The Value Growth Agenda
Transcript of The Value Growth Agenda
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
1/14
Number 13
The Value Growth Agenda
Setting the agendaFinding the right drivers of value growth
With so many options, which initiatives really matter?
By Ted Moser and Hanna Moukanas
As growth opportunities have become more dynamic and transitory,
the traditional pillars of strategy have been rendered obsolete.
Senior managers need a short, coherent list of initiatives to mobilizethe organization, tell outside stakeholders where the company
is headed, and reach the next profit zone before it shifts again.
5 Assembling the components of business design
11 Thought questions
Mercer Management Journal
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
2/14
Mercer Management Journal Setting the agenda 1
Compaq
- 63%
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
1997 1999 2001
Xerox
- 85%
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
1997 1999 2001
British Telecom
- 66%
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
1997 1999 2001
MV declinefrom peak
MV declinefrom peak
Procter & Gamble
- 46%
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
1997 1999 2001
MV declinefrom peak
MV declinefrom peak
$
billions
Note: Data is for April 1997 through April 2001. Source: Mercer Value Growth Database
By Ted Moser and Hanna Moukanas
Exhibit 1 Market value collapse
Finding the right drivers of value growthWith so many options, which initiatives really matter?
Every firm needs an effective value growth agenda, but not all firms have one. How else toexplain the extraordinary number of great firms with strong brands, fine products, and greatpeople that have struggled in recent years: Compaq, British Telecom, Procter & Gamble, and
Xerox, to name just a few (Exhibit 1)?
A high-impact value growth agenda is more than the initiative du jour. Its a prioritized short
list of actions designed to enable a firm to meet or exceed its own value growth targets and
the expectations of investors. It separates the essential must dos from the longer list of
should dos. The agenda often combines a mix of significant operational improvements with
focused fundamental change. It should be tirelessly communicated to all members of a com-
panys value growth coalition: customers, employees, suppliers, and investors. And since the
companys chosen profit zone is a moving target, the agenda needs to evolve over time.
But a value growth agenda only succeeds when it focuses on the right growth levers, at the
right time, and in the right sequence. And the company must execute it effectively. Take
Compaq, for example. At its inception in 1982, Compaqs IBM killer value growth agenda was
perfect in focus, in sequence, on time, and flawlessly implemented. Compaq determined it
could produce the highest performing PCs with surprisingly low prices, thanks to strong engi-
Ted Moser and Hanna Moukanas are vice presidents of Mercer Management Consulting.
Moser is based in San Francisco and Moukanas is based in Paris.
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
3/14
2 Setting the agenda Mercer Management Journal
neering competence, a low-cost manufacturing culture, a dedicated PC focus, and (ultimately)
market share leadership. Compaq became an entrepreneurial star, breaking the business
worlds record for the fastest zero to $1 billion annual sales ramp-up in just five years.
Yet Compaqs value growth agenda didnt anticipate and evolve fast enough to capture the next
several profit shifts in the PC market. Value was migrating to made-to-order PCs (Dell), to serv-
ices-led computing solutions (IBM Global Services), and to enterprise computing (Sun, IBM).
Only after allowing competitors to gain value at its expense did Compaqs agenda changeand
then in all three directions at once. In 1998, within the space of ten months, Compaq rolled out
a variant of Dells distribution system, created a solutions sales force via the acquisition of DEC,
and started an enterprise server product line using DECs Alpha chip design. So much agenda
change in so little time starting so late created huge implementation challenges and failed to
drive a turnaround in value growth.
Todays most successful companies use a high-impact value growth agenda to keep pace with
or to stay one step ahead of Value Migration1, the process by which value growth opportunities
shift within and across sectors. Today, General Electrics agenda is defined as Globalization,
Services, Six-Sigma Quality, and e-Business. And its agenda has evolved over time. From thefamous Be #1 or #2 or get out market leader initiative in the early 1980s, through the Work-Out
program to enhance efficiency in the late 1980s, through the solutions and services efforts of the
1990s, GEs internal rate of change has kept pace with the market. Every GE manager and supply
partner knows these priorities and follows them. Investors, knowing and believing too, have
rewarded the company with exceptional value growth.
