Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor...

10
ORIGINAL RESEARCH Volume 26, Number 11 507 ABSTRACT The object of the current study was to evaluate the efficacy of thermography and ultrasonography in the diagnosis of thoracolumbar lesions in Quarter Horse athletes and asso- ciate the different types of lesions found with the athletic modality practiced. Twenty-four horses were admitted to the Surgery Service for Large Animals of the Veterinary and Animal Science Faculty, UNESP, Botucatu, Brazil, with complaints of back problems. All the horses were submitted for physical examinations to confirm the exis- tence of thoracolumbar alterations and then for thermog- raphy and ultrasonography. Thermography was used to map the lesioned areas of this region and ultrasonography for lesion characterization. The lesions found were supraspinous desmitis, interspinous desmitis, dorsal inter- vertebral osteoarthritis, and impingement of the spinous processes or kissing spines. The existence of a relation be- tween the type of event practiced by the horse and the type of lesion found was determined. In horses that competed in the barrel race, a predominance of lesions in the tho- racic caudal, thoracolumbar, and cranial lumbar regions occurred, with intervertebral osteoarthritis and inter- spinous desmitis being the most common. In cutting horses, most of the lesions were observed in the caudal lumbar region, whereas horses competing in reining showed a preferential location for lesions in the middle lumbar, with a predominance of supraspinous desmitis and myositis. Thermography associated with ultrasonography was shown to be efficient in the diagnosis of the thora- columbar lesions of these horses. Keywords: back pain; lameness; loss of performance; vertebral column From Surgery Service for Large Animals of the Veterinary and Animal Science Faculty of the São Paulo State University (UNESP), Botucatu Campus. Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP – Botucatu - Distrito de Rubião Jr, s/n, CP 560, 18618-000 – Botucatu/SP. 0737-0806/$ - see front matter © 2006 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.jevs.2006.09.007 Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of Equine Athletes B.P.A. Fonseca, MS, A.L.G. Alves, PhD, J.L.M. Nicoletti, PhD, A. Thomassian, PhD, C.A. Hussni, PhD, and S. Mikail, DVM REFEREED INTRODUCTION The elevated incidence of back problems, difficulty of di- agnosis, and importance of this anatomic region in loco- motion of the equine species justify investigations in this area, principally those directed at improved quality in di- agnosis and consequent therapeutic innovation. Currently, a growing number of horses are purchased and trained for participation in equestrian sports in Brazil, especially the western sports engaged in by the Quarter Horse. These horses compete in reining, cut- ting, team roping, and barrel racing events, in which de- mands for exercises at high speeds and abrupt stops or changes in direction are observed and considered unique in the equestrian athletic world. These demands generate a constant challenge to the musculoskeletal sys- tem, often passing the physiologic limits of these horses, with consequent compromise to the health of the loco- motor system, in such a manner that the incidence of certain lesions for specific sports is clear, although back pain is observed in all western modalities. 1 Diagnosis of the source of equine lameness is often difficult, princi- pally in cases in which the pain is located in the proximal hind limbs and is not related to synovial structures. 2,3 Back pain is included in this category of lesions. Lumbar pain, whether of primary or secondary origin, is an im- portant cause of the loss of performance in equine ath- letes. 4,5 Therefore, diagnosis of both the location of le- sions and their magnitude, in terms of pain, is difficult, because frequently the most evident clinical sign is not the pain itself, but the loss of performance. 6,7 We believe that scientific and technological advances in the diagnosis of back problems are essential to enable horses to express their maximum athletic potential, whether in western sports or in many other equestrian sporting modalities. Increased development in thermog- raphy and ultrasonography as complementary diagnosis methods has been observed worldwide by means of the numerous papers published in the last few years. 8,9 In Brazil, notable interest in the use of thermogram and ul- trasonogram in the diagnosis of lameness has been ob- served, though controlled studies relating thermographic

Transcript of Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor...

