THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE...
Transcript of THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE...
![Page 1: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE ENGAGEMENT
Tuesday 8 August 2017Women’s Prison, Constitution Hill
![Page 2: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
ABANDONMENT IN SOUTH AFRICA: SOME IMPORTANT FACTS
• It iscommonlycitedthatabout3500childrenareabandonedannually(approximately300permonth)butthatfigureonlyincludessurvivors.Thetotalnumberofabandonmentsisfarhigher.
• FigurescompiledinGautengshowthatforeveryabandonedchildfoundalive,twoarefounddead.
• ArecentMedicalResearchCouncilstudyonchildhomiciderevealsthatchildren inSouthAfricaareatthehighestriskofunnaturaldeathinthefirstsixdaysoflife.
• Researchshowsthat65%ofabandonedchildrenarenewborns,and90%areundertheageofone.
• A largenumberofbabieshavealready surviveda late-termabortionprior tobeingabandoned.52-58%ofSouthAfrica’sabortionsareillegal(upto150000perannum),andinGauteng,studiesindicatethatuptohalfoftheseillegalabortions(whichareseldompoliced,andoftenunsuccessful)takeplaceinthethirdtrimester.
• 70%ofabandonmentsareunsafe.
• Manyabandonedbabiesareneverfound.
• SafeabandonmentisillegalinSouthAfricasoallofthecountry’sbabysafesoperateunlawfully.
• Girlsundertheageof18canconsenttoanabortion,butcannotplaceachildforadoptionwithouttheconsentofaparentorguardian.
• Foreignersfeardeportationiftheytrytoplaceachildforadoption.Otherslacktheformaldocumentationrequiredtoplacetheirchildrenintothechildprotectionsystem.
• AbandonmentisnolongerlistedasaviolentcrimeinSouthAfrica,orincludedincrimestatistics.NorisitlistedasacauseofdeathinSouthAfricanmortuaries.Thereisthereforenoaccuratetallyofhowmanychildrendieasaresultofabandonment.
• Todate,noformalresearchhasbeencompletedbythegovernmenttotrackabandonment,andnomeasuresputinplacetocounterit.
• Studiesshowthatabandonmentmostfrequentlyresultsfromdesperationduetopovertyandunemployment,thebreakdownofthefamily,HIV/AIDS,culturalbeliefs,rape, incest,“blessersorsugardaddies”andwomenthemselvesbeingabandonedbythechild’sfather.Governmentpolicyisalsoahugecontributingfactor,asisanti-adoptionsentimentonthepartofmanynursesandofficials.
Inconclusion,endemicproblemslikepovertyandabusearehardtoaddress,sochildabandonmentislikelytocontinuelong-term.But,changestogovernmentpolicy,suchasloweringtheageofconsentforadoptionplacement,facilitatingsafeabandonmentthrough the implementation of safe haven laws, and dealing with xenophobic policies regarding foreigners and barriers toadoptionwoulddefinitelysavelives;aswouldpolicing,especiallyofillegalabortionpractitioners.Inaddition,research,andlistingabandonmentincrimeandmortuarystatisticscouldhelptoquantifyandmanagetheproblem.Finally,pregnancyinitiativesareessentialtosupportvulnerablewomenandlessentheriskofthemmakingthetragicdecisiontoabandon.
FirstpublishedintheDailyMaverick,thearticlehighlightsthetragedyofillegallatetermabortionandabandonment
![Page 3: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
A LETTER TO ABORTED TWINS
BY ROBYN WOLFSON VORSTER
To the aborted twins, we failed you because if you died in the womb, even on the cusp of birth, our law says you were not a person and that you have no legal rights. We failed you because if you were born alive, no one will ever know or care. Forensic pathology services will list you as a stillbirth, even though you took a breath, and the police will not classify you as a murder statistic or investigate your unnatural death.
DearInnocents,
Todaycouldhavebeenyourbirthday.Insteaditmarksamonthsinceyourmotherabortedyou,placedyouinaplasticbag,andleftyouundera“safeabortions”sign.NowIthinkaboutyoueveryday.Somanyquestionsremainunanswered:
Whydidyourmotherwaituntilshewaseightmonthspregnantbeforedecidingtoendyourlives?
Whatmadehersuddenlygiveup?
Didtheabortiondrugkillyou?Itdoesn’tkillthemajorityofbabiesatsuchalatestageofdevelopment.Wereyoubornalive?
Didshecrywhenshedeliveredyou?Whataboutwhensheputyouintheplasticbag?
Asyourlifeended,diditcomfortyoutofeelyoursister’sbodynexttoyoursasyouhadinthewomb?