Value Migration changes the rules of the game
Just twenty years ago, most companies had less need for such a dynamic agenda. A company
was defined by what it produced, and everyone knew what it did. Nippon Steel, U.S. Steel, and
Usinor made steel. General Motors, Volkswagen, and Toyota made cars. BT, NTT, and AT&T
ran national telephone services.
Companies also competed in similar ways, typical-
ly relying on the same few levers to increase the
value of the firm. Winning strategies started with
a twin focus on product innovation to achieve dif-
ferentiation and cost reduction to maximize mar-
gins. Market share was the strongest underlying
value driver, as it led to scale economies in areas
such as R&D and branding and a low-cost positionthat preserved profit margins as an industry
matured and prices declined.
Managing the product portfolio for market share
and choosing new markets in line with internal
core competencies ensured sustained value
growth. A mostly silent partner in this approach
was the customer (Exhibit 2).
Market
sharestrategy
Product
portfoliomanagment
Productinnovation
Costreduction
Prof
itable
customerpurchases
Corecompetence
Exhibit 2 Traditional valuegrowth management
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
4/14
Mercer Management Journal Setting the agenda 3
An agenda centered on market share served business leaders well for decades, but it no longer
guarantees sustained value growth, for several reasons:
TSome scale positions have lost their uniqueness. Multiple competitors in global markets have
achieved adequate scale. Outsourcing providers have emerged to provide scale effects to
smaller competitors. Mass markets have given way to segmented ones, and product-based
value propositions to propositions based on solutions and customer economics (Exhibit 3).
TIndustry boundaries have blurred, creating new competitors who attack from the blind side. Being
the leader in telephony networks doesnt matter if customers want data networks. And for
many manufacturing applications, engineers consider the relative merits of metals, plas-
tics, and composites, suggesting a broader materials definition.
TCustomers have grown increasingly sophisticated, demanding, and diverse. The passive customer
has evolved into an active customer, seeking customized products and tailored solutions,
and wanting them promptly. With more options and more information on supplier econom-
ics, customers are armed and dangerous. Moreover, consolidation has made business cus-
tomers larger and more powerful. And the increasing heterogeneity of customers has creat-
ed huge incentives to build business designs precisely tailored to the priorities of economi-
cally attractive customer segments.
These changes have caused a dramatic increase in the rate and impact of Value Migration. With
the sources of competitive advantage having shifted from inside the enterprise to the marketplaceoutside, the task of the business leader has grown exponentially more difficult. Business success
is now determined by how well a company anticipates these shifts and by the speed with which it
mounts a winning response before the window of opportunity closes. Add to this more complex
environment an unprecedented level of pressure on managers to instill investor confidence in
their companys prospects, and the challenge of creating an effective value growth agenda
becomes fully evident.
0
10
20
30
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Revenue ($ billions)
Chemicals 2000
DuPont
Dow Chemical
Hercules
Sigma-Aldrich
IMC Global
Revenue ($ billions)
Aerospace 2000
0
5
10
15
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
BoeingLockheed Martin
United TechnologiesGeneralDynamics
Textron
Returnonsales(%)
Returnons
ales(%)
Source: Mercer Value Growth Database
Exhibit 3 High revenues and market share no longer guarantee high profit.
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
5/14
4 Setting the agenda Mercer Management Journal
Finding the leverage
Every companys value growth agenda can be developed and organized around five growth levers
(Exhibit 4). Which levers to pull and in which order naturally varies by situation. The levers include:
TBusiness design innovation. Some of the largest
value growth opportunities involve the creation
of entirely new business designs responding tothe emerging needs of key customer segments
(see sidebar, Assembling the components of
business design). These new business designs
may supplant, complement, or be only loosely
related to the core business. The traditional
concern with market share remains important,
but subordinate. What makes sense is to maxi-
mize the share of healthy business designs.
