Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in...

31
Summary Our group What is the problem? Our Assumption Our Model Summary Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in Shoulder potentials Ney M. Barraz Jr. (UFRGS) Alan Barros de Oliveira (UFOP) Evy Salcedo (UFSC) Marcia C. Barbosa (UFRGS) 1 de julho de 2010

Transcript of Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in...

Page 1: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Thermodynamic, Dynamic and StructuralAnomalies in Shoulder potentials

Ney M. Barraz Jr. (UFRGS)Alan Barros de Oliveira (UFOP)

Evy Salcedo (UFSC)Marcia C. Barbosa (UFRGS)

1 de julho de 2010

Page 2: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

1 Our group

2 What is the problem?

3 Our Assumption

4 Our Model

5 Summary

Page 3: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Our Grouphttp : //www.if.ufrgs.br/ ∼ barbosa

Page 4: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

What is the Problem?[M. Chaplin, Water structure and science (2010).]

Density Anomaly

Page 5: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

What is the Problem?[ C. A. Angell, E. D. Finch, and P. Bach, J. Chem. Phys. 65, 3063 (1976) ]

Diffusion Anomaly

Page 6: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

What is the Problem?[ P. A. Netz, F. Starr, H. E. Stanley, M. C. Barbosa, Journal of Chem. Phys., 115, 344 (2001) ]

Diffusion Anomaly SPC/E

Page 7: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

How are the anomalies observed?[Angell, Finch, and Bach, J.Chem.Phys. 65, 3063 (1976)]

[Netz, Starr, Stanley, and Barbosa, J.Chem.Phys. 115, 344 (2001)]

There are experimental and simulational data.

Page 8: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

What is the main ingredient for anomaly?

Two Length Scales

The Second Scale has to be deeper

}}||||

||||

!!BBB

BBBB

B

Competition

Page 9: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Effective Potential for Water[A. B. de Oliveira et. al JCP 124 84505 (2006),125 124503 (2006) ]

U(r) = 4ε[(σr

)12−(σr

)6]

+ aε exp

[−(r − r0c

)2]

Page 10: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Phase Diagram

.

Page 11: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Diffusion[A. B. de Oliveira et. al JCP 124 84505 (2006),125 124503 (2006) ]

Page 12: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Integral Equations

βP = ρ− βρ

3N〈∑

~ri · ~∇Vi〉

βP = ρ− 2πβρ2

3

∫dV

drg(r)r3dr

Page 13: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Radial Distribution Function

g(r) =dn

ρ4πr2dr

Page 14: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Gas

Page 15: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Liquid

Page 16: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Solid

Page 17: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Integral Equations

ggas(r) ∝ e−βV (r) Gas

gHNC(r) = e−βV (r)eh(r)−c(r) HNC

gPY (r) = e−βV (r)(1 + h(r)− c(r)) PY

Page 18: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Ornstein-Zernike

h(r) = c(r) + ρ

∫c(|~r − ~r′|)h(r′)d3r′

Page 19: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Correlations

Page 20: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Percus Yevick: Phase Diagram

.

Page 21: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Percus Yevick

c(r) = g(r)− gindirect(r)

c(r) = e−βW (r) − e−(βW (r)−βV (r))

c(r) = g(r)− eβV (r)g(r)

g(r) = e−βV (r)(1 + h(r)− c(r))

Page 22: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

HNC: Phase Diagram

.

Page 23: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Hypernetted-chain

c(r) = g(r)− gindirect(r)

c(r) = e−βW (r) − e−(βW (r)−βV (r))

c(r) = g(r)− 1 + βW (r)− βV (r) = h(r)− Log[eβV (r)g(r)]

g(r) = e−βV (r)eh(r)−c(r)

Page 24: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Inconsistency

βPfluc = ρ− 4π∫ ρ

0

∫ρ′r2c(r, ρ′)drdρ′

βPvirial = ρ− 2πβρ2

3

∫dV

drg(r)r3dr

Page 25: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Roger Young

gRY (r) = e−βV (r)(1 +e(h(r)−c(r))f(r)−1

f(r))

f(r) = 1− e−αr

Pvirial = Pfluc

gRY = gPY r → 0

gRY = gHNC r →∞

Page 26: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Roger Young: Phase Diagram

.

Page 27: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

gr[A. B. de Oliveira et. al European Physics Journal B 64 481 (2008)]

Page 28: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Summary

Two length scales = density and diffusion anomalies

Integral Equations = help in choosing phase space forrunning simulations

Page 29: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

Effective Potential for Water[A. B. de Oliveira et. al JCP 132 164505 (2010) ]

Page 30: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

g(r)

Page 31: Thermodynamic, Dynamic and Structural Anomalies in ...static.sif.it/SIF/resources/public/files/va2010/barbosa_0701.pdf · 1 Our group 2 What is the problem? 3 Our Assumption 4 Our

Summary

Our group

What is theproblem?

OurAssumption

Our Model

Summary

r2