The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an...

32
The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an elementary introduction Uzy Smilansky Department of Physics of Complex Systems, The Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, IL School of Mathematics Cardiff University, Cardiff, Wales, UK Abstract These lectures are intended to introduce the Semi Classical Approximation and some of its intricacies in a consistent and transparent way. The main topics to be covered are The semi classical approximation for the quantum evolution operator. Uniform approximations Semi-classical spectral theory: The trace formula and some of its applications. (For systems in 1-d) It is hoped that the ideas and tools presented here will provide a solid jumping-board for further studies and applications. “Putting quantum flesh on classical bones” (W.H. Miller)

Transcript of The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an...

Page 1: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestriansan elementary introduction

Uzy Smilansky

Department of Physics of Complex Systems, The Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, ILSchool of Mathematics Cardiff University, Cardiff, Wales, UK

Abstract These lectures are intended to introduce the Semi ClassicalApproximation and some of its intricacies in a consistent andtransparent way. The main topics to be covered are • The semi classical approximation for the quantum evolution operator.• Uniform approximations• Semi-classical spectral theory: • The trace formula and some of its applications. (For systems in 1-d)

It is hoped that the ideas and tools presented here will provide asolid jumping-board for further studies and applications .

“Putting quantum flesh on classical bones”

(W.H. Miller)

Page 2: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

a) The buckyball carbon-70;b) The pancake-shaped biomolecule tetraphenylporphyrin (TPP) C44 H30 N4 ; c) The fluorinated fullerene C60 F48 . (atomic mass of 1632 units )

Probing the limits of the quantum worldM. Arndt, K. Hornberger, and A. Zeilinger , Physics World (March 2005) 35-40

Motivation (For Physicists) :

A two slits experiment with heavy moleculesThe correspondence principle in action!

Page 3: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

Motivation (For Mathematicians)

1. Singular perturbation theory:

The Schroedinger equation:

¹h ! 0?

2. Oscillatory integralsRdx ei f (x )=¹h

Page 4: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

Books Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb:Quantum Mechanics and Path Integrals(McGraw-Hill, New York, 1965).L. S. Schulman: Techniques and Applications of Path Integration, (Wiley -Interscience Monographs and Texts in Physics and Astronomy, NY, 1981) David J. Tannor: Introduction to Quantum Mechanics –A time dependent perspective.(University Science Books, 2007)

/www.weizmann.ac.il/chemphys/tannor/Bookhttp://

Bibliography

ArticlesToo many to be listed.These lectures are based on my papers with S. Levit, K. Moehring and David Brink.To download: http://www.weizmann.ac.il/complex/uzy/publications.html # 26,27,29,30,38,39,41,47

Page 5: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

Preliminaries: Classical vs Quantum evolution

Page 6: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 7: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

Feynman Path Integral representation The Democracy of Paths:

t’’

q’

t’

q’’

q(t)

Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibbs, Quantum Mechanics and Path Integrals(McGraw-Hill, New York, 1965).

Page 8: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

± =TN

Page 9: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 10: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

Back to the propagator and the path integral

Page 11: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

Note: The boundary conditions do not determine a classical path uniquely! (examples below) However, there is no conflict with the uncertainty principle: the path is notprescribed by the simultaneous values of the position and the momentum.

Page 12: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

V(q)

qq’ q’’

Tmax

Example: Several trajectories which satisfy the same boundary conditions.

Tmax : If t”-t’>Tmax direct transition becomes classically forbidden

Page 13: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 14: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

Now that we have identified the classical trajectory (trajectories) as the saddle points we should compute the pre-exponential factor in the SPA for the path-integral. An elegant way to do this is offered if the path integral is defined in a different way.

The path expansion representation of the path integral

Page 15: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 16: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 17: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 18: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 19: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 20: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 21: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 22: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 23: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

Classical bones: dynamics (trajectory), action, stability Quantum flesh : transition amplitude, interference, the quantum scale: ~

Page 24: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 25: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

q(t’’; p’)

p’

q’’

dp=2¼h / dq’’

p’i p’2

Classical transition probability

dq’’

Page 26: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 27: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 28: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

t

caustics

Classically forbidden domain

Page 29: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and
Page 30: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

End of section I

Page 31: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and

Appendix

Page 32: The Semi-classical Approximation for Pedestrians an ...mopnet.cf.ac.uk/marco/semi-classical-ilectures_1-2.pdf · Books . Richard P. Feynman and Albert R. Hibb: Quantum Mechanics and