The business design lever is particularly potent
when the future value growth potential of acompanys core business has matured or when
an industry is undergoing some form of funda-
mental change.
TCustomer value growth. Significant opportunities can be tapped by optimizing a companys
relationships with customers. In response to the fragmentation of the mass market and
the explosion of customer alternatives, the traditional focus on product innovation has
become part of an overall customer value lifecycle. Companies frequently have too many
of the wrong customers and too few of the right ones. Fine-tuning value propositions
offer, brand, pricing, distribution, and the customer experiencecan often attract more of
the most lucrative customers and change the economics of the rest. That can result inhuge financial rewards. Keeping value propositions in synch with the changing priorities
of customers through a test-and-learn culture can sustain these results.
TOperational breakthrough. The traditional focus on cost reduction has become part of an
overall operational breakthrough that optimizes cost, quality, time, and assets in the con-
text of the firms chosen value proposition. With business design lifecycles now increas-
ingly measured in years rather than decades, getting the operational side right cant wait
without compromising the total return to investors. In addition, operations today can be a
huge differentiator, enabling customers and suppliers to link with the company in new
and powerful ways.
TPortfolio redesign. Significant value growth leverage can often be found through a recon-
ceptualization and redesign of a company's portfolio. Yet traditional portfolio approaches
are ill-suited to the modern business environment, as they focus on business units and
seek to optimize a company's assets based only on the single dimension of product mar-
ket share, using rear-view-mirror metrics.
Taking other dimensions into consideration can lead to enhanced insights and better deci-
sions. One such dimension is business design, which enables the clustering of business
units into a smaller number of underlying designs across which lessons can be shared. This
Businessdesign
innovation
Portfolioredesign
Customervalue growth
Operationalbreakthrough
Organizationaltransformation
Product innovation Cost reduction
Market share Product portfolio
Custom
er
prio
rities
ValueMigration
Sou
rceso
fvalu
e
Exhibit 4 New value growth approach
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
6/14
Assembling the components of business design
Mercer Management Journal Setting the agenda 5
dimension incorporates the various types of customer relationships and profit models that
a company has. A second dimension is economic neighborhood, a concept that acknowl-
edges that traditionally defined industries are often parts of larger, more porous economiclandscapes. Mapping business designs across economic neighborhoods creates a broader
field upon which to see opportunities, threats, and potential moves.
TOrganizational transformation. This is perhaps the most important lever of all, since the
organization is the mechanism that transforms strategy into value growth. Pull this lever
when a good strategy is being held back by the organizationdearth of a critical capabili-
ty, inconsistent incentive systems, inefficient processes, dysfunctional culture, or unclear
leadershipor pull it when the current business design must be completely reinvented
to capture the next wave of value growth.
(1) Customer selection defines the set of cus-
tomers the company chooses to serve, as well
as those it chooses not to serve. Like other ele-
ments of business design, customer selection
may shift over time, sometimes dramatically:IBM, for example, has emerged as a major sell-
er of basic technology to computer manufac-
turers, turning former rivals into a new cus-
tomer set.
Value propositions define the value that the
company creates for customers. This may
include benefits derived from products, servic-
es, information, and other sources. The more
valuableeven uniquethese benefits are,
the more reasons that customers have to buy
from one company and no other.
(2) The profit model defines how the company
gets rewarded for the value that it creates for
customers. Profits may come from product sales
or service charges, as well as a host of other
value-capture mechanisms such as financing
income and licensing fees.
(3) Scope refers to how the company defines its
activities and its product and service offerings.
The right scope lets a company focus on what it
does best while allowing others to handle activ-
ities they do better, since the company is likely
to realize less value from those activities. Dell
Computer focuses on marketing and assembling
PCs and managing a complex supply network,
leaving to other companies the work of physi-
cally producing computer components.