Page 1: Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP

ORIGINAL RESEARCH

Volume 26, Number 11 507

ABSTRACT

The object of the current study was to evaluate the efficacyof thermography and ultrasonography in the diagnosis ofthoracolumbar lesions in Quarter Horse athletes and asso-ciate the different types of lesions found with the athleticmodality practiced. Twenty-four horses were admitted tothe Surgery Service for Large Animals of the Veterinaryand Animal Science Faculty, UNESP, Botucatu, Brazil,with complaints of back problems. All the horses weresubmitted for physical examinations to confirm the exis-tence of thoracolumbar alterations and then for thermog-raphy and ultrasonography. Thermography was used tomap the lesioned areas of this region and ultrasonographyfor lesion characterization. The lesions found weresupraspinous desmitis, interspinous desmitis, dorsal inter-vertebral osteoarthritis, and impingement of the spinousprocesses or kissing spines. The existence of a relation be-tween the type of event practiced by the horse and the typeof lesion found was determined. In horses that competedin the barrel race, a predominance of lesions in the tho-racic caudal, thoracolumbar, and cranial lumbar regionsoccurred, with intervertebral osteoarthritis and inter-spinous desmitis being the most common. In cuttinghorses, most of the lesions were observed in the caudallumbar region, whereas horses competing in reiningshowed a preferential location for lesions in the middlelumbar, with a predominance of supraspinous desmitis andmyositis. Thermography associated with ultrasonographywas shown to be efficient in the diagnosis of the thora-columbar lesions of these horses.

Keywords: back pain; lameness; loss of performance;vertebral column

From Surgery Service for Large Animals of the Veterinary and Animal ScienceFaculty of the São Paulo State University (UNESP), Botucatu Campus.Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi-ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP – Botucatu - Distrito de Rubião Jr, s/n, CP560, 18618-000 – Botucatu/SP.0737-0806/$ - see front matter© 2006 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.doi:10.1016/j.jevs.2006.09.007

Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back PainDiagnosis of Equine AthletesB.P.A. Fonseca, MS, A.L.G. Alves, PhD, J.L.M. Nicoletti, PhD, A. Thomassian, PhD, C.A. Hussni, PhD, and S. Mikail, DVM

REFEREED

INTRODUCTIONThe elevated incidence of back problems, difficulty of di-agnosis, and importance of this anatomic region in loco-motion of the equine species justify investigations in thisarea, principally those directed at improved quality in di-agnosis and consequent therapeutic innovation.

Currently, a growing number of horses are purchasedand trained for participation in equestrian sports inBrazil, especially the western sports engaged in by theQuarter Horse. These horses compete in reining, cut-ting, team roping, and barrel racing events, in which de-mands for exercises at high speeds and abrupt stops orchanges in direction are observed and consideredunique in the equestrian athletic world. These demandsgenerate a constant challenge to the musculoskeletal sys-tem, often passing the physiologic limits of these horses,with consequent compromise to the health of the loco-motor system, in such a manner that the incidence ofcertain lesions for specific sports is clear, although backpain is observed in all western modalities.1 Diagnosis ofthe source of equine lameness is often difficult, princi-pally in cases in which the pain is located in the proximalhind limbs and is not related to synovial structures.2,3

Back pain is included in this category of lesions. Lumbarpain, whether of primary or secondary origin, is an im-portant cause of the loss of performance in equine ath-letes.4,5 Therefore, diagnosis of both the location of le-sions and their magnitude, in terms of pain, is difficult,because frequently the most evident clinical sign is notthe pain itself, but the loss of performance.6,7

We believe that scientific and technological advances inthe diagnosis of back problems are essential to enablehorses to express their maximum athletic potential,whether in western sports or in many other equestriansporting modalities. Increased development in thermog-raphy and ultrasonography as complementary diagnosismethods has been observed worldwide by means of thenumerous papers published in the last few years.8,9 InBrazil, notable interest in the use of thermogram and ul-trasonogram in the diagnosis of lameness has been ob-served, though controlled studies relating thermographic

507-516_YJEVS569_Fonseca_CP 11/7/06 12:12 PM Page 507

Page 2: Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP

508 Journal of Equine Veterinary Science November 2006

and ultrasonographic images to clinical findings in casesof lumbar pain do not exist.

