The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H....

20
The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

Transcript of The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H....

Page 1: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey

P. Popesso (ESO),

A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste),

H. Böhringer (MPE),

M. Romaniello (ESO).

Page 2: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

The Survey:

●following the variations of the properties of cluster galaxies with the global

properties of the systems (total mass, velocity dispersion, LX, L

op)

●understanding the selection effects introduced by different cluster detection and

selection methods

The method & dataset

● multiwavelenght approach:

✔RASS data for the X-ray properties (LX)

✔SDSS data for optical (Lop

) and dynamical (mass, V) cluster

properties, spectrophotometric properties of cluster galaxies

The cluster samples

● 130 X-ray selected clusters (the RASS-SDSS Cluster Sample)

● 137 optically selected (3D overdensity spectroscopically confirmed) Abell

Clusters

Page 3: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

Outlines:

● Part I

– universality of the cluster Luminosity Function (LF)

– the cluster dwarf galaxy population

– morphology-density relation of the dwarf systems● Part II

– the Abell X-ray Underluminous Clusters (AXU

Clusters) and their nature

Page 4: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

The Composite Cluster Luminosity FunctionThe cluster composite LF is obtained by stacking the individual LFs (background subtracted) within the virial radius.

●Best fit: double Schechter Function

● at the bright end:

● at the faint end:

in the r band

km/s/Mpc )

Page 5: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

Is the cluster LF universal?The composite cluster LF, calculated within the virial radius, is a good representation for more than 90% of the clusters, as confirmed by the 2 test.

When measured within the physical size of the systems (given by r

200), the Cluster LF is

universal (Popesso et al. 2005)

Page 6: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

...at the bright end

● Composite cluster LF is able

to locate the BCGs.

Page 7: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

...at the bright end

Composite cluster LF is able to locate the BCGs (Popesso et al. 2005, A&A submitted).

Solid line LBCG

Lin & Mohr (2004) , Yang et al. (2005)

Page 8: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

...at the faint endDGR=N(-18.5rr

●When measured within r

200

●or r500

, the DGR is constant

Page 9: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

...at the faint endDGR=N(-18.5rr

●When measured within r

200

●or r500

, the DGR is constant

Page 10: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

When the LFs is measured within

a fixed metric aperture of 1 Mpc,

it varies from cluster to cluster.

●the overall disagreement about the faint-end slope of the cluster LF in the literature is due to aperture effects

Page 11: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

The Cluster LF by Galaxy Morphological type

We use the color cut at u-r=2.22 of Strateva et al. (2001) to distinguish red early type galaxies from blue late type galaxies.

Early type galaxies Late type galaxies

Popesso et al. 2005c, astro-ph/0506201

Page 12: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

The dependence on the environment

Page 13: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

Conclusions Part I

● bimodal behaviour of the cluster LF (steepening at the faint end)

● the cluster LF is universal when measured with the virial radius

● DGR increasing with the clustercentric distance

● LF steepening due to dwarf early type galaxies which dominate the cluster core (< 0.6 r

200)

● are the dwarf early type galaxies the spheroidal remnants of stripped and faded spirals as predicted by harassment scenario (Moore et al. 1996, 1998)?

Page 14: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

The Abell X-ray Underluminous Clusters● Do different cluster

detection and selection methods select the same cluster population?

Lx M200

2.04 0.04

scatter ~60%

(Popesso et al. 2005, A&A, 433, 431)

Page 15: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

137 optically selected Abell clusters (3D overdensity spectroscopically confirmed):●88 clusters have clear RASS X-ray

counterpart●27 marginally significant ( < 3)

detection●24 no X-ray detection (Popesso et al. 2005, A&A submitted)

RASS is too shallow to detect such

faint X-ray sources (see also Basilakos

et al. 2004, Donahue et al. 2003)

Page 16: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

● normal X-ray emittting Abell clusters: mean deviation -0.10.3 dex

● AXU: mean deviation -1.00.4 dex

● Tail Index (Beers et al. 1991) and subclustering analysis confirm

reliable estimate of the cluster mass

Page 17: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).
Page 18: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

The nature of the AXU clusters

Page 19: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

The velocity dispersion distribution

AXU clusters: leptokurtic distribution in the outer region,

typical of systems in accretion

Page 20: The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey P. Popesso (ESO), A. Biviano (Osservatorio di Trieste), H. Böhringer (MPE), M. Romaniello (ESO).

Conclusions Part II● Optical selection reveals a population of X-ray

underluminous (AXU) systems

● AXU clusters do not follow the LX-M

200 relation (mean

deviation -1.0 dex)

● AXU clusters do follow the Lop

-M200

relation

● AXU systems show leptokurtic velocity distribution in the outer regions (systems in accretion?)

● systems in formation also at low z?

● multi-wavelength approach is needed for optimizing completeness ans reliability of cluster samples.