(4) Strategic control refers to the companys abil-ity to protect its profit streams from being erod-
ed by competitors (or even by powerful cus-
tomers). It answers the questions, Why should
a customer buy from me? Why must a cus-
tomer buy from me? It may take many forms,
from ownership of patents without which a
particular technology cant be built to control
over customer relationships that determine
how buying decisions are made.
(5) Finally, organizational architecture defines
the management structures, corporate culture,
and talent leverage mechanisms that the compa-
ny uses to execute its business design choices.c
Customer selectionand valueproposition
Value capture/profit model
Strategic control Scope
Organizationalarchitecture
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
7/14
6 Setting the agenda Mercer Management Journal
Other major sources of value can cut across all these levers. For instance, digital technologies
including the Internet can help companies address critical business issues by offering signifi-
cant productivity improvements as well as making possible entirely new business designs and
value propositions.
Playing by the new rules
Rarely are all five levers pulled simultaneously. Typically, at any given time, one or two levers
predominate in a firms agenda, but over time, its agenda will evolve to focus on other levers
in response to changing market conditions. In any company, there are more laudable initia-
tives than available time; thus, prioritization and sequencing are the core arts of establishing
a value growth agenda.
Although value growth agendas require intensive efforts, they are well worth it.
Two examples should help make this clearer.
Wal-Marts value growth agenda
Wal-Mart is one of the greatest value growth stories of all time. Starting in 1969 as a local
supermarket in Arkansas, the company has created over $200 billion in value for shareholders.
Between 1989 and 1998 alone, it represented nearly a quarter of the $726 billion in sharehold-
er value created in the retail industry.
There are four major phases in the evolution of Wal-Marts value growth agenda:
TCapturing markets for one. Sam Waltons initial idea was as bold as it was simple. He
wanted to be the discount retailer for all of Americas small-to-medium-sized towns,
which can only support a single superstore. These markets for one conferred a natural
monopoly on the first retailer to the market. Walton aggressively built out a nationwidechain to ensure that Wal-Mart would be there first. A brilliant business design innova-
tion, these stores remain a bedrock of the firms financial performance to this day.
TStreamlining operations through real-time logistics and decision management. For much of the
1980s and 1990s, Wal-Mart made significant technology investments in electronic data
interchange, the automation of distribution centers, and the implementation of satellite
systems to facilitate ordering, shipping, logistics, and communications. But what really
mattered was how fast Wal-Mart acted on that data. In the store, management focused
on capturing point-of-sale information and mining this data for insights. In addition,
they worked to transform their logistics relationships with suppliers. These initiatives
have helped Wal-Mart achieve an operational breakthroughextraordinary growth with
increasing inventory turns and a competitively superior return on assets (Exhibit 5).
TExtending into new formats and product lines. By the mid-1980s, it became clear to Wal-Mart
that it had a huge value gap. Its stock valuation was not justified by the profit growth
potential of its core store formats, which was tapping out as U.S. markets approached
saturation. So the mid-1980s through the 1990s became a time of exceptional business
design innovation and experimentation for Wal-Mart. Its Sams Club format focused on
new customer segments such as small business owners and budget-oriented con-
sumers by delivering a focused assortment of bulk items in a warehouse club format.
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
8/14
Mercer Management Journal Setting the agenda 7
Source: Mercer Value Growth Database
Inventory levels as % of sales
0
2
4
6
8%
1990 '92 '94 '96 '98 '00-5
0
5
10
15
20%
1990 '92 '94 '96 '98 '00
Inventory turnover Return on assetsCAGR
1990-2000
Wal-MartK Mart 2.6%
Target
Target -1.0%
K Mart
0
5
10
15
20
25%
1990 '92 '94 '96 '98 '00
Wal-Mart -4.5%
Target -1.6%
K Mart -2.1%
CAGR1990-2000 Wal-Mart 3.8%
Exhibit 5 By streamlining operations, Wal-Mart improved inventory turns and ROA.