TheyarequestionsIwillneverbeabletoanswer.WhatIdoknowisthatwefailedyou.Wefailedyoubecauseweallowedyourmothertoliveinpoverty,desperationandviolence.Wefailedyoubecausewedidn’tletherknowthatshehadoptions:thatshedidn’thavetoabortyou,thattherewerearmsachingtoholdyou—armsthatachestill.Wefailedyoubecausewehaveallowedthestigmaofadoptiontoremainunchallenged.Wefailedyoubecauseyourmotherwasnotlegallypermittedtoabandonyousafely.Wefailedyoubecausewedidn’tpolicethepeoplewhoillegallysoldyourmothertheabortiondrug,becausetheyareallowedtocarryout“safeabortions”withimpunity—safeforwhom,Iask?
Wefailedyoubecauseifyoudiedinthewomb(evenonthecuspofbirth),ourlawsaysyouwerenotapersonandthatyouhavenolegalrights.Wefailedyoubecauseifyouwerebornalivenoonewilleverknoworcare:forensicpathologyserviceswilllistyouasa“stillbirth”eventhoughyoutookabreath,andthepolicewillnotclassifyyouasamurderstatisticorinvestigateyour“unnaturaldeath”.
We failedyoubecausenoonewillbeprosecuted foryourdeath:notyourmother (ifshe ischargedatall, itwillonlybe forconcealmentofbirthandsofar,onlyonepersonhasbeenprosecutedforthatcrime),northeabortionpractitioners.Inourlaw,theyareguiltyofillegallydispensingmedicine,not,apparently,foryourdeath.Aboveall,wefailedyoubecauseourgovernment,taskedwithyourcare,turnedablindeyetoillegalabortionandabandonment,anddoessostill.
Dear innocents,wefailedyouandnothingwedocanbringyouback.But,yourdeathsdidnotpassunnoticedlittleones.Wecannotcontinuetofailthemanyothersthatwillfollowafteryou.Nexttimewemustdobetter.Ifso,maybeyourappallingandsenselessdeathswillfinallyhavesomemeaning.
![Page 4: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
TOPIC ONECRISIS AND TEEN PREGNANCY: HOW TO UPHOLD THE SEXUAL AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH RIGHTS
OF VULNERABLE WOMENFacilitator:DrBusiMkwananzi:Researcherandexpertonteenpregnancy
Facts about teen pregnancy:
• Teenagepregnanciesresultin80,000unplannedbabiesannually.
• Morethan179000teenagerswerepregnantin2013,ofthesegirls,2903wereonly13yearsold.
• InSouthAfrica,30%offemaleswillhaveexperiencedateenpregnancybytheageof20.
• Thephenomenonhasadversehealth,socialandeconomicconsequencesforbothmotherandchildmakingitacriticalissuerequiringurgentaddress.
• Researchshowsthat incidenceofpregnancyamong15-19yearolds is15timeshigher thanthatof12-14yearolds. Forwomenagedbetween15and19,statisticsshowthatthereare50birthsper1000women.
• Girlsunder18mayconsenttoanabortionwithouttheconsentofaparentorguardian.However,theymaynotplaceachildforadoptionuntiltheyare18.
• Theimpactofateenpregnancy:
• Ontheteenagemotherincludemorbidity,mortalityandlowfutureprospects.
• Onthechildrenincludepoorerhealth,socialandeconomicoutcomes.
Factors resulting in a teen pregnancy include:
• Loweducationlevels&lowsocio-economicstatus
• Household(HH)factors–includinglargehouseholdsizeandlowhouseholdsocioeconomicstatus
• Communityfactorsincludingculture,genderinequalityandstereotyping.
Recommendations for all crisis pregnancies:
• Sexeducationcoupledwithcontraceptiveavailability.
• Sensitivityofnursesatclinicstosupportyoungwomenwithcontraceptivesandoptioncounselling.
• Optioncounsellingsupport.
Recommendations re teen pregnancies:
• Teenagepregnancypreventionprogrammesneedtotargetgirlsatyoungerages.Suchprogrammesshouldpreferablyoccurattheprimaryschoollevelandaimtoempowerandassistyoungerfemalestocurballformsofinfringementontheirsexualandreproductivehealthrights.
• Programmesneedtobesetupforchildrengrowingupwithoutoneorbothparentstoensurefatherandmotherfiguresarepresentinsuchchildren’slives,andifabsent,pairedupwithscreenedsuitable“substitute”parentfigures.The“substitute”parentwouldactasasourceofsupport,love,validationandencouragementtodecreaseagirl-child’svulnerabilityofidealisingolder‘father-figure’partners,andtolowerherpredispositiontodelinquencyduringadolescence.
• Serviceinaccessibilityiscloselylinkedtoteenpregnancy.Usingserviceinaccessibilityresults,wecanidentifyareasthataremorepronetoteenagepregnancyandensurethattheyaretargetedfor interventionprogramsagainstthisphenomenon.Programmesneed to focuson theprovisionofbasicserviceandpovertyalleviation toensureany riskdue to lowsocio-economicstatusiseradicated.
