^��h�~^k=���m`qp ��pjwY�^w7��`YÝ�� �ißyàj¾1�Gw=v %6�� ¸Þ»¶ÊßmºZ\[�`Õpjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=����w=h�p\wm��pt[���h%vjw=l��^���}hÕß�7ÝÑÞÕ¶³ßyàtº

� �Yl^vj�}���²pj[�`?��`qn7p?ÝKÆ â ß{¶³ã/âÍßyàdvjw=l��^��h/ky�^�$�Gwmv?ß �� Þʶ ß=¾°`ik=��[$~^km���=`qp�� �}h��vtw=km�^��kmh�p%�Gvtwm_ ��wo�o`!Ý��&�ißyà°ptw!ky|}|�pt[�`��=`�vjpj���q`1h,�}�·|��}��`���º,Z\[���h{�}hYvj`1ky|}��Îi`i�E�7r�~8`�vj�Gwmvt_a���^�Þ/¶Íß �}�^�o`i~N`i�^�o`��Ip�km�^�X~Nkyv�ky|}|�`i|����o`i�=pt�}�iky|V~�vtwyptwo�qwm|�hd��vtw=km�^��kmh�pj�}�������¸ÝKÆ â³ßyà:¶ ÝKã â³ßyàvjw=l��^��hYka_/`1hjhtky�=`�wy��|�`i���ypt[$ß,oݯÞ�¶³ßyàC�}�XÞ�¶ ß��o�}hKxswm�}�Ip{�qw=_a~�|�`�pj`��=vtkm~�[^h%wm���ikyv��o���Nky|}�Àpsr× á � � º D�r���`q´^����pj�}wm�awm� � á � � ¾ypj[^`\pjv�ky�^hj_a�}hth��}wm�/�qwIhspVwy�Npj[���hV~�[Nkmhj`���h/� á � � ÝKã�â�ßmà oݯÞV¶·ßmàjº

� 8����^km|�|}rm¾Nkmh�pj[^`�wmvt���=���^km|Ç_/`1hjhtky�=`Õ�}h%�o��h�pjvt����l�pj`i�?w=�?`i�m`ivjrÊ��wm|}l�_a��¾�`ik=��[��^w7��`/Ý�� ���^àCh�`i�^��h���apt[�`,|�kmh�p°vjw=l��^�/~^k=���m`qp���ÇpjwÕpt[�`{Þ wypt[�`�v�hV��wo�o`1hV�}�a��wm|}l�_a��� � ~^kyv�ky|}|�`i|opjwmptkm|�`qn���[^km���m`1hwy��pj[�`Õ~^k=���m`qp�h���kyvt`dvj`1ky|}��Îi`i�Ê�}��pj[�`��o��ÒÇ`�vt`��Ip\��wm|}l�_a�^h=#­º°Z\[�`dpjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=�!�qwIhsp%wm�:pj[^�}h|}k=hsp,vtwml^�^�!��hÕß,oݯÞ�¶³ßyàjº

zol�_a_akmvj�}Î��}���N¾o�Ô`Õwm��ptky�}��pj[�`��}�^�ol^�qpj�}�m`��}��` )Il^km|���psr � á ÝKãIà ������ ¶ � � ��� � � � � ����,� º K

,Yw��³pj[^`Õ�Gwm|}|�w��%�}���a~�vtwm~8w=hj�Àpt��w=����km���8`�h�ptk�pt`i�»º

� � ê��°ê ��� ��� ê �2���� ¡�  ã 4Æ � � á ÝKãIà á � �� ������� � ¶ ���� ß%â �� ������� ��� �

� � ê�ê��&% 8�w=v,ã/Û.�*��`�l^hj`�uVvtwm~8w=hj��pj�}wm�A��º 8^wmv�ß ³ã ³Æ�¾Nky~^~�|�r7�}���Ê�}�^�ol^�qpj�}�m`i|�r � `i_/_*kÊ�|}`ik=��hVptw�� á ÝKãIà �� �! � �� �������#" ¶ � � � � �!$ �� ������� � º ,,wmpj`Ypj[^kypCpj[^`d��wm�^�o��pj�}wm�!ã6LÆÚ�Gwm|}|�w��,hC�Gvjw=_�pt[�`{�Kkm�­ppt[^k�p � `�_a_*ka�/�iky�?�N`�km~�~�|}��`1�?wm��|}r*�Gwmv%Æ �B��º K

MOM í�D m(E(FHG

Page 11: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

� �{©tªy¢��q¢ § ©� ����/© ¦ ¿aª�¥��� �  j©�£^£8©q¥

� "Ó )� %���²������?�L������?������?�Ô����������� )�­��� ���� *) �/����� �� �������

����� ����� ������

8^wmv\`��=`�vtr�� � ��¾o|}`qpY×� �ÛÍÝÑÞ�¶¸ßyà º�Z\[^`��E×! °��h%ky�?l�~�~8`�v%�8wml��N�!w=�!pt[�`�_*k�no��_ l�_Â�7l�_��8`�v%wm��^w7��`ih�[^kS�7���^��vj`1�q`i���=`i�Êhjwm_a`d���o�Gw=vj_*kypj�}wm�!ky� pj`�v�pt[�` �V´^vth�p\vjw=l��^��hiº�8^wmvÕß � ¸Æ²¶²ãI¾o��`d��`�`1�pt[�`Õ�Gwm|}|}w��%�����a�o`�´^����pj�}wm�^hi®

� � _*kyn7�}_�l^_�h��}Î�`Õwm��pt[�`�_a`ihthjkm�m`ih\hj`��Ip,�ol�vt���^� vtwml^�^���=¾�) Û � � � �� ptvtkm�^hj_/��hth��}wm�?�qw=h�p,k�� pt`�v pj[^`Õ´^vth�p���vjw=l��^��hi¾� � ptwyp�ky|»�}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pj�}wm�?vt`i�q`i���=`i���ol�vt����� pt[�`�vjw=l��^���m¾� Û � ! � � �� ptwyp�ky|»�}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pj�}wm�?vt`i�q`i���=`i��k�� pj`iv pj[�`Õ´Nvth�p���vjw=l��^��hi¾

km�^���Ir��qwm�7�=`��Ipj�}wm��¾ � $ Û�� $ Û���º��� � !#"�$&%'��()����� "*��$&+

Z�wÓhsptl^�or$pt[�`Epjv�ky�^hj_a�}hthj��w=�4�qwIhspawm�^��`·h�w=_/`?�m`iv�pt�}��`ih/[^kS�=`?km|�vt`ik=�orÓ�N`i`��¸���o�Gw=vj_a`1�»¾C��`E��`�`1�kApjwÓ�qw=�^h����o`iv ~^kmv�pt�}��l�|�kyv�~^vjwmpjwo�qw=|}h��%[�`�vt`?kX�m�}�m`i�Ë�7l�_��8`�v-,?wy�Yhjwml^vt��`ih/��ky�Lh��}_�l�|�ptkm��`�w=l^hj|�r�^vjwIkm���ikmh�p��}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pt��w=��¾oky�^�?�%[�����[���`���km|�| Èq j¡1ªm¤=«tª�¥­¬ �8 j¡�¬½¡i«�¡ ¦ ¥/. § ¬ �0, ¥q¡y¢o j«�©­¥ º�Ôæ � �Ó� 2 2 � ¡� �ªy£�-!Èq j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ �N j¡y¬Ñ¡1«�¡ ¦ . § ¬ �1, ¥�¡�¢o j«�©q¥��oÉq¡y �ª�£ - � � ß ª�£Ç¤,Éq¡� �ª�2437©�¤ �) �5.C©� ª !�© � �,{Å*687 ÅIÝ<× âÚßyà(� � ¡y j©�¡ !�©q ��Y©���¢^ª ¦¨§ ¬7- � ¡ ¦ ¤�¥a¡�£ ¦ - § É/ª ¦ ¦ ¬ � ©a«�¡S¥­¬K¥ � �9. § ¬ �·ß6 � � �ªy j©/©!��¢^ª ¦9�

� � ê�ê��&%�Z\[�`Õ�Gw=|�|}w��%�}���a[�wm|���h��Gwmv%`1km��[?vjw=l��^� �Ƕ³ß�h�lN��[!pt[^k�p � � �^º

� B�p,_aw=h�p:,i×� °��wo�o`1h%��ky�·hj`��^��_a`ihthjkm�m`1h�¾7[�`i�^�q` � ��� äÞÇÝ;,1×! tà � ��� º� � `�p ��Ý14 � �tà��8`%pj[^`%pjwmptky|N�����Gwmvt_akypj�}wm�avt`i�q`i���=`i�/�7r���wo�o`�4�k�� pt`�v ��vtwml��N��h�º�Z\[�`,�}�o�Gw=vj_*k�pt��w=�h�`i�Ip,�IrÊpj[�`�hjwml^vt��`ih��}hYk�p%_aw=h�p:,mÝÑÞ � ��� àCky�^�?`ik=��[�wm��pt[�`�wypt[�`�v%�^w7��`ih,�iky�Eh�`i�^�?��w*_awmvt`pj[^km���%[^kyp:�Àp�[^kmh�ky|}vj`1km�or{vj`1�q`��}�m`1�»¾�[^`��^��` � ��� <,=ÝÑÞ � ��� àj¶�Þ �>=@?BA���Ý 4 � �tà�Û�,SÞ � ��� ¶�ÞC� º

z7wa�Gw=v%`��=`�vtr��Ôhjl^��[�pj[^kyp��6 � 4Æ�¾o��`Õ[^kS�m`=®� ��� � ¶LÞ�,1× D� ��� � �?#� ��� ݯÞ�¶³ßyàE� ¶LÞ�, � ��� � � #

,Ywypj`,pj[^kypCpj[^`,|�`i_a_ak��}h°pjvtl�`%�Gwmv���Û�ßm¾IkmhV��`,[^kS�=`,× $ Û�ßm¾F� $ ÛJ�^¾=|}`ik=�o���^�Õpjw�� � ÚÞ�, � � Û, � � Ý<× � â¸ßyàtºVϲ`�k=hjhjl�_a`dpj[^kyp,�Àp,[^wm|���h��Gwmv,k/�m�}�m`i� ��ky�N�!��`Õ~�vjw��=`{��p%�Gwmv �»¶³ßmº

K�^3M@K ì

Page 12: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�:§���� ¬��Y¡y¢o£8¤�¥CÉq¡� ��, j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ § £ � �

Ï�` vt`i�iky|}|:pt[^k�p �) �,� ��h,´^n7`1�»º 8�w=vdk�~�vtwypjwo��wm|:�%��pj[�h�w=_a`�pjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=�A�qwIhsp � ��� kypdvtwml^�^��»¶³ßm¾o��`�[^kS�m` �) Û � ��� â � ��� ky�^���7r!�}�^�ol^�qpj�}wm�E[7r7~Nwmpj[�`1h���h