Its Wal-Mart Supercenters focused on new purchase occasions such as grocery shopping,buying prescription drugs, and photo finishing. Management focused as well on interna-
tional expansion of culturally tailored versions of its successful U.S. business designs.
While the jury is still out on its international moves, Wal-Marts new formats effort has been a
huge success. In 1990, new formats represented less than 10 percent of Wal-Marts stores; by the
end of 2000, they represented over 50 percent.
TOrganizing for a consistent customer experience. In the early 1990s, Wal-Mart recognized that
its nearly one million workers represented both a huge risk and a huge opportunity. The
question was how to maintain a consistent corporate culture and customer experience in
a low-wage industry with relatively unskilled labor and high turnover rates. The companyis working to achieve this organizational transformation in a number of ways, including:
- establishing rules of customer engagement such as the friendly greeter at every entrance
and the ten-foot rule that ensures that an associate acknowledges the presence of any
customer who comes within a ten-foot radius
- offering both incentive compensation to reward initiative and a healthy benefits package
to strengthen the basic employment relationship
- sending senior management into the field every week to talk with store managers,
associates, and customers
Through such procedures, Wal-Mart has earned the cooperation of its associates and
has engaged their emotional energy.
Sustaining this exceptional performance (Exhibit 6) will be a challenge. Enhancing the interna-
tional business and leveraging the Internet should both figure prominently in Wal-Marts next
agenda.The company is already at work on a number of Internet initiatives, both customer-facing
(Walmart.com) and supplier-facing. As Wal-Marts e-commerce moves have disappointed to date,
the firm may have to make a big e-commerce acquisition as part of defining the next agenda.
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
9/14
8 Setting the agenda Mercer Management Journal
$
billions
CAGR(1981-2001)1. 1980s-mid-1990s
Streamline logistics, distribution, and supplier network
2. Mid-1980s-mid-1990sPioneer new formats and product lines
3. 1990sDeliver a consistent customer experience
Businessdesign
innovationPortfolioredesign
Customervalue growth
Operationalbreakthrough
Organizationaltransformation
1
2
3
0
50
100
150
200
250
1981 1983 1985 1987 1989 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999
Wal-Mart 30%
Target 18%
Kmart 3%
2001
Note: Q1 1981- Q1 2001
Source: Mercer Value Growth Database
Exhibit 6 Wal-Marts evolving agenda
LVMHs value growth agenda
LVMH, the leading global purveyor of luxury goods, has created more than $25 billion in sharehold-
er value in the past ten years by artfully initiating three important shifts in its value growth
agenda (Exhibit 7):
TIndustrializing the luxury branded experience. LVMH recognized that the value growth potential
of the classic boutique business model was inherently limited. Starting in the early 1990s
under the leadership of Bernard Arnault, LVMH invested heavily in advertising and in open-ing more and larger stores across which to amortize its brand investments. From the begin-
ning, the strategy was based on moving beyond the traditional carriage trade to capture
more aspirational customers. That move took high-end brands to what approached a mass
market, without diluting their cachet. The focus on brand has continued as the company
has expanded. Some brands were moved up-market (such as Veuve Clicquot), others
extended (Diors move into high-end fragrances), and yet others energized with new talent
(Givenchys hiring of designer Alexander McQueen in 1996).
TCornerstoning to capture a greater share of wallet. Wanting to capture a greater share of
the target customers luxury goods spending, starting in the mid-1990s, the company
embarked on a major expansion along three dimensions. First, it reinforced the core port-
folio of brands in fashion, leather goods, fragrances, cosmetics, wine, and spirits with key
acquisitions (Marc Jacobs) and alliances (Prada). Second, it moved into multi-brand retail
(Duty Free Shops and the fragrance and cosmetics superstore Sephora). And third, it
expanded into adjacent economic neighborhoods (watches and jewelry). Through these
portfolio redesign moves, LVMH has captured the leading position in terms of total operat-
ing profit in three of its sectors (leather goods, specialty retailing, and wines and spirits)
and the number three position in two others.