• Resultsoncommunityunemploymenthighlighttheneedofcreativewaystomonitorandsupervisechildren,especiallyduringadolescence. It is imperativethatgovernmentandNGOsbeginsupervisedafter-schoolprogrammesfor learnersuptothematriculationyear.Theseprogrammescouldensurethatchildrenareassistedwithhomework,encouragedtoplaysportsandexposedtoextra-curricularactivitiessuchasdrama,ballroomdancing,chess,debatingclubs,calligraphy,artsandcrafts,flowerarranging, interiordesigning,eventdecor,computerskills,musical instrument training,ballet,culturaldancing,etc.Theseactivitieswouldbemostbeneficialinenvironmentswhereteenslackrecreationhalls,publicsportsfacilitiesandotherresources.Unemployedmembersofthepubliccouldbetrainedandemployedtofacilitateinsuchcentresdecreasingtheproblemofyouthloiteringaswellascreatingemployment.
Questions:
1. Whatprogrammescouldbesetuptodecreaselevelsofvulnerabilityamongwomen?
2. Howcouldbusinessandgovernmentwork together tocombat thecontextual factorsassociatedwithcrisisand teenagepregnancy?
3. Howcanawarenessandeducationcampaignsbesupportedandmaderelevant?
4. Whichpoliciesneedgreaterreinforcementtoupholdthesexualandreproductivehealthrightsofwomen?
5. Howcouldtheprivatesectorandgovernmentassistfurtherinfinancingresearchforthiscriticalarea?
![Page 5: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
TOPIC TWOILLEGAL LATE ABORTION: MANAGING THE PROBLEM AND POLICING THE PRACTITIONERS
Facilitator:RobynWolfsonVorster:ChildProtectionAdvocateandJournalist
Key facts about illegal late term abortion:
• AccordingtoMarieStopes,between52-58%ofSouthAfrica’sabortionsareillegal(upto150000perannum).
• ResearchcarriedoutinGautengindicatestouptohalfoftheseabortionstakeplaceinthethirdtrimesterwhenthebabyisalreadyviable.
• Illegalabortionpractitionersareusuallycriminalswho illegallyprovidedrugs likeCytotec (aschedule4drugused for thetreatment of ulcers, but with a known side effect of producing uterine cramps) to bring on premature labour (or in lesssophisticatedareas,makewomendrinkchemicals).
• Abortionpractitionersdonotverifytheageofthefoetus,noristheviabilityofthefoetusaconsiderationtotheirsaleofthedrugs.Somepractitionersevenadvertisethattheyoffertheservicetowomenwhoareupto38weekspregnant.
• Womenareinstructedtotakethedrugs(orallyorvaginally)andthenfainamiscarriageatalocalhospital.Theyaresometimestoldthatthebaby“willdissolve”orbe“flushedaway”.
• Babiesoftensurvivetheabortionprocess.Theyarebornalive,onlytobeabandoned;ortodiefromprematurity,theeffectsoftheabortiondrugsorevenfrommurderatthehandsofshockedanddesperatemothers(orfamilymembers),appalledatbeingfacedwithalivingbaby.
• Babiesthatsurvivealatetermabortionoftenexperienceseriouspsychologicalandphysicalchallenges,learningdifficultiesandbehaviouralproblems,aswellaschronicconditionslikecerebralpalsyandADHD.OneofthebabiesrecentlyplacedatDoorofHopeweighsonly830g.
• Whilemanyof thesechildrenareadopted (usuallyoverseaswhere familiesaremoreopen toadoptingadisabledchild),thosethatremainoftenspendtheirchildhoodinChildandYouthCareCentres(CYCCs)atgreatexpensetotheCYCCandgovernment.
The law and illegal late term abortion:
• Accordingtothelaw,ababyisonlyaliveifithasbeenbornandtakenabreath.Forthisreason,ifamotherabortsherbaby(eventhedaybeforeitisduetobeborn),hercrimeisaviolationoftheTerminationofPregnancyAct.Ifthatsamemotherkillsherbabyafterithasbeenbornandhastakenabreath,shemaybechargedwithmurder.
• Illegalabortionpractitionerscannotbepolicedunlessthepolicereceiveacomplaint.
• Ifillegalabortionpractitionersarepoliced,itisonlyforviolatingtheTerminationorPregnancyActorforthecrimeofillegallydispensingmedicine.But,theDepartmentofHealthhasnojurisdictionoverthesepractitionersbecausetheyarenotlicencedtodispensemedicine.
• IfillegalabortionpractitionersarecaughtandprosecutedundertheTerminationofPregnancyAct,themaximumsentenceis10yearsimprisonment.