� <,,Å � ��� â � ���� ÅmÝ¯× â¸ßyà

8^vjw=_ � � #\ky�^� � � #­¾o��`��m`�pi®

� ��� � ¶LÞ�,1× �� ��� , � 6 7�� � ��� 7�� � Ý¯× â¸ßy໶4Þo× � �,� � Û � � Ý � �,� à

� ��� ݯÞ�¶äßmàE� ¶4Þ8, � �,� , � 6 7�� � ��� 7�� � Ý¯× â¸ßyàtݯÞ�¶³ßyà8¶LÞ � ��� � Û � � Ý � �,� à

8^l��^�qpj�}wm�^h�� � ky�^��� � kyvt`�ps��w�kyÌ*��`��Gl^�^�­pt��w=�^hd��� � ��� ¾�� � �N`i���^���}�^�qvt`ik=h��}�����%[���|}`�� � ��hY�^wm�oÐ�}�^��vj`1kmhj�����NºÊZ\[�`�vt`q�Gw=vj`=¾��� »Ý�� � Ý � ��� à ��� � Ý � ��� à�à{�}h�hj_*ky|}|�`ivÕpj[^km�Ópj[�`Ê��wm_a_awm�Ó��ky|}l�`*wm��ptky�}��`1��7r!hjwm|}�7���^��� � Ý � ��� à�Û�� � Ý � ��� àjºCZ\[�`�hjwm|}lopj�}wm�?wy��pj[^�}h%`�)Il^k�pt��w=�!��h � ��� Û 6�7�� � ��� ky�N�!��`Õwm�op�ky�}��®

� ��� �� � Ý � ��� à�Û�� � Ý � ��� à�Û� ����»¶äß ÅyÝ¯× ��� âLßmà

Z�w�vt`ikm��[/pt[��}hC�Nw=l��^�»¾I��`,_�l^h�pC[^kS�=`%�7r �}�^�ol^�qpj�}wm� � ��� Û 6 " � � ��� �Gw=v°`ik=��[ � ��¾I�%[�����[*���N�o`�`1��}_a~�|}��`1h�pj[^kypÔky|}|opt[�`,�}�=pt`�vt_a`i�o��k�pt`,�qw=h�pthCkyvt`%` )Il^ky|¯º�¼½� pt[���h°�7��`i��¾ypt[�`%pjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=� w=~opj�}_a��Î1k�pt��w=�_*kSrÊ�8`���km|�|}`i� �  j©�©t¤ - º K

� ê � ê 6 6K�o� ç 2 �� ¡y  � 8����?ÍƸ¶Íß �%¬ � © § £1Éq¡� ­¿*ª�¬ § ¡�£Ë¬¯ jª�£^¥­¿ § ¥�¥ § ¡�£ ��� ª�É�¬Ñ©�  �  t¡�¢o£8¤�¥a¡�É© !�©q .- �8 j¡�¬½¡i«�¡ ¦ � ª"! § £ � 2437©�¤(!Sª ¦ ¢^©q¥�¡�É ��� � � � ª�£Ç¤ � � ¥�ª�¬ § ¥ 2�©­¥��

��� #���,¶ � �\â � ��dâ 8 Åyݯ×���âÓ×��7à � ) #

� � ê�ê��&% 8��}vth�pi¾V��wmpj`�pj[^kyp/ky� pj`�v+8Lvjw=l��^��h/k�p/_/wIhspa×��·��wo�o`1h �iky�4�8`!�}�o�Gw=vj_a`i��º$zow^¾°k�� pt`�vvtwml^�^� 8:¾�ky�!�}�o�Gw=vj_*k�pt��w=�Êptvtkm�^h�_a��hjhj�}wm�!wo�i�ql�v�h°�Gvtwm_×���hjwml�v��q`1hÔ�ol^vj�}�����,â 8?vtwml��^�^h�km�^�Ê�%��pj[k*´�no`i�·�qwIhsp Ý � �,â � �7àjº B%�i�qw=vt�o�}���aptw � `i_/_*k·b=b�ky~^~�|��}`i�E�%��pj[��ÔÛ��Õâ�8�¾ �) Û � �%â � �*ky�N�,dÛä× � �Ô`Õ[^kS�=`aÝ � � â � � à Ú× � � 6 � � 6"!� � � Ý<× � � � â¸ßyà � ky�^��pt[�`�vj`1h�l^|Àp%[�w=|}��hiº K

��æ �Ó�o��L 2Q� 8^wmv?��ky|}l�`ih?wy� �*�mvt`ikypj`�v!pj[^km� Æ ¶ ß=¾ � `i_a_ak bmb��ow7`ih?��wmp?�=���=`²ky� km�i�ql�v�k�pt``1hspt��_*kypj�}wm�Úwy��� �º Z\[���h*��hÊ�ol�`·ptwÓpj[�`A�Kkm�­p*pt[^k�p*�Gw=v � � Æ ¶�ß=¾�pj[�`·_*k�no�}_�l�_ �7l�_��8`�vÊwm�

MOM í�D m(E(FHG

Page 13: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

b�' �{©tªy¢��q¢ § ©� ����/© ¦ ¿aª�¥��� �  j©�£^£8©q¥

�}�o�Gw=vj_a`i�Ê��wo�o`ihÔ�}h\× á ¾7�%[�����[!��hC_ l^��[!hj_akm|�|}`�vÔpj[Nky��× º4,Y`��=`�vjpj[�`i|�`1hjhi¾=|}w���`�vC�8wml^�^��hÔwm�3� á ÝKãIà�iky�Ëh�pj�}|�|��8`��o`ivj�}�m`1���Gvjw=_ �}��`�)=lNky|}�Àpt��`1h � � #�km�^� � � #­¾���lop/pj[^`�r$kyvt`*��wyp pj�}�m[Ip `i��wml^�m[Ëky�N�Ópj[�`vt`q´N��`i�?ky�^km|�rohj`ih��m�}�m`i���}�?pj[�`��^`qn7p,h�`1�­pj�}wm�Nh%ky|}|�w�� pjwawm�op�ky�}���8`qpjpj`iv,vj`1h�l^|Àp�h�º

� w=�^h����o`iv�kÕ�o��hth�`i_/�}�^kypj�}wm��~^vjwmpjwo�qw=|I�%��pj[/wm�^`\hjwml^vt��`Ôl^hj�}���{Æ*¶aã{vjw=l��^��hiº B,� pj`�vCvjw=l��^��Æ*¶aã7¾`1km��[Ó��wo�o`�_�l^h�p [^kS�=`*vj`1�q`i���=`i�ÓkA�qw=_a~�|�`�pj`�_/`1hjhtky�=`*wy�%|}`����mpj[³ß=¾�[�`i�^�q`=¾V�À� ��Ý 4 � �tà � k=h��}�$pj[�`~^vjw7wy�%wm� � `�_a_*k$b=b�#���`���wmpj`ih�pj[�`�pjwmptkm|C�}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pj�}wm�$vt`i��`��}�m`1�Ó�IrÓ��wo�o` 4¸ky� pj`�v �Õvjw=l��^��hi¾��Ô`[NkS�m`��Gw=vdkm�IrE��wo�o` 4L¾ ��Ý 4 ��ÆÚ¶Lã=à ��ßmº,D�rAh�l^_/_a�}���!w��=`�vdky|}|:pt[�` �^w7��`ih � `qn���`�~opdpj[�`ahjwml�v��q`,#��`Õ�m`�p�pt[�`���`�nIp,�}��`�)=lNky|}�ÀpsrÇ®

� á � � �L× á âLß � 6?#

��æ �Ó�o��L 2 � � h��}���Xpj[�`��Kkm�qp pt[^k�pÊky�7rÓ��vtw=k=����k=hsp km|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_ l^h��}����Æ vtwml��^�^h htk�pt�}h�´^`ih � á �× â ßm¾V��`Ê´^�N�4ky�Iky�}�ËuVvtwm~8w=hj�Àpt��w=�Ë�·�Gvtwm_ � `i_/_*k4bmbm¾\§ � © �Ópt[�`Êptvtkm�^h�_a��hjhj�}wm�Ë�qwIhsp � á �}h/k�p|}`ik=hsp%Æ�º

����� � ��$ $�� �"�� "��������

� � ê��°ê ��� ��� ê �2QM � á Ý�ßyà�Û á �,������

� � ê�ê��&%�Ï�`�~�vtw��m`{pj[^kyp � á Ýjßyà � á �,������ �7rÊvj`1�ol^�qpj�}wm�?pjw/pj[^`�ky�^hjl�v��»¾�kmhth�l^_/�}���/pj[^`�`qno�}h�pj`i�^�q`wm��km�Ekm|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_Âl^hj���^�/Æ4¶³ßÕvjw=l��^��h\�%��pj[·k pjv�ky�^hj_a�}hthj��w=���qwIhsp � á ��� � á ������,� º

8��}vth�p��Ô`*~^vjw��=`�pt[^k�p � á ��� ��� º!Ïä�Àpt[$����`�)Il^ky|}�Àpt��`1h � 6 #Õky�^� � � #Õky�^�²�Gvtwm_ � `�_a_*kÓbmb=¾��Ô`

[NkS�m`m® × á âLß � á �,� ݯÞ�¶³ßyà � á ¶4Þ � á ���

� á 6 �á Ý¯× á â¸ßyà

�7rÊ[7r7~8wypj[^`ihj�}hi¾ � á Û � á ��� â � á ���� á �,������ â � á ���

� w=_����}���}���/pj[�`Õpt[�vt`�`Õvj`i|}kypj�}wm�^h�|}`ik=��h�pjw � á ��� ������� � �� ���

�� º

B{h�Þ � á ��� � ßm¾7kÕ��wo�o`Y�%��pj[�w=lopC�}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pt��w=�Ê��ky�^��wyp°vt`i��`��}�m`%`��^wml��=[*���o�Gw=vj_*kypj�}wm�*�ol�vt���^��pj[�`|�kmh�p%vjw=l��^�»º°z7wN¾��ol�vt���^� pt[�`Õ´^v�hsp%Æ vjw=l��^��h\`1km��[!�^w7��`�_�l^h�p%vj`1�q`��}�m`Õhjwm_a`Õ���o�Gw=vj_*kypj�}wm��¾o`�nok=�­pt|�rw=��`Õ_a`ihthjkm�m`Õkmh%× ÛÍÝÑÞ�¶äßmà¯á°º

K�^3M@K ì

Page 14: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�:§���� ¬��Y¡y¢o£8¤�¥CÉq¡� ��, j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ § £ � b=b

� `qp � Û ��� # � �� ß � 4Æ4¶³ß'&Õ�N`Õpt[�`Õ_a�����}_�l^_�qwIhsp%wm��ky|}|»vtwml��^�^h�º�Ï�`�[^kS�m`/ÝKÆ˶Úßmà � � á �,� � á ���� ��� ¾^h�w � � ������ º ,,w���¾o��`��o�}h�pj�}���=l��}hj[�ps�Ôw*��k=h�`1h�º