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
10/14
Mercer Management Journal Setting the agenda 9
CAGR(1990-2000)
$
billions
1. 1990sIndustrialize the luxury branded experience
2. Mid-1990sCornerstone into adjacent economicneighborhoods
3. 1997Integrate to control distributionchannels
Businessdesign
innovationPortfolioredesign
Customervalue growth
Operationalbreakthrough
Organizationaltransformation
1, 3
1
2
*Gucci CAGR is 1996-2000; Hermes CAGR is 1994-2000.
Source: Mercer Value Growth Database
0
10
20
30
40
50
1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000
LVMH 13%
Seagram 10%
Gucci 23%*
Hermes 22%*
Brown-Forman 7%
2001
Exhibit 7 LVMHs evolving agenda
TIntegrating to control distribution channels. Starting in 1997, LVMH embarked on another
business design innovation: to solidify its brand positions by increasing both its num-
ber of outlets and its level of control over brand imaging at retail. Beginning with the
rapid expansion of its flagship boutique stores (Louis Vuitton, Celine, and Loewe),
and continuing with its acquisition of Duty Free Stores to provide access to both Asian
markets and a new travel-related purchase occasion, the company has moved aggres-
sively to be where its high-end customers are. Recent moves into mass retailing, such
as its acquisition and expansion of Sephora, and into the Internet space througheluxury.com, provide LVMH with retail control over a significant portion of its product
sales and ensure a great customer experience. Contrast these moves with several other
fashion houses that chose to mass license their brands, only to see the value of those
brands diluted a short time later.
Setting and communicating the agenda
Wal-Mart and LVMH could have made other choices. Each company was and remains confronted
with a huge spectrum of strategic options. But each chose to focus the limited financial, physical,
and emotional energies of their organizations on a few key initiatives that matteredtransforming
a small town supermarket into a chain of superstores, then a retail occasion phenomenon, and aluxury retailer into a portfolio of powerful brands. And they renewed this agenda as new opportu-
nities and threats arose, thereby delivering sustained and superior economic performance.
Setting the right course is hard. Montgomery Ward and Kmart had access to the same data and
made vastly different and less effective choices in discount retail. And in the fashion space, The
Limited could have taken a similar approach to that of LVMH for The Limiteds own mid-market
customer, but didnt.
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
11/14
10 Setting the agenda Mercer Management Journal
While setting and renewing a value growth agenda is not easy, the benefits clearly justify
investing time in its development. There are four key steps in establishing an agenda:
T Identify and assess the impact of Value Migration patterns in economic neighborhoods served.
In order to develop an accurate assessment of the value growth potential of an enter-
prise, its crucial to have a clear perspective on where tomorrows profit zones will
emerge in all economic neighborhoods served or potentially served. An evaluation of
which Value Migration patterns3 are likely to play out is often the best way to create a
shared vision of future competitive dynamics, threats, and opportunities for the business
designs the company currently operates.
TEvaluate the value growth potential of current initiatives. Its critical to assess the value
growth potential of all current initiatives in light of the management teams shared
insights into future sources of value. Inevitably, some initiatives will see their potential
soar, while others plummet. Comparing the net value growth potential of all initiatives
with the enterprises stated value growth goals will identify the value gap, if any, that
the organization must address.
TDevelop new growth hypotheses. Whether or not a value gap exists, management should
hypothesize which new movesfrom redesigning the portfolio to creating an innovative
business design, achieving operational breakthrough, or building a better customer value
growth systemwill move the company from strategic disadvantage to strategic advan-
tage. Then they should estimate the value growth potential of each significant hypothesis.
T Define the value growth agenda. Armed with a menu of potential moves and their potential
value impact, the agenda-setting process begins. What combination of initiatives
whether focused on reinvention or operational improvementin what sequence over
what timeframe maximizes the firms value growth within the constraints of executive
attention and capital availability?