Thus, the objectives of the current study were to eval-uate the efficacy of thermogram and ultrasonogram in thediagnosis of thoracolumbar lesions in Quarter Horse ath-letes and to associate the different types of lesions foundwith the athletic modalities practiced: cutting, reining,and barrel racing.

MATERIALS AND METHODSTwenty-four Quarter Horses were used, aged between 4and 8 years, of both sexes (11 male and 13 female) and allactive athletes. The horses were admitted to the SurgeryService for Large Animals of the Veterinary and AnimalScience Faculty of the São Paulo State University(UNESP), Botucatu Campus in Brazil, with complaintsof back pain, during the period April 2004 to May 2005.These horses competed in three sporting modalitieswithin western categories: reining (4 animals), cutting (9animals), and barrel racing (11 animals).

A physical examination of the locomotor apparatus ofeach horse was performed with the horse static. The ex-amination evaluated alterations in posture, conforma-tion, and movement to characterize the type and degreeof lameness and to perform flexion tests,10 with the ob-jective of excluding horses that presented lameness unre-lated to the thoracolumbar region. The physical exami-nation of the thoracolumbar region comprisedinspection, palpation, and mobility tests in accordancewith known protocols.5,8,11

A thermography examination (DTIS 500, EmergeVision) was performed after the physical examination,with a period of 1 hour between examinations, so thatbody temperature of the horse returned to normal.Thermographic images were obtained from the followingpositions: side view of the body and neck from both sides,including the side of the hind limb, and dorsal view of theextension of the vertebral column divided into thora-columbar view and lumbosacral view.

The examinations were performed in the Equine SportsMedicine Center (Centro de Medicina Esportiva Eqüina)of the FMVZ, UNESP, Botucatu Campus, Brazil, whilemaintaining the environment as stable as possible in rela-tion to the natural temperature and humidity. Directmarking and visualization of the exact locations of alter-ations in the thermal pattern was realized through the useof adhesive tape (Fig. 1). The parameters of normal ther-mal profile at rest were based on preestablished norms.9 Atemperature difference between antimeres within a rangeof 0.5°C to 1°C was considered normal. After mappingthe thoracolumbar region using the thermography exam-ination, ultrasonography (SSD-900, Aloka, Japan) of thisarea was performed using a 7.5-MHz linear transducer.

For the ultrasonographic examination, the area underevaluation was prepared by moistening the hairs with

warm water and applying hydrosoluble contact gel(Ultra-gel, Ind. e Comércio de Produtos GelatinososLtda, São Paulo, Brazil) for the best contact with thetransducer. Median, paramedian, and transverse ap-proaches were combined for complete access to axialstructures.12

Supraspinous ligament lesions were characterized ac-cording to their echogenicity and parallelism of the fibers;lesions of the interspinous space were classified accordingto increased echogenicity, presence of hyperechoic pointsin the space, and the reduction or loss of the space.Spinous processes were characterized regarding the regu-larity of the dorsal surface. Kissing spines were consideredpresent when a continuity of the bone line between twoor more spine processes, with loss of interspinous space,was observed. This may or may not have been associatedwith supraspinous desmitis.12

Articular processes were classified with regard to theregularity of the articular surface and the reduction or lossof articular space.12 The muscles were characterized bythe echogenicity of the fibers (hypoechoic zones) andperimysium (hyperechoic lines separating the fibers).Presence of a hypoechoic or anechoic gap within the mus-cle fibers was considered a criteria for the myositis diag-nosis. In chronic cases, a fibrosis area can appear as a hy-perechoic circumscribed lesion.13

All examined and diagnosed animals were treated.Treatments used were: supraspinous and interspinousdesmitis: paravertebral infiltrations with steroids (methyl-prednisolone acetate, depo-medrol, Pfizer; 40 mg/pointof injection) and neurolytics (Sarapin, High ChemicalCompany; 2 ml/point of injection) in the lesion area;myositis: muscle relaxants (Tiocolchicosido, Coltrax,Aventis Pharma; 20 mg/animal intramuscularly) andnonsteroidal anti-inflammatories (PhenylbutazoneButazolidina, Novartis; 2.2 mg/kg intramuscularly); dor-sal intervertebral osteoarthritis: local infiltration in themultifidus muscle with steroids; kissing spines: shockwave therapy.