� Z\[�`/_/�}���}_�l�_ �Skm|�l^` � �}hÕk�pjptkm����`1�·�Gw=v � á ��� º BYhÕkÊ�=`�vjpj`qnA�iky�Xvt`i��`��}�m`/k�pÕ_/wIhsp�Þ � ���o�Gw=v�Ð_*k�pj�}wm������vjw=l��^�!Ʋ¶Lßm¾Ipj[�`i�!��p,h�[�w=l�|��Ê�8`{�7��w��³kyp�|}`ik=hspÕß°âXÞ � �����Gwmvt_akypj�}wm�!ky� pj`iv�vtwml^�^�Æ km�^�?h�wN¾�km����wmv��o�}����ptwÊuVvtwm~8w=hj�Àpt��w=���a��`d[NkS�m` � � ß%âÓÞ � �Gw=v�ß � LÆ�º

� Z\[�`\_a�����}_�l^_���ky|}l�` � ��h�k�p�p�ky�}��`i���GwmvVhjwm_a` � $ �%��pj[?ß � $ ¸Æ�º�BYh�pj[^`\km|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_ �Gwm|}|�w��,hk�hj~^ky�^�����^��pjvt`�`{~^k�pjpj`�vt�Ê�ol�vt�}����pt[�`,´^v�h�pÔÆävtwml��^�^h�¾=`qn�km�qpj|}r?ݯ×! ���âE×! �� � � à���wo�o`ihCvj`1�q`i���=`k�p�_/wIhsp � �����Gwmvt_akypj�}wm�Ê�ol^vj�}����vtwml��N� � $ º � `�p��²�8`,pj[^`{hj`qpÔwm��ky|}|^pt[�`{�o`1hj��`��^�^ky�IpthVwm�»pj[�`1h�`��wo�o`ih�k�� pt`�v�vjw=l��^�aÆ��7ky�N�*��wypt`,pt[^k�p � � � Û ÝÑÞ,¶$ßmà¯á � � ݯ×! ���âE×! �� � � à�Û × á âE× á � � º°z7w^¾ky|}|�pt[�`Y��wo�o`1h°�}���²[^kS�m`,kypÔ_aw=h�p � �}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pt��w=�Êk�� pj`ivCvtwml��N� Æ�º�B{h � � ß,7ÝÑÞÔ¶$ßyàj¾=��w���wo�o`����4��km��vt`i��`��}�m`m¾7�}�?pj[�`�|�kmh�p%vjw=l��^�»¾^Þ!_a`ihthjkm�m`ihÔ�Gvtwm_ �^w7��`ih\�}��\º2B{hYÞÇݯ×â � � � à�Û � � � ¾�Ô`Õ�o`1�ol^�q`{pj[Nk�p%�ol�vt����� vjw=l��^�*Ʋ¶Lß{`ik=��[Ê��wo�o`d�����Óvt`i�q`i���=`ihYݯÞÕâÓßyà�_a`ihthjkm�m`1h°wy��|�`i���ypt[k�p\_aw=h�p � �Gvjw=_ �^w7��`ih������$km�^�*wm�^`{_a`ihthtky�m`Ywy�:|}`����mpj[?k�pÔ|}`ik=hspÕÝ�ßCâXÞ � à��Gvjw=_ k���wo�o`d��wyp������º � wm�^hj` )Il�`i�Ipj|}rm¾Çky�7rE��wo�o` �^wyp{�}� �Ú_�l^h�pd[NkS�m`�kypd|}`ik=hsp/Ý�ßYâ4Þ � àÔ�}�o�Gw=vj_*k�pt��w=�Xk�� pt`�vvjw=l��^��Æ�º°z7w^¾ � á ��� � ß%âÓÞ � km�^� � � ß%âÓÞ � �Gw=v�ß � 4Æ�¾o�%��pj[ ���Û � $ º

¼½�ä�8wypt[ ��k=h�`1h*��`·[^kS�m` � á ��� � � ¶ Æ�Ý�ß�â Þ � à�Û ��Ý � àjº 8��}�^ky|}|}rm¾�xsl^h�p!��wmpj`·pt[^k�p �ÔÝ � à���h!kh�pjvt���­pj|}rÊ�o`1�qvt`ikmhj�}�����Gl��N�­pj�}wm�E�}� � º BYh � � �� ��� ¾^�Ô`d[^kS�m` � á ��� ����Ý ������ à�Û á �,������ ¾���wm�Ipjv�km�o���­pt���^�w=l�v/_akm���L[7rI~8wypt[�`ihj��h�º BYh�pj[^`E��wm�^���Àpt��w=�^h�lNh�`1�Ë�}�Ëpj[^�}h/~�vtw7wy�Ykyvt`!�^`i�q`1hjhtkyvtr²pjwX~8`�vj�Gwmvt_ ky�7r�^vjwIkm���ikmh�pC~�vtwypjwo��wm|¯¾mpt[�`���¾o��p\�}h�~�vtw��m`1�/pj[^kyp�� á Ý�ßmà � � á ��� � á ���� ��� ky�^�Êpj[�`dvt`ihjl�|ÀpÔ�Gwm|}|�w��,hC�Gvtwm_u°vjw=~NwIh���pj�}wm��b�'^º K

��� � ��� � $�� �"�� "���������+

D�`��Gwmvt`CptwÕh�ptkypj`%kd|�w���`�v��8wml��N���Gw=v�ps�Ôwd`qn7ptvtkdvtwml��^�^h�¾���`\��`�`1��ptwÕ���Ipjvtwo�ol^��`\kd��`i�4��wmpj�}wm�aky�8wmloppt[�` ¬¯ jª�£^¥�¿ § ¥�¥ § ¡�£�«�¡�¥�¬ º

/?æ10 � � ��� ê ��2+N @d���=`��Ëk·�^`qps��wmvt� 3�%�Àpt[$wm��`�h�w=l�vt��`*�m`iv�pt`qn»º B �������������K�i��� ê ��� 6 O8ê �,�G� ���lNh��}��� �Cvtwml^�^��h��}hYk/��wm_a_�l^���}�ik�pt��w=��~�vtwyptwo�qwm|»hjl^��[�pj[^kypi®

� ¼½����pj��ky|}|�r!pj[�`�hjwml^vt��`{[^k=h,k/_a`ihthjkm�m`Õwy�����o´N���Àpt`�hj��Îi`m¾^km�^�Eky|}|Çpj[�`�wmpj[�`iv%�m`iv�pt�}��`ih\�}� 3�[^kS�=`��w*�}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pj�}wm�:º

� �Yl^vj�}���·pt[�` �dvjw=l��^��h�wy��pj[�`Ê~^vjwmpjwo�qw=|<¾�`ikm��[Ó�=`�vjpj`qn��%�Àpt[Ëh�w=_a`*���o�Gw=vj_*kypj�}wm�$��km�Óhj`��N�ËÞ�o��Ò8`ivj`i�=pYhjl���_a`1hjhtky�=`ih\h�lN��[!pt[^k�p,`1km��[Eh��}Î�`Õ��h\��wyp,�=vj`1k�pj`iv�pj[^km�!pt[�`��7��w��%���}�o�Gw=vj_*k�pt��w=��º

� B�p{pt[�`�`i�^�·wm�Vpj[�` ~�vjwmpjwo�qw=|<¾�§ � © ��k�� pt`�v �\vtwml^�^��hi¾8km|�|�pj[�` �m`iv�pt�}��`ih,�}� 3 [NkS�m`�vt`i�q`i���=`i�·km�ky_awml^�=p%wm���}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pt��w=�?kyp\|}`ik=hsp%`�)=lNky|Çpjw·ß=º

MOM í�D m(E(FHG

Page 15: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

bS� �{©tªy¢��q¢ § ©� ����/© ¦ ¿aª�¥��� �  j©�£^£8©q¥

��æ �Ó�o��L 2 � � |}`ikmvj|}rm¾Spt[�`ihj`Ôpjv�ky�^hj_a�}hth��}wm�/�qw=�^hsptvtkm���Ip�h�kmvj`��Ô`1ky�=`�v�pj[^km��pt[�w=hj`��Gwmv���vtw=km�^��kmh�pj�}���Nº¼½�N�o`�`1�»¾�k�p\pj[^`d`i�^��wy��k�pjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=�!~�vtwyptwo�qwm|¯¾7�Ô`d_*ky�=`{��w*k=hjhjl�_a~opj�}wm�?ky�8wmlop%�%[^kyp�_a`1hjhtky�=`vt`ik=��[�`ih�`1km��[!�=`�vjpj`�nǺ�Ï�`�wm��|}rÊvt`ih�pjvt�}�qp\pj[�`Õ´^�Nky|:km_/w=l��Ip%wy���}�o�Gw=vj_*k�pt��w=���}�E`ik=��[��=`�vjpj`qn»º/?æ10 � � ��� ê ��2 ��� `�p�� á Ý<ãIàd�8`Êpt[�` ��� � � �Ó� 6��������������K�i��� ê ��� ê �i� wy�Ykm�7rApjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=�Ëky|}�mwmÐvt��pj[�_��Gwmv\pj[^`��qwm_a~�|}`qpt`Õ�mv�ky~�[?Ø Ù l^hj���^�/Æ˶Ëã vtwml��N��h�º� � ê��°æ �S� ç 2 � ¥Eª�£ -4È­ j¡1ªm¤=«�ªS¥­¬/ª ¦ � ¡y  § ¬ � ¿ ¥�ªy¬ § ¥ 2Ô©q¥�¬ � ©A¬< tª�£�¥­¿ § ¥�¥ § ¡y£ «�¡�£�¥­¬¯ jª § £N¬K¥��/.C© � ª !�©� á ÝKãIà ��� á Ý<ãIà=�

Ö{l�v%|}w���`�v\�Nw=l��^�E��km���^w�� �8`�hsp�k�pj`1�»º� � ê��°ê ��� ��� ê �F� � � á Ý7%7à�Û á� ������� $ ¶ ����,� â ��� �� á�� �

� � ê�ê��&% 8�vtwm_ uVvjw=~NwIh���pj�}wm�äb�'E�Ô`*[NkS�m` � á Ý7%7à6 á� � ��� � $ ¶ ����,� ºEÏ�`���wm�^hj�}��`�v�ky�$w=~opj�}_*ky|�^vjwIkm���ikmh�p\km|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_Âl^hj�����aÆ4¶ %�vtwml^�^��hiº

B,� pj`�v�pj[�`Ê´^vth�p�vtwml��^��¾�k�p |�`1kmh�pÊÝ�ßÕâ¸Þ � � àY�}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pj�}wm��vt`�_*ky�}�^hÕptw·�N`Ê�^vjwIkm���ikmh�pd�Gvtwm_ pj[�`hjwml^vt��`{�}�·Æ$¶ ßÕvtwml��^�^h�¾^hjw � � ¶³Ý�ß%âËÞ � � à � á Ýjßyà � á � � áÙ $ ¶ �Ù � ky�N�!�Gvtwm_ uVvtwm~8w=hj�Àpt��w=�²b,6��`��o`i��l^�q`=®

