The Psychological Well-Being of “Seeking” and “Achieving” Purpose in Adulthood
1
The Psychological Well-Being of “Seeking” and “Achieving” Purpose in Adulthood Patrick L. Hill, Jessica Collado, Anthony Burrow, Jay Brandenberger, & Daniel K. Lapsley University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN Abstract Seeking one’s purpose is a paramount developmental concern for most individuals, and failure to achieve purpose may be linked to negative psychological well- being. The current research compared individuals who had identified their purpose with those still searching for one, on whether they could be classified as following different patterns of adult development. Our research indicates that purpose seekers did also follow a “seeker” pattern of development, and that those adults who had identified their purpose followed an “achiever” pattern of development. We suggest the possibility of alternative pathways in constructing purposive lives in adulthood. Background Recently, Helson and Srivastava (2001) identified three positive pathways for adult development: 1. “Conservers” sought security and structure in their life, at the cost of having new experiences. They 2. “Seekers” saught new experiences, at the cost of less security and structure. 3. “Achievers” were those able to conscientiously seek new experiences, which decreased their propensity for anxiety. While Conservers were lower in personal growth, and Seekers were lower in environmental mastery, Achievers were able to achieve both due to having clear, ambitious objectives in life. Therefore, while all three pathways to adult development were viewed as positive, Achievers demonstrated Predictions for the Current Study H1: Following the “Seeker” profile, greater searching for purpose should be positively related to personal growth, but negatively related to environmental mastery H2: Following the “Achiever” profile, greater identification of one’s purpose should be positively related to both personal growth and environmental mastery. Correlational Analyses Correlations 1 -.313** -.253** .123* .000 .000 .028 327 303 316 317 -.313** 1 .518** .395** .000 .000 .000 303 306 296 297 -.253** .518 ** 1 .378** .000 .000 .000 316 296 328 321 .123* .395 ** .378** 1 .028 .000 .000 317 297 321 330 Pearson Correlati Sig. (2-tailed) N Pearson Correlati Sig. (2-tailed) N Pearson Correlati Sig. (2-tailed) N Pearson Correlati Sig. (2-tailed) N Searching for Purp Identified Purpose Environmental Mast Personal Growth Searching for Purpose Identified Purpose Environmental Mastery Personal Growth Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed). **. Predicting Environmental Mastery, Searching: B = .25** Identified: B = .45** R 2 = .190 Predicting Personal Growth, Searching: B = -.13* Identified: B = .48** R 2 = .283 Regression Analyses Conclusions Our results seem to suggest that adults who follow a seeker or achiever path during development may be similar to those who are seeking or achieving purpose in their lives. Purpose seekers and purpose achievers followed similar profiles with respect to personal growth and environmental mastery as did the seekers and achievers in Helson and Srinistava’s (2001) study. This also lends support for using the COA Youth Purpose scales for understanding developmental trajectories beyond adolescence. Implications These results also provide larger implications for the study of adult development during mid-life and beyond. Following Ryff’s (1989) suggestion, achieving purpose seems to be integrally linked to psychological well-being during adult development. This study suggests the need to not only examine whether adults have identified their purpose but also whether they are actively seeking one. Helson and Srinistava (2001) suggest that the “seeking” profile is a positive and adaptive one, which led to greater ego development and wisdom in comparison to their other groups. When connecting this to the current work, it suggests that one’s search for purpose may be linked to one’s ego development, which serves as an intriguing hypothesis for future work. Limitations Three possible limitations are of note. First, the population sampled were college alumni, which may restrict generalizability to the overall population of mid-life adults. Second, due to the extended length of the survey, several participants failed to complete all portions. Third, data was collected using an online survey which Method and Reliabilities Participants: 399 (57% M), Notre Dame graduates with an average age of 35 years Procedure: Participants completed multiple scales online and were allowed to quit at any time. Participants who completed at least 2/3 of the survey were included in the final analyses. Reliabilities of Interest: Searching (α = .94), Identified (α = .89), EM (α = .87), PG (α = .88)
-
Upload
melanie-whitney -
Category
Documents
-
view
11 -
download
0
description
The Psychological Well-Being of “Seeking” and “Achieving” Purpose in Adulthood Patrick L. Hill, Jessica Collado, Anthony Burrow, Jay Brandenberger, & Daniel K. Lapsley University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN. Abstract - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Transcript of The Psychological Well-Being of “Seeking” and “Achieving” Purpose in Adulthood
The Psychological Well-Being of “Seeking” and “Achieving” Purpose in
Adulthood Patrick L. Hill, Jessica Collado, Anthony Burrow, Jay Brandenberger, & Daniel K.