Once the agenda has been set, the truly hard job begins. Responsibilities and deadlines must be
established. The value growth agenda must be led from the top. And it must be communicated
early and often to employees, investors, customers, and suppliers. In time, it will become the DNA
of the company and direct a creative organization toward great results. Suppliers and customers
who buy into the agenda will respond more positively and help the firm succeed. Investors who
understand it will support the share price, maintain lines of credit, and resist demands for hasty,
shortsighted moves in an economic downturn or after a bad quarter.
The value growth agenda must remain attuned to the marketplace and thus needs to be renewed
periodically. Changing market conditionswhether macroeconomic, such as an economic downturn;technological, such as the emergence of the Internet; customer-oriented, such as the emergence of
a new segment; or competitive, such as the identification of a new competitor on the edge of the
radar screenwill call for a review, as will the initial signs of Value Migration that threaten the
current business design.
Creating value is easier in good economic times as a rising tide lifts all boats. But with slowing
macroeconomic growth, a value growth agenda based on real strategic insight, on time, in the
right sequence, and flawlessly executed will be a competitive necessity. Times like this represent
a great opportunity. While rivals struggle to regroup, great companies mobilize, disrupt the
rhythm of competition, and seize control of their markets.c
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
12/14
Mercer Management Journal Setting the agenda 11
As you consider building your own Value Growth Agenda,
ask yourself the following questions:
Competitive position
T Is our market value
growing as fast as it
could?
T Do investors value
our company fairly?
T Are we as profitable
as our toughest
competitors?
T Are we meeting our
revenue and earn-
ings growth targets?
T Have we created
barriers to entry for
new entrants in our
industry?
T Can we pinpoint
why customers
choose us overour competitors?
Patterns and trends
T Do we regularly
track changing
customer
and technology
trends, emerging
patterns, or new
regulations in the
industry?
T How is our business
threatened by these
changes?
T How are new
entrants redefining
the traditional rules
of success in our
industry?
T Is our competitive
radar screen
tracking new,
digitally enabledplayers?
T How are the tradi-
tional boundaries
of our industry
blurring?
Growth strategy
development
T Are our strategic
goals and financial
targets ambitious
enough?
T Do senior managers
dedicate time to
think about and
develop new growth
opportunities?
T
Do we have a clearset of initiatives to
improve our current
businesses?
T Do we have an
attractive set of
growth ideas to
develop future
businesses?
T Is our growthstrategy driven
by customer priori-
ties rather than
by internal core
competencies?
T Do we know which
growth initiatives
will create value
beyond what ana-
lysts have already
factored into our
market value?
T Do we have realistic
and action-oriented
plans to realize
these growth initia-
tives?
Growth strategy
communication
T Do employees and
managers have a
clear understanding
of our growth
strategy?
T Are they excited
and motivated by
that strategy?
T Are we clearly
communicatingthe strategy to
investors?
T Are investors
confident in our
ability to grow?
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
13/14
Mercer Management Journal
Editorial Board
James W. Down
Charles Hoban
Nancy Lotane
Joseph Martha
David J. Morrison
Ted Moser
Hanna Moukanas
Patrick A. Pollino
Phyllis Rothschild
Adrian J. Slywotzky
Mercer Management Journal is published by Mercer Management Consulting for its clients and friends.
The contents are copyright 2001 and 2002 by Mercer Management Consulting.
Value Migration is a proprietary trademark of Mercer Management Consulting that has
been registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. NexperimentTM is a trademark;
Strategic Choice Analysis is a registered trademark; Value Net Design SM is a service mark;
and ChoiceboardSM is a service mark; all owned by Mercer Management Consulting.
Cover illustration by Patrick Corrigan.
All rights reserved. Excerpts can be reprinted with attribution to Mercer Management Consulting.
Articles can be found on our Web site: www.mercermc.com.