� � � Þ7ÆÚâ¸ß%âÓÞݯÞoÆLâ¸ßyàÑ× � Û

ß× � â ��� ßÞ7Æ � � #

D�`q�Gw=vj`,pj[�`,|�kmh�pCvtwml��N�»¾=`i�m`ivjr ��wo�o`,_�lNhsp�[^kS�m`,kypC|�`1kmh�pYÝ�ß�âEÞ � á � � à��}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pt��w=��º�Z\[^`�vt`q�Gwmvt`m¾�7rÓ�o`q´N���Àpt��w=�Ëwy�\pt[�`Ê�Gl��N�­pj�}wm��� á ¾��Ô`!�m`qp pj[^kyp � á ��� �}h/k�p�|}`ik=hsp�Ý�ß�âäÞ � á � � à�� á Ý�ßmàjº²z7w � á � �htk�pt�}h�´^`1hCpt[�`�htky_a`Õ����`�)Il^ky|}�Àpsr�kmh � � ®

� á � � �Þ7ƸâLß%â$ÞݯÞ7ÆÚâ¸ßyàÑ× � Û

ß× � â � � ßÞoÆ � ��#

� `qp� ��N`ahjl^��[Apt[^k�p � á � � Û � � ¶LÆ� *¶ � á � � º�DÔrAkm~�~�|}r7����� � wmvtwm|}|}kmvjr�b1�Ê�%�Àpt[ 8�Û ßaky�N���Û³ÆÓ¶³ßm¾7�Ô`Õw=�optkm���1� á �,� ¸Þ�¶� :Ý<× á �,� â²× � àjº°Z\[^`����Gvjw=_�× á âLß #� á � � Ú× � � á ��� ¶4Þ��`��o`i��l^�q`=® ?� ß

× �â � � ß×� � � #

B{h\Æ q× ��h,hj_*ky|}|��qwm_a~^kmvj`1�*ptw·ß,7ÝÑÞ7Æ�àt¾7��wm_ �����^����� � � #­¾ � ��#\km�^� � � #��=���=`ihi®

� á Ý7%oà�Û � á � � Û � � ¶ËÆ� �¶ � á � � �Æ× �

¶ %× � â � � ßÞoÆ�

K

K�^3M@K ì

Page 16: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�:§���� ¬��Y¡y¢o£8¤�¥CÉq¡� ��, j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ § £ � b1�

����� � ��( $�$�� �"�� "����:� ��+

Ï�`d[^kS�m`,�=���=`��Ê�}�!hj`i�qpj�}wm��� ky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_*h°�Gwmv���vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}�����%��pj[!ã�`�n7pjv�k�vtwml��^�^h�¾I���N�ol^�q�}���/l�~�~8`�v�8wml^�^��hVw=��� á ÝKãIàtº 8�wmvV|�kyvt�m`\`i��wml��=[ ��km|�l�`1hVwy�ÇÆ�¾�pt[�`��}vVptvtkm�^h�_a��hjhj�}wm�a�qw=h�p°��km�/�8`Ykm~�~�vtwSn7�}_*k�pt`i��7r�pj[�` h�l�_'wm��pt[�`�ps��w*pj`ivj_*h á� ��������� ky�^� �� º\Z\[^`��Gwmvt_a`�v,��hY��wm_a���Nk�pj�}���*�Gw=vYhj_akm|�|���ky|}l�`ihYwy�Vãkm�^�X��`i�qvt`ik=h�`1h,`�n7~8wm�^`��Ipj��ky|}|�rE�%��pj[�ã7º�ϲ`a~�vtw��m`����²pj[�` �Gwm|}|}w��%�����!pj[^kypd�}�²pj[���hÕ��kmhj`�pt[�`al�~�~8`�v�8wml^�^��hawy�ÕuVvtwm~8w=hj�Àpt��w=� b�'�kyvt`�pj�}�m[IpiºÚZ\[�`�vt`q�Gw=vj`?��`Ehj[�w��Âpt[�`E`qÌÊ�q�}`��N�qrËwm�{wml^vakm|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_*h�¾�%[^�}��[Eky|}|�w�� pjw*�o`1�qvt`ikmhj`Õh��}�m����´N�iky�Ipj|}r*pj[^`Õpjv�ky�^hj_a�}hth��}wm�?�qwIhsp%�%��pj[·k �G`��Íkm���o��pj�}�m`Õvtwml��N��h�º� � æ7ê � æ � � 2�� ¡y  � 4ã LÆ � � á ÝKãIà�Û á� ���,� ��� ¶ � � �� � �

� � ê�ê��&%�ϲ`A�o`ivj�}�m`?[�`ivj`·k�|�w���`�va�8wml��N�Lw=�B� á ÝKãIà�_*kypt��[��}���²pj[�`·l�~^~N`ivÊ�Nw=l��^�¸�m�}�m`i�4�7ru°vjw=~NwIh���pj�}wm�Ób�'^º � `qpd�qwm�Nh����o`�v{ka��vjwIkm���ikmh�pYky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_l^hj�����*ÆL¶4ãavtwml��^�^h�º B%� pt`�vdvjw=l��^�?ãÕâ¸ß��pY��km�E�N`�hj`�`i�Ek=h%ka��vtw=km�^��kmh�p\~�vjwmpjwo�qw=|»�%�Àpt[ � k�p,_awIhsp(#\× ��� � hjwml�v��q`1h�º°z7wa�Gvtwm_ �}��`�)=lNky|}�Àpsr � � #�%��pj[ �VÛäÆ˶Ëã{â¸ßÕ�Ô`��=`qpi®

� á � � ݯÞ�¶³ßyà�Å'� á � ��� � ¶LÞ/Å�× ��� � Å � á � �

D�r!��pj`ivtkypj�}wm�!�Gwmv%Æ � �LÆ˶Ëãdâ¸ß�ky�^�?kmh � �,� � ß=¾o�Ô`Õwm��ptky�}��®

� á � � ¸× � Å�� á ¶� � �� $ ÝÑÞ Åi×��Å � á � � � ½à ¸× � Å'� á ¶äÝ¯× � â¸ßyà

Z\[^`���¾���`�ky~�~^|�r � `�_a_*k?bmbÕ�%�Àpt[ ��Û³Æ�¾

× á #� á � � ¶³ß L× � ÅmÝE� á ¶äßmà L× � Å � � áÆ Ý<×'â¸ßyà8¶³ß km�^���Àp%�Gw=|�|}w��,h�pj[^kyp � á �¸ÆLÅ Ù � � � � �Ù � � Û áÙ � ¶ áÙ � � Å � � Ù �Ù � Û áÙ � ¶ � � áÙ � º

,Yw���¾o�Ô`Õ_�lNhsp,�qw=_a~^kyvt`Ypt[���h%vj`i|}kypj�}wm���%�Àpt[�pt[�`Õl�~�~8`�v%�8wml��N���=���=`����Ir�uVvjw=~NwIh���pj�}wm�E��¾7pt[^k�p��h\��`Õ��wm_a~^kmvj` áÙ �%��pj[ �� º�B{h áÙ ��h%h�_*km|�|���wm_a~^kyvt`i�!pjw �� pt[�`Õ~�vjw=~NwIh���pj�}wm�?[�w=|}��hiº K

Z\[�`,km�Nw��=`\~�vjw=~NwIh���pj�}wm�/��h�_/`1ky���}���=|�`1hjh��%[�`i�aã � �<�=�1���,� Ý<Æ�à�kmhV��p°vj`1�ol^��`ih�pjw � á ÝKãIà�Û� Ý �� àjº¼½�?pt[�`d�Gwm|}|�w��%�}���a�Ô`Õ�}�7�m`ih�pj�}�=kypj`{pj[���h,�ikmhj`Õkm�^���Ô`Õ�m�}�m`�k/�8`qp�pt`�v,�8wml^�^�»º� � ê��°ê ��� ��� ê �F�$�� ¡�  ã��4ÆÚâLß � � á Ý<ã=à*� �� �

� � ê�ê��&%NÏ�`Y�qw=�^hj�}�o`iv°kÕ��vtw=km�^��kmh�pVky|}�mwmvt��pj[�_�lNh��}����Æ�¶�ãYvtwml^�^��hVky�N� [NkS�I�}����k{pjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=���w=h�pÔh�pjvt�}�qpj|}r |}`ihthVpt[^ky�4% yÞǾIky�^�Ê�Ô`Yhj[�w��¸pj[Nk�pCã �LƲâXß=º � `qp � $ �8`,pj[^`Y|�kmh�pCvjw=l��^�*ky� pj`�vÔ�%[�����[

MOM í�D m(E(FHG

Page 17: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

b�) �{©tªy¢��q¢ § ©� ����/© ¦ ¿aª�¥��� �  j©�£^£8©q¥

��pÕvj`i_akm���NhYhjwm_a`��}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pt��w=�A��wypÕrm`�p{��vtw=k=����k=hspY�Gvjw=_pt[�`ah�w=l�vt��`m¾8[�`��N�q` �) � ��� ��ß�yÞǺ+B%� pt`�vvtwml^�^��� $ ¾:Æ vtwml��N��h�kyvt`a��`i��`ihthjkmvjr·ptw·��vtw=km�^��kmh�pdpj[���h�|�kmh�p�~��}`i�q`*wm���}�o�Gw=vj_*k�pt��w=�²�}�Ópj[^`*`��Ipj�}vj`�^`qps��wmvt�8¾�h�w � $ ¶ÚÆ �Æä¶ÚãEky�^� � $ �ã7º @d���=`���pj[�`Êk=hjhjl�_a~opt��w=��w=��pj[�`aptwyptkm|Vpjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=���w=h�pi¾Ô`��m`ivjr4��wo�o`E_�l^h�pÊ[^kS�m`?vt`i�q`i���=`i�Lh�w=_/`E�}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pt��w=�¸ky� pj`�vapt[�`·vtwml��^� � $ ¶�ß=¾Ôwmpj[�`ivj�%��hj`� á � � � � �� ��� ¶³ß,mÞ � % mÞǺ�Z\[�`�vt`q�Gw=vj`=¾o�Ô`Õ[^kS�=` � $ ¶³ß �4Æ�¾o|�`1km�o�}���/pjwaã �LƸâLß=º K

� ê � ê 6 6K�o� ç �$��� ¡y  �<�=�����,� ÝKÆ�àǶäß��¸ã��LÆÚâLß � � á ÝKãIà°Û �� ¶�" � ���$ � �� � ê�ê��&% D�r!uVvtwm~8w=hj��pj�}wm�Xb�'/�Ô`Õ[^kS�=`,� á ÝKãIà �� ¶ � � á � ��� � �� � ��������� º�B{h��Gwmv%ã � � ��������� ÝKÆ�àN¶ %�¾o�Ô`

