The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English...
Transcript of The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English...
![Page 1: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb
Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages
and satisfy all of the specification in the syllabus to receive credit. On an additional seventh page
students are required to list Works Cited. The purpose of the assignment is to familiarize
students with the conventions and challenges involved in writing a Research Project. These
involve critical thinking, presenting thesis-centered arguments, and citing sources in accordance
with the MLA (Modern Language Association).
The Research Project must focus on one to three primary texts. Primary texts are those
belonging to one of the four literary genres: short stories, plays, poems, or novels. Primary
texts for the Project cannot be a biography, a personal narrative, a magazine or a newspaper
article. The work must also be published. Any unpublished work is not acceptable for this
assignment. Students have the option to select a text of their own choosing as long as it meets
with these specifications but are encouraged to use one of the three assignments done prior to the
Project during the semester as a basis for the final paper. A further requirement for the Research
Project is the use of two to four secondary sources. Secondary sources are: biographies,
literary criticism, and historical works. These must be published. Do not cite online sources
such as Wikipedia or Spark Notes on your Works Cited page. If you do use Wikipedia, cite the
published sources listed at the end of the document.
Regarding the structure of the Research Project, students are required to have an introduction and
a conclusion. All arguments must be thesis-centered, meaning that they will be evaluated on the
basis of how well they support the central idea and refute opposing viewpoints.
I have provided a sample outline on page 3 and a sample paper on page 12 of this handout.
(April 2020 Edition)
![Page 2: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
The Research Project:
Write 6 double-space pages about the life and work
of Guy de Maupassant.
A paper outline is on page 3 of this handout.
A sample essay is available on page 12 of this handout.
![Page 3: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Part 1 – Introduction About the Author:
Write a first draft of your introduction. You can and show it to me prior to handing it in.
1. Copy and paste five or more of the biographical passages on pages 4-6 of this handout into a
Word document. If you use other sources, they must be reliable. This means that they must
be published and NOT Internet sources.
2. String these passages together with transitional sentences. You can use my sample paper to
guide you. The sample paper is on page 12 of this handout.
3. The last sentence of your introduction should transition smoothly into the body of your
paper. Since you can recycle your short story paper into your research paper, this transitional
sentence should connect with whatever portion of the short story paper you use. For
example, if your short story essay begins with a discussion of reality, the last sentence of our
research paper introduction should say something about Maupassant’s view of that question.
Example: Just as Maupassant was disillusioned so were some of his characters. The goal of
this paper is to consider the similarities between the author and the people he wrote about.
Part 2 – Maupassant’s Writing:
Write an interpretation of one or several of Maupassant’s stories.
You can recycle the body of your first essay in this section. This means that you can copy and
paste your first short story essay into your research paper. You can also expand upon this by
discussing other stories that relate to your main idea.
Part 3 - Conclusion:
Write what Maupassant and the characters in his story have in common.
Also consider what we all have in common with Maupassant and his characters.
How are his concerns and his writing universal? One underlying theme of Maupassant’s life and
work is disillusionment. We can all relate to this since we have all faced disappointments of all
kinds.
Part 4 – Works Cited: Any academic paper must cite its sources. In the MLA format this is done on the last page of the
essay. The works must be cited on a separate page. To write your works cited page, copy and
paste the sources you have selected from the Book List on page 8 of this handout and/or
whatever other sources you choose to include. Do NOT include the library call numbers I have
provided on the c on your Works Cited Page.
![Page 4: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
Secondary Sources for the Research Project:
Your grade for the research project will depend in
part on whether or not you use secondary published
sources.
Secondary sources can be biography, literary criticism, or
historical works.
For this assignment biographical texts are required.
WARNING:
Students are NOT permitted use any online secondary sources for the Research Project.
Research Projects citing online sources will receive a zero credit. This means that any secondary
sources including the designations http, .com, .org, etc. are unacceptable. E-texts ARE
acceptable provided a publisher is designated.
The citations below are provided to help students avoid the risks of not receiving credit for
failing to following citation protocols for the research project. You can copy and paste the
following quotes into your paper and works cited page.