RESULTSIn all horses, presence of thoracolumbar pain was con-firmed by means of the physical examination performed.The degree and type of pain response and mobility alter-ations varied between horses, whereas more than one re-sponse could be found in a single horse.

Only three horses presented lameness, and in all casesthe diagnosis of back pain preceded that of lameness.Alterations were observed in movement, principally inthe circle gallop examination, where diminisheddorsoventral mobility and shortness of gait were themost commonly observed.

In the thermogram, a high number of hot spots in thethoracic region were observed (65.4%), most in the mid-line (46.1%), corresponding to the trajectory of spinous

507-516_YJEVS569_Fonseca_CP 11/7/06 12:12 PM Page 508

Page 3: Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP

Volume 26, Number 11 509

and supraspinous ligament processes (Fig. 2). In fourhorses, hot spots were observed in the lumbar region,which suggests Longissimus dorsi myositis in the area cor-responding to the increased temperature (Fig. 3), whereasthe predominant finding in the lumbar region was coldspots (Fig. 4).

In the images obtained on ultrasound examination,both soft tissue and bone tissue lesions were identified.The lesion with the highest incidence was supraspinousdesmitis, followed by dorsal intervertebral osteoarthri-tis, interspinous desmitis, spinous processes syndrome,and Longissimus dorsi lesions, suggesting myositis (Fig.

Figure 1. Thermogram with the respective markings of thermographic findings.

Figure 2. Thermogram with hot spots (arrows) alongthe dorsal midline of a horse suggesting supraspinousand interspinous desmitis.

Figure 3. Thermogram with a hot spot (arrow) in thelumbar region of a horse suggesting Longissimus dorsimyositis.

507-516_YJEVS569_Fonseca_CP 11/7/06 12:12 PM Page 509

Page 4: Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP

510 Journal of Equine Veterinary Science November 2006

5), although more than one lesion type could be foundon the same horse.

The ultrasound examination showed that supra-spinous and interspinous ligament lesions and spinousprocesses were best observed in the longitudinal scans;in the case of supraspinous ligament, by the reduceddiameter and by the fact that most of the lesions ob-served were located at the insertion of this ligament inspinous processes, best seen in the longitudinal view.For dorsal intervertebral articulations and epaxial mus-cle, the transverse images were more elucidative (Figs.6, 7, 8, and 9).

Dorsal intervertebral osteoarthritis was observed in thecaudal thoracic and lumbar region of the horses examined(Fig. 5) and occurred either unilaterally (15 vertebrae) orbilaterally (17 vertebrae) in any particular vertebra. Inthree horses, only one lesioned articulation was found,whereas in the remaining horses (n � 9), at least two ar-ticulations were affected.

After performance of both examinations, it was possibleto ascertain a relationship between the images obtainedby thermography and those obtained by ultrasonography.In the case of hot spots, in all locations indicated by thethermography, a corresponding lesion was found; how-ever, in some horses, not all of the lesions that were po-tential causes of local temperature increase observed usingultrasonography were detected by thermography (Fig.10, Table 1).

In contrast, in the images of cold spots, a relation be-tween the thermographic and ultrasonographic imageswas seen in all horses. In the case of cold spots, their ex-tension, rather than their number, was computed.

Separating the horses submitted to the thermographyand ultrasonography examinations according to the ath-letic modality practiced (cutting, reining, and barrel rac-ing), a relationship between these events and the types oflesions found was observed.

According to sporting modality, horses competing incutting events showed a predominance for supraspinousdesmitis (89%), followed by dorsal intervertebral os-teoarthritis (44.4%); in barrel racing horses, osteoarthritiswas the lesion of highest incidence (63.6%), followed byinterspinous desmitis (45.5%), whereas in horses practic-ing reining, supraspinous desmitis was the lesion foundmost frequently (100%), followed by Longissimus dorsi le-sions (50%).

Among barrel race horses with osteoarthritis, 87.5% ofthe lesions observed were unilateral, and of these, 62.5%occurred on the right side, a fact probably due to thehorse turning twice at the barrel on the right side andonly once at the barrel on the left.