[NkS�m`�ÝÑÞ\¶4ßmà � �LÆ�Å�ÝÑÞ%¶Ëßmà � ¾mpt[�`���¾ � á ÝKãIà �� ¶ " � �� $ � ky�N�apj[�`dvt`ihjl�|ÀpÔ[�wm|���hÔ�%�Àpt[�uVvtwm~8w=hj�Àpt��w=��=�oº K

��æ �Ó�o��LB� � ¼Ñp�[Nkmh��8`�`i�$~�vjw��=`i�Apj[^kyp�pj[�`!_/�}���}_�l�_ pjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=�²��w=h�p � á Ý<ã=àÕ�o`i��vj`1kmhj`ihd`qn7Ð~8wm�^`��Ipj��ky|}|�r²�%[�`��Ëk·hj_*ky|}|°�7l�_��8`�v wy�%`qn7ptvtk?vtwml��^�^h��}h�l^hj`i�»º $,w���`��=`�v1¾»pj[���h��8`�[NkS�I�}wml^v�hsptwm~^hk=hÕh�w7wm�Ókmhdã��}h��=vj`1k�pt`�v{pj[^km� � ��� ����� Ý<Æ�àjºa¼½�^��`�`i��¾»pj[�`*_*km���Ó�qwIhsp��8`i�qw=_a`ih % mÞǺaZ\[��}h��iky���N``�no~�|}km���^`i��kmh{�Gwm|}|�w��,hi®{pjwE[^kS�m`aky��l�����p�|}`����mpj[�_/`1hjhtky�=` �^vjwIkm���ikmh�p{�}�Ók?�%[�w=|�`/��`�ps�Ôw=vj�·l��N�o`�vpt[�`/Þ7Я~8wmvjpthY_/wo�o`=¾»k*pjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=�·�qw=h�p{wm�,ß,mÞ?�}h{vj`�)Il���vt`i�?ptw!_*ky�=`�pj[^` _a`ihthtky�m`��=wÊwml�pY�Gvtwm_pt[�`�hjwml�v��q`�ky�N��km|}hjw/pjw*_*ky�=`d��p,`��Ipt`�v,�}�Ipjw*ky�7rÊwmpj[�`iv,��wo�o`mºCϲ`���wml�|��Êpt[��}���!pt[^k�p%pt[�`�~��}~N`i|��}��`pt`i��[��^�+)Il�`1h%�qwml^|}�?�o`i��vj`1kmhj`dpj[���h,�qwIhsp,k=h�pj[�`ir!h�[^wml�|��Eky|}|�w��äptw*[^kS�m`{pj[^`ihj`Õps�Ôw*�qwIhsp�h%�qw��=`�vt`i�*�7r`1km��[Awmpj[�`ivi¾Ç�}�Xw=vt�o`iv,ptw��=w!�8`�|}w���k*ptwyptkm|���w=h�pdwm�*% mÞǺ � �o�Gw=v�ptl��^k�pt`�|}rm¾�uVvtwm~8w=hj��pj�}wm�²�=�*~�vtw��m`1hpt[^k�p,�^w/~^��~8`�|}���^`i�Eky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_��ky�?�8`�l^h�`��Gl�|}|��À��ã��4ÆÚâLß=º

� ��������?�����»���i�!� )�­��� ( � ���� �a����� ����?�!�?�

¼½��pj[���h�hj`i�qpj�}wm��¾���`°�}�7�m`ih�pj�}�=kypj`Vpt[�`Ô�ikmhj`C�%[�`ivj`C_akm�7rd`�n7pjv�k%vjw=l��^��h�kyvt`°l^hj`i�»¾o§ � © ���%��pj[�ã �¸Æ â/ßmº¼½��pt[��}h�vtkm���m`a~��}~8`�|}����`1�Ó~�vtwypjwo��wm|�h�kyvt`*~NwIhjhj���^|�`Êkm�^���Ô`Êh�pjl^��r²[�w�� hjl^��[�pj`i��[^���+)Il�`1h�ky|}|}w���pjw��`i�qvt`ik=h�`{pj[^`Õpjv�ky�^hj_a�}hth��}wm�?�qwIhsp1º

����� ����� $ "�� ���:� ��+��:��� $4%�����$ � � %� 5�5"8�����()+

� � ê��°ê ��� ��� ê �F�$M� ¡�  ã �4ÆÚâLß � � á Ý<ã=à* á � ��.����� �

� � ê�ê��&%YZ\[���h�l�~�~8`�v/�8wml��^���Gw=|�|}w��,h��Gvtwm_ ky�Ëkm|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_Eº?¼½�Ópt[�`Ê�Gw=|�|}w��%�}����� � �%�}|�|��o`��^wypj`pt[�` hj`qpÕwy�°�}�Ipj`i�m`�v�h,_awo�ol�|}w �7ºÕZ\[�`/`�|}`�_a`��Ip�hYwm��� � �%�}|�|��8`�p�ky�m`i�·���Xpj[�`/h�`�p # � �ißI��$%$�$ � �Õâäß'&=ºZ\[^`*�m`�vjpj`�n�hj`qp�wm�Ôpt[�`!��wm_a~�|}`qpj`!�mv�ky~�[ÓØ�Ù ��h�vt`�~�vt`ihj`��Ipt`i���7r��,á ���,� ºEZ\[�`Ê`�|}`�_a`i�=p�h��}���,á �����_*kSr��N`?`qno~�vt`ihthj`i�����4pj[�`?��km��wm������km|C�^k=h�` #�� & ��� � á ¾�pj[Nk�pa�}hi¾V�Ô`!_akSr$�o`i��wypt`�k·�=`�vjpj`�n 4³ÛÝ 4 � � 4 � ��$%$�$ � 4 á à����Yá ����� �7r � á! � 4 »Å � sº Z\[�`Ahjwml�v��q`E��hapj[�`·`i|�`i_a`��IpÊ�%�Àpt[³ky|}|Y�qw=_a~Nw=��`��Ipth

K�^3M@K ì

Page 18: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�:§���� ¬��Y¡y¢o£8¤�¥CÉq¡� ��, j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ § £ � b,6

`�)Il^ky|ÔpjwE��º$¼½�Lpj[�`��Gwm|}|}w��%�����N¾V�Ô`?��`i`i�$ptw���`q´^��`·k4¦ ª=Èt© ¦ ¦¨§ £ �4wy�{pj[�`Ekyv���h�pjw��N`?l^hj`i�4���¸wml�vkm|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_Eº&8�w=v�`ik=��[��^w7��`�4:¾��Gwmv*ß � Þ�km�^�¸ß � �Æ�¾�pt[�`!kyv��?Ý14 � 4?¶ �ÊÅ � ½àY�%�}|�|Ô�N`|�ky�8`�|}|}`i�a�7r �tº�¼½�Êw=l�vÔkm|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_E¾mwm�^|�rakyv���hV|�ky�8`�|}|}`i�*�7r ��kmvj`,lNh�`1�*�ol�vt����� k�vjw=l��^� �VÛ�� ��� Æ�º

,Yw���¾o|�`�p�� �8`Õpj[�`�hj`qp%wm���=`�vjpj���q`ih\hjl^��[�pj[^kyp�� Û #�� � "*ݯØ�Ùdà � � Û���Å � �o�%��pj[Óß � äÞkm�^� ß �##Æ�&Iº 8�w=v!`1km��[ä��wo�o` � ���/¾,|}`qp�� $ Ý � àa�N`�h��}_a~�|}rLpt[�`��m`�vjpj`�n � º ,Yw���¾\�Gwmvß 2� Æ�¾°|}`qp��^Ý � à��N`?pt[�`Epjvt`�`?���N�ol^�q`1�L�Gvjw=_��� � � Ý � à��7rËkm�^�o���^�Ókm|�|�pt[�`·~NwIhjhj�}��|�`Ekyv���h|�ky�8`�|}|}`i���Ir²Ý��»¶�2 � � Æ�àjºVZ\[7l^hi¾�� á Ý � à°��h%k*�o�}vj`1�­pt`i�?h�~^km�����}���/pjvt`�`ÕvtwIwmpj`1�!�}� � º

¼½��pj[���h%�\kSrm¾7��`{[^kS�=`d��`q´^��`1�?Þ�Å­Æ kmvt�mâ,�o��hGxsw=���Ip%h�~^km�����}��� pjvt`�`ih\km�^�Êpt[�`�ky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_Â_*km����|}r��wm�^hj��hsp�h����*~��}~8`�|}�����}������wm�^��l�vjvt`��Ipt|�r��}�a`ik=��[/wm�Npt[�`�_Eº�%Ew=vj`iw��m`�v1¾1pjw�_*ky�}�Iptkm���/pj[^`%�Gl�|}|�l^hj`%wy�Çpj[�`�Nky�^�o�%���7pt[Êl��Ipj�}|^pt[�`,`i�^�*wy�Çpt[�`Y~�vtwo�q`1hjhi¾ypt[�`Y|�kmh�pC~��}`i��`,wy���}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pt��w=�*�}hC��vjwIkm���ikmh�pC�ol�vt���^��pj[�`|�kmh�p%Æ vtwml^�^��h�l^hj�����Êkahj~^ky�^�����^� ptvj`i`Õvjw7wypt`i�����?pt[�`�h�w=l�v��q`mº4,,w���¾o��`��o`iht�qvt�}�N`Õpt[�`�ky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_Eº

� Z\[�`�h�w=l�v��q`,´Nvth�p\��lopth�`�)=lNky|}|�r*��pth\l��^�Àp%|}`����mpj[!_a`1hjhtky�=`Y�}�=ptwaÞoã�¶¸ßÕ�o�}h�pj�}�^�qp%hjl���_a`1hjhtky�=`ihi¾�o`��^wypj`1�?�Ir � � �%�Àpt[Óß � äÞ7ã%¶³ßmº� 8�w=v/ß&� Íã7¾:k�pÕvtwml��^���\pj[^`ahjwml^vt��` hj`��^��hÕhjl���_a`ihthtky�m`�� � � ��� ����� ¾Ç�Gw=v/ß&��#�ÞǾÇpjw��wo�o` � Û ��Å � � ������ á � º

� Ïä[�`��Ëk·hjl���_a`1hjhtky�=` � � ¾��%�Àpt[äß � ÂÞ7ã7¾�[Nkmh��8`�`i�Ëh�`i�=p��Gvtwm_ pj[�`�h�w=l�vt��`/pjwXkE��wo�o`� ���a¾8��pÕ�}h{��vtw=km�^��kmh�p,�}��� á Ý � à��ol�vt�}���Êpt[�`���`�n7pdÆ vtwml��N��h � l^hj�����!pj[�`ivj`i�7rEkm|�|�pj[^` kyv���h|}km�N`i|�|}`i�?�7r��Ckyp,`ik=��[�vtwml��N� �VÛ � � � Æ�#qº

� Z\[�`/|}k=hspÕh�l��^_/`1hjhtky�=` � �.�!�,� ��h{��vjwIkm���ikmh�p,�Gvtwm_ pj[�`ahjwml�v��q` ���Xpj[�`/Æ |}k=hspÕvtwml��^�^h�¾8l^hj�����ky|}|»pj[^`�~NwIhjhj���^|�`�kyv���h�|�ky�8`�|}|�`1�?�Ir � � � Æ kyp\vtwml^�^� ��º