Questions:
1. Whydoyouthinkillegalabortionissuchaprobleminthiscountry?
2. Whoseresponsibilityshoulditbetopreventorpolicethem?
3. Whatcanthefollowinggroupsdotopreventorpolicetheproblem: • Government(whoandwhat)? • SAPS • Legislators
4. Istherearoleforbusinessinfindingandmaintainingasolution?
5. Istherearoleforbusinessincaringforthesurvivors?
6. Willpolicingillegalabortionpractitionersleadtoincreasedabandonment?
![Page 6: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
TOPIC THREEVIOLENCE, GENDER AND THE ECONOMY
Facilitators:LisaVetten:MellonDoctoralFellowoftheWitsCityInstitute,UniversityoftheWitwatersrand &DrZubedaDangor,theDirectoroftheNisaaInstituteforWomen’sDevelopment
Facts about gender violence:
• Violenceisgendered–meaningthatmenandwomendonotexperiencethesameformsofviolence,orperpetrateitatthesamerates.
• DomesticviolenceisthemostcommonformofviolenceexperiencedbySouthAfricanwomen,whilemostformsofsexualviolencearealsofarmorelikelytobeexperiencedbywomenratherthanmen.
• ThegenderedstructureofSouthAfrica’seconomyplaysaroleinwomen’sexperienceofviolence,aswellastheiraccesstohelpingresources.
• Datafromasoon-to-be-releasednationalstudyofreportedrapeestimatedthat60%ofadultcomplainantswereunemployed.Thisisdoubletheproportionofunemployedwomenrecordedbythecensusin2011(29.8%).
• Likeelsewhereintheworld,SouthAfricanwomenearnlessthantheirmalecounterparts,aswellashavinghigherratesofunemployment.Thesegenderedfeaturesoftheeconomyplacewomeninstructuralrelationsofeconomicdependencyuponmen;beinginarelationshipcanbeasmuchamattereconomicnecessity,asitisofromanticchoice.Butthisdependencymakeswomenvulnerabletoabuseandentrapstheminabusiverelationships.
• Workplacesneedtoattendtodomesticviolence. Itaffectswomen’sability toworkbecausetheymayrequiretimeoff toattendlegalproceedings,ortheirworkmayevenbesabotagedbytheirpartners.Colleaguescanalsobethreatenedbytheabusivepartner.Violenceagainstwomenthusentailscoststotheeconomy.
• Domestic violence is implicated inwomen’shomelessness inat least twoways: theymaybemadehomeless toescapeviolence;and, ifhomeless,maybeforcedtoenter intoviolentrelationshipsinordertoobtainsomewheretosleep.Policyinthisregardiscurrentlynotadequateanddoesnotrecogniseoraddresstherelationshipbetweenhousinganddomesticviolence.
• Domesticviolencesheltersarenotadequatelysupported,includingtheirprogrammesintendedtosupportwomen’seconomicdependence.Thecorporatesectorisplayingaminimalroleinaddressingthis.
Recommendations / Key questions for discussion:
1. WeinviteSheEOstoundertakeaSleepOut™ateveryshelterinthecountry.Thiswouldgivethemachancetomeetwomenandstaffandunderstandwhatisneededtosupportwomentoleaveabusiverelationships,aswellashowtokeepsheltersrunningeffectively.
2. WeinviteSheEOstohelpdeveloptheroleofthecorporatesectorinaddressingdomesticviolence.Whatcouldtheyofferintermsoftraining,learnerships/internshipsandopportunitiestogainworkexperience?VerylittleCSIfindsitswaytoinitiativesaddressingviolenceagainstwomen.Howcanthisbechanged?
3. Whatneedstobedonetoensurethatdecision-makersunderstandthatdomesticviolenceisahousingissuethatrequiresrecognitioninhousingpolicy?
![Page 7: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
TOPIC FOURFOREIGN AND UNDOCUMENTED CHILDREN AND MOTHERS, AND THEIR RIGHT TO SUPPORT
Facilitator:TaliaMagnes:SocialWorkerImpilo
Facts about foreign or undocumented mothers and children:
• InSouthAfrica,thereareahighnumberofchildrenandmotherswhoareundocumented/foreign.Authoritieshavenoideahowmany,butitisalreadyconsideredanationalcrisis(atarecentconferenceonUndocumentedChildren,theMECforSocialDevelopmentinGautengdescribedtheproblemasahumanitarianemergency).
• Thesenumbersareplacingstrainonthechildprotectionsystem.
• Thesystemisnotacknowledgingtheproblemandispunitive:HomeAffairs’solutionisarrestanddeportation.
• Thesechildrenandtheirmothershavenoaccesstobasicservicesandresourcessuchaseducation,health,legalsystemandsocialgrants,althoughmanyoftheserightsareguaranteedundertheconstitutionandtheChildren’sAct.
• Undocumentedorforeignchildrenandmothersdonotknowtheirrights.
• Manyforeignmothersarenotabletosafelyplacetheirchildrenintothechildprotectionsystembecausetheydon’thaveavalidformofidentification.
• Fearofbeingarrestedanddeportedresultsinsomeforeignmothersbelievingthattheironlyoptionistoabandontheirchild(oftenanonymouslyandunsafely).