Among the cutting horses with dorsal intervertebral os-teoarthritis, 62% presented this lesion in the caudal lum-bar region, located in the articulation between L3 and L4up to articulation L5 and L6; whereas in barrel-racinghorses, 65% of the affected articulations were found in thecranial lumbar region, from the thoracolumbar articula-tion up to the articulation between L2 and L3. The onlyaffected reining horse presented lesions between L2 andL3, bilaterally.

After treatment, only one animal did not present im-provement in the clinic board after treatment, failing toreturn to athletic performance. This animal was diag-nosed with dorsal intervertebral osteoarthritis. All other

Figure 4. Thermogram with cold spots (arrows) inthe lumbar region of a horse, suggesting dorsal inter-vertebral osteoarthritis.

Figure 5. Alterations found in the ultrasonographyexamination of the horses examined: (DIOA) dorsalintervertebral osteoarthritis; (SSD) supraspinousdesmitis; (ISD) interspinous desmitis; (KS) kissingspines; (MS) myositis.

507-516_YJEVS569_Fonseca_CP 11/7/06 12:12 PM Page 510

Page 5: Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP

Volume 26, Number 11 511

Figure 6. Ultrasonographic image of supraspinous desmitis, showing the irregularity of the associated spinous pro-cess, with an anechoic focus in the ligament. Longitudinal view. CR—cranial; CA—caudal.

horses returned to athletic performance, without present-ing clinical signs of back pain.

DISCUSSIONDetermining the exact location of the lesion and thecause of pain using physical examination only was notpossible, although the pain could be determined as origi-nating from the thoracic or lumbar region,2,11 using as abase the horse’s response to epaxial structure palpation,the mobilization examinations, and inspection at work.

The best gait for examining the movement of the ver-tebral column was the gallop, where the horse’s neck as-sumes different positions.11,14 Among these antalgic gaits,the cervical position during movement of the horsesstood out, because the neck has a direct influence on thebiomechanics of the vertebral spine, especially by meansof the nuchal connection that continues into the thora-columbar spine as a supraspinous connection.15 When theanimal bends its neck, that is, puts it down, a flexion of

the entire thoracic spine occurs, by the augmentation ofthe tension of the nuchal connection, increasing theamount of movement, especially between T6 and T10.Horses with thoracic pain have a tendency to lower theneck during work. In the lumbar region, cervical flexionreduces the amount of lateral bending and rotation al-lowed, especially between T18 and L5. Because of this,horses with lumbar pain tend to raise the neck to increasemobility and reduce stress in this region.15

Regarding thermography in the examined horses in thisstudy, the predominant findings were hot spots; the casesof supraspinous and interspinous desmitis and muscularlesion depicted inflammatory lesions that led to increasedlocal surface temperatures.9,16 The thermographic findingassociated with possibility of myositis is an increase oftemperature in the region of the Longissimus dorsi.Increase in temperature in this region can be from themuscle or from the skin and subcutaneous tissue.17

Animals were examined for dermatological health before

507-516_YJEVS569_Fonseca_CP 11/7/06 12:12 PM Page 511

Page 6: Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP

512 Journal of Equine Veterinary Science November 2006

the thermographic examination, so that only animalswithout cutis lesions in the thoracic and lumbar regionswere submitted to this examination. Therefore, the onlypossible structure capable of creating heat in an abnormalmanner at the time of examination was the thoracolum-bar muscle.

Cold spots occurred in cases of dorsal intervertebral os-teoarthritis, which causes local pain without causing aninflammatory reaction at the lesion location.9 Some au-thors9,18 contradict this statement, classifying only hotspots as active, that is, as causes of pain. In view of the factthat lesions of these articulations were only found in thelumbar region, clearly a predominance of cold spots oc-curs in this location.

For the exact location of hot and cold spots, adhesivetape was used. No reports of similar lesion marking meth-ods were found in the literature, with no description ofany such technique. Thus, thermography presented a greatpotential as an auxiliary in back pain diagnosis, because it

quickly reveals the presence or absence of alterations inthis region, whether inflammatory or degenerative.