Z\[�`·�o��ÒÇ`�vt`��IpÊvjw=l��^��h/l^hj`?pj[�`·htky_a`?pjv�ky�^hj_a�}hthj��w=�L�qwIhspa` )Il^km|\pjwÚß,oݯÞ7ã�¶�ßyàt¾°pt[^k�pÊ��h/pj[�`|}`��^�ypj[?wy��`ik=��[?hjl���_a`1hjhtky�=`mº�Z\[��}h,|�`1km��hÔpjwapt[�`�`qno~8`i�qpj`i��ptwyptkm|��qwIhsp�ÝKÆ4¶ËãIà 7ÝÑÞ7ãY¶äßmàjº K

��� � � � � $ " � ��������+

�Ôæ � �Ó� �$N� ¡� �ªy£�- ã � � � § É � á Ý<ãIà � á � ����!��� ¬ � ©�£ � á Ý<ãY¶$Æ�à � á � � ��� á �� � ��� á � ��� �

� � ê�ê��&% � wm�^hj���o`�v�ky��w=~opj�}_*ky|oky|}�mw=vj��pj[^_ ��vtw=k=����k=hspt���^�Yky� l�����p�|}`����mpj[ _/`1hjhtky�=`°�}��Æ ¶�ÝKÆ ¶ ãIàvtwml^�^��hiº B,� pj`iv�vjw=l��^�²Æ�¾:kyp�|�`1kmh�paÝjß{âÚÞ � á à,�����Gwmvt_akypj�}wm��vj`i_*ky�}�^hdpjwE�8`*��vjwIkm���ikmh�p{�Gvtwm_ pj[�`hjwml^vt��`{�}�EÆ$¶Ëã `�n7pjv�k vtwml^�^��hi¾I[^`��^��`m®

� á ÝKãY¶$Æ�à � � á ¶�� á ÝKãIà:Å=Ý�ß%â$Þ � á à � � á ¶Æ4¶ËãÞ7ã%¶³ß ÅyÝjß%âÓÞ � á à�Û�� � Ý � á à

MOM í�D m(E(FHG

Page 19: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

b�� �{©tªy¢��q¢ § ©� ����/© ¦ ¿aª�¥��� �  j©�£^£8©q¥

,Ywypt`�ky|�h�w pj[^kyp{k�� pt`�v\pt��_a`�Æ�¾^km�?km_awml��Ip,wy��Ý<×'â¸ß%â � á à°�}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pj�}wm�E[^k=h�pjw*�8`Õpjv�ky�^hj_a�Àpjpj`1�w=�Ak�pd_/wIhspÕÞÇÝ<× âäßmàC|}�����ohdk�pY`1km��[·vtwml��N� � kmhYpj[^w=hj`����N�qwm_a�}���*pt[�` hjwml�v��q` kyvt`�l^hj`�|}`ihthA#qº 8�vtwm_� `�_a_*k?bmbm¾o��`Õ�7��w��³pt[^k�p�� á 6 �á ݯ×â¸ßyàt¾�[�`i�^�q`=®

� á ÝKÆ˶$ãIà � � á ¶ßÞ �»ß%â � áÆ Û�� � Ý � á à

B{hC�}�Êpt[�`Y~^vjw7wy��wm� � `i_/_*k!bmbm¾"� � ��h�k��o`1�qvt`ikmhj�}���Õ�Gl��^�qpj�}wm�!�%[^��|}` � � �}h�ky�!���^��vj`1kmhj���^�Õ�Gl��^�­pt��w=��ºzow ����VÝ�� � Ý � á à � � � Ý � á àjà ��� � Ý��7àt¾^�%[�`ivj`��ahjkypj��hs´^`1h � � Ý��7à�Û � � Ý��7àtºÔz7wm|}�7���^� pt[�`�` )Il^kypj�}wm�?�Ô`�=`qp1®�%¶ á � ��.����� Ý�ß%â$Þ��7à�Û �,¶ �� Ýjß%â��á à

� Û á� � ��� á � ���

� � Ý��7à�Û � � Ý��7à�Û á � � �!� á �� � ��� á � ���

zow/��`Õ[^kS�m` � á ÝKÆ˶$ãIà � á � � ��� á �� � ��� á � ��� º K

�Ôæ � �Ó� � � � á ÝKÆ4¶ %7à�Û á � � á � � �� � á � � � ���

� � ê�ê��&% 8�vtwm_ u°vjw=~NwIh���pj�}wm�ä�?6²��`?[NkS�m`C� á Ý<Æ ¶ %7à á � � á � � �� � á � � � ��� km�^�4�7rLl^h��}����pj[^`Xhjkm_a`kmvj�=l�_a`��Ipth���`Õ�m`qp1®á � � á � � �� � á � � � ��� �B� á ÝKÆ4¶ %7à � � á ��� ¶ � á Ýjßyà:ÅyÝjß%âÓÞ � á ��� àá � � á � � �� � á � � � ��� � � á ��� ¶ á �������� Ý�ßYâÓÞ � á �,� à

� á ��� � á �,�� � á � � � ���

� `qp�l^h��o`i��wypt`*�7r � -á ��� pj[^`ahjl�_ wy�Cpt[�`/pjv�ky�^hj_a�}hthj��w=�²�qwIhsp�hÕwy�Ôpj[�`*|�kmh�p�Ƹ¶ ßavjw=l��^��hi¾�[�`i�^�q`� á ÝKÆ4¶ %7à�Û � á ��� ¶ � -á ��� º

á � � á � � �� � á � � � ��� �B� á ÝKÆ4¶ %7à � � á Ýjßyà:ÅyÝjß%âÓÞ � -á ��� ໶ � -á ���á � � á � � �� � á � � � ��� � á �������� Ý�ß%â$Þ � -á ��� àǶ � -á ���

� -á ��� � á �,�� � á � � � ���

zow pt[�`�|}`�_a_*k [^wm|���h�º K

K�^3M@K ì

Page 20: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�:§���� ¬��Y¡y¢o£8¤�¥CÉq¡� ��, j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ § £ � b��

� � æ7ê � æ � � ��� ¡y  ã6�LÆ �Ôª�£Ç¤ ã�ÛJ�<��ßI��% � � Æ � � á ÝKãIà�Û á � ��.�!�,� �

� � ê�ê��&%8Ï�`,l^hj` � `�_a_*k����Õ�}�^�ol^�qpj�}�m`i|�r=º�Z�w��}���Àpt�}kypj`%pt[�`,�}�^�ol^�qpj�}wm�a�Gw=vCãÕÛ��� � � Æ�¾m��`%l^h�`u°vjw=~NwIh���pj�}wm�Ê�^¾=pt[^k�p��}h � á Ý ��à�ÛÚƳ�=`�vt�À�Gr7�}����pj[^`d��wm�^�o��pj�}wm�!wy� � `i_a_ak/���^º�8^wmv�ã�Û�ß � � Æ�¾I�Ô`lNh�`duVvjw=~NwIh���pj�}wm�·b,6o¾=pj[^kyp���h � á Ýjßyà�Û á �������� º 8����^km|�|}rm¾I�Gw=vCã�Û % � � Æ�¾=��`,l^hj` � `�_a_*k��I�Õ�m�}�7���^�pt[�`�`�nok=�­pY��km|�l�`�wy�/� á Ý<ÆL¶�%7àj¾Npj[Nk�pY�=`�vt�À´^`1h\pj[^`���`i`i�o`1�·�qwm�N�o�Àpt��w=�Epjw7w^º 8^wmv,pt[�`ihj`�pt[�vj`i`���k=h�`1h�¾��`Õwm�op�ky�}�7� á ÝKãIà*� á � ��.����� º°Z\[�`�vj`1h�l^|Àp\�Gwm|}|}w��,h��Gvjw=_�uVvtwm~8w=hj�Àpt��w=�E� 6oº K

� ê � ê 6 6K�o� ç � �� ¡y  Æ � # ß�!% ����& ªy£8¤,Éq¡y  ª�£ - ã6�LÆ � � á Ý<ãIàVÛ á � ����!��� �

� ê � ê 6 6K�o� ç � ��� ¡y  ã6�¸Æ � � á Ý<ãIà�Û á � ����!��� â " � �� $ � �� � ê�ê��&%2B{hjhjl�_a`dpj[^kyp,ã � Û��IÆ�¾oã�Û��IÆ˶ 5dky�N�!ã � Û Ý��Õ¶³ßyà¯Æ �%��pj[��&� ß�ky�N� � 5 �LÆ�º

Ï�`d�I�^w��ä�Ir*Z\[�`iwmvt`�_ �y��pj[^kyp � á ÝKã � à�Û ��� �,� � á� � á ��� ¾oky�^�3� á Ý<ã � à�Û�� � � � á� ��� ����� á ��� º2B{h��Ir*uVvtwm~8`�vjpsr )^¾

� á ��h,k/��w=�oЯ�}�^��vj`1kmhj�������Gl��^�qpj�}wm��¾N�Ô`Õ[^kS�=`m®� á Ý<ã � à:� � á ÝKãIà � � á Ý<ã � à��� ��� � á� � á ��� � � á ÝKãIà � ��� � � � á� ��� �,� � á ���

zow/��`Õwm�op�ky�}�!�Gw=v,ã��¸Æ�¾

� á ÝKãIàVÛßÞ ¶

ßÞ� â

ßÞ � Æ�� â " � ß

� � � á ÝKãIàVÛ

ßÞ ¶

ÆÞ7ã â

ßÞ � ã â " � ßã � Û Æ$¶Ëã

Þ7ã,¶äß â " � ßã � K

Z\[�`�km�Nw��=`{~^vjw=~NwIh���pj�}wm�Eky�^�?�qw=vjw=|�|�kyvtra_*ky�m`dpt[�`Õ�Gwm|}|�w��%�}���a�qw=��xs`i�qpjl�vt`Õ�m`�vtrÊ|}���=`�|}r*pjwa[�w=|}��®� ê � � æ �y�(��� æ ��2�� ¡y �ª�£ - Æ ª�£8¤�ª�£ - ã6�LÆ � � á Ý<ã=à°Û á � ��.����� �

