The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

33
The Top Five Things You Need to Know to Conduct Better eDiscovery (and avoid the Money Pit) March 29, 2016

Transcript of The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Page 1: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

The Top Five Things You Need to Know

to Conduct Better eDiscovery(and avoid the Money Pit)

March 29, 2016

Page 2: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Kelly TwiggerPrincipal of ESI Attorneys — Advises clients on all aspects of preparing for and conducting eDiscovery and IGFluent in legal, business and IT Co-author of Electronic Discovery and Records and Information Management Guide (updated annually), published by West Creator of eDiscovery Assistant™, virtual online eDiscovery Consultant for legal professionalsRabid Kentucky basketball and Packers football fan

Page 3: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Matthew StippichPresident, Professional Services, Digital Intelligence, Milwaukee, WI.Co-author of Electronic Discovery and Records and Information Management Guide (updated annually), published by WestUses the knowledge of digital forensics to provide creative ways to attack the challenges of litigation and eDiscovery Alderman, WauwatosaMulti-award winning chili cook!

Page 4: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Sarai GuerraSenior Vice-President, Professional Consulting Services at Ipro; previously Manager of Practice Support Operations, Latham & Watkins Works closely with law firms, corporations, service providers and government agencies to improve internal eDiscovery processes Strong technical background with 12 years in eDiscovery industryScuba diving country music fan living in California

Page 5: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

A party has a duty to preserve information that may be responsive when it knows about or reasonably

anticipates litigation.

— Zubulake v. Warburg, 220 F.R.D. 212 (S.D.N.Y.

2003)

Page 6: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

ESI Challenges

Volume of data (in GB)

Cost

Volume is directly tied to cost196.3 billion emails sent daily$1.4 million to handle 1 TB data

Page 7: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Poll Question:What types of matters are

you handling?

Page 8: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Answers A. General commercial matters/IP

B. Employment matters C. Regulatory investigationsD. Products Liability or Personal

Injury E. Divorce or family matters F. Other

Page 9: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

#1Recognize that ESI

can exist in any size case

Page 10: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

What ESI is Out There? Start thinking specifically about ESI

that may exist and locationsTake an investigative approach — consider Data Equality; organize data by type Technology is only one piece of the puzzle — applying legal thought is key

Page 11: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Sources of ESI

Word docs

agendaspowerpoints

photographsspreadsheets

Databases VideoAudio files

Text messages

Annotations in board portal

GPS data

email

social media

instant messages

Page 12: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

#2Be Strategic About

ESI

Page 13: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Apply Litigation Strategy to Discovery

Identify the MONEY documents Avoid the broad, all-encompassing discovery requests Communicate internally and with the other side

Page 14: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

#3Case Knowledge for ALL team members

is critical

Page 15: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Poll Question:What is your role within

the eDiscovery process at your organization?

Page 16: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Answers

A. AttorneyB. Paralegal C. Litigation Support Professional D. Service Provider or Consultant

Page 17: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Team — version 1

Partners Associates Paralegal Litigation

Support

Page 18: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Team — version 2

Lawyers Outside Providers

Page 19: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Team — version 3

Lawyers Litigation Support

Outside Providers

Page 20: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Define Team Roles Lawyers

Paralegals

Litigation Support

Outside Providers

case analysis, discovery strategy, custodian

identification, knows factsimplements discovery plan, needs to know facts; may

handle data handles data, needs to know what you are looking for and why; value

of casecollects/handles data, needs to

know what you are looking for and why; value of case and budget

Page 21: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Communicate with the Team

Lawyers

Paralegals

Litigation Support

Outside Providers

Scheduling OrderClient goalsPR ConsiderationsDate Range Key CustodiansTiming of MTD or SJ, etc.

Page 22: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

#4Understand

eDiscovery Cost Structure

Page 23: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Poll Question:What is the average value

of the matters you are handling?

Page 24: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Answers

A. >10KB. Between $10K-$50KC. Between $50-100KD. $100K to $1 million E. More than $1 million regularly

Page 25: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Know What Costs You Can Minimize and Eliminate

Be thoughtful about preservation scopeECA can reduce cost significantlyUtilize remote collection/targeted collectionHave eDiscovery professionals provide input into what is collected

Page 26: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

#5Identify Tools for

Use with Any Size Matter

Page 27: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Factors in Tool Selection How many cases/volume of data

annually? Internal resources vs. external — do you need PM/database mgmt? Identify client needs that you will support Budget — outright cost/ROI NO one size fits all

Page 28: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Collection FTK ImagerHarvestereCapture

Review Eclipse SEEverlaw Adobe NextpointLogikcull

ECA Proof FinderIntellaEDT

Cost-Effective Tools

***Understand the limitations of each tool***

Page 29: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Thank You to our Sponsor!

Page 30: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Participants can receive a 10% discount on Eclipse SE from

Ipro (regularly $750/license)

Visit https://my.iprotech.com/ESI_Promo.html

and enter code ESI10

Page 31: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Participants will receive a one month free trial to

eDiscovery Assistant™ — Your Virtual eDiscovery

Consultant

Page 32: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Speaker Contact InfoKelly Twigger

[email protected] @kellytwiggerwww.esiattorneys.com

Matt [email protected]

www.digitalintelligence.com

Sarai [email protected]

www.iprotech.com

Page 33: The Top Five Things You Need to Conduct Better eDiscovery

Thank You!