Lapsley
University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN
Abstract
Seeking one’s purpose is a paramount developmental concern for most individuals, and failure to achieve purpose may be linked to negative psychological well-being. The current research compared individuals who had identified their purpose with those still searching for one, on whether they could be classified as following different patterns of adult development. Our research indicates that purpose seekers did also follow a “seeker” pattern of development, and that those adults who had identified their purpose followed an “achiever” pattern of development. We suggest the possibility of alternative pathways in constructing purposive lives in adulthood.
Background
Recently, Helson and Srivastava (2001) identified three positive pathways for adult development:
1. “Conservers” sought security and structure in their life, at the cost of having new experiences. They
2. “Seekers” saught new experiences, at the cost of less security and structure.
3. “Achievers” were those able to conscientiously seek new experiences, which decreased their propensity for anxiety.
While Conservers were lower in personal growth, and Seekers were lower in environmental mastery, Achievers were able to achieve both due to having clear, ambitious objectives in life. Therefore, while all three pathways to adult development were viewed as positive, Achievers demonstrated the best balance between progress and stability as life goals.
Predictions for the Current Study
H1: Following the “Seeker” profile, greater searching for purpose should be positively related to personal growth, but negatively related to environmental mastery
H2: Following the “Achiever” profile, greater identification of one’s purpose should be positively related to both personal growth and environmental mastery.
Correlational Analyses
Correlations
1 -.313** -.253** .123*
.000 .000 .028
327 303 316 317
-.313** 1 .518** .395**
.000 .000 .000
303 306 296 297
-.253** .518** 1 .378**
.000 .000 .000
316 296 328 321
.123* .395** .378** 1
.028 .000 .000
317 297 321 330
Pearson Correlation
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Pearson Correlation
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Pearson Correlation
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Pearson Correlation
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Searching for Purpose
Identified Purpose
Environmental Mastery
Personal Growth
Searchingfor Purpose
IdentifiedPurpose
EnvironmentalMastery
PersonalGrowth
Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).**.
Predicting Environmental Mastery,
Searching: B = .25** Identified: B = .45** R2 = .190
Predicting Personal Growth,
Searching: B = -.13* Identified: B = .48** R2 = .283
Regression Analyses
Conclusions
Our results seem to suggest that adults who follow a seeker or achiever path during development may be similar to those who are seeking or achieving purpose in their lives. Purpose seekers and purpose achievers followed similar profiles with respect to personal growth and environmental mastery as did the seekers and achievers in Helson and Srinistava’s (2001) study. This also lends support for using the COA Youth Purpose scales for understanding developmental trajectories beyond adolescence.
Implications
These results also provide larger implications for the study of adult development during mid-life and beyond. Following Ryff’s (1989) suggestion, achieving purpose seems to be integrally linked to psychological well-being during adult development. This study suggests the need to not only examine whether adults have identified their purpose but also whether they are actively seeking one. Helson and Srinistava (2001) suggest that the “seeking” profile is a positive and adaptive one, which led to greater ego development and wisdom in comparison to their other groups. When connecting this to the current work, it suggests that one’s search for purpose may be linked to one’s ego development, which serves as an intriguing hypothesis for future work.
Limitations
Three possible limitations are of note. First, the population sampled were college alumni, which may restrict generalizability to the overall population of mid-life adults. Second, due to the extended length of the survey, several participants failed to complete all portions. Third, data was collected using an online survey which necessarily neglected those alumni without access to the internet.
Method and Reliabilities
Participants: 399 (57% M), Notre Dame graduates with an average age of 35 years
Procedure: Participants completed multiple scales online and were allowed to quit at any time. Participants who completed at least 2/3 of the survey were included in the final analyses.
Reliabilities of Interest: Searching (α = .94), Identified (α = .89), EM (α = .87), PG (α = .88)