� &������+i�!���q��

¼½�Ëpj[���h/~^ky~8`�v1¾V�Ô`�[^kS�m`?h�[^w��%�Ópj[�`?`qno��hspt`��^��`!wy�dk·pjv�km��`qÐÑwyÒL�8`qps��`�`i�$pj[^`��7l�_ �N`iv wm�Yvjw=l��^��hkm�^�4pj[�`?pjv�ky�Nh�_a��hjhj��w=�L��w=h�p/wm�{��vtw=k=����k=hsp/~�vjwmpjwo�qw=|}hiº4Ï�`·[^kS�=`��o`ivj�}�m`1�Ëpt���=[=p*�8wml��N��hawm�Lpj[�`_a�}���}_�l�_ ��wm_a_�l��^�}�ik�pj�}wm�apt��_a` ÝKÆX¶Xã=àNÅjµ/¶ � á ÝKãIà^Åj±AÅ�¹*wy�:km�7r/km|��=wmvt�Àpt[�_�lNh��}����ÆX¶XãÕvjw=l��^��h�Gw=v{�^vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}���ÊkÊ_a`ihthtky�m`�wy�C|}`����mpj[�±³�}�Apj[^`������o�}vj`1�­pj�}wm�Nky|VÞIЯ~8wmvjpthd�qw=_a~�|�`�pj` ��`qps��wmvt�?Ø Ù ¾�%��pj[·× ÛÍÝÑÞ�¶äßmà¯áCº°Z\[�`Õ�Gwm|}|�w��%�}��� ptkm��|�`�hjl�_a_*kyvt��Îi`ih�pj[^`��o�ÀÒÇ`�vt`��Ip,vt`ihjl�|�pth�wm�op�ky�}��`i��®

MOM í�D m(E(FHG

Page 21: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

b1� �{©tªy¢��q¢ § ©� ����/© ¦ ¿aª�¥��� �  j©�£^£8©q¥

,,l�_ �N`iv%wy��`qn7pjv�k/vjw=l��^��h %E�}����_ l�_ ptvtkm�^hj_/��hth��}wm�?�qw=h�p � wm_a_a`��Ipã�ÛF� � á Ý �oà�Û³Æ �mvt`�`1�orã�Û ß � á Ýjßyà�Û á �,������ã�Û % � á Ý7%oà�Û á� � ��� � $ ¶ �� ��� â � � �� á � `qno~8wm��`i�Ipj��ky|Çpjv�km��`qÐÑwyÒ%6Lã � ��� ����� Ý<Æ�à8¶ ß � á ÝKãIà�Û á� ���,� ��� ¶ � � �� ��<�=�1���,� ÝKÆ�à8¶äß��¸ã��¸ÆLâ¸ß � á Ý<ã=à°Û �� ¶�" � ���$ � ��w/pjv�km��`qÐÑwyÒã6�LÆ�¾oã�ÛJ� �ißI��% � � Æ � á Ý<ãIàVÛ á � ����!���ã6�LÆÚâLß � á ÝKãIà�Û á � ��.����� â " � �� $ � |}����`1kyv\ptvtk=�o`qÐÑwyÒ

Ö{l�v |�w���`�v��8wml^�^��h [^kS�m`*�8`�`i�$wm�op�ky�}��`i���Gw=v �qw=_a~�|�`�pj`Ê�^`qps��wmvt�7hi¾�pt[�`�vt`q�Gw=vj`apt[�`�r$kmvj`*��ky|}����Gw=v�km�Ir¸ptwm~8wm|}wm�mr=º � wm�7�=`�v�h�`i|�r=¾�w=l�v!_*kypt��[��}���4l^~�~N`iv��8wml^�^��h?�o`�vt���=`i�¸�Gvtwm_ wml^v�ky|}�mw=vj��pj[^_ahvt` )Il��}vt`�hsptvjw=���!��wm����`1�­pt���7��psr!ptw!�8` vt`ik=��[�`i�»º 8�wmvd`qn�km_/~^|�`=¾N��` �iky�Ahj[�w��Ípj[^kypYpt[�` `�no~Nw=��`��Ipj��ky|��`i�qvt`ik=h�`*wm�\pj[�`!pjv�ky�^hj_a�}hth��}wm�Ó�qwIhsp/�ow7`ih��^wyp wo�i�ql�v��}�4k·vt�}���·��`qps��wmvt�Ǻ�$,w���`��m`ivi¾�ky|}|Cvtwmlopt���^�_a`1��[^ky����hj_ah\�Nkmhj`i�?wm�?pj[^`��q�}vt��l��ÀpjÐÑhj�%��pt��[�`1�!_awo�o`��iky��ptky�=`�km�o��km�=p�ky�=`{wm��w=l�v,ky|}�mw=vj��pj[^_ahi¾��ol�`ptw/pj[�`�km�^�o�Àpt��w=�^ky|���wm���^`i�­pt���7��psrÊ~�vtw��7�}�o`1�»º�¼½�?~Nkyvjpj���ql�|�kyv1¾Ipj[�`�� ª"!S© ¦ ©�£ � ¬ � � § ! § ¥ § ¡�£ � ¢ ¦ ¬ § � ¦ © 3I©�¤� ϳ� %<#�wm~opt�}�iky|Çvjw=lopj�}���/��ky��wyÒÇ`�v��Gl�|}|��qw=����`i�qpj�}�7�Àpsr*�}����kmvj�}wml^hÔ��`�ps�Ôw=vj�/pjw=~Nw=|�w=�m�}`ih � hj`�` � �o¾^���-#­ºÖ{l^v{h�pjl^�orE[^k=h%pt[IlNhY�8`�`i�A�Gvtl��Àpj�Gl�|}|�r?ptkm�m`i�A���Iptw!km�i�qwml^�=p{������b(���Gwmvd_�l^|Àpt�ÀÐÑ[�wm~Xwm~opt�}�iky|:vt�}���!ky�N�_a`1h�[L��`qps��wmvt�oh�º 8�l^v�pt[�`�va��wmvt�Óhj[�w=l�|}�L�qw=�^�q`i�=ptvtkypj`�wm�4wmpj[�`iva|�`1hjh/�qw=����`i�qpj`1�$pjw=~Nw=|�w=�m�}`ihi¾��Gwmv�%[^�}��[?�mvt`ikypj`�v\|}w��Ô`iv\�Nw=l��^��h%�%�}|}|�kyvt�}hj`mº

� � +*�� )+q %�?�� ( ,�����

Ï�`�kyvt`d�mv�k�pj`��Gl�|Çpjw��yÐ � º DÔ`ivj_aw=�^�*�Gw=v%[��}h,[�`�|}~o�Gl�|�vt`�_*kmvj�oh\ky�^�E��wm_a_a`��Ipthiº

K�^3M@K ì

Page 22: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�:§���� ¬��Y¡y¢o£8¤�¥CÉq¡� ��, j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ § £ � b1�

� %�� %�� ,�!�� %�

��b*� DdºHD�`ikml )Il���`iviºED�vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}���·�}�4ϳ�+% w=~opj����km|Ôvt���^�=h/ky�^�Óptwmvt�<ºÓ¼½� �� j¡1« � ¬ � © ��� � ��� �� ¡�  �1¥ � ¡�� ��� � ¢ ¦ ¬ § « � ªy£^£Ç© ¦�� �N¬ § «tª ¦ ©q¬;.C¡�  �1¥ � � � ©�¡� .-Eª�£8¤ �� jª=«q¬ § «�©�� ¾N�=wm|}l�_a` ) �/wy� ����#� ��� �1�»©q  § ©q¥\¡y£6� § ¥�«� j©�¬Ñ© � ªy¬ � ©q¿*ª�¬ § «­¥,ª�£Ç¤ � � ©�¡� t©q¬ § «�ª ¦�� ¡�¿��N¢o¬½©�  �»« § ©�£8«�© ¾�~^ky�=`ih �m�� ^���^¾e,lopj�=`�v�h � ���}�m`ivthj�Àpsr=¾ , �^¾ %·kmvt��[²bi�m�=��º B,_a`ivj����km� %·kypj[�`i_*k�pj����km|:z7wo�q�}`qpsr=º

� ��� Ddº+D�`ikyl )=l^��`ivi¾ ��Ð � ºD�`ivj_awm�N�»¾ � º @Õkmvj�Iky��wN¾mu�º $,`�|}|¯¾oz»ºIu�g�vt`��^��`ihi¾Ikm�^� � º��°k=����kmvjwNº;@dv�ky~^[~^vjw=��|�`i_*h�kmvj��h��}���$�Gvtwm_ �\kS�m`i|�`i���ypt[� Ivtwmlopt���^�$��� km|�|� Iw=~opj����km|Y��`�ps�Ôw=vj�ohiº�¼½� �\ j¡i« � ¡sÉ��=£8¤������� � ¡y  �i¥ � ¡��4¡�£ � �8¬ § «q¥ ª�£Ç¤ � ¡y¿ �8¢o¬Ñ©�  �»« § ©�£8«�©�� ����� � ����ª� ­¬,¡sÉ��!� � � " ����� ¾ @d`��^`���k�¾zo�%�ÀptÎ�`�vt|�ky�^�»¾ B,~�vt��|Vb1�m�7�7º7¼ & & &äuVvt`ihthiº

� ��� �yÐ � º D�`ivj_awm�N�»¾ � º�@Õkyvt�=km��w^¾°zǺVu�g�vt`��^��`ihi¾ B�º B�º�e,`iht�q�}�m��wN¾°ky�^� � º �°km�i��kyvtw^º &�ÌÊ�q�}`��Ip��wm|}|�`1�­pt���=`Ô�qw=_a_�l�������kypj�}wm���}��w=~opj����km|=�^`qps��wmvt�7hiºm¼½� �� j¡1« � ¡�É!�#"y t¤$�­£N¬Ñ©� ­£8ªy¬ § ¡y£8ª ¦%� ¡ ¦ ¦ ¡ ��¢ § ¢o¿¡y£ � ¢o¬Ñ¡y¿aªy¬Ñª � .�ª�£ � ¢^ª � ©q¥dª�£Ç¤ �� j¡ �  tª�¿/¿ § £ � �&� � � .,�/" �(')� ¾o�=wm|}l�_a`�b�'=�m�dwy� .�©�«q¬¯¢o j© ¡y¬Ñ©q¥§ £ � ¡�¿��N¢o¬½©q +�»« § ©�£8«�© ¾�~^ky�=`ih 6I�,)* 76y� 6oºIzo~�vj�}���=`�vjÐ+�V`ivj|�ky�N¾ �ml�|}rAbi�=�?��º

� )?� �yÐ � º D�`�vt_awm�^�»¾�u�º�%E����[^km|�|}wm��¾�ky�N�$��º�Z:vtrohsptvtkm_?º7D�vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}���?���$�%v�ky~^kmvjw=l��^�²_a`ihj[�`ih�%��pj[E~^kmvtkm|�|}`�|»_aw=��wo�o��vt`i�qpj�}wm�^km|Ç|��}���oh�º �,ª� jª ¦ ¦ © ¦,� ¡�¿��N¢o¬ § £ �m¾:bi�^® �=�m�* ��)I��¾�b1�m�I�oº