• No formalstatisticsareavailable toshowwhywomenhaveabandonedtheirchildren,but theperceptionamongstsomegovernmentofficialsthatallabandonedbabiesareforeignisuntrue.
• Childrenborntoforeignmothers(regardlessofiftheywereborninSouthAfrica,andoftenregardlessofifthefatherisSouthAfrican)aredeemedtobeforeign,andissuedwithhandwrittenbirthcertificates.ThismeansthattheycannotbeadoptedinSouthAfrica.
Recommendations:
• LinkingourresponsibilitiestotheUN/UNICEF/AUandSArightsandconstitutionalresponsibilities.Thatis,toplacechildrenintofamilies,ratherthanchildren’shomes.
Questions:
1. Whatcanthefollowingdotolessentheproblemofforeign/undocumentedmothersandchildren: • Government(whoandwhat) • Businessandcivilsociety • Legislators
2. Whatoptionscanbeprovidedtoforeignmotherswhoarenotabletoraisetheirchildren?
3. ShouldforeignwomenwhosechildrenareborninSouthAfricabeallowedtoplacetheirchildrenforadoptioninthiscountry?Whyorwhynot?
![Page 8: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
TOPIC FIVEUNSAFE ABANDONMENT AND THE NEED FOR A SAFE HAVEN LAW
Facilitators:WhitneyRosenberg:Lawlectureranddoctoralstudentinchildabandonment &NadineGrabham:OperationsDirectorDoorofHopeBabyHome
Facts about abandonment and the need for safe abandonment:
• Itiscommonlycitedthatabout3500childrenareabandonedannually(approximately300permonth),butthatfigureonlyincludessurvivors.Thetotalnumberofabandonmentsisfarhigher.
• Estimatesareforeveryabandonedbabythatsurvives,twodie.Inotherwords,twoofeverythreeabandonedbabiesdie.
• Forthisreason,arecentMedicalResearchCouncilstudyonchildhomiciderevealsthatchildreninSouthAfricaareatthehighestriskofunnaturaldeathinthefirstsixdaysoflife.
• Researchshowsthat65%ofabandonedchildrenarenewborns,and90%areundertheageofone.
• 70%ofbabiesareabandonedinunsafesitesincluding,toilets,drains,gutters,refusebins,rubbishdumps,andopenveld.
• Manyabandonedbabiesareneverfound.
• SafeabandonmentisillegalinSouthAfrica,soallofthecountry’sbabysafesoperateunlawfully.
• RecentcasesinvolvingamotherabandoningherchildinataxiandanotherplacingachildoutsideofaPlaceofSafetyhaveresultedincriminalinvestigations.Inthecaseofthemotherfromthetaxi,chargeswerelaidandsheappearedincourt.CCTVfootageofmothersafelyabandoningherchildoutsideaplaceofsafetyresultedinherimagebeingpublishedonthepinkladiesmissingpersonsalertandinthepolicedistributingherpicture.
• Bycontrast,womenwhoabandonunsafelyareveryseldomprosecuted.Iftheyareprosecuted,itisusuallyforconcealmentofbirthnotforattemptedmurderormurder.
• Authoritiesareunwillingtoallowsafeabandonmentbecauseofthelossofcultureandbecausetheyareconcernedthatitwillencouragegreaternumbersofwomentoabandon.
• However, researchers in South Africa argue that the opposite of safe abandonment is unsafe abandonment, not noabandonment.
Legislation governing abandonment:
• ThecurrentChildren’sActof2005,section305,whichdealswithoffences,statesthattheparent,guardianorotherpersonhaving parental rights and responsibilities, care-giver, or person who voluntarily cares for a child whether indefinitely,temporarilyorpartially is guiltyof anoffence if thatparentor care-giverorotherperson—subsection (3)(b)—abandonsthechild.Furthermore,thispersonmaybeheldliableasexpressedinsubsection(6)and(7)toafineorimprisonmentnotexceedingtenor20yearsrespectivelyortobothafineandimprisonment.
• ThecrimeofabandonmentisalsomentionedintheGeneralLawAmendmentAct46of1935,section113(asamendedbytheJudicialMattersAmendmentActof2008)definesthedisposingofthebodyofanewborn,eventhoughitisnotproventhatthechildinquestiondiedbeforeitsbodywasdisposedof,asthecrimeofconcealmentofbirth.Mothersfaceconvictionofafineorimprisonmentnotexceedingthreeyears.
• Section233(1)oftheChildren’sActprovidesthatachildmaybeadoptedonlyifconsentfortheadoptionhasbeengivenby-
o (a)eachparentofthechild,regardlessofwhethertheparentsaremarriedornot:Providedthat,iftheparentisachild,thatparentisassistedbyhisorherguardian.