Desmitis of the supraspinous ligament was visualizedas areas of diminished echogenicity and loss of fiber par-allelism in this ligament.12 Another finding related tosupraspinous desmitis in some cases was the presence ofpoints of increased echogenicity in the ligament, indi-cating the presence of tissue fibrosis in certain areas; aspresented in the suspensory ligament of the fetlockjoint,18 an occurrence that was not described by someauthors.8,12

In the case of the interspinous ligament, images wereobtained in longitudinal scans. The lesions found in thisligament were especially characterized by increasedechogenicity and the presence of hyperechoic points. Insome cases, visualizing diminished interspinous space andeven the loss of this space was possible.12

In the case of articular processes, use of a sectorialtransducer of 3.5 MHz or 5.0 MHz to obtain images of

Figure 7. Ultrasonographic image of interspinous desmitis, showing increased dorsal echogenicity and hyperechoicfoci in the ligament. Arrows indicate the lesion location. Longitudinal view. CR—cranial; CA—caudal.

507-516_YJEVS569_Fonseca_CP 11/7/06 12:12 PM Page 512

Page 7: Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP

Volume 26, Number 11 513

This finding reaffirms the fact that kissing spines is oftena subclinical condition found in asymptomatic horses.14,20

Considering the cold spots, a correlation between thethermographic and ultrasonographic findings occurred.All horses that exhibited diminished surface temperaturehave associated lesions found by ultrasonography.

Dorsal intervertebral osteoarthritis was the lesionfound and considered as the cause of this type of alter-ation in the thermal pattern, which led indirectly to di-minished surface temperature by action on the vasomotortonus, causing a local vasoconstriction.9,17 Haussler etal,20 Leclaire et al,7 and Denoix12 stated that interverte-bral osteoarthritis is the greatest cause of back pain inhorses. Taken as stated, this declaration suggests that thegreater part of the lesions found in this articulation wereactive, thus causing pain to the horse. In contrast, in thecurrent study, all horses that showed ultrasonographic al-terations in this articulation also presented cold spots in

this structure is recommended by authors.11,12 However,performing a complete examination of this articulationwith a 7.5-MHz linear transducer was possible.

The findings obtained by thermography could be cor-related to those obtained by ultrasonography, as previ-ously described for cases of tendonitis.19 In the case of hotspots, all of them possessed an associated lesion identifiedwith ultrasonography, but not all the lesions that couldlead to diagnosable increased surface temperature, such assupraspinous and interspinous desmitis, were detectedwith thermography. This was probably because the non-indicated lesions showed images compatible with chronicinactive processes, as also described in studies withThoroughbred racing horses.8

Another case in which thermography did not reveal thepresence of a lesion was in the kissing spines, found infour horses examined here. In these cases, the lesionedarea presented no thermographic alteration whatsoever.

Figure 8. Ultrasonographic image of kissing spines, where the continuity between the bone line of two adjacentspinous processes can be observed, indicated by the arrow. Longitudinal view. CR—cranial; CA—caudal.

507-516_YJEVS569_Fonseca_CP 11/7/06 12:12 PM Page 513

Page 8: Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP

514 Journal of Equine Veterinary Science November 2006

Figure 9. Ultrasonographic image of dorsal intervertebral osteoarthritis, showing the irregularity of the cranial andcaudal articular process, with loss of articular space. (R) right; (L) left; (white arrow) articular space; (red arrow) le-sion. Transverse view.

Figure 10. Relationship between the number of hot spots found in the thermography examination and the numberof lesions found in the ultrasonography examination.

507-516_YJEVS569_Fonseca_CP 11/7/06 12:12 PM Page 514

Page 9: Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP

Volume 26, Number 11 515

their thermal maps, demonstrating that all the lesionswere active.12

Regarding athletic activity, in the current study a rela-tionship could be established between the sportingmodality practiced by the horse and the lesions found. Inhorses that competed in cutting, the lesion showing high-est incidence was supraspinous desmitis, followed by dor-sal intervertebral osteoarthritis. The prevalence of theselesions can be explained by the type of movement per-formed by the horse and in the way this movement al-tered the vertebral column biomechanics in thesehorses.21 In this sport, the horse adopts a position offorced ventriflexion throughout almost the entire periodof competition. This position increases tension in thesupraspinous ligament and on the dorsal intervertebral ar-ticulations of the lumbar region, principally from L4 on-ward. This would explain the findings from this studyshowing a majority of the osteoarthritis lesions in articu-lations of the caudal lumbar region.