![Page 5: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Biographical Texts for The 201 Research Project
Loneliness, Isolation, Disillusionment, and Cynicism:
Guy de Maupassant – A Day in the Country and Other Stories. Translated with an Introduction
and Notes by David Coward. Oxford University Press. 1990.
1. “All the things which commonly pass for the charm of life – love, friendship, happiness – are
so many illusions which nature allows us to compensate for the iron grip in which we are
held” (Coward xvi).
Wallace, Albert H. Guy de Maupassant. Twayne Publishers. New York. Copyright 1973.
2. Concerning Maupassant Wallace writes,
“His inclination toward morbidity would increase alarmingly by the odors of his medications.
The more severe his disease, the more necessary isolation became to him and paradoxically,
the more extensive were his fears of being alone. He tormented himself with loneliness,
however, perhaps in a mood of self-flagellation for not having followed the teachings of his
“father” during his younger days” (Wallace 22).
3. “Maupassant’s self-imposed solitude led to fear and provided him with an uncanny insight
into the terror that loneliness can multiply even in the most sound of his race. This
comprehension of terror is what gives his fantastic stories their extraordinary credible
quality. The stories Lui?, Le Horla, and Qui Sait? are among his most widely read and
appreciated. The autobiographic character of these stories leaves us with a fairly extensive
image of what Maupassant suffered, and hence they will be studied in detail in the
appropriate place” (Wallace 22).
4. “I fear the arriving winter. I feel alone, and my long, solitary evenings are sometimes terrible.
Often when I’m alone seated at my desk with my lamp burning sadly before me, I experience
such complete moments of distress that I no longer know where to turn”
(Wallace 45).
5. Wallace explains that “loneliness was a major factor in the development of Maupassant’s
affliction. Living too much to himself, he formed certain ideas whose very inalterability was
their poison” (Wallace 105).
6. Wallace explains that in Maupassant’s story Miss Harriot “solitude leads to suicide,” that “it
was loneliness that caused the heroine to cast herself into a well” (Wallace 106). Wallace
goes on to quote Maupassant who writes, “We are the eternal playthings of ever renewing,
stupid and charming illusions” (Wallace 231).
![Page 6: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
7. According to Wallace “disillusionment with life is so prominent a factor in his work and in
his mental difficulties” (Wallace 114).
8. Michael G. Lerner. Maupassant. George Braziller New York.
9. In May, 1880, following the death of Gustave Flaubert, Maupassant’s close friend and mentor,
he wrote a letter to Emile Zola, another one of his friends and fellow writers.
“The farther the death of poor Flaubert recedes in time, the more his memory haunts me and the
more my heart is grieved and my mind is at a loss…. I feel at this moment in an excruciating
way the futility of living, the uselessness of all one’s efforts, the monstrous monotony of
everyone and everything and that moral and spiritual isolation in which we all live but from
which I suffered less when I could chat with him; for he had like no one else that understanding
of philosophical thought which opened up new horizons on everything and kept one’s mind at a
sublime level from where one could look down on the whole of mankind and realize the
unending wretchedness of everything…Flaubert’s death thus aroused Maupassant’s latent
pessimism as well as leaving him both more lonely and more insecure than before”
(Lerner142-143).
Edward Daniel Sullivan. Maupassant the Short Stories. Barron’s Educational Series Inc.
Great Neck, New York.
Of Maupassant, Sullivan writes:
10. “It is clear from the stories we have studies the one great premise which underlies his whole
art is his belief in the utter disproportion between appearance and reality – everywhere
and in all forms. His stories are written out of a need to correct that disproportion, if only
fragmentarily, to lift the mask of appearance to expose hypocrisy, to provide an
unobstructed view of a piece of the world as it is, not as it is purported to be. Such a view of
life, when held by an indignant optimist, generally results in high-minded attempts at reform.
For Maupassant the result is sadness, and sometimes even fear; the reality that lies behind
appearance is no more comforting – probably even less so – than the outer falsity itself”
(Sullivan 57).