• Asopposedtosection5oftheChoiceonTerminationofPregnancyActwhichallowsaminortogetanabortionwithouttheconsentofherparentsorguardian.
![Page 9: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
TOPIC FIVEUNSAFE ABANDONMENT AND THE NEED FOR A SAFE HAVEN LAW
Facilitators:WhitneyRosenberg:Lawlectureranddoctoralstudentinchildabandonment &NadineGrabham:OperationsDirectorDoorofHopeBabyHome
Across the globe:
• Rulingsfromcasesacrosstheworldhaveestablishedthattherighttolifetakesprecedenceovertherighttoidentity.
o Fixatingexclusivelyonrespectingtherightofthechildtoknowhisorherparentswithoutconsideringthecircumstanceswillleadtoviolationoftherighttolife.
o Ifthechildcannotsurvivethentherighttoknowhisorheroriginscanneitherbeclaimednorprotected.
o Babyhatchesgivechildrentherighttolifeandfornewborns,survivalismoreimportantthantherighttoknowandbecaredforbyhisorherparents.
o Inprinciple, the rightof achild toknowhisorherorigins shouldbegivenahigherpriority than theparent’s right toanonymity.However,wheredisclosingtheparent’sidentitycouldleadtoabortion,infanticideorunsafeabandonment,theparent’sanonymityshouldbeupheld.
• Safehaven laws thathavebeenadopted inothercountriesallowwomen toabandonachildsafelyandanonymously, inparticularinsafespaceslikehospitalsorpolicestations.Thechildcanbeplacedintocare,andthereisnoriskofprosecutionforthemother.
o USAsafehavenlaws ChildprotectionadvocatesrecommendthatSouthAfricainstitutesafehavenlawstolessenthenumberofchildrendying
asaresultofunsafeabandonment.
Questions:
1. WhatarethesolutionstochildabandonmentinSouthAfrica?
2. ShouldSouthAfricaenactsafehavenlawssimilartoothercountries?
3. Doesanabandonedchildhavetherighttoknowhisorherbiologicalorigins?
4. Wouldsafehavenlawsdecreasethenumberofunsafeabandonments?
5. Rulingsfromcasesacrosstheworldhaveestablishedthattherighttolifetakesprecedenceovertherighttoidentity.WillthiseverbeacceptedinSouthAfrica?
6. Ifnot,whatcanwedotoensurethatbabieswhoareabandonedsafelycanstillaccessinformationabouttheirbirthfamilies?
7. Dobabybinsencouragewomentoabandontheirbabies?Inotherwords,ifsafeabandonmentbecomeslegal,willthenumberofabandonmentsincrease?
![Page 10: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
TOPIC SIXHIGH LEVEL GOVERNMENT SUPPORT IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF ADOPTION
AS A CHILD PROTECTION STRATEGYFacilitator:SueKrawitz:DirectorImpiloChildProtection&AdoptionServices,ViceChairNationalAdoptionCoalition
Facts about adoption:
• SouthAfricahas3millionorphans,ofwhichupto1.2millionarematernalordoubleorphans.
• Inaddition,womeninthecountryexperiencetensofthousandsofcrisispregnanciesannually.Inmanyinstances,themothersarenotabletoraisetheirbabies.
• Atanygiventime,thereareabout550childrenregisteredontheRegisterofAdoptableChildrenandParents(RACAP)andawaitingadoption.
• Estimatesarethatthereare21,000childrenlivingin355registeredChildandYouthCareCentresacrossSouthAfricaandabout2,000livingin115unregisteredones.
• Despitethisneed,adoptionnumbersdeclinedby50%,from2840to1448,between2004and2014.
• In2016,only1165adoptionstookplace,afurther30%dropfrom2014.
• Up to80%of those1165adoptions in2016wereprobably familyadoptions (meaning that less than300wereunrelatedadoptions).
• InKwa-ZuluNatal(theprovincewiththelargestnumberoforphans),only8adoptionstookplacein2016.
Whenfacedwiththesechallenges,theNationalAdoptionCoalitionofSouthAfricawouldliketoachievethefollowing:
• Intersectoralcollaborationtostreamlinetheadoptionprocessandtodevelopabettersynergyinthecollaboration,thatwillpreventunnecessarydelays,stumblingblocksetc.(DHA,Justice,SocialDevelopmentetc).
• CollaborationbetweenDSDandadoptioncommunitytoraiseawareness,todialogue,debateanddevelopbetterinsightintochildren’sneedstopermanency,importanceofearlyattachment,cultureandsoforth.
• Theestablishmentofprogrammesthatwillensurethefastestandmostefficientreferralofpotentiallyadoptablechildren(young,orphanedandabandoned)torelevantpractitioners,topreventthatthesechildrenendupinchildprotectionsystemforlengthyperiods.
• Specialisedandstandardisedtrainingofsocialworkersinthisfield.
• Politicalwillandcommitment toacknowledge the importanceofadoptionasa formofalternative familycareandasanintegratedpartofchildprotection.