In horses competing in three-barrel racing, the infirmi-ties of greatest incidence were dorsal intervertebral os-teoarthritis and interspinous desmitis. In this modality,

lateroflexion and rotation movements are more fre-quently realized by the horse. These movements act di-rectly on the dorsal intervertebral articulations, princi-pally in the lumbar region because of its characteristicconfiguration in this region, and on the interspinous lig-aments, which, during the axial rotation movement, suf-fer increased tension force.15 The articulations affected byosteoarthritis are predominantly located in the lumbar re-gion between L1 and L3, because rotation and lateroflex-ion movements act principally on the cranial lumbar ver-tebrae, whereas from L4 or L5 the vertebrae are stabilizedby intertransverse articulations.15

For horses competing in reining, it was difficult to drawa concise relationship between the alterations in thebiomechanics of the horse caused by the movement dur-ing competition and the lesions found, because only fourhorses were examined, but these animals show a tendencyto present supraspinous desmitis and Longissimus dorsimuscle lesions. This prevalence can be associated withmovements made during competition, where the horsesrepeatedly perform dorsoventriflexion (slide) and lat-eroflexion (spin). These movements increase tension on

Number ofBunning Cervical Cervical Number of Lesions in the

Animal Hoppe Bending 10 Extension Hot Spots Ultrasound

1 - � - 3 32 � - - 5 63 � � - 6 64 � - - 2 25 - � - 4 46 � - - 3 37 �� - - 4 78 - - �� 5 69 - - - 5 510 � - �� 6 611 - � - 2 712 - �� ��� 6 1013 �� - - 4 414 - �� 5 715 � � - 4 416 � - - 2 217 � � - 6 718 � - - 5 519 � �� - 2 420 �� - - 1 121 �� �� - 5 522 - � - 4 423 �� - - 4 424 �� - - 3 4

(-) normal; (�) mild; (��) moderate; (���) severe.

Table 1. Relationship between the physical examination (at work), number of hot spots found in the thermographicexamination, and the number of lesions found in the ultrasonographic examination

507-516_YJEVS569_Fonseca_CP 11/7/06 12:12 PM Page 515

Page 10: Thermography and Ultrasonography in Back Pain Diagnosis of ... · Reprint requests: Professor Doutor Fonseca, Departamento de Cirurgia e anestesi- ologia Veterinária, FMVZ – UNESP

516 Journal of Equine Veterinary Science November 2006

the supraspinous ligament and dorsal intervertebral artic-ulations, respectively, based on thoracolumbar biome-chanics,15,22 which could explain the incidence of thesetwo lesions in these horses. Occurrence of muscular le-sions can be associated with the fact that the competingtime for reining is relatively long with repeated move-ments, as previously noted, which leads to an overloadingof the thoracolumbar musculature, principally the epaxialmuscles, which provide stability to the vertebral columnduring ventriflexion movement.1,15

In conclusion, when analyzing the results obtainedunder the conditions of this study, thermography and ul-trasonography associated with a physical examinationproved to be a rapid and efficient method for diagnosis ofexisting lesions in the thoracolumbar region. In addition,it was found that the sporting event practiced by a horseand the type of lesion present in the thoracolumbar re-gion are related.

REFERENCES

1. Kobluk CN. Exercise intolerance and poor performance in western

performance horses. Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract 1996;12:

581–606.

2. Denoix JD. Aspects fonctionnels des régions lombo-sacrales et

sacro-iliac du cheval. Pract Vet Equine 1992;24:13–22.

3. Jeffcott LB. Diagnosis of back problems in the horse. Compend

Contin Educ Pract Vet 1981;3:S134–S143.