� 6�� �^ºHD�vjl^���Ǿ � нZÕº2$Yw^¾CzǺ.-Õ�}~�����h�¾Ôky�^�Ë� º�ϲ`1k�pt[�`�v�h��7r=º &�ÌÊ����`i�=p*ky|}�mw=vj��pj[^_ah��Gwmv*ky|}|�Ð<ptwyнky|}|��wm_a_�l^���}�ik�pt��w=�^hÕ���Ó_ l�|Àpt�ÀÐÑ~8wmvjp�_/`1hjhtky�=`qÐÑ~^kmhthj������h�roh�pj`�_*hiº*¼½��� £^£^¢^ª ¦ ��� � � -�¿ ��¡S¥ § ¢o¿¡y£?�%ªy jª ¦ ¦ © ¦��{¦ � ¡�  § ¬ � ¿ ¥ ª�£8¤ �  j« �=§ ¬½©t«�¬¯¢o j©­¥/� � � � � " �102� ¾N~^ky�=`ih,�m�m�� o�?'=��¾ � km~N` %AkSrm¾ ,,`i��m`�v�hj`�rm¾ �ml���`ab1�m��)Nº B � %Óº

� ����Ö º �Y`i|�_*k=h�º � ¡y¿ ¿/¢o£ § «�ªy¬ § ¡y£�¥ �oªy #«�¡�¿/¿/¢o¬Ñªy¬ § ¡y£Ü¤=© « §  j«�¢ § ¬K¥ ¤=ª�£^¥ ¦ ©q¥   � ¥�©�ª�¢@3¤ " § £^¬½©q t«t¡y£^£Ç©'3 § ¡�£ º³Z\[�]ihj`·�o`A�owo�­ptwmv�k�p1¾ � �^���=`�v�h���pjg·�o` ,,���q`EÐ zowm~�[���k�B,�Ipj�}~8wm|}�}hi¾ � º 8�º e�º��`�zo�q�}`��^��`ihi¾ &°�qw=|�`��{wo�­ptwmv�ky|}`YÐ�z��q�}`��^��`ih\~8wml�v%| � ¼½�^�mg��^��`il�vi¾ 8^vtkm�^�q`=¾ �mkm�7l^kyvtr·bi�=�I�7º

�û�,� &,º 8�|}`�l^vjr=º.� ¡y¿ ¿/¢o£ § «�ªy¬ § ¡y£�¥��: j¡y¢o¬Ñª � ©{©q¬�ª� j« �=§ ¬½©�«q¬¯¢o j©q¥%¤=©­¥\¿aª=« �I§ £8©q¥�3Õ¿ � ¿*¡ §  j©d¤ § ¥­¬¯  § È­¢ � ©# � ¢o¬½¡�¢o �¤y¢? t¡�¢o¬½ª � ©/.C¡y ­¿ � ¡ ¦ © º�Z\[^]ihj`Õ��`��owo�­pjw=vtkypi¾ � �����=`�v�h���pjg��o` � rmw=��¾ &°�qw=|�` ,Ywmvt_*ky|}`zol�~Ngivj�}`�l^vj`��o` � rmwm�:¾ 8�v�ky�^��`m¾»bi�=�?�^º

� ����u�º�8^vtkm���=����kyl^�»º�u�`�vj�Gwmvt_*ky�^��` km�^ky|}roh���hYwm�Ô��vtw=k=����k=hspt���^�Ê[7rI~8`�v��ql^�N`1h{�%��pj[�vt`ih�pjvt�}�qpj`i�²�qw=_ Ð_ l�������kypj�}wm� �iky~^km���}|���pj�}`ihiº�4 ¡y¢o ­£8ª ¦ ¡�É �%ª� jª ¦ ¦ © ¦ ª�£Ç¤ � § ¥�¬¯  § Èq¢o¬Ñ©�¤ � ¡�¿��N¢o¬ § £ �m¾�b���®}b�65 ����^¾mbi�=�=��º

� ����u�º�8�v�ky�}�m����kylN� km�^� � º � ky�Gwmvt`ih�piºÇ�Y��hKxswm�}�=p�h�~^km�����}���Õpjvt`�`1hVwy�»hj_akm|�|8�o`�~�pj[�ºÇ¼½�1@/º e�º �mwml��8`�vjpi¾� ºNZ�vtr7h�pjv�ky_E¾ 8�º �^º�u�`qpt`�v�h�¾^km�^�?��º ��º &V��ky�^hi¾�`i���Àptwmv�h�¾ �%ªy  � ¡ " �#" ¾^~Nky�m`1hdb�' 6� 8b=b1�o¾Nbi�=�m��º

�}b�'��Õu�º 8^vtkm���=���}kml^�Akm�^� &,º � kyÎ1kyv��»º %E`qpt[�wo��hÕky�^�X~�vtwm��|}`�_*hdwy�Ô��wm_a_�l^���}�ik�pt��w=�A����l^hjl^ky|���`�p�Ð��wmvt�oh�º � § ¥�«q t©q¬½© � ��� ¦¨§ ©�¤ � ªy¬ � ©q¿*ª�¬ § «­¥ ¾ 6y�^®û�y�� Çbi�m�^¾Ôb1�m�?)^ºËz7~8`i�q��ky|\�=wm|}l�_a`�~�vtwo�q`i`i�o�}���=h�}�Ipj`ivj�^kypj�}wm�^km|»�Ôw=vj�ohj[�wm~!wm�E��vtw=km�^��kmh�pj�}���/ky�^���mwIhjhj��~^�����?bi�=�?'^º

�}bmb*��z»º %Óº $,`1�o`qpt���}`�_a�<¾dzǺ ZÕº:$,`1�o`qpt����`i_a�<¾Ykm�^��B�º � º � �}`ih�pj_*ky�:º B h�l^vj�=`�r4wm���mw=hthj��~��}���$ky�N��^vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}��� �}�·�qw=_/_ l�������kypj�}wm�!�^`qps��wmvt�7hiº. ©�¬ .C¡y  �i¥ ¾�b1��® ��bi�* 7�?)=��¾Nbi�=�?��º

MOM í�D m(E(FHG

Page 23: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�?' �{©tªy¢��q¢ § ©� ����/© ¦ ¿aª�¥��� �  j©�£^£8©q¥

�}b1��� � º ZÕº $,w?ky�^��zǺ � º �yw=[��^hth�w=��º�Ö{~opj�}_�l^_ ��vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}���!km�^�A~8`�v�h�w=�^ky|}�}Î�`i�X�qwm_a_ l�������k�pt��w=��}�E[7rI~8`�v��ql^�N`1h�º ������� �  jª�£^¥�ªm«�¬ § ¡y£�¥�¡�£ � ¡y¿ �8¢o¬Ñ©� �¥ ¾^�m� � � #­®}b1��)I�� Çb1���=��¾�b1�m�=��º

�}bi��� �^º $,vtwm_a�=w��I���y¾»e�º�-Õ|�kmhj�}���^¾ Ddº %Ewm�^��`i��¾:ky�N�Xe�º�u�`��}��`=º � ¡�¿ÊÈ § £8ª�¬½¡�  § ª ¦ ©q¬;.C¡�  � � � ©t¡y .- ¾��[Nky~opt`�v*�Y��hth�`i_/�}�^kypj�}wm�4wm�Y�}�o�Gwmvt_*k�pj�}wm�L���¸�}�=pt`�v��qw=����`i�qpj�}wm�Ë�^`qps��wmvt�7h � �^vjwIkm���ikmh�pj�}���Xky�N��=w=hth��}~��}��� #q¾o~^ky�=`ihdb1� 65 ��ob1��º -Õ|}lI��`�v B%�ikm�o`i_a�}�m¾»bi�m� 6oº

�}b*)?� �m`ikm�²�o`ae%l�_a`il�viº � ¡y¿ ¿/¢o£ § «�ªy¬ § ¡y£L¤mªy£�¥ ¦ ©­¥/  � ¥q©�ªy¢@3X¤m© �N j¡1«�©­¥�¥�©q¢o �¥ º � wm|}|�`1�­pj�}wm� &�pjl^��`ih`�pYe%`i��[^`�v���[�`ih�`��E¼½�o�Gw=vj_*kypj�0)=l^`mº�%·k=hjhjwm��¾ou�kyvt��h�¾»b1�m��)Nº

�}b�6�� � º*8�ºÔzIpjw=lop�km�^�BD{ºÔÏ�km�=kmviº³¼½�Ipt`��^hj���=`E[Ir7~8`�v��ql��8`X��wm_a_�l��^�}�ik�pj�}wm�:¾Ô~�vt`ikmvjv�ky�^�m`i�L�qw=_ Ð_ l�������kypj�}wm�Ë�}�4|}���^�=ÐÑ�8wml��^�Ë_ak=��[��}��`ihiº 4 ¡y¢o ­£8ª ¦ ¡sÉ �%ª� tª ¦ ¦ © ¦ ª�£Ç¤ � § ¥­¬¯  § È­¢o¬½©�¤ � ¡�¿��N¢o¬ § £ �m¾b�'�®}b��7� 8b1��b=¾^bi�=�?'^º

K�^3M@K ì

Page 24: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

�:§���� ¬��Y¡y¢o£8¤�¥CÉq¡� ��, j¡iª=¤m«�ªS¥­¬ § £ � ��b

&� ���� ,�����

2��*�8�i� ê ë����y��� ê � �

���:�S� � æ=é ê ��L �

��� � �Cæ ��� ê ����ë �¯ê �!��� ê ��ë��m�^����� � OËé �G� �Ú� �¯æIé æ �i�S��� ê � ��ë�� N

� �Ôê7é�æ ��� ê � ��ë�� �Ñê �!��� ê ��ë��m���i��� � O$é � ���Ú� �¯æIé æ ������� ê ����ë�� �)Nº�b ,Ywyp�k�pj�}wm�4º�ºdº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºdº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�º �)Nº �)u°vj`i|��}_a���^kmvj�}`ih#ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºdº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�º �)Nº � Ö{�^`d`�n7pjv�k vtwml^�^� º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºdº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�º#b�')Nº ) Z���w/`�n7pjv�k vtwml^�^��h*º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºdº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�º#b=b)Nº 6 zowm_a`�`qn7pjv�k vjw=l��^��h ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºdº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�º#b1�

M�� � ê ��ë��m�^����� � OËé �G� � �Ó��� ç¸æ ������� ê ���:ë�� 2 �

6�º�b � ~�~8`�v,�8wml��N��h�®V~^��~8`�|}���^`i�Eky|}�mw=vj��pj[�_*h#º�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºdº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�º#b�)6�º � � w��Ô`iv\�Nw=l��^��h·ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºdº�ºÕº�º�ºÕº�ºÕº�ºÕº�º�ºdº�º#b,6

N � ê �:��6 �:��� ê � 2��

MOM í�D m(E(FHG

Page 25: Tight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost ModelTight Bounds for Broadcasting in the Linear Cost Model Bruno Beauquier, Olivier Delmas, St ephane P erennes To cite this version:

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis2004, route des Lucioles - B.P. 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique615, rue du Jardin Botanique - B.P. 101 - 54602 Villers lès Nancy Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe - 38330 Montbonnot St Martin (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - B.P. 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)

ÉditeurINRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, B.P. 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)��������� ���� ���������� ��� ���

ISSN 0249-6399