• Postadoptionsupportforadoptiveparents,birthmothersandchildren.
Questions:
1. GiventhatadoptionisanintegralpartofthechildprotectionsysteminSouthAfrica,whydoyouthinkadoptionnumbersaresolow?
2. WhataretheculturalissuesinSouthAfricathataffectadoptionandhowdoesunbuntuplayitselfoutwithregardtoadoption?
3. Whatcanbedonetorectifytheproblem?
4. HowdowecreateownershipoftheadoptionprocessandoutcomebySouthAfricansofallraces?
5. Howcanadoptioncontributetothefutureofourcountry?Whatistheimpactonourcountrybeifadoptionisnolongerpartofourchildprotectionsystem?
6. Howcanbusiness:
o Supportadoptionasasolutionforthechildrenofourcountrywhoareabandonedorneedpermanenthomes
o Assistwithpromotingtheagendaoftheadoptioncommunity.
![Page 11: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Dr Sibusiso Mkwananzi
DrBusiMkwananziisanassociatelecturerandPhDstudentwithintheDemographyandPopulationStudiesProgramme.SheisaqualifieddentistandholdsaMastersinEpidemiologyandBiostatisticsfromtheUniversityoftheWitwatersrand.Busi’sPhDresearchinvestigatessocialdisorganisation-rootedcontextualfactorsassociatedwithteenagepregnancyinSouthAfrica.Herotherresearchinterestsincludesexualandreproductivehealth,youth-relatedstudiesanddevelopment.SheisacurrentfellowoftheSouthAfricanHumanitiesDeans’Association(SAHUDA)andapreviousrecipientoftheNationalResearchFoundationInnovationandScarceSkillsFellowship,OppenheimerMemorialTrustFoundationandWitsUniversityPostgraduateMeritScholarships.Busidesires tocontribute to thedevelopmentof thirdworldnations,especially inAfrica throughpioneeringresearch.Sheenjoystravelling,listeningtomusicandreading.
Robyn Wolfson Vorster
RobynhasdegreesinSocialSciencesandHumanResourceDevelopment.Aspecialistinwrittenandverbalcommunications(including training and facilitation) she spent fifteen years consulting in strategic business development and managing theimplementationofsolutionsinthecorporatesectorandgovernment.In2012,afteradoptingherdaughter,sheleftthecorporatesectortofocusonchildprotectionandadoptionadvocacy.Shenowspecialisesinresearching,speakingandwritingaboutchildprotectionandadvocatingforchangestolegislationandpolicy.Robynhaswrittenextensivelyaboutadoption,abandonment,latetermabortion,childhomicide,thechallengesexperiencedbyforeignersandthecrisisinwelfareNGOs,fortheDailyMaverickandotherpublications,includingtheBusinessDay.Shealsoprovidesexpertinputonthetopicsfortelevisionandradio.
RobynlivesinJohannesburgwithherhusbandandtwobeautifulchildren,Luke(10)andAsha(5).Inhersparetime,shelikestoread,takephotographsandtellstoriestochildren.
Lisa Vetten
LisaVettenbeganworkingasalaycounsellorforPeopleOpposingWomenAbuse(POWA)in1991.Sincethenshehasaccumulatedextensivecounselling,para-legalandtrainingexperienceinthefieldofviolenceagainstwomen,aswellasundertakenarangeofstudiesonthetopic.Shehascompilednumeroussubmissionsaroundlawandpolicyapplicabletoviolenceagainstwomenandengagedwithparliamentinthisregard.In2005,sheformedpartoftheUNExpertGroup’sMeetingonGoodpracticesincombatingandeliminatingviolenceagainstwomen.Shehasalsoworkedasatechnicaladvisertovariousgovernmentdepartmentsonthedevelopmentofpolicyaddressingviolenceagainstwomen,includingtheDepartmentofHealth,theDepartmentofJusticeandConstitutionalDevelopmentandtheCivilianSecretariatforPolice(CSP).Shecurrentlyactsonapart-timebasisastheTechnicalAssistanttotheHigherEducationAIDS(HEAIDS)programmeoftheDepartmentofHigherEducationandTraining,andistaskedwithdraftinganationalpolicyframeworktoaddressgender-basedviolenceinthepost-schoolsector.Between2013and2015shewasagenderspecialistonviolenceagainstwomenappointedtotheCommissionforGenderEquality(CGE)intermsofsection6oftheCGEAct.
ShehasaMaster’sdegreeinPoliticalStudiesfromtheUniversityoftheWitwatersrand(cumlaude)focusingonlegislationandpolicy addressing domestic violence. Her dissertation has been accepted for publication as a book by the Human SciencesResearchCouncil(HSRC)Press.SheiscurrentlyaPhDcandidateinthePsychologydepartmentatthesameuniversity.