11. “As an artist Maupassant perfects his senses in order to reveal life as it is, but at the same
time he believes his senses to be deceptive. He is haunted both by what he may miss and by
what he may find, but all he can do is continue his exploration to the end. He justifies his
own activity by the fact that, given our imperfect unreliable senses, most men misuse
them and remain blind and deaf to much that goes on about them…” (Sullivan 59).
![Page 7: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
Madness, Hallucination, Syphilis, and Attempted Suicide:
Guy de Maupassant – A Day in the Country and Other Stories. Translated with an Introduction
and Notes by David Coward. Oxford University Press. 1990.
12. He was “removed to a clinic, suffering from the syphilitic paresis which had driven him
mad. He died on 6 July 1893, at the age of 42” (Coward xvi).
Wallace, Albert H. Guy de Maupassant. Twayne Publishers. New York. Copyright 1973.
13. “There is little doubt that hallucinations so subverted Maupassant’s capacity for drawing
rational conclusions in the latter part of his illness that he finally became incapable of
distinguishing between his wildest fancies and reality. The last years were sad”
(Wallace 22).
14. Wallace quotes Maupassant who wrote, “Fixed ideas have the tenacity of gnawing, incurable
maladies. Once entered into the mind, they devour it, leave it no longer free to think of
anything, to be interested in anything or to have an inclination in the slightest toward
anything” (Wallace105).
15. In one of the most insightful passages in his book, Wallace writes, in reference to
Maupassant’s story Suicide, “The letter’s words provide a foreboding of what must have been
Maupassant’s thoughts when he contemplated suicide. The hero has decided to kill himself
because of an awareness of the irremediable brutality of existence in which he has failed to
find a single strain of poetry his youthful naiveté has assigned to it” (Wallace 114).
16. Wallace explains that in Maupassant’s story Miss Harriot “solitude leads to suicide,” that “it
was loneliness that caused the heroine to cast herself into a well” (Wallace 106). Wallace
goes on to quote Maupassant who writes, “We are the eternal playthings of ever renewing,
stupid and charming illusions” (Wallace 231).
Harold Bloom. Bloom's Major Short Story Writers Guy de Maupassant. Chelsea House
Publishers. Philadelphia.
17. “Maupassant’s own life ended badly; by his late twenties, he was syphilitic. At thirty-nine
the disease affected his mind, and he spent his final years locked in an asylum, after a
suicide attempt. His most upsetting horror story, “The Horla,” has a complex and ambiguous
relation to his illness and its consequences. The nameless protagonist of the story is perhaps
a syphilitic going mad, though nothing that Maupassant narrates actually tells us to make
such an inference” (Bloom 13).
![Page 8: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
Book List For Your Works Cited Page
Available at the BMCC Library
1. Francis Steegmuller. Maupassant: A Lion in the Path - Call Number: PQ2353 .S8 2007
2. Richard Fusco. Maupassant and the American short story : the influence of form at the turn of
the century, by - Call Number: PS374 .S5 F87 1994
3. Harold Bloom. Bloom's Major Short Story Writers Guy de Maupassant. Chelsea House
Publishers. Philadelphia. - Call Number: PQ2356 .G89 2004
4. Albert H. Wallace. Guy de Maupassant, Albert H. Wallace. Twayne Publishers. New York.
Copyright 1973 - Call Number: PQ2353 .W3
5. Michael G. Lerner. Maupassant. George Braziller. New York.
call number PQ 2353 .L44
6. Maupassant in the Hall of Mirrors: Ironies of Repetition in the Work of Guy de Maupassant,
by Trevor A. Le V. Harris, Call Number: PQ2357 .H37 1990
7. Edward Daniel Sullivan. Maupassant the Short Stories. Barron’s Educational Series Inc.
Great Neck, New York. Call Number PQ 2355.S8 1962.
8. Albert, Henri René Guy de Maupassant. A Stroll. classicreader.com/book/610/1/.
9. Albert, Henri René Guy de Maupassant. All Over. Translators: Albert M.C. McMaster, A.E.
Henderson, Mme. Quesada, & others. E-texts.
