The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

18
Michael Fraikin Head of Portfolio Management Invesco Global Quantitative Equity 27th of January 2011 Volatility – an anomaly? This presentation is exclusively for use by professional clients and financial advisors in Continental Europe and is not for retail client use. Please do not redistribute.

Transcript of The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

Page 1: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

Michael Fraikin

Head of Portfolio Management

Invesco Global Quantitative Equity

27th of January 2011

Volatility – an anomaly?

This presentation is exclusively for use by professional clients and financial advisors in Continental Europe and is not for retail client use. Please do not redistribute.

Page 2: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

2

Table of contents

1. Volatility Anomaly – Theory vs. practice

2. Investment Process – A possible approach

3. Performance – Alpha opportunity in a European context

Page 3: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

1. Volatility Anomaly –Theory vs. practice

Page 4: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

4

Theory:More risk = more return and the combinations of market and risk free asset dominates all other portfolio

risk

retu

rn

portfolios

capitalallocation line

efficient frontier

R0

CAPM: Capital Asset Pricing Model

R0: risk free rate

For illustration only

minimum-variance portfolio

market portfolio

Page 5: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

5

-60%

-40%

-20%

0%

20%

40%

60%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%

Annualised Volatility

Annual

ised

Ret

urn

What we observe: higher risk is not rewarded

Source Bloomberg, Invesco Research, European equities members of the Stoxx 600 over the period 30.06.2002 to 30.06.2010 (8 years). Volatility is calculated as annualised standard deviation of monthly returns.

The slope of the regression line is negative!

Page 6: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

6

Highest volatility stocks underperform

Source Bloomberg, Invesco Research, European equities members of the Stoxx 600 over the period 30.06.2002 to 30.06.2010 (8 years). Volatility is calculated as annualised standard deviation of monthly returns.

Decile 1 = 10% of stocks in sample with lowest volatility: 8% return p.a. with volatility <20%

Decile 10 = 10% of stocks in sample with highest volatility: 3x the volatility for 1/3 of the return

0%

1%

2%

3%

4%

5%

6%

7%

8%

9%

10%

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Volatility Decile

Annual

ised

Ret

urn

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Ave

rage

Vol

atili

ty

Return (lhs) Volatility (rhs)

Return per decile

Volatility per decile

Page 7: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

7

Long-term evidence:Relative Performance of European Risk Factors

Source Barra, Invesco Research Data from 12/1994 to 12/2010, For illustrative purposes only

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

220

Dez-1994 Dez-1996 Dez-1998 Dez-2000 Dez-2002 Dez-2004 Dez-2006 Dez-2008 Dez-2010

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

220Momentum

Earnings yield

Dividend yield

Value

Liquidity

Size

Leverage

Growth

Volatility

Page 8: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

8

Long-term evidence: the world

Quelle: MSCI Barra, Invesco Research, 04/1993 bis 12/2010. Based on a simulation of a minimum-variance portfolio. For illustration only.

8

Minimum Variance MSCI Hedged

Return1 yr 0.18% 10.32%3 yr -5.76% -4.94%5 yr 0.67% 1.34%10 yr 3.93% 3.09%

30. Apr. 93 7.88% 8.89%

Volatility1 yr 6.62% 16.09%3 yr 10.10% 21.05%5 yr 9.04% 17.14%10 yr 8.56% 15.72%

30. Apr. 93 8.16% 14.73%

Page 9: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

9

Long-term evidence: the world

Quelle: MSCI Barra, Invesco Research, 04/1993 bis 12/2010. Based on a simulation of a minimum-variance portfolio. For illustration only.

9

3 y e a r r ol l i ng r i sk l e v e l s

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

Dez 96 Dez 97 Dez 98 Dez 99 Dez 00 Dez 01 Dez 02 Dez 03 Dez 04 Dez 05 Dez 06 Dez 07 Dez 08 Dez 09 Dez 10

Minimum Var iance MSCI Wor ld Hedged

Page 10: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

10

Evidence:More risk does not necessarily mean more return

risk

retu

rn

portfolios

capitalallocation line

efficient frontier

R0

CAPM: Capital Asset Pricing Model

R0: risk free return

For illustration only

minimum-variance portfolio

market portfolio

Page 11: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

11

Possible reasons

• Investment restrictions— To increase equity market participation some investors may prefer high beta

portfolios effectively circumventing their investment restrictions. The reverse will not be the case