HerdoctorateaimstoprovideacriticalhistoryofresponsestorapeinSouthAfricafrom1976onward.MsVetten’sresearchhasbeenpublishedinpeer-reviewedjournalssuchasSouthAfricanCrimeQuarterly,GenderandDevelopment,BMCWomen’sHealth,Agenda,FeminismandPsychology,theSouthAfricanJournalofHumanRightsandPLoSMedicine.
MsVettenisaMellonDoctoralFellowoftheWitsCityInstitutebasedattheUniversityoftheWitwatersrand.
PROFESSIONAL PROFILES
![Page 12: THE PROBLEM OF ABANDONMENT FOR THE FIRESIDE …theceosleepoutza.co.za/blog/wp-content/uploads/... · by the child’s father. Government policy is also a huge contributing factor,](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042413/5f2cc1b582bfd47bc47da71a/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
Dr Zubeda Dangor
ZubedaDangoristheexecutivedirectoroftheNisaaInstituteofWomen’sDevelopmentandhasworkedextensivelyinthefieldofgenderviolence.ZubedahasservedontheeditorialboardsofLolaPressaninternationalwomen’smagazineaswellastheWomen’sHealthProjectBookandReclaimingWomen’sSpaces,aNisaapublication.Shehasbeeninstrumentalinestablishingtwosheltersforwomenandchildrenaffectedbygenderviolence.ShewasalsoinstrumentalininitiatingtheNationalShelterMovementandnowservesontheexecutiveoftheNationalShelterMovement.ShehastaughtacourseongenderviolenceandcommunitydevelopmentforMastersstudentsattheUniversityofJohannesburg.Inaddition,shehasconductedextensivetrainingongenderandgenderviolenceandcontinuestoofferconsultingservicesongender,genderviolenceandorganizationaldevelopment. Dr.DangorisaclinicalpsychologistwithaPhdinPsychology;herPhdthesishasbeenpublishedintoabookentitledLifeAfterAbuse:An Exploration ofWomen’s Strategies for OvercomingAbuse. She received a post graduate scholarship through theInstituteforInternationalEducationtostudyattheUniversityofNotreDameintheUnitedStates. In2006,shereceivedaninternationalCommunityServiceawardfromSouthAfricanWomenforWomenbasedinToronto,Canada.In2016,shereceivedanawardfromtheSBSMschoolinLenasiaforoutstandingservicetothecommunity.
Whitney Rosenberg
WhitneyRosenbergcompletedherLLBdegreein2010andwentontocompleteherMastersdegreeincontractuallawin2011.SheisanadmittedattorneyoftheHighCourtofSouthAfrica.Shehassincegoneontopursueherdoctorateinthelawsregulatinginfantabandonmentandtheinvestigationtoasafealternativetounsafeabandonment.Thistopicisveryclosetoherheart.Sheisalecturerof‘lawofpersonsandthefamily’attheUniversityofJohannesburgandwaspromotedtothissubjectafterhavinglecturedCommercialLawfor2years.WhitneyisalsoayouthleaderinhercommunityandchairsasSecretaryonherchurchboard. She has obtained a Goethe Institute certificate for GermanA level language proficiency. She is married to her lovinghusbandof5yearswhoownsamarketingagencyinJohannesburg.Whitneyisalsoananimalloverandmomtotwopups.Shelovestotravelandenjoystheoutdoors.
Nadene Grabham
NadeneGrabhamhasabackgroundisfinance.SheworkedasaforexdealeronthedealingfloorforStandardCorporateandInvestmentBankingfor20years.HerclientsincludedlargecorporateslikeMTN,BarlowsandAECI.In2011,shejoinedDoorofHopeasavolunteer. InJulyofthesameyear,shewasofferedapermanentpositionasBabyHomeManager.Shewasthenpromoted to General Manager and in 2016, became the Operations Director of the organisation. Nadene’s work is diverse,includingspendinghoursinEmergencyinGovernmenthospitalstakingcareofsickanddyingabandonedbabies.ShehasassistedwiththepreparationofmanyadoptionsandnowoverseethedaytodayrunningofDoorofHope’sthreeBabyHomesandcaringforthehealthanddevelopmentofalloftheorganisation’sbabies.
Sue Krawitz
SusanKrawitzgraduatedfromUniversityoftheWitwatersrand1982withaBAHonsSocialWork.Shehasworkedinthefieldofadoptionsince1988.SheinitiallyworkedasanadoptionsocialworkerinprivatepracticebeforefoundingImpiloChildProtectionandAdoptionServices in2003. She isboth theFoundingMemberandDirector. Shehasbeen involvedwithSouthAfricanAssociation of SocialWorker’s in Private practice and served on the board. She is also a Founding Member ofThe NationalAdoptionCoalition.ShehasservedastheChairpersonandiscurrentlythevicechair.Sueispassionateaboutallaspectsofadoption.
PROFESSIONAL PROFILES