4. Haussler KK. The lower back and pelvis of performance horses re-

ceive a closer look. J Equine Vet Sci 1996;16:279–281.

5. Martin BB Jr, Klide AM. Physical examination of horses with back

pain. Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract 1999;15:61–70.

6. Jeffcott LB. The examination of a horse with a potential back prob-

lem. Proc Am Assoc Equine Pract 1985;31:271–284.

7. Leclaire R, Esdaile JM, Jéquier JC, Hanley JA, Rossignol M,

Bourdouxhe M. Diagnostic accuracy of technologies used in low

back pain assessment: Thermography, triaxial dynamometry,

spinoscopy, and clinical examination. Spine 1996;21:1325–1331.

8. Purohit RC, McCoy MD, Bergfeld WA. Thermography diagnosis

of Horner’s syndrome in the horse. Am J Vet Res

1980;41:1180–1182.

9. Turner TA. Diagnostic thermography. Vet Clin North Am Equine

Pract 2001;17:95–113.

10. Stashak TS. Examination for lameness. In: Stashak TS. Adam’s

Lameness in Horses. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins; 2002:113–183.

11. Denoix JD, Desbrosse F. Pathologie du Dos Chez Le Cheval.

Maisons-Alfort: ENV Alfort; 1999.

12. Denoix JD. Ultrasonographic evaluation of back lesions. Vet Clin

North Am Equine Pract 1999;15:131–160.

13. Peetrons P. Ultrasound of muscles. Eur Radiol 2002;12:35–43.

14. Denoix JD, Dyson SJ. Thoracolumbar spine. In: Ross MW, Dyson

SJ, eds. Diagnosis and Management of Lameness in The Horse. 1st

ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 2003:509–521.

15. Denoix JD. Spinal biomechanics and functional anatomy. Vet Clin

North Am Equine Pract 1999;15:27–60.

16. Denoix JD. Ligament injuries of the axial skeleton in the horse:

supraspinal and sacroiliac desmopathies. Proc Dubai Int Equine

Symp 1996:273–286.

17. Townsend HGG, Leach, DH, Fretz PB. Kinematics of the equine

thoracolumbar spine. Equine Vet J 1983;15:117–122.

18. Von Schweinitz DG. Thermographic diagnostics in equine back

pain. Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract 1999;15:161–278.

19. Hall J, Bramlage LR, Kantrowitz BM, Page L, Simpson B.

Correlation between contact thermography and ultrasonography in

the evaluation of experimentally-induced superficial flexor ten-

donitis. Proc Am Assoc Equine Pract 1982;28:429–438.

20. Haussler KK, Stover SM, Willits NH. Pathologic changes in the

lumbosacral vertebrae and pelvis in Thoroughbred horses. Am J Vet

Res 1999;60:143–153.

21. Kirkaldy-Willis WH. Relationship between spinal biomechanics and

pathological changes in the equine thoracolumbar spine. Equine

Vet J 1986;18:107–111.

22. Townsend HGG, Leach DH. Relationship between intervertebral

joint morphology and mobility in the equine thoracolumbar spine.

Equine Vet J 1984;16:461–465.

23. Gundel M, Schmucker N, Budde K, Von Rotz A, Schatzmann U,

Meier HP. Die sonographische untersuchung am rücken des pferds:

grundlagen und untersuchungstechniken an ausgewählten struk-

turen des pferderückens. Pferdeheilkunde 1998;14:322–332.

24. Dyson S. Suspensory ligament desmitis. Vet Clin North Am Equine

Pract 1995;11:177–215.

25. Denoix JM, Germain D. Imaging anatomy of the articular pro-

cesses and synovial intervertebral articulations in the horse thora-

columbar spine. Abstracts of the XXII European Association of

Veterinary Anatomists Congress 1998;22:71.

26. Jeffcott LB. Clinicopathological aspects of some conditions affect-

ing the vertebral column of the horse. Proceedings of the

Symposium “Through The Naked Eye”: Gross Pathology of

Domestic Animals. Sydney, Australia 1987:59–82.

507-516_YJEVS569_Fonseca_CP 11/7/06 12:12 PM Page 516