— High beta seems an easy strategy to outperform a risky asset class

— High beta stocks tend to be small and more difficult to short limiting arbitrage

• Behavioural reasons— Some investors tend to think in terms of more or less risky asset classes and

may ignore the less volatile, seemingly boring end of a more risky asset class

— Blindly trusting CAPM investors expect high return = high risk and concentrateon the easier task of forecasting risk

• Lottery effect— Stocks with high volatility can deliver outsized returns and some investors are

(may be unwittingly) prepared to pay a premium for that

11

Page 12: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

2. Investment Process –A possible approach

Page 13: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

1313

Unconstrained Optimisation: Exit benchmark-orientation

§ Strict risk management

→ Limited volatility

→ Absolute position limits in terms of stock, sector, country and regional weights

→ Liquidity bounds

→ Constructing the portfolio with absolute risk aversion

§ Stronger focus on stock selection

→ Avoiding unattractive index heavy weights

→ High tracking error versus index

→ Ability to emphasise attractive stocks1

1 Based on Invesco GQE forecasts

Page 14: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

1414

Portfolio Characteristics

§ Diversified portfolio

— Maximum stock position1 2,5%

— Maximum industry weight1 25,0%

§ Selected from a universe of 800 (3300) European (Global) stocks

— Minimum requirements in terms of float and market cap

— Holdings limited to 50% of average daily volume1

§ Expected risk below market risk

— Portfolio beta below 1

§ Fully invested

— No strategic cash

— No short

1 at rebalancing

Page 15: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

15

Quantifying our insights: Stock Selection Model

ManagementAction

EarningsMomentum Relative ValuePrice Trend

Forecasted Return

• Capital Allocation• Earnings Accruals• Fundamental Health

Score• Liability Payback

Horizon• Capital Expenditures

• Estimate Revision• Earnings Momentum• Revisions Against

Trend

• Long-Term Strength• Risk-adjusted

Relative Strength• Business Cycle

Reversal• Short-Term Reversal• Volatility Jump

Concepts

Factors1

• Earnings Yield • Cash Flow Yield• Dividend Yield

For illustrative purposes only 1Not all factors are used in all regions

What are the expectationsrelative to fundamental measures?

Are earnings improving or deteriorating?

What does the marketmovement tell us?

What is management telling us?

Stock Selection Universe

Page 16: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

16

Engineering the Optimal Portfolio

Final Review

Stock RiskForecasts

Stock ReturnForecasts

Portfolio

Optimization through GPMS1

Transaction CostForecast

Portfolio Guidelines& Constraints

1Global Portfolio Management SystemFor illustrative purposes only

Page 17: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

1717

Summary

§ Less risk does not necessarily mean less return

§ Combining low volatility and stock selection has generated appealing returns

§ Attractive diversification from both index oriented as well as traditional fundamental portfolio management

Page 18: The Waterside Convention 2011 Invesco - Volatiliteit: een anomalie?

18

• This marketing document is exclusively for use by professional clients and financial advisors in Netherlands and is not for retail client use. Please do not redistribute. Data as at 31 December 2010, unless otherwise stated.

• For information on fund registrations, please refer to the appropriate internet site or your local Invesco office. This marketing document does not form part of any prospectus. Whilst great care has been taken to ensure that the information contained herein is accurate, no responsibility can be accepted for any errors, mistakes or omissions or for any action taken in reliance thereon. Opinions and forecasts are subject to change without notice. The value of investments and the income from them can go down as well as up (this may partly be the result of exchange rate fluctuations in investments which have an exposure to foreign currencies) and investors may not get back the amount invested. Past performance is not an indication of future performance provides no guarantee for the future and is not constant over time. The performance data shown does not take account of the commissions and costs incurred on the issue and redemption of units. Any reference to a ranking, a rating or an award provides no guarantee for future performance results and is not constant over time. Investors should read the fund simplified and full prospectuses for specific risk factors and further information. This document is not an invitation to subscribe for shares in the fund and is by way of information only. It is not intended to provide specific investment advice including, without limitation, investment, financial, legal, accounting or tax advice, or to make any recommendations about the suitability of the fund(s) for the circumstances of any particular investor. You should take appropriate advice as to any securities, taxation or other legislation affecting you personally prior to investment. Asset management services are provided by Invesco in accordance with appropriate local legislation and regulations. www.invescoeurope.com

• This document is issued in the Netherlands by Invesco Asset Management S.A. (Dutch Branch), J.C. Geesinkweg 999 1096 AZ Amsterdam