10. Guy de Maupassant – A Day in the Country and Other Stories. Translated with an Introduction
and Notes by David Coward. Oxford University Press. 1990.
![Page 9: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
Specifications
1. Each essay must be stapled in the upper left-hand corner.
Papers that are not stapled will not be accepted.
2. Each page of each essay must have typed page numbers in the upper right-hand corner.
Papers without typed page numbers in the upper right hand corner will not be
accepted.
3. Each essay must be typed. Essays that are not typed will not be accepted.
4. Font size must be 12.
5. Font style must be Times New Roman.
6. Each paragraph must be indented.
7. There must be no more than one double-space between paragraphs.
8. The name of the student, professor, course, and date must be flush left with a double-space
between each. See example on the following page.
9. Each essay must be double-spaced.
10. For citations more than one sentences, use the following specifications.
See example on page 9.
a. single-space
b. font size 10
c. left indent at 1 right indent at 5.5.
11. Quotation marks and the appropriate MLA citation for all quotes must be used. The absence
of quotation marks where needed is PLAGIARISM. See example of internal punctuation
on the following page. WARNING: Omission of quotation marks is grounds for an F for
the paper and possibly for the final grade.
12. All sources used in the essay must be cited in a “Works Cited” page and be done according to
MLA formats. See example on the page after the following page.
![Page 10: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
Format First Page This is an example of the top of the first page of a paper.
Use double-spaces. The title must be a double-space below the date and centered.
See MLA Handbook - Seventh Edition. 4.3. Heading And Title. 116.
Internal Punctuation
Long Quotations This is an example of how to do a citation longer than one sentence.
1
John Smith
Professor Abraham
English 201
May 7, 2009
Greek Tragedy
When citing a source in the text do as follows: “Oedipus in the play is a free agent” (Fagles 149).
If you provide the name of the author in the sentence, you do not need to include it in the parenthetical citation.
Fagles maintains that “Oedipus in the play is a free agent” (149).
When paraphrasing do as follows: Fagles maintains that Oedipus has free will (149).
When quoting without citing a non-published source, do as follows: My father always said, “follow your heart.”
.
“In the very first year of our century Sigmund Freud in his Interpretation of Dreams offered
a famous and influential interpretation of Oedipus the King:
Oedipus Rex is what is known as a tragedy of destiny. Its tragic effect is said to lie in the contrast
between supreme will of the gods and the vain attempts of mankind to escape the evil that threatens
them. The lesson which, it is said, the deeply moved spectator should learn from the tragedy is
submission to the divine will and realization of his own impotence.
(Trans. James Strachey)
This passage is of course a landmark in the history of modern thought, and it is fascinating to observe
that this idea, which, valid or not, has had enormous influence, stems from an attempt to answer a
literary problem – why does the play have this overpowering effect on modern audiences?”
(Knox, Bernard. Sophocles – The Three Theban Plays. Translated by Robert Fagles. Penguin Books.
Copyright by Bernhard Knox, 1982. 132. Print.)
![Page 11: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Works Cited Page
This is an example of the top of the first page of a works-cited list.
Entries are in alphabetical order with second lines of each entry indented (hanging indentation).
See MLA Handbook - Seventh Edition. 131.
The Works Cited page must be on a separate page.
7
Works Cited
Shakespeare, William. The Tragedy of Hamlet Prince of Denmark. Edited by Edward Hubler.
A Signet Classic. Copyright by Edward Hubler, 1963. Print.
Sophocles. The Three Theban Plays – Antigone, Oedipus the King, Oeidipus at Colonus.
Translated By Robert Fagles. Penguin Books. Copyright by Robert Fagles, 1982, 1984. Print.
![Page 12: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
Andrew Gottlieb SAMPLE RESEARCH PROJECT
Professor Gottlieb
English 201- (section number)
July 12, 2013
The Misery of Maupassant
Guy de Maupassant is regarded as one the foremost of French writers. The goal of this
paper is to discuss Maupassant’s vision of life and how it may have been, at least to some extent,
the cause of his suffering and his attempted suicide. It was on New Year’s Day 1892 that
Maupassant made the attempt. He was “removed to a clinic, suffering from the syphilitic paresis
which had driven him mad. He died on 6 July 1893, at the age of 42” (Coward xvi).
