Theory of documentary

18
THEORY OF DOCUMENTARY

Transcript of Theory of documentary

Page 1: Theory of documentary

THEORY OF DOCUMENTARY

Page 2: Theory of documentary

The aim of a documentary is to report something real with evidence. Documentaries contain actual footage and/or reconstructions of events and situations to provide evidence or contrast with the interviewee's account. They also include narration to anchor meaning, sometimes relying on the unseen narrator. Documentaries are often defined as problematic.

Documentaries have to be real but unfortunately they can't always document with evidence. By reconstructing the event that the interviewee describes it can help the audience to visualise a portrayal of evidence, reconstructions must be based on fact. They don't have to contain analysis and can cover a wide range of genres from political, historical, social, religious and cultural. However they are NOT classed as current affairs.

THE AIM OF DOCUMENTARIES

'What distinguishes a documentary is the portrayal of sound and images of actuality' - John Corner 1995.

Page 3: Theory of documentary

Genres were being defined in the 1930's by John Grierson and his team at the general post office. Grierson's principles of documentary were that cinema's potential for observing life could be exploited in a new art form; that the "original" actor and "original" scene are better guides than their fiction counterparts to interpreting the modern world; and that materials "thus taken from the raw" can be more real than the acted article. He created documentaries such as Coal Face and Housing Problems.

THE HISTORY OF DOCUMENTARY

Page 4: Theory of documentary

He shot real people and real situations in a real environment and believed that is what documentary should be. He wanted to give people a glimpse of other people's lives, which in contrast to our modern day

society it had not been something available to the 1930's audience, real life hadn't been exposed before this was an entirely new concept. Old

style documentaries had a sense of persuasion.

Genre is important, especially for television. Documentary makers would have to carefully consider their genre -would television find is

acceptable to air? is it too controversial?- and then plan their scheduling cleverly to fit in with their target audience. British documentaries are

renowned for their investigative journalism. The word documentary was coined by documentarian John Grierson and defined as 'the creativity of

actuality'.

A range of arguments have carried on since about the balance of creativity. This is because problems arise of authenticity, the more

creative the documentary is the more it runs away from focus.

JOHN GRIERSON

Page 5: Theory of documentary

However film makers argue reconstruction is inevitable as not everything can be/is captured when it happens.

All attempts to record reality is affected as people act differently when they are on camera.

'I think that the truth is what you actually come away with at the end of seeing a film. I mean it's your truth that you're

seeing. Everybody who makes a film is putting their own truth on screen.' - Diane Tammes, Film Maker.

FILM MAKERS

Page 6: Theory of documentary

Creative development over the years means the term documentary covers a huge range of production methods. Some analysts argue it should be replaced with the term 'non-fiction programming'.  

Although people disagree on the styles and term of documentary, they do have a common thread of what a documentary is and should contain.  Some of these are:

Recorded sound- actual reality/experiences

Not just about facts- socially critical arguments, also inviting the audience to draw their own conclusions   

CREATIVE DEVELOPMENT

Peter Mayeux says that 'documentaries present facts about a subject using real events, people, places then creatively interpret all comments on those realities and peoples concerns'.

Page 7: Theory of documentary

Current Affairs: Midway between documentaries and the news, for example Panorama.

Current affairs are more in-depth information about what is happening on the news. They can range from a couple of minutes up to 15 minutes.

Features that are 30 minutes or longer is then a documentary. Current affairs are important for exploring weighty issues and social

development. However, there is a growing concern that they are edging towards being 'rating driven'.

ITV's Trevor McDonald was accused of being sensationalist. He was criticised for distorting the truth and misinterpreting the views of

contributors.

CURRENT AFFAIRS

Page 8: Theory of documentary

Documentary maker John Corner, a professor at the University of Liverpool, believed that there

are 5 central elements to documentaries:1. Observation

2. Interview3. Dramatisation4. Mise en Scene

5. Exposition

FIVE ELEMENTS OF DOCUMENTARY

Page 9: Theory of documentary

Observation: Most documentaries will include observations. Usually they pretend that the camera is unseen which

places the audience as an eye witness. Observations are also used as evidence for interviews. However, they have

been criticised for portraying participants as objects instead of subjects.

Interview: Documentaries rely on interviews and these are used to support or contrast with the observation. The

interviewer can be seen or unseen and pictures are often played to anchor meaning and make the interviews more

interesting. Documentary makers have the choice to intercut fragments of interviews with other material or to

just let the interview run.

OBSERVATION AND INTERVIEWS

Page 10: Theory of documentary

Dramatisation: This is done through the observational element. It is used to create a sense of conflict and build up the arguments. The

audience is placed as an eye witness and they portray people in the events based on fact.

Mise En Scene: This is used in documentaries to construct reality. Mise en scene is extremely important and must be relevant to the

documentary. It includes things such as; set, props, costume, make-up, lighting and colour.

Exposition: This element of the documentary reveals what argument is being explored (topic of the documentary). This is done through description and commentary. Exposition can be obvious, direct or

indirect and finally it can be hidden. Documentaries can also leave it up to the audience to make up their own minds.