For information on reprinting entire articles and all other correspondence, please contact the editor:
John Campbell
Mercer Management Consulting
33 Hayden Avenue
Lexington, Massachusetts 02421
781-674-3323
Director of Publications
John Campbell
Art Director
Michael Tveskov
Digital Edition Team
Ellen M. Zanino
Christopher Hogan
Jamie Klickstein
-
8/9/2019 The Value Growth Agenda
14/14
About Mercer Management Consulting
As one of the worlds premier corporate strategy firms, Mercer Management Consulting
helps leading enterprises achieve sustained shareholder value growth through the development
and implementation of innovative business designs. Mercers proprietary business design tech-
niques, combined with its specialized industry knowledge and global reach, enable companies
to anticipate changes in customer priorities and the competitive environment, and then design
their businesses to seize opportunities created by those changes. The firm serves clients from22 offices in the Americas, Europe, and Asia.
Beijing
Suite 1825B, Tower 2,
Bright China Chang An Building
7 Jianguomennei Avenue
Beijing 100005
86/ 10 6510 1758
86/ 10 6510 1759 fax
Boston
33 Hayden AvenueLexington, Massachusetts 02421
781 861 7580
781 862 3935 fax
Buenos Aires
Florida 234, piso 4
1334 Buenos Aires
54/ 11 4394 6488
54/ 11 4326 7445 fax
Chicago
10 South Wacker Drive
13th Floor
Chicago, Illinois 60606
312 902 7980
312 902 7989 fax
Cleveland
One Cleveland Center
1375 East Ninth Street, Suite 2500
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
216 830 8100
216 830 8101 fax
Dallas
3500 Texas Commerce Tower
2200 Ross Avenue
Dallas, Texas 75201
214 758 1880214 758 1881 fax
Frankfurt
Friedrichstr. 2-6
D-60323 Frankfurt
49/ 69 17 00 83 0
49/ 69 17 00 83 33 fax
Hong Kong
NatWest Tower, 32nd Floor
Times Square
One Matheson Street
Causeway Bay
Hong Kong
852/ 2506 0767
852/ 2506 4478 fax
Houston1136 North Kirkwood
Houston, Texas 77043
281 493 6400
281 754 4328 fax
Lisbon
Av. Praia da Vitria, 71-5.C
(Edifcio Monumental)
1050 Lisboa
351/ 21 311 38 70
351/ 21 311 38 71 fax
London
1 Grosvenor Place
London SW1X 7HJ
44/ 20 7235 5444
44/ 20 7245 6933 fax
Madrid
Paseo de la Castellana, 13-2 piso
28046 Madrid
34/ 91 531 79 00
34/ 91 531 79 09 fax
Mexico City
Paseo de Tamarindos 400-B
Piso 10, Bosques de las Lomas
05120 D.F.
52/ 55-5081 900052/ 55-5258 0186 fax
Montral
600, boul. de Maisonneuve Ouest
14e tage
Montral, Qubec H3A 3J2
1/ 514 499 0461
1/ 514 499 0475 fax
Munich
Stefan-George-Ring 2
81929 Mnchen
49/ 89 939 49 0
49/ 89 930 38 49 fax
New York
1166 Avenue of the Americas
New York, New York 10036
212 345 8000
212 345 8075 fax
Paris
28, avenue Victor Hugo
75116 Paris
33/ 1 45 02 30 0033/ 1 45 02 30 01 fax
Pittsburgh
One PPG Place, 27th Floor
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15222
412 355 8840
412 355 8848 fax
San Francisco
Three Embarcadero Center
Suite 1670
San Francisco, California 94111
415 743 7800
415 743 7950 fax
Seoul
5th Floor
Woori Investment Bank Bldg.
826-20, Yeosam-dong,
Kangnam-ku
Seoul, 135-935
82/ 2 3466 3100
82/ 2 3466 3105 fax
Toronto
BCE Place
161 Bay Street, P.O. Box 501
Toronto, Ontario M5J 2S5
416 868 2200416 868 2208 fax
Zurich
Tessinerplatz 5
CH-8027 Zurich
41/ 1 208 77 77
41/ 1 208 70 00 fax
Internet
www.mercermc.com
www.howdigitalisyourbusiness.com