Maupassant was not the most joyful of men. In his book Guy de Maupassant, Albert H.
Wallace refers to a letter Maupassant wrote to his mother in which he speaks of his loneliness.
“I fear the arriving winter. I feel alone, and my long, solitary evenings are sometimes terrible.
Often when I’m alone seated at my desk with my lamp burning sadly before me, I experience
such complete moments of distress that I no longer know where to turn” (45). Wallace explains
that “loneliness was a major factor in the development of Maupassant’s affliction. Living too
much to himself, he formed certain ideas whose very inalterability was their poison” (Wallace
105). He quotes Maupassant who wrote, “Fixed ideas have the tenacity of gnawing, incurable
maladies. Once entered into the mind, they devour it, leave it no longer free to think of anything,
to be interested in anything or to have an inclination in the slightest toward anything” (105).
Wallace explains that in Maupassant’s story Miss Harriot “solitude leads to suicide,” that “it was
loneliness that caused the heroine to cast herself into a well” (Wallace 106). Wallace goes on to
![Page 13: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
quote Maupassant who writes, “We are the eternal playthings of ever renewing, stupid and
charming illusions” (114). The statement,” Wallace explains, “is also in complete accord with
Maupassant’s disillusionment with life that is so prominent a factor in his work and in his mental
difficulties” (114).
The key in all of these comments is disillusionment. In his introduction to A Day in the
Country and Other Stories, David Coward provides a vivid account of Maupassant’s cynical
view of the world. Of the authors world view he writes, “All the things which commonly pass
for the charm of life – love, friendship, happiness – are so many illusions which nature allows us
to compensate for the iron grip in which we are held” (xvi). Maupassant’s misery and possibly
his suicide attempt were rooted in the loss of illusions. In one of the most insightful passages in
his book, Wallace writes, in reference to Maupassant’s story Suicide, “The letter’s words provide
a foreboding of what must have been Maupassant’s thoughts when he contemplated suicide. The
hero has decided to kill himself because of an awareness of the irremediable brutality of
existence in which he has failed to find a single strain of poetry his youthful naiveté has
assigned to it” (Wallace 114).
Maupassant was not born a cynic. As a young man he had a poetic and possibly naïve
view of life. As time went he was persuaded by experience to adopt a darker view of things.
This change is a loss of faith, a loss of what, after an apparent awakening has occurred, comes to
be viewed as illusions. Whether love, friendship, and happiness are illusions is a matter for
debate. It is important to note that such a loss is not necessarily predicated on a realization of
truth. It may often be the result of a shift in perception. One day the world seems beautiful and
loving, the next it seems ugly and cruel. One day one may see himself as a success; the next he
may see himself as an utter failure. One perception is not more or less real than another.
![Page 14: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Maupassant’s loss of illusion may well have been a loss of faith. He may have lost faith
in the things that for him made life worth living. As we get older, we go through certain
experiences that disturb or shock us. It is our vulnerability in these matters that may lead us
to abandon our beliefs, to disavow our faith, and to lose our confidence and our resolve. This,
I believe, is what happened to Maupassant. It is no thus not surprising that disillusionment is a
recurrent theme in his stories. Two such narratives are All Over and A Stroll.
In All Over, the protagonist, Lormerin, a middle aged bachelor, undergoes a devastating
shift in self-esteem. The story opens with Lormerin gazing admiringly at himself in the mirror.