DRAMATISATION, MISE EN SCENE AND EXPOSITION

Page 11: Theory of documentary

Since the beginning documentaries have struggled with the truth and reality resulting in many counter claims. John Corner says that this is why they need

evidence. Documentaries are real though they have elements of fiction, for example scripted voice overs, and they are not good ratings boosters. Because of

this documentaries are normally the first programmes to be cut. The most popular documentaries are the ones that look at topics such as sex, violence and law and order. The most watched documentary is US Violence In America. Controversial

documentaries are not popular with television as it is difficult to get advertisers to play their adverts in the middle of the documentary since they don't want to be

associated with the controversy. The triangulation of documentary, documentary producer and the audience is a complex relationship. Normally documentaries are

used to tell the stories of society's victims. They use human beings as evidence and exploit and expose people's lives.

TRUTH AND REALITY

'It is critical that the film makers be rid of the fantasy that the documentary can be unproblematic representation of reality and that the 'truth' can be conveniently dispensed and revealed like valium.' -Dennis O'Rourke.

Page 12: Theory of documentary

Documentary maker Ken Loach's documentary of Cathy Come Home, was so influential that the laws were changed

about homeless people.

Documentaries aim to work on people's right to know. For example producing documentaries on information that the government aren't saying openly to the public. They expect

the audience to notice there is a problem and then right that wrong. They show people that something needs to be

done in hope that they will do something.

PEOPLE’S RIGHT TO KNOW

Page 13: Theory of documentary

•Fully narratored: This type of documentary has a direct mode of address and uses a voice over to convey meaning which also makes sense of what's on screen. This is sometimes referred to the 'voice of God' in documentaries. This can be found in documentaries about space and animals.• Fly on the wall: These documentaries rely almost entirely on observations. There is no/almost no narration and lets the audience watch the events as eye witnesses, as if they are actually there. These documentaries appear to be the truth though they are heavily edited which instead means that they are only a version of the truth. This is found in documentaries including police camera action or A&E documentaries.

TYPES OF DOCUMENTARY

Page 14: Theory of documentary

Mixed: Mixed documentaries use a combination to advance the argument, combining; interviews, observations and

narration. They have a news reporting style to them. They have however been criticised for representing 'objective'

reality but they are more edited and balanced and contain the most evidence. Mainly in documentaries about music or

film etc.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W0VfyQd_PhM

-Bruno Mars - Coming Home Documentary

TYPES OF DOCUMENTARY

Page 15: Theory of documentary

•Self Reflective: The subject of this documentary acknowledge the camera and the documentary tends to lose its importance as it becomes more about the host. Critics have said that the are confusing and fall into empty narcissism.• Docudrama: These documentaries contain re-enactments of events based on fact with a fictional narrative. Docudramas are very popular with television and some examples are Hillsborough and Death of JFK. Critics say that they can only ever hope to deliver fiction though they claim to represent the truth. They don't film actuality so they are at best misleading and possibly dangerous.•Docusoaps: This type of documentary has become really popular over the past 10 years, they follow the daily lives of people. For example, Katie Price, Nurses, The Saturdays, Airline and Peter Andre. They originated in the UK and have helped increase the subjects interest from the public making them more famous. Some consider The Only Way is Essex and Jersey Shore as docusoaps however this is seen to untrue by many since the shows are actually scripted and not 'reality'. Docusoaps don't seek to explore topics instead they are more eavesdropping on people's lives. They have no particular story and are a low cost production as they don't have to pay actors.

TYPES OF DOCUMENTARY

Page 16: Theory of documentary

Theory: Disneyfiction: Steven Barnett's Theory

 Steven Barnett looked at the need for television to broadcast things that win ratings instead of serious

documentaries. He believes that documentaries have been 'dumbed down' for audiences since this is what people have become used to. There are claims that this shows television

being 'cheap' and being more concerned about getting 'ratings' instead showing useful or important

documentaries.

DISNEYFICTION

Page 17: Theory of documentary

Documentaries rely heavily on narrative conventions. They have a definite beginning, middle and end also they have a strong focus on

conflict. They also include music and sound effects to make them more interesting.

Beginning: This will lay out the central question of the documentary and go into some action footage or quick interview conflicts.

Middle: This is where the documentary will become more complicated and it will examine the issue in more detail and voice

differences in opinions and the argument becomes strengthened. It will offer a range of different arguments creating complications and

conflicting evidence.

End: The end makes the exposition fully apparent. The complications are resolved and there is no doubt for the audience.

DOCUMENTARY CONVENTIONS

Page 18: Theory of documentary

Conflict: This would include different people with different beliefs in different circumstances with different opinions. It should be shown in action through reconstructions for evidence (drama element).

Music and Sound Effects: These are used to create an emotional response from the audience in reconstructions and music is sometimes quietened throughout interviews.

Selection and Construction: This is very important. Documentary makers must think about the type of documentary they're going to produce, topic, who, what, when, why and how. They must also consider time and cost and be realistic. Then in the editing suite they must select carefully the footage and interviews and music etc that they are going to use to create the documentary, they MUST be careful of misrepresentation.

Overall to create a good documentary the producer must be professional and have knowledge of their chosen subject and discuss and plan techniques and content. Finally they must be organised!

CONVENTIONS CONTINUED