“Lormerin is still alive!” he proclaims. It is evident that Lormerin is aware that he is no longer
young but that he is still attractive. We may also infer that Lormerin’s self-esteem is dependent
in large part upon his appearance. Various details in the narrative may also lead us to conclude
that he is narcissistic. In preparation for his rendezvous with Lise, a woman with whom he had
a love affair in his youth and who has now sent him an invitation to dine with her, he inspects
himself “from head to foot” and thinks, “She must look very old, older than I look.” This seems
to delight him for he feels “gratified at the thought of showing himself to her still handsome, still
fresh, of astonishing her, perhaps of filling her with emotion, and making her regret those bygone
days so far, far distant” (Maupassant 2). He then proceeds to make “his toilet with feminine
coquetry” (Maupassant 2). Apparently, Lormerin’s motivation for seeing Lise is not so much to
enjoy the pleasure of her company and to give her the pleasure of his so much as it is to fortify
his vanity and to do so at the expense of hers. It is for this reason that we may hesitate to feel too
much sympathy for Lormerin when by the end of the day his confidence is so painfully
compromised. We may argue that Lise is the one responsible for Lormerin’s loss of self-esteem,
that she has manipulated the situation to bring her quarry down, but this could only have been
![Page 15: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
accomplished if the quarry had not made himself vulnerable. Lormerin would never have been
so easy to manipulate had he not placed such a high premium on his appearance. An identity
predicated on externals is a flimsy one indeed, and so Lormerin’s self-esteem is an easy target
for the woman who seems to see as clearly through him as she might to the bottom of a shallow
pond.
When Lormerin looks at himself in the mirror at the end of the story, he sees a very
different man than he had earlier that day. At the moment that he sees this “lamentable image,”
and proclaims “All over, Lormerin,” he has in essence adopted a new identity. Yet, as far as his
physical appearance is concerned it is highly unlikely that any significant physical change if any
has occurred. The only alteration in Lormerin is in his mind. The cause of this change is his
encounter with Lise and her daughter Renee.
The question is: which of the two images is genuine? From Lormerin’s point of view,
the last one is more objective. Yet, it is the way Lormerin looks at himself and the way he feels
that has altered his perception. It is reasonable to say that neither of the two images is more
genuine than the other. Each is a manifestation of Lormerin’s state of mind. It’s true that he
may have not paid attention to some of his wrinkles when he looked at himself in the morning,
but it is his way of focusing on such details at the end and the idea he has come to embrace about
himself that alters his self-esteem. To say that he is disillusioned implies that his earlier, more
cheerful impression of himself is false.
Perhaps, this is what Maupassant wants us to think. We cannot be sure of this, but we do
have some idea of how he felt about his own life. Based on the citations mentions at the outset
of our discussion, we have good reason to believe that Maupassant was suffering from feelings
of disillusionment, that he had adopted a cynical view of life and that, like Lormerin, he may
![Page 16: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
have been suffering from a loss of self-esteem. It is in this respect that it is reasonable to assume
a commonality between the author and the protagonist of All Over. Like Lormerin, Maupassant
may have come to the conclusion that his life, or rather his vision of life and of himself, was all
over.
Another one of Maupassant’s stories in which the suffering of the protagonist hinges on
disillusionment is A Stroll. Leras, an old man working as a bookkeeper for Messieurs Labuze
and Company, undergoes a realization, if so it can be called, that has a far more devastating
consequence than that of Lormerin’s. Leras commits suicide. We are led to believe that this
rash act is precipitated by an experience he has in the Bois de Boulogne, a park in Paris
frequented by lovers and prostitutes. During his stroll Leras is approached by prostitutes.
It is then that he feels as though he is “enveloped in darkness by something disagreeable”
(Maupassant 2). He thinks of “all this venal or passionate love, of all these kisses, sold or given,
which were passing by in front of him” (Maupassant 2). Not only is Leras confronted with the
feeling of being an outsider. Now, he sees through the veneer of romance. The charm of the
evening has transformed into something dark and disagreeable. Whatever may have passed for
love he now realizes is only a masquerade, a façade behind which is something sinister and ugly.
But it is not so much the tawdriness of the scene that Leras finds disturbing, although that may
be a part of it. The source of his dismay is that, unlike the people before him, he has “scarcely”
known love. Now, he looks back “at the life which he had led, so different from everybody
else, so dreary, so mournful, so empty,” and has an awakening. “And suddenly, as though a veil
had been torn from his eyes, he perceived the infinite misery, the monotony of his existence: the
past, present and future misery; his last day similar to his first one, with nothing before him,
behind him or
![Page 17: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
about him, nothing in his heart or any place” (Maupassant 2). Leras sees, possibly for the first
time, the emptiness of his life. Everyone else, the “whole of humanity” seems to be “intoxicated
with joy, pleasure and happiness. He alone is looking on and he sees that “tomorrow he would
again be alone, always alone, more so than anyone else.” Leras imagines how “pleasant it must
be in old age to return home and find the little children.” But Leras has no wife, no children and
is consigned, as far as he can tell to spend the rest of his life in solitude.
What is significant here is that he sees himself as a being entirely different from everyone
else. He doesn’t stop to consider that there may be others like him. Nor, is he apparently able
to see the beauty of the evening he had been enjoying. It is the same evening, the same place. The
only thing that has changed is Leras’ way of seeing it. Even his room, the one he has lived in for
so many years, is no longer the same for him: “…a feeling of distress filled his soul; and the place
seemed to him more mournful even than his little office” (Maupassant 3). It is not Leras’ room
that has changed but the way he sees it.
In the end, Leras hangs himself on a tree. The cause of the suicide “could not be
suspected. Perhaps a sudden access of madness!” The author does not conclude his tale by
offering a definitive explanation of Leras’ decision to end his life. He has however given us
good reason to believe that the reason his protagonist takes such a drastic action is because he
has had a revelation. Leras’ vision of himself and his life has been altered by his experience in
the park. It is not, however, the scene that has altered Leras. Leras has altered himself. He is
the sole agent of his transformation.
The question remains, has Leras really had a revelation? Is he really more awake at the
end of the story than he has been his whole life? Has a veil truly been lifted or has another come
along to take its place? Does Leras see the truth of his life or is he simply blind to the
![Page 18: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
possibilities that surround him? If he is enveloped in darkness, is it not because he is doing
the enveloping? Perhaps, one veil was lifted only to be replaced by another. In the end, Leras
may never really have opened his eyes. He lives in Paris, a city full of beauty, charm, and
opportunities but is unable to participate in all it has to offer. It is not circumstance that destroys
Leras but the way in which he perceives it.
What the protagonists in All Over and A Stroll have in common is disillusionment. They
experience a loss faith in the image or idea they had of themselves and of their lives. Because he
no longer sees himself as a youthful and attractive man, Lormerin feels that his life is all over.
Leras, who is confronted with the realization that he has been leading a loveless existence and
the feeling that there is no hope of changing this, commits suicide. One wonders if Maupassant
went through a similar revelation prior to his suicide attempt or if he had been living with the
pain of such a revelation for years before he made it.
It is not difficult to see the connection between Leras, Lormerin and Maupassant.
Maupassant’s writing was in large part a vehicle through which he expressed his feelings about
his own life. His characters, or at least some of them, are reflections of the dark and cynical
view which engulfed the author and which in the end augmented the pain that led to his
attempted suicide. Maupassant’s physical condition due to syphilitic paresis had much to do
with the deterioration of his mind and spirit, but we cannot discount his cynicism as a
participating factor in the suffering he endured and in his attempt to end his life.
![Page 19: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Works Cited
Guy de Maupassant, Albert, Henri René. A Stroll. classicreader.com/book/610/1/.
Guy de Maupassant, Albert, Henri René. All Over. Translators: Albert M.C. McMaster, A.E.
Henderson, Mme. Quesada, & others. E-texts.
Guy de Maupassant – A Day in the Country and Other Stories. Translated with an Introduction
and Notes by David Coward. Oxford University Press. 1990.
Wallace, Albert H. Guy de Maupassant. Twayne Publishers. New York. Copyright 1973.
![Page 20: The Research Project · 2015/8/2 · 1 The Research Project Andrew Gottlieb Students in English 201 are required to write a Research Project. The paper must be 6 pages and satisfy](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022051919/600bd1ae021d252